Latest / Consumerpedia / 51 - How to Hire a Reliable Roofer
Transcript
- 0:01Whether it's flat or pitched, covered with shingle shakes or
- 0:04tiles, the roof protects your house and everyone and
- 0:07everything inside from the rain, snow, sun, and other elements.
- 0:12A good roof can improve energy efficiency and make you feel
- 0:15more comfortable inside. A new roof can boost curb appeal
- 0:18and increase the value of your house.
- 0:20If there's a new roof in your future, we've got you covered.
- 0:24I'm Herb Weissbaum, the consumer man, a contributing editor at
- 0:27checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia at
- 0:31checkbook.org, where the nonprofit that helps consumers
- 0:34select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:37Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:40any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:43completely independent and objective.
- 0:46Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's consumer
- 0:50expert, the Consumer Man Herb Weissbaum.
- 0:53No two ways about it. Roofing work is very expensive,
- 0:56and unless you purchase carefully, you could spend
- 0:59thousands of dollars more than you have to and get less than
- 1:02satisfactory results. In this episode, we'll explain
- 1:06how to find a good roofer, how to review proposals for that
- 1:09roofing job, and how to compare warranties, plus ways to avoid
- 1:13getting ripped off by a shady contractor who will take your
- 1:16money and run. Checkbooks Executive Editor
- 1:18Kevin Rassler is here with all of that and much more.
- 1:21Hello, Herb. So I know for a fact how much
- 1:25you hate paying for home improvement work.
- 1:26You must dread the thought of someday having to pay for a new
- 1:29roof on your house. Yeah, I mean, you know, the way
- 1:32I look at it is the kids are going to destroy this place.
- 1:34No matter what. So.
- 1:35So what's the point of buying new rugs or furniture or even
- 1:38painting walls? But as you mentioned, you know,
- 1:40having to pay for a new roof replacement, I always view it as
- 1:43it's like buying tires. I mean, it's like the worst
- 1:45possible purchase. You have to make.
- 1:48It's something you might have to do, but it's not like, you know,
- 1:50you get to watch a new TV or settle into a new sofa or a
- 1:53newly decorated room and roofing.
- 1:56And I can tell you this from someone who's done it is really
- 1:59expensive. Yeah, I mean, it's become
- 2:00astonishingly so. Even owners of small homes,
- 2:04they're likely going to pay more than $10,000 these days to
- 2:08replace their roofs. So if you hire the wrong
- 2:11contractor, you're going to pay. You're going to pay too much,
- 2:14and you're going to have to deal possibly with headaches during
- 2:16the construction work, and possibly after drip, drip, drip.
- 2:20Is that a hint? Let's make sure this doesn't
- 2:22happen to you. What steps should our listeners
- 2:24take to get this whole process started?
- 2:26Start by making sure you really do need to replace your entire
- 2:30roof. I've owned my current home for
- 2:32about 5 years now. And I've had to have the roof
- 2:35repaired. You know, a few minor repairs
- 2:37done. But for those small repair jobs,
- 2:39you know, I made sure I hired a highly reputable roofer.
- 2:42He let me know that my shingles still have 10 plus years left.
- 2:46And I'm sure some disreputable roofers out there would have,
- 2:49you know, shaken their heads when I pointed out these little
- 2:52leaks and, you know, made that annoying TISK TISK sound and
- 2:55told me I needed a whole new roof.
- 2:57Yeah, that is one of the benefits of having a reputable
- 3:00contractor showing up at your house.
- 3:02So step one. As with any home repair, make
- 3:05sure you're working with that reputable contractor, an honest
- 3:08company. And check out the ratings that
- 3:10we have a checkbook.org if you live in one of the cities where
- 3:12we do ratings and only deal with companies with stellar reviews.
- 3:15Yeah, I mean, as I always say, I mean, you can't squeeze good
- 3:18work out of a bad contractor and don't just invite, you know, one
- 3:22good company out to provide a cost proposal.
- 3:26We suggest you ask at least five of them to do so.
- 3:29And if you have time to ask, ten, do that.
- 3:32Because what we found is that even among the really good
- 3:35companies, the good roofing contractors out there, you'll
- 3:38find huge price differences for the same work.
- 3:41So for example, in in the latest issue of Checkbook, we have
- 3:45results from our undercover shopping where we had three
- 3:48different homeowners collect bids from area roofing companies
- 3:51here in the Washington area where I live.
- 3:54For one home, we were quoted prices ranging from about $8000
- 3:59to more than $24,000 for one job.
- 4:02For the second job, the prices ranged from $8000 to more than
- 4:06$21,000. And for the third house, which
- 4:09was a little bit bigger, prices ranged from a low of about $9400
- 4:14to replace that roof. To more than $35,000, man.
- 4:19So the message is obvious as always.
- 4:22What we always say is get several bids, especially in the
- 4:26case of roofing work, because it's so expensive, and get in a
- 4:30few extra bids may save you thousands of dollars.
- 4:33So you may save $10,000 or more by having several companies out,
- 4:37and you lower the chance of dealing with really high-priced
- 4:40company. And as usual, we found no
- 4:43relationship between price and quality, right?
- 4:45Yeah, exactly right. Companies with poor ratings
- 4:48often quoted high prices when we shop them.
- 4:51Companies with hundreds of positive reviews that we've
- 4:54collected. They often have low prices, but
- 4:56sometimes they have high prices. You the trick is you must have
- 5:00three to five companies and you may as well focus on the good
- 5:02ones, right? Have three to five companies out
- 5:05to bid on your work. Even companies that get really
- 5:07stellar reviews. The best companies in our in our
- 5:10ratings of companies for quality sometimes quote high prices,
- 5:13sometimes have high prices. The only way to know is by
- 5:16having them out and bid. It seems like getting bids takes
- 5:19a lot of work, but checkbooks undercover shoppers found these
- 5:22days they can do this by satellite.
- 5:25I like going to come out to my house, but they can start the
- 5:27thing with satellite images. Yeah, a lot of roofers these
- 5:29days have software where they can give you a price estimate
- 5:33without actually having to visit your home.
- 5:35Especially if your roof is visible from Google Earth.
- 5:38They can use that technology to figure out how about how big
- 5:41your roof is and how much work it's going to be.
- 5:43They can see where the valleys are and things like that.
- 5:45You still want to meet with the contractor you hire, but in
- 5:48terms of collecting prices for multiple companies, this is a
- 5:52huge time saver. And even if companies want to
- 5:55come out to see your home, usually you don't have to be
- 5:58there for that. You can call 10 companies, get
- 6:00prices from them without having to take time out of your day to
- 6:04meet with each one. So obviously if you live in one
- 6:07of the seven cities where checkbook rates roofers, you
- 6:10want to start there. For our listeners who don't live
- 6:12in those cities, I guess the best thing you can do is try to
- 6:15ask folks you know who they use, check them out with a Better
- 6:18Business Bureau, and then do all the other checks necessary to
- 6:20hire a contractor. Yeah, I think, you know, the
- 6:22important thing is to be. Be very careful about selecting
- 6:25any contractor, even those that get stellar ratings from us.
- 6:30You know, one big red flag is if they have more than just a few
- 6:33complaints with a Better Business Bureau, that's a
- 6:35warning sign. I mean, even you know, large
- 6:37companies, should it be generating a lot of complaints?
- 6:40I think you can ask contractors for references.
- 6:43You should check the references. Just know they're not likely to
- 6:46give you names of people who who are suing them in court.
- 6:49I think you should be pretty careful these days about using
- 6:52online reviews of companies. If you do so, make sure there
- 6:56are lots and lots of reviews and really carefully go over the
- 6:59ones that are one and two star reviews.
- 7:01It's a warning flag that they have dissatisfied customers out
- 7:04there that haven't been just kind of overwhelmed by possibly
- 7:07fake reviews they've posted on some of these websites out
- 7:09there. You know, there are several
- 7:11things you should do whenever you hire a contractor,
- 7:13especially one that's going to be working 20 feet off the
- 7:15ground. We'll talk to Kevin about that
- 7:17next. This is Consumerpedia powered by
- 7:19checkbook.org. Want ratings for roofers in your
- 7:24area? Checkbook has ratings for dozens
- 7:26of roofers in these metro areas, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 7:31Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul and
- 7:35Washington, DC. If you live in or around one of
- 7:38these seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, get a free
- 7:4130 day subscription to all of our ratings by going to
- 7:44checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like this podcast, we
- 7:49hope you'll become a Consumer Pedia contributor by using the
- 7:52link at the bottom of the show Notes to make a small monthly
- 7:55contribution. Of course, price is important,
- 7:59but with any home remodeling work, you need to make sure the
- 8:01contractor you hired is insured and licensed.
- 8:04It should carry general liability insurance and workers
- 8:07comp coverage. Kevin, tell us more about that.
- 8:10Yeah. So liability insurance, it
- 8:11protects you if they cause damage to your home.
- 8:14So instead of you having to pay for a broken window, the company
- 8:17that broke it, it has coverage to pay for that.
- 8:20And because roofing work is so dangerous, you know they're up
- 8:23there 30 feet above the ground. They also need to insure
- 8:26themselves against the risk of having a worker get hurt.
- 8:29That protects you from having to pay for any medical costs.
- 8:33It's also important to make sure the company is licensed.
- 8:36Being licensed doesn't mean it's not a guarantee that the
- 8:40contractor will do good work. Is our is our good friend Herb?
- 8:43Connie Thompson always like to say anyone can put out a shingle
- 8:46and say they're a roofer. Connie is just so clever.
- 8:49I love that line. Anyone can put out a shingle and
- 8:51say they're a roofer. But of course, being licensed
- 8:53does mean you might be able to get help more easily if there's
- 8:56a problem, right? Yeah.
- 8:57I mean, it means that the company has at least taken the
- 8:59right steps to secure a bond or do other things that are
- 9:03required in their local area. To prove that they're
- 9:05financially responsible. It also means that if things
- 9:08don't go right, you know, local consumer offices, contractors,
- 9:12boards, they might be more willing to help you because
- 9:15you've taken the time to seek out a licensed outfit.
- 9:18But again, this is important. Even contractors that do really
- 9:22bad work are often licensed. Another point we really need to
- 9:26stress here, absolutely do not engage with companies that come
- 9:30door to door, even if they're local and licensed.
- 9:33Even if they say they're working with your insurer and you won't
- 9:36have to pay a dime for this roof replacement because you got, you
- 9:39know, other homes in the area got damaged by a storm.
- 9:41Even if the company provides references, even if there's a
- 9:44tree through your roof after a storm and they seem gracious and
- 9:48just really wanting to help you out door to door solicitation,
- 9:52it's a huge red flag. Find your own contractors.
- 9:56Do not even talk to those who are looking to find you love
- 9:59where they say we're working in the neighborhood and we had some
- 10:01extra materials leftover so we can give you a really low price.
- 10:04And my question would be a response will be if you're such
- 10:07a good contractor, how come you didn't know what materials to
- 10:09get? Right.
- 10:10Well, in my neighborhood they're pretty clever.
- 10:12They name drop and another thing to check.
- 10:14You may need to have some permits depending on where you
- 10:16live, so that's something a good contractor would check for you,
- 10:19but you need to make sure about that, right?
- 10:20Sometimes it seems easier to skip this permitting process,
- 10:24but in communities where they're required for roofing, work
- 10:26permits, and inspections that process, it exists.
- 10:29This to protect homeowners. So as you're comparing proposals
- 10:32from your various roofing companies you're considering,
- 10:36you have to compare the warranties that they're offering
- 10:38you. What should we be looking for?
- 10:40For roofing work, there's two types of warranties.
- 10:43There's one on the materials from the manufacturer, the
- 10:46shingles, and there's another warranty on workmanship.
- 10:50That warranty? The second one you get from the
- 10:52roofer. The warranties offered by
- 10:54shingle manufacturers are very similar to one another.
- 10:58Basically, these are agreements to pay for the cost, including
- 11:01any labor, to repair or replace shingles if they're proven to be
- 11:06defective, which is a somewhat unlikely risk.
- 11:09So don't assume that lengthy warranty periods cover you
- 11:13against you know, all leaks and other common problems, or that
- 11:16you'll even be protected long term from product defects.
- 11:19The roofing shingles manufacturers warranties.
- 11:22They generally begin with the. Specified time period.
- 11:24For example, five years during which the warranty covers the
- 11:27entire cost of replacing and again it's just defective
- 11:31shingles. But after that initial period,
- 11:33the manufacturer's exposure is reduced.
- 11:36You only get a pro rated base you know, share back.
- 11:38If you do show that, OK, these shingles that were installed,
- 11:42they were defective. So this is a true story, Kevin.
- 11:45When we had our roof done, the contractor asked if we wanted 30
- 11:48year shingles or 40 year shingles, and my wife, Deb, God
- 11:51bless her, said I don't care what happens when we're gone.
- 11:55Let the next owner worry about it.
- 11:56We'll take the 30 year ones. Yeah.
- 11:58Does a longer warranty mean you're getting a better shingle?
- 12:01So maybe your longer warranties. Generally yes, they indicate
- 12:05better products, but you can't really count on that.
- 12:08And the other thing you can't count on is if your roof leaks
- 12:1120 years from now and you bought a 50 year shingles or whatever.
- 12:15Don't assume the shingle manufacturer's going to step in
- 12:18and repair or replace your entire roof, or even do a small
- 12:21repair for free. And maybe that the shingles were
- 12:24installed incorrectly or you weren't doing the right type of
- 12:27maintenance. And even if the shingles were to
- 12:29blame because they were defective, again, these
- 12:31warranties, they had these, you know, sliding scales of payouts
- 12:34where as the years go on, they pay a, you know, a smaller and
- 12:38smaller percent. Of what it's going to cost to
- 12:40replace them. And as you said, you should also
- 12:42get a warranty from the roofing contractor.
- 12:44Yeah, I'd argue that the warranty you get from the
- 12:46roofing contractor, especially in terms of how long it will
- 12:50remain in effect, is more important than looking at the
- 12:52shingle warranties from the shingle manufacturers.
- 12:55And the reason is the warranties you can get from roofing
- 12:57contractors. They may vary in links
- 12:59tremendously. Some mail are only offer you a
- 13:01few years, others may offer you 10 years.
- 13:04The warranties you get from roofing contractors, there are
- 13:07promise. That the roofer did the work
- 13:09correctly and this is really the big risk there.
- 13:12There's a small risk that your shingles were defective and that
- 13:15you discover that is the case after 30 years or whatever.
- 13:18There's a much bigger risk that the roofing company did the work
- 13:22poorly. The problem is the roofers
- 13:24warranties on their labor. They're not as spelled out as
- 13:27carefully as these manufacturer warranties.
- 13:29Some simply say. Labor is guaranteed for three
- 13:32years, Others say guaranteed against defects and workmanship
- 13:36for, you know, five years. A lot of times roofers
- 13:39warranties. They only cover one or two
- 13:41years. We did find that some roofing
- 13:43companies will offer five, even 10 years.
- 13:46So and obviously the longer the warranty you can get, the
- 13:48better. You know, we advise people just
- 13:50to nail this down, this issue down by asking roofers you're
- 13:54considering to include language in their contract that says
- 13:57basically over the next five years, if there's a leak except
- 14:00as a result of accidental damage or a storm or something, the
- 14:04contractor will bear the cost of Labor and materials to eliminate
- 14:07those leaks. And as with any other
- 14:10contracting job, you want to get all kinds of specific details
- 14:14put in the contract, what works going to get done, how much
- 14:17you'll pay if they find rotten plywood underneath or how much
- 14:20extra there might be payment schedule, clean up, that sort of
- 14:24thing. It's really.
- 14:24Important to get all the details in writing.
- 14:27The contract should also clearly define warranties and make sure
- 14:30it includes a point about the contractor being responsible for
- 14:34all cleanup. This is a big source of
- 14:36complaints about roofing work where homeowners say the
- 14:40contractors. This left behind a lot of trash
- 14:43and. And rusty nails.
- 14:45The really good companies will even bring out metal detectors
- 14:48to find every little bit of of leftover nails.
- 14:50They'll bring out these, you know, destrial magnets to make
- 14:53sure they get them all. So should you pay a roof or
- 14:55deposit? And if so, how much?
- 14:57Plus how to avoid a roofing scammer who'll take your money
- 14:59and run? That's straight ahead.
- 15:01I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 15:05powered by checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast facts.
- 15:11Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in the
- 15:14US. They're durable, fire resistant,
- 15:16and easy to maintain. Concrete, clay, and slate roofs
- 15:20are the most expensive, but last the longest, with an average
- 15:23lifespan of 100 years or more. Flat roofs aren't completely
- 15:27flat. They actually have a slope at
- 15:29least 1/4 inch per foot to let water drain.
- 15:36All right, so now we're getting down to the nitty gritty Kevin,
- 15:38what about a deposit? Should I be expected to pay one,
- 15:41and if so, how much and when don't pay?
- 15:43Anything in advance, if you can help it.
- 15:45A company that wants a small deposit of 10% or so, you know
- 15:49that's fine so long as you're certain it's a reputable
- 15:51company. But anything more than that, it
- 15:54should be unnecessary. We find that many companies
- 15:57don't require any deposits. So by paying at the end, you
- 16:01make sure that you get to say when the work was complete and
- 16:04that was done right. And by not giving someone money
- 16:06up front, it greatly reduces your chance of falling victim to
- 16:10a roofing scammer, someone who simply wants to get your money
- 16:13up front and then skip town. And in my 40 year career as a
- 16:16consumer reporter, I have interviewed so many homeowners.
- 16:20It's tragic, Kevin. They come in, they take your
- 16:22money, they rip off the roof, maybe they'll put up a blue tarp
- 16:25and then they disappear And these people are left with no
- 16:28money and they've lost in some cases $10,000 or more and then
- 16:32no roof. And then they've got to hire a
- 16:34real contractor to fix the the thing and hope they didn't do
- 16:37damage. The scam guys didn't do damage
- 16:39in the 1st place. You you really do need to make
- 16:42sure that you don't get hooked up with a scammer.
- 16:44One of the best tips as Kevin said is you never hire anybody
- 16:47who just shows up and knocks on your door.
- 16:48Good roofers have plenty of work and they're not walking around
- 16:51neighborhood saying hi, can I load your roofs got damaged.
- 16:53Let me fix it for you. Give me all the money up front
- 16:55you, even if the. Contractor seems reputable
- 16:58you're asking for. Half the money in advance.
- 17:00Huge red flag. I mean, even if they say, well,
- 17:03I got to buy the shingles, Well, good companies are able to
- 17:05obtain materials and even sometimes a lot of expensive
- 17:08materials either on credit or they can front those costs
- 17:12knowing that their customers in the end are going to be happy
- 17:15and pay, right. And if they can't afford to buy
- 17:17the materials and that tells you something about the contractor,
- 17:19right there, doesn't it? It's a.
- 17:20Big red flag. So here's something I find
- 17:23fascinating. It's a solar roof.
- 17:25No need to install solar panels because the roofing material
- 17:28also generates electricity. I know for some this is going to
- 17:32look better than solar panels. It's also an all in one project.
- 17:35So Kevin, you've looked into this, is a solar roof cost
- 17:38effective and is this a viable technology?
- 17:41Yeah, I. Think Their time hasn't come
- 17:43yet, and I'm not sure if it will.
- 17:45And the short answer for that is that they're a lot more
- 17:47expensive, these roofing tiles and shingles and the labor
- 17:51involved in installing them. It's still more expensive to do
- 17:54that one job. Than it is to rip off your old
- 17:57roof, put on new shingles, and then add panels.
- 18:00Aside from costs, another problem with solar shingles is
- 18:03your panels. When they install them, they can
- 18:05angle them. They're installed on racks and
- 18:07they can angle them to better capture energy from the sun, but
- 18:11you can't really re angle your roof.
- 18:13So panels not only are they less expensive, they're going to be
- 18:16more efficient. They're going to provide you
- 18:18with more juice than a roof can. Final tip, you will have paid a
- 18:21lot of money for that roof. Take the time, spend some extra
- 18:25money to maintain it, whether that's blowing off the leaves
- 18:27and needles or dealing with the Moss.
- 18:29It can save you a lot in the long run in maintenance costs
- 18:33and also extend the life of your roof.
- 18:35Yeah, ask. Your roofer what you need to do
- 18:37and how often to do it. Avoid walking on your roof
- 18:40unless you have to be up there. Even if you have a a very, you
- 18:43know, low pitched roof that's easy to walk on, avoid walking
- 18:46on those shingles. That will create just as much
- 18:48damage as anything else is. Is branches dropping on it or
- 18:51anything else, Kevin? A lot of them.
- 18:53Important information. Hopefully we've helped folks.
- 18:55As always, good to talk to you. Good to talk.
- 18:57To you. Well, that's it for this edition
- 18:59of Consumerpedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 19:01and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 19:05to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 19:08episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 19:11show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 19:15Instagram. And at my Consumerpedia on
- 19:17Twitter. I'm Her Weissbaum.
- 19:19Thanks for listening. Consumerpedia is a public
- 19:22service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 19:25helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 19:28You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 19:31and avoid the worst, with local ratings that are accurate and
- 19:34unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 19:37seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 19:40Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 19:45Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 19:48To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 19:50checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 19:54we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 19:57the bottom of the show Notes to Make a small contribution each
- 20:00month. Consumer Pedia Empowering
- 20:02consumers to Save Money and make smarter choices.