Latest / Creator Generation / A newsletter is not an email strategy - Feat. Haley Janicek, Head of Creator Community at Kit
Transcript
- 0:00Fred: Hey. I'm Fred, and this is Creator Generation. Creator Generation of hype.
- 0:05Haley: But the thing is about email is that it's never been sexy, but it's always been the leading converting, like, the number one tool to convert subscribers into purchasing fans.
- 0:17Fred: Hey, everyone. Welcome back to the podcast. Today, I'm joined by my cohost, Frankie.
- 0:22Franky: Hello.
- 0:23Fred: And we are talking with Haley Janicek, the Head of Creator Community at Kit. Now Kit is one of the most popular email marketing platforms around, and Haley spent a better part of a decade helping some of the best creators in the world optimize and launch their newsletter strategies. And she has some tips you'll really wanna hear. So let's get into it. The mic.
- 0:43Pre create a generation of high Haley, welcome to the podcast.
- 0:47Haley: Thanks for having me. Excited to be here. So, Haley, you're you're you're the head
- 0:52Fred: of Creator Community at Kit. You've been there for a while. Can you tell us what is this... Your current job? What does it entail?
- 0:59What are you what are you in charge of?
- 1:01Haley: Yeah. When people find out how long I've been at Kit, they always give me some... Wow. You've... That's a long time you've been there.
- 1:08How how have you stayed there for that long? It does date me slightly, but no. Yes. My, current role is head of Creator Community. And I started out at Kidd, actually.
- 1:20I was the very first sales team hire. And I learned very quickly, that this is industry of, like, who you know and, like, a really tight knit. Like, the Creator community is just really tight knit. And so I took Nathan, our CEO. I said, hey.
- 1:35I... You've gotta come to this event with me. I was like, I just need an introduction to a handful of these people that are on the list of, you know, deals that we wanna close. You give me one introduction, and I can take it from there. And that is ultimately how I ended up leading all of events.
- 1:51It all started with that very first one. I learned very quickly that, you know, if you're in the right right community, you get one introduction, then, you know, you can... You're off to the races. And so, and that kind of has led me to the role that I'm in now where basically basically I I do do and and manage manage almost everything that we do in person. So in person experiences with our conference, craft and commerce, any in person events that we sponsor, all of our in person activations and things that we host.
- 2:18We run lots of masterminds. And then, of course, Kit Studios, which I am sitting in now. So we have three studios in Boise, Idaho, which is where I'm based, New York City, which is where I'm at currently, and Chicago, Illinois. So we've got three different home studios, and so we provide, these spaces for everyone to record. And so that's like an in person revolving door, so I get to lead up this project.
- 2:45Fred: That's cool. I wanna talk a bit more about your studios and set up in in a while, but just a bit about your background. You weren't always in sales and marketing. I was looking at your background, and you were a a coach, is that is that right, in volleyball?
- 2:58Haley: Yeah. I was. Yes. In a very different life, and it's actually, I guess volleyball is actually how I got into the Creator Economy in the first place. My...
- 3:09I had a strength coach, who is was... Is from Scotland. He's Scottish. And when I was in high school, I was getting into volleyball and my club coach wanted me to jump higher. And so he ended up connecting me to just this trainer, where I grew up.
- 3:26And it turns out he was one of, like, the very OG creators, like, very first creators online. And I remember I went to the, I was playing volleyball in in university, and I did a power clean. And my strength coach was like, where'd you learn how to do that? And, I said, I don't know. I had a trainer.
- 3:44And he goes, well, what's your trainer's name? And I was like, I don't know. His name's Alan. And he goes on to say... He's like, Alan.
- 3:50And I was like, yeah, Alan Kosgrove. I don't know. It's just my trainer's name. Like, you know, why are you asking me this? And he was like, wait a second.
- 3:57Your trainer who taught you how to do that is named Alan Kosgrove. You pulled me into his office, he opened up a Men's Health magazine, and then pulled up another article online. And he goes, this guy? And so I've always been fascinated with the Creator Economy since then. And I had no idea that he was famous.
- 4:15He was a professional speaker, a keynote speaker, well known. They were really known for, like, selling their first digital products. But all that to say volleyball is really what actually got me into the Creator Economy. And then, once I graduated college, I played obviously as well. And then I I got into college coaching, and then I retired on top is what I like to say.
- 4:35So
- 4:36Franky: And also inducted into the athletics hall of fame, I believe.
- 4:41Haley: This is true. Yes. I did in 2023. I got inducted into the the volleyball hall of fame. So I I...
- 4:48Like I said, I retire... I retired on top. You know, I had a great playing career, and then I coached for a little bit and, retired on top. But, I do get to claim that I'm a hall of fame volleyball player, so that's good.
- 5:00Fred: That is awesome. I don't think we've ever had a hall of famer in here, that's good. That's a good edge to have. Tick. And, obviously, you...
- 5:10I mean, you said that that was your introduction into the Creator Economy. Is there anything that you took away from, I guess, the coaching experience that you use now or that it helped shape your, approach to Creators?
- 5:22Haley: Yeah. I mean, coaches are teachers. You know? Like, they're expert in their craft and they're teachers, and I got really good at... I mean, there's there's two paths to this.
- 5:32There's teaching. I actually think some of the the most well respected creators that I know are teachers of what they're an expert in. So I I do feel like I got really good at teaching a skill. As far as selling goes, you know, when I think of, like, my transition from coaching into selling in The States, you know, and I'm sure you have some version of this in Australia as well, but we get, scholarships. And it's very difficult in college and university in The States.
- 6:00You know, it could be nearly a $100,000 or or something along those lines to attend college. And I'm trying to give, you know, someone a $100,000. And... But they have lots of colleges that are vying for their attention and trying to get them to come as well. And so, I was the youngest division one head coach in the country at the time.
- 6:18And so convincing, you know, a 40 year old or 45 year old mom to trust a a 23 year old with their 18 year old daughter, is a lot harder than you would think. And so I got very good at selling, and maybe making people trust me. And so when I got out of coaching, I... I'll never forget it because it was like my first job interview. And I said, you're gonna look at my resume, and you're gonna spend two minutes looking at this telling me why I'm not qualified, and I'm gonna spend two minutes telling you why you're wrong, and then you're gonna hire me because, it's a lot harder.
- 6:50When you're trying to give someone a $100,000, that's a hard... And it's a difficult sale. You know that you're good, at your job. So... Yeah.
- 7:00Fred: Yeah. I wanna ask quick... I I just really gotta digress, but I've been hearing this a fair a fair bit, and I I also think it is important. It's the the skill of selling. Right?
- 7:09The, people, especially the creator economy, a lot of creators feel icky about selling, but it is such an important skill, not just directly to your audience, but your ability to sell yourself to partners and to collaborators. It's such a key skill, isn't it?
- 7:32Haley: It is a very key skill. I feel like, I've been learning this skill since I was five years old. You know? I used to sell mistletoe going like a door to door, out of my wagon, that I would collect. I'm So just like, I have always been a salesperson.
- 7:47But I do think it is in part... It is particularly interesting, for creators to learn that skill because to your point, it does feel very icky. But oftentimes, you're selling yourself. You're not selling a product. And sometimes it's it's really easy to get behind a product that you love, but it's a lot harder to sell yourself.
- 8:06And I think that's actually where it gets really difficult. In my case, I was a coach, so I really was selling myself. You know, I was selling myself. I was selling my program. I was selling my training skills, you know, and whatnot.
- 8:19And so I feel like I learned that very early on. But really for creators, like, if you can't do that, you're certainly not gonna be successful, especially as it relates to closing brand deals or really knowing your worth or where your value is or what your audience is. Like, you really just gotta get over that hump or else the creator economy is not the job for you.
- 8:37Fred: Yeah. Absolutely. And it's one of those things that we we talk to creators about. It's a it's a hard one sometimes to get their mind around, but it is it is a it is a crucial skill, and and we often find the ones who have succeeded whether or not they know it. They're just good at selling an idea themselves or some aspect of of what they're trying to get across.
- 8:55So, yeah, I wish more creators knew that. But look, I would... It's probably a good segue to start talking about some of the stuff we want... You do at Kit and what Kit actually does. Do you wanna give us a quick rundown of of Kit as it has changed over time from not just the brand, but sort of, I guess, Hart's position.
- 9:11You wanna tell us a little bit more of a background of how it works and what people can use it for?
- 9:16Haley: Yeah. Of course. Well, I mean, many people are probably familiar with ConvertKit, which is now Kit. And so that's the first thing. We rebranded a few years ago to Kit.
- 9:26We dropped the convert. But ultimately, we're an email marketing platform that allows, like, for creators that are, have multiple revenue streams. And so we have creators on our platform that range from, you know, Tom Brady to James Clear to Jenna Kutcher and Amy Porterfield to, you know, Emma Greed, for example. And so all of our creators are doing various different things. And we also do a lot of deep dive data analysis on, your subscribers.
- 9:59So we're one of the only platform that gives you insight into who's actually on your list and maybe the collective total, of, like, their subscribers or their influence. And that's one of the hardest things that's, you know, historically on the email side of things is that you you might have a 100,000 people on your list, but you have no idea who's on your list. And so, we have a tool with a product called subscriber skills... Signals that, deep dives into who's actually on your list and tells you lots of very interesting, things about them. But, ultimately, we allow you to communicate one to many to your audience at scale in various different ways.
- 10:37Franky: That's fascinating to me because I love the data side of things here at changer. But also being at events, I find a lot of creators are like, you know, we do always talk about owning your audience, but they're like, I can't even get mine to do what I want them to do. So I... Kit would be perfect for just going, okay. This is who I've actually got.
- 11:00I'm gonna tell them what to do in a in a very succinct manner and and send it through. And then you've just got gold mine for any brand deals as well down the road when you're like, this is exactly who I've got following me. This is why you should partner with me. So there's just so many different, like... It's like a spider.
- 11:21Big spider web.
- 11:22Haley: It is like a spider. And it's actually fun because brand deals are one of the... Like, it's a great use case for this particular product. Right? Because you can look at your list and you can say, well, here's my collective following.
- 11:33Here's who follows me, but also here's their influence. So you can say, well, my collective, you know, total of my audience that, you know, they actually influence 20,000,000 people or whatever the number is. But it's such a strong use case for people that are like, run a community, for example. You know, if, like, you're in a designated city and you're saying my audience is primarily New Yorkers, it gives you so many various different angles, in which you can pitch brand partners. Or it also gives you, like, revenue level.
- 12:02So you can say, well, like, this is the household income of the majority of my creators, male versus female. So you can, like, see so much more data around your subscribers. And so if you're doing a brand partnership, you know, you can start to look at, okay, what what is success or important look like to this particular brand partner? And you can kind of cater your data, to tell the story that you wanted to tell.
- 12:23Fred: Stepping back, why do you think email has become so, you know, sexy again? It used to be the thing that sort of sat in the background and no one cared about it. Then all of a sudden, everyone's like, this is the thing.
- 12:35Haley: Yeah. I like I can answer this question like a million different ways. You know what's funny about this? Everything always comes back around. Right?
- 12:43It's like a talk about Gen Z creators, you know, and, like, they're pulling out the nineties glasses and everything always comes back around. But the thing is about email is that it's never been sexy, but it's always been the leading converting, like the number one tool to convert subscribers into purchasing fans. And so it's still to this day, I always say like a subscriber's worth a dollar, a social media, you know, subscriber is worth a follower. But email just allows you to connect to your audience in a way different way, and they're just far more likely to convert into, actually paying fans than any other platform can offer. And, of course, you own your subscribers.
- 13:26You... Right? You don't own your social followers. We could talk about the algorithm all day and how that's constantly changing. It is funny, though, because I do feel like, you know, the Substack, like Substack as an example, which I don't know if I would go as far as calling Substack a competitor.
- 13:43Maybe, like, in some niche, it's a competitor. But a lot of creators actually use Substack and Kit together. But I do think a platform like Substack made it really sexy again as well, because there's just, like, a lot of interest in the way that they're building, building their business and, like, kind of combining email, and social following. But it is it is fun to watch. It is it is fun to watch, and it's like you're...
- 14:10You... I feel like I've been shouting this off the rooftops for the last ten years. And I'm like, see? It is sexy. See?
- 14:17Fred: You know? So... Yeah. Is there a a reason why it converts better? Like, is it a connection?
- 14:25Is it something more personal? What is it that makes it worth that dollar you said, like, when you get someone who follows you on email or responds to an email?
- 14:32Haley: Yeah. So the first... I mean, the easy answer is that it's really difficult to get email subscribers. And so the way I like to say it is, like, how many... You're scrolling on Instagram, right, or even on YouTube for the most part.
- 14:44And I will casually follow people all the time. I will walk, I'll see somebody that I'm like, oh, that was one interesting piece of content. I like that. I will follow. And obviously, the algorithm either chooses to show me that person, you know, or not and whatnot, but I'm not a true fan yet.
- 15:02Now, if somebody subscribes to your email list, they are a true fan. I don't subscribe. The inbox is a very personal place. The inbox is somewhere that I'm only inviting you into my inbox if I absolutely want what you have to offer me. And I think that has remained true since like email marketing has been a thing, which is a while, is that people don't just subscribe to anything.
- 15:28In fact, they spend more time unsubscribing than they do subscribing. And so, I mean, how often do you go through Instagram and unsubscribe or unfollow people? I bet fairly rarely. But how often do you go into your email list and say, like, I don't want this anymore and you're constantly unsubscribing. And so if you're choosing to stay on someone's email list, you really want what they have because they are your super fans.
- 15:52And so, and it's just as a medium, I think more people buy on their laptops, more people buy through email. It tells a better story. So, yeah, you know, the data data can't be wrong this many years in a row.
- 16:08Fred: I love that. Frank, I think we're gonna steal that and put that in our newsletters like, the the value.
- 16:12Franky: Yeah. A 100%. But I'm definitely guilty of that when a purchase is getting a little bit too involved. I whip out the laptop, and I'm like, okay, we're getting serious now. It's gone from phone to laptop.
- 16:23But I guess as well, you really do have to stand out in someone's inbox, especially because, as you said, they've got so many personal things in there. They've got work, life, personal life, and then you're like, why does this specific creator have to stay in there? So
- 16:38Haley: Yeah. Yeah. You know, I wonder if there's some psychology. I can't prove this. I'm just...
- 16:43I'm actually guessing, but I will say it would feel icky to me. So some of the biggest creators that I know that make, we'll say over 7 figures. They're selling high ticket items, high ticket coaching services, high ticket courses, high ticket masterminds. And something about buying a high ticket mastermind, when I don't have all of the information, on social media just does not feel right. But if somebody lands in my inbox, and it's someone that I trust, I've been reading their content, right, I am much more likely to buy a $2,500 high ticket whatever, on email than I am on social.
- 17:21And so I think it it obviously varies depend... Like, depends on the business model. So in the affiliate marketing world, yeah, sure. I'll buy some eye patches or, you know, some like health and wellness drink off social media. But I'm certainly not buying, you know, Jesse Jeans Yap Challenge.
- 17:38And that was I think only $2.97. So I'd consider that like, you know, middle of the road. I'm not buying Jesse Jeans Yap Challenge on on, Instagram. I'm just not doing that. I'm going through the proper funnel.
- 17:54I'm reading all of the emails about it, and then I'm purchasing through email.
- 17:59Fred: Haley, you know, when you said eye patches, I, for some reason, thought of pirate eye patches. I was like, why would people buy pirate eye... Oh, you mean I did the exact same thing. Don't know. Yarr.
- 18:10Haley: You want a beauty thing, you know, like, anything like, do... I'm gonna buy an ice roller or something like that. Like, beauty. Yeah.
- 18:17Fred: Thought it was a very obscure thing. Don't think you really like pirates. I'm like, oh, no. Wait a minute. This must be something Okay.
- 18:23Alright.
- 18:23Haley: You don't wear eye patches?
- 18:24Fred: Oh, no. No. No. Not not on Tuesdays.
- 18:27Haley: Mark my words, you're gonna get an eye patch company promoting... You know, you're gonna get served an eyepatch ad. You gotta buy it next time. Alright? Yeah.
- 18:36Fred: Yeah. Yeah. Well, look, I'm gonna ask you this or maybe the million dollar question. It might be a bit hard to answer. But is there something about a structure of an email, or an EDM?
- 18:45Would you put it out that really grabbed attention? Have you, over the years, come across a structure you said, hey. If you do a, b, and c for a newsletter, typically, is the foundation of of of success?
- 18:58Haley: So, yeah, that that is a big question. And I'll say it's a big question because a newsletter is not an email strategy. And this is, like, just to get this out of the gate, I feel like a lot of people, especially within the rise of, to your point, newsletters being so sexy. I get a lot of creators coming to me and they're like, I'm gonna start a newsletter. And I'm like, great.
- 19:17Why? Like, what is the purpose of your newsletter? And a newsletter can be your product. Right? So your newsletter can be your product if your newsletter is big enough and you are focusing on brand deals and you are placing sponsorships in your newsletter.
- 19:32It can be the product if you have, a paid newsletter, which is like really the Substack model. You can also do that in kit as well. But Substack is like very well known for having like paid newsletters, you know, that are like low ticket paid newsletters. And so as it relates to the newsletter itself, typically the best newsletters follow a format. So, you know, James Clear's format is three two one.
- 20:00I think it's three ideas for me, two questions for you, one quote from someone else. I'm... And I might be getting that a little bit mixed up, but those are the three ideas. You have, you know, Tim Ferriss' Five Bullet Friday as an example. So typically, the best newsletters, I think, follow a format.
- 20:18They go out at the exact same time. So, like, Five Bullet Friday, you know, for example, Tim Ferriss, like, that's one of the most successful newsletters, you know, that that most people really recognize immediately. And I swear, there are people that are waiting to see exactly what Tim Ferriss's five bullets are. And it is like people are are, they're very connected to it. It's become part of their routine, very similar to to James Clear's.
- 20:43But newsletters are top of the funnel. And typically, I don't like giving a formula for a newsletter because I think a newsletter is just part of an email strategy. Whereas your email strategy should be like, for example, someone subscribes to your list, you give them a welcome sequence. And that welcome sequence, it's a series of like three to five emails, and you're introducing them to who you are and what to... What they should expect from you and maybe your best of and you're linking them back to different content that you have.
- 21:12And then once they complete the welcome sequence, they get funneled into your newsletter or, you know, and you might be pulling them and trying to better understand who they are and what they want from you, why they came to you in general. And then, you know, the newsletter might be a component of your email strategy, but it's usually not your email strategy. And I find that typically, so many folks are like focusing all of their energy on their newsletter, but they're not thinking of how newsletter is part of the much bigger picture into, you know, a very successful, email strategy.
- 21:45Fred: Fascinating. I I love that. It's such it's such a... You don't think about... Everyone thinks about it as, oh, I've just gotta get a newsletter out there.
- 21:51I don't think about it as part of the... That entire strategy around it. But you know what you were saying about people waiting to receive the newsletter? It's so funny because, you know, we do, like, a lot of events. We meet a lot of people in different ways.
- 22:02And the amount of time I've walked up to someone and say where I'm from and they're like, oh, we get your newsletter. We really like it. And we... It's one of those things you hear constantly. It's like the news that a big a key part of what you do, but you sometimes don't realize the impact of that.
- 22:15And it can really help that consistent connection with the audience if you don't see them that often too, kind of, in terms of building that up. We do have a lot of creators that want to start newsletters. They don't know where to start. They're frightened to start, but also they sometimes think it might be too late to start where they are. That's...
- 22:34Does that make sense?
- 22:36Haley: I mean, it makes sense. I don't agree with it, but it makes sense. I mean, that's no different than someone saying, like, you know, it... Is it too late to start a podcast? Is it too late to start social media?
- 22:47The number one key contributor to success for any creator... And I've been working at Kit, you know, in the creator economy for nearly a decade. The number one single biggest contributor is, persistence and showing up week over week over week. So it's not always the biggest creators. It is the people that are showing up over and over and over and over again.
- 23:12And that's with any of their content. You know, that's with the podcast that they're putting out. Usually, it's like the four hundredth episode or something that finally hits. And I feel like, you know, the newsletter is is the same. And here's the thing, if you know your audience, I think one of the things...
- 23:26And this goes back to the conversation centered around your newsletter being the asset or part of your whole email strategy is if you know what the purpose of your newsletter is, if it's providing value, you know your audience, and you're saying, okay, is this providing value to my audience? It's really easy to obviously continue showing up and, you know, sharing your ideas or whatever the case may be. But again, a newsletter is just like one small part of it. And so I think that oftentimes too many people are focusing on the newsletter versus, like, the whole big picture. And I'll give you like a...
- 24:05Like, let me give you like a simple example. Is a lot of, like, authors, like, we have a lot of authors on our platform. We have, you know, so many New York Times bestsellers. Like, I could spit off hundreds, maybe not hundreds off the top of my head, but certainly 20 just off the top of my head. And the email list is, like, the single biggest contributor to their book launch and their book sales and even publishers giving them a very good book deal.
- 24:33And it is fascinating. We run this mastermind in partnership with James Clear, and I've sat around some of the biggest authors in the world. And when you hear them talk about how their newsletter fuels, like, their book launch or how their newsletter fuels the rest of their email strategy, it's it's really fascinating. Because the automations, the the automations that allow you to, you know, let's say, prepare for a book launch or a course launch or whatnot, that's actually where the real revenue is coming from. And they're using...
- 25:04So their newsletter is top of the funnel, and then they're trying to bring them down into something that is going to help them better sell some proprietary products that they have or IP, whether that be a book or whether that be coaching services or whether that be, you know, a course or whatnot. So the newsletter is top of the funnel, and it's just that recurring thing that keeps you top of mind. And then you're... Showing up week over week over week, but it's usually the isolated automations that are actually making you the real money. I don't know if I even answered your question there.
- 25:37I kind of just, like, went off on all things email strategy as a whole.
- 25:42Franky: But it it does show how involved it is. I mean, the world of newsletters and emails is is just it it can be scary. And I and I was gonna say, if you had a creator who did have a million followers at Plus More, who... You know, they've built such a a big social following. What would you say to them if they're like, should I start up, you know, an email?
- 26:07What would you tell them to think about immediately before actually doing it? Because even with that following, it could be too early for them to actually start doing it.
- 26:17Haley: That's a good question. And the first thing is I'll say is you're definitely too late. Meaning, you should have started yesterday. So if you have a million followers on social media, I like to share the metric that you should aim to have 30% of your social followers on your email list. And that is purely from an ownership perspective.
- 26:38And so what I'm aiming, like, that is a more valuable asset than you have. And so you and 30% of your content on social media should be driving traffic back to an owned asset. And that meaning, like, your email list or your website, and your website is therefore has a pop up. Right? And there's a conversion tool there that allows you...
- 26:58So, like, 30% of your content should be pushing back towards, like, something that you own. And so you only have... Especially with the algorithm on social media, like, you only have so many opportunities for someone to see you that's brand new, and you should try to be converting them to an owned asset as quickly as possible. And so I would say if you have a large social following, you should have started your email list yesterday because, again, it's the only thing that you own. Now here's the, like, differentiators.
- 27:25Like, what do you do with that once you have it? So you have a million followers on social media, you decide I'm gonna start a newsletter. And so the... And then to your point, you're like, it doesn't need to be all that involved. Right?
- 27:37I I, like, can work through, like, a very deep, you know, nuanced, you know, email strategy. But really at the end of the day, what I suggest to people is come up with a theme, come up with a day to send it, and send it every single... Like, you know, Thursdays at 02:00. And if if like James Clear, your your theme is three two one, come up with whatever your theme is, and make it something that's easy to easy to write and repeatable and something that you can write in under an hour. So, I think, typically, what people...
- 28:12You know, they they don't want to get started because they're like, they overthink how hard it's going to be. And I'm like, look. James Clear's... Or not even James Clear. We'll use Tim Ferriss.
- 28:21Tim Ferriss's newsletter, one of the most well loved newsletters in the world. It's five bullets, friends. It's so simple. Like, don't overthink it. Come up with a theme, make it super simple, show up in the inbox at the same day, the same time, every single week, and communicate something and like, you know, you're talking to an actual friend.
- 28:43And do it, make it make sure that it's something that's repeatable. And if you can do that, the rest will follow. You know, the rest of... You'll become more advanced as time progresses. You can add in your welcome sequence as time progresses.
- 28:58You can sell your course or whatever it is that you're selling as time progresses. You can plug in your affiliate links as time progresses, but just show up and provide value week over week.
- 29:07Franky: It's like a being a really good mate. Consistent consistent, and people find comfort in, like, being familiar. So they're like, I know exactly what's coming in this email. It's gonna be the... I don't have to overthink it.
- 29:22They're just gonna be there, and they're gonna tell me what I like. It's just like, it's been a good mate. So Exactly. Good mate. Yeah.
- 29:29Fred: It's... It's... We also tell creators foundationally, especially those in the emerging space that consistency is the sort of bedrock of success. Right? And consistency equals connection.
- 29:38The more consistent you are, the more can... More you can connect with your audience. So it's in the same way... It works in the same way for email. It works in the same way for a lot of things.
- 29:46But Mhmm. For some reason, when it comes to email or or or any other type of marketing, they they they don't do what they've done so well in the content space, which is which is funny, or in the in the video space.
- 29:59Haley: I was just gonna say, think people... Like, the medium for some reason writing seems so much harder for so many people. And I think that's because people just think long form. And I'm like, don't overthink it so much. Short form writing can be just as effective, and oftentimes more valuable if you know...
- 30:21Like, if you know what your audience wants from you, short form writing can can do exactly what it needs, what it needs to do, and so there's nothing to be afraid of.
- 30:30Fred: Nice. You did mention James Clear as example. Do you have any sort of more endemic creators in terms of, like, the creator economy, whether they're from YouTube or TikTok or Insta or something who've been able to utilize newsletters really well? Do you have any examples around that?
- 30:44Haley: Yeah. We have, the first YouTuber that popped into my brain is chef Nick, chef Nick Diagevani, and he's a great example. He was he was a really fun team, to onboard. And, he had kind of a unique... So he has one newsletter that's under not chef Nick on YouTube.
- 31:06He has actually two brands. And for him, he didn't own... He had no email list really. And then he had, didn't have a website. So, like, traditional food content creators have a website, and they're actually driving traffic back to their website to drive...
- 31:24Like, they're a publisher, so they're driving to get revenue through ads. And so that's traditionally how, like, food or travel creators are making revenue. And so Nick built out, like, a website that allowed him to optimize for ad traffic, and so email was supporting that. And so he was driving traffic back from his YouTube videos, and then he had a call to action there, and then he was using that to drive traffic back to his site to get ad revenue elsewhere. So, like, that's, you know, one example.
- 31:53John Yushai, who's, like, known as the Creator's Creator, like, he's a great example and a friend, and he's been a fun person to watch on YouTube grow as well. Other creators... I mean, we have a ton of, like, social creators that are just learning how to dig into, like, newsletters and what the actual value of newsletters is. A lot of social creators that have gone on to build their own podcast or create their own podcast, and they're trying to figure out what their podcast flywheel is. Very similar to newsletters, podcasts have the same problem with newsletters and that they're hard to go viral, for example.
- 32:32You know? And so you really have to figure out how you're going to get people to subscribe. And so it's been fun to kind of, help podcast listeners, which is like a very intimate medium. Right? You know, people are in your head in a very similar way newsletter subscribers are in your email box, right, which is we talked about that being an intimate space.
- 32:52But it's really fun to like, collaborations happen, and I'll give you a really good example from a product perspective, for podcasters. And so we'll just use Emma Greed and James Clear as an example. So we have a product called the Creator Network, and the Creator Network essentially allows creators to recommend one another. And so if a creator is on... Two creators are on kit, when someone subscribes to your newsletter, a pop up will pop up.
- 33:17Right? And it'll say, if you like my content, you'd likely like these other, you know, three content creators content as well. And, you know, with one click, you can follow all of them. You can follow some of them, so on and so forth. And so that's typically based on, like, the growth rate.
- 33:30Right? The number of new subscribers that someone is getting on a daily basis. And so maybe you're getting, you know, 500 to two, you know, five to 200 new subscribers a day based on the total number of people that are following you. However, if you... Let's say, you know, James went on Emma Greed's podcast, and they do actually a podcast swap, and they send out their newsletter, and they say, I was just on Emma Greed's podcast.
- 33:57And, if you'd like to follow her newsletter, click here, and then, you know, it automatically with a one click subscribe. Now mind you, that's going out to James', we'll just say millions of subscribers, email subscribers. It gives you an opportunity to then, be promoted to someone's entire list versus just a percentage of people that are newly subscribed. And so that I call, like, the podcast flywheel. And so if you're doing, a podcast swap, they're both both creators are on kit, That's a great way to that's a great way to grow very quickly if your creators are willing to do that, and it makes sense in the context of your newsletter.
- 34:37Fred: Yeah. I was gonna ask because people have said it's, you know, it's always a... Like, you know, with the algorithmic feeds from, like, YouTube and TikTok, the growth or subscribership is a lot easier than, for example, a podcast or or a newsletter. So that's a Yeah. A really interesting way to do it.
- 34:51I mean, do you... Have you heard of any other interesting ways people have grown their newsletter databases?
- 34:55Haley: I mean, of course, paid subscribers. So, you know, if you're using, let's say, a tool like Spark Loop, which you, can use, with Kit. We actually own Spark Loop. But, with a tool like Spark Loop, you know, you can pay for subscribers and you can, build custom audiences and kinda put in a bunch of parameters on on what you're looking for. That is one method.
- 35:16I do feel like with paid subscribers, that the quality of the subscriber, you know, is something that is is sometimes they can be excellent and sometimes not so excellent. And so you really have to, like, get really intentional, with how you're using and paying for subscribers. But what I do see is when people, are paying for their subscribers that they're often not doing the appropriate follow-up work once that subscriber lands in your inbox. And so what I mean by that is when someone is a paid subscriber, the first thing... It's like when someone walks into your house.
- 35:52Right? If you don't... They just walk into your house and you have no idea who they are, and they're like, where am I? How did I get here? And they're unsure of how they got there.
- 36:02And oftentimes, honestly, the subscribers don't actually know how they got there. I always like to give them more credit than, I think I should. But the appropriate thing to do is to, you know, say, hi. It's so nice to meet you, Fred. You landed in my inbox because we have a mutual friend in James Clear.
- 36:23Well, let me tell you about a little bit about me, about what to expect from me. This is how often I email. This is the content that I talk about. Is there any of this content? Are you particularly interested in this or this?
- 36:36You know, click the link, and you're introducing yourself. So I I do find that when people are leveraging, those methods that they're not always doing, we'll call it just hospitable thing of like inviting people into the world. So they end up those subscribers end up not engaging, in always, the way that they had initially hoped. So, but paid subscribers is way that a lot of people are growing, and some people have got it really dialed in, which is fun to watch. What other ways are people growing?
- 37:10ManyChat, of course. ManyChat, I'm sure you all are familiar with ManyChat. From a social perspective, every creator that is trying to own their audience should be using, like, a DM to automation tool. One of my favorite creators, Gannon Meyer, I'm sure you all are familiar with him, but he's a ManyChat expert. He teaches lots of folks how to grow their audience with ManyChat, and, that is just, like, such an easy tool that really allows people to convert, your social followers in, like, a great way, or an easy way.
- 37:45That tool, I think, is getting... I I think you have to get creative in how you're doing that as well because it's so prevalent, and you do want it to feel high touch. And I think there's a lot of great ways, that people are doing that.
- 38:00Franky: Yeah. I I was gonna say you do have to be careful with that because I'm finding more and more people are commenting now for for the the DM automation, and they're trolling it in a way. Yeah. So some people are like, it's good for the, you know, getting your post out there, but then it it is actually becoming a problem now. So again,
- 38:19Fred: it is it is giving that value and clarity on what you're offering.
- 38:23Haley: Yeah. Yeah. I think there's... I mean, you know, automation has its pros and its cons, meaning, like, you know, it's it's not as high touch, so it doesn't feel like everybody knows that it's not coming from that particular creator anymore. But if you are making it easier for them to get the thing that they want from you, I think the, we'll call it just like the casual social follower.
- 38:45So, like, I use it all the time. And I use it all the time because it's it's an easy way for me to get what I want from that creator, and I know exactly what's happening. And I think most consumers know what's what's happening there.
- 38:57Fred: Mhmm. I greatly appreciate the email masterclass here. I I Yeah. Didn't expect to get as many great tips as have. I've been sort of writing notes in the background furiously.
- 39:07Franky: Been talking me. Thread of just being a
- 39:10Fred: good mate. Just being a good mate. Welcome them to
- 39:13Franky: your house. Like, make them a tea. Yeah.
- 39:17Fred: Yeah. Yeah. Talking about that, I guess, that intimate aspect of of what email can be and that connection you build with it too. The other part of your job is obviously community and events and running that. And I wanted...
- 39:29I do wanna talk about that. I mean, it's a little bit different to email, but it's still that deeper connection element, which is becoming particularly prevalent, especially in the age of AI. So we run live events. We love live events. We can see firsthand the incredible power they have.
- 39:45Do you feel that, I guess, live events are gonna be one of, obviously, a very big thing going forward given what I've just mentioned about Age of AI and lack of connection?
- 39:57Haley: So I've been I've I've been doing events since I I joined Kit. Right? And I feel like in the last several years, it's gotten easier and easier for me to get my budget approved because people realize the importance of events. And I I joke and I and I... And I'm not even joking.
- 40:14I'm just saying factually that I could look at our list of a top top winner, top 100 or 200 accounts, you know, largest creators. And I can say, this is where I met them. This is when I... You know, what event it was at. This is what dinner we we attended together.
- 40:29And I think that's true for myself and Nathan, our CEO, and I spend a lot of time on the road being in person with creators. And if... You know, going back to, like, the very first thing that I said, is that I learned so quickly here that this is an industry and like who you know, and that, you know, people trust you. And at the end of the day, this is the way that I think about it. And we can talk about the studios as it relates to this as well.
- 40:54But, at a certain point, many of the platforms out there, especially with the advancements in AI, they are like, there's going to become feature parity, or we're getting closer and closer to feature parity. And so there ends up being brand loyalty and then relational loyalty, to our people. And I know that there are people that would never leave kit because I've invested and poured into them and made sure that I checked in on their launches and made sure that their, you know, their accounts were operating the way they should and made sure when they had their first kid, you know, that we celebrated them or celebrated their accomplishments as it related to becoming a creator. And so, like, we've just invested so much time to be in community with our people. I know that's a differentiator, for many people when they're thinking about choosing Kit.
- 41:42But oftentimes, like, that is the differentiator, you know, for us in the studios, you know, and for those of you who are unfamiliar, Kit Studios is a free podcast video production studio, that is free with your customers. So, you know, free for our customers if you're a Kit subscriber. And so you get six hours of free recording time on one plan and twelve on another, if you're a kit subscriber. And that can be easily worth a thousand dollars sort of thing. And so that's a big differentiator when it comes to separating our brand apart from, let's say, Substack, for example, you know, or or Beehive, for example.
- 42:23And most creators, I would say most now, this is exclusive to everyone, but most creators are really only using 20% of a platform's capacity. You know, it's like you're like, oh, I use 2% of my brain. Most creators are only using, you know, so much of a platform's functionality. And so this is a real differentiator. If you're recording in the city...
- 42:44In any city where we have a kit studios and you're paying a podcast studio for $500, a month, it's it's a no brainer, even if the product... Even if you're happy with a competing product. So we... And we also know that every time they come into the studio, that they get stickier and stickier because I get to help them, I get to chat with them, I get to ask about the last thing that they did. I get to, you know, let them sit in my studio with $1,520,000 dollars worth of equipment, and all they have to do is press a single button.
- 43:15And it's just time and time again that I get to offer them connection and humanity.
- 43:21Fred: Yeah. It's that strategy with that multiple touch points. Right? You've got all those things, and then they... You build that level of intimacy as you get to actually connect with them in person through
- 43:28Haley: Yeah.
- 43:28Fred: Seeing them turn up to the studio. That's excellent. Do a lot of people take up the offer of having the free studios?
- 43:34Haley: They do they do. Our space in New York, we're at, like, probably 60 capacity right now. We only opened in June. And so we have... It's the coolest thing to see.
- 43:45Like, you come into the studios, and you see two creators that didn't know they were there that day. You see one creator that really wanted to meet someone else. You know? It was like, I watched one of my friends meet Mark Manson for the first time, and he walked into the studios, and his eyes were, like, full... He was...
- 44:03It was the coolest moment, you know, and he does, like yap walk and talks. So he goes out and does like street interviews. And, you know, Mark left and he's like, hey, man, like, you know, can I go out and do this this yacht with you? And it's so fun, you know, to see little moments like that happen between creators that have always wanted to meet, that haven't had the chance to meet in person, to creators that are admiring or seeing some creator that's had some big impact on their their career as a creator, their life. So, you know, it's it's really fun to to watch all those moments happen in the studios.
- 44:37Fred: I was also reading there. Are you... Do you name your studio after Taylor Swift songs? Is that that right? Yeah.
- 44:44Is there one called Bad Blood for when there's, like, some beef? No.
- 44:48Haley: There's not a Bad Blood yet. I feel like, though, I will say in Chicago, we are taking over a few additional rooms in Chicago, right now. So I have a few studios to name, and I feel like Bad Blood should be on the list. But, yes, they are all named after Taylor Swift songs. And, Nathan, our CEO, is...
- 45:12Now I'm a Swifty. I am. Okay. I fully admit, like, yeah, she she... I am serious about this, but I I really think that going to the Heiress tour was one of the top five greatest moments of my life.
- 45:27I really do. And and Nathan, our CEO is 10 x the Swifty that I am. And we we made a joke with one we were gonna call his studio, the alchemy. And then we're like, we should do this for every studio. And we just...
- 45:48We went all in. You know? We went all in. And so, yes, everyone is named after a Taylor Swift song.
- 45:53Franky: Is there a Studio twenty two?
- 45:56Haley: There's not a Studio twenty two.
- 45:57Fred: Because, yeah, you could rip that from, like, Studio sixty four and have, like, disco.
- 46:02Haley: Yeah. That is true. No. I'm in I'm in wildest dreams right now. We have Okay.
- 46:07In New York. We have wildest dreams. Welcome to New York, obviously. Lavender haze, long live, blank space, which is fun because blank space is a green screen. So we have like a giant...
- 46:22So it's like it can be whatever you want it to look like. Blank space and then actually romantic. Nice. And so, yeah, it is very fun. They're like, I'm an Actually Romantic today.
- 46:33And I'm like, yeah, you are. Yeah. You are.
- 46:35Fred: Is there is there a Taylor Swift song that would be inappropriate to put it for this DDNA? I don't know many.
- 46:41Haley: There will be many... Actually, that is... We've had a harder time. This was a harder, studio because many of them are about, like, love and drama. You know?
- 46:52And I do try to have them. Like, for example, Wildest Dreams. Like, live your wildest dreams, creator. You're digging... Like, you know, like, you can you can, come up with some connections.
- 47:04Lavender haze is fun because it's a very mid century designed room. I've got these, like, vintage Mario Bellini chairs in there that are just sexy as hell. And it just... With this, like, awesome brick backdrop, and, it just... Her her music video in Lavender Haze is, like, set in this cool mid century house.
- 47:22So it just... You know, they all... They they just come to me. You know? They just...
- 47:26They come to me. I do have, one that's called actually romantic. Because every once in a while, we get a competitor that really... It's like cute. You know, it's actually romantic how much they talk about us.
- 47:41I'll let you guys keep that, you know, imagine who you think that is. But we do have one that's named actually romantic. And they're all for, like, fun inside stories.
- 47:51Fred: I had a really quick question that I really wanted to pick
- 47:53Franky: your brains about because being in the event space, and as soon as you said budget, I was like, it's like my ears have pricked up trying to get trying to get budgets up. But when budget is tight, what's the one thing that you will always spend your money on?
- 48:10Haley: As it relates to producing your own event?
- 48:12Franky: Yeah. So we do a lot of creator events where we get pretty much every... We wanna get everyone in a room. We either teach them, like, a workshop with a guest speaker. It's at like a pub or a club or somewhere that's not corporate.
- 48:25It's not like a Yeah. White carpet, white wall.
- 48:30Haley: I don't know if this is exactly gonna give you the answer you want for your context. I would say production. And the reason why I say that is because Craft and Commerce, which is our conference, and I've produced pretty much since the beginning, and... Or been a part since the very, very beginning and produced really since, 2018. But, I think that we have one of the best conferences in the industry, and I think we have the highest production value.
- 48:57You know, we have the most insane l e... I mean... And we're talking for, like, our size company. Of course, you know, there's huge production companies, you know, that are are... Like, you know, we'll say Adobe Max.
- 49:08Adobe Max, like, you know, it's not Adobe Max quality. But I do think that production, quality really makes a big difference between a mediocre event and an excellent event. The other one is we actually pay for our... We do keynote speakers and workshops. So we do a little bit of both, but we actually pay for our keynote speakers to work with a speaking coach.
- 49:31We're so invested in their success. And so when we put you on our stage, we have you work with a speaking coach. I curate every one of the talks that goes onto our stage, our main stage and our workshops. Mhmm. And so typically, I am...
- 49:48I... We don't take speaker. We don't take... Like, people don't apply to speak necessarily. Like, typically, it all comes directly through me.
- 49:59And I am typically curating, like, a brand new talk with someone. We put a lot of, like, first time speakers on the stage. And so... Yeah. So we we want them to be successful.
- 50:10We want it to be successful, and so we we pay for a speaking coach for them. And so that's that's something that's a huge differentiator that every... I mean, I saw your faces. Right? You were
- 50:20Fred: like, what?
- 50:21Haley: Everyone is always really shocked, by the fact that we do that.
- 50:27Fred: Yeah. That's that's amazing. We we're actually running a conference next year in middle of next year. I think it's basically talking about the crossover between the creator economy and traditional media, what that looks like. Yeah.
- 50:39And one of the big things we we... We're looking at is, like, how do we make sure that the speaker quality is really high? And is that that curation makes such a big difference. Right? So...
- 50:48And... But I love the idea of getting a a speaking coach. Or Yeah. Yeah. Mean, I'm sure that
- 50:53Haley: would make
- 50:53Fred: big difference.
- 50:54Haley: I don't do is I don't do panels. I actually despise panels. And panels can only in my mind work well if you have an excellent moderator. Otherwise, it ends up just being like one question and then one person answers and the next person answers and the next person and it's not a... It's just not a good or compelling conversation where people are, like, furiously writing notes.
- 51:16And so I feel like most creator events focus on panels. And so we really push our creators to do... Like, they do twenty minute style, but essentially, yeah, twenty minute keynotes, and a little bit longer depending on, like, if it's a form like a a... Like Chris Donnelly came and, you know, did forty five minutes or an hour or something. So we'd obviously make exceptions, but we do keynote blocks...
- 51:39Two keynote blocks a day and two workshop blocks. Yeah.
- 51:44Franky: And with the keynotes, do you have... Do you open it up for q and a after? So it's No. No. Okay.
- 51:51Haley: No. No. We don't. We do... May...
- 51:55Maybe with the final keynote. So this year, we did we did one. James Clear hadn't come back for nearly a decade. It was nine years. And so he didn't do a formal keynote.
- 52:05He did, like, a fireside chat with Nathan, our CEO. And then we had q and a open for for James afterwards. And so we had, like, 10 or 15 questions, that came up afterwards. But... No.
- 52:17And typically, our keynotes also do a workshop as well. So typically, keynotes, they're on the stage, they're doing their keynote, and then they go in and they deep dive into their particular skill. But the keynote might be, I'd say, like, my takeaways. I say, okay. For a keynote, I want someone to write no more than, like, two pages of notes on, like, an a five, like, notebook.
- 52:41Right? They're so locked in because they're... It almost like they're watching a movie. You know? They're so locked in with this idea that you're communicating where a workshop, right, you've got the big notebook out.
- 52:51They're furiously writing. You know? They're taking notes. They're working off a PDF. Like, it's much more of a deep dive.
- 52:57And so we're we're optimizing for that on the keynote side of things. So it's just a slightly different... It's more of like a TED talk style.
- 53:06Fred: Very interesting. And, Haley, I was... Had a a a more questions, but we... We've actually run out of time, unfortunately. But but before we go, I just wanna quickly say, mean, it's a bit...
- 53:17It's a big product, and I think it's been around for a while. I think sometimes creators don't know how to engage with it. From everything you said, it sounds... You know, I'm... I...
- 53:24We we don't actually... We use we use a competitor's product, unfortunately, but I'm thinking about converting now.
- 53:29Haley: Okay. Okay. You got you got it on camera.
- 53:33Fred: Yeah. But what what would be the first step? Where's the easiest place to get information or start up and or do... What what would you recommend as the first step for any creator who's keen to to use Kit?
- 53:43Haley: Yeah. I mean, you get a free trial. So just go to kit.com and you can get a free trial. And I mean, I would just say if you wanna come check out the studios, if you're anywhere in New York City, Chicago, or Boise, Idaho, which is probably a little bit less unlikely. But you can come check out the studios and hang out with me or Nathan, and obviously, we can talk to you about the product and and tool and whatnot.
- 54:08Yeah, if you just go to kit.com, then you can grab a free trial and explore the product. And then we have, an entire onboarding team. We have the best onboarding team in the industry, and so they will fully migrate you from... Actually, I think I just heard that you said you were gonna migrate. I've got the migrations team, on standby.
- 54:28Fred: And... My gosh. You're good at sales.
- 54:30Haley: It's alright. We can have it done in five days, maybe even less, depending on the number of subscribers that you have. We'll build out your welcome sequences, your automations. In fact, you're, I'm sure there are some podcasters, that I know that I can go on that are Kit customers. We can set up that, you know, that podcasting flywheel we talked about.
- 54:53So you let me know when you're ready. Wow.
- 54:55Fred: Amazing. You saw me. I feel as if that's like a look what you made me do moment. Yeah. Awesome.
- 55:05Haley, thank you so much for joining us.
- 55:07Haley: Thank you. Thank you. Happy to be here.