Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / “You suck!” How to Respond to Criticism without Losing Your Cool
Transcript
- 0:01Everyone gets criticized. And the more responsibility you have, the more of a target you become. The problem is, though, that if you lose your core, you're also losing your credibility and potentially your sanity. That's why we'll share with you the four wrong ways to react to criticism and the one right path that will ensure that people respect you more. My name is Oliver Aust. I've helped over 300 CEOs become master communicators with my Speak Like a CEO method. And this is Speak Like a CEO, the show that helps you become a top 1% communicator.
- 0:33That's utter nonsense. My colleague said to me years ago at EasyJet, criticizing me, and I was boiling with anger. I shot back, you've no idea what you're talking about. And it went back and forth and it got heated and it didn't help any of us, right? We both looked stupid in the exchange. Lots of wasted energy, lots of negativity.
- 0:52On another occasion, I observed two executives in the boardroom, no less, arguing, or rather one person was shouting at the other. He was saying that because you don't deliver on your side of the project, we are falling short on our targets. And on and on it went, and the other person was just taking it. And at the end of the tirade, he said, that's not helping. Again, both looked stupid. One looked like a bully, the other one like a victim, not like two executives trying to solve a real business problem.
- 1:20Well, these examples show us that there are different ways of responding to criticism. In fact, there are four different kinds of reactions to being criticized. All of these are automated emotional reactions. We've probably used all of them on occasion. The first one is fight, right? You go on the attack and you argue like yours truly not helpful.
- 1:38Second one is flight, which means you're avoiding the conversation, just walk out of the meeting. The third one is freeze. You just sit there and take it, right? You don't know what to do. You freeze in this situation and can't really respond. You probably think hours later, oh, I wish I had said this. The fourth one is to fawn, which means that you try to appease, you apologize. I'm so sorry. It will never happen again.
- 2:02Fight, flight, freeze, or fall. These are adaptive biological behaviors. It makes sense if you're a fighter for survival in the savannah or you're fighting against a lion. But in the business context, they're not helpful. Now, if you fight back, you will look potentially like a bully. You will look like you're not in control because emotional regulation is...
- 2:19valued highly in business. And of course, we also need to be mindful of the long-term fallout. We still have to work with people tomorrow. Getting into these sorts of arguments or being a pushover doesn't help us, doesn't help the team, doesn't help the business. Fortunately, there is one better way of handling situations like this. And I believe it's the only way that ensures that you come out on top of these situations and you keep your credibility and you keep your sanity.
- 2:44What the four ways that I described have in common is that they're automated emotional responses. So that's what we want to avoid. We want to avoid this emotional chain reaction. We wanna be aware of when it happens. So when we feel like anger is brewing or we feel that we are frightened, we need to stop this emotional chain reaction. We need to be aware of what's happened and give us a second to think. We wanna respond and don't react. And the difference is that the response
- 3:12happens slower in the logical part of the brain, our prefrontal cortex, and the reaction, well, that's fast and emotional, and that happens in our reptilian brains. And how do we do this? We need to interrupt this emotional chain reaction before it gets out of control. We need to become aware of the situation and break the chain and think logically about what do we want to do now? How do we want to respond?
- 3:37I know it's not easy, but what helps me is to tell myself, hey, this isn't personal because it probably isn't. This isn't personal, so don't take it personally. Let's make it about the task at hand and let's make sure I keep my cool. Okay, you may say, great, I want to respond. I don't want to react emotionally because that gets me into trouble. But how? How do I do this? What do I actually say?
- 4:01I wish there was this one magical sentence I could give you that would make all the criticism in the world go away. But unfortunately, that doesn't exist because like all leadership communications, it's dependent on context and audience. And you know your context. So what I will give you is seven different ways how you can respond depending on who's in front of you and what the situation is. And by the way, if you prefer this as a simple one pager, I created one for you. Just click on the link down below. Now, the first option you have is to agree at least partially.
- 4:31You may say, I hear you. Yes, we could have done better on this project and we will fix it. Often this disarms the critic and it takes the wind out of their sail. All they wanted to hear is that you know it's gone wrong and you will fix it. So use this if you think that the criticism is justified, but maybe it just was a little over the top. The second option you have is to push back.
- 4:51Always with poise. Well, that's one opinion. Let me share my view, right? So you acknowledge the other person has put their opinion on the table, but you don't accept it. You don't argue about it either. You're just putting your arguments in front of everyone else. You probably aren't going to convince the critic, but you will convince everyone else in the meeting. So this is calm confidence at work. You accept that people have different views, but you're also confident in yours.
- 5:17Here's option number three. Ask a clarifying question. Could you give me an example? Do you have any data to back this up? And you use this if someone is making generalized statements about things you may or may have done, but you think it's unfair and you want them to back this up. What the hell are you talking about, right? But you say this in a polite way, because often what happens is that people don't really have any data or don't have any examples, or at least they're a bit thin, and you come out on top in the conversation. So use this when you think,
- 5:45It's unfair. Don't use this if you think that the criticism is actually justified because you just spent more time hearing about your shortcomings. However, if you think that the criticism is justified, better to use number four, which is bridging. Also known as ABC, answer, bridge, communicate. So you answer briefly, you bridge to what you want to talk about, and then you communicate your key message. For instance, that's fair, but what matters more is this.
- 6:13So this is a proven technique to shift the conversation to what you want to talk about. And that makes it similar to number five, which is reframing. Whoever holds the frame in a conversation usually comes out on top. But compared to bridging, we're not answering the question. We're just changing the frame. Let's say someone criticizes cost overruns. You can say that, yes, cost is important. But let's look at the impact this project has produced.
- 6:39You're shifting the frame to impact and we're no longer talking about cost. There's a different way you can use it. You can also reframe a conversation by saying, what's this really about? If you have the feeling someone is providing superficial criticism, but this is actually about something else, let's have it out in the open. Let's talk about that. It's a high risk move, but sometimes it really pays off. If you can shine a light on what's actually going on, it can be very helpful. But yes, it is a bit risky.
- 7:08What's also risky is option number six, high risk, high reward, I would say, and certainly the most enjoyable. Well, I'm talking about humor, of course. If you're being criticized and say, hey, you're in a great mood this morning, this can diffuse the situation, but it can also add fuel to the fire.
- 7:24especially if the other person feels that you're making fun of them. So you don't want to do that. However, I think there's a great use case for humor. If you're talking to someone, you normally work together well, there is a relationship of trust and you know they can take a joke. So let's say you're at the coffee machine and they start criticizing you without any warning. You may say, hey, you seemed to be in a good mood this morning. And maybe that
- 7:49Yeah, you're right. I'm sorry. I had a bad morning. I had a fight with my kid. I had a terrible traffic jam on the way here. Apologies. And the situation is resolved. But yes, if people think you're making fun of them, that can help you to the fire. If those things don't work, you can still escalate it to up to number seven and you're drawing a boundary. Yes, you're making clear, don't do this. I will not have you talk to me in this way. However, don't say it that way. Don't say...
- 8:16I don't want you to talk to me this way, because usually this leads to escalation and de-escalation. The other person will probably say, I talk to you any way I want, or don't screw up our project if you don't want me to talk to you this way, right? So it probably risks more escalation than de-escalation. Now, here's a better sentence. Instead of this, say, I know you respect me and I respect you, so let's focus on the task at hand.
- 8:41It's very hard to argue with this sentence, right? It's unlikely someone will say, I don't respect you or I don't want to talk about the issue at hand. I want to keep arguing about this, right? Unlikely to happen. So it's a very powerful sentence that you can use in those sorts of situations. And if you truly had enough of the conversation, you can say this. You can say, it seems like we need another meeting to make progress on this project.
- 9:05And that is very powerful because it announces that we are not standing for this sort of behavior. You will walk out of the meeting, but you're not just walking out, right? You're not storming out. You're announcing it with calm confidence to give the other person a chance to de-escalate as well.
- 9:20I hope you will never have to use any of these sentences, ever have to use any of these seven options. But in reality, it will probably happen. It's very likely will happen. And these power phrases will help you when you're being criticized fairly or unfairly so that you can focus on the task at hand, but also maintain the relationship with the other person.
- 9:40But keep in mind, we can't control what other people say. We can only control how we respond. This is what this is really about, that we stop reacting, that we interrupt the emotional chain reaction, that instead we respond with a cool head. So make sure that you download the one pager below on these seven options. Keep them forever because this is evergreen stuff. Remember, if you lose your cool, you're also losing your credibility and your sanity.
- 10:08Do I get it right 100%? No, but close. Because these days I know how to respond and not react. See you next week.