Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How Scarcity Shapes Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: A few weeks ago, I watched a colleague ask for help on a project and get turned down flat. The next week, he mentioned he only had two slots left for a training session — and suddenly everyone wanted in. That's scarcity in action. Luna: So the same person went from ignored to in-demand just by changing the framing from 'I need something' to 'I have something limited'. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just about training slots. Scarcity is one of the most reliable influence triggers in office politics. Robert Cialdini identified it decades ago — people assign more value to things that are rare or dwindling. Luna: But why does it work so well? Is it just fear of missing out? Lucas: Partly. There's a loss aversion component — we hate losing an opportunity more than we enjoy gaining one. But there's also a social proof layer. When something is scarce, we assume others want it, so it must be valuable. That's why your colleague's training slots suddenly seemed like gold. Luna: I've seen the opposite too. A manager who constantly broadcasts 'my door is always open' gets fewer drop-ins than one who says 'I have time for two office hours this week'. Lucas: Right. The open-door policy actually devalues the time because it's abundant. Scarcity creates a perception of high demand and unique value. But it can backfire if you overdo it or if people realize you're manufacturing scarcity. Luna: That's a good point. Let me ask you — if today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps keep the podcast independent and without ads. Lucas: Yeah, and it genuinely makes a difference. We hear from listeners who say the research and examples help them navigate tricky office situations. So if you've gotten something out of this episode — or any episode — consider tossing a coffee our way. Luna: Alright, back to scarcity. You mentioned it can backfire — give us a concrete example. Lucas: Sure. A classic is the colleague who hoards information and then plays the scarcity card — 'I have the only copy of the budget model, so you have to come to me.' That works short-term, but long-term it breeds resentment and people stop trusting you. Luna: And once the scarcity is revealed as artificial, you lose all credibility. So what's the right way to use it? Lucas: Three tactics. First, frame your expertise as time-bound. When someone asks for input, say 'I have thirty minutes tomorrow afternoon — let's focus on your top two questions.' That positions your knowledge as a limited resource they should use wisely. Luna: Second? Lucas: Second, use exclusivity for meetings. Instead of inviting everyone to a brainstorming session, invite a select group and mention that early contributions will shape the direction. People want to be in the room where it happens. Luna: And third? Lucas: Third, avoid overplaying your hand. Scarcity works best when it's genuine — you really do have limited time, a unique skill, or access to inside information. If you cry scarcity on every request, people stop believing you. Luna: That aligns with Cialdini's point that ethical influence relies on real scarcity. I think there's also a cultural component. In some cultures, direct scarcity claims can seem pushy. Lucas: Absolutely. In more collectivist workplaces, saying 'I only have two slots' can come across as selfish. Better to frame it as 'I want to give each person my full attention, so I'm limiting my meetings this week.' Same principle, different packaging. Luna: So scarcity isn't about being stingy — it's about signalling that your contributions have weight. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me to one more nuance: scarcity of access to you can also build allies. If you are seen as the person who can get things done because you have limited bandwidth, people will time their requests strategically, which often leads to higher-quality collaboration. Luna: At my last job, there was a senior analyst who everyone wanted to work with. She only took on two side projects per quarter. That scarcity made her involvement a status symbol — teams would compete for her input. Lucas: Yes! And that's where scarcity intersects with the halo effect — her reputation as being selective made her work seem even better. But notice: she didn't say 'I'm scarce.' She just genuinely had her time allocated. That authenticity is key. Luna: What about when you're on the receiving end? Say you're trying to get a mentor's time and they're perpetually scarce. How do you navigate that? Lucas: You can use the scarcity principle in reverse. Instead of asking for an open-ended meeting, say 'I have this specific question that would take five minutes — can you fit it in this week?' By making your request small and time-bound, you lower the perceived scarcity of their time. Luna: Or you can create scarcity on your side — 'I'm only available Tuesday afternoon, but I'd really value your input.' That can work if you have a relationship already. Lucas: Careful though — that can backfire if they feel manipulated. The best approach is to recognize that scarcity is a signal of value. If someone is scarce, respect it and make your interaction high-value when you get it. Luna: So how do we take this into our own behaviour tomorrow morning? Lucas: Pick one area where you give your time freely — maybe it's reviewing documents, or random Slack questions — and introduce a small constraint. Say 'I'll review your doc by Friday if you send it by Wednesday.' That's scarcity with a deadline, and it also sets expectations. Luna: I like that. It's not about being difficult; it's about being intentional. Lucas: Exactly. Scarcity is a tool, not a trick. Use it to protect your focus and signal your priorities, and you'll find people respect your time more — and your influence grows naturally.