Latest / Jew York Times / Macklemore And Naza And Problematic Ultra Orthodox Pot Heads-- ISRAEL ELECTION UPDATE
Transcript
- Eitan: I went to Israel like a couple of days after the Knicks had won. It actually extended my ticket, my airplane ticket because I supposed to go to Israel for six weeks. And I had pushed my ticket back a couple of days in case there was a game seven in the finals and a parade. So I was like, I need to be there for this thing. Now, as we all know, the game seven was not necessary. so Shanie: Nexon five. Eitan: Nixon Five, baby. the Richard Nixon Five, which is my ska band. No. So I ordered during the course of the run every day I'm ordering. I'm ordering everything. Everything that's being advertised to me. I'm I Michael Rubin made a a billion dollars the week of the Knicks going on on that run. The Strait of Hormuz Shanie: Do you know how many do you how many cups I have? Do you know how many cups I have that say Nick's champions on my house? Eitan: Well, the th thing is, I came back, so I order all this stuff, and then I come back after six weeks in Israel. Forgot I had ordered all this stuff, and there's a pile of Nick's stuff. Irresponsible Nyx purchase, bobbleheads, and banners Shanie: Ha ha ha ha Eitan: and t-shirts. I have a t-shirt, I'll wear it next time. It is it just has Jalen Brunson and then two Victor Webb and Yamas, and it says never forget on it. I ordered a nine eleven NYX t-shirt. Have no idea remember. Do not remember at all when I had bought this thing at all. Anyways, welcome to the New York Times 120 Angry Seats. My name is Aton Levine. As always, I am joined by Shanie Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. We Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: are covering the elections that are happening on October 27th as of now. on today's episode, we're gonna do a little bit of a topical episode. We want to talk about the Malcolmore stuff a little bit, NASA. is in the is in the news. and of course talking about all the election all the updates that are happening in the elections. There's been a bunch of polling that's gone around. There's been some seat swapping. A lot of the slates have been decided. There's a lot of finality that came about a week ago as we hope. Shanie: I hope I hope not final I hope not polling finality. Eitan: Holy f it's over, by the way, it ended a couple days ago. Shanie: Ha ha. Eitan: all those stories and more on today's episode, Sinee. Sing it with me. Ya da da da da. How's it Shanie: Absolutely not. Eitan: going, Shene? Shanie: You ever audition on Broadway or anything like that? Eitan: you ready for an actual crazy story? A couple years ago, Shanie: no. Eitan: when Book of Mormon came out, my manager at the time emails me and goes, Book of Mormon wants to see you. And this is like after it was a is this it was a hit and then Shanie: You would be great on book. You would be a great Mormon. Eitan: I first of all, I am Mormon. A lot of people think I'm Jewish. I don't understand why. I'm Shanie: Ha ha. Eitan: a devout Mormon. but I so they had me audition Elder Cunningham, the Josh Gad role. And this is right after I started. So they had done Broadway, it went very, very big, and then they were doing the Toring Company. So I'm auditioning for the Taurin Company, right? Here's a problem, Shinny. I cannot sing at all. Cannot sing. Shanie: Ooh, that is a barrier. Eitan: It's an issue because it's Broadway. So I go into this audition. Shanie: Yeah. It's a big thing on Broadway, I heard. Eitan: Occasionally they want you to be able to sing on Broadway. So I go into this audition Shanie: So I've heard. Eitan: and I'm in the audition and I have to sing the song Man Up and then 18 18 bars on Man Up and then do some like lines, right? Man Up is a nickelback song, as far as I'm concerned. If you don't know at home, take a minute, pause here, go listen to it, and then come back because I have to sing I can sing that song like Man Up, Man. Like that was the song. Shanie: okay, I get it. Yeah. Eitan: Take a bowl of me. Damn. Like I'm able to do that, right? I'm able to do not singing. Shanie: Right, right. Yeah. Eitan: I get a callback to Book of Mormon on Broadway. And in the second callback, I so in the callback, Shanie: They you sing something different. Eitan: well, that's the problem I kind of ran into here is that they wanted me to sing the baptism song. And the baptism song is like an actual beautiful song. And they had me Shanie: Mm. Eitan: paired up with an actual Broadway lady. And The only way I could describe what happens next is that she's like and then I'm like just like it was terrible. Terrible. And Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: I don't get it. They gave it to Ben Platt. I I w I really like to think at some point Shanie: Who'd have thought? That guy's the that guy is the voice of an angel, honestly. Eitan: He's is he's it's amazing. I'd like to think at some point they were looking Shanie: Voice of an angel. Eitan: at my r my headshot and his and being like, hmm. Shanie: Hmm's a tough call. Eitan: gonna go with the guy who can do this. And then they selected him. You ever done Broadway acting? You ever acting you you got the bug? None? Shanie: No, no, no, no. This is not my this is not my world. I'm not in the entertainment space. Although I've been told Eitan: Yeah. We're getting you I'm getting you Broadway lessons. Shanie: I'm hilarious, but no, I'm not a singer person. Eitan: Side splitting, hilarious. That's what I always tell people. I'm Shanie: Mm. Eitan: like, Israel Policy Forum is the funniest of the policy forums related to Israel. That's what I keep on telling everyone. Shanie: The most hilarious things here. Eitan: everyone knows if you want the if you want the good takes and a couple of yuck yucks, you gotta go to the Israel Policy Forum, which by the I don't know if you're plugging this yet. I think you're plugging this yet. You got a podcast that's coming out with them, right? Check that out. What's the name of it again? Shanie: I had a podcast coming out. Yeah. Disputed territ Disputed Territory. It's a great name. Yeah. Eitan: Disputed territory is gonna be when's it coming out? Shanie: in like one week. I'm getting it having a trailer coming out really soon. We have it, we have an Instagram page already. So go to disputed territory pod. That's our Instagram page. Eitan: What's good is that you're this is after Yom Kipper, so you're gonna have no sins. You're gonna be listening to this sinless. You're giving everyone a fresh a fresh intro into the five, seven, whatever seven, seven. Shanie: That's so beautiful. I don't know what year it is Jewishly. Do you? I don't know. Eitan: I haven't known what year it is Jewishly since maybe middle school is when I would think. I'd actually think it's actually Shanie: I think I think I knew in high school. You went to YU, you knew in college. Don't don't lie. Eitan: N I I was not good at Y U. Also I will say out there, if someone if there is a non Jew that knows what year it is, even if there's a Jew that knows what Jewish year is, that's a red flag. That is immediately Shanie: I have it on my phone. I have it on my phone. It's five seven eighty-seven. I have the Jewish year on Eitan: We're in the eights? Shanie: my phone. We're in the eights, yeah. We're deep in the eights. We've we're deep in the eights. Eitan: We've been in the eights for seven years. Jesus Christ. Shanie: Do you know that? If you asked me, I would have said, I think it's five seven seven seven. That's what I would have said. I thought it was in the sevens too. Eitan: I thought it was in the sevens. I honestly thought it was in the sevens. that's so funny. Well, happy five, seven, seven, eight, everybody. I hope everyone had a good five seven seven eight. This year, I think this is the year that everything calms down. This is actually the year where I think people talking about Israel, positive or negative, is gonna become boring. I think that that is a big thing that is coming up. Shanie: we can only pray. Eitan: I honest to God think that this is the year, especially with the elections coming up, where everyone just goes like, ugh, enough. I don't care. I on this is an honest to God feeling that I have. Shanie: Yo stop it. You don't actually think that. You don't actually Eitan: I Shanie: think that. Eitan: I I say this because I'm this is a genuine thing. You know, this past couple of weeks I was I was doing some stuff at a adult Jewish camp. and I remember that like at one point I had mentioned during one of the sessions, like October 7th, and it felt like old in a weird way that it had it before because I'd done sessions the year before where I remember like, you know, being in the sessions and having saying October 7th and feeling one way. And then a year later feeling like I was still talking about this. And I don't mean that to diminish it. It just means it feels like. With the hostages out and with things kind of at a stalemate in Gaza to a point where the images aren't gonna get worse or better. The situation is not gonna get worse or better in a way that America is gonna like respond to. I think that because people are not activated in the same way they were, that it just becomes boring in a way. Like I think, and not to say that it won't at some point, I guarantee you we'll be talking about something or something bad is always gonna happen on the horizon. It will always be there, and then we'll talk about it again. But I just feel like still making it, injecting it into everything in the same way, it's just getting gauche. Shanie: Think you are severely underestimating how much people love to talk about this. And I hate to be that person, but I do think that I think that anti-Semites delight in seeing Jews as the oppressors. And they like love that they have this amazing opportunity to point to act actual behaviors from Jews to be critical of instead of like just talking about our faces. I I Eitan: Do you think that Shanie: don't think that's most people, but I do think that that's like a big piece of what's driving. The obsession, and then it just like becomes Eitan: Okay. Shanie: this cycle. Eitan: But let's but I'm talking about most people though. I'm talking about like house mom in Ohio, high school kid who's unaffiliated in Alabama, truck driver in Des Moines. Like when they were asked, when they were said when you say Israel Palestine to them a year ago, saying that same just Israel Palestine to them again, like it's gotta have diminishing return. Like I I just feel like it it it's hitting it is it feels like it is hitting a wall in a lot of ways. Shanie: Okay, I hear you. I okay, so I just saw I'm I'm getting very like I'm this is a good timing to be bothering about this because I just saw a tweet thread that is it still called that? I don't know. A thread on X, X, whatever, the everything app, Eitan: Twitter third. X, the everything app. It's all happening now. Shanie: by which said it like spoke about how much more coverage Israel's getting than everything else. and it said on US cable news, Sudan's actual genocide, 400,000 deaths around. topped one percent of airtime on only eight days out of three hundred and ninety days. and Israel exceeded one percent on three hundred forty-four of three hundred sixty-five days. So Israel three hundred forty four days, Sudan, eight days. Four hundred thousand people are dead in Sudan. Eitan: Are people what is the yeah, but that's people, yeah, but that's people who are already looking to get hyped up. They're watching news, they're watching like CNN and I don't, but I don't think Shanie: People watch the news! People watch the news Eitan: that they are getting activated one way or the other way. And like I just don't see it hitting the same way that it did a year ago. I'm seeing protests across the board are so far down. I think it's just like in the zeitgeist that this is how people feel about it. And it more is bias fulfilling and just like, I want to see carnage than anything else. I Shanie: So I, as you know, I'm in school, which is terrible. It's not terrible, but like it's terrible that I'm in school. and I it's, you know, very activist vibes because it's CUNY Graduate Center. And I was in class and they were talking about how come there's not people are not as energized around Israel-Palestine? And they they decided it was because of like the cancel culture to silence protesters. and then that's why people stopped caring. And I was like, it's probably because people aren't like dying every day. Like it's just, it shouldn't be Eitan: Yes. Shanie: the top of the news cycle right now. It just shouldn't be. Eitan: A hundred percent. Shanie: So it makes sense that people are not like sitting out in the streets training themselves to trees or whatever, because it's like it shouldn't be the top of the news. I'm obsessed with it. I care about it. I talk about it. That's all I talk about. But yeah, like, why should the average person be like obsessed with this in the way they once were? but it was very interesting to like be a fly in the wall in the conversation in the class where everyone was like, I don't know how we get people to care more about Palestine. And I was like, You all care too much. You care too much. You didn't care. Eitan: Yeah. You been caring. Everyone's been caring about it. And I say that in the turn of phrase. It's a hundred it Shanie: Like who are these people who think it gets too little attention? Like Eitan: I think that they're I think they're annoyed that they didn't get more attention on it. I think that they've realized that they had a moment where they could Shanie: Yes, they are. Eitan: have swung they could have swung something and it didn't go which I guess is it could have Yes. Shanie: They did swing, they didn't swing actual policy, but they swung public opinion and they they swung public sentiment like there's really crazy high unfavorability of Israel. And it is partially because they created an environment that made it seem like there was a consensus around hating Israel, which made it you Eitan: Yes. Shanie: feel like you're like, if you don't hate Israel, you are a bad person. If you are not yelling Eitan: Hundred percent. Shanie: about hating Israel every day, you are a bad person. So they actually did succeed in a lot of Eitan: If you are not joining my protest to yell at Sloan Kettering Pediatric Medical Center that they are causing Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: the genocide there, then guess what? You hate Palestinians. That's just how it works. Yeah. It's interesting. Shanie: Yes, yes, exactly. So Eitan: wait, that's a pretty good tie-in to this whole Shanie: It's a good segue. Eitan: Malklmore stuff. So as of the this is, I'll give you the timeline. The latest news that we kind of heard today was the last thing that I heard was that Malklemore had told the venue owners that he actually wasn't gonna be talking about. Israel Palestine at his concerts, which I think is very, very funny. Ahead Shanie: Ahead of time he said that. Eitan: of time. He told them he would not be talking about it. I think that the the story here, actually, when you run through the timeline, is that Matt Malmore asks Ed Sheeran to go on tour with him. That's a thing, by the way, is that Malcolmore, according to Ed Sheeran's thing, asked Ed Sheeran, can I come on this tour? Malcolmore, whose tours and concerts are essentially, I've said this online, they're essentially the wiggles. of i i it's it's bluey. It's like Shanie: What does that mean? Eitan: the children are there. You know, Alana Zaichik made made the put, children are there. Like it's a cold play concert. It's like everyone it it's it's nice. People want to go to watch Galloway Girl and then they want to go home and watch Dancing with the Stars. And Shanie: You know what, Aitan? I actually went to a Macamore concert. It must be ten years ago now. And it was like on the beach in Miami and it was like free and it was just like people playing volleyball. And like it was a lot of kid like it was not like you just like walked in and Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: it was just Macamore on stage and everyone's just like playing volleyball and kids and whatever. Yeah. So that's a good point. Eitan: Yeah, it's a nothing. He's a not I mean, like, he's a tiny little beautiful little hobbit who has the sound of a the s the voice of an angel. And but like these are these are apolitical appointers. So he so edge sheeter in goes like, Malcolmore, like fine, you can come and and open for Shanie: Sure. Eitan: me. At some point in between these conversations, I assume that the venue owners or someone on the venue owner side asked Malcolmore, they're like, Hey, like you're not planning on talking about this stuff. He goes, He tells them no, essentially, and then goes on and immediately starts talking about this stuff. he apparently also had been showing war footage during the during the opening act, which is crazy also, because like, why are you showing war footage at an edge hearing concert? then he gets kicked off. Obviously, we know pink the pink whole rigmarole of it. I don't need to go like on timeline of it, but he gets kicked off. Then Ed Sheeran and Robert Kraft had been conversation had been having conversations for like a little bit and had agreed to give two million dollars to Palestinian causes. And then Ed Sheeran's also rallying other venue owners to also give two million dollars. This happened also after McLemore went online and and after calling, you know, Robert Kraft a oligarch Zionist, you know, warlord warlord who hates Palestinians and was like, if you don't need Palestinians, you're gonna donate a million dollars. So it was actually kind of funny that he had to specify that before Macklemore had even asked him to donate to donate the million dollars, he was already considering donating two million dollars to Ed Sheeran. and that's kind of where we're at now with it, where the story is gonna die. And I think at the end of the day, this changes nothing. I think that Macklemore ultimately will get booked three more times tops. His stong is gonna get streamed a little bit more. And then everyone's gonna go back into their corners and by next Tuesday everyone will forget that this ever happened. Shanie: That sounds about right. what what your take was, which interesting, I know it was a long time ago, but I do think the like Nazi salute with the Jew outfit was like that was pretty incriminating. I feel like if I didn't see that, I wouldn't have paid so much attention. I would have been like, okay, like he's just one of the another person who's obsessed with Palestine and like feels the need to talk about it all the time to everyone he talks to because that's like his life now. But paired with that, it's pretty incriminating. Eitan: I I also I need to point out that it is always your white friend who has made everything about Palestine that ruins your events. It's always that friend. It's always that friend. He Ed Sheeran didn't want any smoke. He did a favor for his friend and then immediately his friend like ruined it and then was and then was like, what? What's wrong? Why are you not supporting me? Like it just seemed like there's always that friend that's a mooch, that's an energy mooch, that is a You can't bring them to events because they're gonna act out at events. And then when you call them out, they're Why are you not taking my side on this? We all have that friend. We've all had some version of that friend who we're embarrassed by, but we're linked to, and we can't say no to because we're people pleasers at the end of the day. And there's some sympathetic background there. And she is Irish. I bet the Irish element played in his Irish guilt played into him, you know, having having Macklemore there. Malklemore is that friend. He just is that friend. And To be honest, if I'm a mainstream artist now and there's someone out there like Malmore who made it has made their entire thing about Palestine, I'm not gonna ask that person to come on the tour because I don't want the smoke that this has caused. That's net negative for the Palestinian cause at the end of the day. Like it just is what it is. Where I think that Malcolmore acting out in the way that he acted out, lying to the venue owners. You know, if I'm like someone like Taylor Swift or, you know, Shabuzi, I I don't know who else tourists now. Shabuzi, Shanie: Sure. Eitan: the whiskey song. If I'm Ella Langley, like if I if I'm someone that is touring and is about to do stadium tour, I'm really reconsidering how p you know. Shanie: But is that bad? Is that bad for the Palestinian cause or is that bad for McIlmore's career? Those are different things. Because there are more people talking about Palestine. Maybe that's good for them. Eitan: It is bad for the Palestinian cause. It's bad for the it's bad for the Palestinian cause. This this is net positive for Malmore, is what I would say. Shanie: Definitely net positive for Matt Moore. But ha fine. I hear that. But you wait, but you're saying people don't want to have him on their doors because he's the annoying guy Eitan: No, no, no. Shanie: and now everyone knows how annoying he is. Eitan: I'm talking remove him. I'm talking about any other Palestinian ac I'm talking about any other artist who has made their entire thing Shanie: Remove him. like people are gonna be afraid to have like pro Palestine people on their tours because you never know what they're gonna say. Okay. Yeah, that's fair. That's true. Eitan: Yeah. Yeah. It just there has not been a stable person who has made their entire thing about Palestine. In the same way that there hasn't been a stable person who's made their entire thing about Israel. Like I would say, I would have the same exact problem. If I was an Israeli, if I'm a G if I'm someone like Noah Cahan, for instance, right? Would I bring on someone that has a Malcolmore-esque level? of Israel at of attention about Palestinians about Israel. Does that make sense I don't know if that track, but like if I Yeah. Like what I have let's say R yeah Shanie: Right, like the equivalent. The equivalent on the pro-Israel side, I agree. It's a b it's a liability. Anyone with that much passion about anything is a liability, I agree. Eitan: Yeah. If Lizzie Svetsky was an incredible rapper, like let's say L let's say Lizzie Svetsky all of a sudden it turns out that she's actually pretty good behind the mic on the ones and twos. Like even if I thought that she was Exactly. Shanie: Yeah n yeah, you wouldn't catch her on my tour. Fine. Eitan: It's like I cause I know what that would bring. You know, I would have someone else. DJ Zach Sage Fox, I think would be the the one I would have. Anyways, you know, no one's ever gonna talk about this. And if you thought that was a controversy, here's a NASA controversy. See what I did there? A pun Shanie: I can't with you. I can't with you. Eitan: about NASA. the past week there's been a little bit of a controversy regarding the NASA documentary, which is claiming that Israel it which if I'm not correcting if I'm wrong here, but the documentary surrenders around Israel okaying strikes. That would have a lot of collateral damage versus other times when they would have less collateral damage. There is one scene I think that is very damning in this thing where they had okay to strike that would have potentially 500 casualties in the strike. and that seems so that's the broad you know what the documentary was about. When it was released, immediately every you know single Israeli government side, you know, called it a fraud, said that they were looking for investigations on it. I think that, if I'm not mistaken, the the tie in here with the election was that there had been all of the candidates who are up for election in October had said that they wanted an investigation onto into the documentary. and something that interesting that came out today was that the foreign ministry had been asking officials to tone down their rhetoric against the documentary because they don't really know how that is looking at. And they're they're deciding, you know, how accurate it is. There is another element Shanie: Mm. Eitan: to this where the actual filmmakers. some politicians had talked about revoking their citizenship or or having them face like jail time or something like that. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: Shindy, what's what's the what's the word on the street? Shanie: If somebody breaks the law, you can put them in jail. You don't revoke people's citizenship like that. I I'm very against revoking citizenship in general, for Jews. Like the purpose of Israel is that Jews are never stateless. Don't revoke Jews' citizenship from Israel. It's absolutely unacceptable to me. and I mean they're not they're not actual terrorists like they Eitan: What happens if you have no citizenship? Shanie: like I understand. I under I I recognize that like that it might be irresponsible journalism and like all sorts of things. contributing to maybe even libel it libels about about Jews in Israel, but like, come on, not don't revoke citizenship. I think it's really anti-democratic. but I I understand why people are like very I mean, I've I've read, first of all, most people commenting on it haven't seen it, hasn't been in Israel yet, I haven't seen it yet. but Raviv Drocker from Haaretz, which is the the most like left-wing mainstream paper in Israel, and and is like very, I would say generally comfortable calling out Israel, Israeli military behavior in particular. talk Israeli war crimes. They'll use words like genocide and apartheid regularly in their papers. So they don't shy away from those things. And they had an article from a journalist, Reviv Joker, who says, like, I I trust these guys, I I like them, I know them. I don't think they're terrible people. I saw the film, hear all my issues with them. And I should say specifically on the strike where you said there was they spoke they had soldiers testifying that there was some kind of strike that was supposed to have a 500 person civilian casualty count. There was no record of that ever happening and they couldn't find any. Like he they went to try and verify some of them. There was no record of it happening. which is because ultimately like soldiers' memories are very unreliable. soldiers have a lot of PTSD. And so to to like rely on anonymous testimony of P of soldiers with trauma is not is not so reliable. So you have to go and verify what they've said. and and they've done that in the past. this journalist particular has done in the past with breaking the silence, which also also accumulates testimonials of IDF soldiers specifically accounting alleged war crimes that they've committed often or have seen. and often they're not verifiable and often they didn't happen. And it's not necessarily even because the person is lying. It's because like it's in the fog of war. People don't really know what's going on. They also may not have actual insights into like like to be honest, the average soldier ground like doesn't have such a sophisticated insight into what's happening all the time. All they know is like what they've been told. And there's like a pretty high chain of command. So they might actually not really have awareness into what's happening. Their perception of the decision making might not actually be the reality, to be honest. Like they're carrying out things, but they don't necessarily know all the context around it. So I think that's important to say. first of all, that's also based on like how important is the target. It's not just based on how many terrorists versus how many civilians. If that's not the proportions that we often always talk about, there is a question of like civilian to combatant ratio, but the other question is how important is this target? Is this a guy who has killed a hundred people? Has he call killed a thousand people? Has he killed no people? Is he about to kill people? Like there it there's a lot of questions here. About, like, how how important are they to the chain of the command? Is this a random terrorist, or is this like the head of the chain of the command? So there's there's a lot here at play that we don't have insight into. And I don't think this documentary provides any additional insight into. Like that's not really the goal. The goal is to say, look at I I think the goal is to say, look how like sanitized and disgusting it is to be making these sort of calculations because it is very dehumanizing, right? This is how you dehumanize people, and it is horrible. It is also the way that wars are conducted. And And this is precisely what they're actually required to do. It it's deliberate. It you need to be doing this sort of calculation. Eitan: I think this is my issue. My issue with this is the same issue that I had with the New York Mac with the New York Times' coverage on the prison issues, right? Where Shanie: Mm. Eitan: they had vocalized what I would say were very valid concerns that had a Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: couple of instances in the reporting that you're that immediately disqualify so much of the rest of it. Because if you're like willing to go this far onto one clear lie, then how do you talk about that? Then then does that Clear lie completely eliminate the other reporting and the other stuff that has been done. You know, it's it's a big question when it comes to documentaries and and articles about this stuff, where it's like if they go, if they don't report one or two things correctly, then how much of the rest of it, which I'm sure that there is a real conversation that NASA has. Like there just there is. That Shanie: Yeah. Sure. Eitan: is a very valid thing that we're all dealing with. We're all trying to figure out what is the cost. you know, benefit analysis to the reaction after October seventh. And if you're going out there and you're making a thing that goes that goes too far and has, you know, unverifiable stuff and stuff that is so crazy that you do kind of question the reality of it, like it it just seems like net negative, in a lot of ways. Where I you know, I don't know that's the issue is that I've had with where like how much of other reporting do you disqualify versus, you know, the stuff that is completely inaccurate and the push and pull there. It seems like this is an issue Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: that keeps on coming up, where it's like they go a step too far every single time. Where, you know, it's like, why didn't you stop half a block back? Like why did you have to walk to this point? Shanie: Yeah, absolutely and they lose a lot of people who who would the hypothetically be on their side and like would be part of it. Like my my friends who are are very concerned about about war crimes and human rights violations by the Israeli military are not Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: promoting this video, right? Because the because it's too far. Because it's too far. And Eitan: Yeah. The prison the issue with the prison thing was that it we did not have a conversation past the lie of the dog rape. You can't support it. Shanie: Yeah. Yeah. Of course. Who wants to promote that? Who wants to talk about that anymore? absolutely. Eitan: Exactly. Shanie: So I think a few things. First of all, he Reviv Drucker from the Haareath journalist also talks about their dismissal of Hamas's using human shields, which is widely documented. We know that Hamas very intentionally puts its military infrastructure within hospitals and schools. It's like a really clear strategy that they use. So dismissing that outright and like just Blatantly dismissing Hamas's role in any of this when you're talking about civilian casualties. Like the reason civilian casualties are high, if they are even disproportionately high, which is debatable in the context of this war, is because of the guerrilla, the nature of the guerrilla warfare against Hamas, which is a very specific type of terrorist group that's like pretty intentional and strategic in how they are orchestrating this war to maximize civilian casualties, to make the calculation much harder on the Israeli side. And that's very deliberate and it's very clear. And it doesn't mean that Israel should do it anyway, right? Like maybe they just need to factor that in and say, you know what? The casualty count is too high. Like, we're not gonna do it. And maybe they're not doing that often enough. But the reality is, like, it's still part of should be part of the broader conversation. and one of my colleagues, Gabriel Epstein, you can follow him on X, he talks about this a lot because he does a very like painful, annoying work of basically going through every terrorist organization's obituaries. And so you have like, Hamas, I'm I'm gonna send it to you 18, you're gonna laugh. But like they'll have like a video of this like martyr, quote unquote, and they'll have like Islamic jihad, Hamas, Hezbollah, and they'll say, like, look at this amazing martyr, we love you, our commander who fought, and they'll have pictures of him in uniform. And he will look through those lists. Eitan: It's crazy that they put these in the New York Times, that this is in the New York Times obituary section. I think that that's completely inappropriate. I'll just Shanie: No, it isn't it is not in the New York Times obituary section. It's on their like Telegram channels. He spends time stalking Eitan: Crazy. Shanie: their telegram channels, and then he cross-references the list with the list of nurses, teachers, journalists who are listed. And there's a an insane amount of overlap to the point where my colleague, who's like bl really is a is a pretty is a really good researcher, and he would say that it's a very deliberate strategy from the terrorist side. to have people in dual roles, right? To say, like, we want our commanders to also be journalists. We want to recruit journalists. We want to make sure we're recruiting boys who are 15, 16, 17 years old so that they are listed as children. Like it's a very deliberate strategy. and and it's an effective strategy because it obviously creates an environment where it seems like Israel is actively trying to target healthcare workers and teachers and journalists because they're making sure their commanders are disproportionately in those roles. So there's a and and the and nobody reports on this, by the way. Nobody reports on this. Eitan: Okay, I can ask a de complete devil's advocate question here. Is it possible that they just need two jobs? Like, are the commanders getting like I'm dead serious? Like, if I'm a commander and I'm only making Shanie: Stop it. Eitan: 25 a year, you know, whatever, you know, if I can do some supplemental stuff, take on a nursing role, make a little extra cash on the side. Does that not happen? In this economy, I blame Biden. Okay? It's all biodynamics. Shanie: Stop it. No Hama Hamas fighters Hamas fighters are doing okay. It's all Biden's fault. Thanks, Biden. now you have Hamas Hamas Eitan: You see what he did? Biden before the Biden. Shanie: fighters have to go and be journalists now. Such a shame. Eitan: Yeah. When Biden was doing it, the Hooties were t actually the Houthis got worse after Biden left. I miss Biden for the Houthis. Shanie: Who do you got worse after Biden? Yeah, I I like Joe Biden personally. until he got too old, Eitan: I think I Shanie: you know. Eitan: I I think I owe people an apology for always kind of characterizing the Houthis as these like like rum swillin' pirates where like the joke what? Shanie: That's because of their music video. That's because they made that music video that one time. Did you see that? Eitan: I know. It was the issue was every time you saw the Houthis, it was them taking selfie videos like from jet skis next to like they were always on beaches Shanie: Mm-hmm. It's true. Eitan: and stuff like that. They're now not as fun as they were about three and a half weeks ago, is what I would say. Houthis have kind of become a bit of an issue closing down the strait Shanie: Hmm. True. Eitan: and and Saudi Arabia and stuff like that. You know what? I think that's actually a pretty good time to go into the 120 Angry Seats section of the Jew York Times. Shanik. Shanie: Let's do it. Eitan: Big couple of weeks when it comes to finalizing who we are gonna be seeing in the slates, that are coming up in the election October twenty seventh. What were some of the bigger polling news that had come out before we go into that? Shanie: Okay, so unfortunately for people like me who support the opposition, the polling is not looking great. If the elections were to happen today, I would say the most likely scenario is that nobody's able to form a coalition and we go back to another election three months later. So that's obviously not what people want to hear, but that's what it's looking like. If you look at the averages from three different polls in the last poll, there basically you have the Eisencott block at 53 seats. If you include the ROM party, Eitan: The eyes and block. Shanie: it goes the Eisenblock, I guess, at 53 seats and it goes up to 58, which is not 61. if you include the ROM party, which who knows if he'll even get there, the Netzanyao block at 52. And I don't see anybody that he can actually add to his block. So Netanyahu with clearly not hitting it, Gotti Eisencott clearly not hitting it either. So again, now what I should add is that this is a here you have Amhai Israel, the Ofra Winter Party, making it up to 4.75 seats. they could easily not clear the threshold in this poll there it well we'll Eitan: wow. So they're in now, officially. Yeah. Shanie: talk about the different pol different parties in a second, but basically like that's a party that could easily just fall below the threshold and waste four, five waste four seats. so that could change the dynamic. Like if those that would like change the calculation. so you do have them hanging around the threshold. You also have the religious Zionism, another right wing party hanging around the threshold. So we can talk about why ultimately it favors the Eisencott block because these a bunch of s they're like The right wing's very fragmented right now and has a lot of small parties that sometimes pull at seven seats, but like you can have parties pull at seven seats six weeks before elections and fall below the threshold. Like that's very classical scenario. And they have a they have three or four three of those kind of seats. So I'll talk out the seats, but right now, if the elections were to happen today, I would tell you like there's not going to be a winner and they're gonna spend a lot of time trying to form a coalition and then go back to elections. but again, we know we Eitan: You know we Shanie: have we have a month. We have over a month, so things can change. Eitan: Does the eisenblock include it does not include ROM to this point, correct? Shanie: So the f when I when it's when I said 53, it does not include Ram. Here Raham has Rahm has five seats in this poll or in this like average of polls. So they would add another five seats if they were in, which is possible. I am, as you know, I am optimistic in thinking that Isencott will manage to get Rom in, especially now that he has Saigalovich, a Jewish Zionist from the centrist Yeshati party, as like on his slate, leading the slate with him. I think that helps a lot. Eitan: So what so talk to me about like what each candidate is kind of thinking when it comes to filling that delta. Because you need the sixty one seats. Let's say Eisencock goes to fifty eight, bringing on Rom. How does he get those other three, you know, let's say four seats so that he has a that he has like a pillow? Like where do those four seats come from? Is it from hoping that more people vote? Or Shanie: Nowhere. He doesn't. They don't. No. You have to change the composition. He has to take them from he has to hope that the right wing party on Praisrael falls below the threshold. He has to hope that religious Zionism falls below the threshold. If they do, then we're then we're in good shape. Or he can try to like take more take more likud seats or hope that someone else takes more. I mean, it really just be him taking more likud seats. and you can move things back and forth a little bit, right? You have some undecided voters, it's not that many. especially not between the blocks. like I I they say like twelve percent of voters don't know who they're voting for, but that doesn't mean like they're voting for the Likud or or Isencot. It means they might be like between two parties in the same block. So that doesn't matter at all, as our listeners know by now. it's really only a couple percentage who are actually undecided in that way. but a couple of percentages is is not nothing in this election. You know, that's still a few seats. Eitan: What what like what would you let's say you're Gotti Eisencott right now. Are you what are what are you doing? Are you just like boots on the grounding trying to just make sure that more people vote? Or are you there's no other coalitions to be formed? Like the coalitions are kind of like locked up at this point. Shanie: Turnout matters a ton. Jewish Israelis vote at a very, very high rate. Arab Israelis don't. And even though you know Rom is the only party that would merge, if you have higher voter turnout in the Arab sector, it changes the composition because it's all a percentage. So if you have more people voting for the joint list, that really helps shape the percentages of Eitan: Interesting. Shanie: seats. So I would say if you can get, I mean, I think it's about 50%. Arab Israelis vote, if you can get that up to the Jewish rate, which is up to 75%, 80% even, then you're in much better shape. Even if they're not gonna join in a government, even if they're not gonna join the coalition, it doesn't matter. I think that will still help. And of course, maybe you got people out for the Rom party, which could sit. So maybe Rom gets up to six or seven seats, which is possible if you get enough people out. That's what I would focus on. Eitan: Can you walk me through the the Arab turnout? Shanie: Why there's low Arab turnout? Eitan: No, no, no, no. you say I'm sorry, I was saying that you'd focus on Arab turnout, making sure that there is more Arab turnout. I mean, why is there low Arab turnout? What is is Shanie: why would I focus on that? I mean, why is there low ab turnout? I think that historically there's like a cultural component here too. I think that marginalized groups sometimes like don't want to vote in general. There's also historically been like surveillance and kind of over policing and intimidation tactics used at polling stations in Arab communities specifically, especially in like we saw in the last few elections, and I'm sure we'll see it again this time. So, like there are some real like intimidation tactics happening here to to try to prevent Arabs from voting. And that's certainly part of the problem. Eitan: Well that's not good. Shanie: Yeah, it's not great. It's not great. So that's part of the problem. But again, like there could there's always like some communities vote more. Like Jews vote, right? Like Jews vote. That's our thing. We vote. We always go to vote. Some communities don't go to vote. And like there's a lot of like historical reasons why potentially, especially for marginalized groups that maybe they couldn't always vote, then they could vote, they couldn't So like groups like that have a tendency not to vote. They have a tendency also not to trust the system, which again for like Arab Israelis kind of makes sense. So that's like one of the main things that we're up against. so if I were maybe if I not maybe not Gadi Asgrad specifically, but if I was spending a lot of time thinking about how to help the opposition win this election, then Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: I would be encouraging Arab voter turnout. yeah. Eitan: Interesting. Good to know. it next question is is that like, you know, over the past this has been interesting following this election cycle as closely as been following because I never followed it like in a day-to-day versus, you know, historically I've just, you know, been pr kind of broadly aware of this. It's been interesting following the little like like calendar marks and stuff like that, like the ebbs and flows of this thing where it's the past, you know, now that the parties solidified themselves. Sorry, like the the who is running solidified themselves a couple of weeks ago. You know, over the past couple of months, we've kind of, you know, you know who the big players are and everything like that. Then you find out about the little players. Then there seems to be a little shuffling amongst like the, you know, amongst the different parties and figure out who was going where, and then figure out how many seats do all these parties is are they are they potentially going to get. And then that led us up to where the slates had kind of like been solidified over the past couple of weeks. So over the past like, you we can change like that. So if you just walk me through like where are we at in this cycle? Shanie: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. So we are so so today's September 17th. On September 8th, all of the slates were solidified. That meant that you have to every party had to say, if we're running, who we're running with, are we merging with another party? You had to declare that as well. and that was like hugely impactful because until that moment, your basically all of your polls were about decisions that voters didn't really have yet. Like nobody knew who was running with who. So you didn't even know who you were pretending to vote for in this hypothetical polling survey, right? So I'll tell you what's changed in the major parties. So first of all, you might recall, I think we spoke about it because there were all these like small parties in ATON. You kept asking me, like, who are these parties? What are they doing? Like, why do they exist? And I said, I have no idea. They're all the same. I have no idea Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: why they all exist. This is ridiculous. but it's like good for people like me who don't support them. because again, you can always like they could always fall below the threshold. but basically one of them was the reservist party, which had Yuaz Handel and Chili Trooper. By the end, Khili Trooper left and he went to join Gatti Eisencott's list, which meant that Joaz Hendel is now like running alone with this reservist party, another small right wing party, and they're like it's almost certainly not gonna cross the threshold. What does that mean? They will be wasting right wing votes. Okay. then you have the Ofer Winter part. Yeah, please. Yeah. Eitan: Is sorry, just can I ask your question on that? Sir, the guy what's the name of the other guy who like stayed back at the reservist party? Shanie: Yours, Handel. Eitan: Is he is he pissed at the first guy? Shanie: Probably. I'd be pissed if I were him. Eitan: Okay, so that is that wasn't like a core I guess like the question is like is that coordinated where they're like, All right, like me and you we're gonna run this Shanie: Mm Eitan: thing so that people know who we are and then when they see like, man, we like them, then it'll get me a chance to move over to you know, to a party that can actually like get me in. Or is it like he backstabbed the guy? Shanie: I backstab feels like a strong word for like basic politics and political maneuvering ahead of elections. But yeah, like this other guy is like it's great. Like Clealy Trooper like Eitan: He decapitated the guy. Is that better? Yeah. Shanie: is gonna get into the Knesset and Joes Hendel is not gonna get in the Knesset. Like one person got screwed here, obviously, right? That is, yeah. it's drama. There's a lot of drama. I don't know Eitan: Whoa. That's j that's drama. You think they text? You think they still text? Shanie: if I I think one of them left the WhatsApp group. Eitan: no. I bet Shanie: Ha ha. Eitan: they both have group chats now that are just trashing the other one. That's just how you know, like if either of Shanie: Guaranteed, guaranteed. Eitan: them are listening to this, you know, G York Times will gladly take an observer status role in any of those group chats. If you are a political insider and wants to give me observer status role like the Palestinian state, in any of your group chats, I am in. Let me know. Shanie: Wait, who was the who was the journalist? Was it the the New Yorker, the journalist who was like ended up in a Trump like telegram chat about Iran? Eitan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. He was all of a sudden he keeps getting added to these things where they're just like and the chat's called like do not add Phil and then just Phil is there. Crazy. Shanie: That was great. okay. So let me tell you about some of the other seats that like some things moved around. so who did join US Hendel party was A not Wilf, which is really weird because A Not Wilf, like I thought kind of fancied herself a bit of a liberal and joining US Hendel, who it's like a very interesting dynamic there. But U.S. Hendel and Not Wilf, again, like they're not gonna make it into the Knesset by any poll that I've seen. You could say it's a waste of right-wing votes. They also like they could compete with Gaudi Eisencott a little bit. So it could be wasting some of his votes. I'm not sure. like I could see people being between those two a little bit. but then we have Wolfir Winter, which we've spoken about a lot because there was speculation of if he was going to merge with Batsalas Motrich or Itzamar Bengvir, and if they were gonna, you know, merge together, right? That was like much of the conversation that we heard. Eitan: Overwinter's party's big thing is getting all Israelis judo lessons, if I'm not mistaken. That seems to be the the vibe of it. Shanie: That's that's the vibe. I don't know if that's their like official platform, but Eitan: The official pilot platform was was Red Belt for All, if I'm not mistaken, was we'll pay for your kid to be a a red belt. They're all they're they're the we were we were talking about. They're like the TikTok y. It seems to like they're more boomastic, Shanie: Yes. Eitan: you know, Yosef Adad, who got in a fight with that senator or the the the congressman a couple of weeks ago on that podcast, is in this is in this party. But for a while it seemed like they were polling under the four Shanie: Yeah, it's an interesting group. Eitan: percent, which would would have meant that they weren't going into Knesset, but now This is the first time we've had a podcast where they were pulling above the four percent threshold. So now they're like Shanie: Yes. Yeah. Right now I have them at four point seven. If you look but again, like it's really easy to fall below the thresholds. if you're at four point seven right now, especially for especially for a party like that. So ultimately, Itamar Ben Gvir's party, Utsmayodi, Jewish power, and Batsal Smithrich's party, religious Zionism, and Hai Israel, those are three different parties. they were there was talk of like two of them running together or all three running together, et cetera. And in the end, they're all running apart. For Netanyahu, this is very bad. Like he is furious because separately, if they all make it in, which in these polls, which as I told you, these polls look not like not good for anybody, but but better for Netanyahu than they did before, because it shows them all getting in. It shows Uts Utsmadi Odit with 7.3, religious Zionism 6.3, Am Khaistral 4.7. Right. so together that's like actually a pretty substantial. That's almost 20 seats. But at least one of them could fall below the threshold pretty easily. like that's it's not hard to imagine. And so that would change things a lot. So if we're looking at like what's gonna change the election, it's are any of those gonna fall below the threshold? That would make a huge difference in kind of wasting votes. so the fact that they're all running separately is very, is very not strange, but like I was kind of surprised. I thought some would merge because Netanyahu makes a huge point to bully all of the small parties into running together. He always tells them that. He's the original reason why Betzal Smutrich and Itamar Benger ran together back in 2019, 2020, because he said to them, please don't waste right-wing votes. And it was very controversial because they were so ex they were viewed as extremists at the time. Now they're like mainstream, like they're ministers in the Knesset. But at the time, it was like unfathomable that he would try to work with these Kahanists and get them into the Knesset. What's he, what's he doing? This is crazy. And now, like here we are, fast forward all these years later. So that's kind of the history there. any other mergers to talk about? No, but I did want to talk to you about no, religious Zionism merged with Zahoot, but like like th three people vote for that party, but that's Moshe Faglin's party. He's another like racist small party who his main thing is like legalizing weed and rebuilding the Third Temple and hating Palestinians. And that's like his whole shtick. so he and Smutrich are running together. Eitan: That's what wait, what what a what a three things to have. That's an incredible three pillars. Yeah, wait, this guy Shanie: Wait, you know what? I need to add something. I need to add something because Eitan: there's a religious there's a religious pothead who hates Palestinians and is in charge of the party. That's amazing. He's got my vote. Shanie: Yeah, Moshe Fagelin. The party's called Zahoot. Yeah. So I need to add, he does apparently have another issue that he and Smultrich care about because I was with my cousin of Varosha Shana, and he's he's Israeli and he was telling me that he's voting for this party, and I asked him why. And he said it was because they are the only ones pushing back against the teachers' unions. There's apparently like some niche issue about teachers' unions. And so he said, I have to vote for them because they're the only ones who are gonna fight and and save Israel's education system. I've never heard of this. I don't know what he's talking about. But I'm now I'm adding it to the conversation. Eitan: This guy's like the rent is too day. He's the Jimmy McMillan of of Israel. Just going around. Wait, that's is that a thing where like some of these like off brand topics are like so inst like instigating and such a driving force that like like there's not like a huge group Shanie: No. No, no, no. Eitan: of people that are just like the schools suck and that's why Shanie: I think it's just my cousin. I don't think it's a big demographic. I've never heard anyone else say this. I talk to a lot of Israelis, including people who vote for like far-right parties. I've never heard anyone say that's the reason why. Eitan: Are there a lot of mega religious anti Palestinian potheads that are running for office? Is that like a thing more than Moshe Fa? Shanie: I thought you were gonna say people because I think my cousin might be one of those people. but I Eitan: Is that a big thing? I mean well Shanie: think you definitely have anti r anti Palestinian potheads in Israel. Yes. That's Eitan: Can I Shanie: a c that's a group of people for sure. Eitan: Not to I want to say this with the tenderest of hands, but over the past with the really we're really holding this one, okay? It Shanie: Yes. Eitan: seems to be like drugs, and specifically weed, are a way bigger thing in Israel post October seventh. And if the country itself is getting more right wing in general, and would say at this happened kind of very in lockstep with each other. I I wonder Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: if that also is a thing where it's like if you've been smoking I listen, someone that smokes weed, like you know, if you're in a situation like that and you're just, you know, smoking weed and living in a pressure cooker, then you know, I can I can I can totally see you know, a bunch of people that are like smoking a bunch of weed because of the trauma that they have had. And you know, you kind of come up with some wacky ideas there. I'm saying I understand. Shanie: Makes you paranoid. Makes you paranoid. Eitan: Yeah, like I I once again, tenderest of hands humanly po look at these. Look at these Shiny. Shanie: Ha ha Eitan: But you know what I'm saying? And what I'm saying, I'm sure it isn't a lot of I'm you know, I who knows how many people it is, but I'm just saying that I wouldn't be surprised if these two things are are maybe somewhat pushing into each other a little bit. Shanie: You know, historically I thought that weed was gonna would help Israelis and Palestinians like chill out and it doesn't. It makes them paranoid and weird. So I take it all back. I used to say that's what they need. They need to smoke more weed. And now I'm like, ow, no, no drugs for you guys. Eitan: Yeah. Well, I I think that if there's I think that if the weed is everywhere all the time where you know it's just like if it's like part of the lifestyle versus like a an off ramp every once in a while, like there's a way to use it. I don't know. I feel like the way that the Israelis are using it, not to judge or whatever, it's it's less off ramp and more part of the drive that makes sense. There you go. Wow. Where's Haaretz? Shanie: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it does. One more thing, one more thing on the parties. One more note on the parties. This is very marginal, but I have to tell you about it because I'm super passionate about this. There's an alternative Haredi party. it's called the Haredi Public. It's led by Multi Leitner. And they are not gonna make it in the Knesset. They're gonna waste votes, and that's okay because at least people aren't voting for the actual Haredi parties. they support education reform, they support like real. Actual education for ultra-orthodox kids, which is really important and something that the rabbis obviously oppose. they also support some level of draft. So they wouldn't say like we support a blanket draft, but we support that like some Haredi men should go to the army, especially those who aren't learning. Eitan: Did we talk about this last week? Didn't we Shanie: do we talk? We talked about it, we didn't talk about how they have women on their slate now. Eitan: wait, wait, wait. Yes, wait. Okay. Background to everyone out there. Shanie: I was setting the stage. Eitan: Yes. Okay. Wait. I want to say also, background out there. Today me and Shanille were texting about stuff to talk about. And this was a note that I had. I wanted to ask about this because she you you say, you say, you say. Shanie: Thank you. Okay. So my dear friend Fanny Sukenek, amazing Haredi feminist, and a bunch of other women, a few like about a month ago, they hosted this like online platform that was kind of like a fake primaries. And everyone in the Haredi community was kind of making fun of them. And they were like, if you were to vote in the in the elections, which women like nominate women for this for this Haredi women to run for office? And they nominated people and then they had a whole election. And there were a bunch of like really prominent, amazing, brilliant Haredi women and And people were voting. Now it would this was a fake primary, right? And Faini went on Kikar Shabbat and a bunch of other like Haredi newspapers and podcasts and TV shows to talk about it. And people were like literally mocking her to her face and saying, like, what's the purpose of this? This doesn't make sense. And she and she had meetings directly with Mutti Leitner and and and his party, and they were constantly talking about it. And he would say, I'm so sorry, but like there's just no place for women on this party. Like the people aren't ready for it and like we're just not doing it. fast forward to when the party is actually listed. And they have Dr. Nahumi Yafe, a woman, obviously, a smart Harvard PhD woman, on the slate, which is like really, really, really incredible. so yeah, it this is like all to her credit. So much, much credit to all of the women who work tirelessly for this to happen. Eitan: First time there's a karate woman. Shanie: first time there's a Haredi woman on a Haredi slate. and here's here's what she wrote to. Eitan: there Haredi women on other slates, historically. Shanie: I think there's like what you could call Haredi women like Ben Gvir's slate. Like you have you have Haredi women on other slates, but not representing Haredi parties. this Eitan: What is your policy on getting stoned and hating Palestinians, though? What is the that was a joke. Shanie: I don't think they have policy on either. I'm sure they're not like talking about the Israeli Palestinian conflict very often. but yeah. Eitan: Wait, that's so interesting. That's a really good point though, is that the stuff that they're that the h the Haredi communities are talking about are not related to the defense stuff. It's their own, you know, food stamps and schooling and yeah. Shanie: No, if they're in it's like the Arab part. It's like Rom. It's similar to the Rom party where like they're trying to focus on their own issues. So I haven't seen any quotes. I'm sure they have like a bunch of right-wing people also on the par people who are right and maybe some people who are also left on the party slate. but their focus is much more on internal issues, which are now, because they're growing demographic, have become domestic issues that everybody cares about. Eitan: Yeah. You know, this this reminded me a lot of the ninety three Queen story, which I don't know if you saw the documentary, incredible documentary about the first woman's ambulance corps in the first Hasidic women's ambulance Shanie: Reading. Eitan: corps in Brooklyn and kind of the Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: issues that they came across because you know, there's a he this is the concern. This is the the question that they were trying to solve. Let's say, you know, obviously ultra orthodox communities in Brooklyn, let's say you're pregnant, or let's say you're like a woman who needs some medical at you know, attention. You've never touched a guy, you know, you maybe you've all you've only Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: touched your husband. You've maybe have never talked Shanie: Stressful. Eitan: to any, you know, in in just a social capacity and all that stuff. And all of a sudden something happens and you need to be in a very compromising position because there's a medical emergency with a bunch of Hasidic guys. That is a completely inappropriate, you know, very uncomfortable situation, especially if you're giving birth. Also, no offense to the Hasidic guys out there, but they don't really respect personal space or or feelings and all that stuff. I say this with a lot of love out there, you know, because the bottom north, you I I say this as someone, you know, my dad has a law firm in Borough Park. You know, I I hang with them, you know, occasionally. I, you know, there's a lot of love out there. But at the same time, this isn't exactly a subtle group of of people. which by the way, can I put a pit Shanie: Not wrong. Eitan: on this? You ever my favorite Modi joke about the about Hatsala? Shanie: Love Moody. Eitan: Have you ever heard the the Modi joke Hatsala at all? Shanie: Tell it, tell it. Eitan: He goes, he was was in the emergency room, and this is a Modi joke. Okay, he goes, I was in the emergency room and I'm watching all these strapping. EMTs walking in, and it's amazing watching, you know, EMT FDNY. They're running through their big strong guys with walkie-talkies, and they're what they're like 800 over pole socks. I need 15 milligrams of this. I got I need this stat. Then Hutsalah walks in. Yay, did I a bunch of out-of-shape with keys jangling everywhere? Just like, do you know Dr. Kleinbaum in ophthalmology? Just walking through. You look at the you look at the Hutsala ambulances, it's just a wall of names. Anyone who has ever donated eighteen dollars, Spriggy Bot Malka, Miriam Bashmuchel, just on the side of the ambulance. Anyways, that's the Modi joke. Hutsula Hutsala, you know Shanie: It's a very funny joke. Love Hatala, love Hatala. Eitan: Love Hutsala, they're incredible. But when there was a you know, when it came time to but they don't have any women. That was the whole thing, is that they had no women on Hatsala. So there was, I forgot her name, but she ended up, I think she was actually on the Supreme Court in in New York or in some capacity or in Brooklyn. she started the women's ambulance corps that was all Hasidic women, and they went through hell trying to get it approved because it was not like a work for women. And then these are religious women. So they had to go through the process of getting the rabbis like on board and stuff. And it was a real struggle. I think eventually they did end up getting. you know, on board and it and I think at this point they are still functioning. If not, I they may have been absorbed. I I say this all with a grain of I I don't remember exactly what happened with them, but you know, similar paths to having Hasidic Haredi women try to, you know, make waves in a community while also respecting their own kind of like religious background, you know, and and figuring out how they should navigate if they have certain beliefs about, you know, what their positions are in a community like that. It's really interesting. Shanie: Wait, back to elections for one second because I just got notification that there was a Times of Israel poll that just that they just had out. Again, like this is always these are half polls are coming out all the time, but I just to like emphasize the difference if they make the threshold. We just saw Amcha Israel for Winter's Party at 4.75 seats. they just put out a poll where they didn't make cross the threshold. And would it like just to explain how the impact would be, like that adds basic would add two seats to the Netanyahu block. sorry, to the Eisenhop Eitan: Hmm. Shanie: block. That would give the opposition two extra Eitan: Interesting. Shanie: seats. So they'd be up to fifty five and Netanyahu down to fifty-one. So like it reshapes everything if they don't make it. They would still fall short, but like they would still both still fall short. But if let's say two of the parties don't make it in, changes everything. Eitan: D do do you think Yosef Haddad saw that poll and right now is just in his basement punching a a punching bag just angrily over and over? Shanie: I I think that if you're running in the elections, you're trying really hard not to look at the polls too quo closely, probably. That's what I would be doing. Eitan: That makes a lot of sense. But you know what the interesting also thing about that poll is that let's say fifty five percent with Isencott, sorry fifty five seats with Isencott, Shanie: It type seats. Eitan: and then if they were to add the five seats with Ron, that still only gets them to sixty. So they would still be under Shanie: Mm. Eitan: the sixty one seat threshold, even if you know, if the winter party doesn't get it. Shanie: Correct. You would need to have two of the parties not making it in, like maybe religious Zionism also not making it in, which I don't know how likely that is. But if they both didn't make it in, that's another story. I actually I'm not sure how that would rearrange it, but I assume that it would work in Isaacon's flavor. But but yes, right now that would still, even with Rom, only give them 60. Eitan: What is the next thing in the cycle to kind of be looking for? Shanie: I we're about six weeks out. So I think like as we get closer, you might have platforms solidify a little bit more. You might have heavier campaigning now that everyone has their actual party leaders. so you might end up seeing a little bit more, a little more interviews, a little more media coverage. So that could change things a little bit, but really you just have like the Shana, you had Shauna Orlick on here talking about like what grassroots organizing looks like. Like there's gonna be a lot of campaigning over the next six weeks. Eitan: Nice. You excited? When's Shanie: I'm really excited. Eitan: what are what are you looking for specifically? Shanie: What am I looking for? I think I would wanna see more like platforms coming out. So like I'm I want people to be talking more about what their actual policies are as opposed to like we think the ultra orthodox should draft. Like, okay, yeah, you and everybody else. Like, do you have any opinions? so I'm curious to see if they're like platforms. But honestly, there's a very clear strategy to avoid doing that. So I don't think I'm gonna see that. Like Gotti Eisencott is very intentionally not talking about his opinions. everyone's trying to like keep to themselves because the less you say the better. Just let people like and trust you, and politics will do the rest. and stay quiet. I am also looking for Netanyahu doing any like pulling any tricks, right? Like he's a big fear-monger, he has a tendency to pull through towards the end. So there's a lot that There's a lot that the person in power can do to change an election. Like that's just the reality. You're always going to have the upper hand if you're an incumbent, especially in a country like Israel, where like it's really small, you can affect a lot of change in a lot of ways. For example, you could decide to go to war and then nobody can fly home to vote, or nobody can vote. Like there's just like a lot of things you can do to influence the elections. Eitan: gonna say I I I was gonna say kind of my last question on all this is like if you had to pick the top five ways that the elections don't end up happening, like what are those ways that you see? So obviously war happens, so they would cut it. Shanie: Think it's mostly just war because they've they haven't they've they've never canceled an election like that. So I don't actually think the elections will c get canceled. I think more s a more likely scenario would be that something happens that makes it harder to vote. and so you could have a war that makes it harder to vote where people in the north and the south are not really managing to get to polling stations. the other the only other thing I can think of, which was discussed where Miri Reggae from the transportation ministry was talking about limiting the flights home. Although I think there will be flights chartered at that point to get people home to vote, but essentially just cutting down the flights entering Israel. Because, you know, you really just have like most of the flights are still, I think, LL flights. And so you can kind of limit you can just say like we're limiting flights landing in Israel, and then you have, you know, 50,000 people who aren't cutting to vote anymore. Eitan: What am I wrong in thinking also that if they were to make it so like let's say they were to like invent the war, let's say a scenario here obviously whatever is like invent the war or something, right? And it would to be affecting the communities in the north by Lebanon and then the south kind of by Gaza, if that was where you had said that it would would Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: that are those not like we could see like wouldn't that be net negative Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: for Netanyahu where he couldn't like if he was to have you know the North not vote, that seemed really would be bad for him. Shanie: You'd have you'd also have much lower Arab turnout though, because they had tend to have like fewer shelters and such. Like I think and it's much easier. Like a community that's already not as likely to vote is going to be impacted more. but yes, I I don't know that it's strategic for him either. I I don't I don't think he necessarily would I think it helps him. The people coming from abroad are less likely to be his voters for sure. so he has more incentive to limit them. But I don't I I don't necessarily think he's gonna try to go to war to prevent an election because or to make it harder because I agree a lot of the people in the peripheral towns are his voters as well. That's his base. Eitan: Where would you do a fake war? No, I'm joking. I shouldn't Shanie: Where would I zoom in? You know, I've been thinking things are too quiet with Egypt, so Eitan: You know what? They've been sitting there too, you know, maybe the Houthis need to head over to Egypt and kind of coming through the south, huh? Shanie: Ha. Eitan: This is a pro Houthie podcast now. Shani, is there anything else I'm missing about where we are at and everything and anything at all in the in the in the universe of Israel elections? Shanie: I think you got it all. Eitan: Amazing. Okay. And with that, this has been another episode of the JR Times Presents. 120 Angry She Angry Seats featuring Shanie Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. Shanie's podcast, Disputed Territories is coming out next week. Everyone, I cannot co sign it. Well, actually, I haven't heard any of it. It could be very hateful. I'm actually gonna be honest. I have no idea what's in there. I don't know if Shanid Shanie knows what's gonna be in there. It could honestly Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: be propaganda that is very, very hateful. and the only way to find that out would be to tune into the first episode and you decide. Shanie: We we have a trailer dropping pretty soon. Well, trailer probably dropping early next week. so if you follow Disputed Territory Pod or me, Shani Mika on Instagram, you can find it. Eitan: What's and I will be in Atlanta in the beginning of October, come to the JCC of Atlanta and also October twenty second, Shanie: Thanks. Eitan: ninety second street Y, Jewish or anti-Semitic Live is back. the game Shanie: Nice. Eitan: show is gonna be a ton of fun. and aside from that, I got nothing else to plug. I will see you guys all later in honor of my roommate who was walking in and out here. We l he lives on it's a duplex, by the way, everybody, okay? He he lives on the other end of a duplex, okay? Anyways. And on a rich bar stool.