Latest / Bloomberg Law / US Sues to Stop JetBlue From Buying Spirit
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brasso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: For the first time in more than twenty years, the
- 0:13Speaker 1: Justice Department is suing to stop the merger of two airlines.
- 0:17Speaker 1: Attorney General Merrick Garland announced on Tuesday that the US
- 0:21Speaker 1: is filing an antitrust lawsuit to block Jet Blue Airways
- 0:25Speaker 1: from purchasing Spirit Airlines for three point eight billion dollars.
- 0:29Speaker 1: We alleged that, if allowed to proceed, this merger will
- 0:32Speaker 1: limit choices and drive up ticket prices for passengers across
- 0:37Speaker 1: the country, and we further alleged that the impact of
- 0:40Speaker 1: this merger will be particularly harmful for travelers who rely
- 0:44Speaker 1: on what are known as ultra low cost carriers in
- 0:47Speaker 1: order to fly. This is the second lawsuit against Jet
- 0:51Speaker 1: Blue by the Biden Justice Department, which is also seeking
- 0:55Speaker 1: to unwind its alliance in the Northeast with the American Airlines,
- 0:58Speaker 1: and the Attorney General had a warning for companies in
- 1:01Speaker 1: other industries. Companies in every industry should understand by now
- 1:07Speaker 1: that this Justice Department will not hesitate to enforce and
- 1:11Speaker 1: I trust laws and protect American consumers. Joining me is
- 1:16Speaker 1: Bloomberg Intelligence Senior Litigation analyst Jennifer Ree. This deal would
- 1:21Speaker 1: make JetBlue the fifth largest US carrier based on domestic
- 1:24Speaker 1: passenger traffic. What would the deal do for Jet Blue? Well,
- 1:28Speaker 1: I mean, for one reason, because it would make it
- 1:30Speaker 1: the fifth largest, but also because it says it needs
- 1:33Speaker 1: to do this deal to better compete with the legacy
- 1:35Speaker 1: carriers like Delta and United and even Southwest. You know,
- 1:39Speaker 1: those air carriers combined have about an eighty percent share,
- 1:42Speaker 1: including American in there, and JetBlue wants to be able
- 1:45Speaker 1: to better compete. That's one of their main arguments for
- 1:47Speaker 1: the deal. JetBlue says the combination would create quote the
- 1:51Speaker 1: most compelling national lowfare challenger to the dominant US carriers.
- 1:56Speaker 1: Yet the Justice Department is challenging because they're afraid to
- 1:59Speaker 1: emerge will drive up the cost of airline tickets for
- 2:03Speaker 1: low cost carriers. You know, the thing about it is
- 2:06Speaker 1: they're both right really at the end of the day,
- 2:08Speaker 1: because they're kind of three tiers right affairs. You Like
- 2:11Speaker 1: I said, the legacy carriers that tend to have the
- 2:13Speaker 1: highest fares, and then you have an airline like Jet
- 2:15Speaker 1: Blue that's considered a low cost carrier. The fares are
- 2:18Speaker 1: a little bit lower, but then you have Spirit, which
- 2:20Speaker 1: is considered an ultralow cost carrier, so the fares are
- 2:23Speaker 1: a little bit lower. Now, jet Blue does exert a
- 2:26Speaker 1: competitive pressure on the legacy airlines. There's no doubt that
- 2:29Speaker 1: when Jet Blue enters a route, the fares all tend
- 2:32Speaker 1: to go down. But Spirit does the same thing. So
- 2:35Speaker 1: Spirit is now pulling down the fares of all of
- 2:37Speaker 1: those legacy carriers in addition to Jet Blue, and the
- 2:40Speaker 1: Department of Justice's concern is that when Jet Blue takes
- 2:43Speaker 1: over all the routes that Spirit flies and transforms it
- 2:47Speaker 1: into sort of the Jet Blue model, it turns from
- 2:49Speaker 1: an ultralow cost carrier to a low cost carrier, and
- 2:52Speaker 1: it means the fares do go up. So you are
- 2:54Speaker 1: losing a choice for people who want that rock bottom
- 2:57Speaker 1: fare and don't necessarily care about quality or amended these
- 3:00Speaker 1: or even space. They lose that choice is the cost
- 3:04Speaker 1: of the ticket. The only reason why the Justice Department
- 3:07Speaker 1: is challenging this merger, well it's really the main reason why.
- 3:11Speaker 1: I mean, you know, mergers get challenged because they can
- 3:14Speaker 1: reduce output, and they can increase price, and they can
- 3:16Speaker 1: reduce quality. Now a reduction and quality isn't really an
- 3:19Speaker 1: issue here because Jet Blue would probably increase the quality
- 3:22Speaker 1: of the Spirit flights. But the other two are the issues,
- 3:25Speaker 1: and they're linked. Right. It would decrease output because jet
- 3:28Speaker 1: Blue would take those Spirit planes and put fewer seats
- 3:31Speaker 1: that are bigger, and that reduces output and reduction and
- 3:34Speaker 1: output ends up increasing price. But jet Blue would also
- 3:37Speaker 1: likely increase price because it would increase the amenities and
- 3:40Speaker 1: the quality. So it would do those two things, and
- 3:42Speaker 1: those are both concerns of the Department of Justice. So
- 3:45Speaker 1: tell me what the legal argument is the antitrust argument
- 3:48Speaker 1: that the Department of Justice is going to make. So
- 3:51Speaker 1: they're making a couple arguments here, and they're honestly very
- 3:53Speaker 1: traditional antitrust arguments. I think we've been hearing about other
- 3:57Speaker 1: challenges that the FTC and the DOJ have waged that
- 4:00Speaker 1: have been kind of a unique and novel and may
- 4:02Speaker 1: not have such a chance in court, But this is
- 4:04Speaker 1: really traditional. They say, first, they overlap on certain routes,
- 4:07Speaker 1: and for the routes they overlap, you're going to lose
- 4:09Speaker 1: that competition. And we already have a consolidated industry. The
- 4:13Speaker 1: concentration is too high, and it's presumptively harmful in those
- 4:16Speaker 1: routes where they overlap. Now, second, they say that both
- 4:19Speaker 1: airlines have plans that they've seen to expand, and so
- 4:23Speaker 1: there's this potential competition in the future in these routes
- 4:26Speaker 1: where they might expand and compete. That will be lost
- 4:28Speaker 1: because that expansion won't happen by one or the other
- 4:31Speaker 1: when they become one airline. And then the last part
- 4:33Speaker 1: of it is what I've talked about that for those
- 4:35Speaker 1: routes where they don't overlap, jet Blue would effectively be
- 4:38Speaker 1: taking out this really ultra low cost carrier. It would
- 4:41Speaker 1: take over those flights, take out this really low fared provider,
- 4:45Speaker 1: and people who want to fly those routes at the
- 4:47Speaker 1: lowest price would lose an option. So it has basically
- 4:50Speaker 1: three tiers of arguments, and what's the likely argument that
- 4:53Speaker 1: Jet Blue is going to make in return. So in
- 4:56Speaker 1: these cases, what the judge is tasked with is asking
- 4:59Speaker 1: whether they're harm and then balancing that harm. If there
- 5:02Speaker 1: is harm, and I think there is here against any
- 5:04Speaker 1: kind of pro competitive aspects of the deal. And here
- 5:07Speaker 1: what Jet Blue will argue is that there's this Jet
- 5:09Speaker 1: Blue effect that when it enters a route that it
- 5:12Speaker 1: does exert competitive pressure on all the other airlines and
- 5:15Speaker 1: that fares across the board generally go down for the route.
- 5:18Speaker 1: Now that's been shown to be true, actually, so what
- 5:20Speaker 1: a judge is going to have to do is weigh
- 5:22Speaker 1: those against each other. And to me, at the end
- 5:24Speaker 1: of the day, the Department of Justice's evidence is strong
- 5:27Speaker 1: in this regard what you think of as a pro
- 5:30Speaker 1: competitive efficiency. This is this Jet Blue effect rarely wins
- 5:34Speaker 1: out when there's actually harm from the deal, and the
- 5:36Speaker 1: Jet Blue effect doesn't help the companies again in those
- 5:39Speaker 1: routes that Jet Blue is going to take over from Spirit.
- 5:42Speaker 1: So this is sort of a non legal question. But
- 5:46Speaker 1: the four largest US airlines control eighty percent of the market,
- 5:50Speaker 1: so on its face, it seems unfair not to allow
- 5:54Speaker 1: Jet Blue to get bigger to compete with them. That
- 5:58Speaker 1: kind of argument is an argument that's often aid in mergers,
- 6:00Speaker 1: and it never works where that merger is going to
- 6:03Speaker 1: otherwise cause harm. And I think the other important thing
- 6:06Speaker 1: is the way you dissect this case and the way
- 6:08Speaker 1: the DOJ will present it and the judge will evaluate
- 6:11Speaker 1: it is they ask what is the relevant market where
- 6:14Speaker 1: competition takes place, so that eighty percent is talking about
- 6:17Speaker 1: the nation and the airlines don't compete with each other
- 6:20Speaker 1: in that respect. They compete for certain routes. So what
- 6:23Speaker 1: happens is the DOJ will say this route, this route,
- 6:26Speaker 1: will lay out the different routes in which they compete
- 6:28Speaker 1: from an origin to a destination, and that's what the
- 6:31Speaker 1: judge is going to look at, not this eighty percent
- 6:34Speaker 1: share nationwide. And for some routes, Jet Blue might itself
- 6:37Speaker 1: have eighty percent share for that route. So that's how
- 6:40Speaker 1: it'll look at it. And it's not going to be
- 6:41Speaker 1: about that nationwide eighty percent share that the others have.
- 6:45Speaker 1: Jet Blue and Spirit offered to divest overlapping routes to
- 6:50Speaker 1: try to address the Justice Department's antitrust concerns. And that's
- 6:54Speaker 1: a remedy that the Justice Department apparently has accepted in
- 6:57Speaker 1: previous airline mergers. But and I did here, Well, do
- 7:01Speaker 1: you think that will be held against the Justice Department?
- 7:03Speaker 1: You did it before, you know why you're now changing
- 7:05Speaker 1: the way you're approaching these I don't think it'll be
- 7:08Speaker 1: held against the Justice Department because each merger stands on
- 7:11Speaker 1: its own facts. They're all different, and they all have
- 7:13Speaker 1: a different competitive impact. So what might have fixed a
- 7:17Speaker 1: deal before if divestitures may not necessarily fix this one
- 7:21Speaker 1: because the facts and the competitive dynamics are different now.
- 7:24Speaker 1: No doubt this is a more aggressive DOJ. And this
- 7:27Speaker 1: DOJ has said, when we have a problematic deal, we
- 7:30Speaker 1: no longer want to accept a remedy like divestitures to
- 7:33Speaker 1: clear the deal. And the judge could think about that
- 7:36Speaker 1: and could consider that, but it doesn't mean that there
- 7:38Speaker 1: aren't other issues than that the deal isn't anti competitive.
- 7:42Speaker 1: So again, I think that the DOJ has some good
- 7:44Speaker 1: arguments here, and I think that those divestitures, while they
- 7:47Speaker 1: could fix some routes where the companies compete, they don't
- 7:50Speaker 1: fix the other problem I was talking about with Jet
- 7:53Speaker 1: Blue taking out this ultra low cost carrier from those
- 7:56Speaker 1: routes that Spirit flies and JetBlue doesn't. Today, do you
- 7:59Speaker 1: think at this point there's anything that JetBlue could do
- 8:03Speaker 1: to get the Justice Department to back down and approve
- 8:07Speaker 1: the merger. I do not. I think this is a
- 8:10Speaker 1: really aggressive Justice Department that they're already was concerned about
- 8:13Speaker 1: consolidation and the concentration in the airline industry before this
- 8:18Speaker 1: merger was even announced, And I think that they're going
- 8:20Speaker 1: to make it difficult on any other airlines that want
- 8:22Speaker 1: to merge in the future as well. Jan give us
- 8:24Speaker 1: a little history about how the airline industry became so
- 8:28Speaker 1: consolidated over the years. There were a lot of mergers
- 8:31Speaker 1: over let's say, the last twenty five years, and today
- 8:35Speaker 1: right there's this sort of new antitrust movement, and part
- 8:38Speaker 1: of that movement is this realization that one by one
- 8:41Speaker 1: over the years, too many mergers, not just in the
- 8:44Speaker 1: airline industry, but in other industries as well, got cleared
- 8:47Speaker 1: with remedies or without remedies by the Department of Justice
- 8:50Speaker 1: or Federal Trade Commission. And we suddenly woke up today
- 8:53Speaker 1: with a lot of industries that are too consolidated, and
- 8:55Speaker 1: because of that, there are problems in those industries, like
- 8:58Speaker 1: high fares, like low quality, and I think a lot
- 9:01Speaker 1: of people would agree that that's something that's going on
- 9:03Speaker 1: in the airline industry today. So the Department of Justice
- 9:07Speaker 1: and the Federal Trade Commission are kind of trying to
- 9:09Speaker 1: make up for that today. And the airline industry is
- 9:11Speaker 1: the poster child for those people that think that there's
- 9:14Speaker 1: been lacks enforcement. I mean, it's one of the first
- 9:16Speaker 1: ones agriculture, the beer industry, pharmaceutical many, but the airline
- 9:21Speaker 1: industry is the very first one that proponents of stronger
- 9:24Speaker 1: anti trust enforcement bring up when they talk about too
- 9:27Speaker 1: many mergers over the last twenty years being approved. This
- 9:30Speaker 1: is the second time, the second lawsuit against Jet Blue
- 9:33Speaker 1: by the Biden Justice Department. So tell us about the
- 9:35Speaker 1: other one where that is right. So the other one
- 9:38Speaker 1: is a challenge to an alliance between Jet Blue and
- 9:40Speaker 1: American in the Northeast. It really just deals with Boston
- 9:43Speaker 1: and New York airports mostly, and it's really one of
- 9:46Speaker 1: these code sharing alliances that we know about where you
- 9:49Speaker 1: can swap frequent flyer miles and you can book American
- 9:51Speaker 1: but you fly Jet Blue and vice versa. But the
- 9:54Speaker 1: problem the DJ had with it is that the companies
- 9:56Speaker 1: are sharing capacity information and they're also sharing revenue as
- 9:59Speaker 1: part of that alliance. So the DOJ really actually kind
- 10:02Speaker 1: of sees it as a merger in that area, and
- 10:04Speaker 1: they have some of the same problems with it they
- 10:06Speaker 1: have with this. There was already a trial it completed
- 10:10Speaker 1: months ago, and I think actually last year it completed,
- 10:13Speaker 1: and I think it's likely that we'll get a decision
- 10:16Speaker 1: in the first half of this year. I mean, it
- 10:17Speaker 1: could come anytime. There's no specific timing constraints on the judges,
- 10:21Speaker 1: but I do think we'll get a decision in the
- 10:22Speaker 1: first half. So tell us about what the timing on
- 10:25Speaker 1: this looks like. I mean, has the dj already filed
- 10:28Speaker 1: the complaint, Yes, they filed it yesterday, and what they're
- 10:32Speaker 1: seeking as a permanent injunction, and that could kind of
- 10:35Speaker 1: run from filing to decision anywhere from about six to
- 10:38Speaker 1: nine months, So I think, you know, seven to eight
- 10:41Speaker 1: months here we could actually get a decision, and then
- 10:44Speaker 1: if the losing party, whichever one it is, ends up appealing,
- 10:47Speaker 1: that could tack on another five to six months. But
- 10:49Speaker 1: the thing that's interesting here is that Jet Blue obviously
- 10:52Speaker 1: expected this kind of litigation because the end date in
- 10:55Speaker 1: their purchase agreement isn't until July of twenty twenty four,
- 10:58Speaker 1: and that actually almost gives them time both for this
- 11:00Speaker 1: first ruling and an appeal. You seem to indicate that
- 11:03Speaker 1: DOJ's case is very strong. So why do you think
- 11:06Speaker 1: Jet Blue is willing to go to trial and an appeal?
- 11:09Speaker 1: You know, I think that they're willing to do that
- 11:12Speaker 1: because again, as I said, the way a judge evaluates
- 11:15Speaker 1: these cases is looking at whether there's harm and then
- 11:17Speaker 1: balancing the pro competitive aspects against it. And they have
- 11:20Speaker 1: a legitimate argument right about pro competitive effects here, the
- 11:24Speaker 1: fact that they could actually exert greater competitive pressure on
- 11:27Speaker 1: the Deltas and the Uniteds and Americans of the world.
- 11:30Speaker 1: And they may be hoping because weighing those though two
- 11:33Speaker 1: things is kind of subjective, so they may be hoping
- 11:35Speaker 1: they get a judge that puts more emphasis on that
- 11:39Speaker 1: than on the fact that they'll take out an ultra
- 11:41Speaker 1: low cost carrier. There's some possibility there that that could happen.
- 11:45Speaker 1: And the other thing is that we're beginning to see
- 11:47Speaker 1: a bit of a trend where the DOJ and the
- 11:49Speaker 1: FTC are rejecting remedy offers, but the judges are a
- 11:52Speaker 1: little bit more open to those offers. Now, I don't
- 11:54Speaker 1: actually think that's going to be the case here, but
- 11:56Speaker 1: they also may be banking on that that they have
- 11:59Speaker 1: this remedy offer, they'll present it to the judge, they'll
- 12:01Speaker 1: present the pro competitive aspects. They may be able to
- 12:04Speaker 1: pull the judge over to their side. We talked before
- 12:07Speaker 1: about the DOJ using novel arguments the Antitrust Department. But
- 12:12Speaker 1: this argument here, it's not a novel argument. This is
- 12:15Speaker 1: just a tried and true argument. Yeah, this is tried
- 12:18Speaker 1: and true. This is two competitors compete with each other,
- 12:21Speaker 1: one taking another competitor out of the market. And that's
- 12:23Speaker 1: really the very traditional concern about mergers, and that's the
- 12:26Speaker 1: kind of case that the DOJ and the FTC usually
- 12:30Speaker 1: would bring. You've mentioned today how aggressive on antitrust issues
- 12:35Speaker 1: this Justice Department is. Have they accomplished anything or is
- 12:39Speaker 1: it too early to tell? So I think there's a
- 12:42Speaker 1: lot of talk about a pretty bad track record so far.
- 12:45Speaker 1: Now I don't necessarily agree with that, because what they
- 12:49Speaker 1: have accomplished, a particularly the FTC with this pressure, is
- 12:53Speaker 1: causing deals to get abandoned, and they view that as
- 12:56Speaker 1: a win. You know, they're trying to stop a merger.
- 12:58Speaker 1: The merger got stopped because companies want to deal with
- 13:01Speaker 1: litigation or a challenge and walked away. So they do
- 13:03Speaker 1: view that as a win. And the FTC has had
- 13:06Speaker 1: quite a few abandonments in the last year and a
- 13:08Speaker 1: half now where they've gone to trial. It's correct that
- 13:11Speaker 1: the track record hasn't been great. The DOJ has won
- 13:14Speaker 1: one case. They managed to block and trial the merger
- 13:17Speaker 1: between Simon and Schuster and Penguin Random House. But like
- 13:22Speaker 1: the Jet Blue Spirit deal, that again was traditional. It
- 13:26Speaker 1: wasn't really a novel theory. These are two head to
- 13:28Speaker 1: head competitors that were in a concentrated market, so it
- 13:31Speaker 1: was a traditional theory. They won on a fairly traditional theory,
- 13:35Speaker 1: even though it was about the impact on writers and
- 13:38Speaker 1: labor rather than the price of books, which is a
- 13:41Speaker 1: little bit different. But the others where the theories have
- 13:43Speaker 1: been more novel, the agencies, when it's litigated through haven't
- 13:47Speaker 1: had as much luck. The judges have been really siding
- 13:49Speaker 1: with the companies. Thanks so much, Jen. That's Bloomberg Intelligence
- 13:53Speaker 1: senior litigation analyst Jennifer Ree. The SEC rarely loses an
- 14:00Speaker 1: insider trading case, and now it's convinced the Fourth Circuit
- 14:04Speaker 1: to reverse one of those rare losses. A judge had
- 14:07Speaker 1: abruptly ended the trial of mortgage broker Christopher Clark after
- 14:11Speaker 1: the SEC had presented its evidence and before the case
- 14:15Speaker 1: was sent to the jury. Judge Claude Hilton said that
- 14:18Speaker 1: the agency was simply speculating that Clark received insider information
- 14:23Speaker 1: because he was a little too successful in trading. But
- 14:26Speaker 1: the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the judge's decision,
- 14:30Speaker 1: ruling that a jury should have decided the case. My
- 14:33Speaker 1: guest is corporate law expert James Park, a professor at
- 14:36Speaker 1: UCLA Law School. What were the charges against Christopher Clark.
- 14:42Speaker 1: He was charged with trading on inside information. He traded
- 14:47Speaker 1: in the stock of a company called Corporate Executive Board,
- 14:52Speaker 1: and Corporate Executive Board received a merger offer, an offered
- 14:57Speaker 1: to merge from another company. And typically when a company
- 15:01Speaker 1: is purchased by another company, the stock price goes up
- 15:03Speaker 1: because the stock of the acquired company is purchased at
- 15:07Speaker 1: a premium. And so if you know that in advance,
- 15:10Speaker 1: you're going to be able to buy the stock at
- 15:13Speaker 1: a lower price with the hope maybe the knowledge that
- 15:17Speaker 1: the stock will go up in price, and then you
- 15:20Speaker 1: sell the stock at an easy profit. Christopher Clark and
- 15:24Speaker 1: his son purchased significant numbers of call options, which give
- 15:29Speaker 1: you the right to buy stock at a particular price,
- 15:33Speaker 1: right before the merger was announced. And the allegation is
- 15:37Speaker 1: that he got information that the merger was going to
- 15:40Speaker 1: happen from his brother in law who worked at Corporate
- 15:43Speaker 1: Executive Board. His brother in law's name is William Wright.
- 15:48Speaker 1: So why did the judge dismiss the charges against Clark
- 15:52Speaker 1: before the case was sent to the jury. The District
- 15:56Speaker 1: Court dismissed the charges because the judge I believe that
- 16:01Speaker 1: there was not sufficient direct evidence for a reasonable jury
- 16:06Speaker 1: to conclude that Christopher Clark had received insight information from
- 16:11Speaker 1: William Wright. There was no direct evidence that Wright ever
- 16:16Speaker 1: spoke to Christopher Clark about the merger, and the defendant
- 16:21Speaker 1: argued that Right didn't even know about the merger until
- 16:27Speaker 1: after the decision to merge had already been made. That
- 16:31Speaker 1: was the basic argument that the defendants made and the judge.
- 16:35Speaker 1: The District court judge agreed and said that the case
- 16:38Speaker 1: should not go to a jury, but the Fourth Circuit
- 16:41Speaker 1: disagreed and reversed that decision to dismiss the case. Is
- 16:46Speaker 1: it difficult to get evidence direct evidence of insider trading
- 16:51Speaker 1: unless you flip a witness or get a wire tap.
- 16:54Speaker 1: It's very difficult because typically the defendant is getting inside
- 16:59Speaker 1: and information from somebody they have a close relationship to,
- 17:03Speaker 1: someone who they trust very much, somebody who in this
- 17:07Speaker 1: case was a relative, and so that person is very
- 17:11Speaker 1: unlikely to testify against you. That person is unlikely to
- 17:15Speaker 1: wear a wirecap to record communications conveying inside information. I mean,
- 17:22Speaker 1: so it's very difficult to establish these cases through direct evidence.
- 17:26Speaker 1: Let's talk a little bit about the kind of evidence
- 17:29Speaker 1: that the SEC had. They have surveillance tools and a
- 17:35Speaker 1: special market abuse unit that sort of broadens the way
- 17:40Speaker 1: they can find insider trading. That's right. The SEC has
- 17:45Speaker 1: a market abuse the unit which monitors markets for unusual trading,
- 17:51Speaker 1: especially around merger announcements. And so they will examine activity
- 17:57Speaker 1: in the stock market, the option market, and they will
- 18:01Speaker 1: look for unusual amounts of trading. And they find unusual
- 18:06Speaker 1: amounts of trading right before the merger, then they might
- 18:10Speaker 1: do a further investigation. And so I suspect that the
- 18:14Speaker 1: SEC was tipped off by the fact that Clark bought
- 18:18Speaker 1: significant amounts of call options right around the time the
- 18:23Speaker 1: merger was announced, right before the merger was announced, and
- 18:27Speaker 1: then they followed us and did an investigation which uncovered
- 18:30Speaker 1: some additional evidence. It was not just the unusual trading
- 18:33Speaker 1: that led the SEC to file the case, but Clark
- 18:38Speaker 1: liquidated his wife's retirement account, he borrowed a significant amount
- 18:42Speaker 1: of money at a nine percent interest rate in order
- 18:45Speaker 1: to buy additional call options. His son bought a significant
- 18:51Speaker 1: amount of call options as well, and so there was
- 18:54Speaker 1: additional activity that would indicate something suspicious. And I'm sure
- 18:59Speaker 1: that through the investigation, the SEC learned that Christopher Clark
- 19:03Speaker 1: had a brother in law who worked for the company
- 19:05Speaker 1: that had issued the stock that he was trading in,
- 19:08Speaker 1: and so that additional piece of information would have led
- 19:12Speaker 1: the SEC to suspect that he's getting inside information from
- 19:16Speaker 1: within the company. Is it rare for a judge to
- 19:20Speaker 1: dismiss a case after all the evidence has come in,
- 19:23Speaker 1: so the witnesses have testified, but the jury is not
- 19:26Speaker 1: allowed to reach a verdict. It is rare. Judgments as
- 19:30Speaker 1: a matter of law typically are not granted before the
- 19:33Speaker 1: jury deliberates, and I think part of the reason for
- 19:38Speaker 1: this is that we typically allow juries to resolve factual issue.
- 19:43Speaker 1: That's something that is part of our system. And the
- 19:46Speaker 1: jury is the body that is given the power to
- 19:50Speaker 1: decide whether or not it believes there are sufficient facts
- 19:54Speaker 1: for the case to succeed, and not the judge. The
- 19:58Speaker 1: judge also, you know, has invested a lot of time
- 20:01Speaker 1: in the case, and the jury has been assembled, and
- 20:04Speaker 1: so to take the case away from the jury is unusual.
- 20:09Speaker 1: It does happen from time to time, but it is
- 20:11Speaker 1: an unusual event because if the judge had let this
- 20:16Speaker 1: case go to the jury, there'd be a verdict in place,
- 20:19Speaker 1: and now when he's reversed, there wouldn't have to be
- 20:22Speaker 1: a whole new trial, right, that's correct, that's correct, And
- 20:26Speaker 1: you know, it's possible the jury would have agreed with
- 20:28Speaker 1: the judge and concluded that the sec had not made
- 20:31Speaker 1: its case. And so typically judges will, even if they
- 20:35Speaker 1: have some doubts about the evidence, they'll allow the case
- 20:38Speaker 1: to go to trial. They'll see what the jury does,
- 20:41Speaker 1: and they have the option acid the jury has entered
- 20:44Speaker 1: its verdict to reverse the jury verdict if they believe
- 20:48Speaker 1: that the jury's decision was unreasonable, and so now we
- 20:53Speaker 1: have to reassemble a jury and go through a trial.
- 20:57Speaker 1: So that's another reason why judges typically don't grant judgments
- 21:00Speaker 1: as a matter of law before the jury hears the case.
- 21:03Speaker 1: Do you have any insight as to why the judge here,
- 21:08Speaker 1: you know, didn't think that there was enough evidence. I
- 21:11Speaker 1: mean they did have circumstantial evidence. It was circumstantial, and
- 21:15Speaker 1: I think that you know, he may have credited some
- 21:20Speaker 1: of the testimony by the chief accounting officer of the company.
- 21:25Speaker 1: So apparently William Wright, who was the brother in law,
- 21:29Speaker 1: didn't get the information about the merger directly because he
- 21:33Speaker 1: was not included in the deliberations about the merger, and
- 21:38Speaker 1: so he only learned about the merger relatively laid in
- 21:41Speaker 1: the process from the chief accounting officer who was his
- 21:45Speaker 1: good friend. And the chief accounting officer basically claimed that
- 21:49Speaker 1: he did not tell mister Wright about the merger until
- 21:55Speaker 1: after the decision to agree to the merger offer, and
- 22:00Speaker 1: so that could be seen as powerful evidence that the
- 22:04Speaker 1: brother in law actually didn't have inside information. And if
- 22:07Speaker 1: he didn't have inside information, he could not have passed
- 22:10Speaker 1: it on to the defendant. So the judge, I think,
- 22:14Speaker 1: might have credited that particular testimony and said that there's
- 22:19Speaker 1: no basis for determining that Wright had the information to
- 22:23Speaker 1: pass on the Clark. Now. The error here, though, is
- 22:26Speaker 1: that judges are not supposed to weigh the credibility of evidence.
- 22:30Speaker 1: It's possible that the chief accounting officer was not telling
- 22:34Speaker 1: the truth, and there is some circumstantial evidence that mister Wright,
- 22:38Speaker 1: the brother in law, knew of the merger before the
- 22:42Speaker 1: trading took place, and so you know, those are facts
- 22:46Speaker 1: that the jury could have weighed against the testimony that
- 22:49Speaker 1: Right did not have inside information about the merger. We're
- 22:54Speaker 1: defense lawyers looking at the judges dismissal of the case
- 22:58Speaker 1: and sort of making an argument that the SEC needed
- 23:03Speaker 1: to have direct evidence of insider trading. I think so.
- 23:08Speaker 1: I think that is the basic argument. They were making
- 23:12Speaker 1: a higher standard for insider trading charges that you have
- 23:17Speaker 1: to have direct evidence of the transfer of inside information
- 23:22Speaker 1: from an insider to the person who is training. I
- 23:25Speaker 1: think that was their basic theme, and that's very difficult
- 23:28Speaker 1: to prove. That's very difficult for the SEC to prove,
- 23:31Speaker 1: especially when you have a case where the SEC is
- 23:34Speaker 1: proceeding civil right. The SEC can only bring civil charges
- 23:39Speaker 1: and it's speaking monetary penalties against the defendant. In those circumstances,
- 23:44Speaker 1: you don't have the high criminal standard of beyond a
- 23:48Speaker 1: reasonable doubt. In civil cases, circumstantial evidence, in my view,
- 23:52Speaker 1: should be sufficient to establish insider training violation. So, Jim,
- 23:57Speaker 1: what does this decision by the fourth circuits stand for,
- 24:01Speaker 1: is there anything beyond this case? I think it stands
- 24:05Speaker 1: for the proposition that you can establish that an insider
- 24:12Speaker 1: trading defendant had inside information through circumstantial evidence, and that
- 24:17Speaker 1: those are jury questions typically, rather than decisions that should
- 24:21Speaker 1: be made by a judge. And so I think it's
- 24:25Speaker 1: a fairly narrow proposition. I don't think it's a very
- 24:28Speaker 1: broad legal proposition. I think, though, it is an instructive
- 24:32Speaker 1: decision for district courts, not only in the Fourth Circuit
- 24:36Speaker 1: but across the country that when there is disputed circumstantial
- 24:41Speaker 1: evidence as to whether an insider trading defendant had insight
- 24:46Speaker 1: information that typically should be decided by a jury rather
- 24:49Speaker 1: than a judge. Are the circuits in agreement on this?
- 24:53Speaker 1: Are there any circuits that have contrary decisions? Not, to
- 24:58Speaker 1: my knowledge, it's always possible. But I think that this
- 25:04Speaker 1: is a sensible decision, and I think it's one where
- 25:09Speaker 1: I think other circuits would most likely agree that this
- 25:12Speaker 1: should be the rule. And then the reason why it
- 25:15Speaker 1: might be a somewhat unusual decision is that most of
- 25:19Speaker 1: the time defendants in the situation are going to settle
- 25:22Speaker 1: the case. They're going to agree to a settlement and
- 25:25Speaker 1: so the case doesn't go to trial. There are very
- 25:27Speaker 1: few cases that actually go to trial relative to the
- 25:30Speaker 1: number of insider trading cases that are brought. And you know,
- 25:34Speaker 1: it's interesting that William Wright, the brother in law, he
- 25:37Speaker 1: actually settled with the SEC and pay two hundred and
- 25:41Speaker 1: forty thousand dollars to the SEC to settle the case.
- 25:45Speaker 1: Christopher Clarks, though, decided to fight the charges. And that's
- 25:49Speaker 1: why we have this decision, which looks very carefully at
- 25:53Speaker 1: all of the relevant facts. That doesn't happen every day,
- 25:57Speaker 1: and so I think that it's I think if other
- 25:59Speaker 1: certain it's looked at the same fact, they would come
- 26:01Speaker 1: to the same conclusion. But there there probably are not
- 26:06Speaker 1: a whole lot of other pieces that have had the
- 26:09Speaker 1: opportunity to examine this particular type of situation. And what
- 26:15Speaker 1: kind of testimony did the FEC have a trial? You know,
- 26:18Speaker 1: that's a that's a good question. Actually it's not a
- 26:21Speaker 1: parent from the Fourth Circuit's opinion, because um, it's only
- 26:27Speaker 1: reviewing the record as opposed to the sort of what
- 26:33Speaker 1: might have happened to trial since the trial did not
- 26:36Speaker 1: actually occur. And so you know, I'm sure, um, you
- 26:41Speaker 1: know that it is a good quite you know. My
- 26:42Speaker 1: guess is that William Wright might have testified actually because
- 26:45Speaker 1: he settled with the SEC, and so the brother in
- 26:49Speaker 1: law might have been the person that they might have
- 26:51Speaker 1: called as a as a witness. Um. They also had
- 26:54Speaker 1: some evidence in email, various emails that indicated that right
- 27:02Speaker 1: knew about the merger discussions before the trading occurred, and
- 27:07Speaker 1: so they might have introduced the testimony of the people
- 27:12Speaker 1: who got those emails. So that might be another option.
- 27:17Speaker 1: But you're right there. That might have been a reason
- 27:19Speaker 1: why the district court may have felt like it wanted
- 27:23Speaker 1: it should have should dismiss the case, because you know,
- 27:29Speaker 1: the number of witnesses who would have testified would have
- 27:32Speaker 1: been fairly small in support of the SEC's case. So
- 27:36Speaker 1: on retrial, the defense attorney said, quote, the witnesses who
- 27:41Speaker 1: testified the trial overwhelmingly demonstrated mister Clark's innocence, and we
- 27:46Speaker 1: look forward to the retrial because the evidence will not change.
- 27:50Speaker 1: But my question is the evidence might not change, but
- 27:55Speaker 1: will the SEC lawyers perhaps shore up their presentation address
- 28:00Speaker 1: the weaknesses that the judge saw on the first trial
- 28:04Speaker 1: in a retrial. I think they will you always learn
- 28:09Speaker 1: from a first trial, and I think that they will
- 28:13Speaker 1: take the opportunity to put on a clearer case, the
- 28:16Speaker 1: stronger case. And you never know how a jury is
- 28:21Speaker 1: going to look at the evidence. We don't know how
- 28:23Speaker 1: this jury would have looked at the evidence, and so
- 28:25Speaker 1: I think that they will have learned from what happened
- 28:27Speaker 1: in the first case, and there's a very good possibility
- 28:32Speaker 1: that could be a conviction in this trial. For years,
- 28:35Speaker 1: these insider trading cases keep popping up where you know
- 28:39Speaker 1: the standard is questioned. It seems like that area of
- 28:43Speaker 1: the law is always in flux. It's very much influx.
- 28:47Speaker 1: It is very unclear, and that's why insider trading cases
- 28:51Speaker 1: can be controversial, especially when criminal charges have been brought.
- 28:56Speaker 1: I think in this case, though, that if the facts
- 28:59Speaker 1: are true, then it's very clear that Clark would be
- 29:04Speaker 1: guilty of insider trading. If it's true that he had
- 29:07Speaker 1: inside information from a close relative, his brother in law,
- 29:11Speaker 1: that typically is sufficient. I'm given that William Wright was
- 29:15Speaker 1: an insider of the company with various fiduciary duties not
- 29:19Speaker 1: to disclose that information to outsiders, and so I think
- 29:24Speaker 1: in this case we see that they're not only ambiguities
- 29:28Speaker 1: about what the law is on insider trading, they're also
- 29:32Speaker 1: ambiguities as to the fact and whether or not somebody
- 29:35Speaker 1: actually has inside information. So the defense attorneys made reference
- 29:40Speaker 1: to the fact that the Department of Justice declined to
- 29:44Speaker 1: prosecute here. Does that say anything. It's a good point,
- 29:49Speaker 1: but as I said before, that there may not have
- 29:52Speaker 1: been enough to stublish criminal charges. It may not be
- 29:55Speaker 1: that we can conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Christopher
- 29:59Speaker 1: Clark had inside information from William Wright, but we might
- 30:03Speaker 1: be able to conclude, based upon a lower preponderance of
- 30:07Speaker 1: the evidence standard, that he did have that inside information.
- 30:12Speaker 1: And so I think that the defense attorney's argument here
- 30:16Speaker 1: is not a strong one. I think the fact that
- 30:19Speaker 1: we didn't have criminal charges does not necessarily mean that
- 30:22Speaker 1: civil charges are not appropriate. It's an interesting case because
- 30:27Speaker 1: of the way the SEC found it through their monitoring activities.
- 30:31Speaker 1: It's also interesting that the SEC lost at the lower
- 30:35Speaker 1: court because the SEC typically wins cases like this, and
- 30:40Speaker 1: so it's an unusual and interesting case and it'll be
- 30:44Speaker 1: interesting to see what actually happens at trial. Thanks so
- 30:47Speaker 1: much for being on the show, Jim. That's Professor James
- 30:50Speaker 1: Park of UCLA Law School. And that's it for this
- 30:53Speaker 1: edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always
- 30:56Speaker 1: get the latest legal news Honor Bloomberg Law Podcast. You
- 30:59Speaker 1: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 31:03Speaker 1: Dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and remember
- 31:08Speaker 1: to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at
- 31:11Speaker 1: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 31:14Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg