Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Volunteers for Extra Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've got a team member who volunteers for everything. New cross-functional initiative? They raise their hand. The quarterly all-hands presentation? They'll take it. Someone needs to cover the late shift? They're already typing 'I can do it.' Luna: And at first, you're thinking... this is amazing. Why can't everyone be like this? Lucas: Exactly. But if you're a first-time manager, the over-volunteerer is actually one of the trickier people to manage. Because the problem doesn't look like a problem. It looks like enthusiasm, initiative, team spirit. Luna: Right, until three months later they're burned out, or they've taken on so much that their core work slips, or—and this is the one I've seen—they're hoarding all the interesting work and nobody else gets a chance to grow. Lucas: That last one is the real trap. I want to talk about a specific case. A few years ago I consulted with a B2B software company, about 200 people. There was a senior analyst named Priya. She was brilliant, fast, and she said yes to literally every request that came her way. Luna: I feel like I know this person. Every team has one. Lucas: They do. And her manager, who was a first-time manager named David, was initially thrilled. He thought he'd hit the jackpot. But by month four, Priya was working evenings and weekends. Her analysis quality was dropping. And here's the thing—the junior analysts on the team were getting bored. They wanted those projects. But Priya always swooped in first. Luna: So David had a triple problem. Burnout risk, quality erosion, and a development bottleneck for the rest of the team. Lucas: Exactly. And the hardest part for a new manager is that it feels wrong to tell someone to do less. You're supposed to encourage initiative. But the reality is, managing the over-volunteerer is about channeling, not discouraging. Luna: So what did David do? Did he have a conversation? Lucas: He did. And I want to walk through the framework we landed on, because it's repeatable. The core idea is a three-question pre-commitment checklist that Priya—and David—used before she took on anything new. Luna: Okay, I'm listening. What are the three questions? Lucas: First: 'Does this task directly serve my top three priorities this quarter?' Second: 'Is there someone on the team who needs this experience more than I do?' And third: 'If I say yes to this, what am I saying no to?' Luna: That third one is brutal. Because saying yes always has an opportunity cost, but we don't frame it that way. Lucas: Right. And for Priya, the third question was the most powerful. She realized that every time she volunteered for a presentation, she was saying no to deep analytical work that would have more impact. She was also saying no to her own recovery time. Luna: And what about the second question—'does someone need this more?' That's the mentorship angle. Lucas: Exactly. David started using that question to redirect Priya's energy. He'd say, 'Priya, I love that you want to take this on. But I think it would be a great stretch assignment for Marcus. Could you mentor him on it instead?' And Priya got to feel helpful without doing the work herself. Luna: That's such a smart reframe. She still gets to contribute, but now she's building the team's capability rather than just loading her own plate. Lucas: And it worked. Within two months, Priya's hours normalized, her quality came back up, and Marcus—the junior analyst—got exposure to client-facing work he wouldn't have had otherwise. Luna: So the manager's role here is really to be a gatekeeper, but in a positive way. You're protecting the over-volunteerer from themselves, and protecting the team from an imbalance. Lucas: Yes. And I think the hardest part is that you have to be willing to have a candid conversation. David's first instinct was to just let Priya keep going because it was easier. But the cost was too high. Luna: Speaking of things that are worth the investment—if this episode helped you think about a situation on your team, honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, there's a link. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and focused on real management problems. So if you've gotten value, that's the place. Luna: And we mean it—no pressure. Just a small way to say this helped. Now, back to Priya and David. Lucas: So after the three-question checklist was in place, David also started doing something else. He began proactively assigning the 'glamour work'—the high-visibility projects—to other team members before Priya could volunteer. Luna: That's interesting. So he's managing the opportunity, not just the person. Lucas: Exactly. He'd say, 'I'm giving this project to Marcus. Priya, I need you on the backend analytics work. That's where your impact is highest.' And because the checklist had already created awareness, Priya accepted it. Luna: So the conversation wasn't a one-time thing. It was an ongoing system. Lucas: Right. And here's a specific script if you're dealing with this. You can say: 'I appreciate that you're always eager to contribute. That's a huge asset. But I want to make sure you're focusing on the work that only you can do. For this new request, I think it's better for the team if you mentor someone else through it. Would you be open to that?' Luna: That's direct but not punitive. It frames it as a strategic decision, not a criticism. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is to do it early. If you wait until the person is already burnt out, it's much harder to pull back. Luna: What about the employee who volunteers for extra work because they're afraid that if they don't, they'll be seen as not committed? I've seen that too. Lucas: That's a different psychological driver. In Priya's case, it was genuine enthusiasm. But for some people, it's anxiety. They're trying to prove their value. And as a manager, you need to address the root cause. You can say, 'Your job is not at risk. I value your core contributions. In fact, I need you to protect your time for those core contributions.' Luna: That reassurance can be incredibly powerful. It removes the fear that's driving the behavior. Lucas: And it also helps to talk about what 'exceeds expectations' really means. For many over-volunteerers, they think more volume equals better performance. But you as the manager get to define what excellence looks like. And you can say, 'Actually, deep focus on three priorities is more valuable to me than breadth across ten.' Luna: So you're basically redefining the criteria for success. That's a big shift in mindset. Lucas: It is. And it's one of the most important things a first-time manager can learn. You're not just managing tasks. You're managing people's understanding of what good looks like. Luna: What about the team dynamic? If one person is always volunteering, others might feel invisible or think they don't need to step up. Lucas: That's a real risk. The over-volunteerer can unintentionally create a 'bystander effect' on the team. Everyone assumes the eager person will handle it. So you also need to have a team-level conversation about shared responsibility. Luna: How do you do that without calling out the over-volunteerer? Lucas: You frame it positively. You say, 'I want to make sure everyone gets opportunities to stretch and grow. So going forward, I'll be rotating assignments more deliberately. If something comes up that you're interested in, let me know—but I'll also be proactively reaching out to each of you.' Luna: That takes the pressure off the volunteer and spreads the opportunity. Lucas: Exactly. And it also signals that you, as the manager, are in control of the workload distribution. That's actually a relief for the over-volunteerer too, because they don't have to feel like they're the only one carrying the team. Luna: So the bottom line is: the over-volunteerer isn't a problem to be solved, but a resource to be directed. You just have to be intentional. Lucas: Exactly right. And the three-question checklist, the reassignment to mentorship, and the proactive rotation of opportunities—those three tools together give you a repeatable system. Luna: I think the hardest part for new managers is that it feels counterintuitive to tell someone to do less. But you're not telling them to do less, you're telling them to do the right things. Lucas: That's the perfect way to put it. The goal isn't to dim their light. It's to make sure that light is shining on the right work. Luna: And that the rest of the team gets some warmth too. Lucas: Exactly. So next time a team member says 'I'll take it,' pause. Ask yourself: is this the best use of their energy? And then have the conversation.