Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / No Easy Getaway: State Court Litigation and the Bankruptcy Discharge
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to No Easy Getaway, State Court Litigation
- 0:07and the Bankruptcy Discharge. My name is John
- 0:11Livingston. I am the program chair of Beverly
- 0:15Hills Bar Association's bankruptcy law section.
- 0:19And I will also be moderating today's program.
- 0:23Just to kick things off, I'd like to give a quick
- 0:27introduction to the bankruptcy law section. We
- 0:30are a younger group of attorneys that are interested
- 0:37in bankruptcy. Many of us work in commercial
- 0:40finance and related industries. And we have section
- 0:45meetings about once a month. Our next section
- 0:48meeting is in two weeks. It's on April 14th.
- 0:52And you can find more information on the HBA's
- 0:55website. So I'd like to start by introducing
- 1:01our speakers today. We have the Honorable Martin
- 1:04Barish, the Honorable Lee Bogdanoff, Uzi Renan
- 1:08and Jay Spillane. Judge Barish has served as
- 1:13a United States Bankruptcy Judge in the Central
- 1:16District of California since 2015, sitting in
- 1:19the Woodland Hills Division. Before taking the
- 1:22bench, he practiced at two prominent Los Angeles
- 1:24bankruptcy boutiques. And he has volunteered
- 1:28at the debtor reaffirmation clinic that's run
- 1:31by public counsel. And if I can give one more
- 1:34housekeeping matter, I'd say that we are actively
- 1:38seeking to recruit volunteers to help with that
- 1:41clinic and other programs run by public counsel.
- 1:44So if you're interested, please reach out to
- 1:46me. And then next is Uzi Renan. Uzi is a partner
- 1:52at Greenberg Gloucester with extensive experience
- 1:55representing creditors, debtors, Chapter 11 creditor
- 1:58committees, court appointed receivers, and bankruptcy
- 2:02trustees. His litigation practice includes fraudulent
- 2:05transfer and preferential transfer avoidance
- 2:09actions, non -dischargeability, asset sales,
- 2:13claims disputes, and bankruptcy appeals. He was
- 2:16honored as bankruptcy lawyer of the year by the
- 2:19Century City Bar Association in 2019 and is a
- 2:23regular contributor to Westlaw's commercial finance
- 2:26newsletter. Jay Spillane is the founding shareholder
- 2:30of Spillane Trial Group PLC, a business firm
- 2:34representing private companies and individuals
- 2:37in high stakes litigation. Over more than three
- 2:40decades, he has tried cases involving entertainment,
- 2:43intellectual property, technology, real estate,
- 2:46finance, corporate control, family wealth, and
- 2:50bankruptcy non -dischargeability. He also handles
- 2:53appeals at all levels, including the seminal
- 2:55Ninth Circuit case, Perfect 10 Inc. versus CC
- 2:58Bill LLC, one of the most cited decisions on
- 3:01internet service provider liability for infringing
- 3:03content. Last but not least, Judge Bogdanoff
- 3:08is a neutral at jams with over 30 years of experience
- 3:12as a nationally recognized bankruptcy and reorganization
- 3:15practitioner, handling some of the largest and
- 3:17most complex cases of their time, including representing
- 3:21Enron, Washington Mutual, and NDMAC estates,
- 3:25and serving as lead counsel in the chapter nine
- 3:28cases of Orange County, California and Jefferson
- 3:31County, Alabama. He subsequently served as a
- 3:35Superior Court Judge in Los Angeles County before
- 3:37joining Jams, where he mediates an arbitrary
- 3:40complex business, commercial, and estate and
- 3:43trust disputes. His bankruptcy litigation experience
- 3:46includes fraudulent transfer, preference, valuation,
- 3:49and related issues. And now let's get started.
- 4:00So I'm going to have Suzanne, share the slides.
- 4:05OK, again, that's the panel. And before we start
- 4:10our discussion with the hypothetical, we have
- 4:13some baseline information that we want to have
- 4:18everyone aware of and bringing to the conversation.
- 4:23So I'm going to hand this off to Uzi to talk
- 4:26about the automatic stay. All right. Well, thank
- 4:29you. As I think everyone knows about the automatic
- 4:33stay and to some degree, almost every practitioner
- 4:37who practices certainly in a state court and
- 4:40federal court and obviously in bankruptcy court
- 4:43understand the concept of a bankruptcy. Once
- 4:46it gets filed, it creates an automatic stay.
- 4:49The question is the degree. It's usually the
- 4:52extent of the automatic stay. without getting
- 4:56too much into detail because they have a short
- 4:58period of time, the idea of it is that it commences
- 5:02or automatically stays any kind of actions that
- 5:06were pending before the bankruptcy, and certainly
- 5:10that could have been commenced before the bankruptcy.
- 5:12And so the idea of it is if a claim arose before
- 5:16the bankruptcy was filed, that claim could have
- 5:19been filed, could have been brought, and it's
- 5:21automatically stayed. the devil's always in the
- 5:25detail as to deciding what is a claim. And you
- 5:28could have situations, especially in mass torts,
- 5:32where the claim may not have arisen until after
- 5:37the bankruptcy because it wasn't discovered,
- 5:39but we won't get into that. The idea of it is
- 5:41it could be more complicated than it sounds,
- 5:43but this is the concept. And obviously the enforcement
- 5:46of judgments, if you have a judgment that happened
- 5:48or was obtained before the bankruptcy, or if
- 5:52you have liens that were obtained before the
- 5:54bankruptcy, or if you wanna file any liens against
- 5:57the bankruptcy, all of those are stayed, any
- 5:59collections against the estate, all of that is
- 6:02stayed. And that's kind of a very broad overview.
- 6:06And that's section 11, USC. That's 11 USC section
- 6:10362A, if you're looking at that. There are exceptions
- 6:14and there are actually 29 exceptions to the automatic
- 6:17stay, which I'm not gonna go into. And that's
- 6:2011 USC section 362B. The idea of it is that there
- 6:24are some circumstances and it's usually related
- 6:27to government actions. It's usually related to
- 6:30criminal actions. The government can certainly
- 6:33continue prosecuting those types of actions.
- 6:36a lot of domestic obligations and disputes including
- 6:40child support and paternity issues and the actual,
- 6:45the solution of marriage as long as it doesn't
- 6:48result in distribution of the assets of the estates.
- 6:52So those are some of the basic exceptions. And
- 6:56then the idea of it is that the automatic stay
- 6:59is not forever. It is certainly open to relief,
- 7:04to exceptions. or to getting a modification termination
- 7:09of the automatic stay through a motion. And that's
- 7:1311 USC section 362D or federal rule bankruptcy
- 7:17procedure 4001, where a party can go in and ask
- 7:21the judge to give them relief, to give them,
- 7:24I guess, an exception to the automatic stay so
- 7:29they can go back to the state court and litigate.
- 7:32or to enforce a judgment or to file the lien
- 7:35that they wanted to do. Usually, you have to
- 7:39prove cause. The question is, what is the cause?
- 7:41That's usually where the litigation is. There
- 7:45are also circumstances where you look at whether
- 7:47the debtor had an equity in the property and
- 7:50whether it's necessary for the effect of reorganization.
- 7:54So those are some basics. Something that every
- 7:57practitioner should know are the risks and the
- 8:01and the damages you could suffer for violating
- 8:04the automatic state. And you certainly should
- 8:07look at 11 USC section 362K, which talks about
- 8:10any individual who is injured by a willful violation
- 8:14of the automatic state can recover actual damages
- 8:16from anyone who violates it willfully. And that
- 8:20includes costs and attorney's fees and even punitive
- 8:23damages. I'll mention the fact that it says any
- 8:26individual. There's been a bad case that talks
- 8:29about the fact that Chapter seven trustee, for
- 8:32example, is not an individual. And so if you
- 8:36violate the automatic stay and the trustee seeks
- 8:39damages, they can't do it under the section.
- 8:43They would have to go to 11 USC section 105A,
- 8:46which gives the bankruptcy court some discretionary
- 8:48power to issue sanctions. And that could be an
- 8:51interesting fight as well. So that's kind of
- 8:54the basic idea of the 362. Thanks, Susie. So
- 9:00let's jump two slides. And I want to now talk
- 9:03about the bankruptcy discharge. And I'm going
- 9:07to hand it off to Judge Barish for this, but
- 9:09I think this is why we're here today. I thought
- 9:15that was a little longer sentence. My pleasure.
- 9:20So so the discharge is frequently the reason
- 9:24why a debtor files for bankruptcy. There are
- 9:29actually different kinds of bankruptcies. Chapter
- 9:3511, for instance, is the chapter for reorganization,
- 9:41typically used for the reorganization of a business,
- 9:44but also available to individuals, usually used
- 9:49by folks that either have a high net worth or
- 9:52do not qualify for any of the other chapters
- 9:57of the code. Chapter 7, which is a liquidating
- 10:01case, or Chapter 13, which is a personal repayment
- 10:07plan. These are all different cases, but all
- 10:10of them involve, at some point in the process,
- 10:13earning a discharge. And what the discharge does
- 10:17is it's If the automatic stay is a temporary
- 10:21injunction, the discharge really is a permanent
- 10:24injunction from the enforcement of a pre -bankruptcy
- 10:29debt. Under California law, my recollection is
- 10:34that the debt does not technically go away for
- 10:37whatever that's worth, but it becomes unenforceable.
- 10:41Now, what are not discharged in bankruptcy are
- 10:44liens. Liens are an interest in property. they
- 10:49are unaffected by the discharge, it's personal
- 10:53liability or impersonal liability on the debt.
- 10:58And it only extends to the debtor. So if the
- 11:03debtor is an individual or corporation getting
- 11:10a discharge, a co -debtor probably does not receive
- 11:16the discharge. unless that code debtor is also
- 11:19going through the bankruptcy process. Other sort
- 11:24of high points you need to know, there are some
- 11:28debts that are not dischargeable in bankruptcy.
- 11:33Some of these are categorical, debts that arise
- 11:36from fraud and fraud -like activity. Those cannot
- 11:42be discharged in bankruptcy because bankruptcy,
- 11:46we like to say, is here for the honest but unfortunate
- 11:50debtor. It is not here for crooks and scofflaws.
- 11:56And so you may be a plaintiff in a fraud case
- 12:05and find your defendant file bankruptcy, hoping
- 12:08to interrupt or disrupt your ability to collect.
- 12:14We're going to talk about that in a few minutes.
- 12:19Ultimately, the debt arising from fraud cannot
- 12:22be discharged, but you may have to bring a civil
- 12:26action within the bankruptcy, what we call an
- 12:29adversary proceeding, to obtain that determination.
- 12:33There are some other discharge exceptions. that
- 12:38are more categorical and don't require you to
- 12:41bring suit. So for instance, if you have a claim
- 12:45against the debtor for domestic support obligation,
- 12:49there may be issues about whether the debt is
- 12:52itself a domestic support obligation, but you
- 12:55don't need to bring a lawsuit. If it's alimony,
- 12:58if it's child support, it will not be discharged.
- 13:02And there are other categories, too many to mention
- 13:04here. But I think the most important takeaway
- 13:08is what the discharge is, and that there are
- 13:12many exceptions to the discharge. The ones that
- 13:15are perhaps the most prevalent, that again we'll
- 13:18talk about in a few minutes, the ones based on
- 13:21fraud and fraud -like behavior, you have to bring
- 13:24a lawsuit within the bankruptcy to accept those
- 13:29debts from the discharge. And it may be a lot
- 13:33of work. So let me get this straight, Judge Barish.
- 13:37If you are a plaintiff or counsel to a plaintiff
- 13:41in a state court case and a bankruptcy is filed,
- 13:46you either have to get relief from the automatic
- 13:49stay or maybe the bankruptcy case progresses
- 13:52far enough to where the debtor obtains a discharge.
- 13:55You have to seek non -dischargeability of that
- 13:59debt if you want to continue collecting or prosecuting
- 14:02your action. It sounds to me like you can't just
- 14:05ignore the bankruptcy case. Bankruptcy is going
- 14:07to have some overlay. You ignore the bankruptcy
- 14:11case at your peril. There's a very short fuse
- 14:16for filing a complaint to determine a debt is
- 14:22non -dischargeable. If you don't meet that deadline
- 14:26within 90 days roughly of the bankruptcy filing.
- 14:32you're out of luck. I mean you cannot file that
- 14:37lawsuit and that claim will be discharged. Now
- 14:41if it's in a chapter 11 case you may receive
- 14:45a distribution on that claim but the distribution
- 14:50may be pennies on the dollar. If you don't want
- 14:54to lose your valuable fraud claim you have to
- 15:01move quickly to file suit. I also correct judge
- 15:05that in terms of the automatic stay. If a state
- 15:12court action is pending, and John, you mentioned
- 15:16the idea of just ignoring the bankruptcy, the
- 15:18automatic stay renders anything that happens
- 15:21after the automatic state goes into effect, renders
- 15:24it void. So if the state court continues to proceed
- 15:30with the action. If the plaintiff or the other
- 15:34parties just ignore the bankruptcy without getting
- 15:36relief from the automatic state, literally everything
- 15:38is void from then on without getting the relief
- 15:42from the automatic state. So not only can you
- 15:45be sanctioned, as I mentioned earlier under 362K,
- 15:50but everything you do is just literally worthless.
- 15:54Of course, there's another variation of that,
- 15:56which is that your defendant may file bankruptcy
- 15:59and not bother to tell you, or the state court,
- 16:06in which case they may proceed unknowingly. The
- 16:12law in the Ninth Circuit is that those actions
- 16:17taken in violation of the state, even without
- 16:20knowledge of them, are void. And if you are brought
- 16:25into awareness of the case late in the process,
- 16:31you may have to go to, you probably do need to
- 16:34go to the bankruptcy court and seek the bankruptcy
- 16:37court's blessing. There is a form of retroactive
- 16:41relief that may be available to annul the automatic
- 16:45stay as of the initiation of the bankruptcy case
- 16:49if it turns out that you didn't know. Well, Judge
- 16:55Baris, this is Jay. If the defendant wants to
- 16:59file bankruptcy in part to throw off the state
- 17:02court litigation and have it continue, what I
- 17:04see happen all the time is they file in the state
- 17:06court case a notice of bankruptcy filing. And
- 17:10then, of course, if I get that and I'm plaintiff's
- 17:13counsel... why would I want to have any argument
- 17:18that I'm personally liable for violent in this
- 17:20day? So I would automatically move for relief
- 17:22from stay if I wanted to continue to try the
- 17:26case in state court. That's the situation I usually
- 17:29see. Right. And then basically it becomes the
- 17:33bankruptcy court's job as gatekeeper to decide
- 17:38whether that lawsuit can go forward. Sometimes,
- 17:44in fact, frequently, what the bankruptcy court
- 17:48will decide is that that lawsuit can go forward
- 17:52for purposes of liquidating a claim because the
- 17:57litigation is so far advanced that equity and
- 18:03efficiency counsel in favor of letting it go
- 18:06forward in the state court and then having the
- 18:10plaintiff, the creditor, come back to the bankruptcy
- 18:12court to figure out what that claim actually
- 18:16entitles them to when the estate is divvied up.
- 18:23So a defendant filing a bankruptcy case on the
- 18:27eve of trial will interrupt the process, but
- 18:32not necessarily permanently. In answer to what
- 18:36you're raising, I've had a number of instances
- 18:39where I get a call from state court litigators
- 18:42and it's not clear that the automatic stay applies.
- 18:46It's on the fence somehow and it depends on the
- 18:49assets, it depends on who filed the bankruptcy,
- 18:52et cetera. And more often than not, I will usually
- 18:55say err on the side of caution and go and get
- 18:59your relief from stay rather than litigate and
- 19:02find out later on that the stay applied because
- 19:04a judge looks at it and says, My interpretation
- 19:06is yes, it applies. So I think sometimes it's
- 19:09not clear whether the automatic stay applies
- 19:11and you have to decide what to do. And if the
- 19:14litigation is not far along, then the likely
- 19:17result is going to be you're just going to file
- 19:19a proof of claim and it's going to be either
- 19:21objected to or not objected to in the bankruptcy
- 19:24case, which is what happens most of the time.
- 19:29But if you think you have a good basis to accept
- 19:32the claim from the discharge. Again, in addition
- 19:36to filing a proof of claim, you need to bring
- 19:38one of these complaints to have it determined
- 19:42non -dischargeable. I've seen people do one and
- 19:46not the other and be very disappointed. So Judge
- 19:51Barish, you talked about some common exceptions
- 19:54to discharge. If we could jump to the next slide.
- 20:00Is this your card? Are these the exceptions you
- 20:03were talking about? Well, these are some of them.
- 20:08The exceptions that fall under 5, 23, 8, 2, 4,
- 20:12and 6 are notable because you, as the plaintiff
- 20:17creditor, have to initiate a civil action, again,
- 20:21we call it an adversary proceeding, to have it
- 20:25determined to fall into one of these categories.
- 20:32OK. false representation, false written statement
- 20:37under A2B. We've got fraud or defalcation while
- 20:40acting in a fiduciary capacity, embezzlement
- 20:43or larceny under A4, and then willful and malicious
- 20:47injury under A6. So these are some of the more
- 20:51common exceptions to discharge that are based
- 20:53on debt or misconduct that the bankruptcy court
- 20:56sees. And now I'd like to turn to a final few
- 21:03points on claim and issue preclusion. If we could
- 21:05go to the next slide. I just want to ask Judge
- 21:10Barish, if you want to spend maybe a minute for
- 21:13those who are state court practitioners, what
- 21:16is the difference between an adversary proceeding
- 21:20and the bankruptcy case? And how did they interact?
- 21:24What's the relationship? Sure. Well, The bankruptcy
- 21:29case is where the sort of principal issues relating
- 21:34to administration of the case are dealt with.
- 21:37A lot of what happens in bankruptcy is a fairly
- 21:42sophisticated motion practice, where when a party
- 21:46seeks relief, at least here in the Central District
- 21:50of California, they can be in court within 21
- 21:56days. of filing the motion. I understand from
- 22:01a California state practitioner that I talked
- 22:05to just this weekend, that sometimes it's six
- 22:10or seven or eight months before they can get
- 22:12a hearing, depending on the type of motion. But
- 22:18we're pretty available and bankruptcy is designed
- 22:21to move quickly and summarily in our district.
- 22:26motions are supported and opposed with declarations
- 22:30under penalty of perjury. In contrast, there
- 22:35are some matters that are considered kind of
- 22:39so important that they ought to be treated like
- 22:44a lawsuit with all of the procedural protections
- 22:50and mechanisms that you're familiar with. Our
- 22:56Bankruptcy Rule 7001 says that there are certain
- 23:00matters that can only be dealt with by adversary
- 23:04proceeding. Rather than filing a motion, you
- 23:08have to file a complaint. The complaint has to
- 23:11be answered. There's disclosure obligations,
- 23:16a period of discovery, motion practice, etc.
- 23:19It's a much more involved process. That civil
- 23:23action is essentially attached to the bankruptcy.
- 23:27It's considered part of the case, but it is its
- 23:31own proceeding. Does that answer your question,
- 23:35Uzi? Yeah, I think that's really good. Thank
- 23:37you. So now with that gloss, let's talk about
- 23:42claim and issue preclusion per second. So Jay,
- 23:47what do these mean? when you're talking about
- 23:50different forums. Is it the same for the state
- 23:53court as it is for a federal court? Well, so
- 23:59let me address what I think we're going to do.
- 24:04If I have a case in state court and I want to
- 24:07stay in state court, let's say that's because
- 24:10I think I want to be in front of a jury, which
- 24:12is not available in bankruptcy court. in the
- 24:17defendant files, what I would want to do is get
- 24:21relief from stay, proceed in the state court,
- 24:25get a result, right? And then the question is,
- 24:28is that result going to be a claim or issue preclusive
- 24:33such that when I'm in front of Judge Barish,
- 24:36I can just go see him on a 21 -day motion and
- 24:39say, here it is, just to rule this as issue preclusion
- 24:43and get my judgments non -dischargeable. Or am
- 24:47I going to have to basically try an adversary
- 24:51proceeding in front of him? So in order to set
- 24:58up state court to federal claim preclusion, I
- 25:01would want to set up my case so that whether
- 25:04it's a jury verdict form that's detailed enough,
- 25:08or if I'm trying it in front of a judge, I would
- 25:12want a detailed statement of decision. such that
- 25:16when I have my motion for a judgment of non -dischargeability
- 25:21in front of Judge Barish, he can read what happened
- 25:25in state court, a detailed jury verdict as opposed
- 25:28to a general verdict, a detailed statement of
- 25:31decision as opposed to a one -liner, that he
- 25:35can see that all the necessary elements of a
- 25:38bankruptcy discharge preclusion were met and
- 25:42rule. Now, I'm not sure if this is exactly germane
- 25:50to your question, but I'm looking at the left
- 25:56side about the federal judgment. One can try
- 26:02the underlying facts and whether or not those
- 26:05are non -destrogable all in bankruptcy court.
- 26:08So if, for example, I have sort of a dry technical
- 26:12argument. I don't think there's much jury appeal.
- 26:17Maybe I think I'm going to get in trial in front
- 26:19of Judge Barish quicker than I would in the state
- 26:21court. We could possibly just try the entire
- 26:27action. In other words, hear the facts, present
- 26:30the evidence, and then suggest that I've proven
- 26:33fraud or willful malicious injury under one of
- 26:37these subsections. procedure and result in the
- 26:41California Farms case, which are attached to
- 26:45the material. So I hope that was responsive to
- 26:48your question. I'm happy to. Can I jump in and
- 26:51add to that great explanation, which is that
- 26:57bankruptcies are filed. You as a plaintiff have
- 27:02no control over when your defendant files a bankruptcy.
- 27:07Sometimes it happens. shortly after you file
- 27:13suit. Sometimes it may happen on the eve of trial.
- 27:17Sometimes it may happen after trial. And if your
- 27:22claims include fraud, Jay is absolutely right.
- 27:26You want to get as detailed a decision from the
- 27:32spirit court as to what it is that the Superior
- 27:38Court found and hopefully eliminate those issues
- 27:41when you get to bankruptcy court and seek to
- 27:43have it determined non -dischargeable. Can we
- 27:48possibly go back one slide? There's just something
- 27:52I wanted to quickly mention. Is that possible?
- 27:55Sure. The one that says exceptions to discharge
- 28:01based on debt or mis - there we go. I just wanted
- 28:04to point out The 523A2 is pretty close to state
- 28:10court fraud. It's a false representation of fact
- 28:14or a material non -disclosure intended to make
- 28:18the other party rely on their damage, that kind
- 28:21of thing. That works well in terms of issuing
- 28:24claim preclusion. The biggest mistake state court
- 28:28litigators can make in 523A4 which is most commonly
- 28:35used for breach of fiduciary duty. There is a
- 28:38huge delta between state court breach of fiduciary
- 28:41duty and 523A4. State court breach of fiduciary
- 28:45duty could be any kind of officer, director,
- 28:48partner, manager of an LLC just doing the wrong
- 28:51thing. Whereas 523A4 specifically, Breach of
- 28:56someone who's acting in the position of an expressed
- 28:59trust. So sometimes there's a miss there between
- 29:03this, you know, a state court judgment for breach
- 29:06of fiduciary duty and what the bankruptcy requires.
- 29:09And then wolfhole and malicious injury is kind
- 29:11of a catch -all. It usually doesn't include fraud
- 29:14because that's more specific to the 523A2. But
- 29:19if you want to get into that catch -all and convince
- 29:23Judge Barish that just for issue preclusion,
- 29:26you should conclude it's 523 .86, you're going
- 29:28to want to have a verdict form or a statement
- 29:31of decision that specifically finds that the
- 29:34defendant acted willfully and maliciously, justifying
- 29:39an award of punitive damages. And that could
- 29:41be for something like conversion or battery or
- 29:45anything else that is in that. Isn't that nature?
- 29:50It doesn't require, and it doesn't require physical
- 29:53injury. I mean, a lot of people think will show
- 29:55malicious injury means you've injured the person.
- 29:59You don't have to physically injure them to commit
- 30:01that. Right. It could be conversion actually,
- 30:04which we'll get to later. The other thing I would
- 30:07kind of throw out, Jay, and I think it's a good
- 30:09takeaway, is any state court practitioner who's
- 30:12in trial, who's trying to established fraud and
- 30:15it's trying to get findings, factual findings,
- 30:18and trying to get, you know, thinking ahead if
- 30:21there is a bankruptcy, if you have to at some
- 30:24point litigate the 523 action, pick up the, you
- 30:29know, the code, the bankruptcy code, and look
- 30:32at the definition of fraud under 523 -82. Look
- 30:37at the various elements that you have to prove
- 30:39in bankruptcy court and compare them to state
- 30:42court and make sure that the factual findings,
- 30:46the legal, the conclusions that you get from
- 30:48the judge in the state court match. And the reason
- 30:52is ultimately when you get to the bankruptcy
- 30:54court, you can't really do it by motion. You
- 30:56still have to file an adversary proceeding. But
- 30:59the idea of it as a motion for summary judgment
- 31:01would save you a lot of time and money. And if
- 31:04you think about it ahead of time, and if you
- 31:06compare the elements, and if you ensure that
- 31:09the state court judge gives you the right factual
- 31:12findings and conclusions of law. Judge Barris,
- 31:15for example, would be more likely than not to
- 31:18give you a summary judgment that says that you've
- 31:22complied with the requirements under 523. And
- 31:26just to put a really fine point on it, with the
- 31:31cases in the... the federal system say, and in
- 31:37our Ninth Circuit what the cases say, is that
- 31:40state law controls whether the debt exists, but
- 31:45federal law controls whether the debt is dischargeable
- 31:49or not. So you really, because bankruptcy is
- 31:55always a possibility for a defendant who's trying
- 31:58to get out from under a liability, you really
- 32:05need to familiarize yourself with what the federal
- 32:09cases say about how these statutes are construed.
- 32:14And as Jay pointed out and as Uzi pointed out,
- 32:18understand what those elements are, because they're
- 32:22deceptively not exactly the same as what state
- 32:27law provides. So Judge Barish. Can any court
- 32:31other than the bankruptcy court determine whether
- 32:34a debt is non -dischargeable? No. No. The bankruptcy
- 32:38court has exclusive jurisdiction over that federal
- 32:42question about whether a debt is dischargeable
- 32:45or not. Now, we got a question from the audience
- 32:48that's asking about unemployment benefits that
- 32:51were overpaid. And the question is whether those
- 32:55would be presumed to be fraud under A2A. As I
- 32:59understand it, a lot of these exceptions based
- 33:02on debt or misconduct really hinge on intent.
- 33:05Did they have fraudulent intent? Was it incurred
- 33:09fraudulently? Did they perform the injury with
- 33:15willfulness and maliciousness? Is there a presumption
- 33:20of fraud? No. Okay. All right. Just to put it
- 33:27simply, there's no presumption. I mean, you have
- 33:30to make out a case. It might be fraudulent inducement.
- 33:36If you're the state and you were fraudulently
- 33:39induced to overpay benefits of some kind, the
- 33:45state could conceivably bring a case. Yeah. OK.
- 33:50So with that, let's turn to our hypothetical.
- 33:59One more slide, please. Okay, so in our Western
- 34:05-themed hypothetical, plaintiff, a cattle rancher
- 34:08who wants to retire, owns a very fine bull that
- 34:11he wants to sell. He keeps the bull in a large
- 34:13barn on his ranch. Defendant hears about the
- 34:16bull and asks to go see it. Plaintiff says he'll
- 34:18be out of town on business, but they can negotiate
- 34:21the deal while he's away. Plaintiff gives defendant
- 34:24the code to his barn's padlock to view the bull.
- 34:26While plaintiffs are away, the two reach an agreement.
- 34:30In exchange for the bull, defendant will give
- 34:32plaintiff a deed to defendants waterfront property
- 34:35on the Salton Sea. Knowing the plaintiff wants
- 34:38to retire and get into gardening, defendant tells
- 34:41them the property is very fertile. Defendant
- 34:43takes plaintiff's bull from the barn and leaves
- 34:46a signed deed. Next slide. When plaintiff returns,
- 34:53he realizes defendant also took all of plaintiffs
- 34:57fancy gardening tools that he was gonna use at
- 34:59his waterfront property. Even worse, he visits
- 35:03that property and realizes that A, the salt and
- 35:06C is very salty and not suitable for gardening
- 35:09and B has shrunken considerably such that the
- 35:12property is nowhere near the shore. Wow, plaintiff
- 35:16got screwed over. So next slide. plaintiff decides
- 35:23to sue defendant in state court, and he alleges
- 35:28three causes of action, breach of contract, fraud
- 35:30in the inducement, and conversion. So with this
- 35:34hypothetical, let's take the first question.
- 35:38You're in the middle of discovery and defendant
- 35:40files a bankruptcy petition seeking relief under
- 35:43chapter seven, which is a liquidation case. This
- 35:46is kind of what we've been talking and alluding
- 35:48to a little bit. What are plaintiff's options?
- 35:50What can plaintiff do in this scenario? I'll
- 35:56take that one. So I think a lot of times people
- 36:01tend to want to immediately jump into either
- 36:06emotion for relief from stay or just follow proof
- 36:11of claim and walk away. I think there are some
- 36:13preliminary questions you need to ask yourself.
- 36:16Number one, does the defendant have any money.
- 36:21You have to look at the schedules and try to
- 36:23understand what it is you're fighting for. It's
- 36:26great if you can get relief from stay and Judge
- 36:28Barish says, yes, go forth to state court and
- 36:32prosper. But if the defendant files a schedule
- 36:36that suggests he's living in an apartment and
- 36:38gets social security and no other assets. then
- 36:42you may want to seriously consider whether it's
- 36:45worth fighting for. And maybe figure out what
- 36:49age is the defendant, and is he likely to, even
- 36:56after the bankruptcy and after assuming you get
- 36:59a non -dischargeability determination or judgment,
- 37:02is this defendant likely to work in the future
- 37:05and have any assets and income that you can levy
- 37:09against? So let's assume for a second that you
- 37:12determine that it's worthwhile pursuing. Actually,
- 37:15let me go back. Let's assume it's not worthwhile
- 37:17pursuing. Maybe all you do is file a proof of
- 37:20claim in the bankruptcy court, and you just stop
- 37:25litigating in the state court. Because at that
- 37:27point, you realize, because presumably, the defendant
- 37:30has filed something under oath. unless you know
- 37:35something different, maybe the defendant is hiding
- 37:37assets, and if they are, then you report that
- 37:40to the U .S. Trustee's office. But assuming that
- 37:43everything is on the up and up and the defendant
- 37:45really is doing nothing and he doesn't have a
- 37:49business, the bull has been sold and the money
- 37:53has been dissipated, proof of claim might be
- 37:56just fine and just walk away, because frankly,
- 37:59you don't want to spend good money after bad
- 38:01or throw good money after bad. If it's worthwhile,
- 38:05if there are some assets, then filing a motion
- 38:09for relief from the automatic stay I think is
- 38:11a good play. Why? Because you're in a situation
- 38:14where you get to go back to state court and pressure
- 38:17the plaintiff to ultimately maybe settle, come
- 38:20up with some kind of a compromise. Maybe you
- 38:22can get some money as part of the settlement
- 38:26agreement. You would have to come back to the
- 38:28bankruptcy court and the judge would have to
- 38:30approve. the compromise and ultimately the resolution,
- 38:34but you may get something out of it. Or if there
- 38:36really are assets in the case, you can look at
- 38:39it as simply, why would I litigate? Let me file
- 38:42a proof of claim for the entire amount of money
- 38:44and let the debtor file an objection to my claim.
- 38:49And then we're in bankruptcy court and we liquidate
- 38:54the asset in the bankruptcy court. I don't have
- 38:57to spend as much money. As Judge Barash mentioned,
- 39:00the bankruptcy court is designed to be a little
- 39:02more of a summary type of proceeding. And you
- 39:07can probably get through that process, the claims
- 39:11objection process, faster than ultimately the
- 39:14case in the state court. So those are some of
- 39:17the issues that you should be looking at. I don't
- 39:20know if I missed anything, but if I did, I'm
- 39:22sure my colleagues would jump in. Hey, John,
- 39:25maybe. Let me cover this procedure. I'll just
- 39:28assume that my client and I want to continue
- 39:31the case. It's worth pursuing. If you look at
- 39:34the first two bullet points, there's a big difference.
- 39:36So if we're in the middle of discovery and the
- 39:40bankruptcy is filed, I don't know. If the trial
- 39:45is a year and a half away in state court, maybe
- 39:48the judge hasn't even set the trial date. I think
- 39:51Judge Barish is going to be maybe a little less
- 39:54inclined when I file my motion of relief and
- 39:57stay to think that the state court is necessarily
- 40:00the best place to liquidate that claim. Maybe
- 40:03there might be some more draw towards this litigating
- 40:06and bankruptcy. On the other hand, if the petition
- 40:09is filed on the day of closing arguments, I mean,
- 40:14not only is the trial on calendar, but we're
- 40:18nearly finished with the trial. I'm going to
- 40:21file an ex -party application to have that relief
- 40:25from stay immediately. 99 times out of 100, I
- 40:28would think Judge Barish and his colleagues would
- 40:30agree with me that that was filed just to throw
- 40:33off the state court trial and the best thing
- 40:35is just to see what the jury says and then come
- 40:39back from there. And then this is a good point
- 40:43to mention that in your materials There's copy
- 40:46of a case called in Ray plumber X which is from
- 40:52one of my colleagues here in the central district
- 40:55that adopts a Literally a another one of these
- 40:59sort of 12 factor equitable tests The Bankruptcy
- 41:03Court has an incredible amount of discretion
- 41:07to decide whether you could go forward with your
- 41:11case in state court or not. And when I get that
- 41:15motion, I'm going to consider all 12 of those
- 41:18factors to the extent they're relevant and going
- 41:23to make the best sort of equitable decision I
- 41:26can considering what I think is fair and what
- 41:30I think is efficient would be the best way to
- 41:33describe that 12 factor test. And Jay, I'll add
- 41:36one more thing. None of this is scientific, right?
- 41:41As you say, you look at the factors and where
- 41:44are things in the scheme of the trial? Are we
- 41:47far along? Are we not far along? But more often
- 41:50than not, you're also looking at this strategically.
- 41:52And if you're in front of a state court judge
- 41:54that seems to like the other side better than
- 41:56you do, then you make decisions based on that
- 41:58because you may want to you know, venue shop.
- 42:01I hate to say this, but maybe you do want to
- 42:03go to Judge Barish's court because you feel like
- 42:05you're getting a fresh start and he's going to
- 42:07look at this from a different perspective, whereas
- 42:09the state court judge has been less than kind
- 42:12or vice versa. So I think a lot of it is looking
- 42:15at the facts of your case, understanding the
- 42:18dynamics, and ultimately trying to make a decision
- 42:21that you think will benefit your client the best.
- 42:28Getting back to the second bullet point, if you
- 42:30are on the day of closing arguments in state
- 42:33court, it sounds to me like you've gotten far
- 42:36enough along to where settlement is out of the
- 42:39window, you've had all your evidence in during
- 42:42trial, and now you just need to make your final
- 42:45argument to the state court judge and wait for
- 42:49that statement of decision to come out. Judge
- 42:52Barish, how does that fit into the equitable
- 42:55factors that you've been instructed to consider?
- 42:59Yeah, it's hugely influential. I mean, I don't
- 43:07want to give an advisory opinion on a hypothetical
- 43:09case. But yeah, it's pretty unlikely that I'm
- 43:13not going to allow that matter to continue to
- 43:19judgment. in the state court. Interestingly enough,
- 43:26there was a question that Judge Rosenblum posed,
- 43:33asked us to comment on what is the effect of
- 43:36a judgment. Assuming the court, the bankruptcy
- 43:40court has granted relief from stay to allow the
- 43:44superior court to finish their work and enter
- 43:50a statement of decision. I'm going to give that
- 43:57decision and judgment full faith and credit,
- 44:00as I'm required to by statute and by the Constitution.
- 44:04And I'm going to apply principles of claim, well,
- 44:12issue preclusion. And it's important to emphasize
- 44:15there, issue preclusion. I ultimately have to
- 44:20decide whether a debt is dischargeable or not.
- 44:27But if I have a very detailed statement of decision
- 44:33that sort of defines all of the requisite acts
- 44:40that would lead me to conclude under federal
- 44:43law that it's non -dischargeable, that statement
- 44:46of decision is going to go a very long way and
- 44:50probably avoid having to have a trial in the
- 44:55bankruptcy court and instead simply having, as
- 45:00someone mentioned earlier, I think it was Uzi,
- 45:03a motion for summary judgment asking me to apply
- 45:06the issue of preclusion. The reason why there's
- 45:14no claim preclusion on non -dischargeability
- 45:16is, like we said before, it's a federal claim,
- 45:20and the bankruptcy court has exclusive jurisdiction
- 45:23over that piece. And the case law treats the
- 45:26question of dischargeability separate from the
- 45:30underlying facts that might establish fraud or
- 45:34breach of fiduciary duty or whatever. But as
- 45:37a result of clean conclusion, if the proper findings
- 45:40are included in the statement in the state court
- 45:42statement of decision, it's kind of game over,
- 45:45isn't it? In terms of non discharge ability of
- 45:47the if, for example, the elements of fraud are
- 45:50found. Yeah. Yeah. And that's and that is most
- 45:54typical under 523 a two because 523 a two really
- 46:04sort of incorporates basic common law notions
- 46:08of fraud. Start talking about 523A6, willful
- 46:13and malicious. There's a lot of judicial gloss
- 46:16on what willful and malicious means and it's
- 46:22different than what I think state courts think
- 46:24it means under state law. Right. So you mentioned
- 46:28that bankruptcy court relying on a statement
- 46:31of decision that the state court issued and you
- 46:35can use issue preclusion and get a lot of these
- 46:38elements out of the way, if not all of them.
- 46:42It might be a little bit different though, I
- 46:44understand, if there's been a default, if maybe
- 46:48it wasn't fully litigated at state court. Moving
- 46:53to this fourth bullet point, you know, plaintiff
- 46:55obtains relief from the automatic say independent
- 46:57defaults. So, you know, maybe he just gets a
- 47:02judgment that says Plaintiff wins. Is that enough?
- 47:07So in that situation, I'm going to apply principles
- 47:14of California issue preclusion to a California
- 47:19judgment. And I'm going to ask the question,
- 47:24would issue preclusion apply as a result of a
- 47:29default judgment under California law? What's
- 47:34the answer, John? Well, so we mentioned this
- 47:39earlier. We have issue preclusion elements under
- 47:41California law that are, you know, identical
- 47:43issues. Was it actually litigated? Was it necessarily
- 47:46decided? Is the decision final and on the merits?
- 47:50And is there an identity of the parties or parties
- 47:54in privity? It sounds to me like actually litigated
- 47:58might be. an obstacle to obtaining summary judgment
- 48:05on non -dischargeability. That's where the fight's
- 48:10going to be. Well, look, if all you do is go
- 48:15in on some 15 -minute default prove -up and get
- 48:19a one -liner judgment, judgment for the plane
- 48:22if you haven't done your job. I mean, I'd certainly
- 48:25like to hear from Judge Bogdanoff on this, but
- 48:28you can ask for a detailed evidence. You can
- 48:31present evidence, detailed evidence in support
- 48:34of a default judgment, and you can ask for very
- 48:37specific findings in a default judgment. So I
- 48:41don't think this is actually necessarily litigated.
- 48:44means that the other side was there opposing
- 48:46you. It's just that it was actually decided based
- 48:50upon an evidentiary proceeding. And I'd love
- 48:51to hear. No, that's right. The law is clear on
- 48:55that, even running up to the Ninth Circuit. And
- 48:58even if you don't obtain the findings, if you
- 49:02made the specific request in the complaint, the
- 49:05complaint is detailed. There's even a case that
- 49:07says. that you don't even need the findings in
- 49:10the default prove -up. But the purpose of the
- 49:12prove -up is to set forth the evidence to support
- 49:19your prima facie case and damages. And sometimes
- 49:23parties, and these are written submissions under
- 49:26the state court rules. It's not put on through
- 49:29live testimony. I've had lawyers try to do that.
- 49:33It's not procedurally proper. The issue there
- 49:38is whether somebody is bringing in something
- 49:41that's just totally extraneous to the case. And
- 49:45I had that happen quite often. Somebody's like
- 49:47these weird findings and they're not elements
- 49:50of the case. And you kind of have an idea, maybe
- 49:54they're trying to get, you know, use it for some
- 49:57other purpose. I've never seen it attempt to
- 50:00be used for purposes of what I thought was bankruptcy
- 50:04planning. Quite the opposite. I often felt that
- 50:08the lawyers were kind of asleep at the switch
- 50:09on that. But the law is clear that a default
- 50:14judgment is not a way to evade the preclusive
- 50:18effect of collateral estoppel. And that's just
- 50:24a basic policy. You don't want to encourage people
- 50:26to just run away from the court in order to avoid
- 50:29the consequences of a litigation. Um, somebody
- 50:33asked about arbitration awards. And I think Mr.
- 50:37Salvato did, uh, and, and how that would play
- 50:40out. And I think, uh, if the arbitration award
- 50:44has not been confirmed by the superior court
- 50:47and a bankruptcy intervenes, uh, well, you might
- 50:50want to go and get a relief from the automatic
- 50:53stay to have confirmation. Because I think if
- 50:56there is confirmation and if there's a decision,
- 50:58uh, issued by the arbitrator that is detailed.
- 51:02that likewise is going to be preclusive and entitled
- 51:07to collateral estoppel in the bankruptcy case.
- 51:11But Judge Bogdanov, I have a question. And I've
- 51:14seen this happen a number of times. A complaint
- 51:16is filed and the allegations, the cause of action
- 51:20revolve around a breach of contract type of scenario.
- 51:26And then when they get the default judgment or
- 51:29even a trial, and they realize because someone
- 51:32finally whispers in the attorney's ears that
- 51:35there may be a bankruptcy and well you're not
- 51:38going to get non -dischargeability for a regular
- 51:40breach of contract. Can you for the first time
- 51:43when you're about to get the judgment whisper
- 51:46to the judge's ear or put it in your brief please
- 51:49add facts that would suggest that there's fraud
- 51:51involved. Is that something that you can add
- 51:53at the last minute let's say in a default judgment
- 51:55situation where it wasn't pled in the complaint
- 51:58but you proved it in the provo. process. I would
- 52:04think that if the judge is paying attention and
- 52:07doing their job, the answer to that would be
- 52:09absolutely not. If you haven't pled it, you haven't
- 52:12served that cause of action on the other side,
- 52:16I don't think you're entitled to sneak that in
- 52:18and query whether those findings are going to
- 52:22be upheld by are given the deference that you
- 52:26might want to apply to them in the bankruptcy
- 52:30case. But can you find a judge who will put their
- 52:34John Hancock on the judgment when it hasn't been
- 52:38pled, when it's totally extraneous? Yeah, there
- 52:40are judges that will do that. So we got a question
- 52:45by Anthony Saratella that asks about special
- 52:49findings made by a jury. and really looking at
- 52:54malice under California Civil Code 3294, which
- 52:58provides for exemplary or punitive damages for
- 53:04malice, fraud, and oppression, as that's defined
- 53:07by that specific code section, and looking at
- 53:12the differences between that and the bankruptcy
- 53:17code non -dischargeability section for willful
- 53:20and malicious injury. And they were specifically
- 53:23talking about not based on intentional conduct,
- 53:26but on reckless conduct. And I think we talked
- 53:29about earlier, intent is really important when
- 53:32it comes to non -dischargeability. So, Judge
- 53:37Baganoff, if you are in the state court and you're
- 53:41in this default posture, if you are looking to
- 53:48have a judgment that's going to ride through
- 53:53in the bankruptcy and provide for non -dischargeability,
- 53:57what findings should you be asking for? Is it
- 54:00enough to ask for malice, oppression, fraud under
- 54:033294? No, I mean, you're going to have to if
- 54:08you're talking about the party because the court
- 54:10really could care less that the state court judge
- 54:12could care less about this effort to obtain non
- 54:16-disargeability. Most state court judges, judges,
- 54:18I had a couple of cases where I went out of my
- 54:20way to make findings because I knew that bankruptcy
- 54:22was going to be down the down, down the river.
- 54:26and they actually were and the debts turned out
- 54:29to be non -dischargeable because I went on my
- 54:31way to make sure that they were going to be non
- 54:32-dischargeable debts but I'm a former bankruptcy
- 54:35lawyer so that's kind of the way I rolled. No
- 54:39the the findings need to be linked to the specific
- 54:44exclusions from discharge that are contained
- 54:47in section 523 and the applicable case law and
- 54:51the art is attempting to make sure that what
- 54:55you're seeking from the state court in that scenario
- 54:58or in that situation is commensurate with the
- 55:03cause of action that you've brought and the applicable
- 55:05state law. And, you know, you face these issues
- 55:09if you have a contested case and you have jury
- 55:11instructions and suddenly somebody wants to add
- 55:14something about willful and maliciousness that
- 55:16comports with non -dischargeability and federal
- 55:19law, but isn't an element of California law?
- 55:23Uh, and it isn't in the form jury instructions,
- 55:26you're going to get a lot of pushback from everybody,
- 55:29including the judge. You're just not going to
- 55:30do that. They're not there to help you, uh, advance
- 55:34your, your case for non -dischargeability. Uh,
- 55:37which by the way is no panacea because you know,
- 55:40the, the example that I give it, non -dischargeability
- 55:42is great leverage before the bankruptcy is filed.
- 55:46Once the bankruptcy is filed, uh, you know, the
- 55:49Goldman's chased OJ. for over 30 years. And the
- 55:54estimate that I've seen is that they will end
- 55:56up recovering in the probate case as a result
- 56:00of their $36 million non -dischargeable debt,
- 56:04about $200 ,000. That's after chasing him and
- 56:08now in death for over 30 years. So this is no
- 56:13panacea. It's something that you can pursue after
- 56:18the fact against somebody But chances are, you
- 56:22know, the likelihood that you're going to ever
- 56:24recover anything from somebody on a non -dischargeable
- 56:27debt is fairly remote. To that point, you know,
- 56:31I mentioned earlier that you have to really think
- 56:33about who the defendant is or the debtor and
- 56:35bankruptcy is, what kind of assets they have,
- 56:38not only as to whether you want to get relief
- 56:40from the automatic stay so you can litigate and
- 56:44recover nothing, but if you're going to litigate
- 56:46the non -dischargeability, everything you just
- 56:48said is right. If they have no assets and if
- 56:51they have no future potential for earnings, maybe
- 56:54you have to think twice about having a client
- 56:56pay a lot of money to litigate in the bankruptcy
- 56:59court to get the non -dischargeability, which
- 57:01is a nice piece of paper. You can frame it, but
- 57:04if you can't collect it, it's meaningless. Right.
- 57:07That's why I say it's great leverage when you're
- 57:09sitting across the table before they file bankruptcy.
- 57:11Once they file bankruptcy, it goes way down,
- 57:13which is what I tell people in mediations. So
- 57:18speaking of the possibility of issue preclusion
- 57:23from state court to bankruptcy court, I'm looking
- 57:25at the, I know we were talking about it default,
- 57:29but let's say we try the case in front of a jury,
- 57:31right? And I'm gonna wanna have a detailed special
- 57:35verdict or special interrogatory as do you find
- 57:37malice, oppression or fraud by clearly convincing
- 57:40evidence under 3294. and I'm looking at the case
- 57:44instructions on my screen. Malice, for example,
- 57:48means intent to cause injury or was despicable
- 57:51and done with a willful and knowing disregard
- 57:53of the rights or safety of another. I'm just
- 57:56wondering whether the issue that the fellow whose
- 57:59name is no longer on the question and answer
- 58:01thing raises whether something that's despicable
- 58:05with a willful and knowing disregard of the rights
- 58:08or safety of another? Is there a little bit of
- 58:11daylight between that and intentional under 523A6,
- 58:14or would that qualify? Judge Barish, are you
- 58:20going to give an opinion on that one that's likely
- 58:22to be litigated in front of you? Okay, go ahead.
- 58:25I'm going to let you have that one. No, I think
- 58:28there's case law. which is why I'm not predicting
- 58:33how I would rule, but there's Ninth Circuit case
- 58:35law that says the California's definition of
- 58:37malice is not the same as the federal definition.
- 58:43The cases talk about willful and malicious. This
- 58:51is under 523A6. You need to, as I understand
- 58:56the cases, both intend the act and intend to
- 59:03harm the tort victim as a result. And some 523
- 59:14-826 claims fail because the plaintiff is unable
- 59:19to prove that specific intent was to cause harm.
- 59:29So you've gone through this whole state court
- 59:31trial you've gotten special verdict and You then
- 59:35show up with your big beautiful judgment in front
- 59:39of the bankruptcy judge and the bankruptcy judge
- 59:42says that ain't adequate and So then you have
- 59:44to try this issue These issues all over again
- 59:48if you want to obtain the requisite finding to
- 59:51obtain non discharge ability And that happens
- 59:55often More often than you realize, because people
- 59:58don't always plan at the early stages in state
- 1:00:01court and they show up before Judge Barish and
- 1:00:04they realize they now have to religate, as you
- 1:00:06say. Well, my general impression is fraud and
- 1:00:10523A2 seem to line up pretty well. Very well,
- 1:00:16yeah. I'm hearing that there's enough of a difference
- 1:00:18between types of breach of fiduciary duty under
- 1:00:21state law and 523A4. And then I've just learned
- 1:00:25something important. If I go try all the way
- 1:00:31through a jury verdict and I get malice, oppression,
- 1:00:33or fraud in a 3294 and Judge Barish is going
- 1:00:36to have a doubt as to whether that was non -dischargeable
- 1:00:40under 523 .6, maybe at that point, if that's
- 1:00:44where I think I'm going, maybe I'd rather just
- 1:00:46try the case in front of him rather than try
- 1:00:48the whole case in state court and then have to
- 1:00:51try it again. Yeah. So hopefully with that, we've
- 1:00:57given you all some things to chew on. Unfortunately,
- 1:01:00we are close for time. So I just want to thank
- 1:01:05all of the panelists for the time that they put
- 1:01:07in and for their incredible expertise that they've
- 1:01:11shared with us this evening. And I'd also like
- 1:01:14to thank BHBA. As a reminder, the bankruptcy
- 1:01:17law section is happily welcoming anybody who
- 1:01:22would like to participate. and be a part of our
- 1:01:25fun group. We are having our next section meeting,
- 1:01:28as I mentioned, on April 14th, and you can find
- 1:01:31more information on BHBA's website. Okay, and
- 1:01:36with that, I think we'll go ahead and close out
- 1:01:38the Zoom. Thanks, everybody. Have a good evening.
- 1:01:40John, thank you for being the moderator. Thank
- 1:01:43you.