Latest / Kentucky Tonight / America's Next 250 Years: Civic Engagement & Service
Transcript
- 0:09Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:11Shaw, and we thank you so much
- 0:12for joining us this evening on
- 0:14Saturday. Of course, we
- 0:16celebrated America's 250th
- 0:18birthday with parades,
- 0:19fireworks, concerts and
- 0:21speeches all across the country
- 0:23and throughout Kentucky. But we
- 0:25were celebrating more than a
- 0:27birthday. We were remembering
- 0:28the beliefs and principles that
- 0:29inspired us to seek our
- 0:31independence more than 250
- 0:33years ago. Principles of
- 0:34freedom and liberty, but also
- 0:36the spirit of service and civic
- 0:38engagement are those principles
- 0:40of 1776 still with us in 2026?
- 0:43And what does that service look
- 0:45like today, and what can
- 0:47Americans do in the future to
- 0:48serve the greater good? Well,
- 0:50we have four guests in our
- 0:52Lexington studio to parse out
- 0:53those questions and more.
- 0:55Kentucky Secretary of State
- 0:56Michael Adams Benjamin Gies
- 0:59chairman of Louisville America,
- 1:01250 Gary Gregg political
- 1:04scientist and McConnell center
- 1:05director at the University of
- 1:07Louisville, and Richard Young,
- 1:09founder and executive director
- 1:11of CivicLex. And in our
- 1:13Louisville studio, we're glad
- 1:14to be joined by Jerry Abramson,
- 1:16former Louisville mayor and
- 1:17former lieutenant governor of
- 1:19Kentucky and Maggie Harlow,
- 1:21executive director of the Jack
- 1:23Harlow Foundation. We certainly
- 1:24want to hear from you tonight.
- 1:26You can send us your questions
- 1:27and comments by X, formerly
- 1:29Twitter at Pub Affairs KET.
- 1:31Send an email to KY TONIGHT at
- 1:35ket.org or use the web form at
- 1:38ket.org/ky tonight, or you can
- 1:40simply give us a call at one
- 1:43804 947605. Well, welcome to
- 1:47all of our guests, both here in
- 1:49Lexington and our Louisville
- 1:50studios. We thank you for being
- 1:51here. Post the Holiday Bash
- 1:54America 250. Hope you enjoyed
- 1:56all the festivities. And now
- 1:58let's talk about what a lot of
- 1:59people have been talking about
- 2:00is where we are now, and what
- 2:02could stand for us in the next
- 2:04250 years. I want to go to you,
- 2:06Secretary Adams, and ask you a
- 2:07question about what single word
- 2:09in your mind describes America
- 2:12at 250. Polarized. Explain.
- 2:17>> So here's the good news. We
- 2:21go through waves. History is a
- 2:24cycle, and we have good decades
- 2:26and bad decades. And we go
- 2:28through some stuff. But we
- 2:30ultimately come back together.
- 2:31And what we're seeing today is
- 2:33a lot like the America that we
- 2:35had in the late 1800s. We were
- 2:36highly polarized. The issue set
- 2:38was very cultural. Elections
- 2:39were very close, and they were
- 2:41very contested and there was
- 2:43violence. We had a governor of
- 2:45Kentucky assassinated over an
- 2:46allegedly stolen election. But
- 2:48then things change. We get
- 2:50Ahold of ourselves, we better
- 2:52ourselves. And we have great
- 2:54years, many great years. We're
- 2:56at that bottom point on that
- 2:58chart, and we go in waves and
- 3:00we can only get better.
- 3:01>> So, Doctor Greg, I want to
- 3:03ask you, I mean, is violence an
- 3:05inevitable evolution of where
- 3:06we are now, considering what
- 3:07Secretary Adams just posed to
- 3:09us is where we are in our
- 3:11polarization.
- 3:11>> It's not inevitable. But I
- 3:12think the Secretary is
- 3:13absolutely right. If you ask me
- 3:15that question. I think we're
- 3:17complicated right now. We're
- 3:18always getting better. We're
- 3:19always getting worse. I share
- 3:21the secretary's thought that
- 3:23we're sort of bottoming.
- 3:25Bottoming. Maybe right now
- 3:27we've got a lot, a lot to room,
- 3:28a lot of room to improve. And
- 3:31hopefully moments like this,
- 3:32the fourth we just celebrated
- 3:34will bring us together, will
- 3:36help us think through where we
- 3:38are and maybe what we're going
- 3:39to do tonight, I guess, and set
- 3:42herself on a path to rejuvenate.
- 3:44>> Right. So it's like a
- 3:46Facebook status. It's
- 3:47complicated. What word would
- 3:50you use to describe America at
- 3:52250?
- 3:52>> Well, you know, for me,
- 3:54Renee, I think I would use the
- 3:55word resilient. You know,
- 3:57there's no question that our
- 3:58country has been through quite
- 3:59a lot in the last decade, even
- 4:02in the last 20 years. And we
- 4:03consider all of the upheaval
- 4:04that we've witnessed, whether
- 4:06you're Republican, Democrat or
- 4:08independent. But as I begin to
- 4:10think about our country today,
- 4:11and certainly what I
- 4:13experienced at our Louisville
- 4:14America 250 celebrations this
- 4:15past weekend, we saw
- 4:18louisvillians of all walks of
- 4:19life from every corner of the
- 4:20city come out together in unity,
- 4:24to celebrate and to reflect
- 4:26upon 250 years of American
- 4:28history, and really to
- 4:30challenge ourselves and to ask
- 4:31the question, what could and
- 4:32should the next 250 years look
- 4:35like? I certainly agree with
- 4:36both Secretary Adams and Doctor
- 4:38Greg. I've never quite shared
- 4:40this publicly. But last, well,
- 4:43I guess two years ago now, my
- 4:44wife and I attended the
- 4:45presidential inauguration in
- 4:47Washington, and we had a great
- 4:49time. And since the
- 4:50inauguration, that day was
- 4:51moved inside. We watched it at
- 4:53a bar at Capitol Hill, and we
- 4:55were having a wonderful time
- 4:56until a brick came flying
- 4:57through the window, and my wife
- 4:59and I had to hit the dirt. We
- 5:01didn't know what was going on,
- 5:02but we're definitely in a very
- 5:04polarized time. But we're in a
- 5:06time where people aren't giving
- 5:07up, and we're at a time when
- 5:08people are striving for better.
- 5:10So I think our next 250 years
- 5:12will reflect that resiliency.
- 5:14>> Richard Young So, we've
- 5:15heard complicated, polarized
- 5:16and resiliency. What's your
- 5:18word to describe America at 250?
- 5:20>> This is maybe more than one
- 5:22word, but full of opportunity.
- 5:23I think that in this incredibly
- 5:26polarized time, we have such an
- 5:29opportunity at the community
- 5:30level to really address some of
- 5:32these challenges, right? Where
- 5:33people are frustrated with
- 5:35inaction in government and
- 5:37sometimes incompetence in our
- 5:41communities. We have an ability
- 5:42to actually shape decisions
- 5:44that are getting made in our
- 5:47communities, where people are
- 5:48polarized on national issues,
- 5:50on local issues, folks can find
- 5:53common ground and get work done.
- 5:57And so to me, you know, from
- 5:59where I work at the community
- 6:01level, I can see communities
- 6:02all across this country finding
- 6:04opportunities to renew
- 6:06themselves and to renew the
- 6:07civic life that we deserve to
- 6:09have in this nation. And so I
- 6:11think it's it's a time of
- 6:13opportunity. And the beginning
- 6:14of a season of.
- 6:15>> Renewal and apathy isn't
- 6:17taking root or hold as you see
- 6:19it.
- 6:19>> I think when it comes to
- 6:20national politics sometimes.
- 6:22But when you look at what's
- 6:24happening in city council
- 6:26meetings or in, you know, in
- 6:28state houses, I think people
- 6:30still feel an opportunity to
- 6:34meaningfully engage in our
- 6:36democratic systems, to
- 6:37meaningfully engage in our
- 6:38systems of representation and
- 6:40to participate in, in shaping
- 6:42our communities futures.
- 6:43>> Regardless of the outcome
- 6:44going their way or not. Right.
- 6:46Mr. Abramson, formerly known as
- 6:48the Louisville Mayor for life
- 6:50and former lieutenant governor.
- 6:51How do you see it? What would
- 6:53what one word or words would
- 6:54you describe where the nation
- 6:56is right now?
- 7:01>> Well, as I as I listen to
- 7:03the panel, you know, I really
- 7:05started to think about the word
- 7:07concern. You know, I hope we're
- 7:10bottomed out. I hope we're
- 7:11ready to bounce forward. But
- 7:15this last week or two has given
- 7:16the American people an
- 7:18opportunity to stop and think
- 7:20and be concerned about the
- 7:22things that are happening
- 7:23around them in all aspects of
- 7:26their life within the community,
- 7:28civic arena. And that concern
- 7:31ought to be the thing that that
- 7:33that literally ignites them to
- 7:35get engaged, to talk about
- 7:37bringing about the change that
- 7:38they believe should be
- 7:41occurring, should be engaged in
- 7:43the activities that their local
- 7:45government, as the gentleman
- 7:46said earlier, whether local
- 7:48government or the school board,
- 7:49is making things happen and
- 7:51they need to get engaged to be
- 7:53a part concern about people
- 7:55that aren't listening.
- 7:57Everybody's talking,
- 7:58everybody's yelling, nobody's
- 8:00listening. And and this two
- 8:02week period around July 4th, I
- 8:04think, has given us some time
- 8:06to, to think about those kinds
- 8:08of issues, to be concerned,
- 8:10seriously concerned about them,
- 8:12and to begin thinking about how
- 8:13each of us in our own lives can,
- 8:15can make the kind of change
- 8:17that's necessary to ensure the
- 8:19next 250 years are positive for
- 8:21our country.
- 8:23>> Maggie Harlow, I want to
- 8:24come to you now and ask you the
- 8:26same question. Where do you see
- 8:28America at this juncture, and
- 8:29what are your hopes to move
- 8:30beyond perhaps the bottom, as
- 8:32Doctor Greg described, and
- 8:33Secretary Adams.
- 8:37>> I'm a big believer that our
- 8:39country, while it's 250 years
- 8:40old, is actually still a young,
- 8:44a young and growing opportunity,
- 8:46I think Americans we are still
- 8:49getting our footing as a
- 8:50country. And I know that sounds
- 8:52crazy because we are the most
- 8:54powerful country in the world
- 8:55and we are a standard bearer.
- 8:57But in many ways we are still
- 8:59young and still figuring out
- 9:01who we are as a country and
- 9:04arguing about it a little bit.
- 9:06As families do. We argue with
- 9:07our family members, but I'm a
- 9:10big believer in the American
- 9:12ideals, and I think despite a
- 9:14lot of rhetoric, a lot of
- 9:16polarization, I think in our
- 9:17hearts, we believe in this
- 9:20country and we believe in our
- 9:21system. It's the worst system
- 9:23except for every other system
- 9:25in the world. And I think we're
- 9:26committed to it. And I believe
- 9:28that that will prevail.
- 9:30>> Yeah. Well, on the eve of
- 9:32America's 250th birthday bash,
- 9:34a Gallup poll last week that
- 9:35came out a few days later found
- 9:37that 33% of U.S. adults say
- 9:39they are, quote, extremely
- 9:41proud to be an American. It was
- 9:43the lowest reading in Gallup's
- 9:45trend, dating back to 2001.
- 9:47Another 20% say they were very
- 9:50proud, which means just over
- 9:51half of Americans express some
- 9:52high levels of pride in their
- 9:54country. The remaining shares
- 9:56say they are moderately proud
- 9:5822% and only a little proud.
- 10:0115% are not at all 9%. So I
- 10:03want to ask you, what do you
- 10:05make of those numbers? And do
- 10:06our collective view of American
- 10:08pride? Does our collective view
- 10:10of American pride? Why does it
- 10:12differ than it did after nine
- 10:13over 11, when it seemed to be
- 10:15that we were more rallied? What
- 10:16do you think explains that,
- 10:18Doctor Greg?
- 10:18>> Yeah, I think it's very
- 10:20concerning, very concerning to
- 10:21me. And I think that's I think
- 10:24it's the right and the left
- 10:25that we have to blame for this.
- 10:27The left has spent. Professors
- 10:30have spent the last three
- 10:32decades, four decades pounding
- 10:33America as racist, homophobic,
- 10:36you name it. And and so
- 10:39students have been inculcated
- 10:40with that. Our our journals and
- 10:42our media have told us that.
- 10:45Why would you love your country
- 10:47if what you believed was all
- 10:48the worst things and on the
- 10:51right, we are now in a
- 10:52situation where we have one
- 10:55particular president who is
- 10:57wrapped so closely to the flag
- 10:59that it's hard for everybody
- 11:00else to see. I could love
- 11:01America too, and not love him.
- 11:04And I think so. I think it's
- 11:05right and left is seriously
- 11:06problematic here. And the Great
- 11:09Patriotic Middle has got to
- 11:10take it back and say, we love
- 11:12America. We. We differ on why,
- 11:15perhaps. But this is our
- 11:17country. And like Maggie said,
- 11:19that, you know, we were still
- 11:20young and I think we do still
- 11:22feel young. We still feel young,
- 11:23we still have promise. And if
- 11:26we come together, we love this
- 11:28country. We can improve and we
- 11:29can move it forward in the
- 11:31direction that we think it's.
- 11:32It needs to be.
- 11:33>> And while there are, you
- 11:35know, sins of our past to
- 11:36neglect those and not teach
- 11:37those, some would say would be
- 11:39a misguided notion. It would
- 11:41not serve the country well. So
- 11:42of all the isms that persisted
- 11:45then still persists now, and
- 11:46there's value in talking about
- 11:47that. Isn't that Secretary
- 11:48Adams? Isn't that the case?
- 11:50>> Yeah, I think so. And
- 11:52America's greatest advantage is
- 11:54also sometimes a challenge,
- 11:55which is if you're English, you
- 11:57love England because you're
- 11:59English, if you're German, you
- 12:00love Germany because you're
- 12:01German. Those are countries
- 12:03that are based on bloodlines
- 12:04and tribes that form those
- 12:06countries. But we're different.
- 12:07We're not a tribe. We're not a
- 12:08bloodline. We're an idea. We're
- 12:10a creed. And I think currently
- 12:13in our in our current politics,
- 12:15which is more personality based
- 12:16and less idea based because of
- 12:19reality TV and social media and
- 12:21other things that are making
- 12:23personalities and individuals
- 12:25the face of movements versus
- 12:27ideas behind them. The notion
- 12:29of what it is to be an American
- 12:30is really in question. And if
- 12:32you ask someone who says that
- 12:34he or she is not proud of
- 12:36America, I guess my hope would
- 12:37be, what do you think America
- 12:39means? What is it that you see
- 12:41as American that you that you
- 12:43don't like? Because there's a
- 12:44lot more to America than just
- 12:45that.
- 12:46>> I want to go to you, Mr.
- 12:48Abramson, about that notion of
- 12:49being an American. What does it
- 12:50mean? And even criticizing the
- 12:52country, does that mean you're
- 12:54anti-American? If you express
- 12:55those sentiments that somehow
- 12:58put more scrutiny on the
- 13:00country and even its principles
- 13:01and ideals that perhaps some
- 13:04believe the country has yet to
- 13:05live up to?
- 13:10>> Well, the Declaration of
- 13:11Independence and most
- 13:12specifically, the Constitution,
- 13:14talks about peaceful protests
- 13:16and people being able to go
- 13:18with grievances to their
- 13:20government. What we've got to
- 13:22do is get people to engage. You
- 13:25know, you get tired of all the
- 13:27whining and complaining about
- 13:28this is wrong and that is wrong.
- 13:30And city government screwed up
- 13:32and the county government's
- 13:33messed up, and the school
- 13:34board's messed up and the
- 13:35legislature won't listen. And
- 13:36you go on and on and on, and
- 13:38you finally say to yourself, so
- 13:40do something about it. Because
- 13:41if you don't do anything,
- 13:42you're a part of the problem.
- 13:44If you're not a part of the
- 13:45solution. And so I think, again,
- 13:48I go back to what I said
- 13:49earlier this period in our time,
- 13:51this this last couple of weeks,
- 13:53while people stopped for a
- 13:55moment and listen to the to the
- 13:57reading of the Declaration of
- 13:59Independence that happened in
- 14:00many cities, if not most across
- 14:02the country, and understand
- 14:04what it was about and the
- 14:06weaknesses and strengths, and
- 14:08then look around them in terms
- 14:10of at this point in time, where
- 14:12are we and what can I, as a
- 14:14citizen of this community,
- 14:15engage in to bring about or to
- 14:18ensure the continued values of
- 14:21what America was based upon 250
- 14:23years ago?
- 14:24>> Doctor? Guess what letter
- 14:27grade would you give American
- 14:28democracy right now?
- 14:30>> That's a great question,
- 14:31Renee, especially considering I
- 14:33started my career as an eighth
- 14:34grade civics teacher. What
- 14:36letter grade would I give
- 14:37American democracy right now?
- 14:39You know, I think I'd give it a
- 14:41solid B plus. I think if we
- 14:43take a look at where people are
- 14:45in America right now, the
- 14:47integrity of our elections, for
- 14:48example, which I know our
- 14:49secretary of state will focus
- 14:51on here, there's certainly a
- 14:52great deal of progress yet to
- 14:54go to get to the A plus, right.
- 14:56But if you take a look at where
- 14:58we were even, let's say 4 to 6
- 15:01years ago, right, we were in a
- 15:02very dark place. And if you
- 15:04take a look at people today,
- 15:05they're getting out. They're
- 15:07voting as our former mayor,
- 15:08Lieutenant Governor Jerry
- 15:11Abramson shared. Folks aren't
- 15:12just complaining to complain
- 15:14anymore. They're really asking
- 15:15themselves, what can I do as an
- 15:17individual to make a positive
- 15:19difference? And a positive
- 15:20difference can be your neighbor
- 15:21who volunteers at their local
- 15:23elementary school. A positive
- 15:25difference can be someone
- 15:26running for Congress, even if
- 15:27you don't win. In forming the
- 15:29discussion. I do think that
- 15:31despite all of the rhetoric
- 15:32that we see and that we hear,
- 15:34we are trending towards a more
- 15:36peaceful discourse, or at least
- 15:37I hope so over the arc of at
- 15:39least the last year. And I do
- 15:42hope they will continue to
- 15:43improve upon that. I think that
- 15:44it's incredibly important for
- 15:46all people to realize that
- 15:48regardless of a political
- 15:50opinion, we all have a common
- 15:52civic thread and a common civic
- 15:54virtue, and that by adhering to
- 15:56those is ultimately how we move
- 15:57our city, state and our country
- 16:00forward.
- 16:00>> Do you think that tone is
- 16:01modeled at the very top in the
- 16:03white House?
- 16:03>> I think that the tone is
- 16:05modeled well across all levels
- 16:07of government. I would say that,
- 16:09you know, from time to time
- 16:10we're Americans, we have
- 16:11arguments, we have bitter
- 16:14disagreements. If you take a
- 16:15look at some of our founding
- 16:16fathers, you know, Hamilton is
- 16:18very popular. We had them at
- 16:19our Louisville America 250
- 16:20celebration. Take a look at
- 16:21some of the letters between,
- 16:23say, Alexander Hamilton and
- 16:25Thomas Jefferson. They're not
- 16:27exactly the most polite of
- 16:28letters, maybe polite by our
- 16:30standards, maybe not so much by
- 16:3118th century standards. So what
- 16:33you're seeing on the news today,
- 16:35we have encountered these
- 16:36problems since the founding of
- 16:37the country. Sometimes we
- 16:40button up and we clean up well,
- 16:41like, say, when we come on for
- 16:43Kentucky tonight. But sometimes
- 16:45we get down, we get dirty, we
- 16:47have a little bit of an
- 16:48argument, but ultimately we
- 16:49come together and we move
- 16:50forward. So the only thing I'll
- 16:52say when it comes to rhetoric,
- 16:54you know, certainly on both
- 16:55sides and on all sides, there
- 16:57is a need to tone rhetoric down.
- 17:00There is a need to remember
- 17:01that before we are Republicans,
- 17:03Democrats or independents,
- 17:05first and foremost, we are
- 17:07Americans. And that is what we
- 17:08must all remember at all times
- 17:10as we fight valiantly for the
- 17:13beliefs that we hold dear and
- 17:15the direction that we as
- 17:16individuals would like to see
- 17:17our country move towards.
- 17:19Ultimately, we all have to come
- 17:21together.
- 17:21>> Miss Harlow, curious about
- 17:22what letter grade you would
- 17:25give American democracy at this
- 17:27juncture.
- 17:31>> I'm going to give American
- 17:32democracy a B plus. I think we
- 17:34are in a stage. We're in a wave.
- 17:36We're in a cycle, whatever you
- 17:38want to call it. And I think
- 17:40this is normal development of
- 17:44how culture shifts. There's a
- 17:46lot of conversation about how
- 17:48we're not engaged or we're
- 17:50we're not showing up at bowling
- 17:52alleys. We're not showing up in
- 17:53places to be together. But the
- 17:55reality is we're more connected
- 17:57than we've ever been. Yes, we
- 17:59are choosing sides more
- 18:01frequently. We get to choose
- 18:03what news we want to listen to.
- 18:04We get to choose what, what
- 18:06what we want to see. The
- 18:07algorithms help us see what we
- 18:09want to see. There's a lot of
- 18:11confirmation bias going on, but
- 18:12I do think that things are
- 18:14improving. The pandemic had a
- 18:15huge effect on keeping people
- 18:17at home and insulating us, and
- 18:19we're seeing numbers increasing
- 18:21where we're starting to return
- 18:22to pre-pandemic levels of
- 18:24getting together and spending
- 18:26time together face to face.
- 18:28It's a hybrid world now, and I
- 18:30don't know about everyone else
- 18:31on this panel, but I would say
- 18:33that for sure. I am more
- 18:35connected to my friends and my
- 18:36family and the issues I care
- 18:39about because of the internet
- 18:41and all the things that we have
- 18:42access to. It's still
- 18:44relatively new technology.
- 18:46We're still learning how to
- 18:48question it. Just the other day
- 18:50I was reading something on the
- 18:51internet and I said to my
- 18:53husband, can you believe this?
- 18:54And he said, you need to you
- 18:56need to research that before
- 18:57you believe that. And I was
- 18:58like, he's right. And I
- 18:59researched it. And sure enough.
- 19:01So I think that we will get our
- 19:03arms around it, but I give us a
- 19:05solid B plus.
- 19:06>> Okay. Mr. young, to Miss
- 19:09Harlow's point about we are
- 19:10more connected than we've ever
- 19:13been, or she feels that way.
- 19:14And the technological means by
- 19:16which we are connected
- 19:17certainly are leaps and bounds
- 19:19greater in the digital age than
- 19:20it was upon our founding. But
- 19:22does that kind of technological
- 19:24connectedness mean that we are
- 19:26intrinsically connected to each
- 19:27other or empathetic toward each
- 19:29other? Is there a real, genuine
- 19:31human connectedness that is
- 19:33also keeping pace with the
- 19:36technological, technological
- 19:37advances that make that
- 19:38connectedness happen?
- 19:40>> No, I mean, I think that our
- 19:42connections as humans have
- 19:43gotten actually quite a bit
- 19:45worse as technology has
- 19:46progressed. If you look at
- 19:49national studies on on people
- 19:51gathering together,
- 19:51particularly young people under
- 19:53the age of 35 are gathering in
- 19:56physical space with each other
- 19:57far less than they were 10 or
- 19:5915 years ago. And the same is
- 20:01true for older generations, for
- 20:02people that are more socially
- 20:04isolated, folks over the age of
- 20:0570 are much less likely to
- 20:07spend time with others. And you
- 20:09see that in in rising levels of
- 20:11loneliness, you see all of the
- 20:13health ramifications of that
- 20:14that have played out over the
- 20:16past 5 or 10 years. I think
- 20:18technology has an amazing power
- 20:20to connect us, and it has an
- 20:21amazing power to, to help
- 20:26galvanize movements, to help
- 20:27get people engaged. But I think
- 20:30my concern is that so much of
- 20:32our connection via technology
- 20:36really flattens out our views
- 20:37of the world. I think actually
- 20:39having more access to
- 20:41information tends to make us
- 20:43less curious. I think that if
- 20:47you look at the things that are
- 20:49that are, you know, popular in
- 20:51getting a lot of attention
- 20:53online, they tend to all be
- 20:54national in scope. They tend to
- 20:55be the latest sort of political
- 20:57outrage of the day. Or they
- 20:58tend to be, you know, talking
- 21:00about the most exciting things
- 21:03happening in, in Hollywood or
- 21:04whatever it is or the World Cup.
- 21:07But, you know, I think one of
- 21:09the real concerns that I have
- 21:11as someone that that is focused
- 21:12on my own community here in
- 21:14Lexington is that people are
- 21:17people only have a finite
- 21:19amount of time in their day to
- 21:21care about their community. And
- 21:22if their community is a
- 21:23national culture that is hyper
- 21:27tribalized, that is incredibly
- 21:29divided, that is less time for
- 21:31them to focus on their own
- 21:33community. And I think you can
- 21:34see that in Secretary Adams was
- 21:37talking earlier in the in the
- 21:39green room about, you know, the
- 21:41sort of shrinking of rotary
- 21:43clubs and Kiwanis clubs. And I
- 21:44think, you know, you can see
- 21:46that across a lot of our
- 21:47in-person civic infrastructure
- 21:49in our communities, the more
- 21:51times people spend online, the
- 21:53less time they spend with each
- 21:55other.
- 21:55>> Yeah. And I think Maggie
- 21:56mentioned about bowling alone.
- 21:58And of course, that's Robert
- 21:59Putnam's the name of his book
- 22:01documenting kind of American
- 22:03participation in organizations
- 22:04like Rotary Clubs and Kiwanis
- 22:06Clubs that that's dissipating.
- 22:07So I want to go to you,
- 22:09Secretary Adams, because this
- 22:10was brought up when we had the
- 22:11conversation in Louisville a
- 22:12few weeks ago at the Kentucky
- 22:14Center Arts, about how we are
- 22:15kind of self-sorting and maybe
- 22:18even self-segregating in a way.
- 22:20How do you view it as someone
- 22:22who, whose job it is, is to
- 22:24encourage civic engagement and
- 22:25participation? Where do you see
- 22:27your role in kind of helping
- 22:28this along?
- 22:29>> So civic engagement is way
- 22:31more than just voting. And
- 22:33Kentuckians are voting. Turnout
- 22:36is about what it's been in
- 22:39recent years, maybe a little
- 22:40better. But if you're just
- 22:42voting and you're going home
- 22:43and you come back and vote six
- 22:45months later, that doesn't
- 22:46count. You have to do a lot
- 22:47more than that. And to
- 22:49Richard's point, people are
- 22:50being bombarded with
- 22:51information and they have so
- 22:52many national things. Check
- 22:54your email. Half of its spam
- 22:56from some congressional person
- 22:57running in Pennsylvania or
- 22:59Wisconsin. Like people are so
- 23:01disconnected from their
- 23:03neighborhood. And that's a real
- 23:05problem. But they're also
- 23:06disconnected more generally
- 23:08where they're not joining
- 23:09organizations. So personal
- 23:12anecdote when U of L and UK
- 23:13played basketball last season,
- 23:15my daughter, who's a student at
- 23:17U of L, we all went out and
- 23:19watched the game together and
- 23:20we came back to campus and I
- 23:22thought I would see that place
- 23:24lit up. They just beat the cats.
- 23:25It was dead silent and those
- 23:27students were in their rooms
- 23:28with their doors closed,
- 23:29watching the game on their
- 23:31phones. They weren't in in
- 23:32rooms together, celebrating and
- 23:34having social experiences
- 23:35together. So there's just, I
- 23:37don't want to blame younger
- 23:39generations. We all have our
- 23:40challenges, but I think that
- 23:41generation, Gen Z especially is
- 23:43challenged with the notion of
- 23:44getting together and doing
- 23:45stuff isn't just part of their
- 23:46DNA the way it was, I think,
- 23:48for the rest of us, and I don't
- 23:50think that online connection is
- 23:51the same thing as real
- 23:53connection. Not even not even
- 23:54close. It's far too superficial.
- 23:56It's far too focused on images.
- 24:00That's why you see less and
- 24:02less sophistication in politics
- 24:04among people running for office.
- 24:06Because if you give a
- 24:07thoughtful speech for 30
- 24:08minutes, no one has the time
- 24:09for that. If you say something
- 24:11ridiculous on TikTok, it takes
- 24:1230s or less. That's where all
- 24:14the eyeballs go.
- 24:16>> Yeah. So I don't want to say
- 24:18how old you are. I don't want
- 24:20to assume that you're Gen Z or
- 24:21I know you're not Gen X because
- 24:23that's my.
- 24:24>> I'm a millennial and Gen.
- 24:25>> Z, okay. You're a millennial.
- 24:27Okay. Yeah. So you're mid-level
- 24:28millennial. So do you believe
- 24:29that that kind of social media
- 24:32activism is greater and can
- 24:35bring people together more than
- 24:36that? IRL in real life? I mean,
- 24:39is there a real connectedness
- 24:41that can happen in social media
- 24:43spaces that perhaps older folks
- 24:45don't quite assign?
- 24:46>> I think the answer to that
- 24:48question is it depends. If
- 24:49you're utilizing social media
- 24:51to say, everyone come to the
- 24:52town meeting on Tuesday night,
- 24:54then yes, if you're changing
- 24:57your profile picture to
- 24:58whatever the current trend of
- 24:59the moment is and expecting
- 25:01that to make a difference, the
- 25:02no. I actually have a term for
- 25:04that type of activism. I call
- 25:06it Slacktivism. Slacktivism
- 25:09slacktivism. It's activism for
- 25:11slackers. And so if you really
- 25:13want to make a difference, yeah,
- 25:14you can change your profile
- 25:15picture until the cows come
- 25:17home. But are you going to the
- 25:18town meeting? And when you go
- 25:20to the town meeting, are you
- 25:21behaving in a respectful way?
- 25:23Are you waiting your turn? Are
- 25:25you following the rules?
- 25:27Because contrary to popular
- 25:29popular belief, showing up in
- 25:31raising your voice and tossing
- 25:33the furniture around the room,
- 25:34and I've been in meeting rooms
- 25:35where that has happened before,
- 25:37it's not the way to get your
- 25:38message across, and it's
- 25:40certainly not the way to bring
- 25:41people over to your side. So I
- 25:44think that the answer to the
- 25:46question is, it depends. If
- 25:47you're using it in a
- 25:49constructive way, that will
- 25:50build momentum towards A, I, R
- 25:52l or in real life moment. And
- 25:55once you RIRL, you are behaving
- 25:58in a way that shows respect not
- 26:01only to yourself, but to your
- 26:03community and shows that you
- 26:05respect the thing that you're
- 26:07there to promote the thing that
- 26:09you believe in. And that's
- 26:10something I hope that young
- 26:12people latch on to, is it's not
- 26:14the loudest voice in the room
- 26:16that wins the day. Always.
- 26:18Sometimes, maybe a lot of times
- 26:19it's the quiet person that's
- 26:21shaking hands and building
- 26:22relationships and getting to
- 26:23know the other point of view to.
- 26:25>> Mr. Abramson, you know, all
- 26:26about that kind of retail kind
- 26:28of politics and what is
- 26:29effective and what works and
- 26:30what doesn't. Give us your
- 26:31perspective.
- 26:35>> You know, you were breaking
- 26:36down the generation. So I guess
- 26:39I'm the boomer member of this
- 26:41panel. And so, you know, I sort
- 26:44of go back, I sort of go back
- 26:47to what one of your panelists
- 26:49said about civics, where he
- 26:51taught civics in the eighth
- 26:52grade. I think it's time we get
- 26:54back to teaching civics. I
- 26:55think it's time we get back to
- 26:57having people understand who
- 26:59represents them, how they're
- 27:01voting, whether it's good or
- 27:04bad, and engaging with those
- 27:06representatives, whether you're
- 27:07on your cell phone or whether
- 27:09you're making phone calls or
- 27:11whether you're sending emails,
- 27:13you have to know who your state
- 27:14rep is. You have to know who
- 27:16your state senator is. You have
- 27:18to know who your school board
- 27:19member is. When I was
- 27:21lieutenant governor, I used to
- 27:23be the one that would host at
- 27:25the mansion, the different
- 27:26leadership groups that would
- 27:28come up to Frankfort leadership.
- 27:30Lexington, Louisville, Bowling
- 27:31Green, Pikeville, etc. And as
- 27:35we would talk through issues
- 27:36and these were the leaders of
- 27:37those communities, you know,
- 27:39I'd ask them, how many of you
- 27:40know who your state rep is or
- 27:42your state senator? And we were
- 27:45at a point maybe where 40%
- 27:47would raise their hands. When
- 27:49you got down to how many of you
- 27:51know who your school board
- 27:52member is, who, who's working
- 27:53there, he or she working there
- 27:55with the most precious asset we
- 27:58have our children. You got down
- 28:00in single digits. They had no
- 28:02idea who their school board
- 28:03member was. So, you know,
- 28:05you've got to get to the point
- 28:07where folks understand that a
- 28:09representative democracy only
- 28:11works if you have an educated
- 28:13electorate that is engaging
- 28:16with their elected officials.
- 28:17Because if they're not, then
- 28:20then the elected officials are
- 28:21basically independent
- 28:23contractors. They make the
- 28:24calls the way they want to make
- 28:25the calls, and they're never
- 28:27held responsible for however
- 28:29they might have voted. And that
- 28:31kind of issue ends up creating
- 28:33a. I'll give you another
- 28:35example. When I was lieutenant
- 28:37governor back in the day, if
- 28:39you had 20 people that would
- 28:41call their state rep about
- 28:43something. And in the
- 28:44legislative building, they had
- 28:46people that would answer the
- 28:48phone and give the legislator
- 28:49these pink slips saying, you
- 28:51know, the Smith family called,
- 28:53they'd like you to to do this
- 28:55or that. If you got 20 of those
- 28:57pink slips, the legislator,
- 28:58knowing that 20 people cared
- 29:00about whatever the vote was
- 29:01coming up, they would be aghast
- 29:04that people were watching that
- 29:06carefully and that they really
- 29:07had to think through how they
- 29:09were going to vote, rather than
- 29:10just toss it out on the floor
- 29:12as a yay or nay. We've got to
- 29:14get people to understand that
- 29:16those of us at the sidewalk
- 29:18level back home, literally are
- 29:21the folks that are being
- 29:22represented by not only our our
- 29:25representatives and our city
- 29:26council people and our county
- 29:28commissioners and our state
- 29:29legislators, but also the folks
- 29:31in Washington. You know, again,
- 29:33going back to being a boomer, I
- 29:35was it Peter Palmieri that had
- 29:36that song. You know, the times
- 29:38they are a changing come
- 29:39congressmen and senators, you
- 29:41know, get out of the hall.
- 29:42Don't stand in the doorway.
- 29:43Don't block up the hall because
- 29:45things are changing. And we
- 29:47have to get the citizens of
- 29:48this community to reengage with
- 29:50the system. That then can bring
- 29:53a direct relationship between
- 29:55what we think in the
- 29:57neighborhoods of America and
- 29:59what is occurring. At the City
- 30:00Council meeting, the fiscal
- 30:02court meeting, the state
- 30:03legislature, or in Washington
- 30:05itself?
- 30:06>> Well, thank you for that.
- 30:07And I should have said at the
- 30:09very outset that there's a
- 30:10little bit of a delay between
- 30:12us and Lexington and them in
- 30:13Louisville. So if there's a
- 30:14pregnant pause that explains
- 30:16that. Secretary Adams, I know
- 30:17that you've made civic
- 30:18engagement a part of your
- 30:19platform. It's not just about
- 30:20voting, making it easier to
- 30:21vote and harder to cheat. It is
- 30:23about having an informed
- 30:24citizenry. So of all those
- 30:25things that Mr. Abramson just
- 30:27laid out, whose responsibility
- 30:28is it to know who your school
- 30:29board member, who your city
- 30:31council member is, who your
- 30:32state lawmaker is as well?
- 30:33Who's responsible for helping
- 30:34people understand that?
- 30:35>> So here in Kentucky, under
- 30:37our Constitution, we are unique
- 30:39in that we put a lot more
- 30:40confidence in our voters than
- 30:41most states do. We used to be
- 30:43part of Virginia. They vote for
- 30:44the governor and the lieutenant
- 30:46governor and the attorney
- 30:47general, secretary of states
- 30:49appointed. The judges are
- 30:50appointed. Most of their
- 30:51government is appointed. We're
- 30:52different. We we bend over
- 30:54backwards to have the people
- 30:55choose our leaders at every
- 30:57level. And unfortunately, they
- 30:58don't know who they are. To
- 31:00give you some statistics, we
- 31:02did a study of this a couple
- 31:03years ago, and the average
- 31:05voter in Kentucky voting in
- 31:08every election in Kentucky, not
- 31:09just once in a while, the most
- 31:12regular voters don't know, on
- 31:15average, who the two senators
- 31:16are at the U.S. Senate level
- 31:19don't know the name of a single
- 31:20local official at any level.
- 31:23Don't know the name of a single
- 31:24legislator state legislator.
- 31:26They know who the president is,
- 31:28and most know who the governor
- 31:29is. And after that, not much.
- 31:32So that's a real failing of our
- 31:34system. If you go back and look
- 31:36in Kentucky history, the reason
- 31:37not a reason, the reason that
- 31:39we have public education in
- 31:40Kentucky in our Constitution,
- 31:42is to ensure that we have a
- 31:43citizenry that's capable of
- 31:45self-government. But let me
- 31:46give you an anecdote that kind
- 31:47of proves what Lieutenant
- 31:48governor, Governor Abramson was
- 31:49saying. I was speaking in in
- 31:52Boone County recently in favor
- 31:54of my civics education bill. We
- 31:56don't require civics education
- 31:57in Kentucky. Most states do.
- 32:00And so I went up there and did
- 32:02an event and asked people to
- 32:03contact their legislators. And
- 32:05so a nice lady in the audience
- 32:06stood up and applauded and said,
- 32:08you're right, we need to do
- 32:09that. So I went down afterward
- 32:11and I said, thanks for your
- 32:12comments. Your two legislators
- 32:13are this person and that person.
- 32:15And she just looked at me and I
- 32:17said, could you could you give
- 32:18him a call? Could you email him?
- 32:20And she just looked at me and
- 32:22then walked off. If even the
- 32:23people who stand up and say, we
- 32:25got to do something aren't
- 32:26willing to make those phone
- 32:28calls, those things are just
- 32:29not going to pass. So I don't
- 32:31want to just blame politicians
- 32:32and blame events and like, okay,
- 32:33sure, plenty of blame to go
- 32:35around. This comes down to the
- 32:36citizens and what citizens are
- 32:38willing to do or not do.
- 32:39>> Yeah. Richard, what do you
- 32:41see your role in helping
- 32:42provide for an informed
- 32:43citizenry here in the
- 32:44Lexington-Fayette County area?
- 32:46>> Yeah, I think plus one to
- 32:48everything the secretary said.
- 32:49I think I think the important
- 32:51thing is that we have to start
- 32:52with young people. You know, I
- 32:54think one of the challenges
- 32:56with with the public education
- 32:58system as it teaches social
- 32:59studies, we don't have a civics
- 33:00requirement. We do in Fayette
- 33:02County. So we're we're we're
- 33:03lucky to have that. But one of
- 33:05the challenges that teachers
- 33:06often encounter is that it's
- 33:08really challenging to teach
- 33:09about local civics. And local
- 33:12civics is really where students
- 33:13can get involved and see the
- 33:15progress of, of their
- 33:17involvement, right? They can
- 33:18talk to a city council member
- 33:20in a really clear and direct
- 33:21way. They can understand these
- 33:22issues that are impacting their
- 33:24neighborhoods in a much more
- 33:26personal way than some of these
- 33:27national issues. And so I think
- 33:30we need more organizations that
- 33:31are working at the local level
- 33:32to help build bridges between
- 33:35communities and schools. I
- 33:36think we need more curriculum
- 33:39that is helping young people
- 33:41understand the importance of
- 33:42local civic engagement and the
- 33:44importance of State civic
- 33:45engagement. And we need to sort
- 33:48of take civics out of just
- 33:50being this one little class,
- 33:53and it needs to be an
- 33:55integrated part of how we teach
- 33:57everyone. I think also, you
- 34:00know, one of the big challenges
- 34:01that we experience in across
- 34:03the state of Kentucky is, is a
- 34:07sort of shrinking media
- 34:08landscape and how we can build
- 34:10more media infrastructure that
- 34:12can help people understand the
- 34:13everyday decisions that their
- 34:15local government is making and
- 34:17their ability to get involved
- 34:18in those decisions. I think so
- 34:21much of the crises, so many of
- 34:23the crises that we're going
- 34:24through right now in this
- 34:25country, I think, is because
- 34:26people feel a real lack of a
- 34:29sense of agency in their lives.
- 34:31And I think one of the best
- 34:33things that we can do to help
- 34:35move our country forward is to
- 34:37help people find that agency.
- 34:38And I think a lot of it starts
- 34:40at the local level.
- 34:41>> How does the McConnell
- 34:42center, Doctor Gregg, kind of
- 34:43help along in this effort of
- 34:45getting more folks civically
- 34:47engaged and understanding the
- 34:49world around?
- 34:49>> Yeah. Hear, hear all the
- 34:51whole panel, because this is
- 34:52really where the rubber hits
- 34:53the road is. I think we've, we
- 34:57tend to emphasize so many
- 34:58groups tend to emphasize
- 35:00activism, but if you don't know
- 35:02what you're being active about,
- 35:03if you haven't thought through
- 35:04what you believe and why you
- 35:06believe it, if you haven't
- 35:07thought through separation of
- 35:08powers, checks and balances, or
- 35:09your local people are. It's so
- 35:11easy to fall into passion and
- 35:13fall into just following a
- 35:15party line or a certain
- 35:18political figure, etc. so I
- 35:20think it is so valuable that we
- 35:22get back to that core civic
- 35:24education, and we're very
- 35:26careful about the stories that
- 35:27we tell. What what is America?
- 35:29What is a citizen, what is
- 35:32expected of us? How are the
- 35:34institutions supposed to
- 35:36function? We've been at the
- 35:37McConnell center on this for 20
- 35:40years now, where we start our
- 35:42civic education program. And
- 35:44one of the things that I
- 35:45learned over the years is that
- 35:47a lot of teachers aren't really
- 35:48taught civics, aren't really
- 35:50taught American history. They
- 35:52might have education degrees,
- 35:54but they don't have a
- 35:55substantive degree. So most of
- 35:57our programing is focused on
- 35:59the teachers. It's trying to
- 36:00give them the tools, give them
- 36:01the information, give them the
- 36:04the great literature and the
- 36:05stories from American history
- 36:06so that they can pass those on.
- 36:08We also do some direct
- 36:10education with high school
- 36:11students, but it's a drop in
- 36:12the bucket. It's got we've got
- 36:14to get out there. We've got to
- 36:15help the teachers empower the
- 36:17teachers. But it's all of us.
- 36:18You asked Secretary Adams whose
- 36:19responsibility it was, and it's
- 36:21all of us. It's parents. It's
- 36:23our local communities. It's
- 36:24local political leaders. It is
- 36:27our teachers and it is our
- 36:28school boards. And it is, I
- 36:30think people like me that are
- 36:32that are teaching. So we all
- 36:33have a role to play. If you
- 36:35care about this country, you
- 36:36care about these young people
- 36:38and you care about. I probably
- 36:40wouldn't give as high of a
- 36:41grade as some of our other
- 36:42people give. If you care about
- 36:44improving those grades in
- 36:46American democracy, we all got
- 36:47to engage in this.
- 36:48>> Yeah. What's the grade you'd
- 36:50give since you brought it up?
- 36:51>> Yeah. I don't certainly not
- 36:53a B-plus. Grade inflation. We
- 36:58probably never have been. We
- 36:59probably never been an A in
- 37:01American history. Frankly, if
- 37:02we look at so many problems
- 37:03here and there. But when we
- 37:05have a situation where the
- 37:08young folks today are the least
- 37:11patriotic generation ever
- 37:13recorded in American history,
- 37:15that's a problem. When trust in
- 37:16our institutions is at an all
- 37:18time low. That's a problem when
- 37:20our citizens can't tell you the
- 37:23three branches of government or
- 37:24who your local representative
- 37:26is, that's a problem. We've got
- 37:28lots of problems. And but, you
- 37:31know, we've got problems. We've
- 37:32worked through problems before.
- 37:34We can do it again.
- 37:35>> Before we have a discussion,
- 37:36a little bit about what makes a
- 37:38patriot. I want to ask you,
- 37:40Secretary Adams, when you
- 37:41mentioned about there's not a
- 37:42statewide civics education
- 37:44curriculum program, etc. why is
- 37:45that and how have you tried to
- 37:47change legislators minds about
- 37:49that?
- 37:50>> Yeah, after election reform,
- 37:51I thought this would be an easy
- 37:53issue. But there's two main
- 37:55reasons that I've I've heard
- 37:58and their arguments. One is
- 38:01that you want to make us do
- 38:02this. Are you going to pay us
- 38:04more or are you going to have
- 38:06us not have to teach something
- 38:08that we're already teaching?
- 38:09Are you going to make the
- 38:10school day longer? How are you
- 38:11going to make us teach this?
- 38:13What? What gives? That's one
- 38:15angle of it. It's really kind
- 38:16of a.
- 38:17>> The unfunded mandate kind of
- 38:19thing.
- 38:19>> Yeah. That's right. And
- 38:20teachers are pretty upset about
- 38:22their pay already. And they
- 38:23don't want one more job to have
- 38:25to do. So that's one part of it.
- 38:27And that part's understandable.
- 38:29The other part is
- 38:30understandable, but more
- 38:31concerning, which is they're
- 38:32afraid to teach civics because
- 38:34they're afraid to have angry
- 38:36parents yelling at them and
- 38:38calling for their ouster
- 38:40because they were perceived to
- 38:41take the wrong side of an issue
- 38:43by raising something that
- 38:44happened in American history
- 38:45and touching on it. And you
- 38:47really can't talk about civics
- 38:49in such a dry way by saying, we
- 38:51have X branches of government
- 38:53and this and that and be done
- 38:54with it. You have to bring in
- 38:56the history to enlighten and
- 38:57illuminate.
- 38:58>> But we teach history, though.
- 39:00>> Sort of. I mean, I think we
- 39:02failed at that too,
- 39:03unfortunately. But it's a it's
- 39:04just a difficult time for
- 39:05teachers. They, they have no
- 39:07desire to touch this third rail
- 39:09at all if they can avoid it.
- 39:11And if we don't require it,
- 39:12they're not going to.
- 39:13>> Yeah. Anyone. Yes, doctor.
- 39:15Yes.
- 39:15>> Yes, certainly. I'd like to
- 39:17speak on my own experience in
- 39:18the classroom and having been
- 39:19involved in education and in
- 39:21education policy today for my
- 39:22day job, when I'm not leading
- 39:24city commissions or doing
- 39:26things like that. You know,
- 39:28when we think about education
- 39:30and civic education in
- 39:33particular, when I was in the
- 39:34classroom as an eighth grade
- 39:35American history teacher, I had
- 39:38one very clear metric for
- 39:40myself. And that was, do
- 39:43students know or could a
- 39:45student figure out my private
- 39:46political affiliation? And if
- 39:49the answer to either of those
- 39:50questions was yes, then I had
- 39:52failed my job, especially in
- 39:55the public school system, but
- 39:57especially in the public school
- 39:58system, was to serve as an
- 40:01educator, was to present facts,
- 40:05and were ultimately to give my
- 40:07students the facts. But more
- 40:09importantly than the facts, the
- 40:11skills they would need to form
- 40:12their own rational,
- 40:14well-founded, well thought out,
- 40:16well written, well spoken
- 40:18perspectives. And so, so often
- 40:21today in the classroom.
- 40:24Unfortunately, not all, but
- 40:25some view the classroom as a
- 40:27pulpit. And I think that we
- 40:29have seen folks push back on
- 40:30that as they rightly should.
- 40:32Because at the end of the day,
- 40:34if a teacher is teaching
- 40:35history or civics or science or
- 40:37math or what have you, the
- 40:39students shouldn't be able to
- 40:40say, I think Mr. Geese is a
- 40:42Republican or I think Mr. Geese
- 40:43is a Democrat. And let me tell
- 40:45you, those students would beg
- 40:47me. Well, what do you think?
- 40:48What do you think I said? It's
- 40:50not about what I think. It's
- 40:51about preparing you for what
- 40:53you think. And how can you
- 40:54argue your perspective? In
- 40:56other words, we don't teach
- 40:58students what to think. We
- 40:59teach them how to think. But to
- 41:02the Secretary, to Secretary
- 41:04Adams, Doctor Greg and others,
- 41:05I remember my first year
- 41:07teaching. It was 2016. 2016
- 41:10presidential election. You know,
- 41:11kind of a contentious election
- 41:13there, if you remember. And one
- 41:15of the early assignments I had
- 41:16was for students to watch a
- 41:18presidential debate, to fill
- 41:20out a few facts and say, you
- 41:21know, who do you think won and
- 41:23why? And I got calls. I got
- 41:24calls from parents. I don't
- 41:26want my daughter watching this.
- 41:27I don't want my son watching
- 41:28this. But, you know, I had the
- 41:30discussions on the phone and I
- 41:32said, well, student X, they're
- 41:34going to be they're 14. They're
- 41:35going to be voting in four
- 41:36years. And my concern is if
- 41:38they don't learn how to do this
- 41:39now, how will they know how to
- 41:41do it in four years? And
- 41:43parents would say, you know, I
- 41:44didn't think about that. So we
- 41:46struck a little compromise on
- 41:47the phone. I said, why don't
- 41:48you watch it first, pull out a
- 41:50few clips, whatever you're
- 41:51comfortable with, you're the
- 41:52parent. You're in the driver's
- 41:54seat as it should be an
- 41:55education, by the way, and she
- 41:58can complete the assignment a
- 41:59couple days later. Like there
- 42:01are there are ways to do this.
- 42:04And, you know, to teachers who
- 42:05are afraid, get unafraid. It's
- 42:07your job. Do it.
- 42:09>> But exposure doesn't mean
- 42:11indoctrination, right?
- 42:13>> 100%.
- 42:13>> Yeah. Miss Harlowe, I think
- 42:15you wanted to jump in, so go
- 42:16ahead, ma'am.
- 42:20>> Yeah. I really feel like
- 42:22some of this conversation, not
- 42:23all of it, but some of this
- 42:25conversation feels a little bit
- 42:27like we're yelling about, get
- 42:29off my lawn. Like the world's
- 42:32changing, and we have to
- 42:33embrace technology. We have to
- 42:36embrace what's happening on the
- 42:37internet and figure it out. So
- 42:39while we may look at what's
- 42:41happening on the internet and
- 42:42say, well, it's polarizing,
- 42:43it's doing this, it's doing
- 42:44that. What it's also doing is
- 42:45allowing people to build
- 42:47nonprofits to build their own
- 42:48companies, to build ideas, to
- 42:51express themselves. This young
- 42:53generation is better at
- 42:54expressing themselves than I
- 42:56think our generations were. And
- 42:58yes, I completely agree. We've
- 43:00got to be teaching civics.
- 43:02That's wild to me because I
- 43:04learned civics in high school,
- 43:05so I was not even aware we
- 43:07weren't teaching civics anymore.
- 43:08That seems crazy, but I do feel
- 43:12like we are trying to make
- 43:13voting harder for people. And
- 43:15in some ways, I think the
- 43:17politicians are playing into
- 43:19this idea of they're wrong,
- 43:21we're right. And so they're
- 43:24creating they're a part of this,
- 43:25which of course has been the
- 43:27American way. This is not new.
- 43:28This is not a new dynamic that
- 43:30we're seeing. I think that what
- 43:31we've got to do as a country is
- 43:33really figure out how does
- 43:35technology fit into all of this
- 43:36and how do we how does the next
- 43:39generation deal with the issues
- 43:41that technology has brought
- 43:42forward? Because it's, it's so
- 43:44new. I mean, think of how long
- 43:45we've had phones, cell phones.
- 43:47It's not even been probably 20
- 43:50years, 25 years that we've all
- 43:52commonly had a phone in our
- 43:53hand. So there's a lot we still
- 43:56are learning about how to deal
- 43:58with all this information. But
- 44:00this young generation, I see
- 44:02them wanting to take control
- 44:05and wanting to start
- 44:07organizations and express
- 44:08themselves and find the people
- 44:10that are part of their tribe
- 44:11and grow that. So I, I guess I
- 44:14have a lot of hope and maybe
- 44:16everyone on this panel thinks
- 44:17I'm naive, but I trust in young
- 44:20people to, to figure this out.
- 44:23But we have given them a huge
- 44:25problem to sort out. That's
- 44:27what we've done is we've handed
- 44:29this to them and said, well, do
- 44:30your best.
- 44:32>> So along those lines of
- 44:33civics education, this █viewer
- 44:35says and name unknown and
- 44:37county unknown. Teaching civics
- 44:38is one thing. The issue is
- 44:40teaching people how government
- 44:41affects them. When I talk to
- 44:43people, especially kids, I ask
- 44:45them, how do you like your
- 44:46minimum wage job? Are you
- 44:48concerned about education for
- 44:49your child, your health
- 44:51insurance? That is what gets
- 44:52them to vote. Perspectives on
- 44:56that. Yes. Go ahead. Richard
- 44:57Young.
- 44:57>> Yeah, I think that this is,
- 44:59again, where focusing on what's
- 45:01happening in your community at
- 45:03the local level is just such an
- 45:05effective solution for civics
- 45:07education. I think, you know,
- 45:10we've talked a lot about the
- 45:11potential polarization that
- 45:13comes with with civic education.
- 45:16And, you know, I think that at
- 45:18the local level, you know,
- 45:21potholes getting filled, trees
- 45:22going in people's yards, if you
- 45:25can walk to a grocery store,
- 45:27these aren't incredibly
- 45:28partizan issues, and they are
- 45:30issues that young people can
- 45:32impact, right? Young people.
- 45:34Even if young people can't vote,
- 45:35they can still show up to a
- 45:37city council meeting. They can
- 45:38still write their city council
- 45:40member, they can still attend a
- 45:41school board meeting. And so I
- 45:42think that if we can help young
- 45:44people see to Miss Harlowe's
- 45:47point that all of their
- 45:51engagement, if they if they can
- 45:52focus it in on the local level
- 45:54and really start to shape the
- 45:55things that they see every day
- 45:57in their communities, they can
- 45:58find that sense of agency, and
- 46:00it can be around things that
- 46:01aren't as polarizing as the hot
- 46:03button national issues that
- 46:04we're debating day to day. But
- 46:06when students do engage, and
- 46:07this is what our work at
- 46:10CivicLex does, particularly
- 46:11with young people in Fayette
- 46:12County, when they see elected
- 46:15officials or community leaders
- 46:17come and listen to them and
- 46:19hear their ideas and bring them
- 46:21into decision making processes,
- 46:23it can really unlock a lot for
- 46:25a student. It can unlock a new
- 46:27sense of attachment to the
- 46:28place that they grew up. It can
- 46:31unlock a lifelong love for
- 46:34whatever issue they're working
- 46:35on. It can really deliver that
- 46:37sense of empowerment that I
- 46:38think so many young people are
- 46:40looking for.
- 46:40>> Do we need to reframe the
- 46:42word democracy? Does it make it
- 46:45more accessible and resonate
- 46:47with Kentuckians, Americans
- 46:48that it's not just institutions
- 46:51and policies and rules and
- 46:53procedures, that it's much
- 46:54wider than that, and that it
- 46:56can encompass policies that
- 46:57really can affect one's
- 46:59material well-being. I mean, as
- 47:01I would say, down home, put the
- 47:02jam on the lower shelf for
- 47:04people. Do we talk about
- 47:05democracy in a way that is just
- 47:07not accessible to people who
- 47:08think, well, that's for
- 47:09scholars to discuss, not for
- 47:10the everyday Jane and Joe.
- 47:13>> Yeah, that's the core of it,
- 47:14is getting people engaged, not
- 47:18just showing up at stuff.
- 47:19That's a huge part of it, but
- 47:22following the news, getting
- 47:23information, sorting it. And
- 47:24again, this is a this is a
- 47:26cycle. The way that we are
- 47:29right now is how we were in the
- 47:31late 1800s. And then things
- 47:32changed. One was the secret
- 47:33ballot, the first place in the
- 47:35U.S. in the Western Hemisphere
- 47:36to have secret ballot was
- 47:37Louisville, Kentucky. And it
- 47:39worked so great that the state
- 47:41made that a statewide thing. In
- 47:42our Constitution. We were the
- 47:44first state to have a secret
- 47:45ballot, totally changed voting,
- 47:46and totally changed government
- 47:47in Kentucky because it wasn't
- 47:49one rally and the other rally
- 47:50all showing up and yelling at
- 47:52each other at the polls. It was
- 47:54someone being able to go in a
- 47:55booth, sort out differing
- 47:56opinions and and think for him
- 47:58or herself. That was a that was
- 48:00a new thing. That's the model
- 48:02that we need. And right now, it
- 48:04just doesn't look that way,
- 48:07obviously. But there's, you
- 48:08know, the doubt that we have in
- 48:10institutions today. And it's
- 48:11not just the government, it's
- 48:12everything. It's the church,
- 48:14right? It's it's the Boy Scouts,
- 48:15it's everybody. That's
- 48:18unfortunate, but I think part
- 48:20of it is that people don't see
- 48:21themselves in the institution.
- 48:22And the more we do what our
- 48:24other panelists are saying of
- 48:25people personally getting
- 48:27engaged and being part of that
- 48:30institution, the more
- 48:30confidence you're going to see
- 48:32in the institutions, if there's
- 48:33anyone change. I've seen, even
- 48:34in just six and a half years in
- 48:36this job, when I first got
- 48:38sworn in, I would get calls,
- 48:39emails, letters, physical
- 48:41letters every single day from
- 48:43citizens who had opinions about
- 48:45stuff the state would do or
- 48:47should do wouldn't do. I got a
- 48:50ton of it every day, and then
- 48:53it just stopped. And I don't
- 48:55get it anymore. And I wonder
- 48:57what happened to all those
- 48:58people? And did they stop
- 48:59paying attention to what the
- 49:01state is doing? And if they do,
- 49:03that gap is going to get filled
- 49:04by special interests because
- 49:05they're paying real close
- 49:06attention to what the state's
- 49:07doing. Right? The key is, can
- 49:09you get those people to care?
- 49:11And I think part of the problem
- 49:13is that people's identity now
- 49:14is more their tribe or their
- 49:15religion, or they're this or
- 49:16they're that or the party, than
- 49:18it is their Kentucky in this or
- 49:20their Jefferson County in this
- 49:22or whatever it is. Look, I've
- 49:24lived in other places. I
- 49:25understand parochialism isn't
- 49:26always a good thing. You want
- 49:27to have a larger perspective.
- 49:29It's important to have a local
- 49:30perspective, too.
- 49:31>> Did you respond to all of
- 49:32the fleet of mail that you'd
- 49:35gotten? Perhaps if you didn't,
- 49:37that's maybe why they didn't
- 49:38return.
- 49:39>> They all got a great form
- 49:41letter. Yes.
- 49:45>> Okay. We'll cease and desist
- 49:46on that conversation. Any other
- 49:47comment there before we talk
- 49:49about we think about military
- 49:50service being the ultimate
- 49:52expression of patriotism, right?
- 49:54But what does it mean to be an
- 49:56American patriot? And has that
- 49:58somehow been distorted over a
- 50:00period of years? Doctor. Geese,
- 50:02what do you think?
- 50:03>> It's such an excellent
- 50:05question. I think what it means
- 50:06to be an American patriot is to
- 50:08be one who serves one's
- 50:10community, and that can be in
- 50:12any number of ways. We've had a
- 50:14great conversation here of
- 50:15local issues, of state issues
- 50:17and of national issues. But at
- 50:19the end of the day, a patriot
- 50:21is someone who flies the flag
- 50:23and sets off fireworks on the
- 50:254th of July. But a patriot is
- 50:27also someone who volunteers for
- 50:28the Peace Corps or for teach
- 50:30for America. A patriot is
- 50:33someone, I think, who is
- 50:34willing to give up a position,
- 50:37a job, a post that could
- 50:39benefit them greatly,
- 50:41personally say in dollars and
- 50:42cents, in order to publicly
- 50:45serve their city, state or
- 50:47nation. You know, we certainly
- 50:48see that in the teaching world.
- 50:50We certainly see that in the
- 50:51higher education world. Lord
- 50:53knows we see it in the public
- 50:55service world. So to me, a
- 50:57patriot is someone who's
- 50:58willing to go out and serve
- 51:00others in their community and
- 51:02do it at a time when it may not
- 51:04necessarily benefit them a
- 51:05great deal personally to do so.
- 51:07>> Mr. Abramson, can you expand
- 51:09on that definition? And does a
- 51:10Patriot include those who
- 51:12protest against the nation who
- 51:14may not fly the flag, but may
- 51:16who take a knee instead? Is
- 51:18there room for a patriot to to
- 51:19be defined in that broad scope?
- 51:25>> Yeah, I, I certainly believe
- 51:27so. And I think the founders
- 51:29believe that. And again, I go
- 51:30back to it clearly says you
- 51:33have a right to have peaceful
- 51:35gatherings and take your
- 51:37grievances to the government.
- 51:38So it's not just the specifics
- 51:41of raising the flag. No
- 51:43political party controls the
- 51:45flag or controls the concept of
- 51:48patriotism. I mean, that's what
- 51:49America is about across the
- 51:51board. You know, we were saying
- 51:52earlier, you know, you're not a
- 51:54Democrat, you're not a
- 51:55Republican or independent.
- 51:56You're you're an American. Well,
- 51:58that's what it's about. And,
- 51:59you know, it takes people from
- 52:00around the world coming into
- 52:02the United States right now for
- 52:03the soccer tournament, for us
- 52:05to begin to realize, because
- 52:07they realize how special it is
- 52:09to be in Kansas City or to be
- 52:12in Syracuse or to be in Los
- 52:14Angeles as they come in for the
- 52:16for the matches. I think
- 52:18Americans, we take so much for
- 52:21granted. And when you were
- 52:23asking before about how do we
- 52:24get young people to, to engage
- 52:27in the issues, what comes to my
- 52:30mind are making the issues
- 52:32relevant as a parent, if you've
- 52:34got a 12 year old and you've
- 52:36got broken swings or a broken
- 52:40sliding board in your park
- 52:42where you take your child, you
- 52:44need to let them know that who
- 52:46controls that park? The city
- 52:49council person who has their
- 52:50next town hall meeting, and
- 52:52that child needs to be able to
- 52:54go forward and ask the question,
- 52:56why are the swings broken? Why
- 53:00doesn't the sliding board work?
- 53:02And then when you get through
- 53:03them, as they get more and more
- 53:05involved, I remember telling a
- 53:06group of 15 year olds in school
- 53:08one time that they ought to get
- 53:10out and find a candidate that
- 53:11they believed in and supported
- 53:13them, and they said, well, we
- 53:14can't vote no. And, you know,
- 53:16they said, well, why should we
- 53:18do it? I said, well, let me ask
- 53:20you this. Do you think it's
- 53:21good that you can drive a car
- 53:23at the age of 16? They say, oh,
- 53:25yeah, that's really that's
- 53:26really good. I said, well,
- 53:27guess who sets that? It sets
- 53:29that regulation, your state
- 53:31legislature. So if you, you
- 53:33know, if you better get
- 53:34yourself a candidate and find
- 53:36out whether he or she believes
- 53:38that 16 year olds ought to be
- 53:39able to drive or 15.5 year olds
- 53:42ought to be able to get a
- 53:43permit. Those kinds of issues
- 53:45as they're growing up gives
- 53:46them the chance that when they
- 53:47get a little older and have the
- 53:50critical thinking opportunity
- 53:52to assess what's going on
- 53:53around them, it ultimately then
- 53:56all of a sudden, they begin
- 53:57questioning what's happening
- 53:58with the environment, who's,
- 54:00you know, what is the problem
- 54:01with the environment? What's
- 54:03happening with our water, with
- 54:04our air, what's happening with
- 54:06our power utilities and sun and
- 54:09wind. And those issues become
- 54:12issues that if you've developed
- 54:14or worked with them as children
- 54:15growing up, they had the chance
- 54:18to begin as they have learned
- 54:19to critically think, say to
- 54:21themselves, this is something I
- 54:23need to get engaged with for
- 54:24the future, for themselves,
- 54:25their own families, and the
- 54:27future of the country.
- 54:28>> Yeah, thank you for that.
- 54:30Well, we think data center
- 54:31certainly might be an issue
- 54:32that gets people engaged. We'll
- 54:34save that for another
- 54:35discussion at another time on
- 54:37Kentucky tonight. But as we
- 54:38round out our conversation,
- 54:39Doctor Greg, I mean, you know,
- 54:41you you gave us kind of a low
- 54:43ball grade there at the
- 54:44beginning. But as you look
- 54:45ahead, I mean, what gives you
- 54:47hope? Let's end on an
- 54:48optimistic note, shall we?
- 54:49>> Oh, there's a lot of there's
- 54:51a lot of reason to be hope, a
- 54:53lot of reason to have hope. I
- 54:54should say. I worked with some
- 54:56of the greatest young people I
- 54:57know in America, and they are
- 54:59more dedicated, more energetic,
- 55:01more entrepreneurial, more
- 55:04community oriented and sense of
- 55:06volunteering than my generation
- 55:08was, for sure. So I look and
- 55:10there's hope there. If, you
- 55:12know, we have to do some work
- 55:14on educating them, I'm not sure
- 55:16they have the education that I
- 55:17had when I was a kid, but boy,
- 55:19there's so much better than me
- 55:21in so many other ways.
- 55:22>> Yeah. Maggie Harlow, I'm
- 55:23going to give you 15 seconds to
- 55:24kind of close this out on a
- 55:26final thought.
- 55:30>> Well, I believe that
- 55:32America's core is is steady.
- 55:35And yes, we're we have waves,
- 55:38but we're a boy. And I believe
- 55:40in the American way. And I
- 55:42believe in this young
- 55:43generation that will take over
- 55:44and do a better job than maybe
- 55:46we have.
- 55:47>> Yeah. Good. Final words to
- 55:48end on. Good discussion. Thank
- 55:50you all. Thank you in
- 55:51Louisville. And thank our panel
- 55:52here in Lexington. And thank
- 55:53you for joining us this evening.
- 55:55Make sure you join us each
- 55:56weeknight, including tomorrow
- 55:57at 630 eastern, 530 central for
- 55:59Kentucky edition, where we talk
- 56:00about the issues and the things
- 56:01that are going on in your
- 56:03community. So make sure you
- 56:04catch that tomorrow night and
- 56:05every weeknight. And then Bill,
- 56:07Brian and a panel of Kentucky
- 56:08reporters will be here on
- 56:09Friday night, of course, for
- 56:11comment on Kentucky at 8:00
- 56:12eastern, 7:00 central. Next
- 56:13week, we will be replaying the
- 56:15caregiving experience. If
- 56:16you're in that age where you're
- 56:18thinking about your parents or
- 56:19yourself, you don't want to
- 56:20miss that special report, The
- 56:22Caregiving Experience at 8:00
- 56:23eastern right here next Monday
- 56:25night until I see you again.
- 56:26I'm Renee Shaw. Take really
- 56:27good care. So long.