Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP315: Scaling Smart - How To Make Better Technology Choices for Ecommerce Growth, With Lauren Muir
Transcript
- 0:00Vast majority of failures I've seen with new systems,
- 0:03platforms, migrations haven't actually been the tool's fault.
- 0:06It's been the fact that people haven't bought into it.
- 0:08The training hasn't been done properly, there's been no
- 0:10processes, the proper due diligence wasn't done.
- 0:12The tech most of the time is OK. I don't have any problems that I
- 0:14go do you know what? You're right, your search tool
- 0:16is awful most of the time. Actually your team aren't using
- 0:19it properly. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:22weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:25experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:28Geddon Paul Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:30leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:32leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:35improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:40Shopify and other exciting topic this week we're talking about
- 0:44we're looking into like tech and digital maturity and knowing
- 0:47when to buy versus build, making sensible tech decisions that are
- 0:50aligned with your brand maturity and growth plans.
- 0:53So there's my really rambling title to the podcast that
- 0:56clearly hasn't been put through ChatGPT and really happy to to
- 1:01welcome someone who I've long admired, who puts out a lot of
- 1:04really smart content and is recognised as yeah, strong E com
- 1:09leader, who's ex head of E com for O Polly and is now a
- 1:12strategic consultant. I can't even say strategic this
- 1:15morning. Laura, good.
- 1:16Good morning. Good.
- 1:17Morning. Thank you for that.
- 1:20Yeah, I've really enjoyed, I've really enjoyed like watching
- 1:22your your like reading your content on LinkedIn.
- 1:25You put a lot of interesting stuff and I know you're working
- 1:27with some interesting projects now.
- 1:28So do you want to give people who don't know you a bit of
- 1:31instruction to you, your E com journey and what you're now
- 1:34focused on? Yeah, I can do.
- 1:37I have been in the kind of digital space in general for
- 1:41about six to seven years now. Started while I was at uni.
- 1:44I started doing some freelance and agency side work and paid
- 1:49social, paid search, e-mail, CRM, that kind of side of
- 1:52things. And then just slowly crept my
- 1:54way into like, oh, can I take on see SEO and can I do web content
- 1:58and like how, what, what can I take on?
- 2:00So I did that for a couple of years and then COVID hit and I
- 2:04like graduated in nice forms with absolutely no graduation
- 2:09and started at O Poly full time as soon as I finished uni.
- 2:12So worked agency said in in freelance before that and then
- 2:15went full time with O Poly. It was my first kind of major
- 2:18full time role doing the same kind of thing, digital paid,
- 2:23SEOCRM, all that kind of fun stuff.
- 2:26I owned the Boon T brand, which was a new brand at the time,
- 2:28which was really great because it was COVID and everyone wanted
- 2:31to buy leggings and stuff. And it was it was an active for
- 2:33a brand. So it was really fun and fast
- 2:35growing and learned a lot. And thankfully it was on Shopify
- 2:39or probably at the same was on actually doing a migration
- 2:42between M1 and M2, which was meaty.
- 2:45And we launched bone tea on Shopify and just went, Oh my
- 2:49God, this is like this is the way to go.
- 2:51So within a couple of months, I've been on M2I then got
- 2:54involved with all Poly migrating onto Shopify.
- 2:56And that was kind of my first fully into E com doing third
- 3:00party app integrations and on boardings and things like that.
- 3:02And then it just slowly went from there.
- 3:05I started to migrate from digital over to full E com
- 3:08projects, third parties, migration tree platforms, all
- 3:11that kind of stuff was what I liked.
- 3:13And then in mid 20/22, 3:00-ish years ago, we formalized it in a
- 3:17proper digital product owner. Also I took ownership of all the
- 3:20kind of Rd. maps, anything that was upcoming, any technical kind
- 3:24of changes with to make all of our web development and all of
- 3:28that for a couple of years. And then last year, can I just
- 3:32pre Black Friday 2024, I was asked to kind of head up the
- 3:35ECOM function as well and take over what was already an
- 3:38existing ECOM team and bring that into our encompassing kind
- 3:43of all-encompassing group of people who look after everything
- 3:45front end. So rather than having tech
- 3:47setting separately to ECOM and stuff, we just pulled it all
- 3:49together and had like operational ECOM, merchant
- 3:53trading and optimization, everything all sitting under one
- 3:55umbrella. So that was how I spent the last
- 3:57year and then since October, I've been doing some consulting
- 4:02stuff with brands and SAS partners and agencies and
- 4:06basically using my experience and what I've learned to be
- 4:09like, how do we win and the Shopify ecosystem, What do you
- 4:13need to do? Who do you need to work with?
- 4:16How do you, how do we approach things and how we work with
- 4:18Shopify? Never can I change your models
- 4:20within. So taking yeah, 6-6 or seven
- 4:23years of kind of this, you know, and a lot of change and a lot of
- 4:26growth and stuff to try and help maybe brands that are weirdo.
- 4:29Poly was when I first joined. Can I probably watch do Poly go
- 4:32from like 30 million ish to like 100 and 2000 and 3000 and 40
- 4:37million? And I loved that stage of growth
- 4:40that kind of earlier, like they can get a little bit like can I
- 4:47always changing and fast bro stage was like my favorite part.
- 4:51So I'm enjoying now going back and speaking to Branchwood at
- 4:54that stage and being like, here's here's what we did or
- 4:57here's what we didn't do. So yeah, that's been my last
- 4:59kind of month or two and it's really enjoyable.
- 5:02Nice, I love it because they're not not many people say I just
- 5:05love the re platforming because so many people find it really
- 5:08because it we know right. If you've been through it and
- 5:10I've been through it so many times on so many different
- 5:12platforms now that it's not stress free, it's not problem
- 5:16free. There are always unknown
- 5:18unknowns that hit you. There's always a cost that
- 5:21creeps up that was unforeseen where you have to dip into.
- 5:23There's all these dynamics that, but I think if you have the
- 5:27right sick, twisted mentality, then actually it's a really
- 5:30enjoyable process to go through. It's it's fun at the end when
- 5:33you go, Oh my goodness, thank God I don't need to do that
- 5:36thing anymore that I really need to.
- 5:37Exactly. Well, As for me, though, the
- 5:39only problem is now you've joined me in consultancy world
- 5:41is is when your clients say yes, you go, yes, we've done that.
- 5:45When you're a consultant who does this day in, day out, you
- 5:48go. Yeah.
- 5:48Oh, I've got the next one. Another one.
- 5:51It's like it's like, oh, OK, I'll sleep, I'll sleep in
- 5:54January. It's OK.
- 5:56But I'm really glad you, you join us today because it's
- 5:59really important. I think having having people
- 6:02who've been through growth, who've been through technology
- 6:05decisions, who've learned from mistakes, learned from
- 6:08successes, who can give objective advice because no one
- 6:12knows everything. You know, there's no perfect
- 6:14tech stack for every business and there's nuance in decision
- 6:17making. And that's what we want to get
- 6:18into today. So, and I, I, I think you, you
- 6:22probably came into the industry at a very different point to me
- 6:25when I came in a long time ago as old man of e-commerce,
- 6:28because out in the day when you didn't have modern SAS platform
- 6:32and, and so much was custom built.
- 6:34And Christ to, to see the, to see the, the drop in pain
- 6:38threshold of migrations. And it's still not simple.
- 6:42But you know, just just certain elements in tech, in tech stacks
- 6:46that are just just work now is quite incredible actually.
- 6:50So let's, let's get into the first question.
- 6:53So a big one I think that people struggle with is about when they
- 6:59should invest in tech and what type of tech and how the size of
- 7:02business impacts this because you could have a fast growth
- 7:06business that is really not complex and a fast growth
- 7:09business that is complex. So from your experience, having
- 7:12gone through this journey, you said from 30 million to like 120
- 7:15+ 1,000,000 at O Poly, How does the level of econ maturity and
- 7:19your like existing team size and skills impact tech static
- 7:22decisions? I think it does massively.
- 7:25I've seen O Poly massively different stages like I've been
- 7:29in tech teams of like just me and kind of two IT guys handling
- 7:34everything from like hardware breaking and people spilling
- 7:37coffee on their laptops to Wi-Fi cabling connectivity and
- 7:42everything to like migrations and re platforms like and and
- 7:46front end development work between, you know, me and a
- 7:48couple of IT guys. We a couple of years ago when I
- 7:52first joined the tech team, you know, there would have been like
- 7:54two of us, three of us at the time.
- 7:56And I actually got to a point where we, we had our consultant,
- 8:01long-suffering consultant who's worked with us for years.
- 8:03And at one point it was just me and him and I was like, Andy,
- 8:05you can take all the back end stuff.
- 8:07That's what you do. I'll do the front end because it
- 8:09was the only way to split it because there was not enough of
- 8:11us to, you know, have people properly sitting with defined
- 8:15remits and stuff for what they were looking after.
- 8:17So I've seen us be like that. And in that case, when you're
- 8:20one person looking after something so huge and something
- 8:22which is obviously, no, not at a small scale, you don't really
- 8:26have the time to do everything in depth.
- 8:28And you do need sometimes just the speed and agility and ease
- 8:31of like, I can download an app to do that for me and I don't
- 8:34need to do it myself, which is fantastic.
- 8:37Like, I think when we were definitely that scrappier stage,
- 8:40we needed speed, we needed simplicity, we needed QuickTime
- 8:44to value. We relied a lot on SAS partners.
- 8:47And I would be very open and honest with them and, and
- 8:49discussions and say, I don't have the time to hand hold you
- 8:52during this process or to sit and not through this thing.
- 8:55Like it's my child. I need you to do it like, and if
- 8:59you want to and, and flex your muscles a little bit, I'd be
- 9:01like, if you want to work with opoly and you want this contract
- 9:03that you're going to need to, I need decent customer support.
- 9:06I need someone who's going to come in and be proactive in
- 9:08helping me because I'm one person and I don't have enough
- 9:11time. And that was kind of my work day
- 9:13for years. But now the tech team will Poly
- 9:16are, you know, it's much more built out.
- 9:18It's a much larger, stronger team.
- 9:21We've got ACTO, we've got engineers.
- 9:22And I say, I keep saying we, they have got engineers and BAS
- 9:28and PMS and all these people who can properly like, you know, sit
- 9:31and make these complex decisions.
- 9:32And also people with very different backgrounds, like
- 9:35people who have worked at really large complex businesses before
- 9:38who haven't came from the Shopify ecosystem.
- 9:40So it's quite good to have people, I'll be like, just
- 9:43download an app. We've done that so easily a
- 9:44couple of years ago. Just download an app and then
- 9:46someone else will be like, no, we don't need to do that.
- 9:48And actually, when you've got that kind of breadth of
- 9:52experience and decision making, you do sit and think about it a
- 9:55little bit more. And you, when you've got the
- 9:57time to afford to be able to do that, like to say to someone,
- 10:00which we didn't have a couple of years ago, can you sit and spend
- 10:03a couple of days or even a week this week just proper analysing
- 10:06and getting into this decision and thinking about all the
- 10:08possible options and engaging with suppliers and blah, blah.
- 10:12Lord, in 3-4 years ago didn't have that time And it was, I
- 10:14need this, I need it yesterday, get it done right.
- 10:17OK, I've downloaded an app, I've tested it.
- 10:19It's cool. It's live like, and it's totally
- 10:21different when you're at that different stage of maturity.
- 10:23And I think if I told like my, you know, the CTO, oh, probably
- 10:27that I was going to do that now, he would be like, what, what are
- 10:29you doing? Like, so it's massively
- 10:32different. But I think the key thing for
- 10:34all Polly that I've seen is a benefit of them.
- 10:36They've grown out that tech team.
- 10:38They we didn't, and we definitely tried not to adopt
- 10:41enterprise tech before we needed it.
- 10:43Because I think if me and, you know, a couple of years ago,
- 10:45being one of the only people in that tech team had started to
- 10:48adopt enterprise tech before I needed it, it would have been,
- 10:51you know, a bit of a disaster. We wouldn't have been mature
- 10:53enough to do it would have been nowhere near ready.
- 10:56Whereas no, the team are and they've got people who can sit
- 10:58and project manage things and stuff like that and make those
- 11:01kind of more complex decisions at the time when it, you know,
- 11:04when, when it was just me, it was get it done, get it done
- 11:07quickly. It's so easy.
- 11:09And now you know, they're a little bit, they're a bit more
- 11:12mature and they don't need to do things as scrappily as as we did
- 11:15them a couple of years ago. What do Mattel, Victoria
- 11:19Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 11:24They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 11:28Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 11:31the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 11:35converting check out on the planet Shopify Powering the
- 11:40future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 11:43shopify.com/enterprise. Yeah.
- 11:46Do you know what it was? It was Paul who first introduced
- 11:48me to the word scrappy. And I'd kind of like it because
- 11:53at first I thought that actually, so that makes it sound
- 11:56like it's not controlled and it's not smart, but actually
- 11:58it's not. It's more about the style in
- 12:01which you adopt things. And it because it's, it's
- 12:04tactical on the strategic, right.
- 12:06And I think this, this is, this is the thing I see as well as
- 12:09let's say the example product discovery search, merch
- 12:12recommendations, etcetera. At an early stage the thought of
- 12:17a big license is probably budget prohibitive where implementation
- 12:22not having the expertise to think about how that is properly
- 12:25integrated probably needs somebody with good engineering
- 12:29skills from an API point of view to connect that intelligently so
- 12:32that it doesn't have a massive performance impact on the front
- 12:35end that the data flows are correct and to others.
- 12:37And you suddenly realise, like you said, BAPMS, whatever it is,
- 12:41you need more resource and you need to think about the future
- 12:44adoption of the product road map because you can't do all at
- 12:47once. And if you all these other
- 12:49decisions, whereas you know what, I'm going to use pick shop
- 12:53if I pick big commerce, but whoever it is, OK, I'll use the
- 12:56native search because it does 50% and it's free.
- 12:59Great. I'll plug in a simple
- 13:02merchandising tool that helps me manage the product grid and I've
- 13:05already got more than I've got now and I can do that for a few
- 13:081000 lbs plus a couple of £100 a month.
- 13:11Job done. Exactly.
- 13:14Yeah, it's really interesting because I think sometimes the
- 13:17there's the I want, I want the optimal decision slows people
- 13:20down from going to, you know what, having it, having it
- 13:23better than I've got it now for a low cost is good enough for
- 13:26the next 12 months. 100% And I think if you get yourself really
- 13:30tied down on what the best possible scenario is and then
- 13:34this is exactly what I need and this is all of my requirements
- 13:37all came true all at once. And you know like like 90% any
- 13:41chance it's never going to happen.
- 13:42But also, I would say anything, you don't need it at that point
- 13:46in time. You really don't.
- 13:47And you're never going to like someone.
- 13:49And, and I get really wary of sales people as well.
- 13:51That someone could come in and absolutely promise you the world
- 13:54and promise you a dream. And when you are that slightly
- 13:56more immature brand and you're just like me, I was, I was like,
- 13:59I need these SAS partners to come in and help me.
- 14:01And that time we really, really did.
- 14:03But I do worry that some people might be slightly taken
- 14:06advantage of by a salesperson coming in and promising them a
- 14:09dream and promising them I will solve all of your problems
- 14:11instantly. Right?
- 14:12You know, you get like 2 months and you go, wait a minute, like
- 14:16this is really hard and this requires loads of management and
- 14:19I don't have all these things that I wanted and they're like,
- 14:21oh, that's six months down the road map or that's a
- 14:23professional service. And you start to go, Oh my God,
- 14:26you know, I've not actually that this isn't what I thought it was
- 14:28going to be. And that worries me a little
- 14:30bit. And we definitely got I, I would
- 14:32say we probably got stung by that a few times.
- 14:36And it does take like I, I remember even in this past year,
- 14:40I would go into calls with vendors and stuff like that.
- 14:42And I'd like, can I have ABA commit the call with me?
- 14:44Like can I have someone come in with me just to have a couple of
- 14:46heads to put together? It'd be like, is this 100% what
- 14:50we need to have we done the due diligence properly?
- 14:52Have we gathered requirements and have we challenged them
- 14:55correctly and asked the right questions?
- 14:56And do we get clarity on AB and C?
- 14:59Couple of years ago, I didn't have the skill set or the
- 15:02resource or anything to do that. And I did have to be a bit more
- 15:04trusting and a bit more scrappy. And that now I would go back and
- 15:09really strongly say to people that I, I speak to people all
- 15:11the time who are like, we want to move tools.
- 15:13I want, I hate our search and merch tool.
- 15:15It's awful. And I need to change and I want
- 15:18a new one. And I'm like, right, OK, let's
- 15:21sit and think about this first because you're going to go into
- 15:23these sales calls and be lied to.
- 15:25And I really don't want that to happen to you.
- 15:28And also you are at this stage of growth and you've got one
- 15:31person in your team and this person's going to come in and
- 15:34tell you that this huge, amazing, beautiful enterprise
- 15:36piece of technology can do the job for you.
- 15:38And it can, it needs more people to manage it.
- 15:41And I think some people get this perception of like, oh, well,
- 15:44I'll pay for the technology and if the technology's better, then
- 15:46it'll do a better job. When in actual fact, the vast
- 15:49majority of failures I've seen with new systems, we platforms,
- 15:53migrations haven't actually been the tool's fault.
- 15:55It's been the fact that the people haven't bought into it.
- 15:58The training hasn't been done properly.
- 15:59There's been no processes. The proper due diligence wasn't
- 16:02done. The tech most of the time is OK.
- 16:04I don't ever receive any problems that I go, do you know
- 16:06what? You're right.
- 16:07Your search tool is awful. Like most of the time I'm like,
- 16:10actually, your, your team aren't using it properly or you've,
- 16:13you've bought something like an I mean, we've done it as well.
- 16:16We we used Algolia and we didn't have time to give, you know,
- 16:21multiple people to sit and tune Algolia properly and sit and
- 16:25work on the back end and sit and do rules and fed back to Algolia
- 16:29as well. The AB testing process is
- 16:31laborious and really difficult and we wanted to be fast and
- 16:35agile and quick to doing things. We didn't have the people
- 16:38resource to sit and it was an incredible tool and we'd done
- 16:40everything we needed to do, but we didn't have the thing to give
- 16:42it. So sometimes I worry that people
- 16:44get into a off. I just buy this huge, fantastic
- 16:46piece of technology that gives me everything I want.
- 16:49It'll be like a magic wand. And I'm like, no, you're going
- 16:51to have to give you know what your one team members resource
- 16:54for three months to get this right like, and that's hard.
- 16:57That's the hard bit to try and explain to people, not the the
- 17:00the technology really it's the it's the people in the process.
- 17:03Yeah. I think that's such a critical
- 17:04point is, is if you haven't done your homework about what are the
- 17:09use cases that are driving the need to adopt tech and then
- 17:14explored how you would execute on those and what is what is
- 17:18tech versus what is process and resource to set things up and
- 17:22manage things. That is the critical point.
- 17:24And, and I've I've seen this too many times as well, where the
- 17:27issue is capability, process time, whatever it is, it's
- 17:32internal and, or it's lack of understanding what impacts
- 17:38successful outcomes through algorithms on search.
- 17:41And I've, I've had, I've had people for pick your tool,
- 17:43Algolia Claver, which is now Athos search for any tool that's
- 17:47that's got really good capability.
- 17:48And someone's saying tool's rubbish, the quality of search
- 17:51results are rubbish. And then actually the issue is
- 17:53the quality of the product data and the content you'll feed in
- 17:56there and the fact that you haven't fine-tuned and tweaked
- 18:00algorithms and business rules and controls.
- 18:02So yes, you're, you're giving it crap to surface in the results
- 18:05and that's why you have comprises.
- 18:07Actually, if you trained it better and gave it better
- 18:10quality data, the the tool can do it because all of them can do
- 18:13like relevancy matches, multi attribute searches to different
- 18:17degrees. So yeah, I think that's such an
- 18:18important point to make. Yeah, I think so.
- 18:22But coming back to your point, you said about about it the that
- 18:26that kind of like working agile, adding apps, moving quickly
- 18:30rather than thinking about like, you know, that investment
- 18:31enterprise tech in the early stages.
- 18:33One of the things I see is a there's a challenge here because
- 18:37in the, the app stores and Shopify is the leader with the
- 18:40volume of apps, but Centre's building as App Store, big
- 18:43commerce has got a significant App Store.
- 18:45I mean, all the Madabi's got apps in different ways.
- 18:49It's it's quite easy now because the data integration is, is
- 18:53mainly done to go right. OK, I use that for loyalty, I
- 18:55use that referrals. I use that for search for, for
- 18:58image optimal, whatever it might be.
- 19:01And that can lead to sticking something in because it's quick
- 19:04and easy without necessarily getting it right.
- 19:07And there can be side effects that what how do you advise
- 19:10people that? How do you go about selecting
- 19:13apps because there are so many? I think it's a tough one.
- 19:18I would say I like going out, like I like research and I like
- 19:22going out to market. I like speaking to people like
- 19:24and saying what do you use? Like I, I want to go out and,
- 19:27and get a real understanding of what's new and what's out there.
- 19:29But once you actually start speaking, I get demos of things
- 19:33all the time. I just message people and be
- 19:35like, I like what you do. Can I get a demo?
- 19:36I want to see it and I want to challenge you and I want to ask
- 19:38questions, which is why they can assess.
- 19:40Advisory stuff is appealing so much to me because I've
- 19:42basically done it through my full job at old Bali.
- 19:44I am. I think once you actually get
- 19:47into the nitty gritty, the questions that I asked every
- 19:49single time were about mainly performance.
- 19:51I was very front end focused. I thought about the website, I
- 19:54thought about how the website operated and looked and I wanted
- 19:59the customer experience when they landed on our website to be
- 20:01fantastic as well as the operated experience on the back
- 20:04end to be fantastic. But performance impact on the
- 20:08website is the is the customer experience.
- 20:11My work day was do not add more bells and whistles.
- 20:14And I think, I think if an app is functional, it's differently
- 20:16if an app delivers a functional requirement that you need to run
- 20:19your website, it's different. But if an app is like something
- 20:22nice and fancy, like a, you know, on, on your website, on
- 20:24your front end, it's one of the sexier bits, but it's going to
- 20:28lose, but you know, lower the speed of your website by two
- 20:31seconds. There's no point.
- 20:33No one's going to see it because they're going to bounce off your
- 20:35website instantly because it takes so long to load.
- 20:37I think when I started working on Opoly, I basically moaned my
- 20:41way into doing a bit of SEO because I was doing paid and I
- 20:44was spending a lot of money sending traffic to the website
- 20:48and average load speed to the PLP was like 13 seconds.
- 20:51And I was like, right. And then, you know, we're
- 20:53getting asked internally, this brand are doing this thing and
- 20:56someone else is doing this. And I saw this new piece of
- 20:58technology and this app that you can do that, like allows you to
- 21:00flip the grid and do it. And I'd be like, what's what's
- 21:04the point? While the, while it takes 12
- 21:05seconds to load, no one's going to see it.
- 21:07Like no one's going to get there.
- 21:09Like let's sort the basics first and not add anything until I
- 21:13have absolutely scrutinized these people and said, can you
- 21:15confirm to me it won't add anything to, to the load speed
- 21:18for our website. And we'd put it on stage and
- 21:20stuff and check and be really, really rigorous about that.
- 21:22Because to me that is number one, there is no point in
- 21:25putting something on the website.
- 21:27We, we did remember with a chatbot that was on the website
- 21:30and we, when we analysed the kind of load speed and what was
- 21:33impacting load speed, it was having a much larger impact than
- 21:36Shopify itself. And we think it was adding
- 21:38something like 3 to 3 1/2 seconds to the load speed of the
- 21:40website and you know, lighthouse scores and stuff because it was
- 21:43so large. And I'm like, that is something
- 21:45for me. Usually when things are
- 21:47optimized for Shopify and optimized for e-commerce and
- 21:50things they do tell you they've done as much as they can to not
- 21:52impact your website, but you really need to drill down into
- 21:55that because it's the biggest one.
- 21:57I think the next one for me would be overlap and just doing
- 22:00some sort of analysis or good of like, what does this tool
- 22:03deliver versus what we already have?
- 22:05People get really caught up on, Oh, this, there's this new piece
- 22:09of technology. I'm going to download this app
- 22:10and I'll be like, it does AB test and we've got something
- 22:13that does AB test and or it does personalisation.
- 22:16This would allow you to personalize a user's website
- 22:18experience. Cool.
- 22:19So does native meta fields. Do we need it?
- 22:22Like, and that's the thing because you get really excited
- 22:25by these bells and whistles and fancy, fancy things and then you
- 22:28go actually for drill down into it may add a second or two.
- 22:30It loads be to the website and there's something else that
- 22:32already does it. Yeah, that shiny thing is really
- 22:35cool, but do we need it? No.
- 22:37And then probably data. We had a lot of different tools
- 22:41obviously that we needed over the years.
- 22:43And I would say probably because we matured faster than Shopify
- 22:47grew its native solutions for things.
- 22:50So we had to buy in things that Shopify weren't offering is and
- 22:53and that the enterprise kind of tools and stuff we had weren't
- 22:55doing. So we had to build that.
- 22:57But it's really annoying when those apps don't speak to each
- 23:00other most of the time in the Shopify ecosystem.
- 23:02I'm going, oh, it's native shopifying integrates with
- 23:05Shopify really nicely. Does it integrate with
- 23:07everything else like and if it's an app, how complex is the kind
- 23:12of analytics in the back end structure of the app?
- 23:14Can we sync it into Snowflake and put it in our data warehouse
- 23:18and use that data? Or does it require manual CSV
- 23:21exports, which realistically everyone's really busy and no
- 23:24one's going to sit and remember every day to download the CSV of
- 23:27that day's data from that app. Like so do you end up with
- 23:30really good intelligent data and these apps that do really cool
- 23:33things, but it all sits in individual Shopify stores and
- 23:36individual apps and not really doing anything for you.
- 23:39So that is kind of how selective I am.
- 23:41I think performance on the front end and customer experience,
- 23:45user experience in the back end as it's law as it clunky.
- 23:48I don't want my team to be sitting doing things that are
- 23:51bored and monotonous. I want it to be as automated as
- 23:54possible. I want to make sure there's no
- 23:57overlap with other tools. But if someone comes to me from
- 23:59finance and says, oh, you're spending X amount of money on
- 24:01technology, but some of that may would not be needed if I just
- 24:06start adding, adding, you know, and not actually thinking, Oh, I
- 24:09know that we've got this or I know that Shopify does this.
- 24:11I can get rid of that thing we're paying a couple of grand a
- 24:13month for. So that was a continually every
- 24:15couple of months going through making sure there was no
- 24:17overlap. And if someone did want to buy
- 24:19in something, you need to make sure it's it stands alone, does
- 24:23it's got a really strong benefit.
- 24:25Data flows in and out of it nicely.
- 24:27It's a really cool app. And that's the kind of process I
- 24:29would go through in my head before buying anything.
- 24:32And that's even less something as simple as an app, obviously,
- 24:35if you're buying something that's a proper like like on
- 24:37board and I go layer a nostal, a balloon, reach anything like
- 24:41that. It's a it's a mass process, but
- 24:42you need to go through. But even just an app I would
- 24:45There's questions you have to ask yourself or you're going to
- 24:47end up with a massively bloated app ecosystem and a list of 40
- 24:51apps on your Shopify store that half people won't even know what
- 24:55they're doing. Yeah.
- 24:56And I, I think that I mean the performance bit's critical and
- 24:59the, I mean the essential side of installing things on
- 25:01sandboxes and properly validating what impact it has
- 25:05on. Does it create any glitches from
- 25:06a UX on the front end as it slows stuff down?
- 25:09The the bit that I think that that people don't spend enough
- 25:13time on is the how will we use it?
- 25:16And does it give us what we want?
- 25:17Because it's you, you will have this all the time.
- 25:20People go, we've got an app for that, you know, right.
- 25:22So you got, you got a Shopify app or a big commerce app.
- 25:25You got an app. It integrates natively, right?
- 25:27And we, it can do everything we want.
- 25:28Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then when you tease it
- 25:30apart, it's an exceptionally basic app and it doesn't do all
- 25:34of the functions that the platform natively can do in the,
- 25:38in your as in like the third party system can do within the
- 25:41specific E com platform that it's built an app for.
- 25:43Because it built an app just to tick the box and go I'm in the
- 25:45App Store and then you have all these gaps.
- 25:47So you go right. So we're going to have to do
- 25:49some custom API work or we can't actually do that.
- 25:51We can't feasibly make that work because it's going to be cost
- 25:54prohibitive or it's going to screw up page load.
- 25:57And then then you start realizing that that getting an
- 25:59app is easy getting the right one is challenging.
- 26:02Yeah, 100%. Let's talk about the build.
- 26:07Build versus buy, which is one of the the kind of like rambling
- 26:10bits in my topic when I introduced it is because coming
- 26:13back to your point before the you getting an extra tech is
- 26:20sometimes a really sensible thing to do and it gives you
- 26:22fast tracks capability, but it might not necessarily be the
- 26:25most cost effective way. How do you go about deciding
- 26:29when you should build? So either use an existing
- 26:34capability but extended it and build them on top of it.
- 26:37You mentioned meta fields and ShopRite example and every
- 26:39platform has got its custom fields that you could build out
- 26:41and then use those data endpoints to do things on the
- 26:44front end. When does custom build make
- 26:47sense and what what have you got some examples where you run?
- 26:49Do you know what we don't need about third party tech?
- 26:51We just need to extend what we've currently got or build on
- 26:54top of it. Yeah, I think it depends how
- 26:58complex the solution is for me or how complex the problem is
- 27:01that you're trying to find the solution for.
- 27:03So if it's something to meet something that's small, I'm
- 27:08like, think at first, if it's something that you know, is
- 27:12going to be quite a large undertaking, a complex problem,
- 27:15you're going to do an extra level of due diligence anyway.
- 27:19So for example, a PIM we knew a couple of years ago, well, like
- 27:23product data isn't a bit of a mess.
- 27:25And if we need to grow and you know, we see all these things
- 27:28found in the future with like digital product passports and
- 27:30things like that, where we know that product data is going to
- 27:33have to be a lot cleaner and in a lot of better kind of
- 27:35situation. Our product data lived in like
- 27:39air cable boards and exhale spreadsheets and things like
- 27:41that. And it was, it did.
- 27:43We knew it needed an overhaul. We went to market and selected a
- 27:47market leader PIM. And we went, Yep, 100%.
- 27:50We will get this PIM. They will sort everything for
- 27:52us. It will be so easy.
- 27:53They work with so many cool clients.
- 27:55Like 100%, that's fine. But we didn't actually go deep
- 28:00enough on the due diligence to know and go, oh, before we
- 28:02onboard this, we've got a massive data cleanse exercise to
- 28:05do. We need to properly map out all
- 28:09of our systems, all of our processes, all of our data,
- 28:12where it goes, where it lives, who is responsible for what,
- 28:15where the data comes from, what the what the requirements of the
- 28:18data within our different systems are.
- 28:20We had none of that. We just thought we'd be able to
- 28:22get a PIM and we'll give them an export of all of our products
- 28:25and then they can take it and we'll just run everything
- 28:27through that. And probably quite naively
- 28:28thought it would be easy and after doing the proper due
- 28:32diligence really going through data like we realized an off the
- 28:36shelf solution wasn't going to work for us.
- 28:38And we had so many individual niche requirements and processes
- 28:41because all Poly is very vertically integrated.
- 28:43We'll own our own factories. Everything is completely like
- 28:46custom designed and produced in house and we have quite a niche
- 28:51product flow from a from an idea on a Trello board somewhere all
- 28:55the way through all these different floors that it goes
- 28:57through. And it just the off the shelf
- 28:59solutions just didn't fit. And we made a decision to custom
- 29:01build a PIM on air table, but with our own engineers and stuff
- 29:05and build it out fully from ideation stage all the way
- 29:10through factories, merchandise and buy in placing corporate in
- 29:14E com everything. We'd fully built it to suit the
- 29:17exact floors that we worked on as a business already, but made
- 29:20them better. And we knew, we know that, you
- 29:23know, there was absolutely no way that we could have done that
- 29:25sort of the PIM that we were just going to try and buy in and
- 29:27then try and mould ourselves to. That would have been a much more
- 29:30painful process. I think trying to make our data
- 29:33fit that system and make our processes and our teams buy into
- 29:36that system and go, oh, we need you to stop doing what you're
- 29:39doing now. Change it all completely.
- 29:41Change the format and everything of all of your full job.
- 29:44Put it in this new system. You're going to be doing it at
- 29:46different times, different. Everything would have changed,
- 29:49and what we've done instead is, OK, here's what you currently do
- 29:52that's been working for years, but we're going to make it
- 29:55better and we're going to put some more data controls on it,
- 29:57make it a bit more tightly controlled.
- 29:59We're going to automate boring things and automate HTS codes
- 30:02and all that kind of stuff and the things that can go wrong.
- 30:04And we're going to test from this pattern to every one of our
- 30:07systems, to our warehouse management system, to Shopify,
- 30:10to our next week, to everything like that.
- 30:12It's going to be fully tested. We're going to take out the
- 30:14human error and make it really like fantastic.
- 30:18To be honest, it was, it was incredible.
- 30:19Once it went live, we would never have got that level of buy
- 30:23and I think from the teams and engagement and understanding and
- 30:26everything if we just went here's our off the shelf
- 30:29solution that you need to know move yourself to because that
- 30:34process underpinned everything that we did as a business.
- 30:37And also we built it on air table, which is a system that
- 30:40underpinned everything that we did as a business as well.
- 30:42Air table was used across marketing, across production
- 30:46plan and everything, every part of our business touched their
- 30:48table. So we then used a system that
- 30:50the team already knew and used a fantastic team of engineers and
- 30:54BAS and PMS to create a PIM system that really worked for
- 30:58people. And that I think take taking
- 31:02people on the journey with you. But it really helped because I
- 31:05think if we had tried to get an AI can a standard off the shelf
- 31:10PIM solution, we'd probably still be here now a couple of
- 31:12years later talking about it and not actually getting it done.
- 31:15Whereas we'd we'd fully done that ourselves.
- 31:18And we made it super niche to eyes, completely shaped it in a
- 31:21way that a custom build is all that would have, you know, would
- 31:24have been able to do. Yeah, it's, it's interesting.
- 31:27I've done there's been a few projects I've been recently
- 31:29where building something custom rather than using a third party
- 31:33has been the right way to go forward At AC I worked with who
- 31:37did it for in pet food around based on it's like a, a like
- 31:44almost like a quiz based of what age of pet, what type of pet,
- 31:47how active it is, how much food does it need basically based on
- 31:51the weight of it. And that was built in super base
- 31:54from the database point of view. So don't try and don't try and
- 31:58like bend a third party product selector to do the configures to
- 32:05do the journey is fine. But the complex data
- 32:07calculations just is not natively built to do well.
- 32:10Actually if you've got a fully controllable database where you
- 32:12can programmatically handle that and that's got a really good API
- 32:17connectivity with your ecom platform, the speed of that is
- 32:19actually far quicker. And then for it's easier to
- 32:23maintain because you've got database input tables and when
- 32:26that date input changes, you just change the variable again.
- 32:30You can store that. It was built on Shopify.
- 32:32You can store that as custom metadata in Shopify.
- 32:36Business can just update that. It's not a technical solution.
- 32:39They can go in and change the value from X to Y.
- 32:41That automatically feeds through to the database to automatically
- 32:44change the. So yeah, there are times when
- 32:46you arrive then then go in custom, provided that you have
- 32:50the engineers who understand what they're doing.
- 32:54Yeah, I think so. And I think if for the
- 32:58non-technical, like Pete of some, I don't come from a
- 33:01technical current development background.
- 33:02I've worked in technology now for a couple of years, but
- 33:05there's always used to being the non-technical person in the room
- 33:07or the least technical person in the room.
- 33:10Shopify when like I said, I worked on Shopify with bone tea
- 33:15straight away as soon as I joined do Polly and then we
- 33:17might get to do Polly over. Part of the reason we did that
- 33:20was because it democratized so much of that requirement for
- 33:25engineers and stuff like that. So for for the less involved
- 33:28stuff, the stuff where you don't need an engineer or you don't
- 33:32think you need an engineer, you probably still do.
- 33:33But someone somewhere and a technical ish role and A and a
- 33:38product role or whatever can can do a lot on Shopify that I think
- 33:43you probably can't do on other platforms.
- 33:44I think Shopify has increased the ease of access into data and
- 33:48into apps. And like for me, I was able to
- 33:52do stuff, deploy stuff, get stuff out much faster than you
- 33:57know, using things like Shopify apps.
- 33:59But even using Shopify natively then I would have been able to
- 34:02do if everything was a custom built tech stack.
- 34:04That is amazing if it's controlled and if it is someone
- 34:07not to blow my own trumpet, it definitely didn't need to be me.
- 34:11But someone in a product role who owns that and looks after it
- 34:14and can go like can understand what apps are being used and
- 34:18what data there is and what custom meta fields and stuff
- 34:20we've got and all that. Because if you don't and if you
- 34:22open that access completely, then we had done, it was amazing
- 34:25for Opoly that we were able to bring in marketing people and
- 34:28customer service people and show them analytics and get them used
- 34:30in the back end of Shopify. But if everyone could download
- 34:33apps and if everyone could create custom data in meta
- 34:36fields and meta objects and stuff, it would have been a mess
- 34:40like, and that is not any criticism to it because the
- 34:42ideas and everything would have been incredible.
- 34:44But it needs to be a little bit controlled because you can just
- 34:47start to build things and things can just start to go a bit.
- 34:50And I like we, we used meta fields, met objects and stuff
- 34:53quite a lot. And particularly this year, we
- 34:55started to migrate things back from like custom fields, apps
- 34:57and stuff into like native shop. I met a field and you can see
- 35:01the excitement and people when you start to go, Oh my God,
- 35:03there's so many possibilities here.
- 35:05There's so many things that we can do and there is there is so
- 35:07much that you can do with it. And I love the fact that people
- 35:09got that. And we're starting to think, oh,
- 35:12I could create a meta field for the restock date of that product
- 35:15and pull that through from this system and then show that on the
- 35:17front end of Baba. And it's so quick time to value
- 35:20to do that. And I could be like, yeah, sure,
- 35:22if I does that for you now, natively, you can do this and
- 35:24you can integrate and we can pull it through the pen and you
- 35:27get really excited, but then something breaks or something
- 35:30changes and all of a sudden these simple things actually
- 35:33become quite complex. So it's trying to find that nice
- 35:36balance of doing things yourself, either through a
- 35:40custom build or through Shopify natively with a bit of
- 35:42configuration. Because with flows and APIs and
- 35:45stuff that you've said, there is a lot, a hell of a lot you can
- 35:47do now with Shopify, but still having a little bit of control
- 35:51over it so that someone doesn't go.
- 35:53What does this matter if you'll do?
- 35:55That's Netfield's phone and Al Golia, but I don't know what it
- 35:57is like. You never want to get to that
- 35:58point where you're like someone's made at random.
- 36:01So we've got random data flowing all over the place.
- 36:03So just because we've democratized it and it's amazing
- 36:06and we want people to be really engaged by it and love it and
- 36:09want, you know, have the ideas and that agility and stuff I
- 36:11think is something that you don't really want to lose as you
- 36:14start to. We don't want to add loads of
- 36:16red tape as we grow because it comes really boring for people,
- 36:19but you need to safeguard things a little bit just so that it
- 36:22isn't really messy. Yeah.
- 36:24And this and This is why I love platforms like Centre as well,
- 36:27because they, they have that concept of a custom fields, they
- 36:31have their equivalent of like a, a rule builder which allows you
- 36:35to create flows and connectivity between data points.
- 36:38And it's, I think the key thing though is you touched on it
- 36:42earlier is about somebody needs to own what you have and have
- 36:45that mapping. And I do on every project I work
- 36:47on with regardless platform is a product like a data management
- 36:52doc which defines all of the meta fields.
- 36:54Like a lot of them are customer facing.
- 36:55They do things on like APDP for example, or APLP, but you also
- 36:59have the systemic ones that are needed.
- 37:02I've got one client where actually they need to batch that
- 37:06in the order files. They need to know what batch
- 37:08products are related to because that has an impact on all the
- 37:10management flows. Therefore, when products
- 37:13created, they need to be assigned to.
- 37:14There's three different types of batches spending on the delivery
- 37:17time like a specialist, two man, etcetera.
- 37:21And that's just one very simple systemic data field that the
- 37:23customer never sees, but it's required for back office
- 37:26systems. And but you've got to you've
- 37:28right, you've got, it's got to be documented.
- 37:30There's got to be a reference point that anyone go to any
- 37:32point. Because if the person, you, me,
- 37:34who was doing it leaves a business or a project, you can't
- 37:38have a data silo and a knowledge silo has to be democratised that
- 37:42in that in knowledge and intelligence as well.
- 37:45Yeah. And even like with your table, I
- 37:49mean I'm used to using job finding your table, but the
- 37:51access requirements and stuff as well.
- 37:54Like at one point we realised when we were starting to look at
- 37:58the PIM requirements, that was the most important thing for us
- 38:00to try and lock down because we went, someone has got full
- 38:04access to this database of all of our product data, could just
- 38:08select and delete it all. And then we realized we were
- 38:13creating these meta fields that were customer facing that would
- 38:15have an impact on the front end or that were flowing into
- 38:17systems like Algolia to power search or into Nosto for
- 38:21merchandising or all these different systems we were using.
- 38:24We were underpinning them and really supporting them and
- 38:26making them much better by using Shopify native functionality.
- 38:29But I'm going someone with that level of Shopify access could
- 38:33just go in and delete that and break it.
- 38:35Or even in fact, there's a really not a bad air table one,
- 38:39but I'd kind of started getting messages from customer service
- 38:41ones like the restock dates that are shown on the front end are
- 38:45all showing dates in the past. How can this be?
- 38:49And I was like, no, we've got a, we've got a solution in place to
- 38:51make sure that if the date has passed, the restock date
- 38:54disappears. And if the product and what's
- 38:55happened. And it just turned out that
- 38:57somewhere back in the air table flow, the formula that was
- 39:01powering the restock date and air table and something had been
- 39:05changed from like China warehouse to China or something.
- 39:08And it had broken a full flow, had broken formulas.
- 39:12And that was pulling through and fantastically sinking
- 39:15automatically from your table and at shop finding displaying
- 39:17automatically on the front end. And then we're getting customers
- 39:20reaching out going that says it's going to be delivered in
- 39:232023 like, and I'm like, you know, in these kind of things.
- 39:26And if I didn't know how we built that and hope that all
- 39:29worked and then someone would have been sitting somewhere like
- 39:33what is going on? So that I think it's, it's
- 39:37fantastic that we have these systems, low code, no code
- 39:39systems, really easy integrated, fantastic and easily accessible
- 39:45custom D and things like that. And to be honest, we'd done our
- 39:47full Shopify store and meta fields and towards then there
- 39:49when I was leaving met objects, we had met objects powered and
- 39:52things especially related to promos and stuff using tags to
- 39:55power mesh and across the site and stuff, which it was
- 39:58fantastically easy for me to go in and manage.
- 40:00And it was amazing to not have to ask a developer to do
- 40:02everything for me. Can you put us something on APDP
- 40:05for this? You know, promo that we're doing
- 40:08all that kind of stuff was it was fantastic.
- 40:10But I, I do think that you can, you can extend, you can add
- 40:18extensibility and add complexity to the platform so easily.
- 40:21Now that is it too easy sometimes.
- 40:25And is there things like sometimes I would say things I'd
- 40:27go, oh, I can do it back. My boss would ask me to do
- 40:29something like, oh, can you put this thing on the PDP?
- 40:32Someone wants this, but it's been a request from whatever
- 40:35team, blah, blah, blah. And I would road map it and all
- 40:38the rest of it. But if it was easy, I'd just go,
- 40:40I can do that for you today if you want.
- 40:42And you know, it kind of defeats the purpose of doing all that
- 40:45analysis and making sure that everything's considered and
- 40:47whatever because it's so easy. I'm like I, I was managed the
- 40:50road map and I had any given time up to maybe two months,
- 40:54three months worth of work on a road map at a time.
- 40:56And we'd constantly cycle it and groom the backlog and all that.
- 40:58But something would come in that was easy and I'd go, Do you want
- 41:01me just to put it live this morning?
- 41:03I know it's we, this is the the whole with great power comes
- 41:07great responsibility. And I think this comes down to
- 41:10governance. And, and I've noticed this in,
- 41:13in, in farce growth, predominantly DTC brands in the
- 41:17SAS space and mainly they're on Shopify is they've come from a
- 41:23non corporate, non governance world.
- 41:25Therefore, and governance is often people go, oh, it's going
- 41:28to ruin, it's going to be horrific.
- 41:29We won't get anything done. And actually, no, governance is
- 41:31about helping you do things smarter and giving you control
- 41:34and governance in a 10 million business, it's very different to
- 41:37governance in a 2 billion, you know, PLC.
- 41:40But I think this is the bit that that that's critical when you're
- 41:43working in this environment where it is easy to plug stuff
- 41:46or make adjustments or add in functionality.
- 41:49Is the governance around maintaining roles and
- 41:51permissions and knowing who can and can't do stuff.
- 41:54And the governance around documentation and the governance
- 41:57around looking at where, how, what is our error tracking?
- 42:00What is our alert system? If something goes wrong, how do
- 42:02we know about it? I, I'm putting this in place,
- 42:04but what if it, what's the impact if it cocks up and how
- 42:07will we know? That's a bit where I think that
- 42:10the maturity often doesn't catch up quick enough.
- 42:13Yeah, and you can end up with a proper Frankenstein as well if
- 42:15you've done that early. Like I've seen we've done a lot
- 42:17of things before Shopify could do them for us.
- 42:20And now like, Oh my goodness, if I could start from scratch and
- 42:24get a clean Shopify build, like I would just love to like use,
- 42:27use Shopify's native functionality as far as I
- 42:30possibly can and keep things really lean and like movable,
- 42:35like see something as like a living, see the site is a living
- 42:38breathing thing rather than something that's like a big
- 42:40decision and lumping loads of technology and stuff on.
- 42:42But I would absolutely love that to be like, here's how we start
- 42:47from scratch and here's a fresh clean build.
- 42:50Here is exactly how we start doing it.
- 42:52And to me that would the, the things that we've built and
- 42:55added and lumped on over the years.
- 42:57You do need someone to be constantly on top foot and
- 42:59monitoring it to try and fix it. But even then, like there's
- 43:01things that I'm like, you can have a road map as long as your
- 43:04arm and there's something that will slip through the cracks.
- 43:07I remember looking like one time and finding random, like a
- 43:12random custom app that we had built somewhere and Shopify to
- 43:15link. Like it was like student
- 43:17discount data or something with Clearview or something crazy
- 43:21like that. And it's sitting in some sitting
- 43:24somewhere in Shopify and you're like, this is what happens.
- 43:27And you just go on and don't think about the bigger picture
- 43:28or don't think about it as a as a one living breathing thing
- 43:32just bought on all these little things.
- 43:33And down the line I was looking at it going where, where is
- 43:36that? What did that even come from?
- 43:37Well, heck, I don't remember even doing that because it was
- 43:40probably four years ago when that was the only way of doing
- 43:43things. And things change so quickly.
- 43:45This world that we run as well. I really struggle with people
- 43:48saying, Oh, what's your three-year road map like?
- 43:51I really struggled with that because I was like, things are
- 43:53changing so fast that I don't want, I don't want it.
- 43:56Three years. Yeah, three years, three years
- 43:58and 10 months or something. I really struggled with working
- 44:01something in for such because I've seen the repercussions of
- 44:04us doing things maybe 3-4 years ago and you lock yourself and
- 44:08you think, oh, I'm getting a great deal, I'm going to lock in
- 44:10a three-year contract. And then couple of years down
- 44:12the line you go that is like that feels almost like legacy
- 44:15tech now because there's and we've done things that we've
- 44:19done a couple of years ago you would never you would never do
- 44:21now. But that's, that's the, the
- 44:23again, the importance of having someone like a product owner who
- 44:26is on the button of what is going on and what is happening
- 44:29and can keep on top of that. She can leave things and let
- 44:31them go stagnant. And there's things that
- 44:34somethings I'd say to the team. If I got a new team member, I'd
- 44:37be like, RIP apart the site, RIP apart Shopify, go in and tell
- 44:41me, ask me what things are. And because you do get a little
- 44:44bit and I think this is a good thing.
- 44:46We're doing the consulting now and you'll the less better than
- 44:48me. I did probably get a little bit
- 44:50stuck in like I knew all polished Shopify like the back
- 44:53of my hand and you miss things and you don't, you know, because
- 44:57you're so you think you've got a handle on absolutely everything.
- 45:00But it's so complex and there's so much stuff that I actually
- 45:03loved it when I got someone new and they would come in and go,
- 45:05what does that app do? What does that mean if you'll
- 45:08do? And I'd be like, do you know
- 45:09what? I need to get rid of that.
- 45:11I need to change that. I need to make that better
- 45:13because it does take someone just refresh set.
- 45:15Yeah, sometimes coming in and just look over what you're doing
- 45:17and go, why have you built that that way?
- 45:20But not no single person can ever know everything, get
- 45:23everything right and remember every decision they've ever made
- 45:27and and anyone who says they can is just quite frankly bullshit
- 45:30in you. So it's.
- 45:31Probably dangerous if they do, because then if he.
- 45:34And also, I think as a consultant, the most important
- 45:36thing is to accept that there are people in the room that
- 45:39might be more genie to you who know better than you in some
- 45:42other areas. And that's brilliant because if
- 45:44if every single person, every stakeholder can contribute
- 45:48decisions and inputs to a project, that has to be welcomed
- 45:53because the aim is to make better decisions.
- 45:55And yeah, you're right. But This is why that I come back
- 45:57to governance. And Paul, I laugh about this a
- 45:59lot because I know I'm the dole. I'm the dole man talking about
- 46:02it, but it's and you touched about earlier about the BASPMS
- 46:05and the role they play and how important they are.
- 46:07It's fundamentally somebody as a business scales and becomes more
- 46:10mature and goes from your 30 minutes to 120 minutes plus
- 46:14whatever that scale of growth is.
- 46:16Documentation has to be maintained.
- 46:18Systems documentation, which is the bit that's often ignored
- 46:21them the next time you go to revalue someone goes what's our
- 46:23systems architecture mapping? I don't know, let's draw one
- 46:27that's ability to go right. We we've added another third
- 46:29party and update the map and update the data flow so that we
- 46:33know what it's doing and then you can identify whether there's
- 46:36a potential duplication or an issue.
- 46:38But that's the bit that has to be done regularly.
- 46:42Yeah. And I think it's probably the
- 46:45value of a consultant is written we've, we've valued, you know,
- 46:49benefited massively from this over the years of someone coming
- 46:52in and knowing what stage the business is AT and understanding
- 46:55the culture of the business enough to know how to handle
- 46:58that. Like I know that, you know, now,
- 47:01like I say, the Opoly Tech team, for example, has grown massively
- 47:05and they're really got this fantastic architecture of a team
- 47:08there, an amazing set up and really knowledgeable people and
- 47:11stuff. It is now as a consultant, I
- 47:15think what we would need to do is go in and understand that and
- 47:17know that they've like the O polytech team now versus four
- 47:21years ago. A consultant would have to come
- 47:22in and act completely differently and know that the
- 47:25decision making and the capacity and the process and the people
- 47:28and stuff are going to be completely different.
- 47:30Because right now I'm speaking to some brands that are a
- 47:32compatible size to O Poly and I'm speaking to some brands that
- 47:35are a tiny portion of the size of O Poly.
- 47:38And I'm, I noticed that I'm having to kinda not check
- 47:42myself, but I'm before I go into the, the conversations, I'm
- 47:45going to get yourself out of the main set of that nine figure
- 47:47brand because it's totally different.
- 47:49I'm thinking because I've been so used to over the past year or
- 47:52two, the conversations revolving around having people like BAS
- 47:55and PMS and having these work in a complex structures of teams
- 48:00and things. And sometimes I'm going to
- 48:02speaking to brands where they've got one person working in E com
- 48:05and that person working in E com doesn't have the time or the
- 48:08capacity to sit and go through these complex like processes.
- 48:13And, you know, setting I'm saying isn't let's sit and spend
- 48:16the day just mapping out your systems and mapping out your
- 48:20requirements and what you need by the land they're going.
- 48:21Me, I've got like, I've got a day job to do Like, and that's I
- 48:26can, I can appreciate that because that's what I was a few
- 48:28years ago, but understanding as well and and being able to
- 48:32explain to people their needs in a nice way.
- 48:35So like that company where they might have one person working in
- 48:39Ecom and that one person ecom is fairly junior.
- 48:43They have grown with the business.
- 48:44They started in customer service, The businesses went
- 48:46online, they're having to start doing ecom stuff and they're
- 48:50saying, oh, we want this fancier, better tool or we want,
- 48:54you know, they've got these, they've got these requirements
- 48:55that they want. We don't like the tool that
- 48:56we're currently using. We want something better.
- 48:59And being able to, rather than saying, yeah, I've used the
- 49:02better tool and it's much better, you should use that.
- 49:04It'll really help. Actually been able to say to
- 49:07them, you don't need that. And before you need that, you
- 49:11need to do the basics and you need to do some housekeeping and
- 49:14you need to figure out, are you cheering up your shop, if I
- 49:17correctly, as does the data make sense?
- 49:20Does this, do you understand the systems?
- 49:22Do you understand the flow of data?
- 49:23Do you understand? I have this conversation quite a
- 49:27lot and I've had it over the past kind of four to six weeks
- 49:29where I've been speaking to, to brands and stuff and I actually
- 49:31love it because I'm like, I, I feel like I can help here.
- 49:36Growing before you've had that level of maturity of adding the
- 49:39complexity before you need to don't do actually really end up
- 49:42hurting yourself down the line. And it's it's a difficult one
- 49:46for me. I don't want ever seen.
- 49:48It was my first worry. The first couple of
- 49:49conversations like this I had, I was like, oh, is this going to
- 49:52come across like, are they going to be like, all well and good
- 49:54for you saying you're coming from your 9 figure target.
- 49:57You know what I mean? In that brand where you had all
- 49:59this budget and you had a massive team and being able to
- 50:02relate and say to people and like, I would much rather tell
- 50:05you what you don't need and tell you what you don't need to spend
- 50:08your money on and where you don't need to spend your time
- 50:10and resource. Then try and encourage you to
- 50:12spend more than you need to. Or I mean like I, I think so
- 50:16there's tools that I think are great.
- 50:18There's tools that I think are fantastic that I really
- 50:20recommend people to use. But it depends on the individual
- 50:22person, the, the brand, the size of the team.
- 50:25I couldn't sleep at night if I went and told a brand that was
- 50:27doing like 500 K yearly turnover and a million yearly turnover
- 50:31that they need to go and use ACDP system.
- 50:33I'm like, you don't need that. Use Shopper for it.
- 50:35You you won't get to use it. I I think this is this means a
- 50:39critical thing now in in E com. It's there are so many tools out
- 50:43there. The connectivity is best than it
- 50:44ever has techs been democratised.
- 50:46Like you said before, it's it's much easier to build tech stacks
- 50:51with less engineers. What you still fundamentally
- 50:53need experienced engineers to stress test and help you make
- 50:57better decisions. That's an an absolute no
- 50:59brainer. But it's, yeah, it's, it's the
- 51:04ability to stop and say, why do we need it now?
- 51:07And are we going to get value? What's our time to value from
- 51:10it? Because if I don't have the
- 51:11resource and your point you made earlier in this discussion about
- 51:14I don't have the resource to use 50% of this tool, my time to
- 51:17value is going to be very long and my ROI is going to be crap
- 51:21and stress testing it. I like, I had this recently with
- 51:23a client I'm talking to the moment and they were, they're
- 51:25considering putting a PIM in and nothing I've seen in the product
- 51:29data suggests they need a PIM. It's single site UK, no
- 51:33translations, no complexity, no syndication out to like third
- 51:37parties like retail channel partners, none of that product
- 51:42data feeds being done somewhere else.
- 51:44So you just need, you know, it is a Shopify project, could be
- 51:48any and it could be any SAS platform could be a centre of
- 51:51big commerce where they've got a decent product data models.
- 51:54Like you just need to set your product data model up correctly
- 51:57and you need to ensure that the the process between ERP and E
- 52:01Comm is robust and you are done. You do not need anything else.
- 52:06You do not need to add a 30 grand a year cost and another
- 52:08tool to a process. I know you're right.
- 52:11It's just about knowing the tipping point from when you're
- 52:14getting value from somebody. Yeah.
- 52:16And and having the those honest conversations though.
- 52:19So I think sometimes people will say, oh, should we not be?
- 52:22And I, I was here a couple of years ago as well.
- 52:24We were in a massive stage of growth.
- 52:26We're, you know, growing 100% year on year.
- 52:28And it was, do we, should we not be aiming for where we should be
- 52:31in a year or two ago rather than where we are now?
- 52:33And that's a hard decision to, it's a hard thing to to talk
- 52:36around because you risk buying into technology that you might
- 52:42not need if that growth trajectory doesn't stay up.
- 52:44Things can be so cyclical and trend lead and stuff.
- 52:47Now these things that become huge for like a year and you
- 52:51know, probably the businesses and the systems and stuff aren't
- 52:55mature enough and can't cope with that massive stage of
- 52:58growth. Then people get, Oh my God, we
- 52:59need to buy all these massive systems and we need to go out
- 53:01and we need to, you know, make all these changes because we're
- 53:05in this huge stage of growth. But there is a risk to that of
- 53:07like, what if that growth doesn't persist then?
- 53:10And like, and you, you know, that's, that's quite stressful.
- 53:14Once I remember making that decision with a search tool a
- 53:17couple of years ago and it was, well, we're, you know, we're
- 53:19massively growing. We want, we, we should use
- 53:22Algolia. They're the market leaders.
- 53:23They're the, they're the best search tool.
- 53:25And we started working with Algolia and that was a decision
- 53:28we made at a time we got the full business bought and we said
- 53:30we need to use the market leading tool, Jim Shark use it.
- 53:33But all these different references that we had, we've
- 53:35done, we searched the web and used Algolia, a million
- 53:39different things before we said, yes, we're like, yeah, we need
- 53:41to use that 100%. And that was a decision we made
- 53:44to business. But it's quite difficult to know
- 53:46where you're going to be in a year or two time when you're
- 53:48buying the big bits of technology and it is a risk.
- 53:50What if that was a what if that growth didn't sustain?
- 53:54And then we had got into this massive 6 figure contract for
- 53:58search and, you know, ties ourselves in for a couple of
- 54:02years of working with this tool. So then in a couple of years
- 54:05time, where one of these brands that you see come and go and you
- 54:07go, and thankfully it probably hasn't been that.
- 54:09And you know, we didn't have that issue to contend with, but
- 54:11it was always in the back of my mind of like, we're investing so
- 54:14much money in the technology. Like it's a big decision to
- 54:17make. And it's, it's, it's something
- 54:19that for brands that are no, I think because technology has
- 54:22changed so much where you see these apps popping up, the shop
- 54:25finding of apps, you see these SAS platforms and stuff coming
- 54:29up that are very AI driven, lean one click integrations, which I
- 54:33see through connected teeth. But you see this kind of, and
- 54:39again, the democratization of technology.
- 54:41If I was a, a brand that was growing, that was at smaller
- 54:46scale, would I go and would I take the risk to go for this
- 54:50really robust, huge market leader technology that's a, a, a
- 54:55huge well known name system? Or would I take a gamble and one
- 54:58of the smaller guys, because technology is changing and
- 55:00growing at such a pace and I could go, well, I could maybe
- 55:03get that and, and let you see Shopify native.
- 55:05I know people who use Shopify native search very successfully
- 55:08and don't need to use a search tool.
- 55:10And I'm like, that is the decisions that you have to, you
- 55:12have to make now and you have to be comfortable saying, do you
- 55:15want to make this huge investment?
- 55:19Or like you said, do you want to try and tune something that's
- 55:22smaller, that's lower risk, that you don't have to put too much
- 55:25resource and effort and to know, do you have it three to six
- 55:27months, see what happens, see if that can fit like 80% of your
- 55:31requirements, even 70%. And then what you have to do is
- 55:34kind of calculate almost the gap analysis of, OK, I've got what
- 55:37I've got now, which I'm paying this for that does X percent,
- 55:41the other 20% of my requirements that I'm missing as the cost,
- 55:45does the cost delivered ROI on that incremental gain, yes or
- 55:48no? And then that's the decision you
- 55:49have to make. Whereas what you're doing, if
- 55:51you just go straight ahead into that, I need to buy this
- 55:53technology and I want this, you're comparing it from nothing
- 55:56like you can't, you can't compare it from absolutely
- 55:58nothing to everything. You need to do some sort of go
- 56:01some sort of the way and give yourself that.
- 56:04Like if I was being to everyone now, I'd be like you, Shopify,
- 56:07are you using Shopify flows? Are you using Shopify native
- 56:11apps and searches? And, and if you're, if not, have
- 56:13you tried these apps? They're really low cost.
- 56:15They're monthly rolling contracts.
- 56:17Try that, see what you can do, see how far it can go before you
- 56:20go and make a big decision because you I would just hate to
- 56:23encourage people to spend loads and loads and loads on
- 56:26technology when they don't know if they need it yet.
- 56:28No, exactly. I'm just doing what I this is
- 56:30where I think having the experience, whether you have it
- 56:33in house or through consultancy is important because, yeah,
- 56:36I've, I've had a conversation recently with somebody who's
- 56:38talking about investment in like a full product discovery engine,
- 56:41want to get all these advanced capabilities.
- 56:44Yeah, they want to achieve all this research and actually want
- 56:47to break it down. What they need a merchandising
- 56:50tool because search is used on so few sessions and the search
- 56:54is so absolutely basic. It's one or two keywords.
- 56:56There's no multi attribute, there's no natural language.
- 56:59The nature of the product set is not a visual based search.
- 57:02It's not like in a fashion, for example.
- 57:04So all this additional capability is you're not going
- 57:07to get much value from it. You just need a search that
- 57:10works bloody well, has got some basic semantic capability and
- 57:14you've got a good UI for it. Great.
- 57:16What you need your, your, your collection, your PLP pages are
- 57:19the ones that are getting the traffic and filters aren't
- 57:22working very well. And your ranking is really poor
- 57:27and your product placement is poor.
- 57:28Christ, focus your effort on the tools that are really strongly
- 57:32merchandising and just tick the box and make sure they they
- 57:35search that you can validate that they weren't spelled.
- 57:37It's that I think that's what you need, right?
- 57:39You need scrutiny of what is driving the decision first, how
- 57:44to then evaluate and then that come back to your point, that
- 57:47time to value. Am I going to get value from
- 57:48this? Can I justify the cost now?
- 57:50And I think is it, is it driving from a place of frustration as
- 57:54well? Like, and it's our job to be the
- 57:56ones who come in, I believe and say, are you using the tool
- 58:00properly or so for example, hit or search and merch tool search
- 58:05and merch is awful. And I, I used to get this
- 58:07sometimes search and merch is terrible, results are terrible.
- 58:11And you alluded to earlier, but is it actually the search?
- 58:14Because the tool itself can definitely do relevancy.
- 58:17If you put crap in, you're going to get crap out.
- 58:20Have you validated that the data is correct?
- 58:22Have you validated? Do you know that it's everything
- 58:25in the back end has been tuned as much as it can be?
- 58:27And if so, if that's the case, it might be the tool.
- 58:30But if it's not, and if you look at it and go how much are your
- 58:32team actually using it? Are the team sitting on the
- 58:34tool? You know, are they using all the
- 58:36capabilities? Have you had a QBR with your
- 58:38account manager or do you have an account manager?
- 58:40Is there someone who can come in and tell you that you're not
- 58:42actually using all the functionality properly?
- 58:44Or have you noticed that your team are actually like working
- 58:47around it, working in spreadsheets, not bothering with
- 58:50it? Or, you know, is the analytics
- 58:52really poor? Is that what are they having to
- 58:54export the data manually and they're not really bothered with
- 58:56it and they're not sitting and understanding what they need to
- 58:58do? Because half the time, like we
- 59:00alluded to earlier, it's not the tech.
- 59:02It's, it's the, it's the tool or the it's not, it's not the tech,
- 59:05it's the people. So like all the time when I'm
- 59:08having these conversations, I'm like, well, have you used it?
- 59:12And then if it comes out, actually, no, no, we're not
- 59:15using that. No, it's a bit clunky, No, we
- 59:17don't like it, blah, blah. Then you start to drill down
- 59:19deeper into the RA OK, the team don't like it or the team don't
- 59:23use it because they don't like it because they were never
- 59:24trained on it is don't understand how to use it and it
- 59:27just seems like a useful a useless waste of their day.
- 59:29They're just sitting on this tool and the benefit of it is
- 59:32that what it is right. OK, now let's start looking at
- 59:35the people in process side of it, trying to, you know, up and
- 59:37make it a bit better because the the people who are I hate
- 59:40searching merch. I hate this tool.
- 59:42It's useless, it's rubbish, it's Bubba.
- 59:44Most of the time it comes from a place of frustration, and that
- 59:46might be frustration with the tool.
- 59:47It might be that the back end of the tool as slow as anything
- 59:50that's slowing them down. They're annoyed and it might be
- 59:52that they've actually got 200 other jobs to do and it's the
- 59:55lowest priority one because they don't understand the benefit of
- 59:57it. And that's why I've kind of, as
- 59:59I say, quite a lot recently. I wouldn't you, I wouldn't now
- 1:00:03buy a tool that has a really complex, clunky back end because
- 1:00:07I have seen the, the kind of rain that has on a team.
- 1:00:12Like sometimes I'll say A-Team, well, oh, can you guys sit and
- 1:00:14spend a bit of time when I'll go there today or whatever and
- 1:00:16they'll be like, oh, can you say I've got AB test and I'll go
- 1:00:19there today and they'll go, oh, it takes forever and they get
- 1:00:22annoyed by it. And I can see that with other
- 1:00:24tools and I speak to people and I say, how do you like that too?
- 1:00:26Or I hate the analytics. It's more dirty get reporting
- 1:00:29out of. So I just don't do it.
- 1:00:31And you see that because the operating experience is so
- 1:00:33important. So actually, I know say to the
- 1:00:35team, every single demo that I ever took O Poly, I had my full
- 1:00:38team sit and listen in and I would send them notes
- 1:00:40afterwards. What do you think guys?
- 1:00:42You are the ones that are going to be using it.
- 1:00:44It's all good. Well and good for me to sit
- 1:00:45here. I'm not a daily user of the
- 1:00:46tool. I want to make it integrate
- 1:00:48properly and I want to make it work efficiently, but I'm not
- 1:00:50the day-to-day user. They need to buy into it.
- 1:00:52They need to be the ones using it, making the most out of it,
- 1:00:55getting the money's worth. But imagine having to turn
- 1:00:58around to a brand that's hired you as a contractor and say,
- 1:01:01yeah, I got you this fantastic piece of technology in them
- 1:01:04going, yeah, but our team hate it.
- 1:01:06Team Venkat, you're and you're wasting your time.
- 1:01:10Yeah, adoption is so important. You know what?
- 1:01:11I, I, Laura, I could carry on talking for hours about this
- 1:01:14because it's so important, right?
- 1:01:15It's there's no right, right answer, but there's a right
- 1:01:18process. And I think that hopefully
- 1:01:19that's what people listen, have got from this that, that you've
- 1:01:23got to be able to ask the right questions.
- 1:01:24And if you don't know the right questions, find someone who can
- 1:01:27help you to do that. Because for a little bit of
- 1:01:29extra time and effort up front, you'll save yourself a lot of
- 1:01:32heartache and pain. Look, I really appreciate you
- 1:01:35coming on, Lauren, and excited to see that you've gone into the
- 1:01:38consultancy side as well. I know that you'll be a great
- 1:01:40value to a lot of brands out there who need this level of
- 1:01:42advice. And for anyone listening who
- 1:01:45wants to reach out and and talk to either us more, Lauren's
- 1:01:49contact details are on the landing page at linkside commas
- 1:01:51dot FM and she's also tagged on the episode post that goes out.
- 1:01:55So please do reach out and ask any questions or if you're
- 1:01:58looking for support, you know where to go.
- 1:02:02So yeah, thanks Lauren. Thanks for joining us today.
- 1:02:04Thank you. And thanks for listening as
- 1:02:06always everyone. TuneIn again.
- 1:02:07Next week you're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast.
- 1:02:11Hosted by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul
- 1:02:14Rogers. Inside Commerce is your fast
- 1:02:16track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 1:02:19leading e-commerce retailers, industry thoughtleys and the
- 1:02:21C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 1:02:24strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 1:02:27Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 1:02:30advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 1:02:32strategy and tech. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 1:02:36out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 1:02:38project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 1:02:40episode.