Latest / I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin / Kathleen Folbigg exonerated after 20 years: Quentin McDermott Pt.2
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: The public has had a long held fascination with detectives.
- 0:05Speaker 1: Detective sy aside of life the average person is never
- 0:08Speaker 1: exposed to. I spent thirty four years as a cop.
- 0:11Speaker 1: For twenty five of those years I was catching killers.
- 0:14Speaker 1: That's what I did for a living. I was a
- 0:16Speaker 1: homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead,
- 0:20Speaker 1: I'm taking the public into the world in which I operated.
- 0:23Speaker 1: The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories
- 0:26Speaker 1: from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw
- 0:28Speaker 1: and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some
- 0:31Speaker 1: of the content and language might be confronting. That's because
- 0:34Speaker 1: no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged.
- 0:38Speaker 1: Join me now as I take you into this world.
- 0:46Speaker 1: This is Part two of my chat with Quintin McDermott.
- 0:49Speaker 1: Quentin is the author of a book called Meadows Law,
- 0:52Speaker 1: which is about the death of Kathleen Folbig's four children, Calib, Patrick, Sarah,
- 0:57Speaker 1: and Laura. In Part one, spoke about Kathleen's conviction for
- 1:01Speaker 1: the manslaughter of Calib and the murders of the other
- 1:04Speaker 1: three children. In Part two, we talk about the fight
- 1:07Speaker 1: that led to Kathleen being released from prison and her pardon.
- 1:11Speaker 1: I think you'll be shocked by what you learn about
- 1:13Speaker 1: one of the most controversial criminal cases in Australian history. Quentin,
- 1:19Speaker 1: Welcome back, Thanks Gary, it's good to be here, have
- 1:21Speaker 1: a bit of a break, refreshed our refreshed our brains
- 1:25Speaker 1: on this matter. And yeah, it is complex and I
- 1:30Speaker 1: think it's something that we talk about this case, that's
- 1:33Speaker 1: one of the most controversial, high profile cases we've had
- 1:36Speaker 1: in the country. And I don't think that's overstating that
- 1:39Speaker 1: the stakes were very high and the hopefully lessons are
- 1:43Speaker 1: learned from what occurred and things can be improved. We
- 1:48Speaker 1: left part one and we got in our own inevitable way.
- 1:52Speaker 1: We explained how it got to the point where Kathleen
- 1:55Speaker 1: Fobbick was charged with the murder of four children. The
- 1:59Speaker 1: trial trial rent for seven weeks. It resulved in her
- 2:03Speaker 1: being convicted for murder of the three children, yes, and
- 2:08Speaker 1: manslaughter of the Caleb, the first child. Do you want
- 2:13Speaker 1: to tell us the trial, your view and the trial
- 2:17Speaker 1: that occurred.
- 2:18Speaker 2: Yes, so just very broad brush.
- 2:21Speaker 3: My view of the trial is that the defense was deficient.
- 2:27Speaker 3: To be blunt in one sense, it's very unfair of
- 2:31Speaker 3: me to be saying this because her senior council, Peter Zara,
- 2:34Speaker 3: and indeed junior council have since passed away, and so
- 2:38Speaker 3: I've been in writing this book. I've been unable obviously.
- 2:41Speaker 1: To talk to give them the right.
- 2:44Speaker 3: But one interesting a couple of interesting things about the
- 2:47Speaker 3: trial and the defense I think are the are these
- 2:50Speaker 3: that first of all, there was only one medical expert
- 2:55Speaker 3: witness appearing for the defense, and there were multiple medical
- 2:59Speaker 3: experts appearing for the prosecution. Now, part of this may
- 3:02Speaker 3: have been down to the resources that were available for
- 3:06Speaker 3: the defense. You know, she was being defended by Peter Zara,
- 3:08Speaker 3: who was the senior public defender.
- 3:11Speaker 2: It was legal aid, and.
- 3:12Speaker 3: So obviously their resources were not considerable, and that I
- 3:19Speaker 3: think presented real challenges to the defense prior to the
- 3:22Speaker 3: trial in amassing the evidence they wanted to present. And
- 3:26Speaker 3: then the second thing is that only very recently, when
- 3:29Speaker 3: I was researching the book, did I discover that almost
- 3:33Speaker 3: certainly Peter Zara, her senior council, believed that she was guilty.
- 3:38Speaker 3: Now this was a really remarkable revelation. He had a
- 3:47Speaker 3: kind of private conversation following a law conference seminar with
- 3:53Speaker 3: a clinical psychologist, Char Milerbett's doctor, Char Milibets, where she
- 3:59Speaker 3: said to him, you know, mister Tsara, clearly this was
- 4:03Speaker 3: a horrible miscarriage of justice. I'm paraphrasing, and she said,
- 4:07Speaker 3: you wouldn't think that if you'd read the diaries. So
- 4:10Speaker 3: that's that's, you know, that's that's one remarkable aspect I
- 4:14Speaker 3: think of the trial.
- 4:16Speaker 1: Kathleen didn't give evidence at her trial. My understanding, that's correct. Again,
- 4:22Speaker 1: that's you know, it doesn't surprise. It seems to be
- 4:26Speaker 1: the thought within the legal fraternity. It's very unwise to
- 4:29Speaker 1: put put an accused person in the witness box because
- 4:32Speaker 1: it opens them up to all sorts of cross examination.
- 4:36Speaker 1: Do you think she might have been better served just
- 4:38Speaker 1: and this is you know, two outsiders looking in. Do
- 4:41Speaker 1: you think she might have been better served in hindsight
- 4:43Speaker 1: to explain what the diaries were about? Because in isolation,
- 4:47Speaker 1: a lot of people and you touch on the fact
- 4:49Speaker 1: that even her defense might have drawn some strong inferences
- 4:54Speaker 1: from the diary. Do you think it would have served
- 4:56Speaker 1: a better to get in there and explain what the
- 4:58Speaker 1: diary was all about.
- 5:00Speaker 3: Gary, My sense of it is that in terms of
- 5:03Speaker 3: her psychological state at the time. She was in no
- 5:05Speaker 3: fit state, quite frankly, to give evidence and to be
- 5:08Speaker 3: cross examined by Mark Tdeski, who, and I mean this
- 5:12Speaker 3: in a flattering way if you liked mister Tedesky, I think,
- 5:15Speaker 3: would have kind of torn her apart in the witness box.
- 5:18Speaker 3: And indeed she kind of recognized this herself, I think,
- 5:22Speaker 3: but she also went on later to regret the fact
- 5:25Speaker 3: that she hadn't given evidence. My kind of primary beef,
- 5:29Speaker 3: if you like, with the defense is that they didn't
- 5:32Speaker 3: cast the net wide enough to find psychological and psychiatric
- 5:36Speaker 3: experts who could have given evidence about the diaries and
- 5:40Speaker 3: given an entirely different interpretation to the interpretation given by
- 5:44Speaker 3: the prosecution. So, for example, in one case, in relation
- 5:49Speaker 3: to one diary entry, mister again I'm paraphrasing, but mister
- 5:55Speaker 3: Tedesky essentially said, what could she possibly mean by this
- 5:58Speaker 3: other than I killed children or I killed this child.
- 6:02Speaker 3: Now Never, at any point in any of her diary
- 6:06Speaker 3: entries anywhere did she ever admit to any agency in
- 6:11Speaker 3: killing harming, let alone killing any of the children. She
- 6:15Speaker 3: never admitted in her diaries to harming the children physically. Okay,
- 6:21Speaker 3: I think that would have had a big effect on
- 6:23Speaker 3: the jury. And I just don't believe, to be frank
- 6:27Speaker 3: that Peter Zara hit back hard enough on this, and
- 6:30Speaker 3: I think that one of the reasons for that, as
- 6:31Speaker 3: I say, is because deep down they actually believed that
- 6:36Speaker 3: the diaries were damning.
- 6:37Speaker 1: Okay, it makes for a complex situation, doesn't And we're
- 6:42Speaker 1: talking in the very matter of fact way. But the
- 6:44Speaker 1: trauma associated when I've said about Kathleen going into the
- 6:48Speaker 1: witness box, she's lost four children. Regardless of how that's happened,
- 6:54Speaker 1: there's trauma associated with that. I don't care who you are.
- 6:57Speaker 1: She's been charged with a charged with murdering the four children.
- 7:00Speaker 1: Looking at I think the media were doing their job.
- 7:04Speaker 1: The worst female serial killer and the camera, everything that
- 7:08Speaker 1: goes into play play there. So the stakes were very high.
- 7:12Speaker 1: The trial went for seven weeks, she was convicted. I
- 7:17Speaker 1: think she was sentenced to initially forty years thirty years
- 7:22Speaker 1: on the bottom. They appealed the sentencing and I think
- 7:25Speaker 1: it was reduced to thirty years twenty five years on
- 7:27Speaker 1: the bottom. That was where we're at. Can you take
- 7:30Speaker 1: up the case from there, because for all intents and purposes,
- 7:34Speaker 1: that could have been the last that we heard of Kathleen.
- 7:38Speaker 1: She would stay in jail, But that's so far from
- 7:40Speaker 1: the case. What were the things that started to turn
- 7:44Speaker 1: it round where people believed believed her innocence and people
- 7:47Speaker 1: started fighting for the justice.
- 7:50Speaker 3: Can I just preface if I may, sorry, there is
- 7:53Speaker 3: one other aspect of the trial that needs to be mentioned,
- 7:56Speaker 3: which is indeed the forensic evidence. So the forends evidence
- 8:00Speaker 3: in the trial, essentially to cut it, to cut it
- 8:03Speaker 3: to its most basic element, was that you can smother
- 8:08Speaker 3: an infant without leaving any physical trace. And kind of bizarrely,
- 8:14Speaker 3: in my opinion, and this all relates to Meadows law,
- 8:17Speaker 3: that if there is no physical trace of smothering, which
- 8:20Speaker 3: there wasn't certainly no definite traces of physical smothering in
- 8:24Speaker 3: any of the four cases, that is of itself or
- 8:27Speaker 3: of any other means of killing them, that is, of
- 8:31Speaker 3: itself evidence that they were smothered. Now to me, that
- 8:36Speaker 3: is almost Kafkai esque, but that essentially was what happened
- 8:39Speaker 3: in the trial.
- 8:39Speaker 1: So just try and paraphrase that that if there's no
- 8:44Speaker 1: evidence of the child Moon smothered, that could be evidence
- 8:47Speaker 1: of the fact that the child was smothered because there
- 8:49Speaker 1: is no physical evidence of the child.
- 8:51Speaker 3: Well, I suppose there are two parts to it. Is
- 8:53Speaker 3: there any evidence that they were killed by any other means?
- 8:56Speaker 3: The answer is no. Is there a substantial evidence or
- 9:03Speaker 3: that you know or is the likelihood of four children
- 9:06Speaker 3: dying financial causes so unlikely that they must have been murdered. Well,
- 9:10Speaker 3: if there is that, then they must have been smothered.
- 9:14Speaker 3: And what adds to this argument, if you like, is
- 9:18Speaker 3: the fact that infants can be smothered without leaving any
- 9:21Speaker 3: physical traits, and therefore she smothered them. Now, Mark Tadesky
- 9:25Speaker 3: at the trial gave various kind of scenarios as to
- 9:28Speaker 3: why she might have or how she might why she
- 9:31Speaker 3: might have smothered them. One of them was that she
- 9:34Speaker 3: might have smothered each of them in turn. She might
- 9:37Speaker 3: have suffocated each of them in turn in order to
- 9:40Speaker 3: get them to go to sleep, okay, as opposed to
- 9:44Speaker 3: killing them in a rage. That was another alternative scenario,
- 9:46Speaker 3: that she flew into a rage on each occasion and
- 9:50Speaker 3: she smothered them. And I think, I mean they knew
- 9:53Speaker 3: about a case in the United States there of a
- 9:56Speaker 3: babysitter who would use this suff vocation technique, allegedly in
- 10:02Speaker 3: hundreds of cases where she was babysitting children and she
- 10:05Speaker 3: would smother, she would suffocate them, you know, temporarily to
- 10:08Speaker 3: put them to sleep. And then most unfortunately, she had
- 10:12Speaker 3: actually killed a couple of children, and she confessed to
- 10:15Speaker 3: this and was charged, And so that was one scenario.
- 10:18Speaker 3: But again it's the whole basis for this was that
- 10:22Speaker 3: you can smother an infant without leaving any physical evidence,
- 10:25Speaker 3: and therefore that the means by which she killed them
- 10:28Speaker 3: must have been smothering. Now, in the case of Laura,
- 10:31Speaker 3: that was in fact highly unlikely because once a child
- 10:36Speaker 3: of Laura's age is attacked in this way, they are
- 10:41Speaker 3: going to struggle, and they have teeth, and the teeth
- 10:43Speaker 3: are going to leave marks, almost certainly on the inside
- 10:46Speaker 3: of the mouth. And in Laura's case, at her autopsy,
- 10:49Speaker 3: doctor Carla found no evidence of this. He found no
- 10:51Speaker 3: evidence that she had been smothered or that there were
- 10:54Speaker 3: teeth marks inside her mouth indicating a struggle. So really
- 11:00Speaker 3: the active evidence, if you like, for smothering was non existent,
- 11:06Speaker 3: so that in effect reversed the burden of proof to
- 11:10Speaker 3: make it incumbent on the defense to prove that they
- 11:14Speaker 3: had died from natural causes.
- 11:16Speaker 1: Yeah, okay, once she was convicted, who were the people
- 11:19Speaker 1: that still believed in Kathy, Like you had had people
- 11:23Speaker 1: campaigning on the outside. Who were the people of significant
- 11:26Speaker 1: people that were fighting to get this weather overturned.
- 11:30Speaker 3: Well, it was essentially her closest friends. I mean, you know,
- 11:34Speaker 3: I think one, I can't imagine how hard it must
- 11:38Speaker 3: have been for Kathy at the trial, because you know,
- 11:42Speaker 3: her own foster mother was kind of sitting with Craig
- 11:46Speaker 3: Folbig's family. Craig himself had turned against her. He was
- 11:51Speaker 3: an absolutely key witness for the prosecution, and I would
- 11:54Speaker 3: surmise that his evidence was crucial in the jury reaching
- 11:59Speaker 3: the Verden. They did so her own husband and they
- 12:03Speaker 3: were still married at the time of the trial. So
- 12:06Speaker 3: Craig had turned against her, and really the only person
- 12:10Speaker 3: she had on her side was this Salvation Army major
- 12:14Speaker 3: who Joyce Harmer, who was amazing, and Joyce's husband, Hilton,
- 12:21Speaker 3: who took care of her during the trial, and I
- 12:23Speaker 3: think shielded her from the worst of the media. But
- 12:26Speaker 3: so she was kind of bereft and then for various reasons,
- 12:29Speaker 3: certainly her two closest friends were unable to attend the trial,
- 12:33Speaker 3: and so she was literally on her own apart from
- 12:36Speaker 3: Joyce Harmer's support. And then after the trial, really it
- 12:40Speaker 3: was Tracy Chapman and Meghan Donoghan and you know, one
- 12:44Speaker 3: or two other close friends who were kind of there
- 12:47Speaker 3: to support her.
- 12:48Speaker 2: There was an.
- 12:49Speaker 3: Initial appeal, where as you mentioned, her sentence was cut
- 12:54Speaker 3: from forty years to thirty years with a twenty five
- 12:57Speaker 3: year kind of minimum period in prison, which incidentally would
- 13:02Speaker 3: have meant that she would not even if she was
- 13:04Speaker 3: granted parole, she would not be granted parole for another
- 13:07Speaker 3: three years from now until twenty twenty eight. But then
- 13:10Speaker 3: after that there was a second appeal. What happened was
- 13:14Speaker 3: it was discovered that during the trial, a member of
- 13:17Speaker 3: the jury, well let me go back to the beginning.
- 13:19Speaker 3: During the trial, this infamous or famous line she wrote.
- 13:26Speaker 3: Obviously I am my father's daughter was ruled in admissible,
- 13:30Speaker 3: but when Craig was giving evidence, whether intentionally or unintentionally,
- 13:35Speaker 3: he dropped into his evidence the fact that he had
- 13:40Speaker 3: read this line in her diary. It was a kind
- 13:43Speaker 3: of egregious, you know, flouting of the ruling of it inadmissibility.
- 13:49Speaker 1: And that worthing of what she said, I am my
- 13:53Speaker 1: father's daughter. It looks like I'm my father's daughter. Forget
- 13:56Speaker 1: the exact words, given the fact that her father had
- 13:59Speaker 1: murdered her mother, and the inference being fairly strong and
- 14:03Speaker 1: probity against against her in that.
- 14:07Speaker 3: Regard, exactly well it was it was It was deemed
- 14:10Speaker 3: by I mean Petersarrap quite rightly put forward the argument
- 14:13Speaker 3: that it was enormously prejudicial to for the jury to
- 14:16Speaker 3: be told about this line that she had written, because
- 14:19Speaker 3: they would automatically assume that what she was, as you say,
- 14:22Speaker 3: what she was referring to was the fact that her
- 14:25Speaker 3: her father had murdered her mother. But as I say,
- 14:29Speaker 3: it was ruled in admissible, and then Craig Folbig mentioned
- 14:32Speaker 3: it in his evidence, and then they came down with
- 14:36Speaker 3: the guilty verdict. And then after the trial, after she
- 14:40Speaker 3: she had been convicted, of course, the media went wild.
- 14:44Speaker 3: They were finally allowed to report this line that she
- 14:47Speaker 3: had written in her diary, and and and the media
- 14:50Speaker 3: I think universally interpreted the line she had written as
- 14:56Speaker 3: being a kind of an admission that she had killed
- 14:59Speaker 3: her children. She of course, later gave a very different
- 15:03Speaker 3: explanation for why she'd written it. She said, Look, all
- 15:06Speaker 3: I was saying there essentially was, you know, my dad
- 15:09Speaker 3: was a loser, and you know my life has kind
- 15:12Speaker 3: of gone to shit basically, and you know I've turned
- 15:15Speaker 3: out to be a loser as well. You know, that
- 15:17Speaker 3: was her explanation for it. But for the second appeal,
- 15:22Speaker 3: this was one of the grounds of appeal that that
- 15:25Speaker 3: that there'd been a clear breach of the rules by
- 15:29Speaker 3: a member of the jury and therefore essentially that there
- 15:33Speaker 3: should be a retrial. And I think what was interesting,
- 15:36Speaker 3: what I found interesting was that the appeal the Crown
- 15:39Speaker 3: argued that you know, when this information went back into
- 15:44Speaker 3: the jury room, it would have elicited sympathy from the
- 15:47Speaker 3: other members of the jury.
- 15:48Speaker 2: Now I personally find that absurd.
- 15:51Speaker 1: Look, we're talking hypothetically if that's what happened, but I
- 15:54Speaker 1: don't think I'm not picturing the jury room going sympathy.
- 15:57Speaker 1: I'm thinking, ah, right, we've cracked the.
- 15:59Speaker 3: Case exactly so, and so I find that to be
- 16:03Speaker 3: frank an extraordinary decision of the Appeal Court, the Court
- 16:08Speaker 3: Criminal Appeal.
- 16:09Speaker 1: How did it get to the point where they were inquiries?
- 16:13Speaker 3: Okay, so I'll kind of flash forward, if you like.
- 16:16Speaker 3: In twenty and eleven, Emma Cunliffe, who is Australian, a
- 16:23Speaker 3: legal academic, she's now a professor, but who had moved
- 16:26Speaker 3: to Canada. She started looking at this case. She was
- 16:30Speaker 3: actually I think looking at the case of Linda Chamberlain
- 16:33Speaker 3: at the time, but as she describes it, she realized
- 16:38Speaker 3: when she started researching Lindy's case, in Kathleen's case, that
- 16:43Speaker 3: there were all these other mothers in the UK in particular,
- 16:47Speaker 3: who had been convicted on largely on the basis of
- 16:52Speaker 3: Meadows law or to a great extent on the basis
- 16:55Speaker 3: of Meadow's law, but who had since been acquitted, and
- 16:57Speaker 3: the only mother who had not been acquitted or on
- 17:02Speaker 3: appeal was Kathy. Okay, So she started looking at the case,
- 17:06Speaker 3: and she's quite clear in conceding that she started off
- 17:11Speaker 3: with the view that Kathleen Folbey had.
- 17:14Speaker 2: You know, was guilty.
- 17:16Speaker 3: And she also is very clear in saying that when
- 17:18Speaker 3: she started reading her diaries she was very troubled by them.
- 17:22Speaker 1: Yeah. I found that found that very interesting because that
- 17:25Speaker 1: was her initial reading the diaries. She saw something sinister there,
- 17:31Speaker 1: but then she changed the view on it.
- 17:34Speaker 3: Yes, that's right, and I think that I think I
- 17:37Speaker 3: think a lot of people have, probably including myself, I
- 17:39Speaker 3: have gone through that kind of process of reading some
- 17:42Speaker 3: of the entries in the diaries, you know. The most
- 17:45Speaker 3: famous one of which is apart from my father's daughter,
- 17:47Speaker 3: is probably the one where she says that Sarah, you know,
- 17:51Speaker 3: left with a bit of help, with a bit of help,
- 17:53Speaker 3: and you think, oh my god, what is she saying here?
- 17:56Speaker 1: Now.
- 17:56Speaker 3: Her explanation for that has always been, and can persistently
- 18:00Speaker 3: actually since the very earliest days, has always been that
- 18:03Speaker 3: what she meant by that was that she left with
- 18:05Speaker 3: some kind of divine or you know, supernatural help. It's
- 18:09Speaker 3: a kind of semi religious kind of idea that she
- 18:12Speaker 3: was taken from me by God or however you want
- 18:15Speaker 3: to express it, or.
- 18:15Speaker 2: A higher power. But Emma, in.
- 18:23Speaker 3: You know, not uniquely was very troubled by that, and
- 18:26Speaker 3: I think may will have thought that she was guilty.
- 18:29Speaker 3: But the more she looked into the case, and in
- 18:30Speaker 3: particular the more she deconstructed the trial itself, the more
- 18:34Speaker 3: convinced she became that Kathleen was innocent. And so she
- 18:38Speaker 3: wrote this book, which was a kind of seminal book
- 18:41Speaker 3: really about the case which was published in twenty eleven Murder,
- 18:45Speaker 3: Medicine and Motherhood that was read by, amongst other people,
- 18:51Speaker 3: a close friend of Kathy's, Helen Cummings in Newcastle, and.
- 18:57Speaker 2: She approached.
- 19:00Speaker 3: Isabel Reid who who is a barrister in Newcastle. Isabelle
- 19:05Speaker 3: read then got other lawyers involved, and so round about
- 19:10Speaker 3: that time twenty eleven twenty twelve, lawyers in Newcastle and
- 19:13Speaker 3: indeed the University of Newcastle's Legal Center got involved, did
- 19:18Speaker 3: a lot more research the Legal Center into the case
- 19:21Speaker 3: and the transcripts and everything else. And eventually in twenty
- 19:27Speaker 3: fifteen a petition was put together and it was sent
- 19:33Speaker 3: to the then Attorney General of New South Wales, gabrielle Upton,
- 19:41Speaker 3: you know, calling for a judicial inquiry into her case. Now,
- 19:45Speaker 3: one of the key aspects of that petition, in my opinion,
- 19:49Speaker 3: the most crucial aspect of it, the most crucial element
- 19:51Speaker 3: of it was an enormous report which was written by
- 19:56Speaker 3: the esteemed forensic pathologists, Professor Stephen Cordner, and he'd spent
- 20:00Speaker 3: over a year reviewing the forensic evidence in the case,
- 20:06Speaker 3: and his very clear conclusion was that there were natural
- 20:09Speaker 3: cause of death for all four children, and there was
- 20:11Speaker 3: no evidence whatsoever that she had been smothered, and not
- 20:15Speaker 3: only that, there was actually robust evidence that Laura had
- 20:19Speaker 3: not been smothered because she didn't have any injuries exactly exactly.
- 20:27Speaker 3: So this was presented in I think it was may
- 20:30Speaker 3: Or June twenty fifteen, to the then Governor of New
- 20:34Speaker 3: South Wales, and then passed on to the Attorney General,
- 20:37Speaker 3: gabrielle Upton, and then Mark Speakman, her successor as Attorney General,
- 20:44Speaker 3: came on board. And then following on from that, in
- 20:49Speaker 3: twenty seventeen, I became involved in well, I should in fairness,
- 20:53Speaker 3: I should add that after Emma Cunliffe's book was published,
- 20:58Speaker 3: sixty Minutes did a store about her case, and they
- 21:01Speaker 3: interviewed Emma Cunliffe, and you know, bravoed sixty Minutes, who
- 21:07Speaker 3: actually followed the case right the way through pretty much
- 21:10Speaker 3: to the very end, and consistently argued that there were
- 21:14Speaker 3: reasons to doubt her guilt. So they did that. But
- 21:19Speaker 3: then in twenty eighteen I was working at Australian Story
- 21:24Speaker 3: and I produced a story, an episode, a long longer
- 21:29Speaker 3: than usual episode for Australian Story about Kathy's case, and
- 21:33Speaker 3: one of the things I guess there were two important
- 21:36Speaker 3: elements of that story. One of them was that I decided,
- 21:42Speaker 3: after reading as much of the evidence as I could,
- 21:45Speaker 3: that there was a clear conflict between what Professor Cordener
- 21:49Speaker 3: had said, which was that there was no forensic evidence
- 21:52Speaker 3: to suggest that they'd been murdered, and what doctor Alan
- 21:55Speaker 3: Carla had said, which was supporting the view that awful
- 22:00Speaker 3: children had indeed been smothered. And I was able entirely
- 22:07Speaker 3: independent forensic pathologist called Dr Matthew ord who incidentally was
- 22:12Speaker 3: based in Canada along along with Emma Cunliffe, was suggested
- 22:17Speaker 3: to us as someone to approach, and I approached him
- 22:19Speaker 3: and I said, look, would you be prepared to do
- 22:21Speaker 3: two things to kind of review Stephen Cordner's report, And
- 22:26Speaker 3: he doctor ord had nothing whatsoever to do with the
- 22:28Speaker 3: case prior to that, which I thought was a good thing.
- 22:31Speaker 3: And secondly, if we can arrange for the slides of
- 22:37Speaker 3: Laura's heart tissue to be delivered to you, will you
- 22:40Speaker 3: examine them and kind of tell us what you think?
- 22:44Speaker 3: And I didn't know what his conclusions would be. He
- 22:46Speaker 3: might have he might have said he agreed to do this.
- 22:49Speaker 3: But he might have said, look, I don't agree with
- 22:52Speaker 3: Professor Cordner's report, and I think that the myo choditis
- 22:57Speaker 3: that Laura was suffering from that I agree with Carla
- 23:00Speaker 3: that it was only patche and mild. He might have
- 23:02Speaker 3: said that. In the event, he said that broadly, he
- 23:06Speaker 3: agreed with everything Professor Corden had written in his report,
- 23:10Speaker 3: and he thought that there was a very clear case
- 23:12Speaker 3: of my arcaditis which could have caused Laura's death. The
- 23:15Speaker 3: phrase he used at one point he qualified it. He
- 23:18Speaker 3: said that didn't that didn't prevent the possibility that she
- 23:22Speaker 3: might have killed Laura. But he said that in his opinion,
- 23:25Speaker 3: this was, to quote, an eminently fatal case of my acaditis.
- 23:31Speaker 3: Now I was kind of, at one level stunned by this,
- 23:35Speaker 3: because I thought, well, my god, you know, if this
- 23:39Speaker 3: entirely independent forensic pathologist is saying this is an eminently
- 23:42Speaker 3: fatal case of my arcaditis, why was she ever convicted?
- 23:46Speaker 3: And after he said this, I came back and I
- 23:48Speaker 3: spoke to I interviewed Nicholas Cowdrey, who was, of course
- 23:53Speaker 3: the Director of Public Prosecutions when Kathleen was put on trial,
- 23:58Speaker 3: and interestingly, he said a couple of things in relation
- 24:01Speaker 3: to the pigs might fly quote he said, well, you know,
- 24:04Speaker 3: that's not what I would that's not how I would
- 24:05Speaker 3: have presented it. But in relation to this, he said, well,
- 24:11Speaker 3: you know, even if this went to the Quarter of
- 24:13Speaker 3: Criminal Appeal and she was found not guilty, she was
- 24:16Speaker 3: acquitted of her conviction of murdering Laura, that wouldn't necessarily
- 24:22Speaker 3: mean that the other convictions couldn't stand. And I found
- 24:27Speaker 3: that absurd. I'm sorry as well, because it was the
- 24:30Speaker 3: coincidence evidence that helped drink and case. So so we
- 24:36Speaker 3: then put this story to air in August twenty eighteen,
- 24:43Speaker 3: and I.
- 24:44Speaker 2: Think it's interesting.
- 24:45Speaker 3: You know, I'm sure you've found this Gary in life
- 24:48Speaker 3: as well as in investigations and so on. Timing is everything,
- 24:53Speaker 3: so you know, I pay tribute, as I say, to
- 24:56Speaker 3: sixty minutes, and there were one or two other great
- 24:59Speaker 3: journalists who had written articles and so on prior to
- 25:02Speaker 3: twenty eighteen, saying you know, there are questions need to
- 25:05Speaker 3: be raised about this case, but I think the timing
- 25:07Speaker 3: of this was critical of our Australian story and one
- 25:12Speaker 3: of the other things that Nicholas Cowdrey said on camera
- 25:16Speaker 3: was he said that he believed that the delay in
- 25:19Speaker 3: deciding on the petition, which by then was more than
- 25:22Speaker 3: three years, was an inordinate delay, some exceptional. And nine
- 25:27Speaker 3: days later Mark Speakman got up and said, okay, we're
- 25:33Speaker 3: going to have an inquiry into her convictions. And it's
- 25:36Speaker 3: interesting that the key point that he said the inquiry
- 25:40Speaker 3: would consider was this whole question of whether there had
- 25:47Speaker 3: ever been other cases of three or more deaths of
- 25:50Speaker 3: infants in a family, you know, from natural causes. And
- 25:55Speaker 3: all of the medical experts who gave evidence at her trial,
- 25:59Speaker 3: at Cathy's trial, had said they'd never heard of a
- 26:01Speaker 3: case like that, and then you know, Mark Tdeski himself
- 26:06Speaker 3: had kind of emphasized that by saying pigs might fly,
- 26:10Speaker 3: and so the jury it became very, very apparent. And
- 26:14Speaker 3: Emma Cunliffe pointed this out in her book that there
- 26:16Speaker 3: were of course other cases where three or more children
- 26:19Speaker 3: had died from natural causes, and so this was one
- 26:21Speaker 3: of the one of the one of the points that
- 26:23Speaker 3: we raised on Australian Story, and it was one of
- 26:26Speaker 3: the one of the probably the key point that Mark
- 26:31Speaker 3: Speakman raised and announcing this first inquiry.
- 26:35Speaker 1: Had taken that information into the jury room and that
- 26:38Speaker 1: that's what they've been presented with. It's when when you
- 26:43Speaker 1: break it down, it's still complicated, but at the time
- 26:45Speaker 1: I can just imagine all these things coming into play.
- 26:50Speaker 1: The inquiry was an inquiry was ordered, so there was
- 26:54Speaker 1: I think there was two inquiries. Wasn't it that there
- 26:56Speaker 1: were too?
- 26:57Speaker 2: There were two inquiries?
- 26:58Speaker 3: And can I just mention one other credit cool thing
- 27:00Speaker 3: about the petition. Apart from Professor Cordner's extensive and exhaustive report,
- 27:07Speaker 3: there was also a report by a British mathematician, Professor
- 27:10Speaker 3: Ray Hill, who had given evidence, as it happens at
- 27:15Speaker 3: or presented evidence to Sally Clark's successful appeal. And for
- 27:21Speaker 3: me this was a kind of epiphany. And essentially what
- 27:24Speaker 3: he said was that you know, while the chances of
- 27:28Speaker 3: four children in a family dying from natural causes made
- 27:34Speaker 3: you know it's a rare event, the chances of all
- 27:36Speaker 3: four children being killed is much rarer. And he actually
- 27:41Speaker 3: produced some statistics. He said that his own rough estimates,
- 27:46Speaker 3: which he had published in a paper, was that single
- 27:50Speaker 3: cot deaths outweigh single infant murders by seventeen to one.
- 27:56Speaker 3: Double cot deaths outweigh double infant murders by about nine
- 28:00Speaker 3: to one, and triple cot death that way, triple murders
- 28:05Speaker 3: by about two to one. So you know, the whole
- 28:09Speaker 3: basis really for the kind of for meadows law and
- 28:12Speaker 3: for the prejudice. If you like that I have three
- 28:15Speaker 3: or more children die in a family, it has to
- 28:17Speaker 3: be homicide. Was based on a faulty statistical assumption.
- 28:22Speaker 1: The statistical analysis could be flipped to work against it exactly.
- 28:27Speaker 1: So basically explains that it's with all the experts that
- 28:31Speaker 1: you get in and you mentioned mentioned earlier, and I
- 28:35Speaker 1: just want to read it out when we talk talk
- 28:37Speaker 1: about confirmation bias from from your book, an extract from
- 28:41Speaker 1: from your book, Doctor Cunliffe has made the made this
- 28:45Speaker 1: comment on the basis of doctor Carla's evidence. And I
- 28:49Speaker 1: recall when you said information was passed on, passed on
- 28:53Speaker 1: to another expert when you were doing the research, and
- 28:55Speaker 1: you were very careful not to provide too much information.
- 28:58Speaker 1: I just read this out there. They'll open up some
- 29:01Speaker 1: discussion there. Doctor Cunliffe made this assessment. Cognitive science, she explained,
- 29:06Speaker 1: shows that when someone believes that there is a likely
- 29:08Speaker 1: explanation of a phenomenon that they are observing, they are
- 29:12Speaker 1: more likely than evidence that supports that conclusion and less
- 29:16Speaker 1: likely to notice evidence that can test their conclusion. That
- 29:21Speaker 1: is what leads to the definition of confirmation bias. I've
- 29:23Speaker 1: always had, and I'm talking in a general sense here,
- 29:27Speaker 1: issues and concerns when it might be the prosecutor. We
- 29:32Speaker 1: go to an expert, an independent expert, because they're a
- 29:35Speaker 1: medical person or a scientist or whatever, and they can
- 29:39Speaker 1: be totally objective. But we say, we've got all this information,
- 29:42Speaker 1: can you test this and provide this information and give
- 29:46Speaker 1: us a report back. I think there's contamination time and
- 29:49Speaker 1: time again when experts are providing providing their expert expert
- 29:56Speaker 1: opinion based on what information have provided to them. Okay,
- 30:02Speaker 1: the first inquiry always evidence that we've explained and contained
- 30:07Speaker 1: in your book, the overwhelming evidence that you would think
- 30:09Speaker 1: would carry carry some favor at the inquiry, which was
- 30:13Speaker 1: headed up by Justice Blanche I believe that's right, but
- 30:18Speaker 1: that was rejected.
- 30:20Speaker 3: Yes, so, look, it was a very in some ways.
- 30:23Speaker 3: A lot of the evidence presented at the inquiry was
- 30:25Speaker 3: extremely complex. You know, the neurological evidence and other evidence.
- 30:31Speaker 3: But I supposed to cut to the chase the first
- 30:37Speaker 3: inquiry that there were several kind of important hearings that
- 30:41Speaker 3: took place. One of them was indeed, with four I
- 30:44Speaker 3: think it was forensic pathologists, including doctor Carla and including
- 30:48Speaker 3: Professor Cordner, where broadly speaking, the forensic pathologists all agreed
- 30:55Speaker 3: that yes, there were plausible or possible natural cause of
- 30:59Speaker 3: death for all four children. But Gail Finesse, who was
- 31:04Speaker 3: the senior council assisting the inquiry, asked them, you know,
- 31:09Speaker 3: you know, is it possible that these children, despite the
- 31:14Speaker 3: fact that they may have died from natural course, is
- 31:15Speaker 3: it possible that these children were smothered? And of course
- 31:18Speaker 3: each of them had to say, well, yes, it's conceivable.
- 31:21Speaker 3: So that was one part of the evidence. And then
- 31:26Speaker 3: a second part of the evidence was this extraordinary kind
- 31:29Speaker 3: of revelation that there was fresh genetic evidence demonstrating that
- 31:38Speaker 3: Kathleen Folbig and her two daughters, Sarah and Laura, were
- 31:42Speaker 3: all suffering from a cardiac genetic mutation, which, in the
- 31:49Speaker 3: view of the leading geneticists who uncovered this was potentially
- 31:55Speaker 3: faithal okay, that it was likely pathogenic. Now that there
- 31:59Speaker 3: was an enormous argument. Essentially, at the inquiry about this,
- 32:03Speaker 3: there were there were kind of clinicians on the other
- 32:06Speaker 3: side who were deeply skeptical about this, But the geneticis
- 32:15Speaker 3: the immunogeneticist, Professor Corolla of INUSA, who made this discovery,
- 32:22Speaker 3: was equally clear that in her opinion, this you know,
- 32:27Speaker 3: raised reasonable doubt about you know, her convictions, and that
- 32:31Speaker 3: maybe they had maybe this genetic mutation had indeed triggered
- 32:35Speaker 3: the deaths of Sarah and Laura. And the basis on
- 32:39Speaker 3: the theory that she was putting forward, essentially, if I
- 32:41Speaker 3: can kind of put it crudely, is that both Sarah,
- 32:46Speaker 3: who had an infection before she died, and Laura, who
- 32:50Speaker 3: had my arcaditis, that this triggered this genetic mutation which
- 32:54Speaker 3: essentially causes arrhythmias in the heart and can be fatal.
- 32:59Speaker 3: But at that stage, at the first inquiry, it was
- 33:02Speaker 3: still at a very theoretical point.
- 33:05Speaker 1: Because this is science. The genetic science is something that's
- 33:09Speaker 1: evolved after the conviction.
- 33:11Speaker 2: Of Cafe totally, that's right.
- 33:14Speaker 1: So this is new science. This is new science.
- 33:16Speaker 3: It couldn't have been carried out in you know, genetic
- 33:18Speaker 3: science was in its infancy. Essentially in two thousand and three,
- 33:21Speaker 3: those tests could not have been carried out in two
- 33:23Speaker 3: thousand and three. It was only you know, fifteen years
- 33:27Speaker 3: later that they that they could be carried out. And
- 33:30Speaker 3: it was a remarkable scientific feat actually to enable those
- 33:36Speaker 3: tests to be carried out on the heel prick cards and.
- 33:39Speaker 1: Other just explained that the hill prick cards what when
- 33:43Speaker 1: children are born, a blood sample is taken from the child,
- 33:48Speaker 1: and that's what they relied.
- 33:49Speaker 3: Upon, exactly certain. Yeah, that's right. So it was a
- 33:53Speaker 3: remarkable feat. They established that Kathy, as I say, had
- 33:58Speaker 3: this genetic mutation, carried it past it onto.
- 34:00Speaker 2: Her two girls.
- 34:01Speaker 3: Craigfoldbig and most unfortunately refused to give a DNA sample
- 34:07Speaker 3: which could have aided the scientists considerably, and he refused
- 34:11Speaker 3: to do this. But be that as it may, so
- 34:15Speaker 3: that there was this fresh genetic evidence which pointed to
- 34:19Speaker 3: the possibility, at least the possibility that two of the
- 34:23Speaker 3: children had died from this genetic cause. And then the
- 34:28Speaker 3: next element in the first inquiry, which was highly significant,
- 34:33Speaker 3: was Kathy agreeing to give evidence herself about the diary
- 34:37Speaker 3: entries she had written and what they meant.
- 34:40Speaker 1: And that's what we talked about that before. She didn't
- 34:42Speaker 1: give evidence to the troll about that, so this is
- 34:45Speaker 1: the inquiry. She said, yes, I'll.
- 34:47Speaker 3: Do that, that's right. And she had actually talked about
- 34:50Speaker 3: some of the diary entries on the Australian story. So,
- 34:54Speaker 3: you know, because we had recorded conversations that she had
- 34:58Speaker 3: from prison with Tracy Chapman, her best friend, and we'd
- 35:02Speaker 3: recorded them with Kathy's agreement and with Tracy's agreement.
- 35:05Speaker 1: I'm glad you clarified that in light of what ended. Vikery.
- 35:08Speaker 1: Thank you very much, girl. We know all about that. Well.
- 35:12Speaker 3: I mean, can I just say I think, you know,
- 35:16Speaker 3: I think it was actually quite in some ways courageous
- 35:19Speaker 3: of Kathy to do this, because I mean I think
- 35:21Speaker 3: she could have been kind of severely punished for doing so,
- 35:24Speaker 3: you know, talking to the media from behind prison walls
- 35:27Speaker 3: probably not universally approved. But be that as it may,
- 35:32Speaker 3: that was a kind of friendly discussion that she had
- 35:35Speaker 3: with Tracy. A series of conversations actually, because as you know,
- 35:38Speaker 3: obviously each conversation is cut off after six minutes, so
- 35:41Speaker 3: a series of at least fifteen conversations in which during
- 35:45Speaker 3: which she explained what she meant by some of these
- 35:48Speaker 3: diary entries. So that was a kind of friendly exchange,
- 35:50Speaker 3: friendly explanation. And then fast forward to twenty nineteen when
- 35:55Speaker 3: she agreed for the first time to give evidence in
- 35:58Speaker 3: a court about her diaries.
- 36:02Speaker 1: And.
- 36:03Speaker 3: I can only describe what happened as you know, brutal.
- 36:07Speaker 3: Actually what you know, this was supposed to be an
- 36:09Speaker 3: inquiry where where I think all of her friends and
- 36:12Speaker 3: supporters and probably her legal team assumed that she would
- 36:16Speaker 3: be asked in an entirely neutral way to explain what
- 36:22Speaker 3: she meant by many of her diary entries. What in
- 36:25Speaker 3: fact happened was that she was cross examined in really
- 36:31Speaker 3: ferocious fashion by two senior counsel at three if you
- 36:37Speaker 3: include Gailpiness, who was less ferocious, over two and a
- 36:41Speaker 3: half days. And she was challenged sixty nine or seventy
- 36:47Speaker 3: times during this cross examination to admit that she had
- 36:53Speaker 3: killed one or more of the children, and every single
- 36:56Speaker 3: time she denied it. So, you know, one absolutely fundamental
- 37:00Speaker 3: point here is that Kathleen Folbig, you know, has never
- 37:04Speaker 3: once intimated, let alone admitted that she has harmed any
- 37:11Speaker 3: of her children. And you know, again you you will
- 37:15Speaker 3: know better than I do gary in many cases where
- 37:19Speaker 3: people profess their innocence of murder charges and then and
- 37:23Speaker 3: then they're convicted and they go to prison, you know,
- 37:25Speaker 3: they finally fess up and they say, you know, have
- 37:29Speaker 3: a lot.
- 37:29Speaker 1: In there that's still maintain They.
- 37:30Speaker 3: Know, well that's true too. But but anyway, so that
- 37:33Speaker 3: was the thurd main.
- 37:35Speaker 1: Just on on that, On that point, with the rigorous
- 37:38Speaker 1: cross examination, there can be a counter argument there that
- 37:42Speaker 1: if someone is tested strenuously and they stand up to
- 37:46Speaker 1: that test, that might be more revealing than if the
- 37:49Speaker 1: questions weren't us Is that reasonable to suggest?
- 37:53Speaker 3: So, I think that's fair, and I'm not suggesting for
- 37:55Speaker 3: a moment they should have been you know, it should
- 37:57Speaker 3: have been a kind of cuddly, warm exchange.
- 38:00Speaker 2: You know.
- 38:01Speaker 3: Of course she should have been challenged about some of
- 38:05Speaker 3: the more contentious entries she wrote in har Daries, and
- 38:08Speaker 3: some of the more some of the entries which to
- 38:10Speaker 3: many remain to this day troubling. Of course, she should
- 38:13Speaker 3: have been challenged about that. But my point is that
- 38:16Speaker 3: it was relentless. Now interestingly, one of the psychologists who
- 38:21Speaker 3: gave evidence of the Second Inquiry said, use the word
- 38:23Speaker 3: brutal about was his that was his assessment of the
- 38:28Speaker 3: cross examination which had taken place, and in my opinion,
- 38:34Speaker 3: it acted almost as a substitute for what didn't happen
- 38:38Speaker 3: during the trial.
- 38:39Speaker 1: Yeah, I saw that in the book that Okay, well,
- 38:44Speaker 1: now we've got an opportunity.
- 38:45Speaker 3: Now we've got her on the stand, We're going to
- 38:46Speaker 3: nail her.
- 38:47Speaker 1: There seems to be and I was going to talk
- 38:50Speaker 1: about this later, but there seems to be that real
- 38:52Speaker 1: division between the legal fraternity and the medical science fraternity
- 38:57Speaker 1: at Loggerheads about this whole case. It seemed to be
- 39:00Speaker 1: people in different camps. Is am I reading it right? That?
- 39:03Speaker 3: Yes, I think that is right, And I've written about
- 39:05Speaker 3: that prior to the book, And that's certainly a major
- 39:08Speaker 3: theme of the book, is that it ended up being
- 39:10Speaker 3: science versus the law. Now, that is, of course, in
- 39:13Speaker 3: one sense, a kind of crude summary, because there were
- 39:17Speaker 3: there were some scientists who kind of didn't believe the
- 39:21Speaker 3: fresh genetic evidence should carry as much weight as in
- 39:24Speaker 3: the end it did. But what happened after the first
- 39:28Speaker 3: what happened at the end of the first inquiry A
- 39:29Speaker 3: couple of interesting things. First of all, there was an
- 39:33Speaker 3: expert overseas a world expert in cardiology and genetics, called
- 39:39Speaker 3: professor Peter Schwartz, who wrote to the inquiry. Once he
- 39:43Speaker 3: heard about the case and the evidence, the genetic evidence,
- 39:45Speaker 3: he wrote the inquiry and essentially said, you know, I
- 39:49Speaker 3: can't make a judgment about this, but I think this
- 39:52Speaker 3: calls her convictions into question, and essentially called for further
- 39:57Speaker 3: hearings to investigate the genetics ants further. That didn't happen,
- 40:02Speaker 3: so the commissioner, Reginald Blanche, handed down his report and
- 40:08Speaker 3: dealt with the fresh genetic evidence in an appendix. It
- 40:11Speaker 3: wasn't even part of the Essentially, it wasn't even part
- 40:14Speaker 3: of the main report, which I think a lot of
- 40:16Speaker 3: people found quite troubling, and given that this was supposed
- 40:19Speaker 3: to be an inquiry, not a trial. And he said
- 40:23Speaker 3: his judgment was that the evidence that he had heard
- 40:26Speaker 3: reinforced Kathleen's guilt. I mean it was to many that
- 40:32Speaker 3: was an astonishing I I.
- 40:35Speaker 1: Know that there was a lot of people that took, yeah,
- 40:39Speaker 1: took that quite confronting that that was a fine needs
- 40:42Speaker 1: from that inquiry.
- 40:44Speaker 3: Well, I think a lot of people who were kind
- 40:46Speaker 3: of on her side, if you like, found that quite shattering. Actually,
- 40:49Speaker 3: they just could not believe that he'd said this. He
- 40:52Speaker 3: also said in his report, incidentally, that it was plausible
- 40:56Speaker 3: that each of the children might have died from natural causes,
- 40:59Speaker 3: But he said that given that the lies, as he
- 41:04Speaker 3: described it, this was his personal interpretation of the evidence
- 41:07Speaker 3: she had given in person lies and obfiscation, that the
- 41:12Speaker 3: evidence he had heard reinforced her guilt. And he said
- 41:17Speaker 3: and that the only means possible by which they might
- 41:20Speaker 3: have been killed was by smothering, and that there was
- 41:24Speaker 3: no other person who might have done that. Now, again
- 41:29Speaker 3: I found personally that shocking, because there was another person
- 41:34Speaker 3: who could have killed the children.
- 41:35Speaker 2: Craig and the.
- 41:39Speaker 3: Transcript of the secretly recorded conversation in which he laid
- 41:43Speaker 3: out in detail how he could have killed the children
- 41:45Speaker 3: and his motive for doing so was suppressed by the
- 41:48Speaker 3: first inquiry. It wasn't it wasn't allowed into evidence.
- 41:51Speaker 1: It's confusing, isn't it? And I say that, but I'm
- 41:56Speaker 1: saying it genuinely. It's confusing, like the White Court's inquiries
- 42:02Speaker 1: and the evidence that gets presented. So you've had an inquiry,
- 42:08Speaker 1: there's been the petition. Was there any point that people
- 42:13Speaker 1: were going to give up you're involved in it. By
- 42:15Speaker 1: this stage, you've been covering it, you've been reporting on it.
- 42:18Speaker 1: All the people coming in I know there were people
- 42:20Speaker 1: from Newcastle. Newcastle University would contact me about it, and
- 42:25Speaker 1: a friend, Xanthea Mallett, was a criminologist up there and
- 42:31Speaker 1: we're friends, and she would quite often talk to me
- 42:33Speaker 1: about this case. And I began like I would just
- 42:37Speaker 1: push back for the sake of pushing back, but she
- 42:39Speaker 1: was adamant that there's been a miscarriage of miscarriage of justice,
- 42:43Speaker 1: and even to the point when in discussion she'd say, well, okay,
- 42:49Speaker 1: let's say and talking hypothetically here, make sure we clarify
- 42:53Speaker 1: that that she was guilty, there still wasn't sufficient evidence
- 42:59Speaker 1: for that person to be convicted at trial. And that
- 43:03Speaker 1: sort of sat with me. I understood where she was
- 43:05Speaker 1: coming from. There. We're not talking about guilt or innocence here,
- 43:09Speaker 1: we're talking about there wasn't enough evidence for this person
- 43:12Speaker 1: to be convicted convicted at court. So that got me
- 43:16Speaker 1: looking at a little bit further. Then you have done
- 43:18Speaker 1: heading with reading your book, but where to from their
- 43:23Speaker 1: first inquiry? And Blanche came back stronger than anyone would
- 43:26Speaker 1: have anticipated. In his findings after the first inquiry, the
- 43:30Speaker 1: commissioner from that inquiry, So what was the next move?
- 43:33Speaker 3: Yes, and look, you know, he could have come back.
- 43:36Speaker 3: I suppose he could have come back with a finding that,
- 43:41Speaker 3: you know, the fresh genetic evidence was kind of interesting
- 43:45Speaker 3: but hadn't been.
- 43:46Speaker 2: Fully developed or whatever, you know. But he didn't.
- 43:48Speaker 3: As you say, he came back with his own finding
- 43:52Speaker 3: that the evidence he'd had reinforced her guilt. Now at
- 43:57Speaker 3: that point, you're quite right. I think a lot of
- 44:00Speaker 3: the supporters kind of fell in a heap after that.
- 44:04Speaker 3: They just couldn't believe it, and one or two of
- 44:06Speaker 3: them I think kind of gave up.
- 44:08Speaker 2: Essentially.
- 44:11Speaker 3: The one scientist who didn't give up was Professor Vnusa,
- 44:14Speaker 3: And to her eternal credit, I think she helped to
- 44:18Speaker 3: kind of broaden the scope of the inquiries into this
- 44:22Speaker 3: genetic mutation, which ended up with a team of twenty
- 44:27Speaker 3: seven scientists around the world putting together a paper which
- 44:35Speaker 3: essentially which followed on from laboratory experiments which were carried
- 44:40Speaker 3: out in several different countries to examine whether this genetic
- 44:45Speaker 3: mutation was actually pathogenic or not. And again I'm kind
- 44:50Speaker 3: of I'm paraphrasing, but essentially they came to the conclusion
- 44:53Speaker 3: that yes, it was pathogenic and that it likely killed
- 44:59Speaker 3: or triggered day of Sarah and Laura, and they wrote
- 45:02Speaker 3: this up in a peer reviewed paper for a publication
- 45:09Speaker 3: called EuroPace, which is published in Oxford in the UK.
- 45:13Speaker 3: And so based on this that there was then a
- 45:19Speaker 3: move to kerl or invite actually other scientists and science
- 45:24Speaker 3: advocates to endorse a second petition on her behalf, which
- 45:31Speaker 3: they did, and among the scientists who endorsed this petition
- 45:34Speaker 3: after reading the EuroPace paper and considering all the evidence
- 45:37Speaker 3: were two Nobel Laureates, so you know, which I believe
- 45:41Speaker 3: is unique in the whole kind of history of cases
- 45:43Speaker 3: like this around the world putting their name to that
- 45:48Speaker 3: and endorsing it. So that petition was then lodged with
- 45:53Speaker 3: the Governor of New South Wales and with Mark Speakman,
- 45:56Speaker 3: who was still the Attorney channel. At the same time,
- 46:00Speaker 3: Kathy's lawyers had launched an appeal essentially asking for Reginald
- 46:06Speaker 3: Blanche's findings to be quashed from the first inquiry, and
- 46:10Speaker 3: that appeal the hearing took place, and then the judgment
- 46:14Speaker 3: came down very shortly after the second petition had been
- 46:17Speaker 3: lodged and the appeal finding was negative, they refused to
- 46:24Speaker 3: quash the findings, and indeed they essentially agreed the judges
- 46:28Speaker 3: with Reginald Blanche on all the salient points that he
- 46:32Speaker 3: had made. But there was an enormous burst of publicity,
- 46:37Speaker 3: which I go into in the book how it was
- 46:39Speaker 3: organized and so on, surrounding the second petition, and I
- 46:42Speaker 3: think what that did was I think it helped to
- 46:44Speaker 3: move the dial of public opinion about Kathy's guilt or innocence.
- 46:50Speaker 3: So by the time the second petition was lodged, I
- 46:54Speaker 3: think public opinion was moving steadily more in Kathy's favor.
- 47:00Speaker 1: Seeing her up there. It wasn't just a public opinion
- 47:02Speaker 1: that was changing. Cathy's life was changing on the inside too.
- 47:05Speaker 1: That when she was in prison, going in as a
- 47:09Speaker 1: convicted child killer is not a good place to be.
- 47:13Speaker 1: But I found it interesting at that particular point in time,
- 47:17Speaker 1: even her fellow inmates started to look at her a
- 47:20Speaker 1: little bit differently and treated it differently at that stage.
- 47:23Speaker 2: That's right.
- 47:25Speaker 3: Obviously, she was considered to be the lowest of the
- 47:27Speaker 3: low when she was convicted and went into prison, and
- 47:29Speaker 3: I don't think she was able to speak to another inmate,
- 47:32Speaker 3: probably for about a year. Yeah, I mean, I think
- 47:34Speaker 3: it must have been horrific for her, and she thought
- 47:37Speaker 3: the whole time that, you know, she might be poisoned
- 47:39Speaker 3: or whatever. And then I don't think that Emma Cunliff's book,
- 47:44Speaker 3: and this is no disrespect to Emma. Her book was brilliant,
- 47:46Speaker 3: but it's an academic book. I don't think that kind
- 47:48Speaker 3: of shifted the dial.
- 47:50Speaker 2: Particularly.
- 47:50Speaker 3: I think the first sixty minutes, which I believe was
- 47:53Speaker 3: in twenty twelve, may have shifted it slightly. But then
- 47:57Speaker 3: I think the Australian story in twenty eighteen certainly.
- 47:59Speaker 2: Had a beneficial effect.
- 48:00Speaker 3: And it's interesting that when we were filming that we
- 48:05Speaker 3: were filming outside the perimeter of one of the prisons,
- 48:09Speaker 3: and I spoke to a prison guard who was escorting
- 48:13Speaker 3: us around, and I just asked him, you know, what
- 48:16Speaker 3: do you guys think kind of thing? And he said, oh, no,
- 48:18Speaker 3: you know, we all think she was innocent, which is
- 48:21Speaker 3: interesting because it's the old thing of you know, if
- 48:24Speaker 3: anyone knows whether someone's guilty.
- 48:26Speaker 2: Or it's the prison stuff, you know. So that was interesting.
- 48:31Speaker 3: And then and then Finally, when the when the second
- 48:35Speaker 3: petition was lodged and it was you know, endorsed by
- 48:39Speaker 3: two Nobel laureates, I think that really, you know, she
- 48:41Speaker 3: then began to be treated much much better inside and
- 48:46Speaker 3: to kind of enjoy the support of other inmates, which
- 48:48Speaker 3: of course must have been a gigantic kind of weight
- 48:51Speaker 3: off her shoulders. So then Mark Speakman did not come
- 48:59Speaker 3: down with his decision on the second petition for another year.
- 49:04Speaker 3: And what was happening here, and this relates to science
- 49:07Speaker 3: versus the law, if you like, What was happening here
- 49:10Speaker 3: was that the Australian Academy of Science had become involved,
- 49:14Speaker 3: and there was there was something called Team Folbig, which
- 49:17Speaker 3: was a kind of team of businessmen and philanthropists and
- 49:21Speaker 3: others who had become very involved in behind the scenes
- 49:25Speaker 3: in her case and in kind of pushing the science forward,
- 49:28Speaker 3: and the Australian Academy of Science, their former president John Shine,
- 49:33Speaker 3: Professor Shine spoke out very strongly and repeatedly saying, you know,
- 49:41Speaker 3: the evidence is in essentially scientifically, the evidence is in
- 49:45Speaker 3: that there is a genetic cause for the deaths of
- 49:49Speaker 3: two of the children. You know, why don't you referring
- 49:52Speaker 3: to Mark speakman, why don't you recognize that please and
- 49:56Speaker 3: pardon and release her? Because the request in the second
- 49:59Speaker 3: petition was for Kathleen to be pardoned and released, and
- 50:03Speaker 3: at any point from then on the Attorney General could
- 50:08Speaker 3: have made the decision. He had the power to do that.
- 50:10Speaker 3: He had the power to recommend to the Governor of
- 50:13Speaker 3: New South Wales that Kathy be pardoned and released, and
- 50:16Speaker 3: he didn't do so. But eventually, about thirteen months later,
- 50:20Speaker 3: he announced that there would be a second inquiry.
- 50:24Speaker 1: This is such a complex case what we're talking about
- 50:27Speaker 1: here with Kathy's situation. I can see people are defending
- 50:31Speaker 1: their position, or people are doing their job with the
- 50:34Speaker 1: viga that the same vigor that the prosecutors. I make
- 50:36Speaker 1: this observation in the book, the same vigor in which
- 50:39Speaker 1: the people involved in the prosecution of Kathy demonstrated was
- 50:43Speaker 1: also demonstrated by the people that were fighting for her freedom.
- 50:47Speaker 3: So that's absolutely right, and you know, is it right?
- 50:52Speaker 3: Let me ask you this question, Gary, is it right
- 50:56Speaker 3: that Kathy was eventually pardoned and least only after you know,
- 51:02Speaker 3: members of her legal team had worked thousands of hours
- 51:05Speaker 3: pro bono, money had been raised kind of to help
- 51:09Speaker 3: her defense by you know, philanthropists and senior businessman and
- 51:14Speaker 3: you know, scientists like Professor Vuisa had given up hundreds
- 51:18Speaker 3: and hundreds of hours of their own unpaid in order
- 51:22Speaker 3: to further the science that eventually helped to release her.
- 51:25Speaker 3: Is it right that that you know that those factors
- 51:29Speaker 3: came into play because without those factors, without that help,
- 51:32Speaker 3: almost certainly she we would not be having this conversation.
- 51:35Speaker 1: And there were so many times when she could have
- 51:38Speaker 1: been left left there and that that's the end of
- 51:40Speaker 1: the Kafi Folby story. But yeah, there's a disproportion that
- 51:44Speaker 1: what you're saying there, and the resources of viable to
- 51:47Speaker 1: someone taking on the power of the state is always disproportioned.
- 51:51Speaker 1: We need we need to have a situation that that's
- 51:54Speaker 1: protected as best at best at Kenby. But you're quite
- 51:58Speaker 1: right without that that important. I know the people I
- 52:01Speaker 1: was speaking to, how passionate they were about Yeah, it
- 52:04Speaker 1: was a wrongful conviction and we wouldn't have got to
- 52:08Speaker 1: that point that these people didn't continue on the actual
- 52:13Speaker 1: the process in which she was granted. So last where
- 52:16Speaker 1: we were talking about it was back with Mark's speakman. Yes,
- 52:21Speaker 1: second inquiry.
- 52:22Speaker 3: That's right, Mark speakman overall, and again I don't question
- 52:26Speaker 3: his integrity and he's emphasized repeatedly that he had to
- 52:30Speaker 3: take detailed legal advice on both partitions. Was the paperwork
- 52:38Speaker 3: was voluminous and so on. But I have to say
- 52:41Speaker 3: this overall, taking into account both petitions, it took four
- 52:45Speaker 3: years or for him to call those two inquiries. Anyway,
- 52:51Speaker 3: the inquiry was called. And then at the inquiry itself
- 52:56Speaker 3: there were two kind of fresh elements I suppose. One
- 52:59Speaker 3: was that there was the evidence given in particular by
- 53:02Speaker 3: two Danish scientists who had conducted further research into the
- 53:07Speaker 3: genetic mutation and found it to be pathogenic, and their
- 53:12Speaker 3: very clear view was that the genetic mutation had triggered
- 53:15Speaker 3: the deaths of Sarah and Laura. And then the next
- 53:19Speaker 3: and highly significant part of the fresh evidence was the
- 53:22Speaker 3: expert opinions of as you've said earlier.
- 53:25Speaker 2: Of nine or ten.
- 53:28Speaker 3: Psychologists, expert expert psychologists and psychiatrists, all of whom agreed
- 53:34Speaker 3: that the entries she had written in her diaries were
- 53:39Speaker 3: not incriminatory. They were not admissions of guilt in the
- 53:44Speaker 3: agency of their deaths. They were not admissions of guilt
- 53:48Speaker 3: and having killed her children.
- 53:49Speaker 2: They were, you know, the.
- 53:50Speaker 3: Diaries were suffused with expressions of the personal guilt that
- 53:55Speaker 3: any mother would feel, and the distress and the depression
- 53:59Speaker 3: following the deaths of her children, but they were not
- 54:02Speaker 3: in any way, shape or form admissions of guilt. And interestingly,
- 54:06Speaker 3: right at the end of the second inquiry, the DPP
- 54:10Speaker 3: essentially kind of threw in the towel and agreed that
- 54:14Speaker 3: there was indeed reasonable doubt at that point now surrounding
- 54:19Speaker 3: her convictions. So there was the fresh genetic evidence, there
- 54:24Speaker 3: was the fresh evidence about the diaries, and in the end,
- 54:27Speaker 3: Sophie Callen, who was the council assisting Tom Bathurst, who
- 54:33Speaker 3: was the former Chief Justice in charge of it, they
- 54:37Speaker 3: both agreed that there was reasonable doubt. There were some
- 54:41Speaker 3: scientists who were resisting this, but I think all but
- 54:44Speaker 3: one said that there was a reasonable possibility that this
- 54:48Speaker 3: genetic mutation could have killed Sarah and Laura. And so
- 54:51Speaker 3: in the end, really the new Attorney General decided on
- 55:01Speaker 3: the recommendation of Tom Bathurst to pardon and release Kathleen,
- 55:07Speaker 3: and that happened in June twenty twenty three, and then
- 55:10Speaker 3: six months later in December following handing down his report,
- 55:17Speaker 3: her case went to the Court of Criminal Appeal where
- 55:19Speaker 3: she was acquitted formally acquitted of all five charges.
- 55:24Speaker 1: So breaking breaking the pardon day, and that was, as
- 55:29Speaker 1: the word would employ, she's being pardoned. She was released,
- 55:31Speaker 1: but the acquittal followed on from the Court of Criminal Appeal,
- 55:35Speaker 1: so saying that the convictions no longer fellid.
- 55:38Speaker 3: Yes, And the acquittal was crucial, of course, because even
- 55:42Speaker 3: after she was pardoned and released, Craig Folbig was saying
- 55:46Speaker 3: that he still believed that she was guilty, and indeed,
- 55:50Speaker 3: even after her acquittal. Sadly and unfortunately, so many potential
- 55:54Speaker 3: witnesses had died in the meantime, and indeed, last year,
- 55:59Speaker 3: following on from the Craig Folbig tragically died himself. So
- 56:04Speaker 3: a retrial was never on the cards and it would
- 56:06Speaker 3: have been frankly absurd to suggest that. But the acquittal
- 56:10Speaker 3: was absolutely key because it wasn't just a case of
- 56:13Speaker 3: her being pardoned for what she had done and released.
- 56:17Speaker 3: It wasn't just the criminal justice system saying, okay, you've
- 56:20Speaker 3: kind of served your time, you've suffered enough, will release you.
- 56:24Speaker 3: It was critical because under the eyes of the law
- 56:27Speaker 3: now in the eyes of the law. She is now
- 56:28Speaker 3: an innocent woman. She has been acquitted of all the charges.
- 56:32Speaker 1: It's significant, an amazing, amazing story, complex story that really
- 56:38Speaker 1: calls in the question so many different aspects of our
- 56:42Speaker 1: justice system. How is she now? Do you have any
- 56:46Speaker 1: contact with her since she's moved.
- 56:48Speaker 3: Yes, so, Gary, I've met her a couple of times.
- 56:51Speaker 3: There was on the day of her acquittal, there was
- 56:54Speaker 3: a special lunch put on kind of team Folbig for her,
- 56:57Speaker 3: and of course she was, you know, very happy that
- 57:02Speaker 3: the result that legal result. But I don't think, you know,
- 57:04Speaker 3: there's no getting away from the fact that her loss
- 57:07Speaker 3: has been terrible and the trauma that she suffered has
- 57:10Speaker 3: been appalling over the years, and it's lasted for decades.
- 57:14Speaker 2: And so.
- 57:16Speaker 3: Is she okay, I'm you know, yes, she's I mean,
- 57:19Speaker 3: I'm in touch with her kind of from time to time.
- 57:22Speaker 3: She has a very close circle of friends who were
- 57:25Speaker 3: there to support her every day, and so, you know,
- 57:29Speaker 3: I'm very optimistic that she'll be okay. But I mean,
- 57:33Speaker 3: as I say, there's no getting away from the tragedy
- 57:36Speaker 3: of this case. There's no getting away from the fact
- 57:38Speaker 3: that the broader Folbig family as well as her you know,
- 57:44Speaker 3: lost for children, and that that tragedy may be kind
- 57:50Speaker 3: of softened by time, but it certainly doesn't leave us all.
- 57:55Speaker 1: No, it's a heavy, heavy story. I want to thank
- 57:58Speaker 1: you for coming on coming Nine Catch Killers. I've found
- 58:02Speaker 1: it fascinating. I'm not going to thank you for dragging
- 58:04Speaker 1: me back into a world that I've left. I was
- 58:07Speaker 1: sitting there reading your book with my homicide hat on,
- 58:11Speaker 1: just going okay this, trying to making notes. I just
- 58:14Speaker 1: found it fascinating, and I just want to say everyone
- 58:17Speaker 1: involved in this case, it was a difficult case around
- 58:20Speaker 1: you look at and I'm not just talking from the prosecution,
- 58:23Speaker 1: from the defense. There were so many complexities in there
- 58:26Speaker 1: and subtle little things that you had to look at
- 58:29Speaker 1: that I could imagine. It's yeah, broken a lot of people.
- 58:34Speaker 1: Your book must have taken you a lot of time
- 58:37Speaker 1: to prepare, but it certainly details the nuances of what
- 58:42Speaker 1: happened with this matter. It's given me a greater understanding
- 58:45Speaker 1: of what's happened with this case. So when I do
- 58:47Speaker 1: offer an opinion, now I can offer it with some
- 58:50Speaker 1: informed opinion other than just taking nah it must be
- 58:53Speaker 1: gildysh was convicted.
- 58:55Speaker 2: Well you don't. Gary.
- 58:56Speaker 3: Even now after writing the book, the first question that
- 58:59Speaker 3: almost everyone ask me is did she do it? And
- 59:02Speaker 3: so my recommendation to all of those people is go
- 59:04Speaker 3: out and buy the book and get it. But look,
- 59:07Speaker 3: thank you for inviting me on. And I found it
- 59:12Speaker 3: too to be a really fascinating exchange of views, So
- 59:15Speaker 3: thank you, thank you.
- 59:17Speaker 1: Jeez,