Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / Divorce the IRS: Defusing the Tax Time Bombs Hidden in Your Freedom Plan with Jimmy Miller
Transcript
- 0:00Americans now hold more than $33 trillion in
- 0:03IRAs and workplace retirement plans like the
- 0:06401k. Yet only 3 in 10 of us have any plan at
- 0:10all for the taxes waiting inside those accounts.
- 0:13So today on Escape the Clock, we're aiming to
- 0:16answer the question, how much of your nest egg
- 0:19is actually yours? And how much is the IRS just
- 0:22letting you hold? Because that word, tax -deferred,
- 0:25it never meant tax -free. It means delayed. Every
- 0:30dollar you put into a traditional 401k or IRA
- 0:32was a loan from the IRS, and every loan comes
- 0:36due. At age 73, government forces you to start
- 0:39withdrawing, whether you need the money or not.
- 0:42And when that time bomb goes off, it can result
- 0:45in higher tax brackets, up to 85 % tax on Social
- 0:49Security, and Medicare surcharges. These are
- 0:52terms written directly into the tax code, yet
- 0:55almost nobody sees them coming. Here's the cruel
- 0:58irony. The more disciplined a saver you were,
- 1:00the bigger the bill. So how do you find these
- 1:03tax time bombs before they go off? And what does
- 1:06it actually take to defuse them? To answer this,
- 1:09I will be joined by Jimmy Miller. Born in Zambia
- 1:12and an expat for more than half his life, Jimmy
- 1:14has spent 26 years as a fiduciary financial advisor,
- 1:17founded Baobab Wealth and Baobab Wealth Abroad,
- 1:20and he wrote Divorce the IRS, a book mapping
- 1:23the eight tax time bombs hiding inside American
- 1:26retirement plans. So today we get into the myth
- 1:29of the lower tax bracket in retirement, why a
- 1:31Roth conversion works exactly like refinancing
- 1:33a mortgage, the four accounts that every freedom
- 1:36plan needs before you leave work, and the tax
- 1:39surprises waiting for anyone dreaming of retiring
- 1:41abroad. If your plan holds even one pre -tax
- 1:44dollar, consider this your bomb squad training.
- 1:47Stay tuned. Welcome back to Escape the Clock,
- 2:10a show where we highlight strategies and approaches
- 2:12for achieving financial freedom and having the
- 2:14option not to work. I'm your host, Daniel C.
- 2:16Rodgers. Let me paint you a little picture here.
- 2:18You've spent 20, maybe 30 years doing everything
- 2:21right. You maxed out that 401k, you've been getting
- 2:24that employer match, and you've been benefiting
- 2:27from all the compounding, watching it grow the
- 2:29balance from 50 ,000 to 200 ,000 to eventually
- 2:33something that might look like real financial
- 2:35freedom. And then retirement, thing you've been
- 2:37working so hard for finally arrives. So does
- 2:40the IRS. Because here's what a lot of people
- 2:43don't fully expect about those tax deferred accounts.
- 2:46That word deferred doesn't mean avoided, just
- 2:49means delayed. And the taxes that you didn't
- 2:52pay on the way in will be waiting for you on
- 2:54the way out. By the time you get there, the rules
- 2:56might not be in your favor. At age 73, the government
- 3:00forces you to start withdrawing from those accounts,
- 3:02whether you need the money or not. Those required
- 3:04minimum distributions or RMDs, are treated as
- 3:07ordinary income. They can push you into a higher
- 3:09tax bracket. They can trigger taxation on up
- 3:12to 85 % of your social security benefits. And
- 3:16they can expose you to Medicare surcharges that
- 3:18almost nobody anticipates. It's like a taxation
- 3:21time bomb. And the cruel irony is, is that the
- 3:23more disciplined that you were, the more you
- 3:25saved, the bigger the explosion. But today's
- 3:29guest has not just studied this, he's lived it.
- 3:31Jimmy Miller is a fiduciary financial advisor,
- 3:34the founder of Baobab Wealth Abroad, and the
- 3:37author of Divorce the IRS, a book dedicated to
- 3:39helping people identify and defuse the tax time
- 3:42bombs sitting inside their retirement plans before
- 3:45it's too late. He's a lifelong expat born in
- 3:47Zambia who has built his practice specifically
- 3:50around helping Americans avoid these exact landmines.
- 3:53Jimmy, welcome to Escape the Clock. Happy to
- 3:56be here. Your book opens with this premise that
- 4:00most people think they're saving on taxes when
- 4:03they're contributing to their 401k. but they're
- 4:05actually taking a loan from the IRS with just
- 4:08terrible terms. Can you take me back to when
- 4:11that context crystallized for you and how you
- 4:13first realized how widespread this misunderstanding
- 4:16was? Yeah, absolutely. I've been a financial
- 4:18advisor for going on 26 years now. And this really
- 4:21jumped out at me quite early in my career. So
- 4:24I've been preaching the same things for quite
- 4:26a long period of time. In 2021, I wrote a book
- 4:29about it, Divorce and Arrest, which I'm sure
- 4:31we'll discuss. But, you know, it's been this
- 4:33way for quite some time. And I've always been
- 4:35amazed over my more than two decade career, how
- 4:37people still gravitate towards that pre -tax
- 4:41account that they really believe those deductions
- 4:43today, which is you just described as putting
- 4:46it really just putting it off to later. it will
- 4:48actually benefit them when in most circumstances,
- 4:50certainly for the people that are listening to
- 4:52a podcast like this, it probably won't. Right.
- 4:55And at the scale of this problem is actually
- 4:57quite large because Americans collectively hold
- 4:59over $35 trillion in tax deferred retirement
- 5:03accounts. And every single one of those dollars
- 5:05have never been taxed. So at age 73. RMDs are
- 5:09going to really force quite a lot of withdrawals,
- 5:11which are all treated as ordinary income. So
- 5:13maybe you start by walking through what this
- 5:15tax time bomb actually is and why a lot of people
- 5:18just aren't really planning for it as well as
- 5:21they should be. Yeah, well, I find Americans
- 5:23are happy to put off just about any problem they
- 5:25have in life till later. But this one isn't like
- 5:28kicking the can down the road, as we like to
- 5:31say. I describe it more as pushing a wet snowball
- 5:34down a snowy slope because it's a problem that
- 5:36gets exponentially larger as time goes on and
- 5:40those accounts grow, hopefully, of course, over
- 5:42time. So the book really outlines eight tax time
- 5:46bombs that most people never see coming in retirement
- 5:48until they get there. And oftentimes it's too
- 5:51late to do much. of anything about it. So the
- 5:54book is really educationally focused, designed
- 5:56to bring awareness before retirement to some
- 5:59of these tax time bombs that are coming down
- 6:01the road. You've already mentioned one of them,
- 6:03RMDs. That's when the government starts forcing
- 6:05you to take money out of your pre -tax accounts
- 6:07and paying tax on it. I call the tax deductions
- 6:10people take today a loan from the IRS. And that's
- 6:14because of exactly those RMDs that you just described.
- 6:16A loan always comes due at some point in time.
- 6:18And for sure, the RMDs are just like that loan
- 6:20coming due on the taxes that you kicked the can
- 6:23down the road on. But there's seven other tax
- 6:25time bombs that I talk about in the book that
- 6:27people usually don't see coming that can start
- 6:29to blow up much earlier in your life than age
- 6:3173 when you get to the tax time bomb of RMDs.
- 6:35The decision I think a lot of people try to make
- 6:37when it comes to retirement savings is pre -tax
- 6:40or after -tax. Do I want to make a bet on the
- 6:44tax rate being better today or being better in
- 6:46the future? I could make an argument that it's
- 6:50very difficult to be optimistic about the future
- 6:53with the amount of national debt that we have.
- 6:55The money printing and things like that can add
- 6:57a lot of risk to taxation being the only salvation
- 7:00from the debt that we're in. But still, people
- 7:04are kind of taught that the 401k in particular
- 7:06is the tax saving vehicle they should be using,
- 7:10especially when they're making income. Can you
- 7:12talk a little bit more about why this vehicle
- 7:14can actually be kind of dangerous for people
- 7:16when they're optimizing for today, but not really
- 7:18getting ready for the future? Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:21I have a whole chapter in the book dedicated
- 7:22to the myth of the lower tax bracket in retirement.
- 7:25Because when I start to talk to people about
- 7:27this, that's generally the first argument that
- 7:29comes up. But I'm going to be in a lower tax
- 7:31bracket in retirement. And I hated that in our
- 7:33industry, that's really the only thing that's
- 7:35talked about. I find that the laziest financial
- 7:37advisors push people into these tax deferred
- 7:39accounts, just going with this myth that they're
- 7:41going to be in a lower tax bracket retirement.
- 7:43Now, certainly some people will. Americans are
- 7:45not very good at saving. You've probably covered
- 7:47episodes about that. But your audience, of course,
- 7:50are fire people, and they're going to be good
- 7:53at saving. And people that I work with and people
- 7:55that are savers generally aren't going to be
- 7:56in a lower tax bracket retirement. And that's
- 7:58because all the deductions that they did have,
- 8:00the 401k, if they are doing that, the HSA, the
- 8:03child tax credits, the mortgage. interest deduction,
- 8:06all those things are gone hopefully by the time
- 8:08you get to retirement. And when you factor in
- 8:10social security and maybe rental income and dividends
- 8:13and all that, people end up not being in a lower
- 8:15tax bracket. I tell people all the time this
- 8:18whole idea that you only need 60, 70, 80 % of
- 8:20your pre -retirement income in retirement. Most
- 8:23of the people that I work with want at least
- 8:25the same amount or more income in retirement
- 8:27than they did before because one of the benefits
- 8:29of a job isn't only that it makes you money,
- 8:31but it also stops you 40 hours a week from spending
- 8:34money. And most retirees I know fill those 40
- 8:37hours a week when they retire with things that
- 8:39generally cost them money. So oftentimes they
- 8:41need even more money in retirement to live the
- 8:43lifestyle that they want to have. I know that's
- 8:46been true for me. I have my youth. I have my
- 8:49time. I want to do stuff. I want to travel more.
- 8:52I want to do more activities, learn new things.
- 8:54There's costs with everything. Even doing this
- 8:57podcast has had more costs than I had planned
- 8:59for. Now, it's not to say that you can't adapt
- 9:02and have a good plan that can handle and weather
- 9:05that stuff. But I am curious about the tax part
- 9:07in particular, because I will say that has been
- 9:09my biggest personal challenge. is taxes. I thought
- 9:12my tax situation was going to get much, much
- 9:14simpler when I was done with work and actually
- 9:16it has not proven to be that way at all. What
- 9:19kind of reactions are you getting from people
- 9:20when you're showing them these tax bills, when
- 9:22they have this expectation that everything's
- 9:24about to get easy, but these bombs have been
- 9:26hiding there the whole time? Yeah, it's a wake
- 9:29-up call for a lot of retirees. I try to teach
- 9:32people about provisional income as early as I
- 9:34can in life. Most people, maybe a lot of your
- 9:36listeners, have never even heard of provisional
- 9:38income. That's the calculation the IRS does on
- 9:40you once you get to Social Security age to determine
- 9:42how much, if any, of your Social Security is
- 9:44going to be taxed. So taxes don't necessarily
- 9:46get simpler as you get older and get into retirement.
- 9:50When you have to factor in the RMDs, when you
- 9:52have to figure your provisional income, when
- 9:54you have to calculate how much of your Social
- 9:56Security is going to be taxed, Oftentimes, taxes
- 9:58can get more complex in retirement for some retirees,
- 10:01and it's a real wake -up call. I do get a lot
- 10:03of calls from people in retirement that are now
- 10:07getting those wake -up calls or those tax time
- 10:09bombs are exploding on them, and they're looking
- 10:11for that professional help to figure out how
- 10:12they'd manage this and if there's any moves that
- 10:14they can make still at this time in life. And
- 10:17there always are. It's never too late to improve
- 10:19the future for themselves. So someone who might
- 10:23be pursuing financial independence right now
- 10:25and trying to leave the workforce, let's say
- 10:27in their 40s or 50s, what would you tell them
- 10:30is the most important tax planning opportunity
- 10:32that they're probably missing at the moment?
- 10:34The one that I see the most for those in the
- 10:37FIRE movement is saving enough in a non -qualified
- 10:39account and also then using those tax -free bucket
- 10:42type accounts. As you know, you can take your
- 10:44contributions out of a Roth before 59 1⁄2 with
- 10:47no taxes or penalties, making it much more flexible
- 10:49without forcing you into trying to do a 72T,
- 10:52a substantially equal payment plan, or things
- 10:55like that that get complicated and restrict what
- 10:57you can do and can't do and how long you have
- 10:59to do those programs and things like that. but
- 11:01also to save enough in the non -qualified account.
- 11:04So many people are so into getting money into
- 11:07those qualified type retirement accounts. And
- 11:09there's nothing wrong with that inherently, but
- 11:11there's often an opportunity, especially for
- 11:12those people that retire early, where they have
- 11:14these low income years, right? We have a lot
- 11:17of tax advantages inside of a non -qualified
- 11:19account, especially if you're not making earned
- 11:21income. The brackets for the 0 % capital gains
- 11:24rate is quite high, especially if you're married,
- 11:26filing jointly. And you can take the income that
- 11:29an average person wants to take in retirement
- 11:30retirement tax -free, even when there's gains
- 11:33in that non -qualified account. And that opens
- 11:34up the ability then to do Roth conversions. If
- 11:37you did earlier in life, put a lot of money into
- 11:39pre -tax accounts and that strategy works really,
- 11:42really well for people, but you have to think
- 11:44about it ahead of time and set yourself up with
- 11:46enough money in those non -qualified accounts
- 11:48to be able to live on that tax advantaged, and
- 11:51then at least take advantage of your standard
- 11:52deduction for those Roth conversions over time.
- 11:55And as your listeners probably know, you definitely
- 11:56don't want to Roth convert your whole kit and
- 11:58caboodle in one go. takes many years. So the
- 12:01non -qualified account has to be fairly substantial
- 12:03in order to have those five to 10 years of low
- 12:07to no tax years per the IRS, even though you're
- 12:10taking money out of your non -qualified account
- 12:12and being able to Roth convert and sometimes
- 12:15even pay a little bit of Roth taxes on that from
- 12:18the non -qualified account as well. So that strategy,
- 12:21a lot of people know about it. It's not a secret,
- 12:23but it's one that I see a lot of fire people
- 12:26or people who want to fire are missing. Yeah.
- 12:30And let's go in that one deeper. I think that's
- 12:31really important because I was at Camp Fi and
- 12:34I was talking to a lot of people in the fire
- 12:35movement and there's a lot of interest in Roth
- 12:37accounts and brokerage accounts. And, but those
- 12:39are the enthusiasts, right? The people who are
- 12:41most adept and educated and trying to be successful
- 12:45here. As I work with people outside that community,
- 12:48I have quite a few people who have dollars in
- 12:51pre -tax accounts and that's everything. That's
- 12:54their whole plan. It's all 401k contributions.
- 12:56And it had to be a bit of a wake up call because
- 12:59Because they were assuming that was the money
- 13:01they would have. They hadn't calculated taxes
- 13:04at all. And so there was a bit of a, well, actually,
- 13:07not only is your withdrawal strategy going to
- 13:10be set at a certain age, but you're going to
- 13:12have to be paying a portion of that away. And
- 13:14so Roth conversions made a lot of sense in that.
- 13:17And also, a lot of people don't realize they
- 13:19have a Roth option now through their employers
- 13:21since the SECURE Act. and that employers are
- 13:24supposed to offer you an after -tax retirement
- 13:26account option if they hadn't before. So there's
- 13:29a lot of misunderstandings there, but I want
- 13:30to dive into the Roth conversion strategy because
- 13:32I do think that is a powerful tool. And like
- 13:34you said, I think a lot of people in this community
- 13:36do understand it, but you have to understand
- 13:39how much ordinary income you have. You have to
- 13:41understand what your tax hit is, how to select
- 13:44based on the right cost basis is that it can
- 13:46be complicated. to do it well. Plus there's five
- 13:49-year timers and things. If you plan on withdrawing
- 13:51out what you contribute there. So can you talk
- 13:53a little bit about the Roth conversion strategy
- 13:56and how important do you see, especially for
- 13:58someone on the financial independence path? Yeah,
- 14:01absolutely. So I call a Roth conversion refinancing
- 14:04your IRA because I found this is a really good
- 14:06way to explain to people because there's another
- 14:08area in our financial life that people will rush
- 14:11out and spend all sorts of money and that's mortgages.
- 14:13You know, if you have a 6 % mortgage and mortgage
- 14:15rates drop to 3%, almost everybody will go out
- 14:18and pay several thousand dollars to refinance
- 14:20that and lock in that historic low rate for the
- 14:23next 30 years. And that's exactly what you're
- 14:25doing when you do a Roth conversion. You're going
- 14:27to pay some taxes now, but you have to remember,
- 14:29you're always going to have to pay those taxes.
- 14:31I mean, even if you pass away, unless you give
- 14:32it to a charity, your kids are going to pay those
- 14:35taxes. There's really no way to get out of it.
- 14:37So by refinancing it, by paying those taxes up
- 14:40front now while the account is still smaller
- 14:41at today's known rates, because nobody has a
- 14:44crystal ball about the future tax rates. But
- 14:47as you mentioned in the opening, man, I think
- 14:49that they could be a lot higher in the future
- 14:51looking at our history of tax rates and where
- 14:53the government is going. But set that aside for
- 14:55a minute. Refinancing your IRA can make just
- 14:58a tremendous amount of sense for people. But
- 15:00as you said, we want to make sure that you don't
- 15:01get into a higher tax bracket. So you have to
- 15:03be smart about it. that I really stress is to
- 15:06add a layer of complication to it. In the book,
- 15:08I described something called your ideal number.
- 15:10And as much as I love the Roth IRA, somebody
- 15:12that has all of their money in Roth IRA and not
- 15:15qualified is also not taking full advantage of
- 15:17the system because you want to make sure you
- 15:20take advantage of your standard deduction each
- 15:21year. And as your listeners know, that's the
- 15:23money we get each year tax -free, around $32
- 15:25,000 for married filing jointly. So if you pull
- 15:28that first $32 ,000, just rounding numbers here,
- 15:31out of your traditional IRA or pre -tax account,
- 15:34you can wipe out the tax of their standard deduction
- 15:36and then use the rest from Roth or other tax
- 15:39-free vehicles like cash flow, life insurance,
- 15:41things like that, not qualified account. So tax
- 15:44deferred accounts aren't all bad. It's just important
- 15:47that you do the financial planning to understand
- 15:48what the ideal number is for your situation in
- 15:51a tax deferred account. I really like the way
- 15:53that you describe it as like a refinancing. That's
- 15:55really interesting to kind of see it that way
- 15:58too. And you know, like if we were all perfect
- 16:00people, we would be able to calculate What's
- 16:02the ideal tax rate to pay based on my situation
- 16:06today? But as everyone knows, it can be complicated.
- 16:09You might want to put the right amount of money
- 16:11in a pre -tax account because you're lowering
- 16:13your ordinary income of that year. You're staying
- 16:15out of a higher tax bracket because of the marginal
- 16:17rate. But then later you want to roll just enough
- 16:20over to pay a little bit of tax now to save yourself
- 16:22on tax later. But how do you know what taxes
- 16:24are later? It can get quite complicated quite
- 16:26fast. So it kind of leads me to this next question,
- 16:29which is a lot of people go, well, it's going
- 16:31to be okay. Because I'm going to move. I'm going
- 16:33to leave the country. I'm going to go to a lower
- 16:35cost area. Basically, it's called geographic
- 16:37arbitrage. A lot of people I talk to in the FI
- 16:40community do plan this. They either say, I'm
- 16:42going to move to this country or this area because
- 16:44what I save will stretch a lot further and I
- 16:47don't have to worry about taxes anymore. And
- 16:50this is a significant number of people because
- 16:51in 2024, the expat network said that 5 .4 million
- 16:55Americans were living abroad and 23 % of them
- 16:59were over the age of 65. So this is a lot of
- 17:01people in kind of the retirement community. So
- 17:03what do people not understand about the tax reality,
- 17:06though, of this geographic arbitrage strategy?
- 17:09Yeah, it's a really great question. You know,
- 17:11Tim Ferriss kind of brought that to light with
- 17:13his four -hour workweek book talking about the
- 17:15lifestyle arbitrage, and it became more popular,
- 17:17and it's been gaining traction every year. I
- 17:19also get a lot of people interested, and I specialize
- 17:22in working with Americans that are living, working,
- 17:24retiring overseas is what I do every day. What
- 17:27a lot of people don't realize, and maybe your
- 17:28listeners as well, is that America is the only
- 17:31country that taxes its citizens worldwide. So
- 17:33I also deal with a lot of cross -border families.
- 17:36I'm married to a German citizen, Sonia. She has
- 17:39a green card here in America, but she's a German
- 17:41citizen. And there's financial complications
- 17:43when you have that cross -border thing as well.
- 17:45Now, Sonia, for example, in Germany, when she's
- 17:47not there, she's obviously not using the roads,
- 17:49the schools, the fire department, the police
- 17:51department. She can deregister, and she's not
- 17:53responsible for any taxes in Germany when she's
- 17:55not there. If she moves back, she can re -register,
- 17:57pay taxes, and have all those services. Americans
- 18:00don't get that benefit. We are required to file
- 18:03a tax return in America if we meet any of the
- 18:06regular requirements like earned income, capital
- 18:08gains, all those types of things in America,
- 18:10regardless whether they're here or not. Now,
- 18:12with that said, there are a couple breaks for
- 18:14Americans that are overseas because obviously
- 18:16you're not using the services here in America.
- 18:18The first one is the FEIE or Foreign Earned Income
- 18:21Exclusion Allowance. And basically, in round
- 18:24numbers, that allows an American that's overseas,
- 18:27primarily overseas, more than 330 days a year
- 18:29to not pay taxes on the first $130 ,000 of earned
- 18:34income that they earn outside of America. So
- 18:37if you're an English teacher and you're traveling
- 18:38the world and enjoying that, you know, and you
- 18:40make less than $130 ,000. You still have to file
- 18:42a tax return, but you don't have to pay any taxes
- 18:44because you can exclude it. Now, that comes with
- 18:46some negatives because that income is excluded.
- 18:48You're not allowed to use any child tax credits.
- 18:50You're not allowed to put money in an IRA, Roth
- 18:52IRA, a non -deductible IRA. You can't make any
- 18:55contributions because you didn't actually have
- 18:56any earned income in America because it was excluded
- 18:59with the FEIE. Now, the other thing that Americans
- 19:01can do overseas is the foreign tax credit. So
- 19:04with countries that have a tax treaty, and about
- 19:0760 countries have a tax treaty with America,
- 19:09for countries where you're going to pay a higher
- 19:11tax rate, which is pretty much all of Europe,
- 19:13you're allowed to use a dollar -for -dollar credit
- 19:15on any taxes you pay in Europe against your taxes
- 19:17in America. So that's another way. If you're
- 19:19going to pay $30 ,000 of tax in Germany, but
- 19:22your tax bill in America is only going to be
- 19:23$20 ,000, that credit of $30 ,000 in Germany
- 19:26can wipe all of your taxes in America. But you
- 19:29still have earned income in that situation. So
- 19:32for people that make over the 130 or in higher
- 19:34tax countries that still want to contribute to
- 19:36accounts like a Roth and IRA, still get things
- 19:38like the child tax credit, generally FTC or foreign
- 19:41tax credit is the better tax strategy for them.
- 19:44I do meet a lot of Americans all the time that
- 19:46think that once they leave the border, they don't
- 19:48have that tax liability in the States. But it's
- 19:51not true. And most countries around the world
- 19:53are like America in the fact that they tax worldwide
- 19:56income. So you can move to Thailand. or Bali.
- 19:59But once you're a tax resident there, for most
- 20:01countries, that's once you've been there 183
- 20:03days or longer, you're also going to be subject
- 20:05to worldwide taxes on all your income in that
- 20:08country as well. So it's important if you're
- 20:10thinking about going overseas to consider the
- 20:13taxes in both places and weigh that against that
- 20:16lifestyle arbitrage. It's for sure true that
- 20:19life can be much less expensive in Southeast
- 20:22Asia, but you have to consider the taxes and
- 20:25the complication of taxes. And the extra reporting
- 20:28and things like the FBAR and things, VATCA and
- 20:30things like that along the way so that you can
- 20:33make a good decision whether that's really the
- 20:34right lifestyle for you and if it's going to
- 20:36actually save you money in the long run. Which
- 20:39countries have the most favorable agreements
- 20:41right now when it comes to tax treaties between
- 20:43the US and themselves? Great question. So as
- 20:47far as tax treaties go, the UK is actually the
- 20:50best and strongest one right now. So most tax
- 20:52treaties will eliminate a double taxation situation,
- 20:55which is really what we're after. Then you end
- 20:57up paying the tax rate in the higher country.
- 21:00But one of the problems that a lot of people
- 21:01don't foresee that want to go overseas, especially
- 21:03the people that I meet that want to go to Italy
- 21:06or Portugal or Spain, one of these places, is
- 21:09the tax treaty does not recognize things like
- 21:11the Roth IRA. So if you built a big Roth IRA,
- 21:13but your dream is to go to Italy for retirement,
- 21:16Italy is going to tax a Roth IRA exactly like
- 21:19a non -qualified account. You're going to have
- 21:20to provide a cost basis. So if you got a million
- 21:22bucks in there and $500 ,000 is your contribution
- 21:25and $500 ,000 is growth, when you take $1 ,000
- 21:28out, they're going to expect taxes. in Italy
- 21:30in the 40 -something percent range on half of
- 21:34the money that you would draw from your Roth
- 21:36IRA. So there's another thing that Americans
- 21:37going overseas often miss and why it takes specialized
- 21:40planning if you are going to go overseas. One
- 21:43quick tip I can give everybody, if you are thinking
- 21:45about going overseas, sell everything in your
- 21:47Roth and repurchase everything right before you
- 21:50go to reset your cost basis in there so that
- 21:53if you do end up taking money out while you're
- 21:55overseas, you can show a higher cost basis on
- 21:58your investments. And talk to a tax professional
- 22:00like you, seriously, like you can save us so
- 22:03much money if you don't know what you're doing.
- 22:05That kind of move for sure. Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:07So for someone who is now going, OK, I get it.
- 22:12I should worry about this a little bit more.
- 22:13I'm doing all the saving stuff, but I don't want.
- 22:17bombs hiding in my accounts. What are some of
- 22:20the things they should start thinking about today?
- 22:22And is there a, like a baseline plan that everyone
- 22:25should be aiming towards like a balance between
- 22:28certain accounts? Like everyone should have a
- 22:29brokerage account, a pre -tax and an after -tax,
- 22:32or is it really going to just depend on every
- 22:34single individual? It depends on every individual,
- 22:37but for most people. depending on their income
- 22:40level, they're going to have a non -qualified
- 22:41account, a single or joint, of course, if they're
- 22:43married. And they'll generally have a backdoor
- 22:45Roth IRA to non -deductible IRA. And then they'll
- 22:48have their Roth IRA so they can convert that
- 22:50non -deductible IRA over. A lot of people get
- 22:52tripped up as well. You maybe had an episode
- 22:54on this in the past with the pro rata rule. So
- 22:56a lot of people get excited about that backdoor
- 22:58Roth IRA, and then they don't realize that it
- 23:00doesn't really work for them because they rolled
- 23:02over $100 ,000 401k from a job years ago, and
- 23:05they haven't converted that yet. And now if they
- 23:07make that kind of contribution to the non -deductible
- 23:09IRA. They can totally do that, but converting
- 23:12that to the Roth because of the pro rata rule
- 23:15doesn't make a lot of sense. And then they create
- 23:17complications for themselves by building this
- 23:19account with non -deductible money that also
- 23:21has growth in it over time now. And you've got
- 23:23to keep those things separate because the growth
- 23:25in a non -deductible IRA is really tax -deferred
- 23:27money and is still taxable. Your basis can come
- 23:30out later or be converted. It gets a little complicated
- 23:33with some of those strategies. But everybody
- 23:35should usually have those three accounts, a pre
- 23:37-tax account, a Roth account, or after -tax account.
- 23:40account and a regular non -qualified brokerage
- 23:42account. I would probably add an HSA on top of
- 23:45that if they're able to qualify to do that as
- 23:47well. Even better than the Roth. Yeah. I'm glad
- 23:50you brought up the pro rata. I think that's great.
- 23:52AMT is another thing that was in my mind a bit
- 23:54that I think could surprise people, especially
- 23:56on the higher income side, because they might
- 23:58think they're okay. And then, you know, you pay
- 24:00the highest of the two. So you'd end up getting
- 24:03hit with that one. But I do think most people
- 24:05are just mostly thinking about tax brackets.
- 24:07I think they're thinking, okay, what's my tax
- 24:09bracket now? What's my tax bracket look like
- 24:11in the future? And the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
- 24:14of 2017 did create historically low tax brackets,
- 24:17but they sunsetted at the end of 2025. And so
- 24:21I know that people who are thinking about tax
- 24:24bracket management might feel a sense of urgency
- 24:27right now. about how to think about changing
- 24:30tax rates and things in the future. Is there
- 24:32anything that you recommend for people when it
- 24:35comes to tax bracket management? I mean, it's
- 24:37hard to calculate a marginal rate of taxes. Is
- 24:40this something you have to work with a professional
- 24:42on? Or is this something that people should just
- 24:45stop focusing so much upon? No, that's a really
- 24:49good question. There's things in financial planning
- 24:51that are known and we can control, and then there's
- 24:53all these things that we don't know and we can't
- 24:55control. Inflation, tax rates, it all fall in
- 24:58that we can't control a bucket. So I generally
- 25:00tell people it's best to use what the laws and
- 25:02the rules are today and to do a future tax projection,
- 25:06a lifetime tax plan. Most CPAs are really interested
- 25:09in helping you figure out how to save the most
- 25:11this year. They're not doing a projection out
- 25:14of what your tax breaks might be in the future
- 25:16using today's laws to figure out how to. pay
- 25:17the least amounts of the IRS over the course
- 25:20of your lifetime just this year. And that's the
- 25:22big problem I have with tax professionals. So
- 25:24generally when I use my software and there's
- 25:27lots of different softwares out there that'll
- 25:28do this, you can kind of figure out on today's
- 25:31laws, what your future tax brackets will be.
- 25:33And for people, once they generally get into
- 25:35their thirties, what I find is they get fairly
- 25:37stable. You know, they get into a 22 or 24 %
- 25:40tax bracket. And then if they're a good saver,
- 25:42like most of your listeners, I'm sure are, they're
- 25:45going to have that same type of income. going
- 25:47forward because they don't let lifestyle creep
- 25:49come in. And then when they hit that magical
- 25:51number and they can sustain that for life, they
- 25:53retire and that income stays quite stable. So
- 25:56that's generally what I find is the sweet spot
- 25:58for people. So if I do a plan for somebody and
- 26:01you're in the 24 % tax bracket and we project
- 26:04you out and you're never going to be in a lower
- 26:07tax bracket than 24 using current laws, well,
- 26:10that makes it obvious that we should Roth convert
- 26:12right to the top of the 24 % bracket because
- 26:15I'd rather pay 20. four percent now on my money
- 26:18if i know that i'm never going to pay less than
- 26:20that basically in the future now you can get
- 26:23really detailed into this now and say okay well
- 26:25what about effective rates because you know in
- 26:27the future i'm taking out we got to cut effective
- 26:29rate is more thing and you can look at that but
- 26:32then you have to also factor in the fact of the
- 26:34growth of those accounts as well right so doing
- 26:37a roth conversion at a marginal rate today at
- 26:4024 on 100 bucks and thinking about taking it
- 26:43out later at effective rate you also then have
- 26:45to consider the that $100 is going to be $300
- 26:46down the road when you take it out. And so, yeah,
- 26:49your effective rate might be lower, but you have
- 26:52two times or three times the money in the account
- 26:54that's being taxed down the road. So it gets
- 26:57a little bit muddy in the calculations. And a
- 27:01lot of people like to argue back and forth, but
- 27:02generally doing a Roth conversion to the top
- 27:05of your current or projected future tax bracket
- 27:08is going to make the most sense for the most
- 27:09people. Yeah, it's a lot to think about for sure.
- 27:12And then to make it even more complicated, a
- 27:14lot of the rules have been changing and things
- 27:16like stretch IRAs are pretty much changed at
- 27:20least. And things like doing qualified charitable
- 27:23distributions, there's different strategies for
- 27:25that. Of course, there's businesses involved,
- 27:27like thinking about legacy makes it even more
- 27:30complicated. So for someone thinking about, okay,
- 27:33I'm trying to do the right things, not just for
- 27:34myself, but for my future children or for that
- 27:38charity that I care about, what types of tax
- 27:41considerations should they be starting to put
- 27:43into their plan? Yeah, that's a good question.
- 27:45So pre -tax accounts are perfectly fine and more
- 27:48favorable if you're planning on giving away your
- 27:50money. That's the one instance that you're not
- 27:52going to pay taxes from the grave or taxes when
- 27:55you take the money out or taxes when you hit
- 27:57the RMDs and you're forced to take it out if
- 28:00you give it to a qualified charity. So if that's
- 28:02definitely something that you want to do, then
- 28:05you need to consider that in your financial plan
- 28:06and make sure your tax professional and financial
- 28:08advisor are aware of those wishes because that's
- 28:10going to change what I call your ideal number.
- 28:12You're going to want to have more. in those tax
- 28:15deferred accounts if the plan is to give it away.
- 28:18I do meet a lot of people that think the plan
- 28:20is to give it away, but it's to give it away
- 28:21to my grandchildren. And I'm not going to pay
- 28:23any tax if I give it to my grandchildren. And
- 28:24as you know, the grandchildren, unfortunately,
- 28:27are not a charity, and they are going to pay
- 28:30taxes on that money. And now, as you alluded
- 28:32to, they only have 10 years to take the money
- 28:34out and pay taxes on it instead of the stretch
- 28:36IRA like they used to have. And most kids inherit
- 28:39the money when they're in the highest tax brackets
- 28:42of their life. They retire, they inherit the
- 28:45money when they're 50s, they're making the most
- 28:47money they have, and now they're forced to take
- 28:49it out in 10 years, can push them into quite
- 28:51a higher tax bracket. And oftentimes I see the
- 28:53kids now paying higher taxes to get the money
- 28:55out than what the deceased parents were paying
- 28:57to get the money out. So you have to consider
- 29:00all those things when you're looking at your
- 29:01estate plan for sure, who's going to inherit
- 29:03the money, what the tax brackets are for the
- 29:05kids or the inheritors versus yourself. Amazing.
- 29:10As we wrap up here, I was wondering, is there
- 29:12anything important that you would want people
- 29:15to know about that they could start to take action
- 29:18on today? It could be with their estate plan.
- 29:20It could just be open that account that they're
- 29:23missing. Like you said, it could be talking to
- 29:25a tax professional. Like if you could broadcast
- 29:28a message out to everybody right now, what would
- 29:30you want them to know? Educate yourself. Learn
- 29:32about this stuff. I mean, not to plug myself,
- 29:35but the book Divorce the IRS. I understand that
- 29:38reading a book about taxes is like the broccoli.
- 29:40It's not the most exciting thing, but I promise
- 29:43it's a quick read. It's easily laid out. It'll
- 29:46educate you on all these future tax time bombs.
- 29:48If you're not into reading a book on taxes, I
- 29:50totally get it at the website for the book. You
- 29:53just Google Divorce the IRS. There is a video
- 29:55series outlining the eight tax time bombs and
- 29:58some of the myth of the lower tax bracket. So
- 30:00you can watch this series. of two and three minute
- 30:01videos to get the cliff notes version. There's
- 30:04also a podcast. If you prefer to listen to it
- 30:06on your commute, you can listen to the book through
- 30:08the first 20 episodes of the podcast as well.
- 30:10There's case studies in it, and it will educate
- 30:12you within two or three hours of all of this
- 30:15stuff that we're kind of brushing over the surface
- 30:17and talking about in today's podcast. Beautiful.
- 30:19Thank you, Jimmy, so much for coming to the show.
- 30:21How can listeners connect with you if they would
- 30:23like to get more help directly? Yeah. So I have
- 30:26two websites, Baobab Wealth and Baobab Wealth
- 30:28Abroad. Baobab Wealth is for US -based clients
- 30:31and abroad, obviously for Americans and cross
- 30:33-border families. Most people ask me right away,
- 30:36what's Baobab? It's the tree of life from the
- 30:39Lion King. That's the Baobab tree. I was born
- 30:41in Zambia. I spent more than half my life overseas
- 30:44as an expat myself. That's why I help Americans
- 30:47overseas because I've lived it myself and understand
- 30:49the situation that they're in. And since I was
- 30:51born in Africa, I've really been drawn to the
- 30:53Baobab tree and it's unique shape. And I often
- 30:55say investing is like planting a tree. If you
- 30:57just plant it and give it enough time and leave
- 31:00it alone through all the seasons, it'll grow
- 31:01to something beautiful on its own. So that's
- 31:03why I use the tree for the logo. So baobabwealth
- 31:06.com or baobabwealthabroad.com. Yeah. And protect
- 31:10your tree from the IRS. Thank you so much, Jimmy,
- 31:14for coming to the show. I really appreciate it.
- 31:15Yeah, it's my pleasure. When I left work, I assumed
- 31:27my taxes were just going to get easier. There
- 31:30would be no more W -2 income pushing me into
- 31:32a higher tax bracket and no more stock vesting
- 31:35schedules keeping those golden handcuffs tied
- 31:37on my wrist. And also no more fear that a big
- 31:40financial move was going to create some kind
- 31:41of explosive tax bill. And those things did happen.
- 31:45It was actually the new things that started happening
- 31:48that really surprised me. The things that retirees,
- 31:51especially early retirees like me, are never
- 31:53really taught to expect. And I'm not alone in
- 31:56that. When Northwestern Mutual surveyed American
- 31:59millionaires, their number one burning question
- 32:01about retirement wasn't how much money they were
- 32:04going to need or even whether they had outlived
- 32:06their savings. It was actually how will taxes
- 32:09impact me? So taxes are on our mind. And the
- 32:13people who have already won the accumulation
- 32:14game, you know, we're the ones that are worried
- 32:17about taxes the most usually. And that should
- 32:20tell us something because Jimmy's first lesson
- 32:22was actually really simple. you can kill the
- 32:24myth of that lower tax bracket. Because yes,
- 32:28the tax bracket will drop when your W -2 income
- 32:30stops, but the deductions that sheltered you
- 32:33while you were working, those evaporate right
- 32:35along with it. While things like dividends, interest,
- 32:38royalties, and maybe even rent, that stuff starts
- 32:42flowing in. And here's the part that actually
- 32:44bit me personally. I no longer had a W -4 standing
- 32:48between me and the IRS. I had supplemental income
- 32:51that I was earning. But that still owes quarterly
- 32:54taxes. Now, let's just say that I learned it
- 32:57through a nasty surprise penalty my first year
- 32:59of retirement that I'm now supposed to be calculating
- 33:02and paying those, not my employer. But now I
- 33:05have a calendar reminder a couple times a year
- 33:07to pay the IRS what I've been able to calculate
- 33:10that I've been able to earn. But that's something
- 33:12on me. That's something I wasn't taught. Additionally,
- 33:15as Jimmy pointed out, without the 40 -hour day
- 33:17job, nothing is distracting you from spending
- 33:20money to fill that time. Take it from me, when
- 33:22your work is done, your life does really feel
- 33:25like it starts. You have all these goals and
- 33:27interests and things that you can actually start
- 33:30to prioritize, and most of those things actually
- 33:32cost money. His second lesson is a blueprint
- 33:35that we've actually covered before, but it's
- 33:38an important one. Before you leave work, you
- 33:40want four buckets, a pre -tax account, a Roth,
- 33:43a regular brokerage account, and if you qualify,
- 33:46an HSA. Then optimize what goes where. Us wealth
- 33:51managers, we call it tax drag. Let's take dividends,
- 33:54for example. Dividends are taxed regularly, so
- 33:57holding those in a brokerage account will just
- 33:59quietly fill up that tax bracket. But if you
- 34:02tuck them into a tax -advantaged account, now
- 34:05they'll be able to compound and maximize the
- 34:09return there because you're not losing out to
- 34:11ongoing tax payments. The Roth is that super
- 34:15account because nothing in there is ever taxed
- 34:18again. as long as you meet the qualifications.
- 34:21So open it up early enough, wait until you get
- 34:24past the age for withdrawals, then you're never
- 34:27going to have to worry about losing out on any
- 34:29of those returns. And because of that, that's
- 34:32where your high growth assets belong. We call
- 34:34it the rockets. These are the things that can
- 34:37just really, really take off. What you see, the
- 34:40balance in that account, that is the balance
- 34:42you will have to spend. It's very, very powerful.
- 34:46So you can really put in just plain old stocks.
- 34:49You can put in pretty much anything you need,
- 34:52especially things that you see high growth potential.
- 34:55And then there's that brokerage account. And
- 34:57this is where I see most of the mistakes, especially
- 35:00for folks in the FIRE community, because people
- 35:03working towards FI, they understand you need
- 35:05that brokerage account to bridge those years
- 35:06because you're trying to work towards an FI number.
- 35:09But the thing is, typically folks in the FIRE
- 35:11community will just throw the kitchen sink at
- 35:13the brokerage account. Whatever you think is
- 35:15going to help you move the needle towards that
- 35:17number, But what that does is it will bleed out
- 35:20your gains to taxes. Instead, fill it with assets
- 35:24that generate no taxable income. These are things
- 35:26like non -dividend ETFs. And you can let that
- 35:29tree grow till you're ready to harvest it for
- 35:32what you need to make it across that bridge.
- 35:35If you have a really broad, low -cost index fund
- 35:39that's not paying dividends, then you're not
- 35:41paying out ordinary income taxes on a regular
- 35:44basis, and you're not realizing any type of taxes
- 35:48at all until you finally decide to sell it when
- 35:50you need to. That's a very powerful strategy.
- 35:53Then, of course, with your traditional or 401k
- 35:56pre -tax accounts, You can put in the lower tax
- 35:59drag stuff, things like bonds. You can put in
- 36:02things that you'll eventually have to pay taxes,
- 36:04but they pay out slower. And you can use that
- 36:07to slow down the tax drag because eventually
- 36:10you won't have to dip into those accounts until
- 36:13later in life when RMDs hit in, or you can start
- 36:15to tap into those earlier to minimize the tax
- 36:18drag even more. So if you put the right investments
- 36:21in the right places, then you minimize how much
- 36:24the IRS will collect. Because every dollar in
- 36:26a pre -tax account is in essence borrowing from
- 36:29the IRS. Eventually, they come collecting. But
- 36:33when you optimize, then you're refinancing those
- 36:36loans. And that leads into his third lesson.
- 36:39He talked about this idea of refinancing your
- 36:41IRA. You know, it makes sense. You wouldn't hesitate
- 36:45to pay a few thousand dollars to refinance a
- 36:47mortgage from like 6 % down to 3%. Everyone understands
- 36:50the value of that. A Roth conversion is kind
- 36:53of the same idea. It's about paying the taxes
- 36:56now at a known rate on a smaller balance instead
- 37:00of later at some unknown rate on a bigger one.
- 37:03When you do it slowly and properly, you're taking
- 37:06smaller hits today for a peace of mind in the
- 37:08future, all while building up a contingency since
- 37:12those converted dollars can come back out penalty
- 37:14-free five years after each conversion. I cover
- 37:18Roth conversions as both an optimization and
- 37:21an income stream in my book, Escape the Clock.
- 37:24Because it's been such an amazing tool for me
- 37:25personally. Just watch out, though. There are
- 37:27gotchas there. It can get complicated, especially
- 37:29with things like the prorata rule. So you have
- 37:32to keep in mind some of these complexities. Things
- 37:34like old 401ks, if you have multiple IRAs, even
- 37:38a spouse's account. These can make the math messy
- 37:42fast. And that's where tax professionals, they
- 37:45really earn their keep. Now, you might be thinking,
- 37:48Dan, I don't need all this. We're just going
- 37:51to move. somewhere else like to Southeast Asia.
- 37:54And first of all, congrats. That's awesome. Super
- 37:57jealous. That sounds like something I would love
- 38:00to do. But like, look, if you're thinking that
- 38:03as a tax evasion tactic, it's not going to work
- 38:05because the taxes will follow you. America is
- 38:08the only country that taxes its citizens worldwide.
- 38:11Some of the most beloved retirement destinations,
- 38:14you know, the places like Italy, Spain, Portugal,
- 38:16they don't recognize the Roth IRA at all. Jimmy's
- 38:20tip was actually pretty genius. It's to reset
- 38:24your cost basis before you move. And what he
- 38:27means by this is selling everything in the Roth
- 38:29and immediately just buying it back. What that's
- 38:32doing is that's marking up the cost to today's
- 38:35market value. And therefore, you've washed out
- 38:38all the gains. Therefore, there's nothing for
- 38:40that new country to tax. But remember, that can
- 38:43get complicated, too. So you have to be very
- 38:45careful there, especially if you have a large
- 38:46balance. So you have to remember before doing
- 38:48a move like that, you really, really need to
- 38:50talk to a tax professional. But if you do it
- 38:53right, that geographic arbitrage to Tuscany,
- 38:56it could totally work. You just have to keep
- 38:59in mind it's a tax plan, not a tax escape. Even
- 39:03death isn't an escape from the IRS getting its payday.
- 39:06Which brings me to the last big area worth revisiting,
- 39:09the legacy that we try to leave behind. If charity
- 39:13is part of your goal, pre -tax money is actually
- 39:15a wonderful tool. It is actually the number one
- 39:18strategy that us wealth managers are recommended
- 39:21to do. Because if you give that pre -tax money
- 39:24to a qualified charity, then all of that deferred
- 39:27tax that you are supposed to pay, well, you simply
- 39:30will never have to pay it. Not by you, not even
- 39:33by the charity. It's a really amazing thing because
- 39:36especially if you use something like a donor
- 39:38advised fund, a DAF. You can put in that stock
- 39:42right away. Charity doesn't have to understand
- 39:45the complications of how to transfer the stock.
- 39:48As long as it's highly appreciated and you have
- 39:49gains in there, that gets cashed out by the brokerage.
- 39:53You don't pay any of the gains on that. You get
- 39:55to take an immediate tax deduction for that year.
- 39:58Even if you don't choose the charity that year,
- 40:01you could choose the charity in the future. And
- 40:03that charity will be able to get the cash value,
- 40:05even though it came from a stock. It's a very
- 40:08powerful strategy. But you also have to keep
- 40:10in mind, though, our kids, our grandkids, they
- 40:13don't qualify as a charity, no matter how much
- 40:15they might want us to see them that way. And
- 40:17most heirs, they are going to be required to
- 40:19empty an inherited IRA within 10 years. Your
- 40:23newer rules used to be that you could designate
- 40:26a beneficiary, like a child, and they'd be able
- 40:29to stretch that IRA out. But now anyone other
- 40:33than a spouse and a very few limited others.
- 40:35are required to empty the whole thing in 10 years,
- 40:38and that usually happens during their peak earning
- 40:40years. And that can be an absolute tax nightmare.
- 40:44And that's not our goal. It's not to create a
- 40:46tax nightmare for the ones we love and the ones
- 40:48we're trying to help. You may not have thought
- 40:50much about this, and that's completely fine.
- 40:53That's why I'm doing this. But I do promise you
- 40:55that the IRS has. They are taking advantage and
- 40:58writing into codes things that will make sure
- 41:00that they're getting their payments one way or
- 41:03the other. So the best we can do is understand
- 41:05that. So we're not paying any more than we have
- 41:08to. And in some cases, we can optimize to actually
- 41:11make sure that we may be paying even less than
- 41:14they might expect. So if there's one big takeaway
- 41:17from this episode, it's this. Stop treating taxes
- 41:19like a chore that comes every April and take
- 41:22them on as a serious risk or at least a serious
- 41:24opportunity in your plan. Financial freedom depends
- 41:27on it. I'd love to hear from you. What tax time
- 41:31bomb is ticking in your plan right now? And what's
- 41:33your first move to defuse it? Email me at contact
- 41:36at escape the clock dot com. Leave a comment
- 41:38wherever you listen. I'm Daniel C. Rodgers. Thanks
- 41:41for listening. That's the luck defusing your
- 41:43tax time bombs and escaping the clock. See you
- 41:45next week. That's a wrap on this episode of Escape
- 41:49the Clock. Everything you've heard today is for
- 41:51educational purposes only. Designed to help you
- 41:53think, plan, and build a stronger financial program.
- 41:56Take what resonates, bring it into your escape
- 41:58the clock plan, and review it with a qualified
- 42:01professional before making any major moves. The
- 42:03book, the free planner, and the one -on -one
- 42:05time with me are all waiting for you at escape
- 42:07the clock.com. If this episode was valuable,
- 42:10please leave a rating, share it with someone
- 42:11who needs to hear it. I'll catch you next week.