Latest / Surrounded / Can Talarico Turn Texas Blue? | James Talarico vs 20 Undecided Voters Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00I think I'm fed up and disengaged because I'm tired of the excuse
- 0:03that that person's head,
- 0:05so I get to be a head
- 0:06and,
- 0:07and I kind of wish there was a group that would
- 0:09we could get behind and say,
- 0:10you know what,
- 0:11we are not supporting either of you until one of you
- 0:14acts like an adult.
- 0:16What is it gonna take?
- 0:17I mean,
- 0:18I,
- 0:18I own a gun myself.
- 0:20I'm all for gun safety.
- 0:21It's like how many kids are gonna have to die
- 0:23in schools for there to be some kind of change.
- 0:26So I'm here with Dan,
- 0:28uh,
- 0:28from.
- 0:29The James Tallarico
- 0:30surrounded.
- 0:31Welcome
- 0:32back to the Jubilee Universe and uh thanks for doing this follow-up.
- 0:37Yeah,
- 0:37thanks for having me.
- 0:39So you were probably.
- 0:41Maybe one of the more contentious uh participants in James's episode.
- 0:47You,
- 0:47you gave him some pushback,
- 0:49um,
- 0:50but it wasn't coming from a place of like
- 0:52political opposition as much as maybe political disillusionment.
- 0:57Does that sound accurate to you?
- 1:00I think,
- 1:01I think that's fair.
- 1:03Also a desire to see more engagement,
- 1:05more
- 1:07try and get to the depth
- 1:08of some of the issues.
- 1:10Oftentimes,
- 1:10especially in these kind of platforms,
- 1:12they,
- 1:13they get cut into little,
- 1:14little bits and pieces,
- 1:15and sometimes that
- 1:17dictates how people responded.
- 1:18And so
- 1:19definitely not from a place of malicious or even.
- 1:23Strongly disagreeing with him necessarily,
- 1:25more from a place of let's dive deeper into these issues and see if we can get to some
- 1:29where we actually disagree.
- 1:31Totally.
- 1:32And you were like,
- 1:32give me specifics.
- 1:33What are you gonna do?
- 1:34I've,
- 1:35I've been hearing the same thing for over and over and over.
- 1:39Before we kind of dive into those arguments,
- 1:41cause I want to play those back and we can jump into those,
- 1:44could I get a little bit more of a sense of what is your history?
- 1:47What's,
- 1:47what's kind of your
- 1:49past political,
- 1:51you know,
- 1:51affiliation or identity or,
- 1:53or experiences,
- 1:54um,
- 1:55leading up to where you are now?
- 1:57I haven't been politically involved,
- 1:59and for me,
- 2:00it's much more of a
- 2:01Intellectual curiosity,
- 2:04um,
- 2:04so I've
- 2:05never voted,
- 2:07uh,
- 2:07had plenty of arguments with older friends on that,
- 2:10uh,
- 2:11and,
- 2:11and my involvement in the community has been much more oriented around,
- 2:15um,
- 2:16volunteering in individual relationships,
- 2:20and so,
- 2:20particularly in college,
- 2:22uh,
- 2:23I,
- 2:23I,
- 2:24I say conservatively I was,
- 2:26I was much more conservative leaning,
- 2:29um.
- 2:30In,
- 2:31in a political
- 2:32aspect,
- 2:34but was very liberal leaning in a lot of my behavior.
- 2:37So I did a lot of,
- 2:38a lot of volunteering,
- 2:39probably
- 2:40over 3000 hours of volunteering
- 2:43in college.
- 2:44It was just,
- 2:44it was my
- 2:45something I was so passionate about
- 2:47and played around with a lot of ideas
- 2:50that,
- 2:50uh,
- 2:51that I see coming up on the left
- 2:54now,
- 2:55um.
- 2:56But I've evolved,
- 2:57I've really evolved over time and really tried to challenge myself on issues.
- 3:00So example is,
- 3:01uh,
- 3:02abortion
- 3:03is one where
- 3:04I've evolved a lot.
- 3:05And so if you had asked me when I was young and in college,
- 3:08I would have said it's,
- 3:08it's absolutely murder.
- 3:10Um,
- 3:11and in fact,
- 3:13the natural and leaning into the natural repercussions of that,
- 3:16at one point I was saying,
- 3:17I,
- 3:18I legitimately started asking myself if I really believe abortion is murder.
- 3:22Why would I not go
- 3:23and
- 3:25Take action
- 3:27against an abortion clinic and I,
- 3:29and I started to.
- 3:30Ask myself that and start to lean into that
- 3:33and,
- 3:33and what I found is,
- 3:35why do I believe it's murder,
- 3:37um,
- 3:37with a lot of a Christian background.
- 3:39I know we quote a lot of times,
- 3:40uh,
- 3:41certain Bible verses such as,
- 3:42uh,
- 3:43I knew you in your womb and informed you,
- 3:44and I,
- 3:45and I just realized I didn't find a compelling argument.
- 3:47Um,
- 3:48and so
- 3:49I don't wanna dive too deep into that,
- 3:50but there's a lot of issues where I've,
- 3:52I've started out one way and I've,
- 3:53I've realized
- 3:54whether or not my
- 3:56group I necessarily associate with.
- 3:58Uh,
- 3:58agrees with that.
- 3:59I've started to move in a different direction,
- 4:01just try and take issues one by one rather than as a group.
- 4:04Yeah.
- 4:05What led you
- 4:07to wanting to speak to James?
- 4:09Um,
- 4:10you know,
- 4:10obviously Jubilee might have just reached out to you,
- 4:12but,
- 4:12but were you drawn to this?
- 4:13Was there some kind of larger pull to,
- 4:16to speaking with him face to face?
- 4:19You know,
- 4:21Jubilee doesn't tell you who you're gonna speak with,
- 4:23so I didn't have a specific desire to speak
- 4:26with with James,
- 4:27but I would say the engagement,
- 4:30uh,
- 4:31I got there by watching,
- 4:32so I watch a lot of Jubilee videos and then I watch a lot of
- 4:35everything from,
- 4:36uh,
- 4:36Megyn Kelly to Young Turks and try and really get kind of a.
- 4:41That's a,
- 4:41that's the chasm,
- 4:43you know,
- 4:43yeah,
- 4:45and I enjoy that,
- 4:45and I find that
- 4:47on both sides I find an argument that I,
- 4:49I agree with or disagree with.
- 4:51And as I've leaned into that engagement more,
- 4:54uh,
- 4:55and,
- 4:55and,
- 4:55as an observer,
- 4:56I've thought,
- 4:57man,
- 4:57that would be fun to actually sit there and,
- 4:59and be a participant
- 5:01and
- 5:02was watching one of the jubilee videos at one point
- 5:04and saw that they were looking for participants in my area
- 5:07and,
- 5:07and thought,
- 5:07man,
- 5:08let's,
- 5:08let's dive in.
- 5:09Let's be a participant.
- 5:11Um,
- 5:12and,
- 5:12and part of it is,
- 5:13I'm,
- 5:13I'm sure a lot of people
- 5:15have experienced this.
- 5:16You watch a video and you think,
- 5:17oh man,
- 5:18I could have said something better,
- 5:19or I,
- 5:19I had this,
- 5:20uh,
- 5:21this thing,
- 5:21and,
- 5:22and I'll even catch myself if I'm driving.
- 5:24I'll pause the video and I'll talk out loud to my loud to myself.
- 5:26I'm sure I sound like a crazy person.
- 5:28And so all of that,
- 5:28I thought,
- 5:29why not,
- 5:29why not lean into that and see if I
- 5:31go in and participate,
- 5:33see what it,
- 5:33see what it's like.
- 5:35No,
- 5:35I love that.
- 5:36OK,
- 5:36so I'm gonna play you back a clip cause you had,
- 5:39you know,
- 5:40you,
- 5:41you had some interesting criticisms of just the political system
- 5:44in general,
- 5:45that seemed to resonate uh with viewers.
- 5:48I saw things in the comments,
- 5:49but also with James.
- 5:50And so,
- 5:51I'll play you back this clip and then kind of hear your reaction.
- 5:55Honestly,
- 5:56James,
- 5:56I don't think you're gonna do anything.
- 5:58We've heard it before,
- 5:59you know,
- 5:59drain the swamp,
- 6:00eat the rich
- 6:01until they get voted,
- 6:02and then they're just rich people swimming in the swamp.
- 6:05What,
- 6:05what are you gonna actually do
- 6:07that changes that system that you're talking about?
- 6:09Yeah,
- 6:09let me be honest with you,
- 6:11I alone am not gonna change this.
- 6:12I know there are some politicians who say I alone can fix it.
- 6:15I'm not one of them
- 6:16because I don't
- 6:17wanna promise you something I can't deliver.
- 6:19My goal with this campaign
- 6:21is to be a catalyst
- 6:22for
- 6:23people all over the state to come together and organize
- 6:26so that we can start again,
- 6:28not finish,
- 6:28but start
- 6:29our way toward
- 6:31a more representative form of government.
- 6:33So specifically,
- 6:34we talked earlier about comprehensive immigration reform.
- 6:37I think we also need comprehensive political reform.
- 6:40I hope my first vote if I'm elected as US senator
- 6:43would be the for the People Act,
- 6:45which is something that's already been introduced.
- 6:46I'm sure it'll change the details of it.
- 6:48But a few things that it does
- 6:50is it gets big money out of politics.
- 6:51It ends Citizens United,
- 6:53which may be the most disastrous policy
- 6:56for our democracy in modern American history.
- 6:59And then it goes further and it bans things like gerrymandering
- 7:02because
- 7:03gerrymandering is when politicians redraw
- 7:05political lines to benefit themselves.
- 7:08Democrats do it and Republicans do it.
- 7:09Not always the same amount,
- 7:10but they both do it
- 7:12because it's not an issue of
- 7:13party,
- 7:13it's an issue of power.
- 7:15How did you feel about the response you got?
- 7:18Mm
- 7:19You know,
- 7:19I have mixed feelings.
- 7:21We tend to keep doing the same thing and more of those same things,
- 7:25or
- 7:25rather than finding the right
- 7:27way
- 7:28to fix the system,
- 7:30we just
- 7:31find the next move
- 7:33to
- 7:35Get our side to win in a bad system
- 7:38and you have two sides and one says,
- 7:40I don't care about educating my voters.
- 7:41I,
- 7:42I realized that the best way to get votes is like these clips and rage baiting and,
- 7:47and
- 7:49lesser activity,
- 7:50like
- 7:51not good activity.
- 7:52And so the other side rather than saying,
- 7:53oh my God,
- 7:54how do we change that?
- 7:55How do we change the dynamics and the motivations
- 7:58instead says,
- 7:58oh well,
- 7:59you know what,
- 7:59we gotta do the same thing like
- 8:01get out and it's a race to the bottom.
- 8:04Exactly.
- 8:04And so really,
- 8:06and I could have been better at vocalizing this,
- 8:07really what I was looking for from James is more of
- 8:10a vision of how do you stop racing to the bottom?
- 8:13How,
- 8:14how are you the kind of inspirational leader,
- 8:16um,
- 8:16that's going to change the dynamic
- 8:19and fundamentally change the incentive structure,
- 8:21which,
- 8:22let me be clear,
- 8:23is,
- 8:24is so hard.
- 8:25It's something I spend time thinking about and I don't,
- 8:27I don't have all the answers,
- 8:28but.
- 8:29I think there are a little specific things.
- 8:31Um,
- 8:33one I'm actually curious,
- 8:35you seem very intelligent,
- 8:37so I,
- 8:37I'm actually curious what,
- 8:38what you were hoping you might hear from him.
- 8:41You know
- 8:43I was hoping something,
- 8:44I was hoping I would see that he would,
- 8:46he had thought about this and engaged on it and had some kind of plan,
- 8:50um.
- 8:51And,
- 8:51and a plan such as things I've thought about is
- 8:54um,
- 8:56I would,
- 8:57I would,
- 8:57I would tell you this,
- 8:58and I'll tune into this.
- 8:58If there's ever a Democrat or Republican presidential candidate
- 9:02who has the balls and integrity
- 9:05to make their
- 9:05vice president of the other party,
- 9:08I would vote for them,
- 9:09hands down.
- 9:10I've thought about that as well,
- 9:12yeah,
- 9:12yeah,
- 9:12and,
- 9:12and the hardest thing would be for that vice president.
- 9:15That,
- 9:15that would be the point of contention because it would be such a difficult role to
- 9:19maintain that,
- 9:20but it would be so good for the country
- 9:22rather than this
- 9:23nonsense we see when anything happens of.
- 9:26Ultimate,
- 9:28ultimate right
- 9:29perspective and ultimate left perspective,
- 9:31and you can't give a little because then
- 9:33that that makes you look weak or that makes it
- 9:35seem like there might be validity on the other side.
- 9:37Well,
- 9:37guess what,
- 9:38there is validity on the other side,
- 9:40um,
- 9:41things like that,
- 9:42things like,
- 9:43I,
- 9:43I,
- 9:44I think they're,
- 9:45I think that there's some
- 9:47thoughtful restrictions we could put on voting
- 9:50that doesn't disenfranchise a group,
- 9:53uh,
- 9:53but,
- 9:54but makes here's what you think about that.
- 9:56What do you think about the SAV Act that,
- 9:58that,
- 9:58um,
- 9:59I think it might have just passed the House,
- 10:02um,
- 10:02but just requiring a form of identification or maybe a government-issued ID.
- 10:07There's a lot of pushback from Democrats on that,
- 10:09but,
- 10:09you know,
- 10:09I think Fetterman
- 10:11supported it.
- 10:11What do you think about something like that?
- 10:14So
- 10:15let me clarify,
- 10:15I don't know all of the law.
- 10:17I know I'll say generally,
- 10:18right,
- 10:19requires voter ID,
- 10:21voter ID,
- 10:21and
- 10:22let's just,
- 10:23let's just be honest,
- 10:24Democrats don't like that
- 10:26because we know that,
- 10:27uh,
- 10:27lower income and minority groups generally lean Democratic,
- 10:31and that's likely to be the group affected.
- 10:34But I think that voter ID is a good idea,
- 10:36but you should
- 10:37acknowledge the reason why
- 10:39they're.
- 10:40They don't like it because in a like a corrupt game
- 10:43it gives them a disadvantage
- 10:45and,
- 10:45and it's not what's the right move,
- 10:47it's
- 10:49what gives us an advantage in a corrupt game.
- 10:51I would say Republicans did the same thing years back when they said
- 10:55no,
- 10:55you gotta show up in person
- 10:57because they,
- 10:58which doesn't make sense,
- 10:59not like why would you need to show up in person?
- 11:01Let people vote
- 11:02remotely.
- 11:03And,
- 11:04and I don't know why these two groups haven't come together and said let's,
- 11:08let's give a little,
- 11:08let's acknowledge that both tied,
- 11:10they're trying to play on their corrupt game,
- 11:12but let's also move towards a higher purpose and a higher goal,
- 11:16which is,
- 11:17OK,
- 11:18voter ID makes sense.
- 11:19Also,
- 11:20remote
- 11:21voting makes sense.
- 11:23Let's make it easier for people to vote,
- 11:25but also more secure when they do.
- 11:28Yeah,
- 11:28I think that's a very good point and something I've been thinking about a lot.
- 11:32Democrats,
- 11:34you know,
- 11:35they have to kind of,
- 11:36and I get it,
- 11:36just.
- 11:37It would
- 11:39maybe disenfranchise is not the right word,
- 11:40but it would affect a lot of
- 11:42people of color.
- 11:43They would,
- 11:44it would make it difficult for them to vote
- 11:46if they had to have a form of ID or a specific kind of ID
- 11:50present with them when they showed up to vote.
- 11:52But just because that's true doesn't necessarily make it racist.
- 11:55And things that you've kind of heard,
- 11:57arguments you've heard,
- 11:58I think maybe Chuck Schumer might have said this something like,
- 12:00it's Jim Crow 2.0.
- 12:02You,
- 12:02you know,
- 12:03they kind of reach for the most inflammatory argument that these are
- 12:07racist
- 12:08ideas,
- 12:09you know,
- 12:10voter ID,
- 12:11voter ID laws are racist.
- 12:13And you kind of see it,
- 12:14it sort of reinforces what you're saying where it's like,
- 12:17oh man,
- 12:18like if we're painting the issue with that,
- 12:20you know,
- 12:20that color of,
- 12:21of pen.
- 12:23Everything,
- 12:24the stakes are raised so much higher,
- 12:25and then it kind of prevents Democrats from.
- 12:30I don't know,
- 12:30gaining any favor with the other side,
- 12:32but
- 12:32by being like,
- 12:33yeah,
- 12:33this is true.
- 12:34Let's figure out a way
- 12:36to,
- 12:36to,
- 12:37to do this,
- 12:37or let's figure out a way to make IDs more accessible so that
- 12:40just elections can be more secure in general.
- 12:43And so yeah,
- 12:43and then at the same time,
- 12:45it's so hard for them to kind of make this argument of why it's
- 12:48racist on on television and you you you see clips go viral where,
- 12:53you know,
- 12:53they,
- 12:53they can't quite articulate it in the,
- 12:55in the right ways.
- 12:56So I,
- 12:56I totally hear what you're saying,
- 12:58where it's like
- 12:59it's it's bad faith or it's
- 13:01intellectually dishonest
- 13:02from the get-go.
- 13:04But it's a strategy.
- 13:05It's like we can't let this pass because then we lose a few inches.
- 13:09Yeah,
- 13:09and
- 13:11I hate that,
- 13:11but,
- 13:12but I
- 13:13get it at the same time,
- 13:14right?
- 13:14It's like.
- 13:16It's like the gerrymandering nonsense we did.
- 13:18It's like Republicans very
- 13:20clearly and blatantly said
- 13:23we're going to go gerrymander Texas,
- 13:25and I think that was absolutely wrong and immoral,
- 13:28and I understand their argument,
- 13:30which is,
- 13:30well,
- 13:31Democrats have done it in other places.
- 13:33OK,
- 13:33sure,
- 13:34that's true,
- 13:34but guess what?
- 13:35Then California goes and gerrymanders.
- 13:37It,
- 13:37it's,
- 13:38I,
- 13:39I'm,
- 13:39I think I'm fed up and disengaged because I'm tired of the excuse
- 13:43that that person's a shithead,
- 13:44so I get to be a head.
- 13:46And,
- 13:47and I kind of wish there was a group that would,
- 13:49we could get behind and say,
- 13:50you know what,
- 13:50we are not supporting either of you until one of you
- 13:54acts like an adult,
- 13:56right?
- 13:56Well,
- 13:56and that was something,
- 13:57you know,
- 13:57Tallarico brought up was gerrymandering in his response to you.
- 14:01You know,
- 14:02did you take that seriously?
- 14:03Do you think he would really want to,
- 14:06even if it was to his own
- 14:09sides.
- 14:10You know,
- 14:11disadvantage
- 14:13and gerrymandering,
- 14:14did that feel sincere?
- 14:16I think James is sincere and I think he would.
- 14:19I,
- 14:20you know,
- 14:20I go back and forth between thinking all
- 14:23politicians are evil and all politicians are,
- 14:25are good in a bad system,
- 14:27and I honestly go back and forth between it.
- 14:30I,
- 14:30I,
- 14:30I like to think and give him the benefit of the doubt that he's sincere,
- 14:34but I think,
- 14:35uh,
- 14:35one of the problems is,
- 14:36is
- 14:37let's assume that he's sincere and a good person,
- 14:39and then he gets into a system.
- 14:41That's corrupt and there's incentives that he didn't realize,
- 14:43and there's pressure around the people with the people that you're around.
- 14:48And I wonder what happens to
- 14:51Why do we always see
- 14:53someone who is seemingly sincere
- 14:55get into a situation and all of that sincerity comes to nothing?
- 14:59Did they lose sincerity?
- 15:01Did they realize that
- 15:03what they were after can't happen?
- 15:05I,
- 15:05I don't know,
- 15:06but I know that
- 15:08there's always that disconnect between,
- 15:11uh,
- 15:11I,
- 15:11I'm sincere and I'm gonna do good things,
- 15:13and then when I'm in office,
- 15:14none of that comes to fruition.
- 15:16Most Americans,
- 15:17maybe even like 90% of Americans would.
- 15:21would agree with that,
- 15:22that sentiment
- 15:23of like,
- 15:24you know,
- 15:24people,
- 15:25people seem like they have the right intentions in mind
- 15:28and
- 15:30some sort of erosion happens.
- 15:33I'm curious,
- 15:34you know,
- 15:34uh,
- 15:35have you,
- 15:36you clearly spend a lot of time engaging with American politics
- 15:41on,
- 15:42you know,
- 15:42an analytical level through the content that is,
- 15:45you know,
- 15:46everywhere in our culture.
- 15:48Um,
- 15:49have you ever considered participating in,
- 15:52in more of kind of like,
- 15:53you know,
- 15:53like I wanna run for office or I,
- 15:55I wanna,
- 15:56you know,
- 15:56work in the system to,
- 15:57to better understand it.
- 15:58Has that ever been
- 16:00interesting to you?
- 16:02Uh,
- 16:03I've toyed with the idea,
- 16:05um.
- 16:06But
- 16:07in,
- 16:08in from different angles I've thought about.
- 16:11Running,
- 16:12though I don't know the running in some kind of local office or something,
- 16:15uh,
- 16:15though I don't have a strong inclination to do that,
- 16:18um,
- 16:19or even doing as,
- 16:20as I've talked to different people about why I don't vote,
- 16:23I realized that I don't have a real good source to go to,
- 16:26to see what,
- 16:28what are the local school,
- 16:29what's the difference between the two candidates on the school board?
- 16:32Things like that,
- 16:32and I thought,
- 16:33well,
- 16:33you know,
- 16:33there would be,
- 16:34there's room for someone to get in there,
- 16:36do a podcast where you sit down and explain it.
- 16:38And even better would be
- 16:41not necessarily a hostile
- 16:43way,
- 16:43but
- 16:44local elections,
- 16:45sit down with the two candidates and say,
- 16:48hey,
- 16:48you tell me what,
- 16:49what's the difference between you two,
- 16:50and let's,
- 16:51let's let you both represent yourself
- 16:53in the way that's most accurate
- 16:55and that,
- 16:56and let people digest that and then be able to go and vote
- 16:59uh in local areas and
- 17:01Local elections and local positions like that.
- 17:03I,
- 17:04I've thought about
- 17:05doing something like that,
- 17:06but
- 17:08you,
- 17:08you get to my age and it's,
- 17:10uh,
- 17:11it's not a matter of
- 17:13can I find something worthwhile to do.
- 17:14It's
- 17:16which of the many worthwhile things that I could do,
- 17:19am I going to do?
- 17:21Right,
- 17:21right.
- 17:22Um,
- 17:23OK,
- 17:23I'm gonna pull up this next clip cause I'm,
- 17:25I'm gonna
- 17:26dig into this with you cause this is what's most interesting.
- 17:30This is one of the most interesting things you said,
- 17:32and it's at the very end of the episode.
- 17:36It's nothing against James.
- 17:37It's really not.
- 17:38It's just
- 17:39two things.
- 17:40One,
- 17:40I don't see a vision that changes the system fundamentally.
- 17:44And two,
- 17:44I don't see that much of a difference.
- 17:46I really don't.
- 17:47I,
- 17:47I'm more interested in what I do to control my own life than what the government does.
- 17:52And so I think if I'm going to be civilly engaged,
- 17:55I'm going to do it in other ways other than voting.
- 17:57I'm wasting my time.
- 17:58It's 1 hour to go vote against a bunch of sheep zombies
- 18:01who are controlled by
- 18:02advertisements.
- 18:04Pretty strong.
- 18:06And
- 18:07convicted argument to not vote.
- 18:11But I,
- 18:11I hear.
- 18:13This intellectual engagement with where we're at and
- 18:16what could be done and what could change.
- 18:19And
- 18:21There's,
- 18:21there's,
- 18:22there's a contradiction there.
- 18:23Is there,
- 18:24is there not,
- 18:24you know,
- 18:25choosing not to vote,
- 18:26but,
- 18:26but still kind of being so engaged and so in tune with.
- 18:32With
- 18:32the trajectory of our of our political system.
- 18:37I,
- 18:37I have a good friend who points out this and says,
- 18:40uh,
- 18:41says I'm a massive hypocrite because I have,
- 18:43I engage and talk and,
- 18:45and love looking into politics and then don't vote.
- 18:47Um.
- 18:49I understand that sentiment.
- 18:50I disagree.
- 18:51And so
- 18:53I'll,
- 18:53I'll give two perspectives.
- 18:54One is
- 18:55that
- 18:56a lot of my engagement
- 18:58is,
- 18:58is for fun.
- 18:59It's,
- 19:00it's a hobby.
- 19:01And so it's,
- 19:02it's both fun,
- 19:03a hobby,
- 19:04and I can find it to be an intellectual exercise
- 19:07of to think on these things and stretch my mind and to
- 19:11maybe
- 19:13try and resonate with the perspective that I have an emotional reaction to and,
- 19:17and
- 19:18grow a little bit.
- 19:19Uh,
- 19:19and understand more.
- 19:20So part of it for me is actually
- 19:23a,
- 19:23a self-indulgence intellectual exercise.
- 19:26Um,
- 19:27the other aspect of it is
- 19:28I don't,
- 19:29people generally say there,
- 19:30it's a common saying I'm sure you've heard it of,
- 19:33well,
- 19:33if you haven't voted,
- 19:34I don't wanna hear your opinion on it.
- 19:36Yeah,
- 19:36yeah,
- 19:36I hear that.
- 19:37I flip it the other way.
- 19:39If all you've done is voted,
- 19:40I don't wanna hear your opinion on it.
- 19:42Voting is one of the least
- 19:44things you can do in community engagement,
- 19:46and,
- 19:46and you pick any topic you care about.
- 19:49If you care about supporting the poor.
- 19:52You can go vote for somebody that you think's gonna support the poor.
- 19:55Your time would be much better spent
- 19:57joining an organization
- 19:59or volunteering to help the poor.
- 20:01Go out and go to those,
- 20:02if you care about immigration,
- 20:04go to the immigrant communities
- 20:05and spend time making sure they get connected with your community.
- 20:09Um,
- 20:09offer what you can spend time talking to them.
- 20:12Often times you can do these things,
- 20:15and it's so much more impactful
- 20:17on an individual on a community level
- 20:18than just spending an hour going to go vote for
- 20:21somebody who's probably not going to make any difference,
- 20:24even if your vote made a difference in the election.
- 20:27Um,
- 20:28that's,
- 20:29that's generally how I feel about it.
- 20:31Why not?
- 20:32Yes and no.
- 20:33I mean,
- 20:34uh,
- 20:35everything you said about
- 20:36people being more involved in their communities is so valid,
- 20:40and
- 20:40people are way too under-engaged with their communities,
- 20:43not volunteering enough.
- 20:44You know,
- 20:44people should go to church,
- 20:45even,
- 20:46not even if they necessarily believe in God,
- 20:48but just to be across from their neighbors and to like,
- 20:51you know,
- 20:51have an awareness of what's happening in their community and who they live with.
- 20:55I'm all for that.
- 20:57Um
- 20:58But there's got to be a deeper injury,
- 21:02maybe not injury,
- 21:03but
- 21:03dissatisfaction with
- 21:06what it means to vote
- 21:08in our current system for you.
- 21:10Because your argument would,
- 21:12would support voting as well as volunteering,
- 21:14would it not?
- 21:15Like,
- 21:15like go the extra mile.
- 21:17In,
- 21:18in all cases to be a participant in your community,
- 21:21but to,
- 21:22to me,
- 21:22what I'm hearing is like.
- 21:25Voting in this current system is almost like a.
- 21:28Do you think it's degrading or or?
- 21:32Or something like that because.
- 21:34I'm trying to kind of understand because I,
- 21:36I,
- 21:36I still don't quite understand why it's a barrier for you.
- 21:40Yeah,
- 21:41you know,
- 21:41I think.
- 21:43Let,
- 21:44let me say this too,
- 21:45I speak strongly on this and passionately,
- 21:48partly because I want to hear a strong and impassioned argument
- 21:51against it,
- 21:52um.
- 21:53Between you and me,
- 21:54I'm not as sold.
- 21:57Yeah,
- 21:57I want to see like.
- 22:01It it
- 22:03it's almost like a relationship of like,
- 22:04do you really love me in a sense,
- 22:06right?
- 22:06In the sense of like,
- 22:07do you really believe voting matters?
- 22:09So that's,
- 22:10that's part of it is I'm not nearly as sold on not voting
- 22:13as I,
- 22:14as I argue,
- 22:15because I want to hear a really good argument of why I should vote,
- 22:17and I've,
- 22:18I've had some,
- 22:19um,
- 22:19but the other side of it too,
- 22:21John,
- 22:21is
- 22:22I've said repeatedly,
- 22:24if you are not educated on it,
- 22:26if you are not.
- 22:28If you're not giving an intelligent vote.
- 22:31Don't give a vote
- 22:32and so on a lot of these issues,
- 22:34I,
- 22:36I have not educated myself on all the candidates and so I wanted to rather to avoid,
- 22:42I want to avoid the hypocrisy of
- 22:45you're telling people not to go vote and you go vote.
- 22:48Um,
- 22:49I,
- 22:49I really,
- 22:50it's,
- 22:50it's a lot of it is a pushback against the system as a whole.
- 22:54As well,
- 22:55in the sense of I,
- 22:56I think one of the problems is people are voting
- 22:59with
- 23:00without
- 23:01any thoughtfulness,
- 23:02without
- 23:03any intellectual engagement in the ideas or the candidates,
- 23:06and
- 23:07I,
- 23:07I'm so strongly against that,
- 23:10that
- 23:10I'm just not even voting as my little
- 23:13protest,
- 23:14so to speak,
- 23:15against it,
- 23:15and,
- 23:15and then more so speaking out of,
- 23:18hey,
- 23:18this is why other people shouldn't vote,
- 23:20like
- 23:21protest the system that way.
- 23:23And,
- 23:24and to be,
- 23:25to be fair,
- 23:26I,
- 23:26I do.
- 23:28I've always said that if the right person came along
- 23:31and
- 23:32took the high road instead of,
- 23:33like you said,
- 23:34racing to the bottom,
- 23:35I would get out and I would vote for that person,
- 23:37and I would encourage other people to vote for that person.
- 23:40Yeah.
- 23:41I hear what you're saying.
- 23:42I mean,
- 23:42a lot of what you say,
- 23:43I think is super
- 23:45interesting and valid and,
- 23:46and
- 23:47something I would support,
- 23:48you know,
- 23:48like removing D and R
- 23:50from
- 23:52the names and be like,
- 23:53you gotta know
- 23:54who the person is you are voting for.
- 23:56You can't just go in and be like,
- 23:58OK,
- 23:58where are the D's?
- 23:59Show me the D's,
- 24:00because
- 24:00that in and of itself turns politics into this literal cliff where it's like,
- 24:06We just,
- 24:06we slide one way or the other and everybody's playing kind of the red,
- 24:09blue,
- 24:10um,
- 24:10color coding game and,
- 24:12and,
- 24:13and then,
- 24:14the most extreme
- 24:16belligerent messaging you could possibly think of to
- 24:18push people one way or the other.
- 24:20And that's why kind of our culture is,
- 24:22you know,
- 24:22it's like we've got,
- 24:24it's not like Christian values,
- 24:25it's like Christian nationalism.
- 24:27It's not just um
- 24:29Social progressive ideas,
- 24:31it's woke,
- 24:32you know,
- 24:32it's like these caricatures of,
- 24:35of kind of the former.
- 24:37The seeds of what existed on both sides.
- 24:41So I,
- 24:41I,
- 24:42I think that's a good idea.
- 24:43I think um.
- 24:46I think what you,
- 24:46what we saw in California,
- 24:48Elon Musk,
- 24:48I kind of once heard comment on like
- 24:51the lack of just intellectual diversity or,
- 24:53or political diversity in California was its own.
- 24:57Um,
- 24:58you know,
- 24:59it,
- 24:59it harmed the system because it was like people are just going to vote
- 25:03blue no matter what.
- 25:04And,
- 25:04and
- 25:05what kind of immune system do you have
- 25:08in a state or in a government
- 25:11that like
- 25:12doesn't tolerate any political
- 25:14diversity,
- 25:16um,
- 25:16and where the political opponent doesn't have any chance of,
- 25:19of gaining power and sort of course correcting.
- 25:22So like if there's not tension,
- 25:23you know,
- 25:24you really can fall into these.
- 25:26Into these traps.
- 25:27And so I hear you on,
- 25:29on all of that.
- 25:30And I think
- 25:32I agree with you.
- 25:32I'm like,
- 25:33I feel starved and I think a lot of Americans feel starved.
- 25:36Like,
- 25:36what is something different?
- 25:37Where's somebody who's just radically different?
- 25:40Who's the closest that
- 25:42has been
- 25:43in the political sphere in your lifetime
- 25:45that's got
- 25:47almost gotten you there,
- 25:48almost crossed that threshold of like,
- 25:50this feels
- 25:51real,
- 25:51this feels
- 25:53Like coming from a good place.
- 25:56Uh you know.
- 25:58There's two people who come to mind who have gotten the biggest sense of that,
- 26:02uh,
- 26:03which are very different ends of the spectrum.
- 26:05Um,
- 26:06originally,
- 26:08Bernie Sanders,
- 26:09when,
- 26:10when running against Trump,
- 26:12I think 202016,
- 26:15I,
- 26:16I,
- 26:16as a person,
- 26:17I agreed with,
- 26:19uh,
- 26:19a lot of his sentiment and,
- 26:22and a lot of the bucking of establishment.
- 26:25More and more I've
- 26:27Shown away from that.
- 26:28I just feel like
- 26:30going back to it,
- 26:31and he didn't actually seem that different from a lot of politicians.
- 26:34I was,
- 26:35uh,
- 26:35disenfranchised a bit on,
- 26:38I,
- 26:38I think there's nothing more
- 26:41evil and
- 26:43obnoxious
- 26:44than
- 26:45this idea of,
- 26:46uh,
- 26:47I'm going to go preach what I want.
- 26:50And not live it,
- 26:51and it,
- 26:53it felt
- 26:54very much like that.
- 26:55That's the sense more and more I've gotten from Bernie Sanders,
- 26:58so I've been less
- 26:59uh
- 27:01Less attracted to that person
- 27:03because of it.
- 27:04Um,
- 27:05and then there's the other one is,
- 27:07man,
- 27:07I'm gonna forget his name.
- 27:08He is,
- 27:09I think he's libertarian out of Tennessee,
- 27:11Ron Paul.
- 27:13Oh yeah,
- 27:14he's very independent thinker.
- 27:16He,
- 27:16he is,
- 27:17and,
- 27:17and I really,
- 27:18you know,
- 27:18I'll tell you one of my red flags.
- 27:21If anybody agrees wholeheartedly with their party.
- 27:25I disagree with them
- 27:26because what I,
- 27:27what you can kind of tell
- 27:28is that it's they're not living their principles,
- 27:30they're living with their group,
- 27:32and that's not who I want to be.
- 27:34I don't,
- 27:35I don't
- 27:36consider myself a Republican.
- 27:37I don't consider myself a Democrat.
- 27:39I,
- 27:39I,
- 27:39I actually consider myself now a,
- 27:41a recovering libertarian.
- 27:43Um,
- 27:44because I don't agree with everything libertarians agree with at this point,
- 27:46but I love
- 27:48seeing Ron Paul engage
- 27:50and
- 27:51very quickly,
- 27:52I mean,
- 27:52he,
- 27:53he did a Joe Rogan interview and he talked about it.
- 27:55He was like,
- 27:55why are you,
- 27:56why are you blowing up these,
- 27:57these people?
- 27:58It's a war crime.
- 28:00I don't care if Donald Trump does it or Joe Biden did it.
- 28:02It's wrong
- 28:04and
- 28:05And everyone else was just like,
- 28:07no,
- 28:07Donald Trump said it's good,
- 28:08so it's got to be good.
- 28:10Like,
- 28:10come on guys,
- 28:11like
- 28:13if you,
- 28:13and,
- 28:13and the other part is if you truly care about
- 28:15your team and you truly care about your people,
- 28:18you criticize them.
- 28:19You,
- 28:20you call them out and you encourage them to be better,
- 28:22but instead of doing that,
- 28:23we seem to have
- 28:25this,
- 28:25this idea of
- 28:27whatever is red is correct and whatever is blue is correct,
- 28:30and
- 28:30you can't give a little.
- 28:32I mean,
- 28:32and this,
- 28:32this.
- 28:34These shootings in Minnesota,
- 28:36right?
- 28:36Both sides came out with,
- 28:38with the most
- 28:40extreme stories
- 28:41of
- 28:42totally innocent bystander
- 28:44that
- 28:45just got shot out of nowhere and
- 28:47a terrorist.
- 28:48It's like.
- 28:50Guys,
- 28:51is there any nuance?
- 28:52Do we have any room for nuance?
- 28:54And I see someone like Ron Paul and,
- 28:55and sometimes Bernie Sanders,
- 28:57who,
- 28:58who can
- 28:59acknowledge that,
- 28:59who can acknowledge like,
- 29:01oh shit,
- 29:02this shouldn't have happened.
- 29:04Both sides were a little in the wrong and,
- 29:07and sometimes shit happens.
- 29:08And what I'm kind of hearing is like,
- 29:10you know,
- 29:10the,
- 29:10the Abe Lincoln band of rivals kind of idea,
- 29:14like.
- 29:15Uh,
- 29:15or a team of rivals,
- 29:16sorry.
- 29:18You know,
- 29:18you want,
- 29:19you want tension,
- 29:20you want contrast.
- 29:22It's,
- 29:22it's even kind of if you think about it in sports,
- 29:24if you have a,
- 29:26A team of all Michael Jordan's probably wouldn't be as good as a team with,
- 29:31you know,
- 29:31Rodman and Pippen,
- 29:32and I,
- 29:34that's the,
- 29:34the
- 29:35limit of my
- 29:36memory of that team,
- 29:38but,
- 29:38you know,
- 29:38these diverse players with diverse skills that are complementary,
- 29:42but they're fundamentally very different kinds of players and,
- 29:46But this is where I,
- 29:47I,
- 29:47you know,
- 29:48I'm
- 29:49I'm
- 29:49sorry to put so much pressure on you.
- 29:51You,
- 29:52you are like a purple-minded voter.
- 29:54You're exactly the kind of person that we want
- 29:56to be voting because you're not going to,
- 29:58you know,
- 29:58vote,
- 29:59uh,
- 30:00party line.
- 30:01So,
- 30:03I appreciate everything you said here because I think these are all great ideas.
- 30:06My only thing is,
- 30:07you gotta be,
- 30:08we need you,
- 30:09um,
- 30:10and obviously we would need
- 30:12millions of you
- 30:14to,
- 30:14to guarantee a certain kind of shift in our political climate.
- 30:18But
- 30:18this is exactly the kind of,
- 30:20kind of thinking I have an appetite for.
- 30:22So,
- 30:23it's great to hear these things from you,
- 30:25but I,
- 30:25I would beg you to,
- 30:26to vote and find a way to,
- 30:28to convince
- 30:29everyone else like you
- 30:30to,
- 30:31to also vote,
- 30:32uh.
- 30:32Without this party,
- 30:34um.
- 30:36Differential allegiance.
- 30:39This is not something I'm resolved on.
- 30:40So,
- 30:41I,
- 30:42I'll seriously think about it,
- 30:43and,
- 30:43and,
- 30:44and I have been thinking about it.
- 30:45And every time I hear these arguments,
- 30:46I chew over the idea more in my head.
- 30:49My current stance is if we're on a spectrum and like,
- 30:52here's the turning point,
- 30:54my current stance is like right here on not voting
- 30:57because the more and more I'm like,
- 30:58no,
- 30:58there's enough intelligent people who disagree with me,
- 31:00and I have to ask myself
- 31:02at some point am I just being stubborn
- 31:06and,
- 31:06and.
- 31:08And I try and see,
- 31:09it's,
- 31:09it's easy.
- 31:10One,
- 31:10I think the biggest thing for me is.
- 31:13I could get out and vote,
- 31:14but
- 31:15But what's the end goal?
- 31:16Like what's the,
- 31:16what's the end objective?
- 31:18What's that thing,
- 31:19that tipping point that's going to change us from
- 31:23Everybody votes and,
- 31:24and,
- 31:24and thoughtful people don't really have a chance against.
- 31:29Zombie sheep,
- 31:30right,
- 31:30because they're just a bigger group and until that dynamic can change,
- 31:33I don't know that I wanna waste my time voting.
- 31:36That's still,
- 31:37uh look,
- 31:37I'm on the edge there,
- 31:39uh.
- 31:40And I wonder how many people are like me who are on the edge,
- 31:43who are just like,
- 31:44ah,
- 31:44like I could go be effective in so many other areas of my life,
- 31:48not like not even politics and community,
- 31:50but
- 31:50I could spend that time exercising or or something else,
- 31:54um,
- 31:54and I wonder if
- 31:56I ask myself what would it take to get me,
- 31:58because there's other people,
- 31:59what would it take to get me and others
- 32:01over that ledge,
- 32:02and would that be enough to,
- 32:03to change the dynamic?
- 32:05Mhm.
- 32:06It's really refreshing to
- 32:08To engage with people who are so independent,
- 32:11um,
- 32:11minded,
- 32:12I,
- 32:12I really hope
- 32:14we're,
- 32:15that'll become in vogue.
- 32:17And,
- 32:17uh,
- 32:18hopefully we'll see,
- 32:19you know,
- 32:19that person we're both,
- 32:21we have that,
- 32:22that itch for that longing for to
- 32:25come in and change the tone of politics.
- 32:27Maybe,
- 32:27maybe they're around the corner.
- 32:29I am here with Krista.
- 32:31Uh,
- 32:32Krista,
- 32:32welcome to this round of follow-up.
- 32:34Thank you.
- 32:35So first things first,
- 32:36what was it like,
- 32:38uh,
- 32:39you know,
- 32:39sitting face to face with James
- 32:41Tallarico first surrounded?
- 32:43Yeah,
- 32:43of course,
- 32:44um,
- 32:44overall I felt like it was a good conversation.
- 32:47Uh,
- 32:47we didn't really interrupt each other and we were able to communicate our thoughts,
- 32:51um,
- 32:51as well as get our point across.
- 32:54Mhm.
- 32:55I'm going to play you the first clip,
- 32:57um,
- 32:58which was from your initial interaction with him,
- 33:00and his claim
- 33:01was
- 33:03America's divided,
- 33:04but it's divided by top and bottom,
- 33:06not left and right.
- 33:08And you kind of pushed back on that,
- 33:09um.
- 33:11And so I'll play you this clip and then we'll react to it.
- 33:13So
- 33:14here's that interaction.
- 33:16I believe that economics,
- 33:18uh,
- 33:18like
- 33:18the top versus the bottom accounts for economic inequity,
- 33:22but I believe ideology is where the polarization comes in.
- 33:26So you're a man of faith,
- 33:27correct?
- 33:28So
- 33:29you are definitely.
- 33:31So wouldn't you say that your faith
- 33:33drives who you are as a person and your beliefs?
- 33:36Absolutely,
- 33:37and I agree that political polarization is a problem.
- 33:40What I'm trying to get us to realize is how these systems that we're in,
- 33:43um,
- 33:44a broken political system,
- 33:45a broken media system.
- 33:46A broken social media system,
- 33:48how that exacerbates
- 33:50ideological differences.
- 33:51Of course we're all very different people.
- 33:53We're gonna have different opinions,
- 33:54but these algorithms,
- 33:56these cable news networks,
- 33:57they fan the flames
- 33:59of those disagreements,
- 34:00and that's why we have such polarized politics,
- 34:02in my opinion.
- 34:03So you think it's like an echo chamber like.
- 34:05Yeah,
- 34:05I,
- 34:06I,
- 34:06I think
- 34:07that these billionaires,
- 34:08let's,
- 34:08you know,
- 34:08Jeff Bezos,
- 34:09Mark Zuckerberg,
- 34:10Elon Musk,
- 34:11Rupert Murdoch,
- 34:12the people who increasingly own
- 34:14traditional media and
- 34:15new social media,
- 34:17they have a vested interest
- 34:18in all of us being divided
- 34:20because if we recognize that we are far more alike than we are
- 34:23different,
- 34:24if we realize that we have far more in common,
- 34:26we're gonna take power back from them and
- 34:28we're gonna bring it back into our communities.
- 34:30What comes to mind when you hear.
- 34:33Yeah,
- 34:33you just kind of relive that exchange.
- 34:35I think we had a really productive conversation in that.
- 34:38um,
- 34:39I think when you have this idea that
- 34:42oh it's this group of people's fault,
- 34:43in this case he was saying
- 34:45the top 1%,
- 34:47um,
- 34:47I think you have to be open to seeing other people's perspectives
- 34:51and I do
- 34:52stand by my opinion.
- 34:53I,
- 34:54I do believe that ideology is what creates that polarization,
- 34:57whereas economics
- 34:58that explains,
- 34:59you know,
- 34:59poverty or economic inequity,
- 35:02um.
- 35:03But I think
- 35:04if
- 35:04Talarico keeps this ideology of
- 35:07oh it's only the 1%'s fault,
- 35:10I think
- 35:11yes I agree with him to a certain extent,
- 35:13but I feel like he needs to see the whole picture on that
- 35:16ideology does play a big role
- 35:18and you could see that
- 35:19um
- 35:20with his faith like his faith drives who he is as a person
- 35:24and a lot of his belief systems and I believe
- 35:27you know.
- 35:27That's that's definitely a positive thing for him.
- 35:29That's why he's running for US Senate and that's why he's
- 35:31getting these big audiences,
- 35:33but I believe that the 1% does influence us today.
- 35:37But again,
- 35:38I would have to disagree.
- 35:38I think it all ties back to ideology
- 35:40and we see that with uh multi-millionaires and billionaires
- 35:43how there's multi-billionaires on the left,
- 35:46there's multi-billionaires on the right,
- 35:47and you can see them donate their funds
- 35:49to causes that are,
- 35:51you know,
- 35:52that they support.
- 35:54OK,
- 35:54so you're saying even at the top
- 35:56when you've got all the money in the world,
- 35:58you're still divided by your ideology.
- 36:00You're still putting your money where
- 36:02your belief system
- 36:04is the root.
- 36:04It's a deeper root.
- 36:06I see.
- 36:07No,
- 36:07I think you,
- 36:08I think you make a good point there,
- 36:10um.
- 36:11Something's interesting though about Tallarico is he is a Christian,
- 36:15you know,
- 36:16um,
- 36:17and the right is typically associated with,
- 36:20uh,
- 36:20Christianity,
- 36:21and he's kind of
- 36:22carving out this new niche.
- 36:24We'll see
- 36:25if it works or not,
- 36:26but that's kind of work in his favor 100%.
- 36:29There's no doubt in my mind it's definitely,
- 36:32I think even though he's kind of steering towards the left,
- 36:34do you think so?
- 36:34100%,
- 36:35yeah,
- 36:36100%.
- 36:37I think.
- 36:38I think that's what's making him so successful.
- 36:40The reason I heard about Tallarico is one,
- 36:42because of the Joe Rogan podcast,
- 36:44and two,
- 36:44because I saw that clip of him,
- 36:46um,
- 36:47on social media where
- 36:48he was explaining why he's against the 10 Commandments being
- 36:52in the classroom,
- 36:53I think.
- 36:54Him explaining that it's not
- 36:56friendly to my neighbor in a biblical sense like quoting the Bible um
- 37:00definitely works in his favor.
- 37:02I think
- 37:03that a lot of people who are on the left and are Christian are gonna
- 37:06sway their votes towards him and the same thing for on the right and Christian,
- 37:10um,
- 37:11you know,
- 37:12there's never a perfect candidate but few people who are hesitant about
- 37:15Ken Paxton,
- 37:17um,
- 37:17because again it's gonna probably come down to Ken Paxton,
- 37:20uh,
- 37:20Tallarico,
- 37:21or,
- 37:21uh,
- 37:22I think it's Jasmine Crockett,
- 37:23correct?
- 37:24Um-hum.
- 37:24I believe.
- 37:25Although a lot of people are saying,
- 37:26you know,
- 37:27her,
- 37:27she's not tracking terribly well.
- 37:29Yeah,
- 37:30I,
- 37:30I think Tallarico's gonna get the Democratic vote and I
- 37:33think it's gonna be down to him and Ken Paxton,
- 37:35but I think
- 37:36what
- 37:37makes him such a great candidate and is giving him an edge
- 37:40is his Christianity and not a lot of people on the left,
- 37:44they of course they can identify as Christian,
- 37:46but they choose
- 37:47to separate,
- 37:47uh,
- 37:48church versus state,
- 37:49whereas he is like kind of blurring the line
- 37:51and he's very much attracting
- 37:53that group and especially here in Texas,
- 37:54you know,
- 37:55everybody is so conservative,
- 37:57um.
- 37:59Both are you conservative
- 38:00I would say I'm in the middle.
- 38:02I mean certain things I agree with the left
- 38:04with certain things I agree with the right with,
- 38:06um,
- 38:07but,
- 38:08uh,
- 38:08based off a rare bird.
- 38:11I guess,
- 38:12yeah.
- 38:14I think this is definitely going to work for
- 38:15him and I don't agree with everything he says,
- 38:17but
- 38:18I think he's resonating with a lot of people.
- 38:20Yeah,
- 38:21he's running a really interesting campaign and he's kind
- 38:23of a unique figure to surface in Texas.
- 38:25And you know,
- 38:26something I think about a lot is
- 38:27a lot of people from California have been moving to Texas.
- 38:30So,
- 38:30you know,
- 38:30Texas is kind of more uniquely
- 38:33purple perhaps than it's been in the past and so
- 38:36there could be a flux of ideology and sort of voting
- 38:39patterns in the state,
- 38:40but
- 38:41at the same time,
- 38:42Texas has been very reliably red and.
- 38:45It's been very reliably conservative Christian
- 38:48in a flavor that is not James Tallarico.
- 38:51So,
- 38:51it's kind of TBD in my mind if he's getting as much traction as we think.
- 38:56Something I'm curious though,
- 38:58hearing more from you,
- 38:59he's kind of pointing out,
- 39:00and we're on social media,
- 39:01Jubilee is social media.
- 39:03Jubilee certainly
- 39:04plays in the arena of politics and political conflict,
- 39:09but
- 39:09Tallarico is making this argument that look,
- 39:11These billionaires who run
- 39:13these algorithms,
- 39:15run these platforms,
- 39:16Zuckerberg,
- 39:17um,
- 39:18Elon Musk,
- 39:19Jeff Bezos.
- 39:21Um,
- 39:22Ellison
- 39:24I,
- 39:24I don't know how much influence they truly have on these algorithms,
- 39:26but he's saying
- 39:27they want us to be divided so that they can keep
- 39:30holding power.
- 39:31Do you buy that argument?
- 39:33Do you
- 39:34share kind of that criticism towards the rich that James is,
- 39:37is
- 39:39Trying to kind of
- 39:40frame.
- 39:41See,
- 39:41I,
- 39:42I can't,
- 39:42I agree with him in a certain sense,
- 39:44but I can't fully agree.
- 39:45I agree that the algorithms do play a role,
- 39:48so I work in tech,
- 39:49so basically whatever you like,
- 39:51interact with in your algorithm,
- 39:53it comes,
- 39:54you know,
- 39:54it keeps showing you it because that's what you're engaging with,
- 39:56that's what you like.
- 39:57They want to keep you on the app as long as you can.
- 39:59I don't think necessarily that,
- 40:01you know,
- 40:01the Zuck or Elon,
- 40:03um,
- 40:03are necessarily pushing a certain narrative like,
- 40:07oh,
- 40:07we want X,
- 40:08Y,
- 40:08and Z out there.
- 40:08You need to put this on.
- 40:09Algorithm or you want ABC out there when you put this all on the algorithm
- 40:14I think I mean excuse me,
- 40:15not algorithm on your timeline I think it the algorithm is all based off of
- 40:19what you interact with what I do agree with is if
- 40:21you have a certain for itself to a certain degree,
- 40:24yes,
- 40:24exactly.
- 40:26So if I'm far right or far left and I'm interacting with posts
- 40:30that agree with my ideology like I said in the uh interview or debate,
- 40:34excuse me,
- 40:35um,
- 40:35it definitely does become an echo chamber.
- 40:38Mhm.
- 40:39Right.
- 40:40And,
- 40:41and I guess the only,
- 40:42the only thing I would say that that really supports his argument
- 40:45is
- 40:46there might be economic incentives.
- 40:49So,
- 40:49for example,
- 40:50you know,
- 40:50Mark Zuckerberg
- 40:51famously kind of dictated that um,
- 40:55He sort of aligned
- 40:56Facebook's goals to optimize
- 40:59user sessions as long as possible.
- 41:00We want people to be on Facebook as long as possible,
- 41:03and this was kind of back in 2016.
- 41:05And so
- 41:06just that economic incentive of like we want to capture as much attention as we can,
- 41:11and that's the algorithm's job.
- 41:13The algorithm then discovered on its own in a certain way that
- 41:18Harnessing outrage or feeding people more content that kind of uh
- 41:23aggravated their political
- 41:25sensibilities
- 41:26was the best way to achieve that.
- 41:28So it's sort of an unintended consequence.
- 41:30Something I'm curious about from you,
- 41:32you know,
- 41:33after sitting
- 41:34across from
- 41:35Tallarico,
- 41:36did he win you over?
- 41:37Do you consider yourself,
- 41:39um,
- 41:39a vote for him after this experience,
- 41:42or were you already.
- 41:43Uh,
- 41:44you know,
- 41:44decided going into this.
- 41:45I'm curious.
- 41:47And no,
- 41:47I was undecided.
- 41:48I think for me
- 41:49it's uh between
- 41:50Ken Paxton and Tallarico and,
- 41:53um,
- 41:53a lot of Tallarico's ideology,
- 41:56uh,
- 41:56while I don't agree with everything,
- 41:57it's,
- 41:58it's,
- 41:59uh,
- 41:59pretty similar to mine
- 42:01in a way,
- 42:02um,
- 42:03but
- 42:03again I'll have to do more research,
- 42:05um,
- 42:06see the debates,
- 42:07and if.
- 42:09Yeah,
- 42:09we'll go from there,
- 42:10you know
- 42:10he called you back to the center.
- 42:13um,
- 42:14what was it like to to be the the one chosen?
- 42:16I think the reason he called me back is because we just had a good conversation.
- 42:20Um,
- 42:20I really wanted to talk about gun control and I'm,
- 42:23I'm happy that I got the platform to speak with him one on one on that.
- 42:27I've been following his campaign,
- 42:28but I haven't really been seeing him,
- 42:31um,
- 42:31speak much about gun control,
- 42:33but of course his uh voting patterns
- 42:35have
- 42:36been in favor of gun control,
- 42:37so.
- 42:38It was a good
- 42:39conversation.
- 42:40I'm gonna play you back uh a clip where you kind of
- 42:42lay out your claim and and his initial response to it.
- 42:46My claim is no matter how many how much
- 42:48gun violence happens within the state of Texas,
- 42:50there will never be a gun ban or gun reform.
- 42:54Well,
- 42:54that claim is pretty gut-wrenching,
- 42:56given that we've had 5 of the
- 42:59deadliest mass shootings in American history right here
- 43:01in Texas.
- 43:03One
- 43:04still haunts me to this day as a former public school teacher,
- 43:06and that's
- 43:07the massacre in Uvalde,
- 43:08Texas,
- 43:09in
- 43:10Robb Elementary when we lost
- 43:1219 babies and 2 teachers.
- 43:15Here's where I'll disagree with you on this claim though.
- 43:17I saw
- 43:19those parents from Uvalde.
- 43:21I saw them make the 160 mile drive
- 43:23from Uvalde to the state capitol
- 43:26multiple times
- 43:27during that legislative session,
- 43:28demanding,
- 43:29begging
- 43:30for basic common sense gun safety.
- 43:33They,
- 43:33they believed in the Second Amendment just like I do.
- 43:36But they knew that there needed to be some kind of regulation
- 43:38to keep everyone safe and protect everybody's freedoms,
- 43:41including
- 43:41the freedom of those 19 babies
- 43:43to live and fulfill their potential.
- 43:46What I saw them do just over the course of one legislative session
- 43:50is move the needle.
- 43:52On a common sense bill to raise the age to buy those kind of weapons from 18 to 21,
- 43:56the
- 43:57murderer in Uvalde
- 43:58turned 18 the day before he committed that horrific massacre,
- 44:02right.
- 44:03Did you feel like James,
- 44:04um,
- 44:06you know,
- 44:06changed your mind a little bit on,
- 44:07on your claim?
- 44:08Uh,
- 44:08he kind of,
- 44:09he makes the,
- 44:09the case there that
- 44:11incremental
- 44:12progress,
- 44:13you know,
- 44:14had actually occurred and,
- 44:15and,
- 44:16you know,
- 44:16is,
- 44:17is possible on this issue.
- 44:20No,
- 44:20he didn't change my mind on that.
- 44:21The bill never passed.
- 44:23I think it was Bill
- 44:24House Bill 2744.
- 44:27It never passed.
- 44:28Um,
- 44:29I think if it would have passed or it would have gotten,
- 44:32I think if it would have passed,
- 44:33I would have changed my mind.
- 44:36It almost passed,
- 44:39which
- 44:39that's not enough.
- 44:40I mean,
- 44:41me personally.
- 44:43What is it gonna take?
- 44:45I mean,
- 44:45I,
- 44:46I own a gun myself.
- 44:47I'm all for gun safety.
- 44:49I'm all for um
- 44:51just gun safety background checks and.
- 44:53It's like how many kids are gonna have to die
- 44:56in schools for there to be some kind of change,
- 44:58and it happened,
- 44:59it happened in Texas.
- 45:00It happened in Uvalde,
- 45:01and
- 45:02nothing's changed.
- 45:03You saw how hard those parents went,
- 45:05uh,
- 45:05going back and forth,
- 45:07and Bill 2744 never passed.
- 45:10What is it gonna take?
- 45:10Why is this issue so close to your heart?
- 45:12Is it just because you've witnessed so many mass shootings occur in the news?
- 45:16Um,
- 45:18I think I don't,
- 45:18I don't mean to downplay.
- 45:19I mean they're,
- 45:21they're terrible things to.
- 45:22To hear about,
- 45:23um,
- 45:24I share that with you,
- 45:25but I'm just curious why it's close to you.
- 45:28It's just close to me on a deeper level.
- 45:29Um,
- 45:30I've had multiple friends pass from gun violence
- 45:33and seeing these kids,
- 45:34you know,
- 45:34trying to follow their dreams and go to school.
- 45:37And
- 45:38just have their lives taken is so incredibly insane to me and I see no change.
- 45:43Um,
- 45:43one of my friends who passed away,
- 45:45um,
- 45:45Marco Ramirez,
- 45:46um,
- 45:47somebody was stealing his,
- 45:48uh,
- 45:48father's truck
- 45:49and he went after them to try to get the,
- 45:51uh,
- 45:51truck back and he was shot and killed.
- 45:54Um,
- 45:54another one of my friends,
- 45:55I think this case is a little bit more well known,
- 45:58um,
- 45:58Juvenal Antero,
- 46:00um,
- 46:00he passed away,
- 46:01um,
- 46:02within the same year I think they passed away within 2 months of each other.
- 46:05Um,
- 46:05during a home invasion
- 46:07and it was him,
- 46:08his wife,
- 46:08and his son,
- 46:10and they shot and killed him in front of his family,
- 46:12and the,
- 46:13the three people who shot him are still
- 46:15wanted,
- 46:16um,
- 46:17and that one's a little bit more well known,
- 46:19um,
- 46:20I mean how many,
- 46:22thank you,
- 46:22I appreciate that,
- 46:24um,
- 46:24but how many people are gonna have to
- 46:26die by gun violence for there to be
- 46:28some sort of change if kids are dying in classrooms,
- 46:31um.
- 46:33What is it?
- 46:33What else is it gonna take and
- 46:35particularly like I think of this documentary,
- 46:38um,
- 46:39all I think it's called All the Empty Rooms.
- 46:41Have you heard of it?
- 46:42I have,
- 46:43yeah,
- 46:43the empty bedrooms of,
- 46:45of
- 46:46kids who have been killed
- 46:47and
- 46:48one of the,
- 46:49uh,
- 46:50kids covered in there is Jackie
- 46:52and it shows like the impact like
- 46:55I think we've become so desensitized to gun violence and
- 46:58kids dying all the time in classrooms based off people who are mentally ill or.
- 47:03Um,
- 47:03are just sick.
- 47:05I mean,
- 47:07what is it gonna take?
- 47:09I mean,
- 47:09I,
- 47:09I share that sense of exasperation.
- 47:11This is an issue that has been
- 47:14In the news since,
- 47:15I,
- 47:16I mean,
- 47:16I lived in Colorado,
- 47:17so like Columbine happened when I was in like 2nd grade.
- 47:20And then from then on,
- 47:21it's kind of dominated the American consciousness as
- 47:25a problem.
- 47:26But,
- 47:27and we actually see this kind of violence now spreading to other countries.
- 47:31I think there was recently just a,
- 47:32a,
- 47:33a school shooting or,
- 47:34or a mass shooting in Canada,
- 47:36and these are uncharacteristic events in other countries.
- 47:40And so,
- 47:42I think part of the problem is it's really perplexing.
- 47:45Nobody knows exactly how to pinpoint
- 47:47what this formula is for a mass shooting.
- 47:50Obviously access to guns is part of it.
- 47:53But my impression as somebody who.
- 47:57Doesn't own a gun and doesn't know a lot of people who owns guns
- 48:00is that people who,
- 48:02you know,
- 48:02like the gun community in the United States is
- 48:05so protective of the Second Amendment that they reject
- 48:09gun control
- 48:10measures,
- 48:11um,
- 48:12and their elected representatives,
- 48:14you know,
- 48:15echo that.
- 48:15And so it's,
- 48:16there's,
- 48:16it's just been kind of an impossible
- 48:19barrier to overcome,
- 48:20to get
- 48:21legislation passed.
- 48:23I mean,
- 48:23as somebody who owns a gun and,
- 48:25and
- 48:26But then still wants to see gun control.
- 48:28What do you think when you hear that?
- 48:29Does that sound
- 48:30untrue?
- 48:31Does that sound valid?
- 48:33I can kind of see it.
- 48:34I think a lot of gun owners see it as a slippery slope.
- 48:38If you're banning
- 48:39certain rifles like semi-automatics or things like that,
- 48:43they're going to be like,
- 48:44Well,
- 48:44what's the next step?
- 48:45Are you going to start banning handguns?
- 48:46Are you going to start banning um you know,
- 48:48any type of guns?
- 48:50And we've seen like small incremental changes like
- 48:53they banned the switch on the Glock.
- 48:55now that's,
- 48:56I believe it's a federal offense now.
- 48:59But it's just so hard to balance.
- 49:01I think
- 49:02one thing that I agree a lot of gun owners
- 49:05want to do is have heavy background checks for those who are mentally ill.
- 49:10Again,
- 49:11the murderer at Uvalde,
- 49:13he bought two ARs
- 49:15the day after his 18th birthday,
- 49:17you know,
- 49:17like
- 49:19there's so many
- 49:20things that we can do to prevent this,
- 49:22um,
- 49:23and another bill that didn't pass is like the red flag,
- 49:26um,
- 49:27laws that never passed in Texas,
- 49:28bill targeting local gun,
- 49:30um,
- 49:31and gun-free zones.
- 49:32I live right by the State Fair of Texas.
- 49:34Um,
- 49:34there was a shooting there a couple of years ago.
- 49:36And people attempted to um implement like
- 49:40uh local gun free zones and that didn't pass as well so
- 49:43I mean
- 49:45I think the only thing I can see passing hopefully
- 49:48um
- 49:49is maybe.
- 49:50Raising the legal age,
- 49:52but we saw that in the past with the Uvalde shooting and
- 49:56heavy background checks for those who are mentally ill trying to purchase guns.
- 49:59But
- 50:00again,
- 50:00I,
- 50:01I live in Texas.
- 50:01A lot of people I know own guns.
- 50:03It's super common to
- 50:04own a gun here and
- 50:06I think a lot of us can agree on those background checks.
- 50:10Yeah.
- 50:11No,
- 50:11it's,
- 50:12it's a,
- 50:13it's a terrible.
- 50:15It's a terrible reality and it's,
- 50:17it's probably one of the worst.
- 50:19Features of American identity that we're known for.
- 50:23In my opinion,
- 50:25um.
- 50:27Charlie Kirk kind of infamously said,
- 50:29you know,
- 50:29this is the price we pay for the 2nd Amendment,
- 50:32that we have to accept a certain amount of
- 50:35Gun deaths,
- 50:36um,
- 50:37as the price that
- 50:38we pay for the Second Amendment.
- 50:40And obviously,
- 50:41people have kind of revisited this quote from him
- 50:44in light of his death,
- 50:46and,
- 50:47you know,
- 50:47it's,
- 50:47it's terrible what happened to him.
- 50:49In no way
- 50:51should he be punished for having this opinion and then have to face
- 50:54gun violence,
- 50:54but I'm,
- 50:55I'm curious what,
- 50:56you know,
- 50:57You think of the argument that he made when he said that.
- 51:00I think Charlie Kirk's argument of,
- 51:03you know,
- 51:03having gun deaths being the cost of the Second Amendment,
- 51:07um.
- 51:08I can see
- 51:09where he was coming from on that,
- 51:11but I also believe that
- 51:14there are a ton of measures we can put in place to try to minimize
- 51:18those deaths.
- 51:20It could be again raising the age,
- 51:22heavy background checks,
- 51:23um,
- 51:25I don't know.
- 51:26I mean
- 51:26that that's such a heavy topic to cover and
- 51:29I feel like
- 51:30I can't fully cover that topic,
- 51:33um,
- 51:33yeah,
- 51:33but what I hear coming from you is you're saying,
- 51:35you know.
- 51:37We should have the freedom to bear arms.
- 51:39We don't need to infringe on the Second Amendment,
- 51:43the core idea there.
- 51:44But if we have to put up a lot more,
- 51:46you know,
- 51:46measures to
- 51:48make it harder to access a gun,
- 51:50especially
- 51:51right when you turn 18,
- 51:52and maybe the amount of guns you can have,
- 51:55um,
- 51:55what kind of gun you can have,
- 51:57uh,
- 51:57what,
- 51:58what requirements you need to
- 52:00demonstrate,
- 52:02uh,
- 52:02or,
- 52:02or what kind of
- 52:04credentials you need to acquire to own those.
- 52:07Those are all things we could tinker with just so that we know that.
- 52:11People who use the Second Amendment properly
- 52:14are people who have been vetted to some degree,
- 52:16and people who are risky
- 52:18with mental health disorders or things like that.
- 52:20There's some measure in place to flag that,
- 52:22to identify that,
- 52:23so that those people don't have access.
- 52:24That's kind of what I hear
- 52:26from you.
- 52:27Yeah,
- 52:27100%.
- 52:28There's a ton of prevent
- 52:29preventative measures
- 52:31without
- 52:32impeding on the Second Amendment,
- 52:33right?
- 52:34Well,
- 52:35I appreciate you sharing your perspective and,
- 52:37and Krista,
- 52:38thanks for coming back on to,
- 52:40you know,
- 52:41revisit Surrounded and thank you for just jumping into the arena in the first place.
- 52:46I thought it was very brave and,
- 52:47and awesome to see you go face to face with
- 52:49Potentially a future lawmaker.
- 52:51So good work.
- 52:52For more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 52:54be sure to like,
- 52:55subscribe,
- 52:55leave us a positive review,
- 52:57follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 52:59If you're watching the video version,
- 53:01subscribe to Tubilee.
- 53:03Uh,
- 53:03if you want to see video episodes of Surrounded,
- 53:05subscribe to Jubilee's YouTube channel.
- 53:08Um,
- 53:08thanks for supporting us.
- 53:09Thanks for listening.
- 53:10Remember,
- 53:11you could be wrong,
- 53:12so could I.
- 53:13Keep your mind open until next time.