Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E041: Nobody Puts Bitcoin in a Corner with Mark Connors
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation
- 1:10as we prepare for the Bitcoin having and the next wave of
- 1:13global adoption of this nascent and growing asset class.
- 1:16We are having all annual maintenance fees for clients
- 1:19that secure their wealth before the next Bitcoin epoch.
- 1:23What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:27we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 1:30excrement ever assembled in the history of Gutless
- 1:361974198792972000. And whatever we want to call
- 1:41this, It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:44We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:51when we sell. And we're Ninja launching Mark
- 1:58Connors. Welcome back to the show.
- 1:59You have an on the ground update from a CNBC Digital asset
- 2:03conference. What's going on on the ground?
- 2:05Hey, Marty. Yeah, so CIBC was kind enough to
- 2:09invite me. It's Chatham House Rules.
- 2:12So we can talk about sort of coming into the conference.
- 2:16But what we're what we're clearly seeing in Canada through
- 2:21the lack of movement by the regulator banks is they're not
- 2:27changing anytime soon. They're committed to be
- 2:28custodians. They see the need for it.
- 2:33And I think when you look at incentive structures, if you
- 2:39want to look at what's going to happen the next year or two,
- 2:41it's all in the US what the legislate, what the judicial,
- 2:47what the courts did with that August 29th decision is still
- 2:50the biggest boon for the industry.
- 2:53Judge Rouse saying SEC you're wrong, it's unlawful and then
- 2:57you have what is it guys? Is it?
- 3:00It's over 50 billion now in USETFSI think.
- 3:07What it sounds correct to me I. Think it's 700,000 BTC?
- 3:10We don't we. Don't look at those.
- 3:13You can tell you're you're digitally native, Michael.
- 3:16You're like dollars. Come on man that's like Boomer
- 3:19talk you you talk coins. So yeah so as as everyone knows
- 3:24I'm in I'm in Canada. I'm a my firm's Canadian ETF and
- 3:30and closing fund provider and we we're here because when I left
- 3:35KREZ Swiss, I left before it it did it's swan dive.
- 3:41There weren't many places in the US to be ahead of research and
- 3:44this guy Fred Pipe Pierce The Veil in Canada got a spot of fun
- 3:48going and that was it. Since then Canada has not had
- 3:52constructive regulatory easements for the products.
- 3:57So that's what a lot of people in Canada are saying is what's
- 4:01the next killer app tokenization, is not it right
- 4:04now stable coins probably. And really it's adoption of the
- 4:11of the spot product and and the still slow appreciation that
- 4:17Bitcoin is a very different animal that just needs to be
- 4:22taken in in its native state. That's that's what I think the
- 4:27last three months of my tours of US and Canada has has gotten me
- 4:32to is it still is really you know Bitcoin and then you know
- 4:36as you know everyone's saying looking at Ethereum, but that's
- 4:39the scoop. The scoop is I think banks are
- 4:43not incentivized, doors are closed for now and it's going to
- 4:48be by the incentivized asset managers that are watching
- 4:51margins go down that are taking on.
- 4:54I mean record guys like we had not 13,000 coins to pull from
- 5:01Michael to follow your lead on on talking in in in bitcoins in
- 5:06inflows yesterday alone is that I think that was the right
- 5:08number. Yep, well it was.
- 5:11BlackRock had 1213 thousand in in Bitcoin inflows alone.
- 5:16It was net because of the GBT. Pull the.
- 5:19Chart up. It was like 10,000 net.
- 5:24Yeah, which, you know, I ran the math on.
- 5:26It was 11 times more than the Bitcoin mined yesterday.
- 5:33Yes. And then we had that that flush
- 5:35out of just the speculators, right.
- 5:37That was probably a, you know that we're going to have.
- 5:41Yeah that was that was probably that was the traders in my
- 5:44opinion that was the trader the, the the crypto native traders
- 5:48stepping in to do what they always do at the, you know, when
- 5:51a previous all time high happens which is sell because there's
- 5:55going to be a whole you know preponderance of leverage.
- 5:59Too many leverage longs, late longs that are just you know
- 6:04fish in a barrel for for cascading, you know liquidation
- 6:10if if they can get some cell momentum to the downside.
- 6:13We also saw that there were some blocks, some Bitcoin that was
- 6:17mined in 2010 like collectively like 400 Bitcoin that hadn't
- 6:22moved since then was sold right, right when we hit the previous
- 6:27all time high at 69,000. So you know that's some early
- 6:33enthusiast deciding that they regretted not selling at 69,000
- 6:37a few years ago and they were going to take it when that price
- 6:40came. So you know just like a a shift
- 6:42in in dynamics towards the the sell side because of because of
- 6:49the baggage that people have carried over the last few years
- 6:52and the pattern that has happened at when we breach
- 6:54previous all time highs and you know that has always happened.
- 6:59There's always additional sellers who step in because they
- 7:01regret not selling three years earlier.
- 7:03Yeah, which? And that's what we saw.
- 7:06Natural and healthy, Mark, I'm curious on like the relentless
- 7:09bid because you know these natural market forces, right, we
- 7:13see the liquidations, but to go back and I don't even know what
- 7:15it hit like 61,000 and to see it back close to 68 already.
- 7:19Yeah, it's just it's. Pretty insane. 59 three or so.
- 7:23So we had a a negative $10,000 swing for the for the first time
- 7:29ever in one day. I think it was the. 2nd order
- 7:32of. Liquidations, right?
- 7:34In history? Like out a billion?
- 7:35A little over a billion. Wasn't even one day.
- 7:37It was 5 hours. Yeah.
- 7:40I, I saw the chart of the like the amount of leverage in the
- 7:45system basically just got reset entirely like the the, the
- 7:48amount of leverage longs got wiped out to like healthy
- 7:52levels. And then we, to Michael's point,
- 7:54we've closed 2/3 of that gap already and now have like a like
- 7:59a totally reset healthy level of leverage in the system, so.
- 8:06Yeah, our trader relayed that over the past I think 10 days
- 8:11there's something called the funding rate.
- 8:12So to the viewers out there, everyone's focused on the ETFs
- 8:15which is wrapped spots. So that's good.
- 8:19We like ETFs as far as a product and if you can't natively own it
- 8:26you know the the asset like through on ramp the at least
- 8:30it's not paper Bitcoin it's it's it's wrapped in paper but it has
- 8:33to be a actual Bitcoin behind it that's one buyer or fund flows
- 8:37we're talking about. Then there are folks on chain
- 8:40like the 2010 minted Bitcoin that was sold that Jesse just
- 8:46mentioned and this. And then besides retail there's
- 8:49a fourth buyer or player called the speculative long that
- 8:52usually uses these preferreds and they borrow.
- 8:56They do a basis trade they'll they'll borrow and sell short
- 9:00the preferred which or future which trades at a premium and
- 9:04then they'll buy the Bitcoin and they'll and they'll play the
- 9:07collapse. The funding rates went from 15
- 9:10to 30 to over 100% annualized because of the demand.
- 9:15People thinking saying listen I'm just going to be in it for
- 9:17an hour or three hours, it's going up.
- 9:20I'll make my money. So when you get triple digit
- 9:22funding rates, that's that's a telltale sign that you're a
- 9:25speculative market. Yeah, and and that's what's been
- 9:30totally reset now with all of those guys getting wiped out,
- 9:34the late longs. Like when when we were starting
- 9:37to breakthrough 69 and it looked like there was no resistance
- 9:39there at all and we were surely about to run to 8090 A hundred.
- 9:44Those late longs are the ones that get punished.
- 9:47Yep, rock. It's it's fascinating.
- 9:51We learned this lesson and and and for anybody who's listening
- 9:53out there, this is particularly pronounced in the world of
- 9:58Bitcoin because there are exchanges that let you take
- 10:00obscene amounts of leverage that people get access to, whether
- 10:04it's bit Max. And there are many others by bit
- 10:07around the world that people who want to go 100 X long Bitcoin
- 10:12can do so. So a lot of that that happened
- 10:15on these exchanges. Mark we had a great conversation
- 10:19earlier in the week catching up and and it was awesome to hear
- 10:22kind of your excitement to get on the road and go talk to
- 10:25people face to face would love to you know anything you want to
- 10:28share as far as like our conversation and just like
- 10:30what's happening in the in the streets as far as individuals
- 10:32interests the ETF, well we know the banks aren't coming or at
- 10:36least aren't coming for a while. Just anything that's happening
- 10:40out there, I think we'd love to hear about.
- 10:43Sure. And when when I say the banks, I
- 10:45mean we we expect maybe on the asset management side some of
- 10:49the some date they may allow it given it's an ETF wrap.
- 10:53But on the infrastructure side, you know the, the incentive to
- 10:56have a couple $100 billion on a you know trillion plus balance
- 11:00sheet that has a still not blessed regulatory mandate on it
- 11:09may you know may be difficult. So our discussion was basically
- 11:14saying all we got from our November, October, November
- 11:20roadshow where we said that the ETF is probably coming.
- 11:24And here are 8 questions you're going to get from your clients
- 11:28about Bitcoin. And here are the answers.
- 11:32We we got about four or five responses.
- 11:35We got a few people who did buy, but we got out of 25 meetings,
- 11:38four or five responses saying great call and we share that.
- 11:43Not to say we failed or anything else, but just it's still not
- 11:47registering with people. So this demand that's coming
- 11:51from you know the likes of BlackRock and Fidelity and
- 11:56Bitwise and Arc etcetera is I think driven internally whether
- 12:02it's bring your own assets and they're thrown into funds or
- 12:05it's sovereign wealth or it's not a broad base of clients by
- 12:09any stretch. It's actually just deposit that
- 12:13we talked about it last week about that and that's actually
- 12:17anecdotally heard sovereigns stepping in, but then also have
- 12:21heard from large scale Bitcoin holders that want to access the
- 12:26traditional financial markets about parking Bitcoin there so
- 12:28they can use like debt from when it comes to like financing other
- 12:32products in the like the regular economy or just banking system.
- 12:36So there's a lot of like that that I don't think is basically
- 12:39pent up interest that was built for the past like let's call it
- 12:4312 months before the ETF was launched versus like net new
- 12:45people coming in because the the ETF like they heard about and
- 12:48they like can buy it because I don't think a lot of that's even
- 12:50like turned on yet. So what you're saying, Michael,
- 12:54is that by by switching from say physical to to the ETF and
- 13:00leaving it in the fidelity of BlackRock that they can with
- 13:05commingled assets, they can get leverage on it or they can
- 13:08borrow against it or they can exactly.
- 13:10What you're saying, Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 13:11That's like One Ave. that I've heard and I don't know how big
- 13:14of it, a big of a percentage it is now, but to be able to use it
- 13:20as a financial product to lend against basically the ETF
- 13:22shares. I know you can do that at
- 13:25certain advisors in Canada with the ETF I don't have.
- 13:32I don't have Intel about Fidelity and BlackRock, but I
- 13:34know it is possible. Not at banks, but at brokerages
- 13:38in Canada that they will give you Reg T that's not their Reg,
- 13:41it's US, but a 2 to one leverage on your digital assets you can
- 13:46borrow against. And and and even if it's you
- 13:50know even if it's just a Black Rock and the like pointings
- 13:54their their clients getting them to reallocate internally from
- 14:00other assets into to get a little bit of a Bitcoin exposure
- 14:05for their existing clients. I mean BlackRock has 10 trillion
- 14:09something like that of assets under management and you know it
- 14:16yesterday we had $700 million of net inflows from the ETFs most
- 14:22of which was from BlackRock. Let's say it's, it's all, let's
- 14:24say it's a billion dollars a day, it's short of that, but
- 14:28that's 110 thousandth of the of their AUM.
- 14:34And so you could you could have that kind of flow for every day
- 14:37for you know, 200 trading days a year, 250 trading days a year
- 14:44and not get anywhere near a 1% allocation for your clients.
- 14:50And that might be the target that you know, Fidelity in
- 14:54Canada has talked about has has made that the default of a 1 to
- 14:583% allocation for clients into their Bitcoin products.
- 15:05And so there, there's enough fuel just sitting in these large
- 15:10asset managers to have this kind of sustained bid from ETF demand
- 15:17for quite a long time. Yeah, the the visual of your
- 15:25model comes to mind when you're talking about the osmosis
- 15:31dynamic of the. Whole.
- 15:34You know of the failing Fiat by investors and the absorption of
- 15:40that and that's that's like the visual, like it's like a physics
- 15:43to me. I.
- 15:46About when people pick up. I have fought.
- 15:48I've I've tried several different iterations of like an
- 15:51osmosis diagram. I I have never nailed it, but
- 15:54that is how I view it as well. I mean like value wants to flow
- 15:59to where there is greater scarcity is how I I think of it.
- 16:03And you know you have all these different buckets where there's
- 16:06an osmotic membrane between them where you you can allow value to
- 16:10flow to where it wants to find where it can find more scarcity
- 16:14in the in the better store of value.
- 16:16And Bitcoin is the one bucket where, like scarcity keeps
- 16:18getting added to it, like salt being added to it, Osmotic
- 16:23chamber. But yeah, I have.
- 16:25I've never nailed that diagram, so I've haven't put it out
- 16:29there. Marty, I got.
- 16:30I got a spicy take for you. I didn't want it really, but I
- 16:33got. A little.
- 16:35Spicy I'm and I'm interested. Everybody's thoughts
- 16:36specifically also Marks because it it it landed on me today.
- 16:41It's like I think based on what Mark said when we talked about
- 16:44Allen, the flows aren't here yet from like the traditional
- 16:47market. These are like sovereigns and
- 16:48reallocations, but I think when they do come, people aren't
- 16:52buying Bitcoin as we know it, like they're buying Bonk or
- 16:55whatever. Think about whatever mean coin
- 16:57you buy in the in the sense of or like a GameStop, GameStop,
- 17:02like when the price runs, they're going to be buying a
- 17:04ticker. And the reason I'm bringing this
- 17:06up is because I think this common thought has come up a lot
- 17:09around individuals that have looked at this asset a long time
- 17:11is like, is the ETF good or bad for Bitcoin?
- 17:14And I think without question, it's amazing for Bitcoin simply
- 17:16because when you first buy it, you're not actually, everybody
- 17:19didn't know what they were buying.
- 17:20So you're just buying the appreciation, you're buying the
- 17:21ticker from a mimetic perspective because that's what
- 17:24we do. That's how crazy like the world
- 17:25has got. And we just like see a number go
- 17:27up. And inherently they're not
- 17:28buying Bitcoin because if you're buying it, you're buying it for
- 17:31the reasons that we all understand outside of the
- 17:33system, hedge against and full all the things that we know
- 17:36you're not buying, that you're buying inherently.
- 17:38It's not built into the into the product that they're selling
- 17:40you. And so once they get it, then
- 17:43they're like, oh, I need to go to River, Unchained on ramp,
- 17:46wherever it is, because that's actually Bitcoin.
- 17:49And so it's literally the best thing that could ever happen.
- 17:51But they're not actually buying Bitcoin.
- 17:52They're not even buying anything close to it.
- 17:53They're buying a mimetic number that is attributed to everything
- 17:57we've seen the past 10 years. And it's just the next thing.
- 18:00This is just the thing that's the last thing, if that makes
- 18:02any sense. Yeah, I don't think it's a spicy
- 18:04take. Not spicy, but I think it's like
- 18:06this thought of people think people are buying Bitcoin and
- 18:08they're actually not buying Bitcoin.
- 18:09They're buying Bonk. Like they're buying the next
- 18:12thing that they think. And it's actually the last
- 18:14thing, It's the last trade. And so that's why it's so good
- 18:17for Bitcoin, because like Allen came on last week and he's
- 18:20saying all these things, it's like absolutely, like apparently
- 18:22false. Like it's like the best thing to
- 18:23ever happen. Because at the end of the day,
- 18:25like the Aware, the awareness is the best thing for Bitcoin.
- 18:30Yeah, it's top of funnel. We've discussed this many, many
- 18:32times in the show over the last six months since the filings
- 18:36began flowing in this top of funnel marketing vehicle for
- 18:41Bitcoin. But yeah, like you said, maybe
- 18:42they're not buying Bach, they're buying IBIT, they're buying the
- 18:46other tickers. But Ibit's the only one that I
- 18:49can remember off the top of my head Huddle.
- 18:52And that reflexivity we've never seen.
- 18:53Like, we haven't started it. Because if we're, if we're on
- 18:55this right path that we're saying sovereigns and
- 18:57reallocations are happening, and it actually hasn't even turned
- 19:00into the memetic thing and we'll know it because nobody's called
- 19:02us yet, right? There's like one at it, yeah.
- 19:05Yeah, and Speaking of that, Logan, pull up the tweet
- 19:08Speaking of sovereigns. Not a sovereign nation, but a
- 19:10sovereign state here in the United.
- 19:12States I heard about it. Thank you.
- 19:14The Arizona State Senate is considering adding the Bitcoin
- 19:17ETS to its state retirement portfolios.
- 19:20So this is actually, this is not just like a rumor from Bitcoin
- 19:23Magazine. This is an official statement
- 19:25from the Arizona State Senate. It's a fact sheet expressing the
- 19:30desire of the Senate to be able to allocate the retirement
- 19:35system money to these Bitcoin ETFs.
- 19:37So this is actually a pretty big a pretty big event I think,
- 19:40yeah. Coming out.
- 19:43We we talked about this. We talked about this just just a
- 19:46few weeks ago of about how the ETFs flip the psychological
- 19:50switch of like the norm has been to not include Bitcoin in your
- 19:53portfolio. And now the the switch is
- 19:56happening to the norm becoming of course you should have some
- 20:00Bitcoin in your portfolio. That's what a standard portfolio
- 20:03includes and like this is part of that a switch from, you know,
- 20:08not including Bitcoin in pensions to including Bitcoin in
- 20:11pensions. But that's part of that ongoing
- 20:13process, just the beginning here.
- 20:16It is. And actually harkening back to
- 20:17our first discussion, the last time you were on Mark and we
- 20:21were surmising, we were asking the question, will these ETF
- 20:26issuers begin putting their Bitcoin spot ETFs in other funds
- 20:31that they that they offer their clients And that has been proven
- 20:34true as well. You know I believe BlackRock
- 20:37Canada added it to one of their or or fidelities Canadian ARM
- 20:40added it to one of their funds. I believe BlackRock has filed A
- 20:44prospectus to include the Bitcoin ETF.
- 20:46Their Bitcoin ETF and a couple of their I I forget the specific
- 20:52funds, but a number of other funds that they have.
- 20:54So it seems like that internal demand for these products is
- 20:58going to be driven as well. They're going to begin spreading
- 21:01these Bitcoin ETFs into their other funds.
- 21:03And so when you couple that with Arizona stepping out, with the
- 21:10fact that a lot of these Rias have not had the gates open for
- 21:14them to to flood in, this is crazy to believe.
- 21:17But this is the only beginning, only the beginning of this
- 21:20massive flood into these ETFs. And you know to carry on the
- 21:25bunk mimetic scene that Michael brought up it's kind of like
- 21:32give a mouse a cookie on the on the Bitcoin ETF.
- 21:36And so we have our firm is an ETF provider and when we're on
- 21:40stage talking and there's a Bitcoin maxi, usually cowboy
- 21:44boots and probably from Calgary saying when are you going to,
- 21:51you know you're you're a rent taker and why don't you have
- 21:55everyone go into, you know, into this physical.
- 21:57I go, great, you try to get everyone in the physical.
- 22:01It's not going to happen right away and you want to wait till
- 22:03bitcoin's 100,000. So we, I think the candle on
- 22:07effect, and I mentioned this once before is alive and well in
- 22:10Bitcoin too. If you don't get in, you know
- 22:12you deserve Bitcoin. The price you get it, I'd rather
- 22:15people get it and then we also provide Intel to people if they
- 22:20want to self custody we will, we will have that discussion with
- 22:23them and it'll be away from us. But we're we're eventually going
- 22:26to have more services that go beyond it maybe some of what you
- 22:29guys are doing and that's the path that's the natural order.
- 22:33You know the the mouse with the cookie wants a glass of milk, it
- 22:37wants to go up and you know sort of fill out the meal and that
- 22:41meal is fully, you know, is being fully nourished by self
- 22:45sovereign ultimately. So that's the end of my analogy.
- 22:48So it's not the osmosis, but we're working, you know my my
- 22:51way through different. Yeah, it's a it's a stepping
- 22:53stone. It it, as as Michael likes to
- 22:55say it's a stepping stone to what may be the final the the
- 22:59other side of the of the river is the last trade of taking that
- 23:04final leap into. OK, actually, I control my own
- 23:07UTXOS, you know, in, in whatever form of custody makes sense for
- 23:12that person. But yeah, you know, like, and
- 23:15that, that's why, that's why the ETFs are fantastic from my point
- 23:18of view, because everybody needs the start of their Bitcoin
- 23:21journey and inherently everybody starts before they get into
- 23:25Bitcoin. Everybody is negative on
- 23:27Bitcoin. That's just human nature because
- 23:29you see all these people who have gotten wealthy with Bitcoin
- 23:33and you resent it, and so you don't like Bitcoin.
- 23:37You're rooting against Bitcoin because you want the
- 23:38schadenfreude of of seeing these people lose their wealth because
- 23:42you feel like they didn't deserve to get it in the 1st
- 23:44place. What is this Bitcoin thing
- 23:46anyway? Screw them.
- 23:48So that's the the default mentality.
- 23:50So everybody is anti Bitcoin in some capacity and then
- 23:55eventually there's some reason where something happens or some
- 23:59sequence of events happens where they're like, all right, I want
- 24:02to be a part of that. I want to have a little bit of
- 24:04that too. And then inevitably everybody
- 24:08does the does a little toe dip. They just dip their toe in, get
- 24:12just 1% maybe of Bitcoin. But in doing so, they've done
- 24:17the hardest part. They've gone from rooting
- 24:20against Bitcoin to now they are rooting for Bitcoin.
- 24:24Now they're open to seeing why Bitcoin is good and and why it's
- 24:28a great asset and and now they're learning more about it
- 24:31and opening their eyes to to what it really is and
- 24:35discovering its merits and then they want more.
- 24:39So people that's that's the important stepping stone towards
- 24:42eventually having like you know 1/2 let's say of your wealth in
- 24:46Bitcoin is you first have to do that toe dip to get 1% and then
- 24:51you want more. And so I think that's, that's
- 24:53what the ETFs provide, is this easy way for people to dip a toe
- 24:56in Bitcoin and become pro Bitcoin, become fans of Bitcoin,
- 25:02open to learning more about it, curious about it, rooting for
- 25:05it. And that's such an important
- 25:07value, a service that the ETFs make possible.
- 25:11Yeah. And and just to be clear, Mark,
- 25:13I think you you probably know this, but when I was referencing
- 25:17the ETFs and BONKS and Bonk, it was a generalization on like an
- 25:21asset where you can't take delivery or or have the
- 25:24optionality for that. Because my understanding 3 IQ
- 25:27allows that and there's other funds.
- 25:29But I think that's the core idea of individuals will go to those
- 25:35entities and pay more for them naturally because they
- 25:38understand it and they're being educated on why you want you
- 25:41want that optionality. And that's like the underline
- 25:44without naming names or certain ETFs and custodians that will
- 25:46only let you bring in Bitcoin and they'll only let you take
- 25:49out dollars, which is just like it's.
- 25:51Yeah. I love you covering my
- 25:53commercial back. Yes we in our close end fund you
- 25:56can deliver Bitcoin in and take Bitcoin out and we can store a
- 25:58few. Yes we do we we do provide that
- 26:02and and but we I I guess I didn't even go over that because
- 26:05wherever you want to go with your Bitcoin journey or it, it
- 26:10has to be informed first because as a couple people have said
- 26:14people will lose money. I don't know.
- 26:17What do you guys do, you guys, if you could know everyone who
- 26:20bought Bitcoin for the first time starting say today and and
- 26:24for the next say two years or one year, one year from now, the
- 26:28number of people who entered for the first time, do you think
- 26:31they'll make or lose money by the 12 months from now if
- 26:36bitcoins even higher? Great question.
- 26:38I mean some percentage will lose money that's that's like Dave
- 26:41Portnoy, like you can, you can buy Bitcoin during a bull market
- 26:45and you can still manage to. Lose money.
- 26:46Reference. Love it.
- 26:48Dave, text me if you're listening.
- 26:50I know you listen to the show, Dave.
- 26:51I texted Dave Portnoy this week like, hey, I sent him.
- 26:54His recent video of Bitcoin depresses me.
- 26:56I was like, Dave, I'm here to help you and he refuses to
- 26:59respond. I'm here, Dave.
- 27:01We'll get him in the pool again. Jesse has a a really good chart
- 27:05for the loss funds I'll drop in the deal.
- 27:08But while I'm putting it in there Mark, there's a common
- 27:10trope I'll I'll say during conversations of and I really
- 27:13believe this and I have no data behind it.
- 27:14So you guys correct me if it's wrong is I think that 50% of all
- 27:18Bitcoin holders for the past since the inception don't hold
- 27:21any Bitcoin anymore. And if not higher because
- 27:25they've been shaken out of positions, they sold too early,
- 27:27they they use leverage, all the things that we've known that
- 27:30happened. And so that's where we focus on
- 27:32like the education is because like at the end of the day, like
- 27:35unless you're educated to start, you don't, you're again buying
- 27:37Bonk, you're just finding a number on the screen.
- 27:40Yeah, right here. Yeah.
- 27:45So to provide a little color on this, I, you know, we wanted to
- 27:49quantify how how much money has been lost in crypto because of
- 27:58poor custody specifically. And you know when you think
- 28:00about your major categories of screw ups in crypto broadly,
- 28:06they all come down to they could have all been solved by better
- 28:09custody ultimately, right? Like between the Bitcoin that
- 28:12people have lost which is a huge number like 3 million because
- 28:17they lost their keys. You know if they had done a
- 28:19better job of custodying it, that wouldn't have happened.
- 28:22But then this also is the same root problem for people who lost
- 28:27money on FTXI mean if you're if you're trusting FTX unilaterally
- 28:31with your coins because you're you're trusting that they have
- 28:35those coins and they're responsibly holding them in
- 28:38proper custody and and in managing that properly with, you
- 28:42know, a business that's not committing fraud.
- 28:47And then, you know, there's also the, the hacks and the thefts
- 28:53that are all over the headlines like Mount Gox or Quadriga or
- 28:59whatever, where for whatever reason customers lost access to
- 29:04funds usually because those funds were hacked out of Mount
- 29:08Cox, for example. And so quantifying that, you
- 29:14know, adding up all those buckets, we came up with 120, I
- 29:18think it was, yeah, $120 billion at the time.
- 29:21It's of of lost value from people holding their crypto in
- 29:30the wrong kind of custody. Usually because they either
- 29:34screwed up self custody or because they trusted the wrong
- 29:38counterparty with control of their funds.
- 29:41And that's where not your keys, not your coins comes from
- 29:44because you can. Historically, you could solve
- 29:46for that problem by taking self custody, and so long as you did
- 29:51self custody right, you solved for the other problem of losing
- 29:54your your keys or losing access to your Bitcoin as well.
- 29:58Anyway, together it's a big problem, $120 billion of lost
- 30:03value. And all those people right now
- 30:05are in pain watching the price of Bitcoin and the whole crypto
- 30:10ecosystem rise without them and knowing that their coins would
- 30:16have been worth X amount of dollars if they still had them.
- 30:20But they don't and. I'm convinced like we're not at
- 30:24like 5 trillion to 10 trillion for Bitcoin just because of
- 30:26custody. Like if people like always like
- 30:29the mental model of imagining the asset you would pitch
- 30:31somebody on Bitcoin and the whole thing is there's a
- 30:34likelihood, a non zero chance and it's pretty decent that I'll
- 30:37never get to see its appreciation because that's what
- 30:40people know is they know landfill or North Korean hackers
- 30:43like they can't even actually, no it's it's just true.
- 30:45Like they can't even actually wrap their head around it or
- 30:47earnestly look at the asset because they don't feel
- 30:50confident in the custody because it's ephemeral.
- 30:52It's like it's just this thing that's out there.
- 30:54And so that notion of custody, like it is in my mind, like the
- 30:57chicken or egg thing, it's the first part of solving for it.
- 31:00Even though most people talk about the value property
- 31:02appreciation, it's like no, no, we can anchor it to the real
- 31:04world. Then you can get to like the
- 31:06actual assets attributes because you can open.
- 31:08You can take it with an open mind of like, oh, now I can look
- 31:11at this with real like earnest possibilities because I know I
- 31:14can actually buy it and it'll be there when I want it versus
- 31:17right now. I don't think it's solved.
- 31:18Like, I don't think Coinbase is the best we have right from a
- 31:21name brand recognition, but that's the best we have.
- 31:23Like that's that's exactly the point already.
- 31:25Like there's no, like there's no gold standard for custody that
- 31:30you know you can park it there. Even Sailor, like the best he
- 31:32has is he's probably splitting in or he is splitting it across
- 31:34three, like two or three. Exchanges.
- 31:36I don't know. I don't know if I completely
- 31:39agree with that. I agree.
- 31:40Custody certainly has a lot of room to improve.
- 31:45I think that's what we're trying to do it on ramp other companies
- 31:47are doing. But I mean, objectively, most
- 31:51bitcoins held in self custody. So, like, I don't think that.
- 31:54I think the biggest barrier to entry is just like the whole
- 31:57kinds of people don't understand money.
- 31:59They don't understand that their money's broken.
- 32:01They view Bitcoin as some sort of meme stock like you said.
- 32:05Two parts, two parts on that. One is all the money is not in
- 32:08the system, right? All the trillions are out.
- 32:10They're not going to hold self custody Bitcoin.
- 32:12So that's like the reason why it would be higher and then I'll
- 32:15give you the hot take. This is just like I'm
- 32:17challenging Allen Farrington just last week got got me riled.
- 32:20Up in the. Contrarian takes is I'm
- 32:23convinced that anybody that's holding plastic devices for self
- 32:27custody has a cost basis less than $5000.
- 32:31Because if anybody was net new coming in like $100,000 Bitcoin
- 32:35or $75,000 and you said, here's a like a plastic device and
- 32:39you're going to hold 500K or a million, they'd laugh at you.
- 32:42And I actually know this because I did this for a very long time.
- 32:44It's why on ramp like exists. And I was thinking like about
- 32:47this idea of like plastic devices.
- 32:50Like there's a notion of we're so early that when the price
- 32:53appreciates the whole idea of like a private key sitting on a
- 32:58single plastic device just starts to become, like insane
- 33:01for any material amount of wealth.
- 33:03If it's like 1000 bucks or you know, whatever .1 Bitcoin, it's
- 33:06not to say like self custody won't exist and devices won't
- 33:08exist. It'll just be like pieces of a
- 33:10key that can come back together with other things.
- 33:13Like, there's a lot of ideas that I've been playing around
- 33:14with, but the core idea of like somebody having a bunch of
- 33:17Bitcoin, millions of dollars net new today on a little plastic
- 33:20device, I don't think people come in and step in to move
- 33:23$3,000,000 into a Ledger, basically.
- 33:27I don't know. I'm.
- 33:28I'm gonna prop one of our our publication from last week which
- 33:32was titled Nobody Puts a Baby in a Corner And it's like you just,
- 33:38you know you can't put Bitcoin in a little little device you
- 33:41know it's gonna get bigger and and to and to continue the
- 33:44teenage analogy moving from the Catskills, I don't think I can
- 33:49remember. Yes.
- 33:52Patrick Swayze And what was the name of that movie in the 90s?
- 33:57Roundhouse. No, I love that one.
- 34:00No, this this this was with the the Catskills resort and Patrick
- 34:06Swayze dancing with with with baby.
- 34:09So if you What's that? Dirty Dancing.
- 34:15Dirty Dancing Dirty you get it. So yeah, you don't put baby in a
- 34:20corner. She's got to be loud and proud
- 34:21in front stage. And like Bitcoin is is so young
- 34:26still on every measure from adoption globally to to market
- 34:31value that a parent who has a kid is a good athlete might say
- 34:39oh get your trainer and then they try to get them on the
- 34:41travel team and then they kids good.
- 34:43What do you do with a kid in our town you send them to IMG in
- 34:47Florida. You know you go up the up the
- 34:50curve. So to your point Michael, when
- 34:53this number technology, you know number of technology, it'll
- 34:56impact how people preserve care for the asset because it's no
- 35:00longer just a kid dribbling down to try to you know fill time on
- 35:05the on the on the schedule of your, you know it's now
- 35:07something has to be nurtured and grown and preserved and I think
- 35:13that's definitely what's going to happen.
- 35:14Yeah, and intuitively makes sense.
- 35:16If a Bitcoin is $1000 or $3000 or 5000, it was between that for
- 35:22a very long time and much less than that and you want 10
- 35:24Bitcoin, you're looking at 20 to $30,000 that you're investing.
- 35:29That number is completely different.
- 35:31If you're buying $100,000 Bitcoin, you're buying ten of
- 35:33them, that's $1,000,000. How you secure it fundamentally
- 35:36has to be different because you're that's a different
- 35:38percentage of like your wealth, different percentage of a lot of
- 35:40things that are associated with it.
- 35:42So to think that like it would be how we did it in 2014 or 13,
- 35:45like again, because we're so early.
- 35:47That's why I love the notion of like the companies, the best
- 35:50companies in the Bitcoin space are don't even exist.
- 35:52The person that founded them hasn't even heard of it because
- 35:54that's how early we are that like the first people through
- 35:57the door got some of the stuff right and then other people will
- 35:59build on top of that. Not trying to honestly I I
- 36:04agree. I do think as the value Bitcoin
- 36:08increases and those wallets become heavier people will
- 36:12engage in multi institution multi sig.
- 36:15However, we mentioned them earlier, like how do you think
- 36:17that miner from 2010 that sold 400 Bitcoin yesterday millions
- 36:21of dollars, 10s of millions of dollars with securing his his
- 36:25Bitcoin you probably had probably had on a laptop you
- 36:28mind on. Well, that's the kicker is like
- 36:31the best that we had was to keep it offline like that, that's
- 36:35what kept it safe. But will that be the best that
- 36:38we have in the future? Because like the big one that we
- 36:41talked about with your buddy, it's like it's OK on E SIM side.
- 36:45But when it comes to physical safety, do we all want to be
- 36:48sitting with like the hardware, the the laptop and knowing that
- 36:51like we had that is that thing like the world that we all live
- 36:54in, that we're all holding our own.
- 36:55Bitcoin is like a world that we none of us really want to live
- 36:58in. If you really extrapolate that
- 36:59far, let's say that's why banks exist because people put gold
- 37:02underneath their like cave and then they got hit over the head.
- 37:04Like it's not this stuff is not like rock science.
- 37:06Like this is pretty straightforward.
- 37:08It's actually kind of interesting that like the notion
- 37:10of not your keys, not your coins is is still a full thing when
- 37:13you extrapolate if Bitcoin is money and everybody holds it,
- 37:16like do you want your kids to just walk to school safely?
- 37:19Because now you were early at 2013 in Bitcoin and you somebody
- 37:23can pick up the phone and say I got your kid send me half the
- 37:25coin. Like if that could happen, that
- 37:27doesn't. And that's just like 1 sliver of
- 37:29the idea around like self custody I.
- 37:31Mean I agree but I could say, I mean somebody could know you
- 37:36could have your Bitcoin in multi institution, multi sig with on
- 37:40ramp and they could still pick up your kids and be like hey
- 37:43call on ramp and tell them to move the Bitcoin.
- 37:45Well, that's the same notion of like a bank.
- 37:47Like if you go to a bank, you're, you know, you're under
- 37:49duress. Like they know there's a
- 37:50problem. Like there's a whole slew of,
- 37:52like, weeks that have to go and set it up versus like, you
- 37:55can't, nobody can move a billion dollars out of a bank.
- 37:57No, the point I'm trying to make is like we should be adversarial
- 38:02sinking for those extremes. But are they just that,
- 38:04extremes? Like how common will this
- 38:06become? I'm not sure I could see it both
- 38:08ways. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:11I think there's a it it it's sort of funny that not your keys
- 38:15not your coins has been the best advice to date and and it is
- 38:20still good advice but you know it.
- 38:24It may prevent the Bitcoin community.
- 38:27It may take the Bitcoin community some amount of time to
- 38:29realize that multi institution custody is is a solution that
- 38:33allows for the end user to retain control and and doesn't
- 38:40have the technical hurdles that come with setting up and
- 38:44maintaining your own self custody.
- 38:46And I think that's sort of a blind spot for the Bitcoin
- 38:48community is, you know, we're a bunch of tech savvy millennials
- 38:53and and you know, everybody assumes that there's a certain
- 38:58degree of tech savviness that is inherent to all people that I
- 39:04think is overly generous. You know, especially when you
- 39:08consider the the gaps between different generational
- 39:13demographics and how familiar and comfortable they are with
- 39:17technology. And so, you know, not your keys,
- 39:20not your coins. That being the singular mantra I
- 39:24think that bumps up against the reality that that self custody
- 39:28comes with some risks, some dangers and a lot of discomfort
- 39:33for large portions of of the two yet to adopt Bitcoin population
- 39:40in particular. And so I think that that's where
- 39:44like multi institution custody really shines is bringing into a
- 39:48degree of comfort for people who either don't want to touch self
- 39:55custody at all because they have like a certain awareness of
- 39:59their own limitations when it comes to technology.
- 40:02You know that's one large cohort and then the other cohort is
- 40:05just having a way to diversify the risk that you're taking on
- 40:09by having all of your eggs in one basket.
- 40:11If you've set up your own self custody and you you know have
- 40:14the ability if you're under duress to move all of your
- 40:17assets that that's a liability that self custody comes, it
- 40:24comes with self custody and and multi institution custody
- 40:27diversifies that risk and solves for that wrench attack vector.
- 40:32Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 40:34exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 40:37about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 40:41allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 40:45We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 40:48Yeah. Marty, one thing that you just
- 40:50thought of and I didn't land it earlier when I was talking to
- 40:53Mark about like there are flows coming in my understanding to
- 40:56get like financial exposure to the asset to play in the
- 40:59financial markets. But I think actually that's not
- 41:02the that's not a large percentage of whatever increase
- 41:06in ETF exposure. I think is what Jesse just
- 41:09described of holders that were O GS like you referenced Marty
- 41:14that actually haven't scared shitless about their custody
- 41:17situation and they sent it into BlackRock or an ETF because of
- 41:20the balance sheet and all the things that they know of the
- 41:22financial markets from insurance related.
- 41:24And actually heard this this week from a friend of ours
- 41:27father that basically I think he has it in you know self custody
- 41:30provider or whatever and he's like hey my dad like this
- 41:33thing's getting big he wants to put it he wants to park it in
- 41:35the ETF and and that's again from a boomer.
- 41:39It's not a digitally native person but it goes to the same
- 41:40concept of we have to build better products out there that
- 41:43are like natural to bitcoin's protocol because we know that
- 41:46the ETF isn't good. This like the fact you can't
- 41:48take it back out central point of failure with the custody but
- 41:50at the same point time like the just the self custody thing just
- 41:55starts to like weigh weigh more and I don't think it's like
- 41:57either or I like in it to like firearms in the sense of like
- 41:59it's very hard to convince somebody to give up their guns
- 42:02similar as like their keys. I think that the way that I've
- 42:05seen it in personal speaking from a firearm perspective you
- 42:07like get a safe like they convince you to get a a safe so
- 42:10you keep them a little safer like and it's not all of them
- 42:13but you just have like a natural like wrapper around that that
- 42:16you feel comfortable and there's like redundancy built in.
- 42:18I think that's like the the story that we're finding that
- 42:22lands is like from a heritage perspective and like passing and
- 42:24beneficiary or redundancy in that.
- 42:26Like if you do have a single sig or whatever, you can't get
- 42:29knocked out of the game because you mess up.
- 42:32But yeah, definitely hear like the notion, 'cause we, you know,
- 42:35Margaret, we know it. We have a lot of friends.
- 42:37That not your keys, not your coin is the mantra.
- 42:39And I think it's just like over time, it'll start to slow down
- 42:44just because it it'll be like, wait, so I'm saying not your
- 42:46keys, not your coin. But then that means that I hold
- 42:48all my Bitcoin and people know that that doesn't sound really
- 42:51good or smarter. Well the opposite side of that
- 42:54coin is like you like to say statism is in a bull market and
- 43:00that's I think the biggest worry again in allocating your your
- 43:04custody solutions between self custody maybe collaborative
- 43:10custody multi sig and then you know multi institution multi sig
- 43:13where you don't hold a key. I mean that I mean that's what I
- 43:16think about what I got. I would not be.
- 43:18I would not put it past the American government to point at
- 43:23these solutions at some point in the future of bitcoins at $10
- 43:26trillion market and say, you know what, we're gonna need to
- 43:28confiscate some of this. All these companies that are
- 43:32regulated here obey us. Sign the 2 S re Quorum and send
- 43:36us Bitcoin to this address. I think that is something that
- 43:39should be considered as well. Executive Order 6102.
- 43:45Yeah. But then the BlackRock ET FS
- 43:47already done. Yes, Marty, on that point, like
- 43:51you know if if governments get to a point where they're like,
- 43:53all right, we're we're going to start confiscating Bitcoin, well
- 43:58there's some very easy to confiscate pools.
- 44:01You know namely like what's being held at Coinbase and and
- 44:06it that's that's a company that has unilateral control over a
- 44:10lot of Bitcoin, that'd be your, that'd be your first target.
- 44:14So you know, if you want to get to that extreme scenario, that's
- 44:16who they go after. Again, we're playing both sides.
- 44:20The extreme coin here. And and and you know when that
- 44:23is happening collaborative multi sig and multi institution
- 44:29custody key holders are making sure that they are resilient if
- 44:35they haven't already to such that you know they don't have
- 44:39unilateral control to hand over to an authority that comes
- 44:43knocking. Yeah, Mark, I'd actually be
- 44:45curious your thoughts, 'cause I think there's a more overarching
- 44:47point that we believe on, we believe in is that all
- 44:50institutions should in, in the future will only hold one key in
- 44:54whatever quorum they participate in for this exact reason.
- 44:57Like you never want the game theory to be that you can move
- 44:59unilateral control. And I learned this very early.
- 45:01You know, and Chain is a great example of this.
- 45:02Like, they're never in a position that can move clients
- 45:04funds, which is great for everyone, for them, for the
- 45:06client for and and specifically for them if the government ever
- 45:09did what Marty referenced because it's like I can't do
- 45:11anything. So then it always has the game
- 45:13theory of like, well, am I going to go and actually like knock on
- 45:15their door Because at best I can just like turn off wallet
- 45:17coordination or you know, access to the software.
- 45:20So curious like from your three IQ or maybe not through IQ lens,
- 45:23but just like from an institutional perspective, can
- 45:25you see how that is actually a natural benefit where a
- 45:28government or an army can't go in and breakdown somebody's
- 45:30servers and get access to whatever Bitcoin that they hold?
- 45:33Yeah, so, yeah, so, so you're saying self sovereign like on
- 45:36site versus multi sig versus in a in an ETF omnibus account or
- 45:43or separate one? Basically saying that anybody
- 45:45playing in the custody space from an institutional
- 45:47perspective in the future won't have unilateral control over.
- 45:50Moving all it's not have unilateral single point of
- 45:53contact putting my former risk management hat on, yeah you
- 45:57don't want single point of failure that's that's what you
- 46:01don't want. And you know Marty, you said to
- 46:04most people and agreed probably had that and the guy who minded
- 46:08or gal in 2010 was very happy having it in their cold or even
- 46:12on their PC where they're gaming for the last, you know 14 years,
- 46:15who knows and and it worked for them.
- 46:18So just cause it's worked doesn't mean that it's not ideal
- 46:24and won't be compromised in the future.
- 46:27It's a very dynamic market. Look at what technology does.
- 46:31What is safe today may not be tomorrow.
- 46:33That's why they got to be first principles based and those first
- 46:37principles apply to custody of Bitcoin.
- 46:41But let me pull it back a bit from executive orders and
- 46:45seizures and and you know Amazon finally putting 2% of their
- 46:52treasury into Bitcoin and say right now we are focused on
- 46:57getting people in and the feedback that I can tell you is
- 47:01and it's applicable to our discussion, everyone's
- 47:03different. Everyone has a different trigger
- 47:08point of what we'll get them in and an example is recently we
- 47:13were in a meeting with an asset manager, 2 heads of sales.
- 47:16I won't tell you what region one was from the other and one
- 47:23region guy said our folks are worried about executive orders,
- 47:28Marty. They're worried about asset
- 47:31seizures and their and and they think that there's a debt
- 47:34bubble. So they were dumers.
- 47:36Other guy goes, no way. If I start with that I'm losing
- 47:39the whole room. I need to speak about what you
- 47:43said earlier, Mark about it being like a tech valuation
- 47:47where it's software that's validated, it has a cash flow
- 47:51for token, it has a price to book.
- 47:54So we put in terms that they can understand.
- 47:56You know the the analogy I give is that type of analogy is like
- 48:01the bore model. It's not accurate.
- 48:03It's not how atoms are constructed, but it's a great
- 48:07entry point to have people understand how protons and
- 48:11nucleant protons, electrons and and and the like operate within
- 48:16a system. So I think we really are in such
- 48:19an early stage. You guys and me to degree are
- 48:23more evolved in the system. We got to walk it back.
- 48:25We got to get these folks in and up the curve slowly.
- 48:28So that's kind of where I'm coming.
- 48:30Get in the game and then we'll walk you to custody.
- 48:34It's very astute, Mark. We're sometimes so far down in
- 48:36the weeds we just we just get we get right into it, gotta.
- 48:40I think, I think the fact that my conference room just went
- 48:42dark is is is indicative of what's going on out there.
- 48:46We need to add light to the situation.
- 48:48So let me let me let me get that going right here guys.
- 48:52No, and I I completely agree. And then I threw that extreme
- 48:55out there, 'cause it exists on both sides of the coin.
- 49:00Pun intended. It's just that you need to think
- 49:03about the whole spectrum of of possibilities and realities out
- 49:08there. Yeah.
- 49:10And and and you're right ultimately that like that what
- 49:15what that mantra has been helpful for is pointing out that
- 49:18like people should have control and you should be you should be
- 49:22hesitant to give up control and and when you dip a toe and you
- 49:26buy an ETF product great. That's awesome.
- 49:29Welcome to Bitcoin. Learn a bit more and then think
- 49:32about how you might want to hold on to control for the next
- 49:35tranche of of your you know eventual larger allocation to
- 49:40Bitcoin. And control is really what it's
- 49:43all all about at the end of the day.
- 49:44So not your keys, not your coins really means make sure you have
- 49:48control of a material. If you're doing a material
- 49:51allocation to Bitcoin and you know and it's not not your keys,
- 49:56not your coins, it's a lot catchier phrase and so that's
- 49:59why that has stuck around and is a good phrase.
- 50:04Multi institution custody, collaborative custody, these are
- 50:07formats that allow the end user to retain control and so they're
- 50:11alternative versions of custody where end user has control and
- 50:15that's really what we're what you know is the end game for
- 50:19Bitcoin custody is making sure that the end user has control in
- 50:23a format that that is comfortable for them and and
- 50:26workable for them. And you know the, the coins in
- 50:282010, they were mined onto a a a hard drive and probably tucked
- 50:34away and maybe some copies were made and on an encrypted hard
- 50:39drive that was stashed away and that was effectively air gapped
- 50:43away from from the online environment.
- 50:47And it worked for a few years, long enough to know that it was
- 50:50safe. And then as the value of that
- 50:53kept growing, well, the hesitation of changing that
- 50:56model keeps you from doing it. And so that's what worked for
- 51:01that early cypherpunk. You know, just like the the guy
- 51:05who hacked Silk Road loaded, had 50,000 Bitcoin on a on a hard
- 51:11drive stashed away in a popcorn tin and in the floor of his
- 51:15Georgia home. Like that worked because he's a
- 51:18early tech savvy cypherpunk. But that doesn't work for people
- 51:24who are coming into Bitcoin now and are and are Maybe not
- 51:27cypherpunks, but everybody should be keeping in mind the
- 51:32the North Star of like Eventually you want to have
- 51:35control of your Bitcoin allocation.
- 51:39And keeping on this broader theme, I think bringing up a
- 51:42topical news item over the last week which is we're talking
- 51:49about all this central points of failure, single points of
- 51:52failure. Coinbase, massive central point
- 51:55of failure. Right now they've proven
- 51:57multiple times throughout the week, which is mind boggling.
- 52:00They've had this problem in bull markets, bull cycles in the past
- 52:04and it's insane to me that they have not solved this yet.
- 52:08So for those who are unaware, believe it was three times in
- 52:11the last seven days is the price volatility has picked up
- 52:14Coinbase. Their retail side of the
- 52:18business is essentially broken every time they they the trading
- 52:22stops, their trading engine breaks down, users can't buy or
- 52:25sell Bitcoin and then when they open the app they see a $0.00
- 52:28balance which is not confidence inducing.
- 52:31And I'm wondering what the ETF issuers who are custodying their
- 52:36Bitcoin with Coinbase. Well, yes, it is probably.
- 52:39It is definitely a different entity than the retail trading
- 52:42platform, but it is the same company operating both products.
- 52:45What are the ETF providers thinking when they see this?
- 52:48Is it a big deal to them, Mark? It has not been and so Coinbase
- 52:55the the failures were there on the on the retail side and I I
- 52:59believe as you can tell I'm going to champion the the
- 53:02Coinbase institutional custody part here and it was a separate.
- 53:08So it was the retail side. We have not gotten any incoming
- 53:11because of the distinction and the and the difference between
- 53:15the custody and the exchange part which has been attested to
- 53:20and I think you know that's the major you know take away for us
- 53:25is that there there weren't concerns because of the
- 53:29certifications that they got on the institutional side and how
- 53:31it was distinguished from the retail side.
- 53:33So that's my story and I'm sticking to it there, Marty.
- 53:36By Marty Jones My Marty Jones hat goes on.
- 53:38It's like, are they the Bitcoin circuit Breakers?
- 53:41Because this is like I I don't believe it, but it's just a
- 53:44funny thing to think through. This has happened probably every
- 53:46cycle or at least the past three cycles, right?
- 53:4817 happened, 21 and then now when the price starts to rip the
- 53:53they just pull it. It's like this thing isn't
- 53:55working. It's.
- 53:58Brian Armstrong had his like justification tweet of how they
- 54:01they they tested their system for 10X surge and it's.
- 54:06Insane. And it's like you've seen in the
- 54:10past. Last cycle of the Coinbase's app
- 54:12was the number one downloaded app on the App Store for a few
- 54:15days at a time. Like that's the level of spike
- 54:19that they've seen before. That's bigger than a 10X.
- 54:22And evidently they didn't accom, they didn't plan for a larger
- 54:26than 10X spike. It is a little suspicious.
- 54:30So it's either malfeasance in terms of like being the circuit
- 54:34breaker, or, which is certainly likely as well, like a lack of
- 54:39focus. By trying to be the casino of
- 54:42the western world and not being able to focus on doing one
- 54:46thing, one thing correct, which is making it easy to buy and
- 54:49sell Bitcoin and doing that reliably for your end users has
- 54:53distracted them and spread themselves thin.
- 54:56I. I think you're.
- 54:57Right, Yeah. And on the, the topic of focus,
- 55:01we had a chat with Mark and he was talking about being on the
- 55:03road and the importance of meeting individuals where
- 55:05they're at. And Marty will be pleased.
- 55:07I don't even think we shared this with you.
- 55:09We're launching on ramp branches this week.
- 55:12This is recording Wednesday. So it'll come out Thursday or
- 55:15no, it'll come out Friday, but the branches will come out
- 55:17tomorrow, Thursday. And it's really simple.
- 55:19It's just an ode to banking and being able to meet people where
- 55:21they're at. And so Philadelphia will have a
- 55:23branch, LA, Orange County, Dallas, Austin, Houston and then
- 55:27New Jersey and New York. And the core idea is we have
- 55:30teams, teammates all over the US And so we'll be able to like,
- 55:34schedule time with us and then we'll meet in person.
- 55:36But I think that focus that you're describing is you have
- 55:38this ephemeral asset where you try to go to Coinbase.
- 55:40You can't literally get anybody on the phone, let alone ever
- 55:42meet somebody in in meet space. And so, Mark, I'm curious, like
- 55:47from your experience, you know, you were on the road, you were
- 55:49explaining, you were, you know, giddy.
- 55:51Usually people don't like traveling for work.
- 55:52You're like, I'm ready to get out there and go look people in
- 55:54the eye and shake their hands. And anybody that's been playing
- 55:57in financial services, it's all relationships and trust
- 56:00building, like what that means for you to go out to the market
- 56:03and sit down. I think it'd be great to hear.
- 56:06Sure. So I'll start with being
- 56:08jettisoned out of Credit Suisse a year before they failed.
- 56:15There's there's there's a fire in traditional finance and it's
- 56:20happening today with New York Community Bank halted, you know,
- 56:24it was down 40% to 6 bucks, down 50% to 3 bucks.
- 56:27Now it's a single digit Midget at $1.86 and it halted because
- 56:33they can't raise, they're trying to raise cash.
- 56:36So here we are, the feds going to step in, absorb them, shove
- 56:39them somewhere. And so we do have a problem with
- 56:41valuations at a high interest rate environment.
- 56:45So the reason I'm giddy, as you said is because I, I, I joined 3
- 56:49IQ almost two years ago, it'll be next month.
- 56:53I put my head down for one year, didn't visit anybody, bomed up
- 56:56on what's going on. And finally, I'm convicted of
- 57:00the fact that Bitcoin, of all the traits that you guys already
- 57:03know, it took me, you know, a deeper dive because I started
- 57:06this in 2021 and no one understands it.
- 57:10So I appreciate where they are because I'm relatively new to
- 57:13it, three years in. So I'm ready to find out where
- 57:16they are and slot in where this fits in their portfolio and I'm
- 57:20getting some success. So it is no way going to be sold
- 57:25by a publication or by anyone else and and you're just going
- 57:31to make friends in two years when they say thank God you came
- 57:34in and pushed me to buy some. I just you know our price
- 57:38targets, other folks have had to change them in our industry.
- 57:41We have not. We were pretty clear where this
- 57:45was going to go and we are beyond our mid case on Bitcoin
- 57:51for the halving which was 65 K and you know our year end is 160
- 57:56to 180. So I certainly want to be on the
- 57:58road because I know no one's getting these types of returns.
- 58:02I've we're highly convicted on this and yeah I I I've in my 30
- 58:08whatever it is four year career. There's only one other time
- 58:12where I had this degree of conviction in an asset and it it
- 58:16happened very similarly as a distressed asset.
- 58:18It took a legal precedent. It was then slowly adopted by,
- 58:23you know, back end equity by all the broker dealers and slowly
- 58:27people came up and then it just shot up from a nickel to over
- 58:30300. So that's why I'm giddy as you
- 58:33can tell and sorry for hogging the microphone, but I I if you
- 58:35have something to say, I'll say it and that's what I'll say.
- 58:38It is second time in my career that I've seen price asymmetry
- 58:42that still exists in an asset. What was the first time?
- 58:47It was A, It was a asset called W Fed and it was part of a bank
- 58:56that actually William E Simon started in the 80s and it's kind
- 59:00of related in the in the 80s you had the S&L crisis and all the
- 59:06banks failed. But what the regulator did is
- 59:09they said you guys we can't afford to bring you on like what
- 59:12the Fed's doing now. So we they they gave them
- 59:14something called supervisory goodwill.
- 59:16They gave them a fake asset so they could comply with all of
- 59:20the regulations and capital requirements.
- 59:24It was fake, but they operated. So it basically operating on
- 59:28very little capital, but the government didn't have to
- 59:30resolve them. But in 91, Congress enacted
- 59:34Faria and ripped out all of that goodwill.
- 59:37They took it away and immediately hundreds of banks
- 59:39failed. There was a lawsuit that went in
- 59:42and it took almost eight years. But our firm back then had
- 59:47bought these bonds that were trading at I won't even blow a
- 59:51nickel. And I understood the law, I
- 59:54understood the wrongful taking and I said this asset is not
- 59:59understood and they're going to get part.
- 1:00:00Plus I see so. So that's why I focused on Judge
- 1:00:05Rao's decision in in August of August 29th and like she just
- 1:00:10opened the door for the ETF. That's why we were very
- 1:00:13convicted on the price target. I've seen this movie.
- 1:00:16The regular is going to be against it.
- 1:00:18The law provides it and the market will slowly realize it,
- 1:00:21and that's why I think we're off to the races.
- 1:00:24I I love these these stories of pattern recognition of you have
- 1:00:30this example from your past of digging in deep enough to have
- 1:00:35an information asymmetry and understanding like OK this is
- 1:00:39this is pretty solid and this thing is mispriced and this is
- 1:00:43an opportunity and I'm going to take take action and you have
- 1:00:46that in in your past and you're seeing that again and and you
- 1:00:50know we talked to people who lived through the the tech
- 1:00:54bubble or you know the early Internet era in the 90s and and
- 1:01:00they the pattern recognition right now for them is just
- 1:01:03firing that this is the same thing all over again the same
- 1:01:06story And you know Michael Saylor is an example of this of
- 1:01:12of he he saw the Internet unfolding and he was going to
- 1:01:16build a business in it and invest heavily in it.
- 1:01:20And then you know he saw Apple coming and he made that his his
- 1:01:24big personal bet in his portfolio and made a killing off
- 1:01:28of that when you know before the iPhone took over the world.
- 1:01:32And so we have, we have a quite a few folks who are early to
- 1:01:38Bitcoin from the traditional system right now are the people
- 1:01:41who have for whatever reason have this pattern recognition
- 1:01:45like technology in their head of like I'm going to connect dots
- 1:01:49and then I'm going to build my personal conviction that I have
- 1:01:53an edge based on the the facts of of the matter and and the
- 1:01:58reality that people don't seem to see it.
- 1:02:00Yeah, the one that comes to mind.
- 1:02:01That's what you've done here. The one that comes to mind for
- 1:02:04that also is Amazon. But what's funny is it's less
- 1:02:06tech. If you really think about it,
- 1:02:07it's just a proxy for global liquidity, which is what Bitcoin
- 1:02:11is, right? Like everybody looks at the
- 1:02:12Amazon chart and then it fell, and then it just literally goes
- 1:02:14up and to the right. And is it like underlying
- 1:02:16fundamentals or is it just based on like, you know, the amount of
- 1:02:19dollars in the system, which is effectively like what Bitcoin
- 1:02:22absorbs? It's a very similar like
- 1:02:23Macroscopes, the one that talks like about Amazon and Bitcoin
- 1:02:26from it's like charts anyway. I think there's two things on on
- 1:02:32that, like I'll do the analogy of Hussein Bolt, which I love.
- 1:02:35They're like look, look at the guy Ron, he's brilliant.
- 1:02:38He pulled away every time and you're like he actually
- 1:02:41accelerates as you get towards the finish line.
- 1:02:44And that's not what he does. It's just that everyone else
- 1:02:48slows down more than he does. He's slowing down after whatever
- 1:02:53is 40 meters, 100 meter dash, something like that.
- 1:02:56So that's that in your Amazon stories like, yeah, Amazon is a
- 1:03:01liquidity play. But what happened is the rest of
- 1:03:04retail just failed. They just couldn't keep up.
- 1:03:08Their capital allocation model was poor.
- 1:03:10So Amazon did do something better and they and they were a
- 1:03:14better source of or haven for the growing liquidity.
- 1:03:20But you also had the field fall and back to New York Community
- 1:03:24Bank which supposedly just raised a billion dollars from
- 1:03:27somebody. You know all these banks are,
- 1:03:30they're just behind, they're going to fail and you have to
- 1:03:33have a better way to transfer store money.
- 1:03:37And I think we have it. You know, I'm going to let you
- 1:03:41guys figure out which which protocol I'm talking about, but
- 1:03:43I think we have a better one here.
- 1:03:47Yeah, I mean, let's look at it. We're talked about the banks are
- 1:03:49failing. New York, NY Community Bank
- 1:03:53seems to be done. The government's printing $1
- 1:03:55trillion of of fresh debt every 100 days.
- 1:04:01Egypt. The Egypt # depreciated by 50%
- 1:04:05today in in one day with one interest.
- 1:04:08Rate, I think. It just like.
- 1:04:12Changed the exchange rate. They changed the interest rate
- 1:04:14and then I think the market, the exchange rate was reflected is
- 1:04:20reflective of the market's reaction to that interest rate
- 1:04:23manipulation that the Bank of Egypt did.
- 1:04:25Mark it like it is glaringly obvious.
- 1:04:27I have more conviction than I ever have had in Bitcoin and my
- 1:04:31conviction has been quite strong for some time.
- 1:04:34And then you factor in just a pure outside of those macro
- 1:04:38tailwinds, you look at the pure demand supply dynamics playing
- 1:04:42out. We talked heavily about the ETS.
- 1:04:43We didn't even mention it and maybe that's a good topic to
- 1:04:46wrap up with in the last five minutes.
- 1:04:48Here is Michael Saylor just issued $700 million, he
- 1:04:52announced 600 million then it came out today.
- 1:04:54As you know actually we're at the $700 million of this convert
- 1:04:58offering that we're going to use explicitly to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:05:01He's done this many times in the past.
- 1:05:03He's continuing to do it and looking where micro strategy's
- 1:05:07stock prices. Now you have to imagine there's
- 1:05:10other public company executives looking like hey maybe we should
- 1:05:14try this strategy too. And so like you're looking at
- 1:05:17the macro factors and then all these demand supply dynamics
- 1:05:21that only seem to be accelerating and if you're not
- 1:05:24convicted in this trade, I don't know what you're looking at.
- 1:05:28It's in the taking your point on NYCB and it's failure, it's
- 1:05:34heavy into commercial real estate.
- 1:05:37I don't know the exact amount, but that's that is a portion of
- 1:05:40the losses that they've had to increase the reserve for.
- 1:05:44And in real estate lending, you can go in and do credit work and
- 1:05:51say I think I like the asset, I like the market.
- 1:05:54But when you lend against a hard asset, what you can't really
- 1:05:57deal with if you're a fixed receiver of Fiat is inflation.
- 1:06:02And imagine if you're you know, can you think of a way, Marty,
- 1:06:06where you can, if you're a real estate lender, how you can deal
- 1:06:09with that, how you can offset that risk?
- 1:06:11Would Bitcoin be one way of helping that?
- 1:06:15Yes. Then we have, yeah, there's many
- 1:06:22companies out there, some of which were invested in at 1031,
- 1:06:26that are really thinking heavily and focusing on this problem
- 1:06:29because this is a massive problem.
- 1:06:32You, you, you look at the amount of buildings, commercial or
- 1:06:35retail or residential that have been built across the country.
- 1:06:40You look at interest rates, it's look at the bank's balance
- 1:06:44sheets. It's not a good situation for a
- 1:06:47lot of these people. Going back to the the the MSTRI
- 1:06:51was telling Jesse we were on a call before this.
- 1:06:53I have some screenshots of like I got to send them to you called
- 1:06:56the MSTR like confessionals and have like a lot of friends.
- 1:06:59I'm sure we all do but like these are pretty.
- 1:07:01It seems degen to the upside of one friend said that their their
- 1:07:05wife's 401K last year two years ago was in and then silently put
- 1:07:09the other half into it like 6 months ago or three months ago
- 1:07:13whatever before this recent run up.
- 1:07:15And another friend that orange build, his colleague that's like
- 1:07:18worked his whole life and it's 3X their pension and and like in
- 1:07:23MSTR like there's just no shortage of people that are like
- 1:07:27that that's been their proxy via their like traditional brokerage
- 1:07:30account to get exposure to Bitcoin.
- 1:07:32Yeah, and they're on the cusp of becoming an S&P 500 company.
- 1:07:36They're on the cusp of they may have done it today, who knows.
- 1:07:38Surpassing their all time high set duringthe.com Boom back in.
- 1:07:43Maybe Mark, like that's a good question for you.
- 1:07:46Like just plain the markets. Like how how long can somebody
- 1:07:48not pay attention to that before they do it like somebody else?
- 1:07:54I I think it oh somebody else for that I was going to go to
- 1:07:57the index side. People are so heavily indexed
- 1:08:00that that is the killer app. People look at the S&P as a
- 1:08:04momentum fund. They're like it's a momentum
- 1:08:07fund. They capture momentum whether it
- 1:08:10be in video or or otherwise. They love indexes.
- 1:08:13So MSTR going in there would be a big deal.
- 1:08:16But to answer your question, jeez, I I think it's going to be
- 1:08:20a little slower. There's to be that early
- 1:08:23innovator people are not incentivized.
- 1:08:25If you're a treasurer and you've got a fixed income and you're
- 1:08:28not a partner in the larger firm, why would you risk this
- 1:08:31asset going in? So I'm I'm going to be, I have
- 1:08:35no visibility to say I see where that Domino's going to fall and
- 1:08:40we're going to have acceleration.
- 1:08:42I don't have that visibility on that.
- 1:08:46I like the idea of maybe the one offs.
- 1:08:50You know I'm I'm going to shift that to answering the question
- 1:08:53that Jesse had about the osmosis and it goes to real estate.
- 1:08:58Remember 70s popped for like 500 Alex Guys, I don't know if you
- 1:09:02remember the there was a movie called or show called the
- 1:09:06Beverly Hillbillies about a poor, a poor family that struck
- 1:09:10oil, you know, 70s. And then we had Dallas, the show
- 1:09:13that came out in the early 80s about Dallas, TX and oil.
- 1:09:17It happened because oil went from 2 bucks to I think 35 bucks
- 1:09:21during the 70s and people started drilling and that was
- 1:09:24like the mimetic of wealth. Our mimetic of wealth is going
- 1:09:29to be who sat on Bitcoin. So maybe Michael to answer your
- 1:09:33question, we can get people to think about how their company
- 1:09:38made money 20-30 years ago and slot in Bitcoin as being the
- 1:09:42next thing to to germinate on their portfolio.
- 1:09:45So hopefully I circle that square enough to bring it back
- 1:09:49to your your your question. No, it's perfect.
- 1:09:54Yeah. But zero in Beverly Hillbillies
- 1:09:56guys, right? That that was not on your bingo
- 1:09:58card. When that domino falls, I think
- 1:10:02I agree. I don't know if it's going to
- 1:10:03happen this year, next year, how soon or how much longer it will
- 1:10:08take to happen, but when it falls, you have 5-6 reputable
- 1:10:14publicly traded companies employing the micro strategy
- 1:10:18strategy full on speculative attack.
- 1:10:23It's like this crazy. Like if they're able to issue
- 1:10:26$700 million in a convert now, the interest rate was what, 65
- 1:10:30pips? Yeah, 62 1/2 pips until 2030.
- 1:10:36It's insane. Marty, I can't, like I put price
- 1:10:40targets out there. I'm, I'm in a regulated entity.
- 1:10:42We can't, you know, we don't tell people what to do, but our
- 1:10:47price targets tell you how we feel about the reflexivity
- 1:10:50dynamic, about the asymmetry, about the supply demand.
- 1:10:53I've never seen it as in my career.
- 1:10:56I can say that I haven't. I've observed no, no opportunity
- 1:11:00like this, given the facts, given what's happened.
- 1:11:03And of course, things can change absolutely.
- 1:11:06I've never seen this type of opportunity even outside of
- 1:11:10that, even including that West side opportunity.
- 1:11:15Yeah. So I'm I'm.
- 1:11:17I agree. Get get curious, folks.
- 1:11:20Get curious and we've got a wrap here.
- 1:11:23We're going to leave all you listeners with massive FOMO.
- 1:11:27Gentlemen, we'll be back next week.
- 1:11:29Thank you, Mark. Thanks, Mark.