Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 11th-Great Western Trail
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin, we look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to Board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. So yesterday Steve
- 0:29we spoke about a classic Golden Age game, and today we're talking about the
- 0:36acme of the Silver Age. Alexander Pister never met a mechanism he didn't like
- 0:44to fucking stick pointlessly into a game, And we're talking about his best game.
- 0:51And is it is the highest on this list? I think it is
- 0:54and well deserved, the only game by him. I really like Great Western
- 0:59Trail Stevie. So I think there's gonna be a lot that we have to
- 1:03agree about in this one in this episode. Is this an episode? It's
- 1:07an episode his calendar entry, and a little bit to disagree about. So,
- 1:11first of all, I will continue to maintain that you have your head
- 1:15so far up your ass about Alexander Fister. You're going around for a seconde
- 1:19with you. You are just a fucking obstreperous, irascible, stubborn cunt on
- 1:25this subject. You have not played enough of his games to really weigh in
- 1:29on that. Have you haven't played Mombasa? No? I haven't you have
- 1:33actually admitted to enjoying Boone Lake because you like, oh my goods. Yeah,
- 1:37it's all right, Yeah, you love broom service. Oh yeah,
- 1:40But well I don't consider. There's Alexander Fistic you don't consider. You don't
- 1:44consider. I know he co designed them, but the ones he co designs
- 1:47tend to be lighter. You tend to be lighter. Yeah. Great Western
- 1:52Trail, though, is where our opinions convert. They do. It's a
- 1:55fantastic game. It was far too long until I played this game. Only
- 2:00played it this year, me too. And when I played it, so
- 2:02I played Boone Lake, and I played my least favorite of his games,
- 2:07fucking shitter Kihit. I think you haven't given Maricaibo a fair ship. I
- 2:10fucking I'm gonna play Pirates of Maracaibo. All right, you're gonna change your
- 2:14mind, fucking pirates of shit. Pirates of Maracaibo is the Maracaibo for you.
- 2:20And but I got three turns into Great Western Trail and went, oh,
- 2:24I get it. This is fucking brilliant. And I just thought it
- 2:30was absolutely fantastic, a brilliant piece of design like you are just such a
- 2:36big I'm illustrated by what a tasteless, marginal twat. You are a big,
- 2:39sprawling silver age piece of design. But nevertheless, who is brilliant?
- 2:45You've got to give him another chance? So I played shitter shit? Co
- 2:49you like my goods? Boone Lake depresses me? Oh my goods? Where
- 2:53to depress you? Because like you think about playing, it's like, oh,
- 2:55I'm gonna play this fucking unwieldy shit for three hours? How I think
- 3:00whenever I hang out? What are you looking at your phone for? I'm
- 3:02gonna look up the Alexander Pister games. Okay, I am a I am
- 3:07a known Fister fanboy. Yeah you are. I think I even have the
- 3:09Alexander Pister Uh what do you call it? On BGG micro badge? I
- 3:16got Alexander micro badge. If he did a fucking I fucking would eat all
- 3:22of it. I'd eat it in front of you. Fucking subscribe a group
- 3:24of coups? Would you? Would you join it? Like lemon Cello likes
- 3:30stone My games. Well, he doesn't have his own publishing company, does
- 3:32no? I know? But if he did, I mean I don't buy
- 3:35every single sign. I haven't played uh Kitchen on the Bumbo Malex, I
- 3:40haven't played cloud Aga. No, it's why do you have to give me
- 3:44such ship just because I like something? Just because I appreciate it? Because
- 3:46I don't like it, you you make some excuse up, but I like
- 3:50anything I do a bux and you'd lick it up and fucking smile. Yeah,
- 3:54you would like. Why can't I enjoy what I enjoy? Are you
- 3:59sticking your nose in that this is going out on the main field? Yeah
- 4:03it is. Yeah, I used to have used to have a reputation so
- 4:08blackout Hong Kong. Yeah, have a copy of it. Haven't played it?
- 4:10I have a copy of it. Haven't played It's very well, haven't
- 4:13even opened it up from the shrink cloud aug haven't played ex finished Into New
- 4:15Dallas, supposed to be very good. Yeah, have you played it?
- 4:19And what the fuck do you know? You don't know anything about anything Great
- 4:24Western Trail blah blah blah blah blah, like lots of versions of Great Western
- 4:28Trail isla sky. Yeah, yet I think I like that. I don't
- 4:31consider that Alexander fist again? Why because it's coach designing about other Austrian lasts?
- 4:36So what so they do lights again? Okay? Rosenberg co designs his
- 4:40games with us. But that's you wouldn't take anything away from him, Okay,
- 4:46Mara Kaibo, we talked about Mumbai, Okay. So I think we're
- 4:51gonna play Mombasa this holiday season, Okay, And I want to hear your
- 4:56opinion about Mombasa, all right. I think a lot of my esteem for
- 5:00Sir rests on Mombasa. The rest of his games. I played one of
- 5:02the first games I acquired in Germany when I moved here, Port Royal.
- 5:06Yeah, I'm played uh sky Mines, which is just Mombasa. So we're
- 5:12gonna play Mombasa. We're gonna get past the like, you know, controversial
- 5:15subject matter, and then we're gonna decide if Mombasa Great Western Trail and Isla
- 5:23Sky and let's say, oh my goods and room service are enough for you
- 5:28enough to like, you know, give him enough, like some kind of
- 5:31a positive airing in the fucking Ben Maddox. I think I fucking know everything
- 5:38about it. I just think he's got games, and I'm the only I'm
- 5:40the fucking arbiter of taste. I just think he's got a massive chest at
- 5:43home, just full of mechanisms, and he just sticks his head in him
- 5:46and goes and then you have a fucking massive chest of consciousness. You just
- 5:51fucking stick your dick. It's all over. It's not thing where you stick
- 5:56your head into a lady's breast and go like he motor boats, board game
- 6:00mechanics, you game, you fucking motor boat bush and hot tape. You
- 6:06fucking you fucking ship them out like you have like hot take diarrhea. Yeah,
- 6:11so why you fucking took you fucking took a one of the like amodium.
- 6:17You fucking took a hot take ammodium, and you fucking sat on the
- 6:20toilet a fucking board game opinions. I remember, you know, I remember
- 6:26last year's Advent calendar being quite collegiate, quite nice. This whole Advent calendar
- 6:30is just us fucking shouts at each other. I'm angry at you for your
- 6:32opinions about Alexander Fister. Let's talk about great one. I love Drink Western
- 6:36Trail, Great Western Trail, Top Game, Great Western Trail, Argentina.
- 6:41I think I enjoyed it even more than yeah, yeah, I loved it.
- 6:43I haven't played in New Zealand yet. One of the dickheads on the
- 6:45discord. And by the way, when I say dickhead, this is action.
- 6:48The steam uh said that they didn't like New Zealand as much, so
- 6:53I'm worry. But it's like sheep instead of cows, right exactly, So
- 6:57I have to give it a chance. So would you find that more sexy?
- 7:00No comment, except you know that joke about like why do New Zealanders
- 7:03have sex with their sheep against the edge of a cliff? Yeah? Because
- 7:06they pushed back? Yeah, exactly. So what is great about great Western?
- 7:11So well, he's American, that's true. So the thing about Alexander
- 7:16Fister and what I think he does really well at all of his games,
- 7:18it is the way he handles cards, Okay, and I think he has
- 7:23this in common with Uve Rosenberg, although the way they do it is quite
- 7:26different. I think the deck management in Marcaibo is great. In bou Lake,
- 7:30it's great. Oh my Goods is entirely a card game. The way
- 7:32cards work in broom Service, yeah, is wonderful. It's the best trick
- 7:36taking game. Yeah, yeah, exactly. We've talked about this great Western
- 7:40trail. I will I will use your word acme. Even though it's like
- 7:43a cheap supermarket in the United States from the nineteen eighties, right the Acme,
- 7:46the Pinnacle, the Znith if you will, of card driven like card
- 7:51driven, I shouldn't say card driven the card driven eurogame or something like that,
- 7:56because like, the cows have multiple functions in the game, true,
- 8:00and there are different ways of acquiring them, and the way the cards interact
- 8:03with the board, it just it just works so well. It's also that
- 8:07wonderful way which you have to plan your route through the board, and I
- 8:11love choices you have to choose. I love the circular motion of the game.
- 8:16It is. But he did this in Boon Lake. He did this,
- 8:18Yeah, but he never does it to the same fucking works so brilliantly.
- 8:22So we were talking the other day about about Concordia and how even though
- 8:30Matt Gertz is a great game designer, he hit paydirts with Concordia in a
- 8:35way that he probably couldn't explain himself. And I think Great Western Trail is
- 8:39this. I think there is a certain alchemy to that game that just makes
- 8:41it gloriously engaging in a way that none of his other games are, I
- 8:46think, apart from Broom Service, which is brilliant I think you're probably right.
- 8:50I'm willing to put broom service in like a separate category of achievement.
- 8:54We need to play Mombasa, and I need to like test my opinion here
- 8:56because I'm so over the moon this year with Great Western Trail. I'm sort
- 9:01of like forgetting my earlier plays of Mombasa. As I recall, they're quite
- 9:05different in how they function. The mechanics are quite different, but the sort
- 9:11of like the intellectual engagement of Mombasa was top tier in my experience. But
- 9:16Great Western Trail has this the way it puts in front of you the choices
- 9:22that you have to make, which cals am I going to keep? Which
- 9:24cals am I going to buy? How am I when? And how am
- 9:28I going to get to Buenos Aires or nice pronunciation, whatever it is.
- 9:33What is it Kansas City or Saint Louis or Kansas City in the original edition?
- 9:39Where in Argentina do you have to go Buenos Like we always talk about
- 9:46how we want interesting choices to make in games, right hard decisions, and
- 9:50Great Western Trail has like such an interesting combination of hard decision. You know
- 9:54what I love about Great Western Trail Unlike his other Games, unlike he's solo
- 9:58on the games. Fuck you is you need to give him more of a
- 10:01chance. I give your chance on the great the most overrated designer. You're
- 10:05a fucking mind right. The fucking podcast is over. Thank you for listening.
- 10:13You can support the show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five g
- 10:16f D and join the discord by going to five g f d dot com.
- 10:22Have a very merry Christmas.