Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Just Hired
Transcript
- Lucas: So you just landed a new job. You negotiated the offer, you felt good about the number. And then, three months in, you find out your colleague with the same title and less experience is making fifteen grand more. What do you do? Luna: I think a lot of people in that situation freeze. They think they have no leverage because they just started. Lucas: Right. The instinct is to wait a year, maybe two. But the data suggests that waiting can actually cost you. A 2025 compensation survey from a midsize SaaS company I looked at showed that nearly 20 percent of employees who asked for a raise within their first 12 months received an adjustment. But the window matters — most of those adjustments happened between month six and month nine. Luna: So there is a precedent. But the framing has to be careful. You can't walk in and say 'I'm underpaid.' That sounds like you didn't do your homework before you accepted. Lucas: Exactly. The wrong approach is to frame it as a mistake the company made. The right approach is to frame it as a market shift. Something changed — maybe you took on a broader scope than the job description outlined, or you've delivered results faster than expected, or you've learned that the market rate for your role has moved. Luna: Let's take a concrete example. Say you're a marketing manager at a tech company. You started six months ago at $85,000. You've since run three campaigns that outperformed targets. And you've found out through a peer survey that the median for your title in your city is now $100,000. How do you bring that up? Lucas: First, you don't bring up the peer survey. That can feel like you've been gossiping about salaries. Instead, you bring market data from a published source — like a Radford or Payscale report. You schedule a check-in with your manager, not a formal meeting titled 'raise discussion.' You say something like, 'I wanted to touch base on my compensation. When I joined, we agreed on $85,000 based on the role at the time. Since then, my responsibilities have grown in these ways, and I've seen that market rates for this skillset have increased. I'd like to discuss an adjustment.' Luna: I like that it's collaborative. It's not a demand; it's a conversation. But what if your manager says 'We just hired you, it's too soon'? Lucas: That's the most common pushback. And your response should be prepared. You say, 'I understand the timing is unusual. I'm not asking for a raise based on tenure. I'm asking because the scope and the market have shifted. Can we set a goal for the next three months, and if I hit it, revisit the conversation?' That gives them an off-ramp — a way to say yes without breaking policy. Luna: That's smart. It turns the 'no' into a 'not yet' with a clear path. And it shows you're thinking about the business, not just yourself. Lucas: Right. And the research backs this up. In that same SaaS dataset, the average adjustment for someone who asked before the one-year mark was about 12 percent. That's not trivial. For our marketing manager, that would be roughly $10,000. Luna: But there's a risk, right? Some managers might see this as a red flag — that you're high-maintenance or not a long-term fit. Lucas: That's real. Especially in smaller companies or cultures that value loyalty. But I'd argue that the risk is lower if you've delivered. If you've been there six months and you've already exceeded expectations, any reasonable manager should see this as retention — not entitlement. Luna: Let's talk about timing within the year. You mentioned month six to nine. Why not earlier? Lucas: Before six months, you haven't built enough credibility. You're still learning. The company hasn't seen you produce. And you also haven't had a performance review, which is the natural moment to bring up comp. Month six is often when the first review cycle hits, or at least a check-in. That's your window. Luna: So you align it with a structured touchpoint. That makes sense. What about people who are in roles without clear market benchmarks — like a niche technical role? Lucas: Then you have to build your case differently. You can't point to a survey. But you can point to your output. If you've automated a process that saved the team 20 hours a week, that's a concrete dollar figure. You can say, 'Based on the value I've delivered, I believe my compensation should reflect that impact.' You're making a business case. Luna: I want to push back on one thing. You mentioned using market data rather than peer salary. But what if the disparity is because of a systemic issue — like a gender pay gap? Shouldn't that be addressed differently? Lucas: That's a fair point. If you suspect the gap is systemic, you might want to be more direct. But even then, I'd lead with market data. It's less confrontational. And it forces the company to either adjust or explain why they're below market. If they refuse, that tells you something about the culture. Luna: Right. And then you have a decision to make. Either stay and accept it, or start looking. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the ultimate leverage. Knowing you're willing to walk. But you don't threaten that in the conversation. You just know it yourself. Luna: So let's sum up the playbook. First, gather market data. Second, align with a review or check-in. Third, frame it around scope and market shift, not entitlement. Fourth, propose a future milestone if the answer is no. Lucas: That's it. And the fifth, unspoken step: decide your walk-away number beforehand. If they say no and you know you're worth more, you owe it to yourself to explore options. Luna: You know, this conversation reminds me that a lot of career advice assumes you've been at a company for years. But the reality is, job tenure is shrinking. The median is around three years now. So making your case early is becoming more normal. Lucas: It really is. And if we've helped you think through a career move like this, I'll mention — we deliberately don't run ads on these episodes. If you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just if it's useful to you. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the show ad-free and focused on the questions that matter. Appreciate it. Lucas: So back to the timing question — what about the person who's been in the role for eight months, delivered, but their manager is swamped and hasn't scheduled a review? Do you wait or do you push? Luna: I think you push, but politely. Send a calendar invite with a note: 'I'd like to discuss my progress and future goals.' That opens the door without saying 'raise.' Lucas: Good. And if that meeting happens and you make your case, and they still say no — what then? Do you escalate to HR? Luna: Only if you have data that shows a clear market gap and your manager is being unreasonable. But HR is not your friend — they protect the company. So I'd only go that route if you're prepared to leave. Lucas: That's a crucial point. HR's job is to minimize risk, not to get you a raise. So your best bet is always your direct manager. If they can't or won't help, you have your answer. Luna: One last thing — what about the person who is too anxious to ask at all? They know they're underpaid, but they freeze. Lucas: I'd say: practice the script aloud, maybe with a friend. Record it on your phone. The anxiety usually comes from feeling like you're being greedy. But you're not. You're asking to be paid what the market says you're worth. That's professional, not personal. Luna: And if they still can't do it, maybe it's a sign to move to a company where the culture supports those conversations. Because that anxiety doesn't disappear. Lucas: Right. At some point, you have to decide: is the comfort of staying worth the financial gap? For most people, it isn't. And that's the real career question.