Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 13 – The American Dream Lives at WonkyFolk
Transcript
- 0:02Jed: Hello, Andy and Nina.
- 0:04Great to see you guys.
- 0:05Hey, good morning, Jed.
- 0:06Hey, Nina.
- 0:07Thanks for being with us.
- 0:08Nina: Well, thank you so much for having me.
- 0:10Andy: Yeah, we've been looking forward to this one.
- 0:12Jed: Yeah, this one's pretty special to have you here to celebrate, you know,
- 0:17just an amazing amount of accomplishment.
- 0:20Maybe we should just make you squirm a little bit here at the beginning, Nina,
- 0:24by just, you know, saying incredible things about the contribution you've
- 0:30made over recent years, you'd be too modest to say things yourself,
- 0:34but, you know, let me start dive in first, Andy, if that's all right,
- 0:38you know, and you can pile on right.
- 0:41But, Nina what you've done over the last 11 years has just been astounding and
- 0:48I think also a lot of people just don't appreciate just the amount of contribution
- 0:53that you made and how difficult the challenge was when you first started.
- 0:57There were people that were saying that perhaps the National Alliance for Public
- 1:00Charter Schools would not continue as an organization, that's the baseline
- 1:05and you came in and just very quickly.
- 1:08Changed the entire narrative and got the organization on stride.
- 1:13Hires a great new team and started making better progress on federal advocacy.
- 1:17And now we're 11 years later and people don't even remember that moment.
- 1:21And meanwhile, other things, you know, through your 11 years, growing the
- 1:25CSP program to a level that's just so much higher than it ever was before.
- 1:30Navigating during a period when we've had red, blue.
- 1:34tensions as pronounced as anything that we've ever had.
- 1:38And then just building the whole strength.
- 1:40If there was any moment that showed what progress the organization had
- 1:43made, it was definitely in the spring of 2022 when the Biden administration
- 1:48announced their terrible proposed regs.
- 1:51And I mean, the alliance was there and basically.
- 1:56Turn the administration around in ways that I think will help the
- 1:59movement for many years to come.
- 2:01So at least from my standpoint, Nina, you know, just an amazing, amazing run.
- 2:07And I just want to thank you for everything that you've done Andy pile on.
- 2:11Andy: You know, I think that was, that was well said.
- 2:13Let me think things I'd add to it.
- 2:16I mean, first of all, I think you have done a fantastic job.
- 2:18Nina's done really important things.
- 2:20She's a fantastic professional, very professional, gets the job done.
- 2:24She's also the fantastic person is a great, great human.
- 2:27And it's a wonderful person, a sector and a friend and all of that.
- 2:30And so I want to call both of those out.
- 2:32I think like what stands out to me is the problem.
- 2:36The National Alliance has faced and you're totally right about the challenges when
- 2:40Nina took over, I think, and I think some of those challenges persist now
- 2:44is, everybody's always want to be kind of all things for all people, right?
- 2:48And so there's been just intense cross pressure over the years and I should say
- 2:53like by way of full disclosure I was a founding board member and I was a board
- 2:57member of the organization that was its predecessor So I have some history here.
- 3:03But people it's people have always wanted to be good cop be bad cop do really hard
- 3:09edged, you know Advocacy for charter schools be really collaborative and
- 3:12work with everybody all these things you actually No single organization
- 3:16can do and I feel like Nina has just navigated that with just a poem.
- 3:20I think most leaders would have either become like really frustrated, and
- 3:25that would have led to bad outcomes or would have simply failed at that.
- 3:28And I think that she just deserves just amazing just respect and credit for,
- 3:35not only sort of keeping that going, but actually really accomplishing
- 3:39big things despite all of that.
- 3:41And that, that when I think about that's what I'm most, impressed by as though,
- 3:47I don't think most people would have pulled off with the employment that
- 3:50she did, and she has that combination, and I said, she's a great professional,
- 3:53like just really good political skills, people, instincts, and just a deep
- 3:57commitment to improving education.
- 3:59I've known Nina for a lot longer than her education in charter school days and
- 4:05she's just deeply committed that this system can work better than it does.
- 4:08And like people who believe that and show up to work every day to try to bring
- 4:13that to life are incredibly valuable.
- 4:15So thank you, Nina.
- 4:16Nina: And thank you, Andy, you know, Jed was on the search committee that was
- 4:21involved in hiring me and Bellwether was the firm that was hired to do the search.
- 4:26So both of you played a role in bringing me here, so I appreciate your support.
- 4:31And I'm particularly grateful to Andy because our space is filled with
- 4:35all these, you know, students who graduated from Ivy League schools.
- 4:38We went to Virginia Tech and I think the Values you learn at Virginia
- 4:44Tech and schools like that certainly helped me along the way in terms
- 4:49of hard work and perseverance.
- 4:51And, yeah, and so I'm excited.
- 4:54And also, Andy, we met when you were working at A.
- 4:57S.
- 4:58A.
- 4:58Back when I was at the Heritage Foundation.
- 5:00So, the things we learned in the nineties, we could also so actually
- 5:04fit in one room and one table to talk about education reform back , all
- 5:09of that has changed over time.
- 5:11So I'm really thankful that I'm doing this with you right before the holidays.
- 5:17Andy: Yeah, I appreciate you saying that, Nina.
- 5:18I think after the last few weeks, people might decide maybe they want a few more,
- 5:22you know, good students from good state schools, land grant universities.Actually,
- 5:28we're thinking about doing an episode on some of what's going on in higher ed.
- 5:34You said an interesting thing that you said, like, we could fit in a room and
- 5:37we literally could, like, I can remember, like, a couple of Hill staffers from
- 5:41the Democrat and Republican side, Amy Wilkins, who then was at the Education
- 5:47Trust, me and Nina trying to figure out if there was sort of bipartisan
- 5:50ways through and literally we could fit in a small side room like at a
- 5:55restaurant and then education kind of became this big bipartisan thing.
- 5:59And now I think it's a little bit more back to we're probably back to smaller
- 6:03rooms and restaurants right now as we try to figure out how do you rebuild a
- 6:06more bipartisan coalition going forward.
- 6:12Jed: So, Nina, if you were going to talk about the thing that you are happiest
- 6:17about that's happened over the last 11 years or maybe one of the greatest
- 6:20accomplishments for the alliance, what would you put your finger on?
- 6:26Nina: You highlighted a few of them, Jed.
- 6:28Certainly the focus we brought to increasing the size of
- 6:31the charter schools program.
- 6:33We didn't just do it because we wanted more money in the CSP.
- 6:36If you recall, and I don't know if you were in this meeting we held early
- 6:40on, we had brought all the different stakeholders that were seeking funding
- 6:44through this federal funding program.
- 6:46So it included CMOs, a few people who were running charter associations,
- 6:52those who were tapping into credit enhancement funding and authorizers
- 6:56at the time, the program was getting about $254 million a year and everyone
- 7:02was trying to get a piece of that pie.
- 7:05So instead of focusing on that narrow pool of funding, we decided why don't we
- 7:09just try to get an increase in funding?
- 7:11And we were lucky enough to have some supporters in the house and the Senate
- 7:16who were supportive of these increases.
- 7:19So it came about through small incremental increases over time.
- 7:23I give great credit to Senator Blunt when he was heading appropriations
- 7:28for us every year, he would put the money in and usually with senators,
- 7:33you know, usually their staff are the individuals who handled these things,
- 7:37but he himself was very engaged.
- 7:39I remember running into him at a reception where he pulled me aside
- 7:42and said, you know, I'm going to do it this way and that way.
- 7:44So the fact that you had a senator who was that deeply involved
- 7:47in the work was, was great.
- 7:50And that's going to continue.
- 7:51I think so long as there is demand and interest in the program, and
- 7:54there certainly is, there is also an interest at the federal level
- 7:58to increase these funding streams.
- 7:59When you think about it, the amount of money right now, it's a 440 million.
- 8:03It's a lot more than it was before, but it's still very small compared
- 8:07to everything else that is spent at the federal level on education
- 8:11and certainly other issues.
- 8:13The other thing is the increase in the number of states that
- 8:17started to open charter schools.
- 8:19And when I started Washington state had just passed a charter law through
- 8:23their ballot process, and then that was found unconstitutional.
- 8:29So they figured out a different way to pass it through the legislature.
- 8:32These nascent markets, whenever you go into states at a late stage, they are,
- 8:37it is more difficult not just to pass the law, but also to launch the sectors.
- 8:42And so I'm.
- 8:43quite frankly, proud of the fact that since I came here, we were able
- 8:46to launch eventually in Washington State, in Alabama, in West Virginia,
- 8:51in Kentucky, although we haven't been able to open schools and just recently
- 8:55in Montana, Mississippi also passed the law, they had an earlier law that
- 9:00wasn't generating any or creating any schools and that was revamped.
- 9:04And then we also made some improvements over time in a few
- 9:08other places that had laws, but not laws that were quite effective.
- 9:13During the pandemic, though.
- 9:14I think this happened by itself, but it's a byproduct of the
- 9:18sector that we had created.
- 9:20We just released a new enrollment report that basically summarizes 300, 000
- 9:26students enrolled in charter schools over the past four years, while 1.
- 9:305 million families or students left the traditional public school system.
- 9:34That's a 9 percent increase for the charter school movement and the 3.
- 9:385 percent decrease in the district run schools.
- 9:41So parents are making decisions and leaving.
- 9:45The district run system, whether it's, you know, to a private school or
- 9:50homeschool, but if they have a charter school in their community, this is
- 9:53probably going to be the school that they first pay attention to because
- 9:56we're free, public and open to all.
- 9:59So I'm proud of the fact that it is an option that people are paying attention to
- 10:06and just think of how many more families would be in charter schools if we simply
- 10:10had more of them in our communities.
- 10:14And there are a lot of other things certainly that I can talk about
- 10:18reports that we had written, and publicity brought, attention brought
- 10:23to this diversity of the sector.
- 10:25Certainly that the studies, I mean, I would be remiss not to mention Credo's
- 10:29final analysis that came out right before, it just came out, but it's
- 10:32an analysis of data up until 2019.
- 10:36So when Mackie first started doing her research, she didn't see a lot of
- 10:40difference between District schools and charter schools, the second installment
- 10:45of her study showed some improvement.
- 10:47This last one definitely demonstrate that charters are doing something right.
- 10:52And what was really refreshing was that the longer our leaders stayed in the
- 10:56schools they were running, the better they did in terms of the service to the
- 11:00families and closing the achievement gap, raising student achievement.
- 11:05So, what else do you want?
- 11:07I mean, it's growing, it's having an impact, and it's gaining momentum.
- 11:14So I'm extremely proud of these developments over time and that the
- 11:19developments happen certainly with a lot of folks in the sector, but certainly,
- 11:23I'm proud of the fact that we were part of those discussions or leading
- 11:26those discussions in many instances.
- 11:29Andy: Let's talk about a little bit more than that.
- 11:31It's so interesting so charters like I mean, and the advocacy conversation
- 11:35is exasperating as people still use the language like of the first
- 11:39credo report rather than like a decades worth of new evidence and
- 11:44things we're learning and so forth.
- 11:46But you look, you do see that the sector seems to be getting stronger
- 11:50and qualities improving mackie on recently, we'll put that episode in the
- 11:54show notes, to talk through all that.
- 11:57So that's a little unusual.
- 11:59Usually, when things expand in the education sector, quality
- 12:02sort of regresses, at least, you know, back towards average.
- 12:07On vouchers, we're actually seeing that as these programs, these voucher
- 12:11programs become less targeted, more universal, the outcomes are, we're
- 12:15seeing, you know, weaker outcomes than you used to see with voucher programs.
- 12:20So just talk about that.
- 12:21What do you think that means for charters right now relative to other choice
- 12:24options relative to where the sector is going and relative to the work that a
- 12:29national organization, national leaders need to do and then, and state leaders.
- 12:33So that's like a three part compound questions, it's not very fair, but like
- 12:37really, really important stuff for us to think about with the sector going forward.
- 12:43Nina: Well, I lost track of the three questions, but let me answer this way.
- 12:48Andy: Quality and scale, quality and scale is going better than you thought
- 12:51and better than some other choice options.
- 12:53So how should we think about charters in that context?
- 12:56And how should we think about like what we need by way of leadership and advocacy,
- 13:00either national or state or both?
- 13:03Nina: No, I mean, that was a key point she made, which is that these management
- 13:06organizations that have had steady leadership over time, continued to make
- 13:11improvements, if they were not doing as well, they improved and became better.
- 13:18So that that's crucial.
- 13:19And it's really one of the reasons why, to some extent, some of our
- 13:22district run schools are not doing well, because you have so many
- 13:25superintendents who are coming and going and shifting priorities constantly.
- 13:29But if you keep the leadership stable, the governance of a school stable over
- 13:34time, in this particular instance, it has learned from its mistakes
- 13:38and has become better over time.
- 13:40So that's huge.
- 13:41And I think it's a great contribution actually to the education sector in
- 13:45a sense that if you just had a better governance model, you'd be able to
- 13:49resolve a lot of the issues that both from an academic standpoint and nowadays,
- 13:54also from a political standpoint.
- 13:56Now, with all that said, the pandemic was a mess.
- 14:00I mean, our test scores and that of a lot of other schools are
- 14:03just not where they need to be.
- 14:05One of the things that the pandemic also demonstrated is the value of what
- 14:09our educators were doing by simply having students in our schools, the
- 14:13expanded school day school year, the fact that they were a second parent
- 14:17to a lot of these students became more apparent to us as a sector, the human
- 14:22touch element was really important.
- 14:24And so we all need to focus on that and make sure we gain the
- 14:27momentum that was lost pre pandemic.
- 14:30And quite frankly, the other thing that we need to do is create new schools in
- 14:34states like Arkansas, the governor of Arkansas made a sweeping set of changes to
- 14:39its charter law that allow now for charter schools to open throughout the state.
- 14:43I don't know who is opening schools in Arkansas, but there are these
- 14:46new places that are ripe in terms of opportunities and we need leaders and
- 14:52individuals who can come and hit the ground running and learn from those who
- 14:57have been doing this for a long time.
- 14:59So the fact that we've been demonstrating we can scale with quality pre pandemic
- 15:07tells me that we can do it again, but it's just a matter of keeping that
- 15:11momentum and attracting new people who are interested in opening schools
- 15:16and teachers who are interested in teaching in our schools going forward.
- 15:21Jed: Serving for I've been saying it's 11 years.
- 15:24Is it 11 or is it 10?
- 15:25Or is it 10 and a half?
- 15:26Is it right in that area?
- 15:28Nina: A little over 11 years.
- 15:30Jed: Oh, it's 11 years.
- 15:30Okay, good.
- 15:31So I was right then.
- 15:32Alright, so serving 11 years, there's a long time there to learn and change,
- 15:38and I know at CCSA some of the things I was thinking in my 10th year I would
- 15:42look back and what I was thinking about in the 1st and 2nd year was like, oh
- 15:45my gosh.I had no idea what I was doing.
- 15:49Can you just point to a couple of things that you thought might be the case when
- 15:53you were in the 1st and 2nd year and by, you know, the 10th and 11th year you're
- 15:57really thinking something different?
- 16:02Nina: Well, look, I mean, when I came to this and you were on our board for a long
- 16:06time Jed, so you were with me on this.
- 16:08There was a lot of focus at the federal level, leveraging federal
- 16:11powers to its max and making sure that we were closing the achievement gets
- 16:18sending kids to and through college.
- 16:20I think a lot of focus on college and it wasn't something that I necessarily did.
- 16:25But I think the sector over time began to understand the importance
- 16:31of sending students to schools that fit their needs rather than to an
- 16:35elite school that they may not be able to graduate from or graduate
- 16:38with a huge debt, the focus on CTE.
- 16:41I think a lot of these things changed also our focus from as an entity
- 16:45that was leading on the policy front.
- 16:48But the thing that I wish I had paid a little bit more attention to, and
- 16:53it was happening on its own, but it's sort of the state dynamics.
- 16:55So we have a model law.
- 16:57We rank states based on those laws on we jump in those places where no one else
- 17:03is around to pass a law or improve a law.
- 17:07We haven't played an active role in those places, where others are involved,
- 17:13we're servant leaders in some respects.
- 17:16So we go in if we're asked to help, we don't jump in on our own to do anything.
- 17:20And that's actually a good thing.
- 17:22But over time, though, some of these inconsistencies have harmed our ability
- 17:27to grow or have had an impact on student achievement and I wish that I could
- 17:33have found a way to better help the sector in those states where there were
- 17:38opportunities to seize or threats to mitigate and right now philanthropy also
- 17:45more focused on this, which is great, but they're also only in certain places.
- 17:51So it's great to try to take some sectors from good to great and create
- 17:55these beacons of hope and opportunity to demonstrate the value proposition
- 17:59of charter schools in certain markets, but as an advocacy organization as
- 18:04a political force, I don't know of a lot of other movements that are just
- 18:08focused on doing certain things in certain communities to create these great
- 18:12proof points and ignoring other places.
- 18:15So that's the one thing that I wish I had focused on more, but it's not
- 18:20too late and hopefully the next leader will be able to seize and do more
- 18:24in some of these other communities.
- 18:29Jed: What's been the biggest surprise?
- 18:31Nina: Well, this is not a surprise.
- 18:41I mean, those of us who've been dabbling in politics are not surprised
- 18:44by this, but I've been surprised at the level of, I can naivete to some
- 18:49extent around the politics of education and charter schools in particular.
- 18:54I mean, once, if you have an impact, you're going to get pushback, your
- 18:59pushback is a sign of your effectiveness.
- 19:02But I have been surprised at how people see the pushback as a sign of
- 19:08weakness or a sign that we're not doing something well or something right.
- 19:11And I think it's important to be really clear on what is it that
- 19:15you need to fix and you need to do your dirty laundry behind closed
- 19:19doors to address those issues.
- 19:20There are certainly a lot of things that are need to be addressed in our sector,
- 19:23but I have, you know, I think a lot of our leaders are just here to run great
- 19:29schools and the politics and the noise is not attractive to them, which is
- 19:34as it should be, most people teaching are not here to be in the field of
- 19:39politics or to pay attention to politics.
- 19:42But this is a political system.
- 19:43And as Shabar likes to say, if you don't like it, go run a private school.
- 19:47So I wouldn't go that far.
- 19:49But I do think I am sometimes taken aback as to how certain things that
- 19:53are really come to me naturally in terms of what you need to do to fight
- 19:57back, require far more attention and handholding and funding in some instances.
- 20:04I mean, if something bad is, if a good story is happening nowadays,
- 20:07you have the opportunity to tape it with your phone and publicize it
- 20:11through so many different mediums.
- 20:13And but that doesn't come naturally to most of us.
- 20:16And I think the process of getting most, more of our leaders engaged in
- 20:21the political discussions to get them to register to vote, to make sure that
- 20:25they're showing up to defend what they do or proactively push for it before
- 20:31they're elected officials, that's just taken more time and something that
- 20:35in some instances we should have paid more attention to at the beginning.
- 20:39Andy: Is that because people are just naturally conflict averse, do you think,
- 20:43or, like, I've noticed some of our funders, they make their money they do
- 20:48everything that you're talking about in terms of being very aggressive in the
- 20:51political and regulatory space and all that, and then, in their philanthropic
- 20:55life, they don't want to have to do that.
- 20:57And so they want everything to be collaborative, but as you point
- 21:00out, this is a political space.
- 21:02So is it that?
- 21:03Is it just people are again?
- 21:05People are naturally conflict averse.
- 21:07Is it something about education?
- 21:08Generally speaking, people in education, they don't want to fight.
- 21:11You know, people are here on all sides of these issues, they
- 21:14want to try to do right by kids.
- 21:16So like, why is that?
- 21:17Because I totally agree with you.
- 21:19And it's a very interesting dynamic.
- 21:21Do you like to just take that like one more click down like,
- 21:25Why do you think that is?
- 21:29Nina: Andy, I know you have an answer to this, too, since you
- 21:31think about these issues every day.
- 21:35For many of us, as those who are, students of this movement and a lot of
- 21:42the researchers and academics in this movement, the data was really important
- 21:47and there was a perception by a lot of the individuals who were involved.
- 21:50We're investing in in in this system that if you just showed up with the
- 21:54data, if you could just prove that this model works and that you are able to
- 21:58close the achievement gap, that would have that would be the tipping point
- 22:02that would then make everything else fall into place, other public schools
- 22:07would join hands and emulate it.
- 22:09This would be the case again, if the politics were not part of the mix.
- 22:14Of course, that didn't happen.
- 22:15And in fact, in those places where we had the best evidence, that's when the
- 22:20opposition fought back even harder.
- 22:22I mean, look at Massachusetts, that ballot initiative, that We were trying
- 22:25to pass was grounded only on lifting the cap in those schools that had waitlists
- 22:31in Boston in a very narrow market that was serving black and brown students,
- 22:36and the opposition made it seem that this would take money away from all these
- 22:40suburban schools and take arts and sports from all these other public schools.
- 22:44So, yes, I mean, I think the fact that we thought the evidence.
- 22:48It's in and of itself would be enough to convince the opposition that
- 22:52this is a good thing or to catapult the kind of systemic change in the
- 22:55traditional public school system.
- 22:58Maybe you call it naive, but from a funding side, though, and I don't
- 23:03blame philanthropists for this.
- 23:04They want to go in deep, do something big in one place,
- 23:09but then if it doesn't happen.
- 23:11You know, in our space, you just need to do it consistently over a long
- 23:16period of time until you see results.
- 23:17So if it's just one effort, on a given day, chances are, even if it
- 23:24sticks, it might go backwards after a while if it's a political win.
- 23:30Certainly you have to protect it constantly.
- 23:32So not investing in the political side of the spectrum by electing the right
- 23:38people to office by protecting those who are sticking their necks out those
- 23:43things have had a negative impact on our sector and things that certainly people
- 23:48are paying more attention to, but that has nothing to do with education and
- 23:52what's happening in schools and I think that's maybe surprised some individuals.
- 23:58And the other thing, honestly, is most of the people who are running
- 24:01charter schools who are sending their kids to charter schools are Democrats.
- 24:04And the fact that the Democratic Party in some of these instances or Democrats
- 24:08are not sticking their necks out has surprised a lot of individuals and, but
- 24:13some of that is changing and I know that once you, the great thing about our
- 24:17movement is the minute people notice a flaw, they're quick to go and address it.
- 24:21So I do think people are paying more attention to this and.
- 24:24by giving, by paying attention, hopefully we'll be able to also bring
- 24:30the resources necessary to fight back.
- 24:33Jed: You know, I'm wondering if you can give us a backstage pass
- 24:36to what it's like to lead an organization like this for 11 years.
- 24:40I know that now that I've been out of CCSA for five years, there are
- 24:45certain anecdotes that I'm telling now more to the kids and to friends.
- 24:49A lot of it just kind of fades away, but there are these moments just that seem
- 24:54to crystallize, in my memory anyway, what it was like to serve in that role.
- 24:58Do you have a couple of just anecdotes, like moments you know you're going
- 25:02to remember, you're going to be talking about with your family and
- 25:04friends for the next 30, 40 years?
- 25:10Nina: Your tenure at CCSA was very different from mine because you
- 25:13started at CCSA and it's heyday.
- 25:15You had a lot of charter schools in the space who were Funding the
- 25:20association, you had Kerry Penner and Reed Hastings on your board.
- 25:26So mine, you know, as you noted earlier, I came when the organization
- 25:30was kind of teetering and funders were not sure if they would, they
- 25:34wanted to continue supporting it.
- 25:37For me, it's felt like drinking out of a firehose the minute I started the
- 25:41work and I've loved every minute of it.
- 25:43I think the thing that I will most remember is actually the
- 25:46day we decided to go home.
- 25:49They announced that there's a pandemic and you should go home.
- 25:53You know, as a leader, I can't tell you how many years I lost in the few weeks
- 26:00that when we were home and thinking about the ramifications of the pandemic, both as
- 26:05in terms of fundraising, am I able to keep this organization running, both in terms
- 26:11of how do you serve schools, how do you make sure that these students are getting
- 26:18what you know, the resources they need.
- 26:19And again, we were not in the business of running schools, but
- 26:22what can we do at the federal level to make sure funding is available?
- 26:25And at the time we fought for both SBA loans and ESSER funds.
- 26:31So a lot of the things you had to do in that period of time were very different
- 26:35than what you were doing before.
- 26:37So I'm always going to remember those first few weeks, certainly of the pandemic
- 26:41at home, trying to figure out what this new world means and how do we leverage it.
- 26:46And I'm glad that we came out ahead and our sector certainly responded very well
- 26:51in the first few months of the pandemic.
- 26:53The rally last year where parents and educators came to fight against
- 27:02the Biden administration regulations on the charter schools program
- 27:07are definitely going to be missed.
- 27:08One of the highlights certainly, both because it demonstrated that there is
- 27:13an interest in coming to Washington to advocate for something as obscure
- 27:17as a regulation, just think about it explaining what that regulation did was
- 27:21very complicated, getting individuals who are not living our lives and are not
- 27:27thinking about rules and regulations, especially in communities that honestly
- 27:30didn't stand to benefit from CSP money.
- 27:33So the fact that they came that it got its You know, requisite publicity
- 27:38and all that was one of those moments that I'm always going to remember.
- 27:44But personally, it's the team that, works for me that I guess I'm going
- 27:50to miss the most and the day to day interactions with them that, I don't
- 27:55think there's one point in time, but I do think all the efforts that goes
- 28:00into building teams and certainly now adjusting to remote work and all that
- 28:06is, yeah, I will always remember that.
- 28:10And also making sure that the legacy of what we created continues.
- 28:15I like to tell people like we're celebrating our 20th anniversary
- 28:18next year, so in a way, I came here when the organization when it was
- 28:23in its tween and teenage years.
- 28:25Now it's officially, you know, entering adulthood.
- 28:29So hopefully it can do great things and learn from the things that's
- 28:33learned in the past and move the sector forward in a very evolving world.
- 28:46Andy: Let's stay on this point on sort of political leadership.
- 28:50You mentioned, uh, you mentioned Senator Blunt earlier.
- 28:53You've also had, you know, you had, like Senator Landreau, Mary from Louisiana.
- 28:57Tom Carper, the former governor of Delaware in the Senate, was
- 29:00a enormous leader on charters.
- 29:02Like you had, like some really bipartisan Folks who really were leaning in on this.
- 29:09Who do you see sort of as the leaders now?
- 29:13And what do we need to do?
- 29:14You talked earlier about the partisanship, like what do we need to do
- 29:17to maintain bipartisanship, especially in this time of just really intense?
- 29:22Hyperpolarization.
- 29:26Nina: So we have some great friends, some Democrats and strong Republican
- 29:30friends in the Senate, in particular this bill that we just introduced
- 29:33this summer, which opens the door for CSP money to go to educators who
- 29:37want to apply to charter schools.
- 29:39I was introduced with the support of Senator Bennett and Senator Booker,
- 29:44as well as Senator Hassan from New Hampshire and Senator Schatz from Hawaii.
- 29:48So these are all four Democrats.
- 29:51Senator Scott from South Carolina, Senator Braun from Indiana,
- 29:56Senator Cornyn from Texas.
- 29:58So, look, whenever we have an opportunity at the federal level
- 30:04to push for charter schools.
- 30:06We do have bipartisan support, but to me, the federal government is a few steps
- 30:12away from what it's a lagging indicator of certain things in some respect.
- 30:16So I would pay a lot more attention to what's happening locally and make sure
- 30:20that our local elected officials First, you're inviting them to your schools
- 30:25that they know who you are through the stories and the faces of the movement,
- 30:29that you are staying in touch with them.
- 30:31And if they're your supporters, that you are protecting them because chances
- 30:34are those elected officials are going to move to higher office and I would pay
- 30:38attention at all levels of government.
- 30:40At the mayor level, mayoral level, the city council level, state
- 30:44legislative level, governor level.
- 30:47I would move from that point up and make sure that bipartisanship
- 30:50continues to exist at every level.
- 30:53But at the federal level, look, the Senate has always been our backstop and
- 31:00it's going to continue to be that way because they're a little bit shielded
- 31:03from a lot of the ebbs and flows and the influence of a lot of interest groups.
- 31:09That's not the case everywhere, but some of our biggest supporters right now are
- 31:13not able to say they're big supporters, but they're steady hands in this process
- 31:17are Senator Murray and Senator Baldwin, these are Democrats who have also been
- 31:23supportive of the teachers unions, but they're also good on our issue.
- 31:29A house is a little different in the sense that it's just more
- 31:33volatile and you have more action.
- 31:36And in that respect, again, in the, in the house, we've had a good.
- 31:39Andy: It does seem a little volatile over there these days.
- 31:42Nina: But a lot of congressional black caucus members have been steady
- 31:47signatories of our annual charter schools grant program funding.
- 31:52And I think in that sense, if the leadership of Senator, I'm sorry, if
- 31:57Congressman Jeffries becomes the speaker, that would be quite interesting because
- 32:00he is someone who is not just familiar with the sector and has been supported
- 32:04by many of our advocates and leaders and funders, but someone who also really has a
- 32:10personal understanding of charter schools.
- 32:12So if the house flips, it will be interesting to see what Um, if his
- 32:19influence and his position will influence, uh, the party's posture on
- 32:24charter schools, what I'm most focused on, though, is the 24 elections.
- 32:28I know a lot of people want to go to sleep and wake up after it's
- 32:31over, but I do think we have to pay a lot more attention to the
- 32:35conversations that are taking place.
- 32:37A lot of these candidates are not talking policy or just using soundbites.
- 32:41But as time goes on, and as these primaries move through, it's You know,
- 32:47you know that the issue of choice is going to come up and it's going to be
- 32:50important for us to go in with the right questions and hopefully for those who
- 32:55are running for these seats to give good, solid answers to questions of
- 32:59choice, accountability and education.
- 33:02Andy: On the Republican side, have you heard any, any of the
- 33:05candidates who are particularly like compelling on these issues?
- 33:10Nina: Well, you see the same debates that I see.
- 33:12Certainly, I try
- 33:13Andy: not to see them actually.
- 33:14So that may not be that may not be
- 33:16Nina: true.
- 33:17Well, they all talk about choice and school choice is definitely a buzzword.
- 33:21The Republican Party is from a message discipline standpoint, knows how to
- 33:25use talking points very effectively.
- 33:27Um, What is sometimes disappointing is that those talking points don't
- 33:32always translate into strong policies because they tend not to be as focused
- 33:36on the federal role in education.
- 33:38That wasn't the case when, when I was working at the White House, certainly
- 33:42President Bush was Education reformer and wanted to go down in history as
- 33:46someone who impacted education policy.
- 33:48But with that said, um, on the Republican side, they all have a viewpoint on choice
- 33:54and they talk about choice broadly.
- 33:57They haven't honed in on charter schools specifically, but that's where they are.
- 34:04And Democrats haven't had debates that I know of.
- 34:06So, um, we'll see how this conversation goes.
- 34:10Jed: Is the secret to maintaining bipartisan support just not being
- 34:15perceived as veering in too far in either direction or and try to have
- 34:21some centrist orientation that's not totally offensive to either side?
- 34:27Or is it having a mix of things where like, Hey, there's an
- 34:30aspect of charterness that really resonates on the Republican side.
- 34:35Emphasize that in your engagement with Republicans and vice versa on Democrats.
- 34:39I mean, you've, you've made this look pretty effortless, Nina.
- 34:42I mean, this, when you've had Trump as your president, you have a base that had.
- 34:46very different views about all sorts of different issues.
- 34:50And you managed to keep us together.
- 34:52Um, how did you, how did you do it?
- 34:54And, and how would you recommend for us going forward to, to deal with some
- 34:59of those really vexing issues that are sure to intensify in the years ahead?
- 35:07Nina: Well, I mean, you have some experience in this too, Jed, uh, when
- 35:10you were at CCSA and, um, You know, it's important to focus on what you're
- 35:15trying to accomplish and not get too distracted by the political noise.
- 35:18So our posture has been one of just sticking to what we know how to do
- 35:22and not opine too much around issues that are not central to our work.
- 35:28Now, some would argue You know, and this is not the case just in our case
- 35:32in our in our particular business.
- 35:34I think if you if you look at, um, other sectors, there's a greater
- 35:39focus on making sure leaders are offering comments on a whole host of
- 35:43issues around their enterprise, not just what they're doing on a daily
- 35:47basis, whether it's, um, you know, and certainly it started after George Yeah.
- 35:51Floyd and it's continued.
- 35:53And really, in order to attract people to your workforce and to be seen as an
- 35:58authentic leader, there is a greater um, emphasis on being vocal and showing
- 36:05empathy and giving voice to a lot of these social issues because people don't
- 36:10feel that politicians are necessarily in a good place to represent everyone.
- 36:15Um, so my, my focus has been on focusing on, you know, getting this done.
- 36:20And even then I You know, there's certain been arguments about not
- 36:23pushing more around other things that impacted the students in our
- 36:27schools going forward, though.
- 36:29I do think it's important if you are going to dive into any of these issues
- 36:33at the federal level to understand your strengths and weaknesses first.
- 36:38And in many of these instances, if you're going to advocate for title one funding
- 36:41and school nutrition and other things, and this is what we currently do, it's much
- 36:45better to go in and coalition with other groups that know how to do that work.
- 36:50Well, for a living, then for us to try to become an expert in areas
- 36:55that are not just complicated, they're important for us for sure.
- 36:59But they're not our bread and butter.
- 37:00And so if you if you start to, you know, advocate for all these other
- 37:05things that other advocacy groups are already advocating for and
- 37:09arguably doing a better job at it.
- 37:11If you also do that, first of all, you're too small.
- 37:13So your voice is not necessarily going to register.
- 37:17Um, and it will potentially take away from the other thing that that is
- 37:21really unique to you, which is just charter school policy and politics.
- 37:25Um, but right now we're dealing with it by joining coalitions, like the
- 37:30Community on Education Funding is one of the groups that we belong to.
- 37:34Um, but there are going to be other coalitions that are going to be formed
- 37:38and we should not just be a part of it, but also in many instances, maybe
- 37:42lead the coalition and be a more active participant of it, especially if it's
- 37:47an issue that impacts our families.
- 37:53Jed: That's a really
- 37:54Andy: interesting strategy, because traditionally, a lot of those
- 37:57coalitions have been fairly hostile, cold, indifferent to hostile.
- 38:03And so that's a, I mean, that's a sign of the growing size of the Charter
- 38:08movement and in some cities, how it's instrumental in other places, how it's
- 38:13just pretty significant in terms of, uh, in terms of its size and scale.
- 38:19And so that if over the next 10 years, charters emerge in a leadership role
- 38:24across these coalitions, that does seem like it has the potential to really to
- 38:28change the politics around the issue and change how to have charters are perceived
- 38:33and make the job of this, the sort of reflexive opponents that much harder.
- 38:42Nina: Yes, I
- 38:43Jed: get to
- 38:46Andy: a place where it seems like you could have a dynamic and you're talking
- 38:49about you're talking about the Jeffrey.
- 38:51So it does seem like if you had if someone forced you to bet 1000 on to the
- 38:56next speaker, the house was going to be.
- 38:58Well, actually, I shouldn't say that because we're probably probably a
- 39:00couple more Republican speakers between now and November after the election,
- 39:05the next speaker after November, you know, it seems like things are
- 39:08lining up pretty, pretty well for him.
- 39:11And some other leaders who behind the scenes, like Patty Murray, people don't,
- 39:15you know, think of her as like a charter school champion, but, you know, she runs,
- 39:19she runs her committee pretty effectively with, um, uh, yeah, I think I forgot how
- 39:23you said it, but basically like stability and predictability around things.
- 39:28Um, so is there, is there a scenario you see where you essentially, you'll have
- 39:33all the big fighting, the people like the unions, everybody gets to have their big
- 39:36public fight, but like behind the scenes.
- 39:39Well, they'll actually be like a fairly, just, just a fair amount of
- 39:42like, you know, just path dependency for charters kind of moving forward.
- 39:45And is that a pretty, is that a pretty good outcome in the big scheme of things?
- 39:49Um, let people have their theater, but charters actually get the policy
- 39:52and the resources that they need.
- 39:55Nina: Oh, yes I do.
- 39:56I mean, I think again.
- 39:59The Senate, again, it's hard to predict a year in advance.
- 40:02I think our politics and everything that's happening is so different from
- 40:05what it's what's happened before.
- 40:07So whenever people make these broad predictions, even around the presidency
- 40:11based on today's polls, I just have to question whether you can really count
- 40:15on what people are saying right now to guess at what's going to happen next year.
- 40:20But look.
- 40:22It's the one big benefit of charter schooling is that these
- 40:26are created at the state level.
- 40:27So the federal government can have some influence and it has had influence because
- 40:31Bill Clinton started talking about charter schools on the campaign trail as an idea
- 40:36before there was any charter anywhere.
- 40:38It was just maybe one in Minnesota and he talked about it ad nauseum.
- 40:41That's highly unusual because he was a wonk and he was interested
- 40:45in ideas and education back then.
- 40:47It was cool to be an education governor.
- 40:49So he talked a lot about it.
- 40:50So it's usually not the norm for someone at the federal level and
- 40:54certainly a president to talk about something that hasn't quite started
- 40:58to brew at the state and local level.
- 41:00The fact that all of our laws are created at the state level shields it
- 41:05from any kind of federal influence.
- 41:07The thing you have at the federal level though is the bully pulpit.
- 41:10The fact that there is the charter schools grant program, which has now
- 41:13been around for quite a few years.
- 41:16When something has been around that long and has a constituency,
- 41:20it's hard to get rid of it.
- 41:21So I'm not worried about the CSP, but if you want to grow it, if you
- 41:25want to, you know, turn it into an engine that's driving, um, not the
- 41:31CSP, but if you want chartering to be part of the discussion around.
- 41:35You know, education, reform, policy, issues of economic
- 41:39revitalization, chartering and the charter school movement.
- 41:43Education can be part of a whole host of other discussions that
- 41:47our country is dealing with.
- 41:48And I would hope that whoever becomes president next and whoever is leading
- 41:53these parties pays attention to that.
- 41:56Because if you get education right, all these other problems go away.
- 42:00And certainly a lot of people in our movement are doing some really interesting
- 42:04things in their communities that go above and beyond just running a school.
- 42:07So, um, so I think regardless of who's in power, chartering is going to have
- 42:12a seat at the table, but it's going to be up to us to constantly resell
- 42:17the value proposition and be visible.
- 42:19You can't just say, okay, well, you're doing this thing really well.
- 42:22And the academic performance is good.
- 42:23And look at how many kids were graduating and assume that people at
- 42:27the federal level know who you are and what you do and how well you do it.
- 42:31So now, unless there is a huge sweep and you all of a sudden have
- 42:35a lot of, you know, and Jed was witness to that in California.
- 42:39Um, I think federal is always going to be this way.
- 42:43You may not see a lot of things happen and that's the case right now.
- 42:46Bills are not moving.
- 42:48You just, you basically.
- 42:49looking at appropriation cycles and watching the theatrics.
- 42:53Um, so anyway, I would focus most of my political energy at the state
- 42:58and local level, especially in those places where there is forward momentum
- 43:01to make positive change, bring about.
- 43:03And I would also quite frankly, pay attention to that 28th
- 43:06presidential election, because there are some formidable governors
- 43:10on both sides of the aisle who are poised to run for office then.
- 43:14And those individuals.
- 43:16Right now, if you look at them, if you were to take Shapiro, polis, you know,
- 43:21these individuals just are good on charter schools and a whole host of other issues.
- 43:26And I think by then.
- 43:31You know, we're talking about a very different world, of course, but I think
- 43:35our odds going to be better in terms of leading again at the national level.
- 43:39Andy: Yeah, I think you're right.
- 43:39The 24 elections highly consequential, but the 28 one seems much more interesting
- 43:45in terms of different theories of government and on both sides of the
- 43:48aisle, the cast of characters who might.
- 43:50Make a run for it.
- 43:51And so different governing styles and philosophies.
- 43:54Um, uh, it seems 2028 just seems much more interesting
- 43:58Nina: than the way down.
- 44:00I mean, a lot can happen between now and then, of course, but, um,
- 44:06Jed: I know we're running out of, you know, we only have
- 44:08a couple more minutes here.
- 44:09I'd love to just hear you push us on something.
- 44:12Um, is there.
- 44:14Any one area where you're, where you would say, Hey, this is what we haven't
- 44:18figured out yet, or this is what we've struggled with in the, over the last
- 44:22decade, or this is the, you know, one of the central weak spots that we need
- 44:26to improve to be able to stay on the trajectory that you're talking about here.
- 44:30Is there any place you, you push charter folk in particular?
- 44:35Nina: Um, you know, look, I do think paying attention to the pipeline of
- 44:39talent, uh, that's not something that's.
- 44:42We necessarily are involved with at the National Alliance, but you can have,
- 44:46you know, I was talking to a charter school leader in Texas after all these
- 44:52extra funds were distributed and, you know, certainly the other sources
- 44:56of funding that It's philanthropy and other entities made available.
- 44:59And I was like, okay, so what can we do to help?
- 45:01Because well, for the first time, I don't really money is not my problem.
- 45:05I just can't find people to teach in my classrooms.
- 45:08I don't have enough bus drivers.
- 45:10So, you know, this could be another piece of legislation that attracts people to
- 45:15just teach in schools and especially in needy communities and more specifically
- 45:19in innovative public charter schools.
- 45:21But I do think.
- 45:23If we want to stay at the forefront of education reform and innovation, um,
- 45:29we do need to pay attention to who are we going to attract and how quickly
- 45:33can we get them to hit the ground running in communities that are not
- 45:38as familiar to us as past communities.
- 45:41So, as I mentioned, places like Arkansas and Utah and Iowa.
- 45:45Um, so I would pay a lot more attention to that because all the
- 45:48policy and politics, I mean, these things are par for the course.
- 45:52They're always going to exist and groups like ours.
- 45:54And state associations and others are going to have to do a better
- 45:57job of mitigating the risks and leveraging opportunities.
- 46:01But on the education side, fueling the talent pipeline of the next
- 46:06generation of leaders and making sure they don't make the same
- 46:10mistakes that previous leaders have.
- 46:11And I think that the way that this is made is going to be really
- 46:13important, and I don't know who's paying attention to that right now.
- 46:19Um, and then on the political front, as I said earlier, I mean,
- 46:25I do think there is a greater need to draw dollars to C4 efforts.
- 46:32I know there's no tax deduction attached to it, but you can see the fruits
- 46:35of your labor much faster when you invest in a C4 activity, whether it's
- 46:41an election or some other political activity, and I think we need to Uh,
- 46:46do more and in many states, the cost of doing these things is not as high.
- 46:53Uh, so if you go to Mississippi, for instance, so I think paying attention to
- 46:57some of those, um, dynamics is going to be hugely helpful, especially if it's in
- 47:02service to some of our rising Democrats who are, again, sticking their necks
- 47:08out and could suffer huge consequences.
- 47:13Andy: Thank you.
- 47:13We are almost at time.
- 47:14I know you had one, you have a great, you have a great final
- 47:16question for, for Nina that I'm very interested in the answer to as well.
- 47:21Jed: I was going to ask you this, the Tim Ferriss question.
- 47:23I don't know, Nina, if you listen to Tim Ferriss at all, but he often
- 47:27asks his, his guests the billboard question at the end of his interviews,
- 47:32which is if you had a billboard.
- 47:34And you could put a, you know, a few words on something to broadcast
- 47:37out into the universe, you know, what would that billboard say?
- 47:41And it just seems like a moment to ask you a question like that.
- 47:44If there's something that you would want the charter school world to know,
- 47:48or more broadly, what, what, I mean, yes, free public and open to all.
- 47:51Okay, great.
- 47:53But beyond that, what's the, uh, do you have any just
- 47:57general message that you could.
- 48:05Nina: I think my billboard would be, you know,
- 48:16honestly, I don't, I don't mean to summarize it this way, but it's, you know,
- 48:21this is the ticket to the American dream.
- 48:24And if you want to, if you want a challenging job and have some fun
- 48:29along the way, this is the sector that you should get attracted to.
- 48:33That's too many words for a billboard.
- 48:35So I'll think about and give you a better answer.
- 48:38But the message needs to be aspirational for people to get drawn to it.
- 48:42And, and to me, this movement and everything we do is about offering the
- 48:48door to not just equitable access, but to some extent equitable outcomes in a
- 48:55way that boosts everyone into excellence and a future that's better than the
- 49:00one that they're currently living in.
- 49:02So that would be the way the billboard, which some of the words that would pop up
- 49:08and hopefully with a lot of bright colors.
- 49:11Um,
- 49:13Jed: access to access to dreams or a pathway to dreams or something
- 49:17that charter schools provide
- 49:20Nina: truly are.
- 49:21I mean, it is about fit.
- 49:23It's about bringing the potential of every child and the uniqueness of every child.
- 49:28So, um, so those are the messages that I think we need to talk
- 49:32more about and ones that resonate with just about every family.
- 49:35And when you talk to the average family, they're not interested in
- 49:38charter schools or private schools or public schools or magnet schools.
- 49:41They just want a great school.
- 49:43And I'm proud of the fact that our schools are some of the most innovative public
- 49:47schools out there that are striving to meet the unique needs of our family.
- 49:53Andy: Yeah.
- 49:53And our families still believe in the American dream.
- 49:56People in our sector, you know, spend hours in workshops debating, you know,
- 50:00whether you're supposed to talk about the American dream or not, but when you're
- 50:03actually out in communities, there's plenty of surveyed really to share has
- 50:06done work on this, to show like the, the people were serving, they believe
- 50:10in it, they want it and they deserve it.
- 50:12And I feel like Nina, your life is a little bit, you could
- 50:15have lived the American dream and the promise of this place.
- 50:18And, and so I think that was such an interesting way for you to,
- 50:21uh, Uh, and it's I just want to say thank you for your leadership,
- 50:25your commitment, your friendship.
- 50:26Like the sector is lucky to have, uh, lucky to have leaders like you.
- 50:31And I think a lot of people are excited to see what's next for you.
- 50:34Nina: Well, thank you, Andy.
- 50:36And I, yeah, no, I was just thinking about this American dream story.
- 50:42This 40th anniversary of when we moved to the United States.
- 50:46And it's also the 30th anniversary of when I became a citizen.
- 50:50Um, So that's, you know, it's a big year, not just because I'm leaving
- 50:54the National Alliance, but for those two reasons, and also the year
- 50:58that my daughter went to college.
- 50:59So a lot of change afoot and I'm excited about what's ahead.
- 51:03And I know that whatever I do, I'll still be in touch with both
- 51:07of you and hopefully get back on.
- 51:10Wonky folk one
- 51:11Andy: day.
- 51:12Yeah.
- 51:12Well, we'd love you're welcome back anytime you have a standing invitation.
- 51:16That
- 51:16Jed: would be great.
- 51:18All right.
- 51:18Thank you so much, Nina.
- 51:19Uh, and both of you guys have great holidays.
- 51:22I look forward to talking to you guys soon.
- 51:23Andy: Yeah.
- 51:24You will be back in the new year.
- 51:25Bye.
- 51:27Nina: Bye bye.
- 51:28Bye bye.