Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #76🎙️ |Public Inquiry Noise Week Beginning 16th June 2026 Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:03Unknown: Well, you'll be glad to hear today's public inquiry was
- 0:06a lot calmer and quieter than yesterday. Arriving a couple of
- 0:11minutes late, the atmosphere felt somewhat subdued, almost
- 0:15watchful. Certainly, everyone was on their best behaviour.
- 0:21Straight away we returned to the subject of noise, so you might
- 0:25remember yesterday I explained how we finally got to speak
- 0:28towards the end of the morning and make our points about what
- 0:31had been discussed by the applicant and FODC, and now this
- 0:36morning the other side's Barrister Beatty and their
- 0:39expert witness Keegan set about rebutting those arguments that
- 0:43we made yesterday morning, but before all that, though, we got
- 0:48to hear Emmett correcting claims made by Dalradian yesterday as
- 0:53to the proximity of Gerald Hollywood's house to the mine.
- 0:58This is not the first time that third parties have had to
- 1:00correct the applicants often willful, erroneous information,
- 1:04and we have to be very vigilant. As I explained in podcast number
- 1:0971 about barrister methodology, it is often not what barristers
- 1:14say that matters most, but what they choose not to say. Their
- 1:18omissions can be just as revealing and sometimes more
- 1:22significant than their spoken arguments, mr. McAvoy barrister,
- 1:29appearing on behalf of the silent majority group, which,
- 1:33like its council, has featured only sparingly during the
- 1:37inquiry, then rose to read a statement from one of its
- 1:41members. It was after all important to remind everyone
- 1:45that he was still there. For those unfamiliar with the
- 1:48inquiry, this provides an opportunity to introduce another
- 1:52third-party group that has featured from time to time the
- 1:55silent majority. The group possesses two particular
- 2:00remarkable characteristics. The first is that the opening half
- 2:04of its name is entirely accurate. We almost never hear
- 2:09from them. Indeed, its public appearances are generally
- 2:13limited to the occasional letter in the local newspaper, usually
- 2:18penned by an individual associated with Dalradion, who
- 2:21identifies himself as the group's chair. The second
- 2:25remarkable feature is its use of word majority. One suspects
- 2:31there may have been a mix up somewhere between majority and
- 2:34minority, an understandable mistake perhaps when one
- 2:39considers that many of the group's most visible supporters
- 2:43appear to be either employees of Dalradian or closely connected
- 2:48to those who are. On the other hand, perhaps silent minority
- 2:55might have simply lacked the same marketing appeal. Another
- 3:00contribution came from a member of the silent majority who read
- 3:04a prepared statement in support of the mine. Unfortunately, the
- 3:09statement appeared to have little connection to the
- 3:11question that had actually been asked. Even after the
- 3:15commissioners pointed out that he was not addressing the
- 3:18question, he pressed on regardless, returning fatefully
- 3:22to the content of his statement, it was rather like watching a
- 3:26train continue along its scheduled route after being
- 3:30informed that the tracks had ended several miles earlier. To
- 3:35be fair, the statement was delivered with admirable
- 3:38consistency. The answer never changed, bearing only the
- 3:43slightest superficial relationship to the question in
- 3:46the first place. The appearances of two representatives of the
- 3:51silent majority on the same day was an extraordinary
- 3:54development. Had a third appeared, the inquiry might have
- 3:58had to adjourn to consider the implications, moving swiftly on,
- 4:03as they say, the remainder of the morning was taken up with
- 4:06discussions on noise-related matters, particularly the
- 4:09rebuttals, before we eventually moved on to the dreaded
- 4:14conditions. My conclusion from all of this is that if this mine
- 4:20is approved. It will surely be the most extraordinary mine ever
- 4:23developed. According to the evidence we have heard,
- 4:27virtually nothing associated with it will have any meaningful
- 4:31impact on anyone or anything. Construction phase will have
- 4:37negligible effects. The operational phase will have
- 4:41negligible effects. The noise from the plant will be
- 4:45negligible. The noise from the traffic will be negligible. The
- 4:50cumulative effects of all these negligible impacts, when
- 4:55combined together, will apparently remain negligible.
- 5:01The heavy goods vehicle movements will, it seems, glide
- 5:04silently through the countryside, creating neither
- 5:07disturbance nor annoyance. Blasting operations will be so
- 5:12carefully managed that they will scarcely be noticed. Dust will
- 5:16be controlled, vibration will be controlled, light pollution will
- 5:21be controlled. Visual impacts will be controlled. The power
- 5:26lines will have limited or no effect. The haul roads will have
- 5:30limited or no effect. The processing plant will have
- 5:34limited or no effect. Even the inevitable unforeseen events
- 5:38appear destined to have limited or no effect.
- 5:43Indeed, after weeks of hearing that impacts will be negligible,
- 5:47one begins to wonder whether baseline data is really
- 5:51necessary at all. Why measure existing conditions when every
- 5:56future effect is confidently predicted to be insignificant,
- 6:01and should any concerns somehow arise, we are repeatedly assured
- 6:05that they will be addressed through monitoring, management
- 6:09plans, mitigation measures, conditions, oversight
- 6:13mechanisms, review procedures, reporting arrangements, and,
- 6:18where necessary, self-reporting by the very organisations
- 6:22responsible for the activity in question, listening to the
- 6:26evidence, one could be forgiven for thinking that this is not a
- 6:29conventional gold mine at all, but rather some remarkable new
- 6:33variety of mine that produces ore, traffic blasting,
- 6:38industrial processing, waste rock, power infrastructure and
- 6:421000s of vehicle movements, while leaving scarcely a trace
- 6:46of its existence. It is real magic, or perhaps it's a rare
- 6:53species of mine previously unknown to science. Impactus
- 6:59negligibilis, the invisible mind that does everything and affects
- 7:04nothing. And to finish off, just before we broke for lunch, Mary
- 7:11Brawley read out the following. It was a short application for
- 7:16mr. McAleer's readmission to quote it concerns the blanket
- 7:22nature of the exclusion ordered yesterday, which we say is
- 7:26disproportionate and requires urgent reconsideration. A
- 7:32blanket exclusion of this scope is a severe measure. Number one,
- 7:38we believe that the context of yesterday's events is critical,
- 7:42as mr. McAleer's intervention arose in response to what
- 7:46appears to be a reluctance to permit a third party expert
- 7:50witness to give evidence and was at risk of being excluded, this
- 7:57taking place against the background of the lack of Wi-Fi
- 8:01access for the third parties. The proper course is to hear
- 8:08evidence and assess weight, not to exclude it outright. And mr.
- 8:14McAleer's intervention was therefore an attempt to ensure a
- 8:18fair evidential process. And number two, we believe that it
- 8:23cannot justify his complete exclusion for the duration of
- 8:27the inquiry, that is an exceptional step, and one which
- 8:32requires clear and compelling justification. We submit that no
- 8:38such justification arises here, less restrictive measures are
- 8:43available. We submit that there is a clear issue of fairness and
- 8:48proportionality, excluding mr. McLear, who sought to ensure
- 8:53that relevant evidence is heard, risks narrowing the evidential
- 8:58picture and undermining the robustness of the inquiry's
- 9:02conclusions. I also emphasise that mr. McAleer is in his mid
- 9:0870s with some 40 years involvement in opposition to
- 9:12gold mining, including 15 years in relation to Del Radian. He
- 9:16brings experience capable of assisting the inquiry, he brings
- 9:21longstanding informed and relevant experience to the
- 9:24issues before this inquiry. His exclusion therefore deprives the
- 9:29Commission of a valuable and informed perspective to no
- 9:33evident procedural gain. The extent of the exclusion is, with
- 9:39respect, disproportionate, a blanket exclusion. Secondly, the
- 9:45context of yesterday's events is critical in those circumstances.
- 9:50We respectfully invite the Commission to set aside or vary
- 9:54the ruling of yesterday and permit mr. McAleer to be
- 9:59readmitted. On such proportionate and controlled
- 10:02basis as the Commission considers appropriate. At this
- 10:06point, the Commissioners withdrew briefly to consider the
- 10:09application. They returned quite quickly and informed us that
- 10:13they would reflect on the matter during the next week's break and
- 10:16deliver their decision on the first morning when the inquiry
- 10:19resumes. So that was it for today. Fingers crossed, folks.
- 10:24And we'll see you all soon. A small request: this podcast has
- 10:30grown entirely through word of mouth, people sharing episodes,
- 10:34and listeners coming back day after day to follow the public
- 10:37inquiry, and I thank you for that. If you have found value in
- 10:42it, following the podcast on Spotify or leaving a review on
- 10:46Apple Podcasts makes a real difference. It helps push these
- 10:50conversations out beyond our own circles and into places they
- 10:55might not otherwise reach.