Latest / Automotive State of The Union / FTC Warns Dealers Over Advertising, The $1K Negotiator, BYD Eyes North America
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, March 16th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. I have the one and only Michael Cirillo in the studio today.
- 0:08We're talking about the FTC playing hardball, a $1,000 negotiator, and BYD. Looking at Michael's homeland of Canada with a little more intensity. Every time you're on the show, we s- or there's a Canada thing- Is it-...
- 0:21to talk about Do- does Nathan make this intentional? I swear it's not on purpose. No. [laughs] It's not. I pick the stories. [laughs] It's like I saw it- I'm like, "Canada's in the news again?"...
- 0:30I was like, "Canada is in the news." I mean, what a, what a perfect way to have some commentary. It's, uh, we're halfway through the month. It does- Wow... I feel like March just started, but here we are at the 16th.
- 0:40Wow. [laughs] What is happening? I mean- We're in a time warp... I know. I know. Well, a couple things are really coming in strong. One of those is ASOTU CON and the Auto Industry AI Summit.
- 0:51Uh, just in under 60 days now, we're announcing our opening keynote. So basically, ASOTU CON is May 12th through 14th. The day of the 12th, we're also having a summit called the Auto Industry dot AI Summit.
- 1:03We've had this newsletter for the last, uh, two years, if you don't get it, autoindustry.ai, where we, uh, deliver auto- AI news catered to the auto industry with prompts and specific things from the dealerships you can use.
- 1:16This year, we said, "Let's turn it into a little summit." A lot of people are talking about AI, uh, trying to be at the forefront of it. A lot of those people are close to this community, so let's get everybody together.
- 1:26So we're doing that. One of the coolest things we're announcing is our opening keynote, Zach Shefska. You may have be- been hearing the name around. He's the president, CEO, co-founder of CarEdge.
- 1:36Uh, CarEdge kind of started as a YouTube consumer education channel, then turned into this tech platform. They've been in The Wall Street Journal, on the morning shows, Reuters.
- 1:44Basically, they've developed an AI platform that helps bring more transparency between sellers and buyers. So, uh, Zach is gonna come out, he's gonna talk to us, opening keynote, talk about AI deployment in automotive.
- 1:55Very, very, very smart thinker.
- 1:57And what I love about the way his approach is, is that he brings some outside the industry perspective to us so that we can get out of our bubble a little bit, because it's very easy to think inside the bubble, you know, MC.
- 2:09Yeah. It- well- and can I just say that is the biggest problem any time things shift, and things have shifted. Yeah. Is, is like- I've noticed... can you believe this? I just, I couldn't believe this over the weekend.
- 2:23I just have to say it to this point, which is there are people still hanging on to their phone book businesses out there. Really? Yes. Oh, wow. Well, and, and, and we're at that stage again where we're like adapt or...
- 2:38Wow And he's gonna bring us the goods. He's, the, this, I- I'm excited about the, the Auto AI Industry Summit. I think it's gonna be unreal. It's phenomenal.
- 2:45So you can, uh, check out a little more about that by going to summit.autoindustry.ai, summit.autoindustry.ai. Or you could just go to a ASOTU CON site and get everything together.
- 2:55If you're already going to ASOTU CON, by the way, it's like 20 more bucks. 20 bucks, you can go to the AI Summit and, uh- Come on... hang out with the people on, at the tip of the spear in the auto industry.
- 3:05Um, hey, wanna thank our sponsors today. Uh, good friends of ours, Hey Greenlight. Most dealerships don't have a lead problem, they have a conversion- conversation problem.
- 3:14Hey Greenlight's wing man gives your sales and BDC team live real-time prompts while they're on the call so they say the right things at the right time so you get better openings, uh, stronger objection handling, clear appointment asks.
- 3:26And if you want more consistent performance without hiring more people, check out heygreenlight.com. If you haven't seen it, you should definitely check out the, the launch video.
- 3:36Um, you know, it's a teleprompter for your BDC agents that analyzes sentiment and knows your inventory, so, like, basically a rep can, like, read what's on their screen and sound like the most experienced person to ever handle a phone call.
- 3:49I wish I had that feature in, like, a lot of areas of my life. [laughs] Yeah, like talking to my wife on the phone. That, that would be a great one, or maybe like, "Dad, where do babies come from?"
- 3:58That would've been a great teleprompter moment. [laughs] You know what I mean? [laughs] We've all had, any father's had that situation. You're like, "Oh yeah, that, that, that."
- 4:06Um, all right, [laughs] let's get into some news. Uh, the Federal Trade Commission is sending warning letters to 97 dealership groups over advertising practices the agency says may violate federal law.
- 4:18The FTC says transparent pricing is a priority and outlined six specific practices it considers illegal in vehicle advertising.
- 4:27So basically, they sent, uh, this letter of concern out to these dealers and, uh, said, "We're not saying you did it. We're just saying these are the rules." So it's, it's one of those.
- 4:37This is kind of like a, a fair warning shot. Here are the six examples the letter cites. Advertising a price that does not reflect all required fees.
- 4:46Advertising a price that reflects rebates or discounts not available to all consumers. Advertising a price that fails to take into account the amount of additional required down payment.
- 4:57Conditioning the advertised price on consumers using dealer financing. Requiring consumers to buy additional items not reflected in the advertising pr- advertised price.
- 5:07Or advertising unavailable or non-existent vehicles.
- 5:12The national, uh, the NADA responded saying most dealers are already compliant, but the organization takes potential advertising violations very seriously and plans to work with the FTC on all concerns.
- 5:22Um, the, the Bureau of Consumer Protection director, his name's Christopher, um,
- 5:29Mufforage, said, quote, "The Trump Vance FTC is committed to preventing auto dealers from misleading consumers with low advertised prices and then adding on mandatory fees at the end of the purchasing process."
- 5:41So we have a lot of attention on price transparency. Interestingly enough, Zach Shefska, who's going to be at the Auto Industry AI Summit, is, his whole company and product is around advertising and price transparency.
- 5:53So, um, seems like a lot of things converging in this moment, Michael. I mean, it makes a lot of sense.
- 5:58I had a buddy over the weekend, um, ask me if he would be able to negotiate [laughs]$4,000 off of a Toyota Highlander that had to be brought in from another dealership because they're in such high demand. Mm-hmm.
- 6:13And I said, "Well, where'd you get your original price?" And he told me, and I said, "Good luck." Yeah. And what it made me think is there's, there, there's two sides to this.
- 6:21I think, you know, from inside the industry or from a regulatory perspective, we can do everything we can to educate, to become more transparent.
- 6:31But the other side of the gap, really, and this is gonna sound weird, 'cause, uh, uh, usually I, I, I would be 100% all in on this in defense of, like, people getting the best deal and all these sorts of things.
- 6:41But it's like not enough people know how to buy a car, because you just don't do it often enough. And- Sure... to not know that side of things, to know what you could or could not do,
- 6:52um, really presents the other half of the challenge here.
- 6:54Because no matter what happens, a larger percentage of the market is going to feel like they're being swindled just because they don't know what they don't know about how things work.
- 7:04That presents the biggest opportunity for the dealer body to be that dealer in the market that's going out of their way to educate and to bring people inside the deal. Simple, you know, I think 30-second videos.
- 7:14"Hey, meet Michael. He's the finance manager here. Let him explain to you how the process works, so that when you show up, you know exactly what you're gonna get, how the pricing breakdown works," so on and so forth.
- 7:23I think that's such a great insight. There you see very few people being proactive about the education and saying, "Here's what to expect," and also this continued effort to just make the process simpler. Um- Yeah...
- 7:36it's something that comes across. People send me stuff, right? And just like you were saying, people send you stuff because you're in the industry.
- 7:42Um, and usually when I get sent something, it's like a Twitter thread of people talking about their car buying experience or car buying process.
- 7:49And whenever I read these threads, it makes me, uh, [laughs] it makes me a little sad inside, because you can't argue with the situations often being outlined in the thread, 'cause I can see it happening.
- 8:00But the saddest part is the 200 comments that happens after it, where a lot of other people are saying like, "Oh, I've had a similar experience," or, "I know somebody who has"- Right...
- 8:09or, "I bought my last car at, like, Carvana," or, "You should try this," or, "You should try that."
- 8:14And I think, like you said, to your point, there's so much opportunity to be proactive in investing time, energy, and money, and advertising dollars into an education level thing. "This is why the price is what it is.
- 8:28This is how you go through the process. This is why it's good for you, as opposed to just trying to buy off the street or buy online. Um, these are all the things that we help you with along the process."
- 8:37There's not enough of that. It's one of the reasons we produce the show, The Truth About Car Dealers, to talk about a little bit more broad scale, the value of a dealership.
- 8:44But in, you know, as long as these letters needs to be sent out, um, you know, we're on our heels, bottom line. Yeah. Yeah. All right, this next one.
- 8:51Speaking about someone stepping in to try to help bridge the gap between consumers and dealers. Hold up. That was a long segue. Segway. Time for Two Cents. It was like a Michael Scott headline.
- 9:01[laughs] Some people, right, still know how business should be done.
- 9:04Um, [laughs] so I, I caught, this one caught my eye over the weekend because, uh, I read The Wall Street Journal and I get, um, like these notifications and emails like, "Oh, here's a story we're talking about," and this was the featured story on Sunday.
- 9:15Uh, it's a Wall Street Journal article titled He's Got a Dealer's Worst Ni- He's a Dealer's Worst Nightmare. Meet a guy who spent a decade on your side of the desk, now using everything he learned to work against it.
- 9:27His name's Tommy Makula. He's built a thriving business negotiating car deals for buyers at a flat rate of about $1,000 per deal. He's got 600,000 followers watching his live streams and watching his every move.
- 9:40He was a former car salesman, F&I professional, and, uh, again, $1,000 flat rate to negotiate their next vehicle on their behalf. His company is called Deliverd, D-E-L-I-V-R-D.
- 9:50He has a team of now five negotiators and generates $200,000 in revenue per month, plus his social media following of 600,000 across TikTok and YouTube. His strategy is very intentional.
- 10:01He works the phones from home, pits dealers against one another for competing quotes, and keeps buyers off the showroom floor to re- avoid the sunk cost trap.
- 10:11He said, you know, once you've been in a fl- on the showroom floor, you feel like you have too much time invested to walk away from a deal. So he's like, "Never go to the showroom." Um,
- 10:19basically, he's tapping into buyer frustration, as one in five Americans now has a $1,000-plus monthly car payment, while add-ons like warranties and protection packages can inflate a vehicle price by up to 30%.
- 10:31He says, "You're hiring a middleman to deal with the middleman to make the middleman more efficient."
- 10:36So, um, this is a real world business that's being stood up because consumers feel like they need somebody to stand in the middle and figure it out.
- 10:44And, you know, the fact that the need exists is that it exists, but, um, it doesn't sound like the kind of thing that we as an industry want to have in the middle of us building relationships with a customer.
- 10:53But people are buying it. I mean, M- Makula got kahuna- Yeah. [laughs]... uh, is what's happening. Well, there, there's a couple of things here.
- 11:00I'm like, "Hey, mazel tov to this guy for finding a need and filling it," and 200,000, I mean, like, that's 200 cars a month- Yeah... on average that this guy's helping negotiate.
- 11:09We're seeing this a lot more and more lately, people starting from a very polarizing, controversial position. If he can hang on to this, he might have something really interesting.
- 11:21I think, though, the bigger opportunity from where I sit, where I've made my career as an advocate for the dealer body, like we have here with More Than Cars,
- 11:30is, hey, this also presents an opportunity to you because he's making basically his entire, uh, position off of the fact that you are not doing a good enough job. Well, guess what you do in those circumstances?
- 11:42You do, you do a good enough job. You do a good job. You build the relationship. You, um, you train your people.
- 11:48Like, there, y- look, and I know it's heavier, it's a heavier lift than anybody wants to admit, but if you're gonna spend 9, 10, 12 bell-to-bell hours in the store and that time is gonna pass anyways, you might as well fill your time with the thing that you should've been investing your time in on it anyways.
- 12:03And, and you could be doing this for yourself inside of, in- inside of your own store with a better relationship. Without a doubt. You know, these two stories, they, they've come up.
- 12:11Um, we didn't hold them for this episode so we could run them together. These are literally just two stories that came up over- Right... the last 72 hours. Mm-hmm.
- 12:18And so we feel like it's a great way to just-Help us pay more attention to this. The people who are paying attention, lean into it. Please talk about it more.
- 12:26The people who aren't paying attention, maybe lean into it a little bit and understand that this is the public narrative out there, and if we don't actively combat it and do things to make it simpler, make it easier, make it more transparent, like, we can't fake it.
- 12:39We actually have to do it, and if we don't do it, we're going to continually get- lose the fight. Um, we're going to lose customers.
- 12:45We're gonna lose, more importantly, I think, the customer relationship, because what happens when you have a middleman? You don't have any relationship with the customer.
- 12:52You're separated, so what does retention look like? Abysmal, right? 'Cause you just had someone- Right... negotiate. I have some questions about the business model, though. Um, he said he has five negotiators, plus him.
- 13:02That's six people. That's $200,000 a month, 200 car deals. Mm-hmm. And you start, you start dividing that up a little bit. You're like, "Okay," like, "are these full-time negotiators?"
- 13:12I wonder if some of these negotiators actually work in the business somewhere else. Mm. And you know what I mean? Like- Mm-hmm. But, but either way, I mean, obviously there's a lot of revenue moving through the company.
- 13:23Um- Feel like we gotta talk to this guy. I know. Is he Canadian? Where's he at? [laughs] I have no idea. [laughs] I have no idea. Uh, is that where we drop speaking of Canada? Ah, that is. Or is that too soon?
- 13:34That is exactly where we drop that. Well done. History in the making. On a Monday. [laughs] My first quasi-successful- That was a very successful segue... segue. That's a, that's an 8 out of 10. Wow. 8 out of 10? It is.
- 13:48You know what an eight is on Dave Portnoy's pizza scale? [laughs] Unheard of, yeah. [laughs] Dang, man. Um, okay, so check this one out. The world's largest EV maker isn't just knocking on North America's door anymore.
- 14:00It's looking for a key. BYD is studying Canada for a wholly-owned manufacturing plant and signaling it's op- i- it's open to acquiring a struggling legacy automaker to fast-track its global expansion.
- 14:13There's a couple of those. Yeah. [laughs] Oh, my goodness. Uh, called it back in October. Didn't, isn't this what we do on, on, on More Than Cars? Isn't this what we're about? Yeah.
- 14:20[laughs] We kind of look around corners. We're gonna build a, we're gonna build an AI model called Receipt Tracker for us. Oh, my gosh. What a, that's like- [laughs] But you're like, "That's it. That's it."
- 14:29We just, there's the- That's a great idea... synthesis and the idea. When it comes out, we're gonna build the Receipt Tracker so everything- Oh, my gosh...
- 14:33that you say as a podcast host, we'll scour the news, and then, like, if something comes up where it came true, we're gonna, like, give you a little cha-ching, and then you can- Da-di-di-ding...
- 14:41then you can take a little victory lap. Oh, my gosh.
- 14:44Okay, so BYD executive vice president Stella Li confirmed the company is studying Canada for a wholly-owned factory and made it clear it has no interest in a joint venture. [laughs] Ooh.
- 14:54Ooh, saying, quote, "I don't think a joint venture will work," close quote. [laughs] Pretty conclusive. I think so.
- 15:01A January trade deal slashed- The only thing that they forgot there is adding the word A at the end of it. A? That would've been... They're like, "What's the translation?" A, B, C, D, E, F, G. Yeah, A. Uh, it depends.
- 15:11They, they, they could if they were talking to East Coast Canadian- Okay. Oh, well-... and throw an A in there... what do I know? What do I know? Carry on. Carry on.
- 15:17A January trade deal slashed Canada's tariff on Chinese EVs from 100% to 6.1%, permitting up to 49,000 Chinese-built vehicles annually, fundamentally changing the math for BYD's North American ambitions.
- 15:31Li said BYD is open to acquiring a legacy automaker, noting several American, European, and Japanese manufacturers are struggling under the financial strain of running parallel EV- Mm-hmm...
- 15:42and combustion product lines simultaneously. True story. Yeah, true story. That's true. Uh, talked about it here on the show, didn't we?
- 15:48[laughs] BYD is already one of three finalists bidding for a tw- 230,000 unit Nissan-Mercedes plant in Mexico, but is still avoiding the US market, with Li calling it a complicated environment.
- 16:01All right, that's very, that's very precise PR language, because I don't think they're avoiding the US market. I think they're just being kept out of the US market right now.
- 16:10Um, you know, we talked about the door being cracked open when Canada agreed to this $49,000 unit, and I think that is going to continue to be just what it was. It was a foot in the door.
- 16:21That door's gonna continue to be pried open.
- 16:23It's gonna be very difficult to say no to, uh, all of these dollars coming in to rescue a struggling company, and it makes a lot of sense that a wholly-owned company that makes cars not under BYD's name would be the way BYD can get in, start manufacturing, start making relationships, start integrating product features and designs.
- 16:43And, uh, again, it's just the door is now open a little wider for this factory or something- Yeah... like this goes through. It'll be now, now you can, like, fit somebody. Now you're gonna be able to, like- [laughs]...
- 16:51push people through the door. We're there now. A sideways shimmy. A sideways shimmy through the door. Well, I think- Go ahead...
- 16:56it's, it's important to note, like, y- yeah, some things in life, we're figuring it out as we go. Most.
- 17:02Other things like this, th- this isn't a strategy that, you know, Li wakes up in the morning, Stella Li, doesn't go, "You know what'd be a good idea is if we just, hmm, created it through a different company." Yeah.
- 17:12[laughs] Yeah. Maybe a Canadian company. [laughs] It, uh, this is months, months, months in the making, and, and this is why it's so critical that we need to be leaning in and paying attention. Mm.
- 17:22Because the moves that are leading us to today, actually, in my estimation, started four, five, six years ago. Oh, yeah. And, and we need to be paying attention. We need to be looking around corners.
- 17:35Th- this is how it's gonna happen. People are gonna... Like, everybody knew Canada's gonna throw up. You know, the Canadian citizens are gonna be like, "No, wait. What a minute.
- 17:42W- you're, you're talking about closing down... What, what is it, what's the implication for jobs?"
- 17:46Or, "Oh, no, no, we're gonna start a Canadian company," or, "We're just gonna buy an existing Canadian company- Yeah, and keep all the jobs... and we'll keep operating." Yeah. Yeah. I mean- Mitigating all the red tape.
- 17:54I mean... You know, Gary Vaynerchuk said this to me, one of the first conversations I ever had with him.
- 18:00Uh, we were in Miami, and I asked him, uh, about car dealers, and he said, basically, he was like, "If you think a law is going to protect you long term from something that you're not willing to change," he's like, "That's unrealistic."
- 18:14He goes, "Because laws are made by legislators, and people vote for legislators. And if you can change public opinion in your favor, then the laws will change as well."
- 18:21And I thought, uh, that was very wise, and this is kind of another example of that.
- 18:25If all of a sudden public sentiment shifts and people want this, pressure on lawmakers, laws can begin to, uh, crack and change, which is why we need to spend time and attention today to work on the customer sentiment.
- 18:37Take us full circle all the way back to the beginning of the show. Michael, always a pleasure to start a week with you. Uh, we have a lot more trouble to get into this week. But go to, uh, summit.autoindustry.ai.
- 18:48Get your ticket. We'll see you in May. [upbeat music]