Latest / The Vegan Report / Do Protests Help or Hurt Animals? With Björn Ólafsson | Ep. 82
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan,
- 0:03and before you attend your next pro animal protest,
- 0:07listen to today's episode on why you could be
- 0:11doing more harm than good, and how to make sure
- 0:14your protest has the impact you want it to have.
- 0:19To discuss this topic, I have with me Bjorn Olofsson,
- 0:23a researcher, science communicator and animal
- 0:26rights advocate who has recently written for
- 0:29Phonalytics, the science of protest and demonstrations.
- 0:34Visit the episode notes to connect with Bjorn.
- 0:38You will also find there a link to the Phonalytics
- 0:41article, which is a must read. For the sake of
- 0:45being a more effective movement, Please share
- 0:48this episode far and wide. This is an important
- 0:53PSA episode on the science behind protesting
- 0:58effectively. We have all of this data, all of
- 1:04those studies, all of those, you know, analysis
- 1:08of what are the best methods to make progress
- 1:14in the pro animal space. and we're not using
- 1:18those resources. They're just ignored and activists
- 1:24seem to be completely indifferent to them. How
- 1:29do you explain that? That's a great question.
- 1:31This is the question that sometimes keeps me
- 1:34up at night, right? It's like, why are people
- 1:37defaulting to strategies that aren't effective
- 1:40or at least aren't proven to be effective? What
- 1:45I come back to Is we tend to use strategies that
- 1:51we think would work on us. So I'm assuming most
- 1:55people listening to this are vegan and or, you
- 1:59know, vegetarian or flexitarian or whatever your
- 2:01diet is or whatever you've done to benefit animals.
- 2:04You likely have thought back in your life about
- 2:07the things that have convinced you to change
- 2:11your lifestyle and change your diet and change
- 2:12your behavior. And then instinctually, you take
- 2:18those ideas and then try to work on other people
- 2:21the same way. This doesn't work for two reasons.
- 2:27Number one, most people are actually really bad
- 2:31at understanding their own motivations. This
- 2:33is just true for everybody. I am as well. And
- 2:37when we try to trace our personal vegan journeys,
- 2:40we probably are going to look at very big salient
- 2:44moments And ignore some of the smaller aspects
- 2:49that have transitioned us. So for example, I'm
- 2:52going to make this up. Imagine you're thinking
- 2:55about watching the documentary Earthlings. And
- 2:57for you, this is huge like this transition to
- 3:00overnight. But then you might not think about
- 3:03the fact that you had a conversation a month
- 3:06before you watched Earthlings with a friend who
- 3:08convinced you to watch it. That conversation
- 3:10might not be part of your journey. Then you might
- 3:13not think about the week after you watched Earthlings,
- 3:16you chatted with a vegan friend who gave you
- 3:18a lot of recipes. That might not be part of your
- 3:20journey. You might not think about your access
- 3:23to vegan foods in a supermarket, even though
- 3:25if you aren't able to find good foods nearby
- 3:28you, you might have been less likely to maintain
- 3:30your diet change. You might not have thought
- 3:34about the fact that friends and family might
- 3:36have reacted differently. If when you told people
- 3:39you're doing this diet change and they were either
- 3:42neutral or supportive of you that helps you maintain
- 3:45it but if you happen to have a social group that
- 3:49was dismissive or rude. That could have turned
- 3:53against you so we think of this big moment like
- 3:56a documentary or or a protest or. a really meaningful
- 4:01Ted talk or whatever it happens to be. And we
- 4:03ignore a lot of these subtler moments that guide
- 4:05us on the way to changing our behavior and changing
- 4:08our lifestyles. And another reason is that motivations
- 4:16we have are often not had by other types of people.
- 4:22So vegans tend to be more open minded. A lot
- 4:26of the times vegans tend to care less about what
- 4:30other people think of them because we are going
- 4:32against the curve, going against the grain a
- 4:33little bit. But for a lot of people, social cohesion
- 4:38fitting into their culture, into their surroundings
- 4:41is very valuable to them. Even if they might
- 4:44not say that on a survey, that is something that
- 4:47guides their motivations and guides their behavior.
- 4:50And we have to reconcile with the fact that a
- 4:52lot of people but we might be different than
- 4:58the people we're talking to psychologically.
- 5:00This is not to say we're better or anything or
- 5:02like we're inherently more valuable. It's just
- 5:04there are differences. And when we think about
- 5:07what worked on us, that's not going to work all
- 5:11the time. So instead of looking back, we need
- 5:14to be looking at evidence, at data. We need to
- 5:17be looking to the future. It's not what has worked
- 5:20on me. That's not the good question. The question
- 5:23is, What methods have been tested and will work
- 5:27on other people to make them change their behavior
- 5:31or change their attitudes? Fascinating. And it
- 5:36resonates with me so much. I've had I was interviewed
- 5:41recently by Veg Network in Canada and they asked,
- 5:46you know, the traditional question, what made
- 5:49you go vegan? And I will, you know, give myself
- 5:52a pat on the back because I said, I don't know.
- 5:55I really don't know. You know, multiple reasons,
- 5:59most likely, but I really don't know. Okay. Why
- 6:05protest? Why, you know, people think about protest
- 6:11as I feel a default way of giving, you know,
- 6:17shape to their activism. Why is this the traditional,
- 6:22you know, default way of thinking about activism?
- 6:26Great question. We often associate activism and
- 6:29protest so frequently that, you know, if you
- 6:32do Google image searches or things like that,
- 6:36and you search activist, you will see a protester,
- 6:39even though I would say the majority of activism
- 6:41is often behind the scenes or in different corridors
- 6:45of power. Lobbying could be activism, a conversation
- 6:48could be activism, anything like that. But we
- 6:51associate protests so much with traditional activism
- 6:54because it just feels right in a way. You know,
- 6:58you're on the streets, you're shouting, you're
- 7:00making a sign. Maybe you're chanting, you're
- 7:03singing, you're having, you're really, it's the
- 7:07most visible type of pro, this most visible type
- 7:09of activism that exists. i would say i think
- 7:12most people would agree on that it is the most
- 7:14visible the most salient it's purposefully in
- 7:19your face designed to make you question things
- 7:21and i think many people when they start activism
- 7:28don't have access to systemic ways of changing
- 7:35power dynamics So if you're trying to be an activist,
- 7:38maybe you're in a university, you're young, you're
- 7:41trying to figure out a career path. Not all not
- 7:44all activists are like this, but a lot are. What
- 7:48are you going to do? Are you going to be able
- 7:50to walk into the CEO's office at Tyson and start
- 7:53talking to them about cage free reforms or talk
- 7:56to a member of Congress or Parliament about shifting
- 7:59your dietary guidelines? No, that just seems
- 8:03impossible to you. What can you do? You can post
- 8:06on social media. That's another avenue or you
- 8:09could stage a protest because these are the options
- 8:11you have available to you when you're young and
- 8:14passionate and I want to be clear. I think this
- 8:17is really good. I think having forms of activism
- 8:20that work regardless of if you've been working
- 8:23in NGOs for 20 years or if you're just starting
- 8:26out and are passionate, that's a good thing.
- 8:30But because protest is so visible and so accessible
- 8:33to younger and more inexperienced activists,
- 8:37it is often associated entirely with activism
- 8:41itself. And what I'm trying to do is some people
- 8:46have interpreted my work as saying that I don't
- 8:50like protest or I think it's ineffective. I think
- 8:54protest needs to be used more critically. I think
- 8:56we need to be thinking. when we use protest,
- 8:59which I think is one of the inherent contradictions
- 9:02here, because protest is so passionate. It's
- 9:05so energetic. It's so over the top sometimes.
- 9:10But passion needs focus if it's going to make
- 9:16long term change. And if you're a young person
- 9:19or any person thinking about protest, there are
- 9:23some ways we could do this. We could be doing
- 9:25this more effectively. I would also add that
- 9:28it is cheap. You know, even doing this podcast,
- 9:32I consider that as activism, but I had to spend
- 9:37money on microphone on recording devices on all
- 9:40of that. So it's not reachable to maybe a younger.
- 9:46pro -animal activists, someone who has a tight
- 9:48budget. But protests are cheap. You just need
- 9:51to walk in the streets with a cardboard. It's
- 9:54accessible to everyone, every wallet. Do you
- 9:59feel that protests are also the default mode
- 10:02of doing activism because they're more left -wing?
- 10:08Because I started thinking what conservative
- 10:13right -wing group is doing protest and I have
- 10:19a few Notable examples in mind, but I don't feel
- 10:24it's common to the culture of more conservative
- 10:28leaning people to go out in the streets and you
- 10:32know to protest but I do feel it is more in the
- 10:37culture of maybe left -leaning people and thinking
- 10:41that most vegans and pro -animal people are left
- 10:45-wing, you would expect them to be more attracted
- 10:52to protesting. So I agree that protest is often
- 10:57more utilized by left -leaning groups, but it
- 11:00definitely is a tactic on the right. A lot of
- 11:02the research I looked at was examining the Tea
- 11:05Party protests in the United States around 2009,
- 11:09which is a right, very conservative organization.
- 11:13if you're not familiar. And we can see protests
- 11:15from right -wing groups in many parts of the
- 11:17world as well. I would agree it's more common
- 11:20on the left. And the reason why is we can think
- 11:24about the actual ideologies of the left and the
- 11:27right. The right is conservative. Let's think
- 11:31about that word. They want to conserve what we
- 11:33have. They value tradition. They value the past.
- 11:36They value history. Maybe it's an imagined past,
- 11:39but it still is the idea of the past. Whereas
- 11:43left leaning progressives value progression.
- 11:46They want to change things and move differently
- 11:49into the future. It's a lot easier to protest
- 11:53for change than to protest for the status quo.
- 11:57I mean, just imagine it. You're going to go out
- 11:58in the street, have a sign that says, you know,
- 12:01let's make this the same as it is right now.
- 12:04Like it doesn't really work rhetorically. You're
- 12:08protesting to not change things. It just doesn't
- 12:12lend itself well to that form of ideology. And
- 12:17then we can think about right -leaning protests
- 12:20that have either been successful or very salient.
- 12:24And those are right -leaning protests that have
- 12:26advocated for change. The Tea Party in the United
- 12:29States, Brexit in the UK, for example, these
- 12:35are types of things that are trying to change
- 12:37and go back as opposed to maintaining the status
- 12:39quo. So that's I think the key difference here,
- 12:44vegans and rights activists, we want change.
- 12:47We don't want the status quo at all. Most left
- 12:50leaning people don't want the status quo. They
- 12:53want some sort of progression socially or economically.
- 12:58And that's where that overlap comes from, because
- 13:01this tactic works better when we're advocating
- 13:04for change. Yeah, I'm also thinking about pro
- 13:08-life protests. which are discussed from an animal
- 13:13rights lens in Beating Hearts, a book I always
- 13:17recommend. You brought up an interesting point
- 13:23about how it is passionate and how your work
- 13:29has been interpreted as being against protest.
- 13:34Well, it is much more nuanced than that if you
- 13:37go and read you know what you wrote, you see
- 13:40that no, it's not a definite no against protests.
- 13:47But I'm afraid that not all people will understand
- 13:53the nuances of that. So my first recommendation
- 13:57after reading the analysis would be for an activist
- 14:01would be avoid protests. And if you have to protest,
- 14:06you know, read this analysis or think about it
- 14:09really carefully. But this should not be the
- 14:12default mode for your activism. Do you agree
- 14:16with that advice? I would say we should never
- 14:21have a default mode of activism. I would say
- 14:25we need to think about what is our goal. And
- 14:30then choose a series of tactics and interventions
- 14:34and strategies that are most likely to get us
- 14:36to that goal. Sometimes protest is one of them.
- 14:40Sometimes it's not. So that's really the question
- 14:43we're at here. If you're trying to do something
- 14:47that's good for the animals, what are the three
- 14:49steps along the way that is going to get us there?
- 14:53And maybe it's protest. Maybe not. Okay. Let
- 14:57me submit the scenario to you. I've watched a
- 15:03video years ago of vegans, pro -animal activists
- 15:09entering a barbecue restaurant and you had people,
- 15:15you know, eating peacefully, having fun, families
- 15:18and so on and then entered the angry pro -animal
- 15:24vegans who started screaming and shouting and,
- 15:28you know, pouring blood on their clothes and
- 15:31all of that. And when you looked at the faces
- 15:36of the people eating at that restaurant, you
- 15:40could see how upset they were. And I feel like
- 15:43that is the image of the vegan activists. That's
- 15:49what people think about every time you tell them
- 15:53Hey, I'm a vegan activist or I'm an animal rights
- 15:56advocate or something like that. They see that
- 16:00that protester entering that restaurant and screaming
- 16:03and the militant vegan. Yes. So what's up with
- 16:09that? Is it productive to to do that kind of
- 16:14protest? And why has that image been stuck with
- 16:20us since forever? Great question. And I think
- 16:24you're 100 % correct that that is often an image
- 16:28associated with vegans. Same with throwing blood
- 16:30on fur coats or being really annoying at family
- 16:34gatherings, things like that. We have to realize...
- 16:42Let me say this. That is true. Protest is the
- 16:45most unpopular tactic available for animal rights.
- 16:50In polling, it's always the most unpopular people
- 16:54have negative stereotypes about vegans often
- 16:57associated with these protests. And i want to
- 17:00make it clear that this is not inherent to the
- 17:03vegan movement or to the animal rights movement
- 17:05stereotyping angry protesters goes back centuries
- 17:11and every social movement has to deal with this
- 17:14in a. In their own way like we can think about
- 17:17climate protesters throwing soup on paintings
- 17:20which are very common images that are we can
- 17:23see on our social media feeds even to this day.
- 17:26We can think about women's suffrage we can think
- 17:28about gay rights. We can think about how black
- 17:33lives matter protesters are often the stereotype
- 17:35is being very violent this is not unique to us
- 17:38this is something that is inherent within social
- 17:40movements. But. This is a problem we need to
- 17:44take very seriously. So this is what's often
- 17:49called the backlash or the backfire effect. Protests
- 17:53make people who watch them angry. This is true
- 17:57of most types of protests, especially disruptive
- 17:59protest, which I think would fit into the, which
- 18:03your example fits into. I, in that scenario,
- 18:12I don't think that's an effective form of protest
- 18:15because protest doesn't make people who watch
- 18:18it change their diet. It just doesn't. I wish
- 18:23this weren't the case, but it just is. In fact,
- 18:26in one study, which was done by one of my colleagues,
- 18:28Andrea, she found that people who watched protests
- 18:33a week later actually ate more meat than people
- 18:35who didn't watch a protest or who saw images
- 18:39of a protest in the study. So that's not great,
- 18:45is it? We actually might be making people eat
- 18:47more meat because they might be so irritated
- 18:50by these protesters and associate them with veganism
- 18:53that we're actually harming the cause. However.
- 18:58I would incur if you wanted to go into a barbecue
- 19:00restaurant and associate the eating of meat with
- 19:04violence or murder or blood or all of this aggressive
- 19:07imagery. Maybe we can think about a different
- 19:12goal that we could use protest for. If we can't
- 19:16convince people to vote, if we can't convince
- 19:18people to change their diets, what else could
- 19:21we make them do or convince them to do? Maybe
- 19:25there's a ballot measure in the state that would
- 19:28benefit animals and you could convince people
- 19:30to vote for that. That's one scenario. Maybe
- 19:34there is a corporation that has egregious animal
- 19:39welfare violations and you're trying to convince
- 19:42people to boycott that corporation. That's another
- 19:44possibility. Maybe you're trying to convince
- 19:48a politician or a corporation to change one of
- 19:51their policies and you're going to protest outside
- 19:54of the parliament building or the corporate office
- 19:56or something like that. That's another possibility.
- 20:02So no one is going to go vegan right after seeing
- 20:07a protest. But they might do other things. And
- 20:11this is where I think we can be a bit more critical
- 20:13and tactful with the way that we're using protest.
- 20:17In the scenario I used, I described a type of
- 20:22protest called disruptive protest. You talked
- 20:26about other social movements, you talked about
- 20:28the suffragettes. I thought right away about
- 20:32that event of that woman, you know, going to
- 20:36the horse racing thing and dying, you know, from
- 20:40being trampled by horses in the presence of the
- 20:44king. Quite an incredible historic moment that
- 20:50truly, you know, I think sent a message to all
- 20:54social movements that being disruptive can make
- 20:59a true impact, can really, you know, uh, give
- 21:03attention and wins to, uh, your social movement,
- 21:08but is it also the case for the pro animal movement?
- 21:12Should we think about protests? You know, should
- 21:15we think about investing our time in a disruptive
- 21:19protest or in more like peaceful? Um, I guess,
- 21:25uh, not reclusive, but like, um, Non -disruptive
- 21:32protest. I wish there was a better, sexier word
- 21:38for it, but it's just non -disruptive protest.
- 21:42Yeah, this is a great question. The type of protest
- 21:44here that we're dealing with. So let's talk about
- 21:47disruptive protest. Disruptive protest is when
- 21:51we are disrupting the lives of people around
- 21:53us. This can involve blocking traffic, it could
- 21:56involve going into restaurants like you described,
- 22:00basically causing some sort of public nuisance
- 22:03that people around you have to deal with in their
- 22:06lives. Nearly always creates some form of backlash.
- 22:15People, you know, don't want to have their lives
- 22:17disrupted. That's a normal human response. Some
- 22:20research from the social change lab shows that
- 22:22this backlash subsides over the period of several
- 22:26months. They had a study come out, I believe
- 22:28it was last year, maybe 2023, that showed that
- 22:31this had subsided after the grand national protests.
- 22:36So that's a good thing that this is not inherently
- 22:40sticky form of backlash. But we also have to
- 22:44remember what I was talking about earlier that
- 22:45we have these negative stereotypes of vegans
- 22:47and animal rights activists that are inherently
- 22:49tied to protest. And that's not going to go away
- 22:51anytime soon. So does this mean we should never
- 22:54use disruptive protest? I would say no. What
- 22:58I'm excited about is something known as the radical
- 23:05flank effect, which is basically a social social
- 23:09change terminology for making the so essentially
- 23:15if you have two groups one of which is extremely
- 23:20radical and the other of which is extremely moderate
- 23:22the existence of the radical group makes you
- 23:26more likely to support the moderate group so
- 23:29there's other phrases for this we can call this
- 23:31good cop bad cop we some people call this a shifting
- 23:35the overton window things like that where When
- 23:39you have something very negative, it makes you
- 23:41want to support the more positive thing because
- 23:43you're getting away from that negative, radical,
- 23:45crazy stuff. Let's give an example of what this
- 23:51would look like. Let's say you're trying to get
- 23:56McDonald's to... Let's not use a specific example.
- 24:02Let's say you're trying to get a corporation
- 24:03to remove... meat that was raised in station
- 24:08crates for pigs and you have this really aggressive
- 24:13protest you walk into a bunch of the restaurants
- 24:16and. You put blood on the walls i like your example
- 24:20you have pictures of pigs that are suffering
- 24:23you get really in people's faces. And then a
- 24:27week or two later a more moderate group has a
- 24:30little social media campaign and they're much
- 24:32more approachable. They're much more conversational
- 24:36they say hey like we just want to talk about
- 24:37this like you know i don't i don't agree with
- 24:39what they're doing i don't think we should put
- 24:40blood on people's floors like that's that's too
- 24:42far but you know gestation creates a real issue.
- 24:47We should be taking this seriously i'd love to
- 24:50have a conversation with the the supply team
- 24:53manager for your corporation about seeing what
- 24:55we could do to make the animal welfare a little
- 24:58bit better by removing these gestation creates.
- 25:01Then. Ideally, that corporate manager would be
- 25:06more willing to have that conversation and to
- 25:09make that change. That's just one example. We
- 25:13can do the same thing for politicians, for everyday
- 25:15citizens, et cetera, et cetera. So that's where
- 25:22I think disruptive protests can get really exciting.
- 25:26Instead of just being disruptive, being disruptive
- 25:28doesn't help animals by itself. But if we use
- 25:35disruption as a way to signal for better change
- 25:39that we could be doing right now, in which other
- 25:42groups can kind of take up the, you know, we
- 25:44pass the baton to these other groups, then I
- 25:47think we're using strategy a little better. And
- 25:50this is going to require some coordination. We
- 25:54need to be working together, coordinating together,
- 25:58to make sure that these moderate flank, radical
- 26:00flank effects are being used correctly. Importantly
- 26:03it should not be the same organization the same
- 26:05organization should not be being the modern and
- 26:07the radical arm because then we're going to be
- 26:11that it's harder to get the conversation to come
- 26:13across so. We need to be talking to each other.
- 26:19You know what role does each group play are you
- 26:23the radical militants who are going to make people.
- 26:27go towards the more moderates or are you going
- 26:29to be the ones to sit down and have those conversations
- 26:31with the with the stakeholders? Yeah, that's
- 26:36an issue. Internal coordination and having internal
- 26:42conversations. What about you being offensive?
- 26:49And we mentioned, you know, the blood. I would
- 26:53just, you know, label that as offensive, maybe
- 26:57nudity. We've seen that many times with, you
- 27:00know, protests, mostly against dairy. Images
- 27:06display of slaughterhouse images, such as, you
- 27:09know, through the cube of truth. What is the
- 27:13impact of that? So any form of I think there's
- 27:20two, there's two questions at play here. One
- 27:22is lewd imagery, so things like nudity or basically
- 27:29anything that people or families might not want
- 27:32to see in public for certain people. The second
- 27:35is graphic imagery, which is images of slaughterhouses,
- 27:40of animals under duress or blood, sometimes even
- 27:46animal bodies, for example, in National Animal
- 27:49Rights Day, that are displayed, although in that
- 27:52case, it's rather empathetically displayed to
- 27:54the public. So when we're talking about perhaps
- 27:59lewd imagery, again, that's just an aspect of
- 28:01disruption, I would say we're trying to cause
- 28:05a ruckus and make people feel a little bit uncomfortable.
- 28:10I haven't found any research about the effectiveness
- 28:12of any of this. My gut instinct would be that
- 28:16it falls into the same category of regular disruptive
- 28:18protest. And I do know many scholars and activists
- 28:21have criticized a lot of these protests for being
- 28:25perhaps accidentally or sometimes even purposely
- 28:27misogynistic or just just just not the just not
- 28:35the vein we're trying to approach here where
- 28:38we're basically objectifying human bodies instead
- 28:45of subjectifying animals. So I kind of agree
- 28:50with that criticism, frankly. I think maybe there
- 28:52is a place for that, for lewd imagery. I just,
- 28:58I haven't seen it been done very well in the
- 28:59animal movement very often. Then the second question
- 29:02is graphic imagery. I actually have an upcoming
- 29:05resource that will delve into the idea of graphic
- 29:09imagery a little bit more. But graphic imagery,
- 29:13when we see an animal in pain, it creates something
- 29:17that psychologists call moral shock. Where we
- 29:22essentially freeze for a second and we feel if
- 29:26we are not prepared to see this. It just kind
- 29:29of makes you so defensive and you're in shock.
- 29:32And I think we can relate to this as vegans,
- 29:35even if think of the first time you saw some
- 29:37horrific imagery of an animal suffering. And
- 29:41imagine, you know, if you saw if you just were
- 29:43walking on the street and you saw a dog, you
- 29:46know, hit by a car, it would give you a horrific
- 29:50feeling inside. And a lot of the time, this moral
- 29:55shock. doesn't cause people to take positive
- 29:57action afterwards because it kind of shuts down
- 30:01your agency instead of opening it up. So if we're
- 30:05going to use graphic imagery, we need to be really
- 30:08careful. It should not be overdone. We shouldn't
- 30:12be hitting people over the heads with it. It
- 30:14should be contextualized. We should basically
- 30:18guide people to understand what they're seeing
- 30:21and what could be done about this, right? There
- 30:24has to be hope. There has to be optimism added
- 30:27to this horrible, disgusting, horrific thing
- 30:31that we're seeing. Otherwise, it's not going
- 30:33to make us want to do anything. So if you just
- 30:37have a poster board of a pig in pain, and that's
- 30:41the only thing that you're showing people, that's
- 30:44not going to make people want to change their
- 30:46behaviors. But if instead you use this imagery
- 30:49strategically, guide them in a conversation,
- 30:53Or in a in a in a documentary or a talk or something
- 30:57and then you add in a really well crafted message
- 31:02that helps them understand where their act where
- 31:05their behaviors fit into this cruelty then they're
- 31:08more likely to make a change. So again we can
- 31:15use graphic imagery but. We have to be strategic
- 31:18about this. We can't just go around showing this
- 31:21horrible stuff willy -nilly That's not going
- 31:23to just magically make people turn vegan or make
- 31:26other pro animal decisions. I Think we should
- 31:30address a point related to related to that You
- 31:37advise people at the end of the Article you published
- 31:41to track the effectiveness of their activism.
- 31:48And I feel like this is something we're used
- 31:51to now. Um, everyone in the corporate world,
- 31:54you know, if you have a office job, every time
- 31:57you launch a project or something, there's always
- 32:00a phase of, you know, collecting feedback and
- 32:05a postmortem of your project and what happened
- 32:09and what can we learn about, you know, what we
- 32:12did and, um, And so why haven't we brought that
- 32:17good habit to activism? Many research organizations,
- 32:40there's so many out there, phonetics, brain research,
- 32:43animal ask, and a metrics that are helping people
- 32:46with big picture data, but also sometimes helping
- 32:48them with specific projects of tracking their
- 32:50own work. I do this myself as a freelance researcher.
- 32:54So you can always reach out to me as well. I
- 32:58think this gets back to what we were talking
- 33:00about earlier about why people haven't been tracking
- 33:02it is because when A lot of times when you're
- 33:07a young activist or a new activist, you're driven
- 33:10by passion and intuition and instinct. And those
- 33:13are great things. Those are great things, but
- 33:15you need to harness them correctly. And if we're
- 33:18not going to be learning from our past, if we're
- 33:20not going to be looking at our mistakes and successes
- 33:24and thinking and tweaking and like, what can
- 33:27we do a little bit better next time to convince
- 33:29one more person or to make a little bit more
- 33:31change or to to shift the percentage points just
- 33:33a little bit more. then we're not being the best
- 33:36activists that we can be. Again, this is changing
- 33:41and I'm really happy to see this is changing.
- 33:44A couple years ago, I would have conversations
- 33:46with people and I would have to convince them
- 33:48why data was important. I'm having a lot fewer
- 33:52conversations like that now. People know data
- 33:55is important. Now the conversation is what is
- 33:57the data and how can I use it? And that's a better
- 34:01conversation to me because now people are open
- 34:02-minded and they're excited and they want to
- 34:05make this a little bit better. So for me, this
- 34:08is a turning point. The idea that we are adopting
- 34:12this idea of monitoring evaluation and learning.
- 34:15We're adopting this idea of impact tracking.
- 34:18And for some people, this seems so corporate,
- 34:20right? We have KPIs and we have dashboards and
- 34:22spreadsheets and everything. But without looking
- 34:27to the past and looking inward on what has been
- 34:30working and what hasn't been working. We're not
- 34:33going to be able to make our strategies better
- 34:34in the future. So I'm really happy to see this
- 34:37this shift. So we discussed disruptive versus
- 34:42non disruptive. Now let's talk about the motivation
- 34:46part and the goal of the protest. So we mentioned
- 34:51protests to convince people to go vegan. And
- 34:57then there are the protests that would push for
- 35:02change, political change, corporate change. If
- 35:07I'm an activist and looking at the most impactful
- 35:12way to invest my time and mobilize my friend
- 35:17group or something like that, what should I choose?
- 35:22Which lane? The political lane? um the the corporate
- 35:27lane um uh or uh trying to convince people to
- 35:32go vegan um this is a great question and this
- 35:35is in some ways the question right of like what
- 35:39what can we do what should we be doing how can
- 35:42we optimize our work the most i i might not have
- 35:45an answer that you like unfortunately i don't
- 35:48think in my opinion this actually isn't the right
- 35:50question i don't think If you're an activist,
- 35:54you shouldn't be thinking to yourself, what is
- 35:56the best way we can do activism? Because we need
- 36:02every type of activism working together in a
- 36:06string. They need to be working as a unit. For
- 36:11example, we need documentaries to change the
- 36:18media landscape. We need articles to get people
- 36:20to think about animal issues when they're reading
- 36:23the news. We also need protest to put pressure
- 36:26on key decision makers and lobbyists. We need
- 36:30to be working with corporations. We need to be
- 36:32working with politicians. We need to be doing
- 36:33everything. I meant in terms of protest, if I
- 36:40want to organize a protest, what kind of thing
- 36:45should I protest against? Oh, okay. I understand.
- 36:49I understand your question more now. OK, I would
- 36:52say. So. Number one, don't don't do a protest
- 36:58to convince the people watching the protest to
- 37:00go vegan. It's not going to work. So that's in
- 37:04my opinion, that's pretty definitively off the
- 37:06table. Number two. What? I would look into where
- 37:13you are. and think about what issues are within
- 37:17reach for us, right? Is there a bill that's going
- 37:22to be on the docket this year or next year or
- 37:23something like that? Maybe you can use protests
- 37:26to work on that. Are there corporate campaigns
- 37:30that are happening nearby you that you could
- 37:33perhaps work with or coordinate with to get those
- 37:36corporate campaigns to be a bit more successful?
- 37:40You need to be thinking about the issues that
- 37:44you can kind of push over the finish line and
- 37:46to pressure people to take seriously. It's gonna
- 37:53depend on where you are. It's gonna depend on
- 37:56the language, the culture, physically where you
- 37:59are. And I don't think there's one specific solution
- 38:02all the time. Let me think, is there anything
- 38:06else I would advise? And this comes back to who
- 38:11else are you coordinating with? Because that's,
- 38:14I think, a key issue in activism that isn't being
- 38:15talked about enough. If you protest, if you're
- 38:19on a campus, let's say, and you're trying to
- 38:21convince your university to stop doing animal
- 38:24testing, what is the next step after the protest,
- 38:31right? Protest is good at getting media. It's
- 38:35good at getting eyeballs. It's good at getting
- 38:36clicks online, but then that's not going to be
- 38:41meaningful if there isn't somebody you're going
- 38:43to pass the baton to. Maybe it's you who talks
- 38:46to the Dean and tries to convince them to do
- 38:48this. Maybe it's a different group. Maybe you're
- 38:51going to be working with the university network
- 38:53across your country. So that's I think the key.
- 38:58Right where where does the protest fit into this
- 39:02larger. Systems chain systems changing network.
- 39:09Right. If you're not working with others the
- 39:14the the protest energy is just gonna fade that's
- 39:18kind of one of the unfortunate realities passion
- 39:21does fade energy does fade. I'm sure if you're
- 39:28listening to this and you're the most passionate
- 39:29person ever, I believe you that you're going
- 39:32to be passionate. But at some point it will fade
- 39:34for other people around you who are watching.
- 39:36There has to be a next step. And I think that's
- 39:42going to be where the real impact is going to
- 39:44come from. You mentioned in the paper that you
- 39:48should be in for the long haul. You mentioned
- 39:52coordinating with maybe another organization
- 39:55or something like that. There is something called
- 39:59argument from authority and it is based on this
- 40:04perception that we have of people with credentials,
- 40:11institutions that have a long history and are
- 40:15well established. But if I look at animal rights
- 40:20organizations out there, not all organizations
- 40:24are equal. And if I look at the way they organize
- 40:29activism, they're not all based on data, on what
- 40:34we know to be effective. And so how do we choose
- 40:38to which organization we give our time and what
- 40:45organization we should coordinate with? This
- 40:49is a tricky one, because I completely agree that
- 40:51a lot of organizations are more impactful than
- 40:54others. And a lot of organizations take data
- 40:57and research more seriously than others. I know
- 41:00this firsthand. I can tell you that firsthand.
- 41:04However, if you're working locally, because protest
- 41:07is usually a local tactic most of the time. Right
- 41:13you're working within your community sometimes
- 41:15we have national protest that is absolutely true
- 41:17and those are the ones that tend to dominate
- 41:18the headlines but the majority of protests are
- 41:21relatively small and local. There are hundreds
- 41:25of protests every single year and a lot of countries
- 41:27even for animal issues but most of them are going
- 41:29to make the news. So because protest is usually
- 41:33used locally you're going to you're almost constrained
- 41:35by the local organizations that you have maybe
- 41:38the national organizations so if you're. a protester
- 41:43trying to think of which groups to coordinate
- 41:45with, I would find the ones that are close to
- 41:49you and then maybe work with them to use data
- 41:53and impact and strategy more critically. If you're
- 41:58thinking about Organizations to donate to to
- 42:03maximize your impact there's a lot of charity
- 42:06evaluators out there animal charity evaluators
- 42:08is the most famous for animal nonprofits but
- 42:12that's more on a global scale locally. We need
- 42:16to be thinking about who can i work with who
- 42:19agrees with my vision who is my theory of change
- 42:22and how can we coordinate to be different parts
- 42:26of that theory of change together. A lot of this
- 42:28is just going to come out of community building
- 42:30and networking and working together. That's something
- 42:33I'm working on here in myself. I live in Barcelona,
- 42:37Spain, and I'm working with a lot of the groups
- 42:40here, and they don't always share my opinions
- 42:43about the best ways forward. But we can agree
- 42:48on the goals that we're working towards, and
- 42:50we can agree that sometimes we might take up
- 42:52different roles within the same movement. I obviously
- 42:57am more research oriented. I'm kind of more of
- 43:00the quote unquote, like professional type of
- 43:01activist, but I still work with the more radical
- 43:05activisty types of activists, even if it's not
- 43:09the method I personally would use. So I think
- 43:12collaboration is worth it more times than not,
- 43:17even if you don't agree on the way the other
- 43:19organization is approaching things. I want to
- 43:22ask you, what did you make of effective altruism?
- 43:27I like effective altruism. I consider myself
- 43:30an effective altruist. I specialize in effective
- 43:33animal advocacy within EA. EA has gone definitely
- 43:41a bit of a bad rep, I think, the last couple
- 43:43of years, a lot of which I think it deserves.
- 43:46But one thing I really admire is they are willing
- 43:50to tackle these issues and think about impact
- 43:52and think about how we can maximize the positive
- 43:56change that we're doing into the world. And I
- 43:58really like that they take animal issues very
- 44:00seriously. Most EA people, even if they're not
- 44:04vegan, I've never met an EA person who's basically
- 44:09said animal welfare isn't worthy of consideration,
- 44:12or that animals aren't worthy of moral weight.
- 44:15Maybe they exist, but I haven't met them. And
- 44:18even if they're not purposely working on them
- 44:20they agree that this is something we should be
- 44:21taking seriously and i can't see the same for
- 44:24a lot of other social change movements. So to
- 44:29me that's definitely a win. And you know i obviously
- 44:36there are criticisms of the movement it can get
- 44:38a bit too. Theoretical to the point where the
- 44:43actual practical advocacy might be. not as exciting
- 44:47to some people, they like thinking about the
- 44:48theory of activism more than the practical activism.
- 44:51This is a criticism that you could levy at me
- 44:54myself. I spend way more time thinking about
- 44:56strategy as opposed to being on the streets doing
- 44:59activism, although I do that as well, but to
- 45:01a lesser degree. So I think. Again, if you're
- 45:09an animal activist and you don't agree with everything
- 45:11EA says, that's totally fair. But I think you
- 45:15should take seriously the potential of collaboration
- 45:18with EA folks I would reach out to an EA group
- 45:21near you and see if you could work together on
- 45:24some things I'm sure there are vegans and animal
- 45:27rights activists within that group That would
- 45:30love to have a conversation with you about the
- 45:31most way the best way to have impact for animals
- 45:34so to me, that's exciting the fact that they
- 45:37take animal welfare seriously is Very optimistic.
- 45:43It makes me feel very optimistic. And I like
- 45:46that. One last thing about protests. And that's
- 45:53kind of a weird question. Is it also impacting
- 45:57animals? When I think about big protests, there's
- 46:03a lot of noise. And I feel like, you know, is
- 46:08it in a way creating distress in the local Fona.
- 46:17What do you make of that? Very interesting question.
- 46:20I have to admit, I haven't really thought about
- 46:22this that much. If we're looking at a large protest
- 46:28with chanting and people ringing bells and making
- 46:33lots of noise, I agree that probably does have
- 46:35some disruption on local animals, whether they
- 46:39be companion animals or city wildlife like pigeons
- 46:43or rats or things like that. I'm sure it probably
- 46:47has some negative effect on them. But remember,
- 46:52most protests aren't very large and they're usually
- 46:54pretty localized. So I don't think it's likely
- 46:57that they would have any sort of negative effect.
- 47:00And perhaps a counter -argument might be that
- 47:03protests that shut down Highways or roads would
- 47:08also reduce the amount of cars, which create
- 47:10a lot of noise and disruption and pollution and
- 47:13things like that, even if it's temporary. So
- 47:16perhaps those large protests kind of even out
- 47:19in the way that they harm animals. That's my
- 47:22guess. I haven't really found a study on this
- 47:25specifically, but I think it's a really interesting
- 47:27question to consider. And that's actually a good
- 47:29point. And if you're doing a protest, think about
- 47:31the local animals and how they might be affected.
- 47:34I do think most protests tend to happen in cities
- 47:37where we're looking at city wildlife as opposed
- 47:40to rural wildlife and they tend to be more accustomed
- 47:43to human activity. So I would imagine it'd be
- 47:47not a huge concern, but you know, we're animal
- 47:50advocates. We have to, we have to take this stuff
- 47:52seriously. Do you have in mind an organization
- 47:56that we can look up to and who effectively utilize
- 48:01protests? I feel like it's always good to have
- 48:05a model to look up to and practical examples
- 48:09and maybe a champion of protest you can think
- 48:14about. First of all, I would caution and say
- 48:19we can look at protest examples from big groups,
- 48:23but we should always be a little bit cautious
- 48:26because protest often works best locally and
- 48:29regionally. And a lot of these groups often will
- 48:33have a decentralized network where they have
- 48:35local leaders within a city. Maybe they have
- 48:38like a continent wide organization, but then
- 48:40local leaders. And this is really important to
- 48:44keep in mind that because protest is often very
- 48:47local, looking at large global groups can only
- 48:50take us so far. OK, so with that said, I think
- 48:54a couple that stand out to me are direct action
- 48:56everywhere. I would look at, you know, extinction
- 49:01rebellion, animal rising. I would look at We
- 49:04the Free as examples of groups that are doing
- 49:07this with a lot of tactic and a lot of thought
- 49:10behind what they're doing. But if you are wanting
- 49:16to get involved in protest strategically, you
- 49:20can join one of these groups. You can join a
- 49:23decentralized local version of this group. or
- 49:27you can make your own group, or you could make
- 49:31a group to coordinate with an existing organization
- 49:34nearby, like what we're talking about with the
- 49:37radical flank effect. So the bottom line, if
- 49:41you want to take protests seriously, you need
- 49:44to be thinking about how does this fit into the
- 49:47larger theory of change for positive impact for
- 49:50animals? Passion is great. Excitement is great.
- 49:55Attention is great, but it's not enough. You
- 49:59need to be getting that passion and then turning
- 50:03that into positive change. That's going to take
- 50:07a vision towards the future. You can't be looking
- 50:10at next week. You have to be looking five, 10,
- 50:1350 years down the line. How can I make good change
- 50:16for animals? And that's what we have to take
- 50:20seriously. I love that. Be a visionary. And yeah,
- 50:26have also a fun protest, you know, I think that's
- 50:32important. Protests can be joyful. It can be
- 50:34joyful. I think, you know, I think of the queer
- 50:37rights movement in many parts of the world. Pride
- 50:40is a protest and it's joyful a lot of the times.
- 50:45And I think we can take that seriously as well.
- 50:48It doesn't always have to be doom and gloom,
- 50:50you know. Yeah, and use it to socialize, meet
- 50:53other vegans and also enjoy the summer. I think
- 50:59summer is the season of protests. So yeah. Bjorn,
- 51:07would you like to add something before we end
- 51:11the recording? I would say regardless of what
- 51:14you are doing for animals, you need to be thinking
- 51:17critically about your impact at all times. If
- 51:21you ever want to think about the strategy more,
- 51:24you can reach out to me. You can go to my website,
- 51:28bjornjohann .com, B -J -R -N -J -O -H -A -N -N
- 51:31.com, or go to my sub stack, which is called
- 51:35More Than Meets the Eye, MEAT spelled M -E -A
- 51:38-T -S, because I love a good meat pun. Um, there
- 51:41are lots of other researchers out there too,
- 51:43who are doing, who are tackling really good questions.
- 51:46You could look at the phonetics website. I mentioned
- 51:49a bunch of them, phonetics, Bryant research,
- 51:51animal ask, animal think tank, animatrix, um,
- 51:55animal charity evaluators is doing some, I mean,
- 51:57there's too many groups that I can think of off
- 51:59the top of my head. The bottom line, you need
- 52:04to think about strategy and there's people there
- 52:08who can help you. A lot of whom can help you
- 52:10for either not much money or completely free.
- 52:13So I really encourage you to think about that.
- 52:17Amazing, great parting words. Thank you so much,
- 52:20Bjorn, for your work. Thank you so much for having
- 52:24accepted my invitation to the Fijian Report and
- 52:27having answered my questions. Thank you, everyone,
- 52:30for listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 52:33podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 52:36more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 52:40so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 52:43for a new episode.