Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Putting Together An Ohio State All-Decade Team From The 2010s
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the buck Eye Weekly Podcast. I'm Tony Gerdeman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going well, Tony?
- 0:11This is part three in our ongoing series on the Ohio State All Decades Team.
- 0:17I hope everyone's enjoying this because we've got two more of these coming,
- 0:19so if not, then please download them and we appreciate your support anyway.
- 0:25But I think the feedback we've gotten so far it's been pretty good. So
- 0:28that's uh, that's good. And if you don't like it, you can
- 0:30blame Eisenmack Isac Pack and Tire because he's the one who said the question,
- 0:33and we're like, oh, that's a good question. So thank you to
- 0:36Isaac for the inspiration and thank you to all for your continued patronage. But
- 0:40yeah, I do. I think these these have been kind of a fun
- 0:42trip down memory lane during you know, a somewhat slow time of the year
- 0:47for for football. Knock on wood. Tom the the gall of Isaac to
- 0:53ask this as one part of a listener questions, you know, barrags.
- 0:59It's like, oh, while you're talking about these six other things, here
- 1:03answer this one question, and like, were we supposed to make this.
- 1:07Could you imagine doing this in like five minutes your nineties, your two thousands,
- 1:11two thousands, tens. It would just be like reading names and there'd
- 1:14be no debate. You couldn't even them that the debate. There would be
- 1:18no debate to embrace tom and as you know, we like to hug our
- 1:22debate. This is you know, this has turned into like the Jerry Lewis
- 1:26telethon. We're already an hour and ten minutes or so in and we've we're
- 1:30only halfway through the question. So yeah, so we'll be uh, we'll
- 1:34probably have another another couple episodes for you of you know what what again is
- 1:38hopefully hopefully fun in nostalgic, and I think we're now at the point where
- 1:42you know, we're now today gonna be talking about some players that feel like
- 1:46they literally just finished their Ohio State careers very very recently. And so you
- 1:52know, even if you were on the younger side and don't remember some of
- 1:55the some of the guys we talked about in the nineties or whatever, this
- 1:57is this is going to be a show that has a little something for every
- 2:00one. I think the next year, I'm gonna have my tie is going
- 2:01to be completely undone. I'm gonna be like Warren and Haggard. But let's
- 2:07begin with the greatest decade in Ohio State quarterback history. You look at every
- 2:17single quarterback that has started for the Buckeyes in this decade, Sayer Joe Joe
- 2:23Bossman has either been All Big Ten, a Silver Football Winner, a National
- 2:29champion. So that's a lot to choose from. However, I always end
- 2:35up going back to who I view as the greatest Ohio State quarterback of all
- 2:38time. And even though he only played one year in the twenty tens,
- 2:44that's enough for me. And even though j T. Barry olds all of
- 2:47these records and Braxton Miller was a three year starter, I am going with
- 2:52Justin Fields. I also am going with Justin Fields, and I think that's
- 2:59maybe a testament to exactly how great he was. I mean, you had
- 3:04J. T. Barrett who set all of these records, and a lot
- 3:07of that had to do with longevity. You had Cardale Jones who was just
- 3:09this absolute force of nature. You had Braxton Miller, who was one of
- 3:14the greatest athletes to play the quarterback position at Ohio State history. And you
- 3:21still, to me you can't beat justin fields just in terms of you know,
- 3:24I go back to the summer of twenty nineteen and watching him playing the
- 3:28spring game that year, and it was kind of like, yeah, I
- 3:30mean, you can see the armed talent, but you know, boy,
- 3:34there's a long way to go. And then he finished I think forty one
- 3:36touchdowns and three interceptions, and it was like, oh, okay, well
- 3:39then he's fine. That was that was It turns out that was pretty good.
- 3:43The five star generational talent quarterback turns out to have been pretty good at
- 3:46football Exclusive must credit Buckeye Weekly podcast, And yeah, he's he's someone who
- 3:53had, you know, the arm that c J. Strout had, maybe
- 3:59not quite as accurate CJ. Strout, but pretty darn accurate. But you
- 4:01know, just one one big games, had you know, big moments and
- 4:06and you know he uh you go back to the loss against Clemson, and
- 4:13you know that that last play, that heartbreaking interception at the end of the
- 4:15first the Clemson game in the Fiesta Bowl, and just to come back and
- 4:17just annihilate Clemson the next year in the Sugar Bowl. And I don't really
- 4:23hold the at Alabama game against him because there's you know, with with all
- 4:29the practice stuff and the number of players they were missing, and uh,
- 4:31some of the defensive schemes in that game. You know, there's there's only
- 4:35so much you can do as the quarterback there. So I don't really hold
- 4:39that one against him, But yeah, I think he's he continues I think
- 4:42to be the greatest Ohio State quarterback in my mind and apparently in yours as
- 4:46well, can until until someone else can surpass that. Yeah, he's the
- 4:50most complete he can. He can run like you, you know, if
- 4:56you are a fan of the Terrelle Prior Braxton Miller, he runs nearly as
- 5:00well as them. He throws nearly as well as c J. Strout and
- 5:05Dwayne Haskins. He was a seventy percent completion guy. He could have gone
- 5:10seventy yards at any at a moment's notice. On the ground. He was
- 5:15the perfect combination. He was a he was a created player. It's like
- 5:17when you're creating and it's like, come on, there's nobody that is a
- 5:21ninety speed and also a ninety eight arm accuracy and things like that stuff.
- 5:26You gotta stay realistic. But he was not a realistic guy. He was
- 5:30He was really really good and was tough and was a winner and would give
- 5:35you whatever you needed. So I think that's why all of that reason I
- 5:40went with justin fields. Now, Tom, did you go with three receivers
- 5:45here and a running back? How did you? Or did you go two
- 5:46running backs? Again? I went three running, three wide receivers in a
- 5:50running back on this one, and you know I went with I think this
- 5:56is I'm going to be surprised if we'd have a different answer on this one,
- 5:59because, man, just JK. Dobbins in twenty nineteen, Like sorry,
- 6:02I feel like the discussions over two thousand yards rushing an incredible season,
- 6:06and you know he's there are a thousand what ifs in that twenty nineteen season
- 6:12with that Fiesta Bowl against Clemson. One of them is certainly what if JK.
- 6:15Dobbins doesn't sprain his ankle? And he was just incredible that year.
- 6:19He was just, I mean, one of the single greatest individual seasons I
- 6:26can remember at any position at Ohio State. So he I think was an
- 6:30easy answer for me, even though yeah, Ezekiel Elliott also played for the
- 6:33Buckeyes that decade, But man, I just I can't get over the twenty
- 6:36nineteen, JK. Dobbins, Do you know how many players have led Ohio
- 6:41State and rushing three years in a row like JK Dobbins did. I would
- 6:46guess Archie Griffin did, Jim Otis and Bob Ferguson. Okay, yeah,
- 6:55I was gonna say I was kind of mentally scrolling back in my head through
- 6:58the decades and I'm like, no, oh no, no, yeah,
- 7:00So yeah, that's a that's pretty good. And I'm sure you know a
- 7:05lot of people they're instant, their instant sort of snap judgment on this is
- 7:10going to be Ezekiel Elliott, which is he also was a perfectly fine football
- 7:15player at Ohio State. Yes, agreed, strong agree. And you know,
- 7:18much like you take JK. Dobbins off the field for the Clemson game
- 7:23and the what if there, you take Ezekiel Elliott and he's banged up for
- 7:26that Michigan State game in twenty fifteen, and there's a what if there?
- 7:30But yeah, I think JK. Dobbins is that is the guy to me.
- 7:34But I also don't know that I've ever seen as dominating a three game
- 7:39run for a tailback as Ezekiel Elliott against Wisconsin and Alabama and Oregon at the
- 7:46end of that season. So you know, I will I will allow some
- 7:50I will allow a different answer if you'd like to take one. Well,
- 7:54and I went into this with JK. Dobbins as my guy, because,
- 7:59yeah, Ezekiel Elliott was really good in twenty fourteen, but he wasn't even
- 8:03all Big ten and then he blew up at the end and in those three
- 8:07games. But then you know, he's got his twenty fifteen season. Even
- 8:11though the twenty fifteen season has looked at as kind of a wasted season,
- 8:16he was really really good that year and the Michigan State game netwithstanding. But
- 8:22he's got six two hundred yard rushing games in his career. That's the most
- 8:24in Ohio state history. JK. Dobbins as two. Dobbins finished with the
- 8:28little not quite five hundred yards more rushing in his career, which is pretty
- 8:35impressive when you consider Ezekiel Elliott rushed for three hundred yards as a true freshman
- 8:39and still is only five hundred yards behind. But he had two back to
- 8:43back years of eighteen hundred yards rushing. His average is higher than Dobbins.
- 8:52You just I'm just scrolling through here. Do you know how many times Ezekiel
- 8:56Elliot's name appears in the Ohio State Record Book? And this could just be
- 9:00year by year leaders just random mentions. I'm wondering. I haven't looked yet.
- 9:03I wonder how many more times, or if how many fewer times it
- 9:07has mentioned in Dobbins. So I'm going to do this right now on air.
- 9:11Tom. I can tell you that Ezekiel Elliott's name has mentioned seventy seven
- 9:16times in the Ohio State Record Book. I think that they count individual one
- 9:22hundred yard games are listed out there in that record book, So I think
- 9:24that's you know, and so that that might be half of those numbers or
- 9:28pushing pushing close to half of those numbers. But yeah, I mean he
- 9:33was he was a dominant, dominant player and you know, obviously the key
- 9:37to a national championship at one point. You know, he he had some
- 9:41help, but you know some one of the iconic plays, one of the
- 9:43iconic plays from that year in really each of the two playoff games that year,
- 9:48the eighty five yard run against Alabama that really kind of sealed that game.
- 9:54And then you know the run where he's you know, bowled over the
- 9:56two Oregon defenders right at the goal line, really really iconic moments there.
- 10:03So you know, maybe Tony, I think I'm changing my answer. I
- 10:05think I'd like to have two wide receivers and two running backs on this team.
- 10:07That's probably so. In that twenty fifteen season, Ezekiel Elliot twelve one
- 10:13yard rushing games. In JK. Dobbins two nineteen season, he had ten.
- 10:18And like I said, I went into this as JK. Dobbins is
- 10:20my answer, but then I just kept looking more and more and it's like
- 10:22I feel like I'd be sliding Ezekiel Elliott. And again, he was the
- 10:26Sullivan Award winner in twenty fourteen, but he was never an All American.
- 10:31I don't know that JK. Dobbins was the first team All American. I
- 10:33didn't. I didn't necessarily look at those like when we try to break it
- 10:37down earlier, like with all of the positions, well, let's look at
- 10:39the All Americans. I didn't do that with either of these guys, just
- 10:43because I saw them both and I remember them both quite clearly. But again,
- 10:48I'll just seventy seven times in the record book for Ezekiel Elliott, only
- 10:52fifty five for JK. Dobbins, I'm not even sure he should have been
- 10:54starting. Yeah, it's a it's it's probably closer than my initial reaction was.
- 11:03But you know, I'm I will stick with JK. Dobbins. But
- 11:07again, I I think the top two running backs are better than the top
- 11:11three wide receivers. So you know, maybe a secret should play wide receiver.
- 11:15What do you think? Yeah, And we've already spent over ten minutes
- 11:18on this, and I will say, if if there was no down twenty
- 11:22eighteen, like if if Dobbins just has a regular twenty eighteen like he's running
- 11:28away with this, I think, And again I'm perfectly okay with that being
- 11:31the answer as well. Receivers, Tom, I think there are two answers
- 11:35here and then a third which I am going to go with. And you're
- 11:41not allowed to take Garrett Wilson because he's a true freshman only had like thirty
- 11:43catches. But I am sneaking Chris o'lave into my three wide receivers for his
- 11:50two thy nineteen season where he had twelve touchdown catches over eight hundred yards receiving.
- 11:56Now that's lighting Paris Campbell because I went a slot situation, I went
- 12:05with Curtis Samuel over Paris Campbell. Okay, that's that's an interesting way to
- 12:11do it. I went with Michael Thomas, I went with Paris Campbell,
- 12:15and then, yeah, I think you could include Curtis Samuel here. I
- 12:20think he could include Chris Alava here. Dane Sanzenbacher had a really good season
- 12:24at the very start of the decade. He at least with someone I thought
- 12:28about, Erry McLaurin. I mean, there's there's a lot of good choices
- 12:33here that are not clear runaway All American type choices. So I think I'll
- 12:41go Michael Thomas, Paris Campbell, and wait is Curtis Samuel. I mean,
- 12:48I feel like Curtis Samuel is a more running back than a wide receiver,
- 12:52right or I mean he kind of you kind of like both. I
- 12:56mean hand over eight hundred yards receiving over seven hundred yard receiving, and he
- 13:00played slot as much as he you know, more than he played running back.
- 13:03So that's why I I've got him there. He was a first team
- 13:05All American as an all purpose guy. Because I don't know, you know,
- 13:11so, um, that's why I went him. But if we want
- 13:13to throw an all purpose guy. Now, now we can talk about Paris
- 13:18Campbell as one of the as the fifth at that time one thousand yard receiver
- 13:22in school history. Not to make my top three feels feels a bit like
- 13:28a slight considering how dangerous he was. But I um, I did go
- 13:31with an X and H and a Z, and I'm okay with that.
- 13:37But there's there's a lot of good guys that are not kind of under underrepresented.
- 13:43Philly Brown led the Ohio state receiving two years in a row. Not
- 13:46on list. Brown, I think would be on that list too. Where
- 13:52Devin Devin Smith, Sorry, yeah, Devin Smith, not the current Ohio
- 13:56state quarterback, the former Ohio state wide receiver who just just ran the night
- 14:00route and just score touchdowns and then they always won when he score touchdowns.
- 14:03So yeah, I think there are plenty of good choices in this. In
- 14:07this mix, I'll go with Michael Thomas, Paris Campbell, Curtis Samuel.
- 14:11I think that's a I think that's a good mixture of those of guys there.
- 14:18Tight end boy. I think I think my answered here is Jeff Hireman.
- 14:22I thought about Jake stone Burner, you know, Marcus Ball had some
- 14:26big moments, but I think Jeff Hireman's here is my answer for tight end.
- 14:31What about you? Yeah, I am Jeff Hireman and then followed by
- 14:33Nick VanDette and they were they played together, they were very similar. But
- 14:37Hireman was my answer there, and not just because of the clothes he wore,
- 14:41the shirts he would rain, you know, show up with at the
- 14:43hotel check in days that would horrify Jerry Emig, but you know, he
- 14:48was. He was a solid, complete tight end, and yeah, I
- 14:52went with him. And Nick Vanette was also very very good. But those
- 14:54are my two guys. Yeah, and Hireman had some really really big moments
- 14:58too. You know, I always think of the Perdue a game with Hireman,
- 15:01but yeah, he was. He was part of some very very very
- 15:03big wins for Ohio State. One of the few tight ends, sorry,
- 15:07one of the few tight ends at Ohio State. With the one hundred yard
- 15:09receiving game, I believe, m all right, offensive line, let's you
- 15:15want to run through this real quick? Yeah? Yeah, I mean,
- 15:18I think I've got Taylor Decker at tackle, Michael Jordan at guard, and
- 15:22I know he played center later in his career, but you start as a
- 15:24freshman, Okay, like you start as a true freshman. I think you've
- 15:28got to be on this team, Tony, don't make me choose between Mike
- 15:31Brewster and Billy Price. I don't want to choose between Mike Brewster and Billy
- 15:35Brice. And you're I know you're saying, well, what about how to
- 15:37half line? Oh, Tony, we need a right guard too, So
- 15:39Pat Alfline playing right guard, and I've got Jack Muhart at right tackle.
- 15:43Your thoughts. I've got a lot of those names. I've got them in
- 15:46different positions because all of these guys moved around, Like Jack Muhort played several
- 15:50positions, finished his career as an All American at left tackle, I believe,
- 15:54so I had him at left tackle, Andrew Norwell at left guard.
- 15:58Pat alf Line was an All American center for a year, Billy Price was
- 16:02an All American right guard for a year. Taylor Decker started his career as
- 16:06a starting right tackle, so I went with him. However, I feel
- 16:11like Jonah Jackson has been as good as any any guard that I've seen at
- 16:17Ohio State. So, um, Whyatt Davis is an All American? So
- 16:23but he was? He was a little after he got here in twenty nineteen,
- 16:27so yeah, he doesn't fit in. But Jonah Jackson in two thousand
- 16:32nineteen as good as any guard. So I could have Narwell, Billy Price,
- 16:36pat alf Line, Jonah Jackson, any of those guys. I think
- 16:38you've got a solid group of guys. And we both agree, Jackie Horton,
- 16:42Taylor Deckers just whatever side you want to put them on, Yeah,
- 16:45and I think that that's you know you can. The nice thing is you
- 16:49got all this versatility there where you could really field an offensive line with those
- 16:52guys, and you could you could line them up in a couple of different
- 16:56spots, and you've got multiple Roomington Award winners there and so you could put
- 17:00you know, you could put anyone there you want to. But whether you
- 17:03have JK. Dobbins or ezekiel A lad As you're running back, I feel
- 17:06like they're going to be able to run the ball pretty effectively behind that line
- 17:08almost no matter how you align any mixture of those guys. So Tom now
- 17:15comes the time where we moved to the defense, and I feel like the
- 17:18the we're going to move the defensive and discussion to Patreon and it's gonna be
- 17:22two hours on Patreon. No, I guess we should just get to it
- 17:29because some of the names that are not going to be listed. For me
- 17:33a Big Ten Defensive Lineman of the Year Taekwon Lewis, Sam Hubbard, who
- 17:38is maybe second in the NFL, and sacks from his draft class not going
- 17:44to be mentioned. Big ten defensive Lineman of the Year. No, John
- 17:48Simon, Like John Simon, is not going to be part of this.
- 17:52In terms of Bosa versus Bosa, I went with Joseph. I went with
- 17:57Joey Bosa three years starter at Ohio State. I think Nick Bosa in twenty
- 18:04eighteen was going to have perhaps the greatest season in an Ohio State defensive lineman
- 18:10history, but he got hurt and so I went with Joey Bosa instead of
- 18:15Nick Bosa. Now, Nick Bosa, I think is probably the best out
- 18:18of all of them, but in terms of their time at Ohio State,
- 18:21I went with Joey. Yeah, I think Nick Bosa. That twenty eighteen
- 18:26defense with Nick Bosa and without Nick Bosa is one of those great what ifs.
- 18:29But yeah, that was that to me was the tiebreaker because Joey was
- 18:33so dominant in his time. Nick Bosa, I think probably you know,
- 18:37was a higher ceiling and probably has been a better pro. But man,
- 18:42he just he only played you only really got what three games something like that.
- 18:48He got hurt in the TCU game, which is I believe the fourth
- 18:51game of the season, like in the first half of the game, and
- 18:52just uh, you know, really really really too bad. But you know,
- 18:57one of the defensive end spots, go ahead and write it and Sharpie
- 19:00Chase Young, no one should, no one should disagree with that. And
- 19:03then the other the other spot is I had Nick Bosa there, you know,
- 19:08both guys who are top five Just sorry, Joey Bosa there and Nick
- 19:12Bosa. You know, these are all top five NFL draft picks. These
- 19:15are incredible athletes, guys who were incredible impact players at Ohio State and who
- 19:22since they've left, everyone's going, well, why don't they have one of
- 19:23those guys? It's like, don't they don't. Those don't come around very
- 19:26often. That's why they're so special. That's why their top five NFL draft
- 19:29picks. But yeah, I mean the guys, the guys who you mentioned
- 19:33who are not in this conversation, the John Simons and the Sam Hubbards and
- 19:37Taekwon Lewis. I think still one of the most underrated players in Ohio state
- 19:41history. We put together a you know, top one hundred players of the
- 19:45ozone era list a few years ago, and I had him way too lowly.
- 19:51He was underappreciated by me, even as I'm like covering the team,
- 19:53I was like, we put the list together, I'm like, I had
- 19:56him like thirty spots too low. At least he just was incredibly dominant,
- 20:00but didn't have didn't get the headlines that the bosses did, didn't get the
- 20:04attention that the bosses necessarily did. But an absolutely incredible player. But yeah,
- 20:08I think I think, to me, it's got to be Joey Bosa
- 20:11and Chase Young. But this is one of the most competitive this is this
- 20:15is a position where this is going to be maybe almost as competitive as the
- 20:19twenty twenties All Ohio State twenty twenties team when we do that in you know,
- 20:23twenty thirty seven or something like that. At the wide receiver position,
- 20:27just an absolute murderers row of of defensive ends. Cam Hey, we're twenty
- 20:33and ten defensive end and imagine if Noah Spence had been able to stay at
- 20:38Ohio State, where he would be on this list. Defensive tackle, I
- 20:44think they I think there are four All Americans on a defensive tackle in the
- 20:48two thou and tens and my two, my my number one, and my
- 20:53number two. I went with Jonathan Hankins and Draymont Jones. And Draymond Jones
- 21:00is one of the best free text, most disruptive, most active, most
- 21:03productive guys. I still remember one of my favorite stats from him as a
- 21:08red chart freshman in Big Ten play. I think had one more tackle than
- 21:12Jabrel Peppers in Big Ten play, and Jabrell Peppers was a Heisman finalist and
- 21:18an All American Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year. That's how active he
- 21:22was. Draymond Jones and Big hank was you know, obviously two fat and
- 21:26slow to play at Michigan. We know that was the that was that was
- 21:30a story back then. But Ohio State was like, you know what,
- 21:33We'll take you. And that dude was still playing in the NFL this past
- 21:37season. It's insane. Yeah, And Hankins is a great one. I
- 21:40had Hankins on my team as well. Draymond Jones is a really good choice
- 21:44because he was I mean, you talked about how athletic, how active he
- 21:47was. He had an interception that same TCU game where Nick Bosa got hurt,
- 21:53Draymond Jones had an interception just like picked off I think a shovel pass
- 21:56and rent it back for a pick six. I think he had an another
- 22:00interception for a touchdown. He scored another touchdown at some point too, was
- 22:04at Michigan State. I don't remember, but he had You know, he
- 22:07was someone who made big plays, was just really impactful on the inside of
- 22:11that defensive line. I thought about him. I ended up going with Adolphus
- 22:15Washington. But you know, I and I think he was also an All
- 22:18American. But You've got this is this is another one where I'm not gonna
- 22:23you said Draymont Jones, and I didn't go, WHOA, what are you?
- 22:26What are you talking about? That's you know, I think there are
- 22:29there are a bunch of really good choices of players who you could make a
- 22:34very very strong case belong on this team. Draymond jones second touchdown that year
- 22:38was at Michigan States. He finished m tied with Tate Martel that year and
- 22:45scoring with twelve points that season, also tied with Rashad Barry, so um,
- 22:52you know, pretty good company all around. Michael Bennett also an All
- 22:56American. That's another guy who who was on a list. But I think
- 23:00any of those four and you'll be okay. And I like, I like
- 23:03my two linebackers here, Tom, there are a bunch now. I think
- 23:08the clear first one, I'll just say, I'll just take it and I'll
- 23:11let you go with the next however many want to do. But Brian Shazier
- 23:15as as as a productive and as good a linebacker as I've ever seen at
- 23:21Ohio State. Nobody covers as much ground, Nobody gets into the backfield like
- 23:25him. He was outstanding from the first time they started really playing him as
- 23:30a true freshman in twenty eleven, twenty twelve, twenty thirteen, like twenty
- 23:36two and a half tackles for loss Um. Throughout much of his career,
- 23:41he was overshadowed by Man Tai Tao when he was getting so much attention,
- 23:48and it should have been going to Ryan Chasier. So that's my that's my
- 23:51first guy at linebacker. He was my first guy at linebacker as well.
- 23:55He just was always, always great, always made big plays. He was
- 24:00involved in that the goal line fumble against against Wisconsin. I mean just you
- 24:06just think about his career and it's just big play, big play, play,
- 24:10big play, big play. Yeah, he was an easy first one
- 24:11for me. My second one. I don't know that this is one that
- 24:15you're necessarily going to agree with, but I put Rakwon McMillan on this list.
- 24:18Is that would he be someone you would have there or or yeah,
- 24:22okay, yeah, I mean he to me was someone who came in with
- 24:27the five star hype and then didn't immediately just completely dominate like Andy Katzi Lawyer
- 24:33did. So everyone looked at him and kind of like, well, this
- 24:37is not going to pan out, and it's like, oh no, no,
- 24:38he's fine, he's great. He's unfortunately can't buy a break with his
- 24:42health in the NFL right now, but is you know, it was just
- 24:45a consistently just a great linebacker at Ohio State. And he's someone I would
- 24:52love to see Raykwon McMillan in a Jim Noles defense. I think that would
- 24:55be I think that would be something where you know, he Baron Browning is
- 25:00probably in that group as well. Uh, you know, was someone who
- 25:03I think you just you would I would love to see what Jim Knowles would
- 25:08do with those type of guys at linebacker. But yeah, I think he's
- 25:14he was I think my clear number two. What about what about you?
- 25:18Yeah, he was my my number two as well. And then the leads
- 25:22to a three of a lot of different guys, and I guess it depends
- 25:27on what you're looking for. You know, there's Jerome Baker I thought was
- 25:33very good. Darren Lee was the first guy I thought of based on his
- 25:36twenty fourteen season and the way they used him, and then in twenty fifteen
- 25:41the way offenses tried to negate him by going away from him and just trying
- 25:45to avoid him however they could. Joshua Perry led a team in tackles a
- 25:49couple of years, had a big year in one hundred and twenty five tackles,
- 25:53and I think twenty fourteen, and then you know, Molly Harrison was
- 25:57a two year starter, and I'm thinking, well, what about like,
- 26:00if I'm looking for this hybrid linebacker that can you know also maybe you know
- 26:03or if you're looking for some hybrid player, And that's when I started thinking
- 26:07Pete Warner because he did it, you know, he did it in twenty
- 26:10nineteen. He was all over the place, and I would just be kind
- 26:14of crazy for Pete Warner to receive so much criticism during his time and then
- 26:19for me to be like, you know what, I'll take him over Darren
- 26:23Lee, over Joshua Perry, over Mollie Harrison, over Jerome Baker because he
- 26:27was solid, he was safe. Jerome Baker though that he was a playmaker.
- 26:33I still went Darren Lye as my third. But I don't know if
- 26:38there's some redundancy there, you know, because with him and to rate Ryan
- 26:42chazi're both the attacking the backfield. So I think what I'm gonna do,
- 26:48Tim, I'm gonna call an audible here, and I'm gonna go with Pete
- 26:52Warner, even though I see Jerome Baker sitting there and thinking, man he
- 26:55was he could have done whatever you needed as well. But I'm gonna go
- 26:57Pete Warner because there is ah there. It's testimony instead of theory. We
- 27:03saw him play. We've seen him play as a week side or we've seen
- 27:06him play as saying we saw him play as a bullet. I'm going Pete
- 27:08Warner as my third and I'm a little surprised by that. Yeah, that's
- 27:14not someone that I had. I had I put Mollie Harrison just because I
- 27:18feel like Mallie Harrison is just chronically underappreciated. I saw him at the spring
- 27:22game and it was like I looked at him and I was like, I
- 27:25don't I don't know how many Ohio State fans would look at him and go,
- 27:27oh, there's Millie Harrison. One of the best linebackers played Ohio State
- 27:30in the last decade. But I think he was he was just he was,
- 27:34you know, not the super, super highly touted recruit, but he
- 27:37was just always just always in the right place, always doing the right thing.
- 27:41I liked him a lot. Warner's a great choice because Warner was someone
- 27:45who, every once in a while, you'd see him running with a receiver
- 27:48like thirty yards down field and it's like, what what do you and but
- 27:52they would just every once in a while they would just drop him to deep
- 27:55safety and you know, you just disguise coverage with that, and that's something
- 27:59that most linebacker cannot do and he did a pretty darn good job of it.
- 28:02And so yeah, I think He's a great, great choice as well.
- 28:06Yeah, I mean, you want to put Darren Lye in the spot,
- 28:08that's fine. You want to put Jerome Baker in the spot, that's
- 28:11fine. I'm not I'm not going to fight you on any of those.
- 28:14I just I have always you know, if we did the all time underappreciated
- 28:18Ohio State players, I think Millie Harrison might go on that list for me.
- 28:23Yeah, and he was just very solid and you never had to worry
- 28:27about him. So now I think we might have let's go to corner because
- 28:36I think we're probably gonna have some We're probably gonna have some differences here.
- 28:38I'm gonna go with my my two corners because I think they had two of
- 28:41the best seasons in Ohio State history. I went with Denzel Ward and Marshawn
- 28:48Lattimore. And Marshawn Latimore is twenty and sixteen, is still he toyed with
- 28:53quarterbacks, he toyed with receivers. Denzel Ward was just constantly solid, and
- 29:00so I went with those two. And I realized one name I'm leaving off
- 29:03and another name Bradley Roby, and you know, Chimby check While like I
- 29:07understand, I am going with Denzel Ward and Marshawn Lattimore, and I'm feeling
- 29:11fantastic about it. Yeah, I don't have an argument against those guys other
- 29:17than the fact that you didn't say Jeff Acuda's name, So that's you know,
- 29:19I think he was the obvious one that you were you were not not
- 29:22naming, but you know, it was sort of the obvious other person to
- 29:26have in that conversation. So yeah, I I went with Jeff Acuda and
- 29:30Denzel Ward and not Marshall Lattimore. But Marshall Latimore was, you know,
- 29:33an incredibly dominant player. I had you have two pick sixes in one game?
- 29:38Is that I remembering that? Right? Isn't It's against Tulsa? Right?
- 29:42Yeah, you know, just an incredible corner. And all these guys
- 29:47were talking about were you know, first round picks, and you know Chimney
- 29:52Checko, who was like the fifth name you mentioned was an old American.
- 29:53I mean, this is this is one of these just really loaded units where
- 29:57you can you can make an argument for a whole bunch of different guys.
- 30:00I went with Warden Okuda, but you know, again, like let's let's
- 30:04put this as a nickel and we'll we'll put Marshall Latimore out there as as
- 30:08our slot corner, and then we'll we'll be we'll be set m two interceptions
- 30:15against Tulsa. Only one of those was returned for a touchdown. Though,
- 30:19moving to safety, this one is very clear for me. You've got two
- 30:22all Americans. I think they would do fantastically well together. Von Bell up
- 30:29on near the lane scrimmage, you know, Carry Combs just to call him
- 30:32a slot corner back then as the free safety who played over the slot,
- 30:37and Malie Cooker as the deep safety, the post safety. I think those
- 30:41two guys would go fantastically well together, both all Americans. And you give
- 30:48me those two and any of these cornerbacks that we're talking about, and any
- 30:52of the Bosas and Chase Young, I don't need linebackers. Yeah, this
- 30:59is this is the first defense ever to play a six zero five. But
- 31:03you know, I think I think they might be pretty effective if they did
- 31:07that. I yeah, no, notes, I think we're I think we're
- 31:11agreed on the safeties. Let's just move on to the special teams. Now.
- 31:15I give me your kicker, because I have I have four listed.
- 31:21Yeah. Well, it was like I looked through the most accurate career field
- 31:26goal kickers at Ohio State, and it was like basically the entire decade of
- 31:30the twenty tens. So I kind of went, yeah, all right,
- 31:33I'll go to play hallbial just because twenty eight to thirty five field goals in
- 31:37his career. I think Drew Basil's a perfectly acceptable answer here. I mean,
- 31:41you've got you've got a bunch of guys who I think we're really good,
- 31:44but a hall Beal I went with just because he was you know,
- 31:48I always think of like that twenty nineteen Northwestern game where they hustle him on
- 31:53and he kicks on whatever fifty two yard or right at halftime, like he
- 31:57was just he was rated as the number one kicker in the in his class
- 32:01coming out of like Buffalo, New York or the you know, Upstate in
- 32:05New York, and just was always just very good, very solid, very
- 32:08consistent. And you know, if you want to, if you want to
- 32:12give me someone else, I'm not going to have a strong objection because they
- 32:15have really been fortunate to have pretty strong, consistent kicking basically the whole decade
- 32:21of that of the twenty tents. Yeah, and It was weird because there
- 32:23would be some random single year guys like Tyler Derbin, Devin Barclay, like
- 32:28Jack Willoughby comes in. But Blake Calbill was I think pretty solid. Sean
- 32:31Nurnberger was around for a long time but lost his job a couple of times.
- 32:35So I'm perfectly okay with Blake Calbill. Uh, Cam Johnston is the
- 32:39answer as your punter is that correct time? He is Australian and he was
- 32:45the he was the start. He was the pie piper of Australia. Yeah,
- 32:51I mean he had he has the stats, he has the continent,
- 32:52he has everything you'd want in a punter. So yeah, I think he's
- 32:57I think that was that was. I mean, again, this isn't a
- 32:59spot where all has been pretty solid for It was pretty solid for pretty much
- 33:04that whole decade. But yeah, Kim Johnson to me was kind of the
- 33:07the gold standard there, the piede punter. If you a now I'm moving
- 33:13to kickoff return kick returner, this is can I can I go first?
- 33:19You know when you get those you know, when you get those forms like
- 33:21tax forms or whatever, and uh it says you know, you get the
- 33:24page where it says this page intentionally left blank. That's what I did for
- 33:29this because I'm if you don't return a kickoff for a touchdown in a decade,
- 33:32uh you know I technically they did in twenty ten, but if you
- 33:36look at the record books, you know they didn't. Uh yeah, I
- 33:38think. Sorry, I'm I am under under protest. You don't get a
- 33:43kick returner on this team. Sorry. Now, I will say Paris Campbell
- 33:49deserves some mention here. I just wasn't sure if I was going to ask
- 33:52you. But since I already know the answer, it's like I put Paris
- 33:54Campbell. But since Jordan Hall had a touchdown in the decade, doesn't have
- 33:59to be him, and he was a solid returner aside just from that touchdown.
- 34:01But you're saying no kickoff returners at all, So I'm okay with that.
- 34:07That's not the case of punt return where I'm going with Philly Brown who
- 34:09had two in one season and I think twenty twelve and was pretty solid throughout
- 34:15his days. Now, Jaylen Marshall was really good but terrified Ohio State fans
- 34:22because of how aggressive he would be running up to the football. Yeah,
- 34:25I went with Jaylen Marshall just because he was the most memorable punt returner of
- 34:30the decade. Where you know, Philly Brown was great, but man,
- 34:32Jaylen Marshall, I remember just constantly, just the Jayleen Marshall punt return roller
- 34:38coaster where it was just no, no, no, no, no,
- 34:40no, no, no, no, no no, yes, okay good
- 34:42good, yeah good or yet no no no no no, yes, yes
- 34:46no, don't do that. Maybe nope, don't do that. Nope.
- 34:50Yeah. It was it was exciting, it was memorable. You know,
- 34:53he basically single handedly won the twenty fourteen Indiana game. He scored four touchdowns
- 34:59I think in the fourth order, including a punt return the last punt return
- 35:01for a touchdown at four Ohio State. So yeah, I went with him.
- 35:06But Philly Brown's a great choice too. The way he would attack the
- 35:12punt returns reminds me of do you remember that Jack Handy where he goes the
- 35:17deep thought by Jack Handy was I think a great gift for the president would
- 35:22be a chocolate gun, and when you give it to him, you should
- 35:24run at him with it. That was like that was him, Like every
- 35:30time he'd be like running at it with a chocolate gun, and you got
- 35:34the Secret Service and everywhere like, oh no, this take him down,
- 35:37Take him down. You know something bad is going to happen. That was
- 35:40and I remember talking and Zack Smith saying they loved his aggressiveness. That's why
- 35:45he was back there because it wasn't going He wasn't gonna let it bounce and
- 35:49bounce thirty yards, So that's why they liked him there. And you know,
- 35:52he had a couple of muffs, you know who among us, right,
- 35:57So I think I'm okay with that one. But you know, Lee
- 36:00Brown also a good one. Chris Fields had a punt return touchdown against Toledo,
- 36:05I believe in two thousand and ten ish eleven ish whatever that was.
- 36:08Maybe it's two thousand. I don't know. Tom. We have done it.
- 36:14We have made it through the two thousand and tens, and I feel
- 36:19pretty good about it. I think this is a very, very very quality
- 36:22team, some really unbelievable talent on his team. So I want to thank
- 36:28everybody for tuning in. Hopefully you've enjoyed this series. If you've got any
- 36:31disagreements, feel free to let Tom know find us at the Buckehetdle dot Com
- 36:37became remember say Hello to us there on a message board. Tell us where
- 36:38we were wrong, tell us that no, it's nick Bosa or it's tough
- 36:43Borland. You know, if you fight for your guys, you know,
- 36:46fight for your guys, and of course you can do so in the YouTube
- 36:50comments as well. While you're there, go ahead and the like button and
- 36:54any kind of writing, interviewing you want to do. Five stars only though,
- 36:58just that's the rule one. Thank you all for joining us and we'll
- 37:01talk to you guys later. M