Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Cognitive Dissonance & Persuasion: How Attitudes and Behavior Change
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. Have you
- 0:02ever wondered why you bought that insanely expensive
- 0:05smartphone when your old one worked just fine?
- 0:08Oh, or why you suddenly find yourself tapping
- 0:10your foot to a genre of music you used to completely
- 0:13hate. Yes, exactly. So today, we are two undergrad
- 0:18psychology students geeking out over our notes,
- 0:21taking a deep dive into the source material for
- 0:23chapter four. We are trying to figure out exactly
- 0:26how your brain is constantly being hacked. Yeah,
- 0:29and sometimes those hacks come from advertisers
- 0:31intentionally trying to empty your wallet. But
- 0:34the most surprising realization from these notes
- 0:36is how often we rewrite our own mental programming
- 0:40without even realizing it. It's wild. We're going
- 0:42to unpack all of it today, attitudes, behavior,
- 0:45and persuasion. Our main mission is to figure
- 0:47out why we like what we like, how outside forces
- 0:50manipulate those preferences, and how our own
- 0:54Seemingly harmless actions can secretly rewrite
- 0:56our moral compass right and to get to the bottom
- 0:59of that manipulation Yeah, we kind of have to
- 1:01start with a baseline code in social psychology
- 1:03and attitude isn't just you know having a bad
- 1:05mood, right? It's not just a teenager slamming
- 1:08a door exactly. It's defined as a relatively
- 1:11enduring Evaluation of an attitude object. Yeah,
- 1:15and that object could be a person, a new energy
- 1:18drink, a social group, or even like an abstract
- 1:20political idea. And I found this really great
- 1:22way to visualize this complex evaluation. It's
- 1:25the ABC memory hack. Oh, the ABCs of attitude.
- 1:28Yeah, right. So A stands for affect, which is
- 1:31how you feel. B stands for behavior, which is
- 1:33what you do. And C stands for cognition, which
- 1:36is what you believe. And breaking it down into
- 1:39those three components, let psychologists see
- 1:42exactly where human logic breaks down. Like,
- 1:44take an environmentalist's attitude towards recycling.
- 1:47Okay. Their affect, the emotional part, is a
- 1:49feeling of satisfaction or happiness when they
- 1:51recycle. Their behavior is the physical act of
- 1:54sorting the plastic from the paper. And then
- 1:56their cognition is the logical belief that reducing
- 1:58landfill waste is like necessary for planetary
- 2:01survival. Exactly. ABC, feel, do, believe. That
- 2:05forms a highly cohesive stable attitude. Right.
- 2:08And I always assumed we just, I don't know, passively
- 2:11absorbed those cohesive attitudes from the world
- 2:14around us, like from our parents or our teachers,
- 2:16the media. Sure, that makes sense. But I was
- 2:19looking at the heritability data in table 4 .1
- 2:22of the text, and it completely upends that assumption.
- 2:25Oh, wow. Yeah. The genetic component of our attitudes
- 2:28is genuinely startling. It is. The text provides
- 2:31this statistical breakdown of how much of a specific
- 2:34attitude is influenced by genetics versus the
- 2:37environment. For context, something like doing
- 2:40crossword puzzles has a heritability score of
- 2:43.02. Which is essentially zero. Right. You do
- 2:46not have a crossword puzzle, Gene. But then you
- 2:48scan down to the complex moral and religious
- 2:50stances, and the numbers just spike. And, you
- 2:53know, we're just looking impartially at the textbooks,
- 2:56statistical data here, but the heritability score
- 2:58for the attitude toward abortion on demand is
- 3:000 .54. Wow. The score for the death penalty for
- 3:03murder is 0 .50. Organized religion is at 0 .45.
- 3:08It's crazy. It forces you to rethink how much
- 3:11agency we actually have over our worldviews.
- 3:13Wait, I have to push back on this though. So
- 3:15you're telling me my stance on the death penalty
- 3:18is as baked into my DNA as my love for riding
- 3:21roller coasters. Wow. Because I checked the table
- 3:24and roller coasters are sitting at .52. How does
- 3:27a highly complex modern legal and moral viewpoint
- 3:31get transmitted through a double helix? We didn't
- 3:35like. evolve with courtrooms. It sounds like
- 3:37science fiction. It totally seems impossible
- 3:39until you look at the underlying mechanism. You
- 3:41aren't inheriting a specific death penalty gene,
- 3:44right, or a religion gene. Okay, then what is
- 3:46it? What you are inheriting is your underlying
- 3:49personality architecture, your cognitive style.
- 3:52So things like your baseline level of thrill
- 3:54-seeking, or how much your brain intrinsically
- 3:56values order and structure, or even how your
- 3:59amygdala processes fear and uncertainty. Okay,
- 4:02so it's not the belief itself, it's the filter
- 4:05through which you view the world. Exactly. Think
- 4:07about a person whose genetic code gives them
- 4:10a personality that strongly prefers certainty,
- 4:12tradition, and clear boundaries just to feel
- 4:15safe. Right. They like rules. Yeah. So as they
- 4:17grow up and encounter complex, ambiguous societal
- 4:21issues, their brain is naturally going to gravitate
- 4:24toward attitudes, moral stances, and religious
- 4:27structures that offer clear rules and order.
- 4:30That makes so much sense. The attitude itself
- 4:32isn't in the DNA, but the personality that finds
- 4:35that attitude deeply comforting absolutely is.
- 4:38OK, that structural perspective changes everything,
- 4:41but it introduces this massive contradiction.
- 4:45What do you mean? If our attitudes are that deeply
- 4:47ingrained, literally resting on our genetic personality
- 4:50architecture, why do we constantly act against
- 4:52them? I mean, why does someone who knows smoking
- 4:55is terrible and has a strong negative internal
- 4:57attitude toward it still ask for a cigarette
- 5:00at a party? Oh, right. To explain that attitude
- 5:02behavior gap, we have to look at the psychological
- 5:05drive for social survival. Right. The social
- 5:07stuff. Yeah. Fishbein and Adson's theory of planned
- 5:10behavior illustrates that our internal attitude
- 5:12is really only one fraction of the equation that
- 5:15predicts what we will actually do. I actually
- 5:17use an analogy for this theory for my notes.
- 5:19I think of a planned behavior as a three -legged
- 5:22stool. Oh, I like that. Yeah, if you want the
- 5:24behavior to actually manifest, if you want the
- 5:26stool to stand up, you need all three legs to
- 5:29be strong. OK, what are the legs? Leg one is
- 5:32your internal attitude toward the behavior. Leg
- 5:35two is subjective norms, which is basically the
- 5:38pressure of what your friends and society expect
- 5:41of you. And leg three is perceived behavioral
- 5:44control. which is how practically easy or difficult
- 5:47it is to actually perform the action, right?
- 5:49Exactly. And if any of those legs fail, the behavior
- 5:52doesn't happen or completely contradictory behavior
- 5:55takes its place. The text actually uses a great
- 5:58example of this. It's about a 16 year old named
- 6:00Magritte. So she despises the idea of smoking.
- 6:04She thinks it's dirty, expensive, gross. So she
- 6:07has a rock solid first leg of the stool. Her
- 6:09internal attitude is highly negative. Right.
- 6:11And when she is at home with her parents, who
- 6:13also Hate smoking, the subjective norms, the
- 6:16second leg aligned perfectly with her attitude.
- 6:18The stool is stable, she doesn't smoke. Okay.
- 6:21But put Magritte at a party where the popular
- 6:24kids are smoking and offering her one. The environment
- 6:27fundamentally alters the subjective norms. The
- 6:30stool starts to wobble violently. Exactly. Especially
- 6:34if Magritte is what psychologists call a high
- 6:36self -monitor. Oh, right. A high self -monitor
- 6:38is someone who is acutely sensitive to social
- 6:40cues. They are constantly scanning the room,
- 6:44unconsciously analyzing what they need to do
- 6:46to, like, fit in, be liked, and avoid social
- 6:50rejection. Yeah. And for a high self -monitor,
- 6:53the psychological pain of being ostracized from
- 6:55the group is so intense that the subjective norm
- 6:58leg of the stool becomes heavier than their own
- 7:01deeply held beliefs. Wow. The evolutionary drive
- 7:04to stay in the tribe overrides the logical internal
- 7:07attitude. She takes a puff of the cigarette acting
- 7:10entirely against her own DNA influenced attitude
- 7:13just to appease the social environment. Which
- 7:15basically means if researchers or marketers want
- 7:17to predict our behavior they can't just ask us
- 7:19how we feel in a vacuum they have to account
- 7:21for the specific environment. Yes and that is
- 7:23a massive hurdle in research methodology. A general
- 7:26attitude doesn't predict a specific action. You
- 7:29can't ask someone, are you a religious person?
- 7:31And then accurately predict if they will attend
- 7:34a specific 9 a .m. service next Sunday. Because
- 7:37their general attitude might be yes, but the
- 7:40subjective norms of their family wanting to sleep
- 7:42in or the perceived behavioral control of their
- 7:45car being broken down will completely change
- 7:48the outcome. Exactly. To predict behavior, you
- 7:51must measure a specific attitude. You have to
- 7:54ask, how frequently do you expect to attend church
- 7:56next month? Specificity is the only way to account
- 8:00for all those variables. Okay, so if our internal
- 8:02attitudes are that easily swayed by just like
- 8:05standing in a room with our peers, what happens
- 8:08when a billion -dollar company intentionally
- 8:10designs an environment to manipulate us? How
- 8:13do advertisers and politicians actively weaponize
- 8:16human psychology to rewrite our ABCs? Well, they
- 8:20do it by exploiting the brain's desire to conserve
- 8:22energy. Processing information is metabolically
- 8:25expensive. So our brains toggle between two distinct
- 8:28modes of evaluating messages. There's spontaneous
- 8:30processing and thoughtful processing. I frame
- 8:33this in my notes as autopilot versus manual drive.
- 8:36It helps it stick. That's a perfect way to look
- 8:38at it. Let's look at autopilot or spontaneous
- 8:41processing. This kicks in when an issue has very
- 8:44low personal relevance to us or we are simply
- 8:47distracted and tired. The brain doesn't want
- 8:50to burn calories analyzing logic, so it just
- 8:52relies on superficial cues. Right. On autopilot,
- 8:56we aren't listening to the actual argument. We're
- 8:58looking at the packaging. Like, is the person
- 9:01talking attractive? Is the background music making
- 9:04me feel nostalgic? Or is the speaker wearing
- 9:06a white lab coat so my brain can just lazily
- 9:10categorize them as an expert and skip the critical
- 9:12thinking part? Yes. You accept the message purely
- 9:15because the delivery makes you feel good. Think
- 9:18about Apple's marketing campaigns for the iPhone.
- 9:21They are master classes in spontaneous processing.
- 9:23So, for sure, you almost never see an Apple ad
- 9:25that is just a bulleted list of battery life
- 9:28statistics and processor speeds. It's always
- 9:30a highly emotional mini movie. Exactly. Happy,
- 9:33beautiful people creating art in slow motion,
- 9:35catchy indie pop music swelling in the background.
- 9:38They bypass your cognition entirely and aim straight
- 9:40for the affect. They make you associate the joy
- 9:42of the ad with the rectangle of glass they're
- 9:45selling. Now contrast that with your manual drive
- 9:48thoughtful processing. Manual Drive only engages
- 9:51when the issue has high personal relevance. Like
- 9:54if an advertisement comes on for a medication
- 9:56that treats a disease you or a loved one actually
- 9:59suffers from, you snap off autopilot immediately.
- 10:03Yes. You don't care if the actor is cute. You
- 10:05are listening to the clinical trial statistics.
- 10:07You're analyzing the side effects. You are weighing
- 10:10the logic of the argument. And advertisers know
- 10:12exactly when to use which method. If they know
- 10:15you care deeply, they supply facts. If they know
- 10:18you're uninvested, they supply vibes. Pretty
- 10:20much. But wait, what if the autopilot encounters
- 10:23turbulence? Like, think about a really dirty
- 10:25mudslinging political attack ad. You watch it.
- 10:28You recognize the dramatic black and white photos
- 10:31and ominous music. as blatant manipulation from
- 10:34a slimy, untrustworthy source. Doesn't our brain
- 10:38just reject the message? Initially, yes. You
- 10:40discount the message because the source is compromised.
- 10:43But human memory has a terrifying flaw. Over
- 10:45time, we decouple the source of a message from
- 10:48the content of the message. Oh, the sleeper effect.
- 10:51Exactly. The sleeper effect occurs because remembering
- 10:55the context, like who told me this, takes up
- 10:57unnecessary memory space so it decays quickly.
- 11:00But the salacious claim The danger information
- 11:03is held onto much longer for survival purposes.
- 11:07So weeks later, you might vividly remember the
- 11:09negative claim made in that dirty political ad,
- 11:11but you'll have completely forgotten that you
- 11:13originally heard it from an untrustworthy super
- 11:15pick. the warning label just falls off the memory
- 11:18file. Yep. The untrustworthy source fades, but
- 11:21the message sleeps in your brain until it activates,
- 11:24subtly shifting your attitude to match a claim
- 11:26you initially knew was garbage. Man, that makes
- 11:28modern social media scrolling feel incredibly
- 11:30dangerous. Is there any defense mechanism against
- 11:33this kind of persuasion? Well, the text highlights
- 11:35forewarning. Simply giving someone a heads up
- 11:38that a persuasion attempt is coming allows their
- 11:40brain to preload cognitive defenses. Okay, so
- 11:43if Magritte's parents tell her, hey, people are
- 11:46going to offer you cigarettes at this party,
- 11:48she can actively practice her refusal rather
- 11:50than being caught off guard on autopilot. Right.
- 11:54But the notes also warn that if you push the
- 11:56forewarning too hard, you trigger psychological
- 11:59reactance. Oh, right. Reactance is the profound
- 12:03emotional rebellion we experience when we feel
- 12:06our autonomy and freedom of choice are being
- 12:08threatened. It's basically the ultimate teenager
- 12:10instinct. Yeah. If Magritte's parents are overly
- 12:13authoritative and say, you are absolutely forbidden
- 12:16from ever making your own choices about smoking,
- 12:18she might experience such intense reactance that
- 12:21she smokes a cigarette purely to reclaim her
- 12:23sense of free will. She doesn't want the cigarette.
- 12:25She just wants her autonomy back. Exactly. It's
- 12:29unsettling to think about advertisers and peers
- 12:31hacking our brains from the outside, but the
- 12:34most permanent, profound way our attitudes get
- 12:36rewritten is actually an inside job. Yeah, this
- 12:39is where the psychology gets existential. We
- 12:42naturally assume that our internal attitudes
- 12:44dictate our outward behavior, but sometimes the
- 12:47arrow points the other way. Our behavior dictates
- 12:50our attitude. Yes. This begins with self -perception
- 12:53theory. It posits that we frequently don't actually
- 12:56know what our own attitudes are. They're ambiguous.
- 12:59So we act like external observers of our own
- 13:02lives. We watch our own behavior and reverse
- 13:05engineer our attitude to make sense of it. The
- 13:08Aronson and Carl Smith forbidden toy study illustrates
- 13:11this perfectly. I love this study. It's a classic.
- 13:14So researchers brought kids into a room full
- 13:16of toys, identified the one toy a child desperately
- 13:19wanted to play with, and then told the child
- 13:21they couldn't touch it. Right. And half the kids
- 13:23received a mild threat. If you play with it,
- 13:26I'd be annoyed. The other half received a severe
- 13:28threat. If you play with it, I'll be very angry,
- 13:31take all my toys, and never come back. Which
- 13:33is terrifying for a kid. So the researcher leaves,
- 13:36and surprisingly, none of the kids touched the
- 13:38toy, regardless of the threat level. But the
- 13:41self -perception magic happens when they ask
- 13:43the kids later how much they liked the forbidden
- 13:45toy. The kids who got the severe threat still
- 13:48wanted it. Because their internal dialogue made
- 13:50sense. I didn't play with the toy because I was
- 13:53terrified of the punishment. I still love the
- 13:55toy. Exactly. But the kids who received the mild
- 13:58threat experienced insufficient justification.
- 14:02Right. Their internal dialogue was confused.
- 14:04I didn't play with the toy, but the threat wasn't
- 14:07actually that scary. I could have easily risked
- 14:09it. So why didn't I play with it? I guess I must
- 14:12not actually like the toy very much. Yeah. They
- 14:15observed their own lack of action, couldn't find
- 14:17a strong external reason for it, and so they
- 14:20unconsciously rewrote their own attitude to make
- 14:22their behavior make sense. They changed their
- 14:24own minds to justify their actions. And that
- 14:27mechanism is the foundation for arguably the
- 14:29most important concept in social psychology,
- 14:32Leon Festinger's cognitive dissonance. Oh, absolutely,
- 14:35cognitive dissonance. I call it the mental check
- 14:37engine light. That's brilliant. Yeah? It really
- 14:40is the profound psychological pain we experience
- 14:43when our actions violate our perception of ourselves,
- 14:47especially our identity as moral, rational, or
- 14:50smart people. And neuroimaging actually shows
- 14:53that cognitive dissonance physically hurts. It
- 14:56lights up the anterior cingulate cortex, a region
- 15:00of the brain deeply involved in processing physical
- 15:03and emotional pain. Because your brain cannot
- 15:05tolerate the pain of being a hypocrite. Like,
- 15:09imagine you believe you are a deeply honest person.
- 15:12That's your attitude. But you panic and cheat
- 15:14on a biology midterm. That's your behavior. The
- 15:17two clash. B, the mental check engine light illuminates.
- 15:21Your anterior cingulate cortex is firing. You
- 15:24are in pain. And you have to relieve the tension.
- 15:26Right. So you basically have two options to stop
- 15:29the pain. Option one is to fix the engine. You
- 15:31confess to cheating, take the failing grade,
- 15:33and align your future behavior with your morals.
- 15:35Which requires taking a massive hit to your ego.
- 15:38So most people avoid option one at all costs.
- 15:40Yeah, most people choose option two. They put
- 15:42tape over the check engine light. They rationalize.
- 15:45They change their internal attitude to accommodate
- 15:47the bad behavior. You tell yourself, everyone
- 15:49cheats in college. The professor made the test
- 15:52unfairly hard anyway. I actually had a moral
- 15:54obligation to cheat so I could keep my scholarship.
- 15:56You protect your self -esteem by shifting your
- 15:59attitude toward cheating. But that self -justification
- 16:02creates a dangerous spiral. How so? Well, once
- 16:05you've permanently softened your stance on cheating
- 16:07to protect your ego, the psychological barrier
- 16:10to cheating a second time is gone. Oh wow. Yeah.
- 16:14That is scary. So if we are this desperate to
- 16:17align our actions and our identity to avoid mental
- 16:19pain, couldn't a smart salesperson trick us into
- 16:22doing a tiny good thing just to trap us into
- 16:25buying something later to maintain that identity?
- 16:28Yes. That is exactly how salespeople weaponize
- 16:32cognitive dissonance through the foot in the
- 16:34door technique. They ask for a tiny unobtrusive
- 16:37favor first, knowing it will fundamentally alter
- 16:40your self -perception. The classic Friedman and
- 16:42Frazier study maps this out. Researchers went
- 16:45door -to -door asking homeowners to place a tiny
- 16:47three -inch sticker in their window that said,
- 16:49be a safe driver. It's such a minor request that
- 16:52almost everyone agreed. Right. But by agreeing
- 16:54to that tiny behavior, the homeowners unconsciously
- 16:57shifted their self -perception. They adopted
- 16:59a new attitude. I am the kind of person who actively
- 17:02supports public safety. And then, weeks later,
- 17:05the researchers return. This time, they asked
- 17:08those same homeowners to install a massive poorly
- 17:12lettered, incredibly ugly, drive carefully billboard,
- 17:15taking up their entire front lawn. Which is ridiculous.
- 17:19If researchers asked for the giant sign right
- 17:21off the bat, only about 20 % of people agreed.
- 17:24But for the people who had already accepted the
- 17:25tiny window sticker... Almost 80 % complied.
- 17:2980%. Because if they refused the ugly sign, their
- 17:32mental check engine light would flash. Wait,
- 17:34I have the sticker in my window. I am a safe
- 17:37driving advocate. If I say no to this sign, am
- 17:40I a hypocrite? To avoid the agonizing pain of
- 17:43cognitive dissonance, they agree to a massive
- 17:45unreasonable request. the tiny behavior totally
- 17:49trapped them. We are constantly striving for
- 17:51internal consistency, even when it leads us to
- 17:53make totally irrational choices. It's fascinating.
- 17:56Well, we have covered so much ground in our depth
- 17:59dive today. Our attitudes are the complex ABCs
- 18:02of our mind effect, behavior, cognition. They
- 18:06are heavily predisposed by the genetic architecture
- 18:08of our personalities, constantly bent and warped
- 18:11by the social pressures and subjective norms
- 18:14of our environment. And repeatedly rewritten
- 18:16by our own desperate rationalizations to avoid
- 18:19mental pain. It reveals that we are highly susceptible
- 18:22to our environments, but equally vulnerable to
- 18:25our own internal storytelling. So the next time
- 18:27you find yourself buying a product you definitely
- 18:29didn't plan to, or vehemently defending a mistake
- 18:32you made instead of simply apologizing, take
- 18:35a step back. Yeah, pay attention. Ask yourself,
- 18:38are you driving on thoughtful manual drive? Or
- 18:40did an advertiser just catch your brain on autopilot?
- 18:42Did someone just wedge their foot in your door?
- 18:45Or is your mental check engine light flashing
- 18:47and you're just looking for tape? Which leaves
- 18:49us with a really fascinating philosophical question
- 18:51to ponder. If our moral and religious attitudes
- 18:55are heavily influenced by genetic traits and
- 18:57our daily beliefs are constantly being molded
- 19:00by cognitive dissonance to protect our fragile
- 19:02self -esteem. Wait, wait, don't break my brain
- 19:04here. Listen, how much of our moral compass is
- 19:07actually driven by free will? And how much is
- 19:09just our brain running damage control? Oh, man.
- 19:13That is a question to keep you up at night. Thanks
- 19:15for joining our study session, everyone. We'll
- 19:17see you next time.