Latest / Kentucky Tonight / 2025 Kentucky General Assembly Session
Transcript
- 0:09GOOD EVENING. WELCOME TO
- 0:10KENTUCKY TONIGHT. I'M RENEE SHA
- 0:14OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: THE 2025
- 0:16KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THE
- 0:17SESSION BEGAN LAST TUESDAY.
- 0:20LAWMAKERS HEARD GOVERNOR ANDY
- 0:21BESHEAR’S STATE OF THE
- 0:22COMMONWEALTH ADDRESS ON WEDNESD
- 0:25AND THERE’S BEEN ACTION ON HOUS
- 0:27BILL 1, A BILL TO CUT THE STATE
- 0:29INCOME TAX FROM FOUR PERCENT TO
- 0:30THREE AND A HALF NEXT YEAR. THAT
- 0:32BILL PASSED THE HOUSE THURSDAY,
- 0:3390 TO SEVEN AND NOW WAITS FOR
- 0:36SENATE ACTION WHEN LAWMAKERS
- 0:39RETURN NEXT MONTH. WE WILL TALK
- 0:40ABOUT THOSE DEVELOPMENTS AND
- 0:43ISSUES THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS
- 0:45LIKELY TO CONSIDER WHEN IT RECO
- 0:48FEBRUARY FOURTH. OUR GUESTS, IN
- 0:49OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO, ARE: STATE
- 0:51SENATOR ROBERT STIVERS, KENTUCKY
- 0:53SENATE PRESIDENT AND A
- 0:54REPUBLICAN FROM MANCHESTER;
- 0:56STATE SENATOR GERALD NEAL,
- 0:58SENATE MINORITY FLOOR LEADER AN
- 0:59A DEMOCRAT FROM LOUISVILLE;
- 1:01STATE REPRESENTATIVE DAVID
- 1:03OSBORNE, KENTUCKY HOUSE SPEAKER
- 1:04AND A REPUBLICAN FROM PROSPECT;
- 1:06AND STATE REPRESENTATIVE PAMELA
- 1:07STEVENSON, HOUSE MINORITY FLOOR
- 1:08LEADER AND A DEMOCRAT FROM LOUI
- 1:15WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU. YOU
- 1:18CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:18COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTE
- 1:19-- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET. SEND AN
- 1:20EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T
- 1:23DOT O-R-G. OR USE THE WEB FORM
- 1:25AT K-E-T DOT O-R-G SLASH K-Y TO
- 1:29OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:31WELCOME TO ALL OUR GUESTS. IT'S
- 1:37GOOD TO SEE YOU AGAIN LIKE OUR
- 1:39FOURTH TIME IN FIVE DAYS OR
- 1:41SOMETHING.
- 1:42>> HAPPY NEW YEAR.
- 1:44>> Renee: SESSION IS OFF AND
- 1:45RUNNING AND YOU HAVE THE BREAK
- 1:46BEFORE YOU GO BACK ON FEBRUARY.
- 1:48FIRST QUESTION I WANT TO ASK IS
- 1:50ABOUT THE NUMBER OF BILLS THAT
- 1:51HAVE BEEN FILED SO FAR THIS
- 1:54SESSION.
- 1:55THERE'S AT LEAST 200 IN THE
- 1:56HOUSE.
- 1:5750 OR SO BUT NOT THE PRIORITY
- 2:00BILLS AND I WANT TO ASK YOU WHY
- 2:02THEY ARE NOT THERE YET.
- 2:03HOUSE SPEAKER, TELL US ABOUT THE
- 2:05NUMBER OF BILLS FILED AND THE
- 2:08REALISTIC EXPECTATIONS
- 2:09CONSTITUENTS AND MEMBERS SHOULD
- 2:10HAVE ABOUT WHAT IS GOING TO GET
- 2:12DONE.
- 2:12>> I AM ALWAYS AMAZED BY THE
- 2:15NUMBER OF BILLS THAT ARE FILED.
- 2:17BY AND LARGE, OUR STATE'S BEEN
- 2:19IN EXISTENCE FOR 230 SOME YEARS
- 2:23AND YOU WOULD THINK WE HAVE GONE
- 2:26A LONGTIME WITHOUT NEEDING A LOT
- 2:27OF THESE LAWS BUT IT DOES SEEM
- 2:30LIKE LEGISLATORS GET CREATIVE
- 2:34AND THEY LOVE TO PASS LAWS.
- 2:36LOVE TO PASS BILLS.
- 2:38BUT I THINK BY AND LARGE THIS IS
- 2:40A SHORT SESSION, I THINK THAT
- 2:45STEVE RUDY SETS THE OVER
- 2:48UNDERLINE AND HAS GOTTEN GOOD
- 2:50ABOUT ESTABLISHING THAT LINE.
- 2:52>> Renee: WHAT HAS HE SAID SO
- 2:53FAR?
- 2:53>> HE WILL SET IT BEFORE WE COME
- 2:55BACK.
- 2:56I WOULD SAY THAT IT'S GOING TO
- 2:58BE A RELATIVELY SLOW PACE.
- 3:00I DO BELIEVE THAT.
- 3:02WE HAVE HISTORICALLY SINCE WE'VE
- 3:05TAKEN THE MAJORITY WE HAVE USED
- 3:07THE SHORT SESSION PRETTY
- 3:09ACTIVELY.
- 3:10AS A POLICY SESSION.
- 3:12AND, I THINK, YOU WILL SEE A
- 3:15SLOWDOWN THIS YEAR.
- 3:15I REALLY DO.
- 3:16USE IT FOR --
- 3:18>> Renee: YOU SAY THAT EVERY
- 3:19YEAR.
- 3:20>> YOU THINK YOU HEAR ME SAY
- 3:22THAT EVERY YEAR.
- 3:23BUT WHAT YOU ARE OFTEN CONFUSED
- 3:25WITH IS THE FACT THAT I'VE SAID
- 3:27IN PREVIOUS SESSIONS WE ARE NOT
- 3:29NECESSARILY GOING TO COVER NEW
- 3:30TERRITORY BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN
- 3:32THAT WE WON'T BE VERY ACTIVE.
- 3:34I REALLY THINK THIS WILL BE A
- 3:36CLEAN UP SESSION ONE THAT WHERE
- 3:38WE SPEND A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF
- 3:40THE SESSION MAKING TWEAKS AND
- 3:42SMALL CHANGES TO THINGS WE'VE
- 3:45DONE IN THE PAST.
- 3:47>> Renee: FAIR ENOUGH PARDON ME
- 3:49FOR ANY APERSIONS YOU THOUGHT I
- 3:51WAS CASTING.
- 3:52IN THE SENATE THERE ARE CLOSE TO
- 3:5450 BILLS BUT THERE'S MISSING
- 3:58SENATE BILLS 1-10 LIKE THE 10
- 4:02COMMANDMENTS OF THE SENATE
- 4:03G.O.P. CAUCUS.
- 4:04WHERE ARE THOSE BILLS AND WHAT
- 4:06ARE THE TOPIC AREAS THAT MAYBE
- 4:08ADDRESSED?
- 4:08>> WELL, WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO
- 4:11AND WE'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS WITH
- 4:12THE SPEAKER ABOUT A COORDINATED
- 4:15EFFORT ABOUT WHAT WE WANT TO TRY
- 4:16TO DO AS LEGISLATIVE PRIORITIES
- 4:18OF BOTH CHAMBERS.
- 4:20WE'RE STILL HAVING THOSE
- 4:21DISCUSSIONS AND WE DIDN'T WANT
- 4:22TO RUSH IT.
- 4:24WE HAVE PLENTY OF TIME.
- 4:25I AGREE I DON'T THINK THIS WILL
- 4:27BE A FAST-PACED SESSION.
- 4:29NOTHING COMPARES TO THAT WHICH
- 4:31IS RELATED TO A SINGLE BIG FOCUS
- 4:34OF THE BUDGET THE ULTIMATE
- 4:36POLICY DOCUMENT.
- 4:37MOST OF THE BILLS THAT HAVE BEEN
- 4:39FILED A THIRD OF THEM WERE BY
- 4:43CASSY CHAMBERS ARMSTRONG SHE
- 4:45FILED 10 OR 12 THE LAST DAY.
- 4:47WE WILL BE DELIBERATE AND WITHIN
- 4:50MY CAUCUS WE'VE ASKED PEOPLE
- 4:53THEY SAY WE WANT A BETTER
- 4:55UNDERSTANDING, WE WANT TO SLOW
- 4:56THE PACE DOWN.
- 4:58THEN DON'T FILE 20 BILLS.
- 5:00WE'RE TRYING TO TELL OUR MEMBERS
- 5:01IF YOU WANT MORE DELIBERATION,
- 5:03YOU WANT MORE OPPORTUNITY THEN
- 5:08LET'S GL AT A SLOWER PACE.
- 5:10LET'S WELCOME PAMELA STEVENSON
- 5:13THE FRESHMAN OF THE LEADERSHIP.
- 5:16>> Renee: AND YOU WILL BE EXTRA
- 5:17NICE TO HER THIS TIME AROUND.
- 5:19>> ALWAYS.
- 5:20>> Renee: IS THERE ANYTHING YOU
- 5:21CAN DO TO STOP THE NUMBERS OR
- 5:23LIMIT THE NUMBERS OF BILLS THAT
- 5:25COULD BE FILED.
- 5:26>> ONLY ASK YOUR COLLEAGUES
- 5:30TO --
- 5:30BECAUSE YOU WILL GET INTO THIS
- 5:31AT THE END OF THE SESSION
- 5:33THERE'S SO MANY ISSUES AND SO
- 5:34MANY BILLS FLYING AROUND.
- 5:36WELL, THE WAY YOU STOP SO MANY
- 5:38BILLS AND SO MANY ISSUES IS TO
- 5:39NOT HAVE AS MANY BILLS AND
- 5:41ISSUES.
- 5:42AND REALLY, AND DAVID'S RIGHT
- 5:44THE SPEAKER IS RIGHT, THIS
- 5:46SESSION WASN'T MEANT TO BE HALF
- 5:49OF A REGULAR FULL-BLOWN 60-DAY
- 5:54BUDGETARY SESSION.
- 5:55IT WAS TO LOOK AT BIGGER ISSUES
- 5:57AND FOCUS ON THOSE AND CLEAN UP
- 5:59SOME OF THE THINGS THAT OCCURRED
- 6:01IN-BETWEEN THIS SESSION AND THE
- 6:03PRIOR SESSION.
- 6:05>> Renee: LEADER NEAL TO YOU
- 6:07FIRST ABOUT HOW MANY AMENDMENTS
- 6:09OR HOW MANY BILLS HAS CASSY
- 6:11CHAMBERS ARMSTRONG FILED AND YOU
- 6:14FILED SOME ALREADY AND SENATOR
- 6:16THOMAS WHAT ARE YOUR
- 6:17EXPECTATIONS FOR THIS SESSION
- 6:18AND HOW DO YOU SEE THE DEMOCRATS
- 6:19IN THE SENATE TRYING TO LEVERAGE
- 6:22YOUR POWER OR YOUR NUMBERS OR
- 6:24YOUR INFLUENCE?
- 6:24>> WELL, YOU KNOW IT'S IMPORTANT
- 6:27FOR US AND I THINK WE'VE SET THE
- 6:30BASIS FOR US OPERATING IN A
- 6:32BIPARTISAN WAY.
- 6:33WE'VE DONE THAT IN THE LAST
- 6:35SESSION AND MADE OVERTURES THAT
- 6:37WAY STARTING INTO THIS
- 6:38PARTICULAR SESSION.
- 6:39I THINK AS IT RELATES TO BILLS
- 6:41WE DON'T TELEPHONINGS HOW MANY
- 6:44BILLS TO FILE.
- 6:45BUT THERE IS THE REALITY OF THE
- 6:47SENATE, WHICH IS USUALLY DOES A
- 6:49LOT LESS THAN THE HOUSE DOES IN
- 6:50THE FIRST PLACE AND THIS IS A
- 6:53DIFFERENT TONE IT SEEMS AS TO
- 6:55HOW WE'RE GOING TO PROCEED WITH
- 6:57RESPECT TO THE THIS PARTICULAR
- 6:59SESSION BEING THE SHORT
- 7:00SESSION.
- 7:01SO WE'LL HAVE TO SEE IT'S
- 7:04UNFOLDING NOW.
- 7:05NOT EVERYTHING IS ON THE TABLE
- 7:06YET.
- 7:06WE HAVE TO SEE HOW THAT WORKS
- 7:09WHEN WE COME BACK FEBRUARY THE
- 7:12FIFTH, WE WILL HAVE THE 07 TO
- 7:13GET A CLEARER VIEW OF IT.
- 7:15>> Renee: WHAT ARE YOUR
- 7:18EXPECTATIONS LEADER STEVENSON.
- 7:19>> ONE OF THE THINGS I TELL MY
- 7:21CAUCUS IS DON'T COMPLAIN IF YOU
- 7:23GOT A BETTER IDEA A BETTER WAY
- 7:25OF DOING SOMETHING DO THE
- 7:26RESEARCH AND FILE A BILL.
- 7:28NOW, THE CHANCES OF A BILL BEING
- 7:30HEARD IN THE SHORT SESSION MIGHT
- 7:33BE SMALLER.
- 7:33>> Renee: ESPECIALLY FROM THE
- 7:34MINORITY CAUCUS.
- 7:35>> I WASN'T GOING TO ADD THAT
- 7:37PART.
- 7:38BUT YOU STILL CAN FILE IT AND DO
- 7:41THE RESEARCH AND DO THE TALKING
- 7:43WITH THE MAJORITY TO GET IT
- 7:45PASSED OR HEARD OR SEEN.
- 7:48DON'T BACK UP BECAUSE YOUR MIND
- 7:50TELLS YOU THAT YOU CAN'T GET IT
- 7:52PASSED.
- 7:53IF THERE IS A NEED IN YOUR
- 7:54DISTRICT AND YOU CAN DOCUMENT
- 7:56THAT NEED, THEN START DOING THE
- 7:58WORK THEY SENT YOU HERE TO DO.
- 8:00>> Renee: LET'S TALK ABOUT ONE
- 8:01OF THE DOMINANT ISSUES, IF YOU
- 8:04WILL, THE FIRST DAY OF THE
- 8:04SESSION.
- 8:05I KNOW THIS IS PROBABLY THE
- 8:07LEADERSHIP'S FAVORITE TOPIC AND
- 8:08THAT IS OVER THE RULES.
- 8:10THE RAUCOUS OVER THE RULES AND
- 8:11THE CHANGES THERE.
- 8:13I WANT TO ASK YOU Mr.
- 8:14PRESIDENT DO THE RULES IN THE
- 8:15SENATE THAT WERE CHANGED DO YOU
- 8:17BELIEVE THEY WILL FOSTER A MORE
- 8:20INFORMED AND ENGAGED CITIZENRY
- 8:22AND CONSTITUENCY ABOUT WHAT IS
- 8:23HAPPENING IN THE STATE HOUSE AND
- 8:24THE DECISIONS THAT YOU'RE
- 8:26MAKING?
- 8:26>> SEE, I'VE COME TO LEARN THIS
- 8:29STARTING MY 29TH YEAR ANYBODY IS
- 8:32GOING TO APPLY THE NARRATIVE SO
- 8:34THEY WANT TO WHAT WE DO.
- 8:37WHAT I SAID, WE WANT TO LIMIT
- 8:39THE NUMBER OF BILLS WE CONSIDER
- 8:40OVERALL.
- 8:41HAVE MORE DEBATE.
- 8:43SLOW THE PACE DOWN.
- 8:46THAT'S OUR MOTIVATION.
- 8:48AND IT WAS CLEAR WE ALL HAVE
- 8:52CAUCUS RETREATS THAT THAT'S WHAT
- 8:54MY CAUCUS WANTED TO DO.
- 8:55SO WE LOOKED AT HOW DO WE
- 8:57CONTROL THAT?
- 8:58SO THAT'S WHAT THE PURPOSE OF
- 8:59THE RULES CHANGES WERE.
- 9:02THEY ARE NOT TO DO SOMETHING IN
- 9:04THE DARK OR WITHOUT
- 9:07TRANSPARENCY.
- 9:08BUT I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
- 9:09GIVING THAT THEIR NARRATIVE
- 9:11THOUGH THEY HAVE NO CLUE WHAT
- 9:13THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT.
- 9:14THE RULES ARE JUST THAT TO
- 9:15CONTROL THE FLOW.
- 9:18BUT NOT DO ANYTHING NEFARIOUS.
- 9:22IT IS TO HAVE BETTER, LONGER,
- 9:25MORE INDEPTH DEBATE ABOUT THE
- 9:27ISSUES WE TAKE UP.
- 9:28>> Renee: LEADER NEAL DO YOU SEE
- 9:29IT THAT WAY?
- 9:30>> LET ME PUT IT THIS WAY...
- 9:32WHY ARE WE CHANGING THE RULES?
- 9:34THE RULES WE HAD WORKED VERY
- 9:37WELL.
- 9:37BUT IF THE RULES ARE GOING TO BE
- 9:39WHAT THEY ARE AND WE HAVE BEEN
- 9:41ASSURED ON THE FLOOR OF THE
- 9:42SENATE AT LEAST IN SOME
- 9:44EXCHANGES WE'VE HAD THAT THIS IS
- 9:45NOT GOING TO HAMPER OUR ABILITY
- 9:47TO DEBATE.
- 9:48WE WILL HAVE TO SEE HOW IT
- 9:50UNFOLDS.
- 9:50YOU HAVE TO BE CONCERNED WHEN
- 9:52YOU CHANGE RULES THAT ELIMINATES
- 9:55APPEARS TO ELIMINATE A RESTRICTS
- 9:58YOUR BILL TO GIVE THE LEVERAGE
- 9:59TO THE OTHER SIDE NOT TO GIVE
- 10:01YOU THE TIME YOU THINK IS NEEDED
- 10:02FOR DEBATE.
- 10:04WHETHER IT'S PERCEIVED MAYBE
- 10:07IT'S INACCURATE WE HAVE TO SEE
- 10:08HOW IT UNFOLDS.
- 10:10WE ARE WILLING TO WORK WITH IT.
- 10:11THEY WANT TO SLOW DOWN THE
- 10:13SENATE I'M NOT SURE WHAT THAT
- 10:15MEANS, BECAUSE THE SENATE IS
- 10:16ALWAYS SLOWED DOWN WHAT THE
- 10:19HOUSE DOES AT LEAST
- 10:21HISTORICALLY.
- 10:21THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS IF WE
- 10:23HAVE SOMETHING THAT IS IMPORTANT
- 10:24ON THE FLOOR WE WOULD EXPECT AND
- 10:26WE SUSPECT THAT WE'LL HAVE THE
- 10:29ADEQUATE TIME PROVIDED TO GET
- 10:30THAT DONE.
- 10:32>> Renee: GO AHEAD.
- 10:32>> AND LET ME SAY THIS...
- 10:34WHERE PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND
- 10:36THE RULES IF THERE ARE 20 VOTES
- 10:38ON THE SENATE FLOOR WHICH IS THE
- 10:42REQUIREMENT, THAT BILL WHETHER
- 10:43THE RULES WERE CHANGED THIS YEAR
- 10:48OR NOT THERE IS THE RULE YOU CAN
- 10:50BRING IT TO THE FLOOR BECAUSE OF
- 10:52SOME CONFUSION LAST YEAR, WE
- 10:55CLARIFIED THAT RULE IN OUR RULES
- 10:57CHANGES THIS YEAR SO IF YOU HAVE
- 10:5920 VOTES, YOU PETITION TO HAVE A
- 11:03DISCHARGE PETITION AND YOU CAN
- 11:04BRING IT TO THE FLOOR.
- 11:09AND SO THAT HASN'T CHANGED.
- 11:11>> WHAT REALLY HAPPENS IF WE
- 11:13COMMUNICATE BETTER I'M NOT
- 11:15SAYING SOMEONE INC. TENSION ALI
- 11:17WAS TRYING TO DO THINGS IN TERMS
- 11:20OF COMMUNICATING IF THAT WAS
- 11:22COMMUNICATED AND DISCUSSED
- 11:23PERHAPS THAT ISSUE WOULD HAVE
- 11:25BEEN DEALT WITH LIKE IT WAS
- 11:26DEALT WITH.
- 11:27BUT BE IT AS IT MAY, YOU KNOW,
- 11:31THE MAJORITY'S SHOWED US ON THE
- 11:33FLOOR AND PRIVATELY IN SOME
- 11:35REGARD SAID THINGS SHOULD WORK
- 11:38NATURALLY AND I HOPE THAT IS THE
- 11:39OUTCOME.
- 11:41>> Renee: VIEWER COMMENT THAT I
- 11:42WILL GET TO ALONG THESE LINES WE
- 11:46KNOW MR. SPEAKER THAT THE RULES
- 11:47CAME AFTER WHEN YOU CAME INTO
- 11:49SESSION BUT THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN
- 11:51VOTERS HAD DONE A REPORT THAT
- 11:53ANALYZED 70 SESSIONS OVER
- 11:5625-YEAR PERIOD AND FOUND THERE
- 11:57WAS AN INCREASE IN MANEUVERS
- 12:00THEY SAY MAKE CIVIC
- 12:01PARTICIPATION MORE DIFFICULT.
- 12:03THIS FROM A VIEWER NAME UNKNOWN
- 12:05LOCATION UNKNOWN WHO SAYS WHY
- 12:07SHOULD THE PEOPLE OF KENTUCKY BE
- 12:08SATISFIED WITH THE SUPER
- 12:10MAJORITY IN OUR LEGISLATURE THAT
- 12:11HIDES WHAT IT IS DOING?
- 12:14ABSOLUTE POWER CORRUPTS
- 12:15ABSOLUTELY.
- 12:16ISN'T IT TIME FOR KENTUCKIANS TO
- 12:18RETURN TO HOMEGROWN DEMOCRAT
- 12:19ROOTS AND I WILL STOP RIGHT
- 12:21THERE?
- 12:21>> I THINK THAT THE VOTERS OF
- 12:24KENTUCKY HAVE EXPRESSED THEIR
- 12:25OPINION ON THAT MATTER.
- 12:27THEY HAVE GIVEN US THE SUPER
- 12:29MAJORITY.
- 12:30AND CONTINUE TO ALLOW US TO GROW
- 12:32THAT MAJORITY.
- 12:33I THINK TO SPEAK DIRECTLY TO
- 12:35THAT PERSON WHO WANTS A
- 12:36DEMOCRATIC VOICE WE HAVE HAD AN
- 12:38OVERWHELMING DEMOCRATIC VOICE
- 12:39THAT THEY ARE IN FAVOR OF THE
- 12:41POLICIES THAT WE PASS.
- 12:43FIRST OF ALL, I THINK THAT EVERY
- 12:45YEAR THERE'S LOTS OF DEBATE OVER
- 12:47THE RULES.
- 12:47AND THAT'S BEEN GOING ON SINCE I
- 12:49WAS IN THE MINORITY AND THERE
- 12:52WERE SEVERAL YEARS WHEN WE
- 12:54DIDN'T ADOPT RULES IN THE
- 12:56HOUSE.
- 12:57AND OVER OUR PROTEST TO DO SO.
- 13:02IT'S BY AND LARGE IT'S MORE
- 13:06POLITICAL THEATER THAN IT IS
- 13:10TRUE POLICY.
- 13:11WE HAD A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF
- 13:13DEBATE OVER THE RULE FOR
- 13:15PREVIOUS QUESTION, WHICH IS A
- 13:17MOTION THAT BRINGS AN END TO
- 13:19DEBATE AND BRINGS ABOUT AN
- 13:21IMMEDIATE VOTE ON THE BILL.
- 13:23AND WE DON'T JUST MAKEUP THESE
- 13:27RULES.
- 13:27OUR RULES ARE PROCEDURE ARE
- 13:30GUIDED BY MASON'S MANUAL MASON'S
- 13:34LEGISLATIVE PROCEDURE.
- 13:35EVERYTHING WE DO IS ROOTED IN
- 13:38MASON'S.
- 13:39AND THE RULE THAT WE WROTE THIS
- 13:41YEAR IS IN STRICT COMPLIANCE
- 13:45WITH MASON'S.
- 13:47AND FOR THE ENTIRE TIME WE'VE
- 13:50BEEN IN THE MAJORITY I ONLY
- 13:52RECALL AND I MAY BE WRONG I CAN
- 13:55ONLY RECALL THREE TIMES THAT THE
- 13:56PREVIOUS QUESTION HAS BEEN USED
- 13:58SINCE WE HAVE BEEN IN THE
- 13:59MAJORITY.
- 13:59ONE OF THOSE TIMES WHEN JEFF
- 14:01HOOVER WAS PRESIDING HE ASKED
- 14:05THEN KENNY IMS STATE
- 14:06REPRESENTATIVE TO WITHDRAW THAT
- 14:08MOTION AND IT WAS RESTATED AS A
- 14:10MOTION TO LIMIT DEBATE.
- 14:12AND THEN THAT ONLY MEANS TWO
- 14:13TIMES IN EIGHT YEARS I DON'T
- 14:15THINK IS AN ABUSE OF IT.
- 14:17THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL MOTIONS
- 14:19OVER THE YEARS TO LIMIT DEBATE,
- 14:23BUT AN OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF
- 14:25THOSE TIMES THOSE ARE VETO
- 14:27OVERRIDES WHERE WE ARE AT THE
- 14:29END OF SESSION AND IN MANY CASES
- 14:30WE HAVE DEBATED AND VOTED ON THE
- 14:32BILLS THREE OR FOUR TIMES.
- 14:34AND I THINK A MOTION TO LIMIT
- 14:36DEBATE IS IN ORDER.
- 14:37MUCH OF WHAT THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN
- 14:42VOTERS REPORT FOCUSED ON WAS THE
- 14:43USE OF SHELL BILLS AND THAT HAS
- 14:46GOTTEN A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF
- 14:48COMMENTARY.
- 14:49AND I THINK THERE IS A DRAMATIC
- 14:51DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE AMOUNT OF
- 14:52SHELL BILLS FILED AND THE AMOUNT
- 14:54OF SHELL BILLS PASSED.
- 14:55AND THAT IS A DIRECT RESULT OF A
- 14:57SUPREME COURT RULING SIX OR
- 15:00EIGHT YEARS AGO THAT CHANGED THE
- 15:03WAY WE HAD TO CONDUCT BUSINESS
- 15:04AT THE END OF THE YEAR.
- 15:05AT THE END OF A SESSION.
- 15:07IT USED TO BE COMMONPLACE TO
- 15:11TAKE BILLS THAT WERE COMPLETELY
- 15:16UNRELATED TOPICS AND REPACKAGE
- 15:17THOSE AT THE END OF SESSION.
- 15:19SUPREME COURT RULED THAT WAS NO
- 15:22LONGER --
- 15:22NOT APPROPRIATE.
- 15:23IN TRYING TO COMPLY WITH THAT TO
- 15:25MAKE SURE WE DO HAVE OPTIONS
- 15:28AVAILABLE SHOULD SOMETHING ARISE
- 15:29AT THE END OF SESSION WE HAVE
- 15:31LOTS OF SHELL BILLS WITH EVERY
- 15:35IMAGINABLE TITLE KNOWN TO MAN IT
- 15:38SEEMS.
- 15:38AND RARELY DO THEY GET USED.
- 15:42AND SO THERE ARE VERY FEW IF YOU
- 15:43LOOK AT THE NUMBER OF SHELL
- 15:45BILLS THAT HAVE PASSED YOU WOULD
- 15:46SEE THAT PROBABLY NO MORE THAN
- 15:51THE REPLACES THAT WERE DONE 15,
- 15:5320 YEARS AGO.
- 15:54>> Renee: WE KNOW ONE OF YOUR
- 15:56FELLOW LEADERSHIP IN YOUR CAUCUS
- 15:59LINDSEY BURKE HAD TO TRY TO
- 16:01AMEND SOME OF THOSE RULES, AND
- 16:03THAT PROPOSAL LAST WEEK.
- 16:04WHERE DO YOU GO FROM HERE?
- 16:06NOW THAT THE RULES HAVE BEEN
- 16:08ESTABLISHED IS THIS SOMETHING
- 16:09Y'ALL WILL CONTINUE TO HARP ON
- 16:11OR GO ALONG AND SEE WHERE YOU
- 16:13CAN BE EFFECTIVE?
- 16:14>> EACH ONE OF OUR
- 16:17REPRESENTATIVES REPRESENTS
- 16:1845,000 PEOPLE.
- 16:18THEY ARE THE VOICE OF 45,000
- 16:20PEOPLE.
- 16:21AND ONE OF THE TOOLS THAT WE
- 16:22HAVE IS SPEAKING UP ON THE FLOOR
- 16:25ABOUT HOW BILLS AFFECT THEIR
- 16:28CONSTITUENCY.
- 16:30SO WE HAD OUR SAY AND THE
- 16:32SPEAKER EXPLAINED HOW WERE GOING
- 16:35TO WORK AND WE WOULD STILL HAVE
- 16:36OUR SAY.
- 16:37SO WE ARE GOING TO WORK WE FILED
- 16:41OUR BILL AND IT DID NOT PASS.
- 16:43SO WE'RE GOING TO WORK WITH WHAT
- 16:45WE HAVE AND GET ON WITH THE
- 16:47PEOPLE'S BUSINESS.
- 16:48I AM REALLY IN SPEAKING WITH THE
- 16:55SPEAKER, HE'S MADE ALL TYPES
- 16:57AFTER SURE RENSES THAT OUR
- 16:58VOICES WON'T BE SILENCE I REST
- 17:00WITH THAT AND WE'LL WORK WITH
- 17:02THE RULES.
- 17:03>> AND WHAT IS EVIDENCE OF THAT
- 17:04WE DID SPEND TWO HOURS DEBATING
- 17:06THE RULES AND ANOTHER HOUR THE
- 17:09NEXT DAY DEBATING THE RULES.
- 17:10AND WE SPENT PROBABLY TWO HOURS
- 17:13DEBATING HOUSE BILL ONE WHICH
- 17:14WAS THE TAX BILL, INCOME TAX CUT
- 17:17BILL THE FOLLOWING DAY.
- 17:19NOBODY'S VOICE WAS CUT SHORT IN
- 17:21THOSE THINGS.
- 17:21AND I THINK LIKE I SAID, VERY
- 17:23RARELY HAS IT EVER BEEN.
- 17:25>> Renee: LET'S TALK ABOUT HOUSE
- 17:27BILL ONE.
- 17:30THIS AS I'VE SAID TAKE IT IS
- 17:31FROM 4% TO 3.5% NEXT YEAR, SO
- 17:35THIS DOESN'T HAPPEN AS SOON AS
- 17:37IT PASSES.
- 17:39ALONG THE WAY TO ZERO, WE'VE
- 17:41HEARD FROM THE KENTUCKY CENTER
- 17:43FOR ECONOMIC POLICY ABOUT HOW
- 17:45MUCH THE GENERAL FUND WILL
- 17:47SUFFER $2.2 BILLION.
- 17:50IS THAT CORRECT FROM YOUR
- 17:53ACTUARIAL ANALYSIS OF IT?
- 17:54AND WHEN DO YOU GET TO A POINT
- 17:56WHERE THESE CUTS CAN NO LONGER
- 17:59HOLD HARMLESS STATE GOVERNMENT
- 18:00PROGRAMS AND AGENCIES WITHOUT
- 18:02YOU HAVING TO REDUCE THEM?
- 18:04>> LOOK IT'S NOT GOING TO COME
- 18:06AS A SHOCK I DON'T PUT CREDENCE
- 18:08IN THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR
- 18:10ECONOMIC POLICY'S WORK PRODUCT.
- 18:13THEY HAVE CLEVERLY WORDED NAME
- 18:15THAT INDICATES THEY ARE
- 18:17ECONOMISTS WHEN THEY ARE NOT.
- 18:18BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS,
- 18:20THIS IS A VERY SOUND TAX
- 18:24REDUCTION PLAN.
- 18:25AND FORMULA THAT I THINK IS VERY
- 18:30FISCALLY RESPONSIBLE AND WILL
- 18:31CONTINUE TO MAKE CUTS IN THE
- 18:34INCOME TAX AS THE BUDGET
- 18:36ALLOWS.
- 18:37WE DO NOT BUDGET TO HIT
- 18:38TRIGGERS.
- 18:39WE DO NOT BUDGET TO MAKE CUTS.
- 18:41WE BUDGET TO OUR NEEDS.
- 18:43AND THAT HAS BEEN THE PHILOSOPHY
- 18:46WE HAVE STUCK TO SINCE WE'VE
- 18:48BEEN WRITING THE BUDGET IT IS
- 18:50VERY EFFECTIVE.
- 18:51I THINK IT'S SOMETHING TO BE
- 18:52PROUD OF THAT WE'VE WRITTEN FOUR
- 18:56CONSECUTIVE BUDGETS THAT DON'T
- 18:58SPEND EVERY DOLLAR WE TAKE IN.
- 19:00THERE ARE SOME PEOPLE RECOIL IN
- 19:03HORROR OVER THAT THOUGHT.
- 19:04BUT THE FACT IS WE'RE TRYING TO
- 19:07BE BETTER STEWARDS OF THE
- 19:08TAXPAYER DOLLARS.
- 19:09AND AT THE SAME TIME, TAKING
- 19:11CARE OF THE MANY NEEDS THAT
- 19:13KENTUCKY HAS.
- 19:14>> Renee: THERE ARE SOME
- 19:15REPUBLICANS WHO WANT TO GET TO
- 19:16ZERO MUCH FASTER THAN THE LAW
- 19:18WAS CREATED AND INTENDED TO DO
- 19:21AND CHAIRMAN McDANIEL, THE
- 19:23HOUSE --
- 19:24THE SENATE A AND RSM CHAIR SAID
- 19:27IT'S DELIBERATE AND ON PURPOSE
- 19:29TALK TO US HOW MAYBE THERE'S
- 19:32SOME DISSENTION AMONG
- 19:33REPUBLICANS HOW FAST YOU SHOULD
- 19:35GET THERE?
- 19:36>> I THINK YOU NEED TO GO BACK
- 19:38AND LOOK AT THE PROCESS AND
- 19:40DAVID'S RIGHT.
- 19:41ACTUALLY I THINK DAVID'S
- 19:43UNDERGRAD WAS IN ECONOMICS.
- 19:45JUST SAYING THAT HE MAY HAVE
- 19:47MORE KNOWLEDGE OF ECONOMICS THAN
- 19:49SOME PEOPLE WRITING ABOUT THIS.
- 19:50>> I'M NOT SMART ENOUGH TO MAKE
- 19:53A LIVING DOING IT.
- 19:54>> HERE I WANT TO SAY THIS ABOUT
- 19:57THE TAX PLAN.
- 19:57I HAVE SPOKEN ON MANY OCCASIONS
- 20:00ABOUT THE PRUDENCE OF WHAT WE'RE
- 20:03DOING.
- 20:03AND HOW IT'S BEEN RECOGNIZED
- 20:05EVEN BY THE RATING AGENCIES
- 20:08WHICH EVEN THE GOVERNOR CALLED
- 20:10OUT HOW MUCH THE RATING AGENCIES
- 20:12ARE LOOKING AT US AND ONE OF THE
- 20:14BULLET POINTS IS WE ARE DOING
- 20:17RESPONSIBLE REDUCTION IN OUR
- 20:19INCOME TAX.
- 20:21>> Renee: KENTUCKY WON'T BE A
- 20:23KANSAS?
- 20:23>> NO.
- 20:24SEE WE PUT THOSE MECHANISMS YOU
- 20:27JUST CUT IT BASED ON A FACTOR OF
- 20:29REVENUE GROWTH.
- 20:30NO.
- 20:31THERE'S TWO OTHER THINGS IN
- 20:33THERE.
- 20:33ONE, YOU HAVE TO HAVE A 10%
- 20:35BUDGET RESERVE TRUST FUND OF
- 20:37WHAT YOUR GENERATED REVENUES
- 20:39ARE.
- 20:39AND THEN THERE IS A DELTA THAT
- 20:41YOU CAN NEVER CUT TO WHERE WE
- 20:44WOULD PUT OURSELVES IN A PLACE
- 20:46OF BEING AT DEFICITS.
- 20:48THAT'S TRIGGER NUMBER TWO.
- 20:50PEOPLE WHO TALK ABOUT THIS, IF
- 20:51WE FOLLOW THE LAW AS ENACTED WE
- 20:54CAN NEVER DO THAT.
- 20:55IT MAY TAKE US A LITTLE BIT
- 20:57LONGER TO GET TO ZERO WHICH GETS
- 20:59TO YOUR QUESTION.
- 21:00WE HAVE TO DO THIS RESPONSIBLY.
- 21:02IF YOU START DROPPING IT 1%, 2%,
- 21:06AND I'M SAYING THAT 1% FROM 5 TO
- 21:094 OR 4 TO 3, 3 TO 2 YEARLY THEN
- 21:12YOU WILL BE TALKING ABOUT
- 21:14CUTTING ABOUT A BILLION AND A
- 21:17QUARTER EVERY YEAR FOR THE NEXT
- 21:18FOUR YEARS.
- 21:19THEN YOU WILL HAVE TO START
- 21:21TALKING ABOUT WAIT A MINUTE, DO
- 21:23WE HAVE TO START CUTTING BACK ON
- 21:25STATE POLICE?
- 21:27DO WE START HAVING TO CUT BACK
- 21:29ON PER DIEMS FOR THE JAILS?
- 21:32DO WE START CUTTING BACK ON
- 21:34DOLLARS THAT DRAWDOWN FEDERAL
- 21:35DOLLARS TO WHERE HOSPITALS AND
- 21:37INDIVIDUALS WHO GET REIMBURSED
- 21:38FOR MEDICAID HAVE TO START
- 21:41TAKING MAJOR CUTS?
- 21:43THAT'S NOT BEING RESPONSIBLE.
- 21:46BECAUSE IF YOU WERE TO TRY TO
- 21:48TAKE THIS IN THE NEXT FOUR
- 21:50YEARS, YOU WOULD TAKE A HALF OR
- 21:54$5 BILLION OUT OF THE SYSTEM
- 21:56MUCH OF WHICH HAS FEDERAL
- 21:59DRAWDOWN IMPACT.
- 22:00AND SO WITH THAT, YOU BETTER
- 22:03START TALKING TO YOUR JAILERS
- 22:06YOUR MAGISTRATES YOUR JUDGES
- 22:07YOUR COURT SYSTEM, YOUR NURSES
- 22:09YOUR HOSPITALS AND MEDICAL
- 22:11PROVIDERS BECAUSE WE ARE GOING
- 22:13TO HAVE TO DO CATASTROPHIC CUTS
- 22:15IF WE TRY TO TAKE TOO FAST OF AN
- 22:18APPROACH.
- 22:19>> Renee: LEADER NEAL ARE YOU
- 22:20CONCERNED THAT CATASTROPHIC CUTS
- 22:22COULD BE ON THE HORIZON GOING
- 22:24THE WAY THE LAW IS WRITTEN WITH
- 22:26THE TRIGGERS IN PLACE?
- 22:27>> WELL, I THINK THE TRIGGERS
- 22:29AND THOSE WHO ARE IN CONTROL OF
- 22:30THE POLICY PROCESS CAN STOP IT
- 22:32AT 3.5 FOR INSTANCE.
- 22:35AND LIVE WITH THAT OR THEY CAN
- 22:37GO BEYOND THAT AND WE MAY HAVE A
- 22:39SITUATION LIKE WE ARE ENJOYING
- 22:41RIGHT NOW A FLUSH OF MONEY,
- 22:43ECONOMIC GROWTH IS TAKING
- 22:44PLACE.
- 22:44I DON'T THINK THAT'S GOING TO
- 22:47NECESSARILY IF HISTORY TELLS US
- 22:49ANYTHING SUSTAIN ITSELF
- 22:51THROUGHOUT EVERYTHING GOING
- 22:51FORWARD.
- 22:52>> Renee: AND THE COVID MONEY IS
- 22:53DRYING UP.
- 22:53>> THE COVID MONEY IS DRYING
- 22:55UP.
- 22:56AND NOT ONLY IS THE COVID MONEY
- 22:58DRYING UP IF YOU JUST TAKE THIS
- 23:00TO THE LOGICAL CONCLUSION IF YOU
- 23:02GO TO ZERO, IF, BECAUSE WE'RE
- 23:04NOT THERE.
- 23:05WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
- 23:06WE KNOW THAT WE HAVE TAKEN ABOUT
- 23:09$2 BILLION AND WE'RE NOT GOING
- 23:11TO RECOVER THAT.
- 23:12YES WE HAVE A FLUSH OF MONEY
- 23:13THAT IS THERE NOW BUT THE
- 23:16DYNAMICS THAT ENABLED THAT TO
- 23:18HAPPEN DO NOT MEAN THAT'S GOING
- 23:20TO BE THERE IN THE FUTURE.
- 23:21AT THE END OF THE DAY IF YOU
- 23:22THINK THROUGH THIS PIECE BECAUSE
- 23:24WE ARE NOT THERE IF YOU GO TO
- 23:25ZERO THAT MEANS THAT THOSE
- 23:27MONIES AT LEAST THEORETICALLY
- 23:30AND MAYBE A REALITY WILL NOT BE
- 23:32THERE TO CONTINUE SERVICES AT
- 23:33THE LEVEL WE ARE DOING THEM NOW
- 23:36AND OR THERE ARE THOSE THAT ARE
- 23:38SAYING WE HAVE UNDERFUNDED SOME
- 23:40ASPECTS IN AREAS OF EDUCATION ET
- 23:42CETERA AND WHY ARE WE NOT
- 23:44INVESTING IN THESE THINGS AND
- 23:45THAT IS A DISCUSSION WE CAN GET
- 23:47INTO.
- 23:48BUT THE FACT IS IF YOU GO TO
- 23:50ZERO, THOSE FUNDS ARE NO LONGER
- 23:51THERE.
- 23:52YOU WILL EITHER HAVE TO USE WHAT
- 23:54YOU HAVE WHAT I CALL WE USED TO
- 23:57CALL A BUDGET RESERVE FUND BUT
- 24:00MY POINT IS IS THAT EITHER YOU
- 24:01ARE GOING TO CUT SERVICES DOWN
- 24:03OR YOU ARE GOING TO FIND ANOTHER
- 24:06SOURCE OF INCOME.
- 24:09AND THAT SUGGESTS TO ME IN
- 24:10LOOKING AT HISTORY THAT YOU ARE
- 24:12LOOKING AT REVENUES THAT COME
- 24:14FROM SALES TAX OR MAYBE THERE
- 24:17ARE OTHER MECHANISMS.
- 24:18YOU LOOK AT TENNESSEE THAT IS
- 24:20WHAT TENNESSEE DID TO A DEGREE
- 24:22FROM MY OBSERVATION AND WHAT DO
- 24:25THEY DO?
- 24:26THEY COME OVER TO KENTUCKY TO
- 24:29GET A BETTER SHAKE ON SALES
- 24:31TAXES.
- 24:32WE'RE GOING TO CUT SERVICES OR
- 24:34FIND ANOTHER SOURCE OF INCOME TO
- 24:35TAKE CARE OF THOSE THINGS AND
- 24:37MAINTAIN STATE SERVICES THAT WE
- 24:39NEED AND WE EXPECT.
- 24:41>> Renee: HOUSE BILL ONE DOES
- 24:43NOT ADDRESS EXPANSION OF THE
- 24:44SALES TAX TO OTHER SERVICES.
- 24:46>> IT DOES NOT.
- 24:47>> LEADER STEVENSON YOU HAVE
- 24:49MADE SOME OF THE SAME ARGUMENTS
- 24:53AND IN THE REACTION TO THE STATE
- 24:53OF COMMONWEALTH AND ON THE HOUSE
- 24:56FLOOR AND MADE SIMILAR COMMENTS
- 24:58ABOUT CONTINUING REDUCTION OF
- 25:00THE INCOME TAX.
- 25:02>> I THINK WE HAVE TO DO THE
- 25:03THINKING FOR THE PEOPLE OF
- 25:06KENTUCKY, BECAUSE THAT'S WHY
- 25:07THEY VOTED US IN.
- 25:08AND IF WE LOOK AT THE PROGRAM,
- 25:10YES, RIGHT NOW AND IN THIS
- 25:12MOMENT GOING TO 3.5 ALLOWS THEM,
- 25:17ALLOWS KENTUCKIANS TO HAVE MONEY
- 25:18IN THEIR POCKETS.
- 25:19WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE STATES WE
- 25:21COMPARE OURSELVES TO, TEXAS,
- 25:23TENNESSEE AND FLORIDA, THOSE
- 25:27THREE STATES HAVE ALTERNATE
- 25:30SOURCES OF REVENUE THAT JUST
- 25:32COME INTO THE STATE.
- 25:33I'D LIKE TO SAY WE ARE NOT
- 25:35TEXAS.
- 25:35WE DON'T HAVE OIL.
- 25:36WE ARE NOT TENNESSEE WE DON'T
- 25:39HAVE COUNTRY MUSIC OR DOLLY AND
- 25:41WE ARE NOT FLORIDA AND WE DON'T
- 25:43HAVE MICKEY.
- 25:43SO IF YOU GO DOWN TO ZERO AND
- 25:46TODAY WE CAN'T PAY FOR THE
- 25:48THINGS WE NEED TO PAY FOR, HOW
- 25:50WILL PEOPLE GET THE BASICS?
- 25:54EDUCATION, FOOD, THOSE TYPE OF
- 25:56THINGS THAT THEY RELY ON THE
- 25:58GOVERNMENT FOR.
- 25:58AND THE LAST THING I'LL SAY
- 26:01ABOUT THAT, IS TAXES SERVE THE
- 26:02COMMON GOOD.
- 26:03NO ONE FAMILY CAN BUILD A ROAD.
- 26:06NO ONE FAMILY CAN BUILD AN
- 26:08EDUCATION SYSTEM.
- 26:09THAT'S WHY WE HAVE A
- 26:10GOVERNMENT.
- 26:10AND THE GOVERNMENT HAS TO STAND
- 26:12UP AND SAY FOR THE COMMON GOOD
- 26:14WE'RE GOING TO MAKE SURE
- 26:16EDUCATION, ROADS,
- 26:17INFRASTRUCTURE, AND THE THINGS
- 26:19THAT WE NEED ARE TAKEN CARE OF.
- 26:21AND THAT'S WHY WE WERE ABLE TO
- 26:23VOTE YES FOR THIS YEAR'S BILL.
- 26:26BUT GOING DOWN TO ZERO, I DON'T
- 26:28SEE AN INFLUX OF REVENUE COMING
- 26:30IN.
- 26:31HOW WILL WE PAY FOR THE THINGS
- 26:32WE CAN'T PAY FOR NOW AT 4.0 AT
- 26:37ZERO?
- 26:38IF WE GET TO ZERO AND WE CAN'T
- 26:40PAY FOR THINGS WE'RE GOING TO
- 26:41START CUTTING.
- 26:42>> Renee: YOU DID VOTE LAST WEEK
- 26:44FOR HOUSE BILL ONE?
- 26:47>> YES.
- 26:48>> Renee: SENATOR NEAL WILL YOU
- 26:49SUPPORT HOUSE BILL ONE?
- 26:50>> WELL, WE'RE GOING TO SEE HOW
- 26:52IT PLAYS OUT.
- 26:53WE HAVEN'T HAD THE DISCUSSION
- 26:55YET.
- 26:56BUT I HAVE MAINTAINED THE
- 26:58CONCERN THAT WE HAVE AND AS WE
- 27:00GO THROUGH THIS PROCESS WE WILL
- 27:01BE MAKING DECISIONS.
- 27:03I SUSPECT THAT WE WILL HAVE SOME
- 27:04PEOPLE THAT WILL SUPPORT THAT
- 27:06AND SOME PEOPLE WILL NOT SUPPORT
- 27:08THAT AND THEY ARE FREE TO DO
- 27:10THAT BECAUSE IT'S SPECULATIVE AS
- 27:120 TO HOW THAT POLICY IS GOING TO
- 27:14UNFOLD BECAUSE WE CANNOT PREDICT
- 27:18ASPECTS OF THE FUTURE.
- 27:19THAT'S AN ANALYSIS AND A
- 27:21DISCUSSION WE WILL HAVE.
- 27:22>> Renee: A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS
- 27:23ALONG THIS LINE.
- 27:25FROM HOWARD FITZGERALD FROM
- 27:27LANCASTER REDUCING STATE INCOME
- 27:28TAX IS NOT GOOD FOR RETIREES WE
- 27:31HAVE TO PAY TAX ON SERVICES WE
- 27:33HAVE NOT BEFORE AND I HAVE NOT
- 27:35HAD TO PAY STATE INCOME TAX ON
- 27:37MY SOCIAL SECURITY BUT WITH VET
- 27:39SERVICES I HAVE HAD TO PAY.
- 27:42END QUOTE.
- 27:44>> YOU'RE LOOKING AT ME SO I
- 27:46WILL TAKE IT THIS IS DIRECTED.
- 27:50WE EXEMPT THE FIRST $31,500 IN
- 27:54RETIREMENT FROM STATE INCOME
- 27:56TAXES.
- 27:56RIGHT THERE IS A HUGE EXEMPTION
- 27:59ONE OF THE BIGGEST WE DO.
- 28:00WE ARE VERY GOOD AS A STATE FOR
- 28:05BEING RECEPTIVE AND A GOOD PLACE
- 28:07FOR RETIREES TO RETIRE TO.
- 28:10SECOND THING IS THAT A LOT OF
- 28:11PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE IS WE DO
- 28:14NOT TAX SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS
- 28:16IN THIS STATE.
- 28:17SO IF YOU ARE MAKING $25,000 OR
- 28:21RECEIVING $25,000 IN SOCIAL
- 28:26SECURITY, AND 31,500 IN A
- 28:30PENSION, THAT'S 56,500 THAT IS
- 28:35NOT TAXED BY THE STATE IN THE
- 28:37FIRST PLACE.
- 28:37BECAUSE WE DON'T WE EXEMPT THOSE
- 28:40IN THE TAX PLANS.
- 28:43SO THERE IS SOMETHING THAT FROM
- 28:45A RETIREE THEY DON'T FOCUS ON
- 28:47THAT.
- 28:47TO BE ABLE TO DO THOSE TYPES OF
- 28:51EXEMPTIONS, YES, YOU MAY HAVE TO
- 28:52PAY FOR YOUR DOG TO GET
- 28:55GROOMED.
- 28:55>> Renee: THIS QUESTION ABOUT
- 28:56HOUSE BILL ONE THAT HAD AN
- 28:58AMENDMENT 6 THAT WOULD HAVE
- 29:00GIVEN VETERANS A STATE TAX
- 29:03EXEMPTION.
- 29:04FURTHER COMMENT ON THAT MR.
- 29:05SPEAKER?
- 29:05>> IT WAS NOT GERMAINE TO THE
- 29:09BILL BECAUSE IT HAD TO DO WITH
- 29:12TAX EXEMPTIONS.
- 29:14BUT THAT BILL HAS BEEN FILED
- 29:16SEVERAL TIMES BY WALKER THOMAS
- 29:21WHO'S' GREAT CHAMPION FOR OUR
- 29:22VETERANS.
- 29:23AND IT'S RECEIVED A LOT OF
- 29:25CONVERSATION QUITE FRANKLY.
- 29:26AND THERE IS A LOT OF PEOPLE FOR
- 29:27IT AND A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT ARE
- 29:30NOT SO FOR IT.
- 29:32AND ULTIMATELY THE PREVAILING
- 29:34THOUGHT HAS BEEN WE'RE TRYING TO
- 29:36GET INCOME TAX TO ZERO FOR
- 29:38EVERYBODY.
- 29:38BY CONTINUING TO LOOK FOR ONE
- 29:41OFF EXEMPTIONS IT MAKES IT MORE
- 29:44DIFFICULT TO LOWER IT FOR ALL
- 29:47TAXPAYERS.
- 29:48I DO WANT TO POINT OUT TO THE
- 29:50GENTLEMAN TALKING ABOUT RETIREES
- 29:52IN ADDITION TO ROBERT'S
- 29:57COMMENTS, OUR SALES TAX IS NOT
- 29:59NEARLY AS BROAD AS IT IS IN
- 30:01INDIANA OR IN TENNESSEE.
- 30:03AND WE'RE AT 6% VERSUS 7% IN
- 30:06INDIANA 9% IN TENNESSEE.
- 30:08AND I THINK BY AND LARGE YOU SEE
- 30:10OUR STANDARD OF LIVING FOR
- 30:12RETIREES OR COST OF LIVE
- 30:14SOMETHING FAR LOWER THAN OUR
- 30:16SURROUNDING STATES.
- 30:18>> Renee: DO YOU ENVISION MAYBE
- 30:22NEXT BUDGET SESSION EXPANDING
- 30:23THE SALES TAX TO OTHER SERVICES
- 30:26OR CREATIVE WAYS OF GENERATING?
- 30:28>> THERE'S ALWAYS
- 30:29CONVERSATIONS.
- 30:30AND WE TALK FREQUENTLY WITH THE
- 30:32MEMBERS OF OUR CAUCUS THAT DO
- 30:33WANT TO GET TO ZERO QUICKER.
- 30:35THE ONES THAT WANT TO STOP WHERE
- 30:37WE ARE.
- 30:38THAT THIS IS A BILL THAT WE'VE
- 30:42PASSED THREE YEARS AGO.
- 30:44IT IS NOT A PERFECT DOCUMENT.
- 30:47IT WILL NOT LIVE INTO
- 30:49PERPETUITY.
- 30:49I'M SURE AT SOME POINT IN TIME
- 30:51THERE WILL BE SOME TWEAKS TO IT
- 30:53AND SOME CHANGES TO IT.
- 30:54I CAN'T FORESEE WHAT THOSE MIGHT
- 30:57BE.
- 30:57BUT CERTAINLY THERE WILL BE I'M
- 31:00CERTAIN THERE WILL BE SOME
- 31:01CHANGE BEFORE WE GET TO ZERO
- 31:03THERE WILL BE SOME CHANGE IN THE
- 31:04BILLION WHAT IT MIGHT BE.
- 31:06I WANT TO GO BACK TO PAM'S
- 31:09COMMENTS ABOUT IF WE GET TO ZERO
- 31:11WITHOUT A HUGE INFLUX OF NEW
- 31:15DOLLARS, THAT STATEMENT IS NOT
- 31:18POSSIBLE.
- 31:18BECAUSE IF WE DON'T HAVE AN
- 31:20INFLUX OF NEW DOLLARS WE WILL
- 31:23NEVER MEET THE TRIGGERS TO GET
- 31:25TO ZERO WE HAVE TO CONTINUE TO
- 31:26GROW THOSE REVENUES BECAUSE OUR
- 31:28EXPENSES CONTINUE TO GROW BEYOND
- 31:30OUR CONTROL IN MANY AREAS LIKE
- 31:33MEDICAID, PENSIONS CONTINUE TO
- 31:36SKYROCKET SO THOSE EXPENSE
- 31:39DRIVERS ARE PRETTY MUCH AS LONG
- 31:41AS WE DON'T DO WHAT PREVIOUS
- 31:43LEGISLATURES HAVE DONE AND
- 31:44IGNORE OUR PENSIONS WHICH IS
- 31:46WHAT GOT US INTO THIS SHAPE
- 31:48THOSE NUMBERS WILL CONTINUE TO
- 31:49ESCALATE FOR THE NEXT, GOSH,
- 31:52UNTIL 2041 THAT WE GET TO A
- 31:54LEVELING OUT OF OUR PENSION
- 31:57CONTRIBUTIONS.
- 31:58SO WITHOUT GROWING OUR REVENUES,
- 32:00WITHOUT GROWING THE ECONOMY, WE
- 32:03WON'T GET TO ZERO.
- 32:05SO WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO HAVE
- 32:07THAT INCREASE IN REVENUES.
- 32:09>> Renee: LEADER NEAL?
- 32:11>> STEPPING OUTSIDE OF THE
- 32:12PENSION DISCUSSION, I THINK WE
- 32:13HAVE TO CONSIDER THE FACT THAT,
- 32:17AND I APPRECIATE THE SPEAKER FOR
- 32:19HIS CANDOR HE CANNOT FORESEE THE
- 32:21FUTURE.
- 32:21WE CANNOT FORESEE IT AND THERE
- 32:24IN LIES THE CONCERN AND WE
- 32:25AROUND THE TABLE AND IN THE
- 32:27LEGISLATURE ARE NOT ALWAYS GOING
- 32:29TO BE THERE FOR OBVIOUS REASONS
- 32:31AND THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS
- 32:34WHAT THE FUTURE LEGISLATORS ARE
- 32:36FACED WITH AND THE FISCAL
- 32:38CONSIDERATIONS THAT THEY HAVE TO
- 32:39UNDERTAKE THEN ARE GOING TO
- 32:41DICTATE WHAT THEY DO.
- 32:43SO WHEN WE MAKE STRUCTURAL
- 32:44CHANGES LIKE THIS WHERE WE HAVE
- 32:47$2 BILLION IF YOU JUST LOOK
- 32:48WHERE WE CAME FROM, THAT $2
- 32:50BILLION IS GONE IN THAT
- 32:52PROCESS.
- 32:52AND AS WE CONTINUE DOWN THAT
- 32:54ROAD MORE IS GONE.
- 32:56SO THE CIRCUMSTANCES CHANGE.
- 32:58LET'S SAY THE ECONOMY DOESN'T
- 32:59PROJECT WHAT OTHERS ARE HOPEFUL
- 33:01THAT WILL PROJECT.
- 33:03THESE OTHER THINGS THAT THEY
- 33:05EXPECT TO TAKE PLACE EVEN IF WE
- 33:07STOPPED AT 3.5 WHICH WE'VE LOST
- 33:10$2 BILLION AND WE'LL LOSE MORE
- 33:12IS GOING TO LOOK FOR POLICY
- 33:14CHANGES TO TAKE CARE OF DEFICITS
- 33:16WE HAVE GOING FORWARD.
- 33:17I'M TALKING GENERALLY.
- 33:18I CAN'T FORESEE THE FUTURE
- 33:20EITHER.
- 33:21THAT IS LIES THE CONCERN.
- 33:23I HAVE TO PUT IT IN THE
- 33:24FRAMEWORK OF CONCERN BECAUSE
- 33:26EXACTLY WHAT THE SPEAKER SAID.
- 33:28I DON'T KNOW HOW IT'S GOING TO
- 33:29PLAY OUT.
- 33:30BUT IF I PROJECT MY THINKING
- 33:32THROUGH THAT AND LOOK AT HISTORY
- 33:34IN TERMS OF WHAT HAS BEEN DONE
- 33:36IF I LOOK AT OTHER STATES AND I
- 33:38TRY TO JUDGE WHAT WE'RE GOING TO
- 33:39DO HERE ON THE BASIS OF THEM, I
- 33:42THINK WE ARE RUNNING INTO SOME
- 33:44AREAS OF CONCERN THAT ARE
- 33:45WARRANTED.
- 33:48>> IF THIS WERE A STATIC MODEL,
- 33:52I AGREE WITH SENATOR NEAL.
- 33:54BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHERE A
- 33:57FLORIDA OR A TEXAS OR TENNESSEE
- 34:00WHAT YOU ARE SEEING IS NOT
- 34:03STAGNANT POPULATION GROWTH.
- 34:05YOU ARE SEEING THOSE STATES
- 34:08EXPANDING THE BASE.
- 34:10THEREFORE MORE PEOPLE SPENDING
- 34:12MONEY, MORE PEOPLE GENERATING
- 34:14TAXES.
- 34:15BUT THE INDIVIDUAL IS PAYING NO
- 34:17MORE TAXES.
- 34:18I WILL GO BACK TO WHAT I THINK
- 34:20IS THE BEST EXAMPLE WHERE WE
- 34:22CHANGE THE TAX RATE LOWERED IT,
- 34:25AND CHANGED THE REGULATORY
- 34:28SYSTEM WE TOOK AN IMMEDIATE HIT
- 34:30OF $12 MILLION.
- 34:32BUT NOW THAT INDUSTRY IS ONE OF
- 34:34OUR BIGGEST, BEST AND
- 34:35BRIGHTEST.
- 34:36AND WE DO HAVE BOURBON AND THE
- 34:39BOURBON TRAIL WHICH IS NOW BASED
- 34:42ON ECONOMISTS, ECONOMISTS
- 34:48CALCULATIONS GENERATING OVER
- 34:51$150 MILLION FROM WHERE WE WERE
- 34:54BEFORE WE CUT THE TAXES.
- 34:56>> Renee: TO GET TO YOUR POINT
- 34:57AND I THINK REPRESENTATIVE AL
- 35:00GENTRY MADE THIS POINT LAST WEEK
- 35:03BEFORE THE FLOOR VOTE HOW DO WE
- 35:05KNOW THIS IS WORKING AND HOW DO
- 35:07WE KNOW THIS TAX POLICY IS
- 35:09BRINGING IN MORE PEOPLE,
- 35:10EXPANDING THE POPULATION,
- 35:12THEREFORE YOU HAVE MORE
- 35:13TAXPAYERS ETD SET RA.
- 35:15DO WE HAVE EMPIRICAL INFORMATION
- 35:17THAT THIS IS A RESULT OF IT?
- 35:20>> I DO THINK WE'VE SEEN AN
- 35:23INCREASE IN THE WORKFORCE.
- 35:24WE'VE SEEN AN INCREASE IN
- 35:27WORKFORCE PARTICIPATION.
- 35:28>> Renee: EVEN THOUGH WE ARE
- 35:28STILL NEAR THE BOTTOM.
- 35:30>> EVEN THOUGH WE ARE STILL NEAR
- 35:31THE BOTTOM.
- 35:32AND I THINK THOSE NUMBERS ARE
- 35:34COMPELLING.
- 35:35WE KNOW THERE IS AN INCREASE IN
- 35:37NET INFLOWS OF VENTURE CAPITAL
- 35:39INTO KENTUCKY.
- 35:41AND ONE OF THE HIGHEST OUTSIDE
- 35:43INVESTMENTS IN KENTUCKY OF ANY
- 35:45STATE IN THE COUNTRY RIGHT NOW
- 35:46AS FAR AS PER CAPITA.
- 35:48I THINK IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO MAKE
- 35:51A POINT TO POINT CONNECTION OF
- 35:53THOSE DOTS.
- 35:54BUT THE EVIDENCE IS PRETTY
- 35:56COMPELLING.
- 35:56>> Renee: ALL RIGHT.
- 35:58ANY FURTHER COMMENT ON HOUSE
- 35:59BILL ONE?
- 36:00AND WE HAVE LOTS OF QUESTIONS
- 36:01COMING IN ABOUT THAT.
- 36:02I THINK WE COVERED MOST OF THAT
- 36:05TERRITORY.
- 36:06THERE WAS SOMETHING ABOUT COLA.
- 36:08SO THIS FROM DENISE BRIAN WHAT
- 36:11ARE THE CHANCES HAD BEEN 146 TO
- 36:16RESTORE THE EXCLUSION TO 41,110,
- 36:20GETS A HEARING AND A VOTE?
- 36:23STATE RETIREES HAVE NOT RECEIVED
- 36:24A COLA IN MANY YEARS AND
- 36:27RESTORING THE EXCLUSION WOULD BE
- 36:29HELPFUL?
- 36:30>> I'M NOT FAMILIAR WITH HOUSE
- 36:32BILL 146.
- 36:34>> I'M NOT FAMILIAR WITH THE
- 36:36SPECIFIC BILL.
- 36:37I AM FAMILIAR WITH THE TOPIC.
- 36:42WHEN WE DID OUR TAX CUT IN 2018
- 36:45WE REDUCED THE RETIREE EXCLUSION
- 36:51FROM 41 TO 319.
- 36:54I THINK IT IS UNLIKELY THAT WILL
- 36:56PASS AGAIN.
- 36:57FOR THE SAME REASON AS WE'VE
- 36:59DISCUSSED IT IS OUR HOPE TO
- 37:02CONTINUE TO REDUCE INCOME TAXES
- 37:04ON ALL KENTUCKIANS.
- 37:06AND NOT SPECIFIC GROUPS.
- 37:08>> Renee: LAST ONE ON THIS DREW
- 37:10FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY, WILL
- 37:11PEOPLE WHO GET STATE RETIREMENT
- 37:14SEE A 13TH PAYMENT COST OF
- 37:17LIVING ADJUSTMENT OR WAIT UNTIL
- 37:192026 WHEN A NEW BUDGET IS
- 37:21ESTABLISHED?
- 37:21>> IT WOULD BE MY SUGGESTION
- 37:25WHERE SPEAKER TALKED ABOUT ONE
- 37:27OFFS YOU BUDGET IN THE CONTEXT
- 37:28OF THE WHOLE.
- 37:29YOU DON'T DO A LOT OF ONE OFFS
- 37:32DURING A SHORT SESSION.
- 37:34AND THAT'S THE WAY
- 37:36CONSTITUTIONALLY IT WAS SETUP.
- 37:37BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO HAVE SUPER
- 37:39MAJORITIES TO BE ABLE TO OPEN UP
- 37:42A BUDGET FOR EITHER
- 37:44APPROPRIATION OR TAXATION THIS
- 37:45YEAR.
- 37:46SO THE WRATHS AL BEING BUDGET OR
- 37:48TAX IN THE CONCEPT TAX POLICY BE
- 37:51SET IN THE CONTEXT OF THE
- 37:54WHOLE.
- 37:54AND RENEE, I WANT TO DIGRESS A
- 37:58MINUTE.
- 37:58WHERE YOU HAVE $50,000 OF
- 38:00TAXABLE INCOME YOU WILL PAY
- 38:05$1750.
- 38:06ON THAT INCOME.
- 38:08WHEN IT'S EXEMPT WHICH FOR
- 38:11RETIREES THAT IS THEY ARE NOT
- 38:13PAYING $1750.
- 38:15WHERE EIGHT YEARS AGO ANYTHING
- 38:17ABOVE THE $50,000 WOULD HAVE
- 38:18BEEN TAXED IT WAS HIGHER THAN
- 38:20THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN TAXED AT 6%
- 38:24NOW 3.5.
- 38:25SO THEY ARE GETTING A
- 38:27BROAD-BASED EXEMPTION FOR
- 38:29ANYTHING OVER THOSE EXEMPTED
- 38:31REVENUES THEY HAVE COMING INTO
- 38:32THEIR HOUSEHOLD THEY WILL BE
- 38:34PAYING A LESSER RATE.
- 38:35THEY ARE BENEFITING ON BOTH
- 38:36SIDES OF THE EQUATION.
- 38:38>> Renee: WE WILL MAKE A TOUGH
- 38:40PIVOT FROM THAT CONVERSATION TO
- 38:42TALK ABOUT MR. SPEAKER YOU
- 38:44MENTIONED THIS IS THE SESSION
- 38:45AND A 30-DAY SESSION WHERE YOU
- 38:47TWEAK EXISTING LAWS.
- 38:49CONSIDERING A REPORT THAT
- 38:51HAPPENED A FEW WEEKS BACK, THE
- 38:54LOUISVILLE POLICE CHIEF PAUL
- 38:55HUMPHREY HAS SAID AND
- 38:58APOLOGIZING THAT THEY MADE A
- 39:00MISTAKE IN CITING A HOMELESS
- 39:02WOMAN IN LABOR CAMPING OUTSIDE
- 39:04AND KENTUCKY PUBLIC RADIO
- 39:06RELEASED SOME FOOTAGE THAT
- 39:08SHOWED HER IN THIS SITUATION.
- 39:09WE KNOW THAT THEY ARE
- 39:12AUTHORITIES ARE RESPONDING TO
- 39:13HOUSE BILL 5 WHICH WAS THE
- 39:15SWEEPING SAFER KENTUCKY ACT THAT
- 39:17TALKED ABOUT UNLAWFUL CAMPING.
- 39:19GIVEN THAT INSTANCE DO YOU THINK
- 39:21THERE'S GOING TO BE TWEAKING TO
- 39:22HOUSE BILL 5 TO ADDRESS
- 39:24CIRCUMSTANCES LIKE THIS?
- 39:26>> WELL, FIRST OF ALL VERY
- 39:29UNFORTUNATE.
- 39:30I DIDN'T SEE THE TV REPORTS OF
- 39:33IT.
- 39:33BUT I THINK AS THE CHIEF
- 39:36ADMITTED THAT WAS NOT A PROBLEM
- 39:38WITH THE LAW ITSELF IT WAS A
- 39:40PROBLEM WITH THE WAY THE LAW WAS
- 39:42ENFORCED.
- 39:44AND THERE'S --
- 39:45AGAIN THERE'S ALWAYS TWEAKS TO
- 39:47EVERY PIECE OF MAJOR POLICY.
- 39:50I DON'T KNOW OF ANYTHING
- 39:53SPECIFICALLY CONTEMPLATED ON
- 39:54HOUSE BILL 5.
- 39:54BY AND LARGE MOST OF THE
- 39:56FEEDBACK WE'VE GOTTEN HAS BEEN
- 39:59OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVE.
- 39:59BUT, AGAIN, WE CONTINUE TO LOOK
- 40:01FOR WAYS TO IMPROVE THINGS.
- 40:04TAKE THAT FEEDBACK AND MAKE
- 40:06CHANGES WHEN APPROPRIATE.
- 40:08>> Renee: LEADER STEVENSON THIS
- 40:09IS IN YOUR COUNTY YOUR RESPONSE
- 40:11BECAUSE I KNOW YOU ARE FAMILIAR
- 40:13WITH THIS INSTANCE?
- 40:14>> IT IS A PROBLEM WITH THE
- 40:15LAW.
- 40:15BECAUSE WHEN WE PASSED THAT LAW
- 40:17WE DIDN'T SAY ARREST HOMELESS
- 40:19PEOPLE AND THEN PROVIDE
- 40:21SERVICES.
- 40:22WE JUST SAID ARREST THEM.
- 40:24AND THAT'S THE PROBLEM.
- 40:26WE HAVE THE MONEY IN THE RAINY
- 40:28DAY FUND, IN THE REVENUE TO DO
- 40:31THE THINGS THAT NEED TO BE DONE
- 40:34SO PEOPLE AREN'T SLEEPING WITH
- 40:35SNOW AS A BLANKET AND WE DIDN'T
- 40:38DO IT.
- 40:39WE SAID ARREST THEM.
- 40:41ANYTIME YOU HAVE A LAW THAT JUST
- 40:42SAYS ARREST THEM, YOU ARE AT
- 40:46THE --
- 40:46YOU'RE SUBJECT TO HOWEVER THAT
- 40:47POLICE OFFICER DECIDES TO DO
- 40:48IT.
- 40:49BUT IF WE HAD WRITTEN IN THE LAW
- 40:51YOU CAN'T DETAIN THEM AND TAKE
- 40:52THEM HERE AND PROVIDE THESE
- 40:55SERVICES AND FIND OUT WHY THEY
- 40:56ARE ON THE STREET TO GET RID OF
- 40:59THE PROBLEM FINALLY.
- 41:00THAT IS A DIFFERENT LAW.
- 41:02WE DIDN'T DO THAT.
- 41:05WE JUST GAVE THEM THE AUTHORITY
- 41:06TO ARREST.
- 41:06>> CAN I DISAGREE WITH
- 41:09REPRESENTATIVE STEVENSON.
- 41:10>> YOU CAN'T DO THAT I'M THE
- 41:13ONLY GIRL.
- 41:13>> WE DID APPROPRIATEIATE 22.5
- 41:19MILLION DOLLARS FOR THE PURPOSE
- 41:20OF WHAT WAS CALLED A COMMUNITY
- 41:23CARE CAMPUS WHICH WAS LOUISVILLE
- 41:25AND JEFFERSON COUNTY SPECIFIC.
- 41:30PERIOD.
- 41:30THAT IS TO HAVE HOUSING, THAT IS
- 41:32TO HAVE SUBSTANCE USE TREATMENT,
- 41:34THAT IS TO DEAL WITH MENTAL
- 41:37HEALTH TREATMENT OR A DUEL
- 41:40DIAGNOSIS.
- 41:40NOW IT TAKES TIME TO IMPLEMENT
- 41:42THAT.
- 41:43AND I KNOW THE MAYOR IS WORKING
- 41:45HARD ON IT.
- 41:46I'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS WITH HIM
- 41:47ABOUT IT.
- 41:48WE WANT TO SEE HOW THAT WORKS,
- 41:50BECAUSE WE MAY WANT TO EMULATE
- 41:52THAT IN OTHER PLACES.
- 41:54BUT THERE IS A RESPONSE TO THAT
- 41:58HOMELESS PERSON THAT IS COMING
- 42:00IN JEFFERSON COUNTY.
- 42:01IT JUST TAKES TIME TO BUILD THAT
- 42:04OUT AND PUT THE INFRASTRUCTURE
- 42:06IN PLACE.
- 42:06>> Renee: DO YOU AGREE WITH THAT
- 42:09LEADER NEAL?
- 42:09>> NO, I UNDERSTAND WHAT
- 42:11PRESIDENT STIVERS IS SAYING
- 42:12THERE.
- 42:13AND AGAIN I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY
- 42:15HOW THIS WILL UNFOLD.
- 42:17BUT I THINK THE QUESTION OF
- 42:20WHETHER THERE'S ADEQUATE HOUSING
- 42:22OR NOT GENERALLY, IS A PROBLEM.
- 42:25IT'S NOT JUST THE PERSON YOU
- 42:27MEET ON THE STREET RIGHT NOW AND
- 42:28THE CHALLENGES THAT THEY HAVE.
- 42:31THE QUESTIONS OF WHAT ARE THE
- 42:34DYNAMICS ASSOCIATED WITH THAT
- 42:36AND ADMITTED AND I AGREE, THAT
- 42:37IT TAKES TIME TO DEAL WITH THE
- 42:39HOUSING QUESTION OF ITSELF.
- 42:41WE GO AND CRIMINALIZE THE
- 42:42PROCESS OR SOME PEOPLE WILL
- 42:44ARGUE THAT FOR THE THOSE PEOPLE
- 42:47THAT ARE IN THE MOST WEAKEST
- 42:50POSITIONS YOU CAN GET INTO.
- 42:51WE DO NOT CORRELATE WITH THE
- 42:53HOUSING GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT
- 42:54BUT WE HAVE A POLICY WHERE WE
- 42:55WILL GO IN AND EXTRACT THEM IN A
- 42:59CRIMINALIZE THEM BASICALLY.
- 43:00BUT THE OTHER POINT IS HAVING
- 43:02THE SERVICES THAT HAVE BEEN
- 43:04RAISED BY LEADER STEVENSON AND
- 43:07THAT IS DO IF YOU GOT TO TIE THE
- 43:11SERVICES TO THE HOUSING WHAT
- 43:13KINDS OF HOUSING.
- 43:14WE HAVE AN OVERALL PROBLEM IN
- 43:16HOUSING RIGHT NOW.
- 43:17A HUGE PROBLEM IN HOUSING RIGHT
- 43:18NOW.
- 43:18AND I JUST THINK TO BE
- 43:20AGGRESSIVE ON THIS FRONT AND NOT
- 43:22DO THIS PROPERLY AND HUMANELY
- 43:25SOME WILL ARGUE AND WE'LL HAVE
- 43:26MORE SITUATIONS LIKE THIS
- 43:29PERHAPS, I SUSPECT WE WILL, THEN
- 43:31WE MAY HAVE ASKED OURSELVES
- 43:33WE'VE BEEN DISMISSIVE OF WHAT
- 43:35THE CONCERNS AND WHAT WE SHOULD
- 43:36HAVE IN OUR OBLIGATION TO THOSE
- 43:38PEOPLE WHO FIND THEMSELVES IN A
- 43:40WEAKER POSITION.
- 43:40THAT IS AN ARGUMENT THAT I CAN
- 43:43MAKE.
- 43:43SOMEONE ELSE CAN MAKE HOW THAT
- 43:45PLAYS OUT I CAN'T TELL YOU.
- 43:47BUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT WHAT
- 43:48HAPPENED IN TERMS OF THAT
- 43:52ENFORCEMENT ISSUE IS INDICATION
- 43:53OF THE INCON GREW ENSY THAT
- 43:57TAKES PLACE WITH THE LACK OF
- 43:58HOUSING AND TRAINING FOR POLICE
- 44:00AND WE HAVE LESS POLICE THAN WE
- 44:03NEED.
- 44:03WE LOST PARTS OF THE TOP PART OF
- 44:06THE FORCE ALL THOSE THINGS ARE
- 44:07IMPACTING THIS.
- 44:08IT'S NOT JUST HOUSING OR JUST
- 44:10THE SERVICES, IT'S ALSO THE
- 44:12OTHER INSTITUTIONS THAT DEAL
- 44:13WITH THE RESPONSIBILITY OF
- 44:15SAFETY AND SECURITY AND HOW WE
- 44:17MANAGE OUR SPACE IN THIS CITY
- 44:19AND ACROSS KENTUCKY.
- 44:22SO THIS IS, YOU KNOW, I'M
- 44:24FRUSTRATED BY IT WHEN I LOOK AT
- 44:26IT BECAUSE I KNOW IT IS A HEAVY
- 44:29LIFT IT IS A HEAVY LIFT AND THE
- 44:31PEOPLE THAT GET CRUNCHED ARE
- 44:33GOING TO BE THOSE PEOPLE IN THE
- 44:35WEAKEST POSITION IN OUR SOCIETY
- 44:37AND OUT ON OUR STREETS.
- 44:40>> Renee: ANY POLICY
- 44:41RECOMMENDATIONS OR SUGGESTIONS
- 44:43HOW TO DEAL WITH HOUSING AND
- 44:44WOULD THAT COME FORTH IN THE 26
- 44:46DAYS OF THIS SESSION?
- 44:47>> PUT MORE MONEY IN PEOPLE'S
- 44:50POCKETS BE REDUCING THE TAX RATE
- 44:53FROM 4 TO 3.5%.
- 44:55IT WOULD HELP THEM MAKE A BETTER
- 44:58MONTHLY MORTGAGE PAYMENT.
- 44:58IT DOESN'T MATTER IF IT'S
- 45:00DEMOCRAT OR REPUBLICAN YOU
- 45:01ACTUALLY HAVE WHAT IS PROBABLY
- 45:04MORE DESCRIBED AS A MIDDLE
- 45:07INCOME SQUEEZE.
- 45:08THAT'S A REALLY TOUGH AREA WHEN
- 45:10NURSING HOME'S THE MIDDLE INCOME
- 45:13AREA AND YOU EITHER HAVE
- 45:17SUBSIDIZED HOUSING ON ONE AREA
- 45:18WHICH WE UNDERSTAND AND WE
- 45:20APPROPRIATED IN THREE INSTANCES
- 45:22ADDITIONAL MONEY THAT DID NOT
- 45:24COME OUT OF THE GOVERNOR'S
- 45:25RECOMMENDED BUDGET.
- 45:26WE DID THE TRANSFER PROJECT AND
- 45:28WE PUT $10 MILLION MORE IN THE
- 45:31AFFORDABLE HOUSING TRUST FUND.
- 45:32SO YOU HAVE THAT BUT IT TAKES
- 45:34TIME TO GET THOSE HOUSES ON THE
- 45:36GROUND.
- 45:36YOU CAN'T BUILD IT OVERNIGHT.
- 45:38BUT WE RECOGNIZE THAT HOUSING IS
- 45:40AN ISSUE.
- 45:41A LOT OF IT SOMETIMES CAN BE
- 45:43LAND USE POLICY.
- 45:46OTHER THINGS CAN BE LACK OF
- 45:48INFRASTRUCTURE.
- 45:49THERE'S DIFFERENT THINGS OUT
- 45:50THERE IT TAKES TIME TO WORK
- 45:51THROUGH IT.
- 45:52BUT I COULD GIVE YOU A BILLION
- 45:54DOLLARS TODAY A BILLION, YOU
- 45:56CAN'T GET ALL THE HOUSES BUILT
- 45:58AT ONE TIME SO IT'S BEST TO
- 46:00PHASE IT IN BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO
- 46:02HAVE THE CAPACITY TO DO IT.
- 46:04AND WE ARE ATTEMPTING TO DO
- 46:06THAT.
- 46:06AND I'VE GIVEN YOU THREE
- 46:08EXAMPLES HOW WE DID IN THE LAST
- 46:10BUDGET CYCLE.
- 46:12>> Renee: LET'S --
- 46:13GO AHEAD.
- 46:13>> BUT THEN IT GETS BACK TO THIS
- 46:15QUESTION OF WHAT DO WE DO IN THE
- 46:17MEANTIME TO GET TO THAT POINT
- 46:19WHERE EVERYTHING IS PERFECT?
- 46:22SO WE PUT A POLICY INTO PLACE
- 46:25THAT ACTUALLY IS AIMED AT THE
- 46:27PEOPLE THAT WE'RE TRYING TO HELP
- 46:29THAT TENDS TO CRIMINALIZE OR PUT
- 46:32THEM IN AWKWARD CIRCUMSTANCES
- 46:34AND SOME WOULD ARGUE AND THEY
- 46:35HAVE ARGUED TO ME IN MY DISTRICT
- 46:38AND OUTSIDE OF IT AS OPPOSED TO
- 46:40UPLIFTING AND ACCOMMODATING THEM
- 46:42APPROPRIATELY.
- 46:44DIGNITY GOES ALONG WITH THIS
- 46:46PROCESS HOW YOU HANDLE HUMAN
- 46:48BEINGS ALL LEVELS WHETHER THEY
- 46:50ARE HIGH OR ECONOMICALLY LOW
- 46:52MATTERS.
- 46:53THAT'S WHAT WE ALL ARE ALL
- 46:55ABOUT.
- 46:55AND I THINK MY COLLEAGUES ARE
- 46:57ABOUT THAT AS WELL.
- 46:58THE QUESTION IS WE DISAGREE HOW
- 47:01THIS IS DONE AS IT RELATES TO
- 47:03THIS PARTICULAR ASPECT OF THE
- 47:05RESPONSIBILITY WE HAVE TO SET
- 47:07POLICY FOR.
- 47:08>> Renee: BEFORE I GET TO
- 47:09EDUCATION WE'VE HAD SEVERAL
- 47:10QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ABOUT
- 47:13ABORTION AND ABORTION EXCEPTIONS
- 47:14THIS IS A BIPARTISAN EFFORT.
- 47:16WE HAVE REPUBLICAN KEN FLEMING
- 47:18WHO FILED AN EXCEPTIONS BILL TO
- 47:22KENTUCKY'S ABORTION BAN AND
- 47:23SENATOR YATES HAS DONE THAT ON
- 47:25THE UPPER CHAMBER.
- 47:27BECAUSE OF THE TRIGGER LAW THAT
- 47:28WENT INTO EFFECT AFTER THE DOBBS
- 47:32DECISION WHAT ARE THE CHANCES
- 47:33THAT BILL WILL BE HEARD AND
- 47:35CONSIDERED AND VOTED ON ON THE
- 47:36FLOOR IN THE HOUSE?
- 47:38>> IT CONTINUES TO BE A TOPIC OF
- 47:41CONVERSATION ACTIVE TOPIC OF
- 47:42CONVERSATION AMONGST OUR CAUCUS
- 47:44AND PROBABLY IN THE SENATE
- 47:46CAUCUS AS WELL.
- 47:47I THINK THAT AS LONG AS THERE IS
- 47:51A PENDING LAWSUIT, IT MAKES IT
- 47:54MORE DIFFICULT.
- 47:54IT WILL CONTINUE TO BE VERY
- 47:56DIFFICULT UNTIL THAT LAWSUIT
- 47:58PLAYS ITS WAY OUT TO REPLACE A
- 48:01LAW THAT IS BEING LITIGATED IS
- 48:03GOING TO BE VERY DIFFICULT TO
- 48:05DO.
- 48:07>> Renee: LEADER STEVENSON YOUR
- 48:08RESPONSE.
- 48:09WE KNOW MEMBERS OF CAUCUS HAVE
- 48:11ALSO FILED MEASURES, PERHAPS
- 48:16THERE'S OTHERS WHO FILED
- 48:18SIMILARLY?
- 48:18>> HERE IS THE REALLY BIG ISSUE
- 48:21IS THAT WOMEN ARE DYING BECAUSE
- 48:24WE'RE MOVING SO SLOWLY.
- 48:26AND IT WAS UNINTENDED
- 48:29CONSEQUENCES.
- 48:29WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT CAN'T --
- 48:32WOMEN WHO CAN'T GET TREATMENT
- 48:33FOR PREGNANCIES THAT END UP
- 48:36EITHER GOING OUT OF STATE OR END
- 48:38UP IN A BAD POSITION BECAUSE OF
- 48:40THE LAWS WE'VE MADE.
- 48:42THERE ARE SOME THINGS WE CAN DO
- 48:44WE SHOULD DO TO MAKE THIS
- 48:46RIGHT.
- 48:46AND WE JUST HAVE TO BE BRAVE
- 48:48ENOUGH TO DO IT.
- 48:49>> Renee: I SHOULD SAY THAT FOR
- 48:52REPRESENTATIVE FLEMING'S BILL IT
- 48:54ADDS EXCEPTIONS FOR RAPE,
- 48:56INCEST, LETHAL ANOMALIES AND
- 48:59ECTOPIC PREGNANCIES.
- 49:01FURTHER COMMENT FROM LEADER
- 49:02NEAL?
- 49:03>> I APPLAUD SENATOR YATES FOR
- 49:06GOING DOWN THIS ROAD RAISING
- 49:07THIS QUESTION.
- 49:10OBVIOUSLY THE MANY PEOPLE IN
- 49:12KENTUCKY THINK THAT A WOMAN
- 49:14SHOULD HAVE CONTROL OF HER BODY
- 49:16AND SHOULD MAKE THOSE KINDS OF
- 49:18DECISIONS IT WILL BE SOMETHING
- 49:19THAT WILL BE IN CONTENTION IN
- 49:22KENTUCKY GOING FORWARD LIKE IT
- 49:23IS IN OTHER STATES.
- 49:24AND I THINK THAT HOW THAT PLAYS
- 49:27OUT WE'LL SEE IN TERMS OF WHAT
- 49:29THE ELEMENTS ARE THAT WE CAN GET
- 49:31TO TO ADDRESS THE ISSUE.
- 49:32I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT IS GOING
- 49:34TO PLAY OUT.
- 49:35>> Renee: WHAT'S THE TEMPERATURE
- 49:36IN YOUR CAUCUS PRESIDENT STIVERS
- 49:38ABOUT EXCEPTIONS TO KENTUCKY'S
- 49:41ABORTION BAN.
- 49:41>> FIRST LET ME MAKE IT CLEAR IN
- 49:44THE LAW THE LIFE OF THE MOTHER
- 49:46IS AN EXCEPTION.
- 49:48THAT'S IN THE LAW.
- 49:50SO ECTOPIC PREGNANCY AND I HAVE
- 49:52HAD THAT EXPERIENCE WITH ONE OF
- 49:55MY FAMILY MEMBERS.
- 49:57THAT IS ONE THAT CANNOT BE GO TO
- 50:02FULL TERM WITHOUT TOTAL RISK OF
- 50:05THE MOTHER.
- 50:06AND SO THAT IS AN EXCEPTION
- 50:08ANYBODY THAT SAYS OTHERWISE
- 50:10CANNOT READ THE BLACK LETTER OF
- 50:12THE LAW.
- 50:13SECONDLY, ANYBODY WHO COMMITS AN
- 50:16ACT OF RAPE OR INCEST NEEDS TO
- 50:18BE DEALT WITH HARSHLY AND
- 50:21SWIFTLY.
- 50:21THEN IT GETS DOWN TO AN
- 50:23EMOTIONAL ISSUE ONE OF THE MOST
- 50:26EMOTIONAL ISSUES YOU WILL SEE
- 50:27AND TOUGHEST ISSUES IN THE
- 50:29LEGISLATURE BECAUSE OF PERSONAL
- 50:31BELIEFS.
- 50:31I WILL NOT CRITICIZE NOR
- 50:34CHASTISE ANYBODY FOR ANY BELIEF
- 50:36THEY HAVE.
- 50:37BECAUSE IT IS A BELIEF ABOUT THE
- 50:39SANCTITY OF LIFE.
- 50:41AND SO IF YOU HAVE JUST THE ONE
- 50:44EXCEPTION OR YOU HAVE THE OTHER
- 50:46TWO WHICH FOR A TOTAL OF THREE
- 50:48EXCEPTIONS I'M NOT GOING TO BE
- 50:50CRITICAL.
- 50:50I HAVE MY PERSONAL BELIEFS AND
- 50:52OPINIONS.
- 50:53BUT I CAN UNDERSTAND ANYBODY'S
- 50:55ARGUMENT THAT HAS EITHER ONE.
- 50:58AND I SAY ARGUMENT NOT BEING
- 51:01VISIT OBVIOUSLYIC BUT BEING
- 51:05COLLEGIAL IN THE DISCUSSION I DO
- 51:07NOT CRITICIZE PEOPLE FOR HAVING
- 51:08THOSE POSITIONS.
- 51:10>> Renee: FINAL TOPIC WITH FIVE
- 51:11MINUTES REMAINING.
- 51:14WE ALL HAVE A SHOW ABOUT
- 51:17EDUCATION AND WE'LL TALK ABOUT
- 51:18THAT LATER IN FEBRUARY.
- 51:19IN HIGHER-ED WHEN WE LEFT OFF
- 51:22THE LAST SESSION THERE WAS
- 51:24CONVERSATION ABOUTDAY.
- 51:27POLICIES 2K5E6789 POLICIES IN
- 51:30HIGHER D.E.I. POLICIES IN HIGHER
- 51:32EDUCATION AND WHAT IS THE HOUSE
- 51:34AND MAJORITY CAUCUS WE NEED TO
- 51:36PICK UP WHERE YOU LEFT OFF?
- 51:38>> ONGOING CONVERSATIONS.
- 51:39I DO THINK BECAUSE WE ARE GOING
- 51:41TO RUN OUT OF TIME HERE.
- 51:42I DO THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE TO
- 51:46MENTION THAT THESE TYPES OF
- 51:47ISSUES IS ONE OF THE REASONS WE
- 51:49DIVIDED THE HOUSE COMMITTEE ON
- 51:51EDUCATION WE DIVIDED IT INTO
- 51:54HIGHER-ED COMMITTEE AND.
- 51:57THEY HIT VASTLY DIFFERENT TOPICS
- 52:00AND BOTH DESERVE THE ATTENTION
- 52:06TO DETAIL TO GET THINGS RIGHT.
- 52:09THERE'S ONGOING CONVERSATION
- 52:10ABOUT D.E.I. THERE IS AN ACTIVE
- 52:13CONVERSATION BETWEEN HOUSE AND
- 52:15SENATE MEMBERS TO TRY TO ARRIVE
- 52:19AT COMMON LANGUAGE ON THAT.
- 52:20AND I THINK IT'S ALSO WORTH
- 52:22NOTING THAT CLEARLY A LOT OF THE
- 52:25UNIVERSITIES HAVE IDENTIFIED
- 52:26PROBLEMS ON THEIR OWN.
- 52:28THEY HAVE VERY WILLINGLY MADE
- 52:31SOME CHANGES.
- 52:31I KNOW THAT I HAD A MEETING THIS
- 52:35SUMMER WITH PRESIDENT OF THE
- 52:38UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY AND HE
- 52:43WAS SURPRISED INTO THE POLICIES
- 52:44THEY HAD IN PLACE AND THERE WERE
- 52:46NECESSARY CORRECTIONS THAT THEY
- 52:48WERE UNDERTAKING THEMSELVES.
- 52:49WHAT THAT ULTIMATELY LOOKS LIKE
- 52:51IN THE FORM OF LEGISLATION, I DO
- 52:53BELIEVE THERE WILL BE SOME.
- 52:56MY SUSPICION IS WILL LARGELY
- 53:00CODIFY THE THINGS THAT THE
- 53:02UNIVERSITIES HAVE SAID THE
- 53:03CHANGES THEY ARE MAKING ON THEIR
- 53:05OWN.
- 53:05BUT AS FAR AS THE EXACT DETAILS
- 53:08IT'S PREMATURE.
- 53:09>> Renee: LEADER NEAL YOUR
- 53:10RESPONSE TO WHAT YOU THINK COULD
- 53:12BE COMING AND WHAT YOUR FEAR
- 53:15PERHAPS COULD BE?
- 53:15>> I'M SURE THOSE THAT WILL COME
- 53:18FULL SQUARE ON THE ISSUE.
- 53:19I DON'T THINK IT'S GOING TO
- 53:23WHETHER IT SUCCEEDS OR NOT, THE
- 53:25CAT'S OUT OF THE BAG.
- 53:26I THINK YOU CAN'T SUPPRESS THIS
- 53:28AREA.
- 53:29ALTHOUGH YOU MAY DO IT
- 53:31INSTITUTIONALLY.
- 53:32WHAT DISTURBS ME ABOUT THIS
- 53:35FRANKLY IS THAT IF YOU'VE GONE
- 53:37LISTENED TO THOSE WHO COME
- 53:38BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON THE DEAL
- 53:40AUTOS WITH THIS SUBJECT MATTER
- 53:42THAT YOU WILL FIND THAT THE
- 53:45UNIVERSITIES BASICALLY ARE NOT
- 53:47DOING ANYTHING THAT IS
- 53:48OBJECTIONABLE THAT I'VE SEEN A
- 53:50REACTION TO OTHER THAN SOME OF
- 53:52THE POINTS THAT SPEAKER HAS
- 53:55INDICATED AS IT RELATES AT THE
- 53:58UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY WHICH
- 53:59UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY STEPPED
- 54:00AWAY FROM.
- 54:02I'M QUESTIONING WHY ARE WE GOING
- 54:03IN THIS DIRECTION RIGHT NOW?
- 54:05AND I'M WAITING TO SEE WHAT THIS
- 54:07IS.
- 54:08I LOOK AT IT IN A LARGER
- 54:10HISTORICAL CONTEXT.
- 54:11I LOOK AT IT AS REACTION AN
- 54:14ATTEMPT TO DO CENSORSHIP WHERE
- 54:17IT'S INAPPROPRIATE.
- 54:17I LOOK AT IT'S AN OPPORTUNITY
- 54:19FOR THOSE TRYING TO BRING ABOUT
- 54:21THIS POLICY CHANGE ON PICKING ON
- 54:23CERTAIN THINGS THAT THEY THINK
- 54:25THAT SOMEBODY MIGHT BE OPPOSED
- 54:27TO.
- 54:27MAYBE I'M OPPOSED TO SOMETHING
- 54:29IN THERE AND EXTRAPOLATING ALL
- 54:31AROUND ALL THE UNIVERSITIES AND
- 54:34CALLING THIS THING AND DEFINING
- 54:35IT IN THOSE TERMS SO THAT THEY
- 54:38CAN CREATE A WHOLE PIECE OF
- 54:41REACTION THAT IS UNWARRANTED.
- 54:43I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THAT.
- 54:44I DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY ARE GOING
- 54:45TO BRING.
- 54:46I SUSPECT THEY WILL COME I'M
- 54:48SURE THEY WILL.
- 54:49AND I HOPE WE USE COMMON SENSE
- 54:51WHEN WE GO DOWN THIS ROAD.
- 54:53BECAUSE I THINK IF WE DON'T, I
- 54:55THINK WE MAYBE REPEATING SOME OF
- 54:57THE THINGS THAT HISTORY HAS
- 54:59TAUGHT US SINCE THE BEGINNING OF
- 55:01THE COMMONWEALTH.
- 55:03>> Renee: QUICKLY PRESIDENT
- 55:04STIVERS NOW LEADER MAX WISE
- 55:06SPONSORED A MEASURE LAST YEAR
- 55:07THAT DEALT WITH THIS IS HE GOING
- 55:09TO CARRY THE WATER THIS TIME
- 55:11AROUND?
- 55:13>> I DON'T SAY THAT IN A JOVIAL
- 55:16WAY LAUGH, MAX HAS A LITTLE BIT
- 55:18DIFFERENT ROLE THIS YEAR.
- 55:20HIS TIME CONSTRAINTS WILL BE
- 55:22LIMITED.
- 55:22I DOUBT HE WILL IF THERE IS SUCH
- 55:24A BILL.
- 55:25BUT I THINK WHAT WE HAVE TO LOOK
- 55:27AT HERE IS YOU BASE DECISIONS ON
- 55:31QUALIFICATIONS.
- 55:32AND IF INDIVIDUALS DON'T HAVE
- 55:36ACCESS TO GET TO THE POINT OF
- 55:39BETTER EDUCATIONAL OR ECONOMIC
- 55:40TRAJECTORIES THEN WE NEED TO
- 55:41FIGURE OUT THE UNDERLYING
- 55:43PROBLEMS.
- 55:44I WANT TO GO BACK TO SOMETHING
- 55:46THESE TWO INDIVIDUALS --
- 55:49>> Renee: QUICKLY SIR.
- 55:49>> WE DID THIS AND WENT INTO THE
- 55:52WEST END OPPORTUNITY PARTNERSHIP
- 55:54TO CHANGE ECONOMIC AND
- 55:57EDUCATIONAL TRAJECTORIES WITH
- 55:57LETTING THE INDIVIDUALS OF
- 55:59LOUISVILLE DETERMINE HOW THEY DO
- 56:00THAT.
- 56:01>> MORE ON THAT TO COME.
- 56:03>> THAT DOESN'T SOLVE THE
- 56:04PROBLEM WE ARE ADDRESSING HERE.
- 56:06>> Renee: MORE TO COME.
- 56:07WE THANK YOU FOR WATCHING
- 56:09TONIGHT.
- 56:09WE'LL HAVE MORE IN A COUPLE
- 56:11WEEKS.
- 56:11WE ARE OFF NEXT MONDAY NIGHT IN
- 56:14OBSERVANCE OF MARTIN LUTHER
- 56:15KING, JR. DAY AND SPECIAL PBS
- 56:19PROGRAMMING AND "KENTUCKY
- 56:20TONIGHT" WILL RETURN THE WEEK
- 56:21AFTER AND TALK WITH ANOTHER SET
- 56:23OF LEADERS ABOUT WHAT WILL BE
- 56:24HAPPENING IN THE 2025
- 56:26LEGISLATIVE SESSION.
- 56:27I WILL SEE YOU TOMORROW NIGHT
- 56:28FOR KENTUCKY EDITION AT 6:30.
- 56:31UNTIL THEN TAKE GOOD CARE.