Latest / B2B SaaS Talks with Fexingo: Enterprise Software, Sales Cycles, and Procurement / Why Enterprise Software Buyers Are Ganging Up on Vendors
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this quietly growing trend in enterprise software procurement that most sales teams are still pretending doesn't exist. Buyers are ganging up. Luna: Ganging up? Like forming a union? Lucas: Essentially, yes. Formal buying consortia. Think a group of mid-sized enterprises — each too small to command the discounts a Fortune 100 gets — pooling their software purchasing power to negotiate as a single block. Luna: I've heard whispers of this in healthcare. Hospital systems sharing a regional network and jointly buying EHR software. Lucas: Exactly the example I was going to use. There's a specific case from early this year that crystalizes the whole dynamic. Fifteen mid-sized hospital systems — none of them academic medical centers, none with over a thousand beds — formed what they called the Healthcare SaaS Buyer Coalition. They represented about three hundred million dollars in annual software spend, combined. And they went to their major EHR vendor, which we'll call HealthStack. Luna: And HealthStack actually negotiated with them as a group? Lucas: That's the part that surprised me. HealthStack initially refused. Their enterprise sales VP said they don't negotiate with 'trade unions for buyers.' But the coalition had leverage. They'd already agreed on a minimum common requirement set and had a shared legal framework. They told HealthStack: if you don't give us a consolidated pricing tier, we'll each go to your three biggest competitors individually. The vendor calculated the risk of losing fifteen accounts over the next three years versus offering a steeper discount. They caved. Luna: So what was the actual discount? Lucas: Twenty-eight percent off list, plus a five-year fixed escalation cap of three percent annually. Normally those contracts have six to nine percent annual increases. The coalition members individually were getting maybe eight to twelve percent discounts before. They collectively got twenty-eight. Luna: That's a massive margin hit for the vendor. But it's locked-in revenue for five years. Lucas: Right. And that's the trade-off the vendor accepted. The coalition model is spreading beyond healthcare. I've seen similar structures in manufacturing ERP procurement and in construction project management software. Any sector where you have a fragmented buyer base and a handful of dominant vendors. Luna: But isn't there a legal risk? I mean, buyers colluding on pricing — that's usually a vendor antitrust concern, not a buyer one. Lucas: Generally, buyer cooperatives are legal under US antitrust law as long as they don't involve price-fixing on the buy side in a way that harms competition. The Supreme Court precedent goes back to the 1980s, actually — Northwest Wholesale Stationers vs. Pacific Stationery. Buyer-owned cooperatives are pro-competitive if they increase efficiency and don't exclude competitors. The key is that the coalition members are voluntarily aggregating demand, not coercing suppliers. Luna: But what about information sharing? If they share what each currently pays, that's sensitive. Lucas: That's the grey zone. Most coalition agreements have a firewall — they share aggregate spend data, not individual contracts. The legal paperwork I've seen requires an independent third party to manage the price benchmarking. The members never see each other's line-item costs. They only see the combined negotiation outcome. Luna: Still, this feels like a reaction to a specific market failure — pricing opacity in enterprise software. If vendors are forced to become more transparent, does the coalition still hold together? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. My view is that coalitions are a structural response to a structural problem. Enterprise software pricing has always been bespoke — list price is a fiction, discounts vary wildly, and vendors use nondisclosure agreements to keep buyers in the dark. The coalition doesn't just extract a better price — it reduces transaction costs. One negotiation instead of fifteen. One legal review. One security assessment. Luna: So for the vendor, it's lower sales cost too. Lucas: Exactly. HealthStack spent four months negotiating with the coalition. That's actually shorter than their average enterprise deal cycle of six to nine months for a single large account. And they closed fifteen logos in one contract. The cost of sale per customer dropped dramatically. Luna: But what about the sales rep? The enterprise sales rep who would have run those individual deals — they just lost their commissions. Lucas: That's the human friction point. Vendors are starting to create 'coalition account manager' roles — a single rep who manages the entire consortium relationship. It's a different skill set. Less hunter, more farmer. And the comp structure changes: base plus community bonus rather than individual quota. Luna: Interesting. So the sales playbook is shifting. Let's talk about how a vendor should prepare for a coalition approach. Lucas: First: assume it's coming. If you sell to mid-market enterprises and your pricing is opaque, buyers will eventually organize. I'd recommend proactively offering tiered consortium pricing before they ask. That gives you control over the structure. Luna: Proactively? That seems counterintuitive — you're giving away margin. Lucas: You're giving away margin but you're gaining predictability. The coalition will demand a discount anyway. If you set the consortium terms yourself, you can define the scope — which products are included, which service tiers, what the cap escalation looks like. You control the frame. The Healthcare SaaS Coalition, the vendor didn't set the terms — the buyers did. That's a weaker negotiating position. Luna: So you're saying vendors should build a coalition pricing track before one forms organically. Lucas: Yes. And the second thing: invest in a 'coalition readiness' sales playbook. Train your reps to identify early signals — are potential buyers in the same industry vertical? Do they share a regional association? Are they talking to each other at conferences? If yes, you may have a coalition forming. Luna: The flip side: what if you're a buyer listening to this? How do you start a coalition without getting sued? Lucas: First, lawyer up — specifically an antitrust attorney. Second, keep the scope narrow: aggregate only spend data, not individual pricing. Third, agree on a governance structure. The Healthcare coalition used a rotating chair model — each hospital system's CFO served a one-year term as negotiator. That prevents any single member from dominating. Luna: And the actual negotiation? Lucas: You want a single point of contact, ideally an external procurement consultant. That creates the firewall. The coalition members authorize the consultant to negotiate within a band — say, twenty to thirty percent discount, with certain terms non-negotiable. The vendor negotiates with the consultant, not with the members directly. Luna: That's clean. But it also means the vendor loses the relationship with end users. Lucas: That's the real risk. Vendors hate this model because it commoditizes their product. When you negotiate with a consortium, the conversation shifts from value and outcomes to price per user per month. The product becomes a line item. For vendors whose differentiation is in service and partnership, that's existential. Luna: Do you think this is a permanent shift or a reaction to the current economic environment? Lucas: I think it's permanent. The tools for buyer coordination are better now. Slack communities, LinkedIn groups, shared procurement platforms — the transaction cost of organizing has dropped to near zero. Once buyers realize they have collective leverage, they won't unlearn it. Luna: But vendors will adapt. They'll find ways to break coalitions — maybe offering individual deals that undercut the group. Lucas: That's the classic divide and conquer strategy. But the coalition contract usually includes a most favored customer clause — if any member gets a better deal individually, the whole cohort gets that price. That removes the incentive to defect. Luna: Clever. So the coalition essentially creates a mutual assured destruction clause. Lucas: Exactly. And it works because the members trust each other — they're peers in the same industry, often facing the same regulatory pressures. The social cost of defecting is high. Luna: Let's zoom out. What does this mean for the broader enterprise sales landscape? Lucas: I think we're moving toward a more transparent, more wholesale-like market for enterprise software. Not all software — high-differentiation products with unique capabilities will retain pricing power. But for commoditized categories — CRM, HR, procurement, ERP — buyers will increasingly aggregate. The vendor that embraces this early could actually win market share by being the 'coalition-friendly' option. Luna: So the playbook is: don't fight it. Design for it. Lucas: Exactly. And I'd argue that the vendors who resist will end up with worse outcomes. HealthStack initially said no. They eventually gave a bigger discount than if they'd come to the table with a consortium offer first. Luna: Alright, so if listeners take one thing from this episode: whether you're buying or selling, assume the coalition is coming and prepare. Lucas: That's the takeaway. And frankly, these conversations are exactly the kind of practical insight we try to bring every week. If you find them useful for what you're building or running, it's listener support that keeps this show ad-free and independent. Luna: Yeah, absolutely. It's a small way to ensure we can keep digging into topics like this without any outside pressure. Lucas: If you'd like to support the show, you can do so at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, but it genuinely helps us keep the podcast sustainable. Luna: And we really appreciate it. So back to the coalition trend — what's the one thing you think will surprise people most in the next year? Lucas: I think we'll see a coalition form among AI tool buyers. Right now, enterprises are buying AI software from dozens of vendors with no pricing consistency. I predict by Q2 of next year, there will be a formal buyer consortium for enterprise AI procurement. That will be a shock to vendors who thought they had pricing power because the technology is new. Luna: That would be a fascinating case study. And it would accelerate the transparency shift even faster. Lucas: Exactly. So keep an eye on that. And if you're in enterprise SaaS, start building your coalition playbook now.