Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Lesser-Known Species: A Spotlight on Neighboring and Moral Rights
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Lesser Known Species, a spotlight on neighboring
- 0:10and moral rights. I'm Alla Policastro, Director
- 0:13of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:15Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:17delighted to introduce our speakers, Matthew
- 0:20Fulton and Joshua Graubart. Matt Fulton is the
- 0:24Director of Business Affairs at Writers House,
- 0:26where he guides film and theater adaptations,
- 0:29global publishing deals, and other intellectual
- 0:32property matters for one of the industry's leading
- 0:34literary agencies. He also teaches at Troy University's
- 0:38MBA in Music Industry program and serves on multiple
- 0:41copyright and literary property committees, reflecting
- 0:44his deep commitment to creators' rights. Josh
- 0:47Graubart is the principal attorney at the law
- 0:50offices of Joshua Graubart, where he represents
- 0:52U .S. and international clients in complex copyright
- 0:55and neighboring rights matters. He serves on
- 0:58multiple industry committees and boards, including
- 1:01ALAI's U .S. executive committee, reflecting
- 1:05his deep expertise in cross -border intellectual
- 1:08property issues. We're so excited to hear what
- 1:10they have to share with us today, so I'm going
- 1:12to turn it over to them. Hi. Thank you so much
- 1:16for having us. We're joining you today from New
- 1:19York City, so we're excited to have this bi -coastal
- 1:25presentation today. I'm just bringing up our
- 1:29slides now. My name is Matt Fulton. I'm joined
- 1:39today by my colleague Joshua Grabart and we're
- 1:42very excited to discuss the lesser -known species
- 1:46of copyright law. Today we're going to start
- 1:51with an introduction to copyright versus author's
- 1:54rights regimes as they are found throughout the
- 1:57world. We'll go through what that looks like
- 2:01in the philosophical underpinnings of various
- 2:03regimes. Following that we'll dive more deeply
- 2:07into moral rights, what they are, how they're
- 2:09presented globally in the various foreign authors'
- 2:14rights regimes. And then we'll take a look at
- 2:15how moral rights are presented in the United
- 2:19States, or a little foreshadowing here, if they
- 2:23are presented in the United States. Following
- 2:26that, I'll turn the time over to Josh, who will
- 2:29discuss neighboring rights, both in the US and
- 2:32as they're addressed in international treaties.
- 2:35Following that, as is required and obligatory,
- 2:39we'll talk about artificial intelligence, which
- 2:41I'm sure everyone's really excited about, and
- 2:44how the topics that we discussed today are being
- 2:48affected by artificial intelligence. So with
- 2:51that, we'll talk about the regimes of authorites
- 2:55or copyright. The first one being the French
- 2:59model. So the first two here, the French model
- 3:01and the German model. continental Europe models
- 3:04are what we would call author's rights, which
- 3:09I'll distinguish in a moment from the Anglo -American
- 3:12model or what we call copyright. So the French
- 3:14model, droit de teux, is a dualist system. So
- 3:19essentially what that means is that it treats
- 3:21moral rights and economic rights as a separate
- 3:25set of rights. And I understand I haven't defined
- 3:27moral rights yet. We'll do so in a moment. The
- 3:30moral rights under the French model are inalienable
- 3:33and personal. They are inherent in the author
- 3:36and they cannot be hypothecated away from the
- 3:41author. Whereas economic rights are transferable,
- 3:46but they're not as emphasized as more rights
- 3:49under the philosophy of this model. Moral rights
- 3:53are perpetual. They last forever under this model,
- 3:57whereas economic rights are time limited. The
- 4:01French model can be found in France, France's
- 4:05former colonies, as well as Latin and South America
- 4:08and the Arab world. The German model effectively
- 4:14has the same outcome as the French model in application,
- 4:18but there's a differing philosophical underpinnings.
- 4:24The German model or uhe berecht is a monist system.
- 4:27It treats moral rights and economic rights as
- 4:30one set of rights. You can think of the rights
- 4:33granted to an author as a coin with one side
- 4:36being the moral rights and the other side being
- 4:40the economic rights. Under the German model,
- 4:43the work is seen as an extension of the author's
- 4:47personality and it cannot be fully alienated,
- 4:50meaning you cannot in what in the United States
- 4:53we would call a transfer, you cannot transfer
- 4:55your rights under the German model, but you could
- 4:58certainly license them and even exclusively license
- 5:01them. Since the rights are one in the same, the
- 5:04moral rights and economic rights are treated
- 5:06as one set of rights. they're both time -limited.
- 5:14And as I mentioned, they're inalienable, meaning
- 5:16you can license, but you cannot assign. The German
- 5:20model can be found in Germany and Eastern Europe,
- 5:23Scandinavia, and there's a highly modified form
- 5:26of this in China and Japan. Finally, that brings
- 5:30me to the third model, which is the one that
- 5:33I imagine most of us here today are best familiar
- 5:36with, which is the Anglo -American model, or
- 5:40what we call copyright, which is a purely economic
- 5:43system. There's one set of rights and it's economic
- 5:45rights. The origins of the Anglo -American model
- 5:50are found in the Statute of Anne from the UK.
- 5:56Under this model, rights are framed as economic
- 5:58property only. The philosophy behind this model
- 6:03is that it's designed to incentivize creativity
- 6:07for public benefit. There's no real acknowledgement
- 6:12of moral rights under the Anglo -American system,
- 6:16although... as we'll talk about in a moment,
- 6:19after the Berne Convention, jurisdictions that
- 6:22adhered to the Berne Convention or signed onto
- 6:24the Berne Convention had to kind of add an appendage
- 6:27to their system to cover moral rights. but they're
- 6:31not necessarily native to the model. Of course,
- 6:35the UK and Canada have adopted a system of moral
- 6:39rights through statutes and we'll talk about
- 6:42how the United States has maybe or maybe not
- 6:45done that as well. The Anglo -American model
- 6:47can be found in the US and the UK and all our
- 6:53most former British colonies and most Commonwealth
- 6:57countries. I'll now turn it over to turn the
- 7:03time over to my colleague Josh to discuss the
- 7:05burn convention. Yeah, we should so to begin
- 7:08the burn convention is The great -grandfather
- 7:13if you will of almost all subsequent intellectual
- 7:17property multilateral treaties, so It's set in
- 7:21motion A number of concepts that have been incorporated
- 7:25into every other tree. So it is well worth knowing
- 7:27even if for that reason alone But it has a long
- 7:31history and this cartoon, which by the way, a
- 7:33really lovely copy of which sits in Matt's office,
- 7:36is from an 1886 edition of the US satirical magazine,
- 7:42Puck, out of Boston. And I don't know if you
- 7:44can read, depending on how big your screen is,
- 7:47that the title at the bottom is The Pirate Publisher,
- 7:49an international burlesque that has had the longest
- 7:52run in history. And the gentleman in the middle
- 7:56is the pirate publisher, surrounded by the various
- 7:58accusing parties who are all in different naval
- 8:00uniforms. And there are four reasons, pirate
- 8:03being a joke here. But in particular, I believe
- 8:05it's the fourth from the right, with the mustache,
- 8:10is W .S. Gilbert of Gilbert and Sullivan, the
- 8:13author of Pirates of Penzance, which had premiered
- 8:17in London, I believe, in 1878, and been widely
- 8:22popular I'm sorry, pirated in the United States.
- 8:25It was performed by several touring companies,
- 8:28none of whom painted diamond royalties to Gilbert
- 8:30or Sullivan. As a result of which, by the way,
- 8:34HMS Pinafore, I'm sorry, excuse me, I got these
- 8:36out of order. Pinafore was the one that premiered
- 8:38in 78. And Penzance then was premiered by Gilbert
- 8:43and Sullivan in New York. solely so that they
- 8:45could get some money from the U .S. run before
- 8:48they took it to London because they had been
- 8:50so upset about the loss of all the revenue from
- 8:52the U .S. So the Pirates references to that and
- 8:56there are in fact lyrics to an imaginary song
- 8:58below chant of the chanting of the of the pirated
- 9:00and angry authors the rest of the authors in
- 9:02addition to Gilbert are you know that on the
- 9:05left are all Americans twain John Greenleaf Whittier,
- 9:08Brett Hart, Oliver Wendell Holmes, the father,
- 9:11the poet, not the son who was the jurist. And
- 9:14on the right, Tennyson, Wilkie Collins, Robert
- 9:17Browning, Gilbert, who are all British authors,
- 9:20Claude Tennyson. And somewhat in the back are
- 9:22the French, Emile Zola, Jules Verne. All of them
- 9:25are getting no money. And they're very upset
- 9:29about this. As a result of this, in the 1880s,
- 9:3270s and 80s, there was a movement to get some
- 9:35kind of international protection. especially
- 9:37in Europe. There was a, I believe it was an 1877
- 9:42conference in which Victor Hugo, the author of
- 9:47The Hunchback of Notre Dame and others served
- 9:49as the honorary president, and the working sessions
- 9:51were chaired by Ivan Turgenev, the Russian author
- 9:54of Fathers and Sons, to try and push governments
- 9:58into some kind of international protection. That
- 10:02met annually. That organization, by the way,
- 10:03is called the LAI. It has grown into, over the
- 10:10many years, a kind of study group for international
- 10:13copyright. It meets annually to discuss various
- 10:16topics relating to international copyright protection.
- 10:19But its initial fruit was the Berne Convention,
- 10:23which was finalized in 1883 at a conference and
- 10:26adopted in 1886 and was revised about every 20
- 10:30years through the 1970s. At this point, it has
- 10:34so many members that unilateral amendment is,
- 10:38I'm sorry, excuse me, not unilateral. For some
- 10:44reason, I'm grasping at the word that would cover
- 10:46all parties, but it doesn't say that, I'm sorry,
- 10:48unanimous was the word I was roping for there.
- 10:51It's thought that unanimous approval of any changes
- 10:53is going to be impossible. So as a result, there
- 10:55has not been a substantial change in the Berne
- 10:57Convention since the 1970s. There have it has
- 11:01however been adopted in its entirety into the
- 11:03trips agreement with minus the moral rights provision
- 11:06at article 6bis at the behest the United States
- 11:09And most of its key provisions have been adopted
- 11:12into as I mentioned other copyright and IP provisions
- 11:15the big ones are The sort of three key columns
- 11:23here are national treatments The idea that every
- 11:27state party must treat every other state's party's
- 11:30authors as though they were their own office.
- 11:33So France must treat German authors no worse
- 11:35than it treats its own office and vice versa.
- 11:40The second is minimum standards. Yes, it is true
- 11:42that you have to treat people no worse than you
- 11:44treat your own people. But you also can't treat
- 11:46your own people particularly badly in order to
- 11:49somehow achieve a policy purpose. There's a minimum
- 11:51standard minimum term, minimum levels of protection.
- 11:55Certain things must be protected. Other things
- 11:57are optional. But there is a minimum standard
- 12:00that applies to all parties. They must at least
- 12:02rise to this level. And then finally is the prohibition
- 12:06on formalities. This was, if not deliberately
- 12:09aimed at the UK, the US, it was a function that
- 12:13was common there. The idea that you had to register
- 12:15or send copies of your book to the Library of
- 12:18Congress or to the universities as it was in
- 12:21England in order to achieve copyright protection.
- 12:24The answer was the result was that you had to
- 12:27do nothing in order to receive copyright protection.
- 12:30The author simply had to create the work period.
- 12:32And from that moment, copyright attached. You
- 12:35may ask yourself, well, but the U .S. has registration.
- 12:39Yes, but U .S. registration is not required for
- 12:41protection. It simply adds a bunch of goodies
- 12:43if you have it. But you have protection whether
- 12:45you have it or not, and it has been that way
- 12:47since the 1976 Act was adopted, anticipating
- 12:50U .S. adherence to Byrne, which finally took
- 12:52place 103 years after Byrne was initially adopted
- 12:55in 1989. Matt, do you want to move to more to
- 13:02talk about more rights? Well, I'll mention briefly
- 13:04more rights more rights were not in the original
- 13:06burn burn convention Of 1886 they were adopted
- 13:09in the 1928 Rome revision and they were adopted
- 13:13by all the members, but Not always with this
- 13:17in the same way The general theory is that they
- 13:20should be in the statute, and in many countries
- 13:22they are, but Britain did not actually put them
- 13:25into the statute until 1988. So for 60 years,
- 13:29Britain was adhering to the treaty by using a
- 13:33slightly different version, which Matt's going
- 13:35to talk about passing off and some other related
- 13:37unfair competition rules, to somehow... make
- 13:41it appear or indeed make it true, that it was
- 13:43adhering to the requirement for moral rights,
- 13:45but without incorporating it specifically into
- 13:47the copyright. So before we get into an in -depth
- 13:52discussion about moral rights, I think there
- 13:54is a video that we'd like to share that may help
- 13:58illustrate some of the concerns that we'll talk
- 14:00about. And here it is. He was the best star pilot
- 14:16in the galaxy and a cunning warrior. I understand
- 14:21you've become quite a good pilot yourself. And
- 14:25he was a good friend. Which reminds me, I have
- 14:31something here for you. I had this when you were
- 14:37old enough. For the astute Star Wars fans in
- 14:52the audience today, you may recognize that that
- 14:54is not a clip of the original Star Wars film.
- 14:59So the story behind that was that this is a cut
- 15:02from a Chilean broadcast of Star Wars A New Hope.
- 15:08And to avoid cutting to commercial breaks, the
- 15:11sponsor for the the broadcast just cut in, or
- 15:17caused to be cut in, internal commercials as
- 15:21if they were part of the plot of the film. So
- 15:23rather than Obi -Wan Kenobi handing Luke Skywalker
- 15:25a lightsaber, he hands him a beer. And there's
- 15:30a bunch of cuts that are just real comedic gold
- 15:34that just happen throughout the movie. You can
- 15:36find them online. I just find the one that we
- 15:38showed to be the funniest one. So... Eventually,
- 15:43after this aired, George Lucas, as one would
- 15:46expect, took objection to this butchering of
- 15:49his work, filed suit to prevent it from being
- 15:52shown again. He ultimately didn't win on a moral
- 15:54rights claim, but won on an advertising claim,
- 15:59which leads us into how the US protects moral
- 16:03rights, which we'll get to on the next slide.
- 16:05But we're almost 20 minutes into a presentation
- 16:08on moral rights, and we have not defined moral
- 16:10rights. I think we should cut to the chase here.
- 16:13So the moral rights are non -economic rights
- 16:15that protect the personal and reputational interests
- 16:18of creators in their works. There's three main
- 16:21types of moral rights with a fourth one that
- 16:24is implied from the three. The first one being
- 16:27the right of attribution or non attribution.
- 16:30This is the right to be recognized or to reject
- 16:33recognition as the author of the work. There's
- 16:36the right of integrity, which is the right to
- 16:37prevent distortion. mutilation or other derogatory
- 16:42treatment of the work. Interestingly, if there
- 16:45are any opera fans in the crowd today, there's
- 16:49this concept, especially in Germany, but in Europe
- 16:52of reggae theater versus Verktrue. Verktrue being
- 16:55presentations of older operas as the composer
- 16:58and librettist intended them to be presented.
- 17:00And then reggae theater being presentation of
- 17:02old operas under new light, new scrutiny. putting
- 17:06the emphasis of the director's vision at the
- 17:09forefront. This explains the Met Opera in New
- 17:11York. I'm sure the L .A. Opera as well does this.
- 17:14You might see a Rigoletto or a La Boheme that's
- 17:17set in space or something. There are actually
- 17:20lawsuits in Europe, in Germany, where the heirs
- 17:23of Poulenc took objection to a reggae theater,
- 17:28I might be butchering that pronunciation, but
- 17:30production of Dialogue of the Camelites. It's
- 17:34very interesting. We won't get too much into
- 17:36that. I'm just such a dork that I had to share
- 17:38that. There's also the right of withdrawal, which
- 17:40is the right to withdraw work from circulation.
- 17:43From the right of withdrawal is the implied right
- 17:45of publication, right of first publication. This
- 17:48is the right to put the work out into the world
- 17:50or not. Famously, American composer Charles Ives
- 17:54used to sit at his piano and work on a piece
- 17:56and polish it and make edits and then play it
- 17:59once. take the manuscript and throw it into the
- 18:01fire because under his philosophy he birthed
- 18:05the work into the world and it did not need to
- 18:08be performed again. So that he was exercising
- 18:11his right of withdrawal or his right of publication.
- 18:14So these are the main moral rights. of you that
- 18:20work in this area know that there are not any
- 18:23explicit protections for these rights in U .S.
- 18:26statutory copyright. So what the U .S. does is
- 18:30it has created what we call a patchwork of moral
- 18:33rights. So the U .S. looks to other areas of
- 18:37federal and state law to provide the same protections
- 18:39that would be afforded creators under a more
- 18:45traditional moral rights regime. the Just before
- 18:51the adoption of the 1976 Copyright Act, when
- 18:54the U .S. was making steps to adhere to Berne,
- 18:58Congress commissioned a study to look into whether
- 19:02or not U .S. copyright, U .S. law was sufficient
- 19:05to provide the more rights protections that are
- 19:08required under Article 6B of the Berne Convention.
- 19:10And ultimately, the result was that, yes, the
- 19:14committee found that there is sufficient protection
- 19:17through this patchwork of of moral rights. So
- 19:21I'm gonna go through a little bit to show some,
- 19:23this isn't an exhaustive selection of how it's
- 19:29protected, but these are kind of the main ones
- 19:31that you'll hear talked about most often. So
- 19:32the first one is Gilliam v. ABC. So this happened
- 19:37in the mid 70s. Essentially, Monty Python, the
- 19:43creators of a sketch comedy show called The Flying
- 19:45Circuit, Monty Python's Flying Circus, licensed
- 19:48their rights to the BBC, who then sub -licensed
- 19:52US broadcasting rights to ABC. In order to get
- 19:57the... the shows to fit U .S. broadcasting standards.
- 20:01They needed to cut about 25 minutes of material
- 20:03from each episode, which altered the comedic
- 20:06pacing. It changed some of the jokes. Those of
- 20:08you that might be fans of Monty Python know that,
- 20:11or the Flying Circus more specifically, know
- 20:12that there are recurring jokes and recurring
- 20:15themes that happen throughout the episode and
- 20:16callbacks that, if taken out of order, really
- 20:19lose a lot of comedic effect. After these edits
- 20:22were made without Monty Python's knowledge, they
- 20:25caught wind of the broadcast and they sued ABC
- 20:28for making these edits. Essentially, the Second
- 20:34Circuit held that unauthorized edits could constitute
- 20:38copyright infringement because they create a
- 20:40derivative work without the author's consent.
- 20:43They also made claims under the Lanham Act for
- 20:46passing off Meaning that the essentially that
- 20:51the this Monty Python derivative was a Knockoff
- 20:57of the original and this wasn't there it was
- 21:01Presented as if this was Monty Python when in
- 21:03fact this wasn't this was a bastardization of
- 21:06their art The court acknowledged that US copyright
- 21:09law did not recognize moral rights in the European
- 21:12sense ie the right of integrity Which is what
- 21:15was mainly at issue here, but the decision affects
- 21:18it effectively a approximated moral rights by
- 21:21holding that through the derivative works laws
- 21:23and the Lanham Act claim for false attribution,
- 21:29these theories of law were sufficient to protect
- 21:31the author's interests in preventing distortion
- 21:34or mutilation of their work. This case is often
- 21:37cited as the leading example of how US courts
- 21:39fill in the gaps to protect moral rights. Which
- 21:43brings us to another case, Daystar versus 20th
- 21:46Century Fox. Both of these cases are included
- 21:48in the reading materials that were distributed,
- 21:51if you want a more deeper dive. So essentially
- 21:54in Daystar, after World War II, General Eisenhower
- 21:57published a memoir called The Crusade in Europe,
- 22:01which was... telling of his experiences during
- 22:05World War II. Shortly after publication, 20th
- 22:08Century Fox optioned or acquired rights to produce
- 22:12a 26 episode television series, also called Crusade
- 22:15in Europe. Under the 1909 act, the producers
- 22:21did not apply for an extension term. So after
- 22:2328 years, the work fell into the public domain.
- 22:26In the 1990s, the Daystar Corp. purchased physical
- 22:30copies, video cassettes, of the original TV series.
- 22:34They spliced and cut and edited the footage and
- 22:38repackaged the material into a new video set
- 22:40called World War II Campaigns in Europe that
- 22:43made no mention of Eisenhower, made no mention
- 22:45of the original 20th Century Fox. production
- 22:53and then they sold it so Fox and its partners
- 22:56sued under the Lanham Act for reverse passing
- 22:59off this is selling someone someone else's work
- 23:03under your own label and state unfair competition
- 23:08laws. They couldn't make a copyright claim like
- 23:11the derivative works rule in Gilliam because
- 23:15the work was in the public domain. So in the
- 23:19Supreme Court in a unanimous decision written
- 23:21by Justice Scalia held that the Origin of Goods,
- 23:25as it's used in Section 43A of the Lanham Act,
- 23:28refers to the producer of the physical goods,
- 23:32here the video cassettes, and not the author
- 23:35of the underlying creative content. The court
- 23:38stressed that Congress had not adopted a general
- 23:40attribution right, and using trademark law to
- 23:45protect authorship would improperly extend expired
- 23:48copyrights. So effectively Daystar started to
- 23:52close the door on some of the legal reasoning
- 23:55in Gilliam and makes clear that there are limits
- 23:59to moral rights protections in the United States
- 24:02and perhaps showing that this patchwork has some
- 24:05flaws. To help address some of the flaws in this
- 24:10patchwork, the US did adopt VARA in the 1990s,
- 24:13which did grant some explicit, and as far as
- 24:17I know, the only statutory explicitly more rights
- 24:21provision than a statute. So VARA is a part of
- 24:27the Copyright Act that protects authors of works
- 24:30of visual art only. These are paintings, drawings,
- 24:33sculptures, still photographs that are in limited
- 24:36editions of 200 or fewer and signed and numbered.
- 24:40This does not apply to other areas of copyright,
- 24:43like literary works, musical, audio, visual,
- 24:44mass produced works even. And it granted some
- 24:47limited... Sorry about that. It granted some
- 24:52limited moral rights, including, sorry, I lost
- 24:57my notes here in the scrolling, including the
- 25:03right of attribution, the right of integrity
- 25:05to prevent. destruction and then an even further
- 25:09destruction protection for works of recognized
- 25:12stature. There are certainly exceptions for works
- 25:16that are part of the architecture and there's
- 25:19if you read the statute there's a lot of exceptions
- 25:21and procedures. Here the duration is only for
- 25:24the life of the author for individual works or
- 25:26for joint works until the death of the last surviving
- 25:29author and as I mentioned there are a lot of
- 25:31limitations here it only applies to works of
- 25:33original art of visual art and excludes applied
- 25:37art like posters, maps, as well as motion pictures,
- 25:39books, etc. Which brings us to section 1202 of
- 25:44the Digital Money and Copyright Act, which pertains
- 25:47to digital rights management. as the metadata
- 25:52that states who the copyright holder is or technological
- 25:58measures that prevent piracy or other changes
- 26:01in the work. This is a bit of a stretch, but
- 26:04it does speak to the right of attribution, the
- 26:06right of integrity a bit. And then finally, looking
- 26:11forward, included in the materials was a 20,
- 26:13I guess, looking back now, but the United States
- 26:16Copyright Office report from 2019, where they
- 26:18reevaluated moral rights and whether there was
- 26:20a need to adopt further statutory provisions.
- 26:23You'll see a more in -depth conversation of a
- 26:25lot of the cases that I talked about on this
- 26:27slide. And then also the same conclusion that
- 26:29the United States doesn't really need a statutory
- 26:33provision for moral rights that were covered
- 26:35under our patchwork. Before we move on to the
- 26:38next section, I'd just like to read this quote
- 26:40that ties in a lot of the concepts here. For
- 26:43the sake of legitimizing a hoped for adherence
- 26:46to burn, one school of thought holds that by
- 26:49stitching together the state law, paternity cases,
- 26:53state visual art statutes, the Monty Python case,
- 26:56and other scraps and fragments, we can fashion
- 26:59a loin cloth. or at least a G string that will
- 27:02cover our moral rights nakedness. And that's
- 27:05from Ralph Brown in 1988. So with that, I'll
- 27:08turn the time over to Josh to discuss neighboring
- 27:10rights. All right. So actually, Matt, can you
- 27:14flip back to slide three for just a minute? There
- 27:19we go. To go back to the roundels about the French
- 27:22and the German models, you will notice under
- 27:24the French model, there was... and under the
- 27:26German model, these are both translations of
- 27:29the words authors rights. And authors rights,
- 27:34I think it's worth bringing in sort of two dichotomies
- 27:38here. The first dichotomy, of course, is economic
- 27:40rights versus moral rights, which Matt has spoken
- 27:42about. But the second one is authors rights versus,
- 27:44and here I'm going to be slightly coy, non -authors
- 27:47rights. Matt, if you go back to, is it nine?
- 27:52I'm sorry, eight rather. Um, there we go. They've
- 27:54been rights, non -authors rights or neighborhood
- 27:56rights. Um, and they're not always called neighboring
- 27:59rights, but in more frequently than not, uh,
- 28:02in, in English and in particularly in the United
- 28:04States, we use neighboring rights, which comes
- 28:06from the German. Um, there, the concept is available
- 28:10in French, the related rights or the interest
- 28:13connects us in Spanish connected rights. These
- 28:16are rights that are not authors, but sit. next
- 28:19to them, or are related to them, or are connected
- 28:22to them. They're authors' rights like rights,
- 28:26but they're not actually authors' rights. It
- 28:29is somewhat difficult to define what they are,
- 28:33except by definition of what they aren't. And
- 28:36what they aren't isn't is, rather, authors' rights.
- 28:39And it's hard to define what authors' rights
- 28:41are, but I'm going to have a stab at it, at least
- 28:42as a rule of thumb. Authors' rights begin to
- 28:50clash with copyright when you start to have multilateral
- 28:54copyright treaties where you have to deal with
- 28:55these kinds of distinctions. The British and
- 28:58American copyright system didn't really think
- 29:01in terms of author's rights. And so when you
- 29:04start to have, on the one hand, the continental
- 29:06mob, and on the other hand, the Anglo mob, trying
- 29:09to work together to create something like Byrne,
- 29:11you have this dichotomy of definition. And in
- 29:15order to... It is helpful, perhaps, to put yourself
- 29:19in the mind of the 1880 legislator and artist
- 29:23and think, well, to what do authors' rights adhere?
- 29:27And a good rule of thumb is if, well, Matt's
- 29:31already made a... reference, and I made a Gilbert
- 29:35and Sullivan reference, and to continue our opera
- 29:37theme, for those who are familiar with Puccini's
- 29:39La Boheme, an opera set in Bohemian Paris of
- 29:43that period, I think the 1860s, and the various
- 29:46characters who are engaged in poetry and philosophy
- 29:49and painting in their artist garrets at the top
- 29:53floor of the apartment complex, if that's what
- 29:55you'd call it, top floor of the building just
- 29:57under the eaves. anything they could have made
- 30:00by themselves would qualify for author's rights.
- 30:03So the idea would be a painting, visual arts
- 30:07that can be done with a chisel or a paintbrush
- 30:09by a single author at home, a poem, a play, a
- 30:13novel, anything can be written by a pen, a map
- 30:19which could be done by somebody at home with
- 30:22a pen, anything of that nature, a musical composition,
- 30:26a person at home with his piano. and a pen writing
- 30:30down things on sheet music. Those things qualify
- 30:34for authors' rights. Everything else, with the
- 30:38gigantic asterisks we'll get to in a minute,
- 30:41is it. It's something else. It's a neighboring
- 30:42right. And a lot of what, initially, only those
- 30:46things were what were covered by the Bernkirchen.
- 30:48Everything else was outside of it. those who
- 30:54are familiar with the Berne Convention will know
- 30:56that a couple of things that I didn't mention,
- 30:58which were either current in 1880 or about to
- 31:02become current, have weaseled their way into
- 31:05the Berne Convention, but in a sort of second
- 31:06class status. Photography, which is a somewhat
- 31:10easier one to understand, in that you actually
- 31:13can do it kind of alone in your attic room, provided
- 31:15you can section off part of it as a dark room,
- 31:18but especially in its early days involved a lot
- 31:20of equipment. and technical know -how. And so
- 31:23I think was thought of as a kind of industrial
- 31:25process. The other one is cinematographic works,
- 31:29film and what is now television, which definitely
- 31:32is an industrial process. It involves lots of
- 31:34people. It requires a lot of money. But somewhat
- 31:37under the influence of the French school of cinema,
- 31:42ultimately also sort of landed in French law
- 31:44and in the Berne Convention as being something
- 31:46subject to author's rights. Other things never
- 31:50made it in. and the one that's most obvious and
- 31:52the one that is almost always talked about in
- 31:54the United States, whenever anybody mentions
- 31:55neighboring rights, neighboring rights in the
- 31:57U .S. is almost always in the music industry
- 32:00and almost always means simply performance of
- 32:03sound recordings, the monies that accrue to public
- 32:05performance of sound recordings under section
- 32:071066 of the Copyright Act. But it is a broader
- 32:11term than that. But sound recordings are one
- 32:13of those things that were thought of as being
- 32:15not really something that a single artist that
- 32:18has Garrett could do, and therefore subject to
- 32:22author's rights, a human right inherent in a
- 32:24human, but rather it's a sort of industrial process.
- 32:26You've got to go into the studio. There's a lot
- 32:28of expense involved. It's the kind of thing a
- 32:30company would do. And companies don't get moral
- 32:32rights to jump in the mat. They're not humans.
- 32:35They don't get author's rights. They're not really
- 32:37authors. This is a sort of property right that
- 32:40inheres an industry. And as a result, sound recordings
- 32:43have never been... incorporated into the Ingarden
- 32:46Convention, and most authors' rights systems
- 32:49don't think of them as authors' rights. By the
- 32:53way, I will jump back just briefly because I
- 32:55did want to mention with respect to photography
- 32:57and film, they are included in Byrne as author's
- 33:01rights. Not every jurisdiction treats them as
- 33:03author's rights. And both in Byrne and most of
- 33:05the jurisdictions which do treat them as such,
- 33:07they are treated in a sort of second class way.
- 33:09They don't get the same term. The standard term
- 33:13for author's rights for most works in Byrne is
- 33:15life of the author plus 50 years. But photography
- 33:18is, I believe, 25 years from fixation. That's
- 33:21your minimum standard. And film is 50 years from
- 33:25manufacture or publication. They are different
- 33:27standards. not really author's rights. They're
- 33:30sort of in there by courtesy, but they're not
- 33:32really there. Sound recordings have their own
- 33:33thing and are often outside of it. In addition
- 33:35to sound recordings, broadcasts and broadcast
- 33:38formats, I think particularly in Europe, you
- 33:40have a lot of countries jumping together with
- 33:42short quarters. That means radio and television
- 33:43broadcasts are constantly leaking across national
- 33:46borders and can be easily pirated. So there was
- 33:49a thought to be a need to protect that. And then
- 33:51performances. audio performances, of course,
- 33:54are fixed in sound recordings. And that's that
- 33:56that sort of falls into that category. But other
- 33:58performances, live performances that are unfixed
- 34:00or fixed performances in audio visual works are
- 34:04also perhaps neighboring or connected rights.
- 34:08They're not authors rights generally. Although,
- 34:10again, sometimes these lines can be alike. I
- 34:13have seen versions of this where part of it is
- 34:18often rights in the performance. has a sort of
- 34:21author's right in his performance. But the recording
- 34:23of that performance belongs to a film producer,
- 34:28for example, who doesn't have author's rights,
- 34:29but has some sort of neighboring rights. It's
- 34:31an odd dichotomy that gets, it's a sort of splicing
- 34:34of rights. But in any event, those are some common
- 34:38neighboring rights. There are possibly other
- 34:40things. It's not 100 % clear where the boundaries
- 34:43of neighboring rights are, except to the extent
- 34:44that they are something other than author's rights.
- 34:47that looks kind of like Wofford's rights. So
- 34:50to formalize a little bit more, if you can jump
- 34:52to the next slide, Matt, we can talk about three
- 34:56and I actually will add a fourth convention that
- 35:00address these issues. The Rome Convention is
- 35:04the first one and it deals with sound recordings
- 35:06and with broadcast formats. The US is not and
- 35:10has never been a signatory to the Rome Convention.
- 35:12In 1961, there was no federal protection for
- 35:15sound recordings. And it was thought improper,
- 35:19I think, for the United States to adhere to a
- 35:21treaty when federal government couldn't tell
- 35:22you what those rights were. They were, as those
- 35:25who followed the flow in any cases of the last
- 35:2715 years may have noticed, never really well
- 35:30-defined its state law. It fell to state law
- 35:33to protect sound recordings. nobody really knew
- 35:36what the parameters of those protections were.
- 35:39And of course, they presumably would have varied
- 35:40state by state. All of this has sort of gone
- 35:43away because the introduction of the Music Modernization
- 35:47Act in 2018 brought all of those pre -existing
- 35:50out of federal copyright sound recordings into
- 35:54federal protection. But this is why we had a
- 35:56series of cases headed by Flo and Eddie in the
- 35:59last 10 or 15 years, trying to figure out what
- 36:01those rights were vis -a -vis what they should
- 36:04be paid from public performance. And it varied
- 36:08from state to state, and there was a really questionable
- 36:11notion of what these rights were, if they ever
- 36:13existed at all. But importantly, the US did finally
- 36:18bring sound recordings into federal protection
- 36:20in 1972. Um, leaving, leaving prior sound recordings
- 36:24of hanging out there and state protection, but
- 36:26they never came back to Rome. They never said,
- 36:28you know, now that we have federal protection,
- 36:30we can sign onto the Rome convention. We never
- 36:31did. Um, this has real consequences that we're
- 36:34going to see in a minute. Um, but to jump ahead,
- 36:36even though they didn't sign on to Rome, um,
- 36:3935 years later, the U S now really a leader in,
- 36:42in copier and protection internationally, uh,
- 36:45pushed ahead with two treaties. I mentioned,
- 36:47uh, earlier, uh, that the Bernie convention was
- 36:50thought to be essentially unamendable. because
- 36:52by the 1970s or thereafter because there were
- 36:55so many members now that get unanimous approval
- 36:56would have been. effectively impossible. So instead
- 37:00of doing that, the U .S. effect, not just the
- 37:03U .S., the U .S. was a motivating force, but
- 37:05a number of countries sort of said, you know,
- 37:06we need to fix some things. The sort of two,
- 37:09for those of us who are old enough to remember,
- 37:11copyright hobby horses in the 1990s were technological
- 37:14protection measures and copyright management
- 37:17information. These were going to be the tools
- 37:18that were going to protect copyright in a digital
- 37:20age. And as a result, The goal of these two treaties,
- 37:25which are the WIPO Copyright Treaty and the WIPO
- 37:27Phonograms and Performances Treaty of 1996, was
- 37:31to put protections internationally on those additional
- 37:34parts that were not included in the Berne Convention
- 37:36or the Rome Convention. The idea that you were
- 37:39going to protect technological protection vendors
- 37:41and copyright management information and a few
- 37:43other things. So the US, which never signed Rome,
- 37:46did in fact sign the WPPT, which includes some
- 37:48protection for sound recordings and broadcasts,
- 37:54and also, oddly enough, includes a moral rights
- 37:56provision to which the US has made no effort
- 37:58to adhere whatsoever. But it is in there. It
- 38:02doesn't replace Rome. And one of the problems
- 38:05with US non -adherence to Rome is that, for those
- 38:08familiar with 1066, which was put into force
- 38:10in the 90s, it added a public performance right
- 38:14for sound recordings, but a very limited right.
- 38:17It collects only for digital performance. which
- 38:20for practical purposes means digital satellite
- 38:23radio, SiriusXM, or non -interactive streaming,
- 38:28which effectively means Pandora. And if it's
- 38:30streaming where unlike, say, Apple Music or Spotify,
- 38:34you can't pick what you're going to listen to.
- 38:36You can just only pick, gee, I'd like to listen
- 38:38to something like The Grateful Dead, or I'd like
- 38:40to listen to Adult Contemporary or some sort
- 38:42of genre, but you can't pick a particular song.
- 38:46So those two still fall under uh, uh, the, the
- 38:51one Oh six, six performance, right. Um, but it's
- 38:53a fairly limited, right? It doesn't cover things
- 38:55that are covered everywhere else. Like live performance,
- 38:58you go to a stadium and they, they, you know,
- 39:00the loudspeaker plays a recording. The stadium
- 39:03will have to pay a license to the music for a
- 39:06license to the musical composition holder, the
- 39:09music publisher or the composer, but not to the,
- 39:12to the record company or the sound recording,
- 39:14uh, performer. Um, in the U S in, in, in Europe
- 39:18or elsewhere, they have to pay. Um, this is also
- 39:21true for terrestrial broadcasts. So for when
- 39:24the BBC broadcasts recorded music, it must pay
- 39:26PRS, which is the equivalent of ASCAP or BMI
- 39:29for, for the musical composition. And it also
- 39:31must pay, uh, um, PPL, which is the equivalent
- 39:35of sound exchange. in the U .S. collecting for
- 39:38the sound reporting performance, right? And this
- 39:40is also true for television, broadcast, terrestrial
- 39:42television. But none of that is true in the U
- 39:44.S. So broadcast radio, broadcast television,
- 39:47live performance, sound exchange cannot collect.
- 39:50There is no exclusive right under 106 belonging
- 39:53to those rights holders for that kind of public
- 39:57performance. This creates a problem because most
- 40:00performing societies work by reciprocity. You
- 40:04collect for our guys and you give them money
- 40:06to us and we collect for your guys and we give
- 40:08them money to you. So normally, for example,
- 40:10PRS would collect monies for us sound recordings
- 40:13being performed in Britain and then send it over
- 40:16as appropriate to ask ever VMI or CSEC and then
- 40:19vice versa. Those organizations would collect
- 40:21for British source recordings in the US and send
- 40:24it for distribution to PPL in the UK. But foreign
- 40:30societies may say and some of them do. You know,
- 40:33I'm collecting here for your terrestrial broadcast,
- 40:35but why should I pay it to you? You're not paying
- 40:37it to us. Sound exchange doesn't send us monies
- 40:39for terrestrial broadcast or live performance
- 40:41to the U .S. Why should I give it to sound exchange?
- 40:43So they don't. As a result of which U .S. sound
- 40:48recordings rights holders and performers are
- 40:51unable to receive sometimes performance royalties
- 40:55for their performances that don't fall into their
- 40:58own convention because they were recorded here.
- 41:02The USMCA, which I will add for everyone's general
- 41:07enlightenment, is more euphoniously referred
- 41:09to in Canada as CUSMA, the Canada -US -Mexico
- 41:13agreement, which is the revision of NAFTA from
- 41:16the first Trump administration, includes among
- 41:20many other provisions a requirement that Canada
- 41:22and Mexico treat the U .S. as if it were a Roman
- 41:25convention country for purposes of collecting
- 41:28and transmitting public performances. So when
- 41:32CBC, the Canadian broadcasting company, broadcasts
- 41:35a U .S. source sound recording, the Canadian
- 41:39societies must collect through that and transmit
- 41:40to the U .S. as if it were a Canadian sound recording
- 41:45and not a U .S. sound recording. And the same
- 41:48is also true in Mexico. Um, finally, one thing
- 41:50I will throw on here that is not on this chart,
- 41:52but which I think is worth mentioning, we've
- 41:53talked all about sound recordings and to a certain
- 41:55extent about broadcasts. Um, what we haven't
- 41:57talked about is, is audio visual performances.
- 41:59Um, this was thought about as part of the white
- 42:02boat performances and photographs treaty in 1996,
- 42:04but it was pushed away to say like, well, we'll
- 42:06do that later. So negotiations began in 2000
- 42:09for something which became the Beijing audio
- 42:11visual performances tree. The U S signed it in
- 42:142012, but has never ratified. And it doesn't
- 42:17look like it's that's a that's gonna happen anytime
- 42:19soon However, a bunch of other countries have
- 42:22and from 2020 it's entered into force. What this
- 42:24means is that Unlike in the US and for those
- 42:28of us who remember Google versus Garcia In which
- 42:32the Ninth Circuit almbank reversed itself or
- 42:34reversed the earlier panel to say now artists
- 42:36authors Excuse me actors have no copyright in
- 42:40their performances other jurisdictions Argentina
- 42:43for one off the top of my head have specific
- 42:47rights adhering to performers in their performances.
- 42:50And sometimes those are pushed to the performer.
- 42:54Sometimes they are accorded to the producer of
- 42:57the film and sometimes they're split down the
- 42:58middle to both. But be aware that in many jurisdictions
- 43:02where the actors themselves or other performers
- 43:06on stage, comedians, musicians in an audio visual
- 43:09work have rights in their their audio visual
- 43:12performances that are not that don't exist in
- 43:15the United States. Can we flip to slide 10? Ah,
- 43:23we come to artificial intelligence. Go ahead.
- 43:26Yeah, that's everyone's favorite part of a 2026
- 43:30CLE, the discussion, the obligatory discussion
- 43:32on artificial intelligence. While saving time,
- 43:36I know we have 15 minutes left for questions.
- 43:38I'm actually going to take this opportunity to
- 43:40answer one of the questions in the chat because
- 43:42it'll. nicely guide into this part of the discussion.
- 43:46So Maxwell Herrera asks, do you think some more
- 43:48rights from EU countries might be beneficial
- 43:50here in the USA? Perhaps it would help protect
- 43:53writers and others in New York City and Hollywood
- 43:55to combat AI dangers. I think that adopting more
- 44:02rights certainly could help protect creators
- 44:06in the wave of artificial intelligence. And one
- 44:09way that that could be done is by affording and
- 44:13this is kind of an amalgamation of a neighboring
- 44:14right and a moral right, by affording mandatory
- 44:19compulsory attribution for AI bots. So to kind
- 44:25of illustrate this, as I'm sure many of the copyright
- 44:29practitioners in the room today have been tracking,
- 44:32shortly before Shira Perlmutter was... purportedly
- 44:36terminated as the Registrar of Copyrights, the
- 44:39Copyright Office issued several papers discussing
- 44:45artificial intelligence and copyright. And one
- 44:47of their conclusions was that the outputs of
- 44:50an LLM, the Large Language Model, is not eligible
- 44:55for copyright because it's not sufficiently,
- 44:57it's not created by human and sufficiently creative.
- 45:03what that's required is in the registration process,
- 45:09copyright holders now need to identify portions
- 45:11of their work which were created using artificial
- 45:14intelligence. And as one of our colleagues in
- 45:16the Copyright Society pointed out at the Copyright
- 45:19and Tech Conference last fall here in New York
- 45:21City, this creates kind of a wonky incentive
- 45:24structure. Because what you're on one hand doing
- 45:27is requiring applicants to go through and do
- 45:32the work of identifying what was created by AI,
- 45:34which in many cases with how folks are implementing
- 45:37AI into their workflow is quite tedious to kind
- 45:42of identify what that is. But once they put that
- 45:47work in, what they are doing is removing protection
- 45:50from their work. So you're asking creators to
- 45:54work to... get less of a copyright. So one proposal
- 45:59is, I don't know if anyone's actually proposed
- 46:02this. Someone probably has. Someone much smarter
- 46:05than me has probably thought about this much
- 46:06harder. But what my thoughts are, if we provide
- 46:11attribution rights to LLM bots, meaning like
- 46:15when works are published, when they're registered,
- 46:18if you identify it, the person that is utilizing
- 46:23This is the neighboring rights part of it. The
- 46:24person that's utilizing the output for their
- 46:26original work gets some form of limited protection
- 46:30in that work while also identifying that this
- 46:35was created by AI. And I think this accomplishes
- 46:37a few things. One, if you know that it's AI and
- 46:40you like the way that this was written, then
- 46:44you can go, it's free advertising, it's good
- 46:46advertising for the LLM, for good, it encourages
- 46:49the development of decent, good LLMs, which we've
- 46:53seen, some of them are better than others. It
- 46:55also, there's product liabilities issues here,
- 46:58where if something dangerous comes from an LLM,
- 47:00we know where it came from. And also it protects
- 47:03the consumers, which I think we'll see a lot
- 47:05of trends of, that people... if they knowingly
- 47:10have the choice between consuming human created
- 47:12content and content that's been created by a
- 47:14robot, I think many people are going to choose
- 47:18the work that was created by a human just out
- 47:20of principle, whether or not that work has more
- 47:23merit or less than that created by the robot.
- 47:26So that's just one example of how I think that
- 47:29moral rights can help protect creators in the
- 47:33United States. Of course, you know, maybe now
- 47:37is a better time than any for us to adopt more
- 47:39rights, but I think we've seen, you know, hundreds
- 47:42of years of reluctance on the US's part, on Congress's
- 47:45part to formally adopt explicit more rights.
- 47:50I'll turn it over to Josh to talk about some
- 47:51other applications and neighboring rights. Yeah,
- 47:55so one thing I wanted, I found very interesting,
- 47:58a colleague of this pointed out, excuse me, a
- 47:59colleague of mine pointed this out to me a year
- 48:02or two ago at a conference in Berlin. One would
- 48:06have thought that given the European and the
- 48:10continental model sort of exaltation of the author
- 48:15as a genius creator, human, and indeed the theoretical
- 48:21underpinning of the French and German models
- 48:23is copyrighted as a natural right adherent to
- 48:26the author. The work is a spiritual child of
- 48:29the author. This is not an economic right. It's
- 48:31a natural human right and it here is in humans,
- 48:35given that as a sort of basis that Europe will
- 48:39be at least as resistant as the United States
- 48:41has been to granting copyright or rather authors
- 48:44rights to computer generated work. That thinking
- 48:51is only good to you so far when you remember
- 48:53that the Europeans Well, that's the earth's most
- 48:55of the rest of the world takes the difference
- 48:57between authors rights and neighboring rights
- 48:59quite seriously neighboring rights have never
- 49:01had sort of human rights underpinning to them
- 49:04They're just economic rights belonging to a creator.
- 49:06I'm sorry. Excuse me. We're going to a producer
- 49:08an economic So we look at to sort of take it
- 49:12back I mentioned that WPPT the white both phonograms
- 49:15and performances tree of 1996 has a moral rights
- 49:18provision in that There are rights granted to
- 49:21both the producer and the performer. Economic
- 49:23rights go to the producer, but moral rights go
- 49:25to the performer. And they're completely separate
- 49:27in this sort of French model of a dualist system
- 49:29where there are two sets of rights. But it explicitly
- 49:34affords moral rights to the performers of phonograms,
- 49:37which is to say sound recordings, a right of
- 49:39attribution, a right of integrity. But who is
- 49:42the performer of a computer generated work? And
- 49:45some of you may know that there is a I'm gonna
- 49:48use the word performer here in enormous scare
- 49:50quotes. Under the name Hatsune Miku, she is a
- 49:54Japanese pop star who is not a real person. It's
- 49:58a computer generated icon. She's touring this
- 50:00year in Chicago and Newark and a couple of other
- 50:02places. And she is not, she's a character, a
- 50:05sort of cartoon character that's projected up
- 50:07on a screen and then dances around while a synthesized
- 50:11voice sings her songs. So who is? is this performer
- 50:18who's going to get these moral rights under the
- 50:20WPPT. Under UK law, there is actually a specific
- 50:25requirement. It's section 93 of the Copyright
- 50:30Designs and Patents Act 1988. Computer -generated
- 50:34works do actually get author's rights, not neighboring
- 50:38rights, author's rights, but they've expressed
- 50:39and disclaimed any moral rights protection. Taking
- 50:44that outside putting it in the continental mob
- 50:46where they haven't explicitly said well computer
- 50:49-generated works will get author's rights. I
- 50:50suspect they won't Sound recordings have never
- 50:53been subject to author's rights. They shouldn't
- 50:55be accorded to whoever the producer is I think
- 50:58they had Sunimiku example would be a good one
- 51:01Whatever rights there are just adhere to whoever
- 51:03the the the industrial entity that created it,
- 51:08or put in place the situation where it can be
- 51:12created. So the US, because it doesn't make a
- 51:16substantive distinction between authors' rights
- 51:18and neighboring rights, has simply said that
- 51:20anything that's created by a machine cannot have
- 51:23any kind of copyright without distinguishing
- 51:25between the authors' rights regimes and the neighboring
- 51:28rights regimes. So we may see a divergence between
- 51:33the continental models. and the U .S. model,
- 51:35particularly the U .S. model, as to whether or
- 51:38not, at least in neighboring rights circumstances,
- 51:41whether AI -generated works can have economic
- 51:44or moral rights attached to them. I'd be interested
- 51:46to see how the moral rights thing plays out.
- 51:49Yeah, there are a lot of questions about, I mean,
- 51:51you know, it seems the world of artificial intelligence,
- 51:55especially from a legal standpoint, is certainly
- 51:57still the Wild West, which we're speaking to
- 52:01Californians here. So maybe that's not a PC term.
- 52:04that we use out in New York. But with that, we
- 52:11would love to stay connected. The QR codes beneath
- 52:15our respective pictures will take you to our
- 52:17LinkedIn page. We would love to continue the
- 52:20conversation. Please feel free to reach out to
- 52:22us, add us, message us. Stay in contact, however
- 52:26you'd like. With that, I know there are a few
- 52:28questions in the Q &A. If there are any more,
- 52:32please feel free to type them out and we'll do
- 52:33our best to answer them in the next six minutes.
- 52:36Josh, just scrolling through these, I see one
- 52:38question that I think you would like to answer
- 52:40just based on our conversations. This is from
- 52:42Jay Doherty. Can a U .S. record company and or
- 52:46recording artist obtain payments from e .g. European
- 52:49broadcast or digital transmissions of their recordings?
- 52:52How could they do that? First, hi Jay, I haven't
- 52:56seen you in years, but I hope you're well. Secondly,
- 52:59I understand the question is how can U .S. artists
- 53:01obtain payment for performances overseas? Is
- 53:03that the question? I think so, yeah. you can
- 53:08obtain them through SoundExchange. If a U .S.
- 53:10artist is a member of SoundExchange, SoundExchange
- 53:12will receive some money from overseas. Some foreign
- 53:15collecting societies for sound recording performance
- 53:17will just hand over the money regardless of the
- 53:19lack of reciprocity or under law, for example,
- 53:22under KUSMA, where the Canadians and Mexicans
- 53:24have to do it whether they want to or not. But
- 53:28another way to deal with it is to join SoundExchange.
- 53:33but limit sound exchange collections solely for
- 53:35the United States, and then join a foreign society
- 53:38for foreign collections. So you could say, I'm
- 53:40a member of sound exchange for U .S. performances,
- 53:44but sound exchange is not allowed to collect
- 53:46anywhere else in the world. And instead, I will
- 53:48separately become a member of PPL, the UK's Collecting
- 53:51Society, and say, hey, PPL, you collect every
- 53:53place that is in the United States. So they'll
- 53:55collect through the British performances, but
- 53:56then also through their reciprocity agreements
- 53:58will collect for around the world. Another way
- 54:02to do this. I am told, is to record, even as
- 54:05a U .S. citizen and a U .S. artist, if you go
- 54:09and record in a Rome Convention country, that
- 54:11recording is a Rome Convention recording and
- 54:13is subject to collection as if it were, as if
- 54:16you were not an American. So that is another
- 54:20route is to send recording artists and say, go
- 54:22record in Canada or Britain and do it that way.
- 54:28Just as a side note, I'm going through the attendees
- 54:31here and I see that my former professor, Marshall,
- 54:34is in the audience. So hi, Professor Silverman.
- 54:36It's good to see you. I'm so honored that you
- 54:38joined. Another question from Dean Serwin regarding
- 54:43non -interactive performance. What is Spotify
- 54:45when it goes into radio mode, playing things
- 54:48that others who selected what I did might have
- 54:51also played, i .e. things that I might also like?
- 54:54I think the answer to that, Josh, correct me
- 54:56if I'm wrong, is that when you go into radio
- 54:59mode into Spotify, it's treated, it's the same
- 55:03thing as Pandora. It is treated the way that
- 55:07Josh described with the non -interactive. It's
- 55:09when you use Spotify and what we think of as
- 55:12maybe the traditional sense where you are selecting
- 55:14exactly what song you'd like to be played that
- 55:17it becomes non -interactive media. Anything else
- 55:20to add, Josh? No, I think that's right. There
- 55:22is I believe there's a certain set of standards
- 55:25that are put and I've looked into this once some
- 55:27years ago in the Copyright Act and sort of define
- 55:30how how you have to behave as a Transmitter to
- 55:35be to fall into the non interactive category.
- 55:37You can't have sort of the same artist over and
- 55:39over again You have to divide it up within X
- 55:41number of hours. You can't perform the same artist
- 55:43again the same song again There's a whole rule,
- 55:45but it looks actually oddly enough like the kind
- 55:47of internal policies we had at a radio station
- 55:49I worked at in the 1990s. You know, like don't
- 55:52bore the listeners, don't just play the same
- 55:53stuff over and over again. But adopting for the
- 55:56purpose of essentially avoiding a Spotify -like
- 56:00service. I should say the specific thing that
- 56:03Dean mentions, and by the way, hi Dean, that
- 56:05I don't know Spotify as being a good thing because
- 56:08I'm not a Spotify user. But I agree with you.
- 56:12It sounds like they have an interactive and a
- 56:15non -interactive service. The interactive service
- 56:17is substitutes for purchasing. Gee, I'm not going
- 56:19to buy this record. I can just play it on Spotify
- 56:21whenever I want to. And alternatively, the interactive,
- 56:24it's like radio. I turn it on, and I have a general
- 56:27idea what I'm getting. I'm not going to get classical
- 56:29on the Classic Rock station. But I can't pick
- 56:32the particular thing they're going to play me
- 56:33next. I think we have time for maybe one or two
- 56:36more. Josh, it's like a comparative law question
- 56:40that you would be perfect at answering. This
- 56:43is also from Jay Doherty. Can a US company be
- 56:46transferred the economic rights in a German authored
- 56:48work? What would a typical assignment agreement
- 56:51accomplish? And how would a typical assignment
- 56:53agreement accomplish that? What about a work
- 56:55made for hire with alternate assignment agreements,
- 56:58i .e. how does choice of law work here? This
- 57:01is that question is I can only take the first
- 57:04part of the second one. It's so long and complicated
- 57:05I can't even tend to tackle in the amount of
- 57:07time. Although it is a very interesting question
- 57:08The first one I will answer by saying two things
- 57:11one and I usually say this at the start of every
- 57:13presentation I'm not a German lawyer. I'm not
- 57:15an international lawyer per se I I'm only admitted
- 57:18in three Jewish jurisdiction, but I am told by
- 57:21European lawyers that the The German model, which
- 57:26applies not just in Germany, but in a number
- 57:27of Germans, you know, all the German speaking
- 57:29territories, Austria, Switzerland, but also most
- 57:32of Eastern Europe, the Nordic countries and to
- 57:35in a highly modified form, East Asia. Prohibits
- 57:39actual assignments of a copyright. You cannot
- 57:42assign it. And to the extent you try to do so,
- 57:44it's a no, it's a non transfer. You can, however,
- 57:47license exclusively for life of copyright, which
- 57:49is for all intents and purposes, an assignment,
- 57:51but it isn't formally an assignment. So. I think
- 57:54the best practice is to, if you were going to
- 57:58say, I want these rights, the author conveys
- 58:02to me or assigns to me all rights. And if that
- 58:04fails, it grants it a lifetime of a life of copyright
- 58:11exclusive license to me for the same work, which
- 58:14is for almost all intents and purposes the same,
- 58:18but avoids the problem that an actual assignment
- 58:20is apparently a nullity under German law. Okay,
- 58:24so that takes us to two o 'clock. Thank you guys
- 58:26so much for joining. We were honored to present
- 58:29to Beverly Hills. Please stay in touch. Thank
- 58:31you so much.