Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Tech Companies Reprice Stock Options During a Downturn
Transcript
- Lucas: Tesla shares lost more than 18% in the last five trading days. That puts the stock at about $305, down from recent highs. For a company that uses stock-based compensation as a core part of its pay package, that kind of drop creates a real problem — suddenly, thousands of options are underwater. Luna: Underwater options — so the strike price is higher than the current market price. That means they're essentially worthless unless the stock recovers. Lucas: Exactly. And Tesla isn't alone. NVIDIA fell 7% in the same stretch, Meta dropped over 5%. These are huge employers of engineers who got big equity grants during the IPO or early post ipo days. When the stock tanks, you lose your retention tool. People start looking for jobs where their paper money is actually worth something. Luna: So what do companies actually do? Just wait for the rebound? Lucas: Some do, but that can be dangerous. The classic move is an option repricing — the compensation committee cancels the old, underwater options and reissues new ones with a lower strike price, typically at the current market price. It's effectively a do-over. Luna: That seems generous. But it also sounds like it could dilute existing shareholders, doesn't it? You're replacing old options with new ones that have a better chance of generating value. Lucas: It can, but not directly. Repricing doesn't create new shares — it swaps one option for another. The dilution was already expected from the original grant. The issue is more about incentivizing the employee to stay. Without repricing, the options become worth zero, and the retention effect vanishes. Luna: Right. So it's a retention play. And I imagine not all repricings are the same. Some might also add new RSUs on top. Lucas: That's a common combo. You might see a company say: 'We'll reprice your options, and we'll also issue a special grant of restricted stock units that vest over the next two years.' That locks people in. Shopify, by contrast, is up 10% over the same five days — they have the opposite challenge: their equity grants are in the money, so employees are happy, but the cost to the company is higher from an accounting perspective. Luna: So when the stock goes up, the compensation expense goes up too, because the fair value of the grants increases. Lucas: Exactly. That's the GAAP accounting impact. Anyway, back to the downturn scenario: companies like Rivian, which is down about 4% in five days, might consider a repricing if the stock stays low for a sustained period. But one-off repricings are rare because they're tricky to justify to shareholders — you're essentially rewarding employees for a falling stock price. Luna: And there's a risk of sending the wrong signal — like, 'We think the stock won't recover soon, so we need to reset expectations.' Lucas: That's exactly the perception management challenge. The compensation committee has to weigh retention against dilution optics. Some companies avoid repricings altogether and instead issue 'make-whole grants' — additional RSUs that don't replace the underwater options but supplement them. That adds true dilution because it's new shares. Luna: Which is more painful for existing shareholders. Lucas: Yes. So the decision comes down to: do you want to protect your culture and keep key talent, or do you want to protect your EPS from further dilution? There's no perfect answer. Companies with strong cash positions can also do buybacks to offset some dilution — we talked about that in a previous episode. But in a selloff, cash might be conserved. Luna: And honestly, this level of detail is exactly why this show is so useful. It's listener-supported, no ads, just real conversations about how the business actually works. Lucas: Absolutely. A small group of you already chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's what funds the research for episodes like this. It keeps us independent. Luna: Yeah, if these conversations help you build or run a company, consider joining them. Lucas: So whether you're a founder, an engineer with options, or an investor looking at these compensation decisions, the key takeaway is that stock-based compensation is a dynamic tool. In a downturn, companies can't just let it sit—they have to act to keep their teams motivated. And investors need to watch for those retention costs and dilution signals in the footnotes. Luna: And with volatility likely to continue, this will keep being a front of mind issue for post ipo companies. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening.