Latest / Politics with Paul / States' Rights: Where's the Line Between State and Federal Power? | Politics with Paul #104
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today is going to be about the concept of states' rights.
- 0:13Where's the line between state and federal power?
- 0:17One of the most enduring debates throughout American political history has been over this
- 0:22concept of states' rights.
- 0:25And this dividing line between federal power and authority and state power and authority was
- 0:32central to the crafting and ultimate passage of the US constitution.
- 0:36Yet it's far from a solved issue even two and a half centuries almost later, and it's woven
- 0:42into almost every policy you can think of, including for immigration, abortion, religious
- 0:49expression, LGBTQ issues.
- 0:52And so if we want to have real long lasting solutions for all these matters and more, then
- 0:58we need to come to a better understanding of the divide between federal and state power, why
- 1:04it's important, the development of states' rights philosophy, and the arguments made both
- 1:10for and against states' rights.
- 1:13So let's first talk about the pros and cons of state powers.
- 1:18Because like many things in politics, there are benefits and there are drawbacks.
- 1:24Perhaps the most core part of the argument besides just political philosophies is the need
- 1:32for cohesion versus the need for sovereignty.
- 1:36On the one hand, states' rights is beneficial in the case of they're closer to their
- 1:41constituents than the federal government is, and thus they're more knowledgeable about the
- 1:46intricacies of their state's affairs and voters' preferences.
- 1:50It just makes sense to have some level of efficiency where or it makes some level of
- 1:56sense to have the states lead certain policies because it's more efficient for them since they
- 2:01are closer to the ground.
- 2:03And also federal governments can and has overstepped its bounds in the past, and so the
- 2:08states need to be able to have some recourse to push back.
- 2:12But on the other hand, states can also thwart cohesion across the country by trying to pull
- 2:20in a different direction just because it doesn't like certain policies.
- 2:24And it can also be used as an excuse states' rights could be to deprive rights and powers of
- 2:30their states' constituents.
- 2:32Federal government and state government are both capable of doing good things and doing bad
- 2:38things.
- 2:39And so states' rights, therefore, has had a checkered history.
- 2:44And the complexity of the issue and the evolution of judicial interpretation of federal
- 2:49versus state power and political incentives have made this a fierce debate.
- 2:54The complexity of the issue because it's not always clear and obvious what is state
- 2:58jurisdiction is and what is federal.
- 3:00Yes.
- 3:01There's the tenth amendment, which we'll get much more into in a minute, says that any
- 3:06powers that don't directly belong to the federal government belong to the states, but
- 3:10there's also other parts of the constitution that make that a little bit murkier and supreme
- 3:15court interpretations because the supreme court has evolved in its rulings on how to apply
- 3:21constitutional law and federal statutes to the states.
- 3:25And in terms of political incentives, while some people subscribe more fundamentally to
- 3:31states' rights philosophies, and typically, these are people who are more conservative, the
- 3:36actual support of it fluctuates amongst both parties depending on who is in power.
- 3:41Because when one party controls federal government, they tend to be much more
- 3:45supportive of federal law guiding the states and saying states should get in line.
- 3:51Our people are gonna be running the show, and we are the ones who know everything and and are
- 3:56gonna do everything right.
- 3:58And then the state that's or the power party that's out of power is going to say, well, this
- 4:02is the federal government intruding on state's rights.
- 4:05And both Republicans and Democrats can fall into that way of thinking and independents who
- 4:12lean one way or another.
- 4:14So there is sometimes a level of inconsistency in the support for states' rights based on
- 4:21whether it's a policy that that person or that group or that party want.
- 4:27And, of course, inconsistency is very common in politics because people are trying to get their
- 4:33way.
- 4:33And it's not the way that things should be, but it is the way that things are.
- 4:37But nonetheless, we do need to come to a better understanding of this divide between federal
- 4:44and state power so that we can figure out what is the best course of action.
- 4:48And that's not an easy thing to come up with.
- 4:50A lot of people think that they've got it all figured out, but it's really not a simple, this
- 4:55thing should be federal.
- 4:56This thing should be state.
- 4:57Yes.
- 4:57In some cases, it is that simple, but an overall federal government should be leading or
- 5:06state government should be leading is rarely ever that simple.
- 5:09And so to better understand this debate, we need to go back to the very beginning of this
- 5:14debate.
- 5:15We need to go back to the actual drafting of the constitution.
- 5:19Following the revolutionary war, it was not The US constitution that came into play.
- 5:25It was actually the articles of confederation that became our central document regarding the
- 5:30law of the land.
- 5:31And it was crafted deliberately to vest almost all powers with the state governments and
- 5:38establish a weak central government.
- 5:40But glaring weaknesses soon became apparent because all the states wanted to pull in their
- 5:45respective directions, and they had different ideas of what was good policy.
- 5:49And the unifying power of fighting against the British crown and fighting for independence was
- 5:57no longer there.
- 5:58There was nothing to really to unite these states.
- 6:01They all, in a lot of times, acted more like separate countries than one country as a whole.
- 6:06And to make a long story short, the US constitution was created to more properly
- 6:11balance power between federal and state governments.
- 6:17The antifederalists felt that the US government or the US constitution gave too much power to
- 6:22the federal government at the expense of the states.
- 6:25And one of their main gripes was that there was not a bill of rights.
- 6:29Those first 10 amendments, they were not created until a couple of years after.
- 6:34But initially, James Madison and Alexander Hamilton were against a bill of rights because
- 6:40that they felt they felt that the constitution had laid out the only things that the federal
- 6:46government could do.
- 6:47And so they worried that if there was a bill of rights, that would imply that federal
- 6:51government powers or that the federal government had powers that it did not have.
- 6:56And it would suggest that any rights not in the bill of rights would be unprotected.
- 7:02And this was actually mostly addressed with the ninth amendment, which we'll get into shortly.
- 7:06But that said, that any rights not expressly given to in The US constitution was vested
- 7:15within the people.
- 7:17But ultimately, James Madison, despite his worries about a bill of rights, he ultimately
- 7:21engineered the process for a bill of rights to be added to the constitution a couple years
- 7:25later as a way to appease anti federalist sentiment and get the US constitution ratified,
- 7:32especially in Virginia.
- 7:34And so central to the states' rights debate is the tenth amendment, which says that the powers
- 7:42not delegated to The United States by the constitution nor prohibited by it to the states
- 7:47are reserved to the states respectively or to the people.
- 7:52Well, that sounds pretty straightforward, except it's not.
- 7:57This among other developments showed that Madison and Hamilton were right to some extent
- 8:01that the bill of rights would become an issue in what rights do do the people have that they
- 8:07need to have clearly laid out.
- 8:09What powers do the state governments really have?
- 8:13Some people have interpreted The US constitution to include certain powers within
- 8:17the federal government, and other people have disagreed with those interpretations.
- 8:22And so I wanna cite three key original constitutional passages.
- 8:28So not ones that deal with amendments to the constitution.
- 8:32Ones that were in the constitution to begin with that are also a core part of this debate,
- 8:38not necessarily directly related to states' rights, but would crop up often in debates over
- 8:45states' rights over the course of American history.
- 8:49And the first one is the necessary and proper clause, and this says that the congress shall
- 8:54have power to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into
- 8:59execution the foregoing powers and all other powers vested by this constitution in the
- 9:04government of the United States or in any department or officer thereof.
- 9:08That's sort of nebulous.
- 9:09What would be considered necessary and proper?
- 9:13Many debates of that over the years.
- 9:16The privileges and immunities clause.
- 9:18The citizens of each state shall be entitled to all privileges and immunities of citizens in
- 9:24the several states.
- 9:25And so this protects against efforts to discriminate against out of state citizens.
- 9:29You have to treat out of state citizens like you would if they were native citizens of your
- 9:34state.
- 9:34But what counts under that umbrella?
- 9:37And then lastly, the supremacy clause, which says this constitution and the laws of The
- 9:42United States shall be the supreme law of the land, and the judges in every state shall be
- 9:46bound thereby anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary
- 9:51notwithstanding.
- 9:54This constitution and the laws of The United States, which means federal statutes.
- 9:59So which of these federal statutes has constitutionality?
- 10:05And a lot of arguments for states' rights have said that many of these statutes are
- 10:13unconstitutional or they infringe upon state government powers and authority.
- 10:20The US constitution and federal law supersede any conflicting state laws.
- 10:25Yes.
- 10:25But what laws are in conflict?
- 10:28And so before we get to today's controversies and debates surrounding that, let's talk about
- 10:36how it's developed over time.
- 10:37What are these states' rights controversies and developments that we've seen over the course of
- 10:42history?
- 10:42Because there have been over two hundred thirty five years of development in the states' rights
- 10:47arena.
- 10:48And if I were to really comprehensively cover it all, there wouldn't be enough time in this
- 10:55podcast.
- 10:55So we're just gonna cover several of the really key developments in the states' rights debate.
- 11:04And the first one to talk about in the case of states' rights is the nullification crisis.
- 11:11So back in 1828, there was a tariff that was passed that implemented a whopping rate of 49
- 11:19Tariffs were not a new idea back then, but they had never gone that high before.
- 11:23And they were supported by northern manufacturers as a necessity to protect against
- 11:28British competition and their imports.
- 11:33But consumers and southern planters who took to naming this the tariff of abominations hated it
- 11:38because they relied heavily on European trade to buy and sell goods.
- 11:43And also there was a financial panic not that long before.
- 11:46They worried that this would trigger potentially another financial issue for the
- 11:53country.
- 11:55And it's just one of those many, many conflicts between north and South prior to the civil war.
- 12:04John Quincy Adams, then president, signed the tariff into law, and that was a major reason
- 12:09that he lost reelection in 1828 to Andrew Jackson, who was a southerner.
- 12:14So one would think that Andrew Jackson being a southerner would get rid of this tariff or push
- 12:21for getting rid of this tariff because of how much his fellow southerners hated it.
- 12:26But surprisingly, he actually declined to do anything about the tariff even though he was
- 12:32oftentimes somebody who was reluctant to implement.
- 12:37He he had a very strict interpretation of the constitution as to whether national federal
- 12:43government had power or not, but he declined to do anything about this tariff despite his
- 12:49fellow southerners being very upset about it.
- 12:52And so an incensed vice president John C.
- 12:55Calhoun led the charge for what is called nullification, which is a theory that a state
- 13:00could disregard and void any federal law it felt was illegal under the US constitution.
- 13:07So not just because, well, we don't like to do it even though functionally a lot of times it
- 13:12was simply because that state just didn't like that law because it didn't benefit them.
- 13:15But they had to nullification was the idea that, oh, well, this actually is an
- 13:20unconstitutional law, so we don't have to listen to it.
- 13:24And this triggered a lot of heated discussions and even threatened to spill over into
- 13:33violence.
- 13:34And so congress, in the attempt to quell southern resistance, passed the tariff of 1832,
- 13:40which did lower the tariff, but not considerably.
- 13:43Certainly not enough to appease the South.
- 13:45And so the South Carolina legislature felt that they had to call a state nullification
- 13:50convention, and they passed the ordinance of nullification in 1832.
- 13:55And president Jackson, who saw this as tantamount to treason, was ready to use
- 14:00military force, and South Carolina raised its own force and was ready to secede from the
- 14:05union.
- 14:05And it's sort of both a heavy handed and a diplomatic measure.
- 14:12Congress passed the force bill to allow Jackson to militarily enforce the federal tariff to say
- 14:19to reinforce the power of the federal government, especially the executive branch.
- 14:25But at the same time, they passed the compromise tariff that would gradually reduce
- 14:29tariff rates over time.
- 14:32But this crisis laid the groundwork for the excuses that the South would use to secede from
- 14:37a union at the beginning of the civil war.
- 14:39They saw tariffs as just one way that the federal government was infringing upon states'
- 14:46rights and the southern way of life.
- 14:50And so you saw this as one of the key ingredients to slavery and the outbreak of
- 14:57civil war because states' rights were used to justify slavery.
- 15:02But what a lot of people don't realize is that it was also used to excoriate slavery.
- 15:07On the pro slavery side, they said that the federal government had no authority to ban the
- 15:11expansion of slavery, and they claimed that was discrimination against slave owning states
- 15:16because at the time, many people tried to balance the level of power between slave owning
- 15:24states and free states, and free states being in North and slave owning states being in the
- 15:30South.
- 15:30And they felt that it was infringing upon states' rights to prevent these states from
- 15:36their constituents recapturing escaped slaves.
- 15:40And they also cited how slavery was not fully erased from the US constitution.
- 15:46On the anti slavery side, though, they noted the inconsistency of the South when it came to
- 15:50these states' rights philosophies where they pointed out for one thing, the gag rule in the
- 15:58US house of representatives, which was from 1836 to 1844.
- 16:02And that banned not only trying to get rid of slavery, it banned even bringing up the issue
- 16:09of slavery.
- 16:10You just could not say anything about it at all because of how many heated arguments it had
- 16:17brought up and in times, in some cases, violent conflicts even between sitting congresspeople,
- 16:23like how Charles Sumner was beaten by Preston Brooks with a cane.
- 16:27Charles Sumner being vociferously against slavery and lambasting slave owners, and
- 16:35Preston Brooks took it upon himself to beat him unconscious with his cane.
- 16:40And the North also brought up how the fugitive slave law, which compelled Northern states to
- 16:46return escaped slaves to the South, infringed upon the state's rights of the North, saying
- 16:51that, well, why do states in the South, why do their interests supersede any in the North?
- 16:58If they come into our borders, why should we return fugitive slaves?
- 17:03And these arguments over slavery led to a well, many attempts at compromise, but one
- 17:11particularly notable attempt at compromise in the vein or in the realm of states' rights was
- 17:20the idea of popular sovereignty, which said that states should decide for themselves.
- 17:25Ones who territories who are becoming states should decide for themselves whether or not to
- 17:31be a free state or a slave state.
- 17:33And this popular sovereignty idea was most prominently championed by US senator Stephen a
- 17:38Douglas, who was the other participant in a particularly famous debate featuring Abraham
- 17:44Lincoln before he became president.
- 17:46And so this idea of popular sovereignty was put to the test with the Kansas Nebraska Act, which
- 17:53let these territories decide for themselves whether to become free states or slave states
- 17:59as they went through the process of becoming states.
- 18:02Nebraska didn't really have too much trouble becoming a free state.
- 18:07Kansas, on the other hand, saw four proposed state constitutions and considerable bloodshed
- 18:14during the period known as bleeding Kansas.
- 18:18You saw pro slavery border ruffians launch a series of violent acts and intimidation tactics
- 18:24and electoral fraud to try to make Kansas a slave state, which included the sacking and
- 18:30massacre of the town of Lawrence.
- 18:33Meanwhile, anti slavery Jayhawkers retaliated with violence as well, including the Potawatomi
- 18:39massacre.
- 18:42And you saw even after slavery was eradicated with the thirteenth amendment, with the rise of
- 18:49Jim Crow in the South and the civil rights era, you saw a lot of these similar arguments for
- 18:56slavery being made for segregation.
- 18:59Even though slavery was outlawed, Jim Crow was an attempt to basically recreate the conditions
- 19:07of slavery without actually calling it slavery and without technically enslaving human beings.
- 19:13They were so the this idea was that it was the state's rights for in the case of the South to
- 19:20administer these laws for their society in such a racist way.
- 19:26Another key development in the state's rights in the history of state's rights is the
- 19:33incorporation of the bill of rights.
- 19:35And what the incorporation doctrine refers to is the application of the bill of rights to the
- 19:41state governments.
- 19:42Because in early American history, the bill of rights was narrowly applied actually, only to
- 19:47the federal government, not to the states.
- 19:50And one key example of that was the supreme court case of Barron versus the city of
- 19:55Baltimore in 1833.
- 19:57And so states were much less beholden to the core values that we hold dearly from the bill
- 20:05of rights like first amendment freedom of speech and religion.
- 20:08Although some states had some similar laws to the bill of rights, they had a lot more leeway
- 20:15as to how broad or specific those rights could be.
- 20:19But this legal precedence started to change drastically following the ratification of the
- 20:24fourteenth amendment in the late eighteen sixties, early eighteen seventies.
- 20:28The fourteenth amendment said that no state or it says that no state shall make or enforce any
- 20:35law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of The United States nor
- 20:40shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of
- 20:45law, nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
- 20:51And so it was through this due process clause, parts of the bill of rights, the first 10
- 20:57amendments, started to be applied to state governments.
- 21:01But the amendments have different levels of incorporation in applying to state governments
- 21:07according to Cornell's law school.
- 21:10Cornell says that full incorporation happened for the first, second, fourth, and eighth
- 21:14amendments.
- 21:15So first amendment being religion freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly, and
- 21:21petition.
- 21:22Second amendment for bearing firearms.
- 21:25The fourth amendment, which protects against unreasonable searches and seizures.
- 21:29And the eighth amendment prohibition of excessive fines and cruel and unusual
- 21:33punishments.
- 21:34Those were fully incorporated to apply to the state governments, not just the federal
- 21:39government.
- 21:40But a couple of amendments have only been partially incorporated, and those were the
- 21:46fifth and sixth amendments.
- 21:47So the fifth amendment with its exception for the right to indictment by a grand jury, and
- 21:51the sixth amendment except for the right to a jury selection from residents of the crime
- 21:57location in a criminal case.
- 22:00And then in the case of the third, seventh, and ninth, and tenth amendments, those have not
- 22:06been incorporated at all.
- 22:07The third amendment, which prohibits forcing a homeowner to provide shelter to soldiers, the
- 22:13seventh amendment, which provides the right to a jury in civil cases, those have not been
- 22:19incorporated at all.
- 22:20The ninth amendment, which grants any rights not expressly stated in US constitution to the
- 22:26people, that is rarely ever relied upon in SCOTUS cases, in supreme court cases.
- 22:32And then the tenth amendment applies directly to the states because it's any powers not given
- 22:37to the federal government belong to the states.
- 22:39So you can't really incorporate that because it is directly applicable to the states.
- 22:46And for the last major developments in regards to states' rights that we'll talk about here is
- 22:50the development of federalism.
- 22:53So for about the first one hundred fifty years of The United States under the constitution,
- 22:59we've had what his or we had what is called dual federalism.
- 23:04It's it's imagined like a layer cake because the federal and state governments had mostly
- 23:10distinct spheres of authority.
- 23:11And like in a layer cake, there's distinctly one flavor in one layer, and then another
- 23:16layer, there's a distinctly other flavor.
- 23:20But from the new deal to the nineteen sixties, you saw a lot more of what is called
- 23:24cooperative federalism, which was ushered in by Franklin D.
- 23:30Roosevelt's presidency with the new deal.
- 23:32And this had federal and state governments mostly intertwined and working jointly,
- 23:39especially in the realm of commerce.
- 23:43But from the nineteen seventies to today, you see a lot of people have taken to call new
- 23:48federalism or an era of devolution where there's been a shifting of power back toward
- 23:54state governments and more clear demarcations of authority between federal and state.
- 24:00And one way you see that is through the use of block grants that have been used by presidents
- 24:05like Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan, where sums of money are given to states and local
- 24:11governments to determine more for themselves where to spend the money.
- 24:14Whereas some grants are specifically you have to use it for this particular purpose, like for
- 24:20Rhodes, for example.
- 24:22In the cases of Nixon and Reagan and sometimes with some other presidents, they've been more
- 24:27general as to what they could be used.
- 24:30They basically tell states and local areas to use this money where you see fit.
- 24:36Now, of course, the those are not clear cut like there's never cooperative federalism
- 24:45anymore or there was never dual federalism during the era of cooperative federalism.
- 24:49That's not what that means.
- 24:50But the prevailing concept of federalism, you saw dual federalism for the first one hundred
- 24:57fifty years From the nineteen thirties to the nineteen sixties, it was much more cooperative.
- 25:01And from the nineteen seventies to now has been sort of moving back more towards that dual
- 25:06federalist concept.
- 25:10So that leads us to today, states' rights and today's politics.
- 25:16People sometimes choose pick and choose when to support states' rights depending on if it
- 25:21benefits them.
- 25:22If your party is in power in the federal government, tend to be less supportive of
- 25:27states going a different way and or at least the concept of states' rights is considered
- 25:34differently.
- 25:35And if your party's out of power, you tend to be more supportive of states' rights because
- 25:39you want states to be able to go against what the current ruling party in the federal
- 25:45government thinks is the correct policy.
- 25:47And a recent development in this states' rights debate is the anti commandeering doctrine,
- 25:55which says that federal governments cannot compel states to directly use state resources
- 26:00to enforce federal laws or programs.
- 26:03Federal law is still supreme, but the federal government has to use its own resources to
- 26:09enforce those laws.
- 26:11They cannot tell states they have to do it.
- 26:13Now states can willingly abide by that, and we've seen that over and over again.
- 26:19Right now, we've seen more Republican states be more acquiescent to the federal government
- 26:25because the federal government is run by the Republican Party right now.
- 26:29But when it was the Democratic Party that was in charge in the federal government, you saw
- 26:33more Democratic states acquiesce to the federal government as well.
- 26:39But there is some debate as to how much of it really is the federal government's letting
- 26:45states decide whether to comply or use their own resources to comply with federal government
- 26:50or not, and how much of it has been coercion or pressuring of state governments to follow
- 26:58federal guidelines.
- 27:00So four salient issues that we see in particular when it comes to states' rights and
- 27:07the states' rights debate are immigration, abortion, LGBTQ policy, and religious
- 27:13expression.
- 27:14They're not the only ones, but you see states' rights and whether or not it is a state purview
- 27:21or a federal purview, you see that crop up a lot in these issues.
- 27:26In the case of immigration policy, you see states' rights crop up a lot when it comes to
- 27:32what conservatives call sanctuary cities, ICE deployment, immigration enforcement grants from
- 27:39the federal government given to states and localities.
- 27:43In the cases of sanctuary cities, there's a lot of debate about whether the federal government
- 27:49can force these state and local governments to basically give up these immigrants or whether
- 27:58they are actually housing these immigrants who are depending on your verbiage.
- 28:05We call them illegal versus undocumented.
- 28:10But for some people, they see that as an infringement on states' rights because the
- 28:15states have to decide how to deal with these immigrants, whereas federal government or
- 28:22people who are against the state's rights view, at least in the case of this, say that federal
- 28:28government is simply just upholding its own laws.
- 28:32In the case of ICE deployment, it's a similar thing.
- 28:36Is the federal government intruding on state's rights by deploying ICE federal immigration
- 28:42agents into state areas to try to basically enforce or to force states to comply with
- 28:55federal immigration policy.
- 28:57And you've also seen a lot of enforcement grants provided to certain states and
- 29:03localities, especially ones that are more aligned with the Trump administration.
- 29:09Some people see that as another way that federal government is overstepping its bounds.
- 29:17In the case of abortion, the overturning of Roe versus Wade in the Dobbs versus Jackson case,
- 29:24which returns abortion to being an issue that the states decide.
- 29:27Now is that a state's right situation?
- 29:30Should abortion be decided by the states, or is it protected by the fourteenth amendment?
- 29:35LGBTQ policy, and this is a pretty large umbrella, but for one thing, opposition to the
- 29:43Obergefell versus Hodges case, for a lot of people, they say that's an incorrect reading of
- 29:49federal power given by The US constitution, that that is that gay marriage and other
- 29:56similar policies should be left up to the states, whereas other people will say that it's
- 30:03a fourteenth amendment issue, and so the federal government's power supersedes the state
- 30:08government's power in this case.
- 30:11And there's also concerns about the supreme court possibly reversing the ruling of
- 30:16Obergefell versus Hodges in a future supreme court case similar to what happened with Roe
- 30:22versus Wade in the Dobbs versus Jackson case.
- 30:25And then lastly, with religious expression, you see things like putting the 10 Commandments
- 30:31outside state government buildings or making the Bible required reading in schools.
- 30:36Is this state's rights?
- 30:38Now you might talk about the incorporation doctrine protecting religious expression, but
- 30:44for some of these states that are making the Bible required reading, for example, or putting
- 30:50the 10 Commandments outside of state government buildings.
- 30:53They're saying that this is within state purview, that it's not forcing people to
- 31:00believe something, but it's also that the state should be able to dictate these kinds of
- 31:05things.
- 31:05That they're actually protecting religious expression by doing this.
- 31:10So there's a bunch of different ways that this can be looked at, and just wanted to give a
- 31:14basic overview of these policies.
- 31:17Unfortunately, don't have enough time to really hone in on these particular issues and really
- 31:24wish I could go much more into it, but unfortunately, can't right now.
- 31:29So I wanted to make sure I got this out here.
- 31:32But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 31:35As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 31:37Please like, comment, share, subscribe, and my links are in the show notes.
- 31:42My other works including my meme.com profile, my five day educational email course about how
- 31:47we can more effectively tamp down toxicity and polarization and mitigate it.
- 31:55My book on political independence and why they struggle so much in elections and how they
- 32:03could potentially reverse said fortunes, not arguing that we should or shouldn't have more
- 32:09independence, but wanted to give much more of a view on something that is not very well
- 32:13understood.
- 32:14And then my other links, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my website, and my email, Paul Raider
- 32:21writes at Gmail dot org.
- 32:22So as always, thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.