Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Disney Stock Magic vs Cold Hard_Math
Transcript
- 0:00Mickey Mouse, Iron Man, Luke Skywalker, just saying those
- 0:05names. It it does something right.
- 0:07It just triggers that little dopamine hit.
- 0:09It's nostalgia, it's excitement. It's that that Disney magic.
- 0:13It really is. We all have this, like, deeply
- 0:15emotional connection to the brand.
- 0:17Totally. But today, today we're going to
- 0:19do something that, well, it feels a little bit like
- 0:23betraying your inner child. We're going to stri away the
- 0:25magic, ignore the Ixie dust. Yeah.
- 0:27And look at the Walt Disney Company ticker.
- 0:30Not as fans, but as you know, cold hard Buffett style value
- 0:35investors. And that is the ultimate test of
- 0:37discipline because in the world of finance, falling in love with
- 0:40a product is, I mean, it's the fastest way to lose money,
- 0:43right? Investing is never about how
- 0:44much you love the product. It's strictly about how much the
- 0:47business loves you back. And by love I mean cash flow,
- 0:51dividends and return on equity. And as of today, February 2nd,
- 0:542026, that relationship is. It's complicated, Let's just
- 0:58call it that. Complicated is putting it
- 1:00mildly. I'm looking at the chart right
- 1:01now, and if this were a relationship status, it would
- 1:05definitely be. It's complicated.
- 1:07We're staring at a stock price hovering around, what, $112?
- 1:11Yeah, about there now. Sure, it's recovered from those
- 1:14scary lows of $80.00 back in 2025, but it is nowhere near the
- 1:18highs we saw a few years ago. Not even.
- 1:20Close. We have a massive stack of
- 1:22reports here, fundamentals, technicals, sentiment analysis.
- 1:25And the central tension in this deep dive is actually really
- 1:29fascinating. We're looking at what Warren
- 1:30Buffett would call a wonderful business.
- 1:33I mean the IP is just unrivaled. Oh, unrivaled on the planet.
- 1:38But it's currently operating with what our sources are
- 1:40calling mediocre economics. And that is the crux of the
- 1:43issue. A wonderful business can be a
- 1:45terrible investment if you pay the wrong price for.
- 1:48It So that's the mission today. That's our mission.
- 1:50We need to apply that strict value investing framework and
- 1:53answer one question. Does that $112 price tag
- 1:57represent a golden opportunity, or is it a valuation trap that's
- 2:02just going to keep your money stuck in neutral?
- 2:04OK, let's unpack this. Because if you just scan the
- 2:06headlines or maybe you scroll through social media, things
- 2:09feel like they're finally turning a corner.
- 2:11The famous Disney flywheel seems to be spinning again.
- 2:15So before we get into the ugly math, why shouldn't I be bullish
- 2:19right now? The vibes seem good.
- 2:21The vibes are good and the flywheel is spinning.
- 2:23You aren't wrong. But to understand why the math
- 2:26disagrees with the vibe, we have to look at the landscape we're
- 2:29sitting in right now. It's February 2026, and the
- 2:33macro environment has actually been surprisingly kind to
- 2:36Disney. The soft landing we.
- 2:37Got the soft landing finally. the Fed has rates sitting at
- 2:41roughly 3.5% to 3.75%. Inflation's cooled down to 2.3%.
- 2:47Which means people actually have disposable income for a
- 2:49vacation. Exactly when the misery index is
- 2:52down, people book flights to Orlando, but it's also the
- 2:55broader market, you know, if you look at the total market
- 2:57temperature. And by the way, for anyone
- 2:59listening who likes to track this, I highly recommend
- 3:01checking out the Buffett app on iOS.
- 3:04It's great for seeing if the market's overheated.
- 3:06Disney is benefiting from a general lift in consumer
- 3:09confidence. Right.
- 3:10And that brings us back to the flywheel.
- 3:12For those listening who might not obsess over corporate
- 3:14strategy, this is the core of Disney's business model, the
- 3:17whole thing. It's the idea that a hit movie,
- 3:20say the new Avatar Three, drives people to the parks.
- 3:23Then they buy the merch, then they go home and subscribe to
- 3:26Disney Plus to watch the spin off.
- 3:28It's a virtuous cycle. And it seems like that flywheel
- 3:31is finally. The data absolutely supports
- 3:35that the most critical piece of that puzzle was streaming or
- 3:38direct to consumer DTC. The cash incinerator.
- 3:41For a long time, that's exactly what it was, losing billions.
- 3:44But look at the Q1 numbers we have here.
- 3:47Operating income for DTC is $450 million.
- 3:50It's finally profitable. Wow.
- 3:52That is a huge swing from the billion dollar loss as we were
- 3:55seeing just a couple years ago. That feels like a mission
- 3:57accomplished moment. It is a massive swing and look
- 4:00at the churn, the number of people canceling, it's dropping
- 4:02and that's because of the bundle.
- 4:04Hulu, Disney Plus, ESPN. All tied together, it makes it
- 4:09much harder for someone to just hit cancel because they lose
- 4:13their sports and their shows too.
- 4:15And because of that, plus the parks doing their heavy lifting,
- 4:18free cash flow has essentially doubled.
- 4:20We're looking at an estimated $10 billion for 2026, up from
- 4:24about $4.9 billion back in 2023. OK.
- 4:28So I'm going to push back here. I'm playing the optimistic
- 4:31investor. Go for it.
- 4:33The flywheel is fixed. Streaming is making real money.
- 4:36Cash flow has doubled. The economy is OK.
- 4:39This sounds like a screaming buy.
- 4:40Why are we even hesitating? Why isn't the verdict buy with
- 4:43both hands? And this brings us to the value
- 4:45investors lens. This is where it gets really
- 4:47interesting and honestly a little painful if you're a bull.
- 4:50You asked why we aren't buying. The answer comes down to 3
- 4:53letters, Roe. Return on equity.
- 4:55Return on equity. This is, I mean, this is
- 4:57arguably Warren Buffett's favorite metric.
- 4:59He explicitly looks for companies that earn high returns
- 5:02on the money shareholders have put into the business.
- 5:04His target is usually above 15%. So for every dollar I give you,
- 5:08you're making $0.15 a profit. That's the benchmark for a
- 5:11wonderful business. And where is the House of Mouse
- 5:13sitting today? 6.1%.
- 5:16That is wow, that's remarkably low.
- 5:20Less than half of what Buffett wants.
- 5:21It's anemic. Now to be fair, depending on how
- 5:24you adjust things, some analysts might give them credit for 8.4%.
- 5:28But our deep Value report, which strips out all the noise, pins
- 5:32it at 6.1%. That's just mediocre.
- 5:34But I don't get it. We just said they're making
- 5:36profit, streaming is up, parks are full.
- 5:38Why is the return on equity so low if the cash flow is so high?
- 5:42Explain the math to me like I'm 5.
- 5:44It's the denominator problem. Return on equity is net income
- 5:48divided by shareholder equity. OK.
- 5:50To understand why the equity number is so huge, you have to
- 5:53look at the hangover from that 21st Century Fox acquisition.
- 5:56The $71 billion deal, The Simpsons avatar, all that.
- 6:00That's the one. That massive acquisition just
- 6:02bloated their balance sheet. They issued a ton of shares,
- 6:05diluting everyone and took on debt.
- 6:07So now the equity part of the equation is huge.
- 6:09To get a 15% return on that massive pile, they would need to
- 6:12be generating way more profit than they are right now.
- 6:15So Simply put, we gave them a giant pile of money to buy Fox,
- 6:18and right now, that money isn't working hard enough for us.
- 6:21Precisely. Growth is only virtuous if it
- 6:24returns value. Disney right now is like a very
- 6:27expensive sports car that gets 2 miles to the gallon.
- 6:30Sure it goes fast, but the fuel cost is eating all your
- 6:33winnings. And that leads us to what the
- 6:35report calls the Turn around trap.
- 6:38That sounds ominous. It is a formal term in value
- 6:41investing and the trap is thinking that just because the
- 6:44business operations are getting better, which they are, the
- 6:47stock price must go up. But the market is smart.
- 6:50It's already priced in at. $112, it's already priced in.
- 6:53Our report did a discounted cash flow analysis, basically trying
- 6:57to figure out what the future cash is worth.
- 6:59Today. And what's the number?
- 7:00What's a fair value? The optimistic scenario,
- 7:02assuming everything goes right, puts the fair value at around
- 7:06$124.00, so. If I buy at $112, I'm looking at
- 7:10what, 10% upside? Maybe 12?
- 7:12Roughly. Now compare that to the downside
- 7:14the SAFE analyst in our report, The Pessimist values the company
- 7:17at roughly 85 dollars. Which is a potential 24% loss.
- 7:21I see the risk reward is just skewed the wrong way.
- 7:24You're risking a 24% drop to make a 10% gain.
- 7:27That's a bad bet. It's a bad bet and catch this.
- 7:29That is not a margin of safety. That is a margin of error.
- 7:32As a value investor, you want to buy a dollar for $0.50.
- 7:36Buying Disney at $112 is like buying a dollar for $0.90.
- 7:40Sure, you make a dime, but if anything breaks, you're
- 7:44underwater immediately. And Speaking of things breaking
- 7:47or at least costing money, let's talk about the cost of keeping
- 7:50this machine running, the capital intensity.
- 7:53I was reading about the park expansions, $60 billion
- 7:56committed over 10 years. That sounds exciting.
- 7:58It is exciting for the guest. It is terrifying for the
- 8:00accountant. Why isn't investing in the
- 8:03business a good thing? It depends on the return.
- 8:06And what's fascinating here is that in the modern media
- 8:08landscape, these massive spends $60 billion on parks, $24
- 8:12billion a year on content. They're becoming what we call
- 8:16maintenance costs. So not for gross, just to stay
- 8:18relevant. Exactly.
- 8:19They have to spend $24 billion on content just to keep up with
- 8:22Netflix and Amazon. If they cut that churn goes up.
- 8:24If they cut park spending, people go to Universal.
- 8:27They're running on a treadmill. A very, very expensive treadmill
- 8:29just to stay in the same place. That's what we mean by mediocre
- 8:33economics. Well, you mentioned Universal.
- 8:34We have to talk about the elephant, or I guess the dragon
- 8:37in the room. Universal's Epic Universe opened
- 8:40in 2025. The epic threat, yeah.
- 8:43I mean, the reviews look incredible.
- 8:45Nintendo Harry Potter Is this a Disney killer?
- 8:48The analysts are split. There's a contrarian view, the
- 8:51rising tide theory, that says it just brings more people to
- 8:54Orlando in general. The whole market gets bigger.
- 8:56OK. So family stay longer, do both
- 8:59parks. That's the optimistic view.
- 9:01What's the risk? The risk is market share.
- 9:03If a family has five days and a limited budget, and Universal
- 9:06Law takes two of those days instead of one, that money comes
- 9:09directly out of Mickey's pocket. If epic, dense Disney's
- 9:13attendance by even 5%, just 5%, our models show the stock could
- 9:17reprice down to that $80 level. Wow.
- 9:20That's how sensitive the park margins are to volume.
- 9:22It's a fragile ecosystem. And Speaking of ecosystems,
- 9:25let's talk about the Digital 1, a partnership with Epic Games
- 9:28Fortnite. Disney put a $1.5 billion stake
- 9:31in them. The Disney Digital World.
- 9:33Yes, this is their metaverse play.
- 9:35For me, this feels like the future.
- 9:37This is the next generation theme park for Genelpha kids who
- 9:40don't watch cable TV. Strategically, I don't disagree.
- 9:44It's smart, but as a value investor, I have to look at the
- 9:47financials today. Right now, that is a capital
- 9:50expenditure. It's money going out the door.
- 9:52It's. Not a cash generator yet.
- 9:54Not yet. And the mistake investors make
- 9:56is paying tech multiples like APE of 30 or 40 for a legacy
- 10:00media company because they hope it becomes a tech company.
- 10:03You need to see the receipts first.
- 10:04We need to see the receipts, show me the money, always.
- 10:06There is one more giant cloud hanging over this stock, and
- 10:10it's a person, Bob Iger. The succession anxiety.
- 10:14He's 74. He came back to save the ship,
- 10:16but he's leaving supposedly in 2026.
- 10:19That's this year and we still don't have a name successor.
- 10:22And that creates what the report calls a governance discount.
- 10:25The market hates uncertainty more than it hates bad news.
- 10:29When you buy Disney right now, you're buying a ship without
- 10:31knowing who the captain will be in six months.
- 10:33And the social sentiment backs this up.
- 10:36The sentiment around leadership is described as anxious
- 10:39negative. It's a vacuum and you just don't
- 10:42buy into a governance vacuum. Not at $112 a share.
- 10:45So bring this all together, beloved brand.
- 10:48Cash flow is doubling, but the efficiency, the Roe is low, the
- 10:52price is in a bargain and the CEO is leaving.
- 10:55I think I know where you're going with this.
- 10:57The verdict is holdy. Hold that feels anticlimactic.
- 11:00It's the most boring yet most disciplined decision.
- 11:03If you own the stock, do not sell it right.
- 11:06It is a wonderful business. The flywheel is working.
- 11:09Selling now would be foolish because the fundamental recovery
- 11:12is actually happening. Oh, don't buy new shares.
- 11:14Do you not buy? There is no margin of safety.
- 11:16If you buy at $112, you are betting on perfection.
- 11:20You're betting the successor is great.
- 11:21Epic Universe doesn't hurt them. The ad market stays strong.
- 11:25It's just too many ifs. OK, so for the listeners who are
- 11:28holding or watching from the sidelines, what are we looking
- 11:30for? What's the dashboard?
- 11:31OK. Zero to 6 month road map metric.
- 11:34Number one, watch the DTC margins, the streaming profit
- 11:37margins they need to stay above 10%.
- 11:39Got it. Stay above 10%.
- 11:41If they dip back down because they spent too much on a Star
- 11:44Wars show, that's a bad sign. Metric #2 Roe We need to see
- 11:49that return on equity move from 6.1% toward 10% within two
- 11:53quarters. So we need proof the business is
- 11:55getting more efficient, not just bigger.
- 11:57Exactly. If the stock price stays high
- 11:59but the Roe stays low, the stock is running on hype, not
- 12:03fundamentals. Now let's get actionable.
- 12:05We love specific numbers here. If the market takes a dive,
- 12:09where do we swoop in? What's the backup?
- 12:10The truck price. The aggressive buy target is $85
- 12:14to 88. Does this 80. 5 to 80. 8 That's
- 12:16the sweet spot. At $85, you're getting that
- 12:19margin of safety back. It's a 25% to 30% discount.
- 12:22You're basically buying the theme parks and getting the
- 12:24entire streaming business for free.
- 12:26I like the sound of that. That's when you swing the bat.
- 12:29And on the flip side, what if the market gets euphoric and the
- 12:32stock bumps? When do we sell?
- 12:34The sell or I should say the trim target is 138 dollars
- 12:38$145.00. And why?
- 12:40Because if the price hits $138 without the Roe improving to
- 12:44match it, Mr. Market is being euphoric.
- 12:47He's paying you for growth that hasn't happened yet.
- 12:49So you take some chips off the table.
- 12:50Trim 25% of the position, lock in the wind.
- 12:53Don't get greedy, it's about discipline.
- 12:55You know, it's funny, we started this by talking about magic, but
- 12:58what you've laid out is just incredibly mechanical.
- 13:02It's efficiency, margins, capital.
- 13:05It takes the Pixie dust out of. It Well, that's exactly what
- 13:07Disney needs right now. For a decade they ran on Pixie
- 13:10dust growth. At all costs, just get
- 13:13subscribers. By Fox.
- 13:14Right now they need to run on math.
- 13:17They are graduating from a turn around story to what we call a
- 13:20stalwart. A stalwart.
- 13:22A big, sturdy ship. But to be a stalwart that
- 13:24Buffett would love, they need to prove that every dollar they
- 13:27spend on a ride or a movie brings back more than a dollar
- 13:30in value. They have to focus on being the
- 13:32most efficient, not just the biggest.
- 13:35So what does this all mean? It means we love the movies.
- 13:38We love the parks. But we don't love the stock
- 13:40price yet. Yet I like that.
- 13:43Before we wrap up, I want to leave the listeners with a final
- 13:46provocative thought from the report.
- 13:48It's about governance. Yes, this is a challenge for
- 13:51anyone who holds shares and gets to vote.
- 13:53The report suggests voting against executive compensation
- 13:56packages that exclude ROIC return on invested capital.
- 14:01That's a bold move. Most people just ought to
- 14:02approve those. It is, but if we want management
- 14:05to act like owners, we need to pay them for efficiency, not
- 14:09just for making the stock price go up temporarily.
- 14:12If they want the big bucks, they need to and show they're using
- 14:14our capital wisely. Make them earn the ROIC, it
- 14:17aligns the incentive. It's the only way to align their
- 14:20wallet with yours. Well, there you have it, the
- 14:22magic is back, but the math is still catching up.
- 14:25If you want to dive deeper into the charts, the models, or join
- 14:29our Deep Value Club for more content, check out Deep Values
- 14:32dot AI or the links in the description.
- 14:34And as always, remember we're just two voices.
- 14:37Do your own due diligence. Read the 10K's, check the
- 14:39numbers yourself. Absolutely.
- 14:41Thanks for unpacking this with us.
- 14:43We'll see you on the next deep dive.
- 14:44Take care.