Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Star Trek Lower Decks Season 4 Premires Review
Transcript
- 0:04This episode of word Balloon is brought to you by Ahoy Comics. This follow
- 0:08Hooy comics latest jampacked anthology, Project Cryptid, will feature unbelievably hilarious and hilariously
- 0:16unbelievable tales about cryptids from around the world. Project Cryptid will transport readers from
- 0:21the depths of Lochness to the wilds of the Yettis him and Land Mountains to
- 0:26the Ohio back roads where the Loveland Frogman lurks asking the important questions like are
- 0:32any of these mysteries unthinkable creatures actually real? And more importantly, are they
- 0:37funny? The anthology will feature stories from writers like Mark Russell, Paul Cornell,
- 0:43Alyssa Quitney, Alex Sigura, Leanna Kanis, Henry Barajas, Joe Ilitche,
- 0:48Zander Cannon, Gene haf Steward more, and more, along with art
- 0:53from Jordi Perez, Madeleine Seely, p J. Holden, Mike Spicer,
- 0:58Steve Bryant, Pete House, Richard Pace, Jamal Eigle, and more.
- 1:03Project Cryptid will be published monthly by Ahoy and is available now in direct market
- 1:08stores. For more information, go to a For more updates on Ahoy comics.
- 1:12Visit them on x, Facebook and Instagram. Word Balloon is also brought
- 1:18to you by my patrons, the League of word Balloon Listeners via Patreon,
- 1:23Patreon dot com slash word below. If you could subscribe to word Balloon,
- 1:27it would really be greatly appreciated. Took a bit of a financial hit this
- 1:32year and could really use your help. If you enjoy the content I provide
- 1:36every week here in word Balloon on audio and video, you can really help
- 1:40me out by subscribing to word balloon for the price of a comic book.
- 1:42Can you spare five dollars a month? Can you spare even a dollar a
- 1:47month? If you can, If you think the content is worth your time,
- 1:51it would be great. Patreon dot com slash word balloon. Thank you,
- 1:56League of word Balloon Listeners. Word Balloon is brought to you by Alex
- 2:00ross Art dot com. Alex has been a longtime sponsor of word Balloon.
- 2:06I greatly appreciate it. You gotta go to his website. You will find
- 2:08tremendous art from original work, covers, pages, fantastic lithographs, amazing posters.
- 2:17Every price point is covered and every subject is covered at Alex ross Art
- 2:22dot com. You've enjoyed his iconic looks at DC and Marvel, but also
- 2:27great stuff like his wonderful work on the Monkeys, Monty Python, so many
- 2:30other great pop culture things that Alex has put his fingerprints on. His wonderful
- 2:36Flash Gordon poster that evokes the fantastic Tino day La red as Sam Jones movie.
- 2:42Recently, Alex did things like the timeless Marvel covers featuring great solo shots
- 2:47of all your favorite Marvel heroes, and of course his fantastic four Full Circle
- 2:52graphic novel still available all waiting for you now at Alex ross Art dot com.
- 3:14Welcome back everybody, time again for a new word Balloon, but more
- 3:16importantly a new Yeah Trek Watch. All all the regulars are on an away
- 3:22mission in Baltimore, the last day of the Baltimore Comic Con, but I
- 3:24am always happy to welcome back Ed Whitfield Opinionoid to Word balloon Ed, great
- 3:30to see you, thanks for doing this, as always great to see you,
- 3:34John, Thanks for inviting me back. Well man, we have an
- 3:38embarrassment of riches since our last conversation. The first two Lower Decks and Star
- 3:44Trek Day. I don't know if you watch day we celebrate in England,
- 3:50but it's a little bit quiet. I wasn't sure because it really Star Trek
- 3:54Day. I mean it always is a commercial for Paramount Plus. Yeah,
- 4:00but it certainly wasn't abbreviated Star Trek Day broadcast because of I'm sure the writers
- 4:08are the actors strike and you know they've they're really focused on Jerry O'Connell and
- 4:14the guy that plays Rutherford, and of course Tony Newsome who's Mariner on lowered
- 4:19acts, and that's fine. They're of their animation actors so they can do
- 4:23it. Also, oddly a celebration of Star Trek Animation because it's the fiftieth
- 4:30anniversary of the original animated series, which I'm a massive fan of. I
- 4:34do love that show. Did you watch that show when you were a kid?
- 4:39I did. I loved it and I was a little I guess we're
- 4:43going to talk about the very short track Skin a Cat, which they put
- 4:47up as a tribute, and I don't know. There's there's two ways you
- 4:50can look at that. I suppose you can look at it as a sort
- 4:54of affectionate, tongue in cheek homage to the animated series or what you can
- 5:00see it as a sort of another example of the people who are making trip
- 5:05now not really understanding the central appeal of the thing that they're you know,
- 5:12riffing on or referring to. But you know, I'm sure we'll I'm sure
- 5:15we'll get into that. We say, we saw a very small clip here
- 5:21in England. We didn't get the full you know, well you didn't.
- 5:25You didn't get there. You didn't get the three minute quite actual fullthing.
- 5:30No, no, no, So we've got we've got that. But I
- 5:30was just going to say, because you mentioned at the top that Star Trek
- 5:34Day thing, Jerry O'Connell and so on, I just wonder if you thought
- 5:39it was weird that he seemed to be doing impression of Will Wheaton from the
- 5:42from the yeah, you know, the reading room. What's going on there?
- 5:46What's that about? I don't know, you know, And it's it's
- 5:48I was telling you. Half the year, I had the pleasure of meeting
- 5:53Jerry and Rebecca Remain and I've met Freakes before, but it was nice seeing
- 5:57Freakes again and Jeffrey Colms. They were all a terrific in Connecticut, and
- 6:02really, like Jerry is a very gregarious guy. And my friend and I
- 6:08were in the green room talking amongst ourselves and maybe one of us looked up
- 6:13and saw him, but he walked up to us and we're just sitting at
- 6:15one of the tables in the green room. How you doing. My name
- 6:18is Jerry. I'm like, yeah, I know you are, like I
- 6:20was, I was planning to talk to you. He didn't have an autograph
- 6:24booth. He was really there to a company. Rebecca remain in her table,
- 6:30and he would work the line as people were waiting to get an autograph
- 6:33in a photo with Rebecca and was just charming as hell. And you know
- 6:39how you're doing. I said, oh, I'm so glad you came whatever,
- 6:43And of course everyone was delighted to meet him capt you know, Commander
- 6:46Ransom of course on Lower Dex. But yeah, he was a little too
- 6:49cloying in and I'm sure that's how they're directing him. On a sight,
- 6:57he was so close to Will waiting, you know, if you if you
- 7:00squinted, it was like Will Wheaton was there and I was watching it.
- 7:03I was thinking, is he being directed to talk that way? Or you
- 7:08know, I mean, why not just present with your own sort of personality.
- 7:13What is this kind of affected, strange kind of parody of a Star
- 7:19Trek geek that they that they do or are they both like that? Because
- 7:24every time you still see Will Wheaton these days, it seems to be doing
- 7:28the same stick and you think, well, has something happened to them?
- 7:31And you know in middle eight what's going on? No? I really I
- 7:35really want John. Yeah, they amp up the glee to a really embarrassing
- 7:42level if you're at all an adult. And also, I don't you think
- 7:46it underlines this subtext of I think New Trek in general, where they play
- 7:53at Star Trek they're not and you don't want to. You certainly don't want
- 7:57to come off as one of these uber nerds and maybe v I will as
- 8:01as you know, taking it way too seriously. But it's like it's entertaining
- 8:05enough without it having to be used in Yiddish terms, you know, every
- 8:11five minutes of isn't it silly? Isn't it silly that we love this silly
- 8:15thing? Yeah? Yeah, I know, I know what you made.
- 8:18And it's almost an attempt to tell you how to feel rather than allowing you
- 8:22just to feel something, because you know you have a natural affection for it
- 8:28in some one. It's almost like John, they don't trust the audience.
- 8:33Yes, yes, I think that's true, and I certainly think that's the
- 8:37case of this new audience that they're trying to attract and go, hey,
- 8:41Star Trek's fun. Isn't Star Trek fun? And it's like, yeah,
- 8:43it is fun, of course it is, but again, tone it down,
- 8:46you know. God. One of the things in Star Trek Day that
- 8:50annoyed the hell out of me was they went through all the new shows and
- 8:54they and you know, this is what Discovery is, and this is what
- 8:56Picard is, and this is what Strange and they got into Strange New Worlds
- 9:01and they're like Strange New Worlds that features the early adventures of the Enterprise,
- 9:07but also they went into it I'm gonna miss speak the actual words, but
- 9:13essentially, like, this show plays with a lot of genres from comedy to
- 9:18musical to whatever, and it's like, oh shit, I think they just
- 9:20told this season three is going to be more bullshit and less Star Trek.
- 9:24And it's like, man, you guys think you are so goddamn clever,
- 9:28and it's it's so annoying. It is so annoying. They have said,
- 9:33I think quite openly that they intend to double down in season three and what
- 9:37they've done in season two. There was an article I'm sure you read or
- 9:41maybe I can't think who who who it was who was quoted, but as
- 9:46a member of the Strange New World sort of writer's room, and they were
- 9:50saying, Hey, we wish we could go for twenty episodes a year.
- 9:52You know, it'd be great to go for twenty episodes a year, just
- 9:56like the old Star Trek TV season. And you're sitting there thin, fuck,
- 10:01what would you do with twenty episodes? You know, look, look
- 10:03at the damage you've done with ten is bad? If you want I didn't.
- 10:09I did read an article that was more of I guess slightly critical,
- 10:16saying were there too many gimmicks in a ten episode season? And I'm like,
- 10:22yes, very much so, and that's why maybe tal question, yeah
- 10:26exactly, but but was very positive about each gimmick episode spot being Human,
- 10:33the musical episode. What was the other gimmick of the year, Oh,
- 10:37the crossover of course. No. Listen, we haven't talked d I don't
- 10:41remember if our last conversation we talked about the crossover. I'll even say I
- 10:45liked the crossover. I thought it was fine for what it was. It
- 10:48depends, of course, how much you like Lower Decks, doesn't it.
- 10:52I mean that's the key factor. You know, if this was an import
- 10:56from a show you love, with two characters that you really delighted to see
- 11:00in live action, then yeah, as a perfectly lighthearted and enjoyable episode.
- 11:05But if you think that all the characters and Lower Decks are irritants who have
- 11:11no place in the Star Trek universe, then seeing them in live action is
- 11:16sort of doubly insulting. It's like, oh my god, they've got here.
- 11:20They are, and they're even louder and more immediate than they were in
- 11:24their own show. So I personally didn't like it, but only because,
- 11:28as I'm sure we'll come to, I find Lower Decks almost cruciating and it's
- 11:35very hard for me to watch it. Well, that's interesting, because honestly,
- 11:39I did feel that Boimler and Mariner as live action characters were a bit
- 11:46toned down in my personal opinion. I mean, listen, and I feel
- 11:50so bad because I've seen them in the flesh. I suppose it just you
- 11:54know, it feels like they're a bit closer to you, doesn't it.
- 11:58Well, whatever, it just again I felt Boimler was less, even though
- 12:03there were moments where you know, he in spot blew up whatever they were
- 12:07working on, and some panicky moments here and there, and nervous moments here
- 12:11and there. First of all, and maybe we've discussed before, I know
- 12:15I have when I talk about Lower Dex. When when when I think I'm
- 12:20watching bad comedy, people speak louder and faster to kind of let you almost
- 12:26go, all right, we know this isn't that good, but we'll get
- 12:28through it. Let's just get through the scene. Get through the scene.
- 12:31And I always feel like that is a recurring thing in Lower Dex. And
- 12:35certainly the second episode that they dropped this week I really hated with a passion,
- 12:41But I, like I said, I did feel in the crossover they
- 12:46were a little quieter, a little more real as they should have been being
- 12:50in real real life. But again, to me, really good like The
- 12:54Simpsons doesn't scream at you the way Lower Dex does, and other really good
- 13:01animated King of the Hill, one of my absolute favorite shows, was an
- 13:05animated situation comedy that happened to be an animated would have played it just as
- 13:11well as a live action thing, and it was people speaking in normal tones.
- 13:15I like low key, smart humor. I don't like over the tip
- 13:18idiot humor. I agree, I agree with that, but I think that
- 13:22I mean, maybe it's worth taking a step back and just talking about why
- 13:26Lower Decks isn't funny. If it isn't funny, if you don't find it
- 13:30funny, I wouldn't wish to presume either way. But let's let's imagine for
- 13:35a moment that Lower Decks is stultifyingly unfunny. If that's true, then perhaps
- 13:41the reason is because it exists in this kind of zany comic universe in which
- 13:48everybody's on and everyone's in on the joke. Okay, Now, for me,
- 13:52I think you would have some sympathy with this. The best kind of
- 13:56comedy for me, involves that sort of tension between the real world, the
- 14:01sort of grounded real world or grounded dramatic situation, and characters who have a
- 14:09comic sensibility. So I would say I would give the golden example of this
- 14:13being the original Ghostbusters and nineteen eighty four Ghostbusters. If you look at the
- 14:20difference between it and the twenty sixteen remake of Ghostbusters. Forget all the gender
- 14:24politics crap for a moment. Put that to one side. We're talking purely
- 14:28about tone here, Okay. In the nineteen eighty four movie, the film
- 14:33is set ostensibly in the real world, and the comedy comes from that tension
- 14:39between characters like Vankman and characters like Walda Peck and so on and all the
- 14:45rest of it. Yes, in the twenty sixteen movie, it's a day
- 14:50glow bubble gum comedy sketch universe in which everybody's on and everybody's going for the
- 14:58gag, very funny or smart gags, mostly sort of improvised bullshit. But
- 15:03you know that's the difference. Now. Lower Decks to me is like the
- 15:07twenty sixteen Ghostbusters, not the original. Sadly, if it were the original,
- 15:15then you'd be like, Okay, there's room here. Because we may
- 15:18have talked about this before. The idea of a Star Trek sitcom is not
- 15:24ludicrous enough who work, but tone is very important. Trying to find the
- 15:31humor, the right type of humor to make it work so it doesn't belittle
- 15:37Star Trek. If it doesn't draw attention to it's it's more sort of zony
- 15:46or chooky elements, you know. And we will talk about the season premiere
- 15:50of season four premiere two VIX, which I think you know is a prime
- 15:56example of getting it wrong. But we'll come back to that momentary. So
- 16:00here's the thing, right, You've got a show in lower Decks that is
- 16:06hemmed in in my opinion, right, So it can't be too off the
- 16:11wall or meta, because if it was, then it would not be able
- 16:18to coexist within the Star Trek universe. It couldn't sit alongside TNNG Voyager,
- 16:23d S nine or whatever. And it's going to have any pretensions to be
- 16:27part of that universe, it has to be somehow constrained, you know.
- 16:33It can't be Rick and Morty for example, that risks on sci fi conventions
- 16:37and all the rest of it. But it can't be too a reverend either.
- 16:41But it can't be Red Dwarf for love read Dwarf right. But Red
- 16:48Dwarf is a show where obviously it's said in its own universe, but it's
- 16:52also a show that is sending up science fiction in general. There's a famous
- 16:57scene in in Red Dwarf where Rimmers saying something kind of stoic and philosophical and
- 17:06all the rest of it, and Lister, who's just woken up with a
- 17:07hangover, says that, don't give me that Star Trek crap. It's just
- 17:11too early in the morning, you know, all of this stuff. So
- 17:15they know about you know, it's a world in which all of this stuff
- 17:17at ziss and they understand what the tropes are and the conventions are. But
- 17:22a show, said in the Star Trek universe shouldn't be aware of the tropes
- 17:26and conventions. It shouldn't be a show where all the characters of the same
- 17:30cultural reference points as the audience. That's the fatal flaw in it. Why
- 17:36do they have the same cultural reference points as the audience? Why are they
- 17:40as cited about seeing the Voyager again as we are? Because that's all these
- 17:45riders have got, that's their only source of information. That's there any sort
- 17:49of comic inspiration. They can't go too far in either directions, so they
- 17:55have to draw on the universe itself and sort of eat it if you like.
- 18:00They're kind of like that creature in the second episode that sucks the bones
- 18:04out of the out of the beans and leaves them in a sort of heaper
- 18:10of loose skin. You know, that's what Lower Decks is doing to the
- 18:14Star Trek franchise. It's sucking on its bones essentially, right, So I'm
- 18:19sorry, I was just finish your third please. Yeah. Where I'm going
- 18:25with all of this? It sounds like people are listening to this thinking he's
- 18:29going somewhere. Yes I am, it's not just a tangential rand. What
- 18:36type of humor could work as a Star Trek sitcom? That's the point right
- 18:41now. I was thinking about this because I knew were going to come on
- 18:44talk to you about this, and I thought, well, there must be
- 18:47like a model where you can satirize or draw attention to the insanity in certain
- 18:55situations without belittling the situation itself or making a mockery per se of the universe.
- 19:04And the model I came up with, which I'm sure a lot of
- 19:08people will say, ed, I don't think that this is a good analogy,
- 19:12but go ahead, run with it, is the UK sitcom Blackadder Goes
- 19:18Fourth And I don't know if you're familiar with Blackaddam very much so, and
- 19:22especially in the US, is a sitcom BBC sitcom which is set in different
- 19:30historic periods, and basically each series is about six episodes and it picks up
- 19:37in different eras in British history with the app with the descendants of the previous
- 19:45characters, you know, finding each other again if you like, and being
- 19:48in that situation. I'm a much more of a Blackadder fan than I am
- 19:52a Mister Bean fan. It's Rowan Atkinson, right, and I mean,
- 19:56I appreciate the physicality of mister Bean, but there really is a lot more
- 20:00clever things going on in the various series of Black Addict please get indeed,
- 20:06and Blackadder is is very much deadpan, irreverent, sardonic humor. It's it's
- 20:12sarcastic humor if you like. And the fourth season is set in the First
- 20:19World War in the trenches. The First World War. Now, initially you
- 20:25think, hmm, okay, on paper, this could be problematic, right,
- 20:27they're going to mock the people who who fought and died in the First
- 20:33World War. But no they're not, because the gangs there are of course,
- 20:37there are jokes about the deprivations, about having to eat rats and all
- 20:41the rest of it. And you know, the ludicrous that the cheap value
- 20:45that's placed on human life. In one episode, Blackadder is brought before a
- 20:51court martial because he shot a messaging pigeon, you know, And before he
- 20:56shoots it, he says, look, with fifty thousand men being killed every
- 20:59week, who's going to miss pigeon? But it's the favorite pigeon of the
- 21:03local general. So it gets all of all of this sort of thing.
- 21:07Now here's the point, right, because yeah, there is one, I
- 21:11promise. The point is if you can make a sitcom about the First World
- 21:19War, about being in the trenches, about being in the mud with the
- 21:23rats and fifty thousand people being killed every day, and still finish on a
- 21:30really poignant moment because I won't spoil it for anyone who hasn't seen it,
- 21:34but the finality actually yes, with a deeply moving scene which I won't spoil,
- 21:41but the point, but I'm sure you can guess the gist of it,
- 21:45right they spoiler they don't all go home and live happily ever after.
- 21:51Okay, So here's the point right there? Where do they mind the humor
- 21:56from? They mind it from the ludicrous the insanity of the situation, But
- 22:02you still feel throughout the whole thing, that there is a serious point being
- 22:06made, a serious undercurrent to the whole thing. They're not trivializing it.
- 22:11They're not saying that these men are stupid. They're saying that they're victims,
- 22:15are victims of elitists thinking, they're victims of, you know, a sort
- 22:21of very flippant attitude to human life. They're victims of a incredibly unlikely political
- 22:29situation which has brought them all into this ridiculous war of attrition, which is,
- 22:34you know, not winnable in any real sense. You know. So
- 22:40now, if they can make a sit come out of that, someone can
- 22:44make a sit concept in the Star Trek universe that does not dilute the seriousness
- 22:51of all of the situations that Starfleet officers might get into, whether it be
- 22:56you know, war or life threatening situations on other planets and so on and
- 23:00so on. All it requires is somebody with a little bit of wit and
- 23:06intelligence and a little and an understanding of routing the humor in the characters and
- 23:14their interactions rather than making you know, a mockery of the universe around you.
- 23:21And I know a man would say, oh, but we're not doing
- 23:25that we're not punching down, We're not you know. Well, all I
- 23:29would say to him is maybe you should watch his own show, because you
- 23:33know two Vix, which Two Vix the fourth season opener, which is a
- 23:41sort of sequel to two Vix. Certainly, Look, here's the thing,
- 23:48Two Vix. The Voyager episode is silly enough as it is. It doesn't
- 23:52need to be spoofed. I mean, I mean they put a reference to
- 23:56Threshold in that episode as well. I know tiste Agea, the robotic Salamander's
- 24:02absolutely Sumanders. Yeah, yeah, And I just looked to myself, Look,
- 24:06this is a bit like the difference between Scream and Scary Movie. Right,
- 24:11the people who made Scary Movie didn't get the memo that Scream is a
- 24:18sort of self aware meta horror movie that's both been a great horror movie,
- 24:25but it's also having fun with horror movie conventions. On Absolutely, you don't
- 24:32need to spoof it. You're spoofing a spoof in a way. Right.
- 24:37That to me was like the relationship between two Vics and two Vics. You
- 24:44know, I'll be honest, said, and maybe I've been beaten into submission,
- 24:48but of the two episodes, I actually liked two VIX because I have
- 24:53accepted that this is as you've aptly described it. This is what where dex
- 25:00is lower dex is. Remember every goofy moment of Star Trek, Well,
- 25:04we're gonna take a piss on it, and that's fine. And again I
- 25:07guess I've accepted that. But and I didn't mind. I didn't. I
- 25:14like seeing Voyager much like Teach Space nine last season, they did a great
- 25:18job of presenting Voyager again in a design standpoint. It was great seeing all
- 25:22the the you know, the backgrounds and the various parts of the ship,
- 25:29and you know, it was cute seeing that as they're establishing this Voyager as
- 25:33a museum on Earth, seeing the mannequins that have the costumes on and everything.
- 25:37All that's fine. And I actually I didn't mind. I didn't mind
- 25:41this two VEX. And I didn't mind the premise. I love that they
- 25:45threw in the evil clown and Chaotica and Michael Sullivan and even like the brief
- 25:52moment where Michael Sullivan first of all falls in love with Mariner and then also
- 25:56later says I missed my wife. You know, those were okay, because
- 26:00yeah, I've accepted the premise. What what drives me nuts is the second
- 26:04episode and this insistence that, oh, no, Mariner being a jerk is
- 26:11really really funny, and it's like, no, it really really isn't and
- 26:15and it oh, it was just well I know, and I'm oh,
- 26:18Ransom's trying to screw up my promotion. Well, I'm going to screw it
- 26:19up myself. And it's like, to what end there's no logic. I
- 26:23mean, there has to be logic behind clever humor, and there works and
- 26:29caused the c and they will want to be together, don't they. But
- 26:33they don't. They don't want too much responsibility, which of course is only
- 26:38the other three want the responsibility and love being on the ship. But mentally
- 26:44that ed forgive me real fast the whole and again as opposed to Blackadder that
- 26:49would have a serious moment or a good character moment over they just keep coming
- 26:53back to, well, isn't it great that we're all together and we're all
- 26:56a team, and it's so great that we all like each other. And
- 26:59it's like, is this my little pony friendship is magic? I'm like,
- 27:03come on, be smarter than that. And it's this is the adult animated
- 27:07show, which is ironic. Also, by the way, Star Trek Day,
- 27:11Hey, it was, as Langley pointed out in the comments, Yeah
- 27:15we're celebrating animation, but we're gonna blow off Prodigy. And I get it,
- 27:19it was a commercial for Paramount Plus. It's not I mean even the
- 27:23first season isn't on Paramount Plus anymore. But by the same token, there
- 27:27was this real irony that all of us, as loyal Star Trek fans,
- 27:32are going while you're celebrating animation, and Prodigy is one of the best animated
- 27:36Trek products. I think I think it's a very good show. Let's let's
- 27:41look back for a magent. What did you think of that very short Trek
- 27:44that paid No, we'll get to it. Yeah, absolutely, I'm happy
- 27:48to talk about it now. I didn't what drove me nuts about it?
- 27:52And let's start off with the one of the establishing shots. And right there,
- 27:56now I know they build this man and in gold as Air quotes the
- 28:02captain. Yeah, but come on, come on, don't please, don't
- 28:07gaslight us. We all know who this is supposed to be. And also
- 28:11I will say it's a shame because a really great comedian and a very sweet
- 28:17guy Pete Holmes. I don't know how much or where you are of his
- 28:21humor, but he is, first of all, a very devoted nerd and
- 28:26has made very funny parodies of X Men and Batman and Bain and all these
- 28:30things over the years. So from I understand it was interesting. A friend
- 28:34of mine was like, Hey, how come they name news Paul Wesley.
- 28:37I'm like, no disrespect to pause Wesley. I don't know if he could
- 28:41carry the comedy, but regardless, I think calling him the captain rather than
- 28:47Kirk when we obviously know, come on, this is it's it's supposed to
- 28:51be Jim Kirk. Give me a fucking break. Of course, it's Jim
- 28:55Kirk, who is alien race, really insensitive, alien insensitive, and it's
- 29:03it's their go to move of once again, the white guy's the moron in
- 29:07this equation. And so I didn't I mean, I really didn't mind.
- 29:11And again I have enough of a sense of humor of the premise of somebody
- 29:17saying something like, oh, there's one more than one way to skin a
- 29:18cat, and then we cut to amorous, Hey what are you talking about?
- 29:22All right? Fine, and then you know whatever, whatever the fish
- 29:25metaphor was, and even the absurdity. Oh I don't have it. I
- 29:29don't have it up yet. But the Bloomers, the woman with the Bloomer's
- 29:33character and the twist, et cetera, et cetera, right, all of
- 29:38that, and it's fun. Yeah, nickers in a twist, and I
- 29:41forget what the what the butt Head and the screw characters were offended by.
- 29:47Maybe it's best we don't remember that one. Yeah, indeed, indeed that
- 29:51that funny jokes weren't weren't meant to be. I don't know it if if
- 29:56Bazooka bubblegum made it to the the UK, but it's this little piece of
- 30:02bubble gum and it's always wrapped around a little comic strip. And the humor
- 30:07in those is so bad and so weak that when somebody gets too punny on
- 30:11my show, I go, hey, the main character is called Bazuoka Joe,
- 30:15and it's like, yeah, Bazuoka Joe, save your jokes for the
- 30:18gum er apports, Yeah, we know, we don't. And then absolutely
- 30:22absolutely it's very much Belower decks like humor though, wasn't it really you know?
- 30:27Yeah? And and and again I don't they've they've telegraph what these very
- 30:33short treks are gonna be. Yeah, I don't mind. It's it's a
- 30:37shame because clearly they got their inspiration from those marvelous Voyager and tn uh short
- 30:45animated things that are on YouTube are genuinely great, amazing, amazing, and
- 30:51yeah, you know so, and again I I mean we talked about it
- 30:56earlier. We love the original filmation show, and I love the esthetic of
- 31:00the filmmation show, and it's certainly there is room to play with that stuff
- 31:04in both Wow, wouldn't that have been cool if there was an next generation
- 31:07filmmation cartoon? Or wouldn't I would if there had been a Voyager one.
- 31:11So I don't mind the basic idea, and I'm sure this is a great
- 31:15example of what we're going to get in subsequent very short tracks. Well,
- 31:19the people who did it, who made the shorts that you know ate the
- 31:26style of the animated series, got it right because they understood that the key
- 31:30to the humor is playing it straight. You you the style is the joke,
- 31:37Yes, you don't. There doesn't need to be any actual joking in
- 31:41the dialogue or anything like. In fact, I think I'm right in saying
- 31:45for the Voyager one, they just did Threshold right right, you know,
- 31:51cut and paced the this the audio track from Threshold and animated brilliant, and
- 31:57they did. I think the the TG one it was best to both worlds.
- 32:01I think I'm right in saying, but that's the joke. You watch
- 32:06it and you go, oh, it's funny because it's in that kind of
- 32:09cheap animation style that filmationed it. But you know there was a certain charm
- 32:15to that. Yes, so you know what they that short, very short
- 32:22trick to Skinner Cat fundamentally misunderstands the affection that exists the animated series. I
- 32:31think it's you know, it has to make fun of it because in the
- 32:36mind of the people who are making Star Trek, now you know, the
- 32:38animated ones are the kind of facetious ones, the flip of ones, the
- 32:44humorous ones, the ones where you can tell stupid jokes. You know,
- 32:46that's the that's what the realm of animation is for, not that which to
- 32:52put words in them out. But I think that's what they think. You
- 32:54know, that's the evidence that I that's what I draw from the evidence.
- 33:00But I think, well, and maybe maybe that's why Prodigy doesn't fit their
- 33:06idea of what animated Star Tricks should be. I don't know, but got
- 33:12in fact here I want to go back to some Langley is killing it with
- 33:15some of these comments. Prodigy is faring away a better Animated Tricks series,
- 33:17and Lower dex And is much more mature and it's four kids. Uh yeah,
- 33:22I completely agree Langley, and it's a shame. I wonder when we
- 33:29will hear that Lower Dex or rather Prodigy has found its new home. I'm
- 33:36leaning towards probably Amazon. They haven't made the official announcement, but the fact
- 33:40that we got that scene of the of the doctor, the holographic Doctor as
- 33:46part of Prodigy season two, you know that they put it out there,
- 33:52Well there must be I mean, unless the Haberman brothers are doing things without
- 33:59paramount It's permission and releasing this stuff. I doubt that's the case. Yeah,
- 34:05I don't know. I don't know. If Prodigy is a more successful
- 34:07show, it would be because whatever, you know, the target demographic is.
- 34:14It takes the Star Trek universe seriously. That's the key difference. You
- 34:20know, people who watch Prodigy, no, it comes from a place of
- 34:25sincerity, whereas Lower Decks you know, I understand why some people like lower
- 34:30decks. I understand why you like lower decks, not attacking you for enjoying
- 34:35it, go on that at all. And truly I'm usual the negative voice
- 34:38when I reviewed Star Trek, and I love that we have a slightly difference
- 34:43of opinion. But no, there are things that not lawd cks. Absolutely
- 34:45still annoys me. But I get it because the instinct that you're sort of
- 34:50just letting go, you know, you're just saying, yeah, I'm gonna
- 34:53go, is what it is. Yeah, it is what it is.
- 34:55But also you know, it appeals to its design to appeal to the Trek
- 35:01fan, the nostalgic trick fan in all of us, and for synics,
- 35:06bitter cynics like me. See, i'd have to I have to keep that
- 35:08stuff down. I have to pour water on that in order to maintain a
- 35:14clear head when I'm watching lower decks. I can completely understand people who just
- 35:19say, just give into it, just submit to it. It's like bleeding
- 35:22out in a warm bath, isn't it. Am I going to call for
- 35:24help? I'm just going to let myself die because there's no pain and it's
- 35:31all right. It feels pretty good. A lobster is slowly boiling to death.
- 35:36Yes, you know, he's caught. He's comfortable. Why why get
- 35:39out of the pot. So that's lower decks for me. It is bleeding
- 35:45out slowly, Okay. I mean when you when you watch it, you
- 35:50say, oh, okay, I get it, I get it. Everybody
- 35:53who watches a show is a Star Trek fan. Blah blah blah. They
- 35:58don't understand by referring to it this way, by making the universe smaller,
- 36:05by flaunting their gig credentials, they are inadvertently destroying the thing that they love.
- 36:10But okay, let's let them carry on with it. Blah blah blah.
- 36:14You know, the poor bastards who have sat read my reviews, they've
- 36:20heard all the jokes before. But you know, it's like it's a like
- 36:23a sex doll of your ex girlfriends. You know, it looks like her,
- 36:29it feels like her, and so on and so on, but it's
- 36:31got no head and no heart. Yea. It is like being trapped with
- 36:38those people in the Star Trek Experience at Las Vegas who had to cost plays
- 36:45as Star Trek characters. And what if you went to the Star Trek experience
- 36:49in Las Vegas. First of all, good for you because it was great.
- 36:52Yet, yes, indeed, how I miss it. I'd go again
- 36:57if it's still if it's still there, so true, right, yeah,
- 37:00But when I was there, I remember going around, like you know,
- 37:04doing the tour, and I always remember the girl who took me around and
- 37:08she was asking us questions like, hey, do you know what do you
- 37:12know what la cars means? And stuff like that. I'll say, yeah,
- 37:14I do, I do know what the cars mean. Blah blah blah
- 37:16blah. Now that would be that's like being trapped on the set of Lower
- 37:21Decks. You know, all of the characters know everything, they know what
- 37:25you know, and they're going to they're going to prove to you that they
- 37:30have those Star Trek credentials, but by talking about it every single moment of
- 37:36every single episode. But while they're doing that, the opportunity to tell a
- 37:42real Star Trek story in the non meta, non self aware Star Trek universe,
- 37:49i e. The real Star Trek universe has been missed. Yes,
- 37:53so every episode of Lower Decks is a wasted opportunity. And we're now into
- 38:00season four and it's obviously never going to end. It's always going to be
- 38:04like this till it finally it's acted, which hopefully will be when Secret Hideout
- 38:10are shown the door. But we can get into that, you know.
- 38:15But that's my principal objection to Lower Index. And when I looked at those
- 38:20first two episodes, I thought, with episode one, here is a show
- 38:24that is satirizing, a show that does not need to be or parodying,
- 38:29a show doesn't need to be parodied because it's already sort of a self parody.
- 38:35Although one it might must be said that has a very powerful conclusion.
- 38:40Right before we say to Vix the Voider episode is schlock, we should remember
- 38:45it does have like a really sinister and interesting final five minutes, philosophically really
- 38:52interesting, which the Lower DECKX episode brushes off with a joke like Jane Way's
- 38:59solution will stick to kill kill him. Let's how whoever it doesn't find out?
- 39:04Okay, yeah, yeah, we know, we know, we know
- 39:07it's very funny, but it wasn't funny when we watched it the first time.
- 39:10It was yeah, it was we at the same time it was such
- 39:14a goofy premise, but then it had this very serious are you going to
- 39:17kill this life form? And now I really went from years teasing and I
- 39:22have a friend that every every whenever they showed the rerun of Tuvik's I would
- 39:27send him a screencap of Tuvis and go, look it's Tuviks. And now
- 39:30it's like, wow, that really was a good, high minded science fiction
- 39:34idea of this is a new life form. What do we do with that?
- 39:37Are we doing the right thing? And you're right, You're absolutely right.
- 39:40It's and that's why it's smart. It plays on various levels and it
- 39:46really is at the end of the day, and certainly the Cruise reaction to
- 39:50Tuvix, the original of the real Tuvix was much more. I don't know
- 39:54what to do with this. I mean, my god, poor Quess,
- 39:57her mentor and her lover urged. I mean, and I will even concede
- 40:02that in Lower Decks with the doctor emerging with the engineer and and uh and
- 40:10Jaks, the security gag and yeah, how much do you remember about whatever
- 40:15and the freaked out look and their face. Yes, you know, it
- 40:21was great. But the thing I think about the thing about the Lower Decks
- 40:24episode was that the thing if you take the original episode, the original voyagers
- 40:31goofy premise, as you say, schlocky premise. Hey, let's merge two
- 40:36characters in a transporter accident. But they don't play it for humor. They
- 40:40play it straight. They tease out the philosophical implications of it, and it
- 40:45ends with an absolute sucker punch of a Denomon where oh yeah, the doctor
- 40:51says, I'm not going to do it. I won't participate. This is
- 40:53murder. I understand why you're doing it, but ethically I can't participate in
- 40:59this really interesting end episode. Now, then you get to the Lower DECKX
- 41:04episode. Now, remember the Lower Decks is constrained, okay, because it's
- 41:08supposed to be star trip, but of course they've also it's also got to
- 41:13be funny and which so having spent you know, like three collars of the
- 41:15episode mocking two vix, they can't then go for the serious coder because that
- 41:25would that wouldn't that would kill the humor. So what do they do?
- 41:30They get out of it by merging everybody together into this unsentient blob of flesh
- 41:36and arms and hair and mouths. It's hideous sort of conglomeration of personnel,
- 41:44and Tendy says, oh it's okay. It's not sentient anymore. It doesn't
- 41:47have a it can't think, so by separating it out, there's no moral
- 41:52dilemma, there's nothing to worry about. It's just the sort of the end
- 41:58to that episode. It's just way for them to undo it without how to
- 42:01get into that thorny philosophical territory because the way that Lower Decks is set up,
- 42:07you can't do it. You can't get into real gut Bristons philosophical territory
- 42:14because everything is a goof, Everything is a joke, everything is a throwaway
- 42:19line. And the point is the humor is comes from the recognition that we
- 42:24have of the things that they're playing around with, the sort of the references
- 42:30that they're pulling on from different episodes, and that is not enough to sustain
- 42:36a show on its own. You know, It's fine for a one off
- 42:42spoof or whatever that is not linked to Cannon, is not linked to the
- 42:47Star Trick universe, but as a as a strategy for telling stories in the
- 42:52real Star Trek universe, it's it's catastrophic for the integrity of that show when
- 43:00they try to bring in serious elements like you can almost you can feel the
- 43:04tension. You can feel Mike McMahon behind the scenes sweating, go oh,
- 43:07I want to I want to tell real Star Trek stories BLA, But I
- 43:12can because the forum ATAM my show doesn't elapse. So you had, you
- 43:15know, like season long arcs, you know, like A, I forget
- 43:19what the arc was in season three, there was something that was and now
- 43:23I'm misremembering, I know the backwards maybe that was season two, but I
- 43:28think that was season two in there was. But you've got the you've got
- 43:32the evil ship that they in this season, which we've seen destroy now a
- 43:38cling on bird of prey in a Romulan war bird or yes, So that's
- 43:45the that's your semi serious thread that's going to run through this batch of episodes,
- 43:51you know, because that's the frustrated Star Trek writers in that writer's room.
- 43:57They desperately want to tell a real story in the TNNG universe, but
- 44:01they can't because you know, they're they're hamstrung by the fact that they have
- 44:07to toss off every episode and make it absurd, and they will come back
- 44:13to it and it will be a semi serious threat. Like do you know
- 44:17that the Texas Class starships were at the end of the right, that's what
- 44:22it wasn't that that was last year's that was the thing ed I'll even say
- 44:29truly, both in the case of the Backwards and the Texas class ships,
- 44:34I thought they I thought they kind of succeeded. And again maybe I'm being
- 44:37beaten down, so you know. But but and even this I find intriguing
- 44:42and I'm willing to see how it unfolds. I hope it's good. But
- 44:45again, did you feel the threat? Did you feel the threat the same
- 44:50way as you felt, for example, when the board were attacking the Federation
- 44:58the fleet in the end star Trek piccard. Well, I'll be honest,
- 45:02when it came to that, I rolled my eyes as much as they tried
- 45:06to make it dramatic. And I'm like, again, with the guy,
- 45:08damn Borg, can you come up with something? And especially I don't,
- 45:13and then don't I don't think they explained, and in fact, in subsequent
- 45:16interviews with Terry Mattalas, I think he even said, I wish we had
- 45:21more time to explain the changeling Borg relationship. And it's like you had time,
- 45:27you just used it poorly. And I mean, like I really,
- 45:30I still don't understand how the borg queen met the rogue change links and how
- 45:34they got together and planned it all out without assimilation. Yes, yes,
- 45:38yeah, I mean I know what you mean. I suppose what I'm talking
- 45:43about is the sense that Pacar's Pocards season three, whatever the plot holes or
- 45:47the various problems where the blow block, and that we agree that there are
- 45:51many problems. Sure, what castle that to one side for a man,
- 45:55just concentrate on the final episode and the actual sense of threat. Okay,
- 46:01all right, didn't make a whole lot of sense. But because the show
- 46:07was ostensibly serious, and because it was set in what we presume to be
- 46:13a kind of chanical timeline, so there's real consequences to what's going on and
- 46:17so and so on, you feel a degree of anticipation, a degree of
- 46:23assignment about what's going on in lower decks. I don't think you can really
- 46:28feel anything because you're so numb because of how light and frivolous it is,
- 46:36and how we're all about trading on your memories of better shows that had dramatic
- 46:42integrity. As we discussed earlier, you know, you can have it both
- 46:47ways. You can have a show that has real emotional beats and real dramatic
- 46:52stakes and still be funny. They're not mutually exclusive. I agree. Someone
- 47:00send a memo to Mike mcmam and tell him that that's the case. I
- 47:04don't think it's Mike. I think it's really again Kurtzman and the the Overlords
- 47:09that again have simplified Star Trek to the point where, well, Lower Dex
- 47:15can only be funny. I mean kind They even that cliffhanger of Captain Freeman
- 47:19on Lower Dex being taken away and every and it's like, Okay, yeah,
- 47:25where's this coming from and why? And it's like you're trying to make
- 47:29us care. This is the farcical, silly comedy. What are you doing?
- 47:35And again I think Prodigy, I'm telling him, and I'm sure I
- 47:37don't know how much you watch Prodigy ed, but really like, I've not
- 47:42seen a lot of it because some pieces, because of course, I as
- 47:46I say to you, last time I was on, I was ready to
- 47:50sit down and watch it and then they took it off. Oh yeah,
- 47:52I've just seen segments of it. I haven't seen it. Well, they
- 47:55redeemed Okampa, the Billy Campbell character from Next Generation season two and they gave
- 48:02them an actually interesting storyline twenty years later, thirty years later or whatever,
- 48:07and it was good. And I mean, that's the thing. It's like,
- 48:10there is a subtlety to the way the Aberman's and the Prodigy writers are
- 48:15really approaching this. It's driving me nuts. Man. I really wanted to
- 48:19talk to them, and thankfully they are. We have mutual friends. Two
- 48:23of the Prodigy writers are good friends of mine, and they happen to watch
- 48:29when I had their sisters. It's ironic the Aberman's being brothers and these are
- 48:32sister writers that work together on Prodigy, and I'm like, hey, I
- 48:37really want you guys on word Balloon because they were in the chat and I'm
- 48:39They're like, oh, yeah, no problem. And then they're like,
- 48:42you know something, it'd be better if we just wait until season two comes
- 48:45out. And then everything happened, both the withdrawal of season one on Paramount
- 48:49plus us not knowing where season two is going to get at home, and
- 48:52then of course the writers strike and the actor's strike, and I should just
- 48:57reach out to them because it seems like obviously animation is not under the restrictions
- 49:01that the live action people are right. I'll see if they're willing to talk
- 49:06about maybe they wouldn't want to, and they probably want. I'll wait until
- 49:08at least the announcement is made of season two and where it's gonna hit.
- 49:12I am. I am reasonably certain some streamer we'll see the value of this
- 49:17show and want to run it. But no, you're right, we can
- 49:21have it both ways. And I just think that, well, yea,
- 49:27and you might be right. It might be McMahon as well, you know,
- 49:30kind of shall I tell you why I suspect him? Okay, So,
- 49:37so this is why it's because of the origin of Lower Decks. Lower
- 49:44Decks, as we all know, began as a fan account on Twitter called
- 49:51t Season Night Correct. And this was just a stream of a Reverend tweets.
- 50:00Imagine ludicrous, a ludicrous continuation of ten in which you had premises which
- 50:07were so outrageous and so stupid and so surreal that they belong on Voyager on
- 50:13Tin. But anyway, so you know, I can't remember any of them
- 50:17specifically, but an example of them, something like it would be Wolf's bitten
- 50:23in the crotch by an alien parasite and his testicles swell to the size of
- 50:29a moon, and it creates such gravity that the Enterprise is sucked into the
- 50:34orbit Wolf's testicles and destroyed. Or Captain Pecard's head tips into a time portal
- 50:43and it rejuvenates the hair follicles in his scalp. But they can't stop it.
- 50:46The hair just keeps coming, keeps coming. It suffocates everybody on the
- 50:52ship. And Data says, if we can't cut Pocard's hair, it's going
- 50:55to destroy the universe something like that. Right of course, yes, all
- 51:00account of those we all read them, and we all went they're amusing their
- 51:04lip curling, you know, good fun, good old fund right. But
- 51:08here's the thing, it's a joke. Twitter account kid. The idea that
- 51:15you would read those tweets and say, hey, you know what, we
- 51:20need to get hold of the guy who made that joke about Worf's testicles becoming
- 51:24the size of a moon. We need to get him to write a Star
- 51:28Trek TV show. Whoever thought that somewhere in secret high down should be castrated
- 51:37ed You might know U The Shatner did a very short lived sitcom called ship
- 51:45My Dad. Shit says, I didn't know I didn't know it was and
- 51:49It was also based on a Twitter account of a comedy writer who was writing
- 51:53the quotes from his elderly father. I think that Twitter, and you're right,
- 51:58man, hey, this will make your d series. Well maybe not,
- 52:01and clearly it wasn't because it certainly didn't last be on its first couple
- 52:06of weeks. But I can understand why ship my dad says might work as
- 52:09a sitcom. What I can't understand, and I'm be happy for somebody to
- 52:15educate me on this is how you get You make the leap from tweets that
- 52:22are obviously satirizing Star Trek and obviously cannot work congruously within the Star Trek universe
- 52:30because they're flippant surrealist jokes to that becoming the foundation of an actual Star Trek
- 52:39television series. That those two things do not go together. In order for
- 52:47that to happen, you have to have somebody who's reading those tweets and says,
- 52:54I don't know anything about Star Trek, but I imagine that those tweets
- 52:59that humor would appeal to a certain youthful teenage demographic or whatever. And we're
- 53:07trying to stupidly split the Star Trek fandom up into demographic enclaves, and we're
- 53:15trying to make a show that appeals to every element of the fandom rather than
- 53:20make one show that appeals to all of them. Let's hire this guy and
- 53:24he can do a comic variant on the Star Trek universe. Well, and
- 53:29yeah, going back to I'm sorry real fast as I said, that's the
- 53:31point they make at Star Trek Day is that Hey, this new era of
- 53:36Star Trek, there's a Star Trek for everyone. Please continue. Well,
- 53:38I was just going to say, whoever thought that should have been shaken by
- 53:45someone else and said no, no, no, no, no, no
- 53:47no. You see, you can't do that. You can't have that kind
- 53:51of humor in a real Star Trek show because it would destroy the universe in
- 53:55which it's supposed to be a part of. The two are not congruous.
- 54:00Not that type of humor Star Trek sitcom could be done, but would think
- 54:06very carefully about how to do it. But all they did was they said
- 54:10to my mcmon, hey, we loved your tweets. Can you write that
- 54:14up as a TV show? He's like, yeah, I'd love to.
- 54:16I'm a Star Trek gee kinder, I'm a fan I've been waiting for this
- 54:21call on my adult life. I don't know how to write drama. I
- 54:24have absolutely no idea how to write a real Star Trek story. But can
- 54:29I write jokes about, you know, a character's testicles becoming as large as
- 54:34a moon? You bet I can? Well, I can do that every
- 54:37week. Langley points out it's weird because McMahon's shows Solar Opposites, which is
- 54:42on Hulu, is a great show that is actually funny and has decent dramatics.
- 54:45I agree with that well. And even McMahon wrote some of the best
- 54:50Rick and Morty episodes. They weren't dramatic per se, but like the Pickle
- 54:53Rick the die Hard as a pickle, your protagonist rich, you know.
- 55:00But those shows, and say, I mean, I haven't seen Solar Opposites,
- 55:02so I would defer to any fans of Solar Opposites. It could be
- 55:07it could be that Mike McMahon's seeded there where he's failed on lower decks.
- 55:12The problem he's got with lower decks isn't because lower Decks is obstensibly set in
- 55:16the Star Trek universe. It is, as we were saying earlier, hemmed
- 55:21in he's constrained in what he can do in terms of the humor, because
- 55:24if it takes it too far, then it can't plausibly be Star Trek anymore.
- 55:30If it's you know, if it's too irreverence, it's like the disjoined
- 55:35between what we know, and this becomes too big for us to suspend our
- 55:40disbelief that the two can coexist within the same universe. It destroys the integrity
- 55:47of the basics Star Trek universe, so it destroys its integrity and so on,
- 55:52which is why when you see two vic for example, you're like,
- 55:57okay, I mean, you know, I mean not My first instinct was
- 56:00I didn't think anyone could ever ruin Voyager because from a Voyager on his home
- 56:06is gretty outlandish. But you know, they found a way to make Voyager
- 56:10look even sillier than it than it really is, and it just it just
- 56:16annoyed me to hear, you know, to see that happening, and for
- 56:22them to refer to things like deep cuts and so on. I hate the
- 56:24fact that all the characters are lower decks are twenty early twenty first century fans
- 56:30of Star Trek talk the same way, and they use the same vocabulary.
- 56:36I can't stand it. It drives me crazy. Every time somebody says,
- 56:40hey, that's like that's the deepest cutter or whatever, you know, you
- 56:45think fuck you that they should not have that vocabulary. They shouldn't know what
- 56:52that means. I completely agree. Yeah, So that's that's what gets to
- 56:57me about it, John, That's why I find it very hard to enjoy.
- 57:01I want to relax, I want to let it wash over me.
- 57:04I want to slip my wrists and line the bath for an hour, but
- 57:09I just can't do it. Every time the raising gets close to the skin,
- 57:14I'm like, no, no, no, I'm no, I'm not
- 57:16gonna do it. I'm gonna live. Well. Watch my old favorite episodes
- 57:22of Voya during this gud, I hear you that, I so hear you
- 57:24that it's so and actually all right, Langley makes the point and I meant
- 57:29to make it earlier. It's ironic because the show that is very trek like
- 57:31The Orvial wasn't made into a Star Trek series, but Lower Dex is nothing
- 57:36like Trek and got greenlit. Yeah, I mean, I do think The
- 57:39Orvial does it, and especially by the third season, has a very good
- 57:45balance of the silly and the series, and man, what a triumph in
- 57:50their thirds in my opinion, I don't know if we've talked much about the
- 57:52orval in the past. I was. That's interesting because I think that what's
- 57:57happened with Seth McFarland was a bit like what happening with Mike McMahon. Set
- 58:01set that. Seth McFarland. You know, he naturally starts off with a
- 58:07with a comedy show. Why wouldn't he, that's his that's his thing.
- 58:10Of course, Also, he's aware that I can't make a real Star Trek
- 58:15show because I don't have we don't have the rights to do so, so
- 58:19let's let's just sort of do an affectionate pastiche of Star Trek. Sure,
- 58:23but as he goes on, the fan and him that really wants to tell
- 58:29real Star Trek stories starts to take over, and that the irreverence goes down
- 58:37and the dramatic integrity starts to rise. Absolutely. Now, the problem is
- 58:42that Mike McMahon can't do that because if he if he goes too far up
- 58:50in terms of the actual storytelling telling credentials, because there's no real comic potential
- 58:55in lower decks other than riffing off other Star Trek. Yes, if you
- 59:01stop doing that, it just becomes an animated Star Trek show. So you
- 59:07can't do it. You have to keep you know, mining going back to
- 59:13the well and keep assets stripping, because that's that's you've built a show on
- 59:17that alone. Yeah, and again I think, and I and I really,
- 59:23I mean, I don't want to subject myself to a focus group of
- 59:27younger loving New Trek vans, but it does seem like they are more Again,
- 59:35they they they like the representation and the and you know of of New
- 59:42Trek, which I absolutely applaud. But as I keep saying in the board
- 59:45game of life, that's only square one and you've got the rest of the
- 59:50game to accomplish. And we'll look at all the fact that you know,
- 59:52we're And I forgive me, but I don't mean, like when I do
- 59:54the jazz ants to to uh Marck, the LGBTQ community, the people of
- 1:00:00diversity, the idea that it is that I truly don't So I'm sorry.
- 1:00:06If that offended anybody, I apologize, But my point is that is so
- 1:00:09just the first step. What else do you have? And they don't have
- 1:00:14much. And that's what angers me is we get it. Yes, you
- 1:00:19are here, you are represented on the show. That is great. What
- 1:00:22else is there about your character? Not much? And I'm sorry to say
- 1:00:28that, about the relationship with the non binary and trans people of Discovery,
- 1:00:32the doctor and the engineer, gay couple on Discovery, a lot of these
- 1:00:37things that again and in fact in Star Trek day, Discovery is certainly made
- 1:00:43its mark with its inclusion and diversity in respect to the LGDT LGBTQ community.
- 1:00:51Of course, wonderful, but you still got to do Star Trek. You
- 1:00:53still have to give us an action adventure sci fi show that's smart and makes
- 1:00:59us think. These shows don't make you think. And again, I don't
- 1:01:04know what beyond the because Roberrenett always keeps making the point. I think he's
- 1:01:07right that a lot of the fans are just satisfied with, Oh, we're
- 1:01:13here, there's there's me on Star Trek. I feel like I'm being represented
- 1:01:16on Star Trek. That's great, and they're very satisfied with that. And
- 1:01:21maybe because this is their first Star Trek that they're watching in some cases that
- 1:01:25that's enough for them, but it's not enough for us. I know,
- 1:01:30but I think I think it's a symptom of the ear in which they live.
- 1:01:36So in fairness to them, I think that the main difference between a
- 1:01:40Star Trek fan who's like, say, twenty today and us, shall we
- 1:01:46say, the more seasoned veterans season is simple that in our lifetime we've seen
- 1:01:55a sort of an end to this idea that you know, there's such a
- 1:01:59thing as a grand narrative, and that the arc of progress be arc of
- 1:02:04history bends toward progress, and so on. We've suffered a loss of cultural
- 1:02:08confidence in the West, you know, particularly in the United States. The
- 1:02:13great hegemon that Star Trek represented in the sixties and the seventies, you know,
- 1:02:19Star Trek's confidence was America's confidence. You know that you have to go
- 1:02:22out there and you spread the message, and you do the good thing,
- 1:02:27and you all unite behind an I a single identity and philosophy, and that
- 1:02:31is the human race, humanity. And we're now in an era where that
- 1:02:37has all been questioned and sort of has been, if you like, fragmented.
- 1:02:45So living in a kind of twenty first century version of the fantasy Etler
- 1:02:51where everything is being questioned, you know, it's like the end of Empires
- 1:02:54or whatever, and oh God, who are we and what are we about?
- 1:02:59And all the rest of it. And because everything is now postmodern and
- 1:03:04meta and self referential, and there's this idea that there's no such thing as
- 1:03:08a sort of unifying identity, that you're naive and stupid if you don't go
- 1:03:15into the fragmentary or intersexual elements of identity like race and gender and all the
- 1:03:22rest of it. Those are the things you've got to talk about because they're
- 1:03:27the relevant things. They're the things that actually, you know, set your
- 1:03:35chances in life and all the rest of it. There's a pressure, I
- 1:03:38think, because the people who make Star Trek today have those science fiction credentials,
- 1:03:45but they have been captured by this sort of identitarian ideology that they feel
- 1:03:52that that's how you make it relevant by representing those elements on screen, Whereas
- 1:04:00the people who wrote Star Trek a generation ago, I thought, the way
- 1:04:02you make it relevant is you tell the story of the future utopia where we're
- 1:04:08all under one flag, but we're all committed to progressive Enlightenment values, the
- 1:04:15pursuit of knowledge, the betterment to oneself and soul, and so on,
- 1:04:20and cultural critics will say today some of them will say, you know,
- 1:04:25and you in Berkeley or wherever, Yeah, yeah, but that you know,
- 1:04:30that's fine, but but you're you're not talking about, you know,
- 1:04:33intersectional oppression and so and that's naive. It's naive because that universal philosophy is
- 1:04:42of course the white Western view of how the future should be and so on.
- 1:04:46So it's so it's oppressive in some way. I hate that. Personally,
- 1:04:50I love the idea because what I would say this as a as a
- 1:04:55white man, a white heterosexual man. But I love the idea of a
- 1:05:01future in which these elements of identity have been, if you like, demoted
- 1:05:12to the status of incidental and where what really counts is how hard you work,
- 1:05:18what you do, wanting to expand your knowledge, and you live in
- 1:05:23a society that gives you the freedom to do that, in which somehow we
- 1:05:29don't quite know how, but like you know, institutional bias them has been
- 1:05:34removed. We've got to And Star Trek actually promotes a view of the future
- 1:05:42that makes that plausible because of course, once humanity meets other species, once
- 1:05:47it meets other races in space, if you like it, can't look inward
- 1:05:54anymore. It can't naval days, it can't spend its time thinking about out,
- 1:06:00you know, the different the four hundred differences between genders or whatever,
- 1:06:04because if it does, it's going to get fucking annihilated and whatever. Absolutely,
- 1:06:12because they're securing their identity and they know what they're about, and they're
- 1:06:15they're coming for you, and it's going for us with weapons. Are absolutely
- 1:06:20unless you've got a sort of competing ideology, competing philosophy, and that philosophy
- 1:06:26is humanism and I love that. That's what That's why I like Star Trek.
- 1:06:32I don't think the people who make Star Trek now understand that, or
- 1:06:38rather they've subscribed to a different view of life, which I'm gonna I'm going
- 1:06:45to be bold and say will date new trick very very quickly, because I
- 1:06:49don't think. I think ultimately we'll see it's going to come back to this
- 1:06:55idea eventually, that we're a happier people, happiest species, if we're not
- 1:07:03trying to subdivide and subdivide ourselves into tiny little niche groups of political and social
- 1:07:11interest. Well, actually we need to look at our common goals and our
- 1:07:15common goals lie out there in the stars, not down here on it.
- 1:07:19Well, this middle aged white guy completely agrees with you, Ed, and
- 1:07:23it's to see Langley make this point as well, and he says, the
- 1:07:28issue they only is they only give lip service to diversity but don't do anything
- 1:07:31with it. Jesse Gender, I don't know if you're aware of them,
- 1:07:34Ed, a trans person who's I think. I don't always agree with Jesse,
- 1:07:40but I do think they are a very interesting critic and I always appreciate
- 1:07:45watching their point of view. And I guess Jesse has a great video about
- 1:07:48this Sun season two, about Strange New World season two. And then also,
- 1:07:53as Langley says, what's upsetting is you can do both integrate these issues
- 1:07:57and identities. Were also depicting the Utah be of Star Trek one hundred percent
- 1:08:00man, it's the And again going back to even just what we were saying
- 1:08:04about goofy episodes of Trek and Strange Your World's too many, there were goofy
- 1:08:10episodes of all the other tracks shows, but they also were wrapped into some
- 1:08:15sort of action adventure problem or whatever. And also it was like even the
- 1:08:19outrageous Ocampa or o'kanna episode. You know, there was a whole thing about
- 1:08:28you know, did he did he knock up an alien's daughter? And there
- 1:08:32are two warring factions going on, and uh, and I mean, unfortunately
- 1:08:36they had data trying to understand humor and had the great idea of having him
- 1:08:41learn her humor from Joe Piscopo. I would have been in eating one,
- 1:08:45going yeah, maybe somebody else, but somebody had well and you got it.
- 1:08:48Well, you could had just Whoopy do it, because I think Whoopy
- 1:08:50Goldberg as a superior comedy a comedian to Joe. But regardless, I mean,
- 1:08:57that's the thing. It was always the humors sprinkled in and or even
- 1:09:00like take me out to the Hollow Suite DS nine, the baseball game.
- 1:09:04You know, it's like, okay, you got as we've said before,
- 1:09:08you've got twenty two episodes. You got room for one of these. And
- 1:09:11also you had this great petty Vulcan captain rivalry that Cisco was feeling and everything.
- 1:09:17And even finally the rest of the crew are like, hey man,
- 1:09:21we're supposed to be having fun and you're taking this ship way too seriously.
- 1:09:26This isn't good. You're looking at how you're treating poor Nag and stuff like
- 1:09:30that. I mean, or rather it was Rob pardon me, Rob Nag
- 1:09:34actually knew how to play kind of. But yeah, I mean, right,
- 1:09:38there's plenty of rude the humor in start, right, I mean the
- 1:09:41idea that it's kind of po faced and everybody's kind of you know, got
- 1:09:46their their finger on their chin and they're staring out of of a window into
- 1:09:51into deep. But that's not what it is. It doesn't need to be
- 1:09:55just that. It doesn't need to be just that. It of course they're
- 1:09:59they're humorous characters and humorous situations. But the point is that if it's all
- 1:10:03flipping off the cuff stuff, then it becomes I don't know, it loses
- 1:10:11something, it loses a dimension for me. I so agree, No,
- 1:10:15I so agree. And again that was my problem with the musical episode.
- 1:10:20That was my problem with Spot being human. Not only that, but just
- 1:10:25the fuck around with Cannon. Going back to the very short tricks, they
- 1:10:29stress so hard that listen, this isn't Cannon. We get that, fine,
- 1:10:33but again you got a shit on James Kirk. And again, call
- 1:10:38him the Captain, call him whatever you want, but that is clearly I
- 1:10:42mean also you've got ericson and Scottie I mean and mrs and everything. I'm
- 1:10:47like, all right, this is clearly the animated crew. Well that means
- 1:10:50that's Jim Kirk. And you could say, oh, it's the Captain.
- 1:10:55Well if you, I mean really, it's like that's adorable, but you
- 1:10:59can't guess light us we know what you're saying. And again, I just
- 1:11:02feel like we love we love Star Trek and one of the main we all
- 1:11:06love Spock, but we also love Jim Kirk. And it's like, sorry,
- 1:11:11man, And I know, I know. Shatner is not the nicest
- 1:11:14guy and certainly has his issues with he had issues with the Burman era Trek.
- 1:11:19I mean, he outchrist himself for being on the Enterprise as he could
- 1:11:24have been and stuff. Fine that those are his choices, but don't don't.
- 1:11:30And again, I do think the new generation has a serious issue with
- 1:11:33Shatner because Shatner fights back and they really hate it, and all it does
- 1:11:38is create more and more contempt for Shatner. Paul Wesley as Kirk is such
- 1:11:43a poor, watered down Kirk. And again it just seems like, well,
- 1:11:48this hatred of William Shanner is bleeding into and you know, and and
- 1:11:51also that surface knowledge of Trek while he opts from bed to bed, he's
- 1:11:56always kissing green aliens, yea, all the bs. And it's like,
- 1:12:00then you obviously haven't call it yes. And I love that phrase. I
- 1:12:04learned that phrase this weekend Kirk Drift. That and plot armor was what I
- 1:12:12learned at the end of Strange New Worlds. When you have five of the
- 1:12:15seven main characters as characters we all know will survive to the original series,
- 1:12:19and it's like, oh my god, all this jeopardy and it's like,
- 1:12:23I'm sorry, but Mbega's gonna survive. Chapel is gonna survive. Now they've
- 1:12:29introduced Scotty good Lord. That was unnecessary. Oh can I really say fast
- 1:12:33to. The biggest waste of season two was not doing more with Carol Kane,
- 1:12:39who was a brilliant comedian and dramatic actress. She grew on me as
- 1:12:43the season went on. The first time I saw her character, I was
- 1:12:46like, oh, fuck, what's going what's she doing? But as it
- 1:12:50went on, you sort of thought, Okay, I can see the potential
- 1:12:54here, but I think, actually she's gonna get replaced quite quickly. I
- 1:13:00think they've got Scotty in. I think it's just a matter of time before
- 1:13:03she says, Hey, do you know what I don't like being indeed space,
- 1:13:05I'm going back to the academy to teach takeover, would you Montgomery?
- 1:13:11Oh, my man, seriously, we are so on the same way of
- 1:13:13like that is exactly what I was saying as I reviewed the season and the
- 1:13:16last episode. I bet it happens in the first episode five years from now
- 1:13:21when the show finally comes back, whenever, however long it's going to take.
- 1:13:25With my god, I mean the Part two Strange New the Part one
- 1:13:30a Strange New World's you know story, hergemony or her geminy, depending whatsoever.
- 1:13:35Yeah, I never know properly. I think I think it's a geminy
- 1:13:40in the US and agemony in the UK. Yeah, we do, say
- 1:13:42to Germany. I think you're right, absolutely, man. Yeah, I
- 1:13:45have a feeling that that that's I mean, it wasn't strong enough that you
- 1:13:47can wait like three years for the conclusion. Well, and also an episode
- 1:13:55the indecision on Pike's face and case and I kept because everyone's like, oh,
- 1:14:00this is just like the best of both worlds. No, it's not.
- 1:14:02And here's a great example. Harry comes mister wharf fire. There is
- 1:14:09no indecision in Riker's face. Stevie Cliffhanger of all time. Absolutely, and
- 1:14:16Riker knew what he had to do. He didn't like it, but he
- 1:14:19knew what he had to do. And whereas orders, captain orders captain,
- 1:14:25And it's like, come on, I'm like again, they've already emasculated James
- 1:14:30Kirk and now Chris Pike. And also in that episode when Ortegas is doing
- 1:14:36the sweep the doubt, Wow, Erica, you were born for this.
- 1:14:40It's like, we know, we know she's a great pilot and supposedly as
- 1:14:45as she says, well you were a test pilot. Yeah. But and
- 1:14:48it's like and I and I've had friends. Nothing drives me crazy. Your
- 1:14:51ed when my friends invent things that I think should be expressed actually in dialogue
- 1:15:00and action in the show, And like, well maybe they were thinking,
- 1:15:02and they're like, well, maybe Chris Pike was a different kind of test
- 1:15:05pilot. It's like, no test pilot's face life and death situations. No,
- 1:15:11no, if he I will buy the right stuff, right, he's
- 1:15:14done at all? Yes, Oh my God. And seriously, it's I
- 1:15:18feel like I'm in that film the Snake Pit, where I'm the only safe
- 1:15:21person surrounded by crazy people like well maybe it's this, maybe it's that,
- 1:15:26and it's like no, no, and it's not your job to tell me
- 1:15:29that. It's their job to tell me that. And all they do is,
- 1:15:32like I said, I compared this look of Chris Pike's to this look
- 1:15:36of Curly Howard from The Three Stooges, and it's you know, it's like,
- 1:15:40come on, man, I don't come to Star Trek for our captains
- 1:15:45to be weak. Oh but but here's here's a thing. As about a
- 1:15:48million people have pointed out, So I'm happy to be one million and one.
- 1:15:54Pike shouldn't be in any doubt at all about what's gonna happen because he
- 1:15:57knows he's gonna live right. Well, there's that a hundred percent stake.
- 1:16:04Yeah, biggest mistake is showing him his future in the in the chair.
- 1:16:09He's gonna be fine. He should be uber confident in that situation. You're
- 1:16:14right, age, you know what, Maybe I'll do this, maybe I
- 1:16:15won't, but it's fine because I know nothing can happen to me. I'm
- 1:16:19invulnerable. I know I've seen my future. Yep, no, I agree
- 1:16:26with you. You know what else interests me? And again, I really
- 1:16:29I'm touching on some third rails here, I know for some younger people and
- 1:16:31stuff. But I saw a group of critics on one of the nerd news
- 1:16:36websites discuss Pike winding up in the chair and and I believe there was a
- 1:16:44physically challenged person in the conversation, and they're like, well, you know,
- 1:16:46life doesn't end when you're when basically, and again I'm using my words,
- 1:16:50life doesn't have to end when you're faced with this kind of physical challenge.
- 1:16:56You'll find other ways. And it's like, no, no, no,
- 1:16:58he's not just in a wheel chair and doesn't have the use of his
- 1:17:01legs or even a quadrpolegic where he has no use of his legs and arms.
- 1:17:04He is almost catatonic. He can only he can't speak. He's not
- 1:17:09catatonic. His mind is fine, but he can't even speak. He is
- 1:17:12down to beeps. And I understand the drama of that, but it's like
- 1:17:17that is a much more different state of being than a quadrpolegic would face,
- 1:17:24for example, and it's like you can't. You can't minimize the limitations that
- 1:17:30that sort of life would would face, and also being the demonstrative action person
- 1:17:40that he was, and it's like, no, I'm sorry, I disagree
- 1:17:44with you. I don't think you understand Pike's fate. And I also don't
- 1:17:48think you really saw it in that flash in Discovery where the time crystals show
- 1:17:56Pike is his future, and it's like it's a very nineteen sixties solution to
- 1:18:02the problem, which is, okay, you know, he has no quality
- 1:18:05of life. As far as their concern, they're not going they don't decide
- 1:18:10to go down the route that that medical science can rejuvenate him in any way,
- 1:18:16because of course they're bound by the footage that they're they're cutting in from
- 1:18:20the cage and the realities of nineteen sixties of medicine, please get right.
- 1:18:27But but you know, they're constrained by the episode that they have to incorporate
- 1:18:31into the episode, so they come up the solution. He goes to tell
- 1:18:35us for and he ends up imagined imagining himself to be able, poddied and
- 1:18:42living a lovely life with the equally with that lady I can't remember a name,
- 1:18:47yeah, who, of course is also in reality decrepid and scraped,
- 1:18:54a horrible body, absolutely trapped in a broken body, and so on,
- 1:18:58so that you know, it's so it's a it's a solution that would have
- 1:19:01put a smile on the face of sixties television viewers. O wolves, well,
- 1:19:05that ends well sort of, whereas today, of course, it would
- 1:19:10be probably considered to be ablest or something like. You know, they look
- 1:19:15in and say, hey, he's saying he could only be fulfilled and happy
- 1:19:17if he imagines he's not disabled, and so so you know, you could,
- 1:19:23if you were being wilfully social historically illiterate, say that it's problematic.
- 1:19:31But you know, the point I suppose I'm making is with Pike, as
- 1:19:38you say, they're hopelessly constrained by the fact that they've made this stupid decision
- 1:19:44in Discovery to give him a foretaste of his future, probably at that time
- 1:19:48not realizing that he would be reappearing in his own TV show. You know,
- 1:19:53they thought it was a throwaway thing, their little contract, their idiotic
- 1:19:57contribution to his backstory. And with Kirk, what is their problem with Kurt?
- 1:20:02Well, I mean, I think it was very much what rob My
- 1:20:05Burnett was talking about in his recent video was talking about Kirk Drift, and
- 1:20:11he is worth seeking out that episode of Observations if you haven't seen it,
- 1:20:15because he reads out a very very interesting essay in which the woman who wrote
- 1:20:21the essay points out that such are such are the things that you think you
- 1:20:27know about Kirk through cultural osmosis without actually even needing to see Star Trek.
- 1:20:31It creates this sort of distorting veil through which, when you actually watched the
- 1:20:38show, it distorts your perceptions of Curse of odivasions because in your own mind
- 1:20:44you have a version of the character. You've been inculcated to believe that the
- 1:20:48character is a sort of callous, gung ho womanizer, not born out by
- 1:20:56the material in the actual original series, but you believe it so strongly or
- 1:21:01you're being programmed to think it that when you watch the episodes, you see
- 1:21:05it through that lens. And we know that Alex Kurtzman and Bob Worsey certainly
- 1:21:13had fully, you know, succumbed to Kirk's drift, if you like,
- 1:21:17to Kirk Drift when they penned the two thousand and nine movie, because Chris
- 1:21:23Pine's characterized characterization of Kirk is not Kirk. It is the cultural memory of
- 1:21:30Kirk, as transmitted orally and in spoof and in pastiche in pop culture.
- 1:21:40Yes, that as this independent of the actual material indeed on which it's based.
- 1:21:46And so I don't I don't know what people's problem with William Shatner is
- 1:21:51as a guy. I know he's a tricky kind of guy and he's got
- 1:21:56a problem out. You know, he's got a complicated relationship with Star Trek.
- 1:22:00We all understand that. But here's the thing. I'm prepared to forgive
- 1:22:05William Shannon almost anything. And here's why, because he created one of the
- 1:22:10most iconic characters in TV history, and it would not be the same without
- 1:22:15him. You cannot separate the two, right. It's he is Captain Kirk.
- 1:22:20His characterization is Captain Kirk, and he brought a lot more to that
- 1:22:24than that he gets credit for. I think ed. I don't know about
- 1:22:28British television, but here in the States, we have a rerun channel that
- 1:22:33runs both on a cable but also independently if you only have a digital antenna
- 1:22:40and you can pull it in. It's called me TV, and they run
- 1:22:44classic Star Trek six nights a week, right, well, actually, excuse
- 1:22:50me, they run its seven. They run the original series seven nights a
- 1:22:54week, but Sunday through Friday. They go from the original series to Enterprise,
- 1:23:00where they just have this massive five hour block of show after show after
- 1:23:05show, six hour block whatever they're right, total is and it's like New
- 1:23:10Trek competes with that every time they have a new episode, and it's like,
- 1:23:13well, here's an example of how Star Trek used to be written,
- 1:23:16and it's it drives me insane that, as you say, it is this
- 1:23:21Kirk drift that informs the modern interpretation of the character and what Shatner brought to
- 1:23:30it and what the show brought to Kirk. And it's like, no,
- 1:23:32man, this is the guy. This is why we're still watching this stuff
- 1:23:35fifty seven years later. It's because it's compelling, interesting and well thought out
- 1:23:43science fiction action adventure with interesting characters. Even in the sixties, with all
- 1:23:47of the sixties biases and misogyny and everything, which is real. There's a
- 1:23:53reason why all the girls are in miniskirts on the original series and ron Berry
- 1:24:00third century fashion. John, that's the way it was. But then,
- 1:24:04what are you gonna do. I mean, you know, yes, nine
- 1:24:08didn't make that mistake, did it When they did Charles and Tribulations. Yes,
- 1:24:13they showed Kirk as sort of somebody who was quite In fact, they
- 1:24:15made a joke about it. I think Das was saying, hey, he's
- 1:24:20he's so suave and good looking, isn't he? And Cisco's like, thinks
- 1:24:26he's talking about Kirk, but he's she's actually talking about spot nice s gag,
- 1:24:31nice joke. It's ripping on the stereotype. But it means that the
- 1:24:35riders of that episode are conscious of the stereotypes, and they you know that
- 1:24:42even though women were attracted to Kirk, of course they were. He's a
- 1:24:45charismatic, handsome young starship captain. But that's not the point. The point
- 1:24:53is how he dealt with the women he encountered on his voyages, and he
- 1:24:58had real serious relationships with women, not these frivolous girl in every pool kind
- 1:25:03of cliche that we have we now think about, not the kind of stuff
- 1:25:08that was portrayed in the two thousand and nine movie. Well, as you
- 1:25:11know, they'll do these montages, video montages of just a quick two or
- 1:25:16three seconds and yeah, it's really easy to make this montage of Kirk kissing
- 1:25:21the alien woman of the week. Yeah, I'll be like, well,
- 1:25:24there you go. There there's a proof right there. We're not we're not
- 1:25:28editing anything. I mean, that's that's actual footage from the original series.
- 1:25:30And again it's without context and without really understanding the stories. In fact,
- 1:25:35I don't remember the name of the museum guy on this first episode of Lower
- 1:25:40Decks, but it was a parody of Bijo Tremble, one of the original
- 1:25:45Star Trek fans that created the letter campaign to bring Star Trek back when the
- 1:25:50show was teetering after the second season, and she's she's still with us.
- 1:25:56She's an incredible Trek fan that goes back to the original series. I've never
- 1:26:00met her, but a lot of my friends have and she and in fact,
- 1:26:04she is much more generous about New Trek and she's like, you know,
- 1:26:09Trek has always changed. I've watched it changed from the original series two,
- 1:26:13Next Generation and the rest of the Burman era shows too modern day.
- 1:26:16She's like, it may not be my cup of team, but that's fine
- 1:26:19as long as it's still there. And God bless her for thinking that way.
- 1:26:23But they made this like character's name as kind of an uh, you
- 1:26:27know, cute homage if you're really paying attention. And I've read so many
- 1:26:30reviews on modern news websites and nobody and they even name the character and I
- 1:26:35can't remember what the character's name is, but nobody's even picked up on.
- 1:26:39Yeah, that was a joke, man, that was There was a little
- 1:26:41mini tribute to Bisho Tremble, whose name is b Jo Bijo Tremble. I
- 1:26:45guess I just in the interests of balance, so that doesn't sound like absolutely
- 1:26:50every minute of Lower Decks, you know, is like somebody twisting my testicle.
- 1:26:57It's not there are moment. There are some joke in it which are
- 1:27:00okay. In the second episode, which we haven't talked much about, there
- 1:27:04was a gag about Boiler trying to settle in new quarters on the Sweeter,
- 1:27:12and there was two good jokes. There's one about him being put in a
- 1:27:15room next to the Waltons cells this terrible light flooding into it's got you know,
- 1:27:19that was funny, which I liked that that's a good joke. I
- 1:27:23like, yes, and I like the idea of him being trapped between two
- 1:27:27holidays. Even though that was funny too, it doesn't make any sense on
- 1:27:30its face because you think, of course, obviously they'd have some degree of
- 1:27:33soundproofing or whatever. But but but it is a funny idea that he can
- 1:27:39hear what people are doing that You're right, I'm glad you pointing that out
- 1:27:45it because I hear the second episode so much that, like it said,
- 1:27:47it's just again Mariner's storyline. I'm just like, again, yeah, I
- 1:27:53know. I really felt like they've they've evolved Mariner's character a bit, and
- 1:27:57also thankfully the other three main characters are like, all right, she's one
- 1:28:01off on one of her tears. Whatever, we're gonna do our thing.
- 1:28:04And I really love that, like and they even would put it in the
- 1:28:08trailers or the promos for last year where she's like, I don't think I'm
- 1:28:11the boss of volume. Yeah whatever, boss, Nice to talk to your
- 1:28:14boss, and it's like, yeah, good, because they should be that
- 1:28:17cognizant of man. This chicken thinks she knows everything, and it is so
- 1:28:21annoying. And that's why I once again, I'm gonna I'm gonna full ransom.
- 1:28:25I'm gonna get myself fired and it's like, why stop it, that's
- 1:28:30it's not funny. I agree with you. I agree with you, But
- 1:28:33I I think the reason if I think about it and I think, why
- 1:28:38do why do those jokes with boiler work and something like the cute creature that
- 1:28:45sucks people dry doesn't work? It's because the Boimler gags are kind of situations
- 1:28:54grounded and situational that there things might happen to somebody, Yes, yes,
- 1:29:00below a rank on a starship, and there is humor there. And you
- 1:29:03think those jokes would not necessarily be out of place in a in a real
- 1:29:08star trip show. Surely someone's got to have the room next to the cell,
- 1:29:12you know, and may not know that you can apply a filter to
- 1:29:15the windows to stop it. Yeah, there was. Yeah, But when
- 1:29:20I look at the joke about the cute little sort of Japanese anime character that
- 1:29:27sucks people dry or whatever, which is a sop to the imagined viewer of
- 1:29:31lower decks and whatever their their general sense of humor, I think that joke
- 1:29:36is as old as That's Monty Python and the Holy Grail and all the rest
- 1:29:41of the Killer Arab Yeah. Absolutely, I mean it's so predictable because it's
- 1:29:45become a comic cliche. And when they did a gag about that prop,
- 1:29:50you know, the luminous tube thing, I don't know what it's called.
- 1:29:55Someone will know what it's called. That joke is forty years old. I
- 1:30:00first saw that gagging Airplane two. For Christ's sake. You know, then
- 1:30:05when they're reaching for other things, they're not being particularly original or witty or
- 1:30:12you know, they should stop first and think, well, actually, has
- 1:30:15this been done and has it been done better somewhere else? And where's the
- 1:30:19humor in ours, in our characters in our situation. Now we make them
- 1:30:27funny without relying on riffing on other things, and we're only we're only into
- 1:30:34the I mean, these was the thirty first and thirty second episodes of Lower
- 1:30:39Decks, And not only are they still taking from other shows and other comedy
- 1:30:44ideas, but they're also like kind of again with Mariners choices in that second
- 1:30:48episode, it's like, man, you guys can't get out of your own
- 1:30:51way. It's like, can't you come up with something else? These are
- 1:30:56I can't well, well, but occasionally they can't. I mean, I
- 1:31:00thought when Rutherford discovered his former persona that episode of Lower Dex. Honestly,
- 1:31:06I think that was one of the best episodes of Lower Dex. And further
- 1:31:11and I've got a shot, I like the introduction of t Lynn now as
- 1:31:15a regular crew member, like two that episode of all the other Lower Decks
- 1:31:21aliens, I'll even said that is a brilliant episode. That was a really
- 1:31:27great way of showing the Lower Dex you know, ideas within the other alien
- 1:31:32races. And I thought it was executed quite well. But again, why
- 1:31:36does Ti Lenn work as a character? I would argue it's because the humor
- 1:31:42is again, it's character based in situational. She's a Vulcan and Star Trek
- 1:31:48has always mind a lot of humor out of the tension between the Vulcan's ultralogical,
- 1:31:56ultra rational, emotionless view of the world and the humans, right,
- 1:32:00and Telin is exactly the same. Sure, she doesn't actually say anything that's
- 1:32:06comically ziny or funny, her humor is grounded and based on not understanding them,
- 1:32:15right, which is the same gag that you know. It's like,
- 1:32:18you know, when Sabak says to spark, you know, humor. It's
- 1:32:24a difficult concept. All of this stuff or no sorry when she says to
- 1:32:28him, oh, he's so human, when she's talking about Kirk and spots
- 1:32:30as nobody's perfect absolutely, or even the Kirk and Spark, or rather the
- 1:32:35Spark and McCoy arguments are Leelus and Tuvak. You knows exactly exactly. So
- 1:32:44to Lynn fits in with that traditionally, and they don't even need to try
- 1:32:48very hard to make her funny. All they have to do is keep her
- 1:32:53humor less right. She's the straight mane she's a straight man, and as
- 1:32:57long as she continues to be the straight man, she will get the only
- 1:33:00laughs in every Lower Days episode. I hear you, man, you know
- 1:33:03I also like and I never remember the name of the race, the alien
- 1:33:06race I am. I don't know about you ed the Dharmak episode of TNG.
- 1:33:12I am not a fan because I like it well. It lacks a
- 1:33:15logic to me in terms of uh that the metaphor that they speak in that
- 1:33:23language. But I do like the new character on Lower Decks that is from
- 1:33:26that world, and it's a yes something like that. I'll take the work
- 1:33:33for the Taimar is a is a river in southwest England. I don't think
- 1:33:38it's that I think it's children of the I think they called Tamarians. That
- 1:33:43sounds like someone will know, but that's a children of Tomorrow. But I
- 1:33:47do. I do appreciate this character being on and again it is self referential,
- 1:33:53as is the nine percent of Lower. I do like Darmark, I
- 1:33:57only because even even if the cal sept is a little bit flimsy in terms
- 1:34:02of the choice of what the problem is with the lack of communication, the
- 1:34:10message of the episode is so beautiful. I'm so beautifully done it's hard not
- 1:34:15to classic. I'm a called her less bastard though, if you ever discovered
- 1:34:21that by our covers. And that's good because again I appreciate your frustrations with
- 1:34:28Lower Dex and like I said, I've been working sympathetic at least with that
- 1:34:30first episode, so I appreciate the contrast today. But I'm not made me
- 1:34:34feel something. I want to. I want to feel something what the Lower
- 1:34:41decks. If that ever happens, I'll say, there's hope for this show,
- 1:34:45but I wonder how long it's got to go on before we get it,
- 1:34:47and whether we'll ever get it. Frankly, I mean to bring us
- 1:34:51onto a slightly wider topic. I wonder if any there's any hope for any
- 1:34:58of these Star Trek shows as long as Secret Hideout of producing them, because
- 1:35:01I saw a video earlier today, whether it was a Ledge rumor, I
- 1:35:06don't know if this is true or not, or if it's complete fantasy that
- 1:35:11Paramount commissioned like a five minute proof of concept video for a show that was
- 1:35:16set sort of post Nemesis that was not connected in any way to the Kutzman
- 1:35:23era. Star Trek's true, and that it's caused an almighty bust up.
- 1:35:30Like Alex Kutzman is furious. He thinks they want him out. Apparently some
- 1:35:34people do want him out, but of course they've got to somehow get rid
- 1:35:40of Secret Hideout. And I'm sitting there because I know that some people out
- 1:35:43there think Star Trek Legacy is the answer. Star Trek Legacy is greenlit,
- 1:35:47everything will be okay. Star Trek Legacy, if it's produced by Secret Hideout,
- 1:35:55will always be artistically compromised because exists within that wheelhouse. And I just
- 1:36:02don't trust. I don't think Terry Matalis, God bless him. Hopefully one
- 1:36:09day Hallum bought me on Twitter, but no hard feelings Terry. I hope
- 1:36:13that one day he you know, he's got that freedom to make the show
- 1:36:18that he wants, because I'm going to assume that with Pocard season three they
- 1:36:25didn't quite leave him to his own devices. There were occasions when they said,
- 1:36:29hey, hey, remember what's come before, Remember what the franchise you're
- 1:36:32now part of. You've got to be congress with that, and that compromised
- 1:36:36Pocard Season three would compromise legacy. Even though I don't like the idea of
- 1:36:44a show that basically the Star Trek kids anyway that I think Gena Rowlanberry would
- 1:36:49have thought that it was just weird to have the children of legacy characters.
- 1:36:54And I've seen it a million times. Catherine Janeway or Ben Susko did not
- 1:36:59need to be McCoy's niece, Kirk's grandson, you name it. And from
- 1:37:04the get go with Secret Hideout, oh wow, well you know Burnham as
- 1:37:09Spock's sister, and it's like, fuck you, Card did none of these
- 1:37:15great characters of Burman era Trek needed to be a descendant of classic Trek characters,
- 1:37:21And in fact it was an edict during you as you well know,
- 1:37:26the first few seasons of the next generation. We're not going to talk about
- 1:37:29the old show. No, we're breaking new ground. And you're absolutely right
- 1:37:31about Roddenberry and stuff, and it's like, no, I think he would
- 1:37:34you would object to this legacy show as well. It's like, create your
- 1:37:40own characters, create new characters, look forward, don't look back, don't
- 1:37:45riff on what's come before. You know, give us a new set of
- 1:37:50people that we can get to know, and by virtue of getting to know
- 1:37:55them, they suggest their own stories because they've got their own backgrounds, their
- 1:37:59own world, all the rest of it. That was the guiding philosophy behind
- 1:38:03every successive Trek series in the bermin era, and it should be again really
- 1:38:11until they go back to that, until they get past this sort of postmone
- 1:38:16asset stripping approach. Everything's got to be self referential. Everything's got to link
- 1:38:21back to things that we know about or we don't know what we're doing.
- 1:38:26Until we get past all of that, I don't see how Star Trek can
- 1:38:30connect with a new audience. I'm sure there are people, as you said,
- 1:38:34who love Discovery, who love Lower Decks it's sort of their Trek.
- 1:38:40But whenever I've met a few of these people whenever I meet them. The
- 1:38:43one thing that strikes me is that they don't really know much about Star Trek.
- 1:38:47You know, they have a very casual sort of relationship with it.
- 1:38:51Oh yeah, I like that show. It's okay, blah blah blah,
- 1:38:55but it doesn't mean anything to them if Lower Decks ended tomorrow, like notice
- 1:39:00it was gone. They at the end of Star Trek Day, they had
- 1:39:03that segment where the drag Queen and I don't mean that in a pejorative way.
- 1:39:08Clearly this is a drag queen that was going on and asking people on
- 1:39:11the street do you like Star Trek? What do you know about Star Trek?
- 1:39:13And it was all very basic beating me up, Scottie kind of kind
- 1:39:16of references to Star Trek and that's fine, And a lot of people like,
- 1:39:19no, I really don't know Star Trek. Well do you know what's
- 1:39:24the you know who was the logical guy? Oh it was fun, see
- 1:39:26you do know Star Trek. And it's like, once again, it's all
- 1:39:29it's all surface stuff. Back to your point about hopefully introducing new producers to
- 1:39:33create new Star Trek, You've gotta believe that the people above secret hideout the
- 1:39:39Paramount people see the real numbers, and hear people like us that are like,
- 1:39:46we don't like New Trek for these reasons, and it's like, as
- 1:39:49you said, it's like, well, Star Trek used to be universal and
- 1:39:53we were able to make something that everybody liked. You've got to think that
- 1:39:57they from a granular standpoint, are like, especially now that the post oh
- 1:40:03god, now I'm forgetting his name, the guy that was running Paramount that
- 1:40:06got me twoed out, that ran upn and CBS, Less Moonvez Yeah,
- 1:40:14yeah, in this post less moonves run. And also now that some of
- 1:40:17the Rebstone kind of turned the company to his daughter and stuff. And I
- 1:40:20think there are more people upstairs in Paramount that actually like Star Trek and what
- 1:40:26it was and can see the evidence of well, we had millions more liking
- 1:40:30this product when it was made this way. And certainly I would assume that
- 1:40:35season three of Picard gave him an inkling of well wow, even some of
- 1:40:41the harsh critics are liking this version of Star Trek. Why is it different?
- 1:40:45What makes it different? And I really hope that they are making those
- 1:40:50observations and it's leading to choices that they will make in the future. Allegedly,
- 1:40:56Alex Kurtzman heights Piccard season three. I have no doubt. I don't
- 1:41:02know if that's true, but I can completely believe it. Well because again,
- 1:41:08this other guy, this outsider from their bubble, although he obviously has
- 1:41:13his legacy towards the bermin Era and stuff came in. You know, the
- 1:41:16the circumstances of Metali's running season three of Picard were Goldsman and Kurtzman were busy
- 1:41:26with other projects, and it was the third season, and it was going
- 1:41:30to be a smaller budget, and like, all right, let's burn it.
- 1:41:32And also the the failures of seasons one and two connecting with a large
- 1:41:40audience. Fine, we're we're contractually obligated to do this third season. You
- 1:41:44know, let Lyn the metaphor, let George do it, Let Terry do
- 1:41:46it, and that's fine. And Terry was left to his own devices to
- 1:41:50a degree, and with limited resources, gave us a much more Trek like
- 1:41:57and a much more entertaining season. So I'm sure Crutz been hits him.
- 1:42:01I think the fundamental reason he hates it is because it links to and continues
- 1:42:09an era of Star Trek that he hopes to overwrite it makes it harder for
- 1:42:14him to overwrite it, indeed, particularly because people enjoyed it. You know,
- 1:42:18I had my reservations about it, as did you. Sure, but
- 1:42:23I would concede that it is obviously self evidently the best season the Star Trek
- 1:42:28per card, and maybe the only season of New Trick that felt like real
- 1:42:33Star Trek that we had. And you know, wats and all problems and
- 1:42:39all, But you know, I would rather be fucking thinking about the issues
- 1:42:44around how did the ball Queen meet the change leagues. I'd rather be focusing
- 1:42:48on that than thinking about is this Star Trek at all? You know,
- 1:42:53you don't in a sense in the past we didn't know how well we had
- 1:42:57it. We used to be arguing over plot holes and things like that.
- 1:43:00Now we're arguing about whether or not the shows themselves are really the thing that
- 1:43:04they're supposed to be. Agreed, It's crazy, You're you're so right man,
- 1:43:09Well, you know, ed, is there anything we haven't covered that
- 1:43:12you wanted to talk about today? Because I love I love where the conversation
- 1:43:15is gone. Well, you know, just the state of the world generally,
- 1:43:18John, But I know, I mean, I guess all, I
- 1:43:24would say, write in conclusion, if you like, like it started,
- 1:43:27it was Star Trek Day over the weekend, yes, fifty seven years.
- 1:43:31Oh and by the way, it was very funny. If you do watch
- 1:43:34that Observations episode that everybody assumed it was Rob may have been include to me,
- 1:43:41and I swear to you, I wish for the happy birthdays like chat
- 1:43:44to stop my birthday, and I want you to tell the way the title
- 1:43:46read, I thought you was I felt for him after like the fifty ninth
- 1:43:50person got in touch to wish him a happy birthday. But anyway, here's
- 1:43:56the thing we should be say. It's amazing that Star Trek is still going
- 1:44:01after fifty seven years in some form. My dream is that by the time
- 1:44:08we get to the sixtieth anniversary, it's no longer in the hands of Secret
- 1:44:12Hideout, please, and that it can be relaunched, if you like,
- 1:44:15on its sixtieth birthday with a new creative team, because there would be people
- 1:44:19out there who are watching New Trek who must be spending blood thinking, fuck
- 1:44:27I if only if only I was in charge of this franchise, the things
- 1:44:32I could do, the ideas I've got, you know, put me in
- 1:44:35charge. And I know there are people that say, yeah, go back
- 1:44:39to Ronald D. Moore, go back to those guys. Maybe maybe you
- 1:44:44need to Maybe you need that connective tissue in the same way that DC Fontana
- 1:44:48co wrote I think encounter at fire point. You know, maybe you do
- 1:44:53need to have that linkage. But they're the objective of whoever show runs the
- 1:44:59next next generation of Star Trek if you like to be to bring writers on
- 1:45:03board who understand its central appeal and understand what it is and understand the universe
- 1:45:13in which it's you know, in which it takes place, and what structures
- 1:45:16that universe, What philosophy structures that universe, that overarching grand narrative about human
- 1:45:25progress, which is not inward looking and not divisive and not you know,
- 1:45:31focusing on aspects of individual identity, but is actually thinking about how to advance
- 1:45:40the species and the threats and challenges to our humanist philosophy that we face out
- 1:45:46there in the stars. That's the kind of show that we want, and
- 1:45:49if we can get that show, then Star Trek will be relevant to a
- 1:45:55new generation of people the way it's relevant to us. If we don't get
- 1:46:00that, what will happen is all of these shows that we're talking about,
- 1:46:03lower decks, strange new worlds, whatever, they will fizzle away and disappear
- 1:46:10and will be forgotten because they have no cultural footprint. The people who watch
- 1:46:16these shows like them well enough, they talk about them on Twitter for a
- 1:46:20bit. Hey, I fucking love the musical Fuck You Okay, a year
- 1:46:27from now you won't remember it. There's nothing. There's no intellectual content in
- 1:46:31New Trek, and there's nothing to stimulate thought and to appeal to those people
- 1:46:39out there in the world who feel that they're fundamentally alone in some way,
- 1:46:44and they look to this grand narrative that used to be events by Star Trek
- 1:46:48and say, wow, I'd love to be a part of that. That
- 1:46:50appeals to me. Not because, as many people have said, you see
- 1:46:57yourself in the characters, you don't. You look the characters and you say,
- 1:47:01I'd love to be on a ship with those guys, because the type
- 1:47:04of people I wish I knew but I don't, and that they present something
- 1:47:11that that resonates with me. Not because it reminds me of myself, because
- 1:47:16it represents a certain philosophy or principle or sense of daring, you know that
- 1:47:24I wish that I had and inspirational, aspirational, you know, And so
- 1:47:31that's my that's my dream. But if there is a coup underway within Paramount
- 1:47:39right now to get rid of Alex Kurtzman and Akiva Goldsman and all these mindless,
- 1:47:45imbecilic hacks, if that's happening as we speak, you have our blessing
- 1:47:51God, God bless you. Go for it. And if it needs to
- 1:47:55get violent and bloody, well so be it. You know. I the
- 1:48:00YouTube that surprised me this weekend. And again I don't know if it's factor.
- 1:48:03Rumor was at Warner Brothers that they canceled jj Abram's contract, which was
- 1:48:10made before James Gunn taking over the DC universe. Perhaps if that is true,
- 1:48:17that may be the same could be said for Secret Hideout and Company.
- 1:48:21I certainly hope. So. Yeah, Ed, remind people of where they
- 1:48:26can find you online. Well, you can read my star Trek reviews if
- 1:48:30you dare at Opinionoid that's it would build WordPress dot com. And you can
- 1:48:38find me on YouTube at dotor Macilvoid, where occasionally I pop up and talk
- 1:48:45crap like this for a while. You know, Well, I'm always happy
- 1:48:47that you talk crap with me like this as well. So perhaps at the
- 1:48:53end of Lower Deck season we can talk again, my god, and then
- 1:48:58we're going to face the Well, let's come back to it when it's all
- 1:49:00when it's all over. But I think I think we both know in our
- 1:49:03heart of hearts, don't we, that it's going to be another eight episodes
- 1:49:06of nothing. But we'll see what's wrong. Well. I have better feelings
- 1:49:13for this than the dreaded return of season five of Discovery, which will also
- 1:49:18be wonderful grist for the mill for us to discuss. Oh yeah, I'm
- 1:49:23looking forward to it in an awful sort of way. Oh god, that
- 1:49:26five minute bit of Burman on the on the surface of the ship while they're
- 1:49:30in warp. Yeah, get pulled into the wark field and dissipated sadly,
- 1:49:35but we were hoping. You can't have it all and as always been,
- 1:49:42thank you for taking a good part of your evening talking to me about this
- 1:49:46as always, you know, I always always a pleasure, John, Thank
- 1:49:49you very much. You know I feel the same way man. Thank you
- 1:49:53very much, everybody, thanks for watching and listening. More great warblin coming
- 1:49:58up. This week. It was tough with everybody being in Baltimore at the
- 1:50:00Baltimore Con, but we'll have more content for you in the weeks in the
- 1:50:02days ahead. In fact, tomorrow my buddy Rodney Barnes talking about the HBO
- 1:50:08show Winning Time the La Lakers Dynasty will be on and also talk about his
- 1:50:13comic book work and also gotsh dance lot coming on Tuesday and lots more coming
- 1:50:19up this week. So back to normal with a lot more shows. So
- 1:50:23thanks for watching. Stay safe, stay happy, stay healthy.