Latest / Game Day Gyals / Manchester City Special: A Tainted Legacy
Transcript
- @laurencoys: Hello, hello, hello. The international break is over. Football is back or club football is back and so are we. But we wanted to jump on the mic and discuss what was probably the biggest story over the international break, which was the outcome of Manchester City and their 115 charges. So before we start and before we begin, Run that theme tune! starting off with quick intros in terms of who's on today's episode. You may be like, whose voice is this? I am your host for today because team we're full of we're busy. But you can find me at Lauren Coy's, you can find us everywhere at gamedaygirls. really appreciate the support so far. So please keep following, please keep listening, interact with our posts across all of our socials because every little helps. Moving on. to Ella. Welcome back. Ella E: Thank you, thank you. Interesting topic we're discussing today, but good to be back. Great to hear you hosting Lauren, first of many. @laurencoys: Hahaha! Ella E: Love it. @laurencoys: it and we've also got Faye. GameDayGyals: Hey, come along. @laurencoys: Come on, come on. It feels like it's been literally like it's only been like a few weeks. It feels like it's been ages since we've like we've Ella E: It has... @laurencoys: potted together. GameDayGyals: Ta-da! @laurencoys: So it's nice to be back. But listen, let's get into it. I think it's good to start with with the facts because I think it feels like this has been dragging on for a really long time, which it has. But there's always there's a lot that's kind of gone on over the last couple of weeks. So think let's start with the facts in terms of Sissy were charged by the Premier League back in February of 2023 after their investigation. This covers the period from 2009-10 season to 2017 and 18. Case was heard by an independent commission rather than the Premier League itself, allegedly. And Sissy from the very, you know, from the outset have categorically denied the allegations and have challenged the findings and what's emerged in the last couple of weeks and what the commissioner found is they found them guilty of pretty much all of the breaches in multiple areas. So there's the commercial agreement which is quite a strong statement I think from the Premier League where they described sham contracts with the number of commercial partners that Citi had and relied on sham agreements with others. So that's around artificially inflating the club's revenues to reduce its costs. They also found that the club had filed misstated accounts and concealed the true nature of its finances, both from auditors and football regulators. They also found that City were significantly in breach of both the Premier League and the UEFA's spending limit, so the vast majority of that time would have been FFP. They also found... this is a long old list, but these are the themes, right? In terms of... that yes Manchester City committed multiple breaches of its duties of cooperation and utmost good faith towards the Premier League so three out of those four alleged breaches were upheld i.e. City didn't cooperate so those are the findings and I think it's not just allegations anymore because obviously the Independent Commission have produced their findings but we know as of today, City have appealed, so we're not at end of the process yet, but we have seen quite a strong reaction both on kind of City's internal channels that they've produced right in terms of the hierarchy of the club. We've seen Pep Guardiola come out and say that he's here for the fan base etc etc and within the last hour we've seen Enzo Maresca make his first comments talking about how happy everybody is within the club, so it's been quite a strong reaction to the point where know City have even said that it's a conspiracy theory in terms of what's going on. So starting with you Ella in terms of what was your I guess initial reaction when the the kind of the outcome of the investigation was released? Ella E: From my perspective, I can't quite believe it. I still can't quite believe it because it still feels like there's more to come because we were all, I mean, these investigations have been going on for years, but I was never convinced that they would necessarily be charged or found guilty. thought this would be long after my time on this Earth that they'll be found guilty. It was gonna take that long. And of course they've appealed and stuff, but I mean, it's quite a thing to be charged 114 out of 115. That is a ridiculous amount. I mean, I don't know who their lawyer was, but to only get them off on one charge, the evidence is damning. It's damning. @laurencoys: Yeah. Ella E: From a Liverpool perspective, I am annoyed. I am mad. I'm so upset because, know, Man City, obviously, when they won that first Premier League in what, 2011, 2012? Can't remember. Yeah. The @laurencoys: Yeah, acquirro! Yeah. Ella E: Aguero. To know basically their whole success was essentially built on a lie and on cheating. It's incredibly frustrating because no matter what in terms of we'll talk about punishments and stuff, but in my view, no matter what punishment they give, is it really, as a football fan, it's ruined? Because watching us go so close with them multiple times under clock, it's so frustrating because we got 97 damn points and didn't win it. And for it all to be a lie is so annoying because what they can hand us the trophy, but it's just not the same. It's just not the same and it's just, it's really ruined the integrity and the fact that they've done this over a nine year period, the fact that it's taken this long. And even though it's over a nine year period, the knock on effects of that nine year period. So it, because post 2018, City are a different club. Players want to go there, they're winning things. They get people like Pep Guardiola. None of that happens if they're not winning. So everything is just kind of almost built on a lie. So it's incredibly frustrating. But to be honest, I'm not shocked. I'm not shocked because personally, when was it in COVID? When they said they would made a profit. Who made a profit during COVID? Like @laurencoys: Yeah, and everybody else and everyone else was struggling Ella E: that was for me, that was, yeah, that was alarm bells from there, but that was even after the period. So yeah, incredibly frustrated. shocked but it's not going to be the end of the story but I'm glad at least that they've been found guilty and we can actually talk about it without saying allegedly as it stands. @laurencoys: very very very true. guess coming to you Faye, are you shocked by or what are your thoughts on the severity of the charges because I think what what we have seen before right in terms of we've obviously seen Chelsea fail some breaches of kind of financial regulations and the stuff with the agents we've seen Everton six points for breaching one financial fair play rule we've seen, Nottingham Forest also docked points. But the severity of what's come out from this city investigation, is this one of the biggest, not I'm going to say footballing scandals, but maybe sporting scandals that we've ever had in this country? GameDayGyals: Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. Like honestly, it's just so egregious. It's so egregious. It's so, it's so crazy. Like I saw an article from like... remember when it was but it was like they wanted to get caca and they was going to give him 500,000 a year i mean a week what you know you know when people like cheat and lie and steal there's people that do it with tax and with care city what they were doing was just egregious like like ella says they said they made a profit in covid First all, you barely had any fans. So the fact that you made a profit in COVID is crazy. Yeah. They were doing things like saying that the revenue that they made was more than Manchester United, was more than Real Madrid, was more than some basketball teams. And it's like, you don't sell out your stadium. One. Two, in order for you to sell out your stadium, you have to sell tickets for like 13 pounds. You you're advertising it to students to go like, on students, you can get on. Honestly, when I was a student, I could get tickets on uni days for like cheap. If I was in the Manchester area, I would go. If I'm getting tickets for cheap, why not? Do you know what mean? It was just so egregious. And I just feel like sometimes cooperate. But potentially if they cooperated and you know, there was like, maybe it was a few bad apples and they put the blame to them. Maybe something, okay, fair enough. But it's like you didn't cooperate, you're still not cooperating. You're coming out, you're doing this, you're saying that, you know, the UAE and England and UK, the relationship is not going to be the same. You're saying that something bad, or you're saying, you know, that you can't prosecute because it's the crown prince or whatever. It's like too many things. You're not showing, you're not being humble. You're not being humble. I feel like realistically, from what they did, they did crazy fraud. And that is a crime. And really and truly, someone should be going to jail for what they've done. honestly, someone should go to jail because what they've done is crazy fraud. know, skimping out paying tax with HMRC, doing all this shit. It's fraud. So yeah, I'm not gonna lie, they need to... they used to really, really, really be punished. What they've done is crazy. When there was 115 charges, I was like, okay, maybe they'll be guilty for like 10 or something, but they're not gonna be found guilty for like 99%. I found guilty for 99%. And I'm seeing all things like, okay, cool, maybe they will get relegated. I don't think they will get relegated. I don't think it really impacts the Premier League, if I'm being honest. If Spurs were to get relegated, it would impact. That's why the Premier League, they were doing what they were doing last season. @laurencoys: sorry that's not straight away from the topic now yeah please let's stay on point yeah and we had no we had we had no Ella E: What? How have you spun this? How have you spun this? GameDayGyals: Sorry! Sorry, the writing just came so easily. @laurencoys: help from the officials whatsoever but let's stay on track here please Ella E: You GameDayGyals: You know the way the prom cuspion thinks like, if City got relegated, okay, I don't think really anybody would really care. would be like, Rob, people wouldn't care. It wouldn't impact the Premier League as if like maybe the original top four were to get relegated. Do you know what mean? It wouldn't impact the Premier League. Points deduction, likely. And I think, yeah, I would like that. Maybe not this season because I do not want Arsenal to go back to back. So, I mean, it's just so many things, but I think they're hefty fine. I think crazy transfer ban. And yeah, that's what I think realistically they can and have to do. Maybe as well, the owners should be forced to sell. But the way the prime minister has moved and what he said, now everybody's looking at the dealings that's happened when he was the mayor. I don't think that will happen. @laurencoys: Yeah, I guess from a The city owners right or the hierarchy of city and obviously people connected to city with respect maresca, whatever they've been quite Resolute in their defense of yeah, we believe the club this this isn't true and I have the reaction of city fans surprised you into because I think what I've seen is a I think an understandable siege mentality But I also think we've also seen a section of the city fan base who have not quite yet come to terms with reality. Are you surprised by their reaction or give your thoughts on it? Ella E: I've seen quite mixed reactions, but I'm not surprised by those that are just back in the club saying, wait till they peel, wait till this, wait till that and kind of dodging the matter at hand. But I do get it that it's their club they're going to support. They're going to support their club with whatever. But this is serious. Like this is your club. GameDayGyals: Good. Ella E: I would be if it was me and if it was Liverpool. Those owners for one would not be there. If it was Liverpool, those owners will not be there the next day. Because at the end of the day, so do you know what I think? I think because City, this might sound really harsh, were basically built in terms of their success on this ownership, they're more inclined to back them. But at GameDayGyals: Mm. Ella E: Liverpool, at Chelsea, exactly. @laurencoys: Yeah, they changed their lives. Yeah. Ella E: But for the rest of us, our club has been around and successful before this ownership. We've seen that. So we're not so quick to back them, if anything, we're more critical of them. But it's different for City because their owners gave them everything. They gave them success that they never seen. Before that period, we weren't even thinking about City. Look at the players they were buying with. City weren't even a team that you would think about. Do you get what I mean? So I can understand from that perspective. GameDayGyals: Sean Wright Phillips. Ella E: Do you get what I mean? @laurencoys: Stuart Ireland and all them man. Ella E: Exactly, exactly. GameDayGyals: BAM! Ella E: And it's just they've just completely changed their lives, as you said, Lauren. So I'm not surprised at that degree. But I do think they need to tap into reality because that ownership cannot stay. That ownership cannot stay. If they want their football club to be seen with any kind of integrity again, they can't they can't support the ownership anymore. I get it, but I don't get it. But I also think it comes down to generations. I feel like maybe the older generation, the Man City, the true Man City fans that have seen them basically do nothing, will be bit more inclined to be a bit more realistic. But then you've got the new gen who is a bit more, they haven't known anything else. So it's a bit evil raw, but yeah, I don't know. I don't know. I kind of feel for them because for one, they're not involved. Do you get what I mean? Shall I feel for them from that perspective? Yes, beyond @laurencoys: Yeah, it's beyond that control. Yeah. Ella E: their control. And one person I actually really feel for is Maresca as well, because he's come into a mess. You have to. Nah, Faye, you have to feel for him. GameDayGyals: He knew what he knew what he was getting sorry he knew he @laurencoys: But GameDayGyals: knew because remember his assistant He @laurencoys: he was also there though, it's not his first stint at the club to be fair. Ella E: True. GameDayGyals: knew what was happening. Yeah, you could get this guy give him and his agent under the you know Yeah, we're gonna sabotage Chelsea's season because you know see come Ella E: What? GameDayGyals: even that was illegal It was illegal. It was sorry. I hate @laurencoys: Sit it! Ugh, my goodness, Faye, please! F-Faye, let's stay on point! Ella E: But for him, fae. GameDayGyals: I'm so happy that this has happened to Enzo Morisco. Ella E: But I just don't think he should be @laurencoys: For God's sake! Ella E: the spokesman. He shouldn't be the face. Do you get what I mean? @laurencoys: Yeah, and I think- GameDayGyals: He went there when he knew these charges were active. Ella E: He did, but I don't think anyone, actually there were whispers, apparently, because I don't know if you saw that David Ornstein thing with the overlap, but there were whispers like back in March that it was coming, basically. So you're right. Yeah, @laurencoys: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Ella E: so you're right. And I think that's interesting with the whole pep thing. I think the whole timing of the pep leaving thing, I think it's related personally. It's absolutely, I... GameDayGyals: 100 % @laurencoys: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I think cuz Pep can be like, I'm here for you. GameDayGyals: It is. Allegedly. Allegedly, yeah? Allegedly. Ella E: Yeah. Yeah. @laurencoys: I'm here for you guys, but from afar and to be honest if we Yeah, Ella E: Yeah, the statement was cute but... GameDayGyals: They knew what they knew what they was doing. They knew they knew that's Ella E: Hmm. GameDayGyals: why they were getting all those midfielders spending the hundred and a hundred million for this one this one this one this one because they knew what's coming they got Harland onto another contract so far if we get relegated Yeah, you cost this amount of money the clubs are what you need to pay this amount of money There's no relegation clause. They got better of them on those type of contracts. They knew what was coming Ella E: Yeah. GameDayGyals: Pep knew what was coming. That's why he was so stressed He wants to win the league because he knew this was sayonara, this is the end. He knew. Ella E: Hmm. @laurencoys: Yeah, what I will say is, because I think what we've also seen in this international break, and I agree with Ella, in terms of who becomes the face of this mess, because what we did see as well is that André Jeglerts, is the manager of City's women's team, had to field questions about it as well. And then you think about the impact of that side of the club. It's, I don't know, it's a really messy situation. I guess if I'm going to give my, I guess, opinion as a Spurs fan and how I feel... specifically about the situation that we were in. Obviously we weren't going toe to toe with City for the titles like Liverpool were, but there are four occasions on which we missed out on Champions League football with City finishing in the top four within that period. And I think it's just more of a case of what could have been and you know, sorry, Faye, if I bring Chelsea into that because Chelsea were also guilty of different charges within that period, it's just that, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, like, GameDayGyals: Whoa, whoa, whoa. @laurencoys: listen, you're not getting off of this, Scott, I'm sorry, but when you feel like, you know, when I look at Spurs and what they've GameDayGyals: Yeah. @laurencoys: had to do in terms of trying to build their revenues in an organic way, right, in terms of building the stadium. imposing our own self-inflicted transfer ban because we couldn't afford to buy players because we were building the stadium and staying within the rules and doing things the honest way and doing things the hard way. I think it's just really tough to take. We're trying to play chess here and everybody else is playing checkers and I think that's tough because these kind of teams that have dominated football but were essentially able to do what they like in terms of their interpretations or lack of interpretation of the rules that were in place at the time. I think it's just one of those. think there are obviously there are multiple clubs and as we've seen what's been reported in terms of some clubs are gearing up to Sioux City because whether it's a financial impact or whatever, that there are multiple clubs up and down the league that have been impacted. GameDayGyals: Wish me luck! @laurencoys: by this. because it's, guess, Mu, the thing I want to ask next, and starting with you, Faye, do you now view City's legacy and who they are as a football club differently, even if we, you know, before we get to the point of the appeal and the outcome of the appeal? GameDayGyals: Yes, to me it's very much tainted. When you look at the type of players that they were able to get and the reasoning they were able to get was because they were telling everybody, cool, I'm going to get this player on let's say 50 million. Everybody's like, wow, you're 50 million, we're putting 50 million. How come they're going to see? Why would someone want to go to see instead of London? Doesn't make any sense. It's because they're offering them £500,000 a week. How can anybody compete with that? Sorry, Pep Guardiola, you bought all your leagues and you bought the Champions League as well. When you was in Barcelona, they're under investigation for paying off the refs now. So it's just like your legacy is looking very tainted. So you need Messi, you needed fraud, you needed to pay off the referees. It's looking very dark. Yeah, it is. And the only thing that I can really say is I'm just so happy that during this period Chelsea were able to win the Champions League and they were able to win the league and they were able to beat this corrupt city team to do it! @laurencoys: It's true, Spurs as well, we had no problem being city of the Pemquat GameDayGyals: But, that is, beating this corrupt super team that nobody can compete with, yeah, it makes it even more nice. I don't think they should be stripped of it. I don't think they should be stripped of the things because it's happened now. And maybe Liverpool, maybe United, because you see some of the things like that Aguero one, final day, that hurts. How did they get Aguero? All this type of things, it can make your head spin. If you keep thinking about it. City will, United will come in second, Liverpool will come in second. I personally wouldn't want them to be stripped of anything because it's done. It's done now. But they need to make an example out of There's no ifs or buts. An example has to be made. Obviously, you, Ella, your team has been affected because sometimes you were finishing second to City. So maybe you might feel a bit different than how I feel. Ella E: The thing is, as you said, like nothing will really get the feeling back because the whole point of GameDayGyals: Mm-hmm. Ella E: winning something is that you celebrate it. So I guess GameDayGyals: Yeah. Ella E: them being stripped of it, it feels like it's just being handed. But I do think it's necessary because if you think about, for example, the athletics, when someone is found to be cheating or doping, they get stripped of their medal. It should be the same. GameDayGyals: That's true. Ella E: It should be the same in football. From a petty point of view, I have to say this, if they do get stripped of their title, Gerald is a Premier League winner. So GameDayGyals: See, I don't want that. Ella E: from that angle, @laurencoys: Ha Ella E: they must be stripped because then that whole argument, yeah, I'm coming for everyone. GameDayGyals: The whole slip in. Ella E: I'm coming for everyone. We're gonna do best Premier League midfielders again. All those episodes that we're gonna redo it with this on the back, but that's pending. In all seriousness, it's a tough one because, I mean, as you said, it does make you proud. I mean, the fact that we were able to go toe to toe with them and get a ridiculous amount of points by actually being legitimate and staying in the rules. Yeah, I mean, we don't get rewarded. GameDayGyals: you know of though that you know i personally think a lot of teams have probably cheated not to that extent but everyone's team does the legal shit man come on come on man Ella E: Nah, I don't even know. I don't even know because yeah, @laurencoys: Some clubs have got good governance structures to be honest. Ella E: FSG are very stingy, Faye. Very. They're GameDayGyals: They're stinging, they're doing stuff man. Sorry. Ella E: stingy. They're stingy, I'm telling you. GameDayGyals: I think all clubs are corrupt. In a way, used to, used to. We self-snitched @laurencoys: Bay, not every club operates like yours. Sorry, not every club operates like yours. she's losing past tense. Ella E: No every club. GameDayGyals: and we cooperated. That's why we got a slap on the wrist, yeah? Ella E: I would agree that all owners are a bit, they're not necessarily good people, GameDayGyals: Come on. Come on. Ella E: but I don't necessarily think that all cheats. I don't. Anyway, to the point, GameDayGyals: I'm going to disagree, but yeah. Ella E: of course you're gonna back your club regardless, to the point, it's actually really tough, because the whole existence is on these titles, and if they're not won GameDayGyals: Mm. Ella E: legitimately, can we really classify them as anything? GameDayGyals: Like the fact that they did the treble, that is crazy. The centurions, Ella E: But... did they? GameDayGyals: that is crazy. And they did that because they cheated and they did fraud. So do you know what mean? Ella E: Exactly. It's all... yeah. @laurencoys: But what happens though in terms of... because there's two things right, you can strip them of their titles and say you've cheated so therefore you're not eligible to win those but then can you go as far as saying okay whoever came second or whoever lost that final to them because I agree with you Elo, like I mean we don't know many city fans but we know Joyce right Ella E: Hmm. @laurencoys: and Joyce... She flew out to that final and that feeling of happiness GameDayGyals: Yeah. @laurencoys: that she would have got when her team won the Champions League and completed their treble. You can't take that away from somebody, but Ella E: you @laurencoys: you also can't bottle that feeling and say, hey, you lost the final, you can have it instead. And I think that's GameDayGyals: Mm. Ella E: Yeah. @laurencoys: what sport is, right? You live in the moment, you celebrate in the moment, you create these memories. And ultimately, GameDayGyals: Thank @laurencoys: regardless of whether you get past a title retrospectively, the memory that you have of that game is that you lost. So Ella E: Hmm. @laurencoys: I don't think that does that actually change the feeling? Probably not. So I think I don't know, I think for me personally, I think even if you are going to strip them of the titles, I don't think they should be handed down to the GameDayGyals: Yes, I agree. @laurencoys: next team because I just I just think it will we're just put in asterisk by everything, right? In terms of, yeah, you got that because know, city restrict of it, even though it may have been deserved, don't think it... You know, nobody's gonna go and do a parade to be like, that title that I should have won eight years ago. Ella E: Hmm. GameDayGyals: Maybe it should be a thing where it's just voided, just in general. It's voided because, no, because when you think about it, Ella E: They can't, they cannot null and void those seasons. There's too many. GameDayGyals: it's like, okay, that season where Lauren Spurs didn't end up fourth, yeah, whatever season that was, are they now gonna give you money for going fourth? Are they gonna now give Liverpool money for winning or having the handed down prem? Are they gonna then... give compensation, well they probably have to, to Louis van Gogh Ella E: I to... GameDayGyals: because United didn't finish fourth and he got sacked because of that. Like it's just a ripple effect, all of it ripple effect, lots of money would have to be handed out compensation, they should just void it. Those titles that they got, void it. Nobody gets it. Ella E: I don't think they can avoid the seasons @laurencoys: But who... Ella E: because of relegation sides. @laurencoys: yeah, exactly, you can't put them Ella E: He can't. @laurencoys: back. But then again, who pays for it? I think this probably takes us onto the Ella E: you @laurencoys: final bit to cover it, because obviously you've got a city of fool and foul of Premier League rules. GameDayGyals: Mm. @laurencoys: What does this mean for the Premier League in general? Are we now past the point of no return in terms of the integrity of this league? Because I do think sport in this country, certainly, and football, we pride ourselves on integrity. Look at Wimbledon. Look at the culture of Wimbledon. are... know, we are a nation where we play sports with integrity, we play in an honest way, in the same way that we as football fans absolutely rejected the European Super League as fans of big six clubs who would, our owners tried to drag us in there, right? Because we said it's not competitive. So what does it mean to the Premier League now, if you don't give them a strong enough punishment, how do you then compensate all of the people that missed out? Or does this become a political issue and you do nothing and then it's like well what's the point of having the Premier League? What do you think, starting with you Ella, what do you think the Premier League has got to do to not control the narrative but to make sure that people have faith in the product that is the Premier League after I guess the results of the appeal and whatever the potential punishment may be? Ella E: That's a big question, Lauren, but they have to relegate them. have to. They have to. There's actually no choice. They cannot be seen to be in the Premier League. What they have done is too big. It's way too big. And I think that's a start. I think the relegate, because if you think about it, as you said, Everton got deducted points. All these teams have got deducted points for one breach. @laurencoys: for one breach of the rules. Ella E: 114 they cannot stay in the league they cannot but where do you relegate them to you relegate them to what the bottom of the league to and then probably deduct more points yeah i don't know it's gonna but as fey kind of outlined it's gonna have to be transfer bans gonna have to be a lot of compensation but i just think they have to even though nothing there's no perfect solution that's what we can all agree on that every solution has its problem. But I think if they do those things, the relegation, the transfer ban, the fines, it's a start to at least show that, okay, you're gonna be severely punished from doing this. If they keep them in the league, give them a little fine, fines aren't gonna do it. As you can see, look how much money they hid, let alone, it's not gonna work. So I feel like that's the first step. The only thing the Premier League can do is take that first step. And for me, that starts with relegation to the bottom of the lead to plus deducted points. I think that's the first step. In terms of the titles, I just think they have to be handed down. I don't think we can all avoid the seasons, even though it will never give me the feeling of happiness, apart from that 13, 14 title, because Gerald will be a Premier League winner. But apart from that, it doesn't really do anything for me. But I just think in the name of doing things correctly. You just got to give it to the next people in line. Whether it's something that changes our lives or affects us because we can't celebrate it, that's another debate. But I just think it's principle and they have to. I just don't think they can null and void the seasons. I think that's too, that's even more, even worse personally. @laurencoys: Okay, I mean, we touched on it briefly, but Faye, you've mentioned it GameDayGyals: Mm. @laurencoys: in relation to Chelsea as well, in terms of the Chelsea charges, because you've changed ownership, it's kind of like, well, that was the old regime. Do you think that the city owners should be forced to have to sell? the club and maybe that should be part of the punishment that the Premier League hand out to say you are no longer fit for... because when somebody wants to buy a Premier League club as we saw with the Saudis and them buying Newcastle, they have to pass that you're fit to own cheque, right, in terms of if you're going to own a football GameDayGyals: Hmm. @laurencoys: club. Do the Premier League need to turn around and say actually, since you cannot follow... pretty much a single one of our financial regulations and you've actively deceived us because that's what the commission has found. Do the Premier League need to say that you have to sell the football club to someone else as well? GameDayGyals: 1000 % sorry Roman was forced to sell for just his his nationality Just because of his ethnicity. He was forced to sell us. Yeah They need to force city to sell Sorry They need to sell that club because clearly you think you are above the rules You are above a lot of things and you're not they need to sell I think there needs to be part of it 100 sell the club take out, I don't know, like how much illegal stuff that they were doing, like how much was it, like 900 million or something like that? Close to one billion. Yeah, maybe give that to charity or give it to the city of Manchester, whatever the hell it is, or use it as well for the compensation to go to the different Premier League teams that were affected and stuff like that. They need to sell the club. Hefty fine. I probably feel like maybe States and countries shouldn't be owning certain clubs anymore. I think it just shows that this is the type of thing that's happening because look at what's happening with PSG. They also have come out and said, yeah, we support them. Why? Because we know what you're doing and we know that nothing can happen to them because their league is PSG. And if PSG was to get relegated, it's the end of their league. Just like with Juve, when Juve got relegated, right? Really, Italian football hasn't been the same. Italian football hasn't been the same, yeah? The national team hasn't been the same. So yeah, they need to sell the club, they need to have a massive points deduction, fines, transfer ban, maybe it's like five seasons transfer ban or something crazy like that. Void their trophies, yeah. I don't want Liverpool, @laurencoys: Okay. GameDayGyals: I don't want United to have those trophies. Yes! @laurencoys: Alright, listen, let's leave it there. think, do you know what, I think there's... This is huge. This is huge for our sport in GameDayGyals: Mm. @laurencoys: terms of the breadth and seriousness of these charges is something that we haven't seen before. And I think the punishment that the Premier League has to hand out, you know, it has to be unprecedented. What that will look like, obviously we'll find out after the outcome of the appeal. what happens there. think the good news is, from what I have read, is this actually cannot rumble on for too many years. The appeal has to be heard and the outcome of the appeal before the end of the season. So I think what we will do, we'll leave it here, but we'll come back with a part two because I think there's probably, there's obviously there's going to be so much that's going to emerge, know, Enzo Maresco has to do his press conference over the weekend. this is going to rumble on for the rest of the season, but I think it'll be really interesting to come back and discuss outcome of the appeal, know, if City, you know, if City fail their appeal and discuss our views and what that punishment looks like, because I do think it is a big question for the Premier League. Do you protect one of your biggest assets or... Do you protect the integrity of your products and your competition? And I think that's probably the biggest question that the Premier League have had to answer in ever actually in a really really long time. yes, we will see. We'll leave it there. We will be back again this weekend because yeah, the Premier League is back. But don't forget, follow us on all our socials, at gamedaygirls and we will see you soon. Bye. GameDayGyals: Bye! Ella E: Bye.