Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep5: GRD033: Should I Change Financial Advisors When I Retire?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:29You.
- 0:30A more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:33each side of the debate to your own personal situation to decide
- 0:36what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go.
- 0:39Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 0:43So Jeff, I'm not retiring anytime soon.
- 0:46You are never going to retire.
- 0:48Yeah, that's a given.
- 0:50I'm pretty convinced that my next job will be wheeling you on stage
- 0:53in a wheelbarrow at some point.
- 0:55Whatever it takes.
- 0:56That's it.
- 0:57Gotta get the message out.
- 0:58Get that information out there.
- 0:59Let's say You know, uh, the Met's Win the World series, uh, Right.
- 1:05This podcast grounded in reality, Ed.
- 1:08Yeah, right.
- 1:09Uh, you know, and other things like that.
- 1:11Uh huh.
- 1:11You know, man walks on the sun.
- 1:12Yes.
- 1:13Yeah.
- 1:14Uh, so let's say I retire.
- 1:16At that point, should I change financial advisors?
- 1:22Good question.
- 1:24So, is that the topic for today's discussion?
- 1:26Should I change financial advisors when I retire?
- 1:29What changes?
- 1:30Well, let's start with that.
- 1:31That's a good question.
- 1:33A lot changes, right?
- 1:34Right.
- 1:34When you retire, it is a completely different ballgame.
- 1:38The accumulation phase of financial planning versus the distribution
- 1:43phase are incredibly different.
- 1:46There's different tax planning considerations.
- 1:49There's different investment considerations.
- 1:52There's different health care considerations for most individuals.
- 1:55Um, there's different, uh, you have new income streams that you didn't
- 1:59have to be concerned with before.
- 2:01I, I, there are more differences, I think, than there are similarities
- 2:06between the two phases.
- 2:07Not to mention.
- 2:08There is a huge change in the, uh, the, the, the behavior of individuals, you
- 2:15know, while individuals are working and they know they have that paycheck
- 2:19coming in, everything stays the same.
- 2:21Yeah.
- 2:21I mean, total inertia.
- 2:23You can be a longterm investor a lot easier when that's not
- 2:27your source of income, right?
- 2:28But all of a sudden when a lot of people retire, even people who were.
- 2:32You know, the most stalwart of investors who weren't phased at all by, you know,
- 2:382008 or nine in the crash and who, who looked at, you know, the pandemic drop
- 2:43in in value as a buying opportunity.
- 2:45All of a sudden they retire and they're frozen.
- 2:48The shortest and the littlest blip in the market creates that anxiety
- 2:52that was never there before.
- 2:53So beyond all the, the dollars and cents, the math behind this all,
- 2:57I think it is a huge change just behaviorally for people when they retire.
- 3:01Another thing that we always talk about when we talk about retirement
- 3:04accounts, we always use that analogy of climbing up to Mount Everest and,
- 3:09Everybody knows, I think everybody knows, people that get to the top, most
- 3:13of the people that, that climb Mount Everest who die, die on the way down.
- 3:17That's right.
- 3:18More people die on the way down than die on the way up.
- 3:19Right.
- 3:20So maybe they should have had a better advisor on the way down.
- 3:23Indeed.
- 3:24By the way, here's another random fact for you about Everest.
- 3:27Alright.
- 3:28Did you know that it is so, uh, commercialized today?
- 3:32That you actually, so many people walking up, you have to actually walk around
- 3:36the bags of poop that people live on.
- 3:38And the dead bodies.
- 3:39And the dead bodies.
- 3:40I did see a line, I saw that in a magazine, they were actually
- 3:42dead, mostly on the way down.
- 3:44It is, it is, it's odd.
- 3:45They don't, uh, the air or whatever, I'm no, I'm never, um, that's not for me.
- 3:49But, it's a good analogy because they get, You know, the right advice.
- 3:54You got to get up to the next level, whatever it is.
- 3:56I don't really know what it is.
- 3:57Well, you think you've reached the top, that you've reached the summit
- 4:00and that it's all over, right?
- 4:01Like, I made it to retirement.
- 4:03I hit my number, whatever that is, but you know, there were those
- 4:06commercials years ago, remember?
- 4:07Like, what's your number?
- 4:08Well, that's great.
- 4:08You hit your number, but what about the next 30 years?
- 4:10Who cares what that number was?
- 4:12So, maybe, or it's that book, I forget the title, the, the, what
- 4:15got you here won't get you there.
- 4:17That's it.
- 4:18Yeah.
- 4:18Is that the book?
- 4:19I think so.
- 4:19Yeah.
- 4:20And it's like that maybe with financial advisors.
- 4:22The person to help you make all that money to get to the top of the mountain may
- 4:26not be the, the person that will help you when you start distributing that money
- 4:31and taking the money out in retirement.
- 4:33I think you hit on a point, right?
- 4:35It may not be the person.
- 4:37Who, uh, who will help you?
- 4:38I think the answer, of course, is, is it depends, right?
- 4:42The answer is should you change advisors, uh, when you hit retirement?
- 4:45To me, the answer is it depends.
- 4:46There are certainly some advisors and some companies that focus much, you
- 4:51know, that focus much of their time and much of their effort and their
- 4:55education on the accumulation phase.
- 4:57And that's fine.
- 4:57Because that's how they would train.
- 4:58That's right.
- 4:58Make people more money.
- 4:59Everybody likes people who make them more money.
- 5:02I like more money.
- 5:03Right.
- 5:04But, where I said the person that got you here may not get you there, if you lose
- 5:09it on the way down, what have you done?
- 5:11You built a savings account for the government.
- 5:13Yeah, that's no good.
- 5:14Whether it be taxes, or poor investment decisions, etc.
- 5:17Matter of fact.
- 5:18I just happen to have, where'd that come from?
- 5:20This book of mine, I have one, it's called the Retirement Savings Time
- 5:24Bomb Ticks Louder, but there's one line that I put on the back cover.
- 5:27It says, Unlike losses in the stock market, money lost
- 5:31to taxes never recovers.
- 5:34It's true.
- 5:34And that's where you may need a different kind of advisor to help you
- 5:38get that money out and manage the taxes.
- 5:41You manage the investments generally on the way up, on the way in, and
- 5:45you manage the taxes on the way out.
- 5:48Yeah, I think, I think the key point is that it's a different phase and whether
- 5:53you change your advisor or not, you have to make sure that that advisor
- 5:57has the knowledge and or the resources to turn to, to understand the nuances
- 6:03of the decumulation phase, right?
- 6:05If you start asking questions about, uh, you know, Hey, you know, how do
- 6:09you manage taxes on the way down?
- 6:11Transcribed What do you think about social security planning?
- 6:14And your advisor looks at you with kind of like that, uh, you
- 6:16know, deer in a headlights look, it's probably time to change it.
- 6:19Or if the advisor says, whatever you said, here's the next stock to buy.
- 6:24Yes.
- 6:24Right.
- 6:24Like there's not that that's, you know, not that the investments aren't
- 6:27important, but that, you know, That's almost the table stakes, right?
- 6:31It's like you have to have a good investment portfolio, but beyond that,
- 6:34you need all the specialized knowledge of the tax planning, the, the, the
- 6:38decumulation phase of life, how to manage the portfolio so that it doesn't run
- 6:42out of money before you run out of life.
- 6:44Right.
- 6:45And I've had clients that hit, just like you said, I hit my
- 6:48number or whatever it is, got all the money I need for retirement.
- 6:52And they would tell me, they say, I'm not looking for the next hot
- 6:55stock or next hot fund anymore.
- 6:57I just don't want to lose money now.
- 6:59Alright, so let's talk about like, if we're, if someone's out there and they're
- 7:03thinking, do I need to change advisors?
- 7:05Am I okay with my same advisor?
- 7:07What should I be looking for for someone to help me in the
- 7:11decumulation phase of life?
- 7:13What are like, three, you know, two or three things that someone
- 7:17should look for in an advisor.
- 7:18Well, first, it depends where your money is.
- 7:20Now, we're assuming, since this is retirement, the money's in an
- 7:23IRA or a 401k or even a Roth IRA.
- 7:25Yeah.
- 7:25Where most retirement money is these days.
- 7:28But some people have it in regular taxable accounts, so that's different.
- 7:31If most of the money is in an IRA or 401k, 401k or even a Roth IRA, you need
- 7:37somebody that's educated on the tax rules, especially RMDs, beneficiary
- 7:42rules, tax planning, using the brackets, getting that money out, especially in a
- 7:46traditional IRA where generally all that is coming out taxable and it's forced out.
- 7:51You don't even get a choice after age 73, you're forced to take that money out.
- 7:56All right.
- 7:56So number one thing we're looking for is education.
- 7:59So a fair question to an advisor would be, How do you maintain your education?
- 8:03Yes.
- 8:04Changes going on in the, uh, you know, in the tax world.
- 8:07How do you stay on top of your game when it comes to managing the taxes
- 8:10that will apply to my account?
- 8:12Not only for me, maybe, but also for my heirs when I no longer.
- 8:15Well, it's a fair question to ask your advisor.
- 8:18And in fact, in some of my books, I have, uh, think 10 questions to
- 8:22ask your financial advisor, but they all revolve around the taxes today.
- 8:26Even the rollover rules, moving money.
- 8:29Uh, some people might just say that.
- 8:30didn't have the tax knowledge or financial, I might just say, Oh, roll
- 8:34it to an IRA and they miss a company stock tax break or something like that
- 8:38because they didn't know the nuances.
- 8:40I'm not going to get into it here of the NUA net unreal, uh, and
- 8:44net unrealized, appreciate it.
- 8:46Uh, net unrealized appreciation.
- 8:48I appreciate that you, uh, got that out.
- 8:52Uh, see, it's even hard to say.
- 8:54But you need to have an advisor that has education, and that, to me, that's
- 9:00critical because if a lot of that money is in a 401k, that may be rolled to an IRA.
- 9:06Mm-Hmm . Or you're leaving a job, you're about to retire yet, you
- 9:09now have distribution options.
- 9:11Do I leave it in the plan?
- 9:12Yep.
- 9:12Do I roll to an IRA?
- 9:14Do I take a lump sum distribution?
- 9:16Do I convert to a Roth IRA, that advisor?
- 9:19has to be educated on the pros and cons, benefits, drawbacks, whatever you want
- 9:23to call it, of each option and be able to explain it to you clearly because these
- 9:29rules are not only, and this is the tough part of all the tax rules revolving around
- 9:33IRA distributions, they're among the most complex in the tax law, but to make it
- 9:39worse, they're also the most obvious.
- 9:41Rigid and unforgiving.
- 9:43You don't get a lot of second chances.
- 9:45No.
- 9:45Very punitive Right.
- 9:47You have to have an advisor that gives you the right answer the first time.
- 9:51Alright.
- 9:52I think that's important.
- 9:53I also think no one can know everything, right?
- 9:55Right.
- 9:55So to me, another step in that is, when you don't know an answer, what do you do?
- 10:01Like, where do you turn to as an advisor?
- 10:03What are your resources?
- 10:05What are, like, what, what sort of, you know, I don't want to say back
- 10:08office, but effectively, like, what, when you don't know an answer, how do
- 10:13you go about figuring out that answer?
- 10:14Because no one knows that.
- 10:15Look, Ed, you and I spend our lives going through the tax code.
- 10:20And training advisors.
- 10:21And training advisors.
- 10:22And half the time when some, well, not half the time, but there are
- 10:24often times, it's not unusual for someone to ask a question.
- 10:27We go, you know what?
- 10:28That's a really good question.
- 10:29Right.
- 10:30Let me take a look at it.
- 10:31So, I think that's an important point too, is like, what are your resources
- 10:35when you don't know what to do?
- 10:36Well, you have to, you know, I always say you shouldn't invest with an
- 10:39advisor that doesn't invest in their education, especially in the tax area.
- 10:43You shouldn't invest with an advisor who doesn't invest in their education.
- 10:46What did I say?
- 10:46I just wanted to clarify.
- 10:48You should not invest your funds with an advisor that hasn't invested his or
- 10:53her own funds in their own education for tax planning, especially if most of your
- 10:59money is sitting in a taxable IRA tax deferred, but eventually taxable IRA.
- 11:05I agree.
- 11:06All right.
- 11:06So that's two.
- 11:07How about one more?
- 11:07What's one more thing that someone should look for in a decumulation advisor?
- 11:12Well, somebody that knows the whole picture, too, because your IRAs,
- 11:16you may not, you might not only have IRAs and Roth IRAs, and it
- 11:22may tie in other professionals.
- 11:24You may need to use more than one.
- 11:26It may, you may want to be interested now in estate planning.
- 11:29You know, as you head to retirement, you start looking beyond the horizon.
- 11:33So you might want to talk to an attorney and you may want
- 11:36people working together for you.
- 11:38So I still think the big item is going to be tax planning.
- 11:43But there's also you need somebody that understands where you're coming from.
- 11:48The relationship is important, but you still need somebody
- 11:51that's educated on the tax rules.
- 11:54I can't think of anything more important than that.
- 11:57Yeah.
- 11:57If the money is sitting in an IRA.
- 11:59Yep.
- 11:59Well, listen, even when it's not, we see lots of, you know, times where people
- 12:03will, you know, in a taxable brokerage account, they, uh, you know, will sell
- 12:07an investment at an inopportune time and either trigger more of a surtax or
- 12:10Alright, the tax planning outside the IRA.
- 12:12Sure.
- 12:13There's plenty of that to be done.
- 12:14Absolutely.
- 12:15I also think, I think there's one more that I might throw in there too, and
- 12:18that's What does continuity look like?
- 12:21You know?
- 12:21Oh, that's a good point.
- 12:22The advisor profession is enga, uh, rather, uh, aging.
- 12:25Aging.
- 12:26Thank you.
- 12:26That's the word I'm looking for.
- 12:27Yeah, that's a great point.
- 12:28That's a right.
- 12:29Uh, I know, uh, when I started out planning Mm-Hmm.
- 12:33for clients that were much older than me, I was in my thirties.
- 12:36They were in their sixties.
- 12:37Same.
- 12:38Yeah.
- 12:38They like that because I was younger and That's right.
- 12:41And they used to introduce me to their family.
- 12:42Mm-Hmm.
- 12:43Their beneficiaries and said, you'll be working with Ed and they would,
- 12:46you know, have bring in the, the.
- 12:47kids, kids are not a baby.
- 12:49I mean, they're 30, 40, 50 years old themselves, and they like that idea.
- 12:53I found most clients did not want to keep working with
- 12:55somebody the same age as them.
- 12:58That's right.
- 12:58Well, it, what's interesting is, uh, as you get older, you start to have
- 13:02that mindset of like, well, what's going to happen when I'm not here?
- 13:05I do too.
- 13:06The, uh, the, uh, most advisors, right, their, their clients are within
- 13:12about 10 years of their age, right?
- 13:13Okay.
- 13:13They're the primary.
- 13:14I don't know that for a fact, but you.
- 13:16Yes.
- 13:16Take my word for it.
- 13:17Okay.
- 13:17I'm not here to lie to you, Ed.
- 13:19So most advisors, right, they are either, they're, most of their clients are, you
- 13:22know, 10 years younger, 10 years older as you grow because it's your friends, right?
- 13:26It's your network.
- 13:26And it's people who you.
- 13:27Hang out with and so forth.
- 13:29So the, uh, that becomes effectively what your, uh, what your, your, your
- 13:35cumulative, what they call book of business, which I hate that term, but
- 13:38what your group of clients look like.
- 13:40Most of them are within about 10 years older or younger than you are.
- 13:43But if you think about that, that means when you're getting
- 13:46ready to retire, your advisor is probably not too far behind you.
- 13:50That's a, an excellent point.
- 13:51And you know, even if they live, right, they're, they may not be working.
- 13:54And what does that transition look like?
- 13:56So again, that doesn't mean that you shouldn't work with an advisor
- 13:59who's close to your age, but you need to understand what does their
- 14:03transition process look like?
- 14:04If they're not here, whether by choice or by accident, what is
- 14:08the continuity look like for you?
- 14:10Because the last thing you want is.
- 14:12To spend your life with an advisor, and then when you're 70, 75, 80, or
- 14:16even older, when you're not in the same position to go out there and vet
- 14:20new advisors, and you don't have the same mental faculties, and you don't
- 14:25want to spend all that time explaining every circumstance that you've had.
- 14:29What does the continuity look like for you as a client of that advisor?
- 14:33What is their plan when something, or if something happens to them?
- 14:36You know, I talked about the tax planning, which is key, but this may
- 14:39be even, well, on the same plane.
- 14:41I was going to say more important, because if you want that continuity, especially
- 14:46to your beneficiaries in the full estate plan, like I was talking about, Uh, your
- 14:51beneficiaries, You should have advisors.
- 14:54They still have to have the knowledge.
- 14:56That doesn't go away.
- 14:57The tax planning, the estate planning.
- 14:59But it's probably better off somebody around the same age as your, uh, children.
- 15:05And I, again, adult children, you know, 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s.
- 15:08So the 6 year old financial advisor is not going to be taking
- 15:12over the account that he takes.
- 15:13Yeah.
- 15:13Most times.
- 15:15Although, uh, some of them could be good stock pickers.
- 15:17We could have like a Doogie Howser MD, you know, we could have like
- 15:20Doogie Howser Financial Advisor.
- 15:22No, but I did the same thing.
- 15:23Over the years, I changed trustees on my trust to younger people, the, uh, the, uh,
- 15:28successor beneficiaries, things like that.
- 15:30Yeah, I think that's critical.
- 15:31And look, again, uh, It's not to be, um, ageist, right?
- 15:34You can have your 70 year old or 80 year old even financial
- 15:37advisor or CPA or attorney.
- 15:39You just need to know if something happens to them, what
- 15:42does the next thing look like?
- 15:44How well prepared are they for their eventual either forced
- 15:48or voluntary transition?
- 15:49And as they, I'm gonna follow your same lead there, not to be
- 15:53ageist or whatever the word is.
- 15:55That's the word.
- 15:56How careful are older advisors staying up to date with all the new rule changes?
- 16:03Right, it can be very easy as you get older to get complacent.
- 16:05Yeah, yeah, I say, ah, that's not that important.
- 16:08Well, it is, yeah.
- 16:09You don't want your advisor saying it.
- 16:11it's something to consider.
- 16:12It is.
- 16:13It's that important.
- 16:13Look, we have people in our advisor training programs, uh, that have been with
- 16:18us for over twenty years that are in their eighties and nineties sharp as a tack.
- 16:22It's you know some of them.
- 16:24I do.
- 16:24Yeah.
- 16:24They are, they are incredible people.
- 16:26And, and you want to make sure that you're working with an incredible advisor.
- 16:29So whatever, you know, what, however path you go down, you just want to
- 16:33make sure that when you reach that inflection point, that retirement
- 16:36point, That you're working with someone, again, I think as we've said to wrap
- 16:40it up, is someone who's knowledgeable.
- 16:42Someone who has access to the right resources.
- 16:45Someone who has the right, uh, succession plans for them.
- 16:48And someone who's going to continue to keep your best interest at
- 16:50heart, no matter what happens.
- 16:52I think I would add somebody who's, who's going to get along
- 16:56better with your beneficiaries.
- 16:58That's true too, yeah.
- 16:59Someone who not only can work well with you, but hopefully
- 17:01with your beneficiaries.
- 17:02Because as, as we know it, so many of those mistakes are made, uh, not when
- 17:07you're alive, But, in that moment after death, when that transition occurred,
- 17:12so many of those mistakes and so many of those irrevocable mistakes occurred.
- 17:15Oh, yeah.
- 17:15There's no question.
- 17:16If you remember when we were writing our training manuals, I had a section for,
- 17:21uh, what to do with, uh, the client, the people who have the IRAs, and then
- 17:25I would put another section in it.
- 17:27It's not good enough because the beneficiaries can mess it all up.
- 17:30Maybe they, they have their own advisor.
- 17:32Maybe it's one of their friends who once read a book about it or something.
- 17:36You know, that may not work.
- 17:37And these rules, we've had situations where beneficiaries, they didn't like.
- 17:41I remember one situation, we had a beneficiary.
- 17:43Uh, the guy had about a $600,000 IRA, very conservative, managed, built it
- 17:48up over many years, was not a wealthy person, but a little by little, $600,000..
- 17:53The beneficiaries took over and said, Ah, my dad was so conservative,
- 17:56we're taking it out, we're gonna invest in, in really hot stocks.
- 18:00They took it out.
- 18:01They had a tax on six hundred thousand.
- 18:03They blew the whole thing because they didn't know one key rule.
- 18:07A non spouse beneficiary cannot do a rollover.
- 18:09They took the money.
- 18:10That's it.
- 18:11Fatal error.
- 18:12The whole thing was taxable.
- 18:13So, uh, the beneficiaries can get themselves in trouble as well.
- 18:18No question about it.
- 18:19Well, Ed, I think we've reached our time here for today.
- 18:22Good discussion as always.
- 18:24Thanks for joining us.
- 18:25Thank you for joining us.
- 18:26And hopefully you've taken away something.
- 18:28Of value so that when you reach that magic point you can make the best
- 18:31decision for you and your family.
- 18:33That's right Jeffrey Levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham
- 18:37wealth partners This podcast is for informational and educational purposes
- 18:40only and should not be construed as specific investment accounting legal
- 18:43or tax advice Certain information mentioned may be based on third party
- 18:46information which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 18:50Third party information is deemed to be reliable but its accuracy and
- 18:53completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 18:55The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 18:58and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth Partners.