Latest / CXOTalk / Jobs at Risk from AI Right Now - Future of Work! | CXOTalk #889
Transcript
- 0:00AI is disrupting jobs faster than anyone expected.
- 0:05Today we'll learn who's at risk, how to re skill at scale, and
- 0:10strategies to separate winners from those left behind.
- 0:15Our guest is David Martin, global lead for people and
- 0:19organization at Boston Consulting Group.
- 0:22I'm Michael Krigsman and welcome to CXO Talk episode 889.
- 0:28Thank you so much, Michael. I really appreciate the
- 0:31opportunity. I love listening to you and the
- 0:33great interviews you've done, and so I'm very excited.
- 0:36Give us a sense of your work at Boston Consulting Group.
- 0:40I lead our people and organization business unit and
- 0:44that is everything involving operating model, redesign,
- 0:47talent and skills, culture change management.
- 0:51So really all of the people related components that are now
- 0:53so important on the AI, on the AI front.
- 0:56What do you see are the core dynamics that are driving
- 1:02changes in organizations as as a result of AI?
- 1:07When ChatGPT came out in late 2022, I expected a lot more
- 1:14apprehension from companies to to get their hands dirty.
- 1:18And one thing we're seeing is just, you know, widespread use
- 1:22of the tools. We see a lot of excitement from
- 1:25both employees as well as, you know, in their own lives how
- 1:29they're using the tools. But a lot of increased
- 1:32uncertainty, both at the individual level, what's going
- 1:34to happen to my role in the organization as well as at the
- 1:38leadership level? How do I craft a strategy around
- 1:41this dynamic market? Is my business disrupted?
- 1:44So a great deal of uncertainty as well that companies are are
- 1:47struggling with. Could you identify any large
- 1:54works workforce shifts that are already taking place?
- 2:00Or is this all really kind of pushing into the future?
- 2:04It's both, but certainly to to the first part, there are a lot
- 2:07of workforce shifts. You could look at specific
- 2:10categories of jobs, so specific functions.
- 2:12You see a lot of pushed in the customer service domain across
- 2:16obviously a lot of sectors. You see a lot in software
- 2:19development, you see a lot in marketing.
- 2:22And so you're already seeing workforce shift there.
- 2:24A lot of it is OK, how do individuals in their current
- 2:28role start to use the technology?
- 2:30How does their role change in these spaces?
- 2:34I've spent a lot of work with software developers over the
- 2:37past year or so. I actually was 1 before I joined
- 2:39BCG and you know, the uncertainty about how do I use
- 2:43the tools and how do I deal with such a very rapidly evolving set
- 2:47of tools. You see GPT 5 come out
- 2:49yesterday, you know, which brings a host of new
- 2:51capabilities. So you're seeing the impact
- 2:53there on both the day-to-day work as well as how they're
- 2:56feeling about it. There's obviously much more down
- 3:00the line that that AI is going to impact in the workforce.
- 3:03So I think there's a lot still ahead of us.
- 3:05You raise a very interesting point about programmers and
- 3:09software development, because I think many people were under the
- 3:15impression initially that the kind of jobs that would be
- 3:20automated would be, I'm going to say, more rote or maybe lower
- 3:26skilled jobs. But when you talk about major
- 3:29impacts and software development, it makes you
- 3:33realize that the impact of AI is just everywhere.
- 3:38The tentacles are everywhere. It is making folks question, you
- 3:42know what their role looks like. It is impacting skilled labor
- 3:46administrative tasks too, as you mentioned, kind of the the toil
- 3:49that we talked about of folks day-to-day life.
- 3:52I think very early on, historically one of the the
- 3:56roles that that was supposed to be most resilient to AI was like
- 4:00in the field of psychology and therapy.
- 4:02And you saw data emerging in mid 2023 that actually augmented
- 4:09psychology was showing great benefit.
- 4:11And so it really has been surprising the breadth of of how
- 4:15it's impacting individuals role and how it's helping many roles
- 4:18that maybe didn't expect to to be using AI so quickly.
- 4:22You know, in terms of AI adoption, Greg Walters on
- 4:27LinkedIn asks a question. He says there is a statistic
- 4:32making the round stating that 46% of AI implementations are
- 4:37failing and abandoned. And I'd be really curious just
- 4:40to actually see that. But he's saying there's also
- 4:42another stat that 40 billion has been invested in AI by companies
- 4:48but resulting in only an 8% increase in revenue.
- 4:55So it seems like at least according to what he's saying,
- 4:58that there's this tremendous investment but not yet showing
- 5:05huge amounts of value from a people perspective.
- 5:10Do you have any reactions or thoughts to that?
- 5:13First of all, the stats don't surprise me.
- 5:15Maybe I'm a little surprised it's only 40 billion, but the
- 5:19notion of either a, some companies are struggling to
- 5:22realize the value and so they're calling it unsuccessful or be
- 5:26that that the time to value is long.
- 5:29So not necessarily that they're failing, but it's just, you
- 5:31know, not as not as quickly as as they might want it.
- 5:35It comes for at least two reasons.
- 5:37One is companies did a really good job of decentralizing
- 5:42experimentation and AI. And so you saw what we call 1000
- 5:46flowers blooming and every different part of an
- 5:48organization was testing it in some place.
- 5:52So you saw a lot of initiatives and what our data shows is
- 5:54actually the companies who are showing success and positive ROI
- 5:59right now are actually doing fewer things.
- 6:01That was surprising in our research, fewer, larger, more
- 6:03focused has been faster to value and more successful.
- 6:07But I do think the other side of it is a timeline thing I'm sure
- 6:10we'll talk about. And I've, I've heard you talk
- 6:12with many of your guys previously about data quality
- 6:15and really just some of the the necessary enablers that an
- 6:20organization needs to actually get the most value out of it.
- 6:22And so a lot of companies are having to now play a little bit
- 6:24of catch up on just getting a ship in order.
- 6:28The other thing I would say around delay or maybe even
- 6:32decreasing the magnitude of benefit, which does get right to
- 6:34the heart of the people. Point is adoption of an employee
- 6:38workforce is not always what you know the the leaders and the
- 6:42decision makers have expected. We saw actually the software
- 6:46company, 80% of the engineers had actually expressed
- 6:50excitement about using the new tools.
- 6:52When we actually looked at how their initiatives with deploying
- 6:55some of those tools is playing out, only 20% of the engineers
- 6:58were actually using it. So it's like even if that 20%
- 7:01has improved their productivity 100% and you're still at a much
- 7:04smaller amount of benefit than the company might have expected.
- 7:08And, and so adoption challenges have probably been the most
- 7:12important lever that companies are now using or struggling with
- 7:16and then addressing to capture value and, and I think the
- 7:19problem is, and I'm sure we can dig into it later.
- 7:22So sorry for the long winded answer, but one of the problems
- 7:24with adoption is either they don't have the skills yet, they
- 7:29haven't been taught properly out of prompt or they haven't even
- 7:31been trained on how to use the tool.
- 7:33That's one side the skills and one other component is
- 7:37leadership. And you know, have they
- 7:38communicated a vision on how they expect the role to change
- 7:42or how employees should be using it?
- 7:44What is the what's the purpose of why they're rolling it out?
- 7:47Are they trying to save costs? Are they trying to increase
- 7:49output? So all of those types of people
- 7:51related issues are many different factors diminishing
- 7:55adoption and and consequently, you know, companies might be
- 7:59struggling for for those reasons as well.
- 8:01This is comment question from Simone Joe Moore on LinkedIn.
- 8:07And it's, this is fairly large. And actually, folks, I'm going
- 8:10to ask you to keep your questions on the shortish side
- 8:13so that the host that's me can more easily sort of read them.
- 8:19But here's what she says. It's a, it's a very interesting
- 8:22point. She says there's a growing
- 8:24concern of employees getting too attached personally to the
- 8:28company AI or using their own AI.
- 8:32And therefore, there's 2 problems that arise #1 they're
- 8:36putting inherent bias into the system and sharing far too
- 8:41personal data, and there's not enough guidance.
- 8:45And #2 is when they leave the organization, they're exposing
- 8:49that organization and themselves to mental health, separation
- 8:56anxiety, to the AI that they've been using.
- 9:01It does also point to the fact that training is not simply how
- 9:05to increase the output of the activities you do day-to-day,
- 9:08but training is also how to manage risk of AI.
- 9:12So are you introducing biases, not just about the personal
- 9:14information you share, but you know, if you're in talent
- 9:17acquisition, are you introducing bias to the process?
- 9:20So one is around training on risk, I think is incredible and
- 9:23probably a place that companies have under invested and then
- 9:26training on, you know, how the AI works and how it's using your
- 9:30data. And I think the more we see
- 9:31employees understand the mechanics behind the models, the
- 9:36more we see them using it in ways that probably help address
- 9:40the first piece of it. I would also encourage folks
- 9:43like, you know, if you're aware of it, which, you know,
- 9:45obviously great with the question.
- 9:47That's the first step is, you know, being aware of it is, you
- 9:50know, there's a lot of places in some of these tools like system
- 9:54instruction, custom instructions inside of GPT, where you can
- 9:57actually do a purposeful job of managing what you're sharing
- 10:02that the GBT should kind of base a big part of its answer on.
- 10:05So a lot, a lot of it there is about training.
- 10:08I do anticipate, by the way, on this second piece or on the
- 10:10emotional attachment that especially now and, and in your
- 10:15Lenovo CIO interview, I think he did a good job of talking about
- 10:18now the prevalence of voice. And I do think I, and I see in
- 10:21my personal life as I use voice mode on many of these tools, it,
- 10:25it does start to establish a little bit of a, a sense of
- 10:28friendship there. It's probably a good reason then
- 10:32to also be using AI in your personal life and not
- 10:35necessarily your enterprise tools.
- 10:38And that might, that might soften the blow a little bit if
- 10:43you were to separate. But I it's going to be a
- 10:45challenge. There's not a perfect solve to
- 10:47the to the second part of that, except I wouldn't encourage
- 10:50personal use outside of outside of work on your own model.
- 10:53I have to say that I also like the voice, and there have been
- 10:58times it's like you kind of forget that you're talking to a
- 11:03machine. It's kind, it listens to you, it
- 11:07gives you know, well thought out creative responses.
- 11:11It comes with nice voices and I, I saw a G PD5 that's coming out
- 11:15with more voices. And I mean, the scary thing is
- 11:17it's, that's the worst it'll ever be.
- 11:20You know, the tools are only improving.
- 11:22And I'm sure part of that is how do they become more more
- 11:25empathetic? Subscribe to the CXO Talk
- 11:28newsletter. Go to cxotalk.com.
- 11:30We have genuinely extraordinary shows coming up.
- 11:36So Simone Joe Moore comes back and she says she thinks that
- 11:40there needs to be more proper HR governance over AI during
- 11:46employee onboarding, role security, how they work within
- 11:50their team, department and organization, as well as an
- 11:53offboarding strategy to address some of these issues.
- 11:57Absolutely true. And I think you see onboarding
- 12:00now becoming exactly to this point, more cross functional.
- 12:03Like it can't be an HR only thing.
- 12:06But certainly how HR constructs learning and development and the
- 12:09and the process around onboarding and offboarding is
- 12:12critical to make sure that they're including it.
- 12:14And, and probably including it more and more because some of
- 12:17the other skills they might be training on as part of the
- 12:19onboarding process now that AI can handle on its own.
- 12:24Yeah, so, so completely agree with that one wholeheartedly.
- 12:27I'd, I'd also say some of the tools that HR organizations and
- 12:323rd party software providers are coming out with a employee
- 12:37engagement platform. So a lot of companies, HR
- 12:39departments are pushing on, hey, can we have a single pane of
- 12:42glass for a chat bot to, to work with employees and be more, you
- 12:48know, asynchronous and self-serve.
- 12:51And I think you'll see the onboarding process also have
- 12:53that where employees are a little bit more willing to ask
- 12:56difficult questions. And so I, I think that it's true
- 13:01in the onboarding process, some of it is structure and some of
- 13:03it is enhanced tools will actually help to deliver that
- 13:06type of training as well. Just in order here on Twitter on
- 13:11X, Arsalan Khan says as a disruptive tool, do you think
- 13:18organizations are not adopting AI fast enough due to the lack
- 13:23of vision by the executive leadership?
- 13:27In many cases, I do think that executives are struggling with
- 13:31the uncertainty and they don't have a concrete vision that if
- 13:35they try to communicate, would be compelling to the workforce.
- 13:39So I do think articulating the vision is 1.
- 13:42What's fundamental to the question is, are they thinking
- 13:45about AI disruptively enough? And I would say no to that as
- 13:49well. A lot of companies right now are
- 13:51challenging with near term issues and cost pressure and
- 13:54inflation in geopolitical. And so a lot of the uses of AI
- 13:59in the initiatives that companies are pushing on are too
- 14:02incremental. It is how to use AI to further
- 14:05automate tasks or specific parts of a workflow.
- 14:09And they're losing an opportunity to actually rethink
- 14:12the workflow end to end. And I mean, that might mean
- 14:16consolidating roles. It certainly is how humans and
- 14:19agents are going to work together to deliver a more
- 14:22seamless workflow. It's not just automating
- 14:24specific tasks. And so one pitfall, the
- 14:28companies have certainly experienced this thinking too
- 14:31incrementally and and consequently, you're not going
- 14:33to articulate an incremental vision.
- 14:35So yeah, absolutely. We call that reshaping, either
- 14:38reshaping a function or reshaping A workflow that might
- 14:41be cross functional. You do have to completely almost
- 14:45almost clean sheet design what that should look like so that
- 14:48you can have a meaningful enough and an opportunity maximizing
- 14:54enough approach to using AI. Kurt Milne on X says that if
- 15:02only 20% of an employee group is using AI, and that group has a
- 15:09range of skills and results, then the overall benefit may not
- 15:15meet expectations. No, that's right.
- 15:19That's why adoption is the biggest challenge facing
- 15:22companies right now in terms of getting the value they're
- 15:25looking for out of it. And, and frankly, if you're
- 15:27rolling out tools that only 20% are using it, it's also a little
- 15:30bit deflating. And I'm certainly, I'm certain
- 15:34for the decision makers to see low adoption like that.
- 15:37And for the employees who you know in that case, I I think the
- 15:4020% might be coming from my comment earlier in that case
- 15:42where 80% of the employees were excited about it.
- 15:45Kurt Milne comes back with a really interesting question.
- 15:50He says are there new cognitive skills needed to use AI?
- 15:56For example to run, you run AI three times and you get 3
- 16:01different outputs. Then the need to spend time and
- 16:04mental cycles reading and comparing to pick the best
- 16:07answer, and that is a different skill than copy editing.
- 16:13The path on that one specifically is you're going to
- 16:15start to see agents that smash, you know, feedback up against
- 16:20three models and try to avoid hallucinations, which is great.
- 16:23It's what I do. I'm nervous about hallucinations
- 16:26and how I use it. So I'll take the output from one
- 16:28and put it in the out there and, you know, pressure test it.
- 16:31So yeah, that that is that is a skill set or competency that is
- 16:34changing in some of the roles. You could take customer service
- 16:37too. I think a lot of companies have
- 16:39a vision that a customer service representative who right now is
- 16:43looking at, you know, dashboard with multiple screens and swivel
- 16:47chairing between them, getting instructed by, you know, those
- 16:51tools on what to do. That role might completely
- 16:56change to actually almost a manager of agents and and that
- 17:00individual then is almost like a telecommunications network
- 17:04operation center where they're looking for trends that are
- 17:07coming back from the agents themselves.
- 17:10They're looking for, Hey, when and how do I, you know,
- 17:13intercept some of these customer conversations?
- 17:15So the the skills of being a a manager and observer of agents
- 17:20and knowing when to step in or when to pressure test what
- 17:23they're doing is going to be prevalent in many jobs that
- 17:26currently don't require that at all right now.
- 17:29And and don't usually even, you know, recruit for that type of
- 17:32skill set. I also think like the, there's
- 17:36another one on this cognitive to some degree that being really
- 17:40eager and willing to learn from the AI.
- 17:44So again, working with software developers talking about vibe
- 17:47coding and talking about how to introduce AI into their
- 17:50workflow. Some of the most like exciting
- 17:54interactions I saw the developers have with the tools
- 17:56is like asking a question, OK, why are you suggesting I do
- 17:59that? And so really like embedding
- 18:01into the day-to-day like mindset of how do I use the tools as I'm
- 18:06using them to also help instruct me on what they're doing and
- 18:10potentially improve how I think about and do the job as well.
- 18:14So yeah, IA lot of new cognitive skills.
- 18:16You always hear creativity will be more valued.
- 18:19And I think creativity will be introduced as part of many jobs
- 18:22that currently don't demand it. Critical thinking because of
- 18:25hallucinations. All all of these competencies, I
- 18:27think will be magnified in their importance.
- 18:30There's so much that you just packed into that response, but
- 18:34one of the things that kind of grappling with right now is when
- 18:42you have employees that are managing groups of agents rather
- 18:50than other people as employees, it raises a whole host of
- 18:58issues, not just about job displacement, but definitely
- 19:04raises that issue, but the nature of job augmentation with
- 19:11AI and the relationship of jobs to AI.
- 19:15Can you kind of unpack that for us a little bit?
- 19:19You're going to see a lot of roles either working side by
- 19:22side with agents in a collaborative way or augmented
- 19:24way, or roles that are having to manage agents.
- 19:27It's it's a completely different muscle to build.
- 19:30You mentioned earlier about treating AI like people.
- 19:33Your Jensen Wong talk about, you know, the CIO is the CHRO in the
- 19:37future. Moderna integrated those two
- 19:39roles. So I do think one element of
- 19:42that is really being clear on the role that the agents
- 19:46playing, not just how the role might change for the human, but
- 19:49the role that the agents playing.
- 19:51And then that human who's working side by side with them
- 19:55or looking over many of those agents, their ability to to
- 19:59train it and coach it and intervene to give it more, you
- 20:02know, prescriptive detail. A lot of how the interaction
- 20:05with agents will take place is very much like a manager and a
- 20:10frontline employee where it is, it's collaborative, it's
- 20:12coaching, it's training. I think thankfully the
- 20:16performance reviews and the work life balance matter less for
- 20:20agents, which I know it's been, you know, talked about a lot or
- 20:23or maybe in the future, you know, we get agents who are.
- 20:27Who are very interested in those things.
- 20:28But yeah, I do a lot of components of the day-to-day
- 20:31life with an agent and how employees and even frontline
- 20:34employees like my customer service example earlier are now
- 20:37going to become managers, I think is really important.
- 20:39I think you'll also see, and again, maybe back to the
- 20:42cognitive point, a lot of roles and how this is different than
- 20:46how companies were attacking digital for the past 20 years.
- 20:49A lot of roles themselves are going to be expected to identify
- 20:53where to use agents in the workflow and and to be trained
- 20:58on how to build agents because English is code now and you
- 21:01know, some of those tools are pretty easy to spin up new
- 21:03agents. So many different roles are
- 21:05going to be thinking about how can I introduce agents into my
- 21:08workflow? We have two questions, one from
- 21:12Greg Walters, one from Arsalan Khan that both are questioning
- 21:18the role of the C-Suite. And let me just read you both of
- 21:22these and these are kind of loaded questions, but but but I
- 21:27think there's an interesting point here.
- 21:29Greg Walter says AI is the end of the C-Suite.
- 21:33And he also says, aren't AI and LO Ms. an example of the fall of
- 21:40centralized C level command and control, shifting the way that
- 21:45we work away from 19th century managed structures?
- 21:49And Arslan Khan says on Twitter X, if executive leadership has
- 21:56little vision, then what chance of success does the CIO even
- 22:01have? AI is, again, like any other
- 22:04software adoption, which comes down to leadership and culture.
- 22:10In both cases, they're kind of questioning the role of senior
- 22:16leaders. First of all, to the very last
- 22:19point you mentioned on the role of the leaders in helping
- 22:22facilitate AI adoption is like the statistics on that are
- 22:26incredible. We have seen in our research
- 22:29that maybe surprisingly, maybe not, but as adoption of AI
- 22:34increases, fear of job loss increases, like I said, maybe
- 22:39that's intuitive. You see the power of it.
- 22:41And so you see places where I might be able to, to do more of
- 22:46what you do, but the role of the leader is incredibly influential
- 22:50on that. So 65% of employees, if they say
- 22:54their leader is not supportive or doesn't paint the vision,
- 22:57then they are fearful. Whereas for the 25% of employees
- 23:03who say their leader is supportive, it's only 15%.
- 23:06And one of one of those things is being able to articulate that
- 23:10vision that we talked about. And, and it's funny, I, I know
- 23:12you've had other, other individuals on the podcast who
- 23:15talk about the importance of vulnerability and transparency
- 23:18for leaders, which is absolutely true.
- 23:22I think it's also been really challenging for leaders to be
- 23:25vulnerable and admit they don't have a vision for AI.
- 23:28And so you do have to be able to be both.
- 23:31So communicating the vision incredibly important.
- 23:34Now the role of the C-Suite. I, I do think the first question
- 23:37and the second question around what does that mean for the CIO
- 23:40go hand in hand? Because I mean, first of all,
- 23:42the C-Suite is almost by obligation there for fiduciary
- 23:47responsibility, but more importantly for the success of
- 23:50the organization, you are going to see more of those jobs be
- 23:54less based on practitioner skill sets and more based on strategic
- 23:59thinking. And so I think there's a huge
- 24:03role across those different functions for what is the
- 24:06strategy related to the, the business objective that I'm
- 24:09trying to solve. I think that the C-Suite might
- 24:13consolidate roles and you might see new types of roles emerging.
- 24:16Do more companies, as an example, integrate sales and
- 24:18marketing and have a chief revenue officer like a lot of
- 24:21software companies have done potentially.
- 24:24So you might see the C-Suite look different.
- 24:26Now, the role of the CIO, if you go back to that point that the
- 24:29C-Suite is going to be much more strategic.
- 24:32I mean, this would be the point is the CEO who's dealing with a
- 24:35lot of uncertainty right now about what the strategy is
- 24:38looking to a CIO to help be the thought partner there.
- 24:42And I mean, the problem is, again, CEOs are facing so many
- 24:47different challenges right now. I talked about inflation earlier
- 24:49in the multitude of those that they're not as able to stay on
- 24:53top of the cutting edge trends. Whereas a CIOI think is, is
- 24:57actually very excited and enthused by, you know, all of
- 25:00the changes taking place and the new technology is coming out.
- 25:02So the role of CIO is more important now than ever, and
- 25:05their ability to help craft the corporate vision and not just
- 25:10the technology vision for the organization is more important
- 25:14now than ever. That also will require CIOs to
- 25:20upskill their understanding of how the business functions
- 25:25because historically the CIO role was primarily inward
- 25:30looking, taking care of systems. And now what you're describing
- 25:34is CIO slash CHRO role in a way, but not just managing people,
- 25:43managing groups of agents. And managing all of the risk
- 25:48that comes along with agentic workflows, whether it be
- 25:52alignment risk or cyber risk or bias risk, reputational,
- 25:56obviously a multitude of new risks and a larger amount of all
- 26:00of those risks that the CIO is having to deal with and having
- 26:03to support the organization on. You do.
- 26:07I mean, so it's funny because in HR you always talk about the HR
- 26:10business partner. And I think where IT for the
- 26:15past 40 years has consistently struggled with the dynamic of
- 26:20how do I have a tighter relationship with the business,
- 26:23so to speak. Those walls are being torn down.
- 26:27And, and part of that is because a, the importance of technology
- 26:31is visibly so much more important be the, the
- 26:35understanding of technology is increasing as well.
- 26:38You see, you know, whether it be a president or GM of a business
- 26:41unit or a functional leader, more and more of those
- 26:44individuals are more familiar with technology, more informed
- 26:48on the importance of it. And so you see more of a a push
- 26:52pull, like more collaborative relationship with IT in the
- 26:55business, which I think is incredibly healthy.
- 26:58And then, yeah, the complexity of the CIO role is, is expanding
- 27:02your point on managing agents, discovering them, managing all
- 27:04the risks, supporting the organization and all of that.
- 27:08I think is, I mean, again, I think you're going to see CIO
- 27:12being a, a really critical role for companies who are, you know,
- 27:15realizing value from their investments.
- 27:18You should subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter so we can notify
- 27:23you of upcoming shows. So go to cxotalk.com right now,
- 27:27subscribe to our newsletter so you can always join us because
- 27:30we love your questions. David, your AI at Work report
- 27:38describes frontline employees, a gap between frontline employees
- 27:43adopting AI tools. 51% of frontline employees, according
- 27:50to your report, have adopted AI tools and leadership has an 85%
- 27:56level of adoption. Does that indicate resistance
- 28:02from frontline employees or what's going on there?
- 28:06And maybe we can you can take a step back and just give us an an
- 28:11overview of that research. This is a study we conducted
- 28:14globally across 10,000 employees of all levels.
- 28:18It focused on the the impact that people components of an
- 28:23organization have on adoption and success at AI initiatives.
- 28:27A lot of what we focused on was leadership behavior.
- 28:30We focused on talent and skills. We did get into tool quality.
- 28:33We do see, you know, are the tools are the tools, you know,
- 28:37good enough to use is a piece of that too frontline employee.
- 28:42We look at adoption across all different levels of an employee
- 28:45base and we did see that not only was there a significant
- 28:51difference between adoption between leaders and frontline
- 28:54employees, but also the trend stagnated, I think, which
- 28:58surprised us. The adoption of of AI tools at
- 29:01the frontline actually had not increased since the last time we
- 29:04were in the the survey. There's multiple factors for
- 29:08that. I do think part of it is what
- 29:09you said, which is there is a little bit of reticence to do it
- 29:13unless employees are told exactly what the objective is.
- 29:18Many employees feel our data says many employees feel
- 29:21threatened by job loss and so they don't adopt.
- 29:25But there's also like you can de average that answer frontline
- 29:29employee. In many cases, frontline
- 29:30employees have less use for AI than leaders do.
- 29:35You know, you're looking at retail store employees and field
- 29:39technicians who are more and more using it.
- 29:41But you know, there's a lot of on the ground labor that takes
- 29:44place where AI is not going to be an important a piece of
- 29:49technology for the the employee to use in their day-to-day
- 29:52lives. I'd say the other, the other
- 29:54thing it highlights, which, you know, keeps me up at night, is I
- 29:58do think that leaders have observed that that potential
- 30:04disruption to jobs and potential threat of, of, of AI to the jobs
- 30:09is probably as pronounced for leaders as it is for frontline
- 30:12employees. I think there's been a lot of
- 30:14commentary and, and rightfully so, that that white collar labor
- 30:18and that management all the way up to the top, you know, there's
- 30:23a lot of opportunity to automate a lot of administrative tasks
- 30:27and, and make that part of the workforce more efficient too.
- 30:29So I think they realize, you know, you need to stay ahead of
- 30:32the curve and and get familiar with the tools.
- 30:34What should business and technology leaders be doing in
- 30:40order to encourage broader adoption?
- 30:44I do think how they prioritize which initiatives the push on
- 30:47has probably changed historically for digital
- 30:50investment. You said, you know, it's impact
- 30:53versus feasibility or time and there is a new dimension that
- 30:56does get into the leader piece and does influence adoption a
- 30:59lot on selecting initiatives that also reduce the toil of an
- 31:06employee's life. And again, it may be why leaders
- 31:09are using it more is administrative tasks, as an
- 31:11example, are something that employees would prefer to not
- 31:16have to do and to hand off to AI.
- 31:18So how leaders prioritize initiatives and how they include
- 31:22employee centricity in the decisions they make on where to
- 31:25invest, I think matters significantly.
- 31:28I mentioned vision and I just touched on a more specific part
- 31:31of a vision, which is objective setting.
- 31:33So being able to really clearly communicate what the intent of
- 31:38the impact of AI usage is as as an example, the tech company I'm
- 31:42working with, with their software engineers, obviously
- 31:46huge opportunity to improve productivity.
- 31:48This company has no interest in reducing the size of that
- 31:52workforce or the cost of that workforce.
- 31:54In many cases across companies I'm working with, they're so far
- 31:57behind on their digital road map that they are absolutely looking
- 32:01for quad code and all of the different tools that help cursor
- 32:06all the tools that help support software engineering as a means
- 32:09to accelerate their road map. No interest in cost savings on
- 32:12that front for this company, but because they haven't said that
- 32:15specifically, most of the frontline employees we talked to
- 32:18are worried about that and we see their adoption not be what
- 32:21we think it could be. So that's another piece of
- 32:24leader. The the third one that came out
- 32:26in the research is leaders modeling the right behavior.
- 32:31And I think that comes in two forms.
- 32:33One is using it themselves, which we do see leaders doing.
- 32:37And that we had this funny, I was in India last week and I was
- 32:40meeting with Aceo and his team and they were preparing for a
- 32:43board meeting and they created custom GPTS for different board
- 32:47members. And I mean, you could debate
- 32:50the, you know, the cost benefit trade off and all of that.
- 32:52It was a hilarious use case that I'm imagine a lot of the C-Suite
- 32:56executives are starting to learn how to do.
- 32:59And I was like, you need to tell your employees some of these
- 33:01stories so they understand that you're embracing the technology
- 33:04too, and that you're taking the time to upskill yourself on it.
- 33:09And the the last piece, I was so modeling the right behaviors.
- 33:12It also comes in the form of communication.
- 33:14And are you setting, you know, a positive tone around AI and the
- 33:17benefits that it can have on augmenting, augmenting the
- 33:20workforce? The last one is investing in
- 33:22training. If if you are a company facing
- 33:24cost pressure, you're looking to, you know, reduce people
- 33:28costs with AI tools, then you need to be reinvesting some of
- 33:35that productivity savings in training and upskilling.
- 33:39And if you can cut 25% of time spent, you better be applying 5%
- 33:46or 10% of that back into training the employee, the
- 33:50employee base. And we see it has a huge impact
- 33:53on employee morale. We see it has a huge impact on
- 33:56the effectiveness of adoption. And it's great signalling to the
- 34:02workforce that that you're not just doing it myopically, but
- 34:06that you have more of a plan around it.
- 34:08So upskilling is another big piece that leaders can really
- 34:10invest in. At the same time, yes, leaders
- 34:15should be investing in reskilling, but there is a lot
- 34:19of temptation to use AI purely for cost cutting purposes.
- 34:23Let's get rid of, you know, it's industrial automation only.
- 34:27It's done with agents as opposed to, you know, people, you know
- 34:32machines. That's been true, you know,
- 34:35since predictive AI to your point and you know, finance
- 34:38organizations have used it to improve forecasting and reduce
- 34:42some of the people cost they put into forecasting.
- 34:45So undeniably that's true. My point there is they need to
- 34:48be reinvesting some of that savings and you can't as we
- 34:51would say you know how do you cash the check on productivity
- 34:54if it's in cost, you need to be reinvesting some of them.
- 34:57Elizabeth Shaw has an interesting question and she
- 35:01says you talked about rethinking workflows.
- 35:07This is not a quick process and is fraught with business danger.
- 35:11For remember, there were plenty of organizations that
- 35:14experienced business emergencies and failed projects when quote
- 35:19UN quote redesigning workflows for digital transformation and
- 35:24ERP. Being a former product manager
- 35:27and software engineer, this one touches on the software
- 35:29development life cycle. And they say, you know, how does
- 35:33the bill become a lot? Well, you have market research
- 35:35and consumer insights, customer experience work.
- 35:40You got product management, UIUX solution architecture,
- 35:44enterprise architecture, DeVos front end, full stack
- 35:46engineering data. Like everyone here probably
- 35:49knows all the SDLC. And we've had some organizations
- 35:52say, how do I turn that eleven person team that I don't really
- 35:56know if it's a 2 pizza box team anymore.
- 35:58How do I take that eleven person team and do it with three people
- 36:03using agents? That is a disruptive change
- 36:07exactly to the question. That would be a disruptive
- 36:10change to that workflow that is rife with risk.
- 36:13I would say the first one is just quality risk.
- 36:15Like can those three people actually sufficiently do those
- 36:19jobs at the same level of quality?
- 36:21And then what would the downstream impact be by having a
- 36:23lower degree of quality? But you absolutely, if you're
- 36:27thinking about it end to end, have to have a plan.
- 36:30You need to do it so that your near term decisions, you're
- 36:32making an AI investment and with your people, you're not going to
- 36:36try to rewind those later. You need to have the plan, but
- 36:39call it a three-year end to end vision.
- 36:41And then you need to be looking at what are the proper steps
- 36:44along the way to get to that plan that allow for, you know,
- 36:49some of the risks that you describe, whether it be skilling
- 36:52risks or cultural risks by, you know, that type of disruptive
- 36:55stuff. I think you'll see org
- 36:57restructuring too as part of that I mentioned earlier kind of
- 37:01sales and marketing. You know, you could think about
- 37:04engineering a product, things like that.
- 37:05Companies are not just going to be changing the workflow and how
- 37:10people like the ways of working, but also will be rethinking
- 37:14their organizational structures as part of that.
- 37:16Or if they don't, I think it it increases the risk for sure.
- 37:21Microsoft Research recently came out with a very interesting
- 37:25report where they described jobs that are most likely to be
- 37:30affected or displaced by AI and jobs least likely.
- 37:36And the top jobs that they said were going to be displaced are
- 37:41interpreters and translators, historians, passenger
- 37:46attendants, and we could say parking parking lot attendants.
- 37:50I'm sure we've all been to automated parking lots.
- 37:53And you have to pull out your phone and try to figure out how
- 37:55it works. Sales reps.
- 37:57And among the the least likely to be affected are dredge
- 38:04operators and lock operators. You know, locks like on bodies
- 38:11of water. I live next to Volter's lock on
- 38:14the Thames in Maidenhead, England.
- 38:16It was one of the most exciting things in my day.
- 38:19I was watching the locks work. I can imagine that is a
- 38:21difficult one to replace. Yes, I, I would say also like to
- 38:26to pile on the ones that I'm sure will be in increased demand
- 38:29is if you look at the amount of infrastructure investment that
- 38:32the US and other countries are making on their power as well as
- 38:36in semiconductor manufacturing, there's a lot of both blue
- 38:39collar and white collar work that's needed there that will be
- 38:44I think immune to the the impact of AI.
- 38:48So I do think there's a lot of manual task labor at the front
- 38:52line that we talked about earlier that is highly immune,
- 38:55as you mentioned, and I do. That's going to have an
- 38:57implication, by the way, on education generally.
- 39:00And I know we've talked about, you know, how the education
- 39:03system works for a long time now.
- 39:06But but because those jobs are going to be an increased demand,
- 39:09we're going to need to rethink how we're building skills and
- 39:12building career paths so that we can encourage individuals to
- 39:15step into those roles. There are many jobs, by the way,
- 39:20that will be significantly impacted by AI, but it will not
- 39:24lead to job loss necessarily, but actually just an incredible
- 39:27explosion of, you know, work in that space.
- 39:31You could take software engineering.
- 39:32I'm sure there's going to be a lot.
- 39:34I wondered if lawyers who people say are potentially, you know,
- 39:38there's a lot of automation there.
- 39:39Will there be 100 times the legal case like you do?
- 39:43You do wonder how much people use the productivity
- 39:46improvements from AI to increase output and activity versus just
- 39:52replace human labor. On this topic of training and
- 39:57skilling, a recent Fortune article warned that Gen.
- 40:02Z should learn AI, but their job prospects may still be difficult
- 40:09because of structural changes caused by AI.
- 40:15So what advice do you have for folks in Gen.
- 40:18Z who are going to be facing this wall of automation?
- 40:23You're seeing it some right now. Well, I, I believe I read that
- 40:27unemployment rate for recent grads has ticked up a little
- 40:30bit. And it's interesting.
- 40:31We don't talk about it, but I have a 18 year old daughter
- 40:33who's about to go off to college.
- 40:35So there's a lot of conversation about how AI is going to impact
- 40:38her, you know, post college career and, and what she should
- 40:40study and all those things. I mean, 11 great thing about
- 40:43Gen. Z is I'm positive that they will
- 40:45be highly adaptable and resilient.
- 40:47They're obviously the savviest users of digital technology and
- 40:51it's already embedded into most of the apps that they're using.
- 40:54So at least they'll have the familiarity with the tools.
- 40:56Now what are they going to do from a job perspective?
- 41:00You're going to see an incredible explosion of
- 41:02innovation and new companies and new industries that emerge.
- 41:06I just like we did with.com and I think that Gen.
- 41:09Z will be on the forefront just like, you know, a lot of them
- 41:12created the YouTube creator industry out of nothing.
- 41:16I think you'll see a lot of really neat new industries
- 41:18emerge from the creativity that comes from that age group.
- 41:22I do think probably their career looks very different than what
- 41:25my career looked like. But I think that's true between,
- 41:28you know, myself and my father as well.
- 41:30So that's, that's just the nature of time and how we
- 41:33evolved. But but it is a concern and and
- 41:35like I mentioned, I do think it's a concern too on where they
- 41:38spend their time and how they invest in skills leading up to
- 41:41entering the workforce. Absolutely.
- 41:44You mentioned earlier this time dividend that arises from AI
- 41:51automation. It raises the question to what
- 41:55extent are these benefits real? So as companies adopt AI, will
- 42:02they really migrate employees to higher value work or as we were
- 42:07talking earlier, will, will these employees simply be made
- 42:10redundant and fired as part of garden variety cost cutting
- 42:15measures? So how do you think this all
- 42:16plays out? It's dangerous to only focus on
- 42:20the cost measures. And, and, and here's why,
- 42:22because I think a lot of companies who are probably
- 42:25asking those questions are also potentially ripe for disruption
- 42:30or their industry, you know, being disrupted.
- 42:33And so I think you will see part of the time dividends start to
- 42:37go toward innovation. If you think about the old
- 42:39Google model, and it might still currently be, but I, I know it
- 42:42from a long time ago of, you know, spending 20% of your time
- 42:45thinking about other, you know, blue sky initiatives are working
- 42:48on it. You will see companies more
- 42:51strategically allocate time from this productivity savings and
- 42:55time dividend toward innovation. And, and it's because I think a
- 42:59lot of companies are going to start realizing the disruptive
- 43:01threat of, of, of disruption. Obviously, I think the other
- 43:06piece on on time dividend, and I'll use a specific example
- 43:08because you asked like, will they do higher value activities
- 43:12again, going back to software development, It's going to be
- 43:14true in marketing as well. And we see that a little bit
- 43:17talking to a company about using AI to improve the productivity
- 43:23of the daily coding. And that individual, that team
- 43:27actually was dealing with legacy IT that has a bunch of
- 43:30interdependencies. It's all the technical debt that
- 43:33in all of our enterprise listeners here deal with
- 43:35everyday and they have not been able to spend the time and the
- 43:40thinking power on refactoring code and how do we design this
- 43:45is a Java 8 to Java 11 upgrade or something to that nature.
- 43:49And so it's like the strategy behind improving the quality of
- 43:54the existing assets that the company has, I think will be
- 43:57increasingly an important role for for the time dividend that
- 44:01you're describing right now. Back to the vision point, I do
- 44:04think if companies aren't using it for cost savings, then many
- 44:10companies are not being creative enough or forward thinking
- 44:13enough to not just say, OK, do more of the same.
- 44:17So if you think about that example I just use, it's like
- 44:19you could just say, OK, go build more code and you know, go
- 44:23deploy more code. Instead they're saying OK, let's
- 44:26go re architect. So being really thoughtful
- 44:28about, you know, leaders and setting the expectations for how
- 44:32you're using the time, I think it's really important we see
- 44:35that at BCG as well. You know, we've rolled out a lot
- 44:38of AI tools for our consulting staff.
- 44:40They say they're saving time. You know, we wonder, OK, are
- 44:44they sleeping more at night? Because for us, in a job where
- 44:47our employees work really hard and work life balance is
- 44:50increasingly important, it's like, great.
- 44:52Yeah. Our goal with the productivity
- 44:54is, you know, they can get more time to have a more sustainable
- 44:57work life, but you need a plan for what you're going to do with
- 45:00it. To your point, I don't think
- 45:02that everyone is just going to say do more of the same thing.
- 45:05That would be myopic. On the subject of consulting, I
- 45:11recently saw a demo of agentic AI tools that are designed
- 45:16specifically to replace junior consulting consultants doing
- 45:21research and gathering information.
- 45:24How real is this AI threat in consulting?
- 45:30It's an incredibly helpful tool for our consultants to use is,
- 45:35is one thing. So and, and what I mean by that
- 45:39is yes, it does do a lot of the work that many of our
- 45:42consultants do. So there's a threat side of
- 45:44that. And then in the near term,
- 45:46there's a, it takes a lot of toil out of their job and allows
- 45:48them to be more strategic. I think it opens up
- 45:52opportunities for new business models for us.
- 45:54You know, are there opportunities as an example for
- 45:57us to provide more of a software as a service and a consultant as
- 46:01a service? Because we might think we can
- 46:03train that type of model better than anyone else can.
- 46:06That's one example. But we are tracking and, and by
- 46:08the way, I think all of us partners, before we go into any
- 46:11of our client meetings, are doing deep research on the, on
- 46:14the client. We are pressure testing our own
- 46:17analysis and saying, if I'm a client, what would I be seeing
- 46:20from AI? And are we exceeding that bar
- 46:23and justifying, you know, the fees that we charge?
- 46:25So I think that it's been very important for consulting to
- 46:28appreciate, you know, the, the side by side threat.
- 46:31We actually have been measuring what components of the value we
- 46:36provide our clients are replaced by AI, to your point, and it
- 46:40stretches across many different dimensions, industry expertise
- 46:43and all that kind of stuff. And one place that AI has not
- 46:46come close to cracking the nut is our ability to understand our
- 46:51clients and their needs at a company specific level very
- 46:54deeply and to tailor our answers.
- 46:57Right now, if you run deep research or if you're using any
- 47:00off the shelf tools to try to solve the strategic problems
- 47:04that we saw on a day-to-day basis, it's going to be more
- 47:07generic and more for the industry rather than more
- 47:10specific to the company. And I think that's harder to
- 47:14replace. You'll of course see enterprise
- 47:16models being trained over time, I'm sure.
- 47:18But right now we feel like our ability to really think with the
- 47:22lens of our specific client in mind and tailor solutions for
- 47:26them is is improved because of this.
- 47:28Like back to the point, I think it frees up our time to think
- 47:31more about those strategic tasks.
- 47:33This question about OR issue about LLMS not providing deep
- 47:41company specific information. I wonder if that's at least
- 47:47partially a data problem because I have seen a number of
- 47:52companies recently that go out to essentially aggregate
- 47:58interrogate databases across a company.
- 48:02And once you start doing that, you you build up the data that
- 48:08you need that a sufficiently fast and powerful LLM could then
- 48:12use to report back whatever depth you might want on all
- 48:19aspects of the company, sales, marketing, everything,
- 48:21customers, you name it. Yes, and using a generative AI
- 48:26as a potential mechanism to leapfrog some of the like this
- 48:31is I think part of I think this is partly in there like using
- 48:35Jenny I to actually leapfrog and maybe mitigate some of the lack
- 48:38of connectedness with company data is also an opportunity.
- 48:41I think you're spot on. And and that is fed, you know,
- 48:44historically into things like retrieval augmented generation
- 48:47where you're using off the shelf LLM you're you're injecting some
- 48:52first party data in there to get something that's more company
- 48:54specific. I think that's absolutely right.
- 48:56That's part of the near term future.
- 48:59I think The thing is our clients are not necessarily saying that
- 49:03that is the highest priority place for them to be spending
- 49:06their time. And in a world where as we know,
- 49:08talent is so slim and IT talent specifically and tech talent
- 49:12specifically and core business needs for a company are so
- 49:16pronounced and there's so much opportunity to improve there.
- 49:19I have not seen a lot of our clients dedicate a lot of time
- 49:23and resources to what you just described because they they have
- 49:28incredibly important priorities they're pushing on in parallel.
- 49:32So. Arsalan Khan says I'll just read
- 49:35his question verbatim. What about power of 1 AI in one
- 49:41department versus AI in another department?
- 49:44Whichever department has more power, people, revenue, will
- 49:48they get their way? Who is the AI referee?
- 49:53Right. Well, and you've seen that in
- 49:54like data reporting and analytics now for the past 10
- 49:57years where every organization has their own analytics team
- 50:01that's creating their own dashboards.
- 50:04I think there's some truth to that.
- 50:05I think it, it points toward the importance of IT and the
- 50:09enterprise IT strategy and platform strategy.
- 50:12I think one danger that companies are facing is the
- 50:15fragmentation of platform decisions, you know, across
- 50:18different functions. And so resource allocation, to
- 50:22your point that comes from central IT and the distribution
- 50:25of tech talent toward different functions is increased in
- 50:29importance. There's something about human
- 50:32nature there. And the question that's like, I
- 50:35think of course different parts of the organization are probably
- 50:37going to have more power and influence than others.
- 50:41AI is not solving for, you know, basic human nature at this
- 50:44point, for better or for worse. So that will probably be the
- 50:47case. I think it's really important to
- 50:49be at ACEO and CIO level though, and how the strategy is crafted
- 50:53there. Because what you don't want to
- 50:55do is have a lot of function specific platforms that again,
- 50:59like only really harden how the organization currently works.
- 51:03And the more you can make the platforms cross functional, the
- 51:07more you'll be able to realize a more seamless customer
- 51:10experience. So ideally you're not having
- 51:12those siloed platforms. Your AI at Work report talks
- 51:17about global differences in AI adoption.
- 51:20I think this is very, very important for people to
- 51:22understand. The report states that
- 51:24respondents from the global S have significantly higher
- 51:28adoption rates than in the West. For example, India and folks
- 51:32listen to this has India has 92% adoption compared to 64% in the
- 51:39US. Can you just tell us about the
- 51:42implications of this? It seems very profound to me.
- 51:45The implications are right and I just came back from Delhi in
- 51:48Mumbai and it's incredible what they're doing there.
- 51:51Some of it is job specific. You know, we talked earlier
- 51:54about just the nature of some roles using it more than others.
- 51:57India obviously has an incredibly large and strong
- 51:59population of software developers and those types of
- 52:02roles that are more suited to use it.
- 52:04Demographic difference it does. It points out some of the
- 52:07differences in demographics too and where some of just countries
- 52:11will differ because they're either a younger workforce or a
- 52:15more aging workforce. India on the younger side
- 52:18relative to some of the developed markets it.
- 52:21But your last point I think is the most important, which are it
- 52:24does have implications on what you think the future looks like
- 52:275 years from now. Now I think India like amazing
- 52:31users. You'll probably see a lot of
- 52:33innovation coming from there because of the usage and because
- 52:37of time. Other than all we talked about
- 52:39there, I do think the US while behind on adoption is obviously
- 52:43making very important infrastructure strategic
- 52:46decisions. And so you'll still see despite
- 52:48some of the lack of adoption, I think the incredibly important
- 52:52AI capabilities coming out of the US, but it is it is
- 52:55fascinating to see there's a very broad difference across
- 52:58geographies on, on usage adoption fear.
- 53:01India was also one of the highest in terms of their fear
- 53:04of job loss with AI, which goes back to leader point their
- 53:09interest in shadow. IT was also pronounced in high
- 53:12individuals who are not provided the right tools are using tools
- 53:15on their own, which is I think scary for CIOs and highly
- 53:18prevalent and we talked about that in the report.
- 53:21So a lot of interesting geospecific Nuggets in there.
- 53:24David, fundamentally, are you an optimist, A pessimist, or do you
- 53:32think this world is so confusing that who knows?
- 53:35I'm a huge optimist. I'm not going to end on a down
- 53:37point. It'll be down and up real fast.
- 53:39I had a daughter, 4 kids. One of my daughter's passed away
- 53:43from pediatric cancer a few years ago and I viewed it so
- 53:48close to breakthrough. So I'm an optimist because of
- 53:50the impact that AI is going to have on science and on public
- 53:55health. And so I think you have to be
- 53:58excited just about the innovation that's going to come
- 54:00through there. I think human ingenuity and all
- 54:03of the past data we have in terms of job loss and recreation
- 54:06is like, we're an incredibly resilient population and
- 54:10incredibly creative population. So the doomer side of it, I, I'm
- 54:14very optimistic. I think that we continue to
- 54:17thrive. We, we find the right ways to
- 54:19use AI as a helpful tool to make our lives better.
- 54:22So very, very much an optimist. And with that, a huge thank you
- 54:26to David Martin. He's global lead for people and
- 54:30organization at Boston Consulting Group.
- 54:33David, I can't thank you enough. Thank you for being here with us
- 54:36today. Thank you Michael.
- 54:38I've I've loved loved the time today and really appreciate what
- 54:41you do. Your your podcasts are
- 54:43fascinating. Encourage folks to sign up.
- 54:45So it's great. Yes, yes, folks, before you go,
- 54:50subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter.
- 54:52Go to cxotalk.com. We have genuinely extraordinary
- 54:58shows coming up. You just need to look at the
- 55:02newsletter to see what we have coming up.
- 55:04I mean, really great ones, everybody.
- 55:06Thank you for watching again. Thank you to David Martin, and
- 55:10we'll see you again next time. Take care everyone.