Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the Fed's Interest on Reserves Adds to the National Debt
Transcript
- Lucas: The Federal Reserve's main policy tool – the interest it pays on bank reserves – is quietly adding tens of billions to the national debt each year, and most people have never heard of it. Luna: Wait – the Fed pays interest on reserves. I thought that was just a way to control the federal funds rate. How does that end up in the debt picture? Lucas: It's a direct channel. The Fed earns income from its securities portfolio – mostly Treasuries and mortgage bonds – but it also pays interest on the reserves banks hold at the Fed. Right now the interest on reserve balances, or IORB, is at 3.65 percent. Luna: And banks are holding a lot of reserves. I think the total is something like three and a half trillion dollars. Lucas: Over three trillion, yes. So do the math: three trillion times three-point-six-five percent is about a hundred and ten billion dollars a year that the Fed has to pay out to banks. That money comes out of the Fed's earnings before it sends its profits – what's called remittances – to the Treasury. Luna: So when the Fed pays more in interest than it earns from its portfolio, remittances drop, and the Treasury gets less revenue. That effectively widens the deficit. Lucas: Exactly. In 2021, the Fed sent over a hundred billion dollars to the Treasury. In the current fiscal year, remittances are essentially zero – the Fed is actually running an accounting loss. So the government is missing a hundred billion dollar revenue stream that it used to count on. Luna: That's a big chunk of change. The deficit this year is running around one-point-seven-seven trillion, so this is like six percent of that. Lucas: Right, and it's a structural change. Before 2008, the Fed didn't pay interest on reserves – it just didn't have that tool. So for most of the Fed's history, its profits were essentially whatever it earned on its securities, minus operating costs. Now, with a massive balance sheet and interest rates back above 3 percent, the IORB cost is a permanent fixture. Luna: And this is one of those costs that the public doesn't see because it's buried in the Fed's financial statements. But it's real money that the Treasury doesn't get. Lucas: Exactly. And it ties into the broader national debt story. We talk a lot about the Treasury's borrowing costs – the interest on the debt – but the Fed's own interest payments are another layer. In fact, when you add it all up, the government's total interest burden is higher than the official debt service numbers suggest. Luna: So if you're waking up and walking through the economy with us, and this kind of hidden cost makes something click, consider supporting the show. It's what keeps us ad-free and digging into topics like this. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And we really appreciate that. Now, back to IORB – there's a wrinkle: the Fed also pays interest on overnight reverse repo balances, but that facility has shrunk a lot. The main cost is still the reserve balances. Luna: How long does this last? If the Fed cuts rates, the IORB cost goes down. But the balance sheet is still huge – over seven trillion dollars. Lucas: True, but the Fed is slowly shrinking its balance sheet through quantitative tightening. As reserves decline, the IORB cost will fall. But even if rates go back to 2 percent, on three trillion reserves that's still sixty billion a year. It's not going to zero anytime soon. Luna: And there's a weird accounting thing: the Fed actually books its IORB payments as an expense, but because it's a central bank, it can create money to pay. Still, the real resource cost is the interest foregone by the Treasury. Lucas: Right, and some economists have proposed tiered reserve remuneration – paying less on a portion of reserves – to reduce the fiscal drag. But that's politically sensitive because it would be seen as a tax on banks. For now, the Fed hasn't signaled any change. Luna: So here we are: the national debt at 39 trillion, the deficit at 1.77 trillion, and buried inside that is a hundred billion dollar Fed expense that didn't exist fifteen years ago. Lucas: It's a perfect example of how monetary and fiscal policy are intertwined. And as long as the Fed maintains large reserves and positive interest rates, this cost will be a headwind for the Treasury. Not a crisis driver, but a steady drain. Luna: Which is worth understanding if you care about where the national debt is headed. Lucas: Exactly. The IORB is just one piece, but it's a piece that's going to be with us for a while.