Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 23 - The Customer Is Always Right and 14 Other Supply Chain Myths. Tell Us Where We're Wrong
Transcript
- Keith: Welcome to Under the Pallet Wrap Episode 23. Not the one we expected to do. We sadly had a guest pull out. So we're doing an impromptu episode today. 15 supply chain myths. We're going to be doing some myth busting. is there any truth in them or can they be picked apart? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, Showing our true supply chain colors today. We're being adaptive, resilient. We've taken the crisis of our guests not being able to get here and we've pivoted. And so we're just going to go with this and see what happens. So, let's crack on. Keith: what's the first myth, Dan? Dan Culverhouse: Myth number one is the customer is always right. Keith: Mmm. Dan Culverhouse: What's your view? Keith: I would say No, they're not They're not right, but you must You must treat all Dan Culverhouse: can you say that? Keith: feedback as yeah take all feedback As extremely important you have to make the customer feel they're right Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think it's important to say, I would agree, the customer is clearly not always right, but I think it's a good idea to do everything you can to leave them in that place that they do think they're right as much as possible. sometimes customers just ask for the ridiculous, right? And the unreasonable, and I don't think they should get it. Keith: When do you start saying no to the customer? When do you think saying yes creates a bit of damage? Dan Culverhouse: Well, I guess there's an assessment that you would need to do. And I accept that it's an assessment you need to do in the moment. But it's kind of like, well, who's messed up first? mean, you know, if we've messed up, then we should correct it and we should do everything we can. But they then say, well, you can correct it, but I want it for free and I want six months, you know, for free or. and all these things, and then I think it becomes that if you ever get the sense that I think the customer is trying to. capitalize on the situation, shall we say. But when you get to a point where you kind of think, right, this customer is now really trying to manipulate and make the most of a scenario, I think you're within your rights to say no. And if you lose that customer because of it, okay, so be it. Because if they're gonna be a customer that's constantly trying to get something for nothing, then actually, are they valuable? It's a dangerous game. But you do have to accept in this world of social media that you may have to start protecting your reputation online against somebody. But for me, the customer is not always right, but you should do everything you can to make them believe that they are. What about you? Keith: Yep, yeah I think it's just a case of monitoring things and making decisions based on when a customer request is not benefiting the most of your customers or the rest of your business. What's the most ridiculous request you've heard of in your time? I've worked in luxury and there's been some very small time constraints before that must deliver an item on a specific day otherwise they won't purchase it but I understand that it's because they're traveling they're traveling around you can see it as ridiculous or you can see it as going the extra mile that's the way the way I see it Dan Culverhouse: But there's ways and means of asking for it as well. It's just kind of like you just expect it and it's not a... But if you go to a, you know, if you're trying to buy something and you need something very specific and specific timing, et cetera, I think if you level with the supplier or whoever it is, I think most companies will do everything they can to do that. But if you're just like... I want this, I want it by then, can you do it or not? You're not really feeling the of, the warmth or there's any kind of, like you said, they're asking you for a favor, but they're not even saying please. And I always get this sense that if somebody comes to me with a challenge, I wanna try and fix it before. I wanna try and help them. But if they just come with an expectation of, I know it says 48 hour delivery, I want it this afternoon and I don't want to pay any more. I must admit I would feel less inclined to want to try to fix their problem for them. Keith: I think it's always about leading the way and being the better person and moving forward with a solution. When it starts being damaging we draw the line which brings me to the point of one of the things you can do to keep the customer happy is to always have products in stock. another myth. More stock means better availability. What's your view on that Dan Culverhouse: Almost inevitably not. Keith: Fact or myth? Dan Culverhouse: I think the more stock you have, because you can't have lots of everything because you'll go out of business, because your cash, you'll run out of money. But if your warehouse is full of product, the chances are it's full of product that you don't actually want because the things you have lots of are the things that aren't selling. And therefore you run out of space for having to put the things that you do sell in stock. So I think, you know, just simply saying, we just need to carry three months of everything. You need to be quite a special business to be able to handle that level of stock and think you can keep your entire range in. Keith: It couldn't be a fashion business. You can't have last season's products. Brilliant in way, huh? Dan Culverhouse: Well, I think that's it again, isn't it? So you can you can fill your warehouse up and say, right, at beginning of the season, I think we're going to sell, you know, across my 50 products, we're going to sell a million units. So I'm to get a million of all together collectively. And I've got it in a warehouse and then I can have perfect, perfect availability. Great for that season. But the end of that season, you still got half of it left. You can't do it again for the next season. And then what are you going to do with the old season stock? So, you know, just thinking that having lots of stock solves your problem is a very naive perspective. Keith: It doesn't necessarily mean you won't have stuck outs just because you've got enough of everything. Not if one thing sells more than the rest. No point having all the other stuff and nowhere to put it. So myth! Dan Culverhouse: The day somebody knows the exact fulfillment rates of every product they sell, well, you're bordering on genius, I think, because the reality is you make a prediction, you're almost indefinitely going to be wrong. You just don't know by how much. So active inventory is what you need. Keith: You call it genius, I call it guesswork. Smash that myth. Dan Culverhouse: Ha ha ha ha. Keith: That's a myth. Myth three. Automation automatically makes operations more efficient. We talked about this before. My view, you automate a broken process. You just simply amplify it to be even more broken. Bigger and broken. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I can say, you know, I've always had this mantra, and obviously this is something I've done a lot of in my career, and you know, don't automate a mess, because automating a mess just makes a bigger mess. Automation will accentuate the problem, not cover it up. And I think it's, you to think that if your operation is busy, busy, busy, and it's confusing, and it's chaotic, you think, If I got a machine and I put some machinery in and automation, it would just drive it through. It doesn't. It really doesn't. You really need to understand your business and understand your processes before you ever consider mechanising or automating. Keith: Just make mistakes happen quicker or you can't get to them. That's the other thing. You cannot get to them. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and there's a real risk here, When you start to go down the road of like, want to automate, I want to involve some robotics or something, it's very cool stuff, right? And there's always this risk of kids in the sweet shop scenario where you just want a bit of everything. And I always, I'll never forget, I went to an operation in Denmark for a retailer out there. We were doing some promotional volume through this retailer. And they have this incredibly complex automated warehouse. It's quite new. And they walked us around and it's like amazing. Everything was automated and it was so restrictive. You could only do things in a very particular way. It was destroying them. know, so they had been growing, so they automate the warehouse in their view to get more capacity and accuracy through it. And what it did is it just turned them into a completely inflexible one process that they could handle. And anything that sat outside of that ended up costing them a fortune because they had to manipulate it. And literally they asked us to open a separate warehouse just to do these promotional products. It was insane. But that is the perfect example of somebody automating something because they think it's just going to solve the problem rather than solve the problem and then automate the optimized solution. Keith: So I'm not anti-automation at all. I'm very pro-automation, but I'm anti-automating processes that have not been examined thoroughly first. Dan Culverhouse: Number four. Keith: Yes, so we've got a similar trap but a different area. The cheapest supplier delivers the lowest cost. We've all been there. Is this a myth? most of the time the cheapest supplier in my view especially around 3pl costs and the rest of it they're sacrificing something to to cost so so little all those hidden costs built into the contract based Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: on on performance or other things or they haven't examined your business case near close enough to understand the complexity of it and they've completely neglected to include these costs. then they can refuse to actually carry out tasks without some sort of huge argument taking place further down the line. Dan Culverhouse: I think with this reality is the devil's in the detail, right? Because you can, it could well be that the cheapest supplier is also the best, right? But you've got to do the homework as to, know, if your criteria for making a decision is they're the cheapest, you can almost inevitably say that they probably are not gonna deliver you the best service. But. If you have a proper in-depth criteria that you're going through that is service-orientated, flexibility, systems integration, coverage, future upgrades, manning it correctly, if you have a nuanced and wide-ranging criteria and the cheapest one comes out strongest in that criteria, then they probably Keith: Oof. Dan Culverhouse: will be the best, but. You you can't just say, right, whoever comes in is the cheapest we're going to go with because... Keith: yeah, you have to put it to the tender and you have to know. You have to have evidence of this and you have to be satisfied before you go with the cheapest. I have seen many examples of people going with the cheapest. Dan Culverhouse: You need to interrogate. Keith: What's happened? More complaints, more admin, more fixes. So it ends up being much more expensive from a resource perspective, acquisition perspective, going down the line. The same can apply. We're not even talking about free PLs. paper suppliers, the same thing. You buy the cheapest Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, anything. Keith: and then you find out it's not fit for purpose. It's the same level of detail. You have to assess what is right. Dan Culverhouse: you should always look at the cheapest with a little bit of cynicism and how, you know, why is it, particularly if it's significantly cheap. Keith: Certainly if there's something you think should be on there and it isn't, never assume that it's because they just don't charge for it. raise it. Honesty is always the best relationship anyway. Ask the question, why is there no customer service or management fees, for example? It's not because they don't have them. It's because you didn't Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and this is quite, Keith: ask them. Dan Culverhouse: If you've got a true partner, a partner Keith: when you multiply it by... Dan Culverhouse: who's invested in your success and not just in their own, then it's likely to be a worthwhile investment. mean, obviously, if it's double what the other one is, you're going to need to ask some questions. yeah, you know, let's be honest, it's never really that far out. But there's always value in Keith: Okay. Dan Culverhouse: finding the right partner, even if it costs you a little bit more, because in the long run, it will probably cost you less. Keith: We're moving from the tender inside the warehouse now. So myth five. A busy warehouse is a productive warehouse. A chaotic warehouse certainly isn't productive. You Dan Culverhouse: You Keith: can have as many people as you like walking around seemingly busy, all doing something. It doesn't mean they're productive at all. It's just activity is very easy to see. Have you ever been at a warehouse where... Someone visits and suddenly everyone's doing something. There was a story once about someone steaming a t-shirt once for about 20 minutes, but I picked up and, why are you steaming that t-shirt? And I need Dan Culverhouse: Kill. Keith: to find it was put into a rack and creased about a minute after it's finished with. So yeah, when you get visitors in, you always get the people who are, I'm gonna move up and down. going to get in the forklift, they're going to start packing empty boxes, but yeah it's easy to see someone who's not geared up on it. They might not take a walk around the warehouse and ask people what they're doing, they might just take a glance out the mezzanine over the mezzanine rail and say look everyone's really busy but I think we both know a busy warehouse could be one of the least productive. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Well, normally that I would, you know, almost I guess there's a there's a difference between it just being busy, but being a well-oiled machine. and you know, I think if it's chaotic, you can be almost, almost assured that it is not productive. If it's busy, but a well-oiled machine where every people, everyone seems to know exactly what they're doing. and is focused on getting on with it, then it probably is. But that's always the call, the key difference. I've walked people around warehouses, which I know were pretty busy, but are well controlled and people are going like, it's like there's nothing going on, you guys got nothing to do. it's like, no, we're doing a million units today. You know, but. it just moves, it's smooth, and it's a process and it's controlled. And I also Keith: I I'm... Dan Culverhouse: think you have leaders that hide behind chaos. They like their operations to be in chaos because it's almost like, we talked about Keith: They're the hero and saviour. Dan Culverhouse: it before, they're the hero, they're always pulling it Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: out the bag. Whereas the reality is, it's just because they're not organized and they're not structured. If you put a structure in, it would happen. and it wouldn't be chaos. And yeah, I've definitely experienced that a few times. Keith: Yeah, the leader doesn't quite understand that they would benefit more from elevating their team and having a well-run operation. I see that all the time. I think there's a correlation between how organized or clean a warehouse is. Now even if you're pushed for space, having a system or process in place where everything is organized and you can see everything is going to be way more productive than somewhere where you've got the inbound area absolutely chock-a-block. I remember seeing a returns area that was absolutely... I mean it was... you've never seen so many books in your life and the question I had was what's happened? Obviously something's happened. So I said what's happened? we decided to do away with the RMA number. Okay, I see the result of this action. Dan Culverhouse: Maybe we should put it back. You can see this when you walk in, as you say, if there's crap all over the floor. It's not just they're having a busy day. They don't have a good mindset of clearing up as they go because it doesn't take longer. It just makes the place operate better when it's tidy. And yeah, it is. So I think. Keith: The biggest waste. When you ask someone, yeah, pass me the broom five minutes later, you can see them the other side of the warehouse asking someone for the broom. They are not the most productive warehouse, clearly, because they're doing that 10 to 15 times a day for multiple tasks up and down the chain. So busy warehouses can be productive is the truth of that myth. it's not a fact. Dan Culverhouse: it's not a given that one Keith: No. Dan Culverhouse: follows the other. Keith: the next myth just in time means carrying no inventory. Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely not. It can mean that. I've worked in fresh food operations Keith: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: that everything comes in the morning and everything goes out at night. But actually most just-in-time warehouses, they just balance what comes in and what goes out. There's quite often a nucleus of protection, shall we call it. So what comes in today isn't necessarily what goes out today, but at the end of each day, you've pretty much got the same stock that you started with and therefore you have the flow. But that doesn't mean you don't have a contingency in there because let's be honest, you can't rely on customers to order the same stuff every week, every day. So you always know what your demand is. You do need some flexibility and a just-in-time warehouse with no stock is lean. but it is not agile. So if you know you're gonna sell a thousand every day, order a thousand, distribute a thousand, you don't need to keep any in stock. But if it might be one day 1100 or the next day 900, you need a nucleus to cover that. Keith: You need the controls from beginning to end in order to be lean and agile. You need the controls to be tight from beginning to end otherwise it relies on luck. And any disaster Dan Culverhouse: The reality is that... Keith: that happens anywhere else down the chain you don't know whether we're going to have a weather event. or Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: the transport infrastructure is affected. Dan Culverhouse: I mean, with short life Keith: you need controls. Dan Culverhouse: product, with short life product, the reality is you may order 5,000, your demand may well be 5,000. In fact, it's normally on a very short lead time of ordering. So you do order exactly what the demand is. But you know what? The supplier can't always bring 5,000. Sometimes they might bring 4,800 because that's all they had. Or they might find that they did bring 5,000, but 200 of them were damaged, so you can't shift them. and you just have to apportion it with fresh food and things like that, you accept the availability challenge and you just split that availability issue across a lot of stores, so it's very minor across each individual store. But on a truly stockless environment, the reality is you can't have perfect availability. So that's the trade off that you make. But if you've only got a product that's got three days life, so it's like a lettuce or something, you can't really hold it in stock. But you accept, some days you'll Keith: Do you think businesses... Dan Culverhouse: have more than others. Keith: Do think businesses misunderstand the concept of lean? They mistake it for cheap. Dan Culverhouse: Well, think they, yes. Well, for cheap and for what I would say also it's cost effective. Well, it is when nothing changes. when, Keith: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: as soon as you, as soon as you have external events that impact it, lean can undo itself very quickly, which is why, you know, having a lean mentality is good. Keith: wipe out any saving you've made. Dan Culverhouse: lean is so effective when it's absolutely predictable. But when it's not, you have to balance lean with agile. And otherwise you're going to disappoint people a lot. Keith: So in order to be lean, a lot of people rely on forecasts, which leads us to another myth. Dan Culverhouse: Keep moving forwards. Keith: If we forecast accurately enough, supply chain problems disappear. Forecasting! it's the Bane! Dan Culverhouse: 100 % agree with this. think if forecasting could tell us exactly what we're to have to do every day, my life would have always been so much easier. I don't think that's a myth. I think it's absolutely true. Keith: I think we've got to remember that forecasts are only estimates. Even if you Dan Culverhouse: next. Keith: can forecast at one part of the supply chain accurately, you can never 100 % forecast every element. Sales, sickness, delays. Dan Culverhouse: life would be so easy if it could then, right? Wouldn't it be great if that actually was true? Keith: if that was absolutely true. If someone cracks that, then I mean, Dan Culverhouse: We'll all be out of job. Keith: yeah, well, to a large degree, I mean, it is always going to be one of the biggest pain points in supply chain, forecast accuracy, which is why it's not to be all an end all to me. Yes, it's very important. You have to base your numbers on something. it comes down to when someone's questions the business could questions supply chain. What happened? Where all these costs from? Well, we just followed the forecast. It's not necessarily, it's not good enough. If you put all your eggs in one basket. Dan Culverhouse: Not a good enough answer. I would just like to be very clear. It's definitely a good thing to get an accurate forecast, but there are a number of things that sit around that. The unexpected, you can forecast all Keith: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: you like, but if your supplier can't deliver, then you've got to deal with it. You you can forecast all you like. But you can't, you know, if you have a manpower issue, it doesn't matter that you got exactly the orders you expected, you've still got a problem. So it's not gonna get rid of your problems. it is a good thing. Yeah. And Keith: But it's how you react to those problems which makes you an efficient operation. Dan Culverhouse: if you become too reliant on your forecast being accurate and therefore you only set your business up to be able to handle that amount of work, any deviation and you're screwed. So, you you kind of lull yourself into a false sense of security that will, you know, let's be, let's get, get real. We'll bite you on the ass sooner or later. Keith: I can go both ways as well though can't it? It can be not enough people too many people can veer both ways quite dramatically unexpected influxes in sales and you can't fulfill them that's one of the the Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: biggest issues mean you marketing sales have done Dan Culverhouse: Adverse weather, industrial yet. Keith: all that work and then Ops cannot fulfill Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and this is the fun of supply chain, right? You know, I think the reason people get really into supply chain management, logistics leadership is because of this, because you need to be able to respond. You need to be able to deal with whatever is put in front of you. And my God, does it feel good when you get it right and you get over that line and you fix the, you know, despite all that, you've managed to turn it around. You've been that supply chain hero for the day. As long as you don't have to do it every day, because then you got a bigger problem. But that's why we do the job, right? Because we want to be able to solve problems. I think the next one is a funny one to go move on to from the last one. So given that we talk about forecasting and so outsourcing logistics means you outsourcing all your problems. So it doesn't matter if your forecast is not accurate. If you outsource it, it's not your problem, right? Keith: I've been asked to unpick many 3PL issues in the past but mainly what's going on? You know I've been asked before Where are our products for launch? not just the first day, the first minute of the first day So I was like, okay, well, maybe I know where to start. And that is to find out for myself. So yeah, of course, straight to the 3PL. Where is the communication here? You can, I think people forget, but you can outsource logistics, but you still have to manage that account extremely closely. You still have to ensure that your KPIs are met. There's pros and cons, that's another episode. pros and cons of outsourcing versus in-house. But Dan Culverhouse: Yeah? Yeah. Keith: to just assume it's not your problem. I mean, I've been so many places where people think it's out of sight, out of mind. They can't understand it. Dan Culverhouse: It's interesting that you kind of think, I can't manage this operation. It's too complex. It's causing too much mess. The forecasting is so terrible. So I'm going to give it to somebody else to do because they won't have that problem. And why would they not have that problem? I don't care if you're the best operation in the world. If your forecast is awful, unless you're willing to pay an absolute fortune for it and they can have all the backup that they need, know, sit and waiting just in case, which is obviously not real. And outsourced operation is still an operation that has to work on the information that you provide it. And if you provide it with crap, guess what? It'll end up being crap. Keith: I think it's easier than ever to outsource your operation now. There's a lot of fulfillment centers that help startups specifically. And I'm all for them if they're stopping the founder, stopping the person do the business. They should be focused on marketing, building the business, not packing boxes in their living room. And I 100 % see that that's improved over the years. Dan Culverhouse: But I think what's also Keith: The bridge. Dan Culverhouse: improved, Keith, is that the 3PLs are better at being clear about what you need to do for us to be Keith: Yes. Dan Culverhouse: successful. You know, rather than just say, yeah, we'll take it on and we'll just charge you all the exceptions. I think 3PLs have got much better at going, yeah, we can do all this for you. This is what it costs. And here's the model that you need to work within. You need to be able to manage this. You manage this, you provide us with that. We've got it for you. But if can't give us that. then you can't expect this to perform. Keith: Absolutely. Your onboarding is very important. Also, bring someone in to help you select the right partner to help build your data set, to help build the operational flows. Understand the trade-offs as well because, you know, if you don't own the flow, especially things like the customer service, the carrier management flow. You have to be mindful that's an additional step. You have to understand your universe. It's not just, it's not like for like. You don't own the same things. You don't have the same level of contact with the carriers necessarily. If you move to a fulfillment center that manages that type of thing. understanding how much certain things mean to you before you trade them off. know, you make it very, very clear when picking the partner you have. Dan Culverhouse: I think again, it's outsourcing is not abdication, right? You're not abdicating the responsibility. You're just taking part of the operation and giving it to somebody else to run for you. But what Keith: You're still managing it, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: you have to feed into it and how you manage it will determine how successful it is. You know, they can't run your business from the outside if you don't give them what they need. yeah, yeah. Keith: Yeah, you can't forget about them. They have to be your partner. So the next myth. because it follows on nicely. Everyone thinks that if something comes up on a dashboard looking great, then it's no worry. But technology will give us complete supply chain visibility. We talked about what you put in. If you don't put it in, you won't get it out. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, our IT friends like to say, crap in, crap out. Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: You can have the most beautiful looking dashboards, but if the source of that data or you haven't actually got a single source of information for a certain aspect of your data, it's not worth the screen that you've got it displayed on. So yeah, you know, I think what's really important about technology is it's clear source. where you're getting the data from, there's a clear process for that to be calculated. Everybody understands how it's calculated. So the data that gets shown on that screen is not just a magic number that means everything's okay, that you understand how you've got to that. And there is only one way of calculating it. And the business all runs off the same data. So many, and particularly Keith: the Dan Culverhouse: grown businesses run on non-integrated systems where there's two product files or there's two stock files and, know, depending, know, supply chain have one, but commercial have another one and maybe finance have another one again. And those don't know how sexy your dashboard is. If that's the scenario behind it, it's not telling you anything useful unless you have a dashboard to tell Keith: Yeah, absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: you how many versions of the truth you have, maybe. Keith: Yeah, you have to be able to make decisions based on the data. And we've all sat in meetings before where everyone's going over data. But nothing happens. You leave the meeting. The same thing happens the next week. You look at the same numbers. I've always wanted to interrogate those numbers. What are we meeting for? What do we want to achieve as a business? And what are the numbers telling us? You know, there's no point going in and all our orders are being shipped on time. been processed on time when you're not addressing the fact that they might not be arriving on time to the customer. What does the data mean? What's it actually informing you? So for sure. Dan Culverhouse: what you'll find of course is you end up just fighting about whether the data's right or not, rather than what does this mean? if you've got, yeah, Keith: Yeah. What can we do? Dan Culverhouse: fulfillment shows at 85%, so everyone's going nuts, but the warehouse operations going, every order we've got, we have shipped out fully, our data says 100%. Well, Keith: You put the wrong label on it. Dan Culverhouse: then you just spend all your time working out whose data was right or wrong. And therefore the dashboard is completely pointless. The technology is not giving you what it needs. And those two things need to be integrated so they can't have two different answers. Integration is much more important than a Keith: Yep, absolutely agree. Dan Culverhouse: sexy dashboard. Keith: Our next myth, racing through these myths. Supply chain is a cost centre. We talked about this in a previous episode actually. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It is a cost center generally in a business, that does that, I guess the point of it is, is it a value adding cost or is it just simply the cost of doing business? And of course the reality is it can be a big cost or it can be a much more reasonable cost depending on how that operation is run. And of course, if it's leading, if, You know, your operation is really determining whether your customers are satisfied or not. You know, so if your operation is running well and therefore you're satisfying customers, it is generating revenue because those customers will come back and buy again. You know, so, yeah, it is a cost without a doubt, but it also is an integral part of whether your business is a success or Keith: Why do think so many boards still look at supply chains as something that should just cost less rather than something that can deliver value? Dan Culverhouse: and I think to some reason I would say in some businesses it's a scapegoat. People don't like to look at their own backyard. So, you know, the reality is in most, not most businesses, a lot of businesses, the supply chain is probably not equally represented on the board rather than say commercial or finance or whoever. Therefore, they tend to be slightly junior. Therefore, it's easier to bash. You know, so I think there is... It's seen as a scapegoat and I think there's also a lack of understanding. I don't think people quite understand. I think we've talked about this before as well that I remember I worked in a business where the only KPI that the board looked at from a supply chain perspective was their cost as a percentage of margin. Keith: The rest was too intangible. No doubt it was necessary necessary, but we can't measure it. It's Priceless. Dan Culverhouse: You know, because and so. Yeah, but so, you know, sometimes when you were doing a promotion and you'd shipped out huge amounts of stock, but it's low value stock and our cost as a percentage of margin went up, we used to get bashed for it and it's like, on a second. We have just delivered this incredible Keith: Your customer unit's gone up. Dan Culverhouse: promotion for you and they couldn't see it. And that was just through complete naivety and an unwillingness to really understand it and get past. You know, it was easy to just just keep them under pressure. They spend a lot of money. So let's just keep the pressure on them spending less and less. We're not really interested in anything else. And of course, it's counterintuitive because in the end of the day, the operation stops caring whether they satisfy anybody or not if if they don't get recognized for it. if you just keep pushing that price down and push that price down, of course, the service will diminish, your revenue will drop, and the percentage of your cost of supply chain will go back up and you don't sell. Keith: and then you're back under scrutiny and it's a never-ending circle. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, you don't start anything. Keith: I definitely think the biggest efficiencies come when the bridges are built between your teams and everyone understands the part they can play in making the customer happy. We did touch upon KPIs and that brings us to the next myth. Dan Culverhouse: I just answered the next one already. Cost is a percentage of margin. It's the most pointless KPI I've ever known. It was ridiculous. Keith: Yeah, absolutely. But the question is really, the myth is really the more KPIs we have the better the operation is managed. Only if they matter. Best to start with the ones that matter. Dan Culverhouse: If the outcome of determines whether the operation improves or not, or performs or not, then they're good. Otherwise, it's just noise and it's just distraction. And what it does is it stops you focusing on the ones that do matter. So less is definitely more. Keith: Absolutely. What do you think about operations? Just keep reporting on the same KPIs. We've talked about managers hiding behind chaos, but do think managers also hide behind predictability and they don't start unearthing new KPIs that actually move the business in the next direction or in a further direction. They just keep looking at the same old flat. KPIs without really understanding. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I mean, think there will be some that will always be relevant and some very core, you know, KPIs. You don't need to reinvent the wheel, right? You know, on time and in the fall is a pretty all encompassing KPI that gives you a pretty good indication of how your operation is running. It doesn't tell you whether it's cost effective, but it does give you a good service insight. so I think that they're at the as usual, it's a balance, right? You should always be seeking, is there a better way of reporting? Because different operations are driven by different elements. So you can't just say every operation just needs to have, you know, cost per unit shipped and on time and in forward. And if those two are good, your operation is good. That's not good enough because it depends on what's important in your operation. being open to considering different KPIs is important. I think if it closed off, then potentially your operation will become less and less connected or in tune with the rest of the business and then you're in trouble. Keith: Yeah, you got to answer the problems of the business at the time. Now there's been many a meeting I've been to where it's like we're talking about what we know but we're not talking about what we don't know. That doesn't mean not talking about what we know but let's start questioning the things that we don't know about that people are asking us about. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and same applies to reports, right? Because how many reports does an operation run that nobody ever looks at? I can't think of a single operation I've ever run that didn't have a bunch of reports that nobody ever looked at. Keith: absolutely, yeah. and I didn't understand them. They're just random. So. next myth to discuss. People are the biggest problem in operation. Dan Culverhouse: People are the biggest. Keith: Mm. Dan Culverhouse: That's probably true. It depends which people we're talking about. Keith: Well I don't know. I take this personally because you know at school they had that mentality that it's always the kids, you know the bad kids are the problem, it's the parents, you know they don't listen. If a system doesn't work for you. How can you perform? How can you? If you don't Dan Culverhouse: for sure. Keith: have the incentives or the goals, it's Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: not clear to you why would you suddenly be, why would you perform? We're all different individuals and you know when I talk about the various wastes in Six Sigma and one of them is just time and motion, things like that. Why would you have a system that includes endless steps for example and expect everybody to perform really well? Dan Culverhouse: See, there is a way looking at that. They'd say that's a people problem because there's a person that created it in the first place. Keith: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: So, you know, in some ways, yeah, people are the biggest problem, but it's not necessarily the people that are running the operation. It might have been those who Keith: Well, I've got something to do with everything, don't I? Dan Culverhouse: designed the operation or designed the automation, or maybe it's those guys Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: doing the forecasting or the commercial guys who don't tell us about the promotions. And so people can be quite commonly the biggest problem, but it's not necessarily the people in the operation that are causing it. Keith: Quite often it's the ones who design the process in the first place. I think you've got to look at the tools you give people. That's basically my point. You've got to look at the individual and talk to the individuals who doing the job. Is this working for you? Mistake proof. Automate where you need to. Mistake proof definitely. Take away human effort wherever you can. multiple touch points of course but yeah I think there's been so many examples in my career of someone designing a process who sits far away often in a different country to the warehouse and yeah the onboarding is a series of emails to everybody everybody in ops and a couple of decks Dan Culverhouse: You meet so many people that have spent some time educating themselves on supply chain theory and they will come up with a solution and then when they put it in front of an operator, it will be destroyed. And the reality is that, you know, without really understanding the unexpected consequences, the unintended consequences of various things and how one thing impacts another. very difficult to design an effective operation without ever feeling it, right? If you just do it on theory and data. You need a balance of the theory and the analytical kind of insight alongside a bit of realism, a bit of real world chaos theory thrown in to be able to kind of stand up to reality because reality is messy. It's not organized. Keith: I think you could sum it up by saying before you decide it's a people problem have a chat to the manager and see whether it's a leadership problem. Most often it is somewhere somewhere in the chain. We're talking about Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. All right. Keith: service good service. We move on to our next myth faster delivery always means better service. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, well, Keith: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: there's a key part missing in that statement. It doesn't say it's faster, accurate delivery. So being fast is great. Everyone likes to get stuff quickly. That's OK as long as it's the right stuff or it's in the right condition or you don't have to pay a fortune to do it. So fast is good as long as all the other aspects are covered too. because really the most important thing is you get what you asked for. Granted, if you're up against it, you also need it within a certain timeline, but just being fast is not always going to give you the absolute. Keith: Yeah, sometimes got to expect to pay a bit more for fast because there's so many more levels to ensuring that level of accuracy. Cheap and cheerful fast don't necessarily align. Everybody wants next day. Everyone demands Dan Culverhouse: Well, I think... Keith: next day, but they also demand predictability, reliability. So I would prefer to provide the best service rather than the fastest service. Dan Culverhouse: Well, there's a real risk now because, you know, there are some of our biggest marketplace operators can deliver within a few hours. Right. And that's great. You know, but it is creating an expectation which is not sustainable for many businesses. And, you know, I think it's important that a business that is focused on the quality of its product, the sustainability, environmental impact of his business. should refuse to deliver the next day. They should be like, we deliver at four days notice and here's why. If you buy this product, you're buying it not just because it's nice or it looks good, but because of all the things that go into making it and we do it, maybe they make it bespoke. Maybe they don't want to send an empty truck with one parcel on it to your house just to get it there tomorrow. So I think there's a risk that the big boys have created. Keith: Maybe they've got climb that target. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah, created a monster. But it's important, Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: I think, if you're a smaller niche business that you just refuse to cave to that. You know, you've got to say you're buying our product. You're buying our ethos as well, and we won't deliver it to you tomorrow because it costs so much money and it does so much damage to the environment that we need to be able to pull this and therefore it takes four days. Keith: it's easy to say, but you've got to be brave. If we ever want to turn the corner around sustainability, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: you have to be brave and you have to Dan Culverhouse: There's a place. Keith: make an informed decision over what level of service you want to give your customers. You can follow the herd and obviously convenience is key. But I think people will pay for quality and value and the trend is changing. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, there's a place for speed and convenience, there's a place Keith: and certain regulations. Dan Culverhouse: for quality and sustainability, I think. Keith: Certain regulations are informing these decisions as well. I think balance is key. Have a look at what's out there. Know your customer as well. Know your customer. Don't assume the customer expects the delivery same day or next day. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, absolutely right. right. Number 14 is an interesting one, Keith: ups yes Dan Culverhouse: Keith. So this myth is if every department hits its targets, the business wins. What do you think? Keith: Well, I've been in I've been there I've been there when one one department siloed departments no less Celebrated a particular target. Where is customers services were pulling their hair out because customers were moaning about the delivery Timescale so, you know you've got For every foot, you know what the warehouse were smashing their targets for costs and processing times but customers weren't getting the orders any quicker. In fact they were getting them lot slower because the cost cutting targets superseded the customer satisfaction target. That happens a lot. Dan Culverhouse: I think again, there's a, when you look at, when you read that carefully, if every department hits its target, but if every department just has its own target, the chances of those all Keith: Mm. Dan Culverhouse: being aligned and integrated to deliver an overall great service and great cost, great profitability is pretty unlikely. So every department can work together to achieve the business Keith: If the targets are aligned, great. Dan Culverhouse: objectives, then the business wins. But if everybody's just focused on my bit, if I'm focused on my bit, you are silo thinking Keith: Of course. Have you ever been in a business where it has been that cohesive? Have you ever been Dan Culverhouse: and that costs your business a fortune. Every time, it always does. Because one department is not worrying about the things that they do. I gave a talk on this recently. If you're in procurement and your objective is to buy cheap, then your move, your... your supply from one country or one company to another because you can buy it for 3 % less. Well, if that country that you've just moved it to doesn't have a trade agreement with the UK, you might be paying 10 % more to get it in the country. they can't, unless these are aligned objectives, if everyone just hits their own objectives, you can't ensure that that means the business is going to. Keith: Yeah, bringing more revenue through diversifying products. Buying smash it. We've made more revenue. Ops, yeah, we spent a lot more in shipping, in ad hoc Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: processes, in resources. Our profit was affected. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, collective objectives means business wins. know, if you know, procurement, commercial marketing, supply chain operations, if they have collective objectives and KPIs that each of them have an impact on, but they only win if they all do what they should do, then a business can win. Keith: I would love to see that business where everything is Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: aligned. I haven't quite yet. I've seen some that were on the right track, but maybe none that have got that whole thing in motion. That Dan Culverhouse: Utopian. Keith: takes us to our last myth. Dan, we've steamed through these myths. it's a good one. A good supply chain is one where nothing ever goes wrong. I think a very complacent one. I think one that's unprepared for something that will go wrong in future is one where nothing goes wrong. I think we kid ourselves if we think nothing's going to go wrong. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Well, I think, you know, it's a myth for sure, because I don't think there's ever been one. Nobody could say that for sure, because there has never been a supply chain where nothing goes wrong. you know, it's a theoretical concept that is just not based on reality. Right. So, you know, as we've said, a couple of myths to go, you can theoretically set something up to be perfect. But the problem is life is not perfect and nobody will do absolutely everything that they said they would do at the right time in the right quantity in the right way. So it's something that will never ever occur. So we can never answer this question because there is no such thing as a supply chain with no errors. or no variability in it. Keith: world changes, people change, things change, spending habits change. I think if you think everything's perfect, you're not very good at detecting when things aren't perfect and a lot of assumptions creep in. And you know, I have benchmarked many, many operations in my time and asked for evidence. And it's always enlightening when I go and someone says to me, we're perfect, we're our targets in every area. When I say, can you provide evidence? It's a different story. No. They're not really Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: digging deep enough. They're not looking outside of it day to day. It tends to certainly revolve around things like controls, contingencies. They're not there. They're assumptions. Many are 3PL. No one's ever asked for a KPI on this before. There's no need. Dan Culverhouse: Well, I think it's enough. Keith: There's no need. It's perfect. How do you know? Dan Culverhouse: You can rest assured that anyone who thinks they have a supply chain that doesn't go wrong, they're just not looking. There is a lot Keith: Yeah, absolutely not. Dan Culverhouse: going on that you don't know about is all I can say. Keith: It's supposed to keep you a bit on your toes. think most of us are attracted to supply chain for that mild level of fear and excitement that greets you every day. What's happening Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely. Keith: now? How can I make this better? Yeah, Dan Culverhouse: Never a dull moment. Okay, well, look, 15 myths busted. Do you agree with us? Have Keith: Oop. Dan Culverhouse: we talked complete rubbish for the last hour? Or, you know, have we got one horribly wrong? I'd love to hear your views. I think we've busted all of those myths pretty much. But yeah, what's your views? Keith: Which of these myths, Dan, you think actually cost the business the most? What do you think is the most harmful myth? I think the one we just talked about. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I was going to say, think that this, this anybody who's in this kind of blinkered Keith: Or maybe it's just because it's fresh in my mind, but... Dan Culverhouse: mindset who thinks that everything is going just great, that means you're not looking. And that is a very dangerous place to Keith: You know we've got your feet up. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: be. Keith: Absolutely. Well if you think we've missed the myth, or if you've got your own myth and you want us to smash it, please send your suggestions to us. We'd love to do another episode like that I think. Dan Culverhouse: I'm sure we could find another 15 quite easily. Keith: Yeah challenge us as well you might think that we as Dan said talked rubbish and we're open to that so thanks everyone for listening nice impromptu episode enjoyed it that much we might do another part Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, we survived. We did an episode we hadn't been planning for and we've survived. Feels good. Keith: Yeah, Alright thanks everyone. Like, share, subscribe, enjoy and we'll see you next time. Dan Culverhouse: Yep, hopefully if we plan a guest, we'll have a guest. But if not, we'll find some more myths to bust. All right. Thanks, everyone. See you next week.