Latest / Seasons of Joy / Shame vs. Guilt: Why Knowing the Difference is Important
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever done something you regret and felt that sinking,
- 0:03heavy feeling that didn't just say, I made a mistake?
- 0:07It said, I am a mistake.
- 0:09This distinction has changed my approach to coaching, to motherhood,
- 0:14and to how I talk to myself.
- 0:16Today, we are going to explore the difference between the two and why it is
- 0:21so important to understand.
- 0:23Today, we're talking about shame and guilt.
- 0:27I have been inspired by the research of Brene Brown on this topic,
- 0:30and I wanted to take her foundational ideas and bring them into the work we
- 0:35do here, especially for those of us navigating difficult relationships,
- 0:40faith transitions in our families, and the ever-present inner critic that just won't quit.
- 0:46I have not just studied this, but I have lived this. Let's dive in.
- 0:52Are you a woman of faith who is struggling to navigate your current season of life?
- 0:56Do you feel like life is just happening to you instead of for you?
- 1:00My name is Jill Pack, and I'm a certified faith-based life coach and a member
- 1:05of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- 1:08I want you to know that no matter your season or your circumstance,
- 1:13it is possible to create a more
- 1:15joyful life, and I would love to show you how. Are you ready? Let's go.
- 1:26Welcome back to the Seasons of Joy podcast. I'm your host, Jill Pack,
- 1:31and this is episode number 192, entitled Shame vs.
- 1:36Guilt, Why Knowing the Difference is So Important.
- 1:39When I say the word shame, do you notice any kind of internal reaction,
- 1:44maybe a little tightening, a little bristle, a desire to skip past it?
- 1:49That reaction itself is worth paying attention to, because Brene Brown talks
- 1:54about what she calls the shame one, two, threes in her book,
- 1:58Atlas of the Heart, three things that are universally true about shame.
- 2:03And the second one is that we are all afraid to talk about it.
- 2:07Sometimes we feel shame from just saying the word.
- 2:10So if you felt that before, then you are in the right place.
- 2:14Before we get into the distinction between shame and guilt, I want to delay
- 2:18some groundwork with Brene's framework, because I think it can bring a lot of clarity on this topic.
- 2:25She talks about three things that she believes are true for virtually every human being.
- 2:32First, we all have it. She says that shame is universal. It's one of the most
- 2:37primitive emotions we experience as human beings.
- 2:40The only people who don't experience shame are those who lack the capacity for
- 2:45empathy and human connection.
- 2:47So if you have felt it, and I'm guessing that you have, that's not evidence
- 2:52that something is wrong with you.
- 2:54It's evidence that you are fully human.
- 2:56And second, we are all afraid to talk about it.
- 3:00The interesting thing about shame is that the very act of naming it can make us feel it.
- 3:07Just saying the word can create feelings of discomfort. But the more we talk
- 3:11about it, the better we get at finding the language to describe it.
- 3:15And that matters a lot because of the third point, which is the less we talk
- 3:21about shame, the more control it has over us.
- 3:25Shame hates being spoken. It thrives in silence and secrecy.
- 3:30It grows in the dark. And the moment we bring it into the light by naming it,
- 3:35sharing it with a safe person, and examining it with honesty,
- 3:39its grip begins to loosen.
- 3:42Actually why I wanted to make this episode, because I think a lot of us are
- 3:47being quietly controlled by something we've never been given language for.
- 3:52So what is shame exactly? Brene Brown describes it as the intensely painful
- 3:58feeling or experience of believing that we are flawed, and therefore unworthy of love,
- 4:05unworthy of belonging, unworthy of connection.
- 4:08That's the core wound of shame. It's not just I feel bad about something,
- 4:14it's I'm fundamentally defective,
- 4:16and if people really knew me, really saw me, they would confirm my worst fear,
- 4:22which is, I don't belong here.
- 4:24Now here's where the distinction between shame and guilt becomes so important and so freeing.
- 4:31Guilt says, I did something bad. Shame says, I am bad.
- 4:38Guilt is about behavior, a specific action, a moment you wish you could take back.
- 4:43And guilt, when it's healthy, actually motivates repair.
- 4:48It says, that didn't line up with my values, and I want to do better.
- 4:52Guilt keeps us connected, tethered to our integrity.
- 4:57Shame shapes the behavior into identity.
- 5:01It doesn't say, I made a mistake. It says, I am a mistake. And Brene's research is clear.
- 5:08Shame is correlated with more destructive behavior, not less.
- 5:12When we feel shame, we hide, we shut down, we lash out, or numb.
- 5:17It doesn't make us better. It makes us smaller.
- 5:20Guilt is far more likely to lead to meaningful change. So let me show you what
- 5:25I mean with a story from my own life.
- 5:28When I carried something very heavy. When my children started making choices
- 5:33that looked different from everything we'd had built, our family around,
- 5:37different values, different lifestyles, a different relationship with faith. I didn't just feel sad.
- 5:43I felt implicated, like their choices were somehow a verdict on me.
- 5:48The story running in my head was relentless.
- 5:51A good mother would have gotten this right. If I had done more,
- 5:55said the right things, been more present, more patient, more consistent,
- 5:59They wouldn't be here. This is my fault.
- 6:02Now, this was shame. It wasn't saying I made some mistakes along the way,
- 6:07which is just true of every parent who has ever lived.
- 6:11It is saying I am the mistake. I am the reason.
- 6:16Do you hear Brene's definition underneath that?
- 6:19I believed I was flawed. And because I believed I was flawed, I felt unworthy.
- 6:24Unworthy of being seen as a good mother, unworthy of connection with my kids,
- 6:29maybe even unworthy of grace.
- 6:31I want to name what that felt like in my body because shame isn't just a thought.
- 6:37It is a physical experience. There was a heaviness, like something pressing
- 6:41down on my chest that I couldn't quite shake, and I would carry it into ordinary
- 6:46moments, folding laundry,
- 6:48driving to the grocery store, and it would just be there, this quiet, crushing weight.
- 6:54Shame kept me focused entirely on myself, on my failure, on my inadequacy,
- 7:00and ironically, that meant I had very little capacity left to actually be present with my kids.
- 7:07Shame didn't make me a better mother. It just made me a more hidden one.
- 7:12I had to learn to separate my worth from my children's choices,
- 7:17not to stop caring. I will never stop caring, but to stop letting their journey
- 7:22be the final word on who I am.
- 7:25What I just described, that heaviness, that internal collapse,
- 7:29that's not just emotional, That's physiological.
- 7:32When shame hits, your body doesn't just experience it as an emotion.
- 7:37It experiences it as a threat.
- 7:40Your nervous system goes into protection mode. You might freeze,
- 7:44go quiet, withdraw, disappear from people who matter most.
- 7:48You might go into fawn, over-apologizing, people-pleasing, shrinking yourself
- 7:53to manage everyone else's feelings, or you might flip into fight.
- 7:59Defensiveness, blaming, sudden anger that surprises even you.
- 8:03That's why self-awareness is so foundational. It's difficult to work with an emotion you can't name.
- 8:09When you can pause and ask, is this guilt or is this shame?
- 8:13You've already taken the first step towards regulation.
- 8:17And speaking of defensiveness, that leads me to my second story.
- 8:22Phil and I have been married a long time, and if I'm being honest with you,
- 8:26there's a pattern that I've had in our relationship that I'm not really proud of.
- 8:31When he offers input on how I
- 8:33am doing something, even with the best intentions, my defenses go up fast.
- 8:40I've known this about myself for a while, but knowing something and actually
- 8:44doing something about it are two very different things.
- 8:48In one particular conversation, something shifted.
- 8:51Instead of waiting until I was mid-defensive spiral, I brought it up first,
- 8:56and I told him, I know I tend to get defensive when you try to help me with
- 9:01things, and I'm working on it.
- 9:03Now notice what was happening inside of me in that moment.
- 9:07There was discomfort, a recognition that this pattern hadn't been serving us,
- 9:12but there was no heaviness pressing on my chest, no voice saying you are fundamentally
- 9:17broken. It was something quieter and more purposeful.
- 9:21It said, this specific behavior doesn't reflect who I want to be,
- 9:24and I care enough about us to say it out loud.
- 9:27That's guilt doing its healthy work. And the moment I named it,
- 9:32something in the relationship softened, not because I had it all figured out,
- 9:36but because I was willing to be honest.
- 9:39That's the difference right there. Shame collapsed me inward and made me smaller.
- 9:44Guilt moved me toward something, toward honesty, toward feel, toward growth.
- 9:50It's easy to hear shame is bad and assume that the goal is to let yourself off the hook.
- 9:56That's not what I'm saying. It's not what the research says either.
- 10:00True accountability actually requires getting out of shame because when we're
- 10:05drowning in, I'm terrible, we're too busy defending our worth to actually address the behavior.
- 10:11Shame masquerades as accountability, but rarely produces it.
- 10:16The shift could sound like this. from I'm a terrible mother for how I handled
- 10:20that conversation to I didn't handle that well and that matters to me because
- 10:25I love her. What can I do differently?
- 10:28The second sentence is connected. It's motivated.
- 10:32It's moving toward repair rather
- 10:35than hiding in collapse. This is where my progress formula comes in.
- 10:39Grace or progress equals self-awareness plus self-acceptance,
- 10:44plus self-compassion, plus self-trust.
- 10:47You cannot do any of those things well when you are in shame.
- 10:51Shame short-circuits the whole equation.
- 10:55And remember, Brene said, shame makes us feel unworthy of love and connection.
- 11:00The progress formula is essentially the path back to believing you are worthy of both.
- 11:05I invite you to listen to episode number 149 of this podcast where you can learn
- 11:12more about the progress formula.
- 11:15So how do we actually do this in a real moment?
- 11:19Here are the tools I use with my clients and with myself.
- 11:22First of all, we want to name it out loud. Remember, shame hates being spoken.
- 11:27The moment you say, I think I'm feeling shame right now.
- 11:31You've done the one thing shame doesn't want you to do.
- 11:34You've brought it into the light. You're observing it rather than being consumed by it.
- 11:40Number two, regulate first. You cannot sink your way out of a shame spiral.
- 11:45Your nervous system has to settle down before your brain can come back online.
- 11:51Use your safety sequence by asking, am I safe?
- 11:54Do I feel safe? And then you relax your body with things like taking three slow
- 12:00breaths, putting your feet on the floor, stepping outside.
- 12:03You just want to tend to your body before you try to examine the story.
- 12:08And then you want to ask the guilt question. Once you're a little more regulated,
- 12:14you can ask yourself, is there an action here I want to take responsibility for?
- 12:19If yes, that's guilt doing its job.
- 12:22What's the repair? If you've collapsed into, I'm just a bad person, that's shame.
- 12:28And you can gently redirect, what did I do and what would I do differently?
- 12:34And finally, bring in a witness.
- 12:37Shame cannot survive being shared with a safe person. This is Brene's core message.
- 12:43Vulnerability is the antidote to shame. A trusted friend, a coach,
- 12:48a therapist, someone who can hear your story without confirming your worst fears about yourself.
- 12:54Every single time you do that, you take a little more of shame's power away.
- 13:00I want to speak directly to those of you who are in painful seasons with your
- 13:05children, adult children, who've made choices that have broken your heart,
- 13:09who've stepped away from your faith, or who've pulled away from you entirely.
- 13:13The shame that gets loaded onto a mother in that situation is enormous,
- 13:17and so much of it is unfair.
- 13:20Our culture has a way of making mothers responsible for every outcome in their
- 13:25children's lives. and when things go sideways, shame is right there whispering
- 13:30the story you already feared. You weren't enough.
- 13:33I know that story personally. I've sat in that heaviness and I want to offer
- 13:38you something different.
- 13:39What if it's possible to hold your genuine grief about a relationship and a
- 13:45genuine accountability for the places you want to grow without taking on shame
- 13:50that was never yours to carry.
- 13:52You can say, I want to do better in how I show up for my daughter.
- 13:57That's healthy, motivated, and loving.
- 13:59But you don't have to say, I'm the reason everything went wrong.
- 14:04Those are not the same sentence. And learning to tell the difference might be
- 14:08some of the most important work you ever do.
- 14:11Shame is one of the most powerful forces in the human experience.
- 14:16Brene Brown spent many years of her research life trying to understand it precisely
- 14:22because of how much quiet damage it does when we leave it unnamed and unexamined.
- 14:29So today I wanna leave with you her one, two, threes as a kind of anchor.
- 14:34We all have it, that makes you normal, not broken.
- 14:38We're all afraid to talk about it, but talking is exactly what heals it.
- 14:43And the less we talk about it, the more control it has over us.
- 14:47So let's keep talking.
- 14:49You are not your worst moments. You are a person who sometimes does things you wish you hadn't.
- 14:55And that makes you exactly like every other human being on this planet, including me.
- 15:01Now, if this episode resonated with you, I would love to hear from you.
- 15:05You can find me on Instagram at seasons underscore coaching or at my website,
- 15:10www.seasons-coaching.com.
- 15:13And if you're ready to do deeper work on the shame and conflict patterns showing
- 15:18up in your relationships, reach out.
- 15:21That's exactly the kind of transformation we do together in private coaching.
- 15:25Until next time, keep growing in grace. Thank you for tuning in to the Seasons
- 15:31of Joy podcast. I hope you enjoyed today's episode.
- 15:34And if you like what you heard, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review and
- 15:38share with your friends and family.
- 15:40If you want to learn more about me or how to work with me, just visit my website,
- 15:44www.seasons-coaching.com and have a joyful weekend.