Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the Fed's Balance Sheet Runoff Is Reshaping Treasury Borrowing
Transcript
- Lucas: So the 30-year Treasury yield is sitting at 5.09 percent this week, and the 10-year at 4.61. That's down slightly from recent highs, but still historically elevated. And here's the thing that doesn't get enough attention—the Fed is still quietly reducing its balance sheet by letting roughly $60 billion in Treasuries roll off every month. That's $60 billion of demand that has to be replaced by someone else. Luna: Right, and that someone else is increasingly the private sector—pension funds, foreign central banks, hedge funds. But they're not stepping in at the same price. Lucas: Exactly. So we have this dynamic where the Treasury needs to borrow trillions, the Fed is pulling back as a buyer, and the market has to absorb it all. That's one reason yields are staying elevated even as inflation cools. The national debt just crossed 39 trillion dollars as of January, and the deficit for fiscal 2025 was about 1.77 trillion—slightly smaller than the year before, but still enormous. Luna: And it's not just the size of the debt, it's the refinancing. A huge chunk of Treasury debt is short-term, so they have to roll it over at these higher rates. The average maturity of the debt has actually shortened in the last few years. Lucas: That's the refinancing cliff we've talked about before. But today I want to focus on this less visible channel: the Fed's balance sheet runoff. When the Fed buys Treasuries during quantitative easing, it pushes prices up and yields down. When it lets them roll off—which is essentially quantitative tightening—it does the opposite. It adds to the supply that the market has to absorb, putting upward pressure on yields. Luna: And the Fed has been doing this since 2022. They peaked their balance sheet at around 9 trillion, and it's now down to about 7.5 trillion. That's a lot of Treasuries that have been returned to the market. Lucas: Right. And the pace is roughly 60 billion per month in Treasuries, plus about 35 billion in mortgage-backed securities. So altogether, almost 100 billion a month of securities rolling off. The Treasury has to issue new debt to cover the deficit, but also to replace what the Fed is letting go. That's a lot of paper hitting the market at once. Luna: I remember that the Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee warned about this earlier this year—they said the market's capacity to absorb all this supply is being tested, especially with foreign demand softening. Lucas: That's the other piece. We had a headline last week about tariff uncertainty driving foreign buyers away from Treasuries. That's been a theme. China and Japan, the largest foreign holders, have been either stable or slightly decreasing their holdings. So the marginal buyer is now the domestic institutional investor, and they demand a higher term premium. Luna: Define term premium for someone who's not a bond geek. Lucas: Sure. The term premium is essentially the extra yield investors demand to hold a longer-term bond instead of rolling over short-term bills. When the term premium is high, it means the market is worried about future inflation, or uncertainty about fiscal policy, or just the sheer volume of supply. Right now, estimates put the term premium on the 10-year at around 30 to 40 basis points—positive for the first time in years after being negative during QE. Luna: And we saw that in the yield curve, too. The spread between the 10-year and the 2-year is now about 45 basis points, up from 35 basis points last week. The curve is steepening. Lucas: That steepening is partly because the short end has come down more—the 2-year yield dropped to 4.26 percent, down 3.7 percent over five days, while the 10-year only dropped 1.7 percent. That suggests the market is pricing in rate cuts from the Fed, but for long-term yields, the supply overhang is keeping them higher. Luna: So if the Fed cuts rates, short yields fall, but long yields could stay elevated because of all this supply. That's actually a bad scenario for the Treasury—they're borrowing at long-term rates that are sticky. Lucas: Exactly. And the cost of servicing the debt is already eating up a bigger share of the budget. Debt service costs are now over a trillion dollars a year. Every 100 basis point increase in rates adds about 300 to 400 billion in annual interest costs, given the current debt stock. Luna: So the Fed's balance sheet runoff is essentially a hidden tax on the Treasury, because it forces them to pay higher yields than they otherwise would. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And it's not just the runoff itself—it's the signaling effect. When the Fed is shrinking its balance sheet, it tells the market that the Fed is still in tightening mode, even if they've paused rate hikes. That keeps a floor under long-term yields. Luna: And yet the Fed has said they're watching the market carefully. If liquidity dries up or the Treasury market starts to malfunction, they could pause or even reverse QT. But they haven't done that yet. Lucas: No, they haven't. The July FOMC statement was pretty dovish on rates—no hike—but they made no mention of adjusting the balance sheet runoff. So it's still on autopilot at 60 billion per month in Treasuries. At that pace, they'll continue to reduce holdings through 2026 and possibly into 2027. Luna: But what's the endpoint? Do they want to get back to a 2019-sized balance sheet? That was about 3.8 trillion. We're at 7.5 trillion now. That's a long way to go. Lucas: They haven't given a specific target. The New York Fed's survey of primary dealers suggests the market expects the balance sheet to settle around 6 to 6.5 trillion. But that's still a lot of Treasuries that need to be absorbed. And remember, the Treasury is also issuing more debt to cover the deficit. We're looking at around 2 trillion in net new issuance this year. Luna: So every month, you've got the roughly 60 billion from QT plus the Treasury's new issuance. That's easily 100 to 150 billion in Treasuries that need to find a buyer. And that's not counting the MBS runoff. Lucas: Right. And that supply pressure is one reason I'm not convinced long-term yields are going to collapse even if the Fed cuts rates next year. In fact, if the economy slows and the Fed cuts, the short end will drop, but the long end might not fall as much if the fiscal outlook remains uncertain. Luna: And that has real implications for mortgages, corporate bonds, and the entire cost of capital in the economy. Lucas: Absolutely. So the key takeaway for our listeners is: don't just watch the Fed funds rate. Watch the balance sheet. The runoff is a slow-motion tightening that adds a persistent tailwind to long-term yields, and it's going to be with us for a while. Luna: Yeah, it's one of those behind the scenes forces that affects everyone's borrowing costs, from the government down to your car loan. Lucas: Exactly. And if parsing through this stuff helps you make sense of where yields are headed, that's exactly why we do these shows. The way we keep it ad‑free is listener support—buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a few bucks helps us keep the analysis going without commercials. Luna: I think that's fair. It's a small way to say 'this is valuable to me' and we appreciate it. Lucas: So back to the curve. One thing I'm watching is the 3-month yield, which is now at 3.90 percent—down almost 4 percent over five days. That's pricing in two rate cuts by year-end. But the 10-year is only down 1.7 percent. If the market is right about cuts, the curve will steepen even more. And that would mean the term premium is likely to rise further, not fall. Luna: So a steeper curve isn't necessarily a sign of economic strength—it could be a sign of supply concerns and fiscal risk. Lucas: Exactly. In normal times, a steepening yield curve signals that growth is picking up. But right now, it's partly driven by the supply overhang from QT and the deficit. That's a different kind of steepening—one that's a headwind for the Treasury and for borrowers. Luna: And we haven't even talked about what happens if there's a recession. That would send short rates plummeting, but long rates might not fall as much if the deficit balloons further. Lucas: That's the trillion‑dollar question. The Congressional Budget Office's long‑term projections show debt‑to‑GDP rising from 122 percent now to over 150 percent by 2040. If investors start to question the fiscal trajectory, they'll demand even higher term premiums. The QT runoff just amplifies that dynamic. Luna: So it's a two‑layer story: the mechanical effect of the Fed reducing its holdings, and the psychological effect on market sentiment regarding fiscal sustainability. Lucas: Right. And that's why I think the 30‑year yield at 5.09 percent might not be the peak. If QT continues and the deficit doesn't shrink, we could see 5.5 or even 6 percent on the long bond before the cycle ends. Luna: That would add hundreds of billions more in interest costs. It's a vicious cycle. Lucas: It is. And the only way out is either faster economic growth, serious fiscal consolidation, or the Fed stepping in again with more QE. None of those are easy. So for now, we keep watching the balance sheet runoff—and the yields on the screen.