Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Dec 21st-Twilight Imperium 4
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all time,
- 0:17according to Board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. I take
- 0:28it back then, Well, everything I said about scythe what's that? I
- 0:33don't know. I'm just thinking, you know, it's the holiday season.
- 0:35I should be a little bit more generous of spirit oepen minded, open hearted,
- 0:41open legged. You know, a lot of people enjoy it, and
- 0:44who am I to say that they're wrong to enjoy what they enjoy. So,
- 0:47you know, I've been having a lot of arguments about this. There's
- 0:50this recent trend recently, Yeah, somewhat recent trend. Recently recent trend recently.
- 0:56I like a tautology occasionally, all right, Yeah? Can I not
- 0:59have a tautology? Kah? You like a tautology? You like to repeat
- 1:00yourself sometimes? I like a tautology occasionally, or I'd like to say the
- 1:03same thing over and over and over and over and over again. Yeah,
- 1:07is it? Sometimes? I like a tautology occasionally? Can I not have
- 1:10a tautology? Sometimes? You can occasionally have a tutology, Ben, It's
- 1:12totally fine to have a tautology sometimes occasionally. So so I ended up when
- 1:17I was rehearsing a play. This is completely nothing to do with the game,
- 1:19by the way, But when I was rehearsing a play in the wait,
- 1:23wait, you're going to tell an anecdote that has nothing to do with
- 1:26the subject at hand. Giles and Giles anyway. So we were devising this
- 1:34play about David Bowie in Berlin in the seventies, and we got into a
- 1:38big row about East Germany and the relative merits of the German communist system.
- 1:46And I was on the relative to what, well, like, like,
- 1:49was it okay to live under that fucking hugely oppressive system for fifty years?
- 1:53Okay? And you're you're taking the Khan argument here, Well, so I
- 2:00I am a believer that you can have de facto universal morality, right,
- 2:08right, that there are certain things that you can say are you might be
- 2:14able philosophically to argue that morality is all relative, right, I mean,
- 2:17like, maybe we could have communism if people are into it, but it's
- 2:22not okay to tell them that you have to spend every holiday in Hungary.
- 2:24So, for instance, my argument in this discussion was, if you face
- 2:36the possibility of having a bullet shot through Ukrainian trying to leave the country that
- 2:44is objectively worse than a country that doesn't have that situation, right, That
- 2:47was my argument, okay, And one of the arguments they even used this
- 2:53to defend the North Korean regime, which blew my fucking mind. Were they're
- 2:58just having a go at you. No, I think, but there is
- 3:01this strand they were saying, well, the point is there were some people
- 3:05who lived in East Germany that enjoyed living there, so there I have no
- 3:08doubt. Therefore, they were saying, therefore, that vindicates the East German
- 3:14system. And there was someone who came onto the discord. And I rarely
- 3:16comment on the discord. Isn't this what people call false consciousness? So yeah,
- 3:22possibly? So really, I rarely comment on the discord because I like
- 3:27people have their own discussions and I don't want to one duly influence them.
- 3:30But someone talked about East Germany and they used a similar argument. Firstly,
- 3:36they repeated the myth that East Germany was a feminist utopia, which is just
- 3:39simply not true. And secondly, they said, you know there were people
- 3:44for whom the system you're going to wind up. The dickheads now, aren't
- 3:46you there were people for whom the system worked. And I'm not going to
- 3:50go through and find my response, but there seems to be this trend in
- 3:54modern sort of ethical discussion whereas you say, well, if some people enjoy
- 3:59it, well, that that vindicates the idea. And because because I think
- 4:05there has been a massive, a massive sort of corruption of moral thought with
- 4:12relativism. Right, yeah, there's also what about is them? Right,
- 4:15there's water about it, but I'm not talking about I'm not talking about what
- 4:18it No, but by making this argument is not as if you're saying everything
- 4:23is all well and good in the West. Well, like we've got it.
- 4:26I mean that's a different thing. So so people often couple it with
- 4:30that too, Like if you if you criticize certain religions, they will say,
- 4:34oh, well, this ex religion is also bad. And it's like
- 4:38sure some some people. Like the system works for some people. I mean
- 4:42the fucking the global capitalist system works pretty well for some people too. And
- 4:46so I find and I think there is a a terrible infection into sort of
- 4:53moral thinking with relativism. This idea that if someone the someone's experience overrides obvious
- 5:02objective bad, So you know, if there are. So they literally said,
- 5:09there are some people within North Korea who that are not the leadership,
- 5:13that love the North Korean regime, so therefore you should you should say the
- 5:18North Korean regime, to which I see where you're going on. So the
- 5:21example I used to contradict this was that fundamentalist Mormon sect that was raided a
- 5:30few years ago, where thirteen year old girls were being married off to fifty
- 5:34year old men, and when the women were taken away for their own safety,
- 5:40they were saying the girls of the women, the fucking girls were saying,
- 5:44we want to go back because they had grown up in that system.
- 5:47And I think we can objectively say that fifty year old men raping thirteen year
- 5:51old girls is unacceptable, right, I think I think we can objectively say
- 5:56that, even though the thirteen year old girls would claim legitimately that that is
- 6:00the system in which they want to live, we can objectively say no,
- 6:02right, can mean not. We can't be relativist about that. Yeah,
- 6:06I mean, I guess it's begging the question a little bit, but it's
- 6:09hard for me to find a flaw in your moral reasoning, right anyway.
- 6:12So, so I see you're you're drawing, Would you then draw an analogy
- 6:15between the let's say, benighted populace of North Korea who quite enjoy being there
- 6:23and and have nothing but like positive things to say and feel about the regime
- 6:26under which they live, and those who play and say that they enjoy the
- 6:30game scythe Well, indeed, we're not talking about size but no, but
- 6:33it's there's another game we're gonna talk about it, or indeed, or indeed,
- 6:39people who claim they enjoy shit Puerto Rico, Twilight Imperiom four. So
- 6:46right, So I hate Twilight Perium three. I fucking hate it, and
- 6:49I hate it more than scythe right. I don't hate Twilight Imperium four.
- 6:56I don't hate it either, but I don't like it. So I had
- 7:00a discussion with someone you might know. He's a German bloke, Martin Waller.
- 7:04No, he's a German bloke permanently dyes his hair, loves a bit
- 7:12of loves a bit of ice hockey. But no like will stay same people.
- 7:18Pete will sing like a line for a song. Yeah, four days
- 7:23in a row that all little come out of his mouth. You're just like
- 7:26making this up. There's no a person who behaves that way. Yeah,
- 7:29yeah, there is so he Klauskinski of German. Indeed, he said that,
- 7:36he said that, you know, he played T I four and he
- 7:40just went, it's just nothing more than average, right, And I think
- 7:44that is a I mean, I don't think you actually likes games particularly,
- 7:46but this is a realistic appraisal of his game. He's German. I mean,
- 7:50you have to calibrate sometimes the way people express enthusiasm or that's like I
- 7:56was. I was with a bunch of Russians the other day. If formerst
- 8:01okay, so I get invited once of months to go to a Russian sauna
- 8:03and you can't say no to this, right, Oh, I don't know
- 8:07how a Russian sauna differentiates itself from a normal sauna. They hit you with
- 8:11these birches, Oh okay, nice, Yeah, it's very like this is
- 8:16a very working class sauna establishment. It's like way out on the edge of
- 8:20Berlin. It's not a very nice place. But a former colleague of mine
- 8:24invited me and it's like him and a bunch of Russians and me, right,
- 8:28and we were talking about something and I forget like what it was.
- 8:31We were referring to, but he said, at some point I really like
- 8:35something. I asked his opinion is like, well, I really have nothing
- 8:37to complain about. I thought this to an America, I have to translate
- 8:41this into American. It's fucking amazing, right, like absolutely incredible. Of
- 8:46course this was like we were drinking so lots of lulls. But you know,
- 8:48he realized, like this is actually true. I mean, people really
- 8:52understate their enthusiasm and appreciation for things. I find in Europe in general,
- 8:56probably the further east you go more so. I guess I don't know.
- 8:58It's like a stereotype. And yet in America everything is awesome, right,
- 9:03talk about devaluing a fucking word. Yeah, like people people will say that
- 9:07things are great when they're not so. Right, you have to there are
- 9:11different ways to read in which they actually mean. Well, because you're central.
- 9:13People say America is a Christian country, it's not a Christian country.
- 9:18Your central fucking core tenet is optimism, right, how dare you not be
- 9:24optimist? Our city on the hill, millinery and enthusiasm. Yeah, yeah,
- 9:28I find twilight imperium I almost said struggle there. Yeah, I find
- 9:33twilight imperium to be just tedious. So I think the thing with Toilet Imperium
- 9:41is I love the honest, direct opinion. I love the aspiration of it,
- 9:43I think. So I don't tend to like long games, but I
- 9:50love the aspiration, the sort of the sort of central ideas wantless to be
- 9:56long and epic, and we want to see, you know, one see
- 10:00it grow from tiny acorns into massive bogs. I just don't think it's implemented
- 10:03particularly well. I think it's I think Twilet and Periom four fixed a lot
- 10:07of the sort of issues of Twilight and Perium three, but it's still to
- 10:11me a bang average game. I just find it boring. And I have
- 10:16said it before, I don't like these space games. They're just like me,
- 10:20you know, like the sort of like the the emptiness of of the
- 10:24map and the emptiness of the content, and these contrived alien races. So
- 10:31this is fascinating. I think it doesn't do it for me for some reason.
- 10:33So I love science fiction. I just like these these sci fi games
- 10:37that the four X sci fi games, they just don't work for them.
- 10:41So I think Eclipse is wonderful. I think Last Light is wonderful, and
- 10:46it genuinely plays in a talk to me about Last Light, and I think
- 10:50you're gonna play it again? Yeah? Sure, I think it's genuinely very
- 10:52good. It's a game. It's going to stay in my collection. But
- 10:58I love the act now the twenty twenty four s and no shipping harsh.
- 11:01So there's also another game that has that aspiration to be epic and fundamentally failed,
- 11:09and that's Colonists. Colonists is like the Twilight Imperium for Eurogames. We
- 11:15did a Colonist Bettle report. We did. But the problem with the game,
- 11:18and I think we said it during that is the in Colonists, just
- 11:20do the same thing. You just do it for eight hours. That doesn't
- 11:24feel like an arc Aristotelean ramping up, you know Aristotelean Aristotelean ramping up?
- 11:31What is what does ramping up have to do with Aristotle or Aristotle structure of
- 11:35drama? Right, builds and builds and build and builds and builds to a
- 11:39denuement and then a Colins was a first designed by a first time game designer.
- 11:46Yes, I think that's probably the issue. He wanted to do a
- 11:50really ambitious game, but without knowing how to design a really ambitious show,
- 11:54it ended up being big but repetitive right toilet I periom full feels like that.
- 12:01So I don't dislike it as much as you. But and i'd liked
- 12:07I three, I hate more than SIDI four. I don't ever want to
- 12:09play it again. This is the thing with me. Whereas I adore I
- 12:13absolutely adore Clips because the Clips is just a tighter design. You feel more
- 12:18engaged in the game as you play it. And I think Last Light is
- 12:22not that I think it's a different type of game, but incredibly clever.
- 12:26I was so surprised at how clever it was. Was it and that it
- 12:30gives you that feeling of a big space four X game in and out.
- 12:35Yeah, I think I just need to play Eclipse again. Maybe I'll settle
- 12:37on that one as the one of these types of games I can tolerate.
- 12:39But you Civilization a New Dawn I think is a great game, and I
- 12:43think I appreciate the four X games. I don't think it's a great game.
- 12:46I think it's I like, Okay, I like, I mean,
- 12:48maybe great is overstating it, but I probably enjoy it more than like you
- 12:54would like, all things being equal, because I appreciate that it's on a
- 12:58map. It's like it's civilization themed. I actually quite like the way the
- 13:03it's very like the the turns are like the same mechanic from Arkanova. I
- 13:07like. I like that mechanism that works for me better than the space version
- 13:11of that. I just I get into it more. So. Do you
- 13:13know what the best four X game is? What? I have a guess.
- 13:18Do we consider Cafe I'm Kanal a four X game? Yeah, Cafe
- 13:22I'm kana It's probably my number two four X game. Yeah, because after
- 13:24you after you finish the solo version and have your drink, ye you go
- 13:28x about it on X four times exactly. Through the Ages is the best
- 13:33four X game. Here we go again. You you stopped every fucking category.
- 13:37Through the ag is the best game. It's even if you have to
- 13:41fucking beggar credibility in order to like the best. It's the best dexterity co
- 13:46op. It's semi coo op as well, but it's definitely the best four
- 13:50X game. I it does the best arc. I mean it is a
- 13:52dexterity game because you fucking aren't that good at it, and end up you
- 13:56can flip the data and we all have to like Dodge that they did the
- 14:00first time I played that because Marios is a twaft anyway, so t I
- 14:05four crap or not crap. Thank you for listening. You can support the
- 14:13show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five g fo D, and join
- 14:16the discord by going to five g f d dot com. Have a very
- 14:22merry Christmas.