Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 8 - House Raid)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. This is chapter eight in our Deep Dive on the
- 0:04Psychology of Josh Powell. Emberto isn't here today because when I looked at my
- 0:11notes, it's basically me just yammering, and I didn't want to bore him,
- 0:17so I thought I would just complete the rest of the chapters because I
- 0:24think maybe there'll be two more chapters without him, so that I just don't
- 0:29have to ask him to come over to my house and sit in the chair
- 0:32over there and just watch me yammer. Okay. So to recap where we're
- 0:39at, we're in early twenty ten, just after Josh killed Susan in December
- 0:47two thousand and nine, the previous month, and the disappearance of Susan becomes
- 0:53a huge news story, and there are there's just tons of circumstantial evidence right
- 1:00from the beginning, and it just builds and builds throughout December and then into
- 1:04January of twenty ten. Josh's story doesn't make any sense. He's saying that
- 1:11he went camping at midnight in a blizzard with his two sons, aged four
- 1:18and one, and coincidentally, that's the night that Susan disappeared and Josh the
- 1:26whole time has her wallet and her purse and her cell phone and everything else
- 1:30that she owns. And also randomly, Josh decided to use the rug doctor
- 1:38to clean the couch thoroughly before he left for camping. Also, Susan wrote
- 1:46a secret note saying that if she dies and it looks like an accident,
- 1:49then it's not an accident. And she puts that note in a safe deposit
- 1:53box and explicitly and explicitly states that Josh cannot have access to it. Dos
- 2:00of other details, all indicating that Josh killed Susan seemingly, but there's no
- 2:06body, there's no obvious motive. You have the life insurance, but it's
- 2:13not necessarily a slam dunk. And most murder cases, if you actually talk
- 2:17to prosecutors and investigators, they will tell you that usually you don't have to
- 2:24look very far to find extremely strong evidence of guilt. So the fact that
- 2:32we're looking at this and seeing just an obvious case, especially twenty twenty after
- 2:39Josh kills his children, it's harder when you're actually on the ground level.
- 2:46But the police are still looking into it. They're convinced that Josh killed Steven
- 2:53pretty early on, if not immediately, And from the looks of it,
- 3:00it looks like because the police are blamed a lot for not having done enough.
- 3:04From what I can tell in all of the sources that I looked into,
- 3:07the police I think may have done a lot, but I can't really
- 3:12tell because the only way we have of knowing what the police did is to
- 3:16talk to the police. So take that for what it's worth. But the
- 3:21prosecutor who is apparently in charge of charging someone like Josh was saying that they
- 3:30can't charge him yet because they don't have enough information, they don't have enough
- 3:34evidence. The primary police officer investigating the case of Susan Powell, he has
- 3:39said repeatedly to the press that the prosecutor kept pushing back even though he kept
- 3:46begging the prosecutor to charge Josh, because if they don't charge him, then
- 3:53Josh is free to live in the world and thus clean up all of the
- 4:00evidence, which it looks like he did. And what the main police officer
- 4:03said was that there needed to be twelve months with a missing person's case,
- 4:11meaning that because there's no body then it's considered a missing person's case, and
- 4:17you need twelve months before you can even begin to charge. It just sounds
- 4:23I don't I mean, I don't know, but that sounds ridiculous. And
- 4:28my best guess, based on almost no information, is that the prosecutor's office
- 4:33was way too paranoid about falsely charging somebody, even though they can't really get
- 4:40sued for such a thing. There's a lot of immunity, so to speak,
- 4:44that the prosecutors have so that they have the freedom to make tough decisions
- 4:49like that. So I don't really understand why the prosecutor was so resistant to
- 4:57that. And the prosecutor is never come forward to the press, whereas the
- 5:02police have been in interviews talking about their story. So I don't know.
- 5:08But maybe the prosecutor knows that they screwed up, but they continue to screw
- 5:13up even though because immediately the press and the public and the family were telling
- 5:20the police and the prosecutor to please do something. And so it just seems
- 5:25like one of those cases where the prosecutor, I mean often in these high
- 5:29highly publicized cases, the prosecutors want a grandstand right and be the hero.
- 5:36So I don't know, it's just and maybe there's a legal reason, a
- 5:42viable but I can't see it. So was the prosecutor just too paranoid about
- 5:48being accused of being too flippant about charging someone, or maybe the prosecutor's wife
- 5:59ran off with some other man, and since susan might have run off with
- 6:03another man, the prosecutor's like this just another case of another woman just grasping
- 6:11at straws. So in the days after Susan's disappearance in the month, Josh
- 6:17is seen doing things seemingly to cover up the evidence. He's deep cleaning the
- 6:24house, even though by all accounts he was one of the laziest people on
- 6:29the planet, especially when it came to chores like that. He is seen
- 6:33and there's all sorts of evidence of him driving all over the region, including
- 6:39renting a car and driving eight hundred miles, but the police don't really follow
- 6:44him closely. And there's a lot of details to this, and I won't
- 6:47bore you with all those details. But the police either couldn't get access to
- 6:54follow him closely, or they seemingly drop the ball. I don't know.
- 6:59So Josh at this point probably thinks that he's going to get away with Susan's
- 7:04murder, but he is not going to get the insurance money, which many
- 7:11would speculate, including myself, that that was a major reason why he killed
- 7:16Susan in the first place, but body was never found. There can be
- 7:21no proof of death because Susan might have run off. Then the life insurance
- 7:29doesn't pay up, right, So either Josh wasn't killing Susan for the life
- 7:35insurance money, or, as I laid out in my long description of my
- 7:42theory of what exactly happened the night of Susan's disappearance, I think that Josh
- 7:50panicked for some reason. Either he screwed something up, or there was a
- 7:55new a development, a wrench in the gears of his in new system,
- 8:01or something happened that made him improvise his plan, because it would make sense,
- 8:07given everything that was leading up to Susan's disappearance, that he was really
- 8:13intending on getting that life insurance money. So he's at this point he's thinking
- 8:18it, maybe I'm going to get away with this. The whole world basically
- 8:22thinks he did it, and he knows this because people are telling him so.
- 8:26But he's not going to get the insurance money, and Susan's income is
- 8:31now no longer available, so he's going to have to pay his own bills,
- 8:35and he's obsessed with money in a way that is problematic, you know,
- 8:41would force Susan to keep receipts and justify the smallest of purchases. He
- 8:48made the family live off of some gross, very cheap food like top ramen
- 8:54every night for dinner, even though he was also willing to pay one hundred
- 8:58dollars per month for a life at church policy sit Anyway, so Josh and
- 9:03the boys move from Utah to Washington State to pull up near Seattle to live
- 9:13with Steven again. And people at the time were appalled that Josh was leaving
- 9:18town because Susan is still missing. You'd think you'd want to stay around,
- 9:22and it was just more evidence to everyone that Josh was guilty. And I
- 9:28don't know why Josh decided to move. He was very cheap, very frugal,
- 9:33So maybe he just didn't want to pay rent anymore, or didn't want
- 9:37to pay the mortgage anymore. I don't know. Maybe he wanted to be
- 9:43near someone that at least kind of supported him, because Stephen would support him
- 9:48and stick up for him in public anyway, And I'm guessing Josh didn't have
- 9:54anyone else like that in his life, so that's a possible reason. So
- 9:58the new story he continues to grow and grow as more details start to come
- 10:03out. There's a lot to pour over, as you can tell by the
- 10:07steep dive, and Stephen and Josh I think both struggled emotionally with this public
- 10:16scrutiny. In public criticizing, Josh and Stephen started to talk to the press,
- 10:24even though most people would tell Josh and Steven, including Michael, the
- 10:31other Josh's brother, Michael, who was close to Josh. Michael seemed like
- 10:35the only smart one in the well aside from Jennifer. But Michael seemed like
- 10:39another smart person, and he would tell his dad and his older brother,
- 10:43stop talking to the press. You're not helping your no one is believing you
- 10:48anyway, and you're not good representatives of your case. Josh is Josh and
- 10:56Steven is Steven't y'all just got a shut up and let it blow over.
- 11:01Yet Josh and Steven just keep talking to the press. Steven particularly seems to
- 11:07like talking to the press, I think because of his narcissism. So let's
- 11:11watch a clip of Stephen talking to the press the answer, it would be
- 11:16a Josh's vindication that we would move on. They had Susan, they maybe
- 11:22had Stephen Kosher, of whom we think she's with. You think so he
- 11:26just this is Stephen, by the way, Josh's father, And he just
- 11:31mentioned Stephen Kosher, who I talked about in the last chapter because they believed
- 11:37and some others did too. Other internet sleuth's thought that, and I think
- 11:41the police looked into it briefly. There was another person that disappeared from the
- 11:48same small town around the same time. I think it was a week later
- 11:52after Susan disappeared, or or a month later, maybe a week and there
- 11:56were mysterious circumstances around this Stephen Kosher disappearing, But there was no evidence that
- 12:05Susan and Stephen Kosher were connected, and even if they were, there was
- 12:09no evidence that they were having an unfair or it was just nothing that pointed
- 12:15in that direction. But you hear Stephen Powell dropping that in to try to
- 12:22convince everybody that Josh is innocent. Who I still believe that it's a possibility.
- 12:28So we thought that would be the end of it. We thought they
- 12:31had them down there, and they were just going down to pick them up.
- 12:35They had maybe they had to get an extradition or order of some kind.
- 12:37And so what he's talking about there, I believe is a Mexico extradition.
- 12:45I don't know the country exactly, but they thought and I think the
- 12:48police legitimately looked into it just to uncover all possibilities that they might have fled
- 12:56the country. And so Stephen's talking about thinking that there was a there was
- 13:01going to be an extradition in that everyone would be found from Nevada and then
- 13:07they you know, Friday morning, they'd have a big announcement for us and
- 13:11we'd all move on and live happily. Ever after it just didn't happen.
- 13:13We're really disappointed. So you're belief that she's alive, she's oh, yeah,
- 13:18we believe that. So when Stephen says he's really disappointed, he's not
- 13:22saying I'm really disappointed that Susan wasn't found. No, what he's saying is,
- 13:30I'm really disappointed that the police didn't do their job by finding Susan and
- 13:35Stephen Kosher and extraly, you know, that's what he's saying. We believe
- 13:39she's alive and we believe she left with somebody. We're not sure if she's
- 13:43still with that somebody, but I don't know. She probably is. So
- 13:48they keep saying this and there's no evidence. They never give any evidence of
- 13:54Susan running away or who she might have run away from, or where she
- 14:00went. There's just no indication of that. So for the rest of twenty
- 14:03ten, a lot happens, but I'm just going to highlight some of the
- 14:07most important details. So the family moved to Washington State, and Charlie and
- 14:13Brayden are now in Puyallup near Seattle, and Charlie is going to a new
- 14:20school. He is I don't know if he's in kindergarten or if he's in
- 14:26preschool. He would have been four, maybe five by this point, and
- 14:31at school he is observed by the teachers and the administrators as having a lot
- 14:39of behavior problems. For example, Charlie told a group of kids that the
- 14:46Mormons killed his brother and his mom, which is interesting. Charlie also told
- 14:52a little boy at school that he was going to come to the boy's house
- 14:58at night and kill him because he hated Mormons. You know, Charlie saying
- 15:03I hate Mormons. I'm gonna come to your house and kill you. Charlie
- 15:07also said that he hated Jews, and he also said that he hated Christians.
- 15:11So all of this sounds a lot like Stephen and Josh. Both of
- 15:18them, maybe particularly Stephen said all these things and much much more, And
- 15:26you just got a figure that Charlie was getting it from them, either by
- 15:31just listening to them with you know, overhearing them talking, or by Steven
- 15:37and Josh brainwashing the kids, because there's evidence of both. And there's a
- 15:43secret recording of the household Stephen Powell's household within which Josh, Charlie, and
- 15:50Braden lived, but also two of Josh's siblings, Alena and John, also
- 15:58lived there, and there's a recording, and on this recording are a lot
- 16:02of things, but one of the things is that you hear Steven and Josh
- 16:06saying all number of things along these lines, and you can also hear little
- 16:11Charlie and little Braiden are in the room as well, so we have proof
- 16:18that they didn't edit themselves around the boys. So of course you have to
- 16:22wonder what Charlie and Braden were going through, having suddenly lost their mother and
- 16:30at least for Charlie, the thought is out there that she might be dead
- 16:34and that maybe his own father killed her. I don't know how much Charlie
- 16:38knew, but you just got to figure Charlie and Braden were going through a
- 16:44lot. And also Charlie and Braden had behavior problems in all likelihood because of
- 16:51Josh's extremely bad parenting, which I've already been over. So because of these
- 16:56behaviors, the school would often call Child Protective Services CPS or dshs, And
- 17:04that makes sense. But I also think that since everyone assumed that Josh killed
- 17:11Susan, I think there was a lot of vigilanteism happening, for better or
- 17:17for worse. I of course can't know that, but I imagine that,
- 17:22you know, just imagine you're a teacher or an administrator in a school,
- 17:25in the school and in the middle of this case, all of a sudden,
- 17:30the two boys are in your care, or at least one of them,
- 17:33and you start witnessing some weird stuff. You might even pay closer attention
- 17:40to what he's saying. And there were other reports like that to the teachers
- 17:44or the administrators would overhear Charlie saying something that seemed to indicate maybe that's a
- 17:48hints as to where Susan's body is or something. You know, there's a
- 17:51lot of that going on. And also you got to wonder if Charlie noticed
- 17:55that happening and that was kind of messing it up. I don't know,
- 17:59but the government DSHS, CHOP Predictive Services, they investigate because of the reports,
- 18:06and also I'm guessing because of the hypervigilance about this case and DSHS they
- 18:12visited the house a number of times and these visits are documented, and among
- 18:18those documents they mention observations about John, who is Josh's younger brother, another
- 18:26one of Stevens's children living with him, and they write in the document that
- 18:33John, this man, he was probably in his late twenties at this point.
- 18:38He was witnessed by the DSHS worker as walking around the house nude.
- 18:48On another occasion, he was walking around the house in a diaper. Now,
- 18:53I'm not going to yuck anyone's yum. I don't think anybody should,
- 18:57but let me go on. In his room, John had a hangman's noose
- 19:04just hanging there, and he had a giant poster of a woman with a
- 19:10sword in her genitalsing protruding out of her stomach. So, you know,
- 19:18I sorry to imagine that, but I don't need it. I don't need
- 19:21to imagine it. I was trying to figure out the geometry of that.
- 19:25But anyway, so they document this as it's relevant because the boys are living
- 19:33in this house and they're wondering are these boys, Charlie and Braden safe in
- 19:40this house? Right? And then you see this and you know the implications
- 19:44about anyway, Yeah, this raises a question about are there more crimes in
- 19:51this family? Are there more fantastical angles to the story that we just never
- 19:56found out? I mean, what's the chance that we all of the bizarre
- 20:02things in this family. It's possible that there's a whole other chapter that we'll
- 20:07never find out. Regarding John, I don't know. And also, you
- 20:12know, John was abused severely by Steven and exposed to pornography early in his
- 20:17life, so you know, Sky's limit in terms of what's going on with
- 20:19him. The other thing is this raises a major question as to why the
- 20:26family didn't take that stuff down or tell John to put on clothes when the
- 20:33government arrives at the house. Were they surprise visits or is it just bad
- 20:40judgment or did John resist you know, the family like, hey, put
- 20:45on some clothes or at least take off the diaper and John said no,
- 20:49I don't know. But honestly, this is consistent with other aspects of the
- 20:55case. There's just so many bad choices made by these individuals, which I'll
- 21:00get into some more in a bit around Stephen. So the third thing about
- 21:06this case is why didn't the government take Charlie and Braden out of the house
- 21:11at that point? All these reports, all the CPS reports, John walking
- 21:17around in a diaper with a sword, poster data da. Well, the
- 21:21fact is is that there's a very high threshold for a child to be taken
- 21:26away from their parents by the government, which makes sense, right, And
- 21:30believe me, I've seen way way worse cases than this. Now, this
- 21:37eventually becomes a horrific case, but at this point they don't have any evidence.
- 21:44They don't have enough evidence to take the kids away from Josh unfortunately.
- 21:48All right, so that brings us to the end of twenty ten, and
- 21:52let's take a break, all right, back from the break, so that
- 21:59brings us up to twenty eleven. A lot happens this year. But one
- 22:03of the notable things worth mentioning is that Josh agrees to sit down with ABC
- 22:10News and have a long form interview. Let's watch a clip searching these abandoned
- 22:17minds in the Nevada Desert for clues. Well, Josh and his father,
- 22:21Stephen Powell have been making parts of Susan's old journal's public claiming it provides possible
- 22:26reasons for her disappearance. What do those journals tell you about Susan's life growing
- 22:32up? Susan was very emotionally abused, right, So I forgot to mention
- 22:40that that one of the elements of their narrative trying to vindicate, trying to
- 22:45make Josh look innocent, is by claiming that Susan's parents were abusive. And
- 22:53I didn't see any direct reporting on this, I think because even if they're
- 23:00were indications in the journal indicating that Susan was abused by her parents, that
- 23:06the press didn't want to entertain this idea because they didn't want to support Josh's
- 23:14and Steven's claim. But also, you know, when it comes to Susan's
- 23:19disappearance and then the journals get read by the press, and by the police.
- 23:25We should use discretion around what we publish, right, So I don't
- 23:30know what was in the journals regarding this, but I would be surprised given
- 23:36the way that Susan was with Josh. I mean, she was young,
- 23:40but I've already been over some of the things that we know about her behavior
- 23:45and her mindset. It's possible that she was abused, but we don't know
- 23:49anyway. So Josh, that's what he's referring to here, and he and
- 23:55Stephen will claim up until this point and during this interview that they have all
- 24:00this data from the journals indicating this As a child, her mother has some
- 24:08very she has a very angry personality, her father is very manipulative. Josh
- 24:14Powell claims that at times Susan was unstable, had even contemplated suicide at different
- 24:19points in her life. She has Again that could be true. You look
- 24:26at the journal of anyone and there's a pretty good chance that something along those
- 24:33lines is going to be talked about. At the very least, emotional turmoil
- 24:37and angry feelings and hurt feelings. A lot of people will use their journal
- 24:41along those lines, and from their account, they're saying that she had threatened
- 24:45suicide. Who knows. There wasn't anything like that in the recent years according
- 24:52to reporting, So I'm guessing it was when she was a teenager, but
- 24:56I don't know. She has walked out the front door in her underwear,
- 25:03started walking down the street, and at the time when all this stuff was
- 25:08happening, it was mortifying to me. I've tried to protect her from doing
- 25:12things that I thought might embarrass her or our family. So in this sense,
- 25:18and I didn't hear any other reporting around this, but he in this
- 25:21interview is claiming that while married to Josh, she ran out the front door
- 25:27in our underwear, and then he's saying he tried to cover that up or
- 25:33protect her or something, And it's notable the way he words less. Let's
- 25:38let's review it again. The time when all this stuff was happening, it
- 25:41was mortifying to me. I've tried to protect her from doing things that I
- 25:47thought might embarrass her or our family. So now, would someone be embarrassed
- 25:53if their spouse ran out into the street their underwear, Yeah, depending on
- 25:57the situation, I suppose, But you would also think that the husband would
- 26:03primarily be concerned about the well being of his wife, how is she doing,
- 26:08how's she feeling? Why is she doing this? Also, you would
- 26:12think if you're Josh, that you would highlight that, you would say she
- 26:17was very troubled and I worried a lot about her, and I didn't want
- 26:22to talk about it, and I don't really even like mentioning it here whatever.
- 26:26But this is consistent. Although in this interview he presents much better than
- 26:33other interviews, I think because I'm guessing, and it would be normal for
- 26:37anyone in his shoes, even if they were innocent, to practice, to
- 26:41prepare in that respect. You know. Josh says he thinks Susan may still
- 26:47be alive and wonders if she left him and their two young children for another
- 26:52man, acclaim police will not substantiate. Has she ever been unfaithful to you?
- 26:57Never that I know of? And why do you think that she would
- 27:00just run off with another man? She is a very sexual person, Josh
- 27:03Powell's fuck. So it's kind of interesting that when asked directly, he says,
- 27:08no, I don't know if she ever had an affair. There's no
- 27:11evidence that she ever had an affair, because given everything else that he has
- 27:17said and done, you would think that he would say something like, yeah,
- 27:21she did have an affair, maybe more than one, and I don't
- 27:26want to talk about it, or I do believe she had an affair because
- 27:30of this this this, he just says no. So either this is evidence
- 27:36that he has a convoluted and confusing approach to making him look innocent, or
- 27:44he's smart enough to know that he has to only accuse her of things that
- 27:51he has some evidence of, or he wants to look like he's not entirely
- 27:56biased against her so he can gain I don't know, but it's notable.
- 28:02And I know. Then why do you think that she would just run off
- 28:03with another man? She is a very sexual person. And then that statement
- 28:08is also interesting because that was something that was said by both of them a
- 28:15number of times. She's a very sexual person. One, well, that
- 28:21means that she had an affair, and what are you basing that on?
- 28:26Think what he's basing it on is that she wanted to have sex with Josh
- 28:30because one of the main reasons was because she wanted to have more kids.
- 28:33I have already been over that. But I also think that she had sexual
- 28:37needs and I think that she remembered the way that they used to be in
- 28:41the beginning of their relationship, Josh and Susan, and she wanted to get
- 28:45back there sometimes and it's not unusual to think, well, if we can
- 28:48rekindle our physical intimacy, maybe we'll return back to that lovey times. So
- 28:55there's that. But Paul's father, Stephen Powell, then goes on to make
- 28:59the bazz our claim that he's had a sexual relationship with his daughter in law.
- 29:03So in this interview, if because I've seen all the footage and the
- 29:10interviews with the interviewer, you know, the woman that's interviewing him has also
- 29:15been interviewed, and what she would say is that during this interview with Josh,
- 29:21Steven is there just as a support person. And Stephen keeps interrupting,
- 29:26and then at some point Stephen says hey, hey, you know he takes
- 29:30over, and then you know, the interviewer is like, okay, Stephen,
- 29:34how about you just sit down, let's talk to you, and then
- 29:37he sits down. He's not prepared, he doesn't have a reason to be
- 29:41there. There's really nothing. I don't think anyone at this point thinks that
- 29:47Stephen is involved in the murder. I imagine most people at this point anyway,
- 29:53think that Steven is just being a supportive dad the way that people will
- 29:56be. So watch what happens. Cos was very very sexual with me,
- 30:04She was very flirtatious. I mean, I'm her father in law. We
- 30:11know the truth because we've been over all that data and I've seen a lot
- 30:15more even and maybe you have as well, that she was not sexual with
- 30:21him. He was criminally disgustingly, disturbingly sexual with her, which we've already
- 30:27been over So he's twisting that all around and he just drives, he thinks.
- 30:34So for people with narcisstic person I sort I can't diagnose him, but
- 30:41he has some signs. They want to be in the spotlight. They can't
- 30:45stand it if other people are in the spotlight when they have things to say.
- 30:48And I think that he might have a competition, a narcissistic competition with
- 30:53his own son that I think was a partial reason for him Stephen being infatuated
- 31:00with Josh's wife, because Steven was like, how can you get a nice
- 31:06girl like? I will I'll have that that's mine? You know that kind?
- 31:10And also he believe you know when you have narcisstic person I shorder.
- 31:17You're shut off. You shut yourself off from the outside world, largely because
- 31:22when you're very young, you had to do that in order to survive psychologically
- 31:26and emotionally, and so you don't allow input, which means that you have
- 31:33a hard time interpreting how other people would react. You know, when I
- 31:37was watching the Baby Reindeer stuff and then the Fiona stuff, and of course
- 31:41I have no idea about anything, but if the story and Baby Reindeer is
- 31:48somewhat accurate, and if Fiona is indeed the real Martha, then we are
- 31:55seeing perhaps another example of that where somebody, due to necessary adaptations as a
- 32:00young child, developed a defensive structure that involved what we would call narcisism.
- 32:07But as a part of that, they have to cut themselves off from other
- 32:09people and depend on the self, and they also have to pump themselves up
- 32:14because they're alone and they're scared and they feel worthless, and so they just
- 32:17have to invent that they're okay. But they have to go overboard because there's
- 32:22all these question marks. Am I okay? And the way to defend against
- 32:27that is to say I'm not only okay, I'm superior, and everything I
- 32:30think is superior, and everything is superior. Plus, children are all to
- 32:37some extent narcissistic. We want them to be self centered so that they can
- 32:42develop and take care of themselves. So when you're a child, it's normal.
- 32:47But because of the environment that these children go through who develop narcisstic perconise,
- 32:53or they never grow up, they're stuck in that mindset of the entire
- 33:00universe revolves around me, and so they don't know how to act in the
- 33:06world in a way that even serves what they want. Stephen doesn't want to
- 33:10be attacked by society. He doesn't want to be targeted by the police,
- 33:15which is about to happen. He wants to get attention, He wants to
- 33:21be seen, he wants to be seen as special. And this brief moment,
- 33:25and for these people, they are on a constant treadmill. Even if
- 33:30the previous day they were showered with accolades, the very next day it starts
- 33:37over again because they're on a constant treadmill running away from something that's on their
- 33:42back. The monkey on their back is the abyss of inferiority and nothingness that
- 33:50has always been with them. And they're just running running. They think they're
- 33:52getting away from it, but they're not. And so for him, he's
- 33:57sitting in the wings and the narcissistics supply isn't coming in that very moment.
- 34:00It might have been coming earlier, but it's not coming. Now. His
- 34:06rival is sitting right there, and there's a camera and all the lights,
- 34:10and I could do better than Josh, and he frankly could because Josh isn't
- 34:15great in these situations. So Steven is like, I'm better, and who
- 34:21knows, maybe even I wouldn't be surprised if there were people who actually would
- 34:24write him or DM him or talk to him and say that they support him.
- 34:30You know, when the news story is being watched by millions and millions
- 34:35and millions of people, even if it's point one percent, maybe he thinks,
- 34:39hey, got to get out to my fans or whatever. And then
- 34:43he pushes Josh aside, sits down. I got something to say. And
- 34:47then the first thing out of his mouth he thinks so consciously. I think
- 34:51what he thinks he's doing is that he is bolstering Josh's statement that Susan is
- 34:58a overly sexual person and therefore ran away with someone else, which is just
- 35:04such a sad say, Josh just makes this random statement she was a very
- 35:06sexual person. What where's your evidence for that? And even if she was,
- 35:13so what, even if she was having an affair, so what,
- 35:15it doesn't mean that she ran away with someone given all the evidence that points
- 35:20that you killed her and disposed of the body. But Stephen wants consciously to
- 35:27support his son, so he's like, well, I got a point here.
- 35:30I have a data point about Susan that supports what Josh is saying.
- 35:35Let me tell you, Susan was sexual with me. In fact, we
- 35:39had so watched thistual relationship with his daughter in law. Susan was very,
- 35:46very sexual with me. She was very flirtatious. I mean, I'm her
- 35:51father in law, and she would do a lot of things that I just
- 35:58love. The interviewers what's her name? I can't figure out what her name
- 36:04is, but I'm guessing y'all know. Anyway, let's continue watching she she
- 36:07would do a lot of things that that I mean, she was just she
- 36:12did it. I mean, just think and they've interviewed her and she talks
- 36:15about her internal reaction because she you know, probably for a couple of weeks
- 36:23she's been preparing for this exclusive interview with the Joshua Powell. So she's getting
- 36:30all her ducks in a row, the questions, you know, making sure
- 36:35her outfit is good and everything's going well. She got she got a good
- 36:39night's sleep, and she sits down and talking to Josh and it was probably
- 36:45a little frustrating because the way Josh talks it, it's it's so it just
- 36:51doesn't have a lot of substance to it. It's hard to grab on to
- 36:53anything. But she's getting stuff done and then Steven's like interrupting, which is
- 36:59probably annoying her at first, and then she's like, okay, find sid
- 37:01and then he drops this bomb that you know, bombshell as they say,
- 37:08And that's not hyperbole that Stephen and Susan had a sexual relationship. She's just
- 37:20what is happening? I did? I mean, we interacted in a lot
- 37:23of sexual ways because Susan enjoys doing that. Do you think a part of
- 37:30you started falling in love with Susan? That's pretty likely? Yeah, I
- 37:34mean, I yeah, I would say so. And so these are excerpts
- 37:37from a much longer interview. You can watch the whole interview on YouTube,
- 37:42I believe. But at this point, what is Stephen doing? What is
- 37:49the goal? Because at this point she's now going Okay, well let's lean
- 37:57into this Paula Axe, and there's questions and then she asks eventually do you
- 38:02think that you loved her? And he says, yeah, you know,
- 38:07I think that I did. No one in their right mind would even admit
- 38:13this given the landscape. And then two he's eventually he just starts being honest,
- 38:19which is very very interesting, I think, and I think it points
- 38:22to the narcissism that he's not a psychopath primarily who knows he's breaking the rules
- 38:30and just doesn't care about the rules. He knows that he's harming people,
- 38:34and he just doesn't care. I think he is like a little boy who
- 38:37is looking for mommy, because I'm assuming that Stephen went through some real terrible
- 38:45shit when he was young, and he likes the opportunity to talk about this
- 38:52relationship with Susan. And I'll go over later. I'm gonna devote an entire
- 38:59section talking about Steven's diagnosis, but so I'll save it for there. But
- 39:04anyway, let's continue watching, and there's no question in my mind that the
- 39:07feelings were mutual. Despite his father's claims, Josh is still holding on to
- 39:14hope. And then he says, you know, I'm feeling that it's mutual,
- 39:17which he words it the way that he did before. He's very consistent
- 39:22in his private journal, videos and written journal, in his statements to Susan,
- 39:28and in his public state. There's no difference. He doesn't hide anything,
- 39:34he just states it. He just is like, yep, this is
- 39:37in other arenas, like at work, in other places, he is operating
- 39:43and functioning normally. Why would he be so impaired cognitively and in terms of
- 39:50his reasoning and his judgment in this arena? And I think it has to
- 39:54do with how I've already kind of described it and how I'll get to it
- 39:59later. I think she's still alive At times it's a rollercoaster. What would
- 40:07you want to say to her? She's watching and I miss her, that
- 40:12she's that I love her. She's got two boys who love her. So
- 40:19after this interview, Josh and Stephen keep talking to the press. I'm assuming
- 40:25that Michael, Josh's brother, is continuing to tell them to stop talking to
- 40:31the press. Josh and Stephen are leaning into that narrative that essentially that Susan
- 40:38is a slut and therefore she ran away with somebody, and that they're being
- 40:44falsely accused by an incompetent police department. Now the police are investigating this whole
- 40:52time. They're watching the news too, and they hear what Stephen and Josh
- 40:57are saying, and they hear Josh and Evehn pointing at these journals that are
- 41:01in their house saying we have all this evidence. The police are watching this
- 41:06and they're thinking, this is our chance we can get our hands on those
- 41:10journals, because they are claiming that there's enough evidence in there to point in
- 41:17the direction as to where Susan is, and so therefore it justifies a raid
- 41:22on the house and a warrant for that information. I don't know exactly how
- 41:28the law works in this situation, but because Josh wasn't charged, Josh has
- 41:32certain rights regarding his property, and Susan's journals are his property now. So
- 41:38even if the police wanted it, they wouldn't necessarily have the justification to get
- 41:43it, because the prosecutor in Utah's refusing to play ball. So I think
- 41:47because they are saying we have information that would point in the direction as to
- 41:53where Susan is. They get the courts to agree, and I don't know
- 41:58if this was a Washington thing instead of a Utah thing, and maybe the
- 42:01prosecutor in Washington was willing to play ball. Anyway, the police get a
- 42:06warrant and they raid the house and they take everything, or lots of things.
- 42:10They take Susan's journals, of course, there's a lot of it,
- 42:14and they also take computers, and they look into file cabinets, and they
- 42:20just take boxes and boxes and stuff. And they also did so when they
- 42:27knew that Stephen wouldn't be at the home. There's a whole detail that anyway.
- 42:30So at this point, the police are raiding the house hoping to get
- 42:36the journals because they're wondering if there's something in there that would point to Josh
- 42:43as the killer. They're also hoping that they might be able to find something
- 42:46in there, something that Josh brought into the house from Utah that would point
- 42:52at Josh having killed Susan or would point as to the whereabouts of Susan.
- 42:57You know, maybe it's a little tool that has some blood on it or
- 43:00something, or a computer that has an email about a refuge, you know,
- 43:04that's what they're looking for, but instead they find this pile, this
- 43:12mountain of evidence of the crimes of Stephen Powell. And let's watch a clip
- 43:19from that raid. So this is a video on the YouTube channel called crime
- 43:23con and it's presented by Oxygen. There was pornography found laid out on Stephen
- 43:30Powell's bed, and most shockingly was this cachet of images of Susan Powell,
- 43:38but not just Susan Powell, but all kinds of women. So just think
- 43:43about that. This is a house with two young boys, Charlie and and
- 43:47Braden are maybe six and three at this point, and Stephen isn't home and
- 43:55on his bed is just not only just all this pornograph, but there's all
- 44:00these pictures of Susan and all these other women. Some of the pictures are
- 44:07regular pictures, you know, you can see just regular types of pictures you
- 44:13would take at an event. But then there are other pictures where it's clear
- 44:16that the subject was not aware that they were being photographed. Really just disgusting.
- 44:23So Stephen Powell had been going out in public and filming women, taping
- 44:28women without their consent without their knowledge, and he had this obvious obsession with
- 44:32Susan and other women as well. But as you can see, even from
- 44:36this image here that's blacked out, he was taking videos and images of Susan
- 44:39without her knowledge while she's changing, while she's using the bathroom. So just
- 44:45imagine that you're the police observing this, because of course we know that this
- 44:52was going on. I talked about this, and maybe you knew this from
- 44:54the news stories. They didn't know this. All they thought was that Stephen
- 44:59was a support of Dad. That's all that they knew. And then they
- 45:01hear on this interview and other press interviews that Stephen and Susan had this affairs.
- 45:09What was going on there? Because without any counter evidence, you wouldn't
- 45:15know if Steven's account was wrong or how wrong was it. Steven says they
- 45:20had this very sexual relationship. Now we know that it wasn't sexual except for
- 45:27him he was. You know, we've already been over that, but just
- 45:30imagine how that must have blown your minds, Like what am I seeing?
- 45:37The most troublesome part for me is there's suggestion that Josh Powell knew this was
- 45:42going on. Josh knew his father was doing this and simply allowed it to
- 45:46go forward. So not only was Josh abusing his wife emotionally, physically,
- 45:52financially, but so was his father and he So I've been over that evidence
- 45:58as to the question as to whether or not Josh knew that Steven was doing
- 46:04this, and I'm not clear on that. There's a number of ways of
- 46:07looking at this one that Josh did know or had seen enough signs. I
- 46:13mean, Josh clearly was around when Stephen. Would you know, they'd be
- 46:20hanging around the house, Josh and Susan and Stephen, and Stephen would be
- 46:27filming a home movie and would really be focusing on Susan, maybe in times
- 46:35when she is wearing shorts around the house or whatever. And then the look
- 46:38on Josh's face it just I don't know, it's hard to read people's minds,
- 46:43but it kind of looks like Josh knows, Oh, here's dad.
- 46:46So Josh comes over to Susan, it sits next do her, that kind
- 46:50of thing. It's hard to know, but it's not a stretch. So
- 46:52there's that possibility. Another possibility is that, you know, an analogous situation
- 47:00is you have a father who was sexually abusing his own kids in the house,
- 47:06you know, miners little a ten year old child, and the perpetrator's
- 47:12wife sees a lot of signs, especially if it's ongoing. The spouse might
- 47:17and probably will see a lot of signs. They might even walk in on
- 47:22it sometimes. The emotional turmoil that goes through a spouse's mind. Even for
- 47:30those that eventually go to the cops, it's not like they see something they
- 47:36immediately call CPS. Right, it's a very difficult situation, right, I
- 47:40mean, I could lay out all the reasons why it would be difficult,
- 47:45but I feel like I don't have to do that. And for some of
- 47:47these spouses of perpetrators, they will have been through a lot of abuse,
- 47:53maybe sexual abuse when they're growing up. They might even be sexually abused by
- 47:58the perpetrator themselves, and therefore they bump up against a lot of trauma and
- 48:04trauma reactivity, maybe dissociation or denial or justification or it's normalized or fear or
- 48:10whatever. You know, a lot of barriers to even acknowledging what's happening in
- 48:15your mind. And it's very very common that the spouse of a perpetrator of
- 48:22sexual abuse of a child, the spouse won't do anything. Now, there
- 48:27are extreme cases where the spouse will do things actively to support the abuse,
- 48:31which makes it look like the spouse is also interested in abusing the child,
- 48:37which does happen unfortunately. And if you were abused by one of your parents
- 48:42while the other parent didn't do anything, then you know how enraging that is.
- 48:49For some victims, they will be more angry at the non abusive parent
- 48:57because that person didn't you anything. You know. It's one thing to look
- 49:01at a perpetrator and be like, well, you're a perpetrator. You're a
- 49:05monster, You're going to be a monster, But what about you. You're
- 49:08not a monster. You had a choice, and you didn't do anything.
- 49:14You knew what was happening. You know. It's very upsetting, obviously,
- 49:17but it happens. So was Josh in that situation. Josh was being indoctrinated
- 49:24into Steven's hall of mirrors, I don't know what to call it, like
- 49:29a his horror show, hall of mirrors since day one, and Josh was
- 49:35the main victim, the primary victim of Stephen for Josh's entire childhood physical abuse.
- 49:42You could argue sexual abuse, verbal abuse, no doubt. So for
- 49:46Josh, he's not that old and he's been through no therapy, he's been
- 49:52well. He and Susan did a brief bout of couple therapy that I didn't
- 49:58go into a little on that they blew out of therapy very quickly. I
- 50:01don't know. I don't know exactly what happened, but the way it looked
- 50:07was that Josh was not participating meaningfully anyway. So Josh hasn't recovered. So
- 50:14you know, maybe Josh was in that situation, or we just hate Josh
- 50:20and want to believe that he knew and approved of it. But take it
- 50:23from me, after reviewing all the data that I've seen, it's just hard
- 50:28to know what was going through Josh's mind. And I sell this not to
- 50:32say, hey, let's be nice Josh. No, I'm just saying that,
- 50:39Yeah, that's just how I see it. And we have enough reason
- 50:43to very much have negative feelings towards Josh independent of trying to drum up things.
- 50:50You know what I'm saying, It was allowing it to happen. So
- 50:52they find all these images, but they also find all these tapes and if
- 50:55you can read, I know a small script. It says Susan Powell washing
- 51:00face, brushing teeth, Susan on stool, pantyhose. Yeah. Someone in
- 51:05the audience was like, uh, yeah, right, So we know all
- 51:09this stuff, maybe not the specifics, but in an earlier chapter we reviewed
- 51:15all this stuff because I wanted to lay out the story chronologically. But this
- 51:21is when they find this stuff. So this is, you know, a
- 51:24year and a half after Susan has disappeared. They're going into the house just
- 51:29to get the journals and maybe find something else about Susan's whereabouts, and then
- 51:34they come across this whole other category of crimes, not only on Susan but
- 51:38all these other women, including children, which he'll get to. I think
- 51:44this is Stephen Powell filming Susan without her knowledge. And Ann said he was
- 51:50I guess we'll call him a singer if we're going to call him that.
- 51:52He made his own music and he would write songs about Susan, and his
- 51:57name was Steve Schanson. I think he had, yeah, he had an
- 52:00album an alias, So he does all this. But I think the most
- 52:07shocking piece is what you're seeing in this image. These are all of Susan's
- 52:12undergarments that were found in Susan's or Steven's home. Yeah, I think I
- 52:17forgot about this detail that years at So the last time that he would have
- 52:25had access to her underwear was when they lived with Steven, which was all
- 52:35the way back in two thousand and one, two thousand and two, So
- 52:39this is nine years later. And in the house they find all of this
- 52:49stuff, which I believe is used items. You can see underwear, you
- 52:53can see clothes, you can see what looks to be tampon applicators, looks
- 53:00like there are cotton swabs and other kinds of things, and he would use
- 53:07these to masturbate according to his own journal, which they will discover upon reviewing
- 53:14all these tapes that they have confiscated. These are used tampons other hygiene products
- 53:22that Stephen Powell had collected over the years. And all this is found during
- 53:27this investigation. And at the time, this is August twenty fifth, twenty
- 53:30eleven. At the time, Charlie and Braden are living in that home with
- 53:34their father. Also living in that home is Alena Powell and Josh's brother John
- 53:39Powell. So on that date they don't take the boys out of the home
- 53:43because they don't actually know what all is discovered. So the police raid the
- 53:46house, they take all this stuff, and they take so much stuff that
- 53:51it takes them a while to sift through all of it and catalog all of
- 53:53it. They also took I think almost twenty computers from the house. There
- 54:00are a lot of file cabinets. I've seen a picture of that. There's
- 54:04a closet with just wall to wall file cabinets which I think was filled with
- 54:09all this stuff that Steven had been doing. And once they cataloged everything,
- 54:16they counted forty five hundred photos and videos of Susan four five hundred photos and
- 54:25videos, and they discover that Stephen had been taking pictures and video of young
- 54:32girls in the neighborhood aged eight and ten. Stephen had been for photographing them
- 54:39while they were naked in the bath and while they used the toilet. I
- 54:43don't know how he got access to that. I couldn't find any information on
- 54:46that. It makes sense they wouldn't want to go into detail in the press
- 54:51regarding that, but that's what's been reported. And they testified. The children
- 54:58testified that they didn't know that they were being filmed or photograph, not that
- 55:01that matters, but it just provides some context. So I think the issue
- 55:08here is that there are different levels of crime, right Like if you steal
- 55:15a pack of bubblegum, that's a lower crime than stealing a car. And
- 55:20when it comes to these kinds of crimes, there are also levels to it.
- 55:24I don't know the exact levels, but I think if you are taking
- 55:29secret naked pictures of children and you have other pictures of naked children on your
- 55:36computer, I think that's a pretty high crime. But when it comes to
- 55:40voyeuristic crimes where you are filming your daughter in law in your house, I
- 55:46think those are lower on the list. I'm not entirely sure because the way
- 55:52that the police acted for this point, you know, they and of course
- 55:57they would want to protect the children, and they reacted quite strongly, and
- 56:02they charged him with charges of voyeurism and child pornography. And I've already been
- 56:10over a voyeuristic disorder, I believe in chapter one. So at this point
- 56:16the new story explodes through the stress. It was already a big story.
- 56:22Now it's just a fantastical It's just fantastical, this whole story, and people
- 56:28are now starting to they whoa Stephen? Maybe he killed Susan or he worked
- 56:34with Joshticil Zusan or whatever. So tangent time, I think you could argue
- 56:38that this was perhaps the golden age of true crime in twenty eleven, because
- 56:44I started thinking about all the famous cases, cases that a lot of y'all
- 56:47have asked me to cover and do deep dives on cases like Amanda Knox and
- 56:53Jodiarius and Casey Anthony. It was all around this time. So I decided
- 56:59to make a list of all the elements that support the case that around this
- 57:07time was the golden age of true crime, which is a horrible age to
- 57:15live through because there's horrific tragedies that are happening. So I think a lot
- 57:20of things conspired for this to be true. I mean, one, true
- 57:22crime has always been fasts and a fascination to humans. But around this time,
- 57:28it's in twenty eleven, you have the Internet get to this place where
- 57:32social media and Twitter and Reddit and everywhere else. I'm old enough to remember
- 57:37that if you talked about using the Internet a lot, you were a nerd.
- 57:44If you emailed a lot, oh you're a nerd. And then at
- 57:47some point there was a sea change and it just seemed like everyone was using
- 57:53smartphones and computers. I mean, there was a time when I was younger
- 57:58when just having a computer meant you were so consider that. But when it
- 58:02became just mainstream for people to not only use the Internet but also to participate
- 58:08in the online conversations, that's when the Internet just exploded with the activity,
- 58:15and true crime got sucked up in that Mailstrem Nancy Grace was huge at the
- 58:22time. Doctor Phil was gigantic at the time. And it's hard to understand
- 58:25how big these figures were because in today's fractured media landscape, you can have
- 58:32a huge figure in media today who wouldn't even crack the top fifty in terms
- 58:39of the ratings on TV from ten to twenty years ago because everyone was watching
- 58:45TV all the time. I'm guessing that in thirty forty fifty years, when
- 58:51people think back to the early twenty first century, they will remember more of
- 58:59the true crime stories from this period of time around the time of Susan Powell's
- 59:02disappearance then other times. Because listen to this list, you have a man
- 59:07in Knox from two thousand and seven, you have the Virginia Tech shooting.
- 59:13You have Jody Arius Casey Anthony. You have the Jennifer Hudson family murders two
- 59:19thousand and eight. You have the Batman movie shooting in Aurora, Colorado.
- 59:22Twenty twelve. You have Trayvon Martin. You have the Sandy Hook shooting.
- 59:27You have the Boston Marathon bombing, and that was a big Internet involved thing.
- 59:32You know a lot of Internet slews who I think even well, there's
- 59:36a lot of bad Internet sleuthing that happened like horrible, and you know where
- 59:39they would target an innocent person with the as perpetrating the bombing and then they
- 59:45would be anyway. You had Oscar Pistorius, you had the Slenderman killings twenty
- 59:52fourteen. You had some very famous and notorious police shootings in twenty four teen.
- 1:00:00Eric Garner or Eric Garner was I don't know if he was shot and
- 1:00:02he was killed by the timir Rice Michael Brown, and of course you have
- 1:00:06Elliott Roger around this time. So I don't know, but it just seems
- 1:00:09like some of the biggest stories that I've ever heard about in my life,
- 1:00:15and they're all like in this period of time, and so the Susan Powell,
- 1:00:21Josh Powell, Stephen Powell. When Stephen Powell is discovered with all this,
- 1:00:25I mean, it just shot the story through the roof, which you
- 1:00:29know, because when I put the pull on Patreon asking people to vote on
- 1:00:32or just to suggest things and vote on what the next deep dive would be
- 1:00:39on, I was actually really surprised that Josh Powell won the because the list
- 1:00:44was like forty different things, and I thought, oh, Josh Pawell,
- 1:00:46that's interesting. I mean, that was a long time ago. But you
- 1:00:50know, the story is so detailed, there's so many things, and when
- 1:00:55this Stephen Powell stuff came for it just, you know, the Internet didn't
- 1:01:00know what to do. And I understand. I mean, I have been
- 1:01:02obsessed with this case for the past two months. I spend almost all my
- 1:01:07free time like consuming. It's just there's so many, just bizarre details,
- 1:01:15and I've just been trying to wrap my head around the whole thing. And
- 1:01:19I'll tell you that it's been difficult emotionally, but a part of my efforts
- 1:01:24I think are kind of working in that once I get to a full conceptualization,
- 1:01:29which eventually I did, there is some comfort in it. That I'll
- 1:01:35talk about in a later chapter. All Right, So at this point,
- 1:01:39the government takes custody of the kids as well. They charge Steven, and
- 1:01:45they take custody of the kids because the kids were in the house with Stephen,
- 1:01:52and Josh was allowing the kids, you know, because you would just
- 1:01:55hope that since it was all out there in the open, at least some
- 1:01:59of it was out there in the open, that Josh wouldn't let the kids
- 1:02:02anywhere near the father, Steven, right, And that was the implication anyway,
- 1:02:08So they take the kids and let's take a break. But the rest
- 1:02:13of this episode just going to be for patrons of the podcast. I'm going
- 1:02:15to talk about the custody issue, which is interesting, and then I am
- 1:02:22going to talk about my personal connection to this case. I mean, I'm
- 1:02:28not directly involved, but I'm lightly involved, and I'm going to talk about
- 1:02:34all that. I'm going to talk about the detailed assessment that was done by
- 1:02:37my friend on Josh himself. I have the psychological report in front of me.
- 1:02:45I can read the evaluation and the diagnosis of Josh, and then in
- 1:02:54the patron zone it'll probably get into the murder suicide. I think I don't
- 1:03:01know. We'll see how much I have time for. But anyway, if
- 1:03:04you want to hear the rest of this episode, become a patron of the
- 1:03:06podcast. Otherwise, please take care of yourself because you deserve it. You
- 1:03:08really, really do.