Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Walled Garden Wars: Corporate Chains vs Open Money
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the roller gun. The one thing that's missing?
- 0:44That that will. Soon be developed is a reliable
- 0:47E cash. Hey guys, thanks for tuning into
- 0:52another episode of final settlement.
- 0:54It was a fun podcast covering all things that have happened
- 0:58the past you know, week and 1/2 in the digital assets space
- 1:02positives around Bitcoin adoption along with all coin
- 1:05mania coming back quick word and exciting announcement.
- 1:09You'll be one of the first to hear it.
- 1:10We just launched On Ramp Guardian, really excited to get
- 1:14this out because we've heard from the market all over the
- 1:16board as it comes to security with clients of on Ramp and then
- 1:20prospective clients that are looking to leverage our
- 1:22solution, but have certain aspects of giving up what they
- 1:25deem as control as a negative. It's something that I talked to
- 1:28clients a lot about, if clients have come on from, you know, 50
- 1:32to $250 million and really explaining this notion of a,
- 1:36it's not all or nothing, but also where we're heading to.
- 1:40You're going to be praying for giving up that control as the
- 1:43market starts to realize you don't want hundreds of millions
- 1:46of dollars or even 10s of millions of dollars in your
- 1:48possession. And So what Honor and Guardian
- 1:50does is effectively brings out withdrawal delays, deep fake
- 1:55protection against AI, Instant Three's functionality, and then
- 1:58obviously our Lloyds of London insurance.
- 2:01And then for private clients, it goes even deeper, really
- 2:04thinking through different withdrawal freezes, which has
- 2:07come up a lot, you know, up to 365 days.
- 2:11Custom velocity controls around the amount of capital that can
- 2:13moved. And then a real proprietary 3FA
- 2:16protocol where you have to leverage the blockchain,
- 2:19specifically the Bitcoin blockchain to move UTX OS around
- 2:22to prove that it's verifiably you in an objective manner.
- 2:25Really excited about this. If you want to learn more, if
- 2:27you're already a client, you could just, you know, activate
- 2:30it via the web platform. And then if you're looking to
- 2:33learn more, please feel free to book a consultation or shoot me
- 2:36a note. Always happy to hear from folks,
- 2:37Michael at honor@bitcoin.com. Now on to the rest of the show.
- 2:41All right, boys, we are back. It's another episode of Final
- 2:45SETTLEMENT. Today is Monday, September 8th,
- 2:499:39 AM. How are we doing, gentlemen?
- 2:53Michael, Liam. Good. 1/12/12 Yeah, we're kind
- 2:59of just we're, we're sitting in a range, but we got a good show
- 3:03for you today. We got we got some good, some
- 3:05good links in the pipe. We're going to start, Mike, this
- 3:10was one of yours. Stripe is, is launching a stable
- 3:15coin chain. Seems like this is this is a
- 3:19trend. There's lots of people that are
- 3:21launching stable coin chains and there is a little bit of a, a
- 3:27counter response from David Markets Marcus that we'll get
- 3:30to. But I want to start with this
- 3:33Stripe news. So I'm just pulling up the like
- 3:35now, but go ahead, Mike. Yeah.
- 3:38So there's a lot baked into this.
- 3:42I think the reason we're it initially kind of really caught
- 3:45my attention was because there's a lot of, I don't know if belly
- 3:51aching is the right term, but it probably is across the crypto
- 3:53digital asset space around what Stripes doing versus what the
- 3:58existing crypto projects. And it's just a fascinating, I
- 4:02think taking a step back notion when you think about different
- 4:06proponents of different parts of the digital asset industry will
- 4:09claim certain things around decentralization, secure, what's
- 4:13a security, what's a token? You know, that all of these
- 4:16everyone talks their book based on like where they're coming
- 4:18from. And we've all most individuals
- 4:22would understand that, you know, crypto is decentralized and kind
- 4:26of name only. And there's always a throat to
- 4:29choke, including probably what the most the second largest
- 4:31cryptocurrency, including Ethereum.
- 4:33So point being is everyone came out.
- 4:35So that caught my eye. But the second part was Libra,
- 4:40the notion of Christian Catalini.
- 4:41And then there's David Marcus quote will probably play who
- 4:45kind of have gone through the full gamut of crypto digital
- 4:48assets, building a basket of currencies with Libra and
- 4:52formerly at Meta. And I thought that was really
- 4:55interesting because I was actually at the block at the
- 4:57time they broke and used in 2019 when they got the white paper
- 5:00leaked. And it was it was fascinating
- 5:02because I had the consortium of all the different companies that
- 5:06were in there. And it mirrors very similarly
- 5:08what Tempo has done by you go and get a consortium.
- 5:11And Stripe, obviously with his Sequoia ties, which was where
- 5:15Matt Hong came from before Paradigm.
- 5:18And then Stripe, I believe like Shopify's whole business is
- 5:21built on the back of Stripe. So there's a lot of deep
- 5:23connections there. And that's ultimately what
- 5:25you've always needed in any kind of digital asset space.
- 5:28It doesn't matter really about the underlying fundamentals in
- 5:30the short term. If you have distribution, you're
- 5:32going to really be able to exercise umm, some big
- 5:35influence. And so I thought it was just
- 5:37fascinating because Stripe paradigm there's insanely
- 5:39connected and you can kind of always know when somebody's up
- 5:43to something, when people can't stop talking about them.
- 5:45And so the thread it will link to it.
- 5:49But it's really great to know kind of the ills of what
- 5:51happened with Libra Christian outlines, who's a Co founder of
- 5:56light Spark. But what's fascinating is how
- 6:00it's very similar to Libra and what Tempo's trying to do, but
- 6:05Christian references how, you know, he's obviously talking his
- 6:08book in Bitcoin and we do. We'll talk about later on the
- 6:11show. You know, open systems will win.
- 6:13But it's interesting, you know, Christian kind of gives us long
- 6:16thread, but it ultimately is like, yeah, may work this time
- 6:19because the regulatory climates different versus 2018 and 19.
- 6:24So I'll pause there because I think that's like the initial
- 6:26start of just like the the upcoming trat fi tech wars that
- 6:31I don't think the crypto natives, including the Bitcoin
- 6:33natives were prepared for. Yeah, that's an interesting
- 6:37thought on on it might work this time because it does feel very
- 6:43much like the you know, the six or seven years ago enterprise
- 6:47blockchain cause consortium deal type structures.
- 6:53It feels all very similar. So that, but that is a a valid
- 6:57sort of theory that maybe it is different this time around.
- 7:00And and a lot of stuff gets gets pushed, pushed through with
- 7:04stuff like genius act and also just the general sentiment from
- 7:08this administration being so sort of, you know, let it all go
- 7:12green light on all this crypto stuff.
- 7:15So yeah, maybe that is a possible path.
- 7:17Liam, did you have thoughts on this one?
- 7:19Yeah, somebody's going to figure out how to make this work in the
- 7:22short term for sure, and there will be a lot of different
- 7:24winners. But yeah, as as we'll get into a
- 7:28little bit later on, it's just built on the wrong foundations
- 7:30here. Yeah, let's.
- 7:32So let's play the the David Marcus clip, see if you guys
- 7:39can. Hi everyone.
- 7:40I come from the future and I'm here to tell you Corp chains,
- 7:43they're not the way. And I know because I started
- 7:45Libra and it failed. Most people thought it was
- 7:48killed because it was started at Mehta, but that's wrong.
- 7:52It was killed because 1 corporate controlled network was
- 7:56about to control global payments at the scale of billions of
- 7:59people globally. You'll tell me times have
- 8:00changed. Regulation is clear now we're in
- 8:02a different world. But I don't think so if a
- 8:05centrally controlled Corp chain was to control 30 or 40% of
- 8:09inbound and outbound payments to very big countries like Brazil
- 8:13or the European Union. Or.
- 8:15India. Do you think the central bankers
- 8:17and the regulators of that country would let an American
- 8:20controlled Corp chain control that?
- 8:22No, they would go after it and they would be able to kill it
- 8:25because it's centrally controlled.
- 8:27And when one big company creates a core chain, what do you think
- 8:30rivals will do? They will all create.
- 8:32Their own core chain, so we'll have dozens and dozens of.
- 8:34That won't be interoperable with one another, trapping liquidity,
- 8:38creating inefficiencies. This is not the way.
- 8:41It's pretty clear it's going to create a bunch of subscale
- 8:44fragmented networks that are just going to replace the setup
- 8:48of our current financial system and payment networks with new
- 8:51leaders that are going to need a new gate of a very similar
- 8:55system. And that's kind of not really
- 8:58inspirational to it. Not really inspirational.
- 9:00You always stop it there. Yeah, I think, you know, he's
- 9:04he's salty, which is, which is a little sad because you would
- 9:08think you want to win on merit versus I mean, it is what it is.
- 9:12But the reality is they're not going to stop it.
- 9:15They're going to allow it and then and and govern it in the
- 9:19same way we've been talking about with post 21 and 22.
- 9:23The collapse of these crypto firms ushered in a framework so
- 9:27you can have your fingerprint on everything being built in the
- 9:29space. And so if you're covering that
- 9:32much flow and you have that much oversight and visibility, you're
- 9:35going to be controlled. I mean, we've seen this with 21
- 9:38and 20 when it came to the tech space and the amount of sensory
- 9:42that happened on different social media platforms, like the
- 9:45inner, the the convergence or confluence of like public,
- 9:48private sector. Why would it be any different?
- 9:51Especially in in the powers that be know this.
- 9:53There's a reason why they're they're letting come in.
- 9:57So there there's that, I think. I, I hear what you're saying
- 10:01that, you know, he is, he's obviously talking his own book
- 10:04and thinks all this stuff should be built on Bitcoin.
- 10:06And well, I would agree with him over the long term.
- 10:09I think what you're getting at is, you know, maybe there isn't
- 10:13necessarily as much pushback in the short term to something like
- 10:16this actually being stood up and used.
- 10:19I mean, I think what he's getting at is like, why would
- 10:22other countries want to use stable coins that are issued and
- 10:27managed and centralized with the US corporates?
- 10:30And so I, I kind of see what he's getting at there.
- 10:33I think really what he's getting at though, at sort of a higher
- 10:36level is really getting at the heart of like this entire
- 10:40Bitcoin versus crypto dynamic, which is like, what do you
- 10:44actually need decentralization for?
- 10:48And it's certainly applicable to creating a new form of money.
- 10:53That's that's all of the sort of elements that go into to
- 10:56bitcoins underlying mechanisms from proof of work to the
- 11:00difficulty adjustment to solving the double spend problem.
- 11:02Like all of that is very critical in creating a actually
- 11:07decentralized new form of money. If you're just going to like
- 11:11sort of upgrade the financial system.
- 11:13I think this is the question that he's getting at is like,
- 11:16does that actually need to be decentralized?
- 11:19Like if you are putting stocks on chain, for example, does that
- 11:23actually need to be fully decentralized?
- 11:26And I think the answer that broader, broader crypto is
- 11:29getting towards is no, because nobody actually cares about
- 11:32these things that are marginal improvements to the existing
- 11:35financial system. Not talking about like the new
- 11:38creation of money, but just like marginally improving trading or
- 11:41these other things. Maybe that just doesn't need to
- 11:44be decentralized or people don't care enough for it to be.
- 11:46So it's going to be on these Corp chains basically.
- 11:49That that's exactly right. And I think that's why it's
- 11:51important for us to chat about and talk through because I think
- 11:55part of the show is in at least in our own framing.
- 11:58And we've we've gone back and forth for over a year now on
- 12:01like the status of crypto. And I thought I think that was
- 12:04important because those mental models, for better or worse,
- 12:08even though they're annoying, help influence how you build and
- 12:10how you think about commercialization.
- 12:12And the reality is, as we were talking about earlier, when you
- 12:15get into these rooms and it's the difference between a
- 12:17security and a token and a mean coin and and a scam.
- 12:20It's just like, you know, everyone's just talking their
- 12:23own book based on what you know, their own grift is not grifty.
- 12:26But the next, and it's very similar to what you just said,
- 12:30is crypto is all screaming. Let's take David Marcus out of
- 12:33it. But just in general, crypto and
- 12:34whoever's been building on these different layers, they've all
- 12:37screaming now my tokens more decentralized than yours when
- 12:41they were all not decentralized and all built on faulty
- 12:45premises. So the point is, well, these
- 12:48guys being smart or like, well, why do we even care?
- 12:51Like there is value in a database that is intertwined
- 12:56right, with your other payment partners and bypassing the visas
- 12:59and interchange. And then they have the
- 13:02distribution. And so they're just like, screw
- 13:07it, we'll just go and navigate it this way.
- 13:11And so you have, and I don't know if they're gonna claim it's
- 13:14decentralized or not, but I think that's the most
- 13:17fascinating part. And the thing to take away, at
- 13:20least for me is in the same way we discussed and I think you're
- 13:23coming around how we have, you know, years before people
- 13:26recognize it's Bitcoin versus crypto because of the just
- 13:28traditional inertia. It's taking existing Bitcoin
- 13:31people to learn it's Bitcoin, not crypto because a whole bunch
- 13:34of them are getting scammed with dats and like you would thought
- 13:36they would never happened before.
- 13:38How many years will it be for people to recognize that Bitcoin
- 13:42not only has the store value properties, but then also has
- 13:45all the permissionless properties that you would want
- 13:47and not in a form of government money that's decreed by law.
- 13:52And it's just going to be a long burn and people will end up on
- 13:54the other side of it. But in that period, there's
- 13:56going to be a lot of winners, losers, way to commercialize,
- 13:58way to focus and way to make money.
- 14:01And so I think that's why this is all very fascinating because
- 14:04the incumbent or the traditional crypto incumbents were never
- 14:07going to win this game. This was always my take for
- 14:09years to help set up venture firm to the space, help be in
- 14:12these rooms. And people always get angry.
- 14:14It's like the best founders have not even heard of Bitcoin yet.
- 14:18And look, what do you mean? It's like they're here.
- 14:19They're like doing on payments and lightning and like, you
- 14:22know, rewards. It's like, no, because when you
- 14:25get people from Silicon Valley and Wall Street that are
- 14:28actually have not everyone, but the people have execution and
- 14:31operational chops to step in this space, They're going to
- 14:34wipe the floor with of all the different companies that exist.
- 14:38And so you see this with like Coinbase in their Amex card,
- 14:41like it's the most perfect cohort.
- 14:43It's the kind of area you want to target, not like a stacking
- 14:46sats card that you know, is targeting a penny pincher that
- 14:48like, you know, there's just that's just not a demographic
- 14:50from an enterprise value. And similarly, when you think
- 14:53about payments, it was always going to be built around like a
- 14:57traditional player that understood the space and was
- 15:01going to just leapfrog the existing incumbents like a visa,
- 15:05but also had the distribution. We're going to be built by like,
- 15:08you know, a kid in a hoodie that came in and sold like merchants
- 15:11on. You were going to download an
- 15:12app and pay for it. Like these things have been like
- 15:14told for a lot of people native to the space.
- 15:17And so it's here now and we're going to get to see it play out.
- 15:21And there's going to be obviously on a long time
- 15:23horizon. A lot of this crypto and like
- 15:24stablecoin stuff is all, all noise.
- 15:26But it's, it doesn't really matter because it's like saying
- 15:28the dollar's noise. It's like, well, it's actually
- 15:30the unit of account for, for the next, you know, however long.
- 15:34So we better figure out how to like manage it and make money
- 15:37from it and deal with it. So yeah.
- 15:42Yeah, yeah. Many people don't really realize
- 15:44that there is no token that's needed in order to just send
- 15:48money across borders and people would rather just use the dollar
- 15:51than anything else and doesn't necessarily need to be
- 15:53decentralized. They just want to lower the
- 15:55friction in order to move this across borders and eventually on
- 16:00a. Like.
- 16:02If this gets enough scale, the Corp chains become public
- 16:05private partnerships and there will be some instances of, you
- 16:09know, censorship of money and transactions, But that doesn't
- 16:12necessarily really apply or, or matter to these people who are
- 16:15holding it because not everybody holds a, a significant amount of
- 16:20capital and, and just stable coins or dollars in general.
- 16:23And so in the short term, it doesn't really necessarily
- 16:26matter. This will and, or maybe it's not
- 16:28this one in particular, but these types of ideas and and
- 16:32companies will get a decent amount of traction.
- 16:34And yeah, I completely agreed with everything you've said.
- 16:39Yeah, it's, it's all so fascinating.
- 16:41I think like having these conversations multiple times a
- 16:44week really help with the thought process.
- 16:46And like discussing because I went on Rizzo's pod last week
- 16:49and he made a call that he didn't believe we'd see another
- 16:52layer 1 blockchain. And like, frankly, I hope we
- 16:55don't, but I don't. What is it?
- 16:57What did he even mean by that? Like another one pop up like a
- 17:00Solana and, and, and, and it reminded me of like clown world
- 17:04take or no more crypto. It's just like, I mean the
- 17:06world's insane. Like how would we know?
- 17:08You know, like to and what made me think of this was if JPMCBNY,
- 17:13Fidelity or whoever you call want to set something up like
- 17:16they'll do it and kill distribution right off the bat.
- 17:19So it's like if they built a new chain or whatever, that would
- 17:21mean. The other thing that's
- 17:23fascinating is think about operation choke point and like
- 17:26all the people that have been debanked and still like use the
- 17:29dollar and go get bank. Like imagine somebody having
- 17:31their stable coin seized or locked.
- 17:33Like people wouldn't flood. They'd be like you Jackass.
- 17:35Like why did you say that on Twitter?
- 17:37Like you should be quiet. You know, like the the default
- 17:41state for individuals is not like I'm going to go find a
- 17:43better form of money when my bank account gets closed down.
- 17:46You know, it's like, well, what were you doing?
- 17:48Obviously, you know, this, I'm, I'm not being polarized.
- 17:52I'm just trying to take the other side of like all day long
- 17:55as you have to deal with normies, you have to realize
- 17:56like this is the status of the world.
- 17:58And if you want to make money, you have to figure out how to
- 18:01navigate it and be commercial about it.
- 18:04And the reality is like these things are just going to eat a
- 18:06lot of finance intact. Yeah, I think that's that's all
- 18:11right. But to a certain extent, it's
- 18:14it's going to be all theater to like decentralized
- 18:19decentralization. Theater is going to continue
- 18:22with these things and maybe a nice transition with respect to
- 18:29that and like sort of sort of just narrowing in on like why
- 18:32these things aren't actually decentralized and why it is
- 18:35theater. This was a story from a few days
- 18:38ago so world liberty world Liberty Financial Trump's sort
- 18:43of crypto defy company who had previously I guess partnered
- 18:48with Justin Sun in some way locked his world liberty World
- 18:54Liberty 5 tokens. We'll click into this locking
- 18:57540 million in unlocked tokens and 2.4 billion in locked
- 19:00tokens. They say they believe in
- 19:03exchange has been using their user tokens to sell and push
- 19:06down the price. So basically they're they were
- 19:08sort of accusing Justin Sun of offloading some of his position
- 19:13that he had received through his deal or partnership with them.
- 19:17And so they just froze all of his his wallet addresses that
- 19:20had hold those coins. So basically stopped him from
- 19:23selling by just freezing the account.
- 19:26And you can do this stuff on Ethereum because it's not
- 19:28decentralized. Go ahead, Mike.
- 19:31Yeah, I think there's there's an an interesting aspect we'll come
- 19:35back on this one when we start when we talk Solana and Dats
- 19:38because there's some crazy mechanics happening with locked
- 19:41tokens. And but before we go into that,
- 19:43something that I woke up to and it'll put this on my laundry
- 19:46list of pieces articles that I need to write, is that there's a
- 19:51great lies in every truth and then there's truths in every
- 19:54lie. And I don't even know if this
- 19:56has ever been said, but it would remind me of like what we're
- 19:58talking about here. Because the reason why all this
- 20:00stuff persists is because. In the form of the lie, there's
- 20:04truths and that it's on a blockchain because it is on a
- 20:06blockchain and there's some scarcity because there is some
- 20:09like, you know, relative scarcity.
- 20:10They make up. And so people go into these
- 20:13things believing that they're one thing and but they're all
- 20:17built on, you know, false, false premises.
- 20:19And then this reminds me of the other side, which is like all
- 20:21the we don't talk about here. And it was like in one of the
- 20:24YouTube comments, it actually doesn't really even matter.
- 20:26But the core versus not BS that is all BS.
- 20:29It's actually all positive because it's adversarial
- 20:31thinking. That's what you want in any
- 20:33system. But either way, the conversation
- 20:36around there's truths in every or there's, there's lies in
- 20:40every truth. Meaning like Bitcoins going to
- 20:42be money on a long enough time horizon.
- 20:43But like the notion of peer-to-peer cash, yeah, sure,
- 20:46it also have peers for cash, but it doesn't mean that it has to
- 20:48be on the tote, like the unit level.
- 20:50And so many people go and use that on the UTF solo.
- 20:53People go and use that for a reason to go build all this
- 20:55stuff. And so I think like if people
- 20:57just understood the different dynamics of both of them, they
- 21:00would get like what's happening. But each one just kind of like
- 21:03hide within the other to like push their own, push their own
- 21:07point. And we're still so early.
- 21:10People can hide under all this like kind of like smoking
- 21:12mirrors, which is goes back to the stable coin.
- 21:14And all the things we were talking about before is you'll
- 21:17consistently be able to do this because digital assets
- 21:20tokenization or RW, as are all the like, lies in the truth that
- 21:26is this thing that's distributed and decentralized.
- 21:29And then people never got back to the first principle of like,
- 21:31oh, what's happening here and what one have value?
- 21:34And so they just built everything else from it.
- 21:36And there's a lot of help and money to be made though, because
- 21:39like that's the point of these discussions.
- 21:40And what we're doing is it may seem like short sighted, but
- 21:43that's like most things in life, you don't really look smart for
- 21:46a while in doing something, but you know what's going on.
- 21:48And then eventually it's like, oh, even the tempo guys in
- 21:52Stripe like not strike, but there's other firms, oh the the
- 21:56Kalashi and polymarket people. Well, I don't agree and don't
- 22:00necessarily like prediction markets and gambling.
- 22:02Those guys have been grinding on that for like 6 years.
- 22:04Like they've like actually been working, you know?
- 22:07So anyway, sorry. Yeah, I know.
- 22:09I mean, it's a good, it's a very good point in terms of the
- 22:16theater versus actual value created.
- 22:18And the, and the truth that is sort of residual is like kind of
- 22:22what I referred to earlier around like those marginal
- 22:25improvements. Like that's the truth is like
- 22:28there are slight efficiencies from like a corporate or AB to B
- 22:31perspective for a lot of these things.
- 22:34And so that's the sort of grain of truth that people can sell
- 22:38these much larger promises and visions on.
- 22:40But just I guess one other thing on what we have on the screen
- 22:43here, this world liberty. The other irony here was like,
- 22:46you know, the the Trump family, the Trump sons who are involved
- 22:49in this like their whole come to Jesus around crypto was
- 22:53themselves being debanked by the US government and they are
- 22:58effectively de banking someone on their own blockchain or
- 23:02platform. So just some irony there.
- 23:05But perhaps, yeah. Liam, do you have anything on
- 23:08that before we switch gears? The whole thing that everybody's
- 23:14doing with World Liberty 5 token and all of these other tokens
- 23:17that are associated with different stable coins is the
- 23:20Stripes and the JP Morgan's, all the big banks of the world.
- 23:22They're not going to necessarily do that There's and thus because
- 23:27they're already have enough cash, they're not going to risk
- 23:31messing up their golden goose in order to make a few 100 million
- 23:34or billion dollars on some random token that's going to be
- 23:37associated with their stable coin.
- 23:40It's just there's there's a false premise that everything in
- 23:44crypto has been funded by, you know, launching your own token.
- 23:47And that's the only way in order to make a commercial project
- 23:50that just isn't necessarily going to be applicable to all
- 23:53these other all these net new entrants into this space who
- 23:58already have distribution and enough capital in order to drive
- 24:01better payments networks too. Hey guys, I hope you're enjoying
- 24:04the podcast and it wasn't too doom and gloom.
- 24:08Really just try to share what's currently happening in the
- 24:10markets, how we see it. The altcoin craze is something
- 24:13that sadly will persist, but I believe if you're listening to
- 24:17this podcast, you probably understand that and think deeply
- 24:21about Bitcoin custody. And just a quick word from on
- 24:24ramp. I'm sure a lot of listeners know
- 24:27of the different offerings that we have, whether it's, you know,
- 24:30multi institution custody, the ability for our our trade desk,
- 24:34lending and inheritance, and then the dynasty trust, which we
- 24:37are really excited about. We have no shortage of exciting
- 24:40things coming out this fall. Really I think industry shaking
- 24:44things that across the the landscape we have a lot that
- 24:47we've been working on. The one that I just want to go a
- 24:49little deeper on is Guardian that we announced today and
- 24:52specifically the proprietary and I don't even want to call it
- 24:55proprietary, but the 3FA3FA, we're really excited about that
- 25:00because ultimately it's something that severs the
- 25:03Internet connection from the movement of your Bitcoin.
- 25:06So whether it is, you know, video verification, multiple
- 25:10institutions verifying that 2FA logic time, withdrawals, those
- 25:17are all put in place to protect client assets.
- 25:19But at the end of the day, they leverage the Internet connection
- 25:22specifically from a subjective view, how do you interact with
- 25:25humans in the logic? 3FA takes that a step further
- 25:29and really relies on public private key cryptography,
- 25:33specifically around Bitcoin wallets and the movement of
- 25:36certain UTX OS for a certain client specific PIN.
- 25:39This is something I've been thinking about deeply.
- 25:41It might be overkill for somebody with, call it 1 to $10
- 25:44million, even though it's still open for them.
- 25:47But for clients that we work with that have 10s, if not
- 25:49hundreds of millions of dollars, this is something that I think
- 25:52they're going to be really excited about because ultimately
- 25:55it takes it a step further and leverages either a hardware
- 25:58device that we would ship them or another way that they've
- 26:01generated a private and public key.
- 26:03So if you want to learn more about that, you can look at the
- 26:05blog post or you can feel free to book a consultation if you
- 26:08want to talk with me directly again, Michael at
- 26:10honor@bitcoin.com and hope you enjoy the rest of the show. 22
- 26:15quick things to call out. One is the world liberty deal is
- 26:19I'm pretty confident it's like a complete grift.
- 26:21It like there's no this is something that with a very
- 26:25senior official and from a government side of like crypto,
- 26:30they were breaking down how like crypto is innovative, whatever
- 26:32and like it's actually not. And it's like if you go back
- 26:36because it would really felt, I felt it viscerally because you
- 26:39tell these stories, but then the market goes into a bear market
- 26:41and there's no volume and you're like, this stuff has no use if
- 26:44it didn't have use. Like it's just speculation.
- 26:47And so I think a lot of smart people figured out the playbook
- 26:49because there's certain like mean coins and you dump them and
- 26:51then everyone just like rugs versus where a world liberty you
- 26:56go and you launch the token. I think there's a lending aspect
- 26:59that's supposed to like rival whatever coin Ava or I don't
- 27:04know, But like you see what I'm saying?
- 27:05Like you build a story and a narrative and then they just get
- 27:07super loud about it. So I'm pretty confident that's
- 27:09just like a large grift and there's a playbook.
- 27:12The other quick thing to call out is I do sadly or sadly or
- 27:18not, there's going to be a lot of success from the I don't want
- 27:22to say incumbents like the Visas, but they potentially but
- 27:25like really that middle stripe, I think of Coinbase.
- 27:27Coinbase is the example, right? Because while we know Coinbase,
- 27:32you know, has its flaws, the reality is this notion of like
- 27:37supporting crypto and something I'm still wrestling with, but
- 27:40the notion of supporting crypto, the most of the market can't
- 27:45understand why somebody would be Bitcoin only.
- 27:47And so if you if you go Bitcoin only, you have to really find a
- 27:50like world class product and then really like a area of the
- 27:53market that is like not only on address, but like has it like a
- 27:55Tam that's growing, but also can sustain a business, right.
- 27:59And so coin being is like Coinbase built this business and
- 28:06we know they're not the best in class, but they, they're,
- 28:08they're, they're best in class regarded.
- 28:09And so nobody, everyone goes to Coinbase.
- 28:11We know the whole situation of them being blessed.
- 28:13And I think we're going to see that happen with like payments
- 28:18in the incumbents because there's this intersection
- 28:20happening with like stable coins, native assets being put
- 28:23on chain. And because they support so many
- 28:27things. And the reality is they already
- 28:28had the relationships with all the big banking partners,
- 28:31they're going to go there. And so the short order there,
- 28:34there's a lack of focus that's obviously going to keep them
- 28:36from winning long term, but they will like stumble towards
- 28:38success in the same way that Coinbase doesn't focus on coin
- 28:41on Bitcoin, but they have all the Bitcoin, you know, and I
- 28:44don't think that's fully like appreciated.
- 28:46And so when you when you win and out compete, you have to play a
- 28:49different game. If you try to play their game,
- 28:51you're probably not going to be able to win.
- 28:54And I thought that's just fascinating because when you
- 28:55look at all of. This maybe this is kind of a
- 28:58perfect example of what you're saying.
- 28:59So this was just from this morning NASDAQ filing to allow
- 29:02tokenization and blockchain listening of stocks.
- 29:04It's like, yeah, the crypto, the crypto native firm is not going
- 29:08to like get U.S. stocks listed on block chains.
- 29:11It's going to be NASDAQ who makes the move and does this.
- 29:14Unless it's hyper liquid. Unless it's hyper liquid.
- 29:16Nice transition to what you really wanted to talk about
- 29:19today. Michael, you've been hyper
- 29:20liquid pilled. Can you, can you, can you give
- 29:22us the investment thesis on hyper liquid, please?
- 29:25I definitely haven't even hyper liquid pilled.
- 29:27I think I think, and somebody that's shared with me, I think
- 29:33listen, so they'll probably get an appreciation.
- 29:35I sat down with a lunch for an hour to talk about Bitcoin and
- 29:37then I end up hearing about the hyper liquid because everyone
- 29:39hears about hype and all this stuff.
- 29:41And what was interesting was the guy was very I wouldn't look
- 29:46about anything with price, although like it's probably is
- 29:49going to pump. They just I think this past week
- 29:53A16Z just you know, I think there was like yesterday on one
- 29:56of those like, well, hunters on Twitter saw like, you know, 1.6
- 30:00million of the token, like 60 million just went into like a
- 30:0360Z's wallet or whatever. But I mean, before even going
- 30:09into I'm not at home, so my screens a little bit different,
- 30:15but I'll pull it up here. So just some quick stats, Hyper
- 30:22liquid 700 million total locked value, more protocol revenue
- 30:27than Ethereum and Solana 5.5 billion in stable coin sitting
- 30:30in there. I think my understanding of
- 30:36this, it's obviously not like decentralized, decentralized
- 30:39name only, but it was, I guess, interesting in the crypto space
- 30:44because the founders didn't take any DC capital.
- 30:47They were, I think, working at a previous crypto exchange and
- 30:50before everything fell apart. And the one big innovation, and
- 30:55this is where I find it like the most interesting is perps that
- 30:58we all agree like perpetual futures couldn't be present
- 31:01until you had stable points because you needed the rolling
- 31:04fund rate and to be able to stream that, that collateral or
- 31:07deposit and liquidation. And so perps had historically
- 31:11been out of the US and then they definitely had been away from US
- 31:14equities. And it's my understanding to get
- 31:16another trigger, but perpetual's futures are much better
- 31:20derivative than options for a number of reasons.
- 31:23And so because they're offshore is one thing, but the other
- 31:28thing my understanding is that their technology, it has like 3
- 31:32big things that I thought were interesting.
- 31:34One is it trades spot BTC, which most of these like altcoins
- 31:38indexes weren't. And there has to do with like,
- 31:39again, I'm not technical on this, but there's like a layer
- 31:42between whatever blockchain that they created and then how they
- 31:45received the assets. So the person that was telling
- 31:48me about this like will move their Bitcoin in and out from
- 31:51just like a complete like privacy perspective just to
- 31:53clean it. So there's the three aspects are
- 32:00the perps and spot trading are like flawless.
- 32:04So it's not automated market makers.
- 32:07Again, I had to do some research on just so you can talk about
- 32:10this, because I don't like trade or do any of it and I have no
- 32:13hyper liquid token, by the way, But my understanding is
- 32:20generally on decentralized exchanges, there is limited
- 32:24volume, but also limited spot trading.
- 32:27So they're not very deep in liquid.
- 32:28And that's where you've seen some of this news with
- 32:30different, you know, people showing up and and reverting
- 32:36whatever revolving getting into Ethereum and like other assets
- 32:40from their spot BTC. And it's it's deep enough to do
- 32:42that. So the spot trading, the
- 32:45perpetual trading, but perpetual trading of stocks, I believe is
- 32:48either on there or plan to be on there.
- 32:52And then the derivatives, the perpetual there was one other.
- 33:00But the core notion was that they've already found an insane
- 33:05amount of liquidity. And I guess the way that it's
- 33:08constructed is that you can effectively like spin up your
- 33:11own no to validate. So the idea is similar to like
- 33:15bitcoins. I still believe there's a throat
- 33:17to choke and all this stuff will be shut down in a long time.
- 33:19Or is it or Co opted? But I thought it was fascinating
- 33:23because they basically figured out the two sided market problem
- 33:27of when you have a decentralized, quote UN quote
- 33:28decentralized exchange, you have all this fragmentation on all
- 33:31the products and that's why you go to the centralized exchange.
- 33:34And a lot of volume has effectively moved from finance
- 33:36and other platforms to this, this place Hyper Liquid.
- 33:41And if that's all like sounds like BS, well, yesterday it just
- 33:44came out that they put out, I guess there's again, 5.5 billion
- 33:46sitting there. And those are sitting in
- 33:48T-bills, right? So somebody's making money on
- 33:49that 5.5 billion. So somebody, there's a big
- 33:51bounty to be the stable coin that's native to hyper liquid.
- 33:56They put out a bounty and I think it was part of it for
- 33:59marketing. But now everybody's out there
- 34:03trying to circles talking about it.
- 34:05Paxos, everybody wants to be the native stablecoin issuer for
- 34:09this this new token or this new chain.
- 34:12And so anyway, I thought it was super fascinating just because
- 34:14it's something that we don't generally talk about.
- 34:18And I think the reason why it's relevant here is if it has any
- 34:22validity to have an actual somewhat decentralized exchange
- 34:25in order book and marketplace, it'll over a long enough time
- 34:28horizon be built around Bitcoin. And so that was like the way I
- 34:32posed it to the individuals like, well, if this is all
- 34:34right, because it sounds very interesting, this will just all
- 34:36net to Bitcoin like if these the way it's like, you know, managed
- 34:40even on nodes. So yeah.
- 34:43Yeah, there's a lot there, but there's your, there's your hyper
- 34:47liquid thesis for the day. I think where my mind goes with
- 34:52this. And, and to be honest, I don't
- 34:53know how it plays out because the points you make around, you
- 34:57know, even if it's there is some vector of control and these
- 35:01things aren't truly decentralized, like maybe it's
- 35:03better than the C5 version, right?
- 35:06And so that's really how Hyper Liquid was born.
- 35:08It was born out of people trading perps on finance most
- 35:12predominantly. And then this was, you know, the
- 35:17more decentralized version of that.
- 35:18You don't have to log on to a centralized exchange.
- 35:22You can just do it from your own, your own wallets, etcetera.
- 35:26That's where they found a lot of product, product market fit.
- 35:28But the, I guess the the potential counter to that is,
- 35:33well, what if, you know, Coinbase is able to just do this
- 35:36better and provide more like liquid part markets?
- 35:39And so that's something that they've talked about doing for a
- 35:43long time. And I don't know, these are not
- 35:46available in the United States still.
- 35:49But yeah, see, this is a quote tweeting Coinbase international
- 35:52exchange leveling up, basically just allowing more leverage.
- 35:57So it was previously capped AT20X leverage.
- 35:59Now you can go up to 50 XI, forget what the old limits on
- 36:05Binance where, but I believe it was like, you know, 50 to 100
- 36:08type stuff and hyper liquid's like even more than that.
- 36:11You can pretty much do whatever you want on hyper liquid.
- 36:13So I do think there's going to be some back and forth between
- 36:18the, I guess like the C Phi and the quote UN quote D Phi
- 36:21versions of who's going to win per futures basically.
- 36:25And and I, I still kind of think it's an open question because I
- 36:30do think there is a world in which Coinbase just does this
- 36:33better than Hyper Liquid, but I'm not going to profess to be
- 36:38an expert on this stuff. Yeah.
- 36:40I mean, I think the two aspects at least in the short order were
- 36:45where Coinbase is kind of like wrecked is if they go to 50,
- 36:49we'll whatever is not regulated, we'll just go to 60 and then 100
- 36:54and 120. And then when they can't trade
- 36:58public equities, then they will. And then when they can't trade
- 37:01private equities, then they will.
- 37:03So there's always just like you're trying to be a deeper
- 37:06bucket shop. The other side of it is, it's my
- 37:09understanding that the fees are much lower than Coinbase or any
- 37:14other platform because the idea is that it's almost like a
- 37:18protocol in the sense that anybody can plug in and use it
- 37:20from a front end or back end. So you can place your own ask
- 37:25and just put your own assets there.
- 37:26And then it's just finding on the other side.
- 37:28So the idea is in theory like if there is sound as to this, it
- 37:31should be able to get best execution from the amount of
- 37:34participants plugging in, especially because it's not
- 37:39necessarily a business per SE that has to, you know justify
- 37:44keeping its revenue. Like I don't necessarily know it
- 37:46plays out. My main, I think take away in
- 37:48all of this is that all of these things that find value will
- 37:53ultimately end up in some aspect tied to Bitcoin because there
- 37:57will be that throat to choke when the like The one that comes
- 38:01to mind is the prediction markets, which are another kind
- 38:04of cousin of what's hot right now.
- 38:06And everyone's funding them and you have these different
- 38:09platforms, but they're all eventually, if they pick up
- 38:13enough steam, are going to come under the eyes of any regulator,
- 38:16any participants, attacks them, do whatever.
- 38:18Or just like you can only play certain things within the
- 38:22platform to bet on and you're naturally going to get people
- 38:26further and further on the curve.
- 38:27But then as people get further and further out, you get
- 38:29sketchier when it comes to what's the token, what are you
- 38:32using, what platform and what's the ultimate asset to settle on
- 38:36the censorship resistant that's unseasonable and ends up being
- 38:39BTC. So I think these are just all
- 38:42like kind of precursors on the the framework for how it'll end
- 38:46up. I think that's probably why I'm
- 38:48most fascinated with all of this because it's kind of a glimpse
- 38:51into an actual decentralized future.
- 38:53If you can find product market fitting crypto well, then you're
- 38:55pretty much going to be able to put it on Bitcoin in some
- 38:58respect, whether it's other layers or it's the native token.
- 39:02Yeah. No, that's I like that sort of
- 39:04the last part of what you said there.
- 39:06There is an optimistic spin for all of this where where, you
- 39:09know, week after week we come back and we talk about all this
- 39:12noise. But like the if you want to take
- 39:15a silver lining from it, it it goes back to, you know, over a
- 39:19decade ago when basically it was just Bitcoin and people started
- 39:24thinking about other applications of blockchain
- 39:27technology. Like the, the thought was always
- 39:29sure, go test it out, build whatever you want to build.
- 39:32And, and if it works, if it has product market fit, if it makes
- 39:35sense, then we try to, you know, drafted onto Bitcoin in some
- 39:39way, drafted onto that sound foundation.
- 39:42And so I think over a long enough time horizon, that is
- 39:46basically what's going to happen with a lot of this stuff.
- 39:48To your point, it's what works, what sticks will be built on, on
- 39:53Bitcoin. And we're we're already seeing
- 39:54that with stablecoins, there's multiple different efforts and
- 39:57angles of bringing stablecoins and, and even other assets to to
- 40:02Bitcoin natively. And so I think you know it, just
- 40:04it works on a slower time. Timeline obviously than all
- 40:09these other blockchain networks which can move that move move
- 40:12faster just given sort of the rate of development and
- 40:18consensus required to make any changes to the protocol so.
- 40:23Yeah, the, the hyper liquid stuff is really interesting to
- 40:26me because I mean, I've never really traded or done any of
- 40:31that stuff. And so I'm not, I'm definitely
- 40:34no expert in this, but information tends to be free.
- 40:37And therefore, on a long enough time horizon, it makes sense
- 40:41that there will be publicly available order books just
- 40:44because that just brings more liquidity and ends up being
- 40:48outside of an exchange. As long as the execution is
- 40:52actually right and can have validity and essentially be sure
- 40:57that your assets won't go away. And and then there will be no
- 41:02way for somebody to, to mess up your money because that's,
- 41:06that's really important. But it does make sense that over
- 41:11a long time horizon that all of this will be around different,
- 41:17you know, on Bitcoin itself or, or related to it.
- 41:19Just because I, I did a little bit of digging on hyper liquid
- 41:22and you know, six months ago they had these tiny meme coin or
- 41:27whatever that there was some somebody who was essentially
- 41:30able to manipulate a very illiquid market.
- 41:33And the hyper liquid market makers were rolled back the
- 41:37chain and got all the validators together in order to essentially
- 41:41take back the actual capital that was, was lost by the actual
- 41:47hyper liquid protocol. And eventually it won't go to if
- 41:53there is some sort of decentralized type exchange that
- 41:57just will happen over time because all information tends to
- 42:00be free. It's not going to necessarily be
- 42:03the hype token that is going to accrue all the value.
- 42:06It's going to be either distributed back to everybody
- 42:10who is participating based on the value that they provide in,
- 42:13and the native token in which the capital will go back will be
- 42:17under Bitcoin itself. Yeah.
- 42:23I hope so. I think that's the medium to
- 42:25long term play. But I, I think for a while
- 42:27there's going to be all these other, these other avenues that
- 42:31get more traction as we were sort of talking about earlier
- 42:35that the, you know, the Nasdaq's of the world are, are going to
- 42:39be the ones that tokenize stocks like it just it's logical.
- 42:44All right, switching gears here a little bit, Mike, I think this
- 42:47was yours. We talked about this maybe a
- 42:50week or two ago, but it looks like there's maybe more
- 42:53information on the UAE stacking some Bitcoin, a look into the
- 42:59UAE $700 million Bitcoin holdings.
- 43:01So what? What do you have here, Mike?
- 43:03Yeah, I think one of the the the chain sleuths, I forget what,
- 43:09which one. It's it's titled somewhere in
- 43:11here. Oh yeah.
- 43:11It even says sleuths Arkham Research.
- 43:15It's kind of interesting. Here's a screenshot for anybody
- 43:17that's listening to the the data center in the UAE believe in Abu
- 43:22Dhabi. I think most in the industry
- 43:25have known in the Middle East, specifically in the UAE, they've
- 43:30been mining for a while. I think it's been rumored that
- 43:35they've been mining with nuclear energy and it's been my like
- 43:39assumption this is part of the not just the UAE, but globally
- 43:44sovereigns have been mining with facilities, you know, in their
- 43:48jurisdiction, but also stacking their own kind of treasury.
- 43:54And this ties into the hash rate being just like it kind of, I
- 43:58think it was like 18 months ago just kind of went completely
- 44:01parabolic and a little bit of inorganically.
- 44:04And I think the main reason we're put this in where it's the
- 44:08most interesting is the discussion around SBR and, you
- 44:12know, where do we play out in the cycle and how much longer
- 44:16does it go and do we go to high, you know, higher that we're not
- 44:18expecting? And the base case has always
- 44:21been if sovereigns are accumulating because that's just
- 44:23a different fire. And we know Bhutan, there was a
- 44:29Russia and then UAE and it was just interesting to see they
- 44:32have close to a billion dollars. Yeah, I think that was look at,
- 44:36I mean, just look at that chart. It looks like the money printer,
- 44:39right? If you go back and you, you kind
- 44:42of see this is actually how like M2 looks as well, where if you,
- 44:46there's always an interesting chart for me.
- 44:47If you went back to like 71 to O8, it doesn't really look like
- 44:51anything when you look at it in like going back for 30 or
- 44:55looking at it from a 30 year horizon.
- 44:56But if you just look at that mark, you can see it's steadily
- 44:59increasing because money was just being inserted into the
- 45:01system. And so similar here, like cash
- 45:03rate was slowly coming in. And then in that 22, it just
- 45:07kind of like has gone completely parabolic.
- 45:08And these reminders have been suffering, at least in the US
- 45:11and and other places. But yeah, I think that's
- 45:15probably the most interesting part is that sovereigns are
- 45:17accumulating. And yeah, I mean, some are
- 45:21selling, but I think some are cute.
- 45:22This is their back door into their own strategic Bitcoin
- 45:25reserve. Yeah, they have a pretty
- 45:28holistic digital asset strategy going on at the moment.
- 45:32Back in 2023 Marathon, it was public.
- 45:35The Marathon teamed up with Abu Dhabi's 02 for Middle East,
- 45:39first large scale emergent Bitcoin coal mining and deployed
- 45:44a decent amount of hash into that.
- 45:47Then there's this. The UAE sovereign wealth fund
- 45:52owns, I think last quarter it was something around $600
- 45:56million in Bitcoin ETFs and they made that $2 billion investment
- 46:00into finance, which was I think their largest investment that
- 46:05they've made at that point. So they're looking at this space
- 46:08very deeply from a bunch of different angles.
- 46:12And I would imagine that they continue to make more
- 46:15investments both into Bitcoin itself as well as all of the
- 46:19companies around it just as they get more exposure.
- 46:22Because it seems like they they at least had a lot of what you
- 46:26see is net new entrance into the space, have very poor
- 46:30experiences because they buy the top when everybody's super
- 46:34interested. But these guys started mining
- 46:38back in 2023, made the Binance investment hold ETFs that are,
- 46:43you know, flat to up. And so I would imagine that they
- 46:47have a decent taste in their mouth and only just lean further
- 46:49in here. Yep, it's super logical.
- 46:53You think about a country like the UAE or really any Middle
- 46:57Eastern country or any country with access to natural resources
- 47:04or forms of of energy. It makes total sense to start
- 47:07mining Bitcoin if you have effectively A0 cost energy
- 47:12resource. So expect to see more of this.
- 47:14And yeah, keep an eye on hash rate as a a really great
- 47:18barometer. I've always sort of leaned on in
- 47:21terms of just thinking about sort of non price, non price
- 47:26indicators for Bitcoin demand, Bitcoin adoption, etcetera.
- 47:29Hash rate's a great one in the sense that it shows demand for
- 47:34basically building out mining infrastructure and accumulating
- 47:38Bitcoin through mining. And that's just incredibly
- 47:41bullish because basically the, the most bullish, some of the
- 47:45most bullish operators in the entire Bitcoin ecosystem are
- 47:47miners. And so it's, it's just a
- 47:50generally positive indicator. And, and on that chart that we
- 47:54had up previously, you can see, as Michael said, like it's just
- 47:58been ripping for the past few years.
- 47:59There was the the China migration, which basically cut
- 48:03hash rate in half. And ever since that then at that
- 48:06point it's really been on just an upward Rep.
- 48:09And I think that is reflective of nation state involvement
- 48:12because that that like I said, is the logical move if you have
- 48:16access to effectively 0 cost energy make makes a lot of sense
- 48:21to mine Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 48:23And then it's really important to note too, just because all,
- 48:26pretty much all Bitcoin adoption is defensive of if somebody else
- 48:30who is a perceived competitor to you seems to be acquiring more
- 48:35Bitcoin and potentially outperforming you in whatever
- 48:40way possible, many people will look at that and understand that
- 48:43they need to do a somewhat similar strategy, otherwise
- 48:46they're going to see their capital flow away.
- 48:51And so I would imagine that many other, you know, perceived
- 48:55competitive countries are taking a close look at what exactly
- 48:58they're doing and how they're benefiting from it, as well as
- 49:01starting to think about how they can implement A somewhat similar
- 49:03strategy themselves. Yep, well said.
- 49:09More global news Mike, this one is you as well.
- 49:11India leads global crypto adoption.
- 49:14APAC emerges as the fastest growing market, according to
- 49:16chain analysis. Yeah, I thought this was
- 49:19interesting because I didn't expect that.
- 49:21I think the common consensus has been India's very antagonistic
- 49:25to the space. Obviously India is a big gold
- 49:28country, but yeah, I didn't go deep here.
- 49:32But this was according to the the chain analysis report.
- 49:39I think it ties into the UAE conversation in that sovereigns
- 49:44are slowly recognizing your pro crypto, your pro digital asset,
- 49:48pro Bitcoin stance really is going to matter.
- 49:50It's going to matter from are you storing a hard asset on your
- 49:54balance sheet to Liam's point, are you getting the tribal and
- 49:58knowledge from operating there? Because you can only if you have
- 50:02a first mover, then you're going to be able to efficiently grow
- 50:05that operation ahead of others. And then naturally you want your
- 50:09constituents and your citizens to be able to preserve and hold
- 50:12their wealth because that's what they're going to be able to
- 50:13reinvest. And so it makes sense.
- 50:17India and Asia Pacific has generally been pretty
- 50:19antagonistic to Bitcoin outside of like Singapore and maybe even
- 50:23Hong Kong kind of. So I thought this was just
- 50:26really fascinating to see. The other thing that the other
- 50:33thing that's interesting is this really ties into just like the
- 50:36Bitcoin thesis on, you know, you hear a lot of noise, the not
- 50:40stuff and just in general the you, you want to hear the
- 50:45adversarial nature and the contentious nature of this space
- 50:48because it means that people, there's so much economic value
- 50:52to protect that, that people will figure out solutions.
- 50:55And that's where we've never really held.
- 50:58Not that quantum won't ever be a threat, but it's the notion of
- 51:01whether it's forking the UTXO set, changing the algorithm, and
- 51:05the just different things that come up is there's so much
- 51:07capital. To Brian's point, investors at
- 51:11all the different shapes and sizes from a home miner all the
- 51:13way to a sovereign are investing their own Personal Capital,
- 51:16which is material to them to figure out how to make this
- 51:21thing keep working. And that doesn't really get
- 51:22priced in effectively. Where people think that this
- 51:25thing's very fragile and, you know, past results are
- 51:29indicative of future returns. It's like, well, no, they kind
- 51:31of are because all this capital coming in is forward leading
- 51:34into faking into where the market is going.
- 51:38And so I think this is just another piece with a whole
- 51:41section of the world, you know, getting getting bullish on the
- 51:44underlying asset. Yeah, that's interesting.
- 51:48I, I'd be curious like I, I, it doesn't look like there's a, a
- 51:51detailed breakdown here, but like, you know, what percentage
- 51:54of this is broader crypto versus Bitcoin?
- 51:56Because to your point, India does appreciate gold.
- 52:01And so it would be logical for them to appreciate digital gold
- 52:05and see the, the merit and the value of, of Bitcoin
- 52:07specifically in that context. But I'm not sure on that, on
- 52:11that breakdown. Liam, do you have anything there
- 52:15or do you want to move on? No, it's all sad.
- 52:21I mentioned gold. Some more gold news.
- 52:24Tether is going to invest in some gold miners.
- 52:28The real The real reason I love this report was that Tether
- 52:33apparently internally calls gold natural Bitcoin, which I just
- 52:38love. And yeah, we've talked about
- 52:41Tether a bunch on the show the past several months, but all the
- 52:44moves they're making are extremely logical.
- 52:47They're going to own gold, they're going to own Bitcoin,
- 52:49they're going to own some land, and they're going to own U.S.
- 52:52Treasuries and just print cash. Any thoughts on this?
- 52:58Yeah, there was a there was another there was a few things
- 53:02that came out this week. I think 1 was a little older
- 53:04where Tether CEO referenced that if a global reset were to occur,
- 53:10it would happen in gold, which I think this is kind of a
- 53:14different side to the discussion in the beginning of there's
- 53:19just, you know, when you first come into this space and even
- 53:22for a while, you really listen to common narratives and it's
- 53:26it's it's really akin to life. Like the more you, the more you
- 53:31grow, the more you realize you don't know.
- 53:34And it's very similar to like, OK, you read the Bitcoin
- 53:37standard, you see Bitcoin 21 million all right, global money.
- 53:40But like the time horizon and the implementation is like where
- 53:43all the money gets made and it's the it's the where everyone's
- 53:46hands get dirty and it doesn't get talked about enough.
- 53:49How gold a was going to play such a vital role and is playing
- 53:53a vital role when you think of the sovereign accumulation, what
- 53:56we we've talked about on the last trade with what's happening
- 53:59on in the Shanghai gold markets and some of the trade happening
- 54:03there. And tether, one of the most
- 54:05sophisticated players in this space are insanely long gold to
- 54:08the point that you know, they're they have their their different
- 54:11packs or their their stable coin.
- 54:14That's on Google on gold, stacking gold and then just
- 54:18being, you know, forthright that if any kind of I think that's
- 54:23probably one of the big reasons is you don't know the time
- 54:28horizon for a lot of these things.
- 54:29You just know the direction and you don't want to get caught off
- 54:31sides. And so a reality is, you know,
- 54:34currencies hyperinflate Bitcoin rips, but the market has so
- 54:38much, you know, inertia in gold, you're going to naturally see
- 54:42that RIP in a lot of like market structure will ultimately be
- 54:47around that first. I think very few people would
- 54:49disagree that, you know, BRICS countries and others are going
- 54:53to set up different currencies backed by gold.
- 54:55You know, obviously storage, delivery, all of those things
- 54:58are going to come to the forefront over a long enough
- 55:00time horizon. And then people will realize
- 55:02that there's a better way to do this.
- 55:04But it's just something that doesn't get talked about enough.
- 55:07Everyone's focus on tokenizing real world assets and you know,
- 55:10stable coins and there's just the real pair for the next, you
- 55:15know, call it 20 to 40 years is going to be gold, BTC and then
- 55:18whatever USD, you know, chains going to be ripping.
- 55:22Hi guys, thanks for listening. I hope you're enjoying the pod.
- 55:24Just wanted to give a quick word from on ramp and early riders.
- 55:28You're probably familiar with our venture fund we operate and
- 55:32we will be having some very exciting meeting of the minds
- 55:38over the next few months in Nashville around a few events
- 55:41happening at the Bitcoin Park, as well as in Dallas around the
- 55:46North American Blockchain Summit.
- 55:48We'll be having one-on-one meetings, private roundtable
- 55:52sessions discussing the status of the market, some of the
- 55:54exciting investments that we haven't publicly announced, as
- 55:57well as other ways for individuals to get more involved
- 56:00with everything we're building across the ecosystem.
- 56:03If you're interested in learning more, you can reach out to us
- 56:06directly, you can book time or you can just subscribe to our
- 56:09research. We're going to be publishing a
- 56:11lot of these dates as well as ways to get in touch via the
- 56:15Early Writers newsletter. You can be at our Early Writers
- 56:18Calm. We're always excited to hear
- 56:20from individuals. We have some of those
- 56:22sophisticated listeners and clients and investors and early
- 56:26writers. And I really mean that we're
- 56:28working on kind of the bleeding edges of the space.
- 56:30And so it usually takes individuals that have had to
- 56:32think deeply and follow the space for a while to kind of
- 56:36pick up what we're putting down. But we love hearing from you
- 56:38folks and also hearing about ideas or ways to get involved.
- 56:43There's no shortage of really amazing talent out there trying
- 56:45to kind of either take a one step out of the traditional
- 56:49space and figure out what their next move is.
- 56:51And we love hearing from individuals like that because
- 56:54we're working on a lot of things and it's really our job between
- 56:56the Guild network on ramp and early writers and some of our
- 56:59other portfolio companies to figure out how to help there.
- 57:02So I'd encourage you to reach out if it's not this week,
- 57:05please keep it in mind as you navigate the space.
- 57:07We'd love to speak with you. All right, have a great rest of
- 57:09your week. And we'll be back with the last
- 57:11trade with a very big guest that we're super excited about.
- 57:15I don't know if Jackson will like that.
- 57:16I share it here. So if you want to know, tag him
- 57:19on Twitter and maybe he'll share it on Twitter.
- 57:20I don't want to steal his Thunder.
- 57:22All right, have a great week. Yeah, it's, it's interesting and
- 57:27it's something that my own thinking has evolved on this.
- 57:30I think I used to be not fully in the camp, but at least more
- 57:34in the camp of basically some sort of like leapfrog thesis
- 57:39where we do just move to a Bitcoin standard.
- 57:41But I've I've come around to this notion of again, the
- 57:44inertia of gold 1000 plus year history.
- 57:47Like there's going to be just an interim period where, you know,
- 57:51it's, it's moving back towards neutral reserve assets and
- 57:55predominantly that at least in, you know, this initial phase is
- 57:58going to be gold for most central banks with maybe just,
- 58:02you know, a little sliver of Bitcoin here or there.
- 58:04But like, and, and maybe over time, that transition.
- 58:07But we're talking, you know, multiple, multiple decades that,
- 58:09you know, it would transition more towards Bitcoin actually
- 58:13demonetizing gold to, to a certain extent.
- 58:15I think we're very long, long ways away from that.
- 58:19And I think to your point, Michael, like it, this is a
- 58:21blind spot, I think for a lot of Bitcoiners who who are still in
- 58:24that camp of like, why would you care about the the yellow shiny
- 58:28rock? Like it's, yeah, it's so
- 58:30inferior. We're going to find the asteroid
- 58:33with all the gold on it. Those types of tropes like I do
- 58:37think it is, it is just a little bit misguided with respect to
- 58:42again, that that inertia, that trajectory, the sound money
- 58:45trade that's emerging. It's not just going to be
- 58:48Bitcoin like it is. It is neutral reserve assets.
- 58:51And the the one that is far more ingrained and well understood is
- 58:56gold. So there's going to be this
- 58:59interplay for, you know, probably a good amount of time,
- 59:02probably multiple decades. Yeah, unless people know exactly
- 59:05what's going to be the next reserve asset, we probably get a
- 59:08basket of diversified assets in there, meaning gold, probably a
- 59:13little bit of silver, Swiss francs or whatever the best of
- 59:16the poor Fiat currencies are, as well as the dollar and Bitcoin.
- 59:22It's not going to necessarily just going to be a straight
- 59:26Bitcoin standard over the near term unless there's some sort of
- 59:28summit like there was, you know, to get on a dollar standard
- 59:32backed by gold. But like back in the 1940s, it's
- 59:36just not necessarily how it's going to work, unfortunately,
- 59:39despite my my wishes. Yeah.
- 59:41And I think The thing is it goes further than that.
- 59:44It's like, I don't want to say Bitcoin can't succeed without
- 59:48gold, but it's it's friend because it's very hard.
- 59:53I, I can't imagine most people will come to Bitcoin being money
- 59:56in 100% allocation without going through gold and understanding
- 59:59how gold is money. Because I, I can't rashly
- 1:00:02understand how somebody would say, OK, well, I'm all in to the
- 1:00:05end state without understanding the story, how the story was
- 1:00:08formed to be like this is the end of the story, right?
- 1:00:11Like his gold is money. You have to understand where
- 1:00:14sound money fit into the kind of like past 100 to, you know, 1000
- 1:00:19years. And so gold doing what it does
- 1:00:23is not only important for older generations and individuals that
- 1:00:28understand it, it's also key to like the market structure and
- 1:00:33how you will build out the bit. The the most simple framing is
- 1:00:36you can't print more gold. You know, it's called alchemy,
- 1:00:40like it's never been done before.
- 1:00:42You know, they talk about it and it's the same thing as quantum.
- 1:00:45People will say, oh, you can like make it in a lab, but it's
- 1:00:47not economically viable. In the same way that
- 1:00:50counterparty risk is important with gold, where it sits.
- 1:00:53And people will recognize that and all the different like
- 1:00:55constructs of like where gold failed.
- 1:00:58And so I think that's important because everything else not only
- 1:01:03has these inferior qualities to it as far as kind of the supply,
- 1:01:12but then ultimately people will start to wake up to everything
- 1:01:17outside of gold and BTC. But even gold and Bitcoin from a
- 1:01:19price perspective are derivatives of how much money is
- 1:01:23injected into the system. So everyone's trading around S&P
- 1:01:28bonds, private equity, private credit, land, everything else,
- 1:01:32but the wrong base currency is either gold or Bitcoin because
- 1:01:36both of them have outperformed every other asset.
- 1:01:39And once individuals start recognizing that, they'll get to
- 1:01:41see everything we talked about in the beginning of the show and
- 1:01:44in general portfolio construction as inferior because
- 1:01:48none of it stacks up. But that's the whole like that's
- 1:01:51basically the gap where we have for the next X number of years
- 1:01:55is most people still look at gold and Bitcoin as investments
- 1:01:58versus savings. And it's not until the mental
- 1:02:02mind chef mindset shifts. And I think it will happen
- 1:02:05sooner than we believe, at least from a savings perspective,
- 1:02:08because inflation will continue to persist.
- 1:02:11It's structural that it has to only accelerate.
- 1:02:15And so that's also ties into the blind spot.
- 1:02:18It's less the blind spot is necessarily not necessarily
- 1:02:20important for an individual. They just want to stack a bunch
- 1:02:22of Bitcoin and go about their their life unless maybe
- 1:02:24something crazy happens. You want a little bit in gold,
- 1:02:27but I think it matters if you're building or if you want to talk
- 1:02:29about where we're going. Like it's very hard to be taken
- 1:02:32seriously if you can't recognize that gold will play a very
- 1:02:36serious position in the same way that we won't get to where we're
- 1:02:39going, where everyone holding a plastic device with their money
- 1:02:41on it. Like these are just like tropes
- 1:02:43that were built into people that didn't fully understand, kind of
- 1:02:46like how the world works and how finance works.
- 1:02:49And I'm bullish like this next cycle, people just recognizing
- 1:02:52that it's not that one is, you know, superior.
- 1:02:55It's not that one superior to the other.
- 1:02:57It's just that people have different preferences and
- 1:02:59there's different types of market structure that require
- 1:03:02different things. And yeah, because the
- 1:03:06alternative has been like the crypto people leading the way
- 1:03:08and they don't understand anything with gold and Bitcoin,
- 1:03:11and that's also not a viable path.
- 1:03:13I mean, the other, the other flavor of this transition in my
- 1:03:17mind is like, you know, moving from being a perceived as a
- 1:03:23hedge and moving towards like becoming a core allocation.
- 1:03:27So like historically, gold in tratify circles was, you know,
- 1:03:32with, with some exceptions, obviously, but like by and
- 1:03:35large, you know, my, my prior firm didn't have any gold
- 1:03:39exposure. And if you did, it was a very
- 1:03:42small amount. And it was perceived as this
- 1:03:45like hedge, like almost this doomer hedge that if the world
- 1:03:48blows up, you want to have a little bit of gold.
- 1:03:51And I think people perceive Bitcoin in a similar light as a
- 1:03:55hedge. I think the real transition over
- 1:03:57the next decade or so is, you know, as inflation persists and
- 1:04:02you know, more people recognize it for what it really is.
- 1:04:06As the the fiscal situation continues to deteriorate, the
- 1:04:10shift is going to be, you know, or that that transition is
- 1:04:13really going to be people moving away from like, oh, this is just
- 1:04:16a nice little hedge in the portfolio to like, no, this is,
- 1:04:19this is just sound money. And you want that to be the
- 1:04:21bedrock of your portfolio, you know, at least 40% like
- 1:04:25something along those lines. And so that that's like the real
- 1:04:30sort of monetary order shift that's playing out at a higher
- 1:04:34level is like, well, what is money?
- 1:04:35How do you actually save to your point, Michael, and like what,
- 1:04:40how should you conceive, you know, a, a well-rounded quote UN
- 1:04:44quote portfolio? It shouldn't just have 1% in
- 1:04:48this this hedge. It should be predominantly in
- 1:04:51that as as the core of it. Yeah.
- 1:04:54And I think that it's, while I think that that may happen, I
- 1:05:00think it's more likely that the founders and operators of the
- 1:05:04businesses just understand that Bitcoin or gold is actually the
- 1:05:09unit of account that they should be chasing rather than more
- 1:05:11dollars. And like a fake MUD, just start
- 1:05:13allocating a part of their treasury and savings into that
- 1:05:16harder asset rather than people just out moving completely away
- 1:05:20from stocks and going totally into the gold and Bitcoin.
- 1:05:26I just see that as slightly a more realistic path, but I could
- 1:05:32be wrong there. Yeah.
- 1:05:36No, it's fair. Maybe they happen together as
- 1:05:39well, yeah. Mike, any other thoughts on that
- 1:05:44or I did want to go to that Gort tweet that you'd shared about
- 1:05:48AI? Yeah, let's do it.
- 1:05:52So I had I had seen this original headline from Vlad and
- 1:05:57like literally laughed out loud at it.
- 1:05:59But basically this is a tweet in response to that headline from
- 1:06:03Robin Robin Hood CEO Vlad Tenev says investing for a living
- 1:06:07could replace labor in a post AI world.
- 1:06:10And the the quote tweet says this is extremely bizarre.
- 1:06:15There's some weird illogical belief that once in parentheses,
- 1:06:19if AI can perform the vast majority of jobs, all of a
- 1:06:22sudden the only place real humans will have an edge is in
- 1:06:25financial markets. Does that sound rational?
- 1:06:27Like AI will be a better plumber and Uber driver and brain
- 1:06:30surgeon than any human, but you'll you'll be able to invest
- 1:06:33better than AI. That will be your new job.
- 1:06:35You're an investor now. You just sit around and invest
- 1:06:37shit all day. It goes on, but but you get the
- 1:06:40gist. Michael, what were your thoughts
- 1:06:42on this? I mean, I just thought like it
- 1:06:46doesn't obviously I don't think anybody listening or surprises
- 1:06:49from blood and the notion of investing for a living could
- 1:06:54replace labor in a post world because of course you could just
- 1:06:56create value for nothing. I think I think that the core
- 1:07:02notion is it's really just this understanding of all the faulty
- 1:07:06assumptions based on everything that's being delivered to us,
- 1:07:10whether it's the tempo stuff or what we've been talking about
- 1:07:13the traditional markets that that it's just crept so much
- 1:07:19into the the amount of inorganic capital, the cost of capital,
- 1:07:26but the amount of monetary units has been directly correlated to
- 1:07:30effectively clown world. And I think we like it goes back
- 1:07:34to where I have the problem with taking like the Fed speak and
- 1:07:38all the things we know. Like if you just close your
- 1:07:40eyes, you know, they have to print more.
- 1:07:41You should be long hard assets. It's this notion of all this
- 1:07:44other stuff is noise surrounded based on the underlying
- 1:07:47fundamentals are completely broken.
- 1:07:49And this is just a symptom of it right here.
- 1:07:53And this is like what's they're preparing for.
- 1:07:55And it's where the proliferation of gambling and there's it's
- 1:07:59it's not a coincidence that the Poly markets and the calories of
- 1:08:08the world. And now that's the hot VC trade
- 1:08:11was in the prediction markets. And then there's the perpetual
- 1:08:15futures, which is the new innovation.
- 1:08:16It's just more gambling, more spend.
- 1:08:19And it's just really keep that lens when you look at all this
- 1:08:22stuff because there is signal, there is opportunity, but it's
- 1:08:25not from Fortune and it's not from the Robin Hood CEO.
- 1:08:30Yeah, this was pretty like bleak dystopian outlook.
- 1:08:35Like if you truly believe what Vlad is saying here, like that,
- 1:08:39well, it it doesn't make any sense on his face.
- 1:08:41But like if it were to be true, like that's super dystopian, a
- 1:08:45very sad environment. If like everyone's just in their
- 1:08:48pods, you know, on their Robin Hood app degen trading like the
- 1:08:52this nihilist future of like, but like it's completely
- 1:08:55illogical in that it would like replace later.
- 1:08:57Like I don't even know what he means by that.
- 1:08:59There's a, there's a theme that we've been discussing a bunch or
- 1:09:03before and it tied into what you were sharing about gold and it's
- 1:09:09the notion of it never sat right for 15 years.
- 1:09:13The market wouldn't talk about or reconcile that Bitcoin was
- 1:09:17the best performing asset in the same way that for the past X
- 1:09:21number of years, anybody with a brain is known, bonds have been
- 1:09:25negative, yielding and underperforming, but nobody
- 1:09:27talks about either. 1 And it, and it kind of stems from there
- 1:09:31is a, a function, a like a, a substrate of culture, the
- 1:09:36zeitgeist that shapes these things.
- 1:09:38And my base case was when sovereigns, because sovereigns
- 1:09:42are really dictating a lot of this and what they do.
- 1:09:46And so when you see them stacking gold and the gold price
- 1:09:48move out of the bands that it's been kind of held in for, for
- 1:09:50decades, that that would be the Canary in the coal line of the,
- 1:09:54the, you know, showing that the emperor has no clothes and sort
- 1:09:59of speak that Bitcoin gold hard assets are the thing.
- 1:10:03Like it'll take time, but point being is these narratives with
- 1:10:08AI and trade and AI is another example why I'm bringing this up
- 1:10:11because the amount of capital spent on AI in data centers has
- 1:10:15has been incredible. Yes, no, I, I, I know where
- 1:10:21you're getting at. I had a podcast guess.
- 1:10:26We got a new guest on the show. Liam, did you have any any
- 1:10:33thoughts on? Anyway, that was a basic
- 1:10:34premise. Star was the AI Stuff like AI is
- 1:10:36another example of I think everyone's talking about how it
- 1:10:40was like this nice vacuum in 21 as the market and interest rates
- 1:10:43crept up for people or 22 for people.
- 1:10:46There was all these pockets that needed to move around, get
- 1:10:49marked up. Because when you think about
- 1:10:50portfolios and the amount of markups and valuations these
- 1:10:52companies have had, and I think there's no shortage of jokes
- 1:10:55with open AI and the amount of money they raise.
- 1:10:56And they don't even know to like reconcile and forecast amount of
- 1:11:00depreciating losses they have, whether it's in the data centers
- 1:11:02they invest in. And then what you've seen what
- 1:11:04like D Seek and others are going to naturally do.
- 1:11:07I don't think it's common consensus that these type of
- 1:11:09large LLMS will be the long standing winner when it comes to
- 1:11:13like AI. But nobody talks about it.
- 1:11:16They're just like, oh, it's cool.
- 1:11:17We're we're doing hundreds of billions of dollars in
- 1:11:19investment. But I think the market
- 1:11:21understands like that's going to be destroyed capital and whose
- 1:11:23money is that? Nobody talks about it the same
- 1:11:25way anybody talks about negative yielding bonds, yet fully in
- 1:11:29gold and Bitcoin being the the trades of the future.
- 1:11:33Yeah, I think this is kind of related, but have you guys seen
- 1:11:35this chart of of open AI ChatGPT usage and basically just showing
- 1:11:41as right when schools and college ended, like usage just
- 1:11:45dropped off the Cliff. Like it's it's sort of aligned
- 1:11:48with what you're saying. Like there's all this spend, but
- 1:11:50what is the real value being created?
- 1:11:52I think that's still very up in the air if the vast majority of
- 1:11:56usage for, you know, chat CBT is just people using it for school
- 1:11:59and you know, writing papers like that, that doesn't seem
- 1:12:02like super value add. It actually seems like value
- 1:12:04destructive if like people aren't learning and they're just
- 1:12:07using the tools like that's the the primary use case is is
- 1:12:10homework. Like that's not great.
- 1:12:12Yeah. It's just sad because I mean a
- 1:12:15lot of the things that we've talked about today are just
- 1:12:17value destructive, whether it's creating perpetual futures or
- 1:12:21the Robin or the cow she's or you know, options trading on
- 1:12:25Robin Hood, etcetera. But those right now are where a
- 1:12:29lot of the capital is going rather than just ignoring just
- 1:12:32the sound money thesis that that we know is going on at the same
- 1:12:36time. But it's just not necessarily
- 1:12:38where all the capital is chasing right now.
- 1:12:41Yeah. Well said.
- 1:12:44All right boys. Might be a good place to wrap
- 1:12:47any final thoughts. No, outside of next week, we'll
- 1:12:53all be in Nashville. So if anybody's listening wants
- 1:12:55to get together, we'll be meeting with clients, investors
- 1:12:59face to face and then having a few events.
- 1:13:01So shoot us a note, reach out the Tuesday to Saturday.
- 1:13:06There's a bunch of things going on, Bitcoin parks, throwing a
- 1:13:09summit and then there's imagine if conference they're throwing
- 1:13:12with arc. We will all be there.
- 1:13:15Actually have a random amount of on ramp hats from Bitcoin 2024
- 1:13:22that are really nice. So if anybody's around, shoot us
- 1:13:27a note. We'll we'll save a hat for you.
- 1:13:29I think I have like 20 or 30. So yeah.
- 1:13:34Alrighty. Thanks gentlemen.
- 1:13:36See you next week. Thanks guys.
- 1:13:39Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:13:42If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:13:44episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:13:47app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:13:49today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:13:51Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:13:54for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:13:57nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:14:00Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:14:02to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:14:06to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:14:09advisors.