Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Navigating Trust Taxation in California: A Guide for Practitioners
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to our program, Navigating Trust Taxation
- 0:06in California, A Guide for Practitioners. We
- 0:09are thrilled to have you join us today. My name
- 0:12is Jacqueline Yoo, and I'm the co -chair of the
- 0:14Beverly Hills Bar Association Trust and Estate
- 0:17section. Before we begin, I'd like to take a
- 0:20moment to introduce Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy
- 0:23of the Sanborn team. Nancy and Brian have been
- 0:26the official sponsor of this section since 2006.
- 0:29That's nearly 20 years. Nancy and Brian, please
- 0:33say hello. Thank you, Jacqueline. We just wanted
- 0:35to take a quick moment to recognize California
- 0:38Title, which is one of the sponsors of this section.
- 0:43When it comes to probate and court related sales,
- 0:46having a great title company in your corner can
- 0:49make all the difference. Every time we get ready
- 0:53to list a property, we order a preliminary title
- 0:56report. And you cannot believe how messy some
- 0:59of these things might really be. Someone says
- 1:02if people have led their life messy, so is their
- 1:05title. And anyway, and our title officer that
- 1:09we work with takes the time to go through the
- 1:13title and list any red flags so that we're able
- 1:16to clear everything up in advance. Believe me,
- 1:19this saves everyone a mega, I can't tell you
- 1:23how much time it saves if you do it in advance.
- 1:26There's nothing worse than having a title problem
- 1:28if you get ready to close an escrow. So a big
- 1:31shout out to California Title and especially
- 1:34Bill Thomas who always keeps us out of trouble
- 1:37and just makes the process smoother for everyone.
- 1:39So thank you, everyone. Enjoy the meeting. Thank
- 1:43you, Nancy and Brian. In addition to the Sanborn
- 1:45team, the trust and estate section is also sponsored
- 1:48by Bond Services of California, Liberty Mutual
- 1:52Surety, California Title Company, and Pickford
- 1:56Escrow Company. Now I'd like to turn things over
- 1:59to Rochelle Schultz to provide this month's legal
- 2:03updates. Hi, good afternoon. Today I will describe
- 2:07the case of a state of Roland versus commissioner.
- 2:10In this tax court case, the executor of Faye
- 2:12Roland's estate filed a late estate tax return
- 2:15to make a portability election, but the return
- 2:18estimated the value of the estate and did not
- 2:20provide any information as to the value of the
- 2:23particular assets. Faye's return reflected a
- 2:26dissuie amount of more than $3 .7 million. When
- 2:30Faye's husband Billy later died, The executor
- 2:33of Billy's estate timely filed an estate tax
- 2:35return for his estate reporting phase to suey
- 2:38amount and an estate tax of about $4 .5 million.
- 2:42After Billy's return was selected for audit,
- 2:45the IRS determined that Billy's estate was ineligible
- 2:49to fit to claim phase to suey because phase return
- 2:52was not timely filed and to be deemed timely.
- 2:55The return had to satisfy the requirements of
- 2:58revenue procedure 2017 -34. which required a
- 3:03complete and properly prepared return made in
- 3:06accordance with Treasury Regulation Section 20
- 3:09-2010 -2A7. But Fay's return was not a complete
- 3:15and properly prepared return because it failed
- 3:17to provide valuation information and was not
- 3:20eligible to estimate the value of the estate.
- 3:23The tax court wholly agreed with the IRS and
- 3:26held that as a matter of law, phase return failed
- 3:29to make a timely DSUI election under the revenue
- 3:31procedure, and Billy's estate therefore cannot
- 3:34port the DSUI amount to reduce its taxable estate.
- 3:38Although the revenue procedure in this case has
- 3:40been superseded, the current current revenue
- 3:43procedure includes the same requirement. To make
- 3:46a valid portability election, the executor must
- 3:49do so on a complete and properly prepared estate
- 3:52tax return. This case is an instructive reminder
- 3:55of the importance of preparing an estate tax
- 3:57return in accordance with the applicable treasury
- 4:00regulation. Thank you, and I hope you enjoy the
- 4:02rest of the webinar. Thank you, Rochelle. Now,
- 4:07onto the program. Today's speaker is Sonia Woodruff.
- 4:13Sonia is an attorney for the California Franchise
- 4:16Tax Board, where she spent 15 years in the general
- 4:19tax law division, focusing on all aspects of
- 4:22personal income tax law. As the legal department
- 4:25subject matter expert on the taxation of trusts
- 4:28and estates, she advised on complex issues, including
- 4:31fiduciary income tax, residency determinations,
- 4:35and multi -state trust considerations. Before
- 4:38entering public service, Sonia practiced privately
- 4:41and probate estate planning, tax planning, and
- 4:44trust in estate litigation. Please welcome Sonia
- 4:48Woodruff. All right. Well, thank you, Jennifer.
- 4:52If you all will just bear with me for a moment
- 4:54while I share my screen, get my PowerPoint up.
- 5:02Okay, I hope you can all see my screen here.
- 5:10Oops. Sorry, just a moment. Okay. All right,
- 5:26well, good afternoon, everyone. And thank you
- 5:29so much for joining me today for this event about
- 5:31California income taxation of trusts. My name
- 5:35is Sonia Woodruff, and I am an attorney for at
- 5:38the California Franchise Tax Board, as Jennifer
- 5:40mentioned. I work in the General Tax Bureau,
- 5:43where I am the subject matter expert on the taxation
- 5:46of trusts in the states. But I also work on lots
- 5:49of different issues arising out of the personal
- 5:52income tax code. And I do believe I spoke to
- 5:55your Bar Association several years ago, but it
- 5:58has been quite a long time and we have seen a
- 6:01few new issues cropping up in the world of trust
- 6:03taxation since that time. So I'm excited to be
- 6:06back to talk about my favorite topic in state
- 6:09income taxation and that is the taxation of trusts.
- 6:15So one of the reasons that I so enjoy practicing
- 6:18in this area of the law is because trust tax,
- 6:21taxation is really distinct from other areas
- 6:24of tax. The rules related to trusts have been
- 6:28around since the very inception of our personal
- 6:30income tax code dating back to the 1930s. And
- 6:35that means that we're now in the position of
- 6:37applying nearly 100 year old codes to modern
- 6:41day fact patterns. And that can present a number
- 6:43of challenges. So I hope today's presentation
- 6:45can give you a basic sense of how trust taxation
- 6:49works in this state. Today, I'm going to start
- 6:53with an overview of the basics of trust taxation
- 6:55in California, including a discussion of the
- 6:58state's jurisdiction to tax trusts. And we will
- 7:01also go over the basic mechanics of trust rules,
- 7:05as well as some of the most common questions
- 7:08that arise over and over in this area. And finally,
- 7:12we're going to touch on a new development, and
- 7:15that is Revenue and Taxation Code Section 17082.
- 7:25Okay, so I'm mostly going to be covering laws
- 7:27reflected in the California Revenue and Taxation
- 7:30Code today, so I'm just going to refer to those
- 7:32by the section number. If I am referencing a
- 7:35different code, I will make sure to make a specific
- 7:37reference to that code section. But before I
- 7:41start jumping into the relevant code sections
- 7:43and start talking about the California laws,
- 7:46I want to make note of a couple of really basic
- 7:48premises about trust taxation. I'm sure most
- 7:51of you are aware of these concepts, but it never
- 7:54hurts to start at the very beginning. So first,
- 7:57the rules I referenced today apply to complex
- 8:00trusts rather than simple trusts. And a simple
- 8:03trust, of course, is one that distributes all
- 8:05of its current income, while a complex trust
- 8:08may hold and accumulate some of that income.
- 8:12Just like federal law, There is no second level
- 8:16of tax imposed on a trust in California. Income
- 8:20is either taxed at the trust level if it is accumulated
- 8:23or it is distributed to the beneficiary who will
- 8:26then report the income on their own personal
- 8:28return and pay the tax. So there are a couple
- 8:32of exceptions here, but California follows federal
- 8:34law on this matter. And the next point is that
- 8:38California conforms to the federal grantor trust
- 8:41rules. And those rules explain and define when
- 8:44a trust will be disregarded for income tax purposes.
- 8:47Those rules can be found in Internal Revenue
- 8:50Code Section 671 through 679. And just very briefly,
- 8:56those rules provide that when the grantors of
- 8:58a trust retain sufficient control over or interest
- 9:02in a trust, generally all of the trust's income
- 9:06deductions and credits will flow directly to
- 9:09the grantor's personal income tax return. So
- 9:12the rules we are covering today generally apply
- 9:15to the accumulated income of non -grantor trusts.
- 9:22Okay, so trusts are taxed under Part 10 of the
- 9:25Revenue and Taxation Code, and that's the Personal
- 9:27Income Tax Code. It may not seem particularly
- 9:30remarkable that trusts are included in Part 10
- 9:33of the Reven Tax Code, but this fact really reflects
- 9:37kind of a foundational concept, and that is that
- 9:40trusts are not actually taxable entities, but
- 9:43they are relationships between multiple parties.
- 9:47So trusts are taxed in the same manner as individuals
- 9:50to the extent possible. Now, of course, because
- 9:54trusts have multiple parties involved, they do
- 9:57require specific rules to clarify how and when
- 10:01they're taxable by California. So on this slide,
- 10:04you will see the main sections of the Revenue
- 10:06and Taxation Code containing these specific rules.
- 10:10Our tax imposition statutes are found in section
- 10:1317041E and I. That's down at the bottom of the
- 10:18slide there. And 17041E and subdivision I impose
- 10:23tax upon non -resident taxpayers, which include
- 10:27trusts. Chapter 9 of part 10, and that begins
- 10:31with section 17731, contains our general conformity
- 10:36with federal trust statutes, as well as what
- 10:39I like to think of as our residency rules for
- 10:42trusts. So trusts like individuals are taxed
- 10:49on two main jurisdictional grounds, and those
- 10:52are residence and source, source of the income.
- 10:56So this concept dates back to the seminal U .S.
- 10:59Supreme Court decision in Schaefer v. Carter
- 11:01from 1920, providing that states may tax residents
- 11:05within its borders and also non -residents receiving
- 11:09income earned within its borders. So Chapter
- 11:1510 applies both of these jurisdictional grounds
- 11:18to trust. And how does that work? Well, the basic
- 11:22idea is that trusts treated as residents are
- 11:25taxed on all of their net income. Trusts treated
- 11:29as non -residents are taxed only on sourced income.
- 11:33And trusts that are a combination of resident
- 11:36and non -resident factors are taxed on all of
- 11:40their California sourced income, plus a portion
- 11:43of any remaining income. Now, I want to caution
- 11:46you that really nowhere in the code, other than
- 11:49in the other state tax credit provisions, will
- 11:52you find a definition for the terms resident
- 11:54trust or non -resident trust. But I think it's
- 11:58probably the clearest way to think about some
- 12:00of these concepts. And by the way, the definition
- 12:03of resident trust for purposes of the OSTC is
- 12:07only valid for that provision. So for practical
- 12:10purposes, this means that income sourced to California
- 12:13under our ordinary sourcing rules, beginning
- 12:16with section 17951, will always be taxable when
- 12:20earned by a trust. The rules related to sourcing
- 12:24income to California are honestly quite complex
- 12:27and would require a separate hour -long presentation.
- 12:31So today I'm going to focus mostly on the rules
- 12:33related to when and how a trust will be taxed
- 12:37based on residency. If you would like more information
- 12:41on how to source income in California, I recommend
- 12:44starting with section 17951 and the many very
- 12:49dense regulations under that section, but the
- 12:52general idea is that income that derives from
- 12:55within the state's borders will be considered
- 12:57to be sourced to California. Okay, so how do
- 13:04you determine which trusts are treated as residents
- 13:06and which trusts are going to be taxed like non
- 13:09-residents? Well under section 17 -742, the entire
- 13:14taxable income of a trust is taxable in California
- 13:17if the fiduciary or non -contingent beneficiary
- 13:21resides in California. So California does not
- 13:25look to the residents of the set law. And this
- 13:28is very different from many other states. And
- 13:31in fact, California at one time did consider
- 13:34the residents of the set law in determining nexus
- 13:37to tax trusts. But that was changed way back
- 13:40in, I believe, 1937. And we really have not looked
- 13:44back since then. There are many other factors
- 13:47that other states look to, such as governing
- 13:50law designated by the trust instrument or where
- 13:53the trust is registered or domiciled. California
- 13:57really doesn't look at any of that. We focus
- 13:59primarily on the residents of the fiduciaries
- 14:02and the non -contingent beneficiaries to determine
- 14:05how to tax trusts based on California residents.
- 14:09And so it follows if there are no resident fiduciaries
- 14:12or non -contingent beneficiaries, the trust is
- 14:15going to be treated as a non -resident and taxed
- 14:18under section 17 -041i on all of its California
- 14:22source income. So a question that frequently
- 14:28comes up is who is going to be treated as a fiduciary
- 14:32under section 17 -742, thereby triggering California
- 14:36tax? Well, section 17 -006 gives us this very
- 14:42broad definition. Fiduciary means a guardian,
- 14:45trustee, executor, administrator, receiver, conservator,
- 14:49or any person, whether individual or corporate,
- 14:52acting in any fiduciary capacity for any person,
- 14:55estate, or trust. So as you can see from this
- 14:59definition, the drafters of this statute intended
- 15:01to reach every possible fiduciary -like person
- 15:04or entity that could be out there acting on behalf
- 15:07of a trust. And unfortunately, there is not a
- 15:10lot of authority out there to set any kind of
- 15:14parameters or definitions on who will be treated
- 15:18as a fiduciary under this statute. So this rule
- 15:21really must be kept in mind when looking at a
- 15:23trust because Modern trusts present many different
- 15:27types of roles. So in addition to an ordinary
- 15:31trustee, you may also have trust protectors or
- 15:34trust advisors, investment advisors, or distribution
- 15:38committee members, all kinds of different roles
- 15:40for various people and organizations. So for
- 15:44practical purposes, the FTB looks first to the
- 15:48trust instrument. to determine the named trustee
- 15:51of the trust. We will also look to the other
- 15:55parties acting on behalf of the trust in order
- 15:57to determine who is a fiduciary and whose role
- 16:00is really rising to the level of a fiduciary.
- 16:04We will also look to the practical realities
- 16:07of the trust as well. So if you have a traditional
- 16:11trust protector with just a standard right to
- 16:14remove and replace the trustee, That role is
- 16:17likely not going to be considered a fiduciary
- 16:20sufficient to trigger taxation of a trust in
- 16:24this state. But if the trust protector also holds
- 16:27other more significant roles under the trust
- 16:30instrument, that result may be different. So
- 16:33all of these factors will be weighed and taken
- 16:35into account in determining who is the fiduciary
- 16:39or fiduciaries for the trust. Okay, so 17 -742
- 16:46subdivision A tells us that trusts will be taxed
- 16:49by California if the fiduciary or beneficiary
- 16:52resides here. And for individual fiduciaries
- 16:55and beneficiaries, you determine residency using
- 16:59the ordinary residency rules beginning with section
- 17:0217 -014. Corporate fiduciaries, however, have
- 17:06a special rule, and that can be found under section
- 17:0917 -742B. So to determine residency for a corporate
- 17:14fiduciary, we look to the place where the corporation
- 17:17transacts the major portion of the administration
- 17:21of the trust. And this, again, is one of those
- 17:24rules that presents a lot of uncertainty in the
- 17:27modern era when many people could be working
- 17:29from home or from various locations. Books and
- 17:33records may not even necessarily be stored in
- 17:36a physical location anymore. And so the rule
- 17:39presents additional questions such as what activities
- 17:42are really considered administration of a trust.
- 17:46Does the residence of the corporate employee
- 17:48matter? And what if the corporation has subsidiaries
- 17:51in California? Well, Chief Counsel ruling 96
- 17:55-0681 addresses quite a few of these issues.
- 18:00And in that case, the trustee was a New York
- 18:02corporation acting as trustee for 27 different
- 18:05trusts. The corporation had a California subsidiary
- 18:09However, it was the New York Corporation that
- 18:11was the acting trustee. The portfolio manager
- 18:15for the trust wanted to move to California. And
- 18:18the question was under 17006 and 17742B, would
- 18:26his ongoing investment management on behalf of
- 18:29the trusts from California be enough to cause
- 18:34the trust to be taxed in this state? And the
- 18:37extent of the portfolio manager's involvement
- 18:39with the trust would consist of selecting the
- 18:43trust investment portfolio from a prescribed
- 18:46list. And so that ruling concluded that in this
- 18:50case, the portfolio manager's residence in this
- 18:52state would not cause the trusts to be taxed
- 18:55here because all of the remaining activities
- 18:58performed by the trust officer on behalf of the
- 19:01trust would be done from New York, including
- 19:03contacts with the beneficiaries, storing records,
- 19:08exercise of discretion to make trust distributions.
- 19:11the management of real estate investments, implementation
- 19:14of sales, and purchases of securities. So the
- 19:18ruling found that the major portion of the trust
- 19:21activities were therefore conducted outside of
- 19:24California, and the portfolio managers moved
- 19:27to California alone would not subject the trust
- 19:29to tax in this state. So a couple of points,
- 19:33it is really important to note that the ruling
- 19:35looked to both ministerial and managerial tasks.
- 19:39So you really have to look at the activities
- 19:42of a trust and determine where the major portion
- 19:45of that administration is happening. So it's
- 19:48going to be a very heavily factual analysis.
- 19:56Okay, so as we have already covered, If the trust
- 19:59has only one fiduciary who's a California resident,
- 20:03California will tax the entire taxable income
- 20:05of the trust. But when there are multiple fiduciaries
- 20:08residing inside and outside of California, Section
- 20:1217743 gives us the rule of apportionment for
- 20:17the non -California source income of the trust.
- 20:20And that section provides that where the taxability
- 20:23of income depends on the residence of the fiduciary,
- 20:26and there are two or more fiduciaries for the
- 20:28trust, the income taxable under Section 17742
- 20:32shall be apportioned according to the number
- 20:35of fiduciaries resident in this state. pursuant
- 20:38to rules and regulations prescribed by the Franchise
- 20:40Tax Board. The regulation under Section 17743
- 20:47then clarifies that when there are multiple fiduciaries
- 20:51residing inside and outside of California, the
- 20:55trust is taxable on a all net income from business
- 20:59carried on within this state, from real or tangible
- 21:03personal property located in this state, and
- 21:06from intangible personal property having a business
- 21:09or taxable situs in this state and then b a proportion
- 21:12of the net income from all other sources so this
- 21:16is that combination resident non -resident rule
- 21:20that I referenced earlier and it was this rule
- 21:23set forth in section 17743 and the regulation
- 21:27That was the subject of the challenge in Stoyer
- 21:30v. Franchise Tax Board, which was originally
- 21:32the appeal of Paula Trust before the Board of
- 21:35Equalization. So I'm going to be addressing that
- 21:37case a little bit later on in the presentation,
- 21:40but the opinion essentially affirmed California's
- 21:42application of Section 17743. Okay, so in addition
- 21:50to Section 1774 -3, there's a similar rule, a
- 21:54companion rule for taxing trusts based on the
- 21:56residence of the beneficiaries. Section 1774
- 22:00-4 provides a similar rule for trusts with multiple
- 22:03beneficiaries when they're residing in and out
- 22:06of California. The income of these trusts will
- 22:09be apportioned based on the number of resident
- 22:11non -contingent beneficiaries. And I do want
- 22:14to note that Section 1774 -3 does not actually
- 22:20specify that the income will be apportioned based
- 22:23on non -contingent beneficiaries. However, the
- 22:26regulation under that section does clarify that
- 22:30the section only applies to tax trusts based
- 22:33on non -contingent beneficiaries residing in
- 22:36California. Okay, so I've summarized legal ruling
- 22:43238 here for you and also provided a link to
- 22:46our website in case you'd like to take a look
- 22:48at that yourself. But just a note about the rulings
- 22:52on our website. They are arranged by date, so
- 22:55it's helpful to know that this ruling dates back
- 22:57to 1959. So, it's an oldie, but still a goodie
- 23:02and this ruling. provides an example of how to
- 23:05apply both Section 17743 and 17744 in those situations
- 23:11when a trust has multiple fiduciaries and beneficiaries
- 23:14residing in and out of California. So in this
- 23:17scenario, the trust income is $90 ,000. All income
- 23:22is derived from sources outside of California.
- 23:25The trust has three trustees, one of whom is
- 23:27a California resident, and the trust has two
- 23:30beneficiaries, one residing in California. And
- 23:36essentially, the way that it works is if the
- 23:39trust's non -California source income is a pie,
- 23:43it will get sliced up based first on the proportion
- 23:46of fiduciaries, and then anything left will be
- 23:48apportioned again based on the proportion of
- 23:50resident beneficiaries. So in this example, one
- 23:54-third of the income is taxed based on the fiduciary's
- 23:57residence. One -half of the remainder is taxed
- 24:00based on the beneficiary's residence. with a
- 24:03total of $60 ,000 becoming taxable by California
- 24:06out of the trust's total income, and $30 ,000
- 24:10would not be taxable. So this leads me to one
- 24:17of the most frequently asked questions when it
- 24:19comes to California income taxation of trusts,
- 24:21and that is the question of how to define a contingent
- 24:25beneficiary under Section 17742A. Well, the regulation
- 24:31under Section 17742 states only that a non -contingent
- 24:36beneficiary is one whose interest is not subject
- 24:39to a condition precedent. And the general rule
- 24:42is that a non -contingent beneficiary is one
- 24:45whose interest under the trust is ripe and vested.
- 24:50So there must be no conditions that must occur
- 24:52before the beneficiary is entitled to receive
- 24:55income or principal from the trust. A kind of
- 24:59a classic example of a contingent beneficiary
- 25:02is a beneficiary who must reach a particular
- 25:05age, say 21, before receiving any distributions
- 25:09from the trust. Until that beneficiary reaches
- 25:12age 21, they will be contingent under Section
- 25:1617 -742. Now I just want to know we will likely
- 25:26have a legal ruling coming out on this issue
- 25:28in the near future, but it seems pretty clear
- 25:31under the existing law at this point that trusts
- 25:34that rely on pure trustee discretion to make
- 25:37distributions will be deemed to have contingent
- 25:40beneficiaries. But there may still be. questions
- 25:44when there is any language in the trust that
- 25:47limits or directs the trustee's discretion in
- 25:50making decisions about distributions. So for
- 25:53example, a trust may provide for discretionary
- 25:56distributions, but then in a later provision,
- 25:58create a general power of appointment in the
- 26:00beneficiary. And of course, a general power of
- 26:03appointment is one that grants the beneficiary
- 26:05the power to appoint the assets of the trust
- 26:08in favor of anyone, including himself or herself,
- 26:12his estate, creditors or the creditors of the
- 26:14estate. So in that scenario, I think we would
- 26:17have to question whether the trustee discretion
- 26:20is really a condition precedent. Another similar
- 26:24example of a trust provision that I have seen
- 26:26is one in which the beneficiary has only discretionary
- 26:31distributions, but has the right to remove and
- 26:34replace the trustee at any point in time. So
- 26:37can the beneficiary's interest in the trust truly
- 26:40be considered contingent when the contingency
- 26:43at issue is within his own power to overcome?
- 26:47Or what about where the trust provides for discretionary
- 26:50distributions, but then provides the trustee
- 26:53with an ascertainable standard, such as health,
- 26:55education, maintenance, and support? Can this
- 26:58beneficiary be considered contingent when they
- 27:00have a right to receive income for HEMS? So these
- 27:04are all compelling questions to which Unfortunately,
- 27:07we do not have definitive answers, but it is
- 27:11FTB's position to scrutinize both the language
- 27:13of the trust instrument and the facts on the
- 27:16ground to determine whether a beneficiary's interest
- 27:19is truly contingent. And in the hypotheticals
- 27:22I've listed here today, those are all situations
- 27:25in which the FTB has taken the position that
- 27:27they create non -contingent interests. So finally,
- 27:32a question that often arises is whether a beneficiary
- 27:35is contingent or non -contingent when they have
- 27:38a right to receive the income, but not the principle
- 27:40of a trust. And the answer to that is the beneficiary
- 27:44will be non -contingent as to the income and
- 27:46non -contingent as to the principle when it is
- 27:49distributed. Okay, so that brings us to a very
- 27:56popular subject, and that is what is known as
- 27:59California the California throwback tax. And
- 28:03that's named, of course, for the federal rules
- 28:05imposing taxes on U .S. beneficiaries receiving
- 28:10distributions from certain foreign trusts. So
- 28:13it's important to note that California generally
- 28:15does not conform to the federal throwback provisions
- 28:18as we don't conform to most of the federal rules
- 28:22for taxing foreign trusts. However, we do have
- 28:25our own rule, and that's contained in Section
- 28:2717745. and that taxes trust distributions to
- 28:31California residents if the income was not already
- 28:34subjected to tax in this state. So 17745A essentially
- 28:40provides the general rule that if the trust should
- 28:43have should have paid tax due to residency but
- 28:46did not, then the income will be taxable when
- 28:49distributed to the beneficiary. But if the beneficiary
- 28:52is a non -resident, then only to the extent the
- 28:56income is sourced to California. Now 17745B is
- 29:01the section that trips up many taxpayers and
- 29:03representatives. And that section provides that
- 29:06if the trust has not paid California tax on accumulated
- 29:10income because the resident beneficiary's interest
- 29:13was contingent, then the income becomes taxable
- 29:16to the beneficiary when distributed or distributable.
- 29:20And it's easy to be tripped up here because the
- 29:23way that trust taxation works on the federal
- 29:26level is that accumulated income is typically
- 29:29taxed at the trust level. And when it is ultimately
- 29:32distributed to the beneficiary in a later year,
- 29:34it's not taxable because it is a distribution
- 29:37of previously taxed principal. However, under
- 29:41Section 17745B, California treats these accumulation
- 29:45distributions as subject to California tax. Subdivision
- 29:51C provides that the tax on the income under Subdivision
- 29:54A or B is a tax on the receipt of income and
- 29:58that accumulated income continues to be income
- 30:01even though the trust may allocate the income
- 30:03to corpus. So for example, if a trust with a
- 30:06non -resident trustee accumulates income for
- 30:09a California resident beneficiary, when the income
- 30:13is ultimately distributed, it will become taxable
- 30:15to the beneficiary, even though it may be recorded
- 30:18for trust accounting purposes as a tax -free
- 30:21distribution of principal at the federal level.
- 30:24So trustees will need to be aware of this rule
- 30:27and keep a record of distributions to California
- 30:29resident beneficiaries that may have been previously
- 30:32untaxed by the state. Subdivision D provides
- 30:37that the income will not be treated as received
- 30:40all in the year of the distribution. Instead,
- 30:43the beneficiary will have to calculate the taxes
- 30:46that would have been due if they had received
- 30:48that distribution rateably over a six -year period,
- 30:52including the year of distribution, or the period
- 30:55of accumulation, whichever period is shorter.
- 30:58And these amounts can be calculated and reported
- 31:00on Schedules J and Form 5870A. Now Section 17745E
- 31:11is also important to note because this gives
- 31:14us the general rule that if a resident beneficiary
- 31:17leaves the state and receives a distribution
- 31:20within 12 months, and then returns to the state
- 31:22within 12 months after the distribution, they
- 31:25will be presumed to have been a resident during
- 31:27that entire time. So in other words, you cannot
- 31:31become a non -resident for just one or two years
- 31:34to receive a large accumulation distribution
- 31:37and then move back to California without that
- 31:39distribution becoming taxable by this state.
- 31:45Okay, so everything that we have just covered
- 31:48constitutes kind of the quick and dirty mechanics
- 31:52of trust taxation rules in California. So I'd
- 31:55like to move on to a few of the most important
- 31:57cases in the area that give us a little more
- 32:00perspective on the rules. And the first case
- 32:05I'd like to touch on is hardly new, but it is
- 32:08a seminal one on the issue of California taxation
- 32:10of trust. And that's the California Supreme Court
- 32:13decision in McCulloch v. Franchise Tax Board.
- 32:16The main holding of the McCulloch decision is
- 32:19that California's system of taxing trusts and
- 32:22specifically taxing trusts based on the residence
- 32:24of the fiduciary and beneficiary is constitutional.
- 32:29In that case, the taxpayer was both the beneficiary
- 32:32and co -trustee of a trust that had accumulated
- 32:35income for five years, during which time the
- 32:38beneficiary had resided in California. The trust
- 32:41made a distribution to the beneficiary, and the
- 32:44FTB sought to tax those distributions under Section
- 32:4717745. The taxpayer objected, contending that
- 32:51the accumulated trust income of prior years could
- 32:54not properly be subjected to California income
- 32:57tax in the year plaintiff received it. And the
- 33:00court rejected that argument, finding that the
- 33:03beneficiary's residence in California alone would
- 33:06be sufficient to subject the trust to liability
- 33:08for state income taxes on its undistributed income.
- 33:13The court stated, this statutory system of taxing
- 33:16trusts, as we shall explain, encounters no constitutional
- 33:19prohibitions. The constitutional validity of
- 33:22a tax by the state of residence of the trustee
- 33:25on accumulated net income appears to have acceptance
- 33:28by the United States Supreme Court. The court,
- 33:31however, has not yet had occasion to decide the
- 33:33validity of a tax with respect to accumulated
- 33:36income, where the trustee is a nonresident and
- 33:39the tax is founded on residence of the beneficiary.
- 33:42We find no reason in constitutional principles
- 33:45or in practical application of such principles
- 33:48why the tax founded upon the residence of the
- 33:50beneficiary should not be sustained. We shall
- 33:53point out that just as the protection and benefits
- 33:55afforded by the state of the residence of the
- 33:57trustee serve as the basis for the constitutionality
- 34:00of the tax as to him, so do those factors serve
- 34:04as the basis for the constitutionality of the
- 34:06tax as to the beneficiary. And the court further
- 34:10stated, the tax imposed by California upon the
- 34:12beneficiary is constitutionally supported by
- 34:15sufficient connection with and protection afforded
- 34:17to the plaintiff as such beneficiary. Plaintiff
- 34:20in the instant case has in his role as beneficiary
- 34:23during the years of his residence in the state
- 34:25enjoyed the protection accorded by California
- 34:27for his eventual receipt of these assets. California
- 34:31grants the beneficiary the interim protection
- 34:33of its laws so that he may ultimately obtain
- 34:35the benefit of the accumulated income. So that's
- 34:40a pretty full -throated affirmation of beneficiary
- 34:46residence based taxation. So one little oddity
- 34:50about the McCulloch case that I want to note
- 34:52is that the taxpayer in this case was a beneficiary,
- 34:55but he was also one of the three co -trustees
- 34:58of the trust. So really the trust should have
- 35:00been paying tax on one third of the accumulated
- 35:04income during that period of accumulation. based
- 35:07on his residence in California. But the trust
- 35:09did not pay taxes during those years. And the
- 35:12court in McCulloch did not really address that.
- 35:15It states upfront instead that it is opining
- 35:18only on the income that was being distributed
- 35:21to the taxpayer and taxed under the throwback
- 35:23provision. And so that may have been just a procedural
- 35:27issue. It seems that the FTB assessed only the
- 35:31beneficiary once he received the distribution.
- 35:33And because the trust was not a party to the
- 35:35litigation, the court did not address its liability
- 35:38under the law. But in any case, McCulloch stands
- 35:42for the basic notion that California may tax
- 35:46accumulated earnings of resident beneficiaries
- 35:48once they are distributed. And it essentially
- 35:51affirms the constitutionality of Section 17745.
- 35:56Just to give you some historical context on this
- 35:58decision. The opinion was issued in 1964, just
- 36:03one year after the California legislature had
- 36:05amended Section 17742 and added Section 17745.
- 36:11So previously, Section 17742 contained no language
- 36:15about beneficiary contingency. So, in other words,
- 36:19the state tax trusts based on the residence of
- 36:22any beneficiaries, including contingent ones.
- 36:25Now, many parties raised concerns about this
- 36:28language, and the legislature amended the statute
- 36:31so that the tax only applied to tax trusts with
- 36:34resident, non -contingent beneficiaries. And
- 36:37that turned out to be some excellent foresight,
- 36:40as we will see in this next case. Okay, so jumping
- 36:45forward quite a number of years here to 2019,
- 36:49North Carolina v. Kimberly Rice Kessner Trust
- 36:52versus the North Carolina Department of Revenue
- 36:58v. Kimberly Rice Kessner Family Trust. 2019 U
- 37:04.S. Supreme Court decision, and the facts of
- 37:07this case included a family trust created by
- 37:10a New York resident, Grant Orr, who appointed
- 37:13a fellow New York resident to serve as trustee.
- 37:15The trust agreement granted the trustee absolute
- 37:19discretion to distribute the trust assets to
- 37:22the beneficiaries. And in 1997, one of the beneficiaries,
- 37:26Kimberly Rice Kessner, moved to North Carolina
- 37:28with her family and the family trust was later
- 37:31divided into sub trusts. North Carolina sought
- 37:35to tax the Kimberly Rice Kessner trust under
- 37:38the state law that tax any trust income held
- 37:41for the benefit of a state resident. The state
- 37:44assessed a tax of more than $1 .3 million for
- 37:48tax years 2005 through 2008. And during that
- 37:52period, Kessner had received no distributions.
- 37:56The trust had no physical presence in the state,
- 38:01had made no investments there, and also did not
- 38:04have any income that was sourced from North Carolina.
- 38:08The trustee paid the tax under protest and then
- 38:12sued the state, arguing that the tax violated
- 38:14the 14th Amendment's due process clause, and
- 38:17the North Carolina Supreme Court agreed with
- 38:20the taxpayer. The U .S. Supreme Court upheld
- 38:23the North Carolina court's decision, finding
- 38:26that the presence of an in -state beneficiary
- 38:29alone does not empower a state to tax trust income
- 38:33that has not been distributed to the beneficiaries.
- 38:35where the beneficiaries have no right to demand
- 38:38that income and may be uncertain to receive it.
- 38:45So, Kessler is really the Supreme Court's first
- 38:48statement since the late 1930s delineating due
- 38:52process restraints on state taxation of accumulated
- 38:55trust income based on residence. And the court
- 38:58made clear that the residence of a trust beneficiary
- 39:02alone does not consist constitutes sufficient
- 39:05nexus under the due process clause. But it did
- 39:08leave many unanswered questions regarding the
- 39:11character and the quality of contacts sufficient
- 39:15to survive the due process challenge. The court
- 39:18reiterated the two -step due process clause analysis
- 39:22articulated in Quill Corp. v. North Dakota requiring
- 39:27One, some definite link, some minimum connection
- 39:30between a state and the person, property, or
- 39:32transaction it seeks to tax. And two, income
- 39:35attributed to the state for tax purposes must
- 39:38be rationally related to values connected with
- 39:42the taxing state. So the court's due process
- 39:48analysis focused on the extent of the in -state
- 39:51beneficiary's right to control, possess, enjoy,
- 39:55or actually receive trust assets. And in this
- 39:58case, because the beneficiaries did not receive
- 40:00any income during the relevant years and had
- 40:02no right to demand, control, possess, or enjoy
- 40:06the trust assets, the state's right to tax the
- 40:08trust could not extend to the accumulated income
- 40:11of the trust. So how did this opinion affect
- 40:15California? taxation. Well, first, I think it
- 40:22is extremely interesting to compare the court's
- 40:25view of beneficiary -based taxation with the
- 40:29language of the California Supreme Court in McCulloch
- 40:31back in 1964. The McCulloch court really saw
- 40:35no constitutional violation with a state taxing
- 40:39its resident beneficiaries on income accumulated
- 40:42for their benefit. The key difference, of course,
- 40:45is that the income in the McCulloch case was
- 40:47actually distributed to the beneficiary. And
- 40:50it's also important to note that the limited
- 40:54application of Kessner, the opinion limits itself
- 40:58to the narrow set of facts at hand. The court
- 41:01stated that it does not imply approval or disapproval
- 41:04of trust taxes that are premised on beneficiaries
- 41:07whose relationship to the trust assets differs
- 41:10from the cut Kessner Trust beneficiaries. Several
- 41:14states, including California, filed amicus briefs
- 41:17in support of the North Carolina Department of
- 41:19Revenue. And the court acknowledged those amicus
- 41:22positions in reiterating that the decision was
- 41:25limited to these facts alone. The court expressly
- 41:29declined to pass judgment on statutes such as
- 41:32California's Revenue and Taxation Code Section
- 41:3417742 that limits taxation to trusts with resident
- 41:38non -contingent beneficiaries. So, to take a
- 41:43step back, I think it's really important to note
- 41:45that under California law for the tax years at
- 41:48issue, the Kessner Trust would not have been
- 41:50taxable in California if the beneficiary had
- 41:53resided in this state during those years and
- 41:55on the facts included in the opinion. And that's
- 41:59because of Section 17 -742 and the requirement
- 42:02about non -contingency. Again, trusts which...
- 42:06in which all distributions are subject to the
- 42:08discretion of the trustee will likely be deemed
- 42:10to have contingent beneficiaries until the trustee
- 42:15actually exercises that discretion to make a
- 42:17distribution to a resident beneficiary. So what
- 42:21practitioners can take away from the Kessner
- 42:23decision as it relates to California is that
- 42:26for now it does not change California taxation.
- 42:29but it can inform the analysis we do as we consider
- 42:33a trust residency connections to this state.
- 42:39Okay, and now we're going to touch on the Paula
- 42:42Trust decision, which was one of my favorite
- 42:44cases to talk about for a long time, and not
- 42:47just because we worked on it for six years or
- 42:49because the FTB won on the major issue. The case
- 42:53was really quite challenging because it tested
- 42:56one of the foundational pillars that forms California
- 42:59trust taxation. And just a quick note on the
- 43:03case name, the case started out as a consolidated
- 43:05appeal at the Board of Equalization and it was
- 43:08known as the appeal of the Paula Trust. Later
- 43:11when the trust trustee filed its complaint in
- 43:13Superior Court. It was named correctly after
- 43:16the plaintiff trustee for the trust. So I often
- 43:20still refer to the case as the Paula Trust because
- 43:22of the origins, but the actual case name and
- 43:24citation is listed in the PowerPoint here for
- 43:27you if you would like to look that up. This case
- 43:31began with appeals on deemed denied claims for
- 43:34a refund. The Board of Equalization heard the
- 43:36matter twice. The second time was on a petition
- 43:39for rehearing. and decided in FTB's favor both
- 43:43times. The trust then filed an action in San
- 43:45Francisco Superior Court and prevailed against
- 43:48the FTB on a motion for summary judgment. The
- 43:52Court of Appeal heard the matter in June 2020
- 43:54and issued its decision in FTB's favor shortly
- 43:57after that. So one of the reasons this case presented
- 44:01such an interesting issue is that most of the
- 44:04challenges to the trust rules over the years
- 44:06have pertained to the residency rules. The idea
- 44:10of trusts being taxable on all income source
- 44:14to California, regardless of residence, has never
- 44:17really been controversial before this and was
- 44:20never actually challenged before the appeal of
- 44:22Paula Trust. So, in 2007, the Paula Trust was
- 44:26one of many family trusts to receive distributive
- 44:29share income from California -based pass -through
- 44:32entities. The income attributable to the trust's
- 44:36partnership interest in Sayufi Limited Partnership
- 44:38was gained from the sale of stock in Century
- 44:41Theaters, Inc. And Century Theaters, Inc. was
- 44:44a family -owned and operated theater chain founded
- 44:48in Vallejo, California. The trustees originally
- 44:51reported all of the income on their 2007 income
- 44:54tax return as California source income and then
- 44:58paid tax on all of the income. They later filed
- 45:01an amended California return claiming that actually
- 45:04only one half of the income should have been
- 45:06taxed by California. And the trust argued and
- 45:13took the position that for trust taxation purposes,
- 45:17the source of the income is irrelevant. They
- 45:20argue that the only statutes that tax trusts
- 45:22in California are those found in sections 17
- 45:26.742 through 17 .744. So in other words, they
- 45:31argued that trustee and beneficiary residents
- 45:33are the only means through which California can
- 45:36reach the income of a trust when there are multiple
- 45:38fiduciaries living in and outside of California.
- 45:42So Even though all of the income derived from
- 45:45a California -based business, and even though
- 45:47the sole beneficiary of the trust was a California
- 45:50resident, the trust argued that only one half
- 45:53of the income could be taxed by the state because
- 45:56only one of the two fiduciaries for the trust
- 45:59resided in California. And the trust argued that
- 46:03the sourcing rules beginning with section 17951
- 46:06simply do not apply to trusts. Instead, the taxpayer
- 46:10challenged the regulation under section 17743
- 46:13and made several arguments regarding the legislative
- 46:17history of sections 17742 and 17743. Now the
- 46:23FTB argued instead that the statutory underpinning
- 46:27for taxing trusts did not just begin with Chapter
- 46:309 of Part 10 of the Personal Income Tax Code,
- 46:33but instead began in Section 17 -041. And that's
- 46:37our general tax imposition statute. The FTB pointed
- 46:42out that trusts, like individuals, are subject
- 46:44to tax based on both source and residence, and
- 46:47that Section 17 -742 through 44 really just provide
- 46:51our residency rules for trusts. And in a quite
- 46:58well reasoned published opinion, the court of
- 47:00appeal agreed with the FTB determining that trusts
- 47:03are taxed on all California source income without
- 47:06regard to the residence of fiduciaries. The court
- 47:11continued to state that the statute is clear.
- 47:13The FTB promulgated rules for apportioning trust
- 47:15income when there are multiple resident and non
- 47:18-resident fiduciaries. The statute requires taxpayers
- 47:20to follow those rules. When we read the statute
- 47:23and the regulation together, as required by the
- 47:25plain language of the statute, a trust is taxed
- 47:28on all California source income, regardless of
- 47:31whether the fiduciary is a nonresident or not,
- 47:33and then non -California source income is a portion
- 47:36between California and non -California fiduciaries.
- 47:40After the issuance of this decision, the trust
- 47:43petitioned for review from the Cal Supreme Court,
- 47:45and that review was denied. One more interesting
- 47:50fact I want to note about the Court of Appeal
- 47:52decision here is that the court found that the
- 47:56beneficiary in this case had a contingent interest
- 47:58in the trust. And that was interesting because
- 48:01the court really did not actually need to answer
- 48:04address or even address this question once it
- 48:07had decided the main issue. The FTB had argued
- 48:10in the alternative that the court should find
- 48:13that the California resident beneficiary had
- 48:16a non -contingent interest in the trust because
- 48:19of some of the language in the instrument. While
- 48:23the trustee had sole and absolute discretion
- 48:25to make distributions, the trust did provide
- 48:28some guidelines for how the trustee could determine
- 48:31to make distributions. And then also during discovery,
- 48:36it was determined that the fiduciaries had established
- 48:38a distribution plan in order to make regular,
- 48:42predictable distributions to the beneficiaries.
- 48:45However, the Court of Appeal found that none
- 48:48of the language of the trust instrument diminished
- 48:50the sole and absolute discretion of the trustee
- 48:53to make distributions, and that even the established
- 48:56distribution plan did not alter the trustee's
- 48:59discretion. So accordingly, the beneficiary of
- 49:02the Paula Trust had a contingent interest. And
- 49:04this finding provides a bit more support for
- 49:07the notion that a beneficiary will be considered
- 49:10contingent under section 17 742 if the trust
- 49:14provides for discretionary distribution. OK,
- 49:17so what are we to make of the recent outcomes
- 49:20between this case from the California Court of
- 49:23Appeals and the later decision of the US Supreme
- 49:25Court in the Kimberly Rice Kessner Trust decision?
- 49:29Well, these cases. would seem to be pointing
- 49:33in the direction of confirmation that taxation
- 49:36based on income source and fiduciary residence
- 49:40is constitutional with perhaps a bit more of
- 49:45a skeptical eye turned towards taxation based
- 49:48solely on beneficiary residence without some,
- 49:52you know, minimal connection between the state
- 49:54and the income being earned. Okay. And so that
- 50:01brings us to a subject that has been very popular
- 50:05in California over the last decade or so. And
- 50:08that relates to a type of trust known as incomplete
- 50:11gift non -grantor trust or an ing trust. To give
- 50:16a little bit of background on these trusts, they
- 50:18were beginning to pop up on our radar several
- 50:21years ago as trusts created oftentimes by California
- 50:24residents. And the ultimate goals of these trusts
- 50:28was to remove potentially taxable income from
- 50:31the reach of a higher income tax state, such
- 50:34as California, using several drafting mechanisms,
- 50:37which I'm going to go over in greater detail.
- 50:40And these trusts became popular enough that not
- 50:42only were we seeing them regularly, But we had
- 50:45many questions and concerns raised from the taxpayer
- 50:49community and various representatives about what
- 50:51many saw as essentially an abusive tax structure
- 50:55that was proliferating in pretty great numbers.
- 51:00Okay, so what is an interest anyway? Well, these
- 51:04are trusts established under the law of states
- 51:06with low or no income taxes, hence the D for
- 51:10Delaware, the N for Nevada, et cetera. Most commonly,
- 51:15the grantors remain beneficiaries of the trusts.
- 51:18The grantors transfer assets to a trust they
- 51:21assert is a non -resident to a trust under state
- 51:24tax law. And in order to accomplish that goal,
- 51:27the trust instruments use really quite precise
- 51:30language to avoid the grantor trust rules while
- 51:33also remaining incomplete for gift tax purposes.
- 51:38So several years ago, some taxpayers requested
- 51:40private letter rulings from the IRS to confirm
- 51:43that their trusts would be treated as non -grantor
- 51:46trusts while remaining incomplete for gift tax
- 51:49purposes. And relying on those initial private
- 51:53letter rulings, many taxpayers began to create
- 51:56these trusts and take the position that they
- 51:58were non -grantor trusts under California law
- 52:02and they were non -residents under California
- 52:05law with the end result of all of this creative
- 52:09drafting being that the trust was not taxable
- 52:12in California and had no federal gift tax imposed
- 52:16upon creation. Okay, so how do you know if you
- 52:24encounter an ing trust in the wild? Well, this
- 52:28slide kind of gives us the typical structure
- 52:30created by a California resident grantor. The
- 52:34grantor starts out by making an irrevocable transfer
- 52:37to an ING trust of intangible assets. They do
- 52:42not pay any federal gift tax upon the transfer
- 52:45because they take the position that this transfer
- 52:47is incomplete for gift tax purposes, but complete
- 52:51for income tax purposes. The trust invokes the
- 52:55law of a low or no tax jurisdiction and has a
- 53:00non -resident fiduciary which under section 17742A
- 53:04would remove the trust from California taxation
- 53:07based on residency of the fiduciary. Now, the
- 53:11grantor remains a beneficiary of the trust, often
- 53:15along with their spouse, children, and any other
- 53:18family members. The grantor happens to choose.
- 53:23But the trust permits only discretionary distributions
- 53:26to these beneficiaries, stating that distributions
- 53:29are solely left up to the discretion of the trustee.
- 53:32And of course, as we've been discussing today
- 53:34under Section 17 -742, the trust will not be
- 53:38taxable in California based on the residents
- 53:41of non -contingent, or excuse me, of contingent
- 53:43beneficiaries, even if they are California residents.
- 53:47So that leads us to this fourth prong here, but
- 53:51there is a problem with this arrangement, and
- 53:53that is that it now seems to violate the grantor
- 53:56trust rules contained in Internal Revenue Code
- 53:58Section 671 through 679. So, as I mentioned at
- 54:03the very start of this presentation, those rules
- 54:07explain and define when a trust will be disregarded
- 54:09for income tax purposes. And the basic idea is
- 54:13that if a grantor retains certain powers over
- 54:16or interest in a trust, they will continue to
- 54:20be treated as the owner of the assets of the
- 54:23trust. And all of the trust's income, deductions,
- 54:27and credits flow directly to the grantor's personal
- 54:30tax return. But under Internal Revenue Code Section
- 54:34677, a grantor will be treated as the owner of
- 54:38a trust in which they retain an interest in the
- 54:40income as long as the enjoyment of that income
- 54:43does not require the approval or consent of any
- 54:47adverse party. And so it's this language of Section
- 54:50677 that caused the drafters of interest to create
- 54:55this last common provision in these trusts. And
- 54:58that is the requirement that all distributions
- 55:01be subject to the discretion of a distribution
- 55:04committee. And who is on that distribution committee?
- 55:07Well, it typically names adverse parties to approve
- 55:11of any distributions to be made. And with this
- 55:16language, the grantor is able to take the position
- 55:19that the trust does not trigger the grantor trust
- 55:21rules. Now, these adverse parties are typically
- 55:24the grantor's children or other family members
- 55:27with a potential interest in the trust, and that
- 55:30is what makes them adverse. So although it's
- 55:34quite complex, this is the basic structure of
- 55:37an ING trust. And while it may have technically
- 55:40complied with the law, it seems pretty clear
- 55:43that these trusts were being used primarily to
- 55:45avoid state taxation with little change to the
- 55:48actual enjoyment of the income or trust assets.
- 55:54So in response to the proliferation of these
- 55:57trusts, the California legislature passed Senate
- 56:00Bill 131 in 2023, creating new section 17082.
- 56:06The new statute was inspired by a similar law
- 56:09passed by the New York legislature several years
- 56:11ago to also address the ing trust situation in
- 56:15that state. Section 17082 causes ING trusts to
- 56:19be treated as grantor trusts with all income
- 56:23flowing directly to the grantor's personal returns.
- 56:26And this bill originated from a legislative proposal
- 56:29from the FTB. However, there were quite a few
- 56:33modifications in the statute that did not appear
- 56:36in the original format proposed by the FTB. Okay,
- 56:41so how does 17082 work? Well, the section treats
- 56:45ING trusts like grantor trusts, including the
- 56:49income of a trust in the grantor's income. Under
- 56:52section 17082, an ING trust is one that meets
- 56:56two conditions. First, it's a non -grantor trust
- 57:00under subchapter J of the Internal Revenue Code.
- 57:03And second, the transfer of assets to the trust
- 57:05is an incomplete gift under IRC section 2511.
- 57:11During the legislative process, kind of an interesting
- 57:15carve -out was made in the bill, and that was
- 57:19to create a carve -out for grantor trusts that
- 57:22meet two conditions for the tax year. The trusts
- 57:25must, one, elect to be taxed like resident grantor
- 57:29trusts, and two, distribute at least 90 % of
- 57:33its distributable net income to a charitable
- 57:36organization under IRC Section 501C3. So this
- 57:40is a little exception for certain trusts who
- 57:44are going to be contributing most of its distributable
- 57:47net income to a charity. Okay, so what does this
- 57:50mean for taxpayers and practitioners? Ing Trusts
- 57:54are now going to be considered taxable to the
- 57:56grantors. So if the grantor is a California resident,
- 57:59they will need to report all of the current income
- 58:02of the trust on their current personal income
- 58:05tax return and pay any tax arising from that
- 58:08income. For filing purposes, ING Trust will likely
- 58:13need to file Form 541 and check the box selected
- 58:18for ING Trust or ING Trust with election. And
- 58:22then flow the income directly to the grantor's
- 58:24personal return. One thing I do want to note
- 58:27is that Section 17082 does not apply. to charitable
- 58:32remainder trusts. This is a question that has
- 58:35come up quite a few times. So I do want to note
- 58:39that California does conform to IRC section 664
- 58:42and all of the regulations pertaining to charitable
- 58:46remainder trusts. So I do want to reiterate that
- 58:49and get the word out there that this new section
- 58:52should not impact your charitable remainder trusts.
- 58:56Please check out the FTB's website for further
- 58:58information on filing or a description of section
- 59:0217082. This section is still brand new, so other
- 59:07than the question about charitable remainder
- 59:09trusts, we are really not quite sure where we're
- 59:12going to field questions from people or fiduciaries
- 59:17on how to file. And with that, that concludes
- 59:21my remarks today. time for questions. I'm happy
- 59:25to take them or else you can absolutely feel
- 59:28free to reach out to me at sonia .woodruff at
- 59:31ftb .ca .gov if you have specific questions about
- 59:35trust in the state taxation. Thank you so much
- 59:38for joining me and I hope that you enjoy the
- 59:41rest of your afternoon. Thank you so much Sonia
- 59:45for the excellent presentation. This concludes
- 59:48today's program. Our next program will be regarding
- 59:52the current perspective on probate practices
- 59:55in the LA County Court. It will take place on
- 59:58October 21st with Dean Silliman and Darcy Ann
- 1:00:01Horton. Thank you for joining us this afternoon.
- 1:00:04Bye -bye.