Latest / Before you say yes / Ep. 11 Why joint accounts and share debt can cost you everything: Sue Fraser OAM uncut
Transcript
- 0:00Can we dive in because I love to do a bit of nerd alert and into what some of these terms are that we are agreeing to that we might not understand.
- 0:10And I've had a lot of conversations with people about joint and several liability.
- 0:16Do you know what that means?
- 0:17And most people think it means, oh, it's a 50-50 loan.
- 0:21What is joint and several liability?
- 0:23And tell me some other areas that we
- 0:30Yeah.
- 0:30If someone has a contract where it's jointly and severally liable, it means that if they can't get the money from me, they'll get it from you.
- 0:38So that if I'm out of the picture, 100% of that debt will come to you and you'll be pursued for that.
- 0:45Yeah, that's a big realisation.
- 0:48Where are some of the other contractual obligations that people might not understand what they've signed up to and what that means to them?
- 0:57Look, it can be something as simple as an electricity bill.
- 1:02I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 1:03I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 1:12This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:23So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:29I'm Susan Fraser.
- 1:31What I do and have been doing for many years now is to work across with consumers and with people with lived experiences and then translate that into systems change in businesses and in regulation.
- 1:42And we've known each other for some time now.
- 1:44A long time.
- 1:45I've learnt so much from you, Sue, about your work and also particularly about how you talk to people about some stuff that's complex or emotional without making people feel silly or ashamed.
- 2:00And so I really want to explore some of that as we have this conversation.
- 2:04Yeah, of course.
- 2:05Tell me a bit about how you came to do this work.
- 2:08I was thinking about this just the other day.
- 2:12I found myself at 22 and a half with a new baby and single.
- 2:17My husband at the time decided that parenthood was just too much responsibility and he went fishing one weekend and didn't come home.
- 2:25So very quickly I came from a
- 2:28a young country girl who thought she could do anything and everything, to starting a career, finding out that's not how things work.
- 2:37The expectation if you treat people with dignity and respect went out the window really quickly.
- 2:42And the expectations of life changed because they had to.
- 2:48So from there I realised that I was then treated differently because I was a young single mother.
- 2:54And no one particularly cared how or why that happened, only that you were.
- 2:59And therefore you were a risk to other people.
- 3:01And we're talking 50 years ago.
- 3:03I didn't know anyone else at that stage who was single.
- 3:06And things like childcare provisions were almost non-existent.
- 3:09It was just a different space.
- 3:11And the way banks behaved was also quite different than they do now.
- 3:16So although I didn't realise it, I continued to work across the community sector with predominantly young women, with young children, in helping them build capability and capacity and to understand how the world works.
- 3:31And that was a fantastic grounding for me in terms of recognising and coming to the realisation of my situation and then working with them to work that through.
- 3:42Were you almost learning together as you were doing that work?
- 3:45Absolutely we were.
- 3:46You know, not just in parenting as a single person, but how to have secure housing, how to navigate the financial marketplace.
- 3:55At that stage, I went to the bank to get a loan to buy my husband out and it was at a fixed 19%.
- 4:03So that next 12 months was actually three jobs, one to live, one to bank $400 a month that was the requirement, and one to meet my present debts and living expenses.
- 4:14Crazy.
- 4:15That's extraordinary.
- 4:16Yeah.
- 4:17And look at you now.
- 4:18So you must have helped.
- 4:20thousands of people over your career.
- 4:23Tens of thousands.
- 4:25Tens of thousands.
- 4:26Amazing.
- 4:27You didn't mention the word financial counsellor.
- 4:30Can you explain to me what a financial counsellor is?
- 4:34I fell into financial counselling.
- 4:36It wasn't a career choice.
- 4:38And that's really how my life's gone.
- 4:40That something jumps up and you think, oh, that sounds really interesting.
- 4:43I'll give that a go.
- 4:44Or
- 4:45I've been asked to do something I don't think I have the capability to do, so what do I need to learn to be able to do that respectfully to people and with people?
- 4:53So I became a financial counsellor in the mid-80s.
- 4:56I was working for the state government designing programs that addressed what they called fuel poverty, so people who couldn't afford the energy that they were using but also couldn't make the changes they needed to make.
- 5:07And part of that was to do a financial assessment.
- 5:11And I thought, not equipped for this.
- 5:13I'll go and find a course that will equip me.
- 5:17So I found then the Financial Counselling Association of Victoria and there was a couple of us who were working in that other program.
- 5:27And they said, oh, no, we don't train anyone who's not working in the sector.
- 5:32And my response is, that's OK.
- 5:33I'll send you 40 referrals a week.
- 5:36to do that assessment for me and then we'll talk.
- 5:39Well, that lasted half a week and they came back with the notion that if I'm a reasonable advocate, I should be on their side of the fence, not the other.
- 5:47And that was the beginning of a financial counselling career, effectively, which just showed me where the gaps were rather than where the strengths were.
- 5:56So financial counsellors are free and independent.
- 5:58They provide information to anyone who comes in to help navigate their financial position and their debt position.
- 6:06So they might resource someone to be able to advocate on their own behalf.
- 6:11or in some circumstances they may advocate for that person until they're able to get back on their feet.
- 6:17But in about 1999, maybe 2000, I was finding that women were coming to see me from all over Melbourne, and not because I was fabulous, but because I was female.
- 6:30And it started the thinking that we actually need a family violence financial counsellor who specialised in that space.
- 6:36So I got funding and we put that role in place and learnt from it over the next few years.
- 6:42And it was not just emergency and crisis discussions, it was how to remain financially stable in a really turbulent time, how to think about and protect yourself with joint assets.
- 6:56It was things that we probably knew but we hadn't thought about as a specialty.
- 7:02And pleasingly, now there's probably 24 or 5 funded family violence financial counselors in the state.
- 7:08Yeah, that's extraordinary.
- 7:10And you were one of the pioneers to start talking about, researching, writing about economic abuse and really started charting a course that now I think we're having a much bigger conversation about.
- 7:28How did you see that show up?
- 7:31It was partly seeing women from all over the shop.
- 7:35It was around trying to advocate on people's behalf and there's not being regulatory requirements to support people leaving and stabilising after economic abuse or financial abuse.
- 7:47There simply weren't the protections there, but clearly there needed to be.
- 7:52So part of that work was around documenting what we were seeing
- 7:55how and what people needed, then petitioning businesses to do better and then ombudsmen and regulators to do better.
- 8:05And most of them have, but we're not there yet.
- 8:07No.
- 8:07I mean, that's part of the other challenge.
- 8:09Yeah, yeah.
- 8:11What change have you seen over the time and then what changes do you think need to happen?
- 8:16I think there's enormous change in terms of regulation and expectation.
- 8:21I mean, in the banking industry, they talk about extra care.
- 8:24Well, no one knows what that means.
- 8:26But it's also about...
- 8:29than being much more alert to someone saying, I've been financially manipulated or I can't control my accounts or someone's taken my money or they've had access to it in a way that I haven't given authority.
- 8:41So those sort of conversations are much more regularly occurring now and the businesses now have an expectation to hear just not what's being said but what's not being said and then putting a strategy in place to support them.
- 8:54You know, the issue of safety and accounts and joint names and who can access what.
- 8:59is it about you've been leading for the last few years?
- 9:01But again, it's about we saw it for years but didn't name it.
- 9:06And then there's something that happens and it just focuses your energy on this is wrong.
- 9:12This needs to change.
- 9:13Yeah.
- 9:15I want to maybe wind back a little bit too because one of the reasons that I'm doing this podcast is because...
- 9:24I think a lot of people might go into a relationship, everything's wonderful and rosy, and sometimes they just fall into financial arrangements or who's going to be on whatever account without necessarily being conscious of that or having an open discussion about it.
- 9:45And we've been talking about the idea of consent as well, about when can you say no to some things that you might not want to do.
- 9:51Can you talk a little bit about when you're starting to share money and bills in relationships, what happens in real life?
- 10:00And when does it look good?
- 10:02What's the good, healthy approach versus when there might be some problematic approaches?
- 10:08I think one of the things that we often forget about is to be realistic.
- 10:13At the very beginning of a relationship, you know, how do the norms get formed?
- 10:18What sort of behaviour is acceptable?
- 10:19What's not?
- 10:21You know, is it okay to have 20 phone calls a day to find out where you are and who you're talking to?
- 10:26And no, no is the answer.
- 10:28You know, it's about thinking around what the motivation behind the behaviour is before you even get to the money stuff.
- 10:35And to make sure that our self-talk, women's self-talk is around, is this what I want?
- 10:41Is this what I want in the long term?
- 10:43How do I protect my personal integrity and financial base?
- 10:47And what am I prepared to discuss away or agree to differently?
- 10:51But we need to have that conversation with ourselves first before we have it with someone else.
- 10:57And if someone's come from a difficult family environment, often the self-talk is quite negative.
- 11:02And that absolutely leads to people having less assertion around what their rights are and what it is they're entitled to.
- 11:09Yeah.
- 11:10We were just talking to Angie Wan from Consent Labs and she talks about going into schools and their programs are starting with boundaries too.
- 11:24What do I...
- 11:25What do I believe in?
- 11:27Where's my threshold, I suppose, before they're then having the conversation about how do we negotiate the way that this partnership's going to work?
- 11:37So it sounds to me a very similar concept about know yourself and who you are, what you will and won't do, what you want and what you don't want.
- 11:49And I think some sort of thought around in five years or 10 years or 20 years time, what do I want my life to be?
- 11:55And then you almost build backwards about, well, in order to have that, these are the things I need in place now.
- 12:00How hard is that for people to envisage a life that far ahead?
- 12:08I think we all have plans about what we'll do when we retire, you know, where we might live, where we might travel to.
- 12:14Hopefully they're not too far along our trajectory.
- 12:19But I think it's about just being open and honest with ourselves around that.
- 12:23I mean, I used to see lots of young people going into mortgages or even for guarantors for other people.
- 12:31in terms of money, and they almost always end in disaster because they didn't understand the consequence of what it was that they were signing.
- 12:39No one believes that they could lose their own house because they guaranteed someone else's loan.
- 12:44But if that was explained to them in an honest and open way, then you might have a different conversation and you might decide not to proceed.
- 12:52You know, when you look at relationships and the successful or unsuccessful rates of marriage...
- 12:58Surely we've got to think about what do you do first before you go into that, knowing that there's a chance that it might not be successful.
- 13:05It doesn't mean you're predetermining it.
- 13:07It means you're simply open to the opportunities.
- 13:10Yeah, and planning for the worst, expecting for the best.
- 13:13Yeah, absolutely.
- 13:15Why do you think it is so hard for people to have that conversation?
- 13:20It's like I feel like we almost can talk more about sex and what we want than about money.
- 13:27You talked about people growing up in various situations but it's also for people who may have grown up in a house where they have been assertive, money still seems icky.
- 13:39And what do you see and what have you seen in your work?
- 13:43Yeah, I think it's a division of labour.
- 13:47I mean, the way I understood money as a kid was mum had... Dad would come home, I don't know, whatever, probably Fridays, put his paycheck on the table.
- 13:55Mum would have jars on the mantelpiece and each jar would have a different purpose.
- 14:00So money would go into that and that was how I learned about budgeting.
- 14:04It didn't mean I was any good at it to start with, but that's how I saw it.
- 14:08And I just saw the cooperation between Dad brings it home and makes it available, they discuss what's going to happen and this is then how it happens.
- 14:16So Mum's responsibility, I guess, were the household bits and the internal bit and Dad's piece was the external management.
- 14:24And it's agreed by consensus rather than, well, I'll do this because I'm better at it and you're no good with money, so therefore I'll take control of it for you as well.
- 14:33And I think when we start out, regardless of where we end up, we're products of our environment.
- 14:40And, you know, as little kids, we used to get pocket money.
- 14:43We had to save half of it.
- 14:44We were allowed to spend half of it.
- 14:46So, again, it's subtle, but it's a way of thinking about you don't spend it all at once.
- 14:53And that just became the way.
- 14:55And there's three siblings, and we're all completely different.
- 14:58in how we manage money and what we've done with it over time.
- 15:01Yeah, even though you came from the same kind of...
- 15:03Same experience.
- 15:04...environment.
- 15:05Yeah, yeah.
- 15:06So can we get into some really practical tips around...
- 15:11If, say, someone...
- 15:12If people are starting to move in together, they're starting to share bills, sign a lease, open a joint account, maybe even start thinking about saving for really big expenses like a car or a home...
- 15:26what are they really agreeing to, whether they realise it or not?
- 15:32They're usually not agreeing to much in a voluntary informed capacity.
- 15:37You know, someone will have a credit card or get a credit card and there'll be a second card off that, but not understanding the financial and legal obligations that sit with it.
- 15:46When we buy a car together or when we buy a home together,
- 15:50You know, how that contract's structured is really important.
- 15:53And most people buy as joint owners.
- 15:57Some younger people are now buying as tenants in common, which means that if we have a house together and I conk out, my half can be willed to whoever I want it to be.
- 16:06Now, that might create a problem for you if I leave my half to someone who you might not get on with or don't think that's appropriate.
- 16:13But they're the discussions that need to happen.
- 16:16It's about how do we protect ourselves, but how do we protect each other?
- 16:20It's not always a one-way street.
- 16:23It's about being really clear about what it is that we've agreed to and understanding what the ramifications are.
- 16:29Yeah, can we dive in?
- 16:30Because I love to do a bit of nerd alert and into what some of these terms are that we are agreeing to that we might not understand.
- 16:39And I've had a lot of conversations with people about this contract could be joint and several liability.
- 16:47Do you know what that means?
- 16:49And most people think it means, oh, it's a 50-50 loan.
- 16:54Tell me, what is joint and several liability?
- 16:56And tell me some other areas that we should be looking for as well and understanding what is that legal construct?
- 17:03Yeah.
- 17:04If someone has a contract where it's jointly and severally liable, it means that if they can't get the money from me, they'll get it from you.
- 17:12so that if I'm out of the picture, 100% of that debt will come to you and you'll be pursued for that.
- 17:20Yeah, that's a big realisation.
- 17:22Yeah.
- 17:23A bit like you talked about guarantors as well.
- 17:26What does that mean for me?
- 17:28Where are some of the other sort of contractual obligations that people might not understand what they've signed up to and what that means to them?
- 17:37Look, it can be something as simple as an electricity bill.
- 17:40You know, the bill might be or the account might be in someone's name, but they might not have control of the finances.
- 17:49And in situations we've seen where it's been predatory and harming, someone's abused that account to have the bill be greater so someone else has got a greater burden.
- 18:01You know, when we first started identifying economic abuse in water, for example...
- 18:08Often partners who were very unhappy with the partner leaving would leave the taps on in a property so that the water would continue to run and the bill would be escalated.
- 18:18And eventually that will be caught up with.
- 18:20But it goes further than that.
- 18:21It goes to, even if the bill is only one person's name, in the account there'll be a secondary contact, which will often be the partner or whoever they're sharing their time with at that time.
- 18:33And when they in fact move on, that person's still a secondary contact because no one's ever remembered that that even existed.
- 18:40But it can be quite dangerous because if the person A with the account can't be contacted, they'll go to person B who might not know where they are or what's going on in their life.
- 18:50And we see that sort of thing across a range of accounts and people being, it's not mischievous, it's...
- 18:57It's deliberate in causing harm through money.
- 19:01In the time that you've done this work, you must have helped people kind of unpick that or notice it even.
- 19:09You know, if you're dealing with a whole lot of stuff that's happening in your life, you might not even realise that this has been set up.
- 19:16So what would you say to somebody who's just starting out?
- 19:20Which would be the most important things to start working on, knowing that it might be hard to remember or unpick later?
- 19:31There's the obvious things like joint accounts and financial products that need attention.
- 19:38But we often forget about things like superannuation and who the beneficiaries are.
- 19:43And very often one of the things I was seeing in the early days is women and children would leave a violent relationship
- 19:52And in one case, the woman died through other means and the husband, who'd been the perpetrator of violence, inherited her superannuation.
- 20:01Now, the family were outraged knowing that that would never have been her intent, but it was never changed.
- 20:06Yeah.
- 20:07And I know the government's now stepping in to try and change those rules because of those.
- 20:11So there's lots of those hidden exposures that we don't think about.
- 20:15Yeah.
- 20:15But certainly limiting financial harm is one of the greatest things that needs to be done really quickly.
- 20:23Making sure someone's got safe and accessible housing.
- 20:26Making sure their kids are being supported through the trauma that they've experienced.
- 20:32And to allow them the time to...
- 20:37Grieve is probably the word about the relationship that they thought they wanted and then how it dismantled itself or it was dismantled for them.
- 20:48And now it's time to recreate.
- 20:49So it's really important for people to have time through trauma to actually have the space to sit and think about stabilising and what does that mean for them.
- 21:02I mean, people don't actually know often what they need to do first, but they'll know how they want it to end.
- 21:07Yeah.
- 21:07So that if they can identify they want safe, affordable housing in an environment where they're not known, where they can start a career or change a career, where their kids can have safety and security in a new school environment, if they know how they want that to occur or what the end game should be, you can work backwards with them about what the steps they need to take are.
- 21:31Yeah, what's the first step and the next step and the next step.
- 21:34Yeah, and how do they know that they're...
- 21:37they're actually doing it rather than someone's doing it for them.
- 21:40Now, there's always, always room and always a requirement for people to be given high levels of support.
- 21:47But that should be determined by the person, not by the care community, as I'd call them.
- 21:53Mm-hmm.
- 21:55And giving them their own choice and their own ability to make those decisions.
- 21:59Yeah.
- 21:59I do remember talking to one survivor who said when she was finally able to have her own money, she was making some pretty poor choices, she said, her words, but she said, but they were my choices and I got to make them.
- 22:18Mm-hmm.
- 22:19And then learnt over time how to make maybe better choices around her money, but that was a really important part about having her own choice and her own ability to make those decisions.
- 22:29And not assume that people can't.
- 22:31I mean, that's the other element.
- 22:32When people present in any environment where there's been significant trauma and anyone coming out of family violence situations will experience a range of impacts, trauma being one of them, what we expect from people is mostly unrealistic.
- 22:47You know, they need time to take in information in a way that they're comfortable.
- 22:52They need time to be able to think through what information they need to give because it will often be inconsistent and people will think that they're not being honest in the way they respond, where in fact a traumatic brain responds differently.
- 23:05And we always talk about people being trauma-informed, but it's a bit of a catchphrase.
- 23:09It's about understanding what the impact is.
- 23:13And trauma itself isn't the thing.
- 23:14The trauma is the incident that's happened, but the impact of that is the way our brain tries to make sense of it in protecting ourselves in the future.
- 23:23And it's quite a science in terms of understanding that.
- 23:28and giving people space and the time they need to gather themselves, not the right word, but to be able to think through when they're able what direction they want to take.
- 23:37And to just process and then take those initial steps and then the next one.
- 23:42Well, I still hear workers with best intent saying, oh, you should do this or you shouldn't do that or you should go here and...
- 23:48You know, someone doesn't want to hear what they should do.
- 23:51What they want to know is what are the options are and they can decide for themselves.
- 23:55I know this is going off topic, but I know I should eat less and move more.
- 24:03It's not necessarily the decision I make for right now.
- 24:07It's very different, but it is also relatable that you know that the should word is never very helpful.
- 24:17I want to go into a little bit more about the difference between owning something and then being responsible for it financially.
- 24:29where do you see that that doesn't always line up?
- 24:33Very often, unfortunately.
- 24:35I was, early in the week, I was facilitating a forum for a debt collector, which was interesting, and we were looking at the impact of debt rather than the debt itself.
- 24:47And very often what we find in all of that work is that the debt may well be in my name, but it won't be my debt.
- 24:54And I've never heard a business ask a consumer, is this a debt that you're liable for, for example.
- 25:01Yeah.
- 25:02Because we assume that it is really without any examination of it.
- 25:06Yeah, I've been doing some work actually with the Australian Retail Credit Association about how to manage debt and credit.
- 25:16And we've been talking about, well, what if the debt is fraudulent in the context of domestic abuse and financial abuse?
- 25:25What if it's a coerced debt?
- 25:27And then what if it is debt that...
- 25:30You happily entered into that, but maybe through domestic violence emerging later, you're now having trouble paying it.
- 25:38And it's been a really complex and interesting discussion because that question about if you are pressured into taking out a debt, you might get some benefit out of it because you've been pressured to get a mortgage, for example, and you've lived in the house and...
- 25:56But actually, would you have ever taken that out but for the pressure or that coercion?
- 26:02It's been – it's a really complex thing to unpick.
- 26:07Absolutely it is.
- 26:08And one of the things that businesses, again, don't do well in the main is to, you know, when they're trying to sort out whatever the product is, whatever the industry is, what it is someone can contribute towards that account or that debt, they actually don't ask if they're the ones able to make decisions about their own money.
- 26:29Mm-hm.
- 26:29So something so simple will give you a completely different environment than you need to work in.
- 26:34Yeah.
- 26:35Because you'll often find that they will have a ray of debts in their name but no control over it.
- 26:40Yeah, okay.
- 26:41And probably didn't agree to then the debt being in that name.
- 26:46So it's broader than just observing it.
- 26:48It's around how do we inquire about it in a way that's still respectful to give people the opportunity to let you know what their circumstances are.
- 26:58Yeah.
- 26:59And so if we flip that too for the consumer...
- 27:03How would you say consumers need to think about it?
- 27:08What if someone doesn't know if I'm liable for it or not because there's a debt in my name?
- 27:13How would you encourage consumers to think about that issue from their perspective as opposed to from the business perspective?
- 27:20I think part of it's around sort of the consumer education or community education around consumers.
- 27:25Legal responsibility.
- 27:29But also social expectations about what's reasonable and what's not.
- 27:33And, you know, the old pub test is a good one.
- 27:35You know, if it smells a bit funny, it probably is.
- 27:38And if it sounds unreasonable, it probably is.
- 27:40So then how does the consumer... A consumer's not going to ring a business and say, very often, I'm a victim of family and domestic violence.
- 27:51Some will, but most won't.
- 27:53What they'll say is, I'll try and pay it.
- 27:56Or they'll say, if you ask about, do they control the money?
- 27:59And the answer's no.
- 28:02You know, the question could be, is that likely to change?
- 28:05And if the answer's still no, you've got a different starting point.
- 28:09And I think that's about consumers being more informed about what it is they should and can be asking for, but also have a higher expectation of businesses to respond to their needs.
- 28:20Mm-hmm.
- 28:21And a lot of the new regulation coming in requires that more and more, but probably doesn't go as far as it needs to.
- 28:28But it's an awareness.
- 28:29You know, in the past, the consumer had to identify their difficulty for the business to respond.
- 28:34Totally unacceptable in terms of consumer vulnerabilities.
- 28:39And now there's an obligation to inquire.
- 28:41You know, now it will be more than an obligation to inquire eventually, but to be more proactive and tactical in how they do that.
- 28:48So if I had an experience and I needed to go and get some help and also understand my own circumstances, what would be the kinds of questions or expectations that I should have if I, one, needed to work out what's going on or two, needed to ask for help?
- 29:09I think you need to be able to ask what your legal responsibility is or what the contractual responsibility is.
- 29:16Again, very often we know...
- 29:19When coercion has been used in borrowing, often the person who's been coerced has no idea either what it's for or where the money goes or any control in that.
- 29:28You know, it's about how to explore those and say, well, I didn't have...
- 29:31I didn't receive a benefit as a result of that borrowing or that loan and therefore why should I be liable for it, even if their name's on the contract?
- 29:41You know, it's about the rights and responsibilities of both the industry and consumer around what do they need to know and they need to find out if they are liable for it and is that fair and just.
- 29:52And if it's not, then that's a different conversation.
- 29:56One of the points of this podcast is trying to equip people with what they need to know.
- 30:01What do you think would be, you know, your top three?
- 30:07I think know what you want.
- 30:09I think be really clear about what it is that you're prepared to share and to keep in mind the long game.
- 30:18When you say that, what do you mean?
- 30:20How you want things to turn out and how you want to be able to contribute to that outcome.
- 30:26You know, it's a bit like the weight loss scenario.
- 30:28You know what you need to do and eventually you might get through the process of doing it and you'll have a goal in mind.
- 30:34And we don't often think about the goal in the planning and the doing, but at the back of our mind, that's where we're going.
- 30:41And for people, all people, I think it's important that they consider the actions they take, but also what the detriment could be, and minimise that as much as they can.
- 30:52Mm-hmm.
- 30:53So if someone was going to take that next step in a relationship, they're about to make a big financial decision with a partner, what would be the key questions that they should ask then or that they could ask to get that clarity and then align that with where they want to go in that long term?
- 31:13If I was seeking a loan now, I'd be asking about if things don't turn out as I want, how will you support me?
- 31:20Do you have flexibility to give me additional time if I need it?
- 31:25What sort of financial risk am I being exposed to?
- 31:29And where are my legal protections?
- 31:32They're very simple, straightforward questions.
- 31:33Yep.
- 31:35And you should be able to ask that of anyone.
- 31:37Yep.
- 31:38Any provider and hopefully get the answers that you need to help you make that really big decision.
- 31:44So if life doesn't go as planned because relationships might change, circumstances might change,
- 31:51What then would you say to people about understanding their options if they need to adjust things later?
- 31:59So they've asked the questions up front.
- 32:01Now life didn't quite go the way they thought it would go.
- 32:03Yep.
- 32:04What happens next?
- 32:06I think part of that discussion is based on how you organise your finances at the beginning and you don't commit all of your money to a particular pool, that you need your own money to make your own decisions for the things that are important to you.
- 32:20And you have a shared agreement about what this accounts for, and it probably might be a mortgage or debt that you equally contribute to.
- 32:27So it's about building some of that structure into how you do that.
- 32:31And the other side of that is the other party probably has their own account that they can make their own decisions about.
- 32:38I mean, as soon as things start to go pear-shaped, it's always around, for me, having a conversation with who the lender is, regardless of the product, to explore what the issues are individually and collectively.
- 32:51And that's, again, where the questions come about, well, how do I protect the contribution I've made into this property, depending on how it's been signed up?
- 33:00Is it at the point where we need to make a decision to sell it before we continue to lose equity in the property so that we've actually got something each to start again with?
- 33:10I mean, as a financial counsellor, I often saw people hanging on to property for...
- 33:17That was the thing about how it defines them.
- 33:21And it took a bit of relationship to get to a point to say to someone, this isn't just about money.
- 33:26How else is this impacting on you?
- 33:28And they'll talk about strained relationships and the kids hate them because they can't go to school camp and, you know, the car's broken down and now they're having to walk 2km to the train station in the morning.
- 33:39So if you help people think through the complexity of all of it, not just a house represents me and my family,
- 33:49you know, when the crisis really comes, people are relieved very often.
- 33:53And I wouldn't say looking forward to rebuilding, but confident that they can.
- 33:59Because the relationship may well have disintegrated.
- 34:03Hopefully they've got some asset out of what's remaining and they can move forward with that.
- 34:07At times there'll be nothing left because it's just been exhausted.
- 34:12And again, it's about helping people think through how they want to proceed, but helping them be really clear about what decisions they don't want to make in the future and give themselves time.
- 34:23Yeah.
- 34:24And how much easier would it be for people if they understood how to set up from the beginning if they did need to disentangle or rebuild, make some really tough calls?
- 34:38I think all of those decisions need to be made when they don't need to.
- 34:43You know, with a cool head and a calm heart, effectively.
- 34:47And in the sign-up process of home, for example, there should be a conversation around, if the relationship doesn't continue, how will you deal with joint property?
- 34:57And have that really cleared and agreed and hope that you don't need it.
- 35:02If you're purchasing a car jointly, have the conversation about, again, if our relationship doesn't continue, as a couple, they've probably contributed to that loan, but only one person will drive away in it.
- 35:17You know, to have those key financial decisions settled as much as you can before you have to.
- 35:24Yeah.
- 35:24And what that does is it helps preserve...
- 35:31It's not people's integrity, but they know that they've given it consideration.
- 35:36They know how it's going to fall because it's been previously agreed and they know where they can start to move forward rather than the crisis that it will create and not knowing where to turn at a time that they can't think it through.
- 35:48Yeah, and presumably checking in as well over time.
- 35:52Yeah.
- 35:52Has that changed for us too?
- 35:55For someone who's not been familiar with any of this...
- 36:00What would be one small thing they could do this week after listening to this episode that might give them a bit more clarity or control over their money or their bills and their circumstances?
- 36:13I think there's a few things they can do.
- 36:16One is to...
- 36:20If the household isn't in crisis, start those conversations as soon as they can.
- 36:25In a really level, we want something that's going to work together for both of us.
- 36:29We want something that can protect both of us if the outcome's not what we look to.
- 36:34To do things like superannuation, make sure that the beneficiaries are who you want, to see who your second contact is on essential services.
- 36:44All of the things that are in play that we don't often think about,
- 36:48you know, to start to behave and think about being financially independent and what does that mean?
- 36:53Because for a lot of people, they might not have had that experience ever.
- 36:56And again, that's about talking to your bank, talking to your friends, getting professional advice if you need it, seeing a financial counsellor who's free, just to get the information to help inform you about how do you step forward.
- 37:09But this, one of the things that I used to
- 37:13it used to shock me, is people's negative self-talk.
- 37:18And they'd be, you know, they'd say something, oh, I make really bad decisions and it always goes to shit.
- 37:23And, you know, I just can't trust myself because of whatever.
- 37:28And then they'll go into, you know, I'm just so stupid.
- 37:30Why did I do that?
- 37:32And to get them to stop and say, you know, the fact that you hear you've made some amazing decisions and you've shown such strength, maybe you should be saying to yourself how talented you are and how strong you are, because that's what I say.
- 37:45And start to feed in a different self-talk.
- 37:50And although it's only a small thing, it's so important for people.
- 37:53Yeah.
- 37:54And particularly those who have come out of brutal relationships, the image of themselves and who they are and what they deserve is quite diminished.
- 38:03And that rebuild is critical for them to be able to make informed decisions for themselves in the future.
- 38:09One of the other interviews we did is with a woman who...
- 38:13was fleeced of her entire life savings through a romance scammer, an absolute con man who took money from so many different people.
- 38:25And I described how I had been scammed and I fell for it, I said.
- 38:30It was one of those DHL ones where I just clicked on the link and there were a couple of hundred dollars that went there.
- 38:37And she said, I want to pull you up on that language where you said you fell for it.
- 38:41You didn't fall for it.
- 38:43It was a crime that was committed.
- 38:45Yeah.
- 38:47And I think language is so important.
- 38:50How do you help people reframe if it's the self-talk or the other language that we could be using?
- 38:58What are the strengths inside us or in the people that we care about that we can help to support them?
- 39:05Mm-hmm.
- 39:06Look, I think about women I've sat with who have been brutalised in life and financially, and the strength they show is phenomenal.
- 39:19You know, many years ago I had a woman come to see me in not great circumstances, as she described it, and she had two or three little kids with her and it was a nine o'clock appointment.
- 39:28So, you know, she'd made an enormous effort.
- 39:31I didn't make much effort, but she'd made an enormous effort to get up, get her family there.
- 39:35She was ready to roll at nine o'clock.
- 39:38Before we walked into the interview room, I picked up a bag of toys and I got to the door and she said to me, what do you think you're doing?
- 39:48And what I was doing was keeping the kids busy so I could talk to her.
- 39:50That was the honest answer.
- 39:52And I just said, I thought it's something that the kids might enjoy, fluffing for words.
- 39:58And she said, how dare you assume I'm not a good mother as well as a bad money manager?
- 40:04Oh, wow.
- 40:05Yeah.
- 40:05And you couldn't knock me over with a feather.
- 40:07And, you know, and I'm saying, I'm sorry, that was not my intent.
- 40:11You know, trying to save a bit of ground.
- 40:15She had enormously complex issues.
- 40:17I never saw her again.
- 40:18Mm-hmm.
- 40:21Yeah.
- 40:22And it's really a simple example, but it had a profound impact on how then she was able to work with me and hear what I had to say because in her mind I'd assume she was a poor parent and therefore these other things were true too, which none of it was true as it turned out, but I never did it again.
- 40:40If a woman came with kids, I'd say, look, there's some things there, you as a parent, you decide what you think they'd like.
- 40:45Yeah.
- 40:45And I'd leave the room and leave it to her.
- 40:48Yeah, simple, simple things.
- 40:49It's about how do you demonstrate respect and integrity for someone who doesn't feel it initially, but hopefully they will over time?
- 40:58And how do you not assume that they don't have skills to bring to the table?
- 41:04I think it's such a critical point.
- 41:07We have been talking about, I'd love your perspective on this, if you were a bit worried about someone, someone you care about, that they may be experiencing financial abuse, how do you step into the conversation?
- 41:20I think you just always have to be honest.
- 41:26Whether I knew them well or not, I'd say, from what you've said or the way you look, I'm really concerned about you.
- 41:32And I'd wait.
- 41:34And they would then say, yeah, life's shit, or yes, this has happened, or none of your business.
- 41:40I'd say, that's okay, I'm just wanting to let you know something's telling me something's not right.
- 41:46I don't know what that is and I'm available to you if you'd like to talk about it.
- 41:51So it's not forcing help on people, but giving them the opportunity to take it if they want it.
- 41:57and when you're in a relationship or a friendship or a family and things are going wrong, that can be a little bit trickier.
- 42:05But again, it's just saying to people, I'm here.
- 42:09And I'm available anytime and call me if you need to or call me if you want to.
- 42:15Because one of the things that tends to happen in relationships is that people have been isolated for a long period of time.
- 42:20They don't feel as if they've got connection to people.
- 42:23And it's quite hard to actively build connection with someone who feels as if it's too risky to take up.
- 42:29But just being around and available and, you know, sending a note or, you know, leaving a message on their phone, just saying, thinking of your small things, but they're incredibly powerful for someone who's terrified to reach out.
- 42:42Yeah.
- 42:44Such good advice.
- 42:45Thank you, Sue.
- 42:46It's been such a pleasure to talk to you.
- 42:49I always learn something new every time I talk to you and you remind me how to be a better person.
- 42:55I have to say.
- 42:57As we wrap up, we're asking all guests to complete this sentence.
- 43:03Before you say yes, what would you say, Sue?
- 43:07Before you say yes, I think I would say to people, stop and think about what you want, what it is that you deserve and make sure that you're protected.
- 43:18Thank you.
- 43:18Thanks, Sue.
- 43:19I really appreciate your time.
- 43:21My pleasure.