Latest / First Trust ROI Podcast / Ep 83 | Jim Murchie | Can the Power Grid Keep Up with the AI Boom? | ROI Podcast
Transcript
- 0:09Ryan: What is the long-term impact of the war in Iran on energy prices?
- 0:13Ryan: What's happening with data centers?
- 0:15Ryan: Is it all political?
- 0:16Ryan: And what about interest rates?
- 0:18Ryan: Do rising interest rates have a negative impact on utilities?
- 0:21Ryan: Joining me to answer these questions and more is Jim Murchy, founder and portfolio manager at Energy Income Partners.
- 0:27Ryan: Thanks for joining us on this episode, the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 0:31Ryan: All right, Jim.
- 0:32Ryan: So uh last time we spoke, it was right after the war in Iran broke out and it was having a big impact on oil prices.
- 0:40Ryan: Um, I think the general feeling at the time, at least my thinking, was that it was going to be something that would be relatively short.
- 0:47Ryan: No one really knew, but it would have a temporary impact for a little while on oil prices, and then eventually that would kind of fade away, maybe with some sort of risk premium.
- 0:57Ryan: Um, I'm curious, now that we're in fall, you know, this is going to air towards the end of October.
- 1:04Ryan: Um, where do we stand today with respect to the war, its impact on oil prices?
- 1:10Ryan: Are do you things do you expect prices to stay high for an extended period of time?
- 1:15Jim: Yeah.
- 1:15Jim: So, you know, I watched our last podcast, you know, and and I I would say again what I said then is that this whole thing is not about damage to facilities, although that's starting to happen.
- 1:26Jim: It's about, you know, a straight being blocked.
- 1:30Jim: And that can be relieved in a relatively short time if the belligerents decide to sign it, sign a peace agreement.
- 1:36Jim: But given how easy it was for Iran to disrupt it, how hard it is for the U.S.
- 1:41Jim: to protect those ships, it is hard to imagine the risk premium going to zero anytime soon.
- 1:47Jim: And that's the situation we're in today.
- 1:50Jim: And there really is a remarkable recovery of volumes out of the Middle East.
- 1:57Jim: So before before the war, we were at 23 million barrels a day.
- 2:03Jim: Now, everyone here has the number of 20, but that's through the Strait of Hormuz.
- 2:08Jim: We had we already had stuff coming through the Red Sea, and we already had some stuff in Oman that gets sorry, United Arab Emirates, it crosses their land and goes outside the strait into what's known as the the Gulfable.
- 2:23Jim: So so the 23 was made up of 18 of crude and five of products, you know, gasoline, diesel, jet fuel.
- 2:31Jim: And when the war broke out, and the you know, that 23 went to like, you know, like five, like overnight.
- 2:42Jim: And then of course the Saudis put more crude through their east-west pipeline and can handle seven million barrels a day, but they only send two through to the refineries there.
- 2:54Jim: So, you know, about a million barrels a day came through, and that was refined products.
- 2:59Jim: And then, and then the UAE would ship about two million barrels a day, you know, across.
- 3:04Jim: Um, and so what happened was they ramped up the East West pipeline to all 7 million barrels a day.
- 3:11Jim: So you had five extra to export.
- 3:13Jim: And that worked for a while until, of course, the rebels in Yemen started bombing ships.
- 3:19Jim: So today, where we sit is we are three, four, five million barrels a day short of that original 23, in part because we're using the East West Pipeline more, in part because we're using the pipeline that the UE gets you outside Hormuz more, but you know, only about two-thirds of that five million barrels a day of refining capacity is operating.
- 3:47Jim: And then, you know, what's going on in Russia matters too.
- 3:50Jim: So 10% of the world's refining capacity is really not, it's either damaged, the ones in Russia are damaged, or they're locked behind, you know, the kind of the embargo in um in the Middle East.
- 4:02Jim: So 10% of the world's refining capacity is not available.
- 4:06Jim: That's why diesel prices are so high.
- 4:09Ryan: So how long does it take to ramp up uh additional refining capacity?
- 4:13Ryan: I mean, is that is that something where it has to be existing facilities that come back online, or can you Yeah, in the Middle East, unless some unless they start getting damage, that's quick.
- 4:23Jim: Um, and the oil fields are quick.
- 4:25Jim: And we've seen this now with the protection of the U.S.
- 4:27Jim: Navy, you know, you're almost to where you were before coming through the Strait of Remote.
- 4:32Jim: But of course, those are the, you know, if you graph it out, it's kind of sawtooth.
- 4:36Jim: And of course, what we've seen in the last few days is the Iranians are flying missiles at those ships, that obviously, if you're a ship owner, you have to make that decision.
- 4:45Jim: Some decide to run it, some decide not to.
- 4:48Jim: And you can understand why you're un until there is a complete settlement here that's going to continue for the foreseeable future.
- 5:00Ryan: So, given the amount of crude production that we have in the US that's come on over the last decade and a half, say, um, would it make more sense to have more refining capacity here, or is there some sort of technical reason why that doesn't make sense?
- 5:14Jim: Um, it's just the economics.
- 5:16Jim: So we, you know, the people in the industry and the people who support the industry for years have been saying, oh, you know, we need more refining capacity and these stupid environmental laws are preventing them.
- 5:27Jim: That's not true.
- 5:28Jim: What's, you know, if you drive through refinery and petrochemical alley in East Texas and Louisiana, you'd be hard pressed to say that they haven't built everything they wanted to build.
- 5:41Jim: Okay.
- 5:42Jim: Um, the issue is the economics.
- 5:44Jim: So the economics of starting with a new food footprint and all of that infrastructure don't work.
- 5:50Jim: But what has worked, and again, it's cyclical, over time is expanding existing refineries.
- 5:56Jim: And so, you know, we have enough refining capacity.
- 6:00Jim: And you say, well, okay, but the world's a dangerous place.
- 6:04Jim: And could we, you know, act as a buffer?
- 6:07Jim: And the answer is, well, we could mechanically in theory, but who's going to pay for it?
- 6:12Jim: Remember, the entire industry, I mean, even in Saudi Arabia, I mean, it's a publicly traded company.
- 6:18Jim: Now, granted, they floated, what, 3, 4, 5% of the shares?
- 6:21Jim: You know, it's a state entity, okay?
- 6:24Jim: But these people are profit-driven just like everybody else.
- 6:27Jim: They don't want to waste for every dollar they put in the ground, they want two or three dollars coming back out.
- 6:32Jim: And uh, and so the question for the whole world on any of these raw materials is who's gonna pay for the surplus that is sitting idle most of the time.
- 6:44Jim: And so, you know, competitive markets are brilliant at giving you the products the market wants with the highest quality and the lowest cost.
- 6:55Jim: That's that that's that's why over time they dominate commerce.
- 7:01Jim: But there are these periods of time where you say we really we care a little less about efficiency and we care a little more about cushion.
- 7:09Jim: And the only way you're going to achieve that is with some kind of government intervention, because at the end of the day, you're saying this is a public good to have a cushion.
- 7:20Jim: And if it's a public good, the public needs to pay for it.
- 7:22Jim: And they do that through government policies.
- 7:25Jim: And that's, you know, the issue we're facing on rare earth metals, everything.
- 7:30Ryan: So one of the cushions for the energy sector that was developed, what, 50 years ago, is the strategic petroleum reserve.
- 7:37Ryan: And I was just looking at a chart um earlier today, and it's at levels, I think 1982 was last time.
- 7:42Ryan: Yeah, it's pretty low.
- 7:44Jim: Um, you know, we've used about, I mean, I think we started about 450 million barrels and we're down to like 280 now.
- 7:50Jim: And it's like, oh, you know, we haven't used that much, but you can't get to zero because at the bottom of these reservoirs are this mucky stuff that you and you know, you don't really know exactly how thick it is, so you don't want to get too close to it.
- 8:03Jim: Um, so you know, we're we've probably used about 50 to 65 percent of the usable amount that's there.
- 8:10Jim: And then there's strategic petroleum reserves around the world.
- 8:13Jim: But the real cushion, what's what's making up the difference between what the market wants, that 23 million barrels a day before the war, and call it the 18 or 19 they're getting now, is storage.
- 8:26Jim: And while the strategic petroleum reserves in the US and in Europe are being drawn down, the biggest cushion has come from China.
- 8:33Jim: And so they were buying at least a million barrels a day, more crude than they needed for at least the last two or three years.
- 8:41Jim: And they have been storing, and of course, these are state secrets, so no one exactly knows why.
- 8:46Jim: But a big part of the cushion of why we can be producing less oil and only have an oil price of, you know, $90, $100 as opposed to $200, um, is because of this primarily the Chinese.
- 9:02Jim: At the end of the day, they're smaller refineries, they shut down.
- 9:05Jim: Um, so they have less supply.
- 9:08Jim: So they're either importing more or exporting less.
- 9:10Jim: Um, but they are drawing down from those inventories, and the world doesn't know how big those inventories are.
- 9:17Ryan: They stockpiled essentially.
- 9:19Ryan: They did.
- 9:19Ryan: So are they a I I never really think of the Chinese as being a producer of of uh you know petrochemicals.
- 9:26Ryan: Are they?
- 9:27Ryan: Oh, yeah.
- 9:28Jim: Yeah.
- 9:28Jim: Well, they they import the feedstocks.
- 9:30Jim: I mean, they have some growth, their own food production, but they import feedstocks um and they make a lot of petrochemically.
- 9:35Jim: In fact, in not just China, but Southeast Asia has represented the lion's share of capacity additions to petrochemicals in the last cycle, call it six, seven, eight years.
- 9:45Jim: And so up to the war, that cycle was at its bottom.
- 9:49Jim: We had overbuilt relative to demand and margins were at their troughs.
- 9:52Jim: And so now we've cut off some of those feed stocks because some of those feed stocks come out of the Middle East as a product called Nantha, which comes out of refineries.
- 10:01Jim: And something like 20% of the world's um naphtha comes from the Gulf and a big part of that is is impaired.
- 10:10Jim: And so that tightened up the petrochemical supply-demand situation kind of overnight.
- 10:16Ryan: Okay, so let's let's hypothesize for a minute and say that the war ended tomorrow.
- 10:22Ryan: What would happen to oil prices and would they kind of stick at a certain level?
- 10:27Jim: Well, the try the trouble is defining when the war is over.
- 10:30Jim: That's a good point.
- 10:31Jim: Um, and what's what what you have seen is, you know, the administration will make an announcement, you know, we're very close, we're very close.
- 10:37Jim: And I don't doubt there's some people in the room that want to sign a deal, but there's people in Tehran when they take that deal back and they're like, you know, what about what we told you?
- 10:49Jim: You did you not understand?
- 10:51Jim: Okay, we're not signing that.
- 10:53Jim: We're not signing anything that looks like that.
- 10:54Jim: So we is so there, you know, when you hear the stories, you know, the Pakistanis are spending all their time mediating amongst the various factions that are at the table from from around.
- 11:04Jim: And so it's hard to really know what's going on there.
- 11:08Jim: But if in fact there was something that really was a hard-term deal, then oil goes back to whatever $50, $60, $70 a month.
- 11:15Ryan: Okay, so Jim, we talked a lot about the impact on oil and gas prices of what's happening in the street of Hormuz.
- 11:22Ryan: Uh, but for the sorts of energy companies that you invest in, do the cyclical variations in the price of oil have an impact?
- 11:30Ryan: Are they do they matter?
- 11:31Ryan: Do they not matter?
- 11:33Jim: Yeah, in terms of earnings, there's virtually no impact because the the vast majority of our portfolio are legal monopolies that operate on a cost plus system.
- 11:44Jim: And so if it's not, if it's in their costs, it doesn't matter it's interest rates or higher fuel costs, that's simply going to be passed along.
- 11:51Jim: It doesn't mean, though, that for say the pipeline part of our portfolio that there's a sediment move there in the stock prices, but ultimately those are temporary.
- 11:59Jim: If oil prices go down and stay there, that's not temporary for Exxon, right?
- 12:04Jim: But it is for a pipeline company and certainly has very little effect on a regulated utility, which is all operating on a cost plus minimum.
- 12:12Jim: And so that's been our strategy from the beginning is to avoid all of that uncertainty and cyclicality and focus on the things that management's control.
- 12:20Jim: And so, you know, when you do your research and understand what's going on with a company, it will show up in earnings because these exogenous variables, whether it's interest rates, which are a cost pass-through, or fuel costs, which are a pass-through, it doesn't affect their bottom line profitability.
- 12:35Ryan: Let's talk more about data centers.
- 12:36Ryan: I'm curious, um, as we think about the the ramp up in demand for electricity.
- 12:43Ryan: This is one of the objections that people raise, like, you know, so much electricity demand, it's gonna have an impact on prices and your utility bills are gonna go up.
- 12:51Ryan: And by the way, AI is probably gonna end humanity.
- 12:53Ryan: So why would you want these things?
- 12:55Ryan: Um, so let's start at the demand part.
- 12:58Ryan: Um, are utilities able to meet the demand coming from data centers?
- 13:02Jim: Yeah, they'll so right now, when you look at the sort of announced, not so much announced, but sort of requested hookups, it's well in access of what could ever be built.
- 13:14Jim: Um, but people want to get access to the transmission, so they want to get in that, they want to get in that queue.
- 13:20Jim: So Texas started a process called badge zero saying, okay, all the this is nonsense.
- 13:24Jim: I mean, there literally was announcements for 140 gigawatts of data centers.
- 13:29Jim: Okay.
- 13:29Jim: The peak, like in July and August, because of air conditioning in Texas, just hit 90 gigawatts for the first time in history.
- 13:37Jim: They want to add an additional.
- 13:38Jim: So it's like, okay, that's nowhere near then you know that number is anything.
- 13:42Jim: So let's just ignore that for a time being and say, you know, what are, you know, what is actually happening with demand in spite of the pushback.
- 13:51Jim: When you check in with the utilities, they are telling you that they are, they continue to increase their expectations of demand growth.
- 14:01Jim: And that's from actual discussions with actual people to build actual machines.
- 14:05Jim: And so we have not seen a slowdown from activity when we look at where it was a year ago and two years ago.
- 14:15Jim: The fact that what people have talked about is way more than what gets built.
- 14:20Jim: It's not really that relevant unless you have someone who's gullible enough to believe that ridiculously high number.
- 14:28Jim: So um, so right now, um, you know, the industry, so there's a there's a capacity survey done every year.
- 14:36Jim: Um, the department of the Department of Energy um runs a report, but an independent research group that we use called Wolf Research does the best work is they get on the phone and they call literally everybody on the survey.
- 14:47Jim: And um and what you've seen over the last four years in terms of five-year forward capacity plans um is relative consistency in wind and solar at about 160, 170 gigawatts for the five-year period.
- 15:07Jim: So if we go back to 2023, it was 165, then it was 107, then it was 170, it was 170.
- 15:13Jim: This year it's 195.
- 15:14Jim: It's bounced up a little bit, in part because they're accelerating to get the tax credits, which are going to expire, right?
- 15:22Jim: Because the, you know, because the the bill passed under Biden was so you know, was a budget bill, didn't have the 60 votes, you know, you needed to bust a filibuster in the Senate.
- 15:32Jim: It was, you know, all you need is one vote.
- 15:34Jim: And so when the when the House and the Senate flipped, then you know, they took away some of that stuff.
- 15:38Jim: But they they said, okay, if you get, you start pouring concrete before this date in 2027, 20.
- 15:43Jim: So all that stuff's been pulled forward a little bit.
- 15:46Jim: Coal closures are still 40 to 50 gigawatts over the five-year plan.
- 15:53Jim: That's kind of what it was three or four years ago.
- 15:55Jim: That's what it is today.
- 15:56Jim: Nuclear has gone from zero to plus maybe five gigawatts.
- 16:00Jim: The big change, and we've been talking about this, is natural gas.
- 16:03Jim: We go back to 2023.
- 16:06Jim: The five-year forward plan for natural gas was 20 gigawatts.
- 16:11Jim: In 2024, it was 35.
- 16:13Jim: Last year, it was 75.
- 16:17Jim: Now it's 130.
- 16:19Jim: As of two weeks ago, when this report came out, it has gone from 20 to 130 gigawatts in four years.
- 16:27Jim: That's over the next five-year period.
- 16:28Jim: That's a five-year forward look.
- 16:30Jim: So the real change in what the industry is planning is growth in natural gas generation.
- 16:38Jim: And so that is really the only thing you can get.
- 16:41Jim: No one's going to build a coal plant.
- 16:42Jim: Wind and solar are going effectively as fast as they can, and they're intermittent.
- 16:45Jim: And obviously, the data centers want power.
- 16:48Jim: We say 24-7, 365, but there are some uses that you can cut off intermittently.
- 16:53Jim: Um, and so the big, you know, the thing filling the gap is natural gas.
- 16:59Jim: And we've talked about that before.
- 17:01Jim: And, you know, that has knock-on effects on that part of the business.
- 17:05Jim: But so, so the so the demand's there.
- 17:09Jim: The industry is ramping up its ability to make the machines that generate electricity from natural gas.
- 17:16Jim: Um, all of that is happening about as fast as you can imagine and happening.
- 17:20Jim: Um, but we're still a little bit short.
- 17:23Jim: And so the the constraint still on data center build-out is power.
- 17:29Jim: Now you can say, oh, well, you know, it's chips.
- 17:31Jim: And it's I I'm not an expert.
- 17:32Jim: Maybe it is chips.
- 17:33Jim: It's hard to say which is the more binding constraint.
- 17:35Jim: But I would say if you solve chips tomorrow, you are still bound by how much natural gas fire generation you can manufacture.
- 17:45Ryan: I know you don't want a warehouse full of chips that don't have power to them because they start depreciating them.
- 17:50Ryan: If they do, yeah.
- 17:51Ryan: And uh, you know, you're not getting any usage out of them.
- 17:54Ryan: Yeah.
- 17:54Ryan: Um, so does that figure that you just mentioned for natural gas, does that uh include behind the meter as well as sort of grid, you know, public utility?
- 18:04Ryan: Yeah, it does.
- 18:05Jim: So that that increase from say 70 or 75 to 130, 20 or 30 of that increase is what you call behind the meter.
- 18:16Jim: Um and there are a few exceptions about what I'm about to say, but when you look at how supply is going to react, it's almost all natural gas, there are two categories within that that you have to understand.
- 18:33Jim: The first is that what the utility, what the regulated utilities buy that are in the vertically integrated states, and remember we talked about this last time, right?
- 18:42Jim: So 58% of the electricity consumed in this country comes from 35 states that have a vertically integrated cost plus revenue model with monopoly utilities owning the generation and the poles and the wires.
- 18:58Jim: The other 42% comes from the other 15 states where the poles and wires are cost plus, just like they are everywhere in the world, but power generation is a competitive business.
- 19:09Jim: And so when you look at who has who is in line in the queue at Siemens, Mitsubishi, and GE for the baseload natural gas, it's predominantly the vertically integrated utilities.
- 19:24Jim: Because the merchant guys, all of there's four publicly traded, every single one of them either was formed in conjunction with or themselves have been bankrupt in the last 10 years.
- 19:37Jim: Their shareholders are like, now that the margins are coming back, there's one thing and one thing only I want you to do with that money, and that's give it back to me as a shareholder.
- 19:46Jim: And if you build anything, it better be on the back of a very long-term fixed price, fixed margin contract.
- 19:54Jim: So when we look at the behind-the-meter stuff, it's almost all in those competitive markets.
- 20:00Jim: And virtually all of it is not the large publicly traded independent power producers.
- 20:07Jim: It is a new crop of companies that are basically starting energy service companies where they're buying the generators for somebody else and assembling them on site and operating them for the data center company.
- 20:21Jim: What's so different about those machines is that instead of being a two-stage turbine, which gets 65% of the energy out of the natural gas and converts it to electricity, it's a single-stage turbine that only extracts 36, 37% of the energy.
- 20:41Jim: So a baseload natural gas plant is two turbines.
- 20:45Jim: It's like a jet engine that has a very hot exhaust, hot enough to make steam, and you run that steam through a steam turbine, you know, which is what sits at the back of a coal plant or a nuclear power plant.
- 20:57Jim: You make steam with the heat and you run it through a steam turbine.
- 21:00Jim: So that two-stage process doesn't quite double, but it gets you 70, 80% increase in the amount of energy you're extracting from the fuel that you're running through that turbine.
- 21:10Jim: And so these behind the meter are either a single-stage turbine or they're an old-fashioned reciprocating engine that runs either diesel or natural gas.
- 21:20Jim: They're going to be mostly natural gas.
- 21:22Jim: And so that those machines are still, they're built by Caterpillar and Cummins and Wortzla and people like that.
- 21:30Jim: But they're going to be operated by these service companies.
- 21:35Jim: And some of them are publicly traded, a lot of them are private.
- 21:37Jim: But even big companies like Williams Pipeline Company was early on to provide this service for data.
- 21:44Jim: So they have five projects that they've announced.
- 21:47Jim: And all of those projects will be a single stage turbine.
- 21:51Jim: And maybe I don't think they're going to do reciprocating engines, but some, but other people will do reciprocating engines.
- 21:56Jim: And so those reciprocating engines pollute and the They pollute a lot more.
- 22:01Jim: And so part of the pushback, and you know, we've, you know, this, we can talk all day long about the pushback, where it's coming from.
- 22:10Jim: Public doesn't like AI.
- 22:12Jim: Um, the polit they don't like rising utility bills.
- 22:15Jim: Um, and the politicians, of course, are going to respond to that.
- 22:18Jim: But there's another element here, and that is the environmentalists will push back on these single-stage trick, because they're dirtier.
- 22:26Jim: And it's not just carbon, it's nitrous oxide and things like that.
- 22:30Jim: And so um they're now you run up against the Clean Air Act.
- 22:35Jim: And so the question is what is going to be the regulatory solution for these?
- 22:42Jim: And right now, they're skating by on the language in the Clean Air Act.
- 22:48Jim: So you can the Clean Air Act, stationary sources, is basically designed to mitigate the emissions from coal plants and and baselo natural gas, big, you know, utility scale things, they make exceptions for things that are small, not large, and mobile, not stationary.
- 23:12Jim: So since the smaller turbines are mobile and they're temporary, because each of the data center companies has said in five or six years, when the baseload manufacturing capability catches up and that gets added to the grid by the vertically integrated utilities, we're going to switch back over to the grid.
- 23:32Jim: So by definition, what we're doing here is temporary.
- 23:35Jim: These things are mobile, so the Clean Air Act doesn't apply to us.
- 23:39Jim: That will play itself out in the courts because the administration, at least this one for the next two years, will be writing and interpreting those Clean Air Act rules to the benefit of the data centers.
- 23:53Jim: But it doesn't mean they won't be challenged in court.
- 23:56Jim: And so people need to think about these two separate market structures, where the behind the meter is going, what those machines are versus the baseload, and what that means for local pushback, what that means for Clean Air Act regulations and things like that.
- 24:12Ryan: Okay, so with all the added demand coming from natural gas, um, you know, we we've talked a little bit about oil supply and, you know, the coming out of the Strait of Hormuz and the downstream impact there.
- 24:26Ryan: We we produce a lot of natural gas in the U.S.
- 24:29Ryan: Um, and so do we have ample supply to you know fuel all those different natural gas plants?
- 24:36Jim: Yeah, we do.
- 24:36Jim: I mean the the shale revolution is you know is is a is you know was a real thing.
- 24:40Jim: I mean, there's all this resource that was in the shale um that's still being still being exploited, um, and we have a long runway on that.
- 24:49Jim: Um so in terms of in terms of uh volume, right?
- 24:54Jim: So the U.S.
- 24:55Jim: today consumes, depending on how you want to measure it, because a lot of the natural gas goes back into um the ground to pressure the reservoir.
- 25:04Jim: So you take that out.
- 25:05Jim: A lot of the natural gas runs the turbines to push the natural gas through the pipelines.
- 25:09Jim: So you can kind of take that out.
- 25:11Jim: And what you're left with is called 105, 110 billion cubic feet a day.
- 25:17Jim: All right.
- 25:17Jim: And if you want an energy equivalent, divide by six.
- 25:20Jim: So that's like 18 million barrels a day of oil equivalent, right?
- 25:24Jim: So I mean, with the amount of energy we consume from oil and gas in this country is roughly 50-50.
- 25:29Jim: So that's gives you this idea of the scale.
- 25:31Jim: When we look at the amount of gas you need to fire these new turbines, it's an extra at least 10 billion cubic feet a day, another 10%.
- 25:41Jim: But we also have under construction and that have already been permitted and um sort of financed, another 15 billion cubic feet a day of LNG export capacity.
- 25:52Jim: So that's 25 combined.
- 25:55Jim: And it might be a little higher, might be a little lower.
- 25:57Jim: I'm more on the higher side.
- 25:58Jim: Um, and that would be 25 BCF a day by 2031-32 that we're not consuming today.
- 26:07Jim: So that's roughly a 20, I mean 105, 110.
- 26:10Jim: So that's 20, 25% increase.
- 26:12Jim: It's a compound annual growth rate of like, you know, like three, three and a half percent a year.
- 26:18Jim: And so what's going to happen is it maybe half of that comes out of the permian as a byproduct of production of oil.
- 26:28Jim: So what's happening in the permian is, you know, you always do when you find a piece of geology, you do the best part of the geology first because of the time value of money, and do the you do the worst last.
- 26:39Jim: And the what's happening is the amount of gas you produce for every barrel of oil continues to go up.
- 26:46Jim: And if you graph it out of the line, it's pretty steady and it's going to continue to rise.
- 26:50Jim: So even if oil production in Permian doesn't grow, and it probably will a little bit, natural gas production out of the Permian will.
- 26:58Jim: And it's not really price sensitive.
- 27:00Jim: It's more price sensitive to crude because they can get zero for this gas and the well is still economic.
- 27:06Jim: That's not all we need.
- 27:10Jim: We need more than that.
- 27:10Jim: So that means you need to go into higher cost areas.
- 27:13Jim: And so when you look at the economics, it says, you know, the clearing price of natural gas is, you know, probably $350 to $4 an MCF to be able to incentivize places outside the permeant where it's a byproduct to actually put dollars in the ground.
- 27:30Jim: And so, yeah, it's a little uplift from where it is now in the forward curve, but not much.
- 27:35Jim: Mostly it's the volume that's going to go up a lot.
- 27:38Ryan: Is the current infrastructure that's in place uh adequate to transport all that natural?
- 27:44Jim: No, because you see new contracts being being signed now with um really on the demand side.
- 27:49Jim: So during the shale boom, what you had was it new areas of production.
- 27:54Jim: You had the Bach and shale, you had the Marcellus, right?
- 27:57Jim: And you didn't have enough pipeline capacity.
- 27:59Jim: And of course, a producer is like, well, I'm gonna drill if I can't sell it, and I can't sell it unless I move it through a pipeline.
- 28:04Jim: So the producers actually put some of their capital behind these pipelines.
- 28:08Jim: Um, the vast majority of natural gas pipelines are contracted for by end users, and the vast majority of those are state-regulated utilities.
- 28:17Jim: Um, and so whether it's a utility putting in more gas, fire generation, like we talked about, into a baseload unit, or whether it's one of these developers saying, hey, I'm going to put in some reciprocating engines and some single-stage turbines somewhere here in Ohio.
- 28:31Jim: I need to run a 25-mile line.
- 28:33Jim: Whoever builds that line won't build it without a 20-year count.
- 28:37Jim: That's kind of where everybody is.
- 28:39Jim: What's interesting is how everybody is concerned about obsolescence risk of a data center or the chips that are in the data center or whatever.
- 28:49Jim: So everybody's protecting themselves to make sure that when they put capital on the ground, it is going to be remunerated if that data center operates or not.
- 28:59Jim: So it's interesting to see in this boom how careful the people and the people who are selling the pickaxes to these data centers, how careful they're being with their shareholders' cap.
- 29:11Ryan: I'm curious what you expect post-midterm elections with uh with maybe some of the pushback against data centers.
- 29:19Ryan: I know it's it's not all political, some political, some there's other issues.
- 29:23Ryan: Um, but I guess my expectation is that at least some of the rhetoric will probably die down.
- 29:29Ryan: Seems like there's solutions to many of the issues people raise.
- 29:32Ryan: Yeah.
- 29:33Ryan: Um, but what do you think about that?
- 29:35Jim: So, you know, I uh go to uh energy conference twice a year at the Aspen Institute, and each time there are the senior people in the energy buying groups for the big data companies.
- 29:46Jim: And their opinion in August um, or the last session that we had was that um opposition to data centers is only now just getting organized.
- 29:58Jim: I mean, we're in the second or third inning, according to these folks.
- 30:01Jim: And once it gets organized, because you know, there's organizations out there that exist to organize protests, right?
- 30:06Jim: Because no matter what you say, no matter what you do, in a planet with 8 billion people on it, you're gonna find someone that objects to what you just said or objecting to what you do.
- 30:13Jim: And it's a business to sort of give those people a voice.
- 30:16Jim: And so whether those organizations have an environmental bent or, you know, whatever, there's gonna be more organized pushback.
- 30:25Jim: And the first thing they said was if you just go back two years, when you came into a town with a data center, they're like, okay, what's the property tax impact of this?
- 30:35Jim: And it's like, we're gonna cut your property taxes by a third, or we're gonna cut it by two-thirds, or whatever.
- 30:39Jim: They're like, what do you need to get started?
- 30:42Jim: Most of those data centers didn't have to do with AI, they were cloud computing.
- 30:46Jim: Remember, I mean, the biggest thing people were talking about six, seven years ago was Amazon Web Services, and then we're gonna catch up to them because we're all moving from a server inside of our office to cloud computing.
- 30:56Jim: And so people would welcome them.
- 30:59Jim: Now there is this blur between AI and all data centers, whether they are cloud computing or whether they are for and so what's happened is the pushback is happening on normal cloud computing data set, and nothing to do with AI.
- 31:15Jim: And so um it's, you know, you know, it's it's definitely sort of a rising trend.
- 31:22Jim: But again, we talk to the utilities, we talk to people, really, it's like everybody's moving forward.
- 31:27Jim: The other thing is these are local pushback issues.
- 31:32Jim: And it's like, how many towns or counties in America want a prison?
- 31:37Jim: Right?
- 31:38Jim: Not many.
- 31:40Jim: But there's a bunch that want the jobs and the economic development that goes with that.
- 31:46Jim: Data centers are gonna be the same thing.
- 31:48Jim: There are gonna be so you could have 90% of the counties or 90% of the towns or the townships saying no in a state, you're gonna find you're gonna find a township that says we'll take it because we want, we would like our property taxes to go to zero.
- 32:02Ryan: I think um Data Center Alley, the you know, the Loudoun County Loudoun County, Virginia, like Jane, 80, 90 percent of the 1.2 billion dollars in tax revenue last stirred for 2026.
- 32:13Ryan: Yeah, it's like 80 percent of what the of the tax base.
- 32:15Ryan: It's uh property tax.
- 32:17Ryan: Like there are so there are benefits.
- 32:19Ryan: And so I I just look at, you know, water is an issue that people talk about, but you can have closed systems and you know, you evaporate water, it's right, it rains back down on you eventually.
- 32:28Ryan: Um, noise, uh you know, there's a highway that's being built near my house, and they put up walls as barriers.
- 32:33Ryan: And that, you know, that's so these solutions there are solutions exist, but I think it's got it's happening so quickly, people just want to hit the red stop button.
- 32:41Jim: Yeah.
- 32:42Jim: Um, and politicians are I mean, that's their job.
- 32:44Jim: I mean, their job is to respond, you know.
- 32:46Jim: Yeah, it's like everyone's for democracy until people vote for something you don't like.
- 32:50Ryan: If 70% of people are against data centers and you're a politician, guess what?
- 32:55Jim: Look, isn't that I mean, it's not called the House of Leadership, it's called the House of Representatives, yeah.
- 32:59Jim: Right.
- 32:59Jim: So that they're doing what they're supposed to be doing.
- 33:03Jim: Yeah.
- 33:04Jim: Um, but even on the cost side, you asked about the cost before.
- 33:07Jim: Right.
- 33:07Jim: I mean, again, when we go back and look at these two separate market structures in the competitive markets, in those 15 states, we did a piece on this, it's on our website called Power Struggle Two.
- 33:19Jim: You can just graph out the wholesale prices.
- 33:21Jim: And, you know, they're kind of tracking the vertically integrated cost plus states.
- 33:26Jim: But in the last three or four years, they've diverged because demand is growing faster than supply.
- 33:30Jim: And in a competitive market, that almost always means prices go up.
- 33:34Jim: And in the cost plus states, what's happening is while inflation is affecting all costs, it's not affecting generation that much, which is really most of what a wholesale price is, because you're not moving it that far.
- 33:48Jim: And, you know, it's not all the small wires that run through a neighborhood that have, you know, get knocked down by trees.
- 33:53Jim: You know, at the end of the day, those wholesale prices have been essentially flat for the last three or four years.
- 34:00Jim: Because in fact, what's happening is any cost increase is being offset by a growth in volume.
- 34:04Jim: That revenue model is I take all my costs, divide by all my kilowatt hours in demand, and that's what everybody pays per kilowatt hour.
- 34:12Jim: And what what in talk, in terms of what you're just saying, the solution to this cost problem is making sure, and this is a state-level decision, um, although there's federal legislation in the permitting bill that just got through the Senate, it basically says you're gonna pay at a minimum the cost you're incurring on the system.
- 34:35Jim: But if I'm a state, I'm like, wait a minute, you want to get on this grid as soon as you can, because the grid has this giant mass to it that provides inertia and stability to your voltage and more importantly, the frequency, right?
- 34:49Jim: Because we have an alternating current system, right?
- 34:51Jim: It's you know, it goes from positive to negative 60 times a second.
- 34:54Jim: All of that quality is important to a user like a data center.
- 34:59Jim: We've spent all the money here before you ever showed up.
- 35:02Jim: And you know what?
- 35:03Jim: That cost has overhead, and you're gonna contribute to the costs, even because you're using it.
- 35:10Jim: You may not, you may not be incurring additional cost to that overhead, but you're benefiting from it.
- 35:15Jim: We're not gonna give it to you for free.
- 35:17Jim: Now, some states are desperate for the business and they will give it away for free.
- 35:20Jim: And other states are like, no, no, our our folks want to see bills go down.
- 35:25Jim: And so long as you can get contribution to existing overheads and existing fixed costs, then I'll remind you that, you know, residential rates in this country average 18 cents a kilowatt hour.
- 35:37Jim: 80% of that 18 cents are fixed costs.
- 35:41Jim: So if we can divide those fixed costs by more kilowatt hours, because we have those data centers contribute to overheads, you will actually see in the vertically integrated states, you will see those costs actually go down.
- 35:53Jim: Or if there's rampant inflation, they will go up less than they otherwise would have.
- 35:58Ryan: It seems like that would be a pretty strong incentive to build those data centers in the vertically integrated states.
- 36:04Jim: Yeah.
- 36:04Jim: Yeah.
- 36:05Jim: But again, speed to market matters.
- 36:07Jim: And so if you look at where the deregulated states, the there's 15 deregulated states, okay, and I'll just I'll just go through them here real quick.
- 36:15Jim: Okay, starting from West East, we'll move to West East.
- 36:16Jim: Oregon, California, Texas, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware.
- 36:22Jim: Now let's move north.
- 36:23Jim: New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, um, New Hampshire, and Maine.
- 36:30Jim: Those are the 15 states.
- 36:32Jim: But the new supply for data centers is going to be dominated by Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Texas.
- 36:39Jim: And what do those three states have in common?
- 36:42Jim: Well, they're either red or purple, and they have a lot of natural gas.
- 36:46Jim: And so if you've got so much natural gas coming out of the Permian that I don't have enough pipelines for it, it's like, well, why don't we just use it right here?
- 36:55Jim: What do you mean?
- 36:55Jim: Why don't I use it right here with a data center and run gas turbines with it?
- 36:59Jim: And so what you see is Pennsylvania and Texas passing laws and procedures to make sure that these data centers don't push up prices.
- 37:09Jim: And what that means is they're going to essentially for they're not forcing them, but the rules are going to be that these people are going to have to bring their own power because they're establishing rules, and they're called different things with different acronyms, that essentially say when we get to the peak demand in the summer, and in Texas, the summer and the winter peak demand, I'm not to say because a lot of um electric heat pumps down there.
- 37:32Jim: And so they have two peaks of the year that are roughly close, but north of the Mason-Dixon line, the summer peak is by far the dominant.
- 37:39Jim: Um, we get to one of those peaks, we're kicking you off the system.
- 37:42Jim: And we're not gonna ask and we're not gonna discuss it.
- 37:47Jim: It might not even be a phone call.
- 37:49Jim: It might be a switch that we throw.
- 37:50Jim: And then when we get around to calling you 10 minutes later, you know, you're gonna know your power is shut off.
- 37:56Jim: That's gonna force them to have all of this backup power.
- 38:00Jim: And sometime in the distant future, when the grid catches up, all of those reciprocating and single-stage turbines will still be there as backup for the system.
- 38:11Jim: So when we get on the other side of this build-out, we actually have a much more robust grid than we did before.
- 38:20Ryan: Do you think at that point, say, you know, 10 years down the road, um, that we'll have more nuclear power as well, sort of, especially, you know, we we talked a little bit about the small modular nuclear reactors.
- 38:31Ryan: Is that uh, you know, part of the system, you think, 10 years from now?
- 38:35Jim: Yeah, I do.
- 38:36Jim: Um I'm I'm you know, me, I'm loath to make predictions.
- 38:39Jim: But as I said in our in the last time we spoke, when you look at big tech support for clean energy um and sort of the, you know, energy cost is not as significant to them, but obviously it is small relative to speed to market and the world that they compete in.
- 39:00Jim: Um, and they don't want to be held back by it.
- 39:02Jim: And so they are taking this detour away from clean energy because they have a competitive imperative to get going with the data centers and natural gas, the only way to do that.
- 39:14Jim: Um, so they will come back to that.
- 39:17Jim: But it in more of an investment horizon, what you're seeing is that existing nuclear is being sort of tied up in agreements between the, and most of these are publicly traded, almost they're all publicly traded.
- 39:32Jim: So there's four publicly integrated, publicly traded independent power producers.
- 39:37Jim: And that is where for the independent, you know, with independent companies that own nuclear, they're all publicly traded.
- 39:45Jim: And what they're doing is they're combining an agreement with Meta or Google or Microsoft or Amazon to add capacity to existing nuclear power plants.
- 39:56Jim: So you can call it an uprate.
- 39:58Jim: You're gonna uprate it by putting in more equipment.
- 40:01Jim: Um, but they're gonna combine that with a long-term fixed price contract.
- 40:07Jim: And so what's happening is, and we had an announcement just yesterday or the day before, um, and uh between Constellation, one of those publicly rated companies, and um uh and one of the and and the and the big hyperscalers saying, look, we're we're we have these upright capabilities across our fleet, but we're not gonna do it on a merchant basis.
- 40:30Jim: We need an agreement.
- 40:31Jim: And by the way, since I have you in the room and we're signing an agreement, I'm gonna make you sign an agreement for the existing power that you're buying.
- 40:39Jim: And by the way, it's gonna be a premium to the wholesale price because you're tying it up, you're taking it away from the public, and it's clean.
- 40:49Jim: And you have your, you have that has value to you, I'm gonna charge you for it.
- 40:53Jim: And so these deals have been announced over the last couple, you know, most of them have been announced in the last six to seven months, and one of them was announced yesterday.
- 41:02Jim: Um, in terms of the new technologies, again, I I've said this my whole career, you want to bet against the engineers long term, I'll take the other side of the bet.
- 41:12Jim: Always.
- 41:13Jim: They always come through.
- 41:16Jim: And you say, well, only if there's an economic incentive.
- 41:19Jim: And it's like, I agree, but we are beyond the economic incentives.
- 41:23Jim: Nuclear power is a strategic national security issue for the United States.
- 41:29Jim: The military needs always available power.
- 41:32Jim: Um, they want small module reactors.
- 41:35Jim: They, you know, they and again, you know, you say, well, they can have small gas turbines, but then they're dependent on a pipeline.
- 41:41Jim: So it's sort of like they want to be islanded.
- 41:43Jim: They want to have complete ability to get cut off from the rest of the world and still operate.
- 41:48Jim: And so, and obviously big tech has a strategic imperative to have always available power that's that's zero carbon.
- 41:54Jim: So it's not just economic.
- 41:56Jim: And to the extent that you have two very large strategic buyers that have a seemingly endless supply of free cash flow, tax dollars from one and revenue from the other, um, it seems like, you know, this is this is the best chance you're gonna get in a generation for getting these new technologies actually up and running and getting them cost competitive.
- 42:21Jim: Any thoughts on uh fuel cells?
- 42:23Jim: Yeah.
- 42:24Jim: So fuel cells that are going in use natural gas.
- 42:28Jim: Um, so they just they they convert the natural gas to electrons without you know combusting it in a sort of a conventional way, but they still, they still emit water, carbon dioxide, and to some degrees nice nitrous oxide.
- 42:43Jim: So there's no real pollution benefit there, but there's a speed-to-market benefit.
- 42:47Jim: And so whether that machine is burning natural gas to to you know kinetically spin a turbine, or whether it's using natural gas across a membrane to capture the ions and put those right directly into, you know, an electric circuit.
- 43:06Jim: Um, in each case, they're being sort of fueled by natural gas.
- 43:10Jim: And um so there is there is a big build out also of the fuel cells.
- 43:16Jim: They are about 35% more expensive than the gas turbines and the reciprocating engines.
- 43:23Jim: But again, when the companies that make those reciprocating engines and uh and single stage turbines, and by the way, they're all expanding their capacity, are going as fast as they can, and there's still not enough.
- 43:34Jim: And the fuel cell guys are like, you know, I can make fuel cells.
- 43:38Jim: And it's like, well, why wouldn't I take that?
- 43:40Ryan: But there's not a there's not a um emission advantage for the fuel cells relative to the There's a slight admission advantage because you're not actually combusting it.
- 43:48Jim: Yeah.
- 43:48Jim: But in terms of, you know, at the end of the day, you're still generating carbon dioxide.
- 43:53Jim: I mean, you have, you know, you you still have to take the you have to take that molecule apart.
- 43:59Jim: Yeah.
- 43:59Jim: Um That that methane, which is, which is one carbon and four hydrogens, and you have to extract the electrons from it by combining that with oxygen in the atmosphere, and that creates uh H2O from the hydrogen and carbon dioxide from the carbon.
- 44:19Ryan: Okay, so um let's let's pivot a little bit because we've been talking about all a lot of a lot of what we've been talking about with data centers and infrastructure and all these other um sort of big building projects depend on financing.
- 44:34Ryan: And a lot of that has shifted more towards debt and interest rates are kind of soaring.
- 44:40Ryan: They've I mean we're reaching levels on the tenure that we haven't seen in decades.
- 44:44Ryan: Right.
- 44:45Ryan: And so I'm curious where you think we are gonna peak.
- 44:50Ryan: Again, you're loath to make forecasts, but I'll ask anyways.
- 44:54Jim: Yeah, no, I mean there's definitely a supply-demand issue with debt.
- 44:58Jim: Um, you know, total debt matters, but it also matters who holds the debt.
- 45:04Jim: Right.
- 45:05Jim: Right.
- 45:05Jim: So again, think about how big capital markets are.
- 45:09Jim: Subprime debt was only a trillion dollars.
- 45:12Jim: Okay.
- 45:12Jim: I mean, the stock market goes up and down by a trillion dollars a day.
- 45:16Jim: It's a rounding error.
- 45:17Jim: But if that trillion dollars of debt is held at investment banks that are levered 35 to one, in the case of Deutsche Bank, 50 to one, then it matters who holds that debt.
- 45:29Jim: It's not just the trillion dollars.
- 45:30Jim: It's where is whose balance sheet does it sit on?
- 45:33Jim: Right.
- 45:33Jim: And so, you know, at a time when Morgan Stanley was almost one bankrupt, they had a trillion dollars of assets and they had, you know, what was it, you know, $35 uh billion dollars of shareholder equity.
- 45:48Jim: So my suggestion was a sign across, you know, the entrance to Morgan Stanley every day that says, folks, we're levered 35 to one.
- 45:56Jim: So a small screw up means we're all out of business.
- 45:58Jim: Like a 3% drop on our assets, we're insolvent.
- 46:01Jim: The debt is being taken on by companies that don't have any debt so far, and they have huge free cash flow.
- 46:08Jim: Because remember, these companies were net cash on the balance sheet and were buying back stock like crazy because they couldn't put all that money to work.
- 46:15Jim: Now they have found that in fact they need to build things made of concrete and steel that run power and stuff like that, and they're borrowing money for the first time.
- 46:24Jim: And so it's not as if their Morgan Stanley levered 35 to one, but they they are no longer net cash on the balance sheet.
- 46:33Jim: But it doesn't matter the way you ask the question, there's a supply-demand imbalance for that debt.
- 46:39Jim: There, they are certainly part of, you know, what's what's putting upward pressure on uh, you know, on you know, on on deals by coming to the market with all this.
- 46:51Jim: This there's always so much appetite, especially when the market's falling.
- 46:54Jim: It's sort of like, well, why don't I why don't I just wait, you know, until next year when, you know, the tenure is at five and a half or six or whatever.
- 47:01Jim: I'll buy the bonds then.
- 47:04Ryan: So I've I know these are huge, uh, huge issuance of debt from these companies, but I I was listening to the uh radio earlier today, and and there there was a woman that was talking about those companies having a crowding out effect on the treasury, which I've always thought of it the opposite way.
- 47:22Ryan: The government, you know, crowds out private.
- 47:24Ryan: Um and so I I guess when you get to a certain size that, you know, you you're you're gonna have an impact on the rest of the market.
- 47:31Ryan: But um, it seems odd that corporate debt would crowd out treasury debt.
- 47:36Jim: I know.
- 47:37Jim: Well, the well, there's always this issue of who's crowding out who.
- 47:39Jim: Yeah.
- 47:40Jim: And um, but the other thing is the old frog on the hot water thing.
- 47:43Jim: I mean, this is happening so fast that I think the temperature on the water for the frog, you know, kind of had a kind of a little bit of a jump up.
- 47:52Jim: And the frog is like thinking now, he wasn't even worried about it before.
- 47:55Jim: Now he's thinking about jumping out of the pond.
- 47:57Jim: And you see it, you you see that you see that in the bond market, I guess.
- 48:01Jim: But at the end of the day, the asset side of the balance sheet matters too.
- 48:06Jim: The risk is that people are putting assets on the ground that aren't worth what they cost.
- 48:12Jim: Right.
- 48:13Jim: And so whenever you look at US debt or corporate debt or whatever, you have to look at in the context of the assets that that debt was financing, the value of those assets, as determined by GDP if you're a country, or profitability if you're, if you're a company.
- 48:29Jim: And that really, at the end of the day, is the question is all of the, because yeah, these guys, the the publicly traded hyperscalers, just those four companies are trillion a year at this point.
- 48:41Jim: The exit rate for 2026 is going to be close to a trillion a year.
- 48:45Jim: And so that doesn't include all the other guys and doesn't include all the stuff that they are leasing.
- 48:50Ryan: Right.
- 48:51Jim: I mean, because remember, they're taking on lease obligations in addition to this debt.
- 48:55Jim: Yeah.
- 48:55Jim: And so the question ultimately is what is the profitability of this investment?
- 49:00Jim: Right.
- 49:00Jim: Because if it's there, then the debt will be born.
- 49:03Ryan: Yeah.
- 49:04Ryan: Yeah.
- 49:04Ryan: And obviously they're not going to do it if they don't believe that it's there, but none of us knows the future.
- 49:09Jim: So I mean, no, but yeah, but it's sort of like, you know, it's like this is why they teach in business school.
- 49:13Jim: You know, management's irrational and they make these high-end PP investments.
- 49:16Jim: So it's like, I want to go to these college professors, like, have you ever met any of these people?
- 49:20Jim: I mean, they're human beings.
- 49:21Jim: They make mistakes, they get excited about projects, they see their competitors doing it.
- 49:26Jim: Well, we can't, we can't be left behind.
- 49:28Jim: The other guy's doing it, we have to do it too.
- 49:30Jim: Yeah.
- 49:30Jim: And so, you know, what becomes what goes from being an offensive idea about saying we have this new product, it becomes defensive.
- 49:38Jim: Like if we don't do it, we're gonna lose business.
- 49:41Jim: And now you start defending yourself into unprofitability.
- 49:44Jim: Right.
- 49:45Jim: It's called about it's like a pre-vent defense in football.
- 49:47Jim: Never works.
- 49:48Jim: It doesn't work.
- 49:49Jim: You let them get 15 yards on every pass, and then you know, if they've got a minute left on the clock, that's more than enough time for them to score.
- 49:56Jim: Right.
- 49:56Jim: So if you play to lose, you're gonna play to not lose, you're probably gonna lose.
- 50:01Ryan: You have to play to win.
- 50:02Ryan: All right.
- 50:03Ryan: So I can't let the opportunity talking about interest rates go by without asking you a question that I've asked before that I know the answer to, but I want to give you an opportunity to talk about the relationship between utilities and interest rates.
- 50:16Ryan: Yeah.
- 50:16Jim: So interest rates matter for all financial assets.
- 50:19Jim: Right.
- 50:20Jim: And they matter as a function of their duration.
- 50:23Jim: Right.
- 50:24Jim: And so obviously a long-dated bond is hurt more than a short-dated bond.
- 50:27Jim: You say, well, okay, but that's bonds.
- 50:29Jim: We're talking about equities.
- 50:29Jim: Well, equities have duration too.
- 50:31Jim: Imagine you have a company that's trading at 10 times earnings, um, it's paying out all its earnings because it really doesn't have any growth opportunities.
- 50:37Jim: And you could say this was, you know, this was Altria just a few years ago and I'm almost a 10% yield.
- 50:42Jim: It's like, oh, it's cigarettes, they're shrinking, you know, and they're raising their prices, the two offset each other.
- 50:45Jim: So, okay, you know, it's like, you know, okay, I'll collect a 10% yield.
- 50:48Jim: That's roughly the expected return, you know, on the market.
- 50:51Jim: Well, it's very short duration because the dividend's getting paid every quarter, right?
- 50:56Jim: There's no expectation of growth.
- 50:58Jim: So a high PE stock has a high duration.
- 51:02Jim: A low PE stock with a high yield has a low duration.
- 51:04Jim: And utilities are all towards the low end because, you know, they have three, three and a half percent yield, whatever it is.
- 51:09Jim: You're getting, and let's say this is a 10% expected return, you know, you're getting a third of your expected return every quarter.
- 51:16Jim: That's a much lower duration than a company that doesn't pay a dividend trading at 35 times earnings.
- 51:21Jim: So that's the first thing on the sort of the economic theory of it.
- 51:24Jim: The second one is just like, well, what do we observe?
- 51:26Jim: And the answer is you what you observe is that when there's an interest rate event like non-farm Fridays and CPI Wednesdays, I guess.
- 51:36Jim: Um, and if there's a big number, then you will see bonds move, you will see a move from risk to off, you know, risk on to risk off, or vice versa.
- 51:46Jim: And you will see that utilities, healthcare, and consumer staples get caught up in that.
- 51:52Jim: But then you say, well, what happened over the next month, the next 22 or 23 trading days?
- 51:58Jim: And the answer is it goes right back to zero.
- 52:01Jim: And so we've put together a piece on this where you can see that people's perception of this is driven by those one-day events.
- 52:08Jim: And then the data tells you you should fade whichever way it went.
- 52:14Jim: If it went up, you should sell a little bit, it goes down, you should buy a little bit because because 22 or 23 trading days later, the correlation is right back to zero.
- 52:23Jim: So when we look at the correlation on anything like a two, three, four-month holding period of the utilities versus a 10-year treasury, it's a zero, it's a zero correlation.
- 52:34Jim: And so that that's on average over 25, 30 years.
- 52:39Jim: It doesn't mean that within that, you have periods of time where they're anti-correlated and periods of time where they're correlated and the two offset each other.
- 52:47Jim: And so the average is zero, but it doesn't mean you don't have these runs, like a coin flip.
- 52:50Jim: It's always going to be 50-50 if you do a million of them, but you can have a run of 10 heads in a row.
- 52:55Jim: And so when we have everybody freaking out because the 10-year breached 5%, then people's initial reaction is to say, I'm going to sell the utilities because they're bond substitutes.
- 53:08Jim: And it's like, in your mind only, are they a bond substitute?
- 53:11Jim: Because in reality, they're not bonds at all.
- 53:13Jim: They are equities.
- 53:14Jim: And the consensus average growth rate for the utility index today is 9% a year for earnings over the next three to five years.
- 53:24Jim: It's the highest it's been since, I don't know, the years after World War II.
- 53:28Jim: So these are not bonds.
- 53:30Jim: They are equities that grow.
- 53:31Jim: And by the way, while the growth rate of the SBI 100 earnings now is like low double digits, mid-double digits, the long-term average is 7%.
- 53:39Jim: So the utility's growth rate now, which is kind of locked in from all of these contracts, and because remember, they're a cost plus system, right?
- 53:48Jim: So they put capital on the ground, they get an allowed rate of return on it.
- 53:50Jim: It's not a margin issue.
- 53:52Jim: They have a growth rate now that's 200 basis points a year faster than the long-term average of the SP 500.
- 53:59Jim: And so they aren't bonds, they're stocks.
- 54:02Jim: And so when you see a move like this, it's like they will go back to being equities, which they are, and you will go, you know, again, we'll we'll run the data five years from now, whatever, you will see the exact same almost zero correlations on any kind of holding period longer than a couple of days.
- 54:22Jim: So the conventional wisdom is not borne out by the data.
- 54:25Jim: It's just not.
- 54:26Jim: It's just not.
- 54:26Jim: And so what that means is, you know, rather than spend all your time wringing your hands trying to predict interest rates, just wait for it to happen.
- 54:34Jim: Because history and common sense and economic theory and observable data points going back decades will tell you what you want to do is fade that move.
- 54:45Jim: Either way.
- 54:46Jim: Interesting, either way.
- 54:48Ryan: Well, um, we have used up uh most of our time again, and I'm gonna finish this uh podcast with the way I have the last couple, and that is to ask you for a book recommendation.
- 54:59Ryan: Sure.
- 55:00Ryan: Um what are you what are you reading these days?
- 55:02Ryan: And uh what would you recommend that we check?
- 55:04Jim: So um the uh the the the subject that I think people uh would do well to learn a little bit more about is the Supreme Court in this country.
- 55:15Jim: Because there's there's a lot of back and forth about whichever side of the political your aisle on what's going on in the Supreme Court.
- 55:23Jim: And a little historical perspective would be valuable.
- 55:26Jim: Um and so there's a couple of books that I've just finished recently, because they were they're actually written.
- 55:32Jim: One was written earlier this year, the other was written in November of 2014.
- 55:36Jim: But the uh the first book you want to read, because it's short, is called Last Branch Standing.
- 55:42Jim: And it's um Sarah Isger um is the author, and this was published in April of this year.
- 55:49Jim: And she will take you through why, when you understand how justices vote, it's not as simple.
- 55:54Jim: Are they left, are they right, or are they in the middle?
- 55:58Jim: There are other axes that you need to consider, and she will kind of tell you that the nine Supreme Court justices kind of break down into three categories with three justices in each category, and that's why the outcome of their votes is not solely driven by their sort of, you know, how politically liberal or conservative they are.
- 56:19Jim: And then she gives you a reading list at the end of the book, and uh the best book in that reading list is um is called The Most Powerful Court in the World.
- 56:28Jim: Um, and I think that's the most powerful court in the world.
- 56:31Jim: And Stuart Banner wrote that, and that was published in November of 24.
- 56:35Jim: And it is a history of the Supreme Court.
- 56:38Jim: Um, and I've done a lot of reading on the Supreme Court.
- 56:40Jim: I listened to lectures on it, and this one was even more detailed, and it will give you some perspective about how political you think this court is, because there was a time in the past when justices were politicians first.
- 56:54Jim: They were not legal scholars.
- 56:55Jim: They did not work their way through the appeal system, which is really a relatively recent phenomenon.
- 57:02Jim: Um, and as political as people think these folks are, they on average are multitudes more qualified because they came through the Appellate process, and there is a such a high percentage of them that have graduated from the top law schools.
- 57:20Jim: And I'm not talking about the top 20, I'm talking about the top two or three law schools in the country.
- 57:24Jim: That was not the case 100 years ago.
- 57:26Jim: So a little perspective is worthwhile.
- 57:30Jim: And I would just add to that, instead of reading what the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal says about a Supreme Court opinion, just go to SCOTUS.com and download the damn thing and read it yourself.
- 57:43Jim: And then come back and say, is this newspaper article telling you the whole story?
- 57:47Jim: They are not difficult to read.
- 57:49Jim: They are written for lay people.
- 57:51Jim: And so if you want to shorten it, my recommendation to people is read what's known as the syllabus.
- 57:57Jim: They're generally five pages, and it is a summary of the majority opinion, which may be 60 pages.
- 58:04Jim: Read the syllabus and then go read the first dissenting opinion, which is not going to be a hundred pages.
- 58:11Jim: It'll be 15, 20.
- 58:13Jim: If you read those two things, you'll get both sides of the argument in summary form.
- 58:19Jim: And you'd be surprised at how easy they are to read.
- 58:22Jim: It is not full of legal jargon.
- 58:24Jim: Remember, except for on constitutional issues, the judges are lay people too, but they're present and they are presented with a case in an industry or a situation that they are not experts on any more than you and I are.
- 58:39Jim: And so they have to understand that case in laypersons' terms.
- 58:43Jim: And so they write their opinions in laypersons' terms.
- 58:46Jim: They're much easier to read than most people think.
- 58:48Ryan: I do like the Cliff's notes, uh, reading the syllabus idea.
- 58:51Ryan: Syllabus is great for those almost always a constrained time.
- 58:54Ryan: It it is, I haven't read uh a ton of uh Supreme Court decisions, but um it it has surprised me when I have uh how well some of them write.
- 59:04Ryan: They're they're you know, kind of clever turns of phrase and kind of interesting um for those that have time to read Supreme Court decisions.
- 59:12Jim: Yeah, people spend all this time reading newspaper articles, but it's just like, you know, just you know, just take a little bit of that time and just read the original document rather than what someone says about.
- 59:22Jim: Yeah.
- 59:22Jim: I mean, in our research and our company, that's critical.
- 59:25Jim: We're always on the phone or on a plane, going and getting the the information from the source, not filtered through two or three other people.
- 59:34Jim: That's how you find out how things actually Yeah.
- 59:38Ryan: And and I I think to your point, listening to, you know, corporate conference calls and the way an answer to a question is presented firsthand as opposed to what a reporter said that they said.
- 59:49Jim: And then, you know, talk to the management when they're not on a broadcast.
- 59:52Jim: Right.
- 59:53Jim: Or talk not to the CEO, but when you're on a field trip, the guy who's the factory manager, and talk to him, get him or her off to the side, and then just have them, you know, you're not trying to get in material, not pumpkin.
- 1:00:04Jim: You're saying, you know, like Bob or Sue, just explain to me how this machine works.
- 1:00:08Jim: Why does the machine cost so much?
- 1:00:09Jim: You know, why do you buy this machine and your competitor buy that machine?
- 1:00:12Jim: Just trying to understand the business on a more mechanical level.
- 1:00:16Jim: And it's what you find is that so much of what's talked about is just people repeating what someone else said.
- 1:00:24Jim: It's just like what they it's hear set, basically.
- 1:00:27Jim: It's not the original, it's not the original eyewitness to what's actually going on.
- 1:00:31Jim: Yeah.
- 1:00:33Ryan: Thanks for uh thanks for the book recommendation.
- 1:00:35Ryan: Once again, thanks for coming on the podcast.
- 1:00:37Ryan: It's always uh a great conversation, very insightful.
- 1:00:40Ryan: Um, and uh I always learned something.
- 1:00:42Ryan: So thanks.
- 1:00:42Ryan: Yeah, well, thanks for having me.
- 1:00:43Ryan: It's always great to do these things.
- 1:00:44Ryan: Thanks to all of you as well for joining us on this episode, the First Trust ROI podcast.
- 1:00:49Ryan: We'll see you next time.