Latest / Culture Project: Creativity, art & storytelling / Playing Chess Against Yourself: The Art of Internal Monologue | Culture Project
Transcript
- I watched a woman play chess against herself in a park this morning, and I swear the air around her was vibrating with a silence so loud it made my teeth ache. It wasn’t just a game; it was a conversation with a ghost she carried in her pocket. Let’s look closer at that image for a moment. She sat on a wooden bench, the kind that’s been bleached gray by years of rain and sun. One hand held the white pieces, the other the black. There was no opponent sitting across from her. No one to blame for a bad move, no one to thank for a clever trap. Just her, the board, and the relentless ticking of time. You might think this sounds lonely, or perhaps even a bit mad. But I’ve spent enough years in dusty archives restoring fragile books to know that solitude is rarely empty. It’s full. It’s crowded with voices we usually keep quiet. When you play against yourself, you are not just moving wood and plastic. You are externalizing the arguments you have with yourself every single day. The rational self versus the impulsive self. The cautious self versus the reckless self. Each piece represents a different facet of your personality, locked in a perpetual diplomatic negotiation. Chess is often called a language. But when you record the internal monologue, you turn it into poetry. Think about the questions you ask yourself when you’re stuck. 'Should I take the risk?' becomes a bishop sliding diagonally through danger. 'Is this safe?' becomes a pawn moving forward, square by square, slowly but surely. In that park, I saw her furrow her brow. She picked up a knight, hovered over a square, put it down, then picked it up again. That hesitation? That is where the truth lives. Most of us live our lives in a blur of decision-making without ever stopping to listen to the debate. We act on impulse or habit. But here, in this frozen moment of observation, I realized how much energy we waste trying to convince ourselves we are right. The recording of that thought process is an act of radical honesty. It forces you to articulate why you want something, not just what you want. It strips away the excuses. Now, imagine if she had spoken those thoughts out loud. Imagine the transcript of that match. It wouldn’t be a clean, logical sequence of moves. It would be messy. It would be contradictory. One moment she’s confident, declaring checkmate in three moves, and the next, she’s doubting her entire strategy because a single pawn looked at her wrong. Beauty is messy, isn’t it? We tend to think of art as polished, finished, perfect. But the most profound art is often the documentation of the struggle. When we write down our internal monologues during creative blocks or difficult choices, we aren’t solving problems. We are witnessing them. We are becoming the audience to our own confusion. And there is a strange comfort in that. It validates the chaos. It tells you that it’s okay to feel torn. It’s okay to change your mind. In fact, changing your mind is the whole point of the game. I remember an episode we did recently about unfilmed screenplays. We talked about writing stories for an audience of one. This feels like the physical embodiment of that idea. You are directing a play where the characters are all versions of you. The protagonist who wants to leave the job. The antagonist who is terrified of poverty. The supporting character who reminds you of your mother’s advice. By playing chess against yourself while recording these voices, you give them space to breathe. You stop suppressing the parts of you that feel weak or fearful. Instead, you let them sit at the table. You let them make their case. Maybe the fearful voice makes a terrible strategic move. Maybe it sacrifices a queen for no reason. But that sacrifice tells you something important. It reveals what you value more than victory. Perhaps you value peace. Or safety. Or love. The move itself is less important than the motivation behind it. There is a technique in restoration called inpainting. When a book page is torn, we don’t try to hide the tear completely. We fill it with material that matches the texture but acknowledges its presence. We treat the damage as part of the history. Playing chess against yourself is a form of psychological inpainting. You are filling the gaps in your understanding with conscious thought. You are acknowledging the tears in your logic. I want you to try something small today. Not a full hour-long match. Just five minutes. Set up a simple scenario. A choice you’re facing. And play it out. But do not just move the pieces. Speak. Say out loud why you are making each move. Record it on your phone if you have to. Listen back to it later. What do you hear? Do you hear a tyrant? A victim? A child? The story behind the stitch is always more interesting than the fabric itself. Your internal narrative is the fabric. The choices are the stitches. Together, they make the garment of who you are. It takes courage to hear your own thoughts without filtering them. We spend so much time curating our external lives for social media, for colleagues, for friends. We present a version of ourselves that is coherent, successful, and calm. But inside? Inside it’s a cacophony. Recording that cacophony is an act of rebellion. It refuses to let the noise disappear into the ether. It demands that it be witnessed. And when you witness it, you gain power over it. You realize that the scary thoughts are just thoughts. They are not commands. They are suggestions from a frightened part of your psyche that needs to be heard, not obeyed. The chessboard becomes a mirror. Not of your face, but of your fears. And mirrors, however unflattering, are essential tools for navigation. You cannot fix what you refuse to see. So let’s see it. All of it. The brilliant moves and the blunders. The confidence and the doubt. Thank you for letting me into your quiet moments today. Keep listening to the silence. It has a lot to say. Until next time, be gentle with your contradictions. I’m Leona Donnelly, and I’ll be right here when you need to look closer.