Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Samson Mow - CEO of Pixelmatic and JAN3 | Why Bitcoin Will Hit $1M
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to success story. I'm your host, Scott Clary. The success story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network
- 0:06They have great podcasts you should go listen to but they also have great technology that can help your business
- 0:12The big reason why more than 300 of last year's unicorn startups use HubSpot is because there is no other software that keeps you better
- 0:20Connected with your teams and your customers so you can crush all your business sales revenue marketing goals
- 0:26The new HubSpot sales hub brings you that power of an easy-to-use platform designed for today's top entrepreneurs
- 0:32Today's top sales teams with 360-degree deal management and real-time reporting
- 0:37You get accurate windows into every inch of your business and with AI power tools like their new chat spot
- 0:43You'll have a dedicated assistant that knows your business inside and out chat spot enables your team with one-stop access to a ton of
- 0:50Time-saving functions like pulling data tracking calls managing leads scheduling emails
- 0:55So trade cold calls for warm leads because when it comes to scaling sales your software should be smart and the solutions should be simple
- 1:03Get on track for your best Q1 yet. Check out HubSpot sales hub at HubSpot.com slash sales
- 1:09Today my guest is Samson Moe. He's currently the CEO of Pixelmatic the development studio behind Infinite Fleet as well as a CEO of Jan 3 a new Bitcoin
- 1:27Technology company with a mission to accelerate hyper Bitcoinization
- 1:31Samson is known for his work on El Salvador's Bitcoin strategy and nation-state Bitcoin adoption in general
- 1:36He has previously CSO at Blockstream a leading provider of Bitcoin infrastructure and before joining Blockstream
- 1:42He was the COO at BTC China one of the largest Bitcoin exchanges and mining pools in the world at BTC
- 1:49Samson oversaw day-to-day operations of the company and directly managed the exchange and mining pool business units
- 1:55Now we spoke about the block size war Bitcoin maximalism adoption of crypto by nation states
- 2:00Why Ethereum is a security and a shit coin scaling Bitcoin and why Bitcoin will be the best way we save ourselves from tyrannical governments and or wellian
- 2:091984 societies pick a point in your life a pivotal point in your life
- 2:14It sets you on the path to who you are today could be something that got you involved in Bitcoin
- 2:18It could be something that got you involved in tech it could have been
- 2:21Something your parents did that made you
- 2:24gravitate towards one industry category or the other so pick that point we'll go from there
- 2:28So everything first started when I first read about Bitcoin mining
- 2:33So this is the inflection point at which I understood that Bitcoin was decentralized and it was unique
- 2:42Many people have heard about Bitcoin and they gloss over it and they read about it in the media
- 2:47And it's often portrayed in a very bad light
- 2:50But most people understand Bitcoin is just a digital currency or a virtual currency
- 2:55But when I first read about Bitcoin mining that was when I really dug into the details
- 3:00And I understood that it's an open system that is permissionless that has nobody controlling it
- 3:06Because when you understand Bitcoin mining you understand
- 3:09Anybody can join in and secure the network audit the network and actually run the back end systems of Bitcoin themselves
- 3:17And so you're you already from day one you went into the weeds like you you obviously are very technical
- 3:22Individual you jumped into the weeds, but you decided to build a company in Bitcoin mining
- 3:28What why as opposed just or go ahead. Sorry, go ahead. Sorry. So that was my initial foray
- 3:34So you totally put the moment right so after that
- 3:38It took me a while before I I guess I officially
- 3:41Got into Bitcoin and I say that is when I joined btc China
- 3:45That was a Bitcoin exchange based in China
- 3:48So this is like the inflection point, but then there's another long journey into it
- 3:54Okay, so then what was your so so you know about Bitcoin you just learned casually about Bitcoin mining
- 4:00Did you like spin up some s's not I don't even know what year it was like what what did you did you like
- 4:04Figure out how to order an s9 and like try and like cook it up in your house your condo and realize it was like super loud and super hot
- 4:09Or like what's the first foray in the Bitcoin mining
- 4:13Well, this was a
- 4:152013 I believe so I tried to set up on my laptop, but people were already using GPUs and
- 4:23Maybe FPGA's at that time s9s were not out yet, but I couldn't mine anything with my laptop unfortunately
- 4:29But at least that was the point at which I understood Bitcoin
- 4:32But I didn't really get into it until I joined btc China in 20 late 2014 early 2015
- 4:39And I was the COO there and it was a Bitcoin exchange and mining pool
- 4:43But that's really the start of the journey down the rabbit hole into
- 4:47All the things that I'm doing today with nation-state Bitcoin adoption and gen 3
- 4:52Do you think that somebody has to understand Bitcoin mining to understand Bitcoin is that important or is that more in the weeds?
- 4:59Not at all. I would say because I'm a game developer by trade
- 5:02So I build virtual worlds with economies and it's all centrally controlled right you have a game currency
- 5:07You have to manage the game currency and for me it was understanding Bitcoin in that context that there was nobody controlling the currency
- 5:15That really sparked that light bulb aha moment for myself
- 5:18But anybody can understand Bitcoin you can read the white paper
- 5:22I actually read the white paper after I set up all my Bitcoin mining systems
- 5:26But like people can go into Bitcoin in different ways and they don't need to mine Bitcoin to understand Bitcoin
- 5:34I was always curious about that because we always still are even today
- 5:37I feel like we're we're solving for the problem of of understanding and adoption right like how many well I mean 2013 now or now we're almost 10 years later
- 5:46So I've always wondered if if people went more into the weeds or if there's other adoption problems that you've seen because you've been in this for such a long time
- 5:55Now okay, so you you joined btcc as COO
- 6:00So walk me through that career decision. Why why did so were you in Bitcoin professionally before or was this something that was just more of a hobby
- 6:09And then this is like your first four because COO of a large company is that significant
- 6:14Well, you have to remember everything was a bit smaller back then like
- 6:18BTC China had about 18% of hash rate which was not a lot of
- 6:23Computing power back then but these days 18% is very substantial right because everything is grown
- 6:29But um, I was running my game company pixelmatic and then my friend was running btcc China and our offices were just a kitty corner from each other
- 6:38So he asked me to come on as an advisor originally
- 6:40So I went in and helped them set up the mobile
- 6:43Mobile app development team and started working on some other things and eventually he just said why don't you step in this COO
- 6:50So I had to learn a lot very rapidly about the entire business and about Bitcoin
- 6:54But prior to that I was just reading about Bitcoin and observing from the sidelines
- 6:58But I would say once I was in a Bitcoin company that was when you know
- 7:04You started getting really deep into it
- 7:06And also at that point of the Bitcoin block size war was kicking off too the sort of Bitcoin civil war where
- 7:12All the Bitcoin companies were trying to lobby for a block size increase and changing the rules of the protocol
- 7:18And I kind of got sucked into that that battle and and even described to me like there's a lot of entrepreneurs
- 7:24Listen to this show you you were an entrepreneur building out your own company when you
- 7:30Translate some of those lessons to a disruptive tech like Bitcoin blockchain
- 7:35As stepping into the COO role of of btcc China
- 7:39How did you find some of those skills translated like how do you build
- 7:43A company in an emerging industry. There's no playbook. There's no rulebook
- 7:47what's the
- 7:48What's to take away how you still you know you saw some hair left so you're good
- 7:52But I mean it probably was pretty stressful
- 7:54Well, the the biggest stressful the most stressful part I would say was just understanding how exchanges operate
- 8:01and how um all the different mechanics work because there are new products being built all the time on top of Bitcoin and things like margin lending
- 8:10Um derivatives and things like that. So that was probably new for me
- 8:14But running a big company was not really anything new so before I started pixelmatic
- 8:18I was actually an executive at Ubisoft and I helped them build a game studio in western China from the ground up to about 200
- 8:26Some odd people
- 8:27So I had the experience running a large team for a public company and
- 8:34I think that is valuable experience in a disruptive new tech because a lot of tech companies and as you're aware
- 8:41They may have an idea and they may have
- 8:44You know some traction
- 8:46But they're typically inexperience on the company management side. So I brought a lot of that
- 8:51You know even handed management and you know scaling of the organization itself
- 8:57And running it so at the end to um when I left bd's China
- 9:00I was in charge of the mining pool and the exchange business units and a lot of the core services around operations and the business itself
- 9:08And I'm assuming like now
- 9:10You know several years later like the the whole industry has evolved and I think this is something that
- 9:15We start to see in emerging industries even like cannabis like day one
- 9:19A lot of passionate
- 9:21Product focused operators and entrepreneurs and then you start to have some experience and you start to have people that have
- 9:27You know built scaled sold and then bills people are rolled back in so the whole industry evolves
- 9:33But so after you left btc China um
- 9:37This is probably where and correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you spent the majority of your of your of your
- 9:42Bitcoin career up blockstream correct
- 9:45That was them okay, and walk me through that career decision why blockstream
- 9:51What were you trying to solve for so you were CSO there? I'm pretty sure that was out of that was out of Canada at a Toronto for non-missake
- 9:56Um actually out of Victoria Victoria was still in Victoria too you've been in Vancouver for a while
- 10:01Okay, got you still Canada west coast budget
- 10:04Well blockstream is a Canadian company technically it's incorporated in Montreal
- 10:08But we just marked Victoria as the HQ because I was here, but um, I got none of the spots right
- 10:15Close enough close enough
- 10:17But uh, yeah like the Montreal office is really like a back office of finance people and you know
- 10:23Emailing address, but people would contact us all the time and say can we meet you in Montreal?
- 10:28So we would just say okay HQ is in Victoria at least I can meet them and you know do the bd and discussions there
- 10:33But yeah, the entry into blockstream was really just meeting Dr. Adam back
- 10:38He is the CEO of blockstream and our paths crossed during the Bitcoin scaling wars
- 10:43Because uh, it was the big blockers on one side and then the small blockers
- 10:48The people trying to preserve the consensus rule set on the other side
- 10:51So we were kind of fighting side by side against the
- 10:54The big onslaught of the every single Bitcoin company and mining company, right?
- 10:58So we built up a relationship and uh, working repertoire
- 11:03And I decided to join blockstream because I understood from that battle that things had to happen
- 11:09And Bitcoin infrastructure had to be improved
- 11:11So that we can weather the next storm can you go deeper on that that
- 11:16Uh, like that that issue that that um that fight that you're trying to fight because a lot of people don't who aren't in the weeds would not understand
- 11:22How the what's going on here like how are how are people fighting over Bitcoin?
- 11:27Right, so it was an innocuous change. It's just saying we want more scale uh, higher throughput
- 11:33So more transactions in blocks and the method that the big block camp wanted to use to accomplish that was increasing the block size
- 11:41Like four megabyte 10 megabyte 32 megabyte blocks and so forth
- 11:46And a number of them have branched off and made their own chains and
- 11:50They're basically unused
- 11:52But the small block camp wanted to scale in layers much like the internet
- 11:55So you have you know physical cables then you have a TCP IP HDDP and then you have apps on top and then
- 12:02CDNs and everything like that
- 12:04So it's not trying to increase the the pipes at the bottom
- 12:07But build in a structured layer to scale the technology and we do this through things like the lightning network and the liquid network
- 12:14But layers that sit on top of the base
- 12:17But the slippery slope here is if you start changing a fundamental rule of Bitcoin
- 12:22So the block size is one such fundamental rule and then you have other rules which people are more familiar with like the 21 million cap
- 12:30But if you can change this rule that you can change any of the rules and then Bitcoin just becomes like a fiat currency
- 12:36Some people will just dictate what happens monetary policy etc etc
- 12:42And Bitcoin just becomes meaningless
- 12:44So if Bitcoin actually increased the block sizes
- 12:49And scaled in that method then it would have been impossible for an average user to run a Bitcoin node on say their laptop
- 12:57Or you know old computer
- 13:00But that's really the key to Bitcoin's success resilience and longevity
- 13:05The fact that individuals can run a Bitcoin node and verify the entire
- 13:11Network themselves rather than outsourcing that to say Amazon someone running a big powerful server on Amazon
- 13:18Or by extension a bank because then you're just right back in the original territory where we left right you're back into
- 13:25Centralized control by a small number of people which you have no access to you yet best have read access to what they allow you to read
- 13:33But the whole point of Bitcoin is that you yourself run a node you are an active enforcer of the rules of the network
- 13:39So this was in nutshell what we were fighting for just Bitcoin's soul and because
- 13:45I think that if somebody starts to understand
- 13:47How Bitcoin operates and and somebody could literally amass and maybe walk me through why someone
- 13:54Could not amass a data center or just a ton of servers and and be an actor that could manipulate
- 14:02Yeah, so I think what you're getting into is the 51% attack the mining attack right
- 14:07I'm asking I'm at large amount of machinery
- 14:10A6 and then going to attack the network to rewrite the chain
- 14:13Now that it's been theorized a lot of times and you actually don't need 51% attack
- 14:19You could probably sustain an attack with 30 or 40% of hash rate
- 14:23But the challenge is how does one accumulate that much hashing power and
- 14:29Accumulating that much hashing power in stealth mode because if it's like let's say a nation state attack
- 14:35You'd have to basically
- 14:38By you know gigawatts of a power build out a large farm and then buy
- 14:45A6 from the suppliers or from the market and you could not do that without the market realizing what's happening
- 14:52So it's it's very difficult to pull off this as a stealth move
- 14:55And if it's known then other actors in the space can counter that move because they can they themselves can ramp up and
- 15:03You know acquire more a6 themselves right but the key here is that brick bitcoin runs on a proof of work model
- 15:10Not proof of stake, which is what ethereum and other very valuable protocols use
- 15:15So the problem with proof of stake is you have this this pie right you have the stake
- 15:19And their theory of security is that if you want to attack it you'd have to buy a stake and therefore
- 15:25You know it wouldn't work
- 15:26But the problem is you can co-opt a stake too, which is what happened to ethereum
- 15:30So people delegated responsibility out to the exchanges
- 15:34So most of the exchanges now are staking on behalf of the user
- 15:38So you kind of have this self-inflicted centralization where
- 15:42You know the big entities now have control of it
- 15:45But the problem is you cannot expand the stake you have that pie
- 15:49And like let's say you know there's a it's under attack and you have another actor like you yourself want to
- 15:56Expand the pie you can't do that because it's the stake
- 15:59Whereas with bitcoin mining you have this much hash right now, but let's say the us was going to attack
- 16:06Let's say i'll solve or ones to defend i'll solve or can you manufacture their own silicon make the a6 make the miners
- 16:13Get energy and add to the pie because there's no upper limit to proof of work
- 16:17You can keep adding more and more work to the pie all it's invincible
- 16:22Yeah, you just need to work right you have to build it deploy it, but you can secure it because there's no upper bound
- 16:32I understand okay, so this is this is really what you were fighting for in this is this actually
- 16:37Block streams like what was block streams mission? I know this is something you were very passionate about
- 16:41But what was block streams mission as a company? Well, I would say block streams mission is to
- 16:46Augment bitcoin right building technologies to scale bitcoin like lightning and like liquid
- 16:51So these second layer or even third layers in the future of ways to scale bitcoin because one of the attack vectors
- 16:58On during the block size wars was bitcoin is too slow seven transactions a second. It's not enough for the world
- 17:05But it's not meant to be
- 17:07The the main chain level is not meant to scale to transaction throughputs for billions of people you have to use higher layer technologies where you're
- 17:16You know abstracting away some of that
- 17:18confirmation time and your batching transactions right bitcoin at the base is a settlement layer
- 17:24And that is why the block time is 10 minutes because you need 10 minutes to synchronize the entire world
- 17:31Right, you have to take an account the slowest possible node and
- 17:37Have to propagate transactions and blocks to that slowest node and about 10 minutes is right
- 17:42bitcoin is very much built around real world physics right so you have to factor in the speed of light
- 17:48How long does it take for light to circumnavigate the globe?
- 17:51So there is no way that you can have everything settling on chain for a planetary population
- 17:58You have to use things like lightning where not everything is written to a central repository
- 18:02But individual nodes have their own map of the network themselves and then they they sync up on their own way
- 18:10And you mentioned something earlier that I thought was interesting you mentioned that
- 18:13One of the outcomes of this of this particular battle could render bitcoin
- 18:18quote-unquote meaningless, but
- 18:21I would like to understand because
- 18:24I don't know if there is a
- 18:27Across the board. I'm sure you have I'm sure you have a very defined meaning for bitcoin
- 18:31But across the board it is it doesn't seem like there is a
- 18:35Universal understanding of what it should or should not be
- 18:38So what is the what is bitcoin's meaning?
- 18:42Is it is it something supposed to be transactional?
- 18:44Is something supposed to be a store of value more more symbolic of gold or something like that
- 18:50And then I'm also curious about if you are very bullish on bitcoin
- 18:55And I only know enough to be dangerous. So if I'm misspeaking you tell me
- 18:59But I'm not I'm not as into it as some people are
- 19:02But if you are very bullish on on bitcoin
- 19:05I also want to understand the place that a theorem and
- 19:10Blockchains that in from my understanding operate like an OS or an operating system and you build things on them
- 19:17So that that's just sort of where I'm curious about because I want to unpack that but first let's describe
- 19:23What what bitcoin is how to just how it has meaning versus what is a meaningless version of bitcoin in your in your interpretation?
- 19:31So I guess I'll go with the easy answer first and is that that question is in my bullish on bitcoin
- 19:36And I'm very bullish on bitcoin
- 19:38I see bitcoin as the ultimate end state and that is what you're asking about earlier. What is hyperbiquanization?
- 19:44Hyperbiquanization is the point at which we don't convert back to fiat money
- 19:48Similar to how you don't convert
- 19:50Dollars to seashells anymore you might buy a seashell for a decorative thing or a necklace
- 19:54But you're not going to buy seashells and hoard them to store value right
- 19:59But the other part is what is bitcoin and the answer is very simple bitcoin is simply money
- 20:06So it is all of those things that you mentioned it is a store of value
- 20:10It's a medium of exchange and eventually it will be a unit of account and on some levels. It's ready a unit of account
- 20:16But what is a a useless version of bitcoin? I would say that is ethereum
- 20:22ethereum is centralized is basically a central bank digital currency at this point because
- 20:28There it's just big institutions running the chain
- 20:32So it's kind of defeated the purpose already. You don't have
- 20:37Is it similar to ripple excuse me just to understand is that like similar to ripple in terms of like
- 20:41It's it's similar to ripple it's similar to ftt. It's similar to everything
- 20:45So you have bitcoin on one side of the spectrum which is decentralized permissionless immutable
- 20:50And then you have everything else on varying levels of uselessness, right? So
- 20:56You know
- 20:58I think there are some cryptocurrencies that you could say are relatively decentralized
- 21:02But for the most part 99% of them. They're all
- 21:06Masquerading is decentralized. They still up a Swiss foundation somewhere and they say we're decentralized
- 21:10But it's really vitalic and his body is deciding monetary policy
- 21:14So you effectively have replaced the federal reserve with a bunch of guys
- 21:20You know on a zoom call that know nothing about money deciding what money is and
- 21:25Right now, I mean, they're on a kick to make a theory of sound money. So they're trying to
- 21:30implement monetary policy and make it more valuable right like reducing the supply
- 21:36Burning fees
- 21:37locking things up so that people can't withdraw from stick
- 21:41pools or whatever
- 21:43But that can change like if you can change in one direction you can change in the other direction, right?
- 21:48So when when Ethereum prices high they can say well, we need some inflation
- 21:52We're going to print some more and this is totally within their power to do
- 21:55And this is why a lot of Bitcoin is call Ethereum a shitcoin because it's so malleable
- 22:00They can change anything they want it was hacked. There was a Dow hack
- 22:03They rolled it back on the chain and I believe that was the inflection point for them to just fail
- 22:08They could have been I think that was the first like SEC investigation into anything crypto
- 22:13From not mistaken, wasn't it?
- 22:14Perhaps but I mean if there was really an unregistered security and a lot of these things are unregistered securities
- 22:20FTT included but pretty much every crypto is an unregistered security
- 22:26And this is why Bitcoin is trying to distance ourselves from all those things because they are trying to
- 22:32Affinity scam and say we're like Bitcoin. We're the same thing
- 22:36And they want Bitcoin to be a subset of crypto, but it's actually very different
- 22:41Very interesting and I'm super curious because actually prepping for this interview
- 22:45I saw you actually did a podcast with Vitalik and I didn't realize
- 22:49Now I understand whoever the host was. I can't remember his name
- 22:52But now I understand why he got you both on that call. Yeah, so if if I didn't listen to the whole thing
- 22:58And now I probably will after this I should have I didn't realize there's such like a contentious
- 23:03podcast, but um
- 23:05If if you were going to say this to Vitalik, what would what's Vitalik's argument? Because that's a pretty it's a pretty bold claim
- 23:11I've never heard this claim before that if theorems is shitcoin
- 23:14I've heard a lot of shit coins are shit coins, but not Ethereum
- 23:17Well, things every shit coin likes to call other things shit coins and they think they're not but they are so
- 23:22I remember don't don't don't coin was like laughing at other things and saying all of their all shit coins and uh, you know
- 23:28They're gonna fail we know how that yeah, yeah, you know how that ended up right but Ethereum it's just
- 23:33Malable if you look at some of their early recordings of their meetups and things they're talking about their ICO
- 23:39I mean that in itself is an indicator that it's a security right it's a
- 23:44effort by a group of people to make money and
- 23:47Attract investment into their project. It's just that they don't have a company, right
- 23:52But if you look at everything that Ethereum does it's basically a company
- 23:56Um a Dow is basically a board of directors, right? You're just saying it's a tokenized thing and therefore
- 24:01It's not under the existing framework, but I think regulators and
- 24:06And um, you know the CFTC and SEC they're starting to understand like a lot of that's just bullshit like it's really
- 24:14A securities offering that you're trying to pretend is decentralized and I think the time is running out for these guys
- 24:21Um now then that sort of uh, this is a great way to sort of dovetail into the the thing that I alluded to earlier
- 24:27Which is smart like smart contracts built on Ethereum
- 24:30I've never in my life heard of a smart contract which is again if Ethereum ZOS and you're saying it to centralize
- 24:38ZOS and the points you're making are very valid
- 24:40Um
- 24:41Then you have all these programs built on all these smart contracts and all these other things that we've now
- 24:45You know, it's it's blown up into everything from defied NFTs to whatever every I'm not sure if they're all built on
- 24:52Ethereum I don't think they are but a lot of shit has been built on Ethereum. So
- 24:57I haven't seen much built on Bitcoin. So what's why has there not been more of an explosion in smart contracts and the
- 25:05Understanding that Bitcoin can be an underlying OS for all these applications
- 25:10Well
- 25:11You don't really need an underlying OS the world doesn't need some sort of OS and if it did have an OS
- 25:17It should be decentralized
- 25:18But you there are things built on Bitcoin, but they're not the same scale as Ethereum simply because the Silicon Valley money machine is not investing in
- 25:27Companies building on top of sound money
- 25:30Silicon Valley itself does not understand sound money. They don't even understand gold barely
- 25:35What they're interested in is a quick turnaround and a quick gain on their investment
- 25:39Like if you watch the all-in podcast where you have Chimath and David Saxon those guys
- 25:45They're all talking about Solana and pumping their bags, right?
- 25:48But what the VCs want is super fast liquidity and turnaround on their investment
- 25:54And they can achieve that through investing in these token projects that have no
- 25:58Real purpose or utility
- 26:00It's just an easy way to dump on retail investors. So they don't need to wait
- 26:04Seven to ten years for a company to go public. They buy Solana in the presale and discount and sell it to retail investors and then
- 26:12They're good, right? So this is why there's such a big
- 26:18Big push for all of these projects and smart contracts, right? At the end of the day the you're building smart contracts which
- 26:26are not necessarily
- 26:28immutable or
- 26:31Or
- 26:33Unchangeable because they build back doors into them if you google smart contract back door
- 26:37You'll see a lot of these smart contracts they say you know code is law and they've written their rules set in here
- 26:42But then there's like a access point where they can shut it off and just like a five minute google will show you
- 26:48There's so many of these cases and all of them are very unsecure if you google defy hacks
- 26:53You'll find pages and pages of hacks every week. There's a defy hack because they're just building javascript
- 27:01Constructs that are unsecure and have back doors and centralized. So
- 27:05This is why none of this is really meaningful even a smart contract itself needs some sort of input
- 27:11It's not like a smart contract will just run on it run on its own
- 27:15If you go back to the simple example of buying real estate
- 27:19There has to be some proof that the transaction happens and then the
- 27:23The the funds are transferred, right?
- 27:25So there's always some input into these things but the bigger problem is your building smart contracts and
- 27:32And defy stuff that is just relying on
- 27:36trading governance tokens or worthless tokens like fruit
- 27:40dog tokens
- 27:41For other dog tokens and other governance tokens. So it's really a house of cards where you're
- 27:46Staking some governance token to get another governance token to trade some other governance token at the end of the day
- 27:52None of the government governance tokens even are meaningful because
- 27:56They're centralized and it's a small group of people that's going to decide
- 27:59Regardless of the governance tokens direction or what they think should happen
- 28:05I just want to take a quick second and tell you about one more podcast
- 28:08You have to check out if you're a fan of success story
- 28:11It's sales evangelist hosted by Donald Kelly brought to you by the HubSpot podcast network
- 28:17Each week Donald interviews the world best sales experts successful sellers sales leaders and entrepreneurs
- 28:23Who share their strategies to succeed in sales right now?
- 28:26He brings on Jeffrey Gettimer Jill Conrath Bob Burr Guy Kawasaki
- 28:31They share actionable insights and stories that will encourage
- 28:34Challenge and motivate you to hustle your way to more revenue for your business
- 28:39If you're somebody who's looking to take off in your sales career
- 28:41If you are an entrepreneur who's looking to sell more
- 28:44I think all of us are go listen to sales evangelist wherever you get your podcasts
- 28:49Do you think that there's any
- 28:51Applicate because I I complain about this a lot. I feel like a lot of projects
- 28:56And now, you know, it's just tying into what you just said a lot of projects seem to be creating
- 29:01Trying to solve problems that the founders are creating that aren't real problems
- 29:05I mean if you look at the average person
- 29:09They don't give a shit if they're transacting
- 29:12It whether or not the transaction they did is stored on the blockchain or not like they could have
- 29:17Man like the the most popular CRM in the world is still excel like there's so many problems that are being created to be
- 29:23Solve for that really have no
- 29:25Reason being created and that's you know if we talk about like fundamentals of entrepreneurship
- 29:30I mean you have to actually solve true pain points in the world not just just not makes shit up
- 29:34I feel like a lot of this stuff is making shit up
- 29:36Yeah, and they justify that by saying we have to innovate right and I
- 29:42Going back to your earlier point like how would metallic defend ethereum he would say you know
- 29:46It's pushing the boundaries and innovating on things, but it's really not nothing they've done is really innovative at all
- 29:53And nothing they do like you're saying is really useful in any real world situation right ethereum there's a video of
- 30:00A few ethereum founders saying we knew that ethereum 1.0 would never scale
- 30:05But when they were sourcing investment for their iCO that was not the messaging
- 30:09They were saying this is done and it's a finished product and it's the world computer
- 30:13But then they keep changing their narrative and they just haven't been nailed down to the cross yet about what they're actually doing
- 30:20Which is raising capital if you want to innovate
- 30:23Simply innovate right code. There's a saying cypherpunks right code
- 30:27But they're not writing code. They're soliciting investment
- 30:31For you know their little science experiment and not disclosing the risks and they have no liabilities because it's not a legal structure
- 30:38So it's kind of the worst of every single possible world combined
- 30:42Um with block chain is there innovation that you've seen doesn't and it can be on it can be with Bitcoin
- 30:49It could be like I'm thinking stable coins. Is there any need for any of this? What's something that you're actually excited about
- 30:57Um, I'm really excited about a lot of peer-to-peer tech that um the bifnix and tether guys are working on is called keat and hole punch
- 31:05But they've built this product you can check it out at keat.io
- 31:08But it's a peer-to-peer messaging app and they're getting ready to release the mobile version soon
- 31:14But this is going to actually change a lot of things
- 31:16So if Bitcoin is sound money you still need a medium to
- 31:21Engage with people that is not centralized right if you're still messaging people through
- 31:25I don't know what's that or something. They're still a centralized server and this can be shut off
- 31:29And it can be monitored. There's tons of metadata leaking everywhere
- 31:33But if we can get to more of a peer-to-peer world that in my view supports the peer-to-peer money which is Bitcoin
- 31:39So it's starting to fix the underlying problem with the world now
- 31:44I love people throughout the term blockchain, but I think the innovation is really Bitcoin the blockchain is really just the
- 31:51toxic waste that is
- 31:53Generated to allow us to have Bitcoin which is peer-to-peer cash that we can transact directly with one another
- 32:00If there if it was possible to do that without a blockchain that would be great
- 32:04Because the blockchain is just something that takes up space on your Bitcoin node and it's growing every year
- 32:10But that's the best solution we have right now
- 32:12I think a lot of these second layer technologies things like what blockchain is working on and other companies
- 32:18This will help alleviate that and allow Bitcoin to continue to grow and scale
- 32:23And then so so let's talk about that so
- 32:26Emeliorating Bitcoin
- 32:28That's what block streams mission is and I think that's what you've worked on for you know now you're still working on that
- 32:33I'm curious what Jan 3 is doing because I actually have no idea and I went to the website
- 32:36I couldn't find anything so you're gonna tell me what to do it but
- 32:39And I think it's like probably still because you're building it out. It's like still sort of a little bit new but um
- 32:44so
- 32:45The things that block streams working on so we're talking about lightning network. We're talking about
- 32:50Making Bitcoin better and making Bitcoin more efficient. So what what is the current state of Bitcoin?
- 32:55So what are the upper limits of what it can do that block streams? It's contributed and other people have contributed
- 33:01Well, there's no real upper limit because you're scaling Bitcoin with layers. So the lightning network
- 33:07You can have a theoretical throughput of about 40 million transactions a second right
- 33:11There's no upper bound because you just keep adding more nodes and all of the traffic and interactions are between the different nodes
- 33:18So if you if I'm not transacting with you
- 33:21You don't need to know the transactions I've made and this is how it becomes scalable
- 33:25You can have multiple side chains. So a side chain is a Bitcoin
- 33:30A block chain that's anchored to Bitcoin. So right now there's liquid and
- 33:35You could potentially have other different side chains
- 33:37But the key is that they all settle back to Bitcoin and that they're using Bitcoin and they didn't print a token
- 33:43To make themselves rich
- 33:45So it's just all Bitcoin through and through
- 33:48From Bitcoin base layer to layer two and beyond and so
- 33:52Yeah, sorry. Go ahead. No, go ahead. I lost my train of thoughts. Okay. Oh, no, no
- 33:58Well, I was also gonna say so I'm trying to address all like the the critiques, right?
- 34:01So the other one would be volatility
- 34:03So your goal is to make it so that we don't keep bringing Bitcoin back to to US dollars and and you're 100% right because everyone
- 34:11Even if you say right now like, you know how much how much Bitcoin do you have or what's your value like
- 34:16Psychologically, you're you're pinning it back to a US dollar amount or maybe your local currency, right?
- 34:23So the goal is to eventually not do that, but I mean the critique is volatility
- 34:28I can't what is it? I think it's by cup of coffee or some
- 34:32Some there's some there's some there's some de facto like transaction
- 34:37That we should be able to do the tar to do if prices
- 34:41Increased decrease goal over the map
- 34:43Yeah, so Bitcoin is volatile because it's still growing
- 34:46But it's important to put everything into perspective. So Bitcoin's like 13 years old
- 34:52It's still a baby really and it's actually quite impressive that it's grown this much in you know a decade plus
- 35:00Um, it's same with iPhone like the iPhone is only been around for a very short amount of time
- 35:04I think it was first out in 20
- 35:072009 or something like that
- 35:09I remember switching my blackberry for an iPhone, but it's hasn't been around that long
- 35:12But now it's very ubiquitous and that whole smartphone form factor kind of emerge from that, right?
- 35:19So things can change very quickly
- 35:21Especially with the currencies because they are inherently defective because the central banks can print it as much as they want
- 35:28There is no check and balance here
- 35:31And Bitcoin is just a superior money because you know that there is a set amount of Bitcoin
- 35:36It's 21 million and that can be subdivided into 100 million per coin
- 35:42So you know the rule set you know what you're getting into and one example I like to give is that Bitcoin is a ruler
- 35:48With a finite amount of you know units on that ruler
- 35:51Um, there's no such ruler for financial
- 35:56In financial circles like what people I guess measure in dollars
- 35:59But you can't measure in dollars because the supply is constantly fluctuating up and down right
- 36:04You have you know kilometers or miles for distance you have
- 36:08Answers and milliliters and leaders for volume
- 36:12But what do you use to measure monetary value? It's going to be Bitcoin because that's the only thing that's really set in stone
- 36:19Everything else is just
- 36:20Someone's printing paper and or not even paper now just database entry and it's changing every single day
- 36:27And you know the interest rates and everything change too on a weekly or monthly basis
- 36:33So then okay, so
- 36:34We understand that maybe the printing money is not it's not a great thing and I think we've seen a lot of issues with countries printing money over COVID
- 36:42More than more than ever before
- 36:44So your goal is your goal, I guess is this with Jan 3 now you're trying to
- 36:50Get countries to adopt or help
- 36:52I'll me understand because I know there's like these uh, there's
- 36:56El Salvador um, and there's help me understand like countries adopting Bitcoin versus stablecoins versus
- 37:04CBDC which seems to be the route that everyone's worried a country will take if they'd like the idea of digital currency
- 37:10Walk me through that and sort of what you're doing
- 37:13Right, so
- 37:14What we're doing is um, we have a wallet that we're developing called the aqua wallet
- 37:19It would be for Bitcoin and stablecoin
- 37:20So the the US dollar denominated value instrument is not going away anytime soon and stablecoins are a useful thing
- 37:28That can help give access to the financial system to people in the global south
- 37:33If you can't open a bank account you can still get tether and that is a useful tool
- 37:37So back to your earlier point is there anything useful with the blockchain?
- 37:40well having
- 37:42A stablecoin on the chain or without a chain like for example other protocols that
- 37:47Are more like the lightning network do add value, but it's not necessarily about the chain now
- 37:53I think uh when I joined blockstream it was about augmenting Bitcoin and doing some things to help scale Bitcoin
- 38:00and
- 38:01Basically cut off that sort of a attack vector where people say Bitcoin cannot scale because now it is clear that Bitcoin can scale
- 38:08So that is done
- 38:09But we have new
- 38:11Attacks that are going to come in the next few years or decades on Bitcoin too
- 38:17Such as CBDCs. I would say that's a form of attack
- 38:20I don't believe it will be a successful attack, but it's a type of attack and then you have misinformation
- 38:27A lot at the government levels. We saw some examples in the US where um, you had some people saying you know
- 38:33Bitcoin is controlled by a few developers and a few mining pools and therefore it can be regulated and we want
- 38:40We want software developers to register themselves and whatnot, right?
- 38:44But these are these are bad things and it's a bad direction for human civilization in general because
- 38:50That's just leading to authoritarian authoritarian
- 38:541984 type of life for everybody in the world where you're constantly under surveillance and there's zero freedom
- 39:01So I think Bitcoin is the bulwark against that and what we hope to do is to get more countries like El Salvador
- 39:07Adopting a Bitcoin standard and a part of that is really just re-teaching people
- 39:13What money is money is meant to be a mechanism by which we exchange our value our our time in value
- 39:21It's not supposed to be
- 39:23Something that a central bank is managing and it's not supposed to be a tool by which you can surveil people
- 39:30And it's definitely not something you should be using to try to
- 39:34You know manipulate the prosperity of a nation, right?
- 39:38But all of these things are happening and I think the work we're doing to engage in a nation state level
- 39:44Can help to defend against that because we can educate
- 39:47legislators and
- 39:49Members of parliament or congress like what is Bitcoin and what is money and why is money
- 39:57Critical to success of a nation state
- 40:00And why having sound monetary policy will prevent things like inflation and hyperinflation down the road
- 40:08And and how do you plan on convincing a nation state
- 40:14That they should adopt Bitcoin like like El Salvador is is trying to do versus a CBDC because it seems like a CBDC
- 40:23Is is totally in line with what a like a country would want to accomplish as much as ever
- 40:29You know, I hate it, but people like it makes sense that if I was trying to you if I was trying to you know
- 40:36Have better control over or track my citizens and outside of them pushing back
- 40:41Um, it serves the interests of the government
- 40:44Well, the key here is to change the interests of the government so that they're more pro-freedom
- 40:49So going back home to Canada
- 40:52It's like it's supporting people like peer polyev that are talking about freedom
- 40:56Sound fiscal policy and just common sense things like we shouldn't be buying oil from overseas when we have oil domestically
- 41:05right these things are
- 41:07Are just a nonsensical if you think about it and you step back there are countries that are
- 41:12Energy independent that just put themselves in a place to be dependent
- 41:18And seed sovereignty and I think Bitcoin is a step to restore a lot of that
- 41:23But not just Bitcoin itself, but the the first principles thinking around Bitcoin like why
- 41:28Why what is money? How do we become independent? How do we not be rely on others?
- 41:34And how do we do things that make basic sense, right? A lot of the world has forgotten about what money is people think
- 41:40It's just a number of my bank account. That's a thousand percent a thousand percent. Yeah, I mean, but
- 41:45It's the same for energy people forget you need energy human civilization is dependent on energy
- 41:51But because you know, you're comfortable you have lights on and heat in your house
- 41:56You forget what that comes from and people also don't understand how energy is produced and they think
- 42:04You know, we have to go green. It's got to be all solar and wind
- 42:08But you don't start tracking environmental impact from the point of which you buy that solar panel
- 42:15That has a life before it is available for purchase. It has to be mined
- 42:20The solar panels themselves the the photovoltaic leaves have to be made and they're made with coal
- 42:26And then at the end of life it has to be disposed
- 42:29But it's almost like they look at this narrow slice of the thing and say
- 42:32From the point I buy it to hear it's green therefore it's good
- 42:36But you ignore the beginning and the end of the thing. It's like go in the grocery store and saying
- 42:40Yeah, meat is good like it just appears in the grocery store magically, right?
- 42:46But this is what we're living with I know we're living with it
- 42:48But I mean you're you're taking on um
- 42:51You're taking on a it's a very good thing you're taking on but it's a monumental task
- 42:56Because people are so stressed about their immediate vicinity and the things that can touch and feel and smell and taste that
- 43:02It's hard to get people out of their own bubble, right?
- 43:05And that's what you're saying you're doing you're taking you're getting governments out of their own bubble
- 43:08You're getting people out of their own bubble and their immediate surrounding saying listen
- 43:11We're trying to do this for the betterment of humanity and this is why that's a monumental time
- 43:17Well, but it's all that we can do right and a lot of what we're doing is just simply being a resource and engaging and trying to educate and point people in the right direction
- 43:26but ultimately you know
- 43:29people have to change governments have to change if uh if it's Canada and Trudeau has to go and we need new leadership that understands basic fundamental economics and
- 43:39monetary policy and why you need fiscal responsibility to step in but maybe we can be a resource and
- 43:46Effect change that way, but that's what we're trying at least
- 43:50All we can do is try and walk me okay, so like let's use El Salvador as a as a case study
- 43:55Maybe there's other countries
- 43:57That are probably further along than Canada and the US so um what what is a good adoption of Bitcoin and what's the proper terminology to bring Bitcoin into a country?
- 44:08What's the what's the word it verbiage for that?
- 44:11Uh, I just say Bitcoin adoption. It's just keeping it simple. That's fine. Let's do that
- 44:15So what's a country that's doing it properly? How are they doing it walk me through like a case study?
- 44:19Well, I would say El Salvador is the best example we have right now
- 44:22They've made Bitcoin to go tender which means big basically Bitcoin is money
- 44:26And you don't have to deal with capital gains tax on on Bitcoin on money because you know you can't have a
- 44:33Bitcoin acting as money if you have to track every transaction and report cap gains on it, right?
- 44:38And this is part of that part of that greater initiative that we have at JAN3 which is educating people about what money is
- 44:45Why do you have inflation? Why do you have problems? Why is the economy contracting?
- 44:49It's because you're not treating money as money. You're treating it as a tool for various purposes, but definitely not money
- 44:57Um, I mean Canada itself has a new law coming into effect early January which is denying foreign buyers
- 45:06The ability to buy property in Canada, but how do you expect to grow the economy?
- 45:11How do you expect to have more immigration if you're restricting capital inflow into the country?
- 45:17Right, they can't really squeeze blood from a stone
- 45:21And this is why people want tourism why people want investments
- 45:24And I think El Salvador is on the right track because they're saying Bitcoin is money
- 45:29All the diaspora of El Salvador around the world remit money back home money is money
- 45:36Um, people should invest in El Salvador come to visit El Salvador for tourism purposes, right?
- 45:42I mean if you
- 45:44Uh, go back to Canada you get the third degree like why are you coming back?
- 45:47And that's if you're a Canadian, but they do that to tourists too like why are you coming to Canada?
- 45:52And this is just a uh, uh, a symptom of uh, uh, uh,
- 45:56misunderstanding of how the world works and how money works, right?
- 46:00And I think this is a relatively recent like I mean like even in Canada's relatively recent like
- 46:06From my understanding previous to COVID like Canada had one of the best
- 46:10immigration and refugee programs in the world um, so I don't think that it was always
- 46:15uh
- 46:16Like closing its borders. I know that for they probably close borders
- 46:20There's a significant period of time more longer than most countries
- 46:24But do you think this is like a you're saying this is like a symptom of like government like Trudeau
- 46:29And this is not going away. I haven't been there any year and a half so
- 46:33Well, I would say it's a symptom of uh, just governments in general like you you're either
- 46:39Using money as money or you're entering into some protection as a mode where you're thinking that you're
- 46:44Protecting what you've got, but you're basically committing yourself to a slow decline, right?
- 46:50If you look at history and the growth of the four Asian tigers, they grew very rapidly
- 46:55In the past few decades and that was because they're welcoming investment capital in right you want to invest because you can
- 47:02You know move your money in easily
- 47:04but with things like capital controls and restriction of funds and
- 47:09even
- 47:10You know cutting people's bank accounts off and making it very difficult to move and transact money
- 47:15That just results in economic still a stalemate and death eventually
- 47:20So the hope is that El Salvador can
- 47:23Re-invigorate this and make people understand
- 47:26But even in Switzerland you have a good example, right? The Swiss love money
- 47:29They want you to bring money to Switzerland by Swiss property put your money into Swiss banks and then they can grow and invest
- 47:36But you know most countries don't see that but I think that we're reaching a
- 47:41Infection point where they are starting to understand this because they're seeing Swiss inflation is pretty flat
- 47:48And then every other country around that's trying to use money as a tool for surveillance and control is suffering
- 47:55Um, and I'm curious about one of the aspects that you mentioned
- 47:59The negative aspects of CBDC which is surveillance, but
- 48:03It's funny, you know, you know
- 48:04This is well as I do like bitcoin
- 48:07Everyone kept saying originally that way way way back it was used for a list
- 48:11It means and it was only used to buy drugs on silk road and now everybody knows that it's probably easier to trace a drug transaction through bitcoin
- 48:18That is through actual cash
- 48:20But to that point then right now you I'm curious about privacy
- 48:24So if you do have a country that adopts bitcoin as legal tender
- 48:28Do you not run into some of the same problems as a CBDC because you can trace everything that anyone's ever bought anywhere
- 48:34Um, yes and no, I mean if you're using bitcoin through lightning it is private right
- 48:38It's a restoration of the cash property to money and I think the
- 48:44The other good thing about some of the our initiatives is that we can educate people that cash is a good thing
- 48:49Right
- 48:50It's a way to ensure democracies can be open and free because you can have the right to protest and assemble and have free speech
- 48:59But if you can cut off the monetary spigot you can stop all of that stuff right if you look at protests around the world
- 49:06There's a few things they try to do in authoritarian regimes which is cut off the internet and trace money like
- 49:13See if people spent money on the subway to get to the protest and then go and find them
- 49:17And make sure that they suffer after the fact and we have that in Canada too if you donate it to the truckers
- 49:22Yeah, we're shutting your account down, right? So
- 49:25This is the problem like you
- 49:27Yeah, cash is very important and
- 49:30It's the key to any semi-functioning democracy that people can have their own money
- 49:36So the separation of money in state is of critical importance if you want freedom
- 49:41Because the tendency is towards less freedom because if as the government becomes more fearful of the populist
- 49:47They want to enforce more and more measures to
- 49:50Prevent any threat to them
- 49:52But that's not in the best interest of a country, right?
- 49:55Like if you look at China they had zero COVID policies and then when people actually started protesting
- 50:00They they gave up those policies right and you can say the same in Canada if if there was no trucker con
- 50:06No freedom convoy or trucker protest would we be opening up right now and it's questionable
- 50:13No, I appreciate that. Okay
- 50:16I want to I want to give you like we went through a ton of great stuff and I appreciate that because like I mentioned before
- 50:22I get a lot of different perspectives on on various but I've never had somebody who is
- 50:27So well versed in Bitcoin to be quite honest. So I really appreciate it
- 50:32No, it's actually been like really educational for me, which I mean it's always a good show
- 50:37any any final thoughts on
- 50:39Last things that are hyper important that I didn't ask that you should teach over to the audience sort of like the floors yours
- 50:47And then I'll make sure that people like know where to reach out to you and connect with you and whatnot
- 50:52Yeah, I think we've covered a wide range of topics. I would just leave it to your audience to
- 50:57Maybe think about what money is and how you can protect yourself
- 51:01There are a lot of Bitcoiners that reach these conclusions on their own
- 51:05Michael sailors won such person he's thinking of
- 51:09The macroeconomic scale at a company level right how do I as a company protect the money I have the cash I have
- 51:18And that's rapidly devaluing
- 51:20He's likening it to an ice cube that's melting
- 51:23So that that was why he implemented the corporate policy and micro strategy to buy Bitcoin and that's been a good mood for them
- 51:30Now people might say you're down because Bitcoin is down
- 51:33But that's if you're thinking of things on a very short time horizon and one of the things that Bitcoin does is it puts your thinking on longer
- 51:41Time scales right most people are not buying Bitcoin for themselves
- 51:45But for their children or future generations like if you can earn if you can mine
- 51:49Fiat currency mine Canadian dollars and mine US dollars. You're okay
- 51:53But what you want is to have a generational wealth that can be passed on right and you want a better future for your children and their children
- 52:03Because nobody wants their children to live in a 1984 type Hellscape where they're monitored constantly
- 52:09Right that's not not a world you want to bring new life into
- 52:12So Bitcoin makes you think on the longer time horizon
- 52:17And it makes you understand a lot more of the world in the context of how money works because we've lost the largely forgotten
- 52:24What money is and we've taken it for granted amazing if people want to
- 52:29You should you have a book have you written a book or no? No, it's on my two-three list
- 52:34Okay, it sounds like you've written a book, but okay, so if people want to reach out to you learn more about what you're working on
- 52:41What's the best place for them to connect with you?
- 52:43I'm pretty active on Twitter. So my handle is excelion EXCE L I O N and that's basically it and one day I will write a book
- 52:52Okay, very good. I asked this question to everyone to close it out
- 52:56So after your entire career
- 52:59Multiple successes of built various companies and you're not familiar yourself
- 53:04Um, what does success look like for you at the end of the day?
- 53:07Well, I think success should just be happiness. You should be happy with where you are in life and what you have
- 53:12I think understanding Bitcoin simplifies a lot of that because you understand you know very material things
- 53:20Status symbols and not really meaningful in the end and you should just be happy with the people around you and what you're doing in life
- 53:28That to me is a success