Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Tracing Deportation Flights" with Gillian Brockell
Transcript
- 0:03You're listening to a stage talk titled Tracing
- 0:05Deportation Flights with Gillian Brockell. After
- 0:09running a continuous blog, publishing investigations
- 0:12at well -known news sites and maintaining a global
- 0:15tracker of these types of flights, Gillian felt
- 0:17like the right person to walk us through how
- 0:19to do this kind of open source work. This stage
- 0:23talk is best listened to whilst you explore the
- 0:25tools simultaneously. Gillian broke down the
- 0:28basic tools of her craft and provided some insight
- 0:31into her own experience reporting on this escalating
- 0:34issue. You can find links to all the resources
- 0:37mentioned in the talk in the podcast description.
- 0:40This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Maher on
- 0:43Thursday, the 14th of May, 2026 in the Bellingcat
- 0:46Discord server. Hello all and welcome to another
- 0:58stage talk. This week, we're joined by independent
- 1:01journalist Gillian Brockell, whose work sits
- 1:04at the intersection of open source intelligence,
- 1:07investigative journalism, aviation data and public
- 1:09accountability. A former flight attendant, Gillian
- 1:12has exposed that the US Coast Guard had done
- 1:15hundreds of ice flights on planes meant for search
- 1:18and rescue. was the first to identify the aircraft
- 1:21carrying seven third country nationals to South
- 1:24Sudan last May when it was still mid -flight.
- 1:27She helped to reveal the full extent of Kristi
- 1:29Noem's aircraft buying spree that contributed
- 1:32to her being removed from the DHS and uncovered
- 1:35ICE's secret use of commercial flights to send
- 1:37Liam Ramos and other captured migrant children
- 1:39to the Dili Detention Centre, amongst many other
- 1:42stories. Over the last several years, aircraft
- 1:44tracking has evolved from a niche hobby into
- 1:47a powerful reporting and research methodology,
- 1:50one which we've really tracked within this server.
- 1:54Publicly available aviation signals, registries
- 1:57and flight databases are now regularly used to
- 2:00investigate government operations, migration
- 2:02enforcement, military logistics, corporate activity,
- 2:05sanctions evasion, and crisis response. At the
- 2:08same time, flight tracking isn't something covered
- 2:10in Jensen training or familiar to the general
- 2:12public, so gaps in knowledge arise. Today, we're
- 2:16hoping to close some of those gaps. Gilliam will
- 2:18walk us through the fundamentals of aircraft
- 2:20tracking, the strengths and weaknesses of major
- 2:23flight tracking platforms, techniques for identifying
- 2:25government and ICE -associated flights, and the
- 2:28broader investigative toolkits surrounding aviation
- 2:31data. We will have time for audience questions.
- 2:34You can place your questions in the chat accessible
- 2:36on the right -hand corner of your screen. But
- 2:38please remember that this is being audio recorded
- 2:40for the podcast. So if you don't want me to mention
- 2:43your username, please add that as a note in your
- 2:46question. Okay. Gillian, let's hear more about
- 2:50your work. All right. Thank you so much, Charlie.
- 2:54Hi, everyone. I'm Gillian. I track and report
- 2:56on ice flights, as Charlie said. And I use a
- 3:00lot of flight tracking tools or some of that
- 3:03with you today. And I know that there are a lot
- 3:05of avgeeks in the Bellingcat community. So I
- 3:07just want to apologize in advance. I'm going
- 3:10to assume no aviation knowledge in my talk. And
- 3:14so if a lot of this is repetitive for you, I
- 3:16am sorry. So first I'll talk about signal types,
- 3:20some basic terms and aircraft identifiers. how
- 3:24to use ADS -B Exchange, how to identify an ICE
- 3:28flight, and then I'll touch on some other tools
- 3:31for flight tracking in general, and ICE flights
- 3:34in particular. So there are several types of
- 3:38signals on different aircraft, but by far the
- 3:42most common is ADS -B, which stands for Automatic
- 3:46Dependent Surveillance Broadcast. It's basically
- 3:48the replacement, a modern day replacement for
- 3:51radar, and it's a lot more accurate. So ADS -B
- 3:56sends out information about itself, its identification,
- 4:00aircraft type, location, altitude, and speed.
- 4:03And the key thing about it is that it transmits
- 4:06this flight info to any receiver within range,
- 4:10other aircraft, air traffic control, satellites,
- 4:14and to aviation enthusiasts or av geeks who've
- 4:18bought their own receivers. and set them up in
- 4:21their homes. And that will become very important
- 4:24later in the talk. So in general, civil aircraft
- 4:28are required to have ADS -B on any time they're
- 4:32operating. There are some exceptions, but I'm
- 4:34not going to get into that. It won't really matter
- 4:35here. Military aircraft. Most military aircraft
- 4:40are equipped with ADS -B, but they often have
- 4:44it set in a mode where they're taking in everyone
- 4:47else's ADS -B information, but they're not transmitting
- 4:51their own. However, they do use ADS -B sometimes,
- 4:55and they also use other signals, other signal
- 4:58types that are detectable by most aircraft most
- 5:01of the time. So usually military aircraft only
- 5:06go completely dark and untrackable. when they're
- 5:10in an active combat mission or if they are doing
- 5:13surveillance. And if you ever see a military
- 5:17plane on a flight tracking app and it has like
- 5:20a really squiggly line, that just means that
- 5:23it's being tracked by multilateration, which
- 5:26is not as accurate as ADS -B. It doesn't mean
- 5:29that the plane is actually squiggling around
- 5:31like that. Okay, so let's talk about some basic
- 5:35aircraft terms and identifiers. The first thing
- 5:37you might hear about is the registration number,
- 5:40which is also called a tail number or an end
- 5:43number. Those are all the same thing. This is
- 5:47basically the aircraft's license plate. It has
- 5:50to be visibly displayed on the back of every
- 5:54plane on both sides. And that's probably what
- 5:58you'll use. It's what I use most of the time
- 6:01when flight tracking. And like a license plate,
- 6:03the numbers can be totally random or custom.
- 6:08So you'll see some funny custom and numbers sometimes.
- 6:12And in the US, all non -military aircraft, their
- 6:15registration number starts with the letter N,
- 6:17as in Nancy. That's where N number comes from.
- 6:20And in the UK, it's the letter G. Every country
- 6:24has their own. Kenya is 5Y. I have no idea why,
- 6:27but it is. And then U .S. military registrations
- 6:31are generally numbers only, no letters. And they
- 6:35usually, not always, start with two digits that
- 6:38correspond to the year they came into service,
- 6:41a dash, and then four digits. So nine, eight,
- 6:44dash, one, two, three, four. A call sign is a
- 6:49unique identifier for a flight that is made up
- 6:52of letters and numbers. The call sign can just
- 6:56be the end number. A lot of private jets will
- 6:59just have the end number be the call sign. But
- 7:02in commercial air travel, the letters are generally
- 7:05an abbreviation of the carrier's name, and the
- 7:08numbers are generally the flight number that
- 7:10are on your ticket. So JetBlue flight 1690 from
- 7:14JFK to Austin is always going to have the call
- 7:18sign JDU 1690, regardless of the tail number
- 7:22on that particular day. This is also the ID that
- 7:25air traffic controllers use to communicate with
- 7:29pilots. So if you overhear ATC recordings, they'll
- 7:32be like, jibber, you're 1690, blah, blah, blah,
- 7:34blah, blah. And yeah. So then I'm just going
- 7:38to talk about hex and squawk numbers very briefly
- 7:41because I don't use them that much and they're
- 7:43not that useful for flight tracking. The hex
- 7:46code is essentially an international tail number.
- 7:51for all aircraft, military, and civil. It's a
- 7:54little more complicated than that. Doesn't matter
- 7:56here. It always has six characters and they'll
- 7:59be the letters A through F and the digits zero
- 8:02through nine. And it's also sometimes called
- 8:05an ICAO number. ICAO is like the International
- 8:09FAA. It's like aviation governing body. And they're
- 8:12the ones that give out the numbers. So that's
- 8:14why it's sometimes called ICAO. Squawk. All you
- 8:18need to know about the squawk is that squawking
- 8:217700 means the airplane is experiencing an emergency.
- 8:26Okay, so one more term and then I swear to God
- 8:29we'll look at the lab now. That term is LAD,
- 8:33L -A -D -D. It stands for limited aircraft data
- 8:38displayed. In the U .S. an aircraft owner can
- 8:42apply to the FAA for a LAD designation. And what
- 8:46that will do is hide the tail number and the
- 8:49call sign from flight tracking apps that get
- 8:52their data from government -owned ADS -B receivers.
- 8:56So on Flight Radar 24 and FlightAware, you might
- 9:01see that there is a GoStream 6 flying over Austin.
- 9:05But you won't see that the tail number is N6Q8TS,
- 9:11which is one of Elon Musk's private jets. and
- 9:14it's generally used by rich people to hide their
- 9:17private jets from public view. That's the basic
- 9:19purpose. But this is really important for tracking
- 9:22ICE flights because in April of last year, the
- 9:27FAA gave lab designation to all ICE charter airlines.
- 9:32So for activists, immigration attorneys, family
- 9:35members of immigrants in ICE custody, or just
- 9:38the general public who poke around on those apps,
- 9:42ICE's air operation basically disappeared. And
- 9:46that same month is when their activities really
- 9:49started to boom under the Trump administration.
- 9:53So without further ado, let's look at the live
- 9:56map for ADS -B Exchange. And my share screen
- 9:59function is not working, so we're going to go
- 10:01to Charlie's screen. She unfortunately doesn't
- 10:05have ADS -B Exchange premium, so she's going
- 10:08to have pop -up ads. If you want to pan out so
- 10:14we can see all of North America, that would be
- 10:16great. And that'll just, great. Fantastic. So
- 10:20it'll just take a minute for all of the flight
- 10:22data to come in. Beautiful. So this is a map
- 10:30of all of the aircraft that ADS -B exchange receivers
- 10:37are getting right now. All right, so this is
- 10:42a collection of all the flight data from thousands
- 10:46of avgeeks all over the world who have set up
- 10:50their own receivers. And because they aren't
- 10:53getting the data from the government, the LAD
- 10:56designation does not matter. It means absolutely
- 10:59nothing. And so all of the information is collected
- 11:02and transmitted here. So if you're listening
- 11:05to this on the podcast, we are looking at a map
- 11:08of North America. And it is completely covered
- 11:11in airplane icons, mostly hot pink and purple,
- 11:16but other colors too. And the colors correspond
- 11:19to altitude. So a plane on the ground is orange.
- 11:24It takes off, it turns yellow. As it's climbing,
- 11:26it turns green, then blue. Then purple is the
- 11:29cruising altitude for most planes. And you can
- 11:32probably see that most of the hot pink icons
- 11:36are like smaller airplane icons. Those are private
- 11:42jets. Private jets tend to cruise at 45 ,000
- 11:46feet because it's faster up there. All right,
- 11:52so let's just look at some of the basic functions
- 11:56here. So in the upper right column, you'll see
- 12:00the search and then filters and columns. We're
- 12:06just going to look at search and filters. You
- 12:09can use the main search bar for most of the things
- 12:13you want to do on ADS -B. So let's look for Elon
- 12:19Musk's plane. Just in the main search bar, you
- 12:21can put N628TS. And we see another pop -up come
- 12:29up. that shows the information for that aircraft.
- 12:33You might need to reload to get the screen to
- 12:37isolate. Okay, great. So we're not seeing anything,
- 12:41so that means it hasn't flown in the last 24
- 12:43hours. But what we can do, in that column, you'll
- 12:47see the word history, and you'll click that plus
- 12:50sign, and you'll see the UTC date. The UTC is
- 12:53just universal time. also called Zulu time. It's
- 12:58the same as Greenwich Mean Time. And so where
- 13:01it says previous, yeah, you can click a specific
- 13:04day like you're already doing. Fantastic. Or
- 13:06you can click previous. I think it flew yesterday.
- 13:09And we see a flight come up. And then you'll
- 13:12also see there, you'll see all of the unique
- 13:15information for that aircraft. It's tail number.
- 13:19It's type. Type code just means the type of plane
- 13:22that it is. the call sign that it used, the last
- 13:28time that it flew. All right, very good. And
- 13:31yeah, so if you can X out of that, we'll get
- 13:34the full screen back. And now we'll use the main
- 13:36screen, the main search bar again, to search
- 13:40a call sign. So global X, global crossing, also
- 13:45called global crossing, is ICE's main charter
- 13:49carrier. They always use the call sign GXA. So
- 13:54we'll just put GXA in the main search bar. And
- 13:58it's going to bring up all of the planes that
- 14:00are in the air right now for Global X. And if
- 14:06you scroll over one of the planes, so we'll see
- 14:11GXA 6108. So one thing that we flight trackers
- 14:17know from having tracked a lot of Global X planes,
- 14:20at all of their call signs that are ICE flights.
- 14:24GXA then four digits and it starts at the six.
- 14:27So this is an ICE flight. And then if you can
- 14:30go to the history and we can see that all of
- 14:34the planes that it has brought up have been doing
- 14:36the last few days. And it looks like a lot of
- 14:39ICE flights. All ICE flights take off and return
- 14:44from the same city and ICE airs main hub cities.
- 14:49are Alexandria, Louisiana, which you have your
- 14:52cursor over right now, Harlingen, Texas, El Paso,
- 14:56and Mesa, Arizona. All right. So if you want
- 15:00to clear that search, I'm going to show you the
- 15:04more specific filters. So if you can click that
- 15:08filters tab. So all of this information, you
- 15:12can ask for it more specifically. So one of the
- 15:16pitfalls of the search bar I did GXA. It's going
- 15:20to show me anything that has GXA in any of its
- 15:25flight information. So it might show me a plane
- 15:27in Brazil. It's just a little prop plane that
- 15:31has GXA in its tail number. So if we do it by
- 15:36call sign here, we have the call sign option,
- 15:40GXA, then I'm just going to be getting the Global
- 15:43X planes. Using the main search bar is going
- 15:46to be mostly right most of the time. And you
- 15:49can see you can do it by type. So say I heard
- 15:54about an ICE flight that was going to Africa
- 15:58that was on a new carrier that they hadn't used
- 16:01before, and I didn't know the N number. Well,
- 16:04I know that most ICE flights to Africa are on
- 16:08Gulfstream 5s. So maybe I would put in GLF 5
- 16:12and search. And that's going to show me all the
- 16:14Gulfstream 5s in the air right now. And that
- 16:17might help me to figure out which plane that
- 16:20was. And then if you scroll down, you can see,
- 16:25you can look at, I only want to see planes with
- 16:28the LAD designation. I only want to see planes
- 16:31with a LAD designation. I only want to see military
- 16:35aircraft. I only want to see aircraft that are
- 16:39registered in the United States or in any country.
- 16:42There are specific boxes for all of those. And
- 16:46you can also do it by signal. As you can see,
- 16:49there's ADS -B signal, MLAP mode S. You probably
- 16:54won't use those. OK, so those are the basics.
- 16:58So how do you tell if an ICE flight is an ICE
- 17:04flight? Because remember, these charter airlines,
- 17:08they do also have other clients, not every Global
- 17:11X flight. is going to be an ICE flight. And ICE
- 17:16is also adding new charter partners all the time.
- 17:19I think they've added four of them this year.
- 17:24So first, all ICE trips start and end in an ICE
- 17:27detention hub city. Like I said, Alexandria,
- 17:30Louisiana is the main one, El Paso, Harlingen,
- 17:33Texas, Mesa, Arizona. They're all out and back
- 17:36patterns. You can learn a lot. about an aircraft
- 17:40and what it's being used for just by the patterns.
- 17:43And they're all going to go back the way they
- 17:46came. They generally only stop somewhere for
- 17:50about two hours. And when they have to do a fuel
- 17:55stop or lay over for crew rest, if they're doing
- 17:59like an Africa or Asia deportation, they tend
- 18:03to use the same cities over and over. And then,
- 18:07like I said, most of these airlines also have
- 18:09call sign conventions for their ICE flights.
- 18:12So Global X has GXA, four digits, and they'll
- 18:16start with the number six. If an ICE flight isn't
- 18:21meeting all of these, or if a flight isn't meeting
- 18:24all of these criteria, then I'm not going to
- 18:26say it's an ICE flight. So there could be ICE
- 18:31flights that aren't meeting these criteria. you
- 18:35know, for reporting purposes you want to, you
- 18:37know, are on the side of caution. There are generally
- 18:40about 50 ice flights a day. And then the last
- 18:43button I want to show you, if you see those blue
- 18:47icons that are by themselves next to a black
- 18:51info column, the bottom button that's a triangle
- 18:54with a circle on it, if you click on that, this
- 18:58is going to be how you look at a certain area
- 19:00over time. So if you want to zoom in on Central
- 19:06Louisiana. We'll get Alexandria up here. So you
- 19:11can see on this bottom bar that came up, we have
- 19:16date, and then we have UTC time, and we have
- 19:19speed. So say I wanted to look on a certain day,
- 19:23I used this button for my Coast Guard reporting
- 19:27because I didn't have the tail numbers. But a
- 19:30source that I use a lot named JJNDC, who is in
- 19:33the chat, He was like, I think these Coast Guard
- 19:37planes that are supposed to be for search and
- 19:39rescue are being used for ice flights. They're
- 19:41following ice flight patterns. Search and rescue
- 19:45flight patterns are very different. You know,
- 19:48they go out over the water, they go around in
- 19:50a circle and then they go back to the same city.
- 19:52But now they were doing ice flight patterns.
- 19:55So I didn't have the tail numbers for those.
- 19:56So the way that I got those was going down to
- 20:01Alexandria and looking over time. to spot the
- 20:05planes coming up. And you can speed it up if
- 20:08you want to make it a little faster. But I will
- 20:12say ADS -B Exchange uses a lot of memory on your
- 20:16computer. And the more filters you put on, the
- 20:21more memory it's going to use. Even if you're
- 20:23only looking at one plane, if you're using a
- 20:25lot of filters, it could make your computer crash
- 20:28if you don't have a lot of memory. And there
- 20:31are also usually pop -up ads, although there
- 20:33aren't right now, which is amazing. There are
- 20:35pop -up ads unless you have premium and they
- 20:37can drive you insane pretty quickly. So get premium.
- 20:42Okay. Yeah. So say you want to track a plane
- 20:48that is going into one of the areas that ADS
- 20:52-B coverage is not very good with. So if you
- 20:55want to scroll back out at all of North America,
- 20:59or even the whole world. We'll just wait for
- 21:02all the flight data to come in. All right. So
- 21:05you'll see there are some gaps. There's basically
- 21:11nothing over the Amazon. There's nothing over
- 21:13the Pacific. That doesn't mean that there are
- 21:15no planes flying there. It just means that there
- 21:18are no ADS -B member receivers there. There's
- 21:23nobody in the Amazon who's an ADS -B exchange
- 21:28member. So this is something that I use a lot
- 21:32when I'm tracking flights in Africa. As you can
- 21:34see, the ADS -B coverage in Africa is not very
- 21:36good. So this is where Flight Radar 24 actually
- 21:41comes in really handy. This function only works
- 21:44on the gold version, so you have to pay for it.
- 21:48But because they're using satellite, they can
- 21:52tell you exactly where planes are landing, but
- 21:54they won't give you the ID. So you just triangulate,
- 21:57you know, you say it's usually like off the coast
- 22:00of Senegal. Well, off the coast of Senegal, I
- 22:02can see that on ADSB exchange that N588AT, which
- 22:08is a plane that I track a lot, is about to land
- 22:12in Dakar. Okay. So now, and it's at, you know,
- 22:17UTC 1624. Okay, great. Now I go over to flight
- 22:20radar 24 and I go, ah, a Gulfstream 5. is flying
- 22:27in the exact same position at 1624. That's the
- 22:31plane. Now I can track it as it flies and makes
- 22:35its stop all through Africa. Okay, so now you
- 22:38may be wondering how do I find tail numbers for
- 22:41all the planes in the charter airline fleets
- 22:44or any other planes that you want to track. There
- 22:48are a couple ways. First, some of them put all
- 22:52of their fleet numbers on their company website.
- 22:55Journey Aviation does that. Next, you can try
- 23:00Planespotters .net. It's like a Wikipedia for
- 23:03airplane pictures. There are different flavors
- 23:06of Avgeek. Some people are flight tracking enthusiasts.
- 23:11Some people really like taking photos of different
- 23:15airplanes. Some people are like... aviation or
- 23:18like experiential avgeeks. So like, oh, the Embraer
- 23:20190 is doing its last flight in the United States.
- 23:23I have to be on it. You know, that's a different
- 23:25kind. But the Planespotters folks, they've shared
- 23:31all their photos here. And most of the time,
- 23:34they have pretty good fleet lists. So if you
- 23:40want to put in, in the search bar, if you want
- 23:41to put in N... 279GX. Say I spotted a Global
- 23:49X plane. That's one of them. I can search it
- 23:53and then you will scroll down to the bottom and
- 23:57where it says Global X. You can click where it
- 24:00says Global X and scroll down and it should give
- 24:03you an entire fleet list. Fleet lists, current
- 24:06fleet lists, historic fleet lists. And these
- 24:08are generally pretty accurate. You know, like
- 24:09Wikipedia, it's mostly right. It's not always
- 24:11right. It's not an official source, so I wouldn't
- 24:14use it as my only source for reporting. But it's
- 24:19mostly right. Another thing that you can do is
- 24:22that the FAA also publishes part 135 fleet lists,
- 24:28so every charter carrier and the list of all
- 24:32of the tail numbers in their fleets. But I will
- 24:34say that they're supposed to publish that once
- 24:37a month and they haven't been doing that in Trump
- 24:40too. I think the last time that they published
- 24:45it was in February and it wasn't very accurate.
- 24:48That one seems to be old. So that is not perfect
- 24:52either. Okay. And then another thing is the FAA
- 24:58registry. That's going to be... That's just a
- 25:03searchable website that the FAA has to get information
- 25:06on every tail number in civil aviation. That
- 25:12can be really useful. That will tell you the
- 25:14aircraft's owners, which often do not correspond
- 25:18to the charter airline that's flying them, but
- 25:22can be a rich source of information. So other
- 25:26resources you can use for flight tracking in
- 25:28general, LiveATC .net has air traffic control
- 25:34recordings. And there is an archive function,
- 25:36but it only goes back 24 hours. So you got to
- 25:39get there fast. I only use this if I suspect
- 25:42a flight has had some type of emergency and I'd
- 25:45like to try to hear more about what is going
- 25:48on. So last November, I got a tip that in a Velo
- 25:52ICE flight, had a cabin depressurization, and
- 25:55I was able to get the ATC recording to confirm
- 25:58that and to report that there were six people
- 26:01who were injured. And then the last thing I'll
- 26:05say is ACARS. I'm just going to touch on that
- 26:07a little bit. ACARS are like text messages that
- 26:10the flight deck and the ground can send to one
- 26:13another and come up on a little printout. There
- 26:17is a website. It's sbg .airframes .io, where
- 26:25you can search ACARS. Is it TBG or SBG? JJ, did
- 26:30I get that wrong? TBG works. OK, great. Thank
- 26:33you. bg .airframes .io. Thank you, JJ. And I'll
- 26:39just say that for ACARS, you have to search ACARS
- 26:43by hex. So you will need the hex numbers for
- 26:46that. I don't use ACARS much, but I did use it
- 26:52for a story I did for Rolling Stone last fall
- 26:55about a military ICE flight. The military doesn't
- 26:58do many flights for ICE, but they have done some.
- 27:03And this particular flight, they had gone completely
- 27:06dark. They weren't transmitting any signals at
- 27:09all and became undetectable, but they did send
- 27:13some ACARS. And the ACARS said, what cities they
- 27:18were landing in. So I was still able to report
- 27:21where that plane landed in West Africa. Okay,
- 27:27so some tools for learning more about ice flights.
- 27:31So first, there's this amazing new tool called
- 27:35habeas flight watch. This is the habeas flight
- 27:38watch dashboard. This is the work of JJ and DC
- 27:43and some activists in New England called Lexington
- 27:46Alarm. and they have really good coding skills.
- 27:50So JJ tracks flights every day. You'll see him
- 27:52posting on Blue Sky about them a lot. And he
- 27:56has gotten to a point where he can see their
- 28:00schedules and predict their movements. And he
- 28:04was putting this on Blue Sky, and he is also
- 28:07constantly getting messages from attorneys and
- 28:10activists and journalists saying, hey, is there
- 28:13going to be an ICE flight to this city today?
- 28:16And so they basically built this dashboard with
- 28:20the predicted schedule in it. So it automatically
- 28:23updates once the actual flight data comes up
- 28:27and the flight starts. And so, you know, one
- 28:30of the things that we've seen with combating
- 28:33ICE is that habeas partitions are like one of
- 28:38the most important tools. So when ICE captures
- 28:41someone, They want to fly them down to one of
- 28:46the detention centers in the South as fast as
- 28:49they can. The federal courts there are going
- 28:54to rule in ISIS favor much more. And most of
- 28:59the time the immigrants will have to get a new
- 29:00lawyer. Now they have to get a new lawyer while
- 29:03in prison in an area that they're not familiar
- 29:06with. And so it just becomes much more difficult
- 29:10to fight your case. So, you want to get a habeas
- 29:13petition filed before they get taken. So, I know
- 29:18a lot of immigration attorneys are really overwhelmed
- 29:20right now. So, this is a tool. So, if you live
- 29:23in Boston and you find out that one of your clients
- 29:29has been captured, you can look at the, it's
- 29:32going to be the hand scum one, bed, yes, sorry,
- 29:36Bedford. It's the BED. And you can say, okay.
- 29:40There are no iSlide schedule today. I can hold
- 29:44on a second until I have a minute until I get
- 29:46this petition in. And if let's say you're in
- 29:50Richmond and then click on the red one that says
- 29:52RIC. There's one coming on the way right now.
- 29:55And so I need to get the petition in immediately.
- 29:58And then if you scroll down to the bottom of
- 30:00this thing where it says record. So another thing
- 30:03that's really important is that if the plane
- 30:05is already in the air with your client on it,
- 30:08they're still in your jurisdiction until the
- 30:09plane lands in Alexandria or wherever they're
- 30:12going. This produces a flight record that you
- 30:15can put in the filing to say they were still
- 30:18in the air, they're in our jurisdiction, and
- 30:20then ICE has to bring them back. So, you know,
- 30:24it was started mostly to help immigration attorneys.
- 30:28I think they've been beta testing it, so they
- 30:30haven't been super public with it, but they are
- 30:32now. So share this far and wide with everyone
- 30:34you know. And then I know activists and journalists
- 30:36have been using it a lot too. So if you want
- 30:41to organize an ICE flight watch in your city
- 30:44where you are watching how many people are being
- 30:47taken onto the flight, that's something that
- 30:51you can use this tool to help with that. And
- 30:56then, yeah, so then also a lot of you know or
- 31:01know of Tom Cartwright. He is just an amazing
- 31:06flight tracker. He's a retired JP Morgan executive
- 31:08who just got really involved in advocacy for
- 31:14migrants. And starting in 2020, he started producing
- 31:21these monthly reports of every ICE flight that
- 31:25he had tracked that month. And ICE doesn't have
- 31:29any public records that they're sharing. So this
- 31:32is basically the only records that we have of
- 31:36ICE's activities, ICE's flights, going back to
- 31:392020. And then last summer, he retired, retired,
- 31:45and handed his operation over to Human Rights
- 31:48First. So Human Rights First produces really
- 31:52great reports, monthly reports, full of information,
- 31:55Um, that if you're just getting started tracking
- 31:59ice flights, I really encourage you to like pour
- 32:01over those reports and you can learn a lot. And
- 32:06then, um, the last thing I will say is, uh, my
- 32:11white, my website, ilianbrotkell .com. If you
- 32:15scroll down a little bit and you'll see the map
- 32:19with the green countries. This is my. third country
- 32:24removal tracker. So I'm tracking every known
- 32:27third country removal that ISIS done. These are
- 32:31the, they're not really deportations, but these
- 32:33are when they send someone, a migrant to a country
- 32:37that they have no ties to. And those are happening
- 32:41under a lot of different circumstances. You know,
- 32:44the best case scenario is Costa Rica, where they're
- 32:47actually being offered resettlement. in Costa
- 32:50Rica. Most of the time that isn't happening.
- 32:52Most of the time, these countries are just forcing
- 32:55people to return back to their countries of Oregon,
- 32:59which is called pain refoulement. It's a human
- 33:02rights violation. It's against US and international
- 33:06law, but we are still doing a lot of them, at
- 33:09least 14 ,000 of them so far in Trump too. And
- 33:14then the sort of worst case scenario is East
- 33:16Rotini, formerly known as Swaziland. where they're
- 33:20just holding them in a maximum security prison
- 33:22indefinitely. And yeah, if you're an activist,
- 33:27a researcher, an immigration attorney, or an
- 33:30independent journalist, you are more than welcome
- 33:32to contact me at any time if you ever have any
- 33:35questions about a flight or if you're afraid
- 33:38a client is about to be deported, et cetera.
- 33:41I'm on Blue Sky and my signal is thebrockpale
- 33:44.44. And with that, I'll take your questions.
- 33:46I hope that was helpful. Thank you and apologies
- 33:50about my navigation skills as you were trying
- 33:54to point me towards... No, you said great. It's
- 33:56like real teaching. No, thank you so much for
- 34:01taking us through all of that. And obviously
- 34:03I know some people within here are familiar with
- 34:06some of those tools, but it's always useful to
- 34:08have a little refresher. Again, if you like this
- 34:12subject, we do have channels within here. to
- 34:16talk about that subject and practice the skills
- 34:19that have just been described. Aviation is one
- 34:21of them. And then we also have one that looks
- 34:23particularly at US immigration and customs enforcement
- 34:27actions named as such. Daniel Kim said, if your
- 34:31local area doesn't have robust monitoring activities
- 34:34like the folks in Minnesota, is there a way to
- 34:36figure out how many people were in deportation
- 34:39planes any given day? And if so, what would that
- 34:42process look like in determining an estimated
- 34:44number? So how do you estimate how many people
- 34:47are likely to be on the planes themselves? Is
- 34:49that possible if there isn't robust monitoring
- 34:52activities in that area? No, it's not possible
- 34:55unless there's someone actually watching it.
- 34:59It's not. You can estimate. So, you know, 737
- 35:04has about 150 and 160 seats. And on every ICE
- 35:09flight, there are a ton of guards. So they'll
- 35:14generally have anywhere between 10 and 40 contract
- 35:20security guards and ICE agents on each flight.
- 35:23So, yeah. So the max would be, you know, 110,
- 35:27120. on a 737, but it can, you know, I've seen
- 35:32eight. So it really runs the gamut. Now I will
- 35:37say in Seattle, Seattle is really interesting.
- 35:42Boeing Field, the county is King County that
- 35:47Seattle is in, and the Boeing Field Airport,
- 35:51ICE was using that for years, and the King County
- 35:54executive kicked him out. said, we don't want
- 35:56you doing this here. It was a whole court case.
- 35:59And then the courts ruled that you can't kick
- 36:04the federal government out of a public use airport.
- 36:08And that includes their contractors. So the King
- 36:12County executive said, fine, if you're going
- 36:14to do ice flights here, then they have to be
- 36:16on camera. So there's a live stream that you
- 36:18can watch of every single ice flight loading
- 36:22at Boeing Field. And it's really useful to sort
- 36:29of see what they're like, to see the way that
- 36:33everyone is shackled, to see the way that they
- 36:36treat people in wheelchairs. It hopefully prevents
- 36:40some of the worst abuses, knowing that they have
- 36:43a camera on them, although there are videos where
- 36:46you can see them abusing migrants, even in Seattle.
- 36:50You know, one thing that I would say is that,
- 36:53you know, find out who owns, who governs the
- 36:56airport in your city that is taking ICE flights,
- 36:58and then, you know, start insisting that a camera
- 37:01be set up. If you don't have a big network of
- 37:05activists who can be there, you walk them with
- 37:09your own eyes, or if they're in an area that
- 37:11isn't public, easily they are, and they will
- 37:15know where to walk them to. where you can walk
- 37:19them from a public place. But yeah, I think getting
- 37:24live streams, especially in blue cities and blue
- 37:27states, for all of these is extremely important.
- 37:32I love the uptick on live streams at the moment.
- 37:35It's really useful for a number of different
- 37:37investigations. Daniel actually asked to follow
- 37:40up on that. Is it possible to count retroactively?
- 37:43For example, I want to figure out how many detained
- 37:45people flew out of the airport. Assuming I know
- 37:48which airports were used starting from June the
- 37:506th, 2025 to today. Have you ever had to do that
- 37:54retroactively? Yeah, I mean, I've done that for
- 37:56my own airport, DWI, Baltimore. I live nearest
- 38:02to that airport. I've witnessed probably five.
- 38:07But I went back using, I mean, it took forever,
- 38:11but I did go back to January 20th, 2025 and checked
- 38:17the tail numbers for every ICE aircraft that
- 38:20I'm aware of and made a spreadsheet of every
- 38:25single one that has landed at BWI. And so it
- 38:32was basically like four or five of them until
- 38:36Oh, last August, I would say, is when they started
- 38:39doing twice a week. And then there have been
- 38:42surges and drop -offs. Yeah, you can go back.
- 38:48And on Flight Radar 24 Premium, you can only
- 38:52go back to one year. And then ADS -B Exchange
- 38:56goes back to 2020. I have to say, JJ has been
- 39:00dropping some amazing resources in the chat.
- 39:04I will make sure that they are all mentioned
- 39:07in the description of the podcast, including
- 39:09that Seattle livestream that they've just now
- 39:12linked to. Thank you so much for that. We've
- 39:14been talking about the ease and the... demonstrated
- 39:19how a layman can use some of these tools. But
- 39:22how much of your research balances on your knowledge
- 39:26and experience as a flight attendant? Are there
- 39:28things from that previous job that have helped
- 39:30you better understand potential violations in
- 39:33these cases? Yeah, I mean, that's mostly got
- 39:38to do with the federal aviation regulations that
- 39:41are being violated on every single ice flight,
- 39:43because they're all shackled. You know, every
- 39:48flight attendant, your main obsession is keeping
- 39:52the aisle clear and your passengers unencumbered
- 39:55so that if they have to evacuate an emergency,
- 39:58they can do so within 90 seconds. So if everyone
- 40:03on board is shackled at the ankles, that can't
- 40:06happen. We know that there have been, we know
- 40:10of five emergency evacuations that have happened
- 40:14on ICE flights. between, I believe it was 2014
- 40:18and 2021 because of some court filings and some
- 40:22discovery. And we only know the evacuation times
- 40:25for two of those. One of those was two and a
- 40:28half minutes. The other was seven and a half
- 40:30minutes. There was also another emergency where
- 40:32they didn't evacuate in that accident. They absolutely
- 40:35should have. The cabin filled up with smoke and
- 40:38everyone on that plane could have been killed.
- 40:40It's lucky that they weren't. So yeah, I mean,
- 40:44the thing that really motivates me with this
- 40:46reporting is how angry I am as a former flight
- 40:50attendant that these people are not able to respond
- 40:56to an emergency and care for themselves. From
- 40:59talking to ICER flight attendants, I know that
- 41:01they're being told, if you have to evacuate,
- 41:04just save yourself and let these people die.
- 41:06They're not being told how to evacuate shackled
- 41:09people. And I know from the you know, the Avello
- 41:13depressurization, the six people that were injured.
- 41:15I don't know if those were passengers, guards,
- 41:18or crew members, but I do know that they were
- 41:22injuries to their sinuses. And if you're shackled
- 41:27with a waist chain, you can't reach for your
- 41:29oxygen masks. So, you know, these sinus injuries
- 41:33aren't serious, but they're very painful. And
- 41:36it could have, those could have been caused because
- 41:38they couldn't reach their oxygen masks. Yeah.
- 41:42So I mean, I also have just sort of a general
- 41:47sense of like when a crew is going to time out.
- 41:49And so, you know, they're going to be switching
- 41:54crews and going to layover cities. And, you know,
- 41:57I had a sense of that. And then talking to some
- 42:00of these ISA or flight attendants later, it's
- 42:03like, yeah, that is where the crew is going.
- 42:05I hope that answered the question. Yeah. And
- 42:08it's really useful to understand the patterns
- 42:10as well of whereabouts these fights are taking
- 42:13place. Just being able to kind of watch central
- 42:17airports and call signs, as you mentioned, is
- 42:22really, really useful knowledge just to have
- 42:25in terms of research. Have there been attempts
- 42:28by the government or airlines to try and obscure?
- 42:35some of the data that you're trying to use to
- 42:38track them now that they know that there's groups
- 42:40actively monitoring this, or is that against
- 42:43legal rules? Like, is there ways that they can
- 42:46obscure the data that you're trying to access?
- 42:52And how's that happened? Have you seen that go
- 42:55up in terms of recent development? There are
- 42:59ways. They're rarely used. You wouldn't want
- 43:05to use it a lot. You wouldn't want to use it
- 43:07for all ice flights just because that would risk
- 43:09all of aviation safety and, you know, pilots
- 43:14just wouldn't let that happen. I mean, I do know
- 43:17that, you know, there was the flight I talked
- 43:18about earlier. One military ice flight had its
- 43:23signals turned completely off. Others have changed
- 43:26into modes that are, you know, a little harder
- 43:28to track. There have been incidents that I haven't
- 43:35fully reported out where they're using alternative
- 43:39hex codes. That's only happened once that I'm
- 43:42aware of. And that could have been because of
- 43:44a malfunction just as easily as trying to obscure.
- 43:47And I was still able to figure out where that
- 43:49plane landed through other methods. And so I
- 43:55wouldn't say that they're doing that globally.
- 43:58One thing that I am very concerned about is,
- 44:03you know, you may have read that ICE is buying
- 44:06its own planes because they want to do their
- 44:09own removal flights instead of relying on charters.
- 44:14And, you know, I have the N numbers for all of
- 44:17those planes and in general, like government
- 44:20planes, you know, the FBI jet or whatever, like
- 44:22it's still a civil aircraft. It's not military.
- 44:26They're not supposed to be turning off their
- 44:29signals. But at the end of the day, like government
- 44:33can kind of do what it wants to. So I do worry
- 44:37that they're trying to buy these planes because
- 44:40they want to go dark. It hasn't happened yet,
- 44:45but yes, I do worry about that. No, but I would
- 45:00love it if they did. I do want to say one thing.
- 45:07Ireland, you know, people are very organized
- 45:09in Ireland. And, you know, there's a thing called
- 45:12Shannon Watch that has been tracking military
- 45:15aircraft that land at Shannon for years. And
- 45:19they're great. I mean, they're able to determine
- 45:22if a plane had weapons on it that are going to
- 45:26Israel. They have a list of all of their rendition
- 45:29flights during the global war on terror that
- 45:32refueled at Shannon. And ICE flights do occasionally
- 45:36attract, I think, eight of them that have landed
- 45:38at Shannon. And they'll be there. They'll be
- 45:41watching. They are trying to get their laws enforced
- 45:45there and get police to search the planes there
- 45:49and enforce human rights regulations there. It
- 45:53hasn't happened yet. So they call the cops every
- 45:56time. and ice flight lanes there. So far they
- 46:00haven't been successful, but they are trying.
- 46:03Thanks for that additional information. Yes,
- 46:06it's amazing to hear that there are communities
- 46:08out there trying to prevent this. As I was just
- 46:11saying, there's a couple of more resources that
- 46:14have been mentioned in the chat as well. Lemonador
- 46:17said the new app from ATC .com aka Enhanced Radar
- 46:21supports a degree of search that lets you find
- 46:23ATC broadcasts. where that call sign is mentioned
- 46:25across frequencies. They have much less coverage
- 46:29than live ADC. We talked earlier about the need
- 46:32for historical data. Bellingcat built Turnstone,
- 46:37which is an aggregator for ADS -B data for multiple
- 46:42aircraft over time. So you can search your flights
- 46:45across two areas of interest at once and across
- 46:48time. It's possible to interrogate the baseline
- 46:51level of movement and spot unusual patterns using
- 46:53that. So I'll make sure to drop that in the description
- 46:56of the podcast and in the chat in a second as
- 46:59well. Because there's so many people trying flight
- 47:04tracking for the first time, particularly with
- 47:07deportation flights front of mind, is there any
- 47:11concerns of people misunderstanding data on these
- 47:15sites? And have you seen any cases where that's
- 47:18happened where misinformation has been spread
- 47:20because people have misunderstood? the data that
- 47:23they found on these sites. Yeah, I don't know
- 47:29about misinformation, but a hobbyist did contact
- 47:33me recently saying, I think I found something.
- 47:36I think Delta is doing deportation flights. No,
- 47:41it was American. I think American is doing deportation
- 47:43flights. Look, they are going out of this city
- 47:47and they're going to this place. And one of the
- 47:51things that I know from just watching planes
- 47:53over a long time is that there's a repair facility
- 48:03at this city in Mexico. And so he thought that
- 48:07that was a deportation flight. And they're saying,
- 48:09no, no, no, that plane's going to get repaired.
- 48:11And you can tell by the call signs. They ferried
- 48:15there, so they were using Americans. um, ferry
- 48:18flight call signs. And then it was there for
- 48:21two weeks, which a plane wouldn't be there for
- 48:23two weeks. If it was a deportation, it would
- 48:25go right back. And so that plane was broken and
- 48:28was getting fixed. Um, in terms of misinformation
- 48:32spreading, I don't think any flight data was
- 48:34used for this, but there is a rumor, um, and
- 48:37I have this in my ICER FAQ on my website. There
- 48:41is a rumor that went around, especially last
- 48:44summer, that they're throwing people out of planes.
- 48:49And there's no evidence of that. And I'm not
- 48:55saying that's not happening because I think ICE
- 48:59would never do that. I think they would. But
- 49:03it's just not possible. So first of all, they
- 49:06would have to be on a military plane. Charter
- 49:08planes can't open their doors mid -flight. It's
- 49:10physically not possible. And the rumor was like,
- 49:17look, these five bodies washed up in Italy. And
- 49:23that's actually about the migrants that go from
- 49:27North Africa to Europe on boats, and they get
- 49:29killed by smugglers and thrown overboard. had
- 49:32nothing to do with American military or American
- 49:37migrants. There's no flight data at all to support
- 49:42that this would be happening. And so, like I
- 49:46said, I don't put anything past ICE, but that
- 49:49rumor is completely untrue. It started on TikTok
- 49:54also with someone who has no aviation experience
- 49:57at all. The best rumours start on TikTok, unfortunately.
- 50:07There's still quite a lot of useful things in
- 50:11the chat, which I'll make sure to think, including
- 50:13the link to your websites, which will be in the
- 50:16description of this podcast. Before we go, I
- 50:20just wanted to quickly recap in terms of identifying
- 50:24an ICE -associated flight or a deportation flight.
- 50:28What constitutes sufficient evidence for you?
- 50:31What are you looking for specifically in terms
- 50:34of key pointers for these flights? For those
- 50:37who want to go away after this and maybe start
- 50:40digging into these types of flights. The trips
- 50:45are all going to start and end in ICE Flight
- 50:48Hub City. And so that is going to be Mesa, Arizona,
- 50:53El Paso, Harlingen, Texas. And then the main
- 50:55one is Alexandria, Louisiana. I think there are
- 50:57a couple going out of Jacksonville now too. And
- 51:02yeah, so they're all going to be going in and
- 51:05out of a hub city. They are all going to have
- 51:08commonalities in the call signs. And then the
- 51:14flight patterns are generally out and back. And
- 51:16they don't have long layovers in any of the cities
- 51:19that they land in, generally about two hours.
- 51:24And then you can always check with me or with
- 51:30JJ or Nick Benson, who's ottergoose .net on Blue
- 51:35Sky, who's an amazing flight tracker out of Minnesota.
- 51:38And yeah. So, I mean, a good way to get started,
- 51:43I think, would just be to watch all of the planes
- 51:49that leave out of Alexandria, Louisiana in a
- 51:53day, you know, using the archive button on ADSB
- 51:57Exchange. And then when a plane takes off, just
- 52:00look at it. They'll go, oh, this is Eastern Airlines.
- 52:04Are they an ice flight provider? Yes, they are.
- 52:07Oh, this is Delta. This is just a Delta flight.
- 52:09You know, so it's Global X, Eastern Airlines,
- 52:15Eastern Air Express, Key Lime Air, Air Wisconsin,
- 52:20Bighorn Airways was doing things for a while,
- 52:22although I think they might've stopped, CSI Aviation,
- 52:26Journey Aviation, Palin Air, and sometimes the
- 52:32military. But the Coast Guard stopped about a
- 52:35month and a half ago. Super useful. And as someone's
- 52:41put in the chat, you can also help by building
- 52:45or buying an ADS -B feeder as well, and provide
- 52:49that flight tracking data for ADS -B Exchange
- 52:52and FlightAware and other platforms. As mentioned,
- 52:58I know a couple of people in this server have
- 53:01such devices. and they are super super useful
- 53:04for open source reporting and flight tracking
- 53:08so please do also consider that. Unfortunately
- 53:11we're at time and I don't want to be because
- 53:14I would love to keep discussing this topic forever.
- 53:19If you're like me and you want to continue the
- 53:21conversation you can do in hashtag aviation or
- 53:25in hashtag Both of those channels are appropriate
- 53:31for conversation on this topic. But for now,
- 53:35Gillian, I have to say goodbye. How can people
- 53:38reach out to you if they want to continue this
- 53:42talk? Perhaps have a question for you that's
- 53:43not suitable for Discord. And if you want to
- 53:56send me Proton, it's gibrakel at proton .me.
- 54:01Amazing. I'll make sure to include those in the
- 54:03podcast description as well. Thank you so much,
- 54:06everybody, for listening. Apologies about the
- 54:08tech issues at the beginning of the talk. And
- 54:11thank you for sticking by us. And in two weeks'
- 54:14time, we'll be back with another Stage Talk.
- 54:16All right. Thank you, everybody. Thank you for
- 54:19listening to the Stage Talk. If you'd like to
- 54:22catch a stage tour live where you can ask the
- 54:25guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 54:28server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 54:35The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 54:38Self and is courtesy of Artlist.