Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Climate Change & Health: Understanding Environmental Wellness Principles
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology Undergrad. I am so
- 0:02glad you could join us today for this study session.
- 0:04Yeah, thanks for hanging out with us. Grab a
- 0:06seat, grab your notes, because we are getting
- 0:08into some really heavy but totally fascinating
- 0:10stuff today. We really are. So for this deep
- 0:13dive, we are jumping into Chapter 14, which is
- 0:16all about environmental wellness. Right. And
- 0:18you know, normally in our psych classes, we focus
- 0:20a lot on the individual, like individual cognition
- 0:23or personal trauma. Exactly. But today, our mission
- 0:27is to build what the sources call climate literacy.
- 0:31We are looking at this massive global issue strictly
- 0:33through a psychological and behavioral lens.
- 0:36Because it really is a two -way street. You know,
- 0:38it's about understanding how our cognitive biases
- 0:40drive our impact on the climate and then, in
- 0:43turn, how a changing planet takes a physiological
- 0:46and psychological toll on us. Yeah, it's such
- 0:48a crazy feedback loop. But before we get into
- 0:51the heavy data, let's start with a basic framing.
- 0:54Historically, how have human beings actually
- 0:56thought about the Earth? Well, pretty much across
- 0:58the board. For thousands of years, human societies
- 1:01have relied on this archetype of Mother Earth.
- 1:04Right, like this ultimate nurturing figure. Exactly.
- 1:07We have this deep ingrained mental schema that
- 1:10the planet is just an inexhaustible provider.
- 1:13It will always be there to take care of us. which
- 1:16perfectly sets up this quote from Mahatma Gandhi
- 1:18that was in our reading. It essentially says,
- 1:22Earth provides enough to satisfy every man's
- 1:24needs, but not every man's greed. I love that
- 1:28quote. It introduces a moral framework right
- 1:30from the jump. It totally does. Because it points
- 1:32out this huge tension between what we biologically
- 1:35need to survive, you know, basic food, water,
- 1:38shelter, and what our modern consumer brains
- 1:40have been conditioned to want. Right. Our brains
- 1:42have basically been hijacked to just desire more,
- 1:46more, more. We hoard and consume way past our
- 1:49baseline needs, completely ignoring the physical
- 1:51limits of the environment. Yeah, it's like our
- 1:53biological hardware hasn't caught up with modern
- 1:55society. But okay, to really get into this, we
- 1:58need to agree on the physical reality of what
- 2:00is happening out there. Definitely. And there
- 2:02are two terms the sources bring up right away
- 2:04that people always mix up. Global warming and
- 2:06climate change. Oh yeah, people use them interchangeably
- 2:08all the time, but they trigger very different
- 2:10cognitive reactions. So global warming is specifically
- 2:13the long -term heating of the Earth's climate
- 2:16system. Right, basically the literal temperature
- 2:18going up since the pre -industrial period, so
- 2:20around 1850 or so. And that is mostly driven
- 2:23by humans burning fossil fuels. Exactly. Whereas
- 2:26climate change is the broader umbrella term.
- 2:28It covers the long -term shifts in all weather
- 2:30patterns, like extreme rain, wind, and the temperature
- 2:34shifts. And the main mechanical driver behind
- 2:36that warming is the greenhouse effect. So if
- 2:39you're trying to visualize this, and this is
- 2:41a really common memory trick for psych undergrads
- 2:44picture, a literal glass greenhouse. Yeah, that's
- 2:47a classic way to think about it. You stand outside.
- 2:50You feel the sun. But inside, the sun's rays
- 2:53enter through the glass. They turn into heat.
- 2:55And then that heat gets trapped. It can't escape
- 2:58back out. Because in our atmosphere, we have
- 3:00these trace gases acting like the glass. things
- 3:03like carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide, methane,
- 3:06and water vapor. They just block the heat from
- 3:08radiating back into space. But here is my question
- 3:11for you, purely from a cognitive standpoint.
- 3:13Okay, lay it on me. Those gases are completely
- 3:16invisible. And human beings are evolutionarily
- 3:19wired to react to visible immediate threats.
- 3:22Like a tiger jumps out, we run. Right, the classic
- 3:25fight or flight response. Yeah. So doesn't the
- 3:27fact that greenhouse gases are invisible make
- 3:30it cognitively almost impossible for us to react
- 3:34to this crisis appropriately? Oh, absolutely.
- 3:36It is a textbook evolutionary mismatch. Our brains
- 3:40are built for acute local survival, not for long
- 3:45-term abstract global threats. It's that out
- 3:48of sight, out of mind bias. Exactly. It's something
- 3:50called hyperbolic discounting. We will almost
- 3:53always choose the immediate reward of, say, burning
- 3:56cheap fuel today. over the delayed reward of
- 3:58a stable climate 50 years from now. That makes
- 4:00so much sense, but scientists do have ways of
- 4:02making the invisible visible, right? Yeah, they
- 4:04use ice cores. Right. Which are just incredible.
- 4:06They drill these miles deep frozen time castles
- 4:09out of glaciers. Wait, and they just look at
- 4:11the bubbles trapped in the ice? Literally, yes.
- 4:14Tiny air bubbles frozen hundreds of thousands
- 4:16of years ago. It gives us a pristine record of
- 4:19greenhouse gases going back 800 ,000 years. Wow,
- 4:23800 ,000 years. Yeah, and the data is pretty
- 4:25clear. The current levels of carbon dioxide in
- 4:28the atmosphere are completely unprecedented in
- 4:30that entire timeline Okay, so knowing that knowing
- 4:33the threat is real Are we actually changing our
- 4:36behavior because I was looking at the EPA data
- 4:38in the chapter and there's this wild contradiction
- 4:41You mean the emissions gap? Yeah So in the U
- 4:44.S., total greenhouse gas emissions actually
- 4:46dropped by 12 % since 2005. Which sounds great
- 4:49on paper. Right, but then you look at global
- 4:52net emissions and those went up by 43 % from
- 4:551990 to 2015. It's a massive jump. So my thought
- 4:58is, are we actually solving anything in the U
- 5:00.S. or did we just offshore all our dirty manufacturing
- 5:03to other countries and like pat ourselves on
- 5:05the back for having clean air? That is the exact
- 5:07uncomfortable question the data forces us to
- 5:10ask and honestly, it's a bit of both. Really?
- 5:13How so? Well, the U .S. has made some genuine
- 5:15progress. We've got slightly cleaner energy grids
- 5:18and better vehicle efficiency. But yeah, we buy
- 5:21tons of products made in developing nations with
- 5:23looser environmental rules. So we basically shifted
- 5:26the visible pollution off our own ledger. It's
- 5:29like a total psychological sleight of hand to
- 5:31make ourselves feel better. Pretty much. We kept
- 5:34the consumption habits but outsourced the guilt.
- 5:37But we can't outsource the physical consequences
- 5:39because the earth is definitely reacting. Right,
- 5:42let's get into that mental map of the evidence.
- 5:44For everyone listening, a good way to remember
- 5:46the massive amount of EPA data is to break it
- 5:49down into sky, sea, and soil. I like that. Let's
- 5:53start with the sky or the weather. Heat waves
- 5:55are happening three times more often now than
- 5:57they did in the 1960s. Three times? That's wild.
- 6:00And eight of the top ten warmest years worldwide
- 6:03have all happened just since 2005. Okay, so then
- 6:05for the sea, we're looking at sea levels rising.
- 6:07Parts of the Gulf and mid -Atlantic have seen
- 6:09an 8 -inch rise since 1960. And the ocean is
- 6:12basically acting like a giant sponge for all
- 6:15our excess carbon dioxide. Which makes it more
- 6:17acidic, right? Yeah, the ocean chemistry is changing.
- 6:20It's harming marine life, basically dissolving
- 6:22the carbonate ions that things like crabs and
- 6:25corals need to build their skeletons. It's so
- 6:28sad. And finally, for soil or land... and ice,
- 6:32we have Arctic sea ice shrinking and permafrost
- 6:35warming in Alaska. The pictures of the glaciers
- 6:37are just mind blowing, like the Muir glacier
- 6:40in Alaska in 1941. It was this massive wall of
- 6:43ice. And by 2004, it was basically just open
- 6:45water. Exactly. But, you know, we were talking
- 6:48about how people don't react well to abstract
- 6:50data. A melting glacier thousands of miles away
- 6:54doesn't really change the daily behavior of someone
- 6:56living in Chicago. No, it really doesn't. Our
- 6:58brains just don't process distant geography as
- 7:01a personal threat. What actually shakes us out
- 7:04of our cognitive dissonance is when the local
- 7:06stuff gets disrupted. Right, when it hits close
- 7:08to home. Yeah, like the cherry blossom trees
- 7:10in Washington, D .C. They've tracked the peak
- 7:13bloom date since the 1920s. And because the baseline
- 7:16temperature is warmer now, they're blooming earlier
- 7:18and earlier. Which completely throws off that
- 7:21massive cultural festival they hold every year.
- 7:24Exactly. When climate change ruins a beloved
- 7:26local tradition, suddenly people are like, oh,
- 7:29wait. This is a real problem. And it goes way
- 7:32deeper than just festivals. The research brings
- 7:34up the Snake River in Washington state, which
- 7:36ties directly into religion and morality. Oh,
- 7:40right. With the salmon population. Yes. So between
- 7:421960 and 2020, the water temperature in the Snake
- 7:45River went up by one point nine degrees Fahrenheit,
- 7:48which sounds like nothing to us. Yeah, practically
- 7:50a rounding error. But for the salmon, they need
- 7:53highly specific cold water to spawn. And those
- 7:56salmon aren't just food. or an economic resource,
- 7:59they play a sacred central role in the religion
- 8:02of Native American tribes in that area. Wow.
- 8:05So when the water warms up just two degrees,
- 8:07it's not just an environmental issue. It directly
- 8:10threatens an entire spiritual lifeline. Exactly.
- 8:12It becomes a moral injury. A moral injury. I
- 8:15think that perfectly pivots us to the next section
- 8:18of our deep dive. As psych students, we really
- 8:20need to look at how this shifting environment
- 8:22impacts the human body and mind. Right, because
- 8:24we tend to just think of disaster impacts as,
- 8:27you know, property damage. Yeah, we think of
- 8:30immediate physical danger like drowning in a
- 8:32flood or getting caught in a hurricane. But this
- 8:35is actually a massive threat multiplier for vulnerable
- 8:38populations. It really discriminates based on
- 8:41pre -existing conditions. For instance, think
- 8:43about the cognitive and emotional distress an
- 8:45Alzheimer's patient goes through if they have
- 8:48to be suddenly evacuated for a wildfire. Oh,
- 8:50that would be incredibly traumatizing. Or people
- 8:53with obesity or cardiovascular disease. They
- 8:55have a really hard time regulating their core
- 8:57body temperature, so heat stress is incredibly
- 9:00dangerous for them. And then there are entirely
- 9:02new physical threats emerging. Because the winters
- 9:05are getting milder, ticks are moving further
- 9:07north. Ugh, ticks. I know, they're awful. But
- 9:10the rate of reported Lyme disease cases has practically
- 9:13doubled since 1991. That is unsettling. But okay,
- 9:17here is the part of the reading that absolutely
- 9:19stopped me in my tracks. Right. We know carbon
- 9:21dioxide traps heat, but apparently it is also
- 9:25actively reducing the nutritional value of our
- 9:27food supply. Yeah. That is a really strange mechanism
- 9:30to wrap your head around. I just don't get it.
- 9:32How does CO2 in the air actually drain protein
- 9:36and minerals out of crops like wheat and rice?
- 9:39Well, it essentially speeds up the plant's metabolism.
- 9:42Plants need carbon dioxide for photosynthesis,
- 9:44right? Right. So when there's way more CO2 in
- 9:47the air, the plants grow way faster. They get
- 9:49huge. OK, so bigger plants. That sounds like
- 9:52a good thing. You'd think so, but their root
- 9:54systems can't keep up. They can't pull in the
- 9:57essential soil nutrients like iron, zinc, and
- 9:59protein fast enough to match their massive growth
- 10:03spurt. Wait, so they're basically just growing
- 10:05hollow? Kind of, yeah. They synthesize way more
- 10:08sugars and carbs, but they become nutritionally
- 10:10hollowed out. We are basically force -feeding
- 10:13our staple crops until they turn into junk food.
- 10:16That is terrifying. We're growing more food that
- 10:19sustains us less. That's a huge public health
- 10:22issue. And speaking of health, let's talk about
- 10:23the mental health toll, because I think our societal
- 10:26perception of disaster trauma is deeply flawed.
- 10:29Well, when we watch the news about a flood, the
- 10:32focus is entirely on surviving the rising water.
- 10:35But psychologically, the timeline of trauma is
- 10:38so much longer. Oh, absolutely. The post -event
- 10:40cleanup is exhausting. Right. It's the chronic
- 10:43anxiety of constantly checking the weather, prepping
- 10:46to evacuate, and then dealing with insurance,
- 10:49living in a hotel, seeing your neighborhood destroyed.
- 10:52That displacement trauma lasts for years. It
- 10:56creates a state of toxic stress. And the sources
- 10:58show that this heavily impacts vulnerable groups.
- 11:02Children, the elderly, pregnant women, the homeless.
- 11:05And the first responders, too. They absorb so
- 11:07much community trauma. Definitely. But there's
- 11:09another link between mental health and climate
- 11:11that almost no one talks about, and it involves
- 11:14psychiatric medications. Right. I remember reading
- 11:16this. This is about extreme heat. Right. Yes.
- 11:19Extreme heat waves are actually physically deadly
- 11:22for people managing severe mental illnesses because
- 11:24certain prescription meds like some SSRIs or
- 11:27anti -psychotics actually impair the body's ability
- 11:30to regulate temperature. So they chemically stop
- 11:32the body from sweating. Essentially, yes. They
- 11:35interfere with the hypothalamus or block anti
- 11:38-cholinergic responses. That is a devastating
- 11:41double bind. You take the medication to maintain
- 11:43your psychological stability, but during a heat
- 11:46wave, that exact same pill could trigger a fatal
- 11:50heat stroke. It's terrifying to think about.
- 11:52OK, so if the consequences to our bodies, our
- 11:54mental health, and our food supply are this dire,
- 11:57we have to ask the big behavioral question. Why
- 11:59do we keep doing it? Exactly. Why do humans continue
- 12:03to pollute and consume at this insane scale?
- 12:06And to answer that, we really have to look at
- 12:08overpopulation. The sheer numbers are staggering.
- 12:10I mean, public health advances have been amazing.
- 12:12Life expectancy went from about 48 years in 1900
- 12:15to nearly 78 years today. Which is fantastic.
- 12:18obviously it is but it triggered a massive population
- 12:21bro just to give you some context it took until
- 12:23the year 1803 for the human population to reach
- 12:261 billion people right all of human history just
- 12:29to hit 1 billion and then around 2023 we hit
- 12:328 billion and we are projected to hit 9 .7 billion
- 12:35by 2050 That is just so many people requiring
- 12:39massive amounts of resources. Just think about
- 12:42energy. The sources noted that 40 percent of
- 12:45all energy consumed in the U .S. is used purely
- 12:47to generate electricity. Right. Everyone is keeping
- 12:49the lights on, powering our servers, charging
- 12:51our phones. And with all that relentless consumption
- 12:55comes an unavoidable byproduct. which is waste.
- 13:00Have you ever seen pictures of the Great Pacific
- 13:02Garbage Patch? Oh, the massive floating island
- 13:05of marine debris. Yeah, it's out in the North
- 13:07Pacific. Exactly. Somewhere between California
- 13:09and Hawaii. And it is estimated to be double
- 13:12the size of Texas. Double the size of Texas.
- 13:14That's just so hard to fathom. And the way it
- 13:16was discovered in 1997 is so eerie. This sailor,
- 13:21Charles Moore, took a shortcut through this windless
- 13:24dead zone of the ocean. And he looked out. And
- 13:27for as far as the eye could see, he was just
- 13:29surrounded by bobbing plastics. A haunting image,
- 13:32just plastic everywhere. I was actually thinking
- 13:34about the garbage patch through a psychology
- 13:36lens. I kind of view it as the literal collective
- 13:38unconscious of our consumer habits. Oh, I like
- 13:41where you're going with this. You know how in
- 13:43psych, the collective unconscious is this dark
- 13:46repository for all our repressed instincts and
- 13:49fears? Right, the stuff we try to bury. Well,
- 13:52the garbage patch is the physical repository
- 13:54for all our repressed consumption. It's a massive
- 13:57accumulation of the things society throws away
- 14:00and just desperately tries to forget about. It's
- 14:03our behavioral shadow floating out in the ocean.
- 14:06That is such a brilliant analogy. We literally
- 14:08export our guilt out to the middle of nowhere.
- 14:11And speaking of guilt, we have to talk about
- 14:13the moral dilemma of food waste. Oh, this part
- 14:15made me so mad. It's crazy. We just talked about
- 14:17the fear of overpopulation, right? This underlying
- 14:20anxiety that 8 billion people will lead to massive
- 14:23starvation and resource scarcity. Right, the
- 14:25fear that there isn't enough to go around. Yet
- 14:27look at our actual behavior. One -third of all
- 14:30food in the U .S. goes completely uneaten. And
- 14:33back in 2018, 81 % of household wasted food ended
- 14:37up rotting in landfills. So we have this cognitive
- 14:40fear of scarcity, but our daily habits show a
- 14:43total careless disregard for the stuff we actually
- 14:45have. It's a huge ethical disconnect. It really
- 14:48is. So as psychology undergrads studying behavior
- 14:51modification, the real question is, how do we
- 14:54intervene? Right. How do we change human habits
- 14:58to build a more sustainable world? Well, we've
- 15:01all heard the classic mantra since elementary
- 15:03school, the three Rs, reduce, reuse, recycle.
- 15:07Yeah, but we need to elevate how we think about
- 15:10the three Rs, because we usually treat it like
- 15:12a catchy slogan, right? Yeah. But it's actually
- 15:14a strict cognitive checklist. It is entirely
- 15:17hierarchical. Exactly. Why is our society so
- 15:20obsessed with recycling, but we are absolutely
- 15:23terrible at reducing. Oh, that comes down to
- 15:25the dopamine loop. Tell me more about that. Well,
- 15:28recycling is essentially a behavioral loophole.
- 15:31When you toss a plastic water bottle into a blue
- 15:33bin, your brain gives you a little hit of dopamine.
- 15:36You feel like you did a good deed. Oh, I see.
- 15:38It alleviates the guilt of buying the plastic
- 15:40bottle in the first place. Exactly. But reducing
- 15:43requires the act of suppression of desire. You
- 15:46have to deny yourself a purchase or deny yourself
- 15:48convenience. There's no immediate dopamine reward
- 15:51for not buying something. That makes perfect
- 15:53sense. So for anyone listening, you have to remember
- 15:55they are in that specific order for a reason.
- 15:58Reducing is the primary goal. Reusing is your
- 16:01backup plan. And recycling is truly just the
- 16:04last resort. Right. The final safety net before
- 16:06it hits the landfill. And this ties into the
- 16:08broader concept of sustainability. The National
- 16:11Environmental Policy Act of 1969 really formalize
- 16:16this. Wait, 1969, that early? Yeah. It frames
- 16:19sustainability not just as some ecological goal,
- 16:22but as a moral and social obligation. It's about
- 16:25creating conditions where humans and nature can
- 16:28exist in harmony to fulfill the needs of both
- 16:31present and future generations. I love that framing.
- 16:34It's an intergenerational contract. But to actually
- 16:36achieve that, we can't just rely on individual
- 16:38willpower. We have to use healthy community design.
- 16:41Right. engineering our physical spaces to nudge
- 16:44people toward better behaviors. Exactly. The
- 16:46chapter gives some great examples like Northwest
- 16:48Arkansas building out this massive biking infrastructure.
- 16:51They're changing the physical environment to
- 16:53naturally promote exercise while cutting down
- 16:55on car emissions. And Denver did something similar.
- 16:58They had this huge stormwater flooding problem
- 17:00and they redesigned the landscape to turn it
- 17:03into a health equity opportunity. Oh yeah, they
- 17:06built those green spaces that absorb water but
- 17:08also serve the local community. It's brilliant.
- 17:10It is. But beyond community design, we also have
- 17:14immense power in our daily economic choices,
- 17:17especially with food. Because the modern food
- 17:19system burns so many fossil fuels just processing
- 17:22and transporting stuff across the country, right?
- 17:24Exactly, which is why opting for local environmentally
- 17:27responsible food is a profound moral action.
- 17:31It's not just a health choice. It's an ethical
- 17:33choice. Completely. When you buy local, you're
- 17:35financially supporting fair wages for farmers.
- 17:39You're demanding respect for farm animals, and
- 17:41you're preserving rural communities. You become
- 17:44an active participant in an ethical ecosystem
- 17:46instead of just a passive consumer. Man, we have
- 17:49covered so much ground today. So if you're organizing
- 17:51your psych class notes, here is the core takeaway.
- 17:54Give us the summary. First, everyone needs climate
- 17:57literacy because our brains are naturally blind
- 17:59to these invisible, slow -moving threats. Second,
- 18:03the planet is definitively warming up because
- 18:05greenhouse gases are trapping heat. Right. Third,
- 18:08these physical changes are acting as massive
- 18:11threat multipliers for our physical and mental
- 18:13health. And finally, even though our overpopulation
- 18:17and consumption are driving the crisis, we actually
- 18:19possess the behavioral tools to fight back. We
- 18:22do. But I want to leave you, the listener, with
- 18:25one final slightly provocative thought to mull
- 18:28over before we go. Oh, I love a good thought
- 18:30experiment. What is it? Well, at the very beginning
- 18:32of the deep dive, we talked about how our ancestors
- 18:34viewed the planet as a nurturing Mother Earth.
- 18:37Right, a provider. But today, our modern society
- 18:41basically treats the Earth as a disposable, inexhaustible
- 18:45resource. So how does that profound shift change
- 18:48our collective psyche? Oh, wow. If we spend our
- 18:51entire lives interacting with a physical world
- 18:53that we treat with zero empathy, does treating
- 18:56the planet as disposable fundamentally erode
- 18:59our empathy for each other? That is a deeply
- 19:02philosophical and psychological question to end
- 19:04on. If we treat the world around us like trash,
- 19:08it's not hard to see how that mindset bleeds
- 19:10into how we treat our neighbors. Exactly. Something
- 19:13to think about. Well, thank you all for diving
- 19:15into this complex material with us today. Keep
- 19:17studying and we'll catch you next time on The
- 19:20Psychology Undergrad.