Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E032: New Year Narratives: AI & ETFs with Matt Dines
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:09Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:12management platform built on multi institution custody,
- 0:16leveraging our partnerships with industry veterans Bit Go and
- 0:19Coincover on ramps. Multi Institution Custody is a
- 0:23segregated vault requiring two of three institutions at any
- 0:26point in time to sign once a client's unique permissions have
- 0:30been met. Our industry leading best in
- 0:32class approach to custody helps individuals and institutions
- 0:36secure new and existing Bitcoin positions.
- 0:39All keys are held in deep cold storage and kept 100% offline.
- 0:44Managed with institutional grade security best practices.
- 0:48The custody solution eliminates single points of failure and
- 0:52reduces counterparty risks, ensuring maximum security and
- 0:55Peace of Mind. Onramp's suite of products
- 0:58includes our custody offering, a spot Bitcoin fund, private
- 1:01wealth services and inheritance planning, and managed wealth for
- 1:04advisors. Whether you're new to Bitcoin or
- 1:07a veteran in the space, we would love to connect with you.
- 1:10To understand your needs and how we can serve you, please visit
- 1:13ourwebsite@onrampbitcoin.com or you can schedule a consultation
- 1:17and connect directly with our team.
- 1:19What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:23we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 1:28ever assembled in the history of darkness?
- 1:321974. 198792972000 and whatever we want to call this.
- 1:38It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:40We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell I.
- 1:52Say when we sell, welcome back to the last trade, 1st 2024,
- 1:56We're recording on Thursday, January 4th, 2024.
- 2:01We're joined by Matt Dines from Build Asset Management.
- 2:06With that being said, we're going to have a new format to
- 2:08the show, a little more structure.
- 2:11What do you guys think about a little bit more structure?
- 2:13Is that good? 2024 new new year, new US.
- 2:19New year, New pod. It's not the last, last, last
- 2:23trade. This is it was the last trade of
- 2:24the year. I think we might have confused
- 2:25some individuals in the last year.
- 2:28This is the TLT to be bullish on.
- 2:32Oh Matt coming in and providing the pod with a meme to start the
- 2:37year. This is the TLT you want
- 2:39exposure to. Matt, if you go to tltbtc.com it
- 2:43will redirect you to our our the last trade.
- 2:48That's awesome. Great donate, great domain.
- 2:51With that being said, we new structure of the show is where
- 2:54to come prepared with a few topics to discuss before we get
- 2:59into the main topic. The main topic of the day sure
- 3:03won't be surprising. What would be the ETF approval
- 3:07or further delay is imminent within the next 5 to 8 days I
- 3:13believe. So a lot of people are waiting
- 3:15with bated breath to see what the SEC does.
- 3:18But before we jump into the ETF, we're going to start with the
- 3:22topic of AI and its impact on the broader economy.
- 3:27Obviously, 2023 was the year of AI proliferation.
- 3:32I believe it was October or November of 2022 when ChatGPT
- 3:37launched and essentially provided the the economy with
- 3:41the first consumer app in the artificial intelligence world
- 3:45that that reached mainstream success 2023.
- 3:50Throughout the year we had an explosion of people using the
- 3:53products, people creating companies around artificial
- 3:56intelligence and companies trying to determine whether or
- 3:59not they should implement it or more likely how they're going to
- 4:02implement it into their stack. And then I think a really
- 4:06important topic that's on top of everybody's mind as it pertains
- 4:09to artificial intelligence is its effect on the broader
- 4:12economy, particularly the jobs market.
- 4:15So let's just start with the huge excitement within Tech
- 4:20Chart Logan. And this is pretty this is a
- 4:22pretty astonishing chart, especially when you compare it
- 4:25to the iPhone and the Apple App Store on the iPhone, which is
- 4:31was considered to be probably the the biggest tech innovation
- 4:34and disruptor of the 1st 20 years of this century.
- 4:39And if you look at this chart, you can see that AI using Hacker
- 4:44News trends is exploding above the iPhone levels that hit in 28
- 4:50twenty 08/20/09. Now we must say obviously 2023.
- 4:54There's probably a lot more people on Hacker News, but still
- 4:56this chart is a bit bit astonishing.
- 4:59So Jesse, I'll throw it to you. What are your high level
- 5:02thoughts on AI as a trend? What happened in 2023 and what
- 5:07we can expect in 2024? Yeah, it's it's such a huge
- 5:12topic. I, you know when when AI finally
- 5:18came out, you know, with products that that people can
- 5:23use to implement into into their daily work and their businesses
- 5:28ChatGPT, my instinct was, OK, this is going to be like a
- 5:34classic Gartner tech hype cycle progression where for people who
- 5:41aren't familiar with that, that's the idea that when
- 5:44something is brand new, there's a ton of hype about it and then
- 5:48the hype can't live up to where the actual development of that
- 5:51tech is. And so you enter this like this
- 5:55lull, the the through of disillusionment where it it
- 5:58feels like the IT never delivered that that technology
- 6:02just never materialized as as something real that mattered.
- 6:05But meanwhile real progress is being made with making that
- 6:10technology better and and integrating it into the economy.
- 6:15And then eventually the impact of that technology is greater
- 6:18than the original hype expectation was in the 1st
- 6:22place. But but you go through that
- 6:23through and so that's what happens with every technology.
- 6:27And so you know for the last year I've been assuming that's
- 6:30what will happen with with consumer grade AI here and I
- 6:37still think that that's probably happening.
- 6:39But I have to admit that I think it was maybe it's just like that
- 6:46that this version of AI is is so immediately useful to anybody
- 6:52doing, doing a job that it has impacted productivity already to
- 7:00a degree that that I didn't think would be possible within a
- 7:05year. And I still have, I still have
- 7:07some doubts and I'm very curious to get Matt's thoughts on this
- 7:10about how much of the the sort of stock market rally is
- 7:16actually because of like productivity and the economy
- 7:19doing well versus liquidity. And you know having to print
- 7:24more more debt which the US has been doing in the last nine
- 7:29months in particular and which which ends up adding liquidity
- 7:33to to markets and things rally as a result.
- 7:36So I'm not really sure what's what's happening here, but I
- 7:39have to admit that that AI has been having a greater impact and
- 7:45we've been seeing it at on ramp. I mean it.
- 7:47There are AI tools that we use on a day-to-day basis to help us
- 7:52be more efficient and I'm sure that's happening at in every
- 7:55company right now. Yeah, man.
- 7:59I know you and what you guys are doing at BUILD is really finance
- 8:04focus, credit credit market focus.
- 8:06What what are your thoughts on this?
- 8:08Have you been dabbling with it at all?
- 8:10Is it something outside your purview?
- 8:13So for using the tools themselves directly, I mean it's
- 8:17a. It's a huge assist for you know,
- 8:20I'd say that second step in writing, you know Marty as a
- 8:22writer yourself, you know, cranking out content every day,
- 8:26you know the the way I approach it is the first step is, you
- 8:29know have your outline, but then the next step is just kind of
- 8:32filling in the body, you know, so putting the meat onto the
- 8:35onto the skeleton if you will. And I think just from from that
- 8:39element it like it's it's massive for you know people
- 8:42sitting in my seat where a big portion of our job is just to
- 8:46communicate externally. So it's it's a huge help there.
- 8:50But I think you know to to talk about the the rally over 2023,
- 8:56right you know coming out of 2022, you know if you remember Q
- 9:01end of Q3 there was you know we we Marcus kind of ran into the
- 9:05global constraint of how fast rates could rise and eventually
- 9:11you found out who the weakest link was.
- 9:12Well, it turns out it was AUK pension system and and that's
- 9:16where we really had the, the, the first liquidity driven
- 9:21rally. I would say as Bank of England
- 9:24stepped in with you know what we call maybe like a not QEQE if
- 9:29you will, just a a couple couple weeks of you know just patching
- 9:33up the system offering to you know not go fully ahead with the
- 9:40QT plans. You know give them 3/4 weeks
- 9:43delay for these pensions to to move around money and get their
- 9:48get their, you know they they had to sell something in their
- 9:51books. But a lot of these instruments
- 9:52they were selling you know private credit stuff like that
- 9:54that's a liquid that doesn't have a bid.
- 9:56You get that moved and reshuffle, shuffle the shares
- 9:59and you know that that created a a rally where the the pressure
- 10:03in dollar markets ease you know FXDXY after that massive run up
- 10:08in 2022 just kind of the pressure let out and at the same
- 10:11time you saw energy markets roll over you know for the first like
- 10:16the first time and they did it again recently same thing the
- 10:20September of that Q with the Q3 and you saw it again this year
- 10:25but but last year was I'd say the big one and that really
- 10:28created the the rally going. You know as energy comes down
- 10:32you know dollar a lot of the the capital and the global dollar
- 10:36financial system is actually deployed into these you know
- 10:40shipping containers. You know fill up a a tanker with
- 10:43you know crude or you know something like that like it
- 10:45takes a lot of dollar capital as as you know all of those vessels
- 10:49are in transit globally. So as oil.
- 10:52You know really sold off and the dollar pressure ease those two
- 10:55things created. You know that first run of
- 10:57liquidity and then last year if you're thinking about you know
- 11:00these first three days in the year of trading that we're in
- 11:02now last year as opposed to you know this year we got out of the
- 11:06gate where kind of equities are stumbling a little bit.
- 11:10Last year it was the exact opposite.
- 11:12It was just a really strong rally you know to start the year
- 11:15and then from there it was just kind of just momentum kind of
- 11:19gathering throughout the year. You had that that first
- 11:22liquidity squeeze in March that you know came in with the with
- 11:27the you know the the banking issues.
- 11:30But once this kind of the financial system realized that
- 11:32was not the actual you know credit crisis if you will that
- 11:37would mark the bottom tick of a of a dollar credit cycle.
- 11:41It was just kind of again full steam ahead liquidity driven
- 11:44rally. So I think these two things were
- 11:46playing into each other. You know to go back to the the
- 11:48question the AI was or is you know if you think about like the
- 11:54bleeding edge of tech in the economy, it's always the leader.
- 11:57You know like whether it's the railroad era in the late 1800s
- 12:01or autos in the early 1900s radio and 1930 to you know PCs
- 12:08in in the semiconductor in the 80s, nineties etcetera too.
- 12:11You know the bleeding edge right now is it looks like from a
- 12:15technology standpoint it's AI at this point.
- 12:19So those two things like the the dollar credit system and then
- 12:21you know the real deal, these tools are you know, real.
- 12:26They are going to impact productivity in the economy.
- 12:28They're going to have a massive downstream impact.
- 12:30But I'd say it's it's both of these things, you know, playing,
- 12:34playing off of each other right now.
- 12:36Yeah. Totally, Michael.
- 12:40Yeah. I think Marty, you've been
- 12:41playing around a lot of these tools and I think you've kind of
- 12:43fallen or seen in the camp of like how transformative this
- 12:46stuff will be or can be. And I had this like unlock the
- 12:50other day that. So the that chart we'll put in
- 12:53the show notes, it came from Benedict Evans, I think it was a
- 12:56former partner at A16Z, but he puts out a year in review and I
- 12:59think this one was solely focused on AI.
- 13:02And I think what he referenced is last year it was a lot of
- 13:07like what AI can do. So it was like basically
- 13:09describing or prescribing like, oh, you can do it for, you know,
- 13:13management, consulting tasks like various tasks that you saw
- 13:15in the market This year it was like, oh, shit, like this thing
- 13:18is much bigger. It was what are the questions?
- 13:21And this core question that he put was, is it the next platform
- 13:25shift, similar to like AWS coming from mainframes or like
- 13:28the iPhone? And when you got an iPhone, you,
- 13:30you grabbed it and you didn't really know everything you could
- 13:32do, but it was transformative and it took out like, you know,
- 13:35your flashlight and all these other things.
- 13:36And then years later you start having Uber with geolocation and
- 13:40the other things associated with it.
- 13:41And we still probably don't know all the things that it will be
- 13:43able to do or does it change into the nature of software and
- 13:47like how you interact with it when it comes to coding and the
- 13:49you know things you talk you hear about and how they start to
- 13:53like Daisy chain together and and you really being able to
- 13:55just dream up ideas. But then the last part is like
- 14:00does it take us to AGI And it's like this idea of what does that
- 14:03mean. And and the funny part is I've
- 14:05like looked into this and and I could be wrong but most people
- 14:08don't actually know how this stuff works.
- 14:10Like from the neural networks and the large language models
- 14:12like as the weights start getting calibrated and more data
- 14:15coming through they don't actually know how far it can go.
- 14:18And the the long of it is, is like as I started looking it's
- 14:21like Oh my God, this actually it will change everything and it
- 14:24will change everything in the same way that Bitcoin will
- 14:26change everything and they actually will find a symbiosis
- 14:30with each other because they have to.
- 14:33If you think about like when things change the incumbents a
- 14:37usually don't adopt it because there for fundamental business
- 14:42models. So the it's generally net new
- 14:44entrants that come in. And so when you have that you
- 14:47basically are going to have net new people coming in And if it's
- 14:50AI you're going to need business models around it that accept a
- 14:54borderless or permissionless form of money.
- 14:57Because if it's a weird model that's happening and you don't
- 15:00want it to be used, you're like well I'm not going to let you
- 15:02use your ACH or Visa or whatever it is in the same way.
- 15:07So like the the core idea is like it will naturally grow with
- 15:10each other and I guess where this ties into Bitcoin is a
- 15:13you'll need Bitcoin to pay for it.
- 15:14But then also thinking about like the model when we think
- 15:17about multi institution custody or these other primitives where
- 15:20they're Bitcoin native, they're generally are antithetical to
- 15:23the financial system as it's exists because of like the
- 15:27centralization of assets and how you want to hold custody and
- 15:30then you know build products around it.
- 15:33And it's a similar thing where you know these models that are
- 15:35primitive to Bitcoin will generally be built by net new
- 15:39entrants not the incumbents because it's so fundamentally
- 15:42transformative or disruptive to their to their existing
- 15:46businesses. So I don't know if that like
- 15:48fully crossed, but it's like this idea that both sides are so
- 15:51big and transformative that it will be new entrants that
- 15:54majority it's an over generalization, but 90% come
- 15:57from new business models and you you know looking at what existed
- 16:00but then building it at a more efficient better rate than
- 16:03somebody adopting it and then plugging it into their system.
- 16:08Yeah, I think one thing he said there in particular is very high
- 16:14signal, which is most people really don't understand how
- 16:16these large language models work in the 1st place.
- 16:20And actually, Alex Fetsky from the Bitcoin Times has been
- 16:24releasing a series of articles on TFTC this week talking about
- 16:28exactly this problem. And so building a large language
- 16:32model is not easy. And like you mentioned, the
- 16:34weights and the data you're feeding it and how you're
- 16:36feeding that, it, that data are very particular if you want a
- 16:41particular outcome. And I think that will be the big
- 16:46trend of 2024. Is people really learning how to
- 16:50actually build an LLM appropriately for the end use
- 16:53case they're looking to serve. And then on top of that, like
- 16:56AGI I, I actually had a long discussion with Alex on TFTC
- 17:01about this. He's pretty convinced and he
- 17:05makes a pretty convincing argument that it's just a red
- 17:08herring. Like artificial general
- 17:10intelligence, when you actually understand how these large large
- 17:13language models operate, they're essentially making probabilistic
- 17:17guesses at certain outcomes. They don't really have true
- 17:20intelligence at the end of the day.
- 17:22His thesis is that AGI artificial general intelligence
- 17:25is a red herring boogeyman that the incumbents can use as a
- 17:31means to create a regulatory Moat.
- 17:34And at the end of the day their large language models will
- 17:38achieve quote UN quote AGI as they define it.
- 17:41But at the end of the day it's not really general intelligence.
- 17:43It's could be used as a a ways to to proliferate propaganda
- 17:49because you're basically getting answers from a model that was
- 17:53designed and created in a very particular way.
- 17:56And so that's another big trend I'm looking forward to in 2024
- 18:00as a proliferation of more open source LLMS to compete with the
- 18:04open AIS and the anthropics of the world.
- 18:08And I think that will actually open up the market for these
- 18:12tools. And I do think in regards to
- 18:15what you're saying about the convergence of Bitcoin and AI,
- 18:18that is where Bitcoin will shine most acutely is because these
- 18:23open source models are going to have to be able to monetize.
- 18:26And I think that's the biggest problem with these open source
- 18:29models right now is like accessibility.
- 18:30Who's going to run them? Who's going to run the GPUs?
- 18:33Who's going to give people access to these models and how
- 18:35are they going to monetize. And I think Bitcoin,
- 18:37particularly lightning network enabled paywalls, makes it very
- 18:40easy to monetize those. And you mentioned privacy
- 18:44Bitcoin. If you're a company looking to
- 18:47maintain some semblance of privacy while you're using these
- 18:51tools that are being hosted by third parties, instead of having
- 18:55to set up an account with your name, your address, your company
- 18:58name, and your bank account information or your stripe
- 19:01information, a simple Lightning Network lightning enabled
- 19:06paywall really cuts out all that.
- 19:08It's like, all right, you you give me the money, I give you
- 19:11the result. I don't need any more of your
- 19:12information. So that's a big theme to look
- 19:15forward to. And then in terms of where we
- 19:17are in the hype cycle, I do think it is, we are still in a
- 19:21bit of a hype cycle. I think 2023 brought with it
- 19:24insane valuations for AI companies.
- 19:27Any buddy in Silicon Valley left a big tech firm to start an AI
- 19:31company got funded with insane valuations out of the gate.
- 19:36And I I find it hard to believe that most of those companies are
- 19:39going to be able to provide the value to their equity holders
- 19:43that that actually justifies those valuations.
- 19:48And so I do think that's where we are in the hype cycle where
- 19:50people were just able to slap AI on a business plan and get a lot
- 19:55of money and crazy valuations. I think there will be a massive
- 19:59correction there over the next few years.
- 20:01And then it as it pertains to actually using the tools, I do
- 20:05think there is a lot of signal and like you mentioned, Michael,
- 20:08we've been using it a lot at TFTC as a means to accelerate
- 20:13the amount of content that we can put.
- 20:15On our site, and I've been very public about this, I'll talk
- 20:18about it here as well, but we've been using ChatGPT and assembly
- 20:23AI. So ChatGPT obviously everybody
- 20:25knows is the chat bot provided by Open AI, and then Assembly AI
- 20:30is a transcription AI service. And so the problem I was having
- 20:36trying to use ChatGPT to help us put content on the site is that
- 20:40it would hallucinate a lot. You'd you'd give it a prompt and
- 20:43say, hey I want to write, I need help writing an article about
- 20:46what a Bitcoin UTXO is and ChatGPT would just go scrape the
- 20:51web and go to a bunch of different sources and then give
- 20:54me something that was completely incoherent and I'd had to spend
- 20:58over an hour editing and it really wasn't worth the time.
- 21:02But now with the combination of assembly and ChatGPT via tool
- 21:08called parse prompt dot AI, which is founded by a friend who
- 21:13reached out to me, it's like I have this tool think it could
- 21:15work for you. What we do is we now take audio
- 21:18content where that's podcast YouTube videos, predominately
- 21:22podcast and YouTube videos. We feed them into Assembly AI
- 21:26think it's a transcript of that audio file.
- 21:29And then you tell chat GB TI need you to write me an article
- 21:32specifically on this content and the hallucination essentially
- 21:37goes to 0. And so you can actually get good
- 21:40valuable content in written form that I can then put on the site.
- 21:43And so this is an effort to accelerate what we're trying to
- 21:47do at TFTC, which is curate what we deemed to be high signal
- 21:50content in the realms of Bitcoin, economics, culture,
- 21:55finance, health, all that stuff. And we've been able to
- 22:00accelerate me one man team writing one article a day to
- 22:04anywhere from like 8 to 15 articles a day just using this
- 22:07tool. We're creating a process around
- 22:09it. And so there's definitely signal
- 22:10there when you utilize the tools the right way.
- 22:12So I think that's another thing that will materialize in 2024 is
- 22:16people getting more familiar with this and getting smarter on
- 22:20how to combine and utilize these tools to get the correct
- 22:23outcome. That actually provides a a more
- 22:26productive business at the end of the day and it certainly
- 22:30worked for us at TFTC. Those are two tools that we use.
- 22:34And then the other is mid journey to create images for the
- 22:38thumbnails. And I've I've gotten really good
- 22:40at prompting which has been a fun fun learning experience over
- 22:43the last year. But I do think there's
- 22:45definitely signal, there's definitely a lot of use cases
- 22:48and there's definitely a lot of noise too.
- 22:50And so I think 2024 we're going to begin sifting the signal from
- 22:56the noise and the trends people getting smarter on how to build
- 23:00LLMS open source competing with closed source AI.
- 23:05That is actually one of my goals in Q1 of 2024 is to transition
- 23:09away from ChatGPT and mid Journey to more open source
- 23:14models because I like to I I think they're actually reaching
- 23:17parity with these closed source models and I do think the trend
- 23:20if it continues, we'll have open source models being better than
- 23:26the closed source models. So that's one thing I'm looking
- 23:28to do rather quickly here in 2024.
- 23:32And then that begs the question, what is the effect on the jobs
- 23:36market? And that brings up the headline
- 23:38from Google, which is in 2024 due to their utilization of AI,
- 23:44they expect to lay off 30,000 employees.
- 23:48Yeah. I mean, you mentioned it just
- 23:52for yourself, right, like how deflationary.
- 23:53Imagine having like how many people you'd have to hire to run
- 23:56what you do. And and Jesse mentioned some of
- 23:58the stuff we're working on and like the number, the sheer
- 24:00number of like from an efficiency perspective.
- 24:03But you teed in on a a key concept, Marty, about the open
- 24:06source and the the models. You can imagine a world where
- 24:08like it's every day you kind of look at Twitter and somebody
- 24:11posts about a like ChatGPT or one of them being like 2.
- 24:14Whatever the angle or ideology or political side is, it's like
- 24:181. It's skewed in a certain
- 24:19direction. So you can't even like be
- 24:21confident the information you're getting.
- 24:22So the open source nature is important.
- 24:25But then you kind of dubbed, it dovetails into well, how do you
- 24:27pay for that And that's where like an operation choke point,
- 24:30this stuff all exists where then we'll can you pay with your
- 24:32Visa, can you pay with your credit card, can you do that?
- 24:34And that goes back to the disrupt, the disruptive nature
- 24:37of these technologies. And then when you start to to
- 24:39play with the incumbents, they kind of are able to say, hey,
- 24:42like, you know, maybe we just can't accept your visa because
- 24:44you're providing some of these like API feeds that are given
- 24:47information that we don't think is is good or for whatever
- 24:49reason. That's why that symbiosis with
- 24:52like Bitcoin and AI is like a natural fit because you need a
- 24:54border, a borderless, permissionless form of currency
- 24:58that's also digitally native, right, for for obviously
- 25:01artificial intelligence. But that's where it just feels
- 25:03like natural to like tie in together, which is also
- 25:06applicable for this whole pod of like where this is all going.
- 25:10Yeah, and that's. Sorry, Jesse.
- 25:13It's so interesting that he here, I mean Marty's at the
- 25:17forefront of a practitioner use of AI and and deploying that a
- 25:24lot of things in there that that I found very interesting.
- 25:27And I guess first and first and foremost is Svetsky's position
- 25:32that it's at red herring and the ATI isn't really possible.
- 25:36And I and I agree with that, that reflex to be wary of how
- 25:43this ends up being used politically because that's
- 25:47certainly going to happen. But then my, my neuroscience
- 25:51background, I, my undergrad was in neuroscience has me pretty
- 25:57convinced that the brain is just a machine, just a series of
- 26:00switches. And you know, that becomes a
- 26:02philosophical debate of like do you believe that the soul is, is
- 26:06separate from the brain or do you think that the that the soul
- 26:09is the unconscious product of this machine, this very real
- 26:13machine, just a series of switches and.
- 26:16And I believe the latter. So if you believe that, then
- 26:20it's possible to create a brain, basically, and it's possible to
- 26:23create consciousness, the soul, the soul.
- 26:28The soul's the prompty, the soul's the prompter, Right?
- 26:31The prompter to do things. So you know anyway that I've I'm
- 26:36deeply in that camp as a result of studying that stuff from a
- 26:40from a biological point of view and in all the it's all just
- 26:45synapses and and condition. Neurotransmitters and.
- 26:50Yeah, yeah. Anyway, so that's all very
- 26:55interesting to me and but you know at the at the same time
- 26:59maybe that's the the hype cycle in in in a way too.
- 27:02I agree with your point about valuations being too high
- 27:05potentially to to deliver real you know real economic value And
- 27:12that might be a part of what's happening right now that we're
- 27:15kind of at that Gartner tech hype cycle peak before the
- 27:18through of disillusionment in terms of the economics of this
- 27:21technology. But it could also be that you
- 27:24know people are going to be disillusioned that oh you know
- 27:26what it seems like this this technology just hallucinates all
- 27:29the time and and doesn't have any kind of consistent
- 27:33consciousness that that emerges And so AGI is not possible.
- 27:38Meanwhile like the technology could continue getting better
- 27:42and better and these models turning into full brains
- 27:47basically. And then you have AGI emerge
- 27:50several years from now and and it's all fascinating to me
- 27:54because I was most interested in this stuff about 10 years ago.
- 28:00The book Super Intelligence by Nick Bostrom was kind of mind
- 28:04blowing for me back then and it predicted all this.
- 28:09It predicted the the, you know, it sort of dovetails with the
- 28:15singularity as near hypothesis of as you have this exponential
- 28:19growth of technology and Moore's law continues, where does that
- 28:23lead to? It eventually leads to a point
- 28:25where computers become more intelligent than humans and then
- 28:29computers become capable of making better computers.
- 28:33And then that really, you know, creates the exponential, A
- 28:36singularity moment where beyond that you can't see, you can't
- 28:39predict what the world is like because suddenly progress is
- 28:43taken over by computers instead of humans.
- 28:46And so that's the whole idea of the singularity.
- 28:48And that's what, you know, these tech luminaries for the last 20
- 28:52years have been pointing towards.
- 28:54And part of the predictions that were in place at least 10 years
- 28:58ago were like this slow progression of of, you know,
- 29:03artificial intelligence in niche categories.
- 29:07And then those niche categories broadening until eventually it's
- 29:09AGI and then and then you sort of reach the singularity point
- 29:14and it's weird that we're like it's playing out.
- 29:16I mean I don't know if it's exactly on the timetable that
- 29:20was predicted 1020 years ago, but it sure is playing out in
- 29:25terms of the how it feels this the world just feels to be
- 29:30changing at a faster and faster rate as as tech becomes you know
- 29:34software hits the world. And so I don't know, I agree
- 29:38that 2024 will be all about refining and improving on this
- 29:41stuff. And you know a whole lot can
- 29:43happen in, in one year. And so we might find a greater
- 29:46degree of change over the next 12 months than we saw over the
- 29:49prior 12 months. Yeah, it's gonna be.
- 29:53I would. I was gonna say I'd 2nd that I
- 29:56think what what you guys raised that point about the the
- 30:00regulatory Moat, right. You know, we so far the
- 30:04narrative we've heard mainly in the op-ed pages about kind of
- 30:08reining and regulating this technology.
- 30:10It's been about the left tail wrist right.
- 30:11The the Skynet scenario Terminator.
- 30:13Yeah, it gets holding the nukes and Oh my God, that's the the
- 30:16existential risk to humanity. But I think there's something
- 30:21even bigger when you like listen to Marty's story about what he's
- 30:24doing with TFTC. Like his his use of these models
- 30:27is basically like having another team mate, right.
- 30:31And you could think about that as they get more and more
- 30:33specialized. It's like 1 model is hyper
- 30:35trained for one task and then that that impacts organizations,
- 30:38you know like so instead of like the post industrial area, you
- 30:42know like the, you know post World War 2 era of how
- 30:46corporations and businesses designed out their their
- 30:49hierarchies, right. I mean it's just like a, you
- 30:53know, a tree where you know maybe each each individual in
- 30:57the tree has six direct reports mapping up to them and then down
- 31:01to the bottom of the node where you look at the org chart.
- 31:03It might look like something like a Christmas tree in terms
- 31:07of the organization structure. But as you go through this, this
- 31:12is like this AI and this, this you know begins to really
- 31:15integrate into the the rest of the economy.
- 31:18Like this is going to, this is going to play in like to to all
- 31:21of our social structures, the existing kind of financial
- 31:26position of of organizations as well as you know the the, the
- 31:29public sector which we can get into later.
- 31:32I mean it's well known that that there's serious problems there.
- 31:36And also I think you know you think about the the the dog not
- 31:40barking right now that everybody's kind of aware of is
- 31:43what's going on in commercial real estate, right.
- 31:44There's a lot of, you know, skyscrapers out there that are
- 31:47just impaired properties. But I think what that like what
- 31:51it boils down to is like our social.
- 31:52This is going to change our organization structure.
- 31:54You know, Marty mentions what he's doing at TFTC.
- 31:57Yeah. Compare and contrast that to
- 31:58what the version of TFTC looked like in like the 60s and 70s.
- 32:01I'd say be like the Rolling Stone magazine would be a good
- 32:04comp. Like it's a, you know, an
- 32:06operation, you know, media entity that that tried to
- 32:09capture the, the cultural zeitgeist of all these big
- 32:11things that were happening in the 60s, seventies and and all
- 32:14of that. And I think that's what TFTC has
- 32:16its finger on the pulse for, you know, right now in this era, but
- 32:21now instead of, you know, a massive media operation with
- 32:25hundreds of employees, you know, sending these writers all over
- 32:28the world to get the story, you know, Marty has himself and I
- 32:31don't know how many employees you have, but it's it's, it's
- 32:33not hundreds, it's it's more like 1, maybe two like you.
- 32:37And then you can get all this other work done.
- 32:39And so you're doing the same thing with, you know, just a
- 32:42much lower footprint, right. And that that trickles in that
- 32:45like everything indirectly. If you think about it like it's
- 32:48office space, like now we don't need to fill up, you know, floor
- 32:51in Manhattan with an office for Rolling Stone.
- 32:53Now it's Marty and TFTC and you know, one room off the Commons
- 32:58base, the Bitcoin Commons down in Austin and everything that
- 33:01kind of trickles down through that.
- 33:03But then it's also like the knowledge worker, right, that's
- 33:06been the base of the this big boom in the kind of the post
- 33:101980 world. As you know, the boomers kind of
- 33:13fully entered the workforce in the 70s.
- 33:16And then as they really hit their stride in the 80s, you
- 33:19know, the the, the, the, the primary beneficiary that was
- 33:24like this, this knowledge worker, right.
- 33:27And a lot of these tasks weren't, you know, really high
- 33:32brain activities that a lot of these people were doing.
- 33:34Like a lot of it is just operational paper pushing that
- 33:37is going to be the lowest hanging fruit for not just the
- 33:41AI like the semiconductor and and the Internet have already
- 33:44eaten a lot of the the the the easiest jobs kind of to automate
- 33:48and manage. But now we're going to move up
- 33:50into like the middle market and you know maybe front office part
- 33:53of the stack in terms of like the financial industry
- 33:56footprint. So then when you take it to that
- 33:58level you're like all right, that's going to make this office
- 33:59CRE problem you know materialize as it already is and then that's
- 34:04going to impact the banks and the financial sector.
- 34:07It's also going to impact the fiscal position as you think
- 34:09about like that taxpayer, right. This AI it's basically a a quasi
- 34:15teammate it's it's your new direct report right as you as
- 34:19one individual one human takes advantage of these these tools
- 34:22and and can hyper specialize that those you know what we call
- 34:26them like synthetic workers they don't need benefits.
- 34:29They don't need a four O 1K, they don't need health insurance
- 34:32and they don't you know there's no good way to tax there's no
- 34:35W2. So the real tail risk, like,
- 34:38yeah, sure, maybe they get a hold of Skynet and you know, we
- 34:41all blow up. But I think it's even more in
- 34:44front of us like all of this. So, you know, the faster this
- 34:48integration happens, these organizations and existing kind
- 34:52of social structures from the bottom to the top, like at every
- 34:56scale of society are going to have to absorb this.
- 35:01And it's just going to be one of these periods it looks like
- 35:03where there's a massive amount of change not just in the like
- 35:06the the, you know as Jesse was mentioning, like the singularity
- 35:11is near. The technology is going to get
- 35:13better and better, right. We have tools that can make
- 35:15better tools now but then the speed and the pace that this
- 35:19system has to that our existing systems have to adopt to this
- 35:24massive change like it is it is I could I the way I see this the
- 35:27only way I see it is escalating like it's going to become more
- 35:30and more front and center so that that left tail risk of the
- 35:32nukes firing. I I don't know that that's the
- 35:35biggest thing to worry about right now.
- 35:36It's the eye on the ball is like how do we all of our
- 35:39institutions, like what would be keeping me up at night if I were
- 35:41a policy maker in Washington, DC, is how do I keep society in
- 35:46line and and you know maintain some sense of organization as
- 35:49this massive kind of phase shift takes place.
- 35:52Yeah. We're we're we're entering the
- 35:54it's a massive acceleration of of technology deflation right
- 35:59and what what Booth always writes about and and and Matt to
- 36:03your point like we're going to see the re emergence of Ubi as
- 36:06as some necessary political agenda because there's going to
- 36:11be a lot more people out of work because AI has taken their job
- 36:17and how do we support these people.
- 36:19We should we need Ubi and we need to print money to to help
- 36:24you know retain society as we know it and so that's going to
- 36:29come roaring back and and overall like you you touched on
- 36:32something that I hadn't really thought about before but AI is
- 36:36is really going to cause the shift away from the knowledge
- 36:40economy that we've known that the that the boomer world was
- 36:43based on and back and Bitcoin is a big part of this story because
- 36:47I think it shifts from a knowledge economy back to a
- 36:50capital economy or it's going to be all about like how do you
- 36:54deploy capital to to create a product and and and good by
- 37:00leveraging AI and so Bitcoin becomes the foundation of a new
- 37:04like capital based economy after this transition period that
- 37:09we've had over the last century really of of a knowledge based
- 37:12economy. Hard skills and hard money are
- 37:16the the the next next decade. I mean, just to put some numbers
- 37:20on all this, Matt, while you're speaking, I went to my assembly
- 37:24Open AI and Parse prompt cost. It's cost me $250 over the last
- 37:29month and a half to create more than 100 articles where if I had
- 37:32to pay staff to do that, it would have been thousands of
- 37:35dollars, easily so. So we we probably need our own.
- 37:39We need to do AI dedicated, you know, or themed TLT.
- 37:45But one thing that's like to play this or what you mentioned
- 37:50about like singularity, it's like there's this natural thing
- 37:53that you're doing Marty, that I think is really important and
- 37:54it's kind of like tricked myself into this new pod with final
- 37:57Settlement is getting ahead because we've been so busy
- 38:00working here. And I fundamentally believe that
- 38:02like unless you kind of adopt these tools, you just start to
- 38:05move. It's just like Bitcoin.
- 38:06You start to move behind like in in the world because it's so
- 38:09crazy and transformative and that we look at the deflationary
- 38:12nature of it and the layoffs and all the stuff.
- 38:14It's like if you want to keep pace, it's like getting ahead of
- 38:18understanding the tools, how they impact you.
- 38:20And then I think like for a while, right.
- 38:22It doesn't naturally transition to just no humans are involved
- 38:25in a lot of these tasks. It's just you're augmenting your
- 38:27personal skill set coupled with these tools and that's how you
- 38:31kind of like make the the, the the Cliff of like who's still
- 38:34around and who's not. I think is an important function
- 38:37or like kind of take away from a lot of this is it's not all like
- 38:40doom and gloom. It's like, obviously this is
- 38:41just a natural part of like deflationary aspects of
- 38:44technology, but there's an important aspect of just like
- 38:46starting to look into it because there's a lot of ways to play it
- 38:50where you can benefit. Yeah.
- 38:52And I guess that's the big question.
- 38:53I mean, anchoring back to the Google headline of their plans
- 38:56to lay off 30,000 employees this year because of how AI is
- 39:01affecting their business. I I think that's the big
- 39:04question. What is out there?
- 39:05Does this lead to like a hyper deflationary event that has a a
- 39:10fallout of the job market or do these tools incite something
- 39:16where you have like 1000 roses bloom?
- 39:18Like are these people get laid off, you know, to recognize that
- 39:21they got laid off because of the AI tools and view that as an
- 39:25opportunity to go start their own AI company or start their
- 39:29own business. Maybe not even directly related
- 39:31to AI, but knowing how to leverage AI, which I hope any
- 39:34Google employee would know how to do to go start their own
- 39:36business. I think that's another big
- 39:38question that will begin to get answered in 2024.
- 39:42Is this something that's an existential crisis to the job
- 39:46market? Or are we Luddites and this
- 39:49actually turns out to be something that is making many
- 39:53more people extremely productive and able to go feed themselves
- 39:57because they can leverage these tools?
- 39:59I think it's an ebb and flow kind of thing.
- 40:01If you worked at Google, there's not a lot of places somebody
- 40:03after they get laid off from Google can go and do their brain
- 40:05hasn't worked for for for a while.
- 40:08You know there's 200,000. I mean it's just it's just a
- 40:11fact like you go the the golden handcuffs are a real thing when
- 40:14you these firms hire people so they don't go out to compete or
- 40:17they sit and roll and do the performance review.
- 40:20Obviously that's just a generalization, but it's a
- 40:23reality for a large portion of like just in general like
- 40:25companies. I think too there's an element
- 40:29where it's it's if you get out in the field and you go
- 40:36experience trying to, you know, go stay at a hotel right now or
- 40:38stay at a resort whatever like or go to dinner with your
- 40:43family. There's there's a almost.
- 40:45It's, it's pretty clear like a shortage of employable workers
- 40:50at like the what we call blue collar jobs, right?
- 40:53Like the low value ad jobs. You know traditionally over the
- 40:58last 40-40 years that you did need a college degree for of a
- 41:01class, an economic class that's fallen behind right over this
- 41:06massive bull market and financial assets.
- 41:09There's a shortage now of that type of worker versus you know,
- 41:14where the economy's kind of like shedding jobs at the the white
- 41:20collar sectors of the economy. So there's something massive
- 41:24going on where, you know, this big shift in where society is
- 41:28allocating its its resources, including our human resources,
- 41:31right. Is going to need to take place
- 41:34because like there's just, you know, it's pretty obvious now
- 41:37there's all these impaired office skyscrapers across the
- 41:41the metros in the US And I don't I don't know of too many markets
- 41:44where it it isn't an actual problem.
- 41:47Is is telling you like it's giving signal that there there's
- 41:52something even bigger that needs to take place in terms of where
- 41:55our society has misallocated resources That goes down to
- 41:57where where we've trained up workers, where the college
- 42:00degrees have been. You know what what people have
- 42:02been majoring in and you know where where people have been,
- 42:06you know, kind of funneled into for economic opportunity.
- 42:09You know as like the Luke Groban type of thesis says like we
- 42:13don't have enough you know plumbers, electricians, home
- 42:17build, etcetera and there's just going to be a a massive shift
- 42:21that needs that looks like it needs to take place and.
- 42:25It hasn't been possible, it hasn't been possible to make a
- 42:28life as like a like a hotel worker and and you know provide
- 42:32for your family because of the last 40 years of bull market and
- 42:37financial assets and how that has impacted the price of
- 42:40everything but that. And then that becomes what
- 42:44Bitcoin makes possible again of like you can live a life of a
- 42:47blue collar life of saving Bitcoin and seeing your
- 42:50purchasing power grow over time because you have a good money
- 42:55and you don't need to go to college to chase a high a high
- 43:00paying job. Which has been really the only
- 43:02like viable strategy or has emerged as the consensus only
- 43:07viable strategy over the last 40 years in particular.
- 43:11So you know, but I think that trend, I think that that kind of
- 43:15wisdom only percolates in hindsight.
- 43:18Like after there's there's literally a generation's worth
- 43:21of economic data that then people from you know parents
- 43:26passed down to their children of like here's what worked for my
- 43:29generation, that's what I wish I had done basically.
- 43:32And and so I think you know 20 years from now we'll we'll get
- 43:35people saying you know what just just accumulate Bitcoin and
- 43:41forget about college and be a plumber and and maybe that's,
- 43:44you know it doesn't all start in 20 years.
- 43:46But we'll have a a slow transition back to that being
- 43:50like a a a prudent a bit of advice to give to the next
- 43:54generation. And that all makes it possible
- 43:57to to to restore what has been a gutted blue collar class.
- 44:05So hopefully, hopefully the blue collar workers find Bitcoin and
- 44:10incorporated it into their financial planning because that
- 44:14makes it possible to be a blue collar worker and thrive.
- 44:18So I'm hopeful, But you know, we have to reach them with
- 44:22education too. Yeah, the romantic in me likes
- 44:26to think that this will enable people to focus on more virtuous
- 44:32endeavours like building beautiful things, beautiful
- 44:35sculptures like over break between the last two recordings
- 44:38I was home. I flew into Philly from Austin
- 44:42and got dropped off at 30th St. station in Philadelphia to head
- 44:47up to New York for a pub key event that I was Co hosting.
- 44:50And just sitting there I was. I had to wait for like 45
- 44:52minutes and 30th St. station. And if you've never been to 30th
- 44:55St. station in Philadelphia, I highly recommend you take the
- 44:59trip. If not only when?
- 45:01Was it? When was it built?
- 45:03Marty, if you. That's it was 30th St.
- 45:06Station. It has to be a turn of the
- 45:08century, like Bose Arts or Art Nouveau or or maybe Art Deco
- 45:13kind of building right back 19. 33.
- 45:17Yep. OK, so art deco.
- 45:20Yeah, probably. It's a beautiful piece of
- 45:25architecture. Hopefully we can get back to
- 45:27that with this. I I think we have to find a
- 45:29silver lining in this. The white collar workers are
- 45:31certainly about to see mass extinction, if you will.
- 45:35It seems brash, but if having used the tools myself like it's
- 45:40happening, there's nothing we can do about it.
- 45:41You can be a Luddite and try to dig your feet in the ground and
- 45:45tell the government to slow things down, but it's not going
- 45:47to happen. We're going to have to get back
- 45:50to building beautiful things. And I do think this will shift
- 45:53people away from the software world towards the physical
- 45:56world, which I don't think is necessarily a bad thing.
- 45:58It will just be if you really. Think about it.
- 46:01It's a practical, obvious thing Like if you look at it like a
- 46:04pie and like if everybody's here in the white collar and then you
- 46:07have all these tasks and things that need to be built.
- 46:09And historically for hundreds and thousands of years we've had
- 46:11this filter like we've just outstretched that via like money
- 46:15and all the things we know that you have to start going back to
- 46:17like people have to build things, you have to deliver
- 46:19services. In the real world, it's it's a,
- 46:21you know it actually shouldn't be that kind of like crazy that
- 46:24we say this or like the market is like starting to change.
- 46:27It's like we all have to get into the the, the circles of our
- 46:30confidence and like what the market needs.
- 46:32Yeah. And and that's because the money
- 46:34and and investing in general has made it so that you can't aim
- 46:39for anything but the top 10% of jobs.
- 46:41Like there's just no, there's not.
- 46:44There's no way to thrive you. Know the funny?
- 46:47Hard to thrive. A funny example that's just
- 46:50relevant here is the 2 smartest for sure the one.
- 46:52The other one I haven't worked with but talked to more
- 46:54mechanical that I've worked in in my limited career, called 15
- 46:58years, were Mechanical Engineers.
- 46:59They had to go into like Tradfi because it just didn't pay.
- 47:03And that was what society told them.
- 47:04One was from India, the other one went to Carnegie Mellon and
- 47:07they were the smartest people I ever met.
- 47:08They didn't even want to be doing what they were required to
- 47:10do and they were the best at what they did.
- 47:11They wanted to be out, like working with like kind of like
- 47:14prints and all the things associated with it.
- 47:15But they were there, like working with numbers.
- 47:17And that's because of what Jesse just related to.
- 47:20And there's so many people like that all over the job sector
- 47:23globally that are just forced into these functions that they
- 47:26weren't based to. Like Marty's point, it's not
- 47:27even necessarily a romanticism. It's just a reality that people
- 47:31build things when they're not worried, like beautiful things
- 47:33when they're not worried about like being able to, you know,
- 47:36live paycheck to paycheck and if all the things associated with
- 47:39come with like a bad form of money.
- 47:41So this is definitely going to happen.
- 47:42It's just going to take time, Yeah.
- 47:44I mean the oh, there's. Chiefs not.
- 47:46Go ahead on that one. Go ahead.
- 47:47I was gonna say just to piggyback on that, Michael, the
- 47:49chief investment officer, the fund I worked for out of college
- 47:51I worked under was a Russian cosmonaut and immigrated to the
- 47:57US to to write algos for like hedge fund indexes and stuff
- 48:01like that. This is, yeah, it's the joke
- 48:03about new. I mean yeah, we we we've kind of
- 48:06experienced this as you know the in the 90s all of the the the
- 48:10PhDs, the Quads kind of like got pulled in by Wall Street, you
- 48:13know to create new exotic derivatives or price and create
- 48:15some you know a really complex formula so we can create a new
- 48:20instrument to trade. We've kind of seen the results
- 48:23of that. We we saw this, you know,
- 48:29subprime crisis where we, you know built these models and
- 48:32created the AAA credit securities that the financial
- 48:37system needed. You know at the base layer of
- 48:40the system you you need a AAA, you know, credit asset to keep
- 48:43leveraging on top of the system. And we saw it just completely
- 48:47fall apart in 2008. So we know we're building, you
- 48:50know, where where where engineers are trained to think
- 48:52like in the laws of physics that these are like, you know like
- 48:57honest discoverable truths of the universe.
- 49:00It's not the way you know financial markets and humans,
- 49:03you know at the end of the day kind of operate in practice.
- 49:06But I just, you know had this thought, remember Isaac Newton,
- 49:09right. The the peak quant of all time.
- 49:12Right. There's only a few others who
- 49:14hold up to that name like maybe Gauss you know a few other
- 49:17Einstein like they're they're the best, right.
- 49:19He went through the same thing. I forget what role he had maybe
- 49:22as like chancellor of the ex checker in England or maybe he
- 49:25was the head of his universities endowment.
- 49:27I can't remember who it was but he got roped in massively by I I
- 49:31think it was the South Sea bubble and at the end of the
- 49:34day, like he just threw up his arms and was just going to
- 49:36complete disgust. He's like I can calculate like
- 49:38the masses of heavenly bodies and you know, all of that, but
- 49:41it's like at the end of the day like I cannot calculate or
- 49:44comprehend, you know, the the decision making and financial
- 49:47markets of of like the behaviors of mankind.
- 49:50So this is, you know, other bubbles, you know, throughout
- 49:54history is it's like kind of history rhymes not repeats, but
- 49:57there's there's nothing new under the sun As as much as you
- 49:59know we're talking about this. The term we used, you know, 5
- 50:03minutes or 10 minutes ago to call this was like a mass
- 50:05extinction event, you know, in in the economy and the, you
- 50:08know, knowledge worker, the white collar sector economy.
- 50:10It's like I wouldn't, I wouldn't.
- 50:11Call it that like just because it's it invokes too much sense
- 50:15of fear. I I would I think and panic.
- 50:19This is something you know the economy is like we've been
- 50:22through. There's there's precedents for
- 50:23this. It's going to be painful.
- 50:25There's going to be band aids ripped off and people are going
- 50:27to need to adjust. But we'll make it through and
- 50:33and you know, I've heard you know Marty, I think he did a
- 50:35podcast with Parker talking about the the GFC in 2008 that
- 50:40was a massive rug pull. You know for people to deal with
- 50:43Like just the financial sector got bailed out.
- 50:46You know the bonuses continued for the industry like no one
- 50:50faced any repercussions for the for the mistakes made over you
- 50:56know the pre financial crisis era or or the decades ahead of
- 51:01you know I'll thought out decisions that ultimately LED
- 51:04there in policy but at the end of the day like the American
- 51:08working class whether you're white collar blue collar like
- 51:11you got rug pulled off of that one.
- 51:13So you know as much as you know we're talking about this, this
- 51:17is a big technological shift that's underway and
- 51:19accelerating. But you know we've we've
- 51:22survived worse. I think or heart like the I
- 51:25don't want to say as bad as it is, I can keep digging and
- 51:27hitting rock bottom. But this is just like how the
- 51:31world works. We have to adapt.
- 51:32We have to integrate this into our businesses, into our economy
- 51:37and that's that's really the only way to get to get through
- 51:39this is to get like cross that bridge, build the bridge and get
- 51:41to the other side. But yeah.
- 51:44The Isaac Newton was I. Appreciate that extinction
- 51:46event. It's a bit, it's a bit too
- 51:48alarmist. I agree, Matt.
- 51:49That's actually one thing in 2024.
- 51:50I'm not trying to be doomer. Need white pills.
- 51:54The white pill is we're going to get back to building beautiful
- 51:56things. There will be some turbulence
- 51:58between now and the beautiful things being erected.
- 52:01But as Matt mentioned, this has happened many times throughout
- 52:04history. And Marty was not kidding. 2024
- 52:07New Year TLT The Last Trade is an AI podcast.
- 52:13Yeah, it's an important topic and there is obviously an
- 52:15intersection with Bitcoin And obviously if you're a capital
- 52:18allocator out there thinking about how to the place your bets
- 52:23in the in the financial markets is going to be a big disruptor
- 52:26to that strategy. Because if you're heavily
- 52:29dependent on commercial real estate cash flows that may not
- 52:33materialize the way it has in the past moving forward due to
- 52:36how this is going to affect the job market.
- 52:39And with that I think begin transition to the next topics.
- 52:42But let's just talk about the job market a little bit.
- 52:44We have this chart up here of quits verse hires and they seem
- 52:48to be hitting they point that would signal that many people
- 52:53are wary about losing their jobs and they don't feel confident
- 52:57enough to quit and go find another one.
- 52:59So they're not worried about losing their jobs to worry about
- 53:01finding another job. They may be stuck into place
- 53:04that they don't like, but they're not quitting as
- 53:07aggressively as they as they were in the past.
- 53:09If you're quit, you're confident you can go find another job and
- 53:11then on top of that hires. Both of these quits and hires
- 53:14are below pre COVID levels. So people are holding steady in
- 53:19their jobs and then their employees are not employers
- 53:23excuse me, are not hiring as many people.
- 53:26And this is an interesting chart to juxtapose with the jobs data
- 53:30that came out today, the unemployment data that came out
- 53:32today that's also reaching pre COVID levels as well that that
- 53:39you had it up there, that that one right there, next one, no
- 53:42other way. Logan's looking for it.
- 53:46There you go. So this is an interesting topic.
- 53:50We're getting two different stories from these two charts.
- 53:52One is that people aren't confident to quit and companies
- 53:55aren't hiring. But here, the unemployment claim
- 54:00claims data that was released today came in pretty low back
- 54:04below recession threshold, firmly back below recession
- 54:07threshold. So how are you guys reading the
- 54:10juxtaposition of these two data points?
- 54:13Jesse will throw it to you. But that last one kind of throws
- 54:17me for a loop. I don't know what to make of
- 54:19that. I I'm I'm really not sure.
- 54:23I mean part of part of what confounds all these employment
- 54:27numbers is sometimes you have you you have people with
- 54:32multiple jobs or picking up a second job and that shows as you
- 54:37know like a like good positive employment data.
- 54:41But it's really people struggling and and pushed to
- 54:45find a second job just to fit in some extra hours to make some
- 54:48money. And and so that is an additional
- 54:53layer in in all of this that I don't know what to make of.
- 54:59Yeah. So I'm not sure about, I'm not
- 55:02sure about this. I'm curious what Matt has to say
- 55:04on on employment data right now. Yeah, so the the BLS numbers
- 55:11like the the big print that markets watch is the the monthly
- 55:15NFP print out farm payrolls comes out the 1st Friday of
- 55:20every month. So we'll get that tomorrow as
- 55:23far as this recording, so we don't have that one yet.
- 55:25That's a massive like lagging indicator.
- 55:27It's a it's a model estimate. They don't actually go through
- 55:31like the, the BLS and gathered, you know, W2 data and be like
- 55:37all right, how many new ads did you have?
- 55:38How many like? It's not a precise calculation
- 55:41by any means, like the measurement is horribly
- 55:44inaccurate. It's it's a model and
- 55:51historically you can see this in the data they go through.
- 55:54You know your initial print like we'll get the December number
- 55:57for NFP job creation on Jan 3rd. You go through two different
- 56:03revisions or updates like over the next ensuing 2 months.
- 56:08So you have three months before the December number is locked in
- 56:13and I use air quotes even like it's this is completely
- 56:17ridiculous. But they're not locked in like
- 56:19you see this. They go back and restate after
- 56:22the fact and it can be like 5-5 to five to 10 years later and
- 56:30restate the the let's say drawdowns or or job losses in a
- 56:35in a recession versus you know the expansion and and the
- 56:39business cycle kind of uptick. So the NFP numbers are just like
- 56:44if you're using them as a speedometer like they're
- 56:49terrible you they don't tell you anything like in real time the
- 56:53continuing claims numbers and new unemployment claims, those
- 56:56are better because like they're consolidated from the state
- 56:59level like like like so you have kind of a a more of a bottoms up
- 57:03kind of real time snapshot and they're reported weekly.
- 57:06They're still noisy but if you kind of you use a moving average
- 57:11like it gives you a better signal from week to week.
- 57:14It could be you know there might be noise from the data
- 57:16collection itself. It could also be let's say
- 57:19Google, like if you have one big employer in a state and you know
- 57:22here in Washington state where where I reside say Boeing was
- 57:26going to do some layoffs. As you know, hey, we see plane
- 57:29deliveries or plane orders, you know, slowing down.
- 57:35You might see like a big, a big, you know, abnormal jump week to
- 57:38week. So you could actually just get
- 57:40some some noise that's actually kind of real activity like it's
- 57:45not measurement error but it's just coming from like the the
- 57:48sample and just idiosyncratic decisions from business to
- 57:52business. But those continuing claims
- 57:54numbers are actually kind of better as a as a signal to where
- 57:59the economy is in my opinion than than just watching NFPS and
- 58:03seeing where it comes into month to month.
- 58:04Now the markets, you know there's the equities and bond
- 58:07markets just are hyper attuned to respond to that NFP print as
- 58:13they come in 1-2 and three it's it's it's kind of like the
- 58:18beauty contest if you will and we're we're judging people based
- 58:22on you know what they look like at age 20 as opposed to you know
- 58:26maybe where they are in life, 3040 year olds, whatever in
- 58:30terms of what they've actually accomplished and how how it
- 58:32actually plays out after the fact.
- 58:36So this will create a lot of like noise and markets, but it's
- 58:40not really a reliable signal if you're if you're basing asset
- 58:43pricing on on those reports, but financial markets are doing
- 58:48that. So it it makes it hard from week
- 58:52to week to really get the picture month to month if you
- 58:54will over the short term to see what's going on.
- 58:56But as the bigger, longer term revisions come in, they've are
- 58:59like you already saw the BLS revised down prior months of
- 59:03last year for job creation we claimed happened.
- 59:05And you. Know the first few quarters of
- 59:07the year. Those got revised down and that
- 59:08was after the 3rd and, you know, supposedly final print.
- 59:12Once the facts are rewritten, you'll see the economist come
- 59:15out and, you know, put in some new final estimate and and lock
- 59:19the number in stone. And it just kind of begs the
- 59:21question, like what was the real truth?
- 59:24Like how do you know, 'cause now you're going back and basing
- 59:26this on a model like do we go back and, you know, collect the
- 59:28W twos and see the real data? What was, what was the actual
- 59:33number? It just I I I think in my
- 59:36opinion it just goes to show how hard it is to technocratically
- 59:40manage the like an economy from a central planning standpoint
- 59:44from the tops down based on policy decision.
- 59:47Like like from an office in Washington DC where you're
- 59:50trying to micromanage all of this and it kind of bundles
- 59:53bundled into that question is like how we manage monetary
- 59:55policy. Right now it comes from you know
- 59:57a board of people sitting around a table at the Eccles building
- 1:00:02or communicate like one interest rate and then manage this whole
- 1:00:04thing. It's very hard to do.
- 1:00:07Yeah, it's all kind of backwards looking too.
- 1:00:10I mean jobs numbers can can be looking good right now because
- 1:00:15sentiment is kind of good right now because we've been in nine
- 1:00:18months of positive liquidity that has caused markets to
- 1:00:22surge. And so I I kind of have this, I
- 1:00:25have this sneaking suspicion that we're in a bit of like a
- 1:00:27dead cat bounce sentiment wise right now.
- 1:00:30Like the rally right now doesn't to me.
- 1:00:36It doesn't feel real like or or sustainable I should say, like
- 1:00:40are we really going to rip to new highs right now with what's
- 1:00:44going on with the deficit in particular and and the national
- 1:00:48debt. And you know the AI explanation
- 1:00:51is like OK maybe maybe it's real productivity but this I don't
- 1:00:56know I I have this sneaking suspicion that we're going
- 1:01:01through the same emotions that 2007 into 2008 had with like
- 1:01:10people saying oh we we had a we had a little gully and things
- 1:01:14are recovering and it's all good and people actually fall for
- 1:01:18that sentiment. You know and and you get caught
- 1:01:21in a in a bull trap where you're you get bullish and sentiment
- 1:01:26feels fine right when you shouldn't.
- 1:01:31That's a little bit doomer on my part I admit.
- 1:01:33But I just don't see how we're going to the stock markets are
- 1:01:37going to rip to new highs. But you know then again it it
- 1:01:40comes back to liquidity and and if if we're in a QE environment
- 1:01:44because we're printing fresh debt you know deficit spending
- 1:01:49is is the name of the game maybe that's what's going on.
- 1:01:52I I I don't know. I'm a little perplexed at how
- 1:01:57stock markets have been so positive.
- 1:02:00Well, 'cause it's just. It's easy, right?
- 1:02:01It's just. So just it's just so dislocated
- 1:02:03from the fundamentals, Matt's gonna be able to more eloquently
- 1:02:06explain it. But but from a pure just like
- 1:02:09looking at the market, those numbers, I like the first chart
- 1:02:12because it basically supports what we all have felt.
- 1:02:15Or if you ask anybody, people are getting laid off and they
- 1:02:17can't go find jobs, but everything else will say
- 1:02:20otherwise. And that's like the fundamental
- 1:02:22when you think about like interest rates rising, like
- 1:02:24natural cost of capital increases, people spend less, so
- 1:02:26companies make less. So they have to let people off.
- 1:02:29These are just like natural order things.
- 1:02:30But the stock market and the charts and the Fed speak will
- 1:02:33say otherwise. And I think that's the part
- 1:02:35that's confounding on your site, Jesse, is like well, what's
- 1:02:37happening because we're at all time highs.
- 1:02:39But then there's all this like weirdness around us that doesn't
- 1:02:42feel good. And I think that's natural,
- 1:02:44right, because like we're feeling it and seeing it in the
- 1:02:45market, but the actual stock market is saying otherwise.
- 1:02:50So how to judge where stocks are like?
- 1:02:52That's just the Keynesian beauty contest.
- 1:02:54Like one of the best, like you know, just to say what Kane's
- 1:02:57got right, like talking about it, it's it's really castles in
- 1:03:01the sky and trying to come up with valuations like as much as
- 1:03:04people think like equity markets are the hardest thing to
- 1:03:08predict, like a lot of it is based on like sentiment.
- 1:03:11You. Know as opposed to, you know,
- 1:03:14people who think they're rational, value driven
- 1:03:16investors, you know, like. Dogecoin.
- 1:03:18Thing out like it's like. Dogecoin in.
- 1:03:20Practice. Yeah.
- 1:03:22Here's what we like here. Like it's as far as trying to
- 1:03:25get your bearings on where this thing is like dig deeper into
- 1:03:27the financial system like the commodity, Marcus, are a great
- 1:03:30signal. And then I'd say like interest
- 1:03:33rates and then we can talk about.
- 1:03:35Building a case. Like the the Bitcoin case for
- 1:03:37what we know on top of that. But.
- 1:03:38I think like going into the base layer like down to the studs of
- 1:03:42the financial system, looking at interest rates right now, right
- 1:03:47we've been paused like we've been flat it, you know fed funds
- 1:03:515.25 to 5.5 for now. 2. Quarters right.
- 1:03:56Rates like they're done hiking like from all intents and it
- 1:03:59would take something abnormal versus all the other rate hike
- 1:04:02cycles we've seen in you know the the rich data sample era.
- 1:04:07I'd say like post World War 2 for another hike to need to be
- 1:04:10done here. Like something pretty
- 1:04:12significant would have to take place, but if you're yeah.
- 1:04:17But but historically the the crisis hits like 10 after the
- 1:04:27they pop hiking, right. So we're still like within that
- 1:04:31normal time frame of like, oh. Yeah, totally normal on schedule
- 1:04:35like this. I mean policy might at this
- 1:04:38point actually be a little bit ahead of of the actual business
- 1:04:42cycle where they have some some room as opposed to being on
- 1:04:44their back foot. But I think if you're if you're
- 1:04:46looking at signals for like like rates need to come down like
- 1:04:49you're you're seeing it like with the like we know with
- 1:04:52office CRE like there's a lot of issues there on the rollover
- 1:04:57from the 2021 trot or vintage of of deals that came out like yeah
- 1:05:04and it makes sense right. You had this the massive fiscal
- 1:05:07and monetary like impulse like unseen from from Q 3/20/20 that
- 1:05:13was trickling into the system. So you had a ton of bad deals
- 1:05:16made and so those are gonna get roll over and refi and I was
- 1:05:19listening to yeah the CIO of Muddy Waters last night he's
- 1:05:24made a case for for a short on a Blackstone mortgage Trust where
- 1:05:29I think he said 73% of the loans.
- 1:05:32And I don't know if that's loans like by count or loans by by
- 1:05:35principal value in the portfolio can't finance out of their net
- 1:05:42operating income either sulphur just a loan without the spread
- 1:05:48or sulphur plus the spread of their of their debt financing
- 1:05:52costs. So that's 73% of their portfolio
- 1:05:55they they've assessed as analysts is going to be in
- 1:05:59trouble rolling over on you know commercial properties like the
- 1:06:02skyscrapers and and and metro America throughout.
- 1:06:05So like rates are going to need to come down from that angle on
- 1:06:07bank balance sheets and you see it in the federal deficit as
- 1:06:12well like the interest expense on the chart you go, Fred and
- 1:06:16look that up like it's just a vertical line up.
- 1:06:19Yeah, it is massive that spike gets taken.
- 1:06:23So front end rates and the debt refinancing rates, there's the
- 1:06:27need from the borrower standpoint like it has to come
- 1:06:30down, it's not sustainable and if you're looking at the
- 1:06:32financial markets like for for the capital markets desk like
- 1:06:36within the banks you. Got a lot?
- 1:06:38Of signals that's like they're they're going to come down as
- 1:06:40many people are in still in the we're higher for longer camp
- 1:06:43it's just a matter of time in in my perspective.
- 1:06:46So you got the like the the one year overnight index swap rates
- 1:06:50right the the the these are derivatives contracts if you
- 1:06:54will or swap agreements between counterparties.
- 1:06:58One leg pays fed funds overnight over the term of the contract,
- 1:07:03the other pays a fixed rate. That rate is coming in
- 1:07:05massively. It's it's way inside of fed
- 1:07:08funds now. It's been plummeting since
- 1:07:10September and it's following the two year.
- 1:07:13And you know. The lower duration or maturity
- 1:07:17coupon treasury bonds like they're coming in, you see the
- 1:07:21six month bill auction, you know over the last three weeks and
- 1:07:25December has come in about 25 BPS which is like that's the
- 1:07:29equivalent of one rate cut, right.
- 1:07:31And then you've seen sulphur turbulence pop up like it's not
- 1:07:35Q 3/20/19 by any means yet, but you're starting to see silver
- 1:07:38spikes as we the system starts moving from an excess cash phase
- 1:07:44position to like now we have an excess collateral.
- 1:07:46So it's kind of as Nick Bhatia described it, he had the best
- 1:07:49analogy here. We're going to run out of pawn
- 1:07:52shops who are who are willing to to lend dollars into the system
- 1:07:56like there's too much collateral, not enough dollars
- 1:07:58available for for short term financing.
- 1:08:00So and then on top of that these quarterly refunding
- 1:08:03announcements to where you see where the treasury issues coupon
- 1:08:05bonds like 2 year, three or five year debt that's spiking up.
- 1:08:09So the treasury is reallocating its supply into the 235 year
- 1:08:14type coupon auctions. And so that's bottomed which has
- 1:08:19over the course of you know 4 decades kind of signaled the the
- 1:08:24top of a of a rate hike cycle. And from a borrower standpoint
- 1:08:27that makes sense, right. You wanna start deploying in as
- 1:08:31as raising more more debt there and extending a little bit out
- 1:08:37as rates start to come in. So as far as equity markets, I
- 1:08:40have no idea. Like I, I don't know like as
- 1:08:43just here trying to tell you is this risky here, is this, you
- 1:08:45know, double top, whatever, I no idea.
- 1:08:47But where you can actually build some sort of foundation and get
- 1:08:50your bearings like find a compass, like look to the
- 1:08:53interest rate markets. And then from there I try to
- 1:08:55build up my, you know, my thesis or positioning if you will on
- 1:09:00what's going to happen off of those things too.
- 1:09:02So take it from there, but we get into the meat of the topic.
- 1:09:07So the the Treasury shifting towards dead on the shorter part
- 1:09:14of the curve, they're basically assuming like all right, we'll
- 1:09:16lock in high, high rates for 2-3, five years with the
- 1:09:19assumption that rates will come down and then we can issue
- 1:09:21longer data bonds at. Lower rates, it's, it's, it's, I
- 1:09:25mean it's kind of the opposite. It's like they they're they're
- 1:09:28showing they're going to borrow more there because they see
- 1:09:30rates coming down and that's the signal.
- 1:09:33It's like we're going to start stepping that up because we need
- 1:09:35like rates need to come down, OK.
- 1:09:38And then what? That's gonna do too.
- 1:09:40I mean, we've seen there's all these treasuries out there with
- 1:09:42like massive mark to market losses.
- 1:09:45But as rates come in, I have no idea what's gonna happen to the
- 1:09:48long end. Rates like that may stay.
- 1:09:50You. Know relative ballpark you know
- 1:09:52we're at roughly 4% now we were at like like we were hitting
- 1:09:56five right back at the end of September, long end may still
- 1:10:02stay volatile like we you know base case right now probably
- 1:10:08don't expect to see the long like the long bond coming into
- 1:10:11like 1.25 like where it was at the lowest of 2020.
- 1:10:17I don't think the long end investor at this point like
- 1:10:20trusts the that to like a 30 year debt instrument at 2% from
- 1:10:26the US Treasury to be able to maintain purchasing power like
- 1:10:28that bridge has been crossed. They've taken too many losses
- 1:10:31going to that island they're not going to do it again and and and
- 1:10:35bid that thing to 1.25 like it maybe that happens if it's like
- 1:10:39absolute panic like we get a something worse than COVID at
- 1:10:43the bottom of this credit cycle. But I think the the lessons
- 1:10:47learned and the pain inflicted like I don't see it going there
- 1:10:49again now where front end rates come in and they they you know
- 1:10:55base case they do come in. I don't know how far they go,
- 1:10:58but this whole effect like it's going to make all of the debt
- 1:11:02they issued in 2022-2023 at these higher rates that's going
- 1:11:07to kind of pull up their balance sheet capacity and it's going to
- 1:11:12kind of pull in a lot like let's say you had a five year bond
- 1:11:15issued in 2029 that's a 2025 maturity.
- 1:11:18A treasury it was just due that like 0 basically took massive
- 1:11:23losses in in 2022 and 2023 but now it's kind of pulling to par
- 1:11:28and those and then the rates are going to come in as well.
- 1:11:32So you're going to get more kind of buoying on the bank balance
- 1:11:35sheets and the financial system balance sheets so that you know
- 1:11:38expect that you know base case to create more capacity for more
- 1:11:43credit creation and we have you know some continuation.
- 1:11:46It's going to be weird. We talked about all this kind of
- 1:11:48strange new stuff in AI and commercial real estate, all of
- 1:11:52these dynamics that the system has to deal with.
- 1:11:55But as we go through this cycle like they're going to have some
- 1:11:57capacity to to try to absorb all of those things that they need
- 1:12:01to to tackle. But I'd say this like this is
- 1:12:05going to be like their their, their menu, like what's on
- 1:12:10their, their plate. If you're like a lender or if
- 1:12:12you're at the US Treasury or you know one of the key players in
- 1:12:15their system, I think your, your, your docket of work is
- 1:12:19like harder than most, if not all of the cycles.
- 1:12:23Maybe not 2000. 2008 was like, really hard to deal with.
- 1:12:27But this one's gonna be more of a challenge, I think, in terms
- 1:12:30of like the lineup of what you have to go through if you're
- 1:12:32sitting at one of these desks. Yeah, in the cycle ahead.
- 1:12:36Trying to keep the Rube Goldberg machine.
- 1:12:40Yeah. Absolutely.
- 1:12:42We'll create another four letter acronym and you know, problem
- 1:12:44solved, right? Well, that's another interesting
- 1:12:48thing to look out for in 2024. That's what they do with BTFP in
- 1:12:53a few months here, that's. That's coming up on renewal and
- 1:12:57another interesting impact there like it's based on this one year
- 1:13:00overnight index swap rate and that's come in like massively.
- 1:13:06So you can go and post your one of your 15 different government
- 1:13:10agency bonds that are allowed on the list of collateral that they
- 1:13:13accept. You.
- 1:13:15Can post it take out a loan now on a rate that's come in a lot
- 1:13:19like it's sitting at you know something like with A4 handle
- 1:13:22and you can go redeploy that into another interest bearing
- 1:13:27instrument earning. You know still you can get five
- 1:13:29somewhere say whatever, but there's just a lot of that, a
- 1:13:33lot of that BTFP borrowing is just kind of balance sheet
- 1:13:36arbitrage to pick up free money right now.
- 1:13:39But I think in the months ahead, like if there are real problems
- 1:13:42and you know what we're talking about the loans that are
- 1:13:46underwater impaired that need some sort of work out, expect
- 1:13:50that as we come into mid March to to start to become more of a
- 1:13:54bigger issue is that that that needs attention.
- 1:13:57Does that continue as some sort of perpetual facility or do
- 1:14:00they, you know, close it down? What not, do they roll it over
- 1:14:04something that we're gonna need to see a resolution on?
- 1:14:07Yeah. It's interesting.
- 1:14:08When you issue these new four letter facilities, it creates
- 1:14:12these R plays that were probably unforeseen at the outset that
- 1:14:16have externalities of their own that you have to deal with on
- 1:14:20the back end. Yep.
- 1:14:22Yep. It's all I'm just thinking again
- 1:14:29Rube Goldberg machine that's what it seems like and they're
- 1:14:32scrambling to keep it all together.
- 1:14:34Can they We will see. They've proven to be able to do
- 1:14:37it up to this point. But with that in mind
- 1:14:42transitioning towards last couple topics that we have for
- 1:14:46the episode we're going to end on the ETF.
- 1:14:48Before we get to that stepping stone to that, there was an
- 1:14:50article out in Bloomberg when it dropped dropped January 4th.
- 1:14:59Today this morning city alumni plan Bitcoin securities that
- 1:15:02don't need SEC approval. So the new offering called
- 1:15:06Bitcoin Depository Receipts will be similar to American
- 1:15:09Depository Receipts that represent foreign stocks.
- 1:15:12A start up called Receipts Depository Corporation, Very
- 1:15:16Creative or RDC set of plans to issue the first Bitcoin
- 1:15:19depository receipts to qualify global institutional investors
- 1:15:22and transactions exempt from registration under the
- 1:15:25Securities Act of 1933. Known as BTCDRS, the offering
- 1:15:30will give institutions access to Bitcoin securities through US
- 1:15:33regulated market infrastructure and cleared through the
- 1:15:37Depository Trust Co, according to a release from the company.
- 1:15:41So right before an apparent imminent approval of the Bitcoin
- 1:15:46ETFs, the SPOT ETFs and a group of city alumni are launching
- 1:15:53this Depository Receipts product.
- 1:15:57I've never heard of these products.
- 1:15:58How do they work so? It's a great, great summary
- 1:16:02there, Marty. It's kind of fills in a few kind
- 1:16:06of gaps on my map on understanding what this thing
- 1:16:09was. But I heard a couple keywords
- 1:16:11there, global institutions. So this is going to be U.S.
- 1:16:13financial institutions selling this product.
- 1:16:17And then I was like who is the customer here?
- 1:16:19It says it says global, so it'd probably be X like outside the
- 1:16:22United States, offshore entities.
- 1:16:26So if you think about who does this benefit, right, you're
- 1:16:29getting private keys, you know, the UTXOS, the the, the Bitcoin.
- 1:16:33It sounds like right now is, is DTCC cleared.
- 1:16:37The Bitcoin is going to be to be, you know, custodied.
- 1:16:41You know what do you call its home?
- 1:16:42It's going to be US domicile is is my understanding here.
- 1:16:46So you get the US capital markets, all the rule of law,
- 1:16:49everything that benefits investors and why besides the
- 1:16:52economic growth and we can talk about the bullish case for this
- 1:16:55country, everything we have going for us like within the
- 1:16:58positive column you get those benefits in terms of capital
- 1:17:03markets and the United States has kind of the most well
- 1:17:07structured robust capital markets I would say in the in
- 1:17:11the world. You know you have a lot of
- 1:17:12competition from London, Tokyo, Singapore etcetera.
- 1:17:15But this is still where global capital wants to allocate.
- 1:17:18So I think that's where this product is and part of the theme
- 1:17:22as we get into the Bitcoin ETF and what this means like we can
- 1:17:25talk about the cash settlement. I my read on this is the big
- 1:17:32capital markets players are are they're they're awake and they
- 1:17:38want to see the the real capital stock.
- 1:17:41And at this point, you know, maybe they're not all convinced
- 1:17:43that Bitcoin is the real capital stock.
- 1:17:47Jesse, was this before we were talking or during the interview
- 1:17:51you talked about the shift from kind of a financialized economy
- 1:17:54into like a capital economy. I think that's what this is.
- 1:17:57You want the UTXOS fitting within the borders of your
- 1:18:02nation state. So I think this is, you talk
- 1:18:05about the the ETF, these 13 ETFs that are looking for the
- 1:18:09approval window to come through. I think this is part of that
- 1:18:13theme like this is going to become more and more pressing of
- 1:18:16a challenge as more and more nation states enter the game.
- 1:18:18Marty, you've done a great job talking about this you know and
- 1:18:21the and the follow-ups to El Salvador going first and 2021.
- 1:18:28You know what you talked about with Bhutan, what you talked
- 1:18:30about with Oman, you know entering the mining game there
- 1:18:34been another one like UAE like there's there's other nations
- 1:18:37are. Getting at margin, yeah.
- 1:18:40Yes, I think they're real. I think you need the Bitcoin
- 1:18:43ETUTXOS inside your border if you want to actually have a a
- 1:18:48capital base inside of your society's economy.
- 1:18:55Jesse, thoughts on this? I I yeah I'm unfamiliar with the
- 1:18:59this type of instrument so I I I suppose it's it's like a clever
- 1:19:06way to have like a fund like vehicle but it's unclear to me
- 1:19:13what the like stipulations are in like redemption policies and
- 1:19:18and who knows what but yeah I think I think Matt is keying in
- 1:19:21on this seems like a a play for leveraging all the attractive
- 1:19:29qualities of of having a a structure in the US which is
- 1:19:34beneficial to to the US ultimately in this like in this
- 1:19:39race that people don't seem to know we're in of where it's
- 1:19:43going to be the the native home of Bitcoin.
- 1:19:46Hopefully it's in the US because that'll that'll be that'll be
- 1:19:50our our international advantage or add to our international
- 1:19:54advantages for the next century if if if we managed to achieve
- 1:19:58that. So thankfully capital markets
- 1:20:01are waking up to needing to set up this infrastructure because
- 1:20:06there's an opportunity for them to make money.
- 1:20:08But you know, I think it actually has this geopolitical
- 1:20:11advantages if if people earnestly pursue building
- 1:20:15Bitcoin infrastructure here. Thanks for tuning in.
- 1:20:19If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 1:20:21further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 1:20:25a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 1:20:28our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 1:20:32you on your Bitcoin journey. Yeah.
- 1:20:34It seems like, Matt, what you said, people at the
- 1:20:38institutional level are recognizing, all right, we need
- 1:20:40exposure to this. I think this product's pretty
- 1:20:43unique, particularly that you'll be able to track the UTXOS.
- 1:20:48They'll clear through DTC, which is interesting, an interesting
- 1:20:51development, which hasn't been brought to the fore until today.
- 1:20:56And then this tweet came out which signals that this trend is
- 1:21:00definitely growing by Mardi party breaking a pattern is
- 1:21:04emerging. Other funds registered as
- 1:21:05securities already trading on the NASDAQ are mending their
- 1:21:08prospectuses that they can now expose 15 to 50% of their AUM to
- 1:21:13Bitcoin through the spot Bitcoin ETFs.
- 1:21:17Here we see Advisor's preferred trust filer CIK 00015565 O Five
- 1:21:23can now hold 15% AUM spot Bitcoin through Grayscale GBT
- 1:21:28that would be there ETF. The fund may invest up to 50% of
- 1:21:31its total assets to indirectly gain exposure to Bitcoin through
- 1:21:35shares of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust Pro shares, Bitcoin
- 1:21:39Strategy ETF and Bitcoin Futures contracts.
- 1:21:45Don't need to read the one quadrillion.
- 1:21:48I love it at the. End But this is essentially like
- 1:21:51the amending of prospectuses to include Bitcoin into the buckets
- 1:21:55that they're mandates allow them to invest in.
- 1:21:58Yeah, people, people have been wondering like OK what?
- 1:22:01Who cares about the ETF? Like you can buy Bitcoin
- 1:22:04yourself. Like what does it matter?
- 1:22:07This is why it matters because the the ETFs create a a viable
- 1:22:12vehicle for funds to deploy a portion of their capital into
- 1:22:18Bitcoin exposure which results in in the ETFs having to buy
- 1:22:22Bitcoin to back that that capital.
- 1:22:27They have to you know they have to actually buy the Bitcoin.
- 1:22:30So this is how you know this is how I don't know who who's
- 1:22:34running this fund. It could be a small shop.
- 1:22:36It could be a medium sized shop or a big shop, but that sets a,
- 1:22:41you know, that's a precursor to what's coming I think of of
- 1:22:45every fund saying, oh shit, OK, we can't just have our usual
- 1:22:50strategy in in in this era where Bitcoin is monetizing.
- 1:22:55We need to add in another pillar to our investment strategy and
- 1:22:59have Bitcoin be part of our allocation.
- 1:23:02And then and then they're all going to amend their their terms
- 1:23:06like this and give themselves the flexibility to do that when
- 1:23:11when it's a bear market and you know, Bitcoin has drawn down
- 1:23:1470%, You know, maybe that happens three years from now
- 1:23:18from from a peak of 200,000 and we'll have another drawdown.
- 1:23:23And and then these funds that now have a vehicle, the ETFs
- 1:23:29that they can use and have amended their prospectuses can
- 1:23:34come in and say, all right, now is the moment we've been waiting
- 1:23:36for. Let's pile into Bitcoin.
- 1:23:39And now you know. Now you're talking about setting
- 1:23:41a setting the price floor three years from now in a bear market
- 1:23:45because Wall Street has woken up to this thing is going to keep
- 1:23:49happening. It's beautiful.
- 1:23:54Yeah, a couple weeks ago on the last turn, I can't remember
- 1:23:57which guest it was. We were talking about our
- 1:23:59commodity funds going to allocate in and it comes down to
- 1:24:04like a portfolio manager and the investment committee.
- 1:24:06Someone has to like recommend that that decision like it has
- 1:24:10to go through a process you don't just you know on a fund
- 1:24:15it's not like you you know hey I'm going to buy Bitcoin as an
- 1:24:17individual you're just like I'll just open a Coinbase account or
- 1:24:22whatever an Unchained account, let's go with that route or you
- 1:24:27know sign on with on ramp etcetera and make a decision
- 1:24:30like you've got to go through a process to get this done.
- 1:24:33But the reason you would do that is because I either want to buy
- 1:24:36or sell it like I I see the the market and at the end of the day
- 1:24:40we're all judged as a you know a fund manager on our on our
- 1:24:45portfolio returns against our peers, right.
- 1:24:48You want to get into the top of the category so someone sees you
- 1:24:52know whether they you you would make this decision to allocate
- 1:24:5615 to 1550% in long because you see that as you know a
- 1:25:01performance enhancer if you will like to get in front of that.
- 1:25:05So then you're looking at you know stepping in front of you
- 1:25:08know your peer group and hopefully generating excess
- 1:25:11returns. So as this, let's just say we
- 1:25:14have a Bitcoin bull market that we're in.
- 1:25:16We've already gone through I believe the first wave of it,
- 1:25:19but it's 2024 kind of you know proceeds and we work through
- 1:25:22this. You're going to see the
- 1:25:25portfolio managers and investment committees who make
- 1:25:29the right decision rewarded for it coming to the top of their
- 1:25:33peer group. And you know at the end of the
- 1:25:36day, this is all about capital returns.
- 1:25:38So, yeah, bullish case and this is just another capital route
- 1:25:42pulling in towards ultimately like buying UTXOS.
- 1:25:48Well said, Yeah. And that's and that's from you
- 1:25:51know you're you've been in that seat.
- 1:25:54So you know the incentives that are at play for every portfolio
- 1:25:57managers like how do I get an edge?
- 1:25:59How do I get a promotion because I've delivered performance And
- 1:26:04then here's this low hanging fruit.
- 1:26:07Yep. So here's here's a like a untold
- 1:26:09secret I think of the the fun fund industry.
- 1:26:13If you look at the big passive players, BlackRock, Vanguard,
- 1:26:18you know they're maybe you throw in like I don't know ATA Crab or
- 1:26:20like T Rowe Price or something in there.
- 1:26:21There's only like 3 or 4 who are growing as we've shifted like
- 1:26:26the the dominant paradigm since I'd say like 2000.
- 1:26:30Sometimes like you've seen active phasing out and you know
- 1:26:34they're just the shift, the capital shift like a lot of like
- 1:26:364 O1 KS, that constant monthly drift.
- 1:26:38Like you just have a, a a recurrent and consistent bid for
- 1:26:43passive. The active fund managers, you
- 1:26:47know Franklin Templeton are like predominantly active.
- 1:26:51They're actually not attracting capital inflows and it's it's
- 1:26:54been like since the QE era, since the GFC, you know it's
- 1:26:59like the entire twenty 10s their their AUM growth has been coming
- 1:27:04almost entirely from price return.
- 1:27:07And you know you think about why like QE happens that pushes
- 1:27:10financial assets up and they're not attracting inflows.
- 1:27:15So they see this this problem like how do I beat this bid for
- 1:27:20passive which is primarily coming into or manifesting
- 1:27:25through bidding up equities and and was until you know 2022
- 1:27:32bidding down bond yields or bidding up.
- 1:27:35Bond. Prices that's all started to
- 1:27:38shift in the last, I'd say 1218 months or so.
- 1:27:43But part of this ETF route I I believe is is you know searching
- 1:27:49out you know if you will that alpha, that performance etcetera
- 1:27:52so. You know, we'll we'll.
- 1:27:53See what happens. You know, I think everybody on
- 1:27:56on this, this panel is, is bullish on Bitcoin for 2024 and
- 1:28:01would be making the same decisions if they were in that
- 1:28:04seat. But this is one of those kind of
- 1:28:06strategic business decisions that you can make from from seat
- 1:28:09to seat from a fund like this and it's very hard to
- 1:28:14differentiate yourself from your from your peer group 15 to 15%
- 1:28:17like 50% is a massive allocation like if you're a multi asset
- 1:28:21manager and you're spreading between equities, bonds,
- 1:28:23whatever. I think I hope it works out for
- 1:28:25them like and they time the trades correctly.
- 1:28:29You know if they time it wrong they're going to bid it, they're
- 1:28:31going to buy it. Like buying at the top of a
- 1:28:33Bitcoin cycle right in front of that 85% drawdown can be
- 1:28:37devastating. So like what?
- 1:28:40But they wish them the best. Yeah but there's there's bound
- 1:28:43to be you know we there's a bunch of people on Wall Street
- 1:28:47who have been paying attention to Bitcoin and and have at least
- 1:28:50gotten down the rabbit hole enough now to be like OK the
- 1:28:53having this increasing scarcity thing that's happening pivot you
- 1:28:59know QE environment seems to also juice Bitcoin and and
- 1:29:05everybody's expecting that pivot and there's the ETFs.
- 1:29:10So like there's all these reasons to front run right now.
- 1:29:13So I don't like if I was, if I was a portfolio manager trying
- 1:29:16to like better my career, I would probably be willing to bet
- 1:29:21my career on Bitcoin having a big 18 months and.
- 1:29:24Maybe that's. What's going on with a few of
- 1:29:27them? Yeah.
- 1:29:28Do you think they're that sophisticated or like I think a
- 1:29:32like the concepts Jesse mentioned like I don't even
- 1:29:34think having we talked about 21 million, I think having in 21
- 1:29:38million probably there's 15 to 20%.
- 1:29:40But the question I was gonna ask is how much do you think micro I
- 1:29:43could see them looking at micro strategy instead of like that's
- 1:29:45interesting they. Could have already allocated
- 1:29:48most, most of them. It was probably within policy to
- 1:29:51allocate to a mid cap company like micro micro strategy or you
- 1:29:54know you got to catch that like time your trade well get your
- 1:29:58entry right, be there before you're buying into a bull off
- 1:30:02top. Otherwise if you like, if you
- 1:30:04have the right thesis but you're terrible at execution, like the
- 1:30:08results can be pretty bad from the the standpoint of like what
- 1:30:14can happen. So like I don't want to sound
- 1:30:18like I'm putting anyone down here this is not a negative
- 1:30:21here. But if you look at El Salvador's
- 1:30:23allocation into Bitcoin like you got to pat them on the back for
- 1:30:27making a bold move taking a big risk like going out there.
- 1:30:31But BK Lei like it was 3 weeks ago I think he published his
- 1:30:36trade botter if you will. I don't he didn't put the actual
- 1:30:39trades on, but he put the green dots on the line of Bitcoin
- 1:30:42price where he was increasing his allocation.
- 1:30:46They. Were buying the entire way down
- 1:30:49on you you know the last cycle they they they got in on the
- 1:30:53announcement at Bitcoin conference 2021 and we're just
- 1:30:56adding to lots on dips but you're buying into a market like
- 1:31:00into the lows but it's it's lower lows and lower highs.
- 1:31:05So what they're doing is like averaging down losers, average
- 1:31:08losers, sorry to be so that's I think it's a Paul Tudor Jones
- 1:31:13saying and what they what, how it actually played out in
- 1:31:17practice is they were like massively down and then they
- 1:31:22didn't increase their position into the bull market or into the
- 1:31:27like the bottom of the actual like cup and handle that's
- 1:31:30forming. They didn't have any buys after
- 1:31:32November 22. And two, as there were
- 1:31:34opportunities that you know increase your position size at a
- 1:31:38lower cost basis in a market that's now moving like it's
- 1:31:41trending up. And the net result was like from
- 1:31:45their holding period of like let's say June 2021 to December
- 1:31:482023, they got outperformed by T-bills.
- 1:31:52And so if you do that as a fund manager and I forget which
- 1:31:56ticker symbol this fund was, Marty.
- 1:31:59If you get. Your timing wrong here and these
- 1:32:02guys are starting from an allocation of 0.
- 1:32:04So all of the everything from 1517 K that we were at the end
- 1:32:09of last year to where we are now at 4045, Yeah, we think there's
- 1:32:12more bull run ahead, but they're going to be buying into the
- 1:32:16let's say second and third bull waves of a you know traditional
- 1:32:19bull market. And so the risk is you're buying
- 1:32:23into the like a blow off top and then you're going to be down
- 1:32:26and. A bunch of people will do that.
- 1:32:29They will. And and you're not in a seat
- 1:32:32like Nayabukele. I think he's got his seat kind
- 1:32:35of locked up. But if you're one of these
- 1:32:38portfolio managers and you put up a bad performance like you're
- 1:32:41you're going to get pulled off the off the basketball court or
- 1:32:44off the field and like you're going to be out of a job.
- 1:32:47So you can be right on the right asset class with this massive
- 1:32:50bull market over 15. Years.
- 1:32:53But because the volatility and the candles are so big, like you
- 1:32:57can really shoot yourself in the foot here if you don't know what
- 1:32:59you're doing. Funny enough, more people, more
- 1:33:02portfolio managers will get burned by this.
- 1:33:05Then we'll get promoted because of this.
- 1:33:07You know, the ones that add Bitcoin, the ability to add
- 1:33:11Bitcoin to their funds because people are going to buy the top
- 1:33:15because everybody's new to Bitcoin and everybody learns the
- 1:33:18hard way how this thing actually works.
- 1:33:21And the sharpest like you. Become wise six years later when
- 1:33:24you have already deployed all all your capital.
- 1:33:27Yeah. And the best in the business
- 1:33:29like and I'm not that like Paul Tudor Jones, like he was
- 1:33:31allocating him like a long time ago, like he's already front ran
- 1:33:37like the rest of our peer group in the position.
- 1:33:40So now you're working into the lower, like the middle of the
- 1:33:44stack or the bottom of the stack, and this is where this is
- 1:33:48where mistakes can get made. Yeah.
- 1:33:52Well, 12 months from now is when. 12 months from now, Yeah,
- 1:33:55right, right, right. Well, which begs the question,
- 1:34:01will these ETS be approved next week?
- 1:34:03And if so, how quickly will the capital flow into these assets
- 1:34:07in an attempt to take advantage of the gains that we think are
- 1:34:12ahead of us, not investment advice?
- 1:34:17Yeah, Michael, you've been a bit quiet.
- 1:34:19Continues to be yes they'll be approved.
- 1:34:24I think it's like 95% chance there's you got to allow some
- 1:34:28possibility of like a backroom you know lawmakers decide this
- 1:34:34is mission critical to the dollar and they're going to
- 1:34:37fight it through some shady last minute measure.
- 1:34:41But I think barring that it it goes through next next week and
- 1:34:47and it's a nothing burger for day one.
- 1:34:52Well, actually there, there will be volatility.
- 1:34:54It'll be like you know a Doji candle or it'll go up and down
- 1:34:59on day one That would be would be my bet lot of volatility but
- 1:35:02no real economic substance because no major capital inflows
- 1:35:09And so that you know the price of Bitcoin won't sustainably be
- 1:35:12impacted I think day one, week one, month one, quarter one.
- 1:35:18But and now that those channels are open for capital to flow
- 1:35:22into Bitcoin through those avenues that's very real and
- 1:35:26will be cumulative over time and will add to this to the demand
- 1:35:31side four months before the supply side of the equation gets
- 1:35:37cut in half. You know new supply issuance
- 1:35:40gets cut in half in April. And so I, you know, I think that
- 1:35:43the impact of the ETFs over the the next 18 months will be very
- 1:35:48large in terms of amplifying price discovery to the upside
- 1:35:52because it will increase demand, make it make it possible for a
- 1:35:56whole lot of capital to access Bitcoin during the bull market.
- 1:36:00And so that'll amplify things to the upside.
- 1:36:03But I think that people need to be prepared for complete
- 1:36:06disappointment in the first month in terms of like, oh, ETF
- 1:36:10was approved. It didn't seem to matter at all,
- 1:36:12but it will matter in a cumulative basis.
- 1:36:16Yeah, Matt, would love to hear kind of just what I'm already
- 1:36:19started with and like how big do you think this is?
- 1:36:21Like in reality, there's a lot of takes and, you know, buy the
- 1:36:24news, sell the news, bye, bye. You know, all the different.
- 1:36:27I'm curious, like what are your, you know, being in the markets
- 1:36:30and also being a bit being involved in Bitcoin, You feel
- 1:36:33like you have the best lens of like how big this actually is
- 1:36:36with all the institutions going to be marketing dollars?
- 1:36:38Yeah. OK.
- 1:36:40So just first point like the the event, like the sell, is it a
- 1:36:43sell the news talk to like a lot of trader types.
- 1:36:47We'll. Kind of pitch that which that's
- 1:36:50fine like as a long term holder into this allocation I think you
- 1:36:56actually you want that right. We haven't had any retracement
- 1:36:59in in three months like it and it's it's pretty that's a pretty
- 1:37:04long period you know across bitcoins history and and so like
- 1:37:10yeah, it'd be, it'd be great if you know the first let's say 4
- 1:37:12weeks, I get announces, it feels like a nothing burger and we get
- 1:37:15some drawdown that would be fantastic.
- 1:37:18I think it's actually needed a healthy 20% retracement.
- 1:37:22You know what, hopefully not a 50, but let's just see something
- 1:37:26like that happen. If it does materialize that way,
- 1:37:28great. But I think the case study like
- 1:37:31that to look at on what this means for opening up a public
- 1:37:34fund that's you know the it's the closest thing you can get to
- 1:37:40a UTXO Alex allocation in in an exchange traded fund type of
- 1:37:44vehicle. So now that that that's opened
- 1:37:46up. Yeah this is better than what
- 1:37:48the markets had before for what is in all intents and purposes
- 1:37:54like an inferior product actually owning the UTXOS
- 1:37:57yourself and like holding the keys.
- 1:37:58And we know that everybody on this call if you're listening to
- 1:38:02last trade and you're you're looking for on ramp solution for
- 1:38:07you know working towards that that that end end game but you
- 1:38:10need some hand holding up for up front too.
- 1:38:13It's like all right you you have those type of investors who
- 1:38:16realize a lot of the benefits of of global censorship resistant
- 1:38:22you know transparent immutable public Ledger money like that's
- 1:38:26what you need. But for a lot of people they
- 1:38:28don't realize they just need something that's going to be a
- 1:38:30store of value for their wealth accumulation over their lifetime
- 1:38:35whatnot and it needs to be in their portfolio somehow.
- 1:38:37So they're going to go the easy route whatever it means like
- 1:38:41it's just going to happen is this big.
- 1:38:45I think it's actually massive. I don't know I don't want to put
- 1:38:48numbers on it like you've had you know other podcasts where
- 1:38:52like they put out a price target like irrelevant case study this
- 1:38:58Invesco pro shares Bitcoin strategy ETF.
- 1:39:01It launched in October 2021 basically top ticked the the
- 1:39:07like the second wave of the the last bull cycle this bit O
- 1:39:13ticker symbol actually look what's going on there in that
- 1:39:16adoption you've seen all right it it underperforms Bitcoin by I
- 1:39:22think it's underperformed by 6%. So you have a fee drag like it
- 1:39:25charges 95 bits. So it's a pretty heavy cost like
- 1:39:28from an expense ratio standpoint across other fun category like
- 1:39:32it's it's peer group whatnot. And then you've also got the
- 1:39:37drag, it's not buy and hold UTXOS where you just park them
- 1:39:41and you know very little overhead.
- 1:39:43They're buying Bitcoin futures which you constantly have to
- 1:39:48roll and the the drag from that is you've got to actually roll
- 1:39:54over as your future is coming up on maturity.
- 1:39:57You don't want to actually hold it to cash settlement.
- 1:39:59Usually what you do is you'll sell out of it and then extend
- 1:40:01out and you'll roll it into let's say a a longer term future
- 1:40:04and then you just have to constantly water your garden
- 1:40:06there. That trade will typically cost
- 1:40:09you money in terms of drag just because when you roll in and buy
- 1:40:13the long like there's usually a price gap there on like the the
- 1:40:1812 month that you're rolling into is going to be priced
- 1:40:20higher than than the front end and then and then that's even
- 1:40:23after like. I think up to like 50% of that
- 1:40:27funds allocation is put into T-bills because you have to post
- 1:40:30those as collateral to leverage up and buy the futures.
- 1:40:33So even with T bill rates at multi decade highs like I think
- 1:40:38it's going back to like 2007. I think since you've you know
- 1:40:41that type of era pre GFC where you've seen front end rates hit
- 1:40:46the levels they are now, they're still underperforming by 6%.
- 1:40:49So it's an inferior product if you will.
- 1:40:50The only thing this Bito fund has going for it is it's it's an
- 1:40:54exchange traded liquid vehicle that like retail customers with
- 1:40:57their assets parked in a broker deal dealer can allocate into a
- 1:41:03Bitcoin exposure. Like everybody on this call
- 1:41:06would probably say like yeah, it's kind of Bitcoin, you're
- 1:41:09referencing the Bitcoin price, but it's not Bitcoin, it's not
- 1:41:12actually UTXO exposure. All that aside, if you look at
- 1:41:15share count for this fund through the bear market, it's
- 1:41:20increased 2X, it's doubled like they they seeded it with a
- 1:41:23billion dollars, market cap is up to 1.73 billion and that's
- 1:41:28after price return is dragging that down 40%, it's 2X the
- 1:41:32capital inflows and a bear market.
- 1:41:34So this ETF is telling you if you build it and this is like a
- 1:41:38terrible product in my opinion, people in like they're going to
- 1:41:42allocate in. So then what happens now if
- 1:41:45instead of futures and 50% treasuries, what happens now if
- 1:41:48you have that same value prop and now you've got UTXOS and to
- 1:41:53to to believe that it's going to be like a nothing burger over
- 1:41:57the longer term. Like let's say it's four weeks,
- 1:41:59it plays out as Jesse kind of envisioned there and it doesn't
- 1:42:04happen right away. And it actually the market moves
- 1:42:06the opposite of the way you'd expect like it's it's a
- 1:42:09retracement we're down. I don't think the fundamentals
- 1:42:13when you look at the case studies of of these other ETFs
- 1:42:16that are out there like you're going to get capital allocation
- 1:42:18in. And the other thing is like I
- 1:42:21can't remember when they launched the short version, so
- 1:42:23the Bito goes long futures. They.
- 1:42:26Launched another fund bit bit EBITI that is short the future.
- 1:42:30So it's like this is for people who want to short Bitcoin.
- 1:42:33It did not attract share count creation like capital's not
- 1:42:36flowing into it in a bear market where that one would have
- 1:42:39actually been up. They they, I think they actually
- 1:42:41got it out the gate after most of the draw downs and Bitcoin
- 1:42:45was actually done like it didn't launch until like end of your
- 1:42:48last year roughly right. So they like it's been Bitcoin's
- 1:42:52been on a bull like it's been up trending since.
- 1:42:56So the the end were like the interest in going short Bitcoin
- 1:43:00wasn't there. So I think it's it's pointing
- 1:43:03out this sign that there is a lot of demand that wants to come
- 1:43:07in through this channel, that wants to allocate in and belong
- 1:43:11Bitcoin exposure. Yeah, I don't think anybody's
- 1:43:14bullish enough other than maybe like other other than maybe
- 1:43:18caps, Caps, Odell, who's back. Yeah, I don't, I don't think.
- 1:43:22I think this is like the the chef's kiss on both sides of the
- 1:43:25market where you get fidelity Black Rock and everybody under
- 1:43:30the sun that looks as their Lord and savior kissing and saying
- 1:43:33this is the thing, everybody's been scared.
- 1:43:35They even thought it's for drug dealers and all all the things
- 1:43:38associated with it. And then you get the other
- 1:43:40chef's kiss, which is oh, and you buy this in the way that
- 1:43:42you're used to buying it. You don't have to go and send
- 1:43:44the wire to Coinbase. You don't have to do all these
- 1:43:46things. It's like what else?
- 1:43:47And if that is to be true what ends up happening is the thing
- 1:43:50we've all talked about is you don't need global adoption.
- 1:43:52You need one, two, 3%. The market penetration and the
- 1:43:55reflexivity of the asset does the rest.
- 1:43:58And now we're just off to the races and that's effectively
- 1:44:00what's what's going to happen. So I think it's by the news, by
- 1:44:02the Bitcoin, by everything. Like it's it's it only goes One
- 1:44:05Direction. The fund management industry
- 1:44:08loves this. Like if you look at all the ETFs
- 1:44:11out there, I don't know how many there are like I did, I did some
- 1:44:13analysis. Let's say there's 2000.
- 1:44:16Like if you try, if you segment them out by what they actually
- 1:44:20invest in like you have equity ETFs, you have fixed income ETFs
- 1:44:25and you have like the other most of it is equity and fixed income
- 1:44:28ETFs. Like if you look at the iShares
- 1:44:29suite, it's like we have LQD corporate bonds, we have an
- 1:44:33emerging market bonds, we have mortgage back like you did.
- 1:44:37They slice and dice the entire pie up and it's it's pretty much
- 1:44:40all saturated for like the segmentation like fixed income,
- 1:44:44like there's a couple of firms who's trying to do it a little
- 1:44:46bit more granular. They're like all right now we'll
- 1:44:48go corporate, we'll do the slice and dicing based on rating.
- 1:44:51So this is the AA one to three-year usig corporate bond,
- 1:44:59you know market or maybe they'll split it up like there's
- 1:45:00financials and there's non financials like they're trying
- 1:45:02to micro segment even more there.
- 1:45:04But for all intents and purposes like the equity slices like
- 1:45:08large cap, mid cap, small cap, emerging markets, domestic,
- 1:45:12you're like it's all been sliced and diced enough like it's
- 1:45:15pretty much maxed out. There's no like and and the
- 1:45:19industry you need gold plated records, right.
- 1:45:23You're looking for hits on the wall for.
- 1:45:25Oh yeah what does it say 8000 like that's worldwide.
- 1:45:29Yeah. So if you look at like New York
- 1:45:31Stock Exchange like the US like it's some fraction of that but
- 1:45:35it within equity and fixed income, there's honestly too
- 1:45:37many like we're beyond market saturation and equity and fixed
- 1:45:40income. So the ability to create more
- 1:45:41gold records like a billion, you need billion dollar AUM products
- 1:45:47that are like that's a that's a really profitable investment
- 1:45:51product for the financial services industry.
- 1:45:54Equity and fixed income are tapped out and then you get into
- 1:45:56like the alternatives, the multi assets, those are hard, right.
- 1:46:00It's it's really hard to go into like a distribution pipeline and
- 1:46:03say like you need to like come by our 6045 and it's like
- 1:46:07there's already a bunch of those too and they're like commodity
- 1:46:10funds. You've seen like go to the CBOE
- 1:46:15or CME and you look at every futures contract, you've seen
- 1:46:18those put into ETS now too you can go get gasoline like as a
- 1:46:21retail investor you got I need to buy like UGA gasoline in
- 1:46:25future. I need the oil fund like the US
- 1:46:27and like they've already done this like it's it's already just
- 1:46:30like covered ground like it's it's already saturated.
- 1:46:34But then the the rare bird that stands out in terms of AUM
- 1:46:39growth that what broke through and is generating a massive
- 1:46:43amount of revenue. It's been the GBTC like this,
- 1:46:47this over the counter or this weird you know like pink sheet
- 1:46:52what started out as turned into this massive hit product cash
- 1:46:56cow. And there is nothing else that
- 1:46:58looks like it in the data sample from like the economic
- 1:47:01perspective of of like a fund. So what they see here, like
- 1:47:06there's only what 13 asset managers who've gone out of like
- 1:47:1150, a hundred that have scale and matter.
- 1:47:13So the penetration of those that see it and want to make this
- 1:47:16play, it's not even fully kind of baked in that all of them are
- 1:47:20going for at once. But at this point like 13 of
- 1:47:23them are. So they see the economics that
- 1:47:26hit product and this is where there's too much money to be
- 1:47:29made. You, you, you've got the Wall
- 1:47:32Street players who are now going to be communicating to
- 1:47:35regulators and you know, Washington, DC and like, I want
- 1:47:38to see this happen because we can make a lot of money.
- 1:47:42Yeah. And that's actually a great call
- 1:47:44because that's on the institutional level.
- 1:47:45There's the RRIA side as well. When Matt references like tapped
- 1:47:49out on flows is like the goal of RA is to bring in assets back
- 1:47:52into you know their clients. They're managing, bringing more
- 1:47:55and more capital. So they'll bring new funds, new
- 1:47:58products to the clients and hey, are you interested.
- 1:48:00And the idea is not to move over assets from existing positions
- 1:48:03within the portfolio that they're managing, but to bring
- 1:48:06net new assets selling that property.
- 1:48:08So you know whatever that sits outside of the Ras purview and
- 1:48:12now you have this like fund whether it's the ET, the
- 1:48:14BlackRock ETF fidelities where you can basically say, hey now
- 1:48:17you can pull in net new assets. And then once it starts to be
- 1:48:20recognized that this thing absolutely actually juices your
- 1:48:23AUM and overall percentage, you can bill on.
- 1:48:26That's a whole other side of liquidity from individual high
- 1:48:29net worth investors that will get plugged in this And Ras
- 1:48:33haven't been incentivized to do this because there hasn't been
- 1:48:35any kind of product that they can actually feel good about,
- 1:48:38let alone you know get that that that chef's kiss again.
- 1:48:42So, yeah, I think there's just no shortage of little pockets of
- 1:48:45or large pockets of capital that start to feed into this as this
- 1:48:49thing gets announced. Sorry, you're saying that Suzu
- 1:48:52was just two years too early. The Super cycle is upon us.
- 1:48:57Wait, wait, Marty, how how do you feel about the ETF?
- 1:49:03I'll take the contrarian view and Jesse reference it.
- 1:49:06I would not be surprised if the Treasury Department comes out
- 1:49:09Sunday night with an emergency statement that Bitcoin is a
- 1:49:12systemic risk to our national security and financial system.
- 1:49:16Max Kaiser just tweeted that. Did you see that?
- 1:49:19I tweeted out last night he was talking.
- 1:49:20He just tweeted. Something similar about
- 1:49:23basically saying ETF is going to be.
- 1:49:25I don't even know how true this is, just what a tweet came out.
- 1:49:28It was like a delay because of self custody rules or whatever.
- 1:49:32I would not be surprised. I don't think that's going to
- 1:49:34happen. I think it's like 95% chance
- 1:49:35that it gets approved, but the mental preparation I'm going
- 1:49:39through right now is preparing for some disappointment late
- 1:49:44Sunday night a a Ninja launch of a Treasury statement.
- 1:49:50For the audience just to like you know, it's like Marty and
- 1:49:52Jesse have been around in this space for for a very long time
- 1:49:55and what what you do when you've been around long you you
- 1:49:57basically hedge your your excitement and all the things.
- 1:50:00So that is where they're coming from and and I was going to
- 1:50:03share that and Marty saved you for me.
- 1:50:04He's like well you know I'm just parrying my excitement the the
- 1:50:07you know you always want to be prepared for the downside
- 1:50:09because this happened and and basically to everyone here and
- 1:50:12probably a lot of people listening 2021-2022, we thought
- 1:50:16this thing was doing you know crazy numbers and I think we
- 1:50:19were just a like to your point about Suzie I think we were a
- 1:50:21little early it was just a little like you know Wall Street
- 1:50:24said no no we gotta we gotta wipe the floor with you guys and
- 1:50:26you know get our our spots set up first before we can let this
- 1:50:30thing really run. And I think that's what
- 1:50:32effectively happened the past 18 months and now we're we're on
- 1:50:36the precipice of go time. Yeah, I think they're they're.
- 1:50:39Maced. Oh God, I was.
- 1:50:41Gonna say if I'm being like I I think we'll see go time but you
- 1:50:44like you mentioned you've been around the block.
- 1:50:46So wait, which is it? Is it a big deal or?
- 1:50:49Not, I think it's obviously a big deal.
- 1:50:50I mean, I think like Matt said many times like you should.
- 1:50:56It's much easier to get direct exposure to Bitcoin.
- 1:51:00Maybe it's not easier, but I think it's worthwhile and that's
- 1:51:03what you should do. The longer you've been in
- 1:51:06Bitcoin, the harder it is to get excited about this.
- 1:51:08Marty's been around longer than me.
- 1:51:10He's he's less excited than I am.
- 1:51:12But. Then you go full circle like
- 1:51:13Matt's 10 years, and then you just go insane at the bat.
- 1:51:16Yeah, he now, he's just ready. He's ready for.
- 1:51:17That's that's the goal is to not go insane, and tempering
- 1:51:21expectations is a good way to do that to prevent that insanity
- 1:51:26from but. At the end of the day, the oh,
- 1:51:29go ahead. After 10 years of of every ETF
- 1:51:32filing being denied and everybody like losing faith that
- 1:51:37it would ever happen, it it really does appear to be a week
- 1:51:40away now. Yeah, and a retracement would be
- 1:51:45nice and healthy for Bitcoin over the long term.
- 1:51:49I think like this whatever executive order or whatever this
- 1:51:52Sunday night scenario at the end of the day you're looking at a
- 1:51:57sovereign you know balance sheet of treasury like it's it we need
- 1:52:03answers like to the to the problem that we're in like the
- 1:52:08the fiscal position of the United States like it's you
- 1:52:11know, hopefully we're not past the Rubicon at this point.
- 1:52:14We may be, but you know where I'm going out here.
- 1:52:18Treasury needs, Wall Street's help, like Treasury needs,
- 1:52:21capital markets help at the end of the day to finance itself, to
- 1:52:24keep society running, to keep the goods and services flow like
- 1:52:27to keep to to keep the, you know, the country running if you
- 1:52:33will. So you're looking for solutions
- 1:52:37and ultimately like you can't just you could try this but just
- 1:52:42hammer hammer it down by a dig like you're not doing this.
- 1:52:45But at the end of the day the economics need to need to
- 1:52:48prevail like capital markets that's that's what it's all
- 1:52:51about. It's resources finding their
- 1:52:52highest and best use efficiency etcetera.
- 1:52:55And if you don't follow those signals and where where you know
- 1:53:00returns happen, like ultimately like you're just going to run
- 1:53:03into a problem like continue the direction of where this problem
- 1:53:06is leading us where we're just eating our seed corn going
- 1:53:10deeper and deeper into debt and the whole thing won't work.
- 1:53:14So that you got to play along if you're Washington DC, if you're
- 1:53:18Wall Street, if you're London, well like whoever like you just
- 1:53:22at the end of the day if this thing works, you're going to
- 1:53:23need to align and and come on board.
- 1:53:25And I think with the big name like the, the big players in the
- 1:53:29industry like you're seeing that like we talked about when I was
- 1:53:32on in last June, like these signals you were saying like the
- 1:53:36key personnel from like Citadel or had like just big name hedge
- 1:53:40funds like Bretton, Brevan, Howard, setting up the market,
- 1:53:43making desks in US and in England etcetera like Edx and
- 1:53:50Elwood Technologies. The signs were there that the
- 1:53:52capital players like they wanted to go here because at the end of
- 1:53:56the day they need growth like their income statements, their
- 1:53:58balance sheets, they have to work too.
- 1:54:00Otherwise if their balance sheets are unhealthy, like
- 1:54:03Treasury's fiscal position is not going to get any better.
- 1:54:07So at the end of the day, like, everybody's going to respond to
- 1:54:09incentives. Like once they come around and,
- 1:54:12you know, a lot of times we take these feared paths that, you
- 1:54:15know, run straight onto a, you know, run our heads into a brick
- 1:54:19wall, It's like, oh, that didn't work, but you got to, you got to
- 1:54:22find actual solutions that that work.
- 1:54:24So yeah, even if it's a Sunday night, you know, edict, whatnot
- 1:54:30coming down, like over the long term, you got to, you just got
- 1:54:36to flow with where the water is going and you got to fix the
- 1:54:38problem. Yeah.
- 1:54:40And they're and they're smart like we we talked about it
- 1:54:42before the show started the Hong Kong ETF and close to approval
- 1:54:47there and then we see what's happening in the Middle East
- 1:54:49region and like Dubai and like the capital's gonna flow to to
- 1:54:53Matt's point in one in a direction whether it's approved
- 1:54:55here somewhere else. So there's game theory behind a
- 1:54:58lot of this as well, where this is gonna get approved.
- 1:55:01Yeah, and the, I mean the incitement for me to send that
- 1:55:04tweet out to mentioned here today with Kim Parker and I got
- 1:55:07lunch yesterday. I was asking his opinions, and
- 1:55:10if you just juxtapose the imminent approval with
- 1:55:14everything the Treasury, Elizabeth Warren, the bank
- 1:55:16executives have said over the last few months, like it just
- 1:55:19doesn't, just doesn't align. And I completely agree, like if
- 1:55:25these people were smart, they would let the capital flow to
- 1:55:28where it wants to go. But I think this administration
- 1:55:31particularly has proven that they're not too wise.
- 1:55:33And that's why I put at least a 5% chance on a Ninja Treasury
- 1:55:38statement at some point over the weekend to try to stomp this
- 1:55:41out. I don't I think it's unlikely
- 1:55:44but I I do think it's a / 0 probability.
- 1:55:48And just to highlight the numbers that you were alluding
- 1:55:52to Matt, I I've heard about this last night in the bent trying to
- 1:55:55put you should mention yesterday was January 3rd 2020 four 15th
- 1:56:00anniversary of the Genesis block being mines were 15 years into
- 1:56:04Bitcoin. I took the opportunity to put
- 1:56:06this 15 years into perspective, particularly from the US
- 1:56:10monetary base and federal debt situation.
- 1:56:13If you zoom down Logan right below this chart, the the next
- 1:56:19chart like this paragraph here, it's actually pretty crazy If
- 1:56:21you go down a little bit, if you look at the ratios of like M2 to
- 1:56:27federal debt over the 15 years that Bitcoin has existed.
- 1:56:31So in January 2009 the ratio of national debt to the M2 money
- 1:56:35stock was 1.29. We did $10.7 trillion in debt to
- 1:56:398.3 trillion in M2. Today that ratio is ballooned to
- 1:56:431.6334 trillion debt to 20.8 trillion in M2.
- 1:56:49And as our friend Parker Lewis likes to say, there simply is
- 1:56:51too much debt and not enough dollars to service that debt.
- 1:56:54And this becoming clear and clearer by the day.
- 1:56:57Go down there was like this is like the astonishing set to me.
- 1:57:03Or go up between the two charts. I think I put it in.
- 1:57:09Let me see. I'm sorry.
- 1:57:10Yeah. So put another way, 68% of the
- 1:57:12debt that this country's accrued over the last 248 years was
- 1:57:15added over the last 15 years or 6% of the country's lifetime.
- 1:57:19Like, that's mind boggling. It took 233 years to go from
- 1:57:24zero to 10 trillion. It's taken 1510.7 trillion taken
- 1:57:2815 years ago from 10.7 to 34.1. Where we stand today is that 68%
- 1:57:35of the debt that the United States has accrued since we
- 1:57:38declared our independence in 1776 has been accrued in the
- 1:57:42last 15 years since Bitcoin launched I.
- 1:57:47Was gonna ask about the you referenced some of the like
- 1:57:53politicians and Jamie Dimon came to mind about like some of the
- 1:57:56the comment team made and then finding out they're an
- 1:57:59authorized participant. Matt I'd be curious like, 'cause
- 1:58:03this is like A2 Fer. I know we've gone pretty long is
- 1:58:07explaining or sharing what do you think's going on with like a
- 1:58:10Jamie Dimon insane, like talking out two sides of his mouth
- 1:58:13effectively. But then also kind of going into
- 1:58:17the minutiae of like the cash crates and like what they where
- 1:58:20the authorized participants sit and how these ETFs are going to
- 1:58:22like work in practice. Because I think that's been a
- 1:58:23big topic. And I think all the ETFs that
- 1:58:26are gonna be approved are all cash creates or redeems.
- 1:58:29And just walking through that I think would be be helpful for
- 1:58:32us, but also the the listeners. That is still here, he's just
- 1:58:36checking checking a text message.
- 1:58:38OK. We lost Jesse.
- 1:58:41We'll use this. We used this opportunity now
- 1:58:44because he's still in the stream.
- 1:58:46OK, we we'll use this opportunity to to let you guys
- 1:58:50know that Jesse just Irish exited on us.
- 1:58:52He had to leave to take on other obligations, but we're still
- 1:58:58here and Matt is back. Did am I back?
- 1:59:02Good. Yeah, I know a call just came
- 1:59:04in. I had a red button.
- 1:59:05But then, yeah, the app, it was hard to get audio back on.
- 1:59:09Can you guys hear me? Yes, Sir.
- 1:59:12OK. So, yeah, Chase coming in as an
- 1:59:18authorized participant, there's not all that much business
- 1:59:22impact there. I mean it's just like the the
- 1:59:25ability to create or like increase or decrease share count
- 1:59:28on the Ledger and a lot of parties can do that.
- 1:59:32What that effectively means is like how how the structure of
- 1:59:35the ETF actually plays out. So you have the share count
- 1:59:37right and the way that like the the retail investor or like you
- 1:59:42know the brokerage customers will allocate into shares,
- 1:59:46they'll just buy and sell through their through their
- 1:59:47brokerage. One of the key things like
- 1:59:51that's going to differentiate the 13 ATS is going to be
- 1:59:54liquidity like they need to get their bid ask spreads down to a
- 1:59:57penny and that'll that'll be an early signal on who's which of
- 2:00:02these 13 firms are, are winning, right.
- 2:00:04Because they're not all going to be winners like in a in a in an
- 2:00:08industry or a kind of like niche where they're not competing on
- 2:00:14anything other than expense ratio and you know maybe
- 2:00:17liquidity. Under the hood you could be like
- 2:00:20as like which ones are rehypoticating, which ones are
- 2:00:22not. But that won't be apparent to
- 2:00:24investors on day one. They won't, They probably won't
- 2:00:27be thinking about that. It'll just be those two up in
- 2:00:30front features if you will AUM two like that you won't allocate
- 2:00:37into a fund that's only got 10,000,050 million, 100,000,001
- 2:00:41with like on its market that's where size begets more size.
- 2:00:49So I'd say those those 3 dynamics will be like the
- 2:00:51primary if you're going to allocate and that'll be your
- 2:00:53choice on who you buy from or it might be you also have an
- 2:00:57existing relationship with like let's say BlackRock, your
- 2:01:00pension plan, you you like. BlackRock is kind of your
- 2:01:03consultant or advisor on your multi asset allocation.
- 2:01:07If they come in and recommend to your investment committee or
- 2:01:09your board, it's like hey buy this buy our IBIT ETF right for
- 2:01:14your Bitcoin allocation that will steer in clients from there
- 2:01:19but how do you get there right to out compete the other 12
- 2:01:23offerings or you know it could be more as other firms realize
- 2:01:26it's like oh hey black rock's having success.
- 2:01:28If I'm Vanguard, you know I can claim you know and stick by my
- 2:01:32my kind of logic on my mass like we're value investors or our
- 2:01:37thesis is just on the market how to play and that's it.
- 2:01:42We're not going to go in well, there's going to be business
- 2:01:45that you're losing and giving up because of that.
- 2:01:47So it will, it will come into play.
- 2:01:52But as far as like the cash creates go, they're all going to
- 2:01:55be sorry, they're all going to be cash settled for create
- 2:01:58redeems. There's not going to be any in
- 2:02:01kind redemptions. The prospectus for for BlackRock
- 2:02:03now reads it says we may if they can obtain regulatory approval
- 2:02:09add on in kind creation redemptions in the future but
- 2:02:13that's off the table for now. So what does that actually like
- 2:02:17amount to at the end of the day like if you had had in kind cash
- 2:02:21creates and you're an authorized participant, what you could do
- 2:02:25is trade Bitcoin for shares and that opens up another arbitrage
- 2:02:30route for you as a capital markets desk.
- 2:02:32What do I mean by that? Let's say that the share price
- 2:02:36of IBIT shares or whatever ETF is above the NAV, like you're
- 2:02:44still going to be able to arbitrage that that out.
- 2:02:46Like you see that with every ETF these like the market makers and
- 2:02:50APS they're always trying to to whittle away the arbitrage
- 2:02:55between the the underlying assets and like let's say the
- 2:02:57number of like the UTXO count per share and then the market
- 2:03:00price of that. Like they will still engage in
- 2:03:02those shares or in in that level of arbitrage.
- 2:03:06But there won't be the ability like if you're Chase you're
- 2:03:09involved with markets across the world like every asset class not
- 2:03:13just equity fixed income. Like at this point you're in
- 2:03:15commodities markets like there you've seen headlines in 2023
- 2:03:19about how JP Morgan got spoofed on a nickel delivery and I think
- 2:03:24it was Europe and there's just like rocks in the in in the on
- 2:03:29the pallets or packed in the pallets on the delivery on the
- 2:03:31delivery that we're supposed on physical settle that we're
- 2:03:34supposed to be nickel. But it turns out like yeah you
- 2:03:37got hoodwinked. But in that landscape your
- 2:03:40capital markets desk is can try to arbitrage like if you think
- 2:03:44about it through Bitcoin what is the cheapest way to to acquire a
- 2:03:50UTXO like traditionally so far it's been you use stranded
- 2:03:56energy right. You set up a mining operation
- 2:03:58and you mine Bitcoin and you find the lowest cost to to to
- 2:04:03produce you know one Bitcoin and whatnot and and you sell that in
- 2:04:09the market and that's your profit margin as a producer.
- 2:04:11Now if you had had in kind creation redemption, what you
- 2:04:15could do is set up a series of arbitrage trades like down to
- 2:04:19verticalizing like down to the studs, the energy resource and
- 2:04:23the ASICS and and the foreign exchange cross-border capital
- 2:04:28where you could arbitrage like all the way down the value chain
- 2:04:32and and and get all of the profit from you know basically 0
- 2:04:39up to spot price of of UTXOS. The, the reason to like the
- 2:04:44demand coming in the inflows like the bid for for these
- 2:04:48Bitcoin ETFs that enables that as well.
- 2:04:51So the capital, the more capital you get on the demand side
- 2:04:53coming in through that route the better off you'll be in terms of
- 2:04:58being able to capture as much of that spread between your ability
- 2:05:00to produce the, the raw commodity and that price you
- 2:05:03could sell it at. That's not going to happen right
- 2:05:06now. Like that's not getting
- 2:05:07approved. And the reason is like the
- 2:05:10regulators see like the the that whole market is not ready right.
- 2:05:15Like when you look at energy cross-border like cross-border
- 2:05:18commodity trade like it's still as much as capital markets have
- 2:05:23kind of progressed over this 40 year bull market era.
- 2:05:26In our lifetimes, like we're in the most financialized economy
- 2:05:30that's probably ever existed, there's still a lot of just cut
- 2:05:36corners, you know? Booby.
- 2:05:39Traps that can get you in the commodities trade, you know
- 2:05:41those type of trades that even, you know materialize in like the
- 2:05:45biggest financial institution in the world, JP Morgan Chase can
- 2:05:49get hoodwinked on on a commodity trade.
- 2:05:51So it's like it's clearly not there where we can where where
- 2:05:56regulators see that they can put that whole kind of or open up
- 2:06:00that whole mechanism where you're not just going to get
- 2:06:03some sort of just, I don't know what else to call it like other
- 2:06:07than like just breakdown, malfeasance, whatnot.
- 2:06:11So they they kind of realize they can't police it and they
- 2:06:15can't ensure integrity like if they open up that route.
- 2:06:18So at this point, what's the next best thing like, OK, we're
- 2:06:21just going to do the settlement, cash settlement.
- 2:06:24What that actually kind of boils down to the APS are just
- 2:06:27they're, they're cash processors.
- 2:06:29They don't actually ever touch Bitcoin, right?
- 2:06:31They're just taking in shares and they'll either kind of put
- 2:06:38them to the portfolio manager or the it's actually like the fund
- 2:06:41administrator or like they call it the transfer agent who will
- 2:06:44adjust the share count and they're just settling, settling
- 2:06:47cash where it actually comes into play.
- 2:06:51What it actually means is the the portfolio manager behind
- 2:06:55these funds is the only ones who's going to be making the
- 2:06:58actual Bitcoin to dollar transactions.
- 2:07:02And it means like basically they're they're not an active
- 2:07:05player. They're they're not timing
- 2:07:07price. They can't go out and just post
- 2:07:11bids and wait for the liquidity to come to them.
- 2:07:13Can't just post offers, wait for the liquidity to come that way.
- 2:07:16You know both ways they've got to every time they buy and sell,
- 2:07:20they're going to have to cross the bid ask like they're going
- 2:07:24to have to hit the bids, lift the offers.
- 2:07:26They're just completely passive players.
- 2:07:30So where the value actually flows in this case is to the
- 2:07:35spot market makers in UTXOS and dollars and that's where these
- 2:07:40headlines were talking about last June with all of these key
- 2:07:43personnel. It's like wow, they they opened
- 2:07:45up these market making desks and in Bitcoin and they they're also
- 2:07:49all coining or you know only use four letter words and call them
- 2:07:53what they are. They're also going to do that.
- 2:07:57But the Bitcoin USDA market is, is where the interest is and and
- 2:08:01tying that down and while all of the headlines like everybody was
- 2:08:05following ETSETSETSI think we were missing the kind of the
- 2:08:10forest for the trees on what was really going on.
- 2:08:13The capital markets desks were moving into market making on
- 2:08:18Bitcoin UTXOS and and dollars. So that's that's the that's the
- 2:08:22big deal. I think the the elephant in the
- 2:08:24room is I mean it it's it's ultimately good like you're
- 2:08:27going to have more liquidity in the Bitcoin markets more capital
- 2:08:30flowing in but it it's just I don't know it's it's it's
- 2:08:33changing like you're getting the the professionals involved in
- 2:08:36market making and and Bitcoin which is you think about this is
- 2:08:39where it needed to go like we had and you can say Binance CZ
- 2:08:44like they were you know Marty on RHR you you and Matt have talked
- 2:08:49about like CZS kind of a different breed than the FTI
- 2:08:51like he's been a bitcoiner or he's been in the space longer
- 2:08:56still made a lot of like short term decisions to go after you
- 2:09:02know the altcoins all that dumping on retail.
- 2:09:05But you saw the real kind of fly by nights come in I'd say like
- 2:09:10the between the 2017 cycle and the 2020 cycle where you saw
- 2:09:13like FT actually show up out of nowhere that's all been pulled
- 2:09:16away I think and you've seen like the big players now are
- 2:09:20going to enter the the market making space.
- 2:09:23So I think that's the that's the key tie in I think of what
- 2:09:27what's really happened or like the the main crux of it that I
- 2:09:31think a lot of us are missing. It's the the maturation if you
- 2:09:33will or the absorption and the legacy capital markets of of the
- 2:09:38the Bitcoin market making. And then also I think the other
- 2:09:42element we talked about this before is like where do the
- 2:09:45Bitcoin actually domicile and find their home.
- 2:09:47And I think the the nation states now have realized, you
- 2:09:51know we know at least some El Salvador, Bhutan, Oman, et
- 2:09:55cetera have disclosed publicly and made decisions that they're
- 2:10:00acquiring and holding Bitcoin on their balance sheets.
- 2:10:03But this is a play. I believe, without saying it out
- 2:10:07loud, that US capital markets are realizing the importance of
- 2:10:12having those UTXOS, the Bitcoin custody and domicile within
- 2:10:16within the United States. So.
- 2:10:19Because it's cash. Settled the Bitcoin can't be
- 2:10:21arbitraged. Like you cannot construct the
- 2:10:23trades to arbitrage. You know what we talked about
- 2:10:26it. If you wanted to let Bitcoin
- 2:10:31create redeems come in kind where those Bitcoin could just
- 2:10:34leave and and leave the country if they if they wanted to.
- 2:10:39Now they're kind of, they're contained, they're domiciled,
- 2:10:42they're they're going to be custody I believe with Bitcoin,
- 2:10:44with Coinbase. I think if I have that right,
- 2:10:48correct me if I'm wrong and then you know from there it's it's
- 2:10:54kind of a a Roach motel is the way this is set up.
- 2:10:59The Bitcoin aren't going to leave when there's a sell order,
- 2:11:02dollars go out the door. The actual Bitcoin that the
- 2:11:07portfolio manager at BlackRock or you know, Franklin Templeton
- 2:11:11or Invesco, whoever, they're going to sell the Bitcoin into
- 2:11:16the spot market and then it's going to live on the balance
- 2:11:20sheets of whoever their counterparties are, which is
- 2:11:22also US entities. So it really is a kind of
- 2:11:25compartmentalization of the of the capital stock, you know, in
- 2:11:29my opinion And and I think the the kind of elephant of the
- 2:11:34room, the last time we went through this, like I mean 1970s,
- 2:11:37it was all about where's the gold going to go.
- 2:11:38Like we shut down Bretton Woods in 1971 because too much gold
- 2:11:42was leaving the country. We closed the exit doors.
- 2:11:45It's the same thing in the Great Depression, 1933, he had
- 2:11:48executive order 6102. Private individuals can't hold
- 2:11:53gold. It's going to be all kind of
- 2:11:55mapped in the Army's going to defend it at Port Fort Knox.
- 2:11:59I think we'll realize as we go through these big transitions in
- 2:12:02the global monetary system. The signal you're looking for is
- 2:12:07the nation states are going to be looking to ensure that the
- 2:12:10capital doesn't flee their country.
- 2:12:13And first thing is make sure shut the barn door and make sure
- 2:12:17you know more of your cows and horses don't get out.
- 2:12:20And I think the next move if you want to do this well is to
- 2:12:23attract more capital in. So this idea that you come in
- 2:12:27and shoot yourself in the foot and and Treasury issues in order
- 2:12:31like you can't do this. This is this is this is a threat
- 2:12:35to the this is the threat to the the fiscal position of the
- 2:12:40United States. I think it's it's probably the
- 2:12:42exact opposite. If you do not attract capital
- 2:12:44and or or you can contain it but you don't want to make it too
- 2:12:49heavy-handed because if you if you if you make it clear that
- 2:12:52your exist like you're implementing capital controls
- 2:12:55that's a sign it's going to be taken as a a dog whistle.
- 2:12:58You'll be like I need to get this out.
- 2:12:59I need to get my gold out of Nazi Germany.
- 2:13:02I need to get my gold out of Japan but not as an individual
- 2:13:04is what you'd probably be thinking in those countries the
- 2:13:08way to do it. Well if you're thinking for the
- 2:13:09long term you want your I think you want your nation state your
- 2:13:11your society to prosper is you've got to attract it in.
- 2:13:14So I think this is a key moment to to get it right.
- 2:13:18We'll we'll see with the with the decisions made ahead.
- 2:13:22But yeah let's just a little bit of thoughts on the the cash
- 2:13:26settlement. I think it is a big deal as you
- 2:13:28know there's a there's there's reasoning behind it and it's big
- 2:13:32things are at play that. Was a lot of things.
- 2:13:37Well, that that that now that's made me think we're thinking
- 2:13:39these people are playing 40 chess.
- 2:13:40Maybe all the posturing by the Treasury and Elizabeth Warren
- 2:13:44and Jamie Dimon has been a misdirection play towards
- 2:13:48international markets. Like, no, we don't want it here.
- 2:13:52So to say they're playing 40 chess, I'm like, you're just in
- 2:13:56a massive, like you've gotten yourself in a really bad fiscal
- 2:14:00decisions with like, especially like the decisions made after
- 2:14:04the like. The 1998 kind of global
- 2:14:07Southeast Asian debt crisis is where this kicked off.
- 2:14:10Like, we've just been putting ourselves more and more in a bad
- 2:14:12position ever since. You don't give up your queen on
- 2:14:17like move four or like just like trade like rooks for pawns.
- 2:14:21And like, everybody's doing that, but like to claim like
- 2:14:24you've been playing the long play all along.
- 2:14:26It's like I. Don't.
- 2:14:27I don't know. Like if I were, I'm not a chess
- 2:14:29grandmaster or anything. It's like you doesn't make sense
- 2:14:32to to make those moves and put yourself in in this kind of
- 2:14:35position like this far behind if you will in the in the debt
- 2:14:39situation if you were really trying to play well like 40
- 2:14:44chess analogy. The thing that came to mind when
- 2:14:47Matt was talking with like it's like basically Geopolitical
- 2:14:50Capital silos and the Hong Kong reversal.
- 2:14:55Remember like they took a hard stance on the crypto and the
- 2:14:57banks last year and then that like randomly kind of pivoted
- 2:15:00post ETF approved. Like one of this chatter
- 2:15:04started. You could if if this like thesis
- 2:15:07plays out, you can start seeing these like markets whether it's
- 2:15:10India, Asia Pacific, Hong Kong, we've seen it going on in the
- 2:15:14Middle East where you start developing these like financial
- 2:15:16products and you start to bring in the capital flows
- 2:15:20specifically Bitcoin into these vehicles versus other offshore
- 2:15:23vehicles. Just pause and just reflect
- 2:15:26right now like Marty you're 15 year pace.
- 2:15:29Isn't it just mind boggling that this is where we are right now?
- 2:15:33Like this thing that started with one guy and start like 2?
- 2:15:38Nose with Hal. Finney and it's like it's gone
- 2:15:40here. It's like this tells you
- 2:15:43something like how people are aligning about around or the
- 2:15:47biggest entities in the world our nation states are now kind
- 2:15:49of having to address and and come to deal come to terms with
- 2:15:53aligning around this consensus mechanism is is what's actually
- 2:15:56going on. It's pretty it's.
- 2:15:59Beautiful. It's pretty crazy.
- 2:16:01And doesn't it make it feel like 21 million really isn't a large
- 2:16:05number, you know? It's just the number is
- 2:16:09arbitrary. It could have been two, like
- 2:16:13we'd fractional and we like it'd be sliced up.
- 2:16:15We call the unit of account like sats or you know, whatever.
- 2:16:17But yeah, just got to pick a number.
- 2:16:20There's. Only going to be 21 million
- 2:16:23freaks. If you're listening out there,
- 2:16:26it's going to be a lot of people trying to get their slice of the
- 2:16:3021 million after next week. This has been, we're two hours
- 2:16:35in now. This has been incredible.
- 2:16:37All right, this I like this new format.
- 2:16:40Michael, are you pleased with the format?
- 2:16:46I love it. I think.
- 2:16:48I think there's a lot of things that Bitcoin will touch and and
- 2:16:51and individuals want to hear how it touches it.
- 2:16:55Like the AI thing I think was great.
- 2:16:56I think we probably just got to people.
- 2:16:58I don't think we or individuals have 2 1/2 hours to spend on on
- 2:17:01pods with all the ones coming out.
- 2:17:03So we'll we'll get better on the the timing.
- 2:17:04But I yeah, I love being able to talk to about some of the other
- 2:17:07stuff that tie into Bitcoin. Yeah, we'll have to work on the
- 2:17:11timing. Jesse's a very busy man.
- 2:17:12He only has an hour and a half for us.
- 2:17:14Jesse Irish exit, yeah. He ghosted us.
- 2:17:20Yeah, he. He ghosted us before we ghost
- 2:17:22the audience. Gentlemen, any parting thoughts?
- 2:17:25Parting notes things we didn't cover that you think we should
- 2:17:28touch on before you wrap up. Matt, do you feel comfortable?
- 2:17:35I don't want to do the price, but like what?
- 2:17:36Give me, give me something, give us something on like where, how
- 2:17:39big this cycle goes? Like how?
- 2:17:40Like how should we think about it as compared to I?
- 2:17:43Don't want, I don't want you to mention price, but like how high
- 2:17:45do you think it goes? Maybe it's less about price,
- 2:17:49it's more about just like adoption, right?
- 2:17:51We had, you know, Sailor last year we had El Salvador.
- 2:17:55Like where do we see this entrench into like, you know,
- 2:17:57global like culture, all the things.
- 2:17:59In this next wave. I don't know, I haven't really
- 2:18:03put too much time into coming up with a price target.
- 2:18:05I'm more just kind of I try to watch flows and kind of the the
- 2:18:10waves if you will like it. It's more than it is today,
- 2:18:14obviously top of cycle. I think the last one
- 2:18:17interestingly you know people talk talk about the top of the
- 2:18:20last cycle, this is a weird one because there was a double top
- 2:18:24element. The first peak came.
- 2:18:27It was like right as that China band was coming, right, Which
- 2:18:30was? Marty, you had no.
- 2:18:32Timelines, but June of 21, that was the first peak and that was
- 2:18:36really what you would call like the technical peak of the cycle.
- 2:18:40From there we were, in my opinion, we're in the big
- 2:18:43retrace now. You got the rally from I forget
- 2:18:46how how low it dipped in that intermediate from like 60 K the
- 2:18:50first time and then it hit it again like it went down to maybe
- 2:18:53like 40-30, I don't know somewhere in there.
- 2:18:56But that next rally from like 30 to 40K back up to like a new all
- 2:18:59time high at 65 K My perspective on like what was actually going
- 2:19:04on in the capital flows of market etcetera, what two
- 2:19:07things, one, the money printing and the fiscal stimulus was so
- 2:19:11strong in COVID like the embers just wouldn't burn out on that
- 2:19:15process like we're still dealing with that.
- 2:19:19So that gave a massive like continued tailwind.
- 2:19:22But then I think you're also looking for in terms of that
- 2:19:26like the the, the, the rally, right, the bear market rally,
- 2:19:30which was in my opinion was that second wave at the double top
- 2:19:34that really the, the top tick of that market was the launch of
- 2:19:39that Bito ETF product. And then capital flowed in.
- 2:19:43We talked about how it's an inferior vehicle, it's inferior
- 2:19:46product, but capital flowed in. Share counts up 2X over the two
- 2:19:50years or so it's existed. That tells you.
- 2:19:54It tells me and and and my read on this like this underlying
- 2:19:57bull market like that only happens where you have like that
- 2:20:03that bear market rally that can overshoot that top if the
- 2:20:07underlying bull market is like extremely strong.
- 2:20:10So I think that's that's what I look to for Signal and it's it's
- 2:20:15pretty Dang obvious like the longer you've been here paying
- 2:20:17attention like there's there's something going on in Bitcoin it
- 2:20:21seems to be there's a. Pretty massive bull market going
- 2:20:24on over the last 15 years. You know what we've seen so far,
- 2:20:27every cycle peak is considerably higher than the previous you
- 2:20:33know cycle top. So no idea where we get to in
- 2:20:35the blow off or or in the the final phase.
- 2:20:38I don't know, you know how this bull market cycle ends.
- 2:20:40Like we won't know it until it materializes.
- 2:20:43Like no one saw the the China ban coming like in real time
- 2:20:48unless you had some sort of like inside information and you knew
- 2:20:51they were working on implementing it.
- 2:20:52Like the market was picking up those signals but you didn't
- 2:20:54know what the headline was that would chop it off, right.
- 2:20:57Same thing with the ETF launch. You might have had a sense that
- 2:21:00that product was coming out the filings, we weren't watching it
- 2:21:03to the same degree that you know the the Twitter, Audi or
- 2:21:07whatever the X audience is, just they're just on these ETF
- 2:21:12launches like there's nothing else going.
- 2:21:13Like they're putting so much attention into that.
- 2:21:15But it wasn't that way for the for the Bito ETF when it
- 2:21:18launched. So like that whole point like
- 2:21:21the underlying sentiment of how people are going to behave.
- 2:21:24I have no idea what they'd drive price to this next cycle, but I
- 2:21:28the the actual waves like underneath this thing, like
- 2:21:34there is a lot of energy behind this thing so who who knows like
- 2:21:38where it goes to and I think if. If.
- 2:21:42You're in it for the long trip like the long term, and you're
- 2:21:44using this as your store value. It doesn't so much matter.
- 2:21:47Like don't let the don't let the highs push you like you know,
- 2:21:51past your emotional peak. Or don't let the lows you know
- 2:21:54stop you out parting thoughts. Tsunami.
- 2:21:58That's what I heard. Hey, props, I know Japan had
- 2:22:04that earthquake. It's not.
- 2:22:05It's no, No joking matter. Those are dangerous.
- 2:22:09Yes, I mean. I was trying to throw a little
- 2:22:13joke out there. Hearts, I know.
- 2:22:14Heart's out to Japan dealing with that, that crisis.
- 2:22:17Japan. Indonesia.
- 2:22:19Yeah. Not trying to be, not trying to
- 2:22:22do inaugurate the impact that actual tsunamis.
- 2:22:25It's. Not a good thing you got.
- 2:22:30To be careful, you got to be careful out there.
- 2:22:35With that, Michael, anything? No, it's it's awesome, Matt.
- 2:22:40I appreciate you jumping on. I think your analysis is great.
- 2:22:43I think we'd probably get muted volatility to downside based on
- 2:22:46long term holders and retirement accounts where it's not like you
- 2:22:48people just selling out. That'd be a quasi prediction
- 2:22:52versus the crazy 80% retraces we've seen previously.
- 2:22:56Yeah, yeah. And if.
- 2:22:59The Boomers retirement accounts allocate the Bitcoin, then they
- 2:23:02unfortunately pass and pass it along to their millennial kids
- 2:23:04or Millennial because they're really alright.
- 2:23:06Double down on this. Buy some more of this.
- 2:23:08Here's a great point. I heard a non bitcoiner make on
- 2:23:11a podcast last night. Talked about sentiment.
- 2:23:15Like the last time Bitcoin was at 40K people were a billion and
- 2:23:19this was like on the way down, like Bitcoin conference 2022.
- 2:23:22We didn't realize the depths of what was ahead of us, like all
- 2:23:25of these lending failures of Celsius, Block 5, FTX, etcetera.
- 2:23:31And now that you know bitcoin's back at, you know, 40K.
- 2:23:34But sentiment's not where it was.
- 2:23:36Like I know within this call, like these individuals and then
- 2:23:39you talk to bitcoiners at the at the conferences like they're
- 2:23:42incredibly high sentiment, like their convictions were just like
- 2:23:45steeled with the the banking crisis and we're like what
- 2:23:49happened with SVB whatnot and like just just reinforced all of
- 2:23:54their core convictions. But if you just talk to the
- 2:23:56general public right now, bitcoin's not at an all time
- 2:23:59high. There's much lower sentiment
- 2:24:03than there was the last time we were at 40K.
- 2:24:05So I think that tells you like just understanding where you're
- 2:24:08at in the, in the big picture of this of of this current cycle
- 2:24:14where we are and no idea how this one ends.
- 2:24:18They're all kind of different, but tells you, yeah, keep keep
- 2:24:24riding the trade. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:24:28I think the flows not to go to, but the flows Barney like we've
- 2:24:32been looking at this for so long, I think we forget that.
- 2:24:34Like sending money into Bitcoin is like sending into a casino
- 2:24:37from like a market perspective. Like you have to sell from one
- 2:24:40place, you have to get the cash and then you're moving it to
- 2:24:43Coinbase or a Kraken. Like what is a Coinbase or a
- 2:24:46Kraken to the general audience? Like you might as well be
- 2:24:48sending it to Bovada or wherever to gamble.
- 2:24:51And this idea that like if somebody even wanted to trade it
- 2:24:53requires a lot of work. It's like, let me just wait till
- 2:24:55the ETF from a retail perspective and then from an
- 2:24:58institutional perspective, they can't do it either way.
- 2:25:01So like the idea of that this thing launches and then it just
- 2:25:03kind of like hangs out there for a little bit.
- 2:25:05What we're talking about earlier is I just don't see it because
- 2:25:07it just feels like it's the product that needs to be in the
- 2:25:08market for the flow to actually start to move.
- 2:25:12That's a great point, actually. Glad you raised it, because like
- 2:25:15a lot of the firms who popped up with them, Bitcoin focus.
- 2:25:18Bitcoin only like you know, the Unchained of the World, whatnot
- 2:25:22like they were not going the altcoin route and shilling doge
- 2:25:26to your e-mail list like you were giving up money.
- 2:25:29Like you were choosing to forego like the the marshmallow on the
- 2:25:32table so you could get more later.
- 2:25:35But I think, you know, just opinion here but like that long
- 2:25:42term decision making over the last five, seven years.
- 2:25:47Yeah, like the most, you know, 55-6 year olds like the broader
- 2:25:51population. As you work your way up that S
- 2:25:53curve of adoption, you're trying to breakthrough more than the,
- 2:25:56let's say, 1 to 3% of people who've adopted Bitcoin at this
- 2:25:59point. If you want to get the next
- 2:26:011020, I'm sorry. Like my mom's not going to go
- 2:26:05like she doesn't want to view this as a casino.
- 2:26:06She doesn't go to casinos like she.
- 2:26:08That's not what what works for that person.
- 2:26:11And so you know the the financial institutions, service
- 2:26:16providers like that who are just focused on Bitcoin only I think
- 2:26:21that becomes an asset in this as opposed to foregoing the
- 2:26:25Marshmallow, you know the in the last cycle and the cycle is
- 2:26:31basically sense Ethereum, you know showed up, it's been well I
- 2:26:35guess you had Litecoin even before that and stuff like that.
- 2:26:37But there was always that element of as Michael mentioned,
- 2:26:41yeah, I'm I'm gonna sell my my holdings and whatever I was
- 2:26:45storing value in before and I'm gonna move that to the casino.
- 2:26:48Like no, no, if you're looking for broader adoption like the
- 2:26:51people aren't going to do that. So I think that's if we're
- 2:26:54making hot takes for 2024, I think that's it's when the the
- 2:26:58firms and entities who successfully passed the
- 2:27:01marshmallow test and prior cycles I hope, I I think the
- 2:27:04cycle ahead is where they can get rewarded for that.
- 2:27:09That's a thesis right On RAMP, our thesis at 1031 TFTC.
- 2:27:15Don't eat the marshmallow. Wait.
- 2:27:17Wait for the mountain of marshmallows.
- 2:27:18It's. Poison.
- 2:27:20It's poison. It's.
- 2:27:22Poison. Yeah.
- 2:27:22Gentlemen, it's been a pleasure. Eyes.
- 2:27:24Here. That's it.
- 2:27:27It's. Been a pleasure.
- 2:27:28This is a great way to start the year.
- 2:27:30I guess we'll have may we may have some closure on whether or
- 2:27:35not the ETS are approved by next time of record.
- 2:27:38So next week should be interesting to come back and
- 2:27:41join us at the last trade. Thanks guys.
- 2:27:45See ya.