Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Defeating Motions to Compel Arbitration: Six Strategies to Keep Your Client Out of Arbitration
Transcript
- 0:03Okay, hello. Welcome to the webinar. The presentation
- 0:07today is on defeating motions to compel arbitration.
- 0:11Six strategies to keep your client out of arbitration.
- 0:14I am Mekhan Shelton. I'm a mediator with ADR
- 0:17services, and I'm also the programs chair of
- 0:20the BHBA's employment law section. And today
- 0:23I'm so delighted to introduce our speaker, Valerie
- 0:26McGinty. Valerie is the founder of the law office
- 0:29of Valerie T. McGinty. where she represents plaintiffs
- 0:32on appeal with a focus on affirming plaintiff's
- 0:35verdicts and overturning summary judgments. She's
- 0:38been recognized for both her legal work and her
- 0:41service to organizations such as the Consumer
- 0:44Attorneys of California and is a past chair of
- 0:47the CAOC's Women's Caucus and served on its executive
- 0:51committee. Valerie represented the Consumer Attorneys
- 0:54of California and the California Employment Lawyers
- 0:57as amici parties in the California Supreme Court
- 1:00decision, Sonic Calabasas versus Moreno. We're
- 1:04so fortunate to have her here presenting to us.
- 1:06And with that, I will turn it over to Valerie.
- 1:09Wonderful. Thank you so much, Mekhan. And thank
- 1:12you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 1:14having me here today. I'm so excited to talk
- 1:17with you all about one of my favorite topics.
- 1:21And I thought if it's possible to have just a
- 1:24little bit of information from you, if it's possible
- 1:26to drop into the chat. Suzy, you're going to
- 1:30tell me if this is not. permissible, but I would
- 1:33love to know just your area of practice and also
- 1:36if you've already opposed a motion to compel
- 1:39arbitration. I'll just kind of keep an eye on
- 1:41that, but I'll answer those questions for me,
- 1:44for you right now. I'm a certified appellate
- 1:47specialist. As Mekhan mentioned, I represent
- 1:49plaintiffs on appeal, and I've really seen this
- 1:53issue come up in so many different contexts.
- 1:56It's incredible to me how how much it arises,
- 2:00and in particular, I've handled it in elder abuse
- 2:03cases, in consumer cases, and of course, employment
- 2:07cases. And so, when I report locally, I'm up
- 2:11here in the Bay Area, when I make my monthly
- 2:14report to one of my trial lawyer associations
- 2:17up here, I find that arbitration is one of the
- 2:21topics that I report on most commonly, just because
- 2:24it has such a wide application. And so with that,
- 2:29I'll jump right into the material. And I'm just
- 2:33going to make sure that I've got my eye here.
- 2:35I see here, OK, thank you so much. I see some
- 2:37of the comments here. And I'm going to jump right
- 2:43into sharing my presentation with you. So make
- 2:45sure that you let me know or let us know if you're
- 2:47not able to see. I'm going to share my screen
- 2:49right now so you can see the presentation coming
- 2:53up. And that should be coming up here just momentarily.
- 3:02Okay, and I'm just going to switch over these
- 3:04display settings here. And Susie, can you let
- 3:08me know if there's anything that needs to be
- 3:10adjusted? Looks perfect. Okay, great. Thank you
- 3:13so much. And, you know, I think it's so important
- 3:17to understand what your why is, you know, when
- 3:21you're doing anything in life and particularly
- 3:22when you're trying to work on opposing a motion
- 3:26to compel arbitration. For me, thinking about
- 3:30my role and one of the reasons why I became a
- 3:32lawyer, Thinking about the importance of upholding
- 3:36the Constitution and our right to a jury trial
- 3:38is something that really gets me going. We're
- 3:42all, of course, vanguards of the Constitution,
- 3:44doing our best to uphold the law and to represent
- 3:47our clients in that regard. And so defending
- 3:51and standing up for the right to a jury trial
- 3:53is, to me, just kind of one of the seminal moments
- 3:57really of being a lawyer. That's my why I don't
- 4:01know if it gets you fired up the way it gets
- 4:03me fired up But I find that you know Obviously
- 4:05related to the founding of this country being
- 4:08judged by a jury of our peers was something that
- 4:10was really really important Even in the very
- 4:13very beginning of this nation and and I think
- 4:16it continues to be a defining aspect Of course
- 4:19of our judicial system. So with that That's my
- 4:22why. That's why I get so fired up. But even if
- 4:26you don't have something maybe as lofty as that,
- 4:28one of the things that is really indisputable
- 4:31is that a motion to compel arbitration is a seminal
- 4:34moment in your case. You might be continuing
- 4:37in the trial court, depending on how this comes
- 4:39out, or you might be off to arbitration in a
- 4:42completely different forum. And of course, what
- 4:45do we know about arbitration, whether or not
- 4:48You know, you think strategically it's good or
- 4:50bad for your case. Probably if you're opposing
- 4:52a motion to compel arbitration, you're probably
- 4:54not super excited to go to arbitration. But what
- 4:58we know is that there's no judicial review. So
- 5:02I really encourage folks to think of this as
- 5:05kind of a moment where it's a dispositive motion,
- 5:10if you will. You know, treat it like a dispositive
- 5:12motion. And so marshal all of your resources.
- 5:16And forgive me, I'm still fighting a cold, so
- 5:18if I cough or sneeze, please bear with me. So
- 5:23that's how I think of motions to compel arbitration
- 5:26and why I think they're so important. Excuse
- 5:30me. So one of the first things we're going to
- 5:33look at is does the court have jurisdiction to
- 5:35rule? Now, this is often something that the other
- 5:39side is going to raise, right? They're going
- 5:40to say, oh, well, dear judge, you don't even
- 5:43have jurisdiction to rule on this, because guess
- 5:45what? In the agreement, we already delegated
- 5:48that, the arbitrability of this, to the arbitrator.
- 5:52So this is going to be what's called one of the
- 5:54threshold issues, if you will. And looking at
- 5:58California law, happily, as the Denison case
- 6:01points out, this is on the upper left box of
- 6:03your screen, under California law, it is presumed
- 6:06that the judge will decide arbitrability. unless
- 6:09there's clear and unmistakable evidence that
- 6:11the parties intended the arbitrator to decide
- 6:14that. So as we look at clear and unmistakable
- 6:16evidence, what constitutes that? And by the way,
- 6:19that's the same in federal. On the right side,
- 6:21you can see it applies both in state and federal
- 6:24court. Recently, the Second District agreed with
- 6:26that in the Villalobos case, this concept upholding
- 6:31the trial court's order denying arbitration on
- 6:33similar grounds as in Denison. And so the question
- 6:35becomes, what kind of language shows clear and
- 6:38mistakeable intent. And we're going to focus
- 6:39on that in the next slide. One of the things
- 6:43that I know a lot of people have their eye on
- 6:46is kind of procedurally, how does this crop up?
- 6:50So often, because you're opposing this motion,
- 6:53the other side will have raised this in what's
- 6:57called a threshold issue. And so if they're saying,
- 7:00oh, OK, Judge, you don't even have jurisdiction
- 7:03to decide this, consider saying, well, Even if
- 7:06you don't have jurisdiction, Judge, you should
- 7:09still render an opinion on the other issues that
- 7:12are raised. Three of the cases that focus on
- 7:15this, the BD case. In that case, the Fourth District
- 7:19Court of Appeal, the Fourth District held that
- 7:23the dispute resolution policy clearly and unmistakably
- 7:27delegated arbitrability questions the arbitrator.
- 7:30I do want to touch on the Nixon case. That is
- 7:35a 2023 case. In that case, the arbitration agreement
- 7:38had language that said the arbitrator, quote,
- 7:42and not any, had exclusive authority to resolve
- 7:45disputes. And so Nixon held that this language
- 7:50clearly and unmistakably assigns the enforceability
- 7:54issue to the arbitrator. But let's look at three
- 8:00cases where it was not delegated. And these three
- 8:05cases really focus on the AAA rules being incorporated.
- 8:13So AAA, if you incorporate the rules, the argument
- 8:18goes that that constitutes clear and unmistakable
- 8:24delegation. But courts have really uniformly
- 8:28held over the past couple of years that it does
- 8:31not, the AAA rules by themselves Incorporation
- 8:35of those rules does not constitute clear and
- 8:37unmistakable delegation. And the court says,
- 8:41in fact, specifically in the Beko case, the bottom
- 8:43case on your screen, the Beko case says, look,
- 8:47there's no evidence that the employee had any
- 8:49idea what the AAA rules might have meant, much
- 8:53less that he focused on this issue or knowingly
- 8:56agreed to delegate such disputes. Okay, getting
- 9:00to one of the foundational questions. Did the
- 9:04parties agree to arbitrate? We know that agreement
- 9:08is a cornerstone requirement of enforcing arbitration.
- 9:13Although public policy, of course, favors enforcing
- 9:19arbitration agreements, the key word there is
- 9:22agreement. So if they don't have an agreement,
- 9:26there is no public policy that favors enforcing
- 9:29it. And that's from, of course, the famous Armendariz
- 9:31case. by the Supreme Court. Now, questions, cases
- 9:37that examine this question might be, for example,
- 9:40in the digital consumer agreement context. So
- 9:44when a transaction occurs electronically, so
- 9:49picture this, you're sitting in a waiting room,
- 9:52and this is actually my case, the Doe versus
- 9:54Massage Envy case. You're waiting to get a massage
- 9:58and you have to click through, you know, it's
- 10:01only a couple minutes you have in the waiting
- 10:03room until your massage is beginning. So they
- 10:05said, oh, you got to take a look at this iPad
- 10:07and go through this. So you do the things. And
- 10:11it turns out that on one of the screens where
- 10:14you sign, it says, oh, by signing here, you're
- 10:19agreeing to these terms. And then if you click
- 10:20on that, you go to a completely different screen
- 10:23that actually has an arbitration agreement with
- 10:25a completely different entity. That was what
- 10:28happened in this case. And so the first district
- 10:32said, if you have someone who is checking a box
- 10:36or clicking a button, and it does not manifest
- 10:41a scent that checking a box or clicking a button
- 10:44unless there is a sufficiently conspicuous notice
- 10:48that tells consumers that they are entering a
- 10:51valid and enforceable arbitration agreement with
- 10:53the defendant. Now, in this case, the massage
- 10:57envy's electronic application did not do that.
- 11:01And so the court held there was no arbitration
- 11:03agreement between the parties. And one of the
- 11:06things that I think is so critical about helping
- 11:09the court understand these situations is using
- 11:14some screenshots. You know, if you're able to
- 11:16do that in your briefing, if you're able to get
- 11:19that information, really make it really accessible
- 11:22to the court. I've been able to put that directly
- 11:25in my briefs in the Court of Appeal. But it helps
- 11:29the court see exactly, it really helps them walk
- 11:32through what it was like for the consumer, and
- 11:36see the injustice of it, kind of the bait and
- 11:38switch that's really taking place. Another situation
- 11:44where it comes up has to do with non -signatories,
- 11:47and this is typically in the elder abuse context.
- 11:52So arbitration cannot generally be forced on
- 11:54litigants, of course, who are not signatories
- 11:56of the arbitration agreement. For example, plaintiffs
- 12:01who are suing for their family members wrongful
- 12:03death at a long -term care facility are, of course,
- 12:06suing in their own right. And so they're not
- 12:08ordinarily bound by their decedent's arbitration
- 12:11agreement. And that's the Holland versus Silver
- 12:15Screen health care case from last year. So did
- 12:20the parties agree? to arbitrate. A couple different
- 12:23examples here. On the left with elder abuse.
- 12:28In an elder abuse case with an issue of authorized
- 12:32agency. So we're looking at whether the family
- 12:34member or representative who signed the agreement
- 12:37was authorized to do so on behalf of the elder.
- 12:41And that question often arises. The California
- 12:44Supreme Court. Excuse me. recently decided that
- 12:54if a healthcare agent's power of attorney does
- 12:57not include the authority to bind the principal
- 13:00to a separate optional arbitration agreement,
- 13:03then there is no agreement. And that was clearly
- 13:07stated in the Herod case. That's a good one to
- 13:09know about from 2024. Also important to mention
- 13:13here is in 2025, consumer attorneys of California
- 13:17successfully lobbied for SB 82 along with other
- 13:22organizations to stop infinite pre -dispute binding
- 13:25arbitration agreements. Corporations were improperly
- 13:30extending their arbitration clauses to entities
- 13:33with which an injured consumer has no direct
- 13:37relationship. So real world example was the Disney
- 13:40Plus case. This problem surfaced a woman who
- 13:45died at a Disney owned restaurant due to anaphylactic
- 13:49shock. After repeatedly disclosing her allergy,
- 13:54I believe it was to shrimp. She asked whether
- 13:57or not does the food contain shrimp? No, it doesn't.
- 14:03Unfortunately, she died and her husband brought
- 14:07a wrongful death case against Disney. Disney
- 14:10that attempted to force him out of court and
- 14:13into binding. Arbitration. And their reasoning
- 14:20was, oh look, you signed up for a Disney Plus
- 14:22trial five years earlier. And now you're at a
- 14:28Disney property, a Disney owned restaurant. And
- 14:31so that is really what inspired this legislation.
- 14:36And that's civil code section 1670. So that's
- 14:38a good one to know about. OK. And if there are
- 14:44any questions, I'm trying to monitor this. Oh,
- 14:47you guys are so supportive. Oh, thank you. I've
- 14:51taken every medicine in the book, so I did not
- 14:54want to cancel on you because I know there's
- 14:55MCLE deadlines coming right up. So we will get
- 14:58through this and hopefully we're going to get
- 14:59you some tips and tricks that you can use as
- 15:03you battle against these motions to compel arbitration
- 15:06that are so critical for your clients. So another
- 15:11strategy, and if you do have questions, please
- 15:13do. Put him right in the chat. I think I'm monitoring
- 15:16it, but I know Susie's going to help me if I
- 15:17miss anything. Another thing on your checklist
- 15:20is to look at is arbitration barred by law? Now,
- 15:23I would argue if it is, that goes to the threshold.
- 15:28So they're going to maybe say at their threshold,
- 15:31maybe if they're on top of their game, if they
- 15:34have a jurisdictional argument to make, if they
- 15:36can argue that this issue of arbitrability was
- 15:40delegated to the arbitrator. If I were them,
- 15:43if I were making a motion, I would put that at
- 15:46the top as a threshold issue. But if you're opposing
- 15:49this motion, I would put that at the top, even
- 15:54before their threshold question of jurisdiction
- 15:56to me, because we know the trial court is authorized
- 16:00to interpret the law. And we know that the law,
- 16:04it makes illegal the arbitration of certain cases
- 16:07for certain reasons. In any case, I would recommend
- 16:11putting, if this applies to your case, any of
- 16:13these issues, I would put it at the front. The
- 16:15first is a law that Congress passed in 2021,
- 16:21ending forced arbitration of sexual assault and
- 16:23sexual harassment act. Excuse me. Now, this says,
- 16:33quote, no predispute arbitration agreement or
- 16:36predispute joint action waiver shall be valid
- 16:38or enforceable. if that case relates to sexual
- 16:41assault dispute or a sexual harassment dispute.
- 16:44It has been successfully applied by the courts
- 16:46to prevent arbitration of these claims. The plaintiff
- 16:49had to file a writ. The Court of Appeal granted
- 16:51the writ. That is the case of Casey v. Superior
- 16:54Court. It was last year. And the court did hold
- 16:58that that act preempts attempts under state law
- 17:01to compel arbitration of sexual harassment cases.
- 17:04So a good one to know about there. If you have
- 17:06that issue, I would certainly put it. front and
- 17:09center. And then on the long -term care facilities,
- 17:14you want to look at whether they're receiving
- 17:16federal funding. And some of these I didn't know
- 17:18about until I went to go write this article.
- 17:21Some of this you just have to look at the fine
- 17:23print. But there is a regulation that says that
- 17:28you may not enter into a pre -dispute agreement
- 17:30for binding arbitration with any resident where
- 17:33the arbitration agreement is a condition of admission
- 17:35into the facility. if you are receiving federal
- 17:39funding. So that's a good one to know about.
- 17:43And on the California Secretary of State Registration,
- 17:48this was a case came down in 2021, Taylor versus
- 17:50Eclipse Senior Living. And the defendant entity
- 17:56has to be registered with the California Secretary
- 17:58of State. And I think the idea is, look, if you're
- 18:02gonna take advantage and leverage our laws, you've
- 18:06gotta be registered. and also pay the dues. So
- 18:11if they're not registered, that entity may not
- 18:13compel arbitration. And there's a case on that.
- 18:17I see a question regarding the Secretary of State.
- 18:24You know what? That's a good question. Would
- 18:26that be curable? I'm not remembering in the Taylor
- 18:30case whether that issue was addressed. But it
- 18:39strikes me that there's a published case on it
- 18:41that they weren't able to, maybe they didn't
- 18:44think of it. I have to think they would have
- 18:45thought of it. So it makes me think that it's
- 18:47not, but I don't know for sure. And that's a
- 18:48good question worth looking at. So moving on
- 18:53to the next slide, if an agreement exists, so
- 18:57let's say, okay, we've got an agreement. Now
- 18:58the question is, is it enforceable? And this
- 19:00I would say is one of the most fertile areas
- 19:04to stop the enforcement of an arbitration agreement.
- 19:09I really call this the Armendaris roadmap. Our
- 19:13Supreme Court gave us a gift in 2000 with the
- 19:16Armendaris case, which really enunciated this
- 19:20two -part sliding scale test. And the two prongs
- 19:25are, the first, of course, is procedural unconscionability
- 19:29and addressing the circumstances and the manner.
- 19:32in which the agreement arose. And then, of course,
- 19:34you've got substantive unconscionability. And
- 19:36there, you're looking for terms of the agreement.
- 19:40Are they themselves unfair? Or do they lack mutuality?
- 19:47And that is one of the court's favorite areas
- 19:50to look at when you want to show that an agreement
- 19:53is substantively unconscionable, is to show that
- 19:55it is non -mutual. So with that, We'll get some
- 20:03recent examples here. Someone's asking Susie
- 20:05if we'll get a copy of the slides. I'm personally
- 20:08very happy to send anyone a copy of the slides
- 20:11if the organization does not provide it, if that's
- 20:14permissible, if that's okay with you, Susie.
- 20:18You could certainly drop my email in the chat
- 20:20and anyone could email me. But Susie, I defer
- 20:25to you on that. Okay, if an agreement exists,
- 20:28is it enforceable? Here's some recent examples.
- 20:302025 cases, three of them. The Gerganis case.
- 20:34A trial court properly denied a motion to compel
- 20:37arbitration where multiple agreements simultaneously
- 20:41signed by the employee had the net effect of
- 20:45destroying mutuality. And so you want to be aware,
- 20:48not just of this agreement, but what was kind
- 20:50of the whole context? Oh, okay, it was a packet.
- 20:53Well, what did the packet look like? You know,
- 20:57oh, there were three different things that were
- 20:58agreed on right around that time. Let's get all
- 21:00those agreements and put them together so that
- 21:02we can really understand the context that we're
- 21:06operating in. Another 2025 case, the cruise versus
- 21:09tapestry case. Here the second district held
- 21:13that a gray text on off white checkout web page.
- 21:19had a bunch of other distracting elements on
- 21:21it, and that was insufficient to alert a reasonably
- 21:24prudent internet customer that purchasing that
- 21:28website's products would bind them to the terms
- 21:31of use. And that Cruz case upheld the denial
- 21:37of arbitration on that ground. Now the Sanchez
- 21:40case, another 2025 one, here an arbitration agreement
- 21:44was held unconscionable and thus unenforceable.
- 21:47where it contained oppressive terms, prohibitively
- 21:51high fees, and a language the plaintiff did not
- 21:54speak. So one procedural tip as you're looking
- 21:58at these is considering a declaration, of course,
- 22:00from your client. You want to understand from
- 22:03your client, not just what were the other agreements
- 22:05signed, what was the circumstances? Were there
- 22:08language barriers? Were they rushed or pressured
- 22:10to sign? And consider having your client really
- 22:17You know weigh in on that because not only can
- 22:19that be very powerful, of course But remember
- 22:22that's evidence. You cannot get that in in the
- 22:24Court of Appeal I'm always wanting to make sure
- 22:26people really understand this Front and center
- 22:30we need to get all the the details and the juicy
- 22:33tidbits right in there in the record in the trial
- 22:36court because I can't do anything with that in
- 22:39the Court of Appeal if it wasn't in the record
- 22:41in the trial court, so We want to make sure that
- 22:44we get All those goodies in. Excuse me. OK, now
- 22:50we're going to break it down on the two prongs.
- 22:55So cases focusing on procedural unconscionability.
- 22:59So this is really looking at what are the circumstances
- 23:01and in what way did, of course, the more powerful
- 23:04party impose their will to get this agreement
- 23:08signed so that it really wasn't the product of
- 23:12a knowing and voluntary agreement. On the left
- 23:15side, we got the Odo case. It's a 2019 case.
- 23:18In this case, the court held there was an unusually
- 23:21high degree of procedural unconscionability.
- 23:23And of course, we know, I forgot to mention,
- 23:25but I'm sure it sounds like you're all quite
- 23:28experienced from what I've been scanning here.
- 23:30We're dealing with a sliding scale. So the more
- 23:34procedural unconscionability we have, the less
- 23:37substantive unconscionability we need to show
- 23:40in order to defeat this motion to compel arbitration
- 23:43and likewise. So the more substantive unconscionability
- 23:47that we're able to show, the less procedural
- 23:50unconscionability we need to show. So with that,
- 23:54we want to keep in mind the sliding scale as
- 23:56we go forward. So it's wonderful when you get
- 23:59a court and authority that you can point to that
- 24:02says, hey, when I tick off these boxes, dear
- 24:07judge, that means this evidence and everything
- 24:11that I've got that lines up on all fours. that
- 24:14equals a high degree, a high degree of procedural
- 24:17unconscionability so that the judge feels comfortable.
- 24:20You don't need to maybe, you know, go to such
- 24:23ends on the substantive unconscionability side
- 24:25if you've really lined up with other cases that
- 24:28show that you really do have a high degree of
- 24:30procedural unconscionability, for example, and
- 24:32of course vice versa. So here in the Odo case,
- 24:37You know, for example, talked about human resources
- 24:39employee who approached the workstation standing
- 24:43over him waiting while he was signing the documents.
- 24:46The employee had no opportunity to read or understand.
- 24:49Of course, the documents were in extremely small
- 24:53font with legal jargon. Of course, there was
- 24:56also a language issue. First language was Chinese
- 24:59for the employee. Of course, there was no Chinese
- 25:02translation. The court. said, look, the document
- 25:06itself and the manner of its presentation did
- 25:09not promote voluntary or informed agreement to
- 25:12its terms. And so this is where you can really
- 25:15get the court in touch with what the experience
- 25:18was like for your client. The middle case here,
- 25:21the Hayden case. Hayden versus Elegance at Dublin.
- 25:262023, the first district court of appeal found,
- 25:29again, quote, high procedural unconscionability.
- 25:32based on both oppression and surprise elements.
- 25:35This was in the context of an elder abuse case,
- 25:39dealing with an elderly resident. And the elderly
- 25:43resident ends up signing this agreement without
- 25:46adequate explanation or an opportunity for review.
- 25:50So again, that was a good example, a case that's
- 25:53showing procedural unconscious ability and focused
- 25:56on that element of the analysis. And last, I
- 25:59just want to highlight the hasty case. Again,
- 26:01another 2023 case here. It was the third district
- 26:04court of appeal. Again, finding a high degree
- 26:07of procedural unconscionability where an employment
- 26:10arbitration agreement was presented as a contract
- 26:13of adhesion with significant surprise elements.
- 26:17And, you know, the courts focused on the adhesive
- 26:21nature of the agreement. You know, again, this
- 26:23is just an agreement that's presented on a take
- 26:26it or leave it basis, which is almost always
- 26:28the case. in all the agreements that I've seen
- 26:31in litigation that you're probably gonna be dealing
- 26:33with as well. And then also they're looking at,
- 26:37you know, how is the physical presentation of
- 26:40it? It's dense formatting, it's small font, complex
- 26:43legal jargon, makes it difficult to understand.
- 26:47So it tends to hide or obfuscate, you know, what
- 26:51is it that the person's really agreeing to? And
- 26:54why is that? Because they don't want someone
- 26:56to really know because... um you know they want
- 26:58them to just sign it so pardon me those are good
- 27:04examples of cases that you want to have very
- 27:07recent in your back pocket on um procedural unconscious
- 27:11ability okay moving to substantive unconscious
- 27:15ability the ollie versus daylight case um 2020
- 27:22This is a jam -packed with goodies this 2020
- 27:25case the first district Court of Appeal Just
- 27:29goes to town and highlights a bunch of specifically
- 27:34substance excuse me Substantively unconscionable
- 27:39terms that rendered an arbitration agreement
- 27:42unenforceable, so First they said okay the agreement
- 27:47has a hundred and twenty day statute of limitations.
- 27:49I mean this is outrageous. They said, this is
- 27:53substantially shorter than the statutory limits
- 27:55for labor code claims. Typically, that's three
- 27:57to four year limitation periods, and now it's
- 28:00being shortened. I mean, this is an abridgment
- 28:02of people's rights, so it's substantively unconscionable.
- 28:06Another term. Second, they said, the parties
- 28:10of the agreement required parties to split the
- 28:12cost of arbitration. And they said, look, going
- 28:15back to Armendariz, this has always been frowned
- 28:17upon. because a cost greater than the filing
- 28:21fees associated with litigation deters claims.
- 28:25And that requires employers to bear, Armendariz
- 28:28requires employers to bear most arbitration costs
- 28:31to avoid effectively blocking employees access.
- 28:35So that was another bad one. Third, the court
- 28:38also identified that the agreement contained
- 28:41a one -sided provisional remedy that permits
- 28:45the employer to seek a remedy from the court,
- 28:50but precludes plaintiffs from equivalent access.
- 28:53So therefore, it's non -mutual, it's unfairly
- 28:56asymmetric, and it favors the employer. Great
- 29:01case there that Olly versus Daylight Transport.
- 29:05In 2022, Mills versus Facility came down, and
- 29:08here the Second District Court of Appeal is looking
- 29:11again at multiple substantively unconscionable
- 29:14provisions including provisions barring reallocation
- 29:18of administrative costs, requiring employees
- 29:21to pay arbitrators costs on appeal, and asymmetric
- 29:25attorney fee shifting provisions favoring the
- 29:28employer, as well as, of course, discovery limitations
- 29:31that undermine employees' ability to pursue statutory
- 29:34claims. And that is a good one to know about
- 29:38because there's a whole nother thread of cases,
- 29:40and you're probably aware if you do employment
- 29:43cases, and I handle employment cases that my
- 29:46appeals as well. And you see, excuse me, that
- 29:51courts are absolutely concerned in particular
- 29:55with employment cases about discovery rates.
- 29:58And why is that? Because when you file an employment
- 30:01claim, the person who is the defendant has all
- 30:05the evidence, right? They have your employee
- 30:08file. They employ most of the witnesses. And
- 30:12so, all of a sudden, you're really in a vulnerable
- 30:16position. And courts do appreciate that aspect.
- 30:19And so they are particularly sensitive to provisions
- 30:22that abridge discovery rights in employment cases
- 30:26in particular. So that's something to watch out
- 30:28for. Last one I'm going to highlight here on
- 30:32the substantive unconscionability is 2024 case
- 30:35of Jenkins versus dermatology management. Again,
- 30:38here, the second district court of appeal. focused
- 30:42on the substantively unconscionable terms here
- 30:44in this employment arbitration agreement. Again,
- 30:48dealing with lack of mutuality, which is really
- 30:50just a key. If you can find non -mutual terms,
- 30:54that's really a winner when you're in the substantive
- 30:57unconscionability landscape. In addition, there
- 31:01were shortened statute limitations provisions,
- 31:05cost sharing requirements for arbitrator fees,
- 31:07and discovery limitations. including a provision
- 31:12that limited employees' ability to obtain necessary
- 31:14evidence while not imposing similar restrictions
- 31:17on employers. So again, we see this unfairness,
- 31:22and courts don't like that. So that was really
- 31:24powerful in the Jenkins case. Okay. This is,
- 31:33again, getting back to that basic bedrock principle
- 31:36that you can only be compelled to arbitrate something
- 31:41you've agreed to arbitrate. So maybe the claim,
- 31:46the claim itself is really outside the scope
- 31:48of the agreement. And that's something to look
- 31:50at in particular. Pardon me. In particular, when
- 32:00you're dealing with an assault case, an assault
- 32:05of any kind is a good assault and fraud. And
- 32:09that's there on the lower left. But those are
- 32:11good. You want to kind of have your antlers up
- 32:15and your radar on if you've got those kinds of
- 32:17cases, because it may well be that there's a
- 32:21strong argument that the arbitration agreement,
- 32:26even if there was a valid agreement, it doesn't
- 32:28apply to your claims. So for example, with the
- 32:33Ahern case, and of course, Victoria versus Superior
- 32:36Court, In the Victoria case, the Supreme Court
- 32:41ruled that a plaintiff who was a hospital patient
- 32:46alleged that she was assaulted by a hospital
- 32:50orderly. And the denial of arbitration was upheld.
- 32:54They said, look, this attack could not have been
- 32:57contemplated by either party. And so it's difficult
- 33:00to conclude that the parties agreed that causes
- 33:04of action arising from such an attack. would
- 33:07be within the scope of an arbitration clause
- 33:11that's about patient care. So those are good
- 33:16to have in your back pocket. And courts have
- 33:21to look at, again, that's back to this public
- 33:24policy of enforcing arbitration agreements. It
- 33:26doesn't apply if you actually didn't agree to
- 33:29arbitrate the dispute. And so if it's outside
- 33:31the scope of the agreement, then you didn't agree
- 33:34to arbitrate it. So that's another angle. to
- 33:36take. One thing I want to share with all of you,
- 33:45two things to look at on did the party requesting
- 33:50arbitration fail to pay or did they waive their
- 33:54right to arbitrate? You know, as we think about
- 33:59showing, and there's some recent, you know, obviously
- 34:01statutes and we're going to go through this,
- 34:03but There is conduct that you can point to and
- 34:06you want to be really watching and sometimes
- 34:09you'll see it a mile away. But for the party
- 34:12who's trying to assert the right to arbitration.
- 34:18They've got to be consistent. They've got to
- 34:20follow. And they've got to follow up. They've
- 34:25got to pay the bills and those are requirements
- 34:30that can be enforced. now by statute. So when
- 34:36we're talking about, and I'll take waiver first,
- 34:41when we're talking about waiver, courts apply
- 34:44a fact -intensive analysis. And this is something
- 34:48where you might really be taken by surprise.
- 34:51When you get this motion to compel arbitration,
- 34:55you might be well down the road in litigation.
- 34:58Typically, you see it early on. But sometimes,
- 35:04they might lie and wait. And they might say,
- 35:06well, let's see. Maybe this judge is going to
- 35:10be great. Maybe we're going to have some advantages
- 35:19in this forum. And so maybe we want to stay in
- 35:21superior court. And you might realize that when
- 35:28they when they file a motion to compel right
- 35:31after they lost a big motion you know maybe this
- 35:35whole time they've just been lying in wait to
- 35:38kind of decide when the right time wants to do
- 35:40it or maybe they didn't realize you know and
- 35:42maybe they just now realized oh my gosh you know
- 35:45there's this arbitration agreement and you know
- 35:50let's try to assert our right to arbitrate whatever
- 35:52the case may be Here you are, you're well down
- 35:55the road in litigation, and all of a sudden you
- 35:56get this motion to compel arbitration. And that's
- 35:59a scenario where you really want to look at documenting
- 36:01the conduct, the way that they took advantage
- 36:06of the litigation process, the way that they
- 36:08availed themselves of the trial court before
- 36:12moving to compel arbitration. And you want to
- 36:15be able to make the argument that they have,
- 36:18through that conduct, waived their right to arbitration.
- 36:24And I'm going to share with you, and I apologize
- 36:27in advance because I got so excited about this
- 36:30that I went and found three cases that I wanted
- 36:33to make sure and share with you. And so these
- 36:35are not on the slides. Susie, if it's possible
- 36:39to share my email address in the chat, it's Valerie
- 36:45at plaintiffsappeals .com. But if you're willing,
- 36:48if you're able to just drop that into the chat.
- 36:51anybody could email me directly. I'd be happy
- 36:53to just send you just these three cases, because
- 36:57these are not on the slides. And again, I apologize
- 36:59for that. But if you want that, I'm happy to
- 37:02get it to you. So the first one is the California
- 37:05Supreme Court decision. And it changed the way
- 37:09that courts look at waiver. In 2024, it's called
- 37:12Kwok versus California Commerce Club. The Supreme
- 37:17Court established the current standard for analyzing
- 37:20arbitration waiver claims in California. So,
- 37:24Kwok held that to establish waiver under generally
- 37:28applicable contract law, the party opposing enforcement
- 37:32must prove by clear and convincing evidence that
- 37:34the waving party knew of the contractual right
- 37:37and intentionally relinquished or abandoned it.
- 37:42The waiver inquiry now focuses exclusively on
- 37:45the waiving party's words or conduct with no
- 37:48requirement to demonstrate prejudice or harm
- 37:51resulting from the waiving party's conduct. So
- 37:54that's a big change because it used to be there
- 37:58was this kind of arbitration specific requirement
- 38:00that you also had to show prejudice. Oh, you
- 38:04know, plaintiff would be prejudice if we now
- 38:08move because we've done all these things in the
- 38:10trial court and we've gone down this path and
- 38:12whatever the case may be. But now that's not
- 38:15part of the inquiry under QOC, that 2024 case
- 38:19that I just mentioned. So you want to make sure
- 38:21that they don't try to mislead or just confuse
- 38:24the court with what the standard is. And you
- 38:28want to make sure that you've got that QOC case
- 38:30in your back pocket. Okay, second case I wanted
- 38:33to share, this is the get on waiver. It's called
- 38:36Ledger, L -E -G -E -R. And it's a 2022 case,
- 38:40Ledger versus RAC, Rolling Hills. And this case
- 38:46demonstrates how strategic delay coupled with
- 38:51inconsistent litigation conduct constitutes waiver.
- 38:56So in this case, active care, was an elder facility.
- 39:00They knew of the arbitration agreement, but they
- 39:02waited until, excuse me, but they waited until
- 39:10after receiving an adverse ruling on the plaintiff's
- 39:13motion for trial preference before filing its
- 39:16petition to compel arbitration. The Court of
- 39:20Appeal affirmed the trial court's waiver finding,
- 39:24noting that active care acted inconsistently
- 39:26with the right to arbitration by waiting until
- 39:29the court ruled on the trial preference motion,
- 39:32evidencing progress of the litigation machinery.
- 39:36And that's a 2022 ledger case that I was just
- 39:42reporting on. The last one I wanted to share
- 39:44with you on waiver. And then I see a question,
- 39:47and I'll go to that question next. It's called
- 39:51Davis versus Chic shoes. So in this Davis case,
- 39:57This case illustrates how extensive delay combined
- 40:01with active litigation participation. Again,
- 40:03you want to have that. That's your favorite combination
- 40:05if you can show those things. A lot of delay
- 40:08and they actively participated. And that equals
- 40:12waiver. So here the employer moved to compel
- 40:15arbitration 19 months after the plaintiff filed
- 40:19suit. But the trial court denied the motion.
- 40:27finding the employer waived its right by unreasonably
- 40:31delaying its arbitration demand and acting inconsistently
- 40:35with an intent to arbitrate. And here's a little
- 40:39key detail. Most damaging under the Davis case
- 40:43was a stipulation between the parties where the
- 40:47employers council stated that they required additional
- 40:50time to complete necessary discovery and prepare
- 40:54for trial. which the court characterized as an
- 40:57affirmative averment that the employer intended
- 41:00to proceed to trial on the merits. So that's
- 41:04another good one to know about Davis versus Sheik
- 41:08Shoes. And so again, I'm happy to email those
- 41:13two. I apologize those weren't on the slides.
- 41:16I hope I'm getting, I see, oh, there's a chat
- 41:18also. Oh, thank you, Susie. I see you dropped
- 41:20my email in the chat. Now I've got the chat box
- 41:23up and the question and answer. Okay. Question.
- 41:27What about situations where the party who moved
- 41:29to compel fails to open it? You know that, Elliot,
- 41:41I see your question. The question, I'll read
- 41:43it for the benefit of the group. What about situations
- 41:45where the party who moved to compel fails to
- 41:48open the arbitration with the Arbitration Tribunal
- 41:51after more than 60 days? And I think there might
- 41:58be, I would look at the statute, I'm gonna cover
- 42:02this next, 1281 .98, and that might be limited
- 42:07only to situations of non -payment for arbitration,
- 42:12but it might be worded more broadly. I would
- 42:15check that statute, number one. And then number
- 42:18two, I think you can always, Go back. So they
- 42:27send you an arbitration. They grant the motion.
- 42:31Now you're in arbitration. And you're sitting
- 42:34around. And it's been more than 60 days. And
- 42:37they are not getting things going. I think you
- 42:41could make an argument. I don't know of a specific
- 42:45case that's addressed that. So you might have
- 42:48to kind of see how you do there. But I have not
- 42:51researched that issue specifically. So anyway,
- 42:53that's a good question, Elliot. I'm going to
- 42:55go to, oh, thank you. And I see Lan's question.
- 42:59I hope I'm not mispronouncing. It might be Ian,
- 43:01but it looks like Lan to me or Lan. In a real
- 43:04estate non -disclosure case where only buyer
- 43:07and seller are parties to an arbitration agreement,
- 43:11is waiver an issue if one party proceeds in state
- 43:14court against the other only because the realtors
- 43:17know parties to the arbitration agreement? are
- 43:21also parties. Only buyer and seller are parties
- 43:33to an arbitrage agreement. What's the other one?
- 43:40Oh, the realtors are not, it's just the buyer
- 43:42and seller who are... You know, I... I think
- 43:49you do have to be able to assert, I'm not sure
- 43:54if I catch the full, all the details of your
- 43:57question, Lon, but I do think in order to assert
- 44:01that someone has waived the right to arbitrate,
- 44:04I do think you need to be able to show that that
- 44:07person was a party to the agreement such that
- 44:10they would have, or that under existing law,
- 44:14they would have had at least a colorable right
- 44:16to assert. a colorable argument to assert their
- 44:20right to arbitration. So I think that's how you'd
- 44:23have to. You'd have to be able to say that if
- 44:27you're going to argue that they waived it. I
- 44:29hope that answers helps answer your question.
- 44:32OK, we're going to move over to the right side
- 44:34of the slide here. Failure to pay. Now this was
- 44:36a pretty recent statute and it's been interpreted
- 44:38even more recently by the Supreme Court. So.
- 44:44You know this statute came about. Sometimes,
- 44:48I mean, as we just saw with one of the questions,
- 44:50you know, you get sent to arbitration and then
- 44:53there's more and more delay and then you're thinking,
- 44:56gosh, you know, do I have any recourse here?
- 44:59And even they're not paying the arbitrator and
- 45:02stuff like this. So along comes CCP 1281 .98.
- 45:11And under that statute, It says, look, if the
- 45:17defendant fails to pay, that maybe they forfeited
- 45:22the right to arbitration. So there's some cases
- 45:24going back and forth about this. But finally,
- 45:29just last year, the Hohenschelt, and I apologize
- 45:33if I'm mispronouncing it, Hohenschelt versus
- 45:35Superior Court 2025 Supreme Court case came down
- 45:39and held that, you know what? It's only if the
- 45:45failure to pay was willful, grossly negligent,
- 45:49or fraudulent. And if it wasn't those things,
- 45:54then the statute doesn't apply, is the way that
- 45:58they interpreted that. And before Hohenschelt
- 46:01was decided, there was conflicting appellate
- 46:03authority as to whether, excuse me, whether that
- 46:11consequence under 1281 .98, whether the forfeiture
- 46:16would apply even to innocent misdeadlines. And
- 46:19so people started to say, well, gosh, if it's
- 46:21going to apply even to innocent deadlines, maybe
- 46:24the FAA preempts this statute. So the Hohenschelt
- 46:29holding was really critical in terms of threading
- 46:32that needle to interpret the statute a little
- 46:35bit more narrowly and that under that interpretation,
- 46:38it is not preempted. by the FAA is where it stands,
- 46:42at least as of Hohenschelt, the decision that
- 46:45came down last year. So I want to make sure you
- 46:48have access to that. That's been changing a lot
- 46:50just in the past couple of years. So the Hohenschelt
- 46:55decision has had off the press. I'm going to
- 46:57take us to our next slide. And the thing that
- 47:02you want to do here, of course, you're not successful
- 47:06in the trial court is, as always, to evaluate
- 47:08your options to take it upstairs. And I think
- 47:13the thing that people often assume, and it's
- 47:18of course true, is that RITs are impossible.
- 47:22And they're close to impossible, but they might
- 47:26still be worth a try. It strikes me that One
- 47:33of the things that courts are aware of, and you
- 47:35can always remind them of this when you filer
- 47:38it, is that the law is not symmetrical. If we
- 47:45lose in our attempt to oppose a motion to compel,
- 47:50we do not have a right of immediate appeal. But
- 47:56unsimilarly, if you lose a motion to compel,
- 48:01that you bring, you do have an immediate right.
- 48:05By statute, absolutely. If they bring a motion
- 48:09to compel arbitration and we successfully oppose
- 48:13that and we get the order, the trial court issues
- 48:15an order denying arbitration, they can appeal
- 48:19that right away. We don't have that same option
- 48:25under the law. And the law is not symmetrical
- 48:28in that regard. And that's something that I think
- 48:33courts, because of that asymmetric nature, courts
- 48:39are also, of course, very mindful of economy
- 48:45of resources and the waste of resources and a
- 48:49process. And to send parties off to arbitration,
- 48:58that's unjustly foisted on them is a pretty big
- 49:04punishment. Particularly, as we've said before,
- 49:08we know that there's no judicial review of arbitration.
- 49:13They're not required to actually follow the law.
- 49:17And there's nothing that we can do about that.
- 49:19It's very difficult to have an arbitration award
- 49:22actually overturned. And so court, you know,
- 49:27appellate courts do understand all of that. And
- 49:30I would say, you know, whether it's unsaid or
- 49:34unspoken, excuse me, in my practice, I have had
- 49:42some of the best luck with writs on arbitration.
- 49:48And I've just seen that in my reading of cases.
- 49:52So I've got a couple authorities to share here
- 49:54with you. But I just want to kind of set that
- 49:57stage because generally I do really, I don't
- 50:02know if I would say discourage, but I really
- 50:04advise people to think carefully before they
- 50:09say, oh, I'll take a writ. And turns out it's
- 50:13a lot of work and a very low probability of success.
- 50:17But with an order -compelling arbitration, Excuse
- 50:25me, it might be worth it because there's no judicial
- 50:29review of your award, or very limited judicial
- 50:33review, I should say, of your award. And obviously,
- 50:38your right to appeal afterward is maybe a little
- 50:41bit of a hollow right, and we'll get into that
- 50:43in a moment. So consider doing a writ. If you're
- 50:48a party that's seeking relief from an order -compelling
- 50:51arbitration based on their inability to pay,
- 50:55also, you know, provides another basis for the
- 50:57court to grant relief from an arbitration that's
- 50:59been ordered. So if that applies to you, of course,
- 51:03or your client, make sure you have a declaration
- 51:05in the documentation to back it up to show that
- 51:07they're not able to pay the arbitration filing
- 51:10fee and costs. And, you know, proceeding via
- 51:16writ is certainly a proper route. And there's
- 51:21the Zempch case. And the Parata versus Superior
- 51:25Court case that also said, you know, in this
- 51:28case, the high cost of arbitrating before a three
- 51:30-judge panel and the amount of time necessary
- 51:33to complete arbitration justify reviewing the
- 51:37order compelling arbitration by writ of mandate.
- 51:40So good authorities to have in your back pocket.
- 51:43And obviously, that's just a start. But you certainly
- 51:47do want to really make sure before you go into
- 51:51a writ, And again, so this is, you know, when
- 51:54you're facing this emotional arbitration, really
- 51:59think about what is the evidence you might possibly
- 52:02want or need, you know, from your client related
- 52:06to finances, related to the circumstances, the
- 52:11other agreements that were signed and the like.
- 52:15So that's something to keep in mind. Excuse me.
- 52:25And then, you know, of course, you can take an
- 52:30appeal. But as I mentioned or alluded to earlier,
- 52:34I consider it a little bit of a hollow right.
- 52:38We have to remember that if you appeal after
- 52:44the award, of course, that means that you lost
- 52:47the arbitration. I mean, if you win an arbitration,
- 52:50you probably would not be appealing, right? So
- 52:55it's just a little bit hard to get out from kind
- 53:02of the aroma of, you know, it sounds like, oh,
- 53:06I'm just an unsuccessful party who's moaning
- 53:09about a technicality, I think is the difficulty.
- 53:12And again, that's unspoken and, you know, it's
- 53:16still your right to appeal, but I have not had
- 53:25success with those. And I think it just, I wish
- 53:33we could change the law and just make it a symmetrical
- 53:35right. So that, you know, whether you win or
- 53:38lose the motion, you know, that's an appealable
- 53:40issue right then to me that that's the fix. But
- 53:43anyway, I'm not in the legislature. So I'm gonna
- 53:45stay in my lane. But I do know that In my practice,
- 53:51I have not had or seen success with that. And
- 53:55I just caution folks to say, oh, well, that's
- 53:58no problem. I have a right to appeal. I can just
- 53:59appeal it later, query whether that's worth the
- 54:05effort and expense, obviously, of doing that.
- 54:08I want to address this. Oh, already won a motion
- 54:12for new trial. Oh, great. Wow, that's awesome.
- 54:17OK, good for you. OK. Okay, last thing, and then
- 54:23I'll let you go. I know it's 1 .26 here. We're
- 54:25ending right on time. Is just kind of a recap,
- 54:28thinking about, you know, what are the things
- 54:29you want to do when you're faced with a motion
- 54:31to compel arbitration? So again, obviously, first
- 54:34and foremost, we're going to review that motion.
- 54:36We're going to take a look up and down. What
- 54:39have they argued? What have they not argued?
- 54:41You know, maybe they missed something. We're
- 54:43not going to help them out, but we want to just
- 54:45understand what are the things that they put
- 54:47forth. And then us knowing the law, we can go
- 54:52through this checklist, of course. And obviously,
- 54:54maybe you have other resources and other checklists,
- 54:57but this can be incorporated into your own checklist
- 55:00to make sure that you're presenting the very
- 55:03best arguments. And I would argue all of the
- 55:06arguments that apply, that are the best. Obviously,
- 55:09you don't just make a knee -jerk argument. But
- 55:12where you feel like it's a strong argument based
- 55:14on the facts and the record in your case and
- 55:17the law, Absolutely, I would put that. And part
- 55:21of the reason is, again, even though this has
- 55:25entitled to almost without fail de novo review,
- 55:30we don't want to get to the Court of Appeal because
- 55:32we've already seen that that's a tortured path.
- 55:34Unfortunately, when it comes to opposing motions
- 55:37to compel arbitration, you're probably going
- 55:38to be trying to get there by way of a writ or
- 55:42else by appeal after the arbitration has already
- 55:44occurred. So we really want to win this and win
- 55:47it now. win it in the trial court. And in my
- 55:50view, the best way to do that is to give the
- 55:53trial court so many formidable hurdles. They
- 55:58have to dismiss argument A, and argument B, and
- 56:01argument C. They have to explain if they're worth
- 56:04their salt. And most trial judges are. They're
- 56:06going to go through and say, wow, OK, plaintiff's
- 56:09got five different arguments as to why this motion
- 56:14to compel should not be granted. And they only
- 56:16have to agree with us on one of them. So I really
- 56:20do encourage folks to go through this checklist.
- 56:22Don't just view it as, oh, they made a motion.
- 56:24I'm just going to respond to their motion. You
- 56:27might have additional arguments, additional reasons.
- 56:30And so I really encourage you to think outside
- 56:33the box to go through your own process and to
- 56:35not have it be defined. by their emotion as you
- 56:40mount and articulate all the best possible arguments
- 56:42for your client. And then the last I would leave
- 56:45you with, of course, interview your client. You
- 56:47want to get their story, get it into the record.
- 56:50Especially it's got to be there in the trial
- 56:51court. So if it can be of use anywhere else,
- 56:53it's got to be entered as evidence in the trial
- 56:56court. And then scouring that agreement yourself.
- 56:59And I used to challenge myself, there's no agreement.
- 57:03that I can't find a problem with it. And so I
- 57:06think when you look at it with that eye, I think
- 57:11you'll probably find things that perhaps surprise
- 57:13even you. So with that, I know it's 1 .29. I'm
- 57:17going to end us on time. Really appreciate your
- 57:19time. And thank you for your patience today as
- 57:21I struggled through with my cold. I hope you
- 57:24found something that was useful and helpful.
- 57:26I love this topic. Again, if you have any other
- 57:29questions, please do feel free to reach out.
- 57:31I know my email's in the chat. Valerie at plaintiffsappeals
- 57:34.com. I wish you the best of luck in defeating
- 57:36all of your motions to compel arbitration, and
- 57:39I'm here if you need. All right. Thanks so much.
- 57:41Have a great rest of your afternoon. Bye -bye.
- 57:44This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 57:46so much, Valerie, for an excellent presentation,
- 57:48and thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 57:50great day, everybody.