Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Restoring American Exceptionalism with Robert Choi
Transcript
- 0:10Hey everyone, my guest today is Robert Choi, the founder and
- 0:13creator of choireport.com. The Choi report is dedicated to
- 0:18examining the world as it is, rather than as political
- 0:21activists, elitist intellectuals, or bureaucrats
- 0:24wish it to be. This report is guided by a
- 0:26commitment to four essential values, the primacy of
- 0:30trade-offs over solutions, intellectual clarity on
- 0:33disparities, substantive excellence over symbolic
- 0:36signaling, and the principle of consequential responsibility.
- 0:39Welcome to the show. Robert.
- 0:41Thank you for having me. Of course, yeah.
- 0:44I was wondering if you could tell the audience a little bit
- 0:46about yourself and what you're working on right now.
- 0:50Sure. My name is Robert Choi.
- 0:52I am the founder of a sub stack called the Troy Report and I
- 0:58started that just a couple of months ago and we've been able
- 1:02to reach 250,000 monthly views just in a couple of months.
- 1:07Some people would say it's an overnight success, but there's
- 1:11no such thing in my opinion, because I've been trying various
- 1:14versions of this for years. So, you know, to the extent that
- 1:18that's, you know, an overnight success, I guess it is.
- 1:20But prior to that, I have worked in the federal government, at
- 1:26the Central Intelligence Agency. I've also been a senior
- 1:30executive in the public sector, in the transportation industry,
- 1:35and I've also been a public sector consultant for almost 20
- 1:39years. So that's a little bit of my
- 1:41background and, you know, the sort of mission and purpose that
- 1:46I have overall is, you know, to get people, especially the
- 1:53electorate, the voting electorate, but really anybody
- 1:57who wants to be a reflective, thoughtful person to to get
- 2:01better at two things. And that's asking whenever you
- 2:05hear a story, a statement, a comment, a piece of rhetoric,
- 2:10really asking, is that really true?
- 2:13And discovering if it's really true because in this age of AI
- 2:18and the cultural phenomenon of technology that, you know, over
- 2:22the past couple of decades has really evolved.
- 2:24And it's really coming to a place where, you know, people
- 2:29are questioning objective reality.
- 2:30And that comes down through to the issues of politics as well.
- 2:34So asking is this really true is really important, I think.
- 2:39And the second goal that I have in doing what I do is getting
- 2:44more people asking what is this statement, fact or idea compared
- 2:50to? And the, and what I mean by that
- 2:52is, you know, you, you hear a lot of pronouncements,
- 2:55particularly on the left, but also, you know, on both sides
- 2:59really, where you make statements of fact, where truths
- 3:04are presented, but they're almost always in contemporary
- 3:10media presented as, you know, just truth.
- 3:15But it, there's no compare. It's no comparison.
- 3:18You know, it's, you know, for example, just a stupid example
- 3:21is oh, America's attack on Iran is is evil or, you know, or it's
- 3:27a huge success, whichever, whichever side you're on, I
- 3:29think it's a huge success, but you know, more on that later.
- 3:32But you know, either or it's compared to what what are, what
- 3:39are you making that statement based on?
- 3:41So that's that's my mission is to get people, more people
- 3:45thinking about what is objectively true, supportable by
- 3:49empirical evidence, and also to get people to ask compared to
- 3:53what? Yeah, yes, You know, I, it
- 3:57drives me crazy. Anytime I see it, reporting it,
- 4:01there's always an opinion right there in the title.
- 4:04You know it. I don't know.
- 4:07Just. Absolutely.
- 4:08It drives me. It it drives me absolutely
- 4:11wacko. And, you know, I, that's what
- 4:15fuels me to write and to podcast and to, you know, do what I do.
- 4:21It's, it's looking at what's presented as truth in society
- 4:27and through experience, through, you know, knowledge acquisition
- 4:33research, knowing that it's not true that the things that are
- 4:37being said by credible or quote UN quote credible media sources
- 4:43is completely untrue or it's clickbait a lot of times.
- 4:47And I, you know, I wrote an article about the president's
- 4:51poll numbers recently and the entire media universe, I'll say
- 4:59the mainstream media had two weeks worth of news cycling
- 5:04about how this was a historic drop in poll numbers, how it's a
- 5:09catastrophe, how Trump is going to be, you know, voted out of
- 5:13office if not impeached. But if you look at the actual
- 5:16data, Trump as actually President Trump has actually had
- 5:20the most stable poll numbers of any president in modern history.
- 5:25And Obama, Biden, you know, most recently their poll numbers
- 5:32dropped double digits more over the period of their
- 5:36presidencies, much more than President Trump's.
- 5:39So it's, it's empirical fact that you can anybody can look at
- 5:42it. There's poll numbers out there,
- 5:44wrote an article about it. You can see it on
- 5:45troyreport.com. And this is the news cycle that
- 5:50happens for National, international, even for two
- 5:53weeks. And it's just not true.
- 5:55And you know, not to be all over the map, but this is also true
- 6:00of this term, trickle down economics.
- 6:03If you ask any economist, can you find me a textbook on
- 6:08trickle down economics? Can you point me to a statement
- 6:12about, you know what it is? And they they would not be able
- 6:16to because it doesn't exist. It is political rhetoric that
- 6:20was created by the left to describe the right.
- 6:25And it's just insane that it's just kind of out there as
- 6:28something that, you know, the right created and it's an actual
- 6:33economic theory when it's not. So these are the kind of things
- 6:37that, you know, drive me up the wall that that, that, you know,
- 6:39sustain me in doing what I do. Yeah, you never run out of
- 6:46material doing that. It's so once in a while I'll ask
- 6:51if I haven't been able to pay too much attention to the news
- 6:53cycle, I'll just ask rock like, hey, what were the headlights of
- 6:57their Yeah, highlights of the past two days or something like
- 7:01that. In almost every time recently
- 7:04since since the strikes on Iran, it will say that support for
- 7:09Trump has has dropped almost every single time.
- 7:12But then you go to all these other polls and or you know,
- 7:16I'll other resources and they say the opposite, kind of like
- 7:20what you had said and that, you know, it's, it's interesting
- 7:24that it seems like all these AI things kind of lean to the left.
- 7:28But I mean, that's just one example of like you just you
- 7:32can't trust one source of of information.
- 7:37No, absolutely. And particularly, you know, with
- 7:42this conflict in Iran, really it's an attack on Iran and which
- 7:47I'm completely fine with. It is a very significant event.
- 7:52It's unprecedented in terms of it marking, you know, a seismic
- 7:57shift in global power dynamics. And it is something that
- 8:04previous commanders in chiefs should have done much earlier
- 8:09than now because Iran has posed a threat to the United States,
- 8:14its interest and allies for over 40 years.
- 8:17Whether it's in its financing of terror, whether it's in its
- 8:22regional dynamics and regional status in in threatening their
- 8:29neighbors, whether it's with their clandestine nuclear
- 8:34projects and capability acquisition, they have been a
- 8:40major global threat that nobody has been willing to address.
- 8:46And, you know, the left narrative is whether this is
- 8:50popular or not. And that's not really a great
- 8:53policy approach because great leaders, they don't look at
- 8:57polls great leaders, in my opinion, if you think about
- 9:02great leaders in history, whether it's, you know, on both
- 9:05sides of the aisle, they operate from a place of values and they
- 9:11act according to their values. This is something that, you
- 9:14know, I criticize the left about because for them, too many,
- 9:19especially in the media, it's about what's popular.
- 9:23And that's not how you make decisions in in your national
- 9:28interest, in the national interest of the United States.
- 9:32And, and, you know, I think that the escalation of threat by Iran
- 9:40has had come to a point where it was no longer, you know, you
- 9:44couldn't ignore it anymore. And I and I think that Trump has
- 9:49made the right decision in not ignoring 4 decades of exporting
- 9:54instability and terror from Iran.
- 9:57And, you know, the whole presumption of critics of this
- 10:03action is that it's very complicated.
- 10:09You know, what about the Iranian people?
- 10:11We've been bad at nation building or they say we've seen
- 10:15this in Iraq, we've seen this in Afghanistan, we've seen this in
- 10:19Vietnam. But the underlying presumption
- 10:22of that argument is that it is the United States's
- 10:27responsibility to hold hands and take care of a nation that has
- 10:31been threatening to our interests and our allies.
- 10:35And I completely reject that notion.
- 10:38We don't have to do any kind of regime changing, in my opinion,
- 10:43if that's what the administration decides to do,
- 10:46you know, we'll look at that. But we don't have to change a
- 10:50regime. We don't have to do any nation
- 10:52building. Our responsibility, I believe
- 10:55and leaders responsibility to the American people is to
- 10:59protect our national security and our borders.
- 11:03So whether the Iranian people after the it's these attacks
- 11:09decide to sort out their own country or they want to run
- 11:12around like savages, it's entirely up to them.
- 11:15That shouldn't be part of the America's calculus.
- 11:19You threaten America's national security interests.
- 11:22It is the job of the commander in chief's to address it.
- 11:25And I think that the president has and, you know, frankly, I'm
- 11:31happy to see that the, you know, that we have a president that's
- 11:36willing to use our sophisticated best in the world military and
- 11:45assets to accomplish measurable, achievable aims, which, you
- 11:52know, includes, you know, destabilizing Iranian military
- 11:59assets and threats, weakening, if not destroying their nuclear
- 12:04capability and making sure they understand that we live in a
- 12:10world of real politic, meaning, you know, they have to
- 12:13understand that, you know, there are threats to their behavior.
- 12:17There are consequences to their behavior.
- 12:20And, you know, they that they couldn't continue to go on, you
- 12:25know, threatening the rest of the world, you know, at will.
- 12:29Yes, it it's been quite impressive to see the military
- 12:34in action with this, this term with Trump.
- 12:38And people have been threatening the United States.
- 12:41Other countries have been threatening the United States in
- 12:44various ways for well over a decade now, and no one's done
- 12:49anything about it. And I think that, you know, no
- 12:52one wants to see war. No one wants to see death.
- 12:54But to finally have a president that's standing up for us and
- 13:00trying to keep us safe is it. It's a change.
- 13:04And some people might not be comfortable with it, but I think
- 13:08I think we all need to recognize that I Iran was a threat.
- 13:14I mean it correct me if if I'm wrong, but I thought I read that
- 13:18they were building like 100 around 100 ballistic missiles
- 13:22per month ever since we struck the nuclear sites.
- 13:26Like they didn't they didn't stop at all.
- 13:28They went right back to to building things up.
- 13:31And then I was reading something about the man that was just
- 13:36federally charged that for being involved within with Iran to try
- 13:41to assassinate President Trump. Like Iran was a real a real
- 13:44threat. But people are so wrapped up in
- 13:50the media cycle, like Nancy Guthrie, whatever, that they're,
- 13:54they're ignoring things that that were a danger to us.
- 13:59Yeah. And if you think about how the
- 14:01Obama administration managed this threat, the Iranian threat,
- 14:07it's a real contrast to how President Trump is managing the
- 14:13threat. You know, since the
- 14:16implementation of the joint agreement during the Obama
- 14:20administration, you know, it was called the Joint Comprehensive
- 14:25Plan of Action. And there have been analysis and
- 14:28studies that have taken place post agreement during the bottom
- 14:34administration about nuclear activities in Iran.
- 14:39And Israeli intelligence had found and discovered troves of
- 14:46documents 55,000 pages and 55,000 digital files that
- 14:51documented years of work on atomic weapons warhead designs
- 14:56to your point, missile designs, production plans, it was called
- 15:01Project Ahmad and this effort by Iran had been had been carried
- 15:06forth since 1999. And you know my first question
- 15:12during the Obama and I and I voted for President Obama.
- 15:16I voted for him one time, but. I did too, so yeah.
- 15:21So, you know, I'm not, you know, strictly partisan, but, you
- 15:26know, even at the time I was asking, you're going into this
- 15:31joint agreement and you understand.
- 15:34And then U.S. intelligence sources have told you that they
- 15:37have a clandestine nuclear program.
- 15:41And if you read the agreement, you know, it had a lot of
- 15:47provisions for checking on Iran where essentially the people,
- 15:53the, you know, the Iranian government, all they had to say
- 15:56is, yes, we're doing that. And all they had to say is.
- 15:59And the argument during the time and even now is that, oh, you
- 16:03have inspectors and you have people going in and verifying.
- 16:07Yeah, but you're trying, you're trying to verify a clandestine
- 16:12program. You know, do you think they're
- 16:14going to tell you about it? Do you think they're going to
- 16:17talk to the UN inspectors and say, well, you know, you know,
- 16:20we have a little bit of a program here leftover that's
- 16:23clandestine and we're, you know, we're, we're, we want to talk to
- 16:25you about it. No, that's not what's going to
- 16:27happen. They're going to go further
- 16:28underground with it. And through these documents that
- 16:31were discovered, that's exactly what they did.
- 16:35You know, they were prepared and, you know, investing a lot
- 16:40of resources into developing 5 nuclear warheads, each with 10
- 16:45kiloton yields for delivery in their Shahab 3 ballistic
- 16:52missiles. And, you know, they publicly
- 16:56issued a halt order after the Obama deal, which is pretty much
- 17:02you can take a piece of paper and glue macaroni on it and it
- 17:04has the same, you know, level of credibility.
- 17:08And so all of the documents say that they've, they turned their
- 17:13overt program into a covert program.
- 17:17And, you know, I just thought it was completely absurd that we
- 17:21have people with pedigrees and education and years of
- 17:25experience in government and negotiation willing to, you
- 17:29know, not looking at the common sense aspect of, of, you know,
- 17:34how you investigate A clandestine program.
- 17:37Right. This is a little bit of a spin
- 17:40off, but do you think that Putin might reconsider what he's doing
- 17:48with Ukraine after seeing our military strength against Iran?
- 17:54Well, I think that's an excellent question.
- 17:57And I think that's the right question because, well, first of
- 18:01all, we live under a international structure that's
- 18:06based on power. And you can read that in, you
- 18:09know, every freshman political science student has to read a
- 18:14book called The Theory of International Politics by
- 18:17Kenneth Waltz. And it will tell you that, you
- 18:22know, despite all of the simplification and reductive
- 18:27thinking around, you know, international law and how
- 18:30support things are supposed to work in ideal, in an ideal
- 18:33world, really, we are living in a structure of conflict and
- 18:39power. And a big part of how sovereign
- 18:42nations interact with one another in real terms is through
- 18:48signals of power. And what that means is every
- 18:53nation has to have a posture of some type of deterrence.
- 18:57So for China, it might be their economic power, you know, for
- 19:03the Middle East or, or, or previously with Iran, it could
- 19:06be their threat to Israel. And these are aspects of power
- 19:12signaling that speak to a level of deterrence by other nations
- 19:18from acting. And for some reason, the left
- 19:21has a real problem with America having that same level and
- 19:26calculus of deterring other nations from action by showing
- 19:30our strength. And I think that all sovereign
- 19:33nations do that whether we like it or not, because that's the
- 19:36language of international politics.
- 19:38It's power. It's not, you know,
- 19:41humanitarian. It's not charity.
- 19:44It's not nation building. Those are all ideal arguments
- 19:48that are based on idealist values.
- 19:51But the real world lives on power dynamics.
- 19:55And do I know whether how Putin will react to the actions that
- 20:00we've taken in in Iran? Of course not.
- 20:03But I can tell you that they definitely are destabilizing to
- 20:08people who, you know, view America as a threat, people who
- 20:14are enemies of the United States.
- 20:17You know, it will give them pause.
- 20:18And that pause is very valuable currency in the language of
- 20:23deterrence. Yeah.
- 20:25And, you know, I think Putin and the Ukraine conflict has its own
- 20:31idiosyncrasies. It's very unique.
- 20:33There's some cultural conflict there because of, you know, the
- 20:37regions involved in Ukraine. So it's, it's not as it, it's,
- 20:42it's not as simple over in, in that conflict area as it is with
- 20:47Iran. In my view, Iran is a clear
- 20:50threat to the region, to our interests, their interests, to
- 20:54our as allies in Israel. And it needs to be dealt with.
- 20:59And, you know, Russia in their annexation, you know, this is
- 21:05previous to their invasion of, of, of Ukraine, you know, that
- 21:10was a, that was a lot of murky ground.
- 21:12And so I see that we're on a holding pattern with, you know,
- 21:16seeing how Russia continues to behave.
- 21:20And so that's a little bit of a delicate balance because of the
- 21:23history that we have with the Soviet Union.
- 21:28But I think to your to your question, it absolutely is going
- 21:31to give Putin and his administration some pause and at
- 21:37least some, you know, some might cause them to second guess some
- 21:43of their planned actions or, or, or what they've been doing.
- 21:46And I think that we have to give credit to the what I call the
- 21:51Trump Doctrine, which is really a return to an understanding of
- 21:56international politics for what it is, which is a language of
- 22:01power and understanding of structural power dynamics in the
- 22:05world. You know, it in a ways, it seems
- 22:10like he's almost forgotten about Russia and Ukraine.
- 22:12But one thing I've learned about Trump is he doesn't forget about
- 22:16anything. And he could be working on
- 22:19something and you have no idea what's, and then it just blows
- 22:23your mind. I mean, just trying to keep up
- 22:25with the news cycle with him as president is a completely
- 22:29different world than when Biden. Was probably, he and John
- 22:34Kennedy have a lot in common in the sense that they're both TV
- 22:38presidents. They're great to watch.
- 22:41I I love to watch a, a President Trump press conference.
- 22:47It's informative, but not not only informative, but quite
- 22:50entertaining because he's willing to say things that in
- 22:54the traditional political that that go beyond the traditional
- 22:58political rhetoric. And so he surprises people.
- 23:03And, you know, unfortunately critics of Trump who are
- 23:09emotional and not being rational can't separate that.
- 23:14Yes, sometimes he can be distasteful in in, in different
- 23:18areas, and he has a very unorthodox style, especially
- 23:22when he's competing with his critics and dissenters.
- 23:28But that's different from, you know, whether or not a policy is
- 23:32going to have a net benefit or net a net loss as in terms of
- 23:39impact. And you see, all of the policies
- 23:43that the Trump administration has implemented, or virtually
- 23:47all of them have, have a sort of Nexus in terms of what a
- 23:55president is supposed to do constitutionally.
- 23:58So in that sense, the president is acting as a constitutionalist
- 24:04to one of the one of the chief responsibilities of the
- 24:09president is to protect national security.
- 24:13It's also protect borders. And that's a that's a whole
- 24:16nother issue with a lot of rhetoric around it.
- 24:19But that's constitutionally one of his, one of his duties
- 24:21because you can't have a nation Without Borders.
- 24:23You know, even economically, have we been getting screwed in
- 24:29a lot of our trade deals? Yes.
- 24:32You know, are there? Could there have been
- 24:34improvements in the timing or the ways in which tariffs are
- 24:38implemented or negotiated? Probably nobody's perfect.
- 24:42But if you look at the performance of the markets and
- 24:46you look at the deals that are being made, you know, even if
- 24:50you look at them just in terms of their concepts, you know,
- 24:55they're right on the money because we are getting screwed
- 24:58in terms of the trade deals and trade deficits for no reason.
- 25:02And, and, you know, just to look at that, he's the 1st president
- 25:06to really look at that and speak about it because he wasn't
- 25:10afraid to disrupt some, you know, vague notion of a, a
- 25:15balance or stability that previous presidents have had.
- 25:18Right. It's interesting because I don't
- 25:22know if the average American citizen or, or the voter base
- 25:29that doesn't approve of Trump's tariffs or just Trump in
- 25:32general, I don't know if they need more time to process and
- 25:35think about things. You know, maybe if you had been
- 25:38talking about how we were being taken advantage of with tariffs
- 25:44before, but, well, you know, maybe if he had talked about
- 25:48these things beforehand, people would have had time to process
- 25:51it and not been so against his tariffs.
- 25:54But at the same time, people who don't like him are not going to
- 25:58listen to him or believe anything he says anyways.
- 26:01So it's almost like he's damned if he does, damned if he
- 26:05doesn't. It doesn't.
- 26:06It doesn't matter what he does, certain people are going to be
- 26:08upset about it. For some people, that's going to
- 26:11be true. I mean, and there's nothing you
- 26:13can do about it. It's called, you know, there's a
- 26:15term in psychology that's called ideological lock and anything
- 26:21that, you know, the on both sides, you know who people who
- 26:26are rigid ideologues will see all evidence that refutes their
- 26:30ideas as confirmation of their ideas, and they will reject any
- 26:35evidence that directly challenges what they believe.
- 26:38So, you know, there's definitely a bias in the way that people
- 26:42think about these characters in politics, I'll say.
- 26:49But if you are able to suspend your ideological beliefs and
- 26:53look at the impact of policy, that's what I would encourage
- 26:58people to do. There is so much information out
- 27:01there, so much data, so much research that you don't have to
- 27:04rely on the mainstream media anymore to look at the truth of
- 27:09what's being said. You can look at it for yourself.
- 27:13And that's what I, you know, want to encourage people to do
- 27:17because a lot of the rhetoric does not match reality when you
- 27:22look at the data and the intended impacts of a policy or
- 27:31a program, a government program. You know, Milton Friedman once
- 27:34said the most permanent thing in life is a temporary government
- 27:38program. And that it's, it's the case
- 27:41because people are not yet attuned to looking at results of
- 27:48government. And I, you know, I've written a
- 27:49whole article about bureaucratic outcomes and how they're
- 27:54self-sustaining to protect people's jobs.
- 27:56And they become incentivized to, to stay alive even when they're
- 28:02not working. And they stay alive to stay
- 28:06alive, not to do any good for the, for the country or, or, or,
- 28:09and they've totally digressed from their original intent, but
- 28:13they keep going on and on and they spend billions and billions
- 28:15of dollars and, and it keeps going.
- 28:18So we do need a way to terminate programs in government.
- 28:26That's by design. Yeah.
- 28:29So since we're kind of on the topic of terminating programs,
- 28:33how do you think DOGE performed? And I know that they're still
- 28:37active, they're just not as as vocal about what they're doing.
- 28:43I think that we've needed something like DOGE for for
- 28:46decades. You know, part of my research
- 28:50area is social welfare programs and what a complete disaster
- 28:54they are because of the the crowd out effects that they
- 28:59have, meaning, you know, social welfare programs generally tend
- 29:03to crowd out other forms of support for people and they
- 29:06destroy the American family and, you know, these are unintended
- 29:11effects. And so I think that looking at
- 29:15government programs is something that's absolutely necessary.
- 29:19And if you know, if the people at DOGE want to look at
- 29:24something like the Government Accountability Annual report, a
- 29:28Government Accountability Office's annual report that has
- 29:31been going on for 15 years in a row and for 15 years in a row it
- 29:35has said the same thing. Government is too big.
- 29:38There are is too much redundancy and too much waste.
- 29:42And so every year during every administration in the past 15
- 29:47years, they cut and paste that recommendation into that report
- 29:51every year. And nobody does anything about
- 29:53it. And, you know, there's billions
- 29:56and billions of dollars, weight of taxpayer dollars wasted
- 30:03without anybody, you know, implementing these
- 30:05recommendations from the nonpartisan GAO.
- 30:09And I think the idea of Joe Doge is something that's well
- 30:14overdue. And I hopefully they find some
- 30:17traction in terms of figuring out how to simplify programs and
- 30:24how to eliminate some. Because the a great government
- 30:27program has in its design, it should have in its design its
- 30:32own termination, which is, yeah, you want to, if you want to end
- 30:37poverty, childhood poverty, you want to end hunger, well then it
- 30:41should. There should be a design that
- 30:43says, hey, you know, we've done it.
- 30:45That's what you want to work towards.
- 30:46Unfortunately, the bureaucratic state in this country, you have
- 30:50the exact opposite. You want it to go on and on.
- 30:53And I've written another article called Managed Crisis, which is
- 30:56exactly that. You cannot live on as a
- 31:00bureaucracy if you don't have a crisis.
- 31:03And the media is partners with government agencies in the
- 31:06bureaucratic state and doing this is manufacturing a crisis,
- 31:11providing a so-called solution to the crisis by saying, hey,
- 31:14this is so simple. Let's just do XY or Z,
- 31:18redistribute more funds, create another program, create another
- 31:21administration, create another agency, and then we'll solve the
- 31:25problem. And then reliably and
- 31:27predictably, when the government program or initiative or
- 31:32redistribution does not work or produces negative effects, what
- 31:37the bureaucratic state, and usually, you know, it's going to
- 31:39be on the left, it says it's not working because we didn't do
- 31:45enough of it. So the logic is completely
- 31:49insane, which is that we weren't doing enough of the failing
- 31:53thing to make a difference. So then what do they do?
- 31:56They ask for more money or they ask for more time.
- 31:59They say their favorite thing to say among, you know, liberal
- 32:04intellectuals and elitists is the favorite thing to say is,
- 32:07oh, it's too complicated. It's it's very complicated, this
- 32:10problem. So This is why it's not working
- 32:12out. But when they were selling the
- 32:15program at the point of implementation, it was not so
- 32:18complicated. It was, hey, this is so easy.
- 32:20All we have to do is do this solution, right?
- 32:24It's a cycle. And if you look, I've written an
- 32:27article about redistribution of cycles to end global poverty and
- 32:30hunger. And even Bono has, you know,
- 32:34implicitly agreed with this. Our efforts around the world for
- 32:39the past 20 to 30 years on ending global poverty and hunger
- 32:44are complete failures. And we keep doing it and we keep
- 32:49doing and you, you, we do these 20 year programs and say at the
- 32:53end of 20 years this is going to be eradicated.
- 32:56Whether it's the UN development goals or whether it's, you know,
- 33:01sustainability or poverty, they all don't end and they all don't
- 33:08get solved. And by the time you get to
- 33:1110/15/20 years, now you have a whole network of agencies,
- 33:18contractors, academics, studying it, distributing it, managing
- 33:26it, ministering it, billions and billions of dollars worth of
- 33:32taxpayer money. A lot.
- 33:33And United States is the biggest contributor to all of these
- 33:36programs. And, you know, they just keep
- 33:40going on and on and on. And it's really a, if it weren't
- 33:44so sad and wasteful, it'd be comical, right?
- 33:48Keep doing this. And so I believe that good
- 33:53government programs should have in their design a way to
- 33:57terminate or at least review themselves to make significant
- 34:02revisions if they're not working.
- 34:05Yeah. Sorry to interrupt, I just
- 34:07wanted to tell you about my. Sponsors real quick.
- 34:12Sometimes I get on a roll cleaning or gardening and I need
- 34:14a boost but don't have time for a meal.
- 34:17Big Fork Brands Pork Jerky is the perfect choice to keep my
- 34:20momentum, offering high protein snacks for on the Products come
- 34:32in a variety of delicious flavors, including Thai green
- 34:35Curry and Maple and brown sugar for the meat options and
- 34:38Gangster and Chicago Fire for the.
- 34:40Sauces. I personally think the original
- 34:42flavor of the pork jerky hits just right after tackling a big
- 34:45chore. It's a little salty and very
- 34:47flavorful. My discount code gives you 20%
- 34:51off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 34:53available. Just visit bigforkbrands.com and
- 34:57enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 35:04Are you looking for a gift for a music lover?
- 35:06Or maybe some apparel to show off your quirky side?
- 35:08Old Glory has you covered. With over 300,000 officially
- 35:12licensed items covering music, sports, entertainment and pop
- 35:15culture, you're guaranteed to find the perfect item.
- 35:18They even have seasonal gear. My husband enjoys The Beatles
- 35:22and Led Zeppelin apparel, and I love the Billy Idol apparel.
- 35:25I even found items for my fellow plant enthusiasts.
- 35:28This family owned superstore is known for their quality and
- 35:31customer service. Offers free standard shipping on
- 35:34all orders and orders are shipped the same day you
- 35:36purchase. My discount code gives you 15%
- 35:40off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 35:42available. Just visit oldglory.com and
- 35:45enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 35:51Looking for a game changing way to improve your health?
- 35:54Zevo Life is the world's most nutrient dense whole plant
- 35:57packed with over 50% plant protein, essential amino acids,
- 36:01fiber and antioxidants. Harnessing the best nature has
- 36:05to offer, Zevo Life nourishes your body while driving your
- 36:08performance, vitality and overall well-being.
- 36:11Each serving is a concentrated source of clean, well balanced
- 36:15nutrition designed to support modern lifestyles.
- 36:18And just one teaspoon a day supports your gut, boosts energy
- 36:21and promotes healthier skin and hair.
- 36:23It's no wonder that it's receiving rave 5 star reviews.
- 36:27Step into a healthier future with a 30% discount and a 30 day
- 36:31risk free guarantee by visiting ZIVO dot Life and using my promo
- 36:37code to support my show and to receive 30% off your entire
- 36:40order and to. My promo code JADE, that's JADE
- 36:44at checkout. I personally think if they don't
- 36:47have the the end goal in their in their plan, they shouldn't
- 36:53even be funded. You know, not only.
- 36:56That, but they should have evidence of meeting their plan
- 37:01goal baked into the program, which they sometimes do.
- 37:05But then what happens is they say, oh, we're going to meet XY
- 37:09and Z metrics. And when they don't, they say,
- 37:11oh, we need more money. Yeah, it's more complicated than
- 37:15we thought it was complicated. Right, right.
- 37:18And we do, we've been doing this dance for decades, ever since
- 37:23social welfare. And the idea of it had has been
- 37:26created in the 50s and 60's, the Great Society.
- 37:30And all this is, it's, it's, it's harmful because it's not
- 37:34only those particular programs that were created that, that,
- 37:38that had negative effects, but it's also this idea of it, you
- 37:43know, that this, this vertical dependency that this idea
- 37:47creates on people. And the idea that, you know,
- 37:53American exceptionalism doesn't exist.
- 37:55And, you know, you talk about American exceptionalism for, for
- 37:59those people who, who don't know what it is, It's the idea that
- 38:03the United States is inherently different from other nations in
- 38:06terms of its progress, in terms of its greatness, its its reach,
- 38:12its success economically and otherwise culturally.
- 38:16And that, you know, it's defined by a common culture and a set of
- 38:23Republican ideals, Republican with a lowercase R, which is
- 38:27liberty, egalitarianism of, of opportunity, individual
- 38:33responsibility and laissez faire economics or market economics.
- 38:39And it, it's sometimes called the American creed.
- 38:42And it's, it's very funny that the people who say that this
- 38:46doesn't exist, that America isn't special, that, you know,
- 38:50these things are not true of America.
- 38:52They are, you know, the same people that are critics of Trump
- 38:58and, you know, don't want to look at the policy impacts of
- 39:04these these this vertical dependency.
- 39:08And they want us to be exceptional in the sense that we
- 39:12give more money. We're supposed to nation build.
- 39:16We're supposed to build other nations up.
- 39:19We're supposed to solve the humanitarian crisis is around
- 39:23the world and poverty and hunger.
- 39:25We're supposed to do this for the whole globe.
- 39:28And the only, ironically, the only way that people can make
- 39:34those assumptions and presumptions about what we
- 39:36should do is the very fact that America is exceptional in terms
- 39:42of, and this is the larger problem in all of our, that
- 39:45that's the thread through everything that we're talking
- 39:47about, which is that the American public, some of the
- 39:50American public has a real hard time loving this country and
- 39:55saying, you know, at least acknowledging the exceptional
- 39:59country that this is in terms of modern politics, but also
- 40:03civilizationally. We no other civilization in the
- 40:07history of humanity has achieved more economically, socially,
- 40:12culturally, and a minuscule amount of time, you know, 250
- 40:17years. That's nothing in terms of
- 40:19civilizational time. And it's so ironic to me that.
- 40:24The same liberals who want to spend billions of dollars to
- 40:27solve these world problems, which are human problems, big
- 40:31existential human problems, they want America to do it and
- 40:36anywhere else in the world, any other country, even in today's
- 40:40world. And you know, you start talking
- 40:43about, hey, why doesn't this country solve all of humanity's
- 40:46existential problems? You'd be laughed at.
- 40:50You can't even imagine it for these other countries, but we
- 40:53can is precisely because the doctrine of American
- 40:56exceptionalism, which they also reject.
- 40:59Yeah, yeah, I, I just don't, I just don't understand why they
- 41:06hate our country so much. I've I have been trying to
- 41:10figure out why this, you know, they say like the woke mind
- 41:15virus, because how else do you describe this mindset that so
- 41:22many people have? I I just don't.
- 41:27You know, it's, it's, I think a combination of of, of impacts,
- 41:32you know, from the dissolution and destruction of the American
- 41:37family. And this is also in my article
- 41:40on the Troy report. You know, it's the most damaging
- 41:45consequence of the liberal status quo is the crowding out
- 41:50effect that social programs and a vertical depend in the
- 41:54vertical meaning on the government dependency on the
- 41:57government has done to private initiatives in terms of taking
- 42:01away money, in terms of breaking down familiar support.
- 42:06Research shows that forever in many countries around the world,
- 42:10not even just the United States, every dollar you, you the
- 42:13government gives out is a dollar that the family doesn't give out
- 42:17in family support networks. It's taken away essentially in
- 42:21the family support network. So you're not, you're not
- 42:24relying on your community, on your churches, on your, you
- 42:28know, neighborhood organizations or your family or extended
- 42:31family anymore, which has been completely destroyed by social
- 42:34welfare programs anyway. You're not relying on them
- 42:36because now you're relying on a vertical dependency with the
- 42:39government and not only the federal government, but local
- 42:43programs, state fund funded programs, all of which are
- 42:47pretty much funded by the federal government and the and,
- 42:49and taxpayer dollars. And so this whole, you know, it,
- 42:55it, the research confirms that as government assistance
- 42:58increases, the informal support networks, families, communities
- 43:03tends to contract. And, you know, real per person
- 43:06government spending has grown 20 fold, 20 fold between 1929 and
- 43:132019. And federal regulatory
- 43:16restrictions have increased something like 160% between 1970
- 43:21and 2020. So that means we're spending
- 43:24more money. The way we're spending it is
- 43:26more complicated. The administrative impact of
- 43:29spending. It is more expensive and the
- 43:32cost of administering is more expensive, particularly with
- 43:34means tested social welfare. And, you know, evidence from
- 43:38across all Western democracies show this.
- 43:42And you know, it's it's it's really, you know, if you think
- 43:48about it in broader human terms, this is this idea of a vertical
- 43:53dependency mindset, which the woke, you know, mind virus is a
- 43:58part of or, or the other way around.
- 44:00But the dynamic explains this persistent happiness gap in
- 44:05American life. No, I know it's very funny that
- 44:09there have been, you know, non partisan psychological studies
- 44:12on this. And evidence consistently
- 44:14indicates that conservatives are generally happier than liberals,
- 44:19not only with their country but with themselves.
- 44:22And, you know, it's so ironic that in the media, mainstream
- 44:27media, you see, you know, people talk about happiness.
- 44:30You see Arthur Brooks, you see Oprah Winfrey, you see, you
- 44:34know, other, other social media influencers talking about, you
- 44:39know, how are how do people lead happier lives?
- 44:43And you know, it's across the board the same thing.
- 44:47It's faith, it's family and friends, right?
- 44:51So when you think about, you know, how to achieve happiness
- 44:54and all the research that, you know, mainstream media likes to
- 44:57talk about it. When you start talking about
- 45:00marriage, religion, or, you know, community, it's like code
- 45:07word for MAGA. It's like they, they want to put
- 45:10you into that box and say anytime you talk about marriage,
- 45:15your religion or you know, community networks, you're,
- 45:19you're a person from MAGA. It's it's like when we know the
- 45:22research show that these are actually the only things that
- 45:26make people happy. So the idea that the liberal is
- 45:30unhappy with America, it tracks because you know, of, you know,
- 45:36you're just there and you're thinking about oh, how much
- 45:39racism, how much misogyny, how much homophobia, homophobia this
- 45:44and it's that took of all that. Is.
- 45:47And isms. And that's how you're living
- 45:49your life without faith, without family, without support
- 45:53networks. And that's a real problem for
- 45:56for people in general, but also particularly on the left.
- 45:59And, you know, I think we need to start having a real
- 46:04conversation about how to reintegrate those things back
- 46:08into our lives. Doesn't have to be religion.
- 46:10It could be other things, but some type of, you know, faith,
- 46:14some type of, you know, policies that encourage the family.
- 46:21You know, for many years from the 60s through the 70s, we saw
- 46:26social welfare programs that penalized families with head of
- 46:30households. So, and specifically earlier in
- 46:33that we had policies that specifically said if you have a
- 46:37man in the household, your, your benefits are going to get
- 46:40reduced. And that that that has a very
- 46:44long tail, particularly in black families.
- 46:46And there's been research done on this about those particular
- 46:49programs and the destruction of the back black family, which was
- 46:53highly, highly successful and intact before those programs
- 46:57began. And the number of two parent
- 46:59black families was exponentially increasing since the time of
- 47:04slavery until those programs were enacted.
- 47:08And you started incentivizing, destroying those two parent
- 47:11families. And that's true.
- 47:13And, you know, economic life as well.
- 47:15You see negative economic effects from these.
- 47:18And I'm not saying that, you know, I'm not a crazy person to
- 47:21say that all social welfare programs are negative
- 47:26monolithically, but we all, you know, any time that I question
- 47:31some of the impacts of these programs, people call me a crazy
- 47:34person. And I say, you know, there's
- 47:36going to be good and bad in any policy.
- 47:40And we have to be able to talk about what's good and bad
- 47:44through objective reality, not through, you know, labels and
- 47:49ideological craziness, but to look at the empirical facts.
- 47:53And, you know, the net, the net net of most social programs, is
- 48:01that it's more harmful to the overall production of value in
- 48:06this country than it is helpful. And I think, you know, we have
- 48:10to be able to talk about these things reasonably in order to
- 48:13make them better. Yeah, yes.
- 48:16So while, while you were describing this, it was just
- 48:18kind of making me think about the leftist protesters and those
- 48:24wanting to fight against the right or, you know, labeling, I
- 48:29mean, good positive things as mega or Republican.
- 48:32And it just makes me think that these people are so unhappy.
- 48:36But instead of looking at themselves and their own life
- 48:40decisions and what they're doing, instead they're they're
- 48:43finding who someone to point the finger at.
- 48:46Like, I'm unhappy because of you and what you're doing.
- 48:48I don't even know you. You know, it's they've got to
- 48:53find somebody. What's that?
- 48:54It goes so deep. Yeah, yeah.
- 48:57And, you know, I am a, I'm a, I'm happy to say I'm a
- 49:01therapized person. So we know that these kinds of
- 49:05existential issues, they come from, you know, inside and
- 49:09people have to, you know, the mental health has been on the
- 49:13decline in this country for far too long for a number of
- 49:17reasons, vertical dependency being one of them, in my
- 49:19opinion. But you know, self reflection is
- 49:24a key part of not only making ourselves accountable for our
- 49:29decisions in life, but also holding policy makers and
- 49:33leaders in this country accountable for what they're
- 49:36doing. And if you're so busy being mad
- 49:40at people on the other side of your or people you disagree
- 49:44with, you know, you're not looking at the people who can
- 49:48make change and holding them accountable.
- 49:51You know, and this is one of the biggest structural problem
- 49:56problems in American Society. That doesn't have to be the
- 50:00case, which is that politicians and policy makers are completely
- 50:07detached from and disconnected from the policies they
- 50:10implement. And no matter how much
- 50:12destruction and havoc they cause.
- 50:14And we need to find a way to make policy makers directly
- 50:18accountable for their ideas and for the damage that they do.
- 50:22Otherwise, you know, we're going to continue to spend 10s of
- 50:26billions, hundreds of billions of dollars on these programs
- 50:29that policy makers, you know, introduce fund.
- 50:34And you know, as I, as I was describing earlier, they'll
- 50:37continue on because they, they're, they become
- 50:40bureaucracies that, you know, self sustain without looking at
- 50:46the potentially negative impacts that they're causing and how to
- 50:51make them better. And so in order to make that
- 50:54happen, one of the ways we can do that is to hold policy makers
- 50:58directly accountable for their policies in some way.
- 51:02Do I have, do I know specifically what program, what
- 51:05policy, what law needs to be passed?
- 51:07No, that it's a starting place to recognize that you know, not
- 51:12only do you need self terminating programs, but you
- 51:15need a tie to the outcomes of these policies and their ideas.
- 51:20Right. This actually provides the
- 51:22perfect segue because I wanted to talk to you a bit about
- 51:25immigration before we wrap it up.
- 51:29And it was making me think about the judges who are for well,
- 51:33First off, the court systems, jails, whatever, and judges
- 51:37letting illegal immigrants back out into the streets after
- 51:41committing a crime instead of deporting them, handing them
- 51:45over to ICE. And, and in some cases, not even
- 51:48illegal immigrants, you know, where people have been arrested,
- 51:53you know, 1525 times let back out onto the streets and then to
- 51:58then go set someone on fire, you know, just terrible, terrible
- 52:02actions. It's, it's a real shame and it's
- 52:05a real danger. And this is a great full circle
- 52:09moment in the sense that, you know, what I wish people would
- 52:12do on this issue of immigration is to really think about is
- 52:16what's being said true and what is it compared to?
- 52:20Because if you look at the narrative being constructed in
- 52:24the mainstream media about immigrants, for example, a study
- 52:28was released or, and and then, you know, reposted and
- 52:32circulated in the news cycle about how only 13 to 14% of
- 52:36immigrants are violent offenders, you know, in this
- 52:40country. And, and that, you know, the
- 52:42rest are not violent offenders is essentially the news cycle.
- 52:48But all of the, as I was saying earlier, all of the same data is
- 52:51available to people who want to look into it.
- 52:54And it's true that 13 to 14, I forget specifically which one of
- 52:57it was, there was some number around that of violent offenders
- 53:02are immigrants are violent offenders.
- 53:05But if you look at the whole study, in that same study, you
- 53:08will see that 71% of immigrants have either committed some type
- 53:15of crime and been adjudicated as such that they're convicted as,
- 53:20you know, criminals, or they have some type of immigration
- 53:24violation. So they're not following the
- 53:25rules. They're not following the rules
- 53:27for immigration. So that's the vast majority of
- 53:30the, of the immigrants in this country that we're talking about
- 53:34or that, you know, ICE is looking at as an agency.
- 53:38So that's number one, the the rhetoric around it does not
- 53:41match reality. We do have a problem of, you
- 53:47know, segments of large segments of the immigrant population,
- 53:51They're not following the law and they're not following the
- 53:54procedures to get here legally like every other immigrant who
- 53:58has went through that process legally for decades and have
- 54:02become, you know, major successes in in, in life and in
- 54:06technology. And, you know, a lot of them are
- 54:08a lot of the billionaires are, are immigrants, right?
- 54:11So we know that. We know that immigration can be
- 54:16a tremendous economic value and innovator for the American
- 54:21economy. But at the same time, not all
- 54:26immigration is good immigration. And this idea on the left that
- 54:31America's border is something to be overcome, some obstacle for
- 54:36immigrants to be overcome, is ridiculous.
- 54:39As Mark Gregorian of the Center for Immigration Studies have
- 54:43said, America's border is not an obstacle to be overcome, but
- 54:48instead it's a critical tool for protecting America's national
- 54:52interests. And you know, I understand the
- 54:56human desire, what I call Stage 1 thinking, to focus on the
- 55:01immediate visible satisfaction of helping immigrants or the
- 55:06tired, etcetera, etcetera, come into this country.
- 55:10But in doing only that, looking at only that aspect of it
- 55:13through that lens, we are ignoring the Stage 2
- 55:15consequences, which are the long term structural effects that
- 55:19unfold over the next decade or decades that have a deleterious
- 55:25effect on communities across this country and is a strain on,
- 55:32you know, the government's resources as well as, you know,
- 55:35society's resources in this country.
- 55:38And we see this in Germany, We see this in Poland, we see this
- 55:42in New Zealand. We there a lot of these
- 55:44countries are at a breaking point because of unmitigated
- 55:49immigration. And you know, Poland has done
- 55:51something great in terms of being very transparent about
- 55:54their immigration. And I think we need to move
- 55:56closer to that and say not all immigration is good immigration.
- 56:00We want real human capital to immigrate to this country,
- 56:05people who are great at STEM, people who are innovators,
- 56:08people who are great students, or at the very least people who
- 56:11will follow the law and, you know, not violate it from the
- 56:15beginning. And so, you know, we are not a,
- 56:20we are not an entitlement getting into America being
- 56:25American. It's not an entitlement.
- 56:27We are a country. We have rules, we have borders.
- 56:32You know, our borders are not kind of more morally arbitrary,
- 56:38You know, they, they, they're a function of our self government
- 56:41of our, you know, defined culture as Americans, which the
- 56:46girls tend not to like, but we are all Americans.
- 56:51You know, even if you hate America, you get to hate America
- 56:55because we're. American.
- 56:58And, you know, our the distinctiveness and the
- 57:01exceptionalism of our culture and country depends on closing
- 57:06the borders to some. And, you know, open borders
- 57:11cannot be conceived of as a stable feature of, you know,
- 57:15international life. Immigration is not an inherent
- 57:19right for the immigrant. It's a privilege that any
- 57:23nation, including the United States, grants as the host and
- 57:28why we should be accepted from that.
- 57:32You know that idea I I don't know.
- 57:35Because we are a nation just like any we get to protect our
- 57:39borders. We have national interests, we
- 57:41have our own defined culture and immigration control is not anti
- 57:47immigrant. It's just not.
- 57:50Right. Yeah.
- 57:51It's, it's just it's been interesting, you know, in in
- 57:55talking to legal immigrants, They, they feel the same way.
- 58:00And they actually are great patriots, a lot of them, because
- 58:05they've they've put in the work. They understand what this
- 58:09country can provide and in. Yeah, it's just.
- 58:14It's a fundamental reaction of, and I speak to, you know, I have
- 58:19immigrants of my family and my mother and father were
- 58:21immigrants even though they lived in the United States, but
- 58:23longer than they did in any other country.
- 58:24But, you know, it's a fundamental reaction of
- 58:28unfairness. It's hey, I did all of the work
- 58:31that it takes to become AUS citizen.
- 58:34I followed the rules. I started a business, you know,
- 58:37and I'm living the American dream and, and all of that.
- 58:41And, you know, I didn't just come here expecting to be given
- 58:45things and thinking that citizenship was an entitlement
- 58:49because I crossed the border. And of course, there's a
- 58:52reaction by immigrants to immigrants who are are not doing
- 58:57it that way. And I completely sympathize with
- 58:59them. And, you know, history tells us
- 59:02the story that the, the success of immigration is tied to the
- 59:08transfer of specialized human capital, technical skills, work
- 59:13ethic, whether it's Jews, Chinese, Italians, they're
- 59:18bringing skills, Germans. And you look at the their
- 59:21migrations all over the world, These immigrants bring
- 59:26specialized skills, work ethic, and also commercial networks.
- 59:30You know, you know, you can find this on the Troy report.
- 59:33There's vast diasporas of immigrants.
- 59:37We, we would, we would love to have more of, of these folks in
- 59:41the modern world coming into our country.
- 59:43So I am immigration friendly, but I'm not.
- 59:47But immigration has to be controlled and be and having
- 59:50controlled borders is not anti immigrant.
- 59:53It's a foundational act of national self-defense and
- 59:58American integrity. Yeah, Yep.
- 1:00:02All right, I've. I feel like there's so much more
- 1:00:06that I can talk to you about. And so I I do hope that you will
- 1:00:10come back again. And yeah, I have so much more to
- 1:00:15say. But but for now, is there
- 1:00:17anything else you'd like the audience to know?
- 1:00:20No, I just to reiterate, you know, try to always ask, is what
- 1:00:26you're hearing really true and what is it compared to?
- 1:00:31And we do a lot of that kind of analysis every week at the Troy
- 1:00:35Report. You can go read it at the
- 1:00:37troyreport.com. We'll set merch, very high
- 1:00:40quality merch, you know, very high athletic wear textures.
- 1:00:47I, I highly recommend it. But you know, most importantly,
- 1:00:50you're going to learn something if you go to troyreport.com, I
- 1:00:53promise you. Nice.
- 1:00:55I'm going to check out some of some of the athletic wear.
- 1:01:00Perfect. Thank you.
- 1:01:01So. Much Sam, it was a pleasure
- 1:01:02being with you. I appreciate your time and
- 1:01:05willingness to hear me out. Right, yes, right back at you.
- 1:01:09I feel like I learned, learned a lot throughout this.
- 1:01:13And it's always nice to to hear, yeah, hear things from people
- 1:01:19with different backgrounds and everything.
- 1:01:20So some one of these days, I want to, I want to hear about
- 1:01:24your time with, with the CIA. Absolutely.
- 1:01:26To the extent I can say. Right, right.
- 1:01:31Sounds good. All right, have a great rest of
- 1:01:33the week. Yes, you too.
- 1:01:35I'll talk to you soon. Bye, bye.
- 1:01:36Bye. Bye.