Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Coast in Contest: Federal Pressure, State Power, and the Shifting Map of Coastal Regulation
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07The Coast in Contest, Federal Pressure, State
- 0:11Power, and the Shifting Map of Coastal Regulation.
- 0:14I'm Alla Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:17Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:19Association. And today I am delighted to introduce
- 0:21our speakers, Douglas Karsten and Maggie Hall.
- 0:25Douglas is the managing partner of Karsten Black
- 0:28and Menteer LLP and has extensive experience
- 0:31in environmental, land use, municipal, and natural
- 0:34resource law. He has been lead counsel on numerous
- 0:38CEQA appellate cases and has been named a Southern
- 0:40California Super Lawyer for environmental law
- 0:43every year since 2009. A graduate of Cornell
- 0:46University and UCLA School of Law, Doug also
- 0:49served five years as a Navy officer prior to
- 0:51law school. Doug is a published writer and frequent
- 0:54lecturer on CEQA, water quality, public trust,
- 0:57and historic resource issues. Maggie Hall is
- 1:01the Deputy Chief Counsel at the Environmental
- 1:03Defense Center, a nonprofit law firm that defends
- 1:06nature and advances environmental justice on
- 1:09California's Central Coast through advocacy and
- 1:12legal action. Maggie manages EDC's docket on
- 1:15issues ranging from climate and energy to ocean,
- 1:19land, water, and environmental justice. Before
- 1:22joining EDC, Maggie worked at Los Angeles Waterkeeper.
- 1:25She's been published in the Natural Resources
- 1:28Journal on Ninth Circuit Administrative Law.
- 1:31We can't wait to hear what they have to share
- 1:32with us today, so I'm now going to turn it over
- 1:34to them. Okay, well, thank you so much, Alla,
- 1:40and I'm really glad to be here and really like
- 1:42to thank you and the association for having us
- 1:48here to talk about the Coastal Act and the coastal
- 1:52issues that are both issues related to the state's
- 1:58relations to local governments and also the state's
- 2:01relations to the federal government. Thank you
- 2:03for that kind introduction. Maybe the Navy background
- 2:06is what gives me an affinity for coastal issues
- 2:10and where the ocean meets the land. That's enough
- 2:15about us at Carstens Black and Meteor. We are
- 2:18here in Redondo Beach, but we practice throughout
- 2:21the state. I wonder if before we jump into all
- 2:23this, we might turn to Maggie for a little more
- 2:26introduction and understanding about the Environmental
- 2:29Defense Center. Thank you, Doug. And honored
- 2:33to join you today. As Alla mentioned, EDC is
- 2:36a nonprofit environmental law firm. We're based
- 2:38here in Santa Barbara, and we represent other
- 2:40nonprofit organizations. Our focus is really
- 2:43on defending nature and advancing environmental
- 2:46justice. And our work covers the Santa Barbara,
- 2:49Ventura, and San Luis Obispo County areas. After
- 2:52Doug's portion of the presentation, I plan to
- 2:54address some recent federal threats to the California
- 2:57coastline and the role of the Coastal Zone Management
- 3:00Act in responding to those threats. But first,
- 3:02I'll hand it back to you, Doug. OK. Well, thank
- 3:06you so much, Maggie. Then let's dive right in.
- 3:09The Coastal Act. We're now at the 50th year anniversary.
- 3:14This is something the Coastal Act itself was
- 3:16passed in 1976. It started and was initiated
- 3:21by an initiative, Prop 20, Proposition 20 in
- 3:25November 1972. when the voters of all of California
- 3:29established the Coastal Commission. And a few
- 3:32years later, the legislature passed the Coastal
- 3:34Act. There was an adaptation of the Code of Regulations
- 3:40to implement the Coastal Act. And before getting
- 3:45into kind of the nuts and bolts of this, I wanted
- 3:47to refer a little bit to the importance of what
- 3:52the Coastal Act and Coastal Protection and Environmental
- 3:55Laws mean to California. This is something where
- 3:59just last week the NOAA or the National Oceanic
- 4:05Atmospheric Administration was considering something
- 4:08Maggie will get into much more later in the presentation.
- 4:12During that presentation, there was one particular
- 4:15comment from Surfrider, and I'd like to quote
- 4:18it. They noted that our world -class beaches,
- 4:21surf spots, fishing grounds, and wildlife populations
- 4:24are national treasures that are enjoyed and valued
- 4:27by residents and visitors alike. Our state's
- 4:30coastline is also an economic engine that supports
- 4:32over 600 ,000 jobs and contributes to a $60 billion
- 4:37coastal economy. From coastal recreation, tourism,
- 4:41fishing, shipping, science and education, our
- 4:44state's economy is fundamentally dependent on
- 4:46a clean and healthy coastal environment. So how
- 4:50do we keep that clean and healthy coastal environment?
- 4:54I think the majesty and power of the Coastal
- 4:58Act and the Coastal Zone Management Act as well
- 5:00here are critical to the ability to do that.
- 5:07we could go to the next slide please. The Coastal
- 5:12Act is umbrella legislation that is designed
- 5:14to work with and encourage local governments
- 5:17to create local coastal plans and to govern decisions
- 5:21that determine the short and long -term conservation
- 5:23and use of coastal resources. Geographically
- 5:27speaking, you can see, even though it's a very
- 5:29small print, but the coastal zone, it covers
- 5:32about 1 .5 % of the state's land mass. But it's
- 5:36right there, of course, along the coast. It's
- 5:391 ,100 miles from Oregon to Mexico, border to
- 5:45border. It includes 287 miles of shoreline surrounding
- 5:50nine offshore islands as well. The little green
- 5:53dots you can see off of California's coast. So
- 5:57the coastal zone encompasses 1 .5 million acres
- 6:00of land, and it stretches from three miles out
- 6:03into the water. and to an inland boundary that
- 6:06varies from several blocks in urban areas to
- 6:09as much as five miles in less developed areas.
- 6:13This is made up of or includes 15 counties and
- 6:1761 cities, and that means a total of 76 jurisdictions
- 6:22are covered and co -administer the act with the
- 6:27Coastal Commission. If we could go to the next
- 6:29slide, please. The functions of the chapters
- 6:34of the Coastal Act, the Coastal Act itself is
- 6:37divided into 10 chapters. Each of them has their
- 6:43own different topics. For instance, one is the
- 6:47findings, two is definitions, six covers implementation,
- 6:52eight is about ports, nine is about judicial
- 6:55review. But the heart of these chapters of the
- 6:59Coastal Act are found in chapter three. which
- 7:02is the Coastal Resources Planning and Management
- 7:05Policies, Section 30200, et cetera. And Chapter
- 7:123 contains seven articles. We'll dive into and
- 7:15talk about each of those seven articles. They
- 7:18mandate protection of public beach access, recreational
- 7:22opportunities, protection of marine and land
- 7:26resources, and they govern all development. So
- 7:29let's learn more about Chapter 3 of the Coastal
- 7:33Act. Starting with Article 1, this is where the
- 7:38policies are defined as basically standards for
- 7:42review of coastal development inside the coastal
- 7:45zone. Article 1 mandates that where these Chapter
- 7:483 policies might be in tension with each other
- 7:51or they conflict, they need to be resolved in
- 7:54a manner which on balance is most protective
- 7:57of significant coastal resources. So you'll see
- 8:00when we get there, there's some policies to protect
- 8:02access. There's some policies to protect environmentally
- 8:05sensitive habitat areas. When different policies
- 8:10pull in different directions, the protection
- 8:13of significant coastal resources has to come
- 8:16first. Let's go to the next slide, please. In
- 8:19Article 2, the Coastal Act addresses public access
- 8:25It mandates that new developments shall not interfere
- 8:28with the public's right of access to the sea.
- 8:31The public's right of access to the sea is an
- 8:33ancient concept. Even as far back or even before
- 8:36the Institutes of Justinian, there was a doctrine,
- 8:40the public trust doctrine, that would allow people
- 8:43access to the waters of the ocean and to the
- 8:46shores of the waters. And I find the Coastal
- 8:50Act to be a modern manifestation of that, ensuring
- 8:53access and right of access to the sea. The Coastal
- 8:57Act mandates developers shall provide new access
- 9:00to the sea, and it places a priority on lower
- 9:05-cost visitor -serving facilities. Even though
- 9:07it's not a straightforward application, it's
- 9:09not clear what lower cost means. The Commission
- 9:12does not specify rates for hotels. It's not even
- 9:16that clear of what visitor serving facilities
- 9:18means. The commission has allowed development
- 9:23of condo hotels, some of which can be considered
- 9:27privatization of the coast. There are policies
- 9:31related to short -term rentals, such as Airbnbs.
- 9:36So the function or Article 2's whole purpose
- 9:41is to increase and promote and protect that public
- 9:44access. Let's go to Article 3, please. Article
- 9:483 deals with recreation. Coastal areas, of course,
- 9:53are suited for coastal recreation activities
- 9:55and have to be protected for such uses. The Coastal
- 9:58Act places priority on coastal dependent recreation
- 10:02and visitor serving uses over residential uses
- 10:05of the coast. Upland areas necessary to support
- 10:08coastal recreation are reserved for such uses.
- 10:11and for coastal aquaculture, and they're given
- 10:14priority except over other coastal dependent
- 10:16uses. So if there's something like a boat storage
- 10:18facility or area, that, because it's coastal
- 10:21dependent, would receive the highest or higher
- 10:24priority. Next is Article 4 regarding the marine
- 10:29environment. Marine resources need to be maintained
- 10:33and enhanced and where feasible restored, and
- 10:36uses have to sustain the biological productivity.
- 10:40of coastal waters. Biological productivity and
- 10:44the quality of coastal waters includes protecting
- 10:47streams, wetlands, estuaries, and lakes. There
- 10:52are major sections of the Coastal Act dealing
- 10:54with wetlands such as 30233 and what's allowed
- 10:58in a wetland and whether you can armor the coast,
- 11:02that is protect against wave action and regarding
- 11:05stream alterations. So let me go to Article 5
- 11:11about land resources. In Section 30240 and 302433,
- 11:19these are the heart of the heart of the Coastal
- 11:21Act pertaining to protection of habitat and species.
- 11:25They protect environmentally sensitive habitat
- 11:27area, which is also abbreviated ESHA, or pronounced
- 11:31E -S -H -A. and it's one of the strongest environmental
- 11:35laws in the nation protecting Esha areas. Esha
- 11:39under the coastal act means any area which plant
- 11:42or animal life or habitats are either rare or
- 11:45especially valuable because of their special
- 11:48nature or role in the ecosystem and they could
- 11:51easily be disturbed or degraded by human activities
- 11:54and development. So even Esha that is degraded
- 12:01is protected by act will serve its biological
- 12:09six, please. Article six of the chapter three
- 12:12policies deals with development. And development
- 12:18is required to be clustered to protect the scenic
- 12:21and visual qualities of the coastal areas. And
- 12:25the location and amount of new development has
- 12:28to maintain and enhance beach access. Public
- 12:32resources, code, provisions, and articles in
- 12:34each of the overheads. I won't read all the numbers,
- 12:35but they're there, buried in the text. New development
- 12:39may not require armoring or substantial alteration
- 12:42of landforms. Again, this is where, especially
- 12:46these days with the inevitability of sea level
- 12:49rise, development along the coast is facing challenges
- 12:53of impinging rising sea levels and wave action.
- 12:57But because of the prevention of armoring, that
- 13:03has created a tension among interests seeking
- 13:07to develop and with the Coastal Commission and
- 13:10Coastal Act seeking to protect landforms and
- 13:13the coast. Just a note, Highway 1, which is Pacific
- 13:17Coast Highway, must remain scenic and a two -lane
- 13:21road in rural areas. I've got actually Pacific
- 13:24Coast Highway right outside the window here in
- 13:26Redondo Beach. but in rural areas it has to remain
- 13:29a scenic two -lane road and article six also
- 13:33mandates coastal development must be coastal
- 13:37dependent and that has a priority over other
- 13:41development. The coast and we see in article
- 13:45seven is also the home of extensive industrial
- 13:50development. Industry also has a place the commission
- 13:54has permitting authority over all offshore oil
- 13:57and gas and energy development within three miles,
- 14:00as well as onshore facilities within the coastal
- 14:04zone. Oil and gas development, tanker facilities,
- 14:09refineries, oil pipelines, all of this is country
- 14:13and the world, so necessary development, but
- 14:17subject to the rules of the Coastal Act. Article
- 14:227 encourages industrial facilities to locate
- 14:25or expand within existing sites and it allows
- 14:28accommodation for coastal dependent facilities
- 14:30such as energy generation requires cooling water
- 14:35sometimes or in certain ways that might be regarded
- 14:39as a coastal dependent use. So the commission
- 14:42has limited input in the siting and design of
- 14:46coastal power plants. Section 30260 states coastal
- 14:51dependent facilities may be permitted even if
- 14:54they're inconsistent with other chapter three
- 14:56policies if alternative locations are infeasible
- 15:00or more environmentally damaging and do otherwise
- 15:04adversely affect the public welfare. So it's
- 15:10possible to approve the coastal power plants,
- 15:13but they have to be mitigated to the maximum
- 15:16extent feasible. That and other coastal industry.
- 15:20If we can go to the next page, please. That wraps
- 15:22up chapter three policies and brings us to a
- 15:26discussion of local coastal plans, other planning
- 15:29documents, and periodic reviews. Local coastal
- 15:33programs, or LCPs, are basic planning tools used
- 15:37by local governments to guide development in
- 15:39the coastal zone. And they're done in partnership
- 15:42with the coastal commission, as we'll explain
- 15:45here. LCPs, the acronym for local coastal programs,
- 15:51They contain the ground rules for future development
- 15:53and protection of resources in 74 coastal cities
- 15:57and counties. We saw the map in earlier slide.
- 16:00They specify the location and type and scale
- 16:03of new or changed uses of the plan. Each LCP
- 16:06includes a land use plan or an LUP and an IP
- 16:11or an implementation plan with measures to implement
- 16:15the plans like zoning ordinances for the coastal
- 16:18areas. This is a good moment to address or bring
- 16:23up a recent Supreme Court case just this year.
- 16:26It was called Shearer Development versus the
- 16:29California Coastal Commission. This is a California
- 16:32Supreme Court case, I should say. And what was
- 16:35interesting and unique about this case was it
- 16:40required an interpretation of an LCP that the
- 16:45county of San Luis Obispo had adopted. and the
- 16:48county had its its interpretation the coastal
- 16:51commission had a different interpretation this
- 16:54was about protection of significant coastal resource
- 16:57areas and the supreme court had to determine
- 17:01how to go about interpreting because sometimes
- 17:04there will be deference due to an agency's interpretation
- 17:07of the coastal act the coastal commission or
- 17:11sometimes the deference goes to the local agency
- 17:13like the county of san luis obispo But when each
- 17:17of those agencies has a different interpretation,
- 17:20then the court found deference wasn't due to
- 17:23either. It required application of traditional
- 17:26principles of statutory interpretation and review
- 17:34of the LCP as a question of law to determine,
- 17:38in that particular case, the Supreme Court found
- 17:40the county's interpretation was the better reasoned.
- 17:46But I find it an interesting illustration of
- 17:49the interplay of the State Coastal Commission
- 17:52interpretation of the LCP versus the local governments
- 17:55or the counties interpretation of the LCP and
- 17:58the cooperation between those two. Let's go to
- 18:01the next page please because this is a bit of
- 18:08a dense slide but in summary the The showing
- 18:13here is many of the 74 counties and cities divide
- 18:18their coastal zone jurisdictions into separate
- 18:21geographic segments. So it ends up that there
- 18:24are about 126 separate LCPs in the state, even
- 18:28though there's only 74 jurisdictions along the
- 18:32coast covering these. As of 2024, just a few
- 18:35years ago when this was posted on the Coastal
- 18:38Commission's website, approximately 76 % of LCP
- 18:42segments have been certified, representing close
- 18:45to 90 % of the geographic area of the coastal
- 18:47zone. So local governments with a certified LCP
- 18:51would be issuing coastal permits in these areas.
- 18:56In some areas, the certified LCP is for only
- 18:59part of the coastal zone. So if there's an area
- 19:02that is not certified or doesn't have a certified
- 19:04LCP, that would be called a white hole or an
- 19:07area of deferred certification. And one thing
- 19:11that's notable about this is some jurisdictions
- 19:13have a very small amount of coastal area, such
- 19:17as Los Angeles or Ventura County, very small
- 19:21percentage. And then over on the right, you see
- 19:24some jurisdictions, 91 to 100 % of their jurisdiction
- 19:28is within the coastal zone, like Del Mar or Laguna
- 19:32Beach areas like that. If we could go to the
- 19:34next slide, please. After a LCP has been approved,
- 19:40the commission's permitting authority over most
- 19:43new development transfers to the local government.
- 19:45That's how the two of them work together, local
- 19:47and the state review, and the local government
- 19:50applies the requirements of the LCP. The commission
- 19:53retains postal permit jurisdiction over development
- 19:57in tidelands, submerged land and public trust
- 20:00land, basically under the water, and also acts
- 20:03on appeals, certain appeals, from the local government.
- 20:05the commission reviews and approves amendments
- 20:07to the LCPs because they are governing documents
- 20:11for the local actions. So the commission certifies
- 20:15those and reviews amendments to them. If we could
- 20:17go to the next page, please. So when an area
- 20:20has a certified LCP, the local government has
- 20:25authority over most development. But if the local
- 20:31city or county approves a project that's not
- 20:34consistent with the certified LCP, it's possible
- 20:37to appeal that under what's called the commission's
- 20:41review jurisdiction. Only by people who have
- 20:45participated at the local level, and it must
- 20:47be done quickly within 10 days after the local
- 20:50government's notice of final local action. there's
- 20:55a very quick small or short closing window for
- 20:58appeals to the commission of local decisions.
- 21:01Local coastal programs are the standard of review
- 21:07and the commission retains as you said jurisdiction
- 21:12over tidelands and public trust lands. Let me
- 21:14go to the next slide because there's also other
- 21:17planning documents and I'll wrap up the next
- 21:19let's say two slides and rather quickly. But
- 21:23in addition to LCPs, there's also long range
- 21:25development plans or LRDPs. They're similar,
- 21:28but they relate to public universities and colleges.
- 21:33Similarly, amendments to LRDPs have to be reviewed
- 21:36by the commission. And then there are port master
- 21:38plans which relate to the ports like San Diego,
- 21:42Los Angeles, Long Beach, and they come to the
- 21:44commission for review and approval of consistency,
- 21:47but the commission is then only notified or noticed
- 21:51of impending development. There's also public
- 21:53work plans or planning documents for major public
- 21:55works, and parks and other public agencies treat
- 22:00these similarly as LRDPs. And the last slide
- 22:03from my presentation would be about LCP periodic
- 22:08reviews. Every five years, the Coastal Act requires
- 22:12the commission to review certified LCPs for conformity
- 22:17and the local government reviews the recommendations
- 22:20of the commission makes about these and within
- 22:22a year is supposed to decide how to take action
- 22:25to implement the review recommendations, which
- 22:29the commission then reviews and reports to the
- 22:32legislature. This sort of review is theoretically
- 22:36a good check and a balance between the back and
- 22:39forth, but it does seem to not have as much teeth
- 22:42as might maybe the legislature hoped in developing
- 22:46this. set of provisions. Let me turn to just
- 22:52a quick comment about federal jurisdiction, because
- 22:56the commission also has jurisdiction over federal
- 22:58permits and activities that federal agencies
- 23:01undertake. But for this discussion, let me turn
- 23:05it over to Maggie for discussion of the Coastal
- 23:09Zone Management Act and other issues related
- 23:13to federal activities in coastal zones. Maggie?
- 23:17Great. Thank you, Doug, and great transition.
- 23:21So I will be picking up on Doug's discussion,
- 23:24especially with respect to the Coastal Act policies
- 23:26with a few more recent case studies from real
- 23:30world examples. So the examples I'll talk about
- 23:33involve federal threats to our California coastline.
- 23:37All of them involve the state's role in reviewing
- 23:39federal projects that arises under the Coastal
- 23:41Zone Management Act. So I'll start with a high
- 23:44level review of some of the key provisions of
- 23:46the CZMA for context. The CZMA was enacted in
- 23:501972 to preserve, protect, develop, and where
- 23:54possible to restore or enhance the resources
- 23:57of the nation's coastal zones, a very ambitious
- 23:59goal. And the law establishes an important dynamic
- 24:03of cooperative federalism. So coastal states
- 24:05develop their own coastal management programs
- 24:08that are tailored to their unique environmental,
- 24:11economic, and social conditions. And once approved,
- 24:14these programs are the basis for managing coastal
- 24:16resources within the state as well. Doug just
- 24:18touched on quite a bit. So under the Coastals
- 24:20and Management Act, that gives states the right
- 24:23to review certain federal actions that affect
- 24:25coastal resources to evaluate if they're consistent
- 24:29with the state programs. So this is broadly referred
- 24:32to as the consistency review process. I will
- 24:37touch on two aspects of the consistency review
- 24:41process with respect to two different kinds of
- 24:43actions. So first, private activities that are
- 24:45subject to federal permits Permits or licensees
- 24:49and affect coastal resources are subject to 16
- 24:53U .S. Code 1456C3A. Such actions must be fully
- 24:59consistent with the state's approved management
- 25:01program. There's implementing regulations that
- 25:04fully describe the process for these activities.
- 25:07They must undergo, which involves the middle
- 25:10of a consistency certification to the state.
- 25:13And then in response to a consistency certification,
- 25:17the state can either concur, object, or it can
- 25:21conditionally concur, in which case it includes
- 25:24a list of conditions that must be satisfied before
- 25:27the project can go ahead. If a state objects
- 25:31to a consistency certification, the federal license
- 25:34or permit cannot go forward as is, but that decision
- 25:38is appealable to the Secretary of Commerce to
- 25:42evaluate if the activity is consistent with the
- 25:45objectives of this chapter, the Coastalism Management
- 25:47Act, or is otherwise necessary in the interest
- 25:50of national security. So again, this is Section
- 25:54C3 dealing with private activities that involve
- 25:57federal permits or license. Then federal agency
- 26:03activities themselves, so activities that are
- 26:05carried out directly by a federal agency that
- 26:08affect coastal resources. must also be consistent
- 26:12to the maximum extent practicable with enforceable
- 26:16policies of the approved state management programs.
- 26:19So this section, C1, the federal agency itself
- 26:24submits what's called a consistency determination
- 26:27to the state. And again, the state can concur,
- 26:30object, or conditionally concur. The outcome
- 26:33of that decision can be challenged in court.
- 26:36And if a court determines that the activity violates
- 26:40C1 of the CZMA, the president may nonetheless
- 26:43exempt the activity from compliance if it determines
- 26:46the activities in the paramount interest of the
- 26:49United States. So those are the two provisions
- 26:54that come up a lot of the time that trigger the
- 26:56consistency review process in our practice. And
- 26:59I'm just going to briefly highlight a couple
- 27:01cases of interest. So first, the CZMA used to
- 27:04include language that effects must be, quote,
- 27:07direct. to trigger consistency review and under
- 27:10that language, a case went to the Supreme Court
- 27:13of the United States and the court determined
- 27:16that lease sales did not trigger the CZMA consistency
- 27:19review process. So in response to that, Congress
- 27:23explicitly amended the CZMA in 1990 to delete
- 27:28the direct effect language and therefore expand
- 27:31the scope of activities that would trigger CZMA
- 27:33review. And consistent with that, The CZMA scope
- 27:39of review authority was also an issue in a 9th
- 27:42Circuit case California v. Norton. That case
- 27:45concerned the government's decision regarding
- 27:47whether to extend certain releases for offshore
- 27:50drilling in California, and the port found this
- 27:53to be a federal agency activity subject to Section
- 27:57C1. This case also made clear that the provisions
- 28:01I just discussed that deal with provisions C1
- 28:04and C3 for federal agency activities and federal
- 28:07license or permits are mutually exclusive. So
- 28:10it's either one or the other and there's sometimes
- 28:13debate about which is the relevant provision
- 28:15and we see that being litigated. So, during this
- 28:23consistency review process under either of those
- 28:26provisions, the Coastal Commission is really
- 28:28looking at consistency of the activity with the
- 28:31California Coastal Management Program. And as
- 28:33Doug mentioned, in California, Chapter 3 of the
- 28:36Coastal Act is really considered the heart of
- 28:38the CCMP, and it provides the key policies governing
- 28:41the coastal zone. So, these policies specifically
- 28:45include protections for marine resources, biological
- 28:48productivity, water quality, ESHA, cultural resources,
- 28:54and commercial and recreational fishing. So with
- 28:58this background in mind, I'm going to turn to
- 29:01an example of a current threat on our coastline,
- 29:04which is an EDC case in which we represent the
- 29:08Santa Barbara Channel Peeper, along with our
- 29:10partner Center for Biological Diversity and Wish
- 29:13Toyo Foundation. So right now there's an oil
- 29:16company called Decor that's currently proposing
- 29:18to conduct fracking from Platform Gilda, which
- 29:21is located in the Santa Clara unit offshore of
- 29:24Ventura County. This project would involve 38
- 29:27fracking treatments to occur at 16 offshore wells
- 29:31over a five -year period. And fracking involves
- 29:35highly toxic chemicals being injected at extreme
- 29:38pressures under the seafloor, and in the case
- 29:40of Platform Gilda, using outdated infrastructure.
- 29:44So it would extend the life of this platform,
- 29:46which has already been operating for 45 years,
- 29:50which is more than twice its anticipated lifespan.
- 29:53This project has potentially devastating impacts
- 29:56for the environment, marine life, recreation
- 29:59and coastal access, commercial and recreational
- 30:01fishing, cultural resources, and of course, climate
- 30:05goals because it prolongs the use of fossil fuels.
- 30:10So, for context, this map shows the offshore
- 30:13platforms in the Santa Barbara Channel region
- 30:14for those not familiar with it and the history
- 30:18of our region. is actually quite interesting.
- 30:21The very first offshore oil drilling in the world
- 30:23occurred in 1896 off Summerlin, California. And
- 30:27then once that technology was developed to go
- 30:30further offshore, the platforms that we see in
- 30:32Santa Barbara today were installed. And that's
- 30:34really between 1967 and 1989. And those are all
- 30:38located in federal waters, approximately four
- 30:40to 10 miles offshore. So five of these platforms
- 30:43are already slated for decommissioning. Those
- 30:45are the ones highlighted in yellow, including
- 30:48the one ones that are in the Santa Clara unit
- 30:51right next to platform Gilda to the far right
- 30:53of the map. If you can see them on this screen.
- 30:58And of course, we all know that drilling in this
- 31:01Santa Barbara channel region has come with historic
- 31:04potentially disastrous consequences. One of the
- 31:08notorious examples of that is in 1969, the well
- 31:12blowout at Platform A in Santa Barbara sent an
- 31:15estimated 3 million gallons of crude oil into
- 31:17the Pacific Ocean, which devastated wildlife,
- 31:21marine ecosystems, and tourism and gave rise
- 31:23to the modern day environmental movement. So
- 31:27this spill and the more recent 2015 Plains spill
- 31:31that occurred at Refugio State Beach are some
- 31:34examples of the inherent risks in offshore drilling.
- 31:37Decor's project would extend the life of the
- 31:40platform and thereby prolong all of these risks,
- 31:43such as the risk of oil spills. In addition,
- 31:48fracking also presents additional risks because
- 31:51it involves highly pressurized injection of toxic
- 31:54chemicals. So there's the risk that these chemicals
- 31:57could spill and that platform discharges would
- 31:59be contaminated, which could affect marine life
- 32:02like sea otters, birds, whales, and also degrade
- 32:05coastal water quality. So just as a side note,
- 32:10There's a bit of a complex history here. This
- 32:13proposal by DECOR is really set against a background
- 32:16of years of litigation that results in an injunction
- 32:19that we actually have in place today that prohibits
- 32:22the federal government from approving fracking
- 32:25and acidizing and other forms of these unconventional
- 32:28practices are collectively called well, simulation
- 32:30treatments until and unless it complies with
- 32:33various environmental laws. So that all came
- 32:36about first in 2011. Our organization launched
- 32:41an investigation on the use of fracking from
- 32:43platforms as that practice started to become
- 32:45known on shore. And at that time, we uncovered
- 32:48about 51 permits that approved fracking without
- 32:51any environmental analysis or public process.
- 32:54So that led to a lawsuit and the government settled
- 32:57committing to do the first ever environmental
- 33:00analysis. After releasing the analysis, it decided
- 33:04to allow the use of well simulation treatments
- 33:07without any conditions or any limitations throughout
- 33:10the platforms and federal waters across Southern
- 33:13California. So not just the Santa Barbara Channel
- 33:15region, but all Southern California waters, 23
- 33:19in total. So that led to another lawsuit challenging
- 33:23the adequacy of that analysis under the National
- 33:26Environmental Policy Act, the Endangered Species
- 33:29Act, and the state of California brought a claim
- 33:33under the Coastal Zone Management Act. So our
- 33:36cases all ended up in the Ninth Circuit, where
- 33:38the court found that the approval of fracking
- 33:40and acidizing violated all of these laws and
- 33:43prohibited the practices until the federal government
- 33:46conducted the required analysis. So, regarding
- 33:51the CCMA specifically, the court held that the
- 33:54action is a federal agency activity. And going
- 33:56back to those two provisions I just mentioned,
- 33:59there was some dispute as to whether it should
- 34:01be classified as a C1 or a C3 activity. And the
- 34:05court held that it fell under 16 U .S. Code 1456C1
- 34:11as a federal agency activity and that it was
- 34:14outside the scope of C3 concerning federal licenses
- 34:17and permits. And the court also stressed kind
- 34:21of the purpose of the CZMA and its ruling that
- 34:25it was, quote, important to keep in mind that
- 34:27in this sphere of the law, both the federal government
- 34:29and California have an important role to play
- 34:32to keep the coastline safe and prosperous. And
- 34:35it's really stressed the need for this programmatic
- 34:38level of review to happen under C1 of the CZMA
- 34:41before any actions could go forward. So, since
- 34:50that litigation with that injunction still in
- 34:52place, we haven't seen any efforts by the federal
- 34:54government to move forward on offshore wealth
- 34:57simulation until the proposal I just mentioned
- 35:00by. So. While the federal government has not
- 35:05satisfied the terms of the injunction, we are
- 35:08nonetheless faced with this proposal, which decor
- 35:11took to the coastal commission and submitting
- 35:14a consistency certification. And just last week
- 35:18on Thursday, the coastal commission held a hearing
- 35:20and objected to the project based on numerous
- 35:24inconsistencies with the coastal act. So the
- 35:27staff report concluded that fracking would materially
- 35:30increase the risk of a spill of crude oil and
- 35:33other. hazardous substances by extending and
- 35:36intensifying the use of aging infrastructure.
- 35:40So this goes back to Section 30232 of the Coastal
- 35:45Act, which requires that Projects have effective
- 35:49containment and cleanup facilities in place and
- 35:53because there was the risk of a spill and also
- 35:56the risk of oil also the risk of a spill of the
- 35:59chemicals used in the fracking process. The coastal
- 36:03commission evaluated the cleanup and containment
- 36:06measures that has in place and determined them
- 36:09to be ineffective. So it found a violation of
- 36:12this section. And an inconsistency with Section
- 36:1530232 that is enough to give them grounds to
- 36:20object. To the project, so the coastal commission
- 36:24in light of an inconsistency can object. It can
- 36:28also object if it finds that there's inadequate
- 36:30information to be able to even evaluate whether
- 36:34a project is inconsistent with certain policies.
- 36:37So, in this case, the commission staff report
- 36:41concluded that the, there was an inconsistency
- 36:44with this section and ultimately the commission
- 36:46adopted that recommendation. Sort of stemming
- 36:54from that finding of the increased risk of oil
- 36:57spills and the toxic chemical spills, the staff
- 37:01report also elaborated on numerous other inconsistencies
- 37:06with policies related to marine life, water quality,
- 37:10and fishing that all stem from those increased
- 37:13risk of oil spills. It also talks about the potential
- 37:17for discharges from the platform to contain remnant
- 37:22fracking fluids, and those discharges and the
- 37:24impacts on marine life have not been adequately
- 37:26studied. So that all led to inconsistencies based
- 37:30on the protection of coastal waters, water quality
- 37:33and marine resources, and impacts to commercial
- 37:36and recreational fishing. And finally, it found
- 37:42the project would not assure against coastal
- 37:45hazards over its lifetime or provide maximum
- 37:48coastal access and recreational opportunities.
- 37:52This area is highly seismic. There's known active
- 37:56faults near the platform and our comment letters
- 37:59highlighted studies that link fracking to increased
- 38:02seismicity. So there's a concern about intensifying
- 38:07coastal hazards and the platform itself was not
- 38:10really designed and has aged significantly. but
- 38:15was not designed in the 1st place to be able
- 38:16to withstand the kind of ground shaking we would
- 38:19expect to see in the event of an earthquake.
- 38:21So those are all contributions to coastal hazards
- 38:24that give rise to inconsistencies with sections
- 38:2730253A and B of the Coastal Act. And a couple
- 38:31other sections that relate to coastal access
- 38:34and recreational opportunities are 30210, 30213
- 38:39and 30220 and the Commission found inconsistencies
- 38:43with all of those policies in its staff report.
- 38:46The staff recommended that and ultimately the
- 38:48commission voted unanimously in support finding
- 38:54an objection to this project. So just noting
- 38:59next steps there, like I said, there is a potential
- 39:02for an appeal of a decision based on objection
- 39:07to a consistency certification. So this just
- 39:09happened last week and we'll be monitoring for
- 39:11any next steps. So I just want to briefly highlight
- 39:15a couple more active threats to our coastline.
- 39:19One is the Trump administration's proposal to
- 39:21do entirely new offshore oil and gas drilling
- 39:24off California. So in California state waters,
- 39:27no new leasing has occurred since the 1969 oil
- 39:31spill. And in federal waters, no new leasing
- 39:34has occurred in our region since 1984. But BOEM,
- 39:40the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, has announced
- 39:42it is developing a new five -year leasing program.
- 39:46Overall, the program includes new oil drilling
- 39:48and 3 out of the 4 regions in the United States,
- 39:51including the Gulf, Alaska, and the Pacific with
- 39:54a schedule of 34 these sales that could begin
- 39:56as early as 2027. And it includes California.
- 40:02So under the comment period, EDC and thousands
- 40:06of others objected and said that. You know, the
- 40:09state of California should be excluded from new
- 40:11leasing. Unfortunately, the current drop does
- 40:14include California. There was 6 lease sales to
- 40:18occur in 2027, 2029 and 2030 and 3 of those to
- 40:23occur in our region in Santa Barbara, which is
- 40:26designated as the Southern California program
- 40:28area. And I should say extends all the way down
- 40:31down the coast. California. So just for context,
- 40:37this leasing program arises under the Outdoor
- 40:40Continental Shelf Lands Act, which involves a
- 40:43four -step process to approving oil and gas drilling.
- 40:46This process falls under step one, which is the
- 40:48development of a five -year leasing program.
- 40:51That would be followed by lease sales, exploration,
- 40:54and, ultimately, development and production.
- 40:58This particular process is still ongoing. There's
- 41:02been a request for information on the concept.
- 41:04There was a public comment period associated
- 41:06with that. Then there was a 60 -day comment period
- 41:10that ended in January after first draft was circulated.
- 41:13Right now we're waiting for the next draft to
- 41:15be released, which would trigger a 90 -day comment
- 41:17period. So as this program goes forward, if The
- 41:25federal government is really pursuing new California
- 41:27lease sales. That's an enormous threat to a very
- 41:31sensitive region. Santa Barbara area in the channel
- 41:35is known as the Galapagos of North America because
- 41:37we have such incredible biological diversity
- 41:39and this. program really creates significant
- 41:43risks for our state's environment, tourism and
- 41:45recreation, economy and quality of life. As many
- 41:49of you probably know, this region is home to
- 41:51specially designated places like the Channel
- 41:54Islands National Park. We have two national marine
- 41:56sanctuaries and we have key habitat for countless
- 42:01species including bluefin and humpback whales,
- 42:04sea otters, sea turtles and more than 500 different
- 42:07fish species. So, in addition to moving forward
- 42:11on this 5 year leasing program, we've also seen
- 42:14an inappropriate sort of skip forward to trying
- 42:19to get ahead of the environmental review process
- 42:21for the California lease sales specifically.
- 42:24So, the federal government already held a comment
- 42:26period on lease sales, even though the. The program
- 42:31itself has not been approved, so I'm just highlighting
- 42:34this project because, as you can imagine, many
- 42:38of the impacts that I just mentioned, and the
- 42:40resources at stake in California's coastal waters.
- 42:45Are going to be threatened and the coastal act
- 42:48policies provide. important tools for addressing
- 42:51those threats. So that's why the consistency
- 42:54review process will be very important. If these
- 42:57lease sales are to go forward, we would expect
- 42:59to see a consistency review process where the
- 43:01state could evaluate whether the new lease sales
- 43:04are in fact consistent with the Coastal Act policies.
- 43:12So I will end with one final timely action that
- 43:16continues in this theme of the current administration's
- 43:21threat to local resources. In June 2026, the
- 43:25National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,
- 43:28or NOAA, announced that it's seeking public comment
- 43:32on the review of the California Coastal Management
- 43:34Program. So this is incredibly concerning because
- 43:38it could essentially result in the decertification
- 43:41of the CCMP, and there's really no reason to
- 43:44be evaluating this program at this time. So,
- 43:48as we just talked about, the CZMA has this really
- 43:50important role for states to play in reviewing
- 43:52certain federal actions, and the Coastal Act
- 43:55policies give agencies like the Coastal Commission
- 43:59teeth to object to certain projects based on
- 44:02inconsistencies or inadequate information, as
- 44:05we just saw with the example of the deport fracking
- 44:07proposal. And periodic reviews are appropriate
- 44:13under the CZMA. Section 312 provides for the
- 44:17focus of these reviews and they're supposed to
- 44:19be based on how the state has implemented and
- 44:22enforced its program and address coastal management
- 44:26needs. So the state of California has long excelled
- 44:30and its track record is quite remarkable. It's
- 44:33really a nationwide leader in protecting coastal
- 44:35resources. There's incredible language in the
- 44:39past. 19 evaluation, establishing California
- 44:43as a leader and excelling in the criteria of
- 44:47implementing and enforcing its program and addressing
- 44:49coastal management needs. California is already
- 44:53subject to an ongoing 2025 evaluation that has
- 44:58draft findings that also continues in that direction
- 45:04of an excellent review of the state. So we saw
- 45:07this. Announcement from the federal government
- 45:10right in the middle of an already ongoing process
- 45:13that is improperly seeking to invoke this periodic
- 45:17review authority. But it really seems to be targeting
- 45:21certain areas, like offshore oil and other industries.
- 45:25So. There was a hearing in Santa Monica where
- 45:28Noah received comments from the public and EDC,
- 45:32along with many other state agencies and other
- 45:35partners, advocated to Noah to abandon this process.
- 45:40Essentially the vast majority of the time that
- 45:43the Coastal Commission reviews federal projects.
- 45:46Something over 95 % of the time, it does not,
- 45:49in fact, object to these projects, but when it
- 45:51does, it's based on good reason with benefits
- 45:54for the coast, for tourism, for the economy.
- 45:58So these outliers shouldn't be a reason to, you
- 46:01know, undermine the entire process. So that was
- 46:04the focus of the hearing on Monday. There is
- 46:06currently a written comment opportunity and comments
- 46:10are due on Friday. Anyone who's interested in
- 46:13that process. And with that, I think we wanted
- 46:18to leave time for some questions. And I know
- 46:21Doug also had a few additional remarks. If you'd
- 46:25like to jump back in, Doug, otherwise we can
- 46:27answer some questions. Well, thank you, Maggie.
- 46:31Yeah, I think entertaining questions would be
- 46:34great. There were some topics or sort of closing
- 46:39the loop or some of the things that you covered
- 46:42reminded me of asking. You mentioned a little
- 46:47bit of the other federal laws in addition to
- 46:52the CZMA, the bearing of the Outer Continental
- 46:57Shelves or OXLA, right? Or I think there's also
- 47:02laws like the marine protection, marine mammals
- 47:05protection or NIMS. Have you seen, do those come
- 47:10into play? during the the czma reviews or are
- 47:15those sort of independent and and where do they
- 47:18fit in and how do they work with the czma that
- 47:22that's a very interesting question i think um
- 47:26what i would say is that so in the edc versus
- 47:29bohm opinion that was actually addressed when
- 47:32the court looked at you know which Federal laws
- 47:36are triggered by, for example, the federal government's
- 47:39decision to allow fracking and the federal government's
- 47:42position in that case. was that their decision
- 47:45wasn't an agency action at all. So that had relevance
- 47:49to several environmental laws. So I think it's
- 47:52important when you're thinking about what is
- 47:55the trigger for whether the CZMA process even
- 47:58applies to think about, well, if you have an
- 48:02agency action that triggers the CZMA process,
- 48:04what other laws does that also trigger? And I
- 48:06think. Those are pretty similar standards. So,
- 48:10under the Endangered Species Act, you have a
- 48:13definition of agency action that is quite broad
- 48:16and in alignment with the Coastal Zone Management
- 48:19Act. And then under the National Environmental
- 48:22Policy Act, you have federal agency Actions or
- 48:27final agency actions that are subject to the
- 48:29court's review. So, in our case in ABC versus
- 48:34phone, that case went to the nice circuit and
- 48:36the court rejected all of the government's arguments
- 48:40that there was no agency action and it found
- 48:43that the approval of fracking. Was in fact an
- 48:46agency action that triggered. NEPA, as well as
- 48:50the Endangered Species Act, and also the Coastal
- 48:53Zone Management Act. So I think it's more of
- 48:56a question to think about when you're thinking
- 48:58about what triggers the threshold for even having
- 49:02to go through this CZMA process. I will say during
- 49:07the Coastal Commission hearing on the fracking
- 49:10example, the question of compliance with federal
- 49:14laws, I would say, is outside the scope of the
- 49:17Coastal Commission's authority, and that became
- 49:20pretty clear in the hearing. It was interesting
- 49:24because, like I mentioned in our fracking case,
- 49:27there's currently an injunction that says the
- 49:30federal government shall not approve any applications
- 49:34for fracking, acidizing, or any form of wall
- 49:36stimulation until it complies with the CZMA and
- 49:40other laws. Um, so some of the commissioners
- 49:43during their deliberations said, well, can we
- 49:46even be entertaining this if there's an adjunction
- 49:48that prohibits the federal government from approving
- 49:51it? So it really puts them in a bind. Um, and
- 49:55the staff report recommended that even though
- 49:57we don't think. We should even be looking at
- 50:00the consistency of this 1 project with the coastal
- 50:04act. The problem is in the implementing regulations,
- 50:09if the coastal. Commission receives a consistency
- 50:12certification or determination. There's really
- 50:16strict deadlines on which they have to act. And
- 50:19if they don't object to a project, they could
- 50:21risk being deemed to have concurred. In the project,
- 50:26so the coastal commission staff report said,
- 50:29well, we don't think this should be happening,
- 50:30but we don't want to risk essentially accidentally
- 50:33concurring by our silence. So. Their recommendation
- 50:38was to nonetheless act on the consistency certification
- 50:41and some questions were directed to legal staff
- 50:45for the commission, which also agree that this
- 50:47was somewhat of an unprecedented situation and.
- 50:53You know, we'll see it, we'll see how it plays
- 50:55out in terms of, you know, whether this project
- 50:58is continuing to go forward. Speaking of, yeah,
- 51:03talking about an unprecedented situation, I think
- 51:06one of my questions to you would have been what
- 51:08your forecast for this might be, but that might
- 51:11be a little bit unfair trying to predict where
- 51:14something is going to go if it's not really happened
- 51:17before. But I think you mentioned the comment
- 51:21period. What comes next or what may come down
- 51:25in terms of actual uh mandated steps that will
- 51:32occur so there is the opportunity for the secretary
- 51:37of commerce to address an appeal of the consistency
- 51:40certification um that also came up at the hearing
- 51:44um sort of in the background i think some commissioners
- 51:48had on their minds um the next step so if if
- 51:52the Secretary of Commerce addresses this issue,
- 51:55it would be evaluating whether the action is
- 51:58in the interests of national security. So, while
- 52:01that question of national security is not. directly
- 52:05relevant to whether the Coastal Commission finds
- 52:07a project is inconsistent with Coastal Act policies,
- 52:11it did still come up at the hearing. And we actually
- 52:15retained an expert economist that evaluated the
- 52:19role of the decore fracking proposal in context
- 52:23of military uses and global and national consumption
- 52:27rates and drafted a letter for us that we've
- 52:31submitted now in the record to the Coastal Commission.
- 52:33that states that the amount of crude oil that
- 52:39this company would contribute is truly knowledgeable
- 52:42and would therefore not support national security
- 52:46interests. And also that the way that the military
- 52:49functions doesn't actually rely directly on crude
- 52:52oil in this way. And so this conclusion was that
- 52:55there's basically no chance that this would be
- 52:58justified under a finding of national security.
- 53:01Have you seen something like that as well? Sort
- 53:04of the invocation of the national security angles
- 53:06in, say, the Sable situation or other efforts
- 53:10where the federal government may find reasons
- 53:13or excuses not to allow California to regulate?
- 53:18Yes, and I'd say that's a big theme right now
- 53:21with the federal government in particular in
- 53:23relation to oil projects invoking These sort
- 53:27of emergency procedures as a way to bypass important.
- 53:33Important policy and process for certain environmental
- 53:38laws. So we've seen some shortcutting of the
- 53:41comment periods. For example, the national environmental
- 53:44policy act. Under the 5 year leasing program,
- 53:48we actually saw. What I had seen is the tightest
- 53:52deadline I had ever seen was a 10 day scoping
- 53:55period under NEPA to actually comment on the
- 54:00environmental analysis and that. That 10 -day
- 54:03scoping was actually under the deep work fracking
- 54:04proposal. But we're seeing these really truncated
- 54:07environmental review processes. And also, they've
- 54:11abandoned the practice of circulating a draft
- 54:13environmental impact statement for comment. So
- 54:16we're seeing these efforts to invoke the so -called
- 54:20emergency, which our facts undermine to try to
- 54:24expedite these projects. And you've talked about
- 54:28oil drilling, and certainly that. both drilling
- 54:31and transportation on land, but there's so many
- 54:35other federal activities. I believe SpaceX and
- 54:40the launches that are up and down and affecting
- 54:44the coast. What other federal activities would
- 54:48the CZMA cover in addition to oil drilling and
- 54:52transportation? I would say the plain language
- 54:58of Of the is quite broad. It's really any. Federal
- 55:05action that requires a, you know, or any private
- 55:09action that requires a federal permit or license
- 55:10that affects the coastal zone. Um, or coastal
- 55:14uses and resources, um, or federal activities
- 55:17themselves that likewise have that effect. So,
- 55:20I would say the most popular ones that were raised
- 55:23at the hearing during the NOAA review had to
- 55:27deal with space issues as well as oil and gas.
- 55:31Um, but really, you know, whatever arises, um,
- 55:36you know, as currently drafted, the language
- 55:38would encompass, um, you know, anything that
- 55:40really threatens those coastal resources. And
- 55:44with the CZMA being federal, I imagine it applies
- 55:48to other states, Florida, Maine, Michigan, even.
- 55:52Do other states have a coastal act like California
- 55:55does? And how do they protect their coast? I
- 55:58mean, to the extent you know, or do they? I'm
- 56:01not as familiar with implementation outside of
- 56:04the state other than to say that I know California
- 56:07has been deemed, you know, really a model for
- 56:10other states. And, you know, its track record
- 56:13is so strong that we don't think this review
- 56:16should even be happening in the first place.
- 56:19Aren't there about, is it this one that other
- 56:22states follow California's lead that maybe, you
- 56:25know, a informal, or it may actually be something
- 56:29that affects other states' plans. If this review,
- 56:34which is unprecedented, goes forward, it could
- 56:36affect their protection as well. I think so.
- 56:42I think it's just a dangerous precedent. Like
- 56:46a lot of these activities, if one bad action
- 56:52goes forward, we're worried about the ramifications
- 56:54for Activities across the coastline, so we're
- 56:58worried about, for example. If 1 oil company
- 57:02is allowed to frack from 1 platform. You know,
- 57:06will other oil companies pursue that in other
- 57:09regions and I think that. You know, the, the
- 57:13way that the federal government. Right now has
- 57:17disregarded laws and the state and federal level,
- 57:20as we've seen in many of our cases is particularly
- 57:23concerning because these processes we've described
- 57:26really establish an important role for the state.
- 57:30Your reference to, like, NEPA, the National Environmental
- 57:33Policy Act, reminds me, there's EISs, of course,
- 57:37environmental impact statements at the federal
- 57:39level that are done. In California, the corollary
- 57:42is the environmental impact report under the
- 57:44California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA.
- 57:47Somewhere during the presentation, I'm thinking
- 57:50it might be worth noting. I'm trying to think
- 57:53of which slide it might have fit in, but the
- 57:56Coastal Commission is what's called a certified
- 57:58regulatory agency or an agency that actually
- 58:03implements its own essentially version of environmental
- 58:07review. So it doesn't have to comply with, there
- 58:10are two chapters of the California Environmental
- 58:12Quality Act that it's exempted from. So that's
- 58:19just by way of illustrating the Coastal Commission
- 58:22and their implementation of the Coastal Act is
- 58:26a little bit of a different animal than a local
- 58:32or a city or county's implementation of an environmental
- 58:36law like the California Environmental Quality
- 58:38Act. They have their own program, both with regard
- 58:41to the local projects, but then with regard to
- 58:44the federal projects. So yeah, the certified
- 58:51regulatory nature of it did distinguish the commission
- 58:57from others. When you mentioned the big players
- 59:02who are involved with projects like this, do
- 59:05they ever claim that they cannot be regulated
- 59:07because it would be unconstitutional because
- 59:09it might be a taking or in some way, you know,
- 59:13not giving them a permit would interfere with
- 59:15their reasonable expectation of being able to
- 59:18conduct their activities. We have seen arguments,
- 59:23you know, generally in oil projects about takings
- 59:29and other constitutional claims. I would say
- 59:33at this stage, Of the coastal commission process,
- 59:37that's really not relevant. It really is a narrow
- 59:40review of consistency with coastal act policies.
- 59:45So. Ultimately, um. You know, the question of
- 59:50takings is really not going to influence the
- 59:52commission. Okay, yeah, that may be something
- 59:55more to the state vis -a -vis local agencies.
- 1:00:00Cities and counties will often encounter resistance,
- 1:00:04let's say to some regulatory measure, and it
- 1:00:08might manifest itself by people claiming if they
- 1:00:10can't develop in the way that they're proposing
- 1:00:13that that would be unconstitutional. There's
- 1:00:16a provision in the Coastal Act 30010 that allows
- 1:00:21the commission to basically interpret the takings
- 1:00:24clause in a way to make sure there's no violation.
- 1:00:33So that's a component that I didn't mention as
- 1:00:37we were talking about the local government working
- 1:00:39with the state regulatory authority. Is there
- 1:00:43anything else that you wanted to cover or make
- 1:00:46sure was said? Because I see we're getting closer,
- 1:00:49maybe just past our hour. of time. And if there
- 1:00:54are any questions, we'll take them certainly.
- 1:00:56But Maggie, did you want to add anything big
- 1:00:58picture or before we before we close? I think
- 1:01:05I mean, big picture. I probably already made
- 1:01:08this point, but I just think that this dynamic
- 1:01:12of cooperative federalism is so essential, especially
- 1:01:15now and seeing the teeth that the state's policies
- 1:01:19really have. No one else is going to be in a
- 1:01:23better position to know the issues that our coastline
- 1:01:27faces. And so seeing those policies, we need
- 1:01:31to keep ensuring that they are in place and continuing
- 1:01:37to be implemented when it comes to important
- 1:01:39projects like this. I think that's a great closing
- 1:01:43note. The cooperative federalism is reflected
- 1:01:46also in the cooperative state and local relation
- 1:01:51between cities and counties and the Coastal Commission.
- 1:01:54There's overlapping authority, there's different
- 1:01:59jurisdictions or views on how to implement things.
- 1:02:04I think the state currently or I should say the
- 1:02:07federal government is very much out of step with
- 1:02:09some state values and implementations and that's
- 1:02:13evident. Sometimes the state is at odds with
- 1:02:17local governments. Some, you know, in certain
- 1:02:21policy choices, very different from others. So
- 1:02:25this is what we meant by the Kostin contest.
- 1:02:29There is this shifting map of power and dynamics
- 1:02:33and really appreciate, you know, being able to
- 1:02:37cover this with you and for the audience's attention.
- 1:02:41So really really would like to again thank the
- 1:02:44Beverly Hills Bar Association for allowing us
- 1:02:47to make this presentation. And I'll second that
- 1:02:52gratitude. I hope that was informative and happy
- 1:02:55to answer any questions. Feel free to always
- 1:02:57follow up with email if you have a question that
- 1:03:00later arises and thank you to the association
- 1:03:03for hosting us. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:03:08Thank you so much to Doug and Maggie for an excellent
- 1:03:10presentation today and thank you so much to our
- 1:03:12audience for joining us. Have a great day everybody.